ML081120490
| ML081120490 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 04/07/2008 |
| From: | Shapiro S Public Health & Sustainable Energy (PHASE), Rockland County Conservation Association, Sierra Club, Atlantic Chapter, Westchester Citizens Awarenesss Network (WestCAN) |
| To: | NRC/SECY |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-247-LR, 50-286-LR, ASLBP 07-858-03-LR-BD01, RAS E-79 | |
| Download: ML081120490 (127) | |
Text
RAS E-79 PAS r7 DOCKETED USNRC April 8, 2008 (8:30am)
OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND Susan Shapiro ADJUDICATIONS STAFF 21 Perlman Drive Spring Valley, NY 10977 (845) 371-2100 (845) 371-3721 palisadesart@aol.com mbs@ourrocklandoffice.com 4/7/08 Office of the Secretary U.S. NRC 16 th floor I Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, Maryland 200852 RE: WestCAN et al. RESPONSE TO ASLB APRIL 1, 2008 ORDER Please find enclosed 1 original and 2 copies of WestCAN's response, Table Contents and Exhibits A - I. This same document was transmitted electronically on April 7, 2007.
Please do not post any credit card information or courier service account numbers contained in the exhibits.
Sincerely, Cc: ASLB TetI~LA1F e643 SCV-V.bl5 93
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative Judges: Lawrence G. McDade, Chairman Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop Dr. Richard E. Wardwell In the Matter of ) Docket Nos. 50-247 and
) 50-286-LR ENTERGY NUCLEAR )
OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLBP No, 07-858-03-LR-BDO0 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating )
Units 2 and 3) ) April 7, 2008 PETITIONERS' WESTCAN ET. AL. REPLY-TO THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD ORDER OF APRIL 1, 2008 AND MOTION FOR REVISION OF CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE On April 1, 2008, the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (hereinafter "ASLB" or "Board") electronically served an Order requiring a response from the Petitioners' Westchester's Citizen's Awareness Network (WestCAN), Rockland County Conservation Association (RCCA), Public Health and Sustainable Energy (PHASE), Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club) and Assemblyman Richard Brodsky (collectively referred to as WestCAN or Petitioners). Petitioners' good faith response, upon information and belief, is contained herein.'
A. Service of WestCAN's reply WestCAN's reply was perfected by service of the original and two paper copies to the office of the Secretary of the Commission, which was deposited in the DHL courier box on February 1 5th. The receipt is attached as Exhibit A.
The License Renewal Proceedings for Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 2 and 3 were docketed and commenced on August 1, 2007. The rules of service that apply are 10 CFR PART 2 Rules Of Practice For Domestic Licensing Proceedings and Issuance of Orders in affect as of August 1, 2007, as articulated under the revised 10 CFR Part 2 Rules of Practice became effective on August 28, 2007, begins with the following note: "Electronic filing and service of documents in proceedings for which notices of opportunity for hearing were published in the Federal Register or on the NRC website before October 15, 2007, are governed by the Part 2 rules in effect prior to the NRC E-Filing Rule (72 Fed. Reg. 49139 (Aug.
28, 2007)).
Subpart C Section 2.302 (a) (1) states that "documents must be filed with the Commission". On February 15, 2008, WestCAN et al, deposited a copy of their Reply brief addressed to the SECY in the Courier service box. The SECY received a hard copy of Petitioners WestCAN's Reply on February 19, 2008, which was the None of the documents contained herein were sent by Richard L. Brodsky, Esq. However, pursuantto the ASLB
first business morning after electronic filing.2 WestCAN understood that service on the Office of the Secretary, Att: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff, was service on the on Adjudication Staff. (Exhibit A). 3 WestCAN understood that service on the SECY constituted service on the Adjudicating Staff, as the address for the SECY states the following: "Office of the Secretary, Att: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff." The ASLB Order of February 1st confirmed WestCAN's
.understanding that service on the ASLB was accomplished by serving the SECY, as Item 4 specifically ordered that only for amending pleadings the ASLB was to be served directly.
10 CFR § 2.304(f) states "a document filed by electronic mail or facsimile transmission need not comply with the formal requirements of paragraphs (b), (c) and (d) of this section if an original and two (2) copies otherwise complying with all of the requirements of this section are mailed within two (2) days thereafter to the Secretary, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission."
The ASLB Order of February 1, 2008 page 3, item 1 clearly stated "documents may be served on the Board in hard copy, on CD-ROM or as files attached to e-mail messages." (italics added). The February 1 St Order further Order of April 1, 2008, Attorney Brodsky has signed this document.
2 Monday, February 18, 2008 was a federal holiday, President's Day.
3 Proof of service was presented to the ASLB by WestCAN submissions of March 3rd, 12th, 21st, and 24th, 2008.
stated that a signed paper original and two paper copies.. .must be submitted to the Office of the Secretary." (italics added). The February 1st ASLB Order item unambiguously stated that only with regard to amending filings, MUST the ASLB be directly served. (emphasis added).
WestCAN perfected service on the ASLB, by serving the SECY as required by 10 CFR 2.304(a)-(g) and the February 1, 2008 ASLB Order. Within 2 business days of original filing WestCAN sent courtesy CD-ROM copies of the Reply via courier, on February 2 0 th, the most expeditious means available at an undue burdensome expense, to the individual members of the ASLB, one of which was in Colorado, and other individuals listed on the Certificate of Service dated March 6, 2008. (Exhibit B). CD-ROM copies for individuals with offices at the same address or Mail Stop were sent in one Fed Ex package in which individual envelopes were addressed to each individual at that location. For example the package delivered to Mail-Stop T-3-F23 at the NRC contained CD-ROM copies in separate envelopes for Lawrence G. McDade, Chair, Dr. Richard E. Wardwell, ASLB Board Panel, and Zachary S. Kahn, Law Clerk.
The CD-ROM sent by courier to the ASLB, Staff and other parties listed on the certificate of service, contained the original transmittal letter of February 15; which stated that the first transmittal, the "WORD document" should be deleted, and only the ADOBE PDF file be considered the Reply, and a transmittal letter for
February 201h of the courtesy copies. (Exhibit C). Petitioners acted in good faith demonstrated by our actions, by sending courtesy copies of CD-ROM, hardcopies by courier, and the errata of the Certificate of Service.
B. Explanation of the discrepancies in the three different Certificates of Service The Second Revised Certificate of Service dated March 6, 2008 states who was served. (Exhibit D). The difference between the preceding Certificates of Service and the March 6th Certificate of Service is that the email addresses were corrected to reflect who was actually served by email. CD-ROM's were sent to all the parties whose mailing addresses were listed.
C. Courier service, and the disposition of packages, including waybills and other documents Subpart C Section 2.302 (a) (1) states that "documents must be filed with the Commission." the staff of the Commission is considered a party." The Secretary of the Commission (SECY) then dockets the filing, under 10 CFR § 2.303, and distributes the documents to the ASLB.
On February 15, 2008, WestCAN deposited a copy of their Reply brief addressed to the SECY in the courier service box. The SECY received a hard copy of Petitioners WestCAN's Reply on February 19, 2008, which was the first
business morning after electronic filing. 4 WestCAN understood that service on the Office of the Secretary, Att: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff, was service on the on Adjudication Staff. (Exhibit A). The ASLB order of February 1st confirmed WestCAN's understanding that service on the ASLB was accomplished by serving the SECY; item 4 specifically ordered that only for amending pleadings was the ASLB to be served directly. On February 15, 2008, WestCAN et al, deposited a copy of their Reply brief addressed to the SECY addressed to: "Att:
Rulemaking and Adjudicating Staff' in the courier service box. The SECY received a hard copy of Petitioners WestCAN's Reply on February 19, 2008- the first business morning after electronic filing. (Exhibit A & D).
D. Responses Required from WestCAN regarding Discrepant Pleadings The ASLB correctly notes the minor differences between the "WORD version" of the Reply brief sent at approximately 12:00 a.m. February 16, 2008 compared to the Adobe' Version emailed at approximately 12:53 a.m. on February 16, 2008, sent in hard copy, and burned on the CD-ROM. The differences were highlighted in exhibit F of WestCAN's response on March 21, 2008.
E. ASLB Order March 7, March 24, and April 1, 2008 4 Monday, February 18, 2008 was a federal holiday, President's Day.
On March 21, 2008, in response to the ASLB's Order of March 7, 2008, WestCAN electronically served a two part email response to all parties. A hard copy was mailed only to the Office of the Secretary and the NRC Staff Counsel on Friday, March 21, 2008, as required by 10CFR 2.304(a)-(g) and the February 1, 2008 ASLB Order. An additional exact hard copy was mailed on Monday March 24,'2008 to the ASLB Panel and to William Dennis, Esq.
Exhibits H and I and the Table of Contents were electronically submitted to all parties on March 21, 2008. There is only one table of contents, entitled "3.21.08 TABLE OF CONTENTS," thus WestCAN cannot explain or-understand why the table of contents they and other parties received did not have all the exhibits listed. Either an electronic glitch or clerical error,caused Exhibit H and I to be omitted from the received Table of Contents, even though the actual Exhibits H and I were included. Moreover, WestCAN's hard copy mailings all contained the table of contents and Exhibits H and I.
The email sent on March 21; 2008 was sent in two parts. Part two of the email contained exhibits H and I. (See responses by NYS, 4/7/08, Town of Cortlandt & Entergy (4/4/08)). Part 2 of the email was not deliverable to the following email address: Christopher.chandler(iinrc.gov, HearingDocketwnrc.gov, marc ia.Carpentier~nrc.gov, David Rothnrc.gov, a REWanrc.gov, KDL2c)nrc.gov, Sherwin.Turk((znrc.gov, OCAAMAIL(a),nrc.gov,
Llovd.subin(nrc.gov, Beth. Mizuno-nrc.gov, Kimberly.Sexton~knrc.gov, zxk I @4ýnrc.gov, OCAAMAtL.Resource(5nc .- ov. (Exhibit B). Copies of all electronic mail sent or received by WestCAN on March 21, 2008 are annexed hereto. (See Exhibit E).
The Board correctly notes that the documents attached to Part 2 of the email are approximately 4.5 megabits. Since the NRC can receive transmission up to 12 megabits, it is not clear why Part 2 of the email was undelivered, however numerous emails to the NRC were undeliverable. (Exhibit E).
In response to a request by Zachary Kahn, from the NRC, WestCAN emailed "zip" file, which inadvertently omitted Exhibit H, on March 24, 2008.5 (Exhibit F & H). Also on March 24, 2008, WestCAN mailed a hard copy to the ASLB Panel. The "zip file" was not deliverable to William Dennis, wdennis'd,)entergy.com, and thus, a hard copy was also mailed to him on March 24, 2008.
Exhibit F is also comprised of 2 parts. Part 1 of Exhibit F, submitted March 21, 2008, was the "Adobe version" submitted by email at approximately 12:53 a.m., in hard copy, and contained on the CD-ROM. Part 2 of Exhibit F, submitted 5 Exhibit H contains the DHL receipts Petitioners' WestCAN et al. have sending their Reply Brief on February 15, 2008. These same receipts were submitted with Petitioners' Reply to Entergy's Motion to Strike as Exhibit A.
These receipts were also submitted attached to Petitioners' Response to the NRC Reply to Entergy's Motion to.
Strike as Exhibit A, At least one party did not receive the zip file; thus Petitioners' mailed courtesy hard copies to additional parties on March 24, 2008. These copies were identical to the hard copies mailed Friday, March 21, 2008.
March 21, 2008, was selected pages from the "WORD version" (exhibit A submitted on March 21, 2008). The selected pages highlighted the differences between the 12:00 a.m. and 12:53 a.m. versions. The ASLB correctly concludes that "there are no material differences between the text in Exhibit F, Part 2 and that in the 556 KB version of Exhibit F, Part 1." (ASLB Order April 1, 2008, p. 9).
On March 25, 2008, in response to the ASLB Order of March 24, 2008, WestCAN emailed and sent hard copies to parties listed on the corresponding certificate of service. The following documents were emailed as part of WestCAN's March 21, 2008 submission: (i) the table of contents, (ii) the DHL receipts submitted as Exhibit H on March 21, 2008 and March 24, 2008, (iii) the two part emails sent to all parties on March 21, 2008, and (iv) Exhibit I, an email from Sherwin Turk, Esq. on February 15; 2008, submitted as Exhibit I and on March 21, 2008 and March 24, 2008 respectively. (Exhibit E &
1). The ASLB's interpretation of these documents outlined on page 9 of the April 1, 2008 Order is correct.
However, WestCAN disagree with the ASLB's conclusion contained in footnote 29 on page 9 of the-April 1, 2008 Order. The NRC Staff was notified within two business days, on or about February 19, 2008 with the paper copy delivered by DHL and CD ROM, which included, Exhibit A, that contained the original transmittal letter of February 1 5th which stated that the first transmittal, the
"word document", should be deleted and only the "ADOBE PDF version" be considered the Reply of WestCAN. (Exhibit C)f6 F. Motion by WestCAN Electronic transmissions between WestCAN and the NRC have been plagued with difficulties. Last week WestCAN learned that in the middle of these proceedings the NRC has changed servers, and therefore email addresses have changed, even though old addresses are still being used in this proceeding.
WestCAN does not have an IT department, and therefore question whether the transmittal difficulties may be due to, or partially due to, the compatibility of our computer systems and the internal computer changes at the NRC.
The current Certificate of Service includes multiple individuals in the same offices at the ASLB, NRC Staff, and at Morgan, Lewis, and Bockius, as well as, individuals that are no longer part of the proceedings. This ever growing list is onerous and financially burdensome. Accordingly WestCAN respectfully makes a motion that the Certificate of Service be revised to reflect only one individual at each distinct physical address be identified to receive service, and that those individuals no longer involved in the proceedings be removed from the Certificate of Service, in order to expedite and simplify electronic transmittals.
6 February 19, 2008 was a federal holiday, President's Day.
CONCLUSION For the reasons set forth above, the ASLB should not exclude Petitioners' February 15, 2008 Reply Brief.
Dated: April 7,2008 Respectfully submitted, Co- sel for Petitioner WestC et. al d L. frodsr Esq. / C Co-counsel for Petitioner 14 /AN et. al
/7 Co-counsel Petitioner WestCAN et. al
TABLE OF CONTENTS Exhibit A- Copy of the DHIL receipts for service of Petitioners WestCAN's Reply Brief sent on February 15, 2008.
Exhibit B- Petitioners WestCAN's Second Revised Certificate of Service dated March 6, 2008.
Exhibit C- Cover Letter contained with the CD-ROM of Petitioners WestCAN's Reply Brief.
Exhibit D- FedEX receipts for mailing CD-ROM's.
Exhibit E- Email sent March 21, 2008 by Petitioners' WestCAN with notices of non-delivery.
Exhibit F- Email sent March 24, 2008 by Petitioners' WestCAN with notice of non-delivery and cover letter to ASLB.
Exhibit G- Tracking information for documents sent by UPS on March 21, 2008.
Exhibit H- Tracking information for documents sent by UPS on March 24, 2008.
Exhibit I- Tracking information for documents sent by UPS on March 25, 2008.
EXHIBIT A 041v":08B8 1!:01i 34:i37, 3721 MILTONI 8 AP0 PAa5 02
~LnL. ril it LL LIttv-ry ýtIwfj[UM uettan Page I of I Delivery Signature Detail SP-1 thiospace Signature details for 53769120845 4CXW GOOD CMI"COT ASNOJUR Sum mary details V Shipment ODtv~lylrod Detivefed an~ 21191089:44am Dae~tord 11 Shtping Do6k A PEARSON Receiver Information OFFICE OFTHE SECRtETAPY RodwYills, 1641?0662 UnwitsedSlown Trucking Oetedpwvkftd by OHL: VU72000 7z.07;4 AM Youjwe sut.rwizfd touaaOHLta use of DM1.
~ckig Ss"nn 5040~Y to6-aý shttpmcnts t.womd by prbir you to OHL.Anry fttw trecktog yaterns eavifrfvnsi~on Is stid*Y Prohrrd.
+
£k .
vs
.4441 33M I aw OW.I.K
--- 005
04/07/230e 11:01 94!3-713721 MILT01 SHP0 PAGE 03 it. rtistCI Vcly 3iIIOWI 19 tuMCIII Page 1 of I Delivery Signature Detail 1,Printthspg Signature details for 53769120646 RECL"MIVE ~CER N CDOOMM EXE ASNOTED Sufrhmary details Currant Status . Shipment Dei~vered DeI~wtmd on VIVitt 9 44 sr, D&Ov~red lo Snipping Dock Signedto, by R PEARSON Receiver Information O~FnCFOf THESECRFTARY TmO~tndvesM Iovided by DHI,ý447/20081:09V0kAM You era 4 uthomlea to use DelL tmOdna system solely to back shiipnuinits"desrddbyeor for you to OIIL. Any otho' use of OHLtraddr systems ad inforinatio'r, isstry prohiblt.
7077~~~
~)%flow.. Nu769P' 1206.4 7 _
~ +
r~~
yM0 V 1
-IJ
-J htTP:/fslgpod- dhl-usa,ccm/printbysig asp 4/7/2008
MRLTN 5 SHAPIRO f4,107.'2006 11:01 Bat 3713721, Page 1 of 1 Delivery Signature Detail , Prin this page Signature details for 53769120941
$EIW~IC60D OME1R &XCWAS M6TME Summary details CunmnmitS* V" Shipml.nI O.Iftred 2I1,0ma89:4 gm Delred to Shipping Ood Signed fat by R PEARSON Receiver Information QFFICE OF RES SECRETAFY RoAQ",*,.MD 20852 Uniteds'sea Thtdong doWt19vkde by r-L: 417=21O360:19:37 AM YTOW END to aU DHL !ra"Cking systfOs Scify to Fhy U1111honed ' OpMend%
IpIk et.Id a by Or u to DHL Any odwer you DHL tiacknQ syMsl use O01f aia inciwOllon is sticlly,prohlbihd "5'
~, ~po.J I-o tLJAk~1L~'O-'
' .1 -u,1
- 1~ SyNVEWS COPY
-J
-r. 101J.;-
ý100717008 1ý:E" OLS3713721 MTLTCN9 SH*PIFC um) 14'rnt L)el'verY Sic.,nature detail Page PA.E I 05 of I Delivery Signature Detail 0 pr t this p age Signature details for 53769121442 Ramuyjg IN C()OtOROMfEXVIPTA-SýOJM Summary details D*Rwrd on 2f'9/08 10:263m Pnbv"red to Sq,.d f. bY A J04E5 Receiver Informnation K 3U*-roNIP aosserrL Washing~ton, OC 20004 Unftd Stoma Trp*AVg dniall provildedby Ot4L 417U0O086:21:23'AU Youareaueorizmd to use OH-Lt Vvd" sys£ye~m,sogki to trackmlpfmrits tanctared byor for you to OHL,Anyother V" of DHLtradtno systeamsgrdatworrwomtoisstr1oy prohibited.
Fri
+--
,i tbt Wo~
3n.., Pt,.
P~nan~FLm,
04iolI2009 11:03l B451713721. MILTON B ViPR PAGE 9Er rI Ut!wulf aeio 6,- r iilL L.ICI#VwY J11I3yjl Delivery Signature Detail , P~n hspg Signature details for 61491770841
~(~IN COCOGawat FXCWPTASý61%
Summary details ClJ7~ft $~jSV Shippirn~tDollwifrd Doh~weod -vZM 9/M 9:44 am Oewword to Suuipinlg Doed, SV9fl. fu try R PEARSON Receiver Information 3HERuWN TURK Do 20556 Weiroau~nglm UnitmdS%06s Trdf~v MiswHPnm~dd try OH:4171M7:11:59AM Yo r uhrzdt s H rýsse o"Wtaksofns earlb rfryut HýA te OHLtraddQ systm~ atd rnfonnatiotis stiicty oml~bbod.
0Mo PF90 A-- Numb- 0,tp.,l r NO , vlO~
z__ FI I
- A- i 14/712=1`{
EXHIBIT B
- Piti..nac~(A c iisubnlissioni: second Reviscd (.O( .1, 4.8crvm I'mr OS Va-le I .0 2 GnuSarah Wagner -sarahwagneresqiq-qmaiI~com'ý Petitioners WestCAN et al. submission: Second Revised COS for 2.15.08 service, I Message Sarah Wagner <sarahwaqn~resqi~gmaI.com> Fri, Ma~r7, 2008 at 1:ý48PM To. LGMv1@nr-..gov. 0CAAm!AL r-L,rc..gcv, OCAP.MAIL. Resource <OC)CAMAIL Rpasour-e@nrc go-v;,
PE'.1VC-nrc gov, tnc's HearingE~cckel@nrzagova. zxk1@nrc~qov~ KDL2nrc gov "Greene.
<e~gcc Mann! rnannaioit.clearýw ýr -ýTg>, "Dennts. Wittliiam' <cwdernnis~energy~comn2> "Sutton. Kathryn-cksuttOngrn-organlewis.co'rý Beasertie Paul" pbesserteamrnoianit-wis.coni>, "ONiMartin" rn.~lin0 i~ogaU~ea n '~m'Pruyne-Justin 'ld;3@)westchesteroov corn>.S~e Daniel"
,Vo~b'a-eslwebnTei>, "elle,.n~y, Micrhael" 'maelarwy~nycedc ~-orn- "LeKay. John' <fuse _usa@yatro0 COrn>
"Sicos,john" <Jo'ir Siposi ýt tag, state..ny us> -Matthews. Joan" '-ifmattnei~vgw dec state nP~ us> "Kremer, Artnur ~aj~k remer@ rinoc~ccr, rtu~'rmr~ae lireOg "rmr2 Curran. Diane"
<idcurran@harmoncurran corni> "Snlok, Rocierf' irocbertsnook'~pc sate ci us,' Musegaass Phillip"
<piptliip@niverkeeeper org> "T auVco afuiriveee Riesel, Daniel" drieeil~sprlaw zom>,
"r~
"Steinberg, Jessica" .jstejnbergagsprlar. com-, "Zoli, Elise" <ezoli~joodwinprocter -cm>,
lanie dean@o.ag -state. ny s my Ian, Dene rsteinLýoag, state, ny. us, "Burton Nancy- <Nan.43unoni1T@ao!. cam;,.
Kimbenly.Sexion@nrc .gov..St.'win Turk -Sherwin Turý,nrc gov'iCrsohrChnlrncgy Marcia Caroenfier -ara apie*rcg 'aiaeatalon'Palisades art aol. com>. Ui-i'nt VAlitf
'u~r~~ucwiteconi>
Iv RIvnw iwl.. rl~t'isub inti~d b, 'u n d.i'sui oi ni luuTii1. LI(.C., Ii lun di. tN I'm; Puoin,.i and iyi 1iCh:;ir :iporatlo lm. I~ Ida ~
'm I \iiNcly-ir (i.'ncrijitiu Stativ'. I.;mi 2 and Pt).nkct Nos 51O.241-LWi54)2t- ASIAI No.ih i~I-l~
DkI Pa66I cuccirC'in:yrA ' aurvns Nc r. rk i~e-ot AN). Rck arid ('ounrv Cowinsr:ritirrAs,wilirr I R, t. Al l'uý,bfic !+,-Aili mh i i;;--7. -Ini:il Ei NuuI AISF) 5Cm S. ClUlb-Alilriri Ch1J'lrprrSc Yorl CLuir, t.`.rdNe'.
'5alsnubc i cbin:1,4 i.ttrn'dk\-
L.~ 100 , I .uin Ti~Iviirimllerý" i.ery'b\ ,41ruril Iis rh 5' kn'u. Cenifec wd SAah dL.I A urr k.,. !itt lii m i o ýc.n I .i I i r12I:_'.'."'t b 11(icb 4 ~ I Ii201 4ia
(ial- lui~ifiiicmrs. WVest(.-N c1 al. stibission: Second Rcvised (.0()s iNt-2.145.(M8 scrviiv Pavz 2 o'f 2 WESTCAN REVISEO !ND CERT OF SERVICE 2.7,08,pdf 2ui~ I &ik-iihL' I cd5~' I ~ ~j~i&:I~~ 1 ~ 41
UN'TED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. Docket Nos. 50-247,'286-LR rindian Point Nuclear Generating)
Units 2 and 3)
SECOND REVISED CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Reply of ,,estCAN et al. dated February 15. 2008, have been served lpon the Office of the Secretary, US. Nuclear Regulatory. Sixteenth Floor, One Flint Nurrihc I Ruok.ilI" Pike I ilW.,urvltind 21.l52 AII i countsY paper oP" has bv:vnse ww tt and Enlerg " attomrn- s. I further certify that CD copies of the foregoing Reply of WesICAN et al. dated February 15. 2008, have been served upon the following addresses provided below. this 1,51h day of February. 2008 by DHL courier service.
AclditicirialY., I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Reply Brief of WestCAN et al. dated February 15. 2008, hove been electronically served only upon the email addresses provided below, on the 16th aa- of February 2008.
Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licansing Board Panel U, S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-1 F22 Mail Stop. O-16G4 U, S Nuclear Pegu,at:}` Commiss~or Washington, D.C 20555-0001 Washington. D C 2D!55-0001 Email: OCAAMAiL*&ri-ir.oov Dr. Richard E. Wardw'!l Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Lic ansing"Board Panel Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop -- T-3 F23 Mail Stop: O-16G4 U. S. Nuclear Reguiatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, DC. 20555-0001 Email: H-EARINGDOCKEI'*nrc.gov Dr. Kaye 0. Lathrop Zachary S5 Kahn, Law Clerk Atomic Safety and Lic,!nsing Board Atomic Safely and Licensing Board 190 Cedar Lane E. Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Ridgeway. CO 51422 U. S Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Atomnic Safely and Licznsing Board U. S- Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Washington, D.C. 205ý55-0001
William C. Dennis. E 3q, Manna Jo Greene Assistant General Counsel Hudson River Sloop Clearwater. Inc Entergy Nuclear Operations, inc. 112 Little Market Street 440 Hamiton .*venui: Poughkeepsie. NY 12601 White Plains. NY I0(C1 Emai wdenniw,,)ent.:.rov corn Kathryn M. Sutton. E ;q, Justin D Pruyne. Esq.
Paul M. Bessette. Es 4 Assistant County Attorney Martin J 0 Neill, Esq Westchester County Attorney's Office Moroan, Lewis & Bocktus, LLP 148 Marfine. Avenue, 65"Floor 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW \'Mite Plains, NY 10601 Washington. DC. 20004 E-mail: ksutron,3nimr.,an!ewis.cor' E-mail. obeszeitleE-. roanlewis.cor Daniel E. O'Neill, Mayor E-mail: marlin. oneillcomoroanlewis.cor James Seirmarco, M.S.
Village of Buchanan Michael J. Delaney, Esq. Municipal Building Vice President - Eneigy Department Buchanan. NY 10511-1298 New York City Econo:mic Development Corporation (NYCDEI>
110 Atlliam Street John J. Sipos, Esq.
New York. NY 10i'ý8 Charlie Donaldson. Esq.
Assistants Attorney General New York State Department of Law John LeKay Environntental Protection Bureau FUSE USA The Capitol 351 Dyckrnar Street Albany, NY 12224 Peekskill. NY 10556 Arthur J, Kremet. Chairman Joan Leary Matthews. Esq.
New York Affordable Reiiable Electricity Senror Attorney for Special Proiecrs Alliance (AREAl New York State Department of 347 Fifth Avenue. Suite 508 Environmental Conservation New York, NY 100t6 Office of the General Counsel 625 Broadway. 141;" Floor Albany, NY 12233.1500 Diane Curran Esq.
Harmon. Curran, Srie berg & Eisenberg. l.LP 1726 M Street. NW. S'jite 600 Washington. DC. 20036 E-.mai1t r.,_ ncurran r.
Robert Snook, Esq. Victor Tatur, Esq.
Office of the Attorney Oeneral Phillip Musegaas, Esq, State of Connecticut Riverkeeper, Inc.
55 Elm Street 828 South Broadway P,O. Box 120 Tarrytown. NY 10591 Hartford* CT 06141-;j22
Daniel Riesel, Esq Thomas F. Wood. E.*q.
Ms. Jessica Steinherg, j D Sive, Paget & Riesel P C.
460 Park Avenue New York. NY 10022 Efise N, Zolik Esq Gooawin Procter, LLP Exchange Place Ms. Nancy Burlop 53 State Street 147 Cross Highway Boston, MA 02!09 Redding Ridge. CT (6875 Janice A. Dean Sherwin Turk. Esq.
Assistant Attorney General Office of the General.Counsel Office of the Attorney General U.S Nuclear Regulalory Commission 120 Broacway, 26ý. F*or Mail Stop 0-15-D-.21 New York. NY 10271 Washington. D.C, 20555 EMAIL lvrca enra'~nrcp.aoy cmo(gnrc ctc'v esrxdda.'rc-, a Diate.n'lrr h G. 00 Sarah L. Wagner. Esp.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFCRE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC, Docket Nos. 50-247"286-LR ASLBP No. 07-853-03-LR-BDO1 (Indian Point Nuclear Generatingi Units 2 and 3)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I nereby cerlify that copies of the foregoing Second Revised Certificate of Service for service of Petitioners WestCAN et al. reply brief served February 15. 2008- have been served upon the following by electronically and by first class mail as shown below. this7th day of March. 2008:
Lawrence G. McDade. Chair Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Pane! U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop. O-16G4 U, S. Nuclear Regula:ory Commission Washington. DC. 20555-0001 Washington. D.C. 2D.155-0001 Email: OCAAMAILnrc.qov E-mail: LGM Viar'.c aiv D,. Richard E Wardwitl Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and ..icarising Board Panel Attn Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop - T-3 F22 Mail Stop: O-1604 U S. Nuclear Reguatlri Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington. DC. 2:)555-0001 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 E-mail REW*Vnrc cci Email: HEARINGDOCKETýW*c gov Dr. Kaye 0 Lathrop Zachary S. Kahn. Law Clerk Atomic Safety and LUconsing Board Panel Atomic Safely and Licensing Board Panel 190 Cedar Lane E. Mail Stop - T'3 F23 Ridgeway. CO 81432 U S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: KL)-24anri coy- Washington. D.C, 20555-0001 Email, ZXKir&inrc..oov Atomic Safety arid Licinsing Board Panel U. S Nuclear Regulatonr Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Washington, D C 2-555-0001 William C. Dennis. Est., Manna Jo Greene Assistant General Cou,'sel Hudson River Sloop Clearwvater, Inc Enlergy Nuclear Opnrationes, Inc 112 Little Market Street 440 Hamitt6n Avenue Poughv~eepsie, NY )2601 White Plains, NY 10601 Email: !arirc~e*'water ora
ýJ
Ema ilI. we v nr I e !e., 1; .rc Kathryn M. Sutton, ;sq. Justin D. Pruyne. Esq.
Paul M. Bessette. Esc Assistant County Attorney Martin J O'Neill. Esa. Office of the Westchester County Attorney Morgan. Lewis & Bocikius, LLP 148 Marline Avenue, 6" Floor 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue. NW White Plains, NY 10601 Washington, D.C. 20104 E-mail; idp33.iwesichesieroov corn E-mail; ksuanon)morrtaniewis. con E-mail ' abessentedErnqaanlewis corn Daniel E O'Neill, Mayor E-mail martin .o'e IeIlmorqanlewis.com James Seirmarco, M.S Village of Buchanan Michael J Delaney Esq Municipal Building Vice Presideni - Energy Department Buchanan, NY 10511-1298 New York City Economic Development E-mail; vobbestweb.net Corporation (NYCDECI 110 William Street John J.Sipos, Esq-New York. NY 10038 Charlie Donaldson, Esq.
E-mail :dein " d Assistants Attorney General New York Staie Department of Law John LeKay Environmental Protection Bureau FUSE USA The Capitol 351. Dyckman Street Albany, NY 12224 Peekskill, NY 10566 .E-mail: LgUjiii.aros~lpp~gstaia my~u E-mail fuse usa.a-,oc.com Arthur J Kremer, Cheirman Joan Leary Matthews, Esq.
New York Affordable Reliable Electricity Senior Attorney for Special Projects Alliance (AREA) New York State Department of 347 Fifth Avenue Sui-e 508 Environmental Conservation New York, NY 10016 Office of the General Counsel E-mail aikimeicrmant cam 625 Broadway. 14" Floor Kr rnercarea allianCe2reo Albany. NY 12233-1500 E-mail ilmaithe.6cw dec state. nv us Diane Curran. Esq.
Harmon. Curran. Sapilberg & Eisenberg, LLP 1726 M Street. NW Suite 600 Washington, C C. 20(,36 E-mail: r'.hirrcncurran corn Robert Snook. Esq Victor Tafur, Esq.
Office of the Attorney General Phillip Musegaas. Esq.
State of Connecticut
- Riverkeeper. Inc.
55 Elm Street 328 South Broadway P.O_ Box 120 Tarrytown, NY 1059.1 Hartford, CT 06141-0120 E-mail; philliporrirverkeeper~orq E-mail: tahern anooncpo nstate. -,'is vtatur Iaýrive rkeeper, or Daniel Riesel, Esq.
Thomas F.. Wood, Es*.
Ms.-Jessica Steinbeig: J.D Sive, Paget & Riesei P C.
460 Park Avenue New York. NY 1002:
E-mail: ý driesal, rktw corm Elise N. Zoli, Esq.
ist os rlaw corn Goodwin Procter, LLP Exchange Place Ms. Nancy Burtop 53 State Street 147 Cross Highway Boston, MA 02109 Redding Ridge. C- )6876 E-mail. otiq.'goodwinpr octer. conr E-mraii nanclturn,,v t..aol corn Janice A. Dean Counsel for NRC Steff Assistant Attorney General U.S. Nuclear Regu.aoryv Commission Office of the Attorney General Office of the Generai Counsel 120 Broadway, 26` Floor Washington D.C 20555 New York. NY 10271 E-mail: kirine - , . E-mail jance dearvi5'caq state,ry us Sherywin tu.k*,inriz*ov christopher cliand eri5nrc qcr, Office of the Secretary' Mylan L. Denerstein U.S, Nuclear Regula'ory Executive Deputy Attorney General Sixteenth Floor Office of "he N.Y. Attorney General One Flint North 120 Broadway. 2 5w floor 11555 Rockville Pile New York, New York 10271 Rockvil~e, Marýlanc 20852 E-mail Mvlan Denersteir. "l'oao.statenv US NI:rcim Carpl .nt ir ! Clerk Al\oiik; sal' aod I-.cnsimn Bioard Mail Stop: T-3 E2E U S. Nuclear Regula'ory Commission Washington D C_ 20355-0001 E:-mail: M',.*.'rgi.L ] Jv .r,"!: ,__.
,s!
'Sarah L. Wagner, Esq,
- Original and two ,opies
EXHIBIT C THE ASSEMBLY
-STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY FRCHARD L BRODSKY Asssemolymar 92° D)istrict( CHAiRMAN COMMItee on We';tchesle! Counti Corpnrations. Authoutips ald Commisions February 15. 2003 Office o f the Scct-etary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Committee Sixteenth floor One White Flint North 11555 Rockville )ike Rockville, Maryland 20852 Re; Indian Point License Renewal, Docket No. 50-247'286-LR To Whom It Ma. Concern:
Enclosed please find Petitioners Westchester Citizen's Awareness Network (WestCAN).
Rockland County Conservation Association, Inc (RCCA), Promoting Health and Sustainable Encrty, Inc. (PHASE). Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club), and New York State Assemblyman Richard I... lrodsky Reply Brief in response to the NRC Staff*ad Enter-,.
Also enclosed is ihe original signed hard copy of the Reply. the Certificate of Service, T'able or Content:.. Exhibits. A courtesv CD-ROM is being sent separately.
As you arc awtrc I was experiencing problems with the NRC's server as we discussed with Rebecca Gitver. We transmitted the document as a word file, but are concerned it may be corrupted, if it arrived at all. We transmitted an Adobe PlDF file via another office which we believe successfully went to all the parties, Therefore please delete the first transmittal, tne "word document", and consider the Abode PDF file the Reply.
Sincerely, Sarah, L. Wagner J, ALA~NY OFF:CE. ROOM,422. Lteqjslotive Offiae builang, Alr)atyný
.5IwTr 5.7; FICE S West Main.StI~ttl z'wJIe2105 E1,rst,0, New y,>k lG5qtmiW j T$TRAOF
EXHIBIT D FEx., ."=pre USAirbill ', -, 8608 4742 8550 I Fiwm I'*Fadxfrsrt Noiom~
41d~ 2pesPacEwg Sems.S~ -jiiruo.., ii ,,,
Sewet's Name -Ph~on- - I,.,-,
- 4b&B~wm fts *vimgfts $pm - ... ...
ISaEvicerd ~w~
Pac*Minew f~ais I - V.j Fsdfl a Fr.m F x F-jhW ~
-._'-----'+::_L.--.*_.
e++*...................
Ad*+
p ziSat~ 5j PackIagin ak jWg e
-~t _ _ _ _
J Fwelow*
i *OX i ;.,o W* FTun, o Your lomnal Billing R.l ranc-
! 6 Spoeil HandIng Li SATIMAY lskuy 11W O .ju M- Os.I,, e Fed uJ F,= ."
_ N,,
r'.,cd. ,Z 0,/ C-, ,
r 7 NOI AY~l
.. +,
.l..........
RW cpe- wma 9.."
-hdat mm-sa~~
Oý hokw U /l. ,- , ..,, .......
.. . To NOi 2l ~ Yes ~ Ddid k
-zw.3S1~.
9 NEW Rlsidential Delivery Signafti Options .. ,., o,.s,, o,+
NOSs~aat~re - lrakect~2 ~ re Retuwecl
- .CUa .~
[ flw.otS.go~i,.
[520]
- nw,.. wn S *e~fI C.,
- O...m.,I.,artt.. ~Ai6fl..*W00 nn,$A Sm,
oc*x liSAirbill .44EB6 Sem-lat -- b 4b Expmuftvio~ors hdmwmce-
!~ Fa~. C.. Fre-
Ma Cu " R - -r
. ..... 4b Exxussoese enics Pak' PadEt.ea C3m Yowwm hv lim ewe~
6 Spivial endling TO I S1AYMRY oHOWWv 1 HOLD Sauedtb
~ tlNMeb*
ArMle44M 1w AwiI.h ONLY ft, O~~gr.b d**rr..
1pastmet Maic I.j seee b1=-A,.ý0"rW-
__ - Sim C ) zip 8 NEW Rezidentiol Delivery Signeture Opflons Li-j ~ s 521
- ,ra[5:10]
FeCLx,' *.:Express US Airbill "--*8608 47.42, 8571 I Frm., ,. ., 4a txpressracstageberflce:
Date_ Accoum Nufter FiI g-, Wa59 4 FedExMnom e~h Fed~Soussr SaveI Name (
- SdE --
_ 4b &MpusfteightSewvica Pada*,s nw IAk
- I tadEXIDaZ~fies&W FedEx May Ffo~r Adoiess 5 Packaging Ste~a El F-6. i Fedb Pavr i b f Fed. 06 Erweiope* -. em Tube t Y*tr nmomIl Billing pawerma 6 SpeciallHandling ,*
- 3 TO LjSAIURUV Dmh~wv LI "Mkd xd NOI~rarI9kb' sdE.LcaN.
IAo '~o. ~ ~ e . ........... s
~ ~ Ofl~
W. ~ ~ ~ ~ ...Cf~r*.P
.... ~ .)
-ACargcAscraft trdy 7 Pavuw*g &a RtcOiam Thi Party CrednCard CaShvrl~si lo Packmomm TOM~V h~
9 NFW Rmidseditial Delivery Signeture Options . .n.n a.
No Sipaour.
]I Required QrOisrgntis~te 1rket.Z 2 nTe
- t* [$Thi*
EXHIBIT B Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.corn>
FW: WestCAN's Reply to the ASLB Order 3.7.08 I message From: Sarah Wagner frnailto:sarahwaaneresqalamail. com]
Sent: Friday, March 21 2008 4:44 PM To: LGMI1 )nrc.qov; OCAAMAIL(dnrcqov; OCAAMAIL Resource' hearinqdocketronrc oov: Hearing Docket: REW*,nrc.gov KDL2fonrc .ov: zxklanrcqov: Dennis. William; Greene, Manna Pruyne Justin: Sutton, Kathryn: Bessette. Paul, O'Neill, Martin: Delaney,. Michael: LeKay, John: Kremer, Arthur; Kremer(2). Arthur: O'Neill, Daniel, Sipos, John; Joan Matthews: Curran, Diane: Snook. Robert:
Musegaas, Phillipi Tafur, Victor: Riesel, Daniel: Steinberg. Jessicai Burton, Nancy: Zoli, Elise, ianice.dean(ooaq state Ls mvlan,Denerstein0oaq. state.ny.us- Kimberly.Sexton(3.nrc oov; Sherwin Turk: Christo,!ner Chandier('nrc.gcov-Beth Mizunoenrcqov; David.Roth~nrcaov; Iloyd.subinP*nrc gov Parker, John Louis; Richard Brodsky: Ulrich Witte: palisadesarltnaol.com
Subject:
WestCAN's Reoly to the ASLB Order 3.7.08 Re: Indian Point License Renewal, Docket No. 50-247!286-LR To Whom It May Conci:rn:
Attached please find Pe,*titioners Westchester Citizen's Awareness Network (WestCAN). Rockland County Conservation Association. Inc. (RCCA). Public Health and Sustainable Energy'(PHASE).
Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club). and New York State Assemblyman Richard L. Brodsky Reply Brief in response to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Order of March 7, 2008. Paper copies are only being sent to the Office of the Secretary, as required by the ASLB Order of February 1 2006. and a second paper copy is being mailed to the Office of Counsel for the NRC Staff.
I will be sending twc eniail.s to. include all the exhibits If you cannot open any of the attachments.
please contact me Sincerely.
Sarah L. Wagner Legal Counsel for Assumonblyrnan Richard L. Brodsky LO.B Room 422
Albany. N Y 12248 518-455-5753 5 attachmofnts 3.21.08.
3 COS.pdt 42K 3.21.08 TABLE OF CONtENTS.pdf 14K A 3.21.08 REPLY TO ASLS ORDER3.7.08.pdf 53K 3.21.08 Exhibit A Word copy of WestCAN Reply. BricfFinaL_ 211].15.08..pdf 475K 3.21.08 Exhibit B Emnail with Adobe copy of Reply Brief Final_ 2(1].15.08..pdt 68K
fti.(1 of 4 Gmuaii - \Ve-sWA.N ;-ýpbv to .- \SLB Order 3.7.08 b Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
WestCAN reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 6 messages Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail-com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:59 PM To: "Snook. RoDertl <rober. siooK@po.state.ct.us>- "Deianey. Michae:" <rneianey@nycedc com>.
Chrinstooher Chandler@nrc-oc,, "Curran. Diane" <dcurran@narmoncurran.com>
CO Sherwin Turk <Sherwin TJrk@nrc.gov> "hearihgdocket@nrc-gov" <HearingcDocket@nrc.gov>, Hearing Docket <Hearing. Docket@nrc.gov>. Richard Brodsky <richardbrodsky jrmsn corn>. "palisadesart@ao!.con-
<Paiisadesart@aot corn>. OCL\AMAIL@nrc gov. OCAAMAIL Resource <OCAAMAIL.Resource@nrc gov>
Dear Sir o- Madam' 1 attempted to email you two separate emails containing Petitioners' WestCAN et al.'s reply to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Order of 317/08. 1receivedi notification that the email was not deliverable due to the size of the emails or that delivery of the email failed. Please contact me if you would like me to re-send the emaiis Please advise what your megabits size limitation is- Thank you, Sincerely.
Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 5:00 PM TO: Lawrence McDade <Lawrence.McDade@nrc gov>, Marcia Carpentier <marcia.Carpentieronrc.gov>.
KDL2@nrc.gov. zxki@nrc gv, "O'Neill. Martin" <martin o'neillimor-ganlewis.com>, "Sutton. Kathrn"
<ksutton('morganlewis corn, Zachary Kahn <Zachary.Kahn@nrc.gov> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 5:12 PM To: Sarah Wagner <sarahw gneresq@gmail.com>
Ms, VWagner -
Would they areit be odessed to :end each exhibit separatelv" Or perhaps you can zip the documents possible com1 m so s
Thak o.
L
\VesiC.N-X rclYIlY i< .1/4S1..B Ordcr ',.708 Pd"* -2 cv4 GCirnall -
Zach Kahn Zachary S. Kahn Law Clerk.
Atomic Safety and Liceniing Board United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Phone: .....
- 5-* 5,'
E-Mad. Zachary, Kahn.ý i-c.oov From: Sarah Wagner Imai to: arahwagnere sqgCraail .com]
Se_1nt: Friday, Match 21, 2C08 5: I PM To:i:Lawrence McDade, M,:rcia Carpentier: Kaye Lathrop, Zachary Kahn: O'Neill, Martin. Sutton, Kathryn
Subject:
Fwd: WestCAN rzly to ASLB Oraer 3 7 08 Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 10:31 AM To: Zachary Kahn <Zachary Kahn@nrc.gov>.-LGM1 @nrc.gov, OCAAMAIL@nrc.gov, OCAAMAIL Resource
<OCAAMAIL.Resource@nr .gov>. REW~nrc~gov. "hearingdocket:dnrc.gov" <HearingDocket@nrc gov>
Hearing Docket <Hearing Dockethnrc.gov>, KDL2@nrc.gov. zxkl1 @nrc.goV, "Dennis, William"
<wdennisj@entergy.com>. "Greene, Manna" <manna o@clearwater.org>, "Sutton, Kathryn"
<ksutton@morganlewis con >, "Bessette, Paul" <pbessette@rnoroanlewis.corn>. "O'Neill, Martin"
<martin o'ne'i@morganiiewi;.com>., "O'Neill, Daniel" <vob@lte~tweb.net>. "Pruyne. Justin"
-Jdp3@westcnestergov cn)n>. "Deianev, Michael" <mdelaney~nycedccor>, "LeKay. John"
<fJse_usa(ýyahoo corn> "1'emer.Arthur" <ajkremer@rmtpc.corn> "Kremer(2). Arthur" <kremer@area-allianceorg>. Joan Matthew.,s <jlmatthe@gw dec.state.ny.is>, "Sipos, John" <John Siposroag.state nv us>,
"Curran. Diane" <dcurran* ,armoncurran.dom>, "Snook, Robert" <roberLsnook@postate.ct.us>. "Musegaas.
Phillip` <philiipgriverkeePe- org>, "Tafur, Victor" <vtafur@nvverkeeper org> "Riesel. Dahiel"
<driesel@sprlaw.corn> Steinberg, Jessica"<jsteinberg@sprlaw.com>, "Zoli: Elise"
<ezoli goodwinprocter. con.', "Burton, Nancy" <NancyBu-tonCTt aol:com>, janice dean oag. state ny. us.
mylan.Denersteinýoag.sta:e.ny.us, Kimberly.Sexton@nrc.gov, Sherwin Turk <Sherwin Turkgnrc..gov>.
Cnrstphe.Candrnrc. Betvh.Mizuno. nrc.gov, David Roth@nrc.gov, llovdsubin@nrc.gov Parker, John Louis" <JIarker@gw.d ec.st3te.ny us>, Marcia Carpentier <marciaCarpentiercnrc.oov> Richar., Srodsky
<richard-rodsky @msn.corr>. "piisadesa')aoý.com" <Palisadesart*aolcom> Ulrich Witle
<ulrich~ul~chwitte cOre>
,. 0A-I 1; . -
- v~?Ni~~. xL tr Page 5'01 Av !~ rwopr enmaH in: a u W.Test 'r"&- ea:icSentJounnInz-,s Frsi~a. Mxa-t-r 2(108 s;Ienoe x, ob" twnn r cnumerits~mn d-m e anci
'Mrit arQ the Pedotiners Wastcnestor C.Azers Awarnqn \ ork Q t( Rocklantd Cour'-, Const.rvtor Associatimi. inc. ;,RCCA), ?utblic H-kahh and Susmainaldl Energ (PHSE)Sierria Cliub - Adlntic Chpa (kr-a C.UI~ and New York Sraue Assernniymnr P.chiard W.l~osky Repl Brief I gr "st u:otheAtomic Safiie'xi -noicnsmm Board 0rder of M.I~arcIh '7200&S Az prevo' ljsl4rý pa~-os 0111 snix totr -ý OFIC Secretary aS r w o .rcSf-B id 1.20.ada n akim nl pane; eor was naild wntLI0hccForune fur e NHC Staff'.
Sarah L. \aenor
- ;. 3.21.08 WestCAN Re;ly to ASLB Order 3.7.08.zip Sarah Wagner <sarahwagqeresq@gmail,com> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 10:34 AM To Zachary Kan c ahnnýnrz. ov>
Dear Mr Kahn:
I re-se all tWe ocum.. Z. all the parties in a zip flclerý Please let me know if I should submit another -
certifica'fe of service. The same documents were sent by email today and by email on Friday. March 21. 2008 to all Ve same arties. Thus. if I dc not hear from you. I will assume that the certificate of service originallv sent is sufficient.
if ycu cannot oper the "t> "oider or any of the documents. I can mail you a paper copy or rry to seno the documents separately Thank you for your cocporration.
Sincerely.
Sarah L. Wagner On 33211. Zachary Ka,-inZacharsKahr~nr-,: wrote
(ijail - Par 2 \V.esICAN's Reply to ASLB Order 3.7.I) Page 1 of 6 G ,Sarah 'sarahwagneresqgmail.com> Wagner Part 2 WestCAN's Reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 15 messages Sarah Wagner <sarahwagnerasq@gmail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:49 PM To: LGMi@nrcgov. OCAAMA:L@nrc.cov. OCAA-MAIL Resource <OCAAMAIL.Resource@nrc.gov>.
REW@nrc.gov, KDL2@nrc.gov. zxkl@rrcogov "hearingdocf;et@nrz.gov" <HearingDocket~nrc.gov>. Hearing Docket <Hearing. Docket@n' z,ov>. Ulrich VWitte <ulrch@uirichwitte comr>, "paiisadesar.t@ao.com"
<Palisadesart@aol.coM>. Ric-_ard Brodsky <richardbrodsky@msn.corn>. "Dennis. William" Swdennis@entergy .com,>, "Gruene. Manna" <rnannajo@ciearwnater.org>. "Pruyne. Justin"
<edp3@westchestergov corn>. "Sutton, Kathryn" ;zksutton@morrganlewis.com>. "Bessette, Paul"
<pbessettemorganlewis.corre>, "O'Neill, Martin" <martin.o'neill@nmorganlewis.com>, "Delaney, Michael"
<mdelaney@nycedc corn>, "0 Neill, Daniel" <vob@bestweb.net>. "LeKay, John" <fuseusa@yahoo.cornm>
"Kremer. Arthur" <ajkrerner@rrnfpc.com>. "Kremer(2), Arthur" <kremer area-alliance~org>, "Sipos, John"
<Johrn.Sipos@gag. state.nyus' Joan Matthews <jlmatthe@gw.dec.state.ny.us>, "Snook, Robert"
<rober'tsnook@po. state ct us, "Curran. Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran.comr-, "Musegaas, Phillip"
<pnillip@riverkeeper org>, "Tafur, Victor" <vtafurLriverkeeper org>, "Riesel. Daniel" <driesel@sprlaw corn>.
"Steinberg. Jessica" <Jsteinberg@sprlaw.com>, "Burton, Nancy" <NancyBurtonCT@aol.com>' "Zoli. Elise"
<ezoli@gobdwinprocter corn> anice..dea.n 'oag. state. ny.us, mylan. Denerstein@oag, state. ny us Kimberly.Sexton@nrc.gov. Sh.'rwin Turk <Sherwin.Turk@nrc gov>. Christopher Chandler@Arc gov.
Beth.Mizuno@nrc.gov. Davyd.Roth@nrc.gov. lloyd subin@nrc.gov, "Parker. John Louis"
<jlparker@gw.dec. state. ny.us,-. Marcia Carpentier <marcia. Carpentier@nrc.gov>
Re Indian , oint license Ren:eý.dal, Docket No.* -C2._86-RL
- T'o \hon It Ma' Concern:
\,rtach d please fRnd Petifibner- \Vestchesicr Ci'ii~n's Awareness N.twork (WesICAN). Rockland Counti Cons-rvation
%ssoc tiori, Inc. `RCCA , F'utiic Health and Sustainable Encriev (PHASE). Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club).
411d N,-w oi-rk SPar A in Richard L Prodskv R'piv [Trief in response to the Atomic Satfen, and Licern;ing Bo ard COrder oa NMIrch Paper conies are nh bein"s P2b h ff',Yict of the Secrelar\. as reequired bx the ASLB Io the
'der cif "'brry I, OS ( :mi a second paper copy ib being mailed Ch ro f ounsil for thc NRC( taif Ai ofC, I will be sendin"4 two 'mai'.ý t,." include all ,he exh hbi'tI ou can:o', ,,pe nao, of the attachments. ni-ase tomati, ie.
8 attachments
-w 3.21.08 Exhibit C- Email 12_53 am 2.156.08.pdf 21K 3.21.08 Exhibit DCover letter February 15 hardcopy transmittal[1].pdf 3.21,08 Exhibit Ecover letterCD-ROM table of contents and exhibits.pdf
Gmrail - Pan '2\XcstCAN', F'cply IoASI.B COrdcr i)S P a 2 C-22(Ž 01- 6
"* 1245K
- 3.21.08 Exhibit F Part I REDLINED OCUMENT.pdf 551-
, 3.21.08 Exhibit F Part 2 WORD DOCUMENT.pdf 173K 3.21.08 Exhibit GWE 3TCAN REVISED 2ND CERT OF SERVICE 3.7.08.pdf 58K 3.21,08 - Exhibit H WestCAN receipts.doc 4761K
- 3.21.08 Exhibit I Email from Atty Turk 2.1 5.08.pdf 43K Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To: sarahwagneresqgmala am This is a" automatically gererated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the foliowing recipient failed permanently:
Christop.er.Cb.a dlerq@ rc coy Technical details of permarent failure:
PERMFAILURE: SMTP E 'or (state 16) 552 #5.3 4 message size exceeds limit
-Originalmessage Received- by 10 140.12H.1 I with SMTP id al I mr1617506rvd.232.120613'2 5824537.:.
Fri, 2 Mar 2008 13 49 42 -0700 (PDT)
Received: by ,,..- ,14.014., ' with HTTP; Fri. 21 Mar 2008 1,2:493"9 -0700 (PDT)
Message-ID: <983c6_1 e .0_8031 ý_349S6338a4bc Cf5de-54@ 0.mail u.naoiLcorn>
Date: Fri 21 Mar 2008 1 :9 39 -0400 From, "Sarah Wagner" <-s.rahwagt¢esg[.mai.corn>
To: L.GM.1.@._nrq .ov.
OCk.-,JL@ cgaov, "OCAAMAIL ,Resourcc-- <OCAAA[IL Resource@nrc.,gyov>. PEW .r.c.gx,'
"hnearngdcke@nrr v" "<Hear.nq2ocket.'Kt@nrc cy>.
"Hearing Docket" <He., 3ring Doc_*et~n'c goy.
"Ulrich Witte" <uiric, ', ulicrhWitt_.comrn>
"calisadesa.,rtt.aol.conr'" <Paiisadesat @ ao. corn-*',
"Richard Brodsky" .ric'ardb.osky.mSn. .om-=
"Dennis. William" <'i n._{en.ergy corina.,
"Greene. Manna" <-Z1anaJo.cleaaatero.rg.
"Pruyne, Justin" <irp (vescne.teroov "Sutton, Kathryn" <WSittonoroanlewls com>
"Bessette. Paul" <.besette@mor.anlewis conM>,
"O'Neill. Martin" <marrin. o'n iM,.gr~iewis. . corn "Delaney; Michael" <r.,de-janev@nycedccor>
"O'Neill, Daniel" <vob 5 bestweb.net>.
"LeKay. John" <fuse isa @ah.oo,.o.-nr>,
"Kremer. Arthrr" < . rer.rn~f .ca.
"Kreme-r(2 A.rithur <'--?-Z@arealLance q>
ic"S vie Jo :"<J.. " '<-o s ... .. .
"Sn,.c Robert"' < . ,' ) t-
..... m , ....-. 1"--,r.-' .i ,i,,-,,-.:, , , . -'-b-,
... T;1."_. 4
Cimail - Part 2 WestCAN's I1\`vpt to ASLB (rder 3. 7.08 Pale 9 ol h "Musegaas. Philici" <chil.ip riverkeener.or;>,
"Tafur. Victor" <vtafur'ý)tnverkeper.r>,
"Riesel.o Daniefl <drie_ s. *spriaw~com;,>
"Steinberg Jessica" <.t-i t.-rgprjawcorn;>
"Burton. Nancy" <Nan v, rtonCT@ao. corn->
'Zon, Eiise" <e'oi': goovr *rocter.co m>
Lanice.deanpoag sat, y__g.us5 r.y.Denersteiht*oag state ny.us.
K__n~berl.*Sexton~nr_.zg "Sherwin Turk" <Sherwin.Turk@n_& .gg;,
.Christopher.Chan~diKer.@r'2cv, Beth. Miz un o@nr~cov.
"Parker, John Louis' <jk'ark~er@gw_.dec._..state._ n,.US>.
"Marcia Carpentier" <m.rcia Carentfir@.0_cc.aov>
Subject:
Part 2 WestCAN's Reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 MIME-Version: 1_0 Content-Type: rultjpart,'mixeý.
boundary= Part 1282 4828291. 120613-2581826"
- Part1282 48282r 1.1206132581826 Ccntent-Type: multipartialtenative-boundary="--.. Part._ 1783_2540291.1206132581827"
-- _--- Par_ 1283_2 54*0-"9... 1205132581827 Content-Type. tex;ptain; charset=ISO-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Disposition: inline Re, indian Point License Renewal. Docket No 50-247/286-LR
-Message truncated-Mail Delivery Subsystem <riailer-daemon@googlemaiL.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To: saranwagneresq@g!,mnail.mr This is an automatically .nererated Deliver- Status Notification Delivery to the following recipient failed permanently:
Hea*ng.Qocket(n3nrc..,Dv Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnailer-daemon@googlemaii.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmail.com This is an automatically -je ierated Delivery Status Notification Delivery t* the following re.ioient failed permanently Mail Delivery Subsystem <railer-daernon@googlemail.corn> Fri, Mar 21. 2008 at 4:50 PM To sarpah'waneresc;e:.z,-- ;tv! .corn This is an auron'a.~i.a~l,:, ze.nerate* Deiiverv Status .Notfcatior,
(1imail - Pant 2 \VceStC'AN>. Rpeiv to ASL-B Order 370 Paa gt 4 of:'
DeiVe~ to the fciwn n! r ae ornrrl ci r Inrc. cv Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To sarahwagneresq@gmai com This -s an autormatica@4 en~ir3ted Delivery Status Notification Deivery to the followimn r,.-*lcer. fariec ,ermanentlv David fQ)I- zI\.)_
- Pthnr.
Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: safahwagneresq@gna;!.ccm This is an automatically generated Delivery- Status Notification Deiivery to the following recopient failed perrnarnently,
! r-rc glov RE.'*..
Mail Delivery Subsystem <rrnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmail orn This is an automatically c.-rerated Delivery, Status Notification Delivery to the following .recipient failed permanently.
KDL2(Snr~c~goov
'Mail Delivery Subsystem <mrailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwaaneresq@gmai. ...:or This is ar automatically generated Deiivery Status Notification Deiivery t,-,, the following re-cqpient failed permanently Sherwin .Turki~nrc g_9 Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq~gmnail z;or ncSS anr3' atD m a ialHy 'ie-,eratd Delivervy Sta.u N, iiza,10o1 zne~~ ~~~~nIwicrcen ae rane it v k
- -7 c~f. x 8d3 0bI 6a & sv~a,,- I
Gimall - Part] sCA~.R ci to' A&L.B (.)rdur37fi p ":I Lýýfý 0 1 6 Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To sara 1wagneresqz)gmai ce TIý,s'*San a-iomaiicali; cený:ratec'Deliver)y Status Nctification Delivery tc the following rech:iet failed. permanen,:lv fLoyocsu~pin(q)n~rC ooV Mail Delivery Subsystem <rrailer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwaoneresq@gmail cnm This s an automaticalv oereraied Deihvery Status Notification Deiverv tc ;ollowing recz foe ýent faioed permanen.n Mail Delivery Subsystem <piailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmail, corn This is an automatically gerierated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to tne folkwing -e-biieni failed permanently:
Beth~i _~uonr~
Mail Delivery Subsystem <:Tiaiier-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To sarahwagneresqgigmail com This is an automatically generated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following recipient failed permanently:
K.i'mber-l,y Sex.1t.n::,n;i'.':
Mail Delivery Subsystem c mailer-daemonegooglemail.com> Fri, Mar.21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To, sarahwagqneresqi gmai corn This is ar auTomatically o:nerated Deiivery Status Notification Delivery to the foliowinc u-.cipient failed permanently:
Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnaiier-daemon@gooylemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM
'~~ r'itw &~
cSc~8~~~ .. -tI .> 0 (8,
r2 Wc'stCAN's R::plv to ASLB Order 3T.7.u8 GCnia-i - Pan Paue 6 of 6 To sarahwaqneresqt,9.mnaih.l o-rTis s an automafiCa2kV Pe'.e a ere,Status Notifization Deiiverv to the followvin re:zi.ient failed permanentY pO.C_,A,,*,4".L.,Res ourz*-e nr ":.oov
,.... \I . I cSs 4 ]
nimail - Retur-ned maill set: tr~inscripi For detailsPaj Page1 1 01f1 oI Gij Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
Returned mail: see transcript for details rmessaoe Fri, Mar 21. 2008 at 4:50 Mail Delivery Subsystem <MAILER-DAEMON@chiesmtal-5.messageone.com> PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmaiU corn
-The following addresses had permanent fatal errors
<mdyeaneey.g. q m>edc~com" (reason: 552 mail, yceac. om: your message size exceeds maximum inbound size of 10240 kilobytes)
.... Transcript of session follows ---
.. while talking to [.,42.1. I:
>>> MAIL From:<sarahwa geresq.@gmaio.pom> SIZE=10949576
<<< 552 maiL.nycedc.co*n.m your message size exceeds maximum inbound size of 10240 kilobytes 554 5.0.0 Service unavailable Final-Recipient RFC822. m,.eiany@nyzedcc.m Ac-aon: failed Status: 5.34 Diagnostic-Code: SMTP, 552, 'maii.nycedoca.Cmý your message size exceeds maximum inbound size of 10240 kilobytes Last-Attempt-Date: Fr;, 21 fVar 2008 13,50,21 -0700 7-, noname
. OK
Gmn-tiI - LiiexSutius Noni ication (faiitirc PaLý,-,
Pc 1 Ioof' I Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmaiI.com>
Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
I message postmaster@postatexct.us <,postmaster@po.state.ct.us> Fri, Mar 21,2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gma I.comr This is an automaticaliv gen.rated Delivery Status Notification.
Delivery to the following reci:,ients failed Rober:w Snook~d:oc.szate -t~us Final-Recipient: rfc822. Robert SnookC .p _state..¢L uS Action: failed Status: 5.2.3 X-Display-Name: Snook. Rcbert D, i ,4%Z'y *ý .,d
, ,Z'
,- .,-4 ),
G'mail - Deiixerv Staiis Noti .iizaton PTail1Urt` Pa~ie 1 01 1 GIk1I Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmaiLcom>
Delivery Status Notification (Failure) 1 message postmaster@harmoncurran.com <postmaster@harmoncurran.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:56 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmaii-com Th~s is an automatically genetrated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following rec¶)ients failed.
dgurranLrharmpncurran qorn Final-Recipient rfcS22:dcur~an@hbarronCurran. com Action: failed Status: 5.2-3 X-Display-Name: Diane Cu~ran N
I .. . - . -.. I -,,
&~ &dS OC~ l 94~bbTt~Q s.~... 4 1..20'S
Gniail - F-AhibitsPaeIf PaL_,e 'I of'I Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
Exhibits message Kaye Lathrop <klathrop@inciependence.net> Fri. Mar 21. 2008 at 7:23 PM To: sarahwagneresq0gmaicm I received one email with 5 attachments including Exhibits A and B Please try sending the emai's with any remaining exhibits to this email address-it has at least 15 mb capacity
- ~~ .2 Z .
Gnmil - Z11- Viic BlockinML) ei AS.1 ()ckr37I toWsCN Pau( I ol' Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmai.com>
ZiP File Blocking - Re: WestCAN reply to ASLB Order 3.,70'8 I message exadmin~ente~rgy.com <exadmnin@entergy.comn> Mon. Mar 24, 2008 at 10:31 AM To: sa IraI wagneresq~gmait'!c r-m The container files*: 3,21 Oc 0 WestCAN Reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08.zlit were deleted The original attac;.hment was biocked from delivery due to current attachment blocking rules. If you wisn to send a container file, please renam;3 the file extension to an unknown extension.
(irail -,W\'esICAN reply tW ASLB Order 3.7,08 Page I ot 4 Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
WestCAN reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 6 messages Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmait.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:59 PM To: "Snook, Robert" <robert.snrak@po.statect.us>, "Delaney, Michael" <mdelaney@nycedc.com>,
Christopher.Chandler@nrc.gov, "Curran, Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran.com>
Cc. Sherwin Turk <Sherwin.uT rk@nrc.gov>, "hearinadocket@nrc.gov" <HearinaDocket@nrc-gov>, Hearing Docket <Hearing.Docket@nr-c. gov>, Richard Brodsky <richardbrodsky@msn.com>, "palisadesart@aolcom"
<Pairsadesart@aol com>. OCOAAMAIL(cnrcgov. OCAAMA1L Resource <OCAAMAIL Resource@nrc.gov>
Dear Sir or Madam:
I attempted to email you two separate emails containing Petitioners' WestCAN et al.'s reply to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Crder of 3/7!08. 1received notification that the email was not deliverable due to the size of the emaiis or that delivery of the email failed. Please contact me if you would like me to re-send the emails. Please advise what your megabits size limitation is. Thank you.
Sincerely,
. F, 7 -4 Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 5:00 PM To: Laweence McDade <Lawrence. McDade@nrcgov>, Marcia Carpentier <marcia.Carpentier@nrc.gov>
KDL2@nrc gov. zxkl@nrc gciv, "O'Neill, Martin" <martin.o'neill@morganlewiscom>, "Sutton, Kathryn"
< ksutton@morganlewis.coanI, Zachary Kahn <Zachary.Kahn@nrc.gov> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 5:12 PM To: Sarah Wagner <sarahw'z gneresq@gmail.com>
Ms. Wagner -
Would it be possibie tc ,end each exhibit secarete!y? Or perhaps you can zip the documients so they are compressed?
ThanK y/o 1i 1- .r&i;~ ?C'IC'
&v~ .*.. .~2*~;
(Imail - \V'_s!CAN replY tc..ASLB Order 3,.7'.08 ac2f42 of 4 Paue Zac~h Kahn Zachary S. Kahn.
Law Clerk.
Atomic Safety and Licensiig Board United States Nuclear Reciulatory Commission Phone: (301) 415-6754 E-Mail. Zacharr.Ka_@nc.gov From: Sarah Wagner [mailto)sarahwacnereso~a~ma~iico!*]
Sent: Friday, March 21. 2008 5:01 PM (
To: Lawrence McDade; Marzia Carpentierý Kaye Lathrop, Zachary Kahn: O'Neill, Martin: Sutton, Kathryn
Subject:
Fwd: WestCAN re:;iy to ASLB Order 3.7.08 Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 10:31 AM To: Zachary Kahn <Zachary.Kahn@nrc.gov>, LGMl@nrc.gov, OCAAMAIL@nrc.gov. OCAAMAIL Resource
<OCAAMAIL. Resource@nrc.gov>, REW@nrc.gov, "hearingdocket@nrc gov" <HearingDocket@nrc.gyv>,
Hearing Docket <Hearing. Docket nrc.gov>, KDL2@nrc.gov, zxkl@nrcgov, "Dennis, William"
<wdennis@entergy.com>, "G-eene, Manna" <mannajo@clearwater.org>, "Sutton, Kathryn".
<ksutton@morganlewis. corn>, "Bessette, Paul" <pbessette@morganlewiscom>, "O'Neill. Martin"
<mnartin~olneilt@morganlewis. zom>,. "O'Neill, Daniel" <vob@bestweb.net>, "Pruyne. Justin"
<jdp3@westchesterqov.com>, "Delaney, Michael" <mdelaney@nycedc.com>, "LeKay, John"
<fuseusa@yahoo corn>. "Krmer, Arthur" <ajkremer@rmfpc,com>, "Kremer(2), Arthur"' <kremer@area-alliance.org., Joan Matthews <jimatthe@gw.dec.state. ny. us>, "Sipos, Johnr" <John.Sipos@oag state.rny.us>,
"Curran. Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran.com>. "Snook. Robert" <robert.snook@po.state.ct.us>. "Museaaas Phillip" <philiip@riverkeeper.,r.>, "Tafur, Victor" <vtafur@.riverkeeper.org>, "Riesel, Daniel' odr esel@sprlaw.com>r "S:ei,%berg Jessica" Kjsteinbergxsprlaw.com>. "Zoli, Elise"
.<ezolicgoodwinprocter.ccrn:., "Burton. Nancy" <NancyBurtonCT*ao!.corn>, anice. dean@cag.state.ny us.
mvian.Denerstein@,oag state ry.us. KimbelySexton@nrc gic. Sherwin Turk <Sher.win Turk@'nrc.9ov>.
Chst-pher.Ch dtie'rc ,:-v_BethMizunonrCo.gov, David.Roth@nrc.gov, iovd.subininrc.gav. "Parker. john Louis" <jiparer gw.dec.state.ny us> Marcia Ca:pertier <marcia Carcentier()nrc -ov>. Richar- Broosk'
<:richardbr-o sky vrmsn or-'> 'paiisadesar,@ao!.ccm" :Palisa esart(qaol.zrn, Ulrich /itte
1 ... : ~ ~-.~mI S '~Tb~iS~sa.....(05ý
Gmratil - %VtsiCA.Nreply to ;1_S'LB Ordei-..8Pae~o PaL,.cý 3 of 4 RI: Indian Point License Renzw-wa, Docket No. 50-247 286-LR To Nhorn
, It MaY Concern:
Due to tdh size of the documz.nt ; sent or Friday. March 21.. 008. 1 anm resendine the same files that were contw'ained in tile " o par Imail in I Zip fil'. I-nes* Cocuments although exactil th! same as the documents sent Friday, March 2 2008. supersede an% other vhcci onic documents submitled. The. attached are th. -Peitioners Westchest-r Citizen's A'wareness Network (WeXstC.VN', Rockland Counrm Conscrvation Association. Inc. (RCCA). Public I.Health and Sus!tainable En~erev,-, (PHASE. a Clut - Atlantic Chaptur (Sierra Club). and Newk York S-ate Assembivman Richard L. Brodskx. Re:pl. Brief In re.;pcnse to the Atomic Saferx and 1 icensint' Board Order ofMha 7. _200S.
As previously s-,taed, paper cop es were only sent to the. Office of tie Secrctar.+/-- as required b%the ASLB Order of
!:abruar. I 2008. and a n addt*ona! paper copy was mailed to tihe tffifce f Cotulse! for the NRC S.taff.
If you cannot open anm of thct a~tachments, please contact me, Sincerely, Sarah L, Wagrner 3.21.08 WestCAN Reply to ASLB Order 3,7.08.zip 459-19 K Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq~gmaiI.corn> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 10:34 AM To- Zachary Kahn <Zachary +.ahn@nrc gov>
Dear Mr. Kahn' I re-sent all the documen:s to all the parties in a zip folder. Please let me know if I should submit another certificate of service. The same documents were sent by email today and by email on Friday, March 21, 2008 to. all the same parties. Th s. if I do not hear from you. I will assume that the certificate of service originally sent is sufficient If you cannot open the zji. f'lder or any of the documents. I can mail you a paper copy or try to send the documents separately.
Thank you for your coopec-tion.
Sincerely.
Sarah L. Wagner On 3121/08. Zachary Kahn .<_Zacha.v*Kahn_. innrc.-,grc.v> wrote Ulrich Witte <uIrichliuIrichwitte.com> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 11:05AM o: Saran Wagner <sarahwsgneresq(ggmail cor>
Let me guess. . busily do a linebyline. i not word by wor d co srenwn .... a s.. of the 10 s Gooc-IIJ 10,-, You* su..cessfull. ttid 1 Jp for dnays ,,a S-.r.~~ C-li
-"] 2** ':)S:
Gmail - W\esiCAN reply to L.SLB Order 3.7.08a PaLge 4 of"4 B.t w. i offered to draft a n-tion to modify the proceedings to subpar, G to Susan this morning. Any concerrs- Dis you oe:-fire a-pea!?
-Urich From: Sarah Wagner lmna ltc:saranwagrriesq@g.ma..il.com.-
Sent: Monday, March 24, 2C08 10:31 AM To: Zachary Kahn, LGM1tr!r..ao__.vv: OCAA MAIL@nercggogy: OCAAMAIL Resource, REWd_.nrcgov:
e.ardo.ke@lnrc-pv Heiring Docket: KDL2@nrc.gay, z xk.@ý{c__ngov: Dennis, William, Greene. Manna:
Sutton, Kathryn. Bessette Paul O'Neill, Martin, O'Neill, Daniel- Pruyne,. Justin. Delaney, Michael: LeKay.
John: Kremer. Arthur, Kremer 2), Arthur; Joan.Matthews: Sipos. John, Curran, Diane; Snook,, Robert:
Musegaas, Phillip, Tafur, /ictor, Riesel, Daniel; Steinberg, Jessica: Zoli. Elise: Burton, Nancy; janice.deanoac state n.yu'g. mvlan.Denerstein0ag_.state *ny u.S KimberlnSexton@nrc.aov, Sherwin Turk Christooer.Chandlern@nrc :cv: BethMizuno_@nrq. ov: David Rqoth-@nr0cgo. iloyd_ ibjo nrc.gov: Parker.
Jonn Louis; Marcia Carpentiar; Richard Brodsky; p*ljsadesarti@a.lcomý Ulrich Witte
Subject:
Re: WestCAN reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 c{mi~ l'u1&:~i~:
'd~I '~\\V~n 118e13Ci(NJ C~76
Gmail - FW: VestC.AN~s Re',)I\ to the ASIB Order 3,7.08 Pa~ oi2 PieI) 1 Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
FW: WestCAN's Reply to the ASLB Order 3.7.08 1 message Ulrich Witte <uIrich@ulrichwitte.com> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
From: Sarah Wagner lmailth.sarahwa neresq,.mail comm Sent: Friday. March 21..2008 4:44 PM To: L GM 1MnrC oov; OCAAMAIL@Lrc ov. OCAAMAIL Resource, hearingdock t*nrq.ga.v: Hearing Docket:
REW@jnrcgov: KDL2n-.. gov; zxk1.@a rcngoo; Dennis. William; Greene, Manna; Pruyne, Justin; Sutton, Kathryn; Bessette, Paul; O'Neill, Martin;. Delaney, Michael; LeKay, John; Kremer, Arthur;Kremer(2), Arthur:
O'Neill. Daniel; Sipos. John:. Joan Matthews, Curran, Diane: Snook, Robert; Musegaas. Phillip: Tafur. Victor, Riesel, Daniel: Steinberg. Jessica; Burton, Nancy' Zoli, Elise; ianice.denan@pagstate;n,.us
.n rt_ KiLberfy .Soxt o@nfgoy,; Sherwin Turk-Christopie-.Chand.er@!ýco: fteth..Mizuno,@nrqc liQyd.subi.@nrcgay n, .Dagd y:.@nm.gov Parker.
John Louis, Richard Brocsk.¢: Ulrich Oitte, p.l..adesa.t*ao.corn
Subject:
WestCAN's Reply to the AS'LB Order 3.7.08 Re: Indian Point License Renewal. Docket No 50-247:286-LR To Whom It May Concern.
Attached please find Petiticners Westchester Citizen's Awareness Network (WestCAN), Rockland County
,Conservation Association, inc. (RCCA), Public Health and Sustainable Energy (PHASE), Sierra Club -
Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Clut), and New York State Assemblyman Richard L. Brodsky Reply Brief in response to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Order of March 7, 2008. Paper copies are only being sent to the Office of the Secretary, as required by the ASLB Order of February 1, 2008, and a second paper copy is being mailed to the Office of Counsel for the NRC Staff I will be sending two email s to include all the exhibits lf you cannot open any of the attachments, please contact me Sincerely, 1 ~.. rA~jri :~i~~e8J;t:; 4 S
Ginail - FAW: \kkestC.-N's R Ivto the ASLB Order 3,.708Pa. Pae'c 2 of 2-Leca! Counsel for Assembiyman Richard L. Brodsky LO B Room 422 Albany, N Y. 12241 518-455-5753 5 attachments 3.21.08. COS.pdf 42K, 3.21.08 TABLE OF CONTENTS.pdf 14K 3.21,08 REPLY TO ASLB ORDER3.7.08.pdf 53K
- 3.21.08 Exhibit A Word copy of WestCANReply Brief Final_ 211].15.08..pdf 475K 3.21.08. Exhibit B EmaiV with Adobe copy of Re~ply_BriefFinal_ 211].1 5.08..pdf 68K 16.1 & 8SJS~S~.3Ac.
Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresqgmail.comr>
WestCAN reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 6 messages Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:59 PM To: "Snook, Robert" <robe t. snook@po.state.ct us>. "Delaney, Michael" <mdeianey@nycedc.com>,
Christopher. Chandler@nrc. .gov, "Curran. Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran~com>
Cc- Sherwin Turk <Sherwjh. Turk@nrc.gov>, "hearingdocket@nrc.gov" <HearingDocket@nrc.gov>.
Hearing Docket <Hearing.DAocket@nrc gov>, Richard Brodsky <richardbrodsky@msn.com>.
'palisadesart@aol.com' ,;'alisadesan@raoi.com>-. OCAAMAI L@nrc.gov. OCAAMAIL Resource
<OCAAMAIL.Resourcee:Dir:: gov>
Dear Sir or MaCam:
I attempted to email VOL tw'o separate emails containing Petitioners' WestCAN et al.'s reply to the Atomic Safety and Licer sing 8oard Order of 3.7!08 1 received notification that the email was not deliverable due to the size of the emails or that delivery of the email failed. Please contact me if you would like me to re-send the emails. Please advise what your megabits size limitation is. Thank you, Sincerely.
Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmait.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 5:00 PM To: Lawrence McDade <..awrence.McDade@nrc gov-,, Marcia Carpentier <marcia.Caroentier@nrc.g.ov>.
KDL2@nrc.gov. zxkl@n',c.gov, "O'Neill, Martin" <martin o&neill@morganiewis. com>, "Sutton, Kathryn"
<ksutton@morganlewis.com>
Zachary Kahn <Zachary.Kahn@nrc.gov> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 5:12 PM To: Sarah Wagner <saranjwagneresq@gmail.comn'.
Ms. Wagner -
,.,Wuld be oossible to send each exhibit Or perh'as you can zip 0-cara-ely'. e*.
c ;umetms so me,.i ;::-re compressed?
Thank you Zacn Kahn Zacnary S. Kahn Law Clerk Atomic Safety and Licansing Board United States Nucleai Regulatory Commission Phone: (301) 415-6c7f4 E-Mail: Zacha~ry.KKa-ýnrc.lov From: Sarah Wagner [riailto: sarahwaaneresc'aorail. cornj Sent: Friday. March 21 2008 5:01 PM To: Lawrence McDace: Marcia Carpentier: Kaye Lathrop. Zachary Kahn, O'Neill, Martin: Sutton, Kathryn
Subject:
Fwd: WestCA4, reply to ASLB Order 3 7,08 Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmaiU.com> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 10:31 AM Toý Zachary Kahn <Zachary.Kahn@nrc.gov>, LGMI@nrc.gov, OCAAMAIL@nrc.gov. OCAAMAIL Resource <OCAAMAI L.-esource@nrc.gov>. REW@nrc.gov, "hearingdocket@nrc.gov"
<HearingDocket@nrc. gov>, Hearing Docket <Hearing. Docket@nrc.gov>, KDL2@nrc. gov, zxk l@nrc gov, "Dennis, William" <wdenris@entergy.com>. "Greene, Manna" <mannajo@clearwater.org>, "Sutton.
Kathryn" <ksutton@morganlewis.com>, "Bessette, Paul" <pbessette@morganlewis.com>, "O'Neill, Martin" <rrartin.o'neill@rnorrganlewis.com>, "O'Neill, Daniel" <vob@bestweb, net>, "Pruyne, Justin"
<jdp3@westchestergov.comr>, "Delaney, Michael" <mdelaney@nycedccom>, "LeKay, John"
<fuse_usa@yahoc corn>. "Kremer. Arthur" <ajkremer@rmfpc.com>, "Kremer(2), Arthur" <kremer@area-alliance.org>. Joan Matttews <jlrnatthe@gw.dec.state.ny.us>, "Sipos, John"
<John.Sipos@oag.state.- y,us>, "Curran, Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran.com>, "Snook. Robert"
<rober.snook@pc. stare. :t us>, "Musegaas. Phillip" <phillip@riverkeeper.org>. 'Tafur, Victor"
<vtafuir@riverkeePer o-g:-., "Riesel, Daniel" <driese l@sprlawcorn>, "Steinberg. Jessica"
<;steinbera@spriaw.com>, "Zoli, Elise" <ezoii5go:*dwimprocter..com>. "Burton. Nancy"
<Nanc~yButonCT'ao!.cfr)m>. ianice.deancoag.stateny. us, ryianDenerstein@oag. state.r,'vLs.
Kimberly.Sexton(nirr-gck Sherwin Tu"k <She-wi,.", Turk@nrc.gzv:'. Christcpher ChandlerQnrc.o9v.
Beth.Mizunotnr-.gov Lavic.Rmoth(nrc.gov. I~oyd subingnrcagov, "Parker, John Louis"
<ilparkerQgw~decstt -y.us- Marcia Carpentier arciaCarpentiert9@nrc.gov>. Richard Bro'Iskv
<richardDrodsky,,:rmsr ,->. "palisadesa,,-@aol corn" <PatlsadesartC~aol.com>, Jirich Witte
<urInch..muiricnwirte .corm -
Re: india., Poin'. ' cn e P. .-n.c l ,,!' .. Nr ock 7.
To Whom 11Nia,-C',cc re Due to the size of tnh-doomw 'nu sent on Friday, March 21.2 008, i am resending the same fiiesuthal were contained in the iwo pan te-ai! in a zip file. These documents although exactly tOe same as the docunments sent Friday, March 2 1. 2008. su:)rsede any other electronic documents submitted. The attached are the Petitioners N-estchest r Citizen's Awar-ness Network (WestCAN). Rockland County Conservation Association. Inc.
.RCCA), Public Health anc Sustainable Energy (PIASE). Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club". and New York State Assemblvraan Richard L. Brodskv Repty Brief in responst to the Atomic Safery and Licen.sine_
Board Order of March 72)G8.
-As previousIv state& paper .opies were o(]l\ sent It) the Office of the Secretar.. as as required te ASLB Order of Februar. I. 2008. ant : additional paper copy was mailed to the )(f'ice of Counsel for the NRC Staff.
I!\'(U Caflnot o0', -T;\ Of' lc attachments. please contacllat lne,.
Sincerely.
Sarah L. Wainer 3*21.08 WestCAN Reply tc ASLB Order 3i7,08.zip 4519K Sarah Wagner <sarahwa!gneresq@_.gmai.comr> Mon, Mar 24, 2008 at 10:34 AM
- o. Zachary Kahn <Zacna-y.KahnPnrc gov>
Dear Mr. Kahn.
Ire-sent all the documents to all the parties in a zip folder. Please let me know if I should submit another certificate of service. The same documents were sent by email today and by email on Friday, March 21, 2008 to all the same parties. Thus, if I do not hear from you, I will assume that the certificate of service criginally sent is sufficient.
If you cannot open the zp folder or any of the docuuments. I can mail you a paper copy or try to send the documents seoarately Thank you for yojr coo. eration.
Sincerely, Sarah L. Wagner On 3/21!D8; Zachary Kahn <'Zacharv.Kahr(d)nrc.aov> wrote:
a.l - Par .... eply to ASLB Ordekr 3,7.08 Paue I of46 G
- t Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
Part 2 WestCAN's Reply to ASLB Order 3.7.08 16 messages Sarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmaiL.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:49 PM To: LGM I anrc.gov_ OCAAM-IL@nrc.gov, OCAAMAIL Resource <QCAAMAIL. Resource@nrc.gov>.
REW@nrc.gov. KDL2@nrc.gcv,, zxkl@nrc..gov, "hearingdocket@nrcgov" <HearingDocket@nrc gov>. Hearing Docket <Hearing.Docket@rrc gov>, Ulrich Witte <uirich@ulrichwittecorn>, "palisadesart.aoi.cor"
<PaIisadesart@aol.com>. Ricl-;ard Brodsky <richardbrodsky@msn corn>, "Dennis. William" cWdennhs~entergy~corn>, "Gr~ene, Manna" <mannajoqciearwater.org>. "Pruyne. Justin"
<jdp3@wesTchestergov.com> "Sutton. Kathryn" <ksutton@morganiewis.com>> "Bessette. Paul"
<pbessette rmorganlewis.coran>, "O'Neill, Martin" <ma.-tin.o'neill@morganlewis. corn> "Delaney, Michael"
<rndelaney @Liyrcedc.cn>. "C'Neifl Daniel" <vob@bestweb.net>, "LeKay, John" <fuse_usa@yahoo.com>,
"Kremer, Arthur" <ajkremer@rmfpc.com>, "Kremer(2), Arthur" <kremer@area-alliance.org>, "Sipos, John"
<John. Sipcs@oag. state. ny. us >. Joan Matthews <jlmatthe@gw.dec. state. ny. us>. "Snook, Robert"
<robert.snook@po.state.ct.us.>, "Curran, Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran.com>, "Musegaas. Phillip"
<phillipgriverkeeperlorg>, "Tafur, Victor" <vtafur@riverkeeper.orgp, "Riesel, Daniel" <driesel@sprIaw.com>,
"Steinberg,, Jessica' <jsteinbe' .@sprlawcom>, "Burton. N~ncy" <NancyBurtonCT@aoI.com>, "Zoli, Elise"
<ýezoli@goodwinprocter.corn> janice dean@oag.state. ny.us, mylan .Denerstein@oag.state. ny. us Kimberly Sexton@nrc gov, Sherwin Turk <Sherwin.Turk@nrc.gov>, Christopher.Chandler@nrc.gov, Beth.Mizuno@nrc.gov, David Roth@nrc gov lloyd.subin@nrc gov, "Parker, John Louis"
<jlparker@gw.dec. state.ny.us:, Marcia Carpentier <marcia.Carpentier@nrc.gov>
Re: indian Point License R'neval. Dock-ei No. 5 -24 7.,28 -LR To.Whoim It May Concern:
A'tached please find Petitioners Westchesier Citizen's Awareness Network (WestCAN)i, Rockland Countv Conservation Association, Inc. (RCCA), Pullie Health and Sustainable Energy (PHASE), Sierra Club - Atlantic Chapter (Sierra Club),
and New York State Assembl., man Richard L. Brodskyc Reply Brief in response to the Atomic Safery and Licensing Board Order of March 7, 2008. Paper copies are only being sent to the Office of the Secretarvy. as required by the ASLB
- Ordero, February 1, '008, and a second paper copy is being mailed to the Office of Counsel for the NRC Staff.
I. will be sding ,:wo email.s I. include all the exhibits Ifvou cannot open an\. of the attachments, please contact me.
8 attachments
, 3.21.08 Exhibit C- Email 12_53 am 2.156.08.pdf 21K zw- 3.21.08 Exhibit D_Coter letter February 15 hardcopy transmittal[1].pdf 3.21.08 Exhibit Ecover letter CD-ROM table of contents and exhibits.pdf
, "' - , i, c .....', . .,, =:; - 1 1c-h..- rS. ,, .. 44.' 1 2008 iJ-ix
Ginil - Part 2 Reply to ASLB Order ,.7.08o ResiC.N'. P aue 2. o f 6 I .2" 1245K
-- 3.21.08 Exhibit F Part 1 REDLINED OCUMENT.pdf 557K 3.21.08 Exhibit F Part 2 WORD DOCUMENT.pdf 173K w-,* 3.21.08 Exhibit G WESTCAN REVISED 2ND CERT OF SERVICE 3.7.08.pdf 58K 3.21.08 - Exhibit H WestCAN receipts.doc 4761K 3.21.08 Exhibit I Email from Atty Turk 2.15.08.pdf 43K Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To: sarahwagneresq~gmai'!c m This is an automatically gen*,rated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following recipient failed permanently:
Qbhistopher.ChandlegZn'zýr.goyo Technical details of permanant failure-PERM-FAILURE: SMTP Error (state 16): 552 #5.3.4 message size exceeds limit Original message-Received: by -1Q. 140. 1'28**1 'with SMTP idal a1mr1617506red.232.1206132582453:
Fri, 2" Mar 2008 13149 42 -0700 (PDT)
Received: by .IQ!4 _-.-1l with HTTP; Fri. 21 Mar 2008 13149:39 -0700 (PDT)
Message-ID: <983 61eb98 D3211349s63;3a4b-iS.. ccf5de,.4566@maiL.mailorm>
Date. Fri, 21 Mar 2008 15:"9 39 -0400 From: "Sarah Wagner" < a'anwaoneresq@gmaiIcorn>
To. LGM nrc.g9oNv, nr gav.
IOCA..AILa "OCAAMAIL Resource' <OCAAMAIL.Resource@nrc.gov>. R.E_ -c~ao, KDL29_r..__g*Lov, z_x_ki,2nprc.gov.
"ea, inqdogket_@nrcg:.v" < HearinaDocket@nrgýy,.
.go>
"Hearing. Docket" <Heqring.Docket(mnr.
"Ulrich Witte" <uiricha'ulrichwitte cor>
"palidesar@aolcom" <Patisadesartoaol corn>,
"Richard Brodsky" <richardbods kymsn.com>,
"Dennis, William" <,vdtmnis@enterfa.com>.
"Greene, Manna" <mapnaaio@ciea.rWater org>.
"Pruyne. Justin" J_3, e orn>.
"Sutton. Kathryn" <ks...onm.r.gaqnlewis corn->.
"Bessette, Pail" <pne ;stte corn>.
rmorcanlewis
__J!.. , . ,.-
g_a. [ :._-
"O'Neill, Martin" <mzart n.o',- _ @mn:.
I morg ntewm cor,>,.
"Delaney, Michael" <nicelaney.@.ny,cedc.com>.
"O'Neill, Daniel" .<v,'b Dbesrweb.net>,
"LeKay. John" <f4. se, >saahoo.corn>
"Kremer. Arthur" <a.r-.mernmL.crn2com>,
"Kremer(2), Arthur" .
"Sipos. John" <John'-' .O'. soac=tate. ny*us>,
"JoanMatthews" <lmI÷t*e!*. w-estte.ny.us>.
"Snook. Robert" o nook' o sat-*c.us>
"Curran. Diane' <dcuvre @arnmn._:.com>
A-v k- I 8 '6O
(irnail - Panr2 %VIsrCAN's Repiv to ASI-3 O.r1lt 7r Pae 3 of 6 "Musegaas. Phillip" <,ilio@riverKeeoer.orc>I
'Tafur. Victor" <vtifurfariv.- pog>.
"Riesel, Daniel" <'zrjse.l _Slprtaw corn>.
"Steinberg. Jessica' <sttýnberaDsopaw.corn>.
"Burton, Nancy .<Nan 3ýBUirtonCT-eaolicomrn>
'Zoih El'se'; !ezolie golwinprotter corn>.
anicg~eg gn@ at rnyiDenerrseint5-,g)o I iageri P5 Kimberly.Sedtb nrcýgv. "Sherwin Turk" <Sherir-urk()nrc.aov;..
Qhristopher Chandler -,imc.gov, Beth. Mizurio@,r.,gov.
David. R.trc.gOv, llcvd.subio .@coev, "Parker. John Louis" <i* arker@tgw~d ate.Qy .us>.
"Marcia Carpentier'" <m*ircia.CaroentierLnrc.govl>
Subject:
Part 2 WestCAN's Reply to ASLB Order 3.7.03 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipartmix*-xd.
bounidary="----= Part _ 1282_4328291.120613258!826"
-- _--- Part_1282_4828291 1206132581826 Content-Type: mu Itipartate native:
boundary="---.. Par._ 1283_2540291.1206132581827'
- Part1283_2540291 1206132581827
=
Content-Type: text'plain. chharset=ISO-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding 7bit Content-Disposition: inline Re' Indian-Point License Renewal, Docket No. 50-247!286-LR Message truncated Mail Delivery Subsystem <riailer-daemon@googlemaiI.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To: sarahwagnere(q@gmail ;-orn This is an automaticaily geierated Delivery Status Notification Celivery to the following reripient failed permanently:
H~earingocke~tn ri_.c c_
Mail Delivery Subsystem <mnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To sarahwagneresqZgmail corn This s ar automattically oeneratecd Delivery Status Notification Delivery tc the following recipient failed permahently.
Hearinev Sbketem<nccgF 2 a Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> .Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM Tc. sara vagnerescr~mai .corn 1 ~ '...i;j., I Q> "'A.-~?VX-1l1="1 ! %~ ~c3F.52Szca~&sc~r... 4 ~
GCiai) - Part 2 WestCAN's Rephy toAS1.B Order 37..08 PUage 4 of 6 Delivery to the following re:*, 'en' failed permanentlyý riarcaa rpentier; nrc.gc;v Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:50 PM To: sarahvagneresq@gmai .cmr This is an automatically generated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the foliowing recimient failed pernanentiy David R-oth@nrc oov Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To sarahwagneresq@gmai: crm This is an auiom,atical gen.-rated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the foliowino rec-o~ent failed permanentyv.
Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmail.com This is an automatically gere-ated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following rec pient failed permanently KDL2~nrc.*gov Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq@grnail,cmrn This is an automatically ge -crated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following -ecipient failed permanently:
Sherwý.n.Turký5nrc a, Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sara.hagneresqgmai..:om This ,s an 3:-,r iman-.al:,
. i.. .d Delivery Statas N3 ca3cn Delivery ;c toe fo"owing e failedprmanm,
.... n ^.o . - - "
Gmail - Part 2 WVesICANN's Reply to ASL Order 3.7.08 Page 5;of'6 Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sararlwagneresq@gmaIi cum This is an automatically generated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following reci:)iert failec permanentiy ovyd ,s-_ýuin_ nrc.QgY Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To. sarahwagneresq@gmail.corm This is an automatically gen.vrated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following reciDbent failed permanently:
"LGM~ .nr~cg_..gV_
Mail Delivery Subsystem <'railer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To sarahý,agneresq@gma.l corn This is an automatically gereýrated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following recoient failed permanently Beth. Mizuno ,cr.gov Mail Delivery Subsystem <mailer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM To: sarahwagneresq@gmail.c-.om This is an automaticallyg ererated Delivery Status Notification Delivery to the following -ecipient failed permanently:
Kirmbl.ýiS.exton 'rc g9v Mail Delivery Subsystem <rlailer-daemon@googlemail.com>
Fri, Mar 21. 2008 at 4:51 PM o: sarahwagneresq@gmail :orn This is an automar4ically gel;erated Delivery Status Notification Delivery 'c the fo.lowin, re,:iient. failed permanently:
Mail Delivery Subsystem <rnailer-daemon@googlemail.com> Fri, Mar 21, 2008 at 4:51 PM
.- r.i.~[ef ~~~~~~~~~~~~k J~<&iwn'~l=
vi.
Cimlail - Par, 2 WkestCAIN';- F-eply to ASLI3 Orier 3.7.09 ~~ 1t6 paiý'e 6 of, To: sarahwagn~eresq~gmai).com This is an automaticativ .aeneirated Delivery Status Notification Deliverv to tihe %foiowing,reo1inlent failed permnanently OCAAMAIL Res.ou~rc9Znrca.ov i'~v ~ ~~~~~~~~~'i I~ j! ~'2~2S~
EXHIBIT F timail R !\tesc te A SL B Ord1er Iartch: 2 4, 21(1)
-st>-Id Qa~
8 Pa ge I o1f5ý GSarah Wagner <sarahwagneresq@gmail.com>
WestCAN's Reply to the ASLB Order March 24, 2008
".messaces Sarah Wagner <sarahwagnuresq@gmaiI.com> Tue, Mar 25, 2008 at 10:21 AM To. LGM!@nrc.govOCAA.M.- ýL@nrc.gov, OCA.AMAIL Resource <OCAAMAIL..Resource@nrc.gov>,
"palisadesart@aol. com" <Fal sadesart@aol.com>. Ulrich Witte <ulrich@ulrichwitte.com>, Richard Broasky
<richardbrodsky@msn.corr>, "hearingdocket@nrc.gov" <HearingDocketZnrc. gov>, Hearing Docket
<Hearing. Docket@nrrc.gov:., :xk! @nrc.gov, REW@nrc.gov. KDL2@nrc.gov. "Dennis. William"
<wdennis@entergy.com'n. :G-eene. Manna" <mannajonclearnvater.org>', "Sutton. Kathryn"
<ks tton@morganlewjs conm. "Bessette, Paul" <pbessette@morganlewis.com>, 'O'Neill. Martin"
,r artin.o'neill@moCranlevis :rem>. "Delaney, Michael" <mde=aneycEnycedc.com>. "LeKay. John"
<4use usaa@z yahoo com>. 'Kra-ner, Arhur" <alkremer rinfpc c "Kremer(2l. Arhur" <kremerýarea-alhance.org>. "Curran, Diare' Kdcurran@harrnoncurran,,coMr> Joan Matthews <jilmatthe@gw.dec.state.ny us>
"Sicos, John" <John.Siosa'ai.Lag state ny.us>, "O'Neidl Daniel" evobobestweb. net>, "Pruyne. Justin"
<jdp3@,'westchestergov comt: "Snook, Robert" <robert.snook@po.state ct. us>, "Musegaas, Phillip"
<phillip@riverkeeper.org>, 'Tafur. Victor" <vtafur@riverkeeper.orq>. "Riesel. Daniel" <driesei@sprtawcorm>.
"Steinberg. Jessica" <jsteirbErg @sprlaw.com>, "Burton, Nancy" <NancyBurtonCT@aol.com>, "Zoli. Elise"
<ezoii@goodwinprocter.con-; janice.dean@oag~state.ny. us, mylan. Denerstein@oag state ny.us, "Parker, John Louis" <jlparker@gw dec.statr- ny us>, Kimberly. Sexton@nrc. gov, Christopher. Chandler@nra.gov, David.Roth@nrc.gov, lloyd SL binCnrc.gov, Sherwin Turk <SherwinTurk@nrc.gov>
Re: Indian Point License Rcn(,\ aL. Docket No. 50-24'7 '2l6-L.R 5,o '.k.om It X'av Concern:
Petitioners , ubrhi lithe illo( ni'g in response to the Atom;ic licensine and Satv Board s\'estCA , )rder of Maarch24,2008 and in furthet'r support o, letitioiirW n', dated March2.2 2008'. Pluse coniac, mif voua cannot open anv ofthe attac-hnens. Copie" will also be mailedto the p'tries on the Cenrificaie of Service. Thank you.
S ncereiy Sarah L. Wagner Legal Counsel for Asserrbl'.'-nar Richard L. Brodsky LO.B Room 422 Abanv N.Y. 12248 518-455-5753 7 attachments
.,- 3.25.08 WestCAN Rep.y to ASLB Order 3.24.08.pdf 48K
--- 3.24.08 TABLE OF t-T'ACHMENTS.pdf Att 1- 3.21.08 TABLE ()F CONTENTS.pdf ZK
- ~'~' ~ CU7' ~ ~' \s-tt.&1it' I I 8a 'dOhckI'b I
e~
(r'n~~~~~~~~il~~ -~teA et'A' AUdrN h 24. Ish8[ 2C' 0 SAtt 2 sent on 3.21.08 as Exhibit H WestCAN receipts.doc 47E:i K s Att 3 Email sent 3.21 .08 Part l.pdf
.i-mN Att 4 Email sent 3.21.08 Part 2,.pdf 71 77K
-- Att 5- 3.21.08 Exhibit I Email from Atty Turk 2.15.08.pdf 43K David Roth <David.Rothtnrc.gov> Tue, Mar 25, 2008 at 2:53 PM To: Sarah Wagner <.sarahw.igneresq rgmaii.corns, Lawren ce McDade <Lawrence McDade'nrcgov>.
OCAAMAIL Resource --O > ,M.-L.Resource;)nrc cov> OCAAMA!L Resource
<CCAAMAlLResource@rr gov>. "pakisadesarl@aol'com" <Palisadesart@ab.rcom>, Ulrich Witte
<uirich(Dulrichwitte.com>, R chard Brodskv <richardbrdsky@msncorn>. Hearing Docket
<Hearing. Docket@nrc.go"> Hearing Dociket <Hearing.Docket@nrcgov>, Zachary Kahn
<Zachary Kahn@nrc gov- . Richard WVatdwell <Richard.Wardwell@nrc. gov>, Kaye Lathrop
<Kaye Lath rop@nrc gov" "'Dennis. William" <wdennis@entergy.com>, "Greene. Manna"
<marinajo@clearwwaer.or.> "Sutton, Kathryn" <ksutton@morj-anlewis.com>, "Bessette. Paul'ý
<pbessette@morgantewi s.c:rn>. "O'Neill, Martin". <matin.o'neill@morganlewis.corn>, "Delaney Michaei"
<mdelaney@nycedc.com-, ' LeKay. John" <fuseusatyahoo,corn>, "Kremer, Arthur". <ajkremer@rmfpc corn>,
'"Broosk-y(2) Richard" <ric.-a dbrodsky@msn.com>, "Brodsky. Richard' <brodskr@assembly.state.ny us>.
"Burton, Nancy" <NancvB Gýio)CT@,aol corn>, "Curran, Diane" <dcurran@harrnoncurrancom>. "Delaney.
Michael" <mdelaney@nycecc corn>, "Dennis, WVilliarm" <wdennis@entergy corn>, "Greene. Manna"
<rnanrajo'@cieanvater .or,>. Hearing Docket <HearingDocket@nrc.gov>, Kaye Lathrop
<Kaye Lathrop@nrc goy,> "KZrernerl2). Arthur" <krerner@area-alliance.org>. "Kremer Arthur"
<a kremer@rmfpc corn> a.v.ence McDade <Lawrence. McDade@nrc.gcv> "LeKay. John"
<fuseusa@vyah6o.com>. Marcia Carpentier <Marcia.Carpentier@nrc.gov>. "Matthews, Jcan"
<jilrnatthe@gw oec.state.ny.!is>, "Musegaas, Phillip" -.phillip@riverkeeper.org>. "O'Neill. Daniel'
<vob@bestweb.net>, "O'Nei I, Martin". <martin o'neill(nmorganlewis.com>, "Pruyne, Justin"
<Jcp3@westchestergov curr>, Richard Wardwell <Richard.Wardwell@nrc.gov>. "Riesel. Daniel"
<d -iesel@sprlaw.com>, "SNhpiro, Susan" <mbs@ourrockiandofficecorm>, "Sipos, John"
<John.Sipds@cag state.ny us>. "Snook. Robert" <Robert. S.nock@po.state. ct.us>, "Steinberg. Jessica"
<jsteinberg@sprlaw corn>, "Sutton, Kathryn" <ksutton@morganlewis.com>, "Tafur, Victor"
<vtafur@.riverkeeper org> Zachary Kann <Zachary.Kann@nrc.gov>, "Zoli, Elise" <ezoli@goodwinprocter corn>.
Beth Mizuno <Beth Mizun:4nrc.gov>, Bo Phar '-BcPham@nrc gov>, Brian Newell <Brian.Newell@nrc gov>,
Christooher Chandler <Ct riEtopher.Chandler@nrc gov> David Roth. <David. Roth@nrc. govw, 1PNonPubiicHearingFile <P:'onPublicHearingFie@nrc.gov>: Karl Farrar <Kar! Farrar@nrc gov>, Kimberly Sexton <Kimberly SextonrJr rc gov>, Lloyd Subin <L!oyd.Subin@nrc~gov>, Sherwin Turk
<Sherwin. Turk@nrc gov>. CCAAMAIL Resource <OCAAMAIL.Resource@nrc.govw,. "Bessette. Paul"
<pbessette@morganlewis c'rn>, "Kremer(2),. Arhur" <kremer@area-allance cr9>, "Curran. Diane"
<dcurran@harmoncuirran.co ,-n>. Joan Matthews <jlmatthe@gw.dec.state. 'ny.us>, "Sipos. John"
<John.Sipos@oag state.ny.i s>. "O'Neill, Daniel" <vob@bestweb. net>. "Pruyne, Justin"
<Jdp3@wes'chestergov ccim" "Snook. Robert" <robert snook@po.state.ct us>, "Musegaas, Phillip"
<pnIlio@riverkeeper org> "afur, Victor" <vtafur riverkeeper org >. "Riesel. Daniel" <driesel@sprlaw corn>
"Steinberg. Jessica" <Jsteinbarg@spriaw.corn>, "Burton, Nancy" <NancyBurtonCT@ac.com>r "Zoli, Elise"
<ezoliiýgoodwinprocter.cr-' "Janice.dean@oag state ny.us" <ianice dean@oag.state ny us>.
myianr Denerstein 0oag. sT.a:e ny us" < myian: DenersteinS'oa. state ny .us>, "Parker, John Louis"
<l,Iparkeraa,',*N -state n,. ":, K'mberoy Sexton -Kim'erlv Sextcntnrc.qov>' y Chrnstcpher C,,an.er
<r, ' - ' _r*>rd loVyd Su'ir <L' ovv Sutbirc.'nrc aco-, S 'herin Turk "-"< -e,'. . nr gncv"
. .. '. " "' S a ' ,r'e r for '1Vestcnester C -t,,en'sawareress NetworK. e:
Sa ',a an rjessaae o various persons on the italan Point license renewal oroceeding, with th.e subjoec ine "VestCAN s Reph tch - ASLB Order March 24. 2008 " Ms, Wagner's E-mail message had se'ven attachmens, o for thre NRC Sdaff noted that the attachment designated. "At, 2 sen, On 3 21 08 as Exhibit H WestCAN rec'its doc" contained -ersonal credit card information Which should not be ma*e
-ubliclv available-t;,. -1,W
I ~\ MISLV.*'\~ trte i(% ASLB rz N-larc:h 24. 2-0(18 Shortiv after recei,,, of Ms Wagrer's E-maic message, David Roth, Counsel for the Staff. teleohoneac the
-icenscng Board's oierk Z-3chary Kancr and employees In th.*e Office o; the Secretarv iRebecca &Giter arc Emuie Ju;ian.x to nform r-em o the i;ciusior, of redi care nformation irhMs. V~laners5ransm. r. Mr.
Rotn also forwarded, w'thut comment. a copy -of Ms. Waners E-mail with attachrnents tc Ms G0tter inasrmucr as she statec tf a: she had not recev the, revMCous'y ie Staff wtshes !o :cafl !h matter to tho atenon of Ms Wagner and the oersons to whom she :rarsmttted he, E-mail message C:ht~r recipienrs of the e-rai! should taIKe apovoprate steps to prevent n* a ,ve-,-,
discIosure Of the credint na ntormatior-, pendinc the recei-pt of any further communication from Ms Wagtner martino'neill@morganlewis.com <martin.o'neilI@morganIewis.com> Tue, Mar 25 2008Pat 3:49 PM To. David Roth <David.Rot hý.ýnrc.gov>
Cc: "Kremerr Arthur" <a krer-er@rmfPc con>. Beth Mirun. <Bet.h.Mizunofnrc.gov>. Go Pham
-,BoPham9--nrc.gov>, Brian 'jewell <BrIan.Neweli@nrc.gov> "Brodsky. Richard"
<brodskra'assembly. state n,.us>., Christopher Chandler <Christopher Chandler@nrc. ov> David Roth
<David Roth@nrcgov>, "Cuiran, Diane" <dcurran@harmoncurran corn>. "Riesel. Daniel" <dresel@spriaw corn>.
"Zoii. Elise" <ezoli@goodw,,inproceer.comrn. "LeKay, John" <fuseusa, yahoo corn> Hearing Docket
<Hearing. Docket@nrc gov,. PNonPublicHearingFile <lPNonPublicHearingFile@nrc.gov>.
janice.dean@oag.state.ny u-;" <janice.dean@oae state, ry.us>. "Pruvne. Justin" <jdp3owestchestergov.com>.
"Matthews, Joan' <jlmattheagw.dec.state~ny us>. "Parker, John Louis" <jlparker@gw dec.state.ny us>. "Sipos John" <John Sipos@oag.stat'. ny.us>. "Steinberg, Jessica" <jstemnberg@sprlaw.corn>, Karl Farrar
<Karl; Farrar@nrc.gov>. Ka.e Lathrop <Kaye.Lathrop@nrc.Sov> Kimberly Sexton <Kimberly Sexton@nrc gay>.
"Kremert2j, Arthur" <kremerc..Jarea-alliance org>. "Sutton Kathryn" <ksutton morganiewis.com>. Lawrence McDade <Lawrence. McDade 5nrc:gov>, L.16id Subin <Lioyd.Subin@nrcgov>, "Greene: Manna"
<mannajo@ciearvvater org:- Marcia Carpentier <Marcia Carpentier5nrc.gov>. "Shapiro, Susan"
<mbcs@ourrocklandoffice corT > "Delaney. Michael" .<mdelaney@nycedc.com>,
'mylan Denerstein oag.state ry us" <mylah Denerstein@oag state.ny.us>, "Burton. Nancy"
<NancyBurtonCTaoi~corr> OCAAMAIL Resource <OCAAMAIL.Resource@nrc gov> "palisadesan@aol corn"
<Pa;isadesaii@aol corn>, "5S ssette, Paul" <pbessetteimorganlewis. corn>, "Musegaas, Phillip"
<phillip@riverkeeper org>. Richard Wardwell <Richard.Wardwellknrc.gov>, Richard Brodsky
<richardbrodsky@msn comr,, "Snook. Robert" <Robert. Snook@po. state. ct. us>, Sarah Wagner
<sarahwagneresqagmail.cojný>. Sherw'in Turk <Sherw"in.Turkgnrc.gov>. Ulrich Witte <ulrich@ulrichwitte.corM>
"O'Neill, Daniel" <vob@besw,.b. net>, "Tarur, Victor" <vtafur@riverkeeper.org>. "Dennis. William"
<wdennis@entergy.corn>, Zachary Kahn <Zachary.Kahn@nrc gOy>
Further to Mr Roth's e-mail :eiow counsel for Entergy notes that it first noticed WestCAN's inclusion of personal credit card informaion iate last week. but in the context of Attachment A to WestCAN's March..n 2008 filino with the ASLB Pws Sutton, lead counsei for Entergy, promptly attempted to contact Sarah Wagner. counsei for WestC/,N, last Friday. Ms. Sutton left a voice message for Ms Wagner, apprising her of the situation, and requesting that Ms, Wagner or Mr Brodsky return Ms. Sutton's call. We did not near Dack from Ms. Wagner or Mr. B'oc(sky.
Counsel for Entergy just con:irmed that the March 3. 2008- filing (including the credit card information! hnas been olaced in the NRC's .u .riiclvavaiiabie Electronic Hearnno Docket and in ADAMS (Accessio-n N,.
ML8807 30C435
,vea * .
h~~~~tt~~; tui0ý ra. 'c k(il(cit ~ '~'h~tl-i
ý'. Lccrr 'e4by I Uc~
- '~~'-'<~,ik..the h'.S.I.~fB rcN~~~ -~~~~l PRa Lýe 4 o f ;
Cqunsel for Etre g7 Martin J. O'Neill
.... e,*, .. :. v>'
"David R~oth" <Dav ,dRjoth@rrc.gpv L r4 A\qieiir` ~ cr,, o miarw. "I awrenzce ',ADde-wr~'C-t-' "w'nc ojuý- "OCAAMAIL Resiource"
-1AIRew-rc - nr"ý go 'OCAAMAIL Resource" aiiactitdr'i "cm ýo' p 1 Witte, arosy licrnard
"'Pnc~h~tezr rtrisk'rv"m ' L.eainrg Docket"
, eHari n n criarrn
.' c y ' an ti n "
D
~
0 - - Hae"rc an q ,ýq ý . c ov>'
- -!it 1i Djr-Kahilrni 'wA;tfle'jw '-m'"rec Mn alaraiw-q ; Sutton. Kathir'yn u::n~ror~nleia~orn 'tessptte -aul
~estt~nopnleww -fq7rr-p' ~'-0Neil Martin" maiim oineiwbmcpoitgwrs cOrn -ea'i 0 Michael'
-no "eiP-ay, John' <fseý usac vanccq-rv narbrrusly~'rrs cmi>."'Brodsky, Richard
<Nancv~qvrtonjZT CaqLc 1>, "'Curran. Diane"'
~"'Bur~nc Nancy" M~crnan~t~rrrto .cm."Delaney, -Mra Mrncta C"'
.'mqelangy,ýi,-ycedc 'orn,' "'Dennis. William"' <rwenn.Laitrvnte~r2ýL
"'Greene, Marina` <mnq%2ajqiC5.Laraier~or . "Hearing CnI>'
Docket"
~n CIO LL V' "aye Lathrop" ýKAveLtro1'oi
"'Kirernef( 1.Arthur- <krgyemetealacog' "'t'retpr. Anhwi"
- m ramp-qr>"Lawrence f-- McDade" 1'0Lawrngq.MCac'trqtv>, "'LeKay. Johin'
<fu e Lsa:'aZ-v nc. Corr,,-
"Marc;a Carpoittier'. <,larcia Epen C. er'ncggv -%vths.
Joan"'
~r~ittei'~w~ec 'ate yi" Musegaas Philir"'
'atin <moninl~u.il' ir'nee"n'SPti JOSrIn" ja:-vet iirtiJn Rtnichror" Vw~f
,:Pcnar.tr ','rc4iq " 'i. qo" ieselý Daniel" rorne 'sprwccn
'ocer;'$-L 1ic
ý'po "tle
'Steinberg. 'etaica-1;fseinerg'sp~iaycmn. '"Sutton. Kathryn" Z-nary i(ainn -ZacifaIr' ,Aqrmirwnrc gpv Zoli. Elise-'
'i"'ijcwiioi('tr 'tin'"Beth f'lzuric' ""'i'nco
ham" -- Ii" 5.
""v')@ý' l-gcc' '",itai Newel "Eria Ntt,,p1F'-jrc o!cy'r.
%r-Chocnu'e Chandiler' ~Vi C r2Of' DCntpe avid Roth'
- 'rin-ii""n' g.'"Karl '-ar'ar
" ýan-ara-'nrc.go>..
mt1n)ei' r~o Sexstoniýýrnerf nrcx
-iriCiy f!Cqpv', "Lo-o Subinl OvOotnirnn ov,. "Sierviin ' ur" "Stiewýin Tr'n"gii
"!MILRescurce" eour~a.o~iessette. "OG~~l Pa'ut" <"p~$tttinranevi oi "lKreme'1-2). Arthur" keriner'Erlare3-alian n>, y. 'Curran, Dianeprin~amnua r>Ja rvatthews' <inatg~t~ttfyua'Si John "Jotr -iosourj mte us'O'Neill, Daniel" -vq -)t~awon "Pruneid~wejc ustl esteooypor> "nook. Rooerl' rrr~i~t floK~'o iat A s>"Musegaas, Phillip"
<pfhttprrivrce'pq n "Riesel, Daniel" dnerie
~"Tiafur, Victor' <vt ft r'ýrve Iee[3m
%Yprlw.rStenbeig. Jessica"
"<enis srtwcon "Burton, Nancy' <NancvBurtnC*aicn"
>rinvar-'ers""e~infd'ca" smt -ate i d " aix-r. john Lonus'
~ijt cc "ivU S 'Kiinov'iv Sexton:
.'- '~~'~.~r
' S rrr..'4
~r'~ ~ i ~:'-' 'c15 t~i ~j,~ -!t&'t~ki J 4 cl7 I'd - *"
&tK AN\ S tcthfe AStI. C rdr\Lrc 1A201 Ptze- 2 ('1 Ž was C7 K. '- K'
.~
~' V t:.
cX\ k dbc91 - . ';
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY
- 'IC,;A ;D L. 3C')SK ."-'AIR NAN March 24. 2008 Atoinic Safety and _icnsing Board U.S. Nuclear RegouLat ry Commission Mail Stop- T-' F2' Washington. 1), C. 20. 55-00 1 Re
- Indian Point Lic-rse Renewal. Docket No. 50-247I286-LR Io Whom It May Con;:Crn:
Because it appears thai you were not able to receive the electronic submission of the enclosed document, I am sendin , you this courtesy copy. To ensure that you receive a copy, enclosed please find a courtesy copy ofrPetitioners WestCAN et. al.'s response to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Order cf March 7, 2008. Unless directed to do so, we will not submit a new certificate of service. fb: submission of these courtesy paper copies.
Sincerely.
Sarah L. WV~agner Co-counsel for Petitioners WestCAN et. al.
2i~:
i n.* :,m .y.
S :A ;. ."° i ,: C . N < .22. L,
,.. $ *,*.**7::.i<c 3;::i 5 "! 2: i<a ::*!.: 2iE:,;..i{ krso d *-e.;
~'f.'.*
> - 224'3.
- '~:
! 22, {
- <
- 4
-0:3
EXHIBIT G rE 0'C Ce~ Se~rch, UPS United States Welcome. John Barber Track Shipments Track Shipments .,- i Fr..k Packanes & Freight OLuantum View F'oe: GIobaI View 7t r.F CR 1"Z, ,
Tracking Detail JIL!*:!:k V')!!,!'.. VV'_{ Your package has been delivered, VV Tview Proof of Deliverv, pIease select the link.
7r--kira Number. IZ 129 9503 0 101 290 5 Package Delivered 77 03125120086C!52 AM.
S~~&By: DILLARD OFFICE De' vered To: 155.5 ROCKV\ILLE PIKE ROCKVILLE. MD. US 208.52 0 32 1 2 0018' 049 Find Answers to Your GROUND Tracking Questions .90 Los Package Progress Location Date Local Description Time LAUREL. 03/2512008 10 52 A.M. DELIVERY MI. US 03!25/200 5749 A.M OUT FOR DELIVERY
._4DOVdER, C3/25/2008 4 45 A.M. OUT FOR DEL',/ERY
',4D, US 03/25/,"2008 3:30 AM, ARRIVAL SCAN IL.A 'I .!z-'-
," L.
us 03:24.2008 10:5 P. M. DEPARTUR'E SCAN r.4 [ U S 0,3,a4 ;=-', 712 ,A1M Ar.RRAVAL SCAN SE IU CU C. 2324.2220 2.15 AM. DEPARTURE SCAR I,"'
2 M. RI".AL SCAN
, 'i 72 ---JKfilli.' irlfOTTIV I ;W11 PS nrtps:xvxv~va:~ps
~~~ckinu lnr()rtriau~Lursuor /\k~bTrau~: i~~sii~iur' C O1NIE. NE 3 22/., 4-06 AM DEPARTURE SCAN
- roAM, N Y. '-"S LNiE.
N I5 3 M,0MORIG:N SCAN 1-rM
- c:
1,j'.
-3'21,"205 4:.. P.M BhLING N..DRM-REC EIVE D
-rckn, results nrovided _N UPS. *0327/20D..- AM. ET Claim Information H -ive problems or questions about your oacka-2*
oet Notified: Quantum View NotifysM
ý-mail this pace to uz to three recipients.
E-mail: Language:
Tha rberjxassernbly.state United States - Engish United States - English United States - English Fersonal E-mail Message:
7axrl'.um 15Z zharac!rs1 NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS trackirng systems soiely to track shirments tendered by or for you to UPS for deiver and for no other purpose.
An\ other use of UPS 'racking systems and information is strictly prohibited.
azv -.. rc c o' er-.... , ,,.:Srv
N CIC ~ŽI Dr m i<'n
'=2100 4W0 ýL,M A 14C
, j 1EU
, 7-'+ .S _4_N C3/2 11/02' E:58 P.M.
- ORIGIN SCAN LTHAM, NY. US us 030212008 4:27 PM BILLING INFORMATION R EC E VECD Tracking resulTs orovided tv. UPS 03!27ý2008 9.256 A M ET Claim Information i-ave probiems or questions about your package?
... ......... .... I.....S , }*;ae:!**".... *....,i,':, [ - .'
Get Notified: Quantum View NotifySM E-ma!t mis page to up to three recipients.
E-mail: Langdage:
barberj@assembly state United S:ates - English United States - English United States - English
.ersonal E-mail Message:
NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS trazkinc systems solel a .
sr oments 'endered by or for YOU to UPS for deliver¶' and for no cther purpose.
A.1 other use of UPS "rackino systems and information !s strictly prohiited
- ~~o ..... 1010. n GIN 0 va 0,1110.In Unden Pnk S-,n W Amea. inc. ANINgats reserved.
(13/21 /013 BI9 PkC) I 0'q9 Pti44 6 1f, 0 110 Ti It(I 36 014,12 9 (1 UJPS ' 1 92
UPS United States tIC Ki~
Eeki~Siiji~ri 4B~ Sitlutins :~rtgLC~oe TraC inc a Welcome. John Barber Track. Shipments Track Shipments
< .) 4.C - 3 7/.
SC7,, P,". 7T a 7K f',; Track Packages & Freight Quantum View -iex Globa! View im ici _T.;-'a :*n<
Tracking Detail
.m,,:"': :;:**.J[] 8 C't i* .r ,
Your package has been delivered.
C. :.:.'
T: view Proof o' Deliver-. piease select the link Tracking Number: 1Z 129 935 03 0101 289 8 Type. Package Status' Delivered -7 ' .-
Delivered On: 03i2512008 10:52 A.M Signed By- DILLARD ocation: OFFICE Delivered To: 11555 ROC.KVILLE PIKE
'**hpediBdllea Onr ROCKVILLE. MD. US 20852 03"21!2008 Reference Nu'moberts. 049 Find Answers to Your Se rvice GROUND Tracking Questions ANeighT: 10.A00 Lbs Package Progress Location Date Local Description Time LAUR EL, 03/25:!200 1052 AM DELIVERY MD US 0;3.'25*,20 4928 A.M OUT FOR DELIVERY LAUREL. 03/24,2008 11:55 A M. DESTINATION SCAN MD US 03/24/2008 7 12 A M. ARRIVAL SCAN SECAUCUS, 2:15 A.M DEPARTURE SCAN NJ, US SECAUCUS 03/22/2008 728 A.M. ARRIVAL SCAN NJ. US CO LONIE ; 4, 4..'-06A.M DEP-RTURE SCAN LATHAM, Nv US ULS
- TA J R;. S CAN Ip~N T.&T*AM.
JS :T~.M iLLINC- NOPMA`T1DN1 rackng resut provided by UPS, 03"'27/2I 8 9_20 A.M ET laim Information iave problerns or questions about your .package?
3et Notified: Quantum View NotifysAn E-mail this cace "c u ,to three recipients.
E-mail: Language:
- oarberj @assembly state United States - Engfish Uniied States - En-gish Unitec States - Enghlish Personal E-mail Message
unaximum 150 characters)
NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS tracking systems solely to track Fhioments tendered by or for you to UPS for delivery and for no other purpose i ny other use Df UPS tracking svstems and incrmation 7Sstrctly crohibhted Ccpynrigt© C994- 2 08 United Parce Serice of Amernca, Inc, 11rights resered.
1111,21/0 D114 Ik $131If 12) lips 0 4, 09 Wt.: :111.00 It, 1I"S,., Nuclear Rbegulatory Commission ixteethFio**r.
155,5 R~o&kvflfe Pike Y.4:r
.U: racki nu frnP(1yaeIo Pa*'* ] (Hl cv.
Tracking Summary Tr-aicikjng-Nuý miýbým'ý`-',--,
Tracking Number: IZ 12 99 3G0 010-1 2952 Type Packaoe Statuss Etxception New Delivery AJddess ROCKVILLE. MD. US Service. NEXT DAY AIR Tracking Number: 'Z12993501 0101 2972 Type, Package Status,
'Delivered Delivered On: (3/25/2008'
£:36 A.M.:,
Delivered To: ROOKVILLE. MD US Signed By: DILLARD Service NEXT DAY AIR Tracking Number: 1Z 129 935 01 0101 299 0 Type: Fackage Status:
Delivered Deiivered On. 03,25/2008 9 3eA.M De'ivered To7 ROCKVILLE. MD, US Signed By. DILLARD Service NEXT DAY .AIR
'Tracking resu!ts provided by ULIS 0-3/2512008 12:34 P.M. ET NOTICE: UPS authorizes you t. use UPS tracking systems solely to track shipments tendered by or for, you to UPS for delivery and for no other purpose. Any other use ofUPS tracking systems and informatcio is strictly prohibited.
L,:2L'}CSe V',,*IT*
- OW Cs::~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~... ...........
- -'=4-.:(::*Lri:d:*..............: ... **q:: 7:
fl.* Am*h. ,-e..e'
Office of the Secretarý,
U.S. Nuclear Regulat<ory Commission Sixteenth Floor One Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville. MD 20852 Sherwin Turk Esq.
Counsel-for NRC Staff U.S. Nuclear Regulatcry Commission Office of the General Counsel Washington. D0C.20555
E%:.--iA.A LUY'.S 'rzcki:! Nt-- ' 17C :!
Fromec: JH
'I'S~:~ N~ t(
Date 7ý1= 5 r n - n:.in ;:. .n John Barber of NYS Assembly has requested that we send you this exception alert. The UPS shipm~ent listed below has experienced an exception.
Exception Details for 0 4tbound Shipments(s)
Service: UPS Nexi Day Air Shipment ::ceferenz.e No, 2L. 0514 Ship To Inform-ation O~CEOF OMM1E~K; A-PELLAT~A.e AASI-I N G 0 No, Tracking Rescheduled E~teption Descr-iption Exception Resolution Numnber/Retererce Delivery Date Nu m b e r AC 7 ýI ST - D E ý; H S E~
_71E~E CrIS CCE..THDOE: T',
0~ RIIEY
- .. Disvove,, rno~e about UPS Visit USCO Ex lore UPS Business Solutions Learn About UPS Companies SinU For A*dtionaE-1;-ail From UPS Read Compass Online SZ2J6u-:ed Pax'e! S'aviý'. C;'.n '2 In:U, 1.7 3 fe UPS n .nzdkthie zolo, r~ :,o er&. of~h ?nlte ! s~xe.'
A )rc, Al.; rig,.ts vc
- lease n-treplynzrecl ~ ~ J;IS wli. ficr rece'- ;any rei.&Y
- z Ž ~
ý1a..Qn r;Ia% aj :'isi nr:] a JP .9i F,^mavo criii i . De nL!'Le J;C1ir-5i" ;i~7~?~V7ir-l7- na C~rd a. ~S~~e:lelC 5~CrD~..D~S 5 -2 C-08 AM
Ex A!SrrbiTkr. a iI i Nu.rnHý! 77!2993') _
Date- "i'ý-z. 25 ,a 0t' , ...
TH John Barber of NYS Ass;embly has requested that we send you this exception alert. The UPS shipment listed below has experienced an exception.
Exception Details for Outbound Shipments(s)
Servi:..... UPS e X! Dav Ai.
-rIipmemPrrneN Ship To Information ATOMIC SA ETY LC I& SNC;NG;BCARD PAN WASHINGTON DC No, Tracking Rescheduled Exception Description Exception Resolution N umber/Reference Deliver Date Number 6 52 L8 F-L, JPS ExASTIT 7 ::7 AZ)~R~S.JPDRTT$S LTCZL. c -,JCK 5C1,!
F: C>t'4LETE :;ELvEr&*". lS55....~~S 2 2y8d NvVayX-l AX E Discover more about JIS Visit uos.com Explore UPS Business Solutions Learn About lIPS Companies inU Up Fobr Addificna[ E-mnailFrmU2 Read Cornrass Online
- ,'2ZCS0Ur~i.ot *rc~; .3e-rvi:se of ,Ame~iza. inc. UPS: TheUF'S brjn~martk arnd *"- colo *rowar, zacemarrs of r'pite
- r. a F-a2.:5*..:v,*3*
Fs r ogre wnftm or, ConUPS' pr.:aac raciies ree t-ne ?5 PnvsUi F!UaScf Po'ev~my n!v'w04 rezly ¢ this a -c, S reiv e - rvý',r ssage f4.*S[wA Vl$m* C1*ntac: a'Ot are notH*lll. '0 q*s m~m a.o oq~the I."
n io nea esls~ n~*!fL r o{[eme :C~f-ma * ~~~,fl h edr:,*#-,
r a *ifws o .;rf e ": h o [.: [*,i;.* ,aLi ,.... "- °n'- .'* *q * *. aei~ ..td: i.*; _,4[* i*i-=#a*;o,*da*y
- .-r-. - -- C A D'U"N:t '20,. ,[`t ::48 -64
" 1:
John Barber of NYS Assembly has requested that we send you this exception alert. The UPS shipment listed below 'nas experienced an exception.
Exception Details for Cutbound Shipments(s)
Service: jPS Nexl Day .Air Shipment Reference j,.. 054 Ship To Information OFFICE OF Tr-E SC: -TARY DC -
No. Traclking Rescheduled - Exception Description EKception Resolution Number!Reterence Delivery Date Numbe~r iE S-, SDI'r 01- THE LAFEEL !S THE ADDRESS HAS 5;:=N i *19935ýýi0 zi ! 0:2.'gb 03/25C0.q :NcoTa UPS S ATTEMPTING TO
... ETER-. lii C 7H CORRECT iTA'TE- r1o HAS F~S\--$C 2 ýl2' 12_8CXkenp-;u~ suI;-tJsSpbC)SJýtNsS 1O8xJ__
Discover more about IUPS:
Otanol Ccrwn'ct Visit uos.corn Exrlbre UPS Busress Soiutions Learn About jPS Comranies Sian Uo For Additional =-mai, From UPS j Read Compass Online
_-Lt m !C n, "SV,! ~:rrlea Tn! *u -i-> a*,: ant\ .- rw ~
,D M
'- a:c~---d n t tr
EXHIBIT H PStarchte wL JPS United States ShpngTrack~iog F i i- Welcome, John Barber "
Nly Adad P 5~,* a_ -.i_8vol Track Sh ipments Track Shipments-' -
Hyer Track Packages & Freiaht Quantum View R~ex Global View Tracking Detail.
': :*¢ a ;. *
'Your package has been delivered.
c view Proof of Deiivery, please seiect the link.
Trackinc Number Package Status, Delivered .. . -* -
Deiivered On: 03/25/2008 9736 AM, Sicned By: o LLARD Location: OFF:ICE Deiivered T 555 ROCKVILLE PIKE
.ROCKVILLE. MD. US 20652 Shcpped/Billed On: 03/2 ~!2008 Reference Numberls) 084 Find Answers to Your Service: NEXT DAY A!R Tracking Questions 'Neig ht 3.30 Lbs Package Progress Location Date Local Description Time LAU REL. 1) 25 2010,8 9 . DE LIVERY MD US A.M.
03!25.'2008 6-50 OUT FOR DELIVERY A. M
,AN D O 'ER,. 03/2520,C5 5: 40 MULTIPLE ERRORS EXIST IN MID, US M. THE ADDRESS LABEL. UPS IS ATTEMPTING TO DETERMINE THE CORRECT INFORMATION TO COMPLETE DELIVERY ,
THE ADDRESS HAS BEEN CORRECTED. THE DELIVERY HASQB-EE N RE SC hED ULE"zD AM ARF..IAL SCANN
PA, US PHILA DELP H IA. 1 5,7 . .. 14'
...V ,L- C,.S r,
P. M US WINDSS OR I 6 DEPARvTURE SCAN LOCKS, P.M Is C'324;2O ARRiVAL SCAN P.M LTH A Iv, 8:3- DEPARTURE SN NY US P. M 03!2 4!200;ý 8.01 ARRIVAL SCAN P. M.
COLONIE. 03/24/2008 7i51 DEPARTURE SCAN LATHAM. P.M, NY. US 03/241/2'00S 6:49 OPIG1N SCAN P.M Js { 03,'2;2008 4:01 BILLING I.ORMATION PM REC EIVED racing res-uts provided by UPS 03,27;2200S9.,31 A.M ET Claim
- -iavemuestioqInformation problemis 0r about y;cur cackaae?
Get Notified: Quant.um View NotifysM E--mail this page to up to three recipents E-mail: Language:
barberjI.5assembiy state United States - English United Siates - English United States - Englisn 2
- ersonal E-mail Message:
- q .*:,;;:.'i.,*;t)) 1 57:: =Ra"a*:'..*:'s
- -A.
0, a "VIA L!tý NOTICE: U'PS j~rcstoo use rackina svstems soleiv to :rarck
- P s~immetstencre cv r yo to UPS; for deliverv and icor no other Or~e for us uvote :aon r sf n? s'ys emrns anr, in frm rato r ts Srcty roict.
C* rnign 7 I9 4 -2 0S Yn::ed Parcee Service of America no. AH rigt;ts reserved AýV
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY, N. Y. 12248 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board. Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatorýy Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001
,.* ,eJ v
0'!2/Z'11) 519 Pkq4ýJ84 Pi: 44696 381 21 TrV41111.fl1f112972 Wf 4 .1.11 Lb
v'.v~ms.u~2~n \; Iru;k :nu AZ~~fq. ~ '~S~ eH .Sea rchýý
-~T~ 2-2 'r2~ JPS United States tL~Frih __________
Mly lip,, A~dd-r Dook
. Welcome. John Barber -!1.:-.ý
<-~' ~
Track Shioments Track Shipments -- 7
>akc Packages S & i-hr Quantu: iew Flex Globaf View Tracking Detail - :
LL,,,u.Zi£ r Your package has been delivered.
To view Proof of Delivery, please s.Jel.o the link, T-acking Number I Z 129 935 0t1 01C 1 298 1 Type Packaae S:atus: Delivered...........-
.ehlvered (Dr.. 03/25!2008 9,25 A.M Signed By: ADELMAN OFFICE Ueiivered To 440 HAMILTON AVE WHITE PLAINS, NY US 1060C.
,Uhoppea'Biied 0ThF 03/2 '22008
,efarence N u 3eE r-ern Service:
Fird Answers to Your NEXT D.Y.A*IR Tracking Questions 3.3G Lrs Packghg' Package;ýProgress Location Date Local Description Time ELMSFORD, 03"2512008 9:25 AM. DELIVERY NY, US 03125,200 8 :33 A:M, OUT FOR DELIVERY 03/25/2008 5601 A.M. DESTINATION SCAN 03'25/2,!-,0e 5 52 A.M, ARRIVAL SCAN VIASPETH. 03..25 2008 4 54 A.M 'DEPARTURE SCAN
\Y. US 03;;25!2000 2 02 ANM. ARRIVAL SCAN
- OLONIE. C/24-12008 *:!3 P M. DEPARTURE SCAN
- AT HAM.
.I'Y US 0312-4.;
2 I 3'9 P M ORIGIN SCAN f0 5'! L N- INFORMATIO% O R ECEIVED
Torac,;i~ res:Wts p*ro',,*ded by UPS; C.S'2:J2,0c0e 9:32 AM.M ET Claim Information L-ave orobiems or cuestons aco.t your oack.aoe?
Get Notified; Quantum View NotifySM E-ra!i this sage CIuQ 4c three revpier'ts.
E-mail: Language:
ba.rtberasse n b. s~a!e Umfted States - Enghsh United States - Enciish United States - Enc~ish Personal E-mail Message; NOTICE: UPS authorzes you to use UPS tracking systems solely to track slinmoents tendered oy or for you to UPS for deiivery and for no other purpose.
any other use of UPS tracking system s and ýnfornation is strictly pronibied Copyrght ig 994-200C Urtied Parcei Service cf America. inc. A.1 rionts reserved
.. . . - v
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY, N.Y. 12248
'.**.iiamC.Dennis, Esq.
A,sistant General Cou Insel Ertergy Nuclear Operations Inc.
4z:.0 Hamilton Avenue V\hite Plains, NY 10601 U)""-I21/0B8 B19 Pkgq*11184
.D 1.()2 IP 7 .29 Wt 4 0U(1 .
.: i ..... i 1/2..'.iu P= "
- ?P Ica.
John Earher f,: NYS A.ssmrIvy has r.quso.d that wN send you this exception aler-., The UPS shipment listed beiow hs experienced an excaption, Exceptio-n Details for Outbound Shipments(s)
SerIvice UPS Npext Dvy Air Sriiprnent -7eference No 2: C:34 Ship To !nformnatic
"*i:*IC
. O F ? ,',,tr, .S
",* . -- '.*..r-' -I*T .zD i T.-acking Reschydled Exception Description Exception Resduticn N~umbe-,/Referance Mveivry Date.
Nuniber
.1 ' .3.' N.
E
___2112t2y8pihFuGUVK3~zVDZU334AGHlL32U24LxlL93_
Visit uos corn Explore UPS Business Solutions Learn About UPS Companies Sign Up For Additional E-mail From UPS Read Compass Online
.. .. . . . . .. . &. t o j "S U.
Fz- q. ., ,+..7 f Oman spy zo'bj a"'ma
./.
Saoown; . -
- l. 0020 WMA
- e *SercWi" UPS United States Welcome, John Barber ____
"I,,l11:' Addm'e:s. Book Track Shipments t cý !-týc rack Shipments rev c rack Packages & Freight Quantum View Flex Global View Tracking Summary-Tracking Number: Z 129 935 01 0101 296 3 Type, Packnge Status Delivered Delivered On. 03/2612008 9:26 A.M, Delivered To: ROCKVILLE. MD. US Signed By; HILLARD Service: NEXT DAY AIR I racking results provided by- UPS: 03/2712008 8:49 A.M. ET lut Find Answers to Your Tracking Questions NOTICE: UPS authorizes vou to use UPS tracking systems solely to track s-tpmerts tendered by or for you to UPS for defivery and for no other purpose.
AT-y other use of UPS tracking systems and information is srinctly pr-ohlbited, Copyriaht 1994-2008 Unitei Parcel Service of America. Inc. All rights reserved W_ F*"rrer ,-"y
- TfT . r,-
TE. ASSEMXBLY STATE',OF NW Y.ORK ALBANY, N.Y. -12248
.Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication UI: S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop;: 0-1604 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 0-1/2I/on3 LA" PPqJ#0134 P044696.30 2 3 rk~1f~~~ 6 UPS ID 1014 9. 12 WE: 1 0 lb 1(
EXHIBIT I UPS United States Cu~tamer /
Welcome, John Barber __ . M'UP' Addre jo Track Shipments Track Shipments 6-./
J' -Z~
7 'rack Packages & Freight Quantum View Flex Glcbai View Uýr a aC-S "racking Detail -
jýrees 7a!xi" "racking Numnber. 1Z 129 935 01 0101 312 2
-:ype: Packace In Transit Fes~meduled Deliver?, 03:27`2008
'evDe~i:verv A ddress: U,S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM 1555 ROCKVILLE PIKE ROCKVILLE, MD US 20852 27739 S'- pp;eof.illed Or' 03/25/2008 Raference Nurnberis): 097 S -Ivice NEXT DAY AIR VA=~ight .30 Lbn Find Answers to Your p-ackage Progress Tracking Questions I.ocation Local Description Date Time LAUREL. 03/26/2008 11 25 DESTiNATiON SCAN MD. US P.M_
03/26/2008 10:50 ARRIVAL SCAN P.M LANDOVER. 03/26/2005 9:41 DEPARTURE SCAN MD, US. P.M 03,"26/2008. 8:i6 GUT FOR DELIVERY A. M 3,26/2008 .8 15 MULTIPLE ERRORS EXIST IN AM THE ADDRESS LABEL. UPS IS ATTEMPTING TO DETERMINE THE CORRECT INFORMATION TC COMPLETE DELIVERY..
THE ADDRESS HAS BEEN CORRECTED.'THE DELVERY HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED OLT FOR DELPVERY M.AI AR£P.ALSCN
.4
",,\,WVV' zi 42A4,us Dý_PAR COLONiE.
LATHIAM NY. US N
.," B!4_
Bi:Lti.N 1NFO RMATION racking resuits crov'*de. ov ULPS.Ps 7",' ET Get Notified: Quantum View NotifySM n-maiithis pace to up to three recipients UPS can a!sc notify you via e-mai!
when this shioment is deilvered or if an ee,.. occurs.
Send:
. This Tracking Page Exception Notification Delivery Notification E-mail: Language:
ibarberj@assembly.state United'States - English United States - English United States - English Personal E-mail Message:
- ax,,*imurr i .50 charaters ?
NOTICE: UPS authornzes vou to use UPS tracking systems solely uc track s iomens tendered by or for you to UPS for delivery and for no other purpose.
A*,. other use of UPS tracking systems and information is strictly prohibited.
Ccovc2t, .,994-2003 Un",te,= Parcel Service of America ric All righs reserved
} ._z . 7'.o
.r. . a. :IT z? . :ano -i- -'--
P '-- .:P'
-1OM THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY, N Y. 12248 Office of the Secreta.ry Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop: 0-16G4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washiegton. D.C. 20555- 001 v
F*#4'696*1 ,fl Trtfl'. ;[f(!lf'l 3:V22 UP 1.0 7 6.
w -, c"n i.
siie Gu S tet UPS United States Welcome, John Barber ,1y upýý Ad,ýmiss Doi rack. Shipments Track Shipments -
rack Package-s & Freight Quantum View Flex Glo ba! View 1",L racking Detail our package has been delivered.
Io view Proof of Delivery. please select the link.
Traokina Number: 17 129 935. 1 010 1 Type: Package S atus, Delivered Dýhivered Ori 031256`2008 9:26 A.M.
S,:ed Bv HILLARD Lý cation: OFFICE
.Divered Tc 1555IPOCKVILLE PIKE ROCKVILLE. MD1US 20852 SrppedfBled O D3,225.2008 fEf-rence Numbner.sj C)97
- e'vice NEXT DAY AIR Find Answers to Your L0*
- 80 !int:
Tracking Questions Package Progress Location Date Local Descriptior Time L;UREL, 03/2612008 9.26 DELIVERY MD: US A.Mr 0,3!2."2rn 5.44 OUT FOR DELIVERY A.M 0*3,"5.20n 5 49 ARRIVAL SCAN A.M 2.63/26Q20U5 3: 4 DEPARTURE SCAN
!LADELPHIA.
03C25,!200, 7:00 ORIGIN SCAN C,LONIE. P M.
-A. HAM
'"N. US 4 BILLING NFCRMAT mN P M R. ,:" E IVEV*E Ji:,
'.,';,V 0 C.1 O 59 . ET
-27 ',;** ." \v
, n2!Lt L28 ps:", U-, qC jrj o ýStjjjjr, ,, r Claim "Information Have problems or questions about your paskage?
Get Notified: Quantum View NotifySM E-rmail this page to uP to three recipients E-mail: Language:
Jbarberi@assenbiy. state United States - Engiish United States - English United States - Enolish Personal E-mail Message:
NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS tracking systems solely to track shipments tendered by or for you to UPS, for delivery and for no other purpose.
&nv other use of UPS Tracking systems and information s strict!v prohibitec.
Copyright -294-2008 ULi d Parcel Service of America. Inc, Alt nghts reserved
.! "2,- .*iR O,_','i :.*,N.I
mwor.
PW-THESTATEOF ASSED NEW T.ALBANY, N.,Y. 12
'Office cf the.,Secretary U.S t Lcltear Regulatory Commission Sixteen1 h Ffoor One Flint North 11555 FRockville Pike Rockvill.- MD. 20852 (JJ/'2./'Oe B1.9 Pkq:ifl97 JFS 1 D J03 7 7:1
'4 I ( 1 b
~p fr~*
FROM TKHE ASS.SEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY, N.Y. 12248
- Office oHýthe Secretary IUS. Nu-,Iear Regulatory CommissIor
?Sixteenth Floor One Flirt North 11 55 F ockville Pike Rockvillt.h -MD. 20852 03./25/1/9 5319 PkgyJ097 P#,446963ei32 )31 Tr-It#flr lifli (&
UPw I.DI ) 3. 7.73 wt 1..- 111 1b q-
ý;v r - - p11 UPS UniiW, PAddreýs hrc Sbiome~nts rrack Shipments-2 Track Packages & Freight QawnView i~-' ew 01'-'a view" a v -
Tracking Detail racKInr Number Z 12993 5 01 0 315 9 PacKage V~ *r' :*taus. In Transit E-~C C schedulA Delivery. 03f27/2008 N ew Delivery Address- U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM 1 1555 ROCKXVILLE PIKE ROCKVILLE, MD. US 20852 2739 S iuppedlBilled On: 03f25/2008 R.-;ferenceNumberns): )97 3e FViCe' NEXT DAY AIR 40 Lb P3ckage Progress Find Answers to Your Tracking Questions Date Local Description Lý)cation Time
÷ 7t.!:,T--k,:, A DESTiNATiON SCAN L-,U R EL.
MD. ij5 RM AýR.RIVAL SCAN DEPAR T URE SCAN P 110-A DOVER OR TOWN IS 9:08 A CORRECT CITY UPS 0.26/2008 kM. NEEDED FOR DELIVERY.
TO OBTAIN IS ATTEMPTING
) THE THIS INFORMATION ADDRESS HAS BEEN THE DELIVERY C-ORRECTED.
HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED
'--UIT FOR DELIVERY 022520`03 90S CUT -OR DE!IVERY A,.
.ARRIVAL SCAN
b11p~.:~':v.'1/2v~r:p$DS.N2n NV~
TM.
US COLONIE, 3,C;25123 0-S 702 'ORIGIN SCAN LATHAM, P.M.
NY. US Us 03,2512008 40/- BILLING INFORMATION P M. RECEIVED Track*ng results orov dec by UPS. 03!27208 9:38 AM. ET Get Notified: Quantum View Notify SM E-mail this page to up to three recipients UPS can also notify you via e-mail when this shipment is delivered or if an e -ii2 occurs.
Send:
... This Tracking Page Excepiion Notification Delivery Notification E-mail: Language:
United States - English barber @assembiy.state United States - English United States - English Personal E-mail Message:
mnaimu! 0 ,;bta ac, ers, NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS tracking systems solely to track snicments tendered by or for you to UPS for delivery and for no other purpose.
other use of UPS tracking systemns and information is strictly prohibited.
ony
.* ' yrqn
- .o 'Q--,-
.8 Ur
- -* *n-I- 4E Parce*. of A4'erica,
,Sevice-' . Inc. ,^" rights
%rig reserved t res ____
rvd
"* 11ý ) 1 6 o, *'s A,\,.
PP-PPI-'
F R O .!*.1:
THE ASSEMBLY OF NEW YORK STATE 12248 ALBANY, N.Y.
She.rwon TurkEsq.
Staff Counsel forýNRC Commission U.S. Nu IeaKReguiatorY Counsel Office o the-General Wasntn. :D.C. D0n, 20555 P94 4f 6j3j' Tri,.,10 1.(1.- 1 jý lfp D:irj ?7 w fir,. I
T UPS United States
~Sh~ppng> hckino__
ii Welcome. John Barber UPS Py Add__ .Book Tract Shipments rTack Shipments -/i T.ack Packages & Freight. Quantum View Flex GDobal View 5 *c,ý 1
i-rý Tracking Detail Trackina Number IZ 129 935 01 0101 314 0 Tye. Package Status. In Transit Rescn,eCuled Dehivery: 03127/2008 New Delivery Address; US NRC 11555 ROCKVILLE PIKE ROCKVILLE, MD, US 20852 2739
-nipped/Billed On: 03/25!2008 Reference Number's): 097 Service: NEXT DAY AIR
\Veight: .30 Lb Leaýnmore aboutý "A
Find Answers to Your Package Progress Tracking Questions Description Location Date Local Time LAU REL. 03126/2208 11 22 DESTINATiON SCAN MD US PM 22*0 0. B 00:50 ARRIVAL SCAN
-,ANDOVER.
03i1251200$ 9:41 DFPARTURE SCAN P.M.
'AD. US 03/26/2008 8:24 A CORRECT CITY OR TOWN IS A:M. NEEDED FOR DELIVERY. UPS IS ATTEMPTING TO OBTAIN THIS INFORMATION I THE ADDRESS HAS BEEN CORRECTED. THE DELIVERY HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED 03C26.,02008 6.24 OUT IFOR DELIVERY AM.
C'U T FO0R -'E:LfVE Ry AM, A.RVA I-,A M.
,.. 7, 'ý
ý'.:lT.
P H,"L)nt.D E ý-4 P US .,.M.
COLON lE. 03!25/2008 7:00 ORIGIN SCAN LATHAM, P M.
NY, US US 03/25/2008 4:04 BILLING INFORMATION P.M RECEIVED Tracking results orovidec cv UPS* 0312712008 937 A.M. ET Get Notified: Quantum View NotifySM E-mail this page o up, to three ,ecipientsUPS can also notify you via e-mail when this shiprnent is delivered or if an e--ec, occurs.
Send:
This Tracking Page Exception Notification Delivery Notificaticn E-mail:. Language:..
barberjgasseni bly. state United States - English United States - English United States - English Personal E-mail Message:
- raxirum 150 characters.
NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS tracking systems solely to track s:ý,iipments tendered by or for you tc UPS for deliveryand for no other purpose
.Anv other use of UPS tracking sy5temns and information is strictly prohibited Copyright ( 1994-2r08 Unite 4 Parcel Ser vice of America. Inc. All rights reserved.
ieT r-s:.":>. -e ~ v*',,*:,*, r'-:r'r 3!: aTa .;f/-2~ 4*i,I C2 .. ii
.*."- ':i'!*.* *-i " -g A N,1
F R C) M,.
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY. N.Y. 12248 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
'Mail Stop - T-3 F23 AWashington, D.C. 2O555-O"OOI v
(13/ 2!W(113 Bi.9 Plwg.00197 UPS tD 1(14 7 64 WtI i ,(inl l t
j i,ýPs i Gý'i -- Se arch UPS United States
- 2 _
aWe ]Icome. John My UPS Add,', Dook Trackln Barber ___
Track Shipments Tra ck Shipments FRI Tr I ,' E-rnai!
k_,
- _ - 'E'rrT.
aiL -rat tk Packages & Freight Quantum View Flex Global View S c at;r_!
esTre Tra cking Detail Tra ckng Number. 1Z 129 9.35 01.0 101 3 131 Package JS. In Transit scheduied Deivery v Delivery Address. US NRC 11555 ROCKVILLE PIKE NeI pped!Billed On: ROCKVILLE. MD. US 20852 2739 03!25/2008
- erence Number(s): 097 3er rvice- NEXT DAY AIR Vve 59igh: .30 Lb Find Answers to Your Package Progress Tracking Questions Location Date Local Description Time LAUREL. 03/263/2008 1 1.5 DESTINATION SCAN MD, US P.M.
03/26/2008 I0:50 ARRIVAL SCAN PM.
LANDOVER C6,z262@081 9:41 DEPARTURE SCAN MDa US P.M.
03/26/2008 5:22 A CORRECT CITY OR TOWN IS A.M. NEEDED FOR DELIVERY, UPS IS ATTEMPTING TO OBTAIN THIS INFORMATION / THE ADDRESS HAS BEEN CORRECTED. THE DELIVERY HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED 03/26/2003 8,22 OUT FOR DELIVERY A.M, OUT O-P1,RDELIVER`Y A. M 3/262003 347. ARRIVAL SCAN AM.
PflA.3 3/25/200:8 7:00 ORIGIN SCAN P.M NY, US
, 4.04BILLING INFORMATiON P.M. RECEIVED its ~rovided b;UPS:
.nsS -;127-0c'09:36 AM. ET Get Notified: Quantum View NotifysM E-mail this page to up to three recipients. UPS can also notif you via e-mail when t is shipment is delivered or if an cat O*0 ccurs.
Send:
This Tracking Page "xception Notification Delivery Notification E-mail: Language:
ibarber .@assermbiy state Unired States - English United States - English United States - English Personal E-mail Message:
(maximum 150 nharacters)
NOTICE: UPS authorizes you to use UPS tracking systems solely to track slipments tendered by or for you to UPS for delivery and for no other purpose.
Any other use of UPS tracking systems and information is strictly prohibited.
Copyrght zn. 1994-2-00 Unn t Pacel Service of Aei"c-a. Inc. All rights reserved
%M
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK 1 ALBANY, N. Y. 12248 Dr. Richard E, Wardwell JAtomic Safety and icensing Board PaneI
.Mail Stop - T-3, F23 U. S. NucIear Regulatory Commission
- Washington, D0C. 20555-0001 0'
0 3 2 5/0 13 B 3.9 P k q 919 7 P-1449638 1 32 Tvýfl DII I ll3'11 7
UPS IrD 104 ,f,4 W-. I .fl ) Ii,
I Icinl j 93O]C29, 2Q9_-- 5~~t 0r~ir 10:~
1r Subj-ct: 1 I pýi t 7Z i I( -S 1
From. ,\m. L "
Du,, TuC. `vll~i: 200S JK
... ; -04CK0('
John Barber of NYS Assembly has requested that we send you this exception alert. The UPS shipment listed below hb.s experienced an. exception.
Exception Details for Outbound Shipments(s)
ServiCe; UPS Next Dsy Air Shipme:n Peterar'e Nc,. : )84 Ship To Information OFFICE OF COMMISSIOIJ APPELLATE ADJU WASHiNGTON CC US No, Tracking Re;chad~lJed E~~cieption Description - ZxCeption Resolution Number/ Referenlce DelIivery Date Number A -'A TR5S5 5SyI ArEMPTHiýZi T.0 DTA.7'M THI!S ;,A$ BTEEN'HE~I2
!111PCRMAIITION
.21,2 ! 2v8p ihFU GUVG 4VD ZU13 34AGH IL32 U24Lx 11-9)3 Disoovet more sbotu UPS Visit uos.oom Explore UPS Business Solutions Learn About UPS Companies Sin Up For Additional E-rnjai From UPS Read C maass Online Watch the UPS bifling PortWia De'rngr&
P'w-O(- se1/4rzOrvize QfArle: Inc. ~UPS
'eS :ciI
=w~nn;A r rnare -rdrik fU'iec Par~ee f~~r~
Ane cir,..A; rigras reserveZ',
For~ fT-Or' rrforr'ýalton C 'iUps-;'vac prazices, refer it, ite U ' s PrivacyIi:
ýý c¶.acre.p!y Ji~rennly to !rPS ~r~ wi; nul~ i'rv repiv nn!'33 F~rajrs"m 0!. S ~: ~ UPS.
rrz~~ I~i cr~~:~.
I c r~fl~fl3:'. ~a z~.~erT;~. y~i~ :i ~ ~i~Ih.e: rea:ing, zCopyji'g an rz: i_!ý.c ilý" I n;&-'z JP-'
/{(A~7~~Z 1 4;> 312~
-[ - ~.:uc~ l~:Z'AN
2,?Sý I --.askiq hiorne- -ADOUI UPS Cwtz PS 1 erm.: Starreý &.UPS.=-i IS116~o UPS United States Tiracone Shcim Johkn Barher n piy UPs iddr=; Book Tr-acki ng Track Shipm~ents Track Shipments Track by Emnail Sions.iurc Trackinci 1 rack Packages & Freight Quantum View Flex Global View imnron Trackinc
'qum~b &s iracking Summary Wresrankina ~eIcZ a-k w'ith Ou~imnur Tracking Number: IZ 129 035 01 01C1 Z95 3 Ancess Flex Gla0ba: View V ~d a5;ipmen, I yope: Package Delivered
)eliverec On:
9':2e AjV.
Deliveced To: ROCKVILLE. MD, US 31gned By. HILLARD 3ervice: NEXT DAY AIR Tracking results provided by UPS: 031272008 3:49 A.M. ET bqut Find Answers to Your Trackinq Questions NoTICE: UPS authorizeas y13u to uSe JPS Irac~ing systems solaly Motrack sn ornents tendere-i by or f,-r vc),u to UPS for delivery and for no othe purp se.
ry tihe, use ofi UPS trarvir'. system~s anc mi naor'ma ics svric:tW pruhibited.
iE I~ ~ ~ d:~ i ~ n Iolc L~P
______- 1 Q-151 nlm,;ý UPS nrfe ____________t Co~yrightiý 199420-0 E Urvi-d Parzel SerJiC o. mrc Ins. All richS reserved.
\Ne r'mSte i, se-'r~'~vPoliýcy Tager-, -DK JlPST rffe Tes and oUtr
'A.-,
I': ackinL' Int-Onn. -AtIzi~ Pa.ue 1I (-,12 Tracking Detail Your package has experiEnced an exception.
Tracking Number IZ 129 935 01 0101 3,12 2 Type: Packaae Status, Exception See description below New Delivery Address: ROCKVILLE, MD, US Shipped/Bilied On, 03125/2008 Service: NEXT DAY AIR Weight! .30 Lb Package Progress LocationV bate L~ocal Time Description' LANDOVER 03 126'?2',DO8 5815A.M, MULTIPLE ERRORS EXIST IN THE MD US ADDRESS LABEL. UPS IS ATTEMPTING TO DETERMINE THE CORRECT INFORMATION TO COMPLETE DELIVERY i THE ADDRESS HAS BEEN CORRECTED.
THE DELIVERY HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED OUT FOR DELIVERY 03126i2008 5647 AM.
ARRIVAL SCAN PHILADELPHIA 03/26/2008 3:29 A.M: DEPARTURE SCAN PA. US COLONIE 03/25/"008 7:00 P M ORIGIN SCAN LATHAM, NY, US US 03/25t?008 4704 P.M. BILLING INFORMATION RECEIVED Tracking results provided by JPS: 03126/2008 12,34 P.M. ET NOTICE: UPS author;'zes v'.u to use UPS trazkinz svstems s,3eiy to, -rack sh ets teoered by or for yvoi to .J PS for dehvery and for rn_other purcpcse Any other use cf UPS tracKing sVstems inr.f0, at, is stric'v orobiteO 1;~.\u~~p. ... Ml Wr-~7Frc"":~y1~. ~ p
U.PS: TrackinL, InforMat iOJIIau1 f f2 sei : ~--i, r-r.
, x -*\ ",
3_1 t
Tracking Summary Trackinn Numbers I -Y~ ~~-Kj Tracking Number: IZ t29 935 01 0101 3122 Type:
Status:
Package Exception
~3I~2-i New Delivery Address. ROCKVILLE. MD. US Service: NEXT DAY AIR TrackiriigNumber:. Z12935 01. 0101 3168&
Type: )a~ckage Status:
Sched. Delivery: 33!2612008 Shipped To: ROCKVILLE, MD, US Service: NqEXT DAY AIR Tracking Number: 129 935 1 0O1 C 315 9 12 Type: !:ackage Status. fException 2-i New Delivery Address: ROCKVILLE. MD, US Service: I1EXT DAY AIR
[. Tracking Number: Z.129 935 01 010-1 314 0
-Type:. Package Status, ExCeption New Delivery Address ROCKVILLE, MD, US Service: NEXT DAY AIR.
Tracking Number: 1Z 129 935 01 0101 313 1 Typeý ; ackage Status:
New Delivery Address Exception FCOCKVILLE, MD, US 3/-2 Se-vice: NEXT DAY AIR
,Trac~inq results provided byi US: 03/26,2003 9 58 A'M El NOTICE: UPS authornzes you to use UPS trazking systems soleiy to track snipmers tencered by or for you to UPS fa! delivery and for no other p'roose. Anyvother use of UPS trackino systems and infcrmat!c-n ;s strictly prohibited.
I racLin~ lnroranJvQn I -'
hr~n \\yy~'~nflzz!~n<z' V¶~ '-C
~)ijfl&g
FR DM THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY. N.Y. 12248 Office of the Secretary Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop: O-16G4 U. S. Nuslea-rRegulatory Commission Washinýg-n, D.C 20555-0001 J/
,db f
- , */z I 742g--
j3//,.5/G8 BJ9 Pkq#Oq P9 ý4 696 3B aVT, 'ýP UPS .ID 104 7. 64ý wt, ; 1 rin I-
FROM:
THESTATE OF NEW ASSEMBLY YORK ALBANY, N. Y. 12248 A
- Office of the Secretary U.S. Nucle'ar Regulatory Commission Sixteent[ Floor One Flirt, North 11555 Rockville Pike
- Rockville, MD 20852
.4b
~'~z 2 1<k' k, 1,1
-~ //-127/l/e93 2 6 U~S D 13 7.71*
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF NEW YORK ALBANY. N.Y. 12248 Sherin rurk,-,Esq.
Counsee for NRC Staff U.S. Nuclear.Regulatory Commission Office of-the General Counsel Washingrton, D.C. 205155 3 /2FE/ne C1 B~p; Tr+00 10 :jj1 'C UsID iflq,
- 7. 6 4 iwflc I io j
=R CýVI:
THE ASSEMBLY STATE OF ,NEW YORK ALBANY, N.Y. 12248 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23
'Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 8
v
)3 /2!ý7/n a B1.9 PPgV()97 P, f 9614 6 132 $ Il *1(1 313 4 0 Trk9, UPS ID 1.04 7 64 WI:t .1V lb
- .7R :) rM:
,F
&THE ASSEMBLY YORK STATE OF NEW ALBANY, N. Y. 12248 Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Ui. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 2055-)0001 v
9 Vqh(9 f'2
.~2~:*~l I I)1 U P4q9c8 HP 3 ID IJI'1 7 F./I wt - I 1h
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC.) Docket Nos. 50-247/286-LR (Indian Point Nuclear Generating) )
Units 2 and 3) ) ASLBP No. 07-853-03-LR-BDO1
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of Petitioners' WestCAN et. al reply to the Atomic and Safety Licensing Board Order of April 1, 2008 has been served to the addresses below to the following by electronically on 7th day of April, 2008:
Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licensing Board/Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop: O-16G4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, D.C.' 20555-0001 Email: OCAAMAILL(nrc.gov E-mail: LGM1 )nrc..qov Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Office of the Sepretary Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop: O-16G4 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 E-mail: REW(anrc.,qov Email: HEARINGDOCKETgnrc.,qov Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop Zachary S. Kahn, Law Clerk Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 190 Cedar Lane E. Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Ridgeway, CO 81432 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: KDL2(anrc.gov Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Email: ZXK1(@nrc.qov Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 William C. Dennis, Esq. Manna Jo Greene Assistant General Counsel. Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Inc.
Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. 112 Little Market Street 440 Hamilton Avenue Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 White Plains, NY 10601 Email: Mannaiooclearwater.orq Email: wdennisaentergy.com
Kathryn M. Sutton, Esq. Justin D. Pruyne, Esq.
Paul M. Bessette, Esq. Assistant County Attorney Martin J. O'Neill, Esq. Office of the Westchester County Attorney Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP 148 Martine Avenue, 6 th Floor 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW White Plains, NY 1,0601 Washington, D.C. 20004 E-mail: idp3Cawestchesterqov.com E-mail: ksuttonm-morganlewis.com E-mail: pbessettetmor-ganlewis.com Daniel E. O'Neill, Mayor E-mail: martin.o'neill@morganlewis.com James Seirmarco, M.S.
Village of Buchanan Michael J. Delaney, Esq. Municipal Building Vice President - Energy Department Buchanan, *NY 10511-1298 New York City Economic Development E-mail: vobdbestweb.net Corporation (NYCDEC) 110 William Street John J. Sipos, Esq.
New York, NY 10038 Charlie Donaldson, Esq.
E-mail: mdelaneyvnycedc.com Assistants Attorney General New York State Department of Law John LeKay Environmental Protection Bureau FUSE USA The Capitol 351 Dyckman Street Albany, NY 12224 Peekskill, NY 10566 E-mail: iohn.siposoag.qstate.ny.us E-mail: fuse- usaiyahoo.com Arthur J. Kremer, Chairman Joan Leary Matthews, Esq.
New York Affordable Reliable Electricity Senior Attorney for Special Projects Alliance (AREA) New York State Department of 347 Fifth Avenue, Suite 508 Environmental Conservation New York, NY 10016 Office of the General Counsel E-mail: aikremera-rmfp.com 625 Broadway, 1 4 "hFloor kremer*.area-alliance.orq Albany, NY 12233-1500 E-mail: ilmatthe*.(*w.dec.state. nv.us Diane Curran, Esq.
Harmon, Curran, Spielberg & Eisenberg, LLP 1726 M Street, NW, Suite 600 Washington, D.C. 20036 E-mail: dciurranCa),harmoncurran.com Robert Snook, Esq. Victor Tafur, Esq.
Office of the Attorney General Phillip. Musegaas, Esq.
State of Connecticut Riverkeeper, Inc.
55 Elm Street 828 South Broadway P.O. Box120 Tarrytown, NY 10591 Hartford, CT 06141-0120 E-mail: phillipýriverkeeper.orq E-mail: robert.snook@po.state.ct.us vtafura-riverkeeper.org Daniel Riesel, Esq.
Thomas F. Wood, Esq.
Ms. Jessica Steinberg, J.D.
Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C.
460 Park Avenue New York, NY 10022 E-mail: drieselLcsprlaw.com Elise N. Zoli, Esq.
isteinbergqsprlaw.com Goodwin Procter, LLP Exchange Place Ms. Nancy Burton 53 State Street 147 Cross Highway Boston, MA 02109 Redding Ridge, CT 06876 E-mail: ezolieaoodwinprocter.com E-mail: nancyburtonctcaol.com Janice A. Dean, Esq.
Counsel for NRC Staff Assistant Attorney General U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of the Attorney General Office of the General Counsel 120 Broadway, 2 6 th Floor Washington, D.C. 20555 New York, NY 10271 E-mail: kimberly.sextonc5nrc.qov E-mail: ianice.deanqoag state, ny. us Sherwin.turk0,nrc.qov christopher.chandleranrc..qov Beth. Mizunoc(Dnrc.qov DaVid.Rotha-nrc.qov Lloyd. Subin(&anrc.cov Office of the Secretary* Mylan L. Denerstein U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Executive Deputy Attorney General Sixteenth Floor Office of the N.Y. Attorney General One Flint North 120 Broadway, 2 5 th floor 11555 Rockville Pike New York, New York 10271 Rockville, Maryland 20852 Mvlan. Denerstein.oaa.state. nv. us John Louis Parker, Esq. Marcia Carpentier, Law Clerk Regional Attorney Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Office of General Counsel, Region 3 Mail Stop: T-3 E2B NYS Dep't of Envt'l Conservation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 21 S. Putt Corners Road Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 New Paltz, New York 12561-1620 Marcia.Carpentier(Dnrc.gov ilparkeremov.dec.state.nv. us
ýýa Shap)re,EX_
- Original and two copies