ML081220434

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Pilgrim Watch Response to Entergy'S Request for Guidance on the First Circuit'S Administrative Stay
ML081220434
Person / Time
Site: Pilgrim
Issue date: 04/21/2008
From: Lampert M
Pilgrim Watch
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY RAS
References
50-293-LR, RAS J-107
Download: ML081220434 (4)


Text

DOCKETED USNRC April 21, 2008 (1:18 pm)

-UNITED STATESOF AMERICA OFFICE OF SECRETARY' RULEMAKINGS AND NULEARGREULATORY COMMISSION ADJUDICATIONS STAFF BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the matter of Docket# 50-293 Eneg orporation Pil~grimf Nuclear Powe'r'Station, License Renewal Application . " April 21,2008 PILRIMWATH RSPOSE O ENTERGY'S REQUESTFOR GU"IDANCE ON THE FIRST CICU IT'MS ADMINITRATIV STAY The ited States.Court of Appeals for the First Circuit order rfrs to closingte hearing';it; Firs Cicigre o~yeerfr to, and dosn thodrany sta of "tetriaino h adjudicafion" [Entergy Mo.tion at 3].

If Entergy'objects to thoe order, the proper place for it to register it ob n e First Circuit; not to the NRC's Atomic Safety LicensingBBoard. It seems evident that Entergy is "knockingon

ýthe wronig do." ' '

a-void heFirt Circit ord never says, t delayite s ofthe evidentiary hearing until the' tue ordered foirteen days from the6date of issuance of mandate -

will prejudice Entergy. The Model Milestones provision that t inital decision should issue within,,906dys oof the. end ,of the evidentiary. herin a ,rag .f..record" belies rather than 1Massachusetts v. NRC, Nos. 07-1483 W Cir. Apr. 8, 2008).

' J:' ,:: *( ' ,,*"!/

-. ), : " :.-:." . . .. . ,::..  ; . . .. i ,. :: ;: * " ,

supports Entergy's position._. Endi the evidentiary hearing: and closing the record would eviscerate the right to participate that the Court of Apeals granted the Commonwealth.

The Commonwealth's brief referred to by Entergy was: filed somned 5 months ago. At this point, in ite we-d inoknow the extentioi6 whic the Commonwealt will seek to paiticipate; nor do we knowwhat new, and signifct issue might hav'e'occujrr~ed sicethat timei whicth hteaing* be..stayegd; 1 itiI:*i 14 dadys from thie ;date o*f :issane of .the *manchte. to '"give the Commonwealth wifoid desires, terigt tr 'patii -aetreach Thnkyo fo you consideration,

.. . 2 1 . . . do Mary - rt - .-.

Pilgrim Watchi,'pro' S-e

.148 -Washinigton Stree Duxbury, MA 02.332.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETYAND LICENSING BOARD In the matter of DOcket # 50-293-LR Entergy Cororation Pilgrim Nuc1~arPoer Station licenseRenewl bonplcatio Apr i21$2008

'CERTIFICATE-OF SERVICE I ereby certify that tj6 followýingvas 'er" April 2108by elctroimalndb Mail,-Fi"C o --

S "U.S. eList: ,gr w th .ResponseTo gs Reuest For-Guidanie On T.h& First Cii~cuit's, Adinitative Stay-1 Administrative Judge, Secretary ',o'f the Commission Anm Marshall Yo"u;gChair, Attf: Ruk~lernakings and Adjudiclation's Atomic Safety and L-giqnsing Board Staiff Mail Stop - T-3 F231 MailStop 0-16 Cl1 US NRC United Sta~tes Nuclear Regulatory,:

Washigto, DC,2055570001 ..-.ompi* sion7 rwro Copies]

sdiitr~ti-V:Ju'dg-e! o ComisionAppjellate Offie idiuca.4ion Amic saft V"'andLiensing' Board-Mail Stop Tr3-`P3F ':t.es- uclear-Regulatory US NRC Comssion Washington, DC'20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Administrative Judge,ý, :Atomic Safety.and Licensing Board Richard F.Cole. Mail Stop T-3, F23 Atomic Safety anid Licens~ing:Boad nited States Nuclear Rgulatory.

Mail Stop -T3F2 -

Commission- -

WashngtnDC-20555-0001`

Was 0higo, DC 20555-0001

Susan L. Uttal, Esq- Sheila.'Slocm Holli~s, Esq.

Kitberly Sexton, Esq. TOWn1 of Plymouth MA James Adler, Esq., Duae orrsLLP Dav Roth, Esqz. 505.9_,Street, N.,WJ.000 Offce of Genera Counsel .Washingtonf DY.C. 20004-2166 1,i 1opO-5 b21t United StatesNuleardRegulatory RichrdtR. MacDonal Commission, TowMnagrTor of Duxbury WaShitn DC 255-.0001 DuburyM 023321:

Pýaul A. Gaukler, Esq...

FirChef&DDietor DEMA,.

.,Pillsbury, Withrop, haqw, Pittman, Townof ux-bury LLP 688tiemont Street 2300N11- Street, NMW ,:P.O. Box 2824 Washington,-DC 20,037-1138" .D'xbry MA 02331 1Mr. Mark Sylviad.

Town Manager, Ton of ,Plymouth PlymouithMA 02360l.

JMary La'qper-t PilrimWathpro se-148 Washigton St.,

buxbury,,MA.0,23332 2