ML093490869
| ML093490869 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Callaway, Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 12/08/2009 |
| From: | Woolard S Engine Systems |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| Download: ML093490869 (6) | |
Text
FSI ENGINE SYSTEMS, INC.
175 Freight Road Rocky Mount, NC 27804 Telephone: 252/977-2720 Fax: 252/446-1134 December 8, 2009 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001
Subject:
10CFR21 Reporting of Defects and Non-Compliance -
Engine Systems, Inc. Report No. 10CFR21-0099, Rev. 0 Woodward PGPL Actuator with Remote Servo P/N 5296-044 P/N: 9903-539
Dear Sir:
The enclosed report addresses a reportable notification for a Woodward PGPL actuator with remote servo, P/N: 9903-539.
A copy of the report has been mailed to our affected nuclear customers.
Please sign below, acknowledging receipt of this report, and return a copy to the attention of Document Control at the address above (or, fax to number 252/446-1134) within 10 working days after receipt.
Yours very truly, ENGINE SYSTEMS, INC.
Susan Woolard Document Control Please let us know if ANY of your mailing information changes - name of recipient, name of company/facility, address, etc. Mark the changes on this acknowledgment form and send to us by mail or FAX to the number above.
RECEIVED:
93 DATE:
A1I~N Quality Performance With Pride
ENGINE SYSTEMS, INC.
175 Freight Road, Rocky Mount, NC 27804 Telephone: 252/977-2720 Fax: 252/446-1134 Report No.
Rev. 0:
1 OCFR21-0099 12/07/09 10CFR21 REPORTING OF DEFECTS AND NON-COMPLIANCE COMPONENT:
SYSTEM:
CONCLUSION:
Woodward PGPL actuator with remote servo P/N 5296-044 P/N: 9903-539 Emergency Steam Turbine Reportable in accordance with 1 OCFR21.
Prepared By:.
Reviewed By:
-/
Engineering Manager QAss M
Quality Assurance Manager Date:________
Date:_____
Quality Performance With Pride
Report No.
10CFR21-0099 Record of Revisions Page:
1 of 1 REV DATE PAGE DESCRIPTION 0
12/07/09 Initial issue.
Report No.
10CFR21-0099 Revision:
0 Date:
12/07/09 Page:
1 of 3 COMPONENT:
Woodward PGPL actuator with remote servo P/N 5296-044 P/N: 9903-539
SUMMARY
Engine Systems Inc. (ESI) began a 10CFR21 evaluation on 10/9/09 to evaluate two (2) separate PGPL remote servo failures. The evaluation was concluded on 12/07/09 and was determined to be a reportable defect as defined by 10CFR21.
Woodward failure analysis report #85572-ROO1, dated, 10/9/09, addressed two separate PGPL remote servo failures. The failure analysis report discusses a silver sulfide corrosion issue with surface mount resistors used in the PGPL remote servo feedback transmitter circuitry.
Woodward part number 9903-539 consists of a PGPL actuator and a remote servo. The PGPL actuator is mounted on the turbine's governor drive and the remote servo (Woodward part number 5296-044) is mounted at the steam valve. Hydraulic lines interconnect the PGPL to the remote servo. The PGPL actuator and remote servo was supplied by Engine Systems, Inc. (ESI) to the Callaway and Vogtle nuclear plants as part of a digital governor upgrade (Woodward 505 control) on their steam turbine generators. These are the only nuclear plants that use the P/N 9903-539 actuator/remote servo assembly.
Two failed remote servos were sent to Woodward for root cause determination. One servo was from Callaway (S/N 12369963, original manufacture date Nov, 2000) and the other was from Vogtle (S/N 13798414, original manufacture date May, 2004).
Both failures were attributed to silver sulfide corrosion (sulfuration) of surface mount resistors on the feedback board. On S/N 12369963, resistor R4 was open and on S/N 13798414, resistor R10 was open. A similar failure also occurred with resistor R1 1 on S/N 12369963 in 2004, at that time it was determined to be a random failure. Both feedback circuit boards contained Dale Vishay type CRCW surface mount resistors. Woodward has reported that they have only seen sulfuration on the CRCW resistors and that they began processing engineering changes in late 2005 and early 2006 to remove the Dale Vishay type CRCW resistors from their approved supplier list for this reason. The CRCW resistors were replaced with resistors manufactured by KOA Speers because sulfuration failures had not been identified with these specific resistors. Woodward has not had any sulfuration failures on the resistors currently used.
As part of this evaluation, ESI sent their test specimen PGPL remote servo to Woodward for examination. This servo was from ESI's test specimen PGPL actuator assembly, part number 9903-539, S/N 12254234 with an original manufacture date of Dec, 1999. Woodward found signs of sulfuration on two (2) of the resistors on the feedback board but no failures had occurred.
Report No.
10CFR21-0099 Revision:
0 Date:
12/07/09 Page:
2 of 3 Discussion:
Part number 9903-539 consists of a PGPL actuator and a remote servo. The PGPL actuator is mounted on the turbine's governor drive and the remote servo is mounted at the steam valve.
Hydraulic lines interconnect the PGPL oil supply to the remote servo. The electronic governor (a Woodard 505, in this case) senses turbine speed via a magnetic pickup input signal. The electronic governor output signal is connected to a Woodward PGPL Driver (located in the turbine control panel). The driver uses this signal, in conjunction with the remote servo position feedback signal, to send a corresponding output signal to control the PGPL actuator. Based on signal received from the driver, the PGPL actuators ports oil to the remote servo to push or pull the steam valve to achieve the desired change in turbine speed. Refer to the connection diagram below.
PGPL DRIVER LL *
.,OIN
,-_____, ___GOVERNOR 723, 2301A, 505, Peak 150, or any pom~
)_
other with 0-200
=
.1 mA output.
PGPL DRIVER 24 VDC POWER SUPPLY
]I
~Actuator 9903-539k boundary 5296-044 I
Remote servo
!l I
I oi I.....
Report No.
Revision:
Date:
Page:
1 OCFR21-0099 0
12/07/09 3 of 3 AFFECTED USERS:
Six (6) remote servos with suspect resistors have shipped to nuclear customers as safety related' items. Failure of the suspect resistor has caused operability problems of the corresponding safety related turbine; therefore, this deviation is considered to be a defect as defined by 1 OCFR-part 21.
LISTING OF WOODWARD PIN 9903-539 PGPL ACTUATORS WITH SUSPECT RESISTORS Serial Number Born Date Shipped to 12369963 Nov 2000 Callaway 13305595 July 2002 Callaway 13798414 May 2004 Vogtle 13798415 May 2004 Callaway 14141720 Feb 2005 Vogtle 14409400 Sep 2005 Vogtle CORRECTIVE ACTION:
The remote servos from the PGPL actuator assemblies listed in the table above should be returned to Engine Systems Inc. to have the feedback board replaced as soon as possible. Contact ESI's Customer Service department with the part number and serial number of the component(s) to be returned.
Note: Serial numbers 12369963 and 13798414 recently had the feedback board replaced during the failure analysis; these require no further corrective action.