ML070220411

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
New England Coalition, Inc.'S Motion to Compel, with Exhibits 1 - 16
ML070220411
Person / Time
Site: Vermont Yankee Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 01/16/2007
From: Tyler K
New England Coalition, Shems, Dunkiel, Kassel, & Saunders, PLLC
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY RAS
References
50-271-LR, ASLBP 06-849-03-LR, RAS 12885
Download: ML070220411 (923)
v • d • e


Text

DOCKETED USNRC January 16, 2007 (4:36pm)

UNITED STATES OFFICE OF SECRETARY NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR VERMONT YANKEE, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLB No.06-849-03-LR

)

(Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station) )

NEW ENGLAND COALITION. INC.'S MOTION TO COMPEL Pursuant to 10 C.F.R.. § 2.323 and the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's ("the Board's) Initial Scheduling Order in this matter, issued November 17, 2006, the New England Coalition, Inc. (NEC) moves to compel the clarification of Entergy's privilege logs, attached hereto as Exhibits 1-15 , and to compel the production of documents, as follows:

1. NEC requests that the Board require Entergy to amend its privilege logs to state the actual purpose for which all documents for which it claims work product privilege, but not attorney-client privilege, were prepared;
2. NEC requests that the Board compel production ofall documents Entergy has withheld as work product-privileged that were prepared for the purpose of developing or supporting Entergy's application to the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources for its NPDES permit(s), § 316 determination or variance and equivalent permits and supporting documentation, or which otherwise concern the administrative proceedings before the Agency of Natural Resources concerning this permit(s);
3. NEC requests that the Board require Entergy to produce data concerning fisheries and hydrological modeling for which Entergy has claimed work product privilege; and
4. NEC requests clarification of privilege log entries for "articles" on "research regarding fisheries" for which Entergy claims work product privilege.

Note that hand-written notations on Entergy's privilege logs are those of NEC's counsel, and not of Entergy's counsel.

=f cy X- D9

I. NEC ATTEMPTED TO CONSULT ENTERGY Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.323(a), and the Board's Initial Scheduling Order, NEC's counsel e-mailed Entergy's counsel on January 11, 2007 to consult regarding the issues raised in this Motion. See, Exhibit 16. To date, Entergy's counsel has not responded to this e-mail.

If. ARGUMENT The work product privilege protects only:

(1) documents and tangible things, (2) prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial and (3) by or for another party or by or for that other party's representative.

In the Matter of Public Service Company ofNew Hampshire, et. al. (Seabrook Station, Units 1 and 2), 17 NRC 490, 495 (1983). The work-product privilege is not absolute: a party may obtain discovery of attorney work product upon a showing that it has a substantial need for the materials, and is unable to obtain their substantial equivalent by other means. 10 C.F.R. § 2.705(b)(3). The purpose of the work product privilege is primarily to protect the confidentiality of legal strategy and tactics. Pacific Gas and Electric Company v. United States, 69 Fed. Cl. 784, 808 (2006). In ordering discovery of work product, the Board is therefore to "protect against disclosure of the mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories of an attorney for a party concerning the proceeding." Id.

2

The work product rule in practice before the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is currently codified under the Subpart G rules,2 and reads in full as follows:

Trial preparation materials. A party may obtain discovery of documents and tangible things otherwise discoverable under paragraph (b)(1) of this section and prepared in anticipation of or for the hearing by or for another party's representative (including his attorney, consultant, surety, indemnitor, insurer, or agent) only upon a showing the party seeking discovery has substantial need of the materials in the preparation of this case and that he is unable without undue hardship to obtain the substantial equivalent of the materials by other means. In ordering discovery of such materials when the required showing has been made, the presiding officer shall protect against disclosure of the mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories of an attorney for a party concerning the proceeding.

10 CFR § 2.705(b)(3). 3 This rule was adopted from Rule 26(b)(3) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 4 and caselaw interpreting the federal rule is therefore instructive. In the Matter\ ofLouisiana Energy Services, L.P. (ClaiborneEnrichment Center), 37 NRC 64, 68 (1993)("Where an NRC rule of practice is based on a Federal Rule of Civil Procedure, judicial interpretations of that federal rule can serve as guidance for the interpretation of the analogous [NRC] rule.").

2 The Subpart C rules do not appear to include a statement of the work product rule. NEC therefore references the rule as codified under the Subpart G rules, on the assumption that the work product rule is the same in all practice before the NRC.

3This rule was previously codified in the same terms at 10 C.F.R. § 2.740(b)(2).

4Federal rule 26(b)(3) is nearly identical to 10 C.F.R. 2.705(b)(3), and reads as follows:

"[A] party may obtain discovery of documents and tangible things otherwise discoverable under subdivision (b)(1) of this rule and prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by or for another party or by or for that other party's representative (including the other party's attorney, consultant, surety, indemnitor, insurer, or agent) only upon a showing that the party seeking discovery has substantial need of the materials in the preparation of the party's case and that the party is unable without undue hardship to obtain the substantial equivalent of the materials by other means. In ordering discovery of such materials when the required showing has been made, the court shall protect against disclosure of the mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories of an attorney or other representative of a party concerning the litigation."

F.R.C.P. 26(b)(3).

3

A. NEC requests that the Board require Entergy to amend its privilege logs to state the actual purpose for which all documents.for which it claims work product privilege, but not attorney-client privilege, were prepared.

Entergy's privilege logs are inadequate to permit NEC to assess the applicability of the work product privilege to the majority of documents for which Entergy claims work product privilege. The majority of the materials Entergy identifies as attorney work product, on all of the privilege logs Entergy has produced to date, predate NEC's May 26, 2006 Petition to Intervene in this matter, in some cases by many years. See, Exhibits 1-

15. These materials cannot, therefore, have been prepared "in anticipation of' the litigation of NEC's contentions. NEC does not dispute that documents prepared in preparation for other litigation to which Entergy has been a party in the past might be work product-privileged in this litigation. But likewise, many of these documents predate the appeal of Entergy's NPDES permit amendments and many may predate the uprate proceedings. Indeed, Entergy had to conduct water quality studies in order to apply for the NPDES permit amendments and the uprate. Such studies are not prepared in anticipation of litigation. Entergy's privilege logs, however, do not state the purpose for which purportedly work product-privileged documents were created.

A party resisting discovery on grounds of work product privilege has the burden.

of establishing that the material is protected by the rule, and must provide a privilege log describing the nature of the materials withheld as work product in sufficient detail to enable other parties to assess whether the privilege applies. 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(a)(3)(privilege logs must include "sufficient information for assessing the claim of privilege or protected status of the documents."). "A mere assertion.., that the material 4

withheld constitutes attorney work product is insufficient to meet that burden." In the Matter of Public Service Company of New Hampshire, Supra.

NEC is unable to evaluate the applicability of the work product privilege, especially to those documents that predate this litigation, without knowing the purpose for which materials were prepared. Pacific Gas & Electric Company, 69 Fed. Cl. at 798-99("the purpose for which a party created a document is the fundamental requirement of the [work product] Rule, and ...when litigation is reasonably anticipated, certain, or even underway, a court must still undertake an examination of why a document was produced."(emphasis in original)). NEC therefore requests that the Board require that Entergy amend its privilege logs to state the purpose for which all documents for which it claims work product privilege, but not attorney-client privilege,5 were prepared.

B. NEC requests that the Board compel production of all documents Entergy has withheld as work product-privileged that were prepared for the purpose of developing or supporting Entergy's application to the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources for its NPDES permit(s), § 316 determination or variance and equivalent permits and supporting documentation, or which otherwise concern the administrative proceedings before the Agency of Natural Resources concerning this permit(s):

Much of Entergy's withheld materials appear to have been prepared in the process of developing Entergy's application to the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources for the Clean Water Act NPDES permit(s) and § 316 variance (or equivalent permits, determinations, variances, and supporting documentation) authorizing its thermal discharges to the Connecticut River, or to otherwise relate to the administrative proceedings concerning this permit(s) before the state agency. Such materials are not privileged work product because they were not prepared in anticipation of adversarial 5NEC does not, at this time, contest Entergy's assertions of attorney-client privilege.

5

litigation, but rather in the ordinary course of business or to satisfy public requirements unrelated to litigation. NEC requests that the Board require that Entergy produce them.

The Advisory Committee notes to the federal work product rule explain that the privilege does not apply to materials developed in the ordinary course of business or pursuant to public requirements unrelated to litigation.

Materials assembled in the ordinary course of business, or pursuant to public requirements unrelated to litigation, or for other nonlitigation purposes are not under the qualified immunity provided by this subdivision.

F.R.C.P. 26(b)(3), Advisory Committee Notes, 1970 Amendment. This exception means that "documents.. . that would have been created in essentially similar form irrespective of litigation are not protected," and applies even though a party may anticipate that the documents will be helpful in the event of litigation, and even if they do in fact become relevant to litigation. Pacific Gas & Electric Company, 69 Fed. Cl. at 791-92, 798.

This exception is reflected in NRC precedent. See e.g, In the Matter of Kerr-McGee Chemical Corporation(West Chicago Rare Earths Facility)and In the Matter of Kerr-McGee Chemical Corporation(Kress Creek Decontamination),22 NRC 604, 621 (1985)( "[M]aterials developed 'in the ordinary course of business or pursuant to public requirements unrelated to litigation' are not [work product-privileged]); In the Matter of Commonwealth Edison Company (BraidwoodNuclear Power Station, Units I and 2), 23 NRC 177 (1986)("The input of counsel to documents required under the regulatory process and otherwise discoverable cannot immunize these documents from discovery.");

In the Matter of GeorgiaPower Company, et. al. (Vogtle Electric GeneratingPlant, Units 1 and 2), 37 NRC 469, 473 (1993)(materials that are not prepared in anticipation of 6

litigation are not work product-privileged despite their subsequent relevance to other litigation).

Federal courts have applied this exception to deny work product protection to materials prepared in making an application for a state permit, and to documents that concern state agency proceedings concerning permit applications. A recent decision of the United States Court of Federal Claims, Pacific Gas andElectric Company v. United States, 69 Fed. Cl. 784 (2006), includes a very extensive discussion of this issue, and a broad review of relevant federal caselaw. Id. at 787-810.

The Court, in Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E), considered whether the work product privilege should apply to materials- related to proceedings before the California Coastal Commission (CCC), concerning PG&E's application for a building permit on coastal property. The Court concluded that work product privilege should not apply either to materials PG&E developed to prepare its permit application, or to materials concerning the proceedings before the CCC. It found that CCC permit proceedings, which involved a public hearing on the permit application, and an opportunity for persons opposing the application to submit comments, were not "litigation," as this term is understood for purposes of the work product privilege, but rather "primarily exparte administrative, not adversarial proceedings." Pacific Gas and Electric Company, 69 Fed. Cl. at 804. The Court further noted that PG&E was required to obtain a coastal development permit in the ordinary course of its business, and that documents created in preparing a permit application therefore were not "in anticipation of litigation." Id. at 804 n. 10.

7

Like the proceedings before the CCC, proceedings before the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources to obtain a state NPDES permit are non-adversarial. The state agency is required to provide public notice of each permit application, and must either hold a public hearing, or provide opportunity for written public comments on the application before making a final ruling. 10 V.S.A. 1263.6 These proceedings are not "litigation" for purposes of the work product rule. It is a quasi-legislative process - not quasi judicial. Materials Entergy or its agents prepared in assembling its application(s) for NPDES permit(s) were prepared in the ordinary course of business, or pursuant to public requirements unrelated to litigation, and are not work product-privileged. The fact that the grant of Entergy's NPDES permit subsequently became the subject of "litigation" when the permit amendments were appealed to the Vermont Environmental Court7 does not retroactively create a work product privilege for the permit application, or for documents concerning the proceedings before the state agency. See, In the Matter of GeorgiaPower Company, et. al. (Vogtle Electric GeneratingPlant, Units 1 and 2), 37 NRC 469, 473 (1993)(materials that are not prepared in anticipation of litigation are not 6 This provision reads in relevant part as follows:

"[T]he secretary shall provide for notice of each application to the public and any appropriate officials of another state and the federal government including the administrator of the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and shall provide an opportunity for written comments or a public hearing or both on the application before making a final ruling on the application.

If the secretary determines that the proposed discharge will not reduce the quality of the receiving waters below the classification established for them and will not violate any applicable provisions of state or federal laws or regulations, he shall issue a permit containing terms and conditions as may be necessary to carry out the purposes of this chapter and of applicable federal law."

10 VSA 1263(b), (c).

7 Vermont statute provides that "any person aggrieved" may appeal the grant of an NPDES permit to Vermont's Environmental Court. 10 VSA §§ 1269, 8504. The Vermont Supreme Court hears appeals from the Environmental Court. 10 V.S.A. § 8505.

8

work product-privileged despite their subsequent relevance to litigation); Pacific Gas &

Electric Company, 69 Fed. Cl. at 791-92, 798 (documents prepared in the ordinary course of business or pursuant to public requirements unrelated to litigation are not work product privileged even if a party anticipates that they will be relevant to future litigation, or if they are in fact relevant to litigation).

NEC requests that the Board require Entergy to produce any materials Entergy or its agents prepared in assembling its application(s) for NPDES permit(s), or which relate to the proceedings concerning Entergy's NPDES permit(s), § 316 determin~ations or variances, equivalent permits and supporting documentation before the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources.

C. NEC requests that the Board require Entergy to produce data concerning fisheries and hydrological modeling for which Entergy has claimed work product privilege.

Entergy claims attorney work product privilege for what appears to be a large quantity of data, charts and graphs, maps, reports, computer animations, and studies concerning "fisheries data" and "hydrothermal modeling." There are many such entries on all of Entergy's privilege logs. The log NEC has labeled Exhibit 13, for example, contains approximately 80 such entries. See, Exhibit 13, document numbers 43-45, 54, 57, 60-62, 64, 65, 87-89, 123-147, 149-165, 168, 170-71, 173-176, 178, 180-185, 187, 188, 221, 222, 225, 231, 260, 261,273, 274, 283, 290, 292-293, 326, 328, 331.

NEC can obtain discovery of this type of factual information, even if it is attorney work product, provided that it does not reveal an attorney's mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories, upon a showing that NEC has substantial need for the materials, and is unable to obtain their substantial equivalent by other means. 10 9

C.F.R. § 2.705(b)(3). Data Entergy has developed or compiled concerning the Connecticut River fishery, and the impact of its thermal discharges to the river is clearly relevant to NEC's Contention 1, which concerns whether Entergy has adequately assessed the impacts of these thermal discharges during the proposed renewed license term. Entergy is, to NEC.'s knowledge, the sole custodian of its analyses. Due to resource constraints, NEC is unable to replicate them.

As NEC, a small not-for-profit organization that relies on volunteers and local donations, has a substantial need for this information and is unable to obtain it by other means, NEC requests that the Board require Entergy to produce materials its privilege logs identify as data, charts and graphs, maps, reports, computer animations, and studies concerning "fisheries data" and "hydrothermal modeling." NEC would not object if the Board requires Entergy to produce in redacted form any such material that reveals its attorneys' mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories.

D. NEC requests clarification of privilege log entries for "articles" on "research regarding fisheries" for which Entergy claims work product privilege.

Entergy claims attorney work product privilege for a number of "articles" on the subject of "research regarding fisheries." See, Exhibit 14, document numbers 1246-1252.

NEC requests that Entergy clarify the nature of these documents. If they are published journal articles, NEC requests that the Board require that Entergy produce them, as they are not work-product privileged.

III. CONCLUSION NEC's Motion to Compel should be granted.

10

January 16, 2007 New England Coalition by: k 1j I - -

Ro*ald A. Shems J Karen Tyler SHEMS DUNKIEL KASSEL & SAUNDERS PLLC For the firm Attorneys for NEC 11

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )

)

Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. ) ASLBP No. 06-849-03-LR

)

(Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station) )

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Karen Tyler, hereby certify that copies of the NEW ENGLAND COALITION, INC'S, MOTION TO COMPEL in the above-captioned proceeding were served on the persons listed below, by U.S. Mail, first class, postage prepaid; by UPS overnight to Judge Elleman; and, where indicated by an e-mail address below, by electronic mail, on the 16th day of January, 2007. Due to the large volume of Entergy's privilege logs, Exhibits to NEC's Motion to Compel were not served by e-mail.

Administrative Judge Office of the Secretary Alex S. Karlin, Esq., Chair Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Mail Stop: O-16C1 Mail Stop T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: hearingdocket@nrc. gov E-mail: ask2@nrc.gov Sarah Hofmann, Esq.

Administrative Judge Director of Public Advocacy Thomas S. Elleman Department of Public Service Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 112 State Street, Drawer 20 5207 Creedmoor Road, #101 Montpelier, VT 05620-2601 Raleigh, NC 27612 E-mail: sarah.hofmann@state.vt.us E-mail: elleman@eos.ncsu.edu Mitzi A. Young, Esq.

Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Steven C. Hamrick, Esq.

Mail Stop: O-16C1 Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop 0-15 D21 Washington, DC 20555-0001 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: OCAAmail@nrc.gov Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: may@nrc.gov; schl@nrc.gov Administrative Judge Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Marcia Carpentier, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop T-3 F23 Mail Stop T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: rew@nrc.gov Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail mxc7@nrc.gov; Jmr3@nrc.gov

Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq. Jennifer J. Patterson, Esq.

National Legal Scholars Law Firm Senior Assistant Attorney General 84 East Thetford Road Environmental Protection Bureau Lyme, NH 03768 33 Capitol Street E-mail: aroisman@nationallegalscholars.com Concord, NH 03301 Jennifer.Patterson@doj.nh.gov David R. Lewis, Esq.

Matias F. Travieso-Diaz Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP 2300 N Street NW Washington, DC 20037-1128 E-mail: david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com matias.travieso-diaz(*,pillsburylaw.com SHEMS DUNKIEL KASSEL & SAUNDERS, PLLC by: _ _____

Karen Tyler 91 College Street Burlington, VT 05401 802 860 1003 802 860 1208 (fax) ktyler@sdkslaw.com for the firm Attorneys for New England Coalition, Inc.

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No Typeof Date Recipient CC Sublect Privlileed Asserted Document Lynn Dewald; Chuck Barlow;, George Thomas; Attorney-Client Susan Ward; Elise Zoli; Communication; Attorney 1 eMail 2/15/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to Barbara Ripley, Mark strategy for communications Attorney-Client Mattson; Lynn Dewald; with ANR; Fisheries data; Communication; Attorney 2 eMail 12/1/2005 Chuck Barlow David McElwee Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Barbara Ripley, Chuck Barlow; Lynn Dewald; David McElwee; George 3 eMail 11/30/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Susan Ward; Chuck Barlow; Terence Burke; Steve Vekasy; George Thomas; David McElwee; Ricky Buckley, Jill Brochu; Carry Young; David Lueh; Douglas Taylor; Eileen 4 eMail 10/12/2006 Mike Metell Lynn Dewald Shuvrau Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 5 Memo 9/22/2006 Mike Metell Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product Attomey-Client Lynn Dewald; Chuck David McElwee; Mike Communication: Attorney 6 eMail 12/7/2005 Barbara Ripley Bariow Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney 7 Memo 12/4/2005 Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Attorney-Client Barlow; David McEhwee; Rob Williams; David 316(a) Demonstration; Communication; Attorney 8 eMail 12/1/2005 Barbara Ripley Mike Mattson Rocchio; Peter Van Oot Hydrothermal modeling Work Product 9 eMail with attachment 212412004 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 10 eMail with attachment 3/29/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll; Chuck Barlow, Mark Mattson; George Attorney-Client 11 eMail with attachment 8/19/2004 Lynn Dewald Barbara Ripley Thomas Versar Report Communication 12 eMail. 318/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Attomey-Client 13 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald 316(a) Demonstration Communication Attorney-Client Communication: Attorney 14 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald I 1316(a) Demonstration Work Product Page 1

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

NoTne of. C.CPrleedAstd N Document Date Recipient !cc Sublect Privileged Asserted 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 15 Draft Letter 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald with ANR; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 16 Notes 3/7/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 17 Notes 7/9/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 18 Memo 8/13/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 19 Memo 8/29/2006 Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Communication; 20 Notes 5/2612006 Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 21 Notes 5/26/2006 Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 22 Draft Letter 1/25/2005 Lynn Dewald with ANR Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; 23 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald Versar Report Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 24 Memo 7/24/2004 Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 25 Memo 2/6/2006 Lynn Dewald with ANR Work Product Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Dewald; Mark-Mattson; strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 26 eMail 1/30/2006 Barbara Ripley Elise Zoli with ANR Work Product 27 Memo 1/31/2006 Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Dewald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 28 eMail with attachment 1/31/2006 Elise Zoli Chuck Bariow Kevin Pechulis with ANR Work Product 29 Notes 2/2/2006 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling . Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Lynn Dewald; Mark strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 30 eMail 2/2/2006 Chuck Barlow Barbara Ripley Mattson; Elise Zoli with ANR Work Product Page 2 4

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

N of Document Date Recilent Cc Sublect Privileged Asserted Barbara Ripley; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Dewald; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 31 eMail with attachments 1/31/2006 Chuck Barlow Mattson with ANR Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 32 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product 33 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 34 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewaid Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 35 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 36 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 37 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 38 Memo 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product 39 Chart Undated Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 40 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 41 eDoc Undated Chuck Barlow Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 42 Notes Undated Chuck Barlow Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 43 Data 1/17/2003 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 44 Data Undated Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 45 Data Undated Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 46 Notes 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 47 Notes 7/10/2006 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 48 Notes 7/7/2006 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 49 Notes 7/7/2006 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 50 Memo 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 51 Notes Undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 52 Memo 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 53 Memo 2/16/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 54 Data 8/3/2004 Sankar Subbayya Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 55 Memo 2/17/2004 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 56 Memo 2/17/2004 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 57 Data 11/27/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 3

.. 2_.J

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No rvoeof Document Su ec

_ Do m Date Recipient Suble Privileged Asserted Fisheries data; 316(a) 58 Memo 3/31/2005 Lynn Dewald Demonstration Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 59 Draft Letter Undated Elise Zoli modeling Attorney Work Product 60 Report 1/11/2005 Lynn Dewald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 61 Report 1/27/2004 Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 62 Report 4/13/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Chuck Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 63 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoli Barlow; Elizabeth Mason modeling Attorney Work Product 64 Data 4/5/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 65 Report 5/21/2004 Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Fisheries data; Hydrothermal CommunicaUon; Attorney.

66 eMail with attachment 8/16/2004 Elise Zoli Lynn Dewald modeling Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Attorney-Client 67 eMail with attachment 2/28/2005 Elise Zoli Lynn Dewald Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Communication Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Lynn Dewald; George modeling; 316(a) 68 eMail with attachment 3/9/2004 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson Thomas; Suzanne Arena Demonstration Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Lynn Dewald; Chuck strategy for communications Attomey-Client 69 eMail with attachments 12/31/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow; Mark Mattson Mark McEiwee with ANR Communication Barbara Ripley;, Lynn 70 eMail 2/2/2004 Mark Mattson Dewald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Lynn 71 eMail 2/24/2004 Mark Mattson Dewald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Barlow; George Thomas; Susan Ward; Elise Zoli; 72 eMail 10/24/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barlow; Lynn Dewald; David McElwee; George 73 eMail with attachments 10/24/2005 Thomas I 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Page 4 0 )._

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

Typeof No Document Date Recilent cc Sublect Privileged Asserted Susan Ward; Chuck Correspondence relating to Barlow, Terence Burke; strategy for communications Attorney-Client 74 eMail 12/11/2005 Lynn Dewald Steve Vekasy with ANR Communication Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Attorney-Client Rob Williams; David with ANR; Fisheries data; Communication; Attorney 75 eMail with attachment 3/17/2004 Rocchlo; Peter Van Oct Hydrothermal modeling Work'Product Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoll; Mark Mattson; Vic Nutter; Attorney-Client Ricky Bucldey, George Communication; Attorney 76 eMail 5/17/2005 Lynn Dewaid Thomas Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Barlow, Dave McElwee; strategy for communications Attorney-Client 77 eMail with attachments 12/1412005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Peter Van Oct with ANR Communication Barbara Ripley; Suzanne Arena; Mark Mattson; Attorney-Client 78 eMail 7/14/2003 Lynn Dewald George Thomas 316(a) Demonstration Communication 79 eMail 3/30/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 80 eMail 4/20/2006 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 81 eDoc 2127/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald George Thomas modeling Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson; George Attomey-Client 82 eMail 3/9/2004 George Thomas Elise Zoli; Lynn Dewald Thomas Hydrothermal modeling Communication 83 eMail 7/5/2006 Dolord DeForge Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to George Thomas; Elise strategy for communications 84 eMail with attachment 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Zoli with ANR Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client George Thomas; Elise strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 85 eMail 7/14/2004 Lynn Dewald Zoli with ANR Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Attorney-Client with ANR; Hydrothermal Communication; Attorney 86 eMail 7/14/2004 Lynn Dewald George Thomas modeling Work Product 87 Report 6/20/2004 Dan Yasi Craig Nichols Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 88 Report 6/20/2004 Dan Yasi Craig Nichols Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 89 Report 6/20/2004 Dan Yasl Craig Nichols Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 5

. Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

NO Type of Date R ent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted

-Document 90 Draft Pleading 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Mattson; Susan Ward Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson; Susan David McElwee; Ward; George Thomas; Attomey-Client 91 eMail 3/29/2006 Chuck Barlow Saythayer Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Communication George Thomas; Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley; Mark Communication; Attorney 92 eMail 3/19/2006 Chuck Barlow Mattson; Elise Zoli Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Lynn Dewald; Mark Attorney-Client Mattson; Susan Ward; Communication; Attorney 93 eMal 1/27/2006 Chuck Barlow Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Lynn Dewald; Dave McElwee; Mark Mattson; Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley, J. Communication; Attorney 94 eMail 12/8/2005 Chuck Barlow Thayer; R. Buckley Fisheries data Work Product Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney 95 Draft Letter 12/2005 J. Thayer Fisheries data Work Product Elise Zoli; Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; George Thomas; Travis McCullough; Jay Thayer; Dave Terence Burke; Robert Attomey-Client 96 eMail 3/30/2006 Chuck Bariow McElwee Sloan Hydrothermal modeling Communication J. Thayer; Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley, Dave McElwee; Correspondence relating to George Thomas; Susan strategy for communications Attomey-Client 97 eMail 10/4/2005 Chuck Barlow Ward with ANR Communication Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Chuck Barlow, Mark Ricky Bucldey; Susan with ANR; 316(a) Attomey-Client 98 eMail 10/17/2005 Lynn Dewald Mattson; Elise Zoli Ward; J. Thayer Demonstration Communication Internal client e-mail 99 eMail with attachment 9/25/2006 Lynn Dewald Susan Ward forwarding work product Attorney Work Product Victoria Braun; Craig Anita Beren; Stephen 100 eMail 6/10/2004 Daniel Yasi Nichols Vigeant; Rhonda Falumb Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley, George Attorney-Client Thomas; D. Rocchlo; J. Communication; Attorney 101 eMal 6/20/2004 Barbara Ripley Thayer 316(a) Demonstration Work Product Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney 102 eMail 6/20/2004 Linda Paskiewicz Barbara Ripley 1316(a) Demonstration Work Product Page 6 ci )

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No TNpeof Document-D- Date Cent Sublect Privileged Asserted 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to Chuck Barlow; Susan strategy for communications Ward; Mark Mattson; with ANR; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client 103 eMail with attachment 10/18/2005 Lynn Dewald Barbara Ripley; J; Thayer modeling Communication Chuck Barlow; Ricky Buckley; George Correspondence relating to Thomas; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Attomey-Client 104 eMail with attachment 512/2005 Lynn Dewald Mattson; Barbara Ripley with ANR Communication Internal client e-mail 105 eMail with attachment 7/5/2005 Lynn Dewald Ricky Buckley forwarding work product Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Barlow; Mark Mattson; Attomey-Client David McElwee; George Communication; Attorney 106 eMail 12(7/2005 Barbara Ripley Thomas Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Chuck Barlow; George 316(a) Demonstration; Thomas; Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Communication; Attorney 107 eMail 3/31/2005 Lynn Dewald Dave McElwee with ANR Work.Product Chuck Barlow;, George Thomas; Mark Mattson; Attomey-Client 108 eMail 3/30/2006 Lynn Dewald Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Communication Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoll; Chuck Barlow; George Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 109 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas modeling Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoll; Chuck Barlow; George Thomas; Dave McElwee; Litigation strategy relating to Attomey-Client 110 eMail 9/8/2006 Lynn Dewald Susan Ward permit appeal Communication 111 Timeline 02/2005 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow, Mark Mattson; Dave McElwee; Correspondence relating to Jay Thayer George strategy for communications Attomey-Client 112 eMail 10/4/2005 Lynn Dewald Thomas; Susan Ward with ANR Communication Barbara Ripley; Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; Attomey-Client Elizabeth Mason; George Communication; Attorney 113 jeMall 11/1/2004 Elise Zoli Thomas Chuck Barlow 316(a) Demonstration Work Product Dave McElwee; David Attomey-Client 114 eMail 1/3/2006 Barbara Rlpley Rocchlo Susan Ward; Lynn Dewald IHydrothermal modeling Communication Page 7

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No Twe of.

- Document Date Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted Chuck Barlow;, George Thomas; Mark Mattson; Litigation strategy relating to Attomey-Client 115 eMail 3/18/2006 Barbara Ripley Elise Zoli; Lynn Dewald Susan Ward permit appeal Communication Lynn Dewald; Chuck Barlow; Dave McElwee; Attomey-Client Mark Mattson; George Communication; Attorney 116 eMail with attachment 7/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Thomas; Jay Thayer 316(a) Demonstration Work Product Chuck Barlow; Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Dave McElwee; George Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney-Client 117 eMail 10/4/2005 Jay Thayer Thomas; Susan Ward permit amendment Communication Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client 118 eMail 6/22/2005 Barbara Ripley George Thomas 316(a) Demonstration Communication Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 119 eMail with attachment 8/18/2004 Lynn Dewald George Thomas modeling Attomey Work Product Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley; George Thomas; Chuck Barlow;, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client 120 eMail 8/19/2004 Lynn Dewald Mattson Versar Report Communication Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney 121 eMail 6/22/2005 Barbara Ripley George Thomas 316(a) Demonstration Work Product Chuck. Barlow; George Thomas; Elise Zoll; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client 122 eMail 1/28/2005 Lynn Dewald Mattson; Barbara Ripley modeling Communication 123 Computer Animation Undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 124 Computer Animation Undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 125 Computer Animation Undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 126 Computer Animation Undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 127 Computer Animation Undated Hydrothermal modeling . Attorney Work Product 128 Computer Animation Undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 129 Report 4130/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 130 Chart Undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 131 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 132 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 133 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 134 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 135 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings __Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 136 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 137 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings IHydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 8 J

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

Type of Dt eilnIc Sublect Privileged Asserted No DocimCnt Date 138 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 139 Chart Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 140 Report Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 141 Report Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 142 Report 0412004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 143 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 144 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling; 145 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 146 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 147 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley-, Mark Mattson; Attorney-Client 148 eMail 3/18/2004 Lynn Oewald George Thomas Fisheries data Communication 316(a) Demonstration; 149 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 150 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration:

151 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 152 Computer Animation 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 153 Computer Animation 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 154 Computer Animation 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 155 Computer Animation 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 156 Computer Animation 04/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 157 Table Undated Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 158 Table Undated Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 159 Table 8/3/2004 Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 160 Table 7/28/2004 Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 161 Table . 7/29/2004 Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product 162 Table 1/25/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 163 Report 1/9/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 164 Report 1/14/2004 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 165 Report 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson IHydrothermal modeling. Attorney Work Product Page 9 C.

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License RenewalProceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No Type of Date R ei t Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserted Document D _

Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; George Attorney-Client Thomas; Chuck Barlow, Communication; Attorney 166 eMail with attachment 1/14/2005 Lynn Dewald Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli Fisheries data Work Product Mark Mattson; Lynn Dewald; Barbara Ripley; George Thomas; Chuck Attorney-Client 167 eMail 8/4/2004 Elise Zoli Bariow Fisheries data Communication Mark Mattson; Craig 316(a) Demonstration; Swanson; Lynn Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 168 Study Undated Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 169 Draft Letter 81312004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 170 Draft Report Undated Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 171 Report 04/2004 Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product.

316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 172 Draft Letter 3/15/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 173 Draft Study 4/5/2004 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 174 Computer Animation Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 175 Computer Animation Undated Craig Swanson _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 176 Computer Animation Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Elise 316(a) Demonstration; 177 eMail 4/21(2006 Mark Mattson Zotl Craig Swanson; Dan Yasi Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 178 Computer Animation Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 179 eMail 4/26/2006 George Thomas Mark Mattson Dan Yasi Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 180 Computer Animation Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 181 Chart Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 182 Diagram Undated Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 183 Chart Undated Dan Yasi Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 184 Table Undated Ram Srinivasan Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 185 Report 41412004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck Badow; Elise Zoli; Susan Ward; George 186 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald Thomas Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 187 Draft Study1 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 188 Table 5/15/2006 Mark Hutchings _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 10 (1

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

N._DocTvyeof Date Recipient CC Sublect Privileaed Asserted 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 189 Draft Letter 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson modeling Attorney Work Product 190 Table 1/28/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli; Attorney-Client 191 eMail 10/7/2006 Lynn Dewald Mark Mattson Fisheries data Communication George Thomas; Bryan 192 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Coke Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 193 eMall 7/13/2005 Lynn Dewald Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 194 Memo 7/11/2005 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Attorney-Client 195 Memo 8/15/2005 Chuck Barlow with ANR Communication Fisheries data; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 196 Memo 7/111/2005 Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; George Thomas; Mark Mattson; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 197 eMail 8/21/2004 Lynn Dewald Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; George Thomas; Mark Mattson; Attorney-Client 198 eMail 8121/2004 Lynn Dewald Chuck Bariow Versar Report Communication Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; Chuck Barlow, George Attomey-Client 199 eMail with attachments 9/13/2004 Lynn Dewald Thomas; Barbara Ripley Versar Report Communication George Thomas; Travis McCullough; Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley;, Lynn Attorney-Client George Thomas; Dave Dewald; Mark Mattson; Communication; Attorney 200 eMail with attachment 3/29/2006 Chuck Barlow McElwee Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Work Product George Thomas; Elise Chuck Barlow; Lynn 201 eMail with attachment 4/24/2006 Mark Mattson Zoli Dewald; Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Mark Fisheries data; 316(a) 202 eMail with attachments 5/9/2006 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoli Hutchings Demonstration Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 203 Notes 3130/2005 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 204 Memo 2/6/2006 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 205 Memo 2/7/2006 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Page 11 0

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

0rDocument Date RecipienI CC Sublect Privileged Asserted Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 206 Memo 3/24/2004 Mark Hutchings modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 207 eMail 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Chuck Barlow, Barbara George Thomas; Dave strategy for communications 208 Memo 7/19/2005 Lynn Dewald Ripley, George Thomas McElwee; Mark Mattson with ANR Attorney Work Product Julie Hayward; George Thomas; Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley, Mark Attomey-Client 209 eMail with attachment 5/2/2004 Lynn Dewald Mattson; R. Mast Versar Report Communication Sarah Heaton Hydrothermal modeling; Concannon; Lynn Litigation strategy relating to 210 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Dewald Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli permit appeal Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 211 Draft Letter 7/11/2005 Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Lynn Dewald; Richard Master; Mark Mattson; Barbara Attorney-Client 212 eMail 6/1/2004 Elise Zoli Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client 213 eMail 4/6/2004 Lynn Dewald Ripley; George Thomas Versar Report Communication 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data: Hydrothermal 214 Memo 11/22/2005 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 215 Draft Letter 12/8/2005 George Thomas modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; 216 Draft Letter 08/2004 Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Chuck Barlow; Elizabeth Mason; 217 eMail with attachments 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoli Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Chuck Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 218 eMail with attachment 2/14/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoli Barlow, Elizabeth Mason modeling Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Chuck Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 219 eMail with attachment 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn Dewald; Elise Zoli Barlow;, Elizabeth Mason modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; Correspondence relating to strategy for 220 Slides 8/12/2004 Chuck Barlow communications with ANR Attomey Work Product Page 12 0 'I

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No Typeof Date iin cc Sublect Privileged Asserted Document Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 221 Slides 2/812005 modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 222 Report Undated Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; Correspondence relating to strategy for 223 Memo 11/1/2004 Chuck Bariow communications with ANR Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 224 Draft Legal Document W131/2006 Chuck Bariow modeling Attorney Work Product 225 Slides 1/26/2004 Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal modeling; 226 Draft Legal Document Undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 227 Letter 3/7/2005 Barbara Ripley modeling Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Dave McElwee; Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson' George 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client 228 eMail 6/29/2005 Barbara Ripley Thomas; Jay Thayer Hydrothermal modeling Communication 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 229 Draft Outline 8/5/2004 Chuck Bartow modeling; Versar Report Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 230 Draft Outline 6/28/2006 Chuck Barlow modeling;. Versar Report Attorney Work Product 231 Draft Report 4/25/2006 Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 232 Notes 12/2/2005 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Lynn Dewald; Chuck with ANR; 316(a) Attorney Work Product; Barlow; Dave McElwee; Peter Van Oot; David Demonstration; Fisheries Attomey-Client 233 eMail 12/11/2005 Barbara Ripley Rob Williams Rocchio data; Hydrothermal modeling Communication Lynn Dewald; Chuck Attorney-Client 234 eMail 12/8/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow; Mark Mattson I Fisheries data Communication Page 13 C K._'-

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

__ TNo TTT e of Document Date _________ Recpent ICC Sublect Privileaed Asserted Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling;316(a) 235 Draft Letter Undated Lynn Dewald Demonstration Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 236 Draft Letter 8/16/2004 Chuck Barlow modeling; Versar Report Attorney Work Product Fisheries data;316(a)

Demonstration; Hydrothermal modeling; 237 Draft Letter 3/3/2005 Barbara Ripley Versar Report Attorney Work Product 238 Table Undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Versar Report; Fisheries data;316(a) Demonstration; 239 Draft Letter 3/7/2005 Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Versar Report; Fisheries data;316(a) Demonstration; 240 Draft Letter 3/7/2005 Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Strategy for communications 241 Notes Undated with ANR Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow; Barbara Ripley; Lynn Dewald; Fisheries data; Susan Ward; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to George Thomas; Mark strategy for communications 242 eMail 1/19/2005 Elise Zoli Mattson George Thomas with ANR Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Barlow, George Thomas; strategy for communications Attorney-Client 243 eMail 8/11/2005 Dave McElwee Peter Van Oct Susan Ward; Mark Mattson with ANR Communication Chuck Barlow; Dave McElwee; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Elise Zoli; Barbara strategy for communications Attomey-Client 244 eMail 3/16/2005 Lynn Dewald Ripley; George Thomas with ANR Communication Fisheries data;316(a) 245 Draft Letter 8/5/2004 Chuck Barlow Demonstration Attorney Work Product Litigation strategy relating to 246 Study 2/11/2003 Lynn Dewald NPDES appeal Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Barlow; Dave McElwee; strategy for communications Attorney-Client 247 eMail 12/1/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson David Rocchio with ANR Communication Page 14 J

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No Type of Date Reciplent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted N.__ Document Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli; George Thomas; Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; Attomey-Client 248 Memo 4/18/2006 Dave McElwee Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Communication Litigation strategy relating to 249 Notes 1/23/2003 Lynn Dewald NPDES appeal Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR; Fisheries data; 250 Notes 2/2/2005 Lynn Dewald Versar Report Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Lynn Dewald; George Attomey-Client Thomas; Chuck Barlow; Communication; Attorney 251 eMail 11/9/2004 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson Elizabeth Mason Fisheries data Work Product Correspondence relating to Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Chuck Barlow; with ANR; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client 252 eMail 3118/2006 George Thomas Elise Zoli; Lynn Dewald Susan Ward modeling Communication Elise Zoli; Lynn Dewald; Barbara Ripley, Chuck 253 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Chuck Barlow; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to George Thomas; Dave strategy for communications Attomey-Client 254 eMail 3/23/2005 Elise Zoli McElwee; Barbara Ripley with ANR Communication Chuck Barlow;, Lynn Dewald; Dave McElwee; Correspondence relating to George Thomas; Mark strategy for communications Attomey-Client 255 eMail 4/22/2005 Barbara Ripley Mattson with ANR Communication Chuck Barlow, Lynn Dewald; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Barbara Ripley;, George strategy for communications Attomey-Client 256 eMail 3/18/2005 Elise Zoli Thomas; Dave McElwee with ANR Communication 257 Table Undated Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow; Lynn Dewald; Dave McElwee; Correspondence relating to George Thomas; Mark Peter Van Oct; David strategy for communications Attomey-Client 258 eMail 7/912005 Barbara Ripley Mattson; Jay Thayer Rocchio with ANR Communication Page 15

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No of Date Recent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted Lynn Dewald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Barlow- Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Attorney-Client 259 Memo 81112005 Dave McElwee George Thomas with ANR Communication 260 Report 02/2003 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product" 261 Slides 7/31/2003 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to Barbara Ripley; Lynn strategy for communications Attorney-Client Dewald; Dave McElwee; with ANR; 316(a) Communication; Attorney 262 eMail 12/11/2005 Chuck Barlow Mark Mattson Demonstration Work Product 263 eMail 7/31/2003 Craig Swanson Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 264 Table 1/29/2003 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow; Barbara Lynn Dewald; Dave Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 265 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Ripley, Elise Zoli McElwee modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow;, Barbara Lynn Dewald; Dave 266 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Ripley, Elise Zoli McElwee Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Strategy for communications 267 Draft Study Undated with ANR Attorney Work Product Strategy for communications 268 Draft Letter 4/30/2004 Lynn Dewald with ANR Attorney Work Product 269 Table 7110/2003 Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; 316(a)

Demonstration; 270 Draft Letter 12/7/2005 Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; 316(a)

Demonstration; 271 Draft Letter 12/2005 Chuck Barlow Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; 316(a)

Demonstration; 272 Draft Letter 12/5/2005 Chuck Barlow Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 273 Data Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 274 table Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 275 Notes 7/1/2005 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product 276 Notes 4/15/2004 Barbara Ripley Draft letter to ANR Attorney Work Product Draft letter to ANR regarding 277 Notes 4/15/2004 Barbara Ripley NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product 278 Table Undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 279 Draft Letter Undated Lynn Dewald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 280 Draft Letter 3/16/2004 Carol Carpenter with ANR Attorney Work Product 1281 Draft Letter 12/2005 George Thomas Fisheries data Attomey Work Product

  • Page 16 I

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

Typeof NoSDocument Date Recipient Sublect Privilened Asserted Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 282 Data 1/22/2005 Lynn Dewald with ANR Attorney Work Product 283 Chart 11/22/2005 Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) 284 Draft Letter 01/2006 Carol Carpenter Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn Dawald; Mark Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli; Attorney-Client 285 eMail 2/2/2005 Barbara Ripley Mattson George Thomas Hydrothermal modeling Communication Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR; Hydrothermal 286 Memo 5/18/2006 Chuck Barlow modeling; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn Dewald; Barbara Attomey-Client 287 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Ripley; Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Communication Attomey-Client 288 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Communication Chuck Barlow; Lynn Attorney-Client Dewald; Mark Mattson; Litigation strategy relating to Communication; Attorney 289 eMail 2/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Elise Zoli NPDES appeal Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 290 Data 10/16/2006 Lynn Dewald modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck Barlow; George Attorney-Client 291 eMail 12/4/2005 Lynn Dewald Thomas; Susan Ward Barbara Ripley Fisheries data Communication 292 Data Undated Mark Hutchlngs Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 293 Data Undated Mark Hutchlngs Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll; Chuck Barlow; George Thomas; Dave Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client 294 eMail 3/23/2005 Lynn Dewald Mark Mattson McElwee; Barbara Ripley modeling Communication 295 Memo Undated Chuck Barlow Versar Report Attorney Work Product 296 Slides 11/22/2005 Chuck Barlow 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 297 Memo 4/24/2006 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 298 Memo 1/12/2005 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Strategy for communications Attorney-Client 299 Notes 6/13/2005 Carol Carpenter with ANR Communication Attorney notes regarding 300 Notes 9/26/2005 Lynn Dewald NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; Dave McElwee; Chuck Barlow; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client George Thomas; Lynn strategy for communications. Communication; Attorney 301 eMail 6/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Dewald with ANR Work Product Page 17 J

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

No Document Date RCenc Sublect Privileged Asserted Dave McElwee; Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barlow; Attorney-Client George Thomas; Lynn Susan Ward; George 316(a) Demonstration; Communication; Attorney 302 eMail with attachment 6/22/2005 Elise Zoli Dewald Thomas; Elizabeth Mason Fisheries data Work Product Chuck Barlow;, Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; George Thomas; Barbara Ripley, 303 eMail 3/7/2005 Lynn Dewald Dave McElwee Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 304 eMail 6/29/2005 Lynn Dewald George Thomas Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Norman Rademader; Susan Ward; Bill Pittrnan; Ed Harris; George Thomas; William 305 eMail 5/15/2006 Lynn Dewald Maguire; John Dreyfuss Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR; Litigation strategy relating to 306 Notes 1/17/2005 Chuck Barlow permit appeal Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney 307 Memo 10/19/2004 Chuck Barlow Hydrothermal modeling Work Product Attorney-Client Litigation strategy relating to Communication; Attorney 308 Notes 3/24/2006 Chuck Barlow permit appeal Work Product Litigation strategy relating to 309 Notes 8/5/2005 Chuck Barlow permit appeal Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 310 Notes 8/4/2004 Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 311 Notes 8/4/2004 Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product Litigation strategy relating to 312 Notes 2/7/2006 Chuck Barlow permit appeal Attorney Work Product Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal; Hydrothermal 313 Draft Letter 3122/2006 Chuck Barlow _modeling Attorney Work Product Page 18

Privilege Log for Documents Through October 23, 2006, Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

Prepared by counsel for Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY). ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log.

NOType of Dt C No DDome Recipient C Sublect Privileged Asserted

'ocument D Dt eoet________

Litigation strategy relating to 314 Draft Letter 3/22/2006 Chuck Barlow permit appeal; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 315 Draft Letter 12/7/2005 Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 316 Draft Letter 317/2005 Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR; Hydrothermal 317 Draft Letter 3/22/2006 Chuck Barlow modeling Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 318 Letter 2/7/2006 Barbara Ripley with ANR Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 319 Notes Undated Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product 316 (a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 320 Notes 216/2006 Chuck Barlow with ANR Attorney Work Product Page 19

0 7)

Privile e Lou for O22umrnts Throunh October 23, 2006 This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) In connection with Entergy Vermont Yankee Ucense Renewal proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary _ "_

ho. Document Date Author/Sendar Recipent Sublect Privileged Asserted 1 Data 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 2 Report 12/29/2004 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 3 Memo Undated Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 4 Memo Undated Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 5 Report Undated Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 6 Data Undated Mark Hutchins, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 7 Data 4/10/2006 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling

. .eMa..il 7/14/2003 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson3......................(a).Demonstration tomeyWork Product A...............

9 Letter 718/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 10 Memo 10/7/2004 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 11 Memo 9/22/2004 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 12 Data 12/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 13 Memo 3/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 14 Data 8/3/2005 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 15 Data Undated Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 16 Data 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 17 Memo 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 18 Memo 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product 19 Memo 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins 316(s) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 20 Memo 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_____modeling 21 Chart 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 22 Memo 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 23 Letter 4/6/2006 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 24 Memo 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 25 Memo 4129/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 26 ;Report 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 27 Chart 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 28 Report 4/24/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 29 Report 4/27/2006 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_ 1_ modeling tIl Page 1

0 9 No. 1X2Lof Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Sublect Privilened Asserted 30 Report 4/21/2006 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 31 Chart 3/22/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 32 Chart 3/22/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 33 Report 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 34 Data 4/20/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 35 Memo 8/2/2004 Mark Hutchins Fisherles data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 36 _Report 12/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 37 _Data 3/19/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 38 Report 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 39 Report 8/5/2004 Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 40 Data 3/19/2006 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 41 Report 12/14/2004 Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 42 Report 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 43 Re~port 4/28/2004 -- Mark Hutchins Fisheries q data Aýý _ _ ....-.......... Atm*Wr,,P.,,~,

........... rdc 44 Report 4/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 45 Data Undated Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 46 Data 8/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 47 Data 8/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 48 Data 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling . Attorney Work Product 49 Data 8/11/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 50 Table 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 51 Report 4/21/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 52 !Report 4/20/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 53 !Data 5/14/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 54 Data 5/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 55 Data 5/9/2005 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 56 Data 5/9/2005 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 57 Data 5/9/2005 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 58 Data Apr-04 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 59 _Data Apr-04 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 60 Report Apr-04 Mark Hutchins H',drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 61 Report Apr-04 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 62 Chart 4/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 63 Chart 4/27/2004 Paul Lindsay Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 64 Chart 3/23/2006 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 65 Report 2/9/2005 Lynne DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 66 _ Report 2/9/2005 Lynne DeWald Fishedes data Attorney Work Product 67 Report 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 68 _Report 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 69 Report 4/14/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product Page 2

0 0 No- Te of Document Date Author/Sender Reciient Cc Sublect Prlvileged Asserted 70 Report 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Versar Report 71 Memo 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 72 Memo 2/25/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 73 Chart 4/2012005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 74 Report 2/11/2005 Marcia Seneca Hvdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 75 Chart 2/24/2005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 76 Chart 2/14/2005 Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 77 Data 1/18/2005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 78 Data 2/24/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 79 Data 2/18/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 80 Data 7/27/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 81 Data 8/9/2004 _ Paul Undsay Hydrothermal modeling. Attorney Work Product 82 Data 8/6/2004 Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 83 Report 3/18/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 84 Report 7/2212004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 85 Data 8/9/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 86 Report 9/1/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 87 Data 8/2/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 88 Memo 7/9/2004 Ken Cox '._ 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 89 Data 8/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 90 Memo 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 91 Memo 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 92 Memo 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 93 Memo 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 94 Memo 8/4/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 95 Memo 3/18/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 96 Memo 8/2/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 97 Data 8/9/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 98 Data 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 99 Report Feb-03 Craig Swanson, Hyu Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Sook Kim, Sankar Subbayya, Paul Hall, Oigaresh Patel 100 Chart Undated Craig Swanson, Hyu Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Sook Kim, Sankar Subbayya, Paul Hall, Oigaresh Patel 101 Report Feb-03 Craig Swanson, Hyu Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Sook Kim, Sankar Subbayya, Paul Hall, Olgaresh.Patel..........-..... ... ..... . . ..-................ ... . ... o -- o -u..... ............

10e ot Feb-03 -. ----

r-o-t-herm

-- _H__yd al-mo-deai IA-ittorney Wo-Gr-k n-g--------------------- P-ro-d~uc~t Page 3

(

0 0 No. Type of Document Date AuthorlSender Recipent CC Sublect I Prlvileaed Asserted 103 Report 3/15/2004 Mark Mattson. Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 104 Report 3/18/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 105 Report 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark. 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul modeling; Fisheries data Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 106 Report 3/11/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 107 Report 3/13/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 108 Chart 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 109 Chart 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson . Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 110 Table 319/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 111 Table 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 112 Report 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 113 Report 3/31/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 114 Report 3/19/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne

____________________DeWald _________________________

Page 4

(

0 0 No. Type Document Date AuthorlSender Recipent CC Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserted 115 Report 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 116 Report 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 117 Report 1/31/2006 Mark Mattson, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hutchins, Paul Hydrothermal modeling Harmon, Craig Swanson, Lynne DeWald 118 Chart 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 119 Chart 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 120 Chart 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 121 Table 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 122 Table 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 123 Memo 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 124 Memo 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 125 Study 2/27/2004 Mark Mattson, Lynne 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product DeWald, Craig Hydrothermal modeling Swanson 126 Slides 1/27/2003 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 127 Slides 1/27/2003 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 128 Video Undated 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 129 Video Undated 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 130 Video Undated 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 131 Table 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling Page 5

0 .0 No. Tvoof Document Date Author/Sender Recopent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 132 Video Undated 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 133 Vdeo Undated 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 134 Slides 10/27/2003 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 135 Slides 10/30/2003 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration: Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 136 Slides 10117/2003 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 137 Study 4/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 138 Draft Letter Feb-04 Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product

, communications with ANR regarding NPDES 139 Draft Study 2/27/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 140 Table 8/3/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 141 Table 2/5/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 142 Memo 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Lynne DeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 143 Table 3/19/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 144 Table 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 145 Table 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 146 Table 2/10/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 147 Table 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 148 Draft Study 3/23/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 149 Draft Study 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 150 Draft Study 1/9/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 151 Draft Study 1/9/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 152 Table 2/5/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 153 Table 2/13/2004 Mark Mattson-- Fisheries data Aom yWorProduct 154 iDraft Study 2/7/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 155 Table 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 156 Draft Study 2/5/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 157 Draft Study 2/5/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 158 Study Jan-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 159 Draft Letter 3/12/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 160 Draft Letter 3/12/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 161 Draft Letter 2/19/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 162 Draft Letter 2/24/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 163 table 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 164 165 Chart Chart Undated 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal Hydrothermal modeling modeling Attorney Attorney Work Work Product Product 166 Chart 1/6=2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 167 Chart 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 6

(

© 0 No, TypeA Document Date Author/Sonder Recipen CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 168 Chart 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 169 Chart 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 170 Chart 116/2004 Mark Mattson _ _ _ _ Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 171 Chart 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 172 Chart 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 173 Chart 1/612004 Mark Mattson . H ydr al moe!ng AoneyworProduc .............

174 Chart 116/2004 Mark Mattson H)drotharmal modeling Attorney Work Product 175 SAS Output 1/612004 Mark Mattson H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 17_6 SAS Output 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson _ _Fisheres data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 177 Graphs 1/2/2004 Chris Gershln Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 178 Graphs 1/2/2004 Chris Gershln Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 179 Graphs 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 180 Graphs 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin _Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 181 Graphs 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 182 Chart 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 183 Chart 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 184 Chart 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 185 Chart 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 186 Chart 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 187 Chart 1/2/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 188 Table 116/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 189 Table 2/12/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 190 Table 3/12/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 191 Presentation 1/712004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 192 Table 2/13/2004 Chris Gershln Fisheriesdata; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 193 Table 3/9/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 194 Chart 2/17/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 195 Chart 2/19/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 196 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 197 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 198 Chart 2/17/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 199 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 200 Chart 2/17/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 201 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 202 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 203 Chart 2/19/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hycdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 204 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin _ Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 205 Chart 2/18/2004 Chris Gershin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 206 Chart 2/1712004 Chris Gershln _ Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 207 Draft Letter 1/28/2006 Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product communications with ANR regarding NPDES Page 7

0

(

No. Te Iof Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileoed Asserted 208 Letter 10/12/2006 Dave Lewis; Mark Chuck Barlow; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Mattson; Lynn Terrence Burke, Elise DeWald Zoli; Barbara Ripley;,

Mark Mattson; Mark Hutchins; Craig Swanson; Thomas George; David McElwee; Steve Vekasy, Rick Buckley; Jill Broche; David Lach; Garry Young; Bob West 209 Draft Pleading 6/27/2006. Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 210 Draft Pleading 6/16/2006 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 211 Memo Mark Mattson Sara Heaton Chuck Barlow; ElIse 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Concannon; Lynn Zoli DeWald 212 Draft Pleading 6/19/2006 Ross Jones Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 213 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N Concannon, Sarah Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Heaton 214 eMail 6/19/2006 Zoll, Elise N Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Heaton 215 eMail 6/19/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah Fisheries data; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Heaton; Fitzgerald, strategy for communications with ANR Robert H regarding NPDES 216 eMall 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N Concannon, Sarah Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney Work Product Heaton 217 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N Concannon, Sarah Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney Work Product Heaton 218 eMail 6/16/2006 Williams, U Gwyn Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N Attorney Work Product 219 eMail 6/8/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Fisheries data; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Wander IV,Samuel; strategy for communications with ANR Product Zoll, Elise N; regarding NPDES Rademacher, Norman L; Pittman, Bill; Mark Mattson 220 eMail 4/24/2006 Williams, U Gwyn Chuck Badow; Zoli, Elise N Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client DeWald, Lynn; Dave Communication McElwee; Barbara Ripley, Mark Mattson; Thomas George Page 8

0 No. Tyeo Document Date Author/Sender Recipient cc Sublect Prlvilened Asserted 221 eMail 4/20/2006 Barlow. Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson communications with ANR regarding NPDES 222 eMall 4/18/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product McEiwee, David; communications with ANR regarding Barbara Ripley; Zoli, NPDES Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 223 eMail 4/18/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product McEIwee, David; communications with ANR regarding Barbara Ripley; Zoli, NPDES Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 224 eMail 4/10/2006 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Barbara Ripley; NPDES Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Wender IV,Samuel 225 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Yasi, Daniel; Zoll, Senkel, Frank Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Elise N 226 eMall 4/6/2006 Yasi. Daniel Mark Mattson; Zoli, Senkel, Frank Hydrothernal modeling Attorney Work Product Elise N 227 eMail 4/6/2006 Mark Mattson Yasl, Daniel; Zoli, Senkel, Frank Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Elise N 228 eMail 3/2912006 Gordon, Anne T Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck 0 Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client communications with ANR regarding Communication NPDES 229 eMall 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Zoll, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N Product 230 eMall 3/24/2006 Thomas, George Zoll, Elise N; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 231 eMail 3/23/2006 Thomas, George Zoll, Elise N DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product Page 9

0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Redolent C.C Sublect Privileged Asserted 232 eMall 3/22/2006 Thomas, George Barlow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McCullough, Travis; Product Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Smith, Terrence 233 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Wonder IV,Samuel; Hydrothermal Modeling; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck Barlow; Zoli, George Thomas relating to strategy for communications with Product Elise N; DeWald Lynn ANR regarding NPDES 234 eMall 2/21/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client Elise N; Wander IV, Timothy Brush communications with ANR regarding Communication Samuel; Barbara NPDES; Fisheries data Ripley 235 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES; Fisheries data 236 eMail 2/7/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 237 eMail 1/27/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mark Mattson; Barbara Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Ripley; Wander IV, communications with ANR regarding Product Samuel; Zoll, Elise N NPDES 238 eMail 1/18/2006 Wonder IV,Samuel David Rocchio Zoli, Elise N Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 239 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Zoll, McElwee, David communications with ANR regarding Elise N NPDES; Hydrothermal Modeling; Fisheries data 240 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Zoli, McElwee, David communications with ANR regarding Elise N NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Page 10

q No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privilened Asserted 241 eMai 1212112005 Mark Mattson Baflow, Chuck D; DeWaid, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Zoli, McElwee, David communications with ANR regarding Elise N NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data 242 eMail 11/21/2005 DeWald, Lynn Vekasy, Steve; C. Wamser Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lefrancois, Mark; Product Pennino, Dennis; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N

  • 243 eMail 11/17/2005 DeWeld, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow. Product Chuck D; Tim Brush; Wender IV,Samuel 244 eMail 10/26/2005 DeWald Lynn Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; McCullough, Travis Barbara Ripley; McElwee, David; Peter Van Oot David Rocchlo 245 eMail 10/18/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 246 eMail 10/18/2005 Zoli, Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Mark Wender IV,Samuel; communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson Thayer, Jay;, NPDES Georgian, Kathryn A; Mason, Elizabeth F 247 eMail 10/18/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson Wender IV,Samuel; communications with ANR regarding Product Thayer, Jay; NPDES Georgian, Kathryn A;

_Mason, Elizabeth F 248 eMail 10/17/2005 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Wender IV,Samuel; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark Mattson Thayer, Jay; NPDES Georgian, Kathryn A4 Mason, Elizabeth F 249 eMail 10/17/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Buckley, Ricky N;. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Zoll, Wender IV,Samuel; communications with ANR regarding Elise N . Thayer, Jay NPDES Page 11

0 0 No. Typeof Document Date Author/Sender Reciplan CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 250 eMail 10/15/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zol., Elise N; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Chuck D NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 251 eMail 10/14/2005 Zoli, Elise N Mark T. Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Lynn DeWald; Chuck communications with ANR regarding D. Barlow NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 252 eMall 10/13/2005 Mark Mattson Z6i1,Elise N; Barlow, Chuck; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 253 eMail 10/13/2005 Zoll, Elise N Mark T. Mattson Chuck D. Barlow;, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 254 eMail 7/1212005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Product McEIwee, David; Jay NPDES Thayer; Mark Mattson; Thomas George 255 eMail 7/1/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas George; Zol, NPDES Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Jay Thayer, Mark Mattson 256 eMail 6/29/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; McEiwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley; Mark communications with ANR regarding Communication Mattson; Zoli, Elise N NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 257 eMail 6/29/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication McEIwee, David; Jay communications with ANR regarding Thayer; Zoll, Elise N; NPDES Mark Mattson; Thomas George Page 12

0 No. Typeo A Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Subiect Prvileged Asseied 258 eMail 6/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald. Lynn; McEiwee, David; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Wender IV, Samuel; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Nichols, Craig NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Elise N; Mark Mattson 259 eMall 6/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thayer, Patty;, communications with ANR regarding Product McElwee, David; NPDES Barlow. Chuck D; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley 260 eMail 6/8/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Elise N; Thomas, NPDES George; Barbara Ripley G; McElwee, David 261 eMail 5/24/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Elise N; Barlow, NPDES Chuck D; Thomas.

George 262 eMail 5/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Mattson 263 eMail 5/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication EliseN; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley, Thomas, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration George; Mark Mattson 264 eMall 5/17/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Elise N; Mark Mattson NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal modeling 265 eMail 5/12/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; David Elise N; Thomas, communications with ANR regarding M. Rocchlo; McElwee, George NPDES David 266 eMail 5/12/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; David Elise N; Thomas,. communications with ANR regarding M. Rocchlo; McElwee, George NPDES David Page 13

0 0 No. Type of I Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 267 eMail 5/9/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Mason, Alan Palmer Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elizabeth F communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 268 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication McElwee, David; communications with ANR regarding DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 269 eMail 4/27/2005 Barbara Ripley Badow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication David McElwee; communications with ANR regarding DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 270 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product DeWaid, Lynn; Zoli, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 271 eMail 4/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Mark communications with ANR regarding Mattson; Zoll, Elise N; NPDES McElwee, David 272 eMail 4/19/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Mark communications with ANR regarding Mattson; Zoll, Elise N; NPDES Dave McElwee 273 eMail 4/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley Barbara NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Ripley; Zoll, Elise N 274 eMail 3/31/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Attomey-Client Thomas, George; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Communication Elise N; Mark NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; McElwee, I_ _ f_

David I Page 14

No. Tyeof Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 275 eMail 3/29/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication McElwee, David; Mark communications with ANR regarding Mattson; Zoli, Elise N; NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Barbara Ripley 0 276 eMail 3/18/2005 Zoll, Elise N Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; communications with ANR regarding DeWald, Lynn; Mark McElwee, David NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Mattson; Thomas, George; McElwee, David 277 eMall 3/18/2005 Barbara Ripley Zoll, Elise N: Barlow, DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Thomas, George; communications with ANR regarding Lynn; Mark Mattson; McEIwee, David NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Thomas, George; McElwee, David 278 eMail 3/18/2005 Zoll, Elise N Barlow, Chuck 0; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Mark communications with ANR regarding Mattson; Barbara NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Ripley- Thomas, George; McElwee, David 279 eMail 3/17/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; DeWald, communications with ANR regarding Lynn: Thomas, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration

  • George; Mark Mattson 280 eMail 3/17/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley; Thomas, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration George; McElwee, David; Zoli, Elise N 281 eMail 3/11/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Fisheries data; correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication McElwee, David Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications with ANR George; Barlow, Chuck D 282 eMail 3/10/2005 Barbara Ripley McElwee, David DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Fisheries data; correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications with ANR Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D Page 15

No. Tvoeof Document Date Author/Sender Reciient CC Sublect Privlleced Asserted 283 eMail 3/10/2005 McElwee, David Barlow, Chuck D; Fisheries data; correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications with ANR Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 284 eMail 3/8/2005 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWaid, Lynn; communications with ANR Product Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, David 285 eMail 3/8/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, McElwee, David Fisheries data; correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barlow, Chuck strategy for communications with ANR; D Hydrothermal modeling 286 eMail 3/8/2005. DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Mark communications with ANR Product Mattson 287 eMail 3/8/2005 Zoll, Elise N DeWald. Lynn; McEiwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR Product Mark Mattson 288 eMail 3/8/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Badow, McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark communications with ANR Mattson 289 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Fisheries data; correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark strategy for communications with ANR; Mattson; Thomas, Hydrothermal modeling George; Barbara Ripley G; McElwee, David 290 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Zoll, communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Elise N; Barbara modeling Ripley G; Thomas, George; McEIwee, David; Wender IV, Samuel 291 eMail 3/7/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Chuck Barlow communications with ANR Product 292 eMail 3/7/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Product modeling Page 16

K>

No. TyAeof Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Prlvlaged Asserted 293 eMail 3/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoll, communications with ANR Elise N; Thomas, George; McEiwee, David; Mark Mattson 294 eMail 3/3/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoli, Elise N. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Product modeling 295 eMail 3/3/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; McEiwee, David; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Ciient Communication Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR Barbara Ripley G; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 296 eMail 3/3/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Clent Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, communications with ANR Product Chuck D; McElwee David; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 297 eMail 3/3/2005 McElwee, David David M. Rocchio; Thomas, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N 298 eMail 3/3/2005 David M. Rocchlo Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR Product DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson 299 eMail 3/3/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR Product Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee David; Mark Mattson 300 eMail 3/3/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR Product Elise N; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson Page 17

0 No. Tpe1 Document Date Author/Sender Recipient 9C Sublect I Privlleged Asserted 301 eMail 3/3/2005 McElwee, David Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR Product DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 302 eMail 3/3/2005 Badow, Chuck D McEIwee, David; David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR Product DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 303 eMail 3/3/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Thomas, communications with ANR Product George; Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee David; Mark Mattson 304 eMail 3/3/2005 McEiwee, David Barbara Ripley; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Lynn; communications with ANR Product Thomas. George; Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 305 eMail 3/3/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D Vic Nutter, Brent Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Dorsey; Chuck D. communications with ANR Product Barlow; Jack M.

Fulton; Jim Steets; John J. Kelly; John McCann 306 eMail 3/3/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; communications with ANR Product Barbara Ripley G; Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn 307 eMail 3/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson; McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley G; communications with ANR Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N 308 eMail 3/2/2005 Mark Mattson Zoil, Elise N; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product communications with ANR Page 18

I-0 0 NO. Document Date Author/Sender Reciient C2C Sublect Privileaed Asserted 309 eMail 3/2/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; communications with ANR Product McElwee, David; Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 310 eMail 3/2/2005 Balow. Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR McElwee, David; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 311 eMail 3/2/2005 David M. Rocchio Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR McEiwee, David; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 312 eMail 3/212005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay;, David M. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; Rocchlo communications with ANR Product Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 313 eMail 3/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay; David M. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Rocchio communications with ANR Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 314 eMail 3/2/2005 McElwee, David Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; David M. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Thomas, George; Zoli, Rocchio communications with ANR Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; DeWald.

Lynn 315 eMail 3/1/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Zoll, McElwee David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark communications with ANR Product Mattson; Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D Page 19

0 0 No. Tv*o, Document Date Author/Sender lent cc I Privileged Asserted 316 eMail 3/1/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Zoll, communications with ANR Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; McElwee, David 317 eMall 2/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR Product

"__Ripley G 318 eMail 2/28/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald Mark T. Mattson Ph. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work D. (Mark Mattson) communications with ANR Product 319 eMall 2/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Badow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N communications with ANR 320 eMall 2/25/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; 316(a) 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data Elise N 321 eMail 2/24/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication OsWald Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Elise N Hydrothermal modeling 322 eMail 2/24/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 323 eMail 2/24/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer. Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; communications with ANR Product Thomas, George; Wender IV,Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 324 eMall 2/24/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; communications with ANR Product Thomas, George; Wander IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson Page 20

0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Prlvlleged Asserted 325 eMail 2/24/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McEiwee, David; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; communications with ANR Product Wender IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 326 eMail 2/16/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark communications with ANR Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Thomas, George 327 eMall 2/15/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Product Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Wander IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 328 eMail 2/15/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Product Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Wender IV, Samuel; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 329 eMail 2/15/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Thomas, George; communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Wender IV,Samuel; Hydrothermal modeling Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 330 eMail 2/14/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Mason E. modeling 331 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N - Barlow, Chuck D; E. communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Mason; Barbara modeling Ripley 332 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N Barlow, Chuck D communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Page 21

0 0 No. Typeoi Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect Privnlened Asserted 333 eMall 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N Bartow, Chuck D; B. communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Mason Hydrothermal modeling 334 eMall 2/9/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 335 eMall 2/9/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Mattson 336 eMall 2/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise NKMark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Mattson communications with ANR; Fisheries data 337 eMail 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for. Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Elise N; Thomas, communications with ANR George 338 eMall 2/2/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; DeWald Lynn Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley 339 eMail 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara DeWald Lynn Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley 340 eMail 2/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll. communications with ANR Elise N; Barbara Ripley G; Mark Mattson 341 eMail 2/1/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, communications with ANR Elise N; Barbara Ripley G; Mark Mattson 342 eMail 1/28/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Ellse.N; DeWald. communications with ANR; 316(a)

Lynn; Thomas, Demonstration; Hydrothermal modeling; George; Barbara. Fisheries data Ripley G; Tim Brush 343 eMail 1/28/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR; 316(a)

Thomas, George; Demonstration; Hydrothermal modeling; Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush Page 22

0 011 No. Tyeof Docunent Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privilened Asserted 344 eMail 1/28/2005 Zoli. Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR; 316(a) Product Thomas, George; Demonstration; Fisheries data Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush

  • 345 eMail 1/28/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 346 eMall 1/28/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald. Lynn; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, communications with ANR Product Chuck D; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 347 eMail 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Jennifer Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Griffin 348 eMall 1/27/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George 349 eMail 1/26/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, communications with ANR Product Chuck D; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 350 eMail 1/24/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay;, Thayer, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Jay;, Thomas, George communications with ANR Barbara Ripley; Wender IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Tim Brush 351. eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 352 eMail 1/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay; Thayer, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Jay; Thomas, George communications with ANR; Hydrothermal DeWald, Lynn; modeling Wender IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Tim Brush 353 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 23

OJ 0 Type i

ýNo.

Document Date Author/Sender lent Cc Sublect Privileed Asserted 354 eMall 1/21/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barlow -

355 eMail 1121/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR Chuck Barlow 356 eMail 1/21/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Mark communications with ANR; Fisheries data Product Mattson; Chuck Barlow 357 eMail 1/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Mark communications with ANR; Fisheries data Product Mattson; Chuck Barlow 358 eMall 1/20/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson Ph. D. communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Product Mark Mattson; Hydrothermal modeling Barbara G Ripley; Chuck D. Barlow 359 eMall 1/20/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay;, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; Thomas communications with ANR; Fisheries data Wonder IV, Samuel; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George; Tim Brush 360 eMall 1/19/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; Thayer, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Jay; Thomas, George communications with ANR; Fisheries data Product DeWald, Lynn; Wender IV, Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 361 eMail 1/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay;, Thayer, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Jay;, Thomas, George communications with ANR; Fisheries data; Wender IV,Samuel; Hydrothermal modeling Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Tim Brush Page I, >

0 0 Typ No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recipien CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 362 eMall 1/19/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay; George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Wonder IV, Samuel; Thomas communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Product Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, modeling; Fisheries data Elise N; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Tim Brush 363 eMail 1/19/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay; George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Wender IV,Samuel; Thomas communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Product Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, modeling; Fisheries data Elise N; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Tim Brush 364 eMail 1/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Wender IV,Samuel; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Elise N; Thomas, modeling; Fisheries data George; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush 365 eMall 1/18/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Product Elise N; Thomas, modeling George; Mark Mattson; McCullough, Travis; Wender IV, Samuel 366 eMail 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Zoll, Elise N; Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product DeWald; Mark Mattson 367 eMail 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Lynn DeWald; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Mattson; Zoli, Elise N.

368 eMail 1/13/2005 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, communications with ANR Product Chuck D; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 369 eMail 1/13/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Chuck Barbara Ripley G Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow; DeWald Lynn communications with ANR Product Page 25

C 0 0 No. Typeo Document Date Author/Sender Redolon CC Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserted 370 eMail 1/13/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Mattson; Barbara modeling Ripley G 371 eMall 1/13/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Hydrothermal modeling; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark relating to strategy for communications with Mattson; Barbara ANR Ripley G 372 eMall 1/13/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barlow, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Mattson; Barbara modeling Ripley G 373 eMall 1/13/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Zoli, Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; DeWald, communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Lynn modeling 374 eMail 1/13/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Chuck Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Barlow; DeWald Lynn communications with ANR; Hydrothermal modeling 375 eMail 1/12/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Chuck D. Barlow; Barbara G Ripley Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald: Mark communications with ANR; Hydrothermal Product T. Mattson Ph.D. modeling 376 eMail 1/1212005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; McCullough, Travis; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Thomas, George communications with ANR; 316(a)

EliseN; Mark Mattson Demonstration 377 eMail 1/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McCullough, Travis 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 378 eMall 1/11/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Fisheries data; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark strategy for communications with ANR Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 379 eMall 12/29/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 380 eMall 12/29/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Ellse N; Barlow, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Doane, Larry Chuck D; Wander IV, Samuel; Mark Hutchins 381 eMail 12/22/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley G; Barlow,

_____________________Chuck D____________________

Page 26

© 0 No. TTypeof h Document Date AuthorlSender Reciple C.C Sublect Privileged Asserted 382 eMall 12/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; ZolI, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D 383 eMail 12/13/2004 Zoli, Elise N: Mark Mattson; Chuck D. Barlow 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Product Elise N 384 eMail 12/13/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Elise N 385 eMail 12/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D 386 eMail 12/7/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 387 eMail 12/6/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll. Elise N DeWald Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 388 eMail 11/9/2004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR Product Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson 389 eMail 11/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Thomas, communications with ANR Product George; Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson 390 eMail 11/9/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; DeWald Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; George communications with ANR Product Thomas; Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson 391 eMail 11/9/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; communications with ANR Product George Thomas; Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson 392 eMail 11/4/2004 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck 0; Zoli, Mason, Elizabeth F Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mason, Demonstration Product Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George Page 27

0 0 No Typeof Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 393 eMail 11/4/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mason, modeling Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 394 eMail 1114/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; modeling Product.

Mason, Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 395 eMall 11/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mason, modeling Product Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 396 eMall 11/2/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication Ripley-, Mason, modeling Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 397 eMail 11/2/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley: Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mason, modeling Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 398 eMail 11/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Chuck Barlow 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elizabeth F; DeWald modeling Product Lynn; Mark Mattson; George Thomas 399 eMail 11/1/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Chuck D. Barlow 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mason, Elizabeth F; modeling Product DeWald Lynn; Mark Mattson; George Thomas 400 eMail 11/1/2004 Barbara Ripley Mason, Elizabeth F; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; George Thomas Page 28

( 0 0 N Tyne Document Date Author/Sender Recipient Cc Sublect Privilaeed Asserted 401 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Zoll, Elise N; Jennifer 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Griffin; Michelle modeling Comeau 402 eMail 1012512004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration, Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 403 eMail 10/20/2004 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck E; Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Elizabeth Mason 404 eMail 10/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mason, Elizabeth F Mattson; Thomas, communications with ANR George; Barlow, Chuck 0 405 eMail 10/19/2004 Barbara Ripley Mason, Elizabeth F DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N;Mark Mattson; communications with ANR Product George Thomas; Bartow, Chuck D 406 eMall 10/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Chuck Barlow; George Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Elizabeth Mason Thomas; Mark Hutchins; DeWald Lynn 407 eMall 10/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley G; communications with ANR Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D 408 eMall 10/18/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elizabeth Mason; Product Mark Mattson; Chuck Barlow; George Thomas 409 eMail 10/11/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; George Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas; Elizabeth Product Mason; Mark Mattson 410 eMall 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley-, Thomas, George 411 eMail 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Thomas, George Page 29

(,-,*

0 N. Tvneof No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 412 eMail 10/8/2004 Zoll, Elise N: Mark Mattson; Zoll, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley, DeWald Lynn; George Thomas 413 eMall 10/8/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N: Barbara Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Ripley, DeWald Lynn; George Thomas 414 eMail 10/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoil, Elise N; Barbara Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney-Client Communication Ripley G; Alex Gonyaw;, Mark Mattson 415 eMail 1015/2004 Mark Hutchins Lynn DeWald Zoll, Elise N; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Mattson 416 eMail 9/30/2004 Barbara Ripley Thomas, George; Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Lynn; Nichols, Craig; modeling Product Brown, Lois 417 eMail 9/30/2004 Zoii, Elise N; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attomey Work Mark Mattson Elise N; DeWald, modeling Product Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Brown, Lois 418 eMail 9/30/2004 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; DeWald, modeling Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Brown, Lois 419 eMail 9/23/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas DeWald Lynn; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Elise N; Mark modeling Hutchins 420 eMail 9/21/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication Ripley G; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D 421 eMail 9/16/2004 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G Page 30

0 0 No. Type

& Document Date Author/Sender Recipient Cc Subject Privileged Asserted 422 eMall 9/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G 423 eMail 9/14/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; DeWald Barlow, Chuck D Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Lynn communications with ANR 424 eMall 9114/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attomey Work DaWald, Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George 425 eMail 9114/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mark Barlow, Chuck D 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson Ph. D. relating to strategy for communications with Product ANR 426 eMalf 9/14/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 427 eMail 9/13/2004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Zoii, Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Product Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G 428 eMail 9/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G 429 eMail 8/26/2004 Mason, Elizabeth F Barbara Ripley Zoll, Elise N 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication modeling 430 eMeil 8/26/2004 Barbara Ripley Mason, Elizabeth F Zoll, Elise N 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work modeling Product 431 eMail 8/25/2004 Mason, Elizabeth F Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attomey Work modeling Product Page 31

V 0 0 No. Typeo Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Sublect Privilened Asserted 432 eMail 8/24/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Lynn; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mark T. Mattson Ph. D.

433 eMail 8/24/2004 Zol, Eise N; DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Zoll, Product Elise N; Barlow.

Chuck D; Barbara Ripley;, Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.

434 eMail 8/24/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.

435 eMall 8/23/2004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald; Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Product Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D 436 eMall 8/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D 437 eMall 8/19/2004 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Zoll. Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, Product Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.;.

Thomas, George 438 eMail 8/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.;

Thomas, George 439 eMail 8/17/2004 Barbara Ripley Chuck Badow; Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work George Thomas; Product DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson Page 32

0 0 t

Type No.. Document Date Author/Sender Recilen Cc Sublect I Privileged Asserted 440 eMail 8113/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product communications with ANR; Versar Report 441 eMail 8/13/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn communications with ANR Product 442- eai 8..... 4 ... Ma-rkMa'-tso-n e LnZ.. Elsie N Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product communications with ANR 443 eMail 8/13/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson Ph. D. Product 444 eMail 8/12/2004 Mark Mattson Fitzgerald, Robert H; Rick Simmons 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Zoli, Elise N 445 eMail 8/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Thomas, George; communications with ANR Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N 446 eMail 8/6/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Mason, Elizabeth F Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; Product Barbara G Ripley; George Thomas; Mark T. Mattson Ph.

D.

447 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark T. Mattson Ph. Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D.; Lynn DeWald; communications with ANR Product Barbara G Ripley, George Thomas; Chuck D. Barlow 448 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark T. Mattson Ph. Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D.; Lynn DeWald; communications with ANR Product Barbara G Ripley-George Thomas; Chuck D. Barlow 449 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Hutchins communications with ANR Product Elise N 450 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Chuck D. Barlow Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee David; communications with ANR Product George Thomas; DeWald Lynn; Mark Mattson Page 33

(

0 10 N. Type ofI Document Date Author/Sender Redlen C Sublect Prlvileed Asserted 451 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoll. Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Chuck D. Barlow Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George Thomas; communications with ANR Product DeWald Lynn; Mark Mattson; Chuck 0.

Barlow 452 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR Product Ripley; Bowman, Carol A 453 eMail 8/3/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; George Thomas; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Mark Product Mattson 454 eMail 8/3/2004 Barbara Ripley George Thomas; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoll, communications with ANR Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 455 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Eise N; Mark communications with ANR Mattson; Thomas, George 456 eMail 8/3/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark communications with ANR Product Mattson; George Thomas 457 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Ripley;, Thomas, communications with ANR George; Mark Mattson 458 eMail 8/2/2004 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Nichols, Craig; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Dreyfuss, John; Ripley;, Mark Mattson Thayer, Jay 459 eMall 8/2/2004 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR Product Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 460 eMall 8/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thomas, communications with ANR George; Mark Mattson 461 eMail 7/28/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR Page 34

!F ,

1o. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subtect Prlvlleed Asserted 462 eMail 7/27/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Zoli, Elise N; George Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Thomas; Mark Hutchins 463 eMall 7/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mason, Elizabeth F Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Product Mark T. Mattson Ph. communications with ANR D.

464 eal 77/04 Zoli, EIs  ; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Thomas, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Zoll, Elise N; communications with ANR Product Barbara Ripley 465 eMail 7/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR Ripley 466 eMail 7/23/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins; Craig communications with ANR Product DeWald Lynn; Swanson George Thomas 467 eMail 7/22/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; relating to strategy for communications with Product DeWald Lynn; ANR George Thomas 468 eMall 7/21/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George Thomas; Product DeWald Lynn; Mark Mattson 469 eMail 7/21/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson Ph. D.; communications with ANR Product Barbara G Ripley; George Thomas 470 eMail 7/19/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mason. Elizabeth F Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Product Richard Master Mark communications with ANR Mattson 471 eMall 7/16/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Richard Master;, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn Mason, Elizabeth F Product 472 eMail 7/13/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Victoria Brown; Barb Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product Paros 473 eMail 7/8/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Product Richard Master; Mark Mattson 474 eMall 6/2/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Mark George Thomas; Elise 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Zoli Product Page 35

0 0

! Tvoeof I Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Subiect I Privileaed Asserted 475 eMall 6/2/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Ripley; George modeling Thomas 476 eMail 6/1/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Product Master, Richard; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley 477 eMall 5/28/2004 Zoil, Elise N; George Thomas; Craig Nichols; Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; Wander IVSamuel; Product Richard Master; Mark Chris Rose Mattson; Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley 478 eMail 5/28/2004 Zoll, Ellse N; Mark Mattson; Elise Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Zoll DeWald Lynn Product 479 eMail 5/27/2004 Zoil, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Product T. Mattson; Richard Masters; George Thomas 480 eMail 5/18/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara G Ripley, Mason, Elizabeth F; Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; Mark George Thomas Product T. Mattson _

481 eMail 5/7/2004 Thomas, George DeWaid, Lynn; Mark Wander IV,Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Nichols, Craig Ripley; Elise Zoli 482 eMail 5/3/2004 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication; Attomey Work Richard Master, Zoli, relating to strategy for communications with Product Elise N ANR 483 eMail 5/3/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Richard Master; Zoil, Elise N 484 eMail 5/2/2004 Zoll, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Hayward, Julie; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Thomas, George Product Mattson; Richard Master 485 eMail 5/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Hayward, Julie; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mark Mattson; Richard Master Page 36

0 0 fo Type o Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 486 eMail 4/3012004 Mark Mattson Julie Hayward DeWald Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barbara Rlpley;-Ells'e Zoli 487 eMail 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; Julie 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hayward modeling 488 eMail 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Elise Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Zoli 489 leMail 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Eise N; Barbara Julie Hayward; 318(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley DeWald Lynn; Arena, Suzanne E 490 eMail 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Julie Hayward; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley DeWald Lynn; Arena, Suzanne E 491 eMail 4/28/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Richard Master; Zoll, Communtcation Elise N; Mark Mattson 492 eMail 4/28/2004 iBarbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard Master; Zoll, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 493 eMail 4/28/2004 Hayward. Julie Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Wender IV, Samuel; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; Master, Richard; Suzanne Arena DeWald, Lynn 494 eMail 4/28/2004 Hayward, Julie Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Wender IV,Samuel; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Ripley; Mark Mattson; Master, Richard; Suzanne Arena DeWald, Lynn 495 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald Lynn; Richard Master 496 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald Lynn; Richard Master 497 eMail 4/28/2004 Bill Richkus DeWald Lynn Brian Kookier;, Carol 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product Carpenter; Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; George Thomas; Julie Hayward; Steve Schreiner Page 37

0 No. Tg~eof Document Date Author/Sender Recpient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 498 eMail 4/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Bill Rlchkus Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication Hayward, Julie; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Elise N; 499 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Rlpley, DeWald Lynn; Richard Master 500 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Ripley;, DeWald Lynn; Richard Master 501 eMail 4/28/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Product Richard Master; Mark Mattson 502 eMail 4/28/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Arena, Suzanne E Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Product Richard Master; Mark Mattson 503 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Lynn Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product DeWald; Barbara G modeling Ripley 504 eMail 4/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark T. Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; Product Barbara G Ripley 505 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 506 eMali 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 507 eMail 4/27/2004 Barbara Ripley. DeWald Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard Master; Zoli, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 508 eMail 4/27/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mason, Elizabeth F; Bednar, Charlotte L; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley Lynn DeWald; Mark T. modeling Product Mattson 509 eMail 4/26/2004 Zoil, Elise N; Barbara G Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark T. Mattson; Product Lynn DeWald; Richard Gerdus 510 eMail 4123/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Richard Master; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley;, DeWald Lynn Arena, Suzanne E 511 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Richard Master, 3 16(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley;, DeWald Lynn Arena, Suzanne E Page 38

0 0 INo.

Document Date Author/Sender Reciplan CC Sublect Privileaed Asserted 512 eMail 4/23/2004 Barbara Ripley Richard Master Mark George Thomas; Zoli. Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Mattson Elise N; 513 eMail 4/22/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara G Ripley Bednar, Charlotte L Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 514 eMail 4/21/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client Ripley; DeWald Lynn Master, Richard modeling Communication 515 eMail 4/21/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E; 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client Ripley; DeWald Lynn Master, Richard Communication 516 eMail 4/20/2004 Barbara G Ripley; Zoll, Elise N Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Barb Paros Communication 517 eMail 4/2012004 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client Communication 518 eMail 4/20/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoll, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Communication 519 eMall 4/19/2004 Master, Richard Zoli, Elise N; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-ClientCommunication Ripley;, Mark Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George; Master, Richard 520 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley; Communication DeWald Lynn 521 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client; Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; DeWald Lynn 522 eMail 4/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Ripley; DeWald Lynn Communication 523 eMail 4/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client; Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald Lynn 524 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client DeWald Lynn; Mark Communication Mattson 525 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley 526 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley I Page 39

0 0 NO. Type of Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect PrIvIlened Asserted 527 eMail 4/16/2004 Bednar, Charlotte L Zoll, Elise N; Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client Communication 528 eMail 4/16/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; Mark Mattson 529 eMail 4/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara

_Ripley 530 eMail 4/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara

_ _Ripley 531 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley.,

532 eMail 4/12/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication 533 eMail 4/12/2004 Zolil, Elise N; Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication 534 eMail 4/12/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoll, Elise N; DeWald Lynn 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication 535 eMail 4/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Master, Richard; Wender IV, Samuel 536 eMail 4/8/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George;. 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication McEIwee, David; Rocchio, David; Thayer. Jay; Arena, Suzanne E; Barbara

_ _Ripley;, Elise Zoll 537 eMail 4/8/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication McElwee, David; Rocchio, David; Thayer, Jay; Arena, Suzanne E; Barbara

_Ripley; Elise Zoli 538 eMail 4/7/2004 DeWaid, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Mattson Product 539 eMail 4/7/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Mattson Product 540 eMail 4/7/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Mattson Product Page 40

( 0 Document Date Author/Sender Rec.lent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 541 eMall 4/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Elise Zoll Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson 542 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; Product Mark T. Mattson 543 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product Barbara G Ripley, Mark T. Mattson 544 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Mark T. Mattson 545 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attomey Work Product Barbara Ripley; Mark T. Mattson 546 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoll, Elise N: Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley; Mark Communication T. Mattson 547 eMail 415/2004 Zoil, Elise N: Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley; Mark Communication T. Mattson 548 eMail 414/2004 Barbara G Ripley; DeWaldLynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barb Paros George Thomas; Zoli, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley 549 eMail 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson Lew, Christine Mark Hutchins; P. 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Harmon; Craig Swanson 550 eMail. 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson Grachuk. Jeanine L G DeWald Lynn; Zoli. 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Arena, Product Suzanne E 551 eMall 3/29/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thayer, Jay; Wender 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication IV, Samuel; Gardus, Richard; Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mark Mattson 552 eMail 3/29/2004 Grachuk, Jeanine L G Mark T. Mattson Ph. Lynn DeWald; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D. Elise N; Arena, Product Suzanne E 553 eMail 3/29/2004 Grachuk, Jeanine L G Mark T. Mattson Ph. Lynn DeWald: Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D. Elise N; Arena, Product Suzanne E 554 eMail 3/29/2004 Grachuk, Jeanine L G Mark T. Mattson Ph. Lynn DeWald; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work D.. Elise N; Arena, Product Suzanne E Page 41

0 k>

No. Typeof 1

Document Date Author/Sender R lentcc Subject Privileged Asserted 555 eMail 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product Elise N; Grachuk, Jeanine L G 556 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Product Elise N; George Thomas 557 eMail 3/24/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Cliont Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson; George NPDES Thomas 558 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; P. Zoil, Elise N; Grachuk, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product; Attorney-Client Harmon; Craig Jeanine L G Communication Swanson; DeWald Lynn 559 eMail 3/18/2004 Mark Mattson DeWaid, Lynn; Zoli, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Thomas, George 560 eMail 3/18/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 561 eMail 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn 562 eMail 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson. DeWald Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Rlpley 563 eMail 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product Ripley; George Thomas; Mark Hutchins; Craig Swanson 564 eMail 3/2/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 565 eMail 3/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 42

0 0 No. Type Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC PiieedAsre Sublect Privileged Asserted 566 eMail 3/2/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication DeWald Lynn communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 567 eMail 3/2J2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Mark Elise Zoll Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Mattson communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 568 eMail 3/1/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Barbara Ripley; Elise Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Zoll communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 569 eMail 2127/2004 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Nichols, Craig; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Mattson; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara Ripley; NPDES McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay; Wander IV,Samuel 570 eMail 2/25/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley 571 eMail 2/24/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley; Thomas, NPDES; Fisheries data George 572 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Thomas, George 573 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication.

Elise N;,Barbara Ripley-, Thomas, George, 574 eMail 2/10/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara relating to strategy for communications with Ripley ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermai modeling Page 43

0 0

& Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privielegd Asserted 575 email 2/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll. Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara relating to strategy for communications with Ripley ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 576 eMail 2/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara relating to strategy for communications with Ripley ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 577 eMail 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley Product 578 eMail 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley Product 579 eMail 1/29/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Mark Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 580 eMail 1/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson 581 eMail 1/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Versar Report Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson 582 eMail 1/28/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Barbara Ripley; Elise Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Zoll communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 583 eMall 1/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley 584 eMail 1/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thayer, Jay; Thomas, 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication George; Leach, Don; relating to strategy for communications with Dreyfuss, John; ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal Nichols, Craig; Wells, modeling Connie C; Barbara Ripley 585 eMail 1/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Elise Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Zoli Page44

C' 0 0 No. Tyne oI Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 586 eMail 1/24/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mark Brennan Jr, Robert L; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson; Barbara G Arena, Suzanne E communications with ANR regarding Product Ripley - NPDES; Versar Report 587 eMall 1/23/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 588 eMail 1/20/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Brennan Jr. Robert L; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Mark Arena, Suzanne E communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson NPDES 589 eMail 8/29/2006 Zoli, Elise N; Buckley, Ricky N; Travieso-Diaz, Matias Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney-Client Communication Lewis, David R F; Burke, Terence A; Hoehner, Holly J; Barlow, Chuck D; Rademacher, Norman L; Hoffman, John 590 eMall 8/29/2006 Buckley, Ricky N Lewis, David R Travieso-Diaz, Matlas Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication F; Burke, Terence A4 Hoehner, Holly J; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; Rademacher, Norman L 591 eMall with 8/29/2006 DeWald, Lynn. Barlow, Chuck D; Williams, U Gwyn; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication attachment McElwee, David; Zoll, Concannon, Sarah Elise N; Thomas, Heaton; Burke, George; Barbara Terence A4Wonder IV, Ripley Samuel 592 eMail 8/28/2006 Barlow. Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 593 eMail 8/8/2006 Zoli, Elise N; Gordon, Anne T 316(a) Demonstration; Litigation strategy Attorney Work Product relating to permit appeal 594 eMail with 8/8/2006 Lewis, David R Zoli, Elise N; Travieso-Diaz, Matias 316(a) Demonstration; Litigation strategy Attorney Work Product attachment Buckley, Ricky N; F; Burke, Terence; relating to permit appeal DeWald, Lynn; Chuck Barlow McElwee, David; Entsrgy 595 eMall with 6/10/2004 Yasl, Daniel Victoria Brown; Beren, Anita; Vlgeant, Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product attachments Nichols, Craig Stephen; Felumb, Rhonda; Thomas, George Page 45

0 0 No Type of Document Date Author/Sender Recient Sublect Privlleaed Asserted 596 eMail with 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Concannon, Sarah Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachments Heaton 597 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Concannon, Sarah 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Heaton 598 eMail with 6119/2006 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Concannon, Sarah Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachments Heaton 599 eMail with 6/10/2004 Yasi, Daniel Victoria Brown; Beren, Anita; Vigeant, Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product attachments Nichols, Craig Stephen; Felumb, Rhonda; Thomas, George 600 eMail 6/18/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Williams, U Gwyn; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; Thomas, Fitzgerald, Robert H; George; McElwee, Concannon, Sarah David; Barbara Heaton; Tabor, Anna-Ripley; Wender IV, Marie; Rademacher, Samuel; Mark Norman L Mattson 601 eMall 6/16/2006 Zo1l, Elise N Chuck Barlow, Terence A. Burke; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Mark Williams, U Gwyn; Product Mattson; George Tabor, Anna-Marie; Thomas: David K. Concannon, Sarah McElwee; Barbara Heaton Ripley 602 eMall 6/8/2006 DeWald, Lynn Bariow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Wender IV,Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; Rademacher, Norman L; Pittman, Bill; Mark Mattson 603 eMail 4/24/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; Wender IV, Samuel; Rademacher, Norman L; Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George 604 eMail 4/20/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson 605 eMall with 4/18/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal; Attorney-Client Communication attachment McElwee, David; 316(a) Demonstration Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George Page 46

C 0 0 No. Type Document Date Author/Sender Recalent Cc Sublect Privileged Asserted 606 eMail 4/18/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communicaton McElwee, David; Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George -

607 eMail 4/18/2006 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George; DeWald, Lynn 608 eMail 4/18/2006 McElwee, David Barbara Ripley; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George; DeWald, Lynn 609 eMail with 4117/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication attachment Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N 610 eMail 4110/2006 Zoll, ElIse N; DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Badow,-Chuck D;. Product Barbara Ripley; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Wender IV,Samuel 611 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Yasi, Daniel; Zoli, Senkel, Frank Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Elise N 612 eMail with 4/6/2006 Yasi, Daniel Mark Mattson; Zoli, Senkel, Frank Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachments Elise N 613 eMail with 312912006 Gordon, Anne T Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Attomay-Client Communication attachment 614 eMail 3/28/2006 Zoli, Elise N Barlow, Chuck D DeWald Lynn; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara G Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F; Vic Nutter 615 eMail. 3124/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Dan Yasi; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Zoll, Elise N Hutchins 616 eMail 3/24/2006 Thomas, George Zoli, Elise N; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; Mark Mattson Page 47

0 0 0 Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 617 eMail 3/22/2006 Thomas, George Barlow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication McCullough. Travis; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Smith, Terrence 618 eMall with 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Wender IVSamuel; Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney-Client Communication attachments Chuck Barlow; Zoli, George Thomas Demonstration; Fisheries data Elise N; DeWald Lynn 619 eMail 2/21/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Wender IV. Timothy Brush Samuel; Barbara Ripley 620 eMall with 2115/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication attachment Elise N; communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 621 eMall 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; 622 eMail 2/7/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; 623 eMail with 2/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication attachment Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley; Mark Mattson NPDES 624 eMail with 1/31/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barlow, Chuck D; modeling Product Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N 625 eMail 1/27/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson; -Barbara Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson. Ripley G; Wender IV, Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; 626 eMail 1/27/2006 Barlow, Chuck 0 DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mark Mattson; Barbara Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication Mattson Ripley G; Wander IV.

Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; 627 eMail 1/3/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Wender IV,Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Zoli, Elise N; Buckley, Ricky N 628 eMail 1/3/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Wender IV,Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N; Buckley,

__Ricky N Page 48

/

0 0 No. TypeP e

& Document Date Author/Sender Redlent CC Sublect PrIvIlened Asserted 629 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoll, McEIwee, David I Elise N; 630 eMail 1212112005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermai modeling Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoll. McEIwee, David Elise N 631 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Zoll, McElwee, David Elise N 632 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Zoli, Wender IV,Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N

633 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Wender IV, Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N*

6-3-4eNal 10/18/2005 .. Zoi,-Eli-selN . arow, Chuck D; Bucldey, Ricky N; 316(a) Demonstration - Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Mark Wender IV,Samuel; Mattson Thayer, Jay; Georgian, Kathryn A; Mason, Elizabeth F 635 eMail with 10/17/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Buckley, Ricky N; . 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication attachment Mark Mattson; Zoli, Wender IV, Samuel; modeling Elise N Thayer, Jay 636 eMail 10/15/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Mark Hydrathermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D 637 eMail with 10/14/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Mark T. Mattson; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication attachments Lynn DeWald; Chuck D. Barlow 638 eMail with 10/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication attachment Yasi, Dan; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Hutchins; Vekasy, Steve 639 eMail 10/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck 0 DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Yasl, Dan; Thomas, Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Cllent Communication Elise N; Mark Mattson George 640 eMail 10/5/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Yeas, Dan* Thomas, Hydrothermal rmodeling Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, George Elise N Page49

0 I

NO. Typ Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privlleged Asserted 641 eMail with 7/1/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication attachment McElwee, David; modeling George Thomas; Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Wender IV, Samuel; Jay Thayer; Mark Mattson 642 eMall 6/29/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; McEIwee, David Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley G; Demonstration Mark Mattson; Zoll, Elise N; 643 eMall with 6/2/2005 Barbara Ripley Zoll, Elise N; Chuck 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication attachment Barlow; DeWald Lynn 644 eMall 5/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Barbara Ripley G; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 645 eMail 5/12/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Barbara Ripley; David Elise N: Thomas, communications with ANR regarding Communication M. Rocchio; McEIwee, George NPDES David 646 eMall with 5/9/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Allan Palmer 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication attachment Elizabeth F 647 eMall with 5/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorhey-Client Communication attachment Elise N; 648 eMail with 5/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-ClIent Communication attachment Buckley, Ricky N; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Thomas, George 649 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McEIwee, David; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR regarding DeWald, Lynn; Zoti, NPDES Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George Page 50

0 Document Date Author/Sender Recentcc Sublet Privilened Asserted 650 eMail with 3/31/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication attachment Thomas, George; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; McElwee.

David 651 eMail with 3/30/2005 Zoli, Elise N Charles D. Badow;, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication attachment Ripley, Joyce M; Lynn DeWald; Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.

652 eMail with 3/30/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication attachment Barlow, Chuck D; Lynn DeWald; Mark T. Mattson Ph. D.

653 eMail 3/23/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Barbara Ripley G

654 eMail 3/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Barbara Ripley G

655 eMail 3/23/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Barbara Ripley G 656 eMail 3/23/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, David McElwee communications with ANR regarding Elise N; Mark NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George; McElwee, David 657 eMail 3/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark communications with ANR regarding Mattson; Thomas, NPDES George; McElwee, David; Barbara Ripley

_G I I Page 51

0 0 Tye.of Document Date AuthorlSender Recipent CC Sublect Privileaed Asserted 658 eMail with 3/18/2005 Zoll, Ellse N; Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration; Litigation strategy Attorney-Client Communication attachment DeWald, Lynn; Mark relating to permit appeal Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Thomas, George; McEiwee, David 659 eMail 3/17/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; McElwee David; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 660 eMail 3/111/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David Mattson; Thomas, Product George; Barlow, Chuck D 661 eMail 3/10/2005 Barbara Ripley McElwee, David DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Mattson; Product Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D 662 eMall 3/10/2005 McElwee, David Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara Ripley; Zoli, NPDES Elise N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 663 eMail 3/8/2005 McElwee, David DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Product Chuck D; Zoli, Elise NPDES N; Barbara Ripley 664 eMail 3/8/2005 Zoli. Elise N; Mark Mattson; Hydrothermal modeling. Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Product Barlow, Chuck D; David McElwee 665 eMail with 3/8/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment DeWald, Lynn; Product Barlow, Chuck D 666 eMail 3/8/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for. Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Mark communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Page 52

0 0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Relent CIC Sublect Privileged Asserted 667 eMail 3/8/2005 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck 0; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark Mattson NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 668 eMail with 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Mark Product Mattson; Thomas, George, Barbara Ripley G; McEIwee.

David 669 eMail with 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Mark Mattson; Zoli, Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley G; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Wender IV, Samuel 670 eMail with 3/7/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Eilse N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachments Ripley; Chuck Barlow Product 671 eMail 3/4/2005 Baadow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Thomas, NPDES George; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson 672 eMail with 3/3/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Attorney Work Product attachment communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 673 eMail with 3/3/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, David; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara Ripley G; NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Zoli, Elise N; Mark modeling Mattson 674 eMail 3/3/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, David M. Rocchlo Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, Product Chuck D; McElwee David; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson Page 53

0 ©J oype Document Date Author/Sender Recilent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 675 eMall 3/3/2005 McElwee, David David M. Rocchlo; Thomas, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Product DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, NPDES Elise N; Barbara Ripley 676 eMail with 3/3/2005 David M. Rocchlo Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Communication DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, NPDES Elise N; Thomas.

George; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson 677 eMail 3/3/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; communicaUons with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; NPDES Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee David; Mark Mattson 678 eMail with 3/3/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment DeWald, Lynn; Zolt, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Thomas, NPDES George; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson 679 eMall 3/3/2005 McElwee, David Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR regarding DeWald, Lynn; NPDES Thomas, George; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 680 eMail 3/3/2005. Barlow, ChuckD McElwee, David; David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley, communications with ANR regarding DeWald, Lynn; NPDES Thomas, George; Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 681 eMail.with 3/3/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Thomas, communications with ANR regarding Product George; Barlow, NPDES Chuck D; McElwee David; Mark Mattson Page 54

K-)

&0. Document Date AuthorlSender Recipen cc Sublect Privileaed Asserted 682 eMail 3/3/2005 McEIwee, David Barbara Ripley; David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR regarding Thomas, George; NPDES Thomas. George; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 683 eMail 3/3/2005 Zoli, EIIse N; Barlow, Chuck D 'Ac Nutter; Brent Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Dorsey; Chuck D. Product Barlow; Jack M.

Fulton; Jim Steels; John J. Kelly; John McCann 684 eMail 3/3/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George; McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; communlcations.with ANR regarding Product Barbara Ripley G; NPDES Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn 685 eMall with 3/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson; McElwee, David Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barbara Ripley G; communications with ANR regarding Product Barlow, Chuck 0; NPDES DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N 686 eMail 3/2/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; David M. Rocchlo Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Thomas, George; communications with ANR regarding McElwee, David; NPDES Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 687 eMail 3/2/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR regarding McElwee, David; NPDES Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson 688 eMail 3/2/2005 Gordon, Anne T; Zoli, Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N DeWald Lynn; Zoll, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley Page 55

0 0 No yeof Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Prlvileaed Asserted 689 eMall 3/2/2005 David M. Rocchlo Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR regarding Communication McElwee, David; NPDES Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Zoil, Elise N; Mark Mattson eMail 3/2/2005 Barbara Ripley .90 DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay;, David M. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McEIwee, David; Rocchlo communications with ANR regarding Product Barlow, Chuck D; NPDES Thomas, George; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 691 eMail 3/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay;, David M. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Rocchlo communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; Zoll, NPDES Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 692 eMail 3/2/2005 McElwee, David Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; David M. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Zoli, Rocchio communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark NPDES Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; DeWald, Lynn 693 eMail with 3/1/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Zoli, David McElwee Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Mark Product Mattson; Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D 694 eMail 3/1/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Zoli. communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark NPDES Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; McElwee, David 695 eMail with 2/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Product Ripley G NPDES; Fisheries date; Hydrothernnal modeling Page 56

Q No. Tn~eot Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 696 eMall with 2/28/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald Mark T. Mattson Ph. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment D. communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 697 eMall 2/25/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client DeWald Lynn; Zoll, communications with ANR regarding Communication Elise N NPDES; Fisheries data 698 eMail 2/24/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoll, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N NPDES; Fisheries data 699 eMall with 2/24/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Elise N communications with ANR regarding Communication NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 700 eMail 2/24/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; NPDES Wonder IV,Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 701 eMail 2/24/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; NPDES Wander IV,Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson 702 eMaIl 2/24/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; communications with ANR regarding Product Wander IV,Samuel; NPDES Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 703 eMall 2/15/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck 0; communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; NPDES Wander IV,Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson Page 57

0 0 Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 704 eMall 2/15/2005 ZolJ, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; NPDES; Versar Report Wender IV,Samuel; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 705 eMail with 2114/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; Communication Elizabeth Mason 706 eMali with 2/13/2005 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; George Thomas; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment DeWald, Lynn; Mark Chuck Barlow communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 707 eMail with 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; Communication Elizabeth Mason; Barbara Ripley 708 eMail with 2/11/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark George Thomas; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment T. Mattson Ph. D. Chuck D. Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara G Ripley NPDES.

709 eMail with 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoil, Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client attachment Ellse N Barlow, Chuck D communications with ANR regarding Communication NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 710 eMail with 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoli, Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client attachment Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; Communication Elizabeth Mason 711 eMail 2/9/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Elise N Communication 712 eMail with 2/9/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Mattson Product 713 eMail 2/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, EliseN; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 714 eMall 2/2/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; DeWald Lynn Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley Product 715 eMail with 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara DeWald Lynn Fisheries data Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client attachment Ripley "_Communication Page 58

0 No. Tv*o Document Date AuthorlSender Redlent C2C Sublect Privileged Asserted 716 eMall with 2/1/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Barbara NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Ripley G; Mark Mattson 717 eMall 1/28/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product Elise N; DeWald, communications with ANR regarding Lynn; Thomas, NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling George; Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush 718 eMail 1/28/2005 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Product Thomas, George; NPDES Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush 719 eMall with 1/28/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Thomas, George; Zoll, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark NPDES; Fisheries data Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush 720 eMall with 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Jennifer Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Griffin Communication 721 eMall 1/24/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay;, Thayer, Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Jay;, Thomas, George Product Barbara Ripley; Wender IV,Samuel; Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George; Tim Brush 722 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Communication 723 eMail 1/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay;, Thayer, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Jay; Thomas, George communications with ANR regarding Product DeWald, Lynn; NPDES Wender IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Tim Brush 724 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client communications with ANR regarding Communication NPDES Page 59

0 0 I

NLo. Type

  • Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect I Privlleaed Asserted 725 eMail 1/21/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara Ripley; NPDES Chuck Barlow 726 eMall 1/21/2005 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWeld, Lynn; Mark communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson; Chuck NPDES Barlow 727 eMail 1/20/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson Ph. D.; modeling Product Barbara G Ripley; Chuck D. Barlow 728 eMail 1/20/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay; George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client DeWald, Lynn; Thomas communications with ANR regarding Communication Wender IV,Samuel; NPDES Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George; Tim Brush 729 eMail 1/19/2005 Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck D; Thayer, Jay;, Thayer, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Jay;, Thomas, George communications with ANR regarding Product DeWald, Lynn;. NPDES Wender IV, Samuel; Zoli. Elise N; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 730 eMail with 1/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Wender IV,Samuel; Thayer, Jay. Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Thomas, NPDES George; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G; Tim Brush 731 eMail with 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Zoll, Elise N; Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment DeWald; Mark Communication Mattson 732 eMail with 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Lynn DeWald; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment Mattson; Elise Zoll Communication 733 eMail with 1/16/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Chuck D; Zoli, Elise communications with ANR regarding Product N; Barbara Ripley G; NPDES Thomas, George Page 60

0 0 ho.

o. Document Type o Date Author/Sender lent cc C Sublect Privlleged Asserted 734 eMail with 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Mattson; Thomas, communications with ANR regarding Product George; Barlow, NPDES; Fisheries date Chuck D; Barbara Ripley G; Elise Zoli 735 eMall 1/14/2005 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Product Chuck D; Zoll, Elise NPDES N; Barbara Ripley G 736 eMall 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Chuck D; Zoli, Elise NPDES N; Barbara Ripley G 737 eMail 1/14/2005 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Product Chuck D; Zoli, Elise NPDES; Versar Report N; Barbara Ripley G 738 eMall with 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Wender IV,Samuel Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barlow, Chuck D; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark Mattson; Zoll, NPDES; Versar Report; 316(a)

Elise N; Barbara Demonstration Ripley G 739 eMall with 1/13/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Chuck D; Zoll, Elise communications with ANR regarding Product N; Barbara Ripley G NPDES 740 eMail 1/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; McCullough, Travis; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Thomas, George Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 741 eMall 12/29/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client Communication 742 eMail 12/29/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client Doane, Larry Chuck D; Wender IV, Communication Samuel; Mark Hutchins 743 eMail 12/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Doane, Larry Mark Mattson; Zoll, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Etuse N; Barlow, Product Chuck D; Wender IV, Samuel; Mark Hutchins Page 61

0 0 No. Te Type of I Document Date Author/Sender Recipent C.C Sublect Privileged Asserted 744 eMail 12/2212004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara modeling Product Ripley G; Barlow, Chuck D.

745 eMail 12/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Product Hutchins 746 eMail 12/1 3/2004 DeWld, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, Product Chuck D 747 eMall 12/13/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Chuck D. Barlow Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Elise (Chuck Barlow) Product Zoli 748 eMail with 12/13/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Elise Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Zoli 749 eMail 12113/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow. Product Chuck D 750 eMail 12/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, Product Chuck D 751 eMall 11/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Thomas, Product George; Barlow, Chuck D: Mark Mattson 752 eMail 11/9/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; DeWald Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; George Product Thomas; Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson 753 eMail 11/9/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Product George Thomas; Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Mattson 754 eMail with 11/4/2004 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Mason, Product Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George Page 62

C 0 No. Typ of Document Date Author/Sender Recdon CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 755 eMall 11/4/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mason, Product Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 756 eMail with 11/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barlow, Chuck D; Product Mason, Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 757 eMail 11/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mason, Product Elizabeth F; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 758 eMail 11/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Chuck Barlow 316(a) Demonstration. Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elizabeth F; DeWald Product Lynn; Mark Mattson; George Thomas 759 eMail 11/1/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Chuck D. Barlow 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mason, Elizabeth F; Product DeWald Lynn; Mark Mattson; George Thomas 760 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Elise Zoll 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 761 eMail 10/20/2004 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley G; Elizabeth Mason 762 eMail 10119/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoli, ElIse N; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mason, Elizabeth F Mattson; Thomas, George; Barlow, Chuck D 763 eMail 10/19/2004 Barbara Ripley Mason, Elizabeth F DeWald Lynn; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Mattson; Product George Thomas; Barlow, Chuck D Page 63

0 No. Tvoo h Document Date Author/Sander Redolent CC Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserted 764 eMall with 10/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Chuck Barlow, George 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client attachment Elizabeth Mason Thomas; Mark Communication Hutchins; DeWald Lynn 765 eMail with 10/18/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elizabeth Mason; Product Mark Mattson; Chuck Barlow; George Thomas 766 eMail with 10/11/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; George 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Thomas; Elizabeth Product Mason; Mark Mattson 767 eMali 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley; Thomas, George 768 eMall with 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley; Thomas, George 769 eMall 10/8/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Zoli, Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley; DeWald Lynn; George Thomas 770 eMail with 10/8/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Ripley;, DeWald Lynn; Communication George Thomas 771 eMail 10/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley G; Alex communications with ANR regarding Product Gonyaw, Mark NPDES Mattson 772 eMail with 10/5/2004 Mark Hutchins Lynn DeWald Zoll, Elise N; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client attachment Mattson Communication 773 eMall 9/30/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Elise N; DeWald, Product Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Brown, Lois Page 64

C. 0 0 No. Typ Document Date Author/Sender Reclent C9_C Sublect Privileged Asserted 774 eMail with 9/30/2004 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley G; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; DeWald, Product Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Brown, Lois 775 eMail 9/29/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley G; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; communications with ANR regarding Product Thayer, Jay; NPDES McEIwee, David; Victoria Brown; Nichols, Craig:

Dreyfuss, John 776 eMail 9/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Victoria Brown; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product Nichols, Craig; NPDES McEIwee, David; Thayer, Jay; Zoli, Elise N 777 eMail 9/27/2004 Victoria Brown Barbara Ripley; Craig Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Nichols; McElwee communications with ANR regarding Product David; Jay Thayer; NPDES DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Elise N 778 eMail 9/26/2004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; David Edwards, Charles; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work M. Rocchio; Linda Jonasch, Stephen; communications with ANR regarding Product Paskiewicz; Nichols, Rogers, James; NPDES Craig; Rose, Chris; Farabaugh, Kenneth; McEIwee, David; Wierzbowski, George; Thomas George Barbara Ripley G; Barlow, Chuck D 779 eMail with 9/23/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas DeWald Lynn; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Elise N; Mark Communication Hutchins 780 eMail 9/16/2004 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson; Thomas, NPDES; Versar Report George; Barbara Ripley G 781 eMail 9/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Product Chuck D; Thomas, NPDES; Varsar Report George; Barbara Ripley G Page 65

\V.__

0 0 INo. Tv eo Document Date Author/Sender len cc Subiect I Prvleaed Asserted 782 eMail 9/14/2004 Barbara Ripley Zoll, Elise N; Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George 783 eMail 9/14/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mark Barlow, Chuck D 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work T. Mattson Ph. D. Product 784 eMail with 9/14/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Thomas, George; Zoll, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley G 785 eMail 9/1312004 Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Mark Product Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G 786 eMail with 9/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Mattson; Barlow, Product Chuck D; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley G 787 eMail 8/24/2004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Barlow, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.

788 eMail 8/24/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barlow, communications with ANR regarding Product Chuck D; Barbara NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Ripley, Mark T.

Mattson Ph. D.

789 eMall 8/13/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Communication 790 eMail 8/13/2004 Zol!, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES Page 66

0 Do.cum eunt D Date Author/Sender Reciient Cc Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserted 791 eMail with 8/1312004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Elise Zoli Versar Report Correspondence relating to Attorney-Work Product Attorney-Client attachment strategy for communications with ANR Communication regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 792- e~aili-- - 8/320 Zoll, El6ise; N: -- 'Lyn"n-D-e-W ald,;,M Mar'k- M-a-so-n,Elizab6e'th F, C*orr-e-s-pon d'e-n'ce,-a

-rela"tin"g,t'o'strate-g'y fo'r' Att'orn-ey--,Clie-nt Coam m-unice-ation"; Attorn'me-y Wa T. Mattson Ph. D. communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES; Versar Report 793 eMail with 8/12/2004 Mark Mattson Fitzgerald, Robert H; Rick Simmons 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attorney Work Product attachment Elise Zoll relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 794 eMail with 8/4/2004 Zoli, ElIse N; Mark T. Mattson Ph. Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence Attomey-Client Communication; Attomey Work attachment D.; Lynn DaWald; relating to strategy for communications with Product Barbara G Ripley; ANR regarding NPDES George Thomas; Chuck D. Barlow 795 eMail with 8/4/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark T. Mattson Ph. Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment D.; Lynn.DeWald; communications with ANtR regarding Product Barbara G Ripley; NPDES; Fisheries data George Thomas; Chuck D. Barlow 796 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Elise Hutchins. communications with ANR regarding Product Zoli NPDES 797 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald. Lynn Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Elise N; Mark communications with ANR regarding Mattson; Thomas, NPDES George 798 eMall with 7/27/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Zoll, Elise N; George Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Thomas; Mark Hutchins 799 eMail 7/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark T. Mattson Ph. NPDES D.

Page 67

@ 0 0 No. Tsypeof h Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC 5ublec Privilened Asserted 800 eMail with 7/27/2004 Barbara Ripley George Thomas; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment DeWald Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark Mattson NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a)

Demonstration 801 eMail with 7/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Product Ripley NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data 802 eMail 7/23/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins; Craig communications with ANR regarding Product DeWald Lynn; Swanson NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling George Thomas 803 eMail 7/16/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Richard Master, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn Mason, Elizabeth F Product 804 eMail 6/11/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWaId, Lynn; communications with ANR regarding Product Master, Richard; Mark NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Mattson; Barbara Ripley 805 eMall 5/27/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark T. Mattson; NPDES; Versar Report Richard Masters; George Thomas 806 eMail with 5/11/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Zoli, DeWald Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Elise N; Jay Thayer Richard Master communications with ANR regarding Communication NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 807 eMall 5/7/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard Master; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark Mattson NPDES 808 eMail 517/2004 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Mark Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Nichols, Craig communications with ANR regarding Product Ripley; Elise Zoli NPDES Page 68

CI: 0 0

ýN Type ofPrvlgdAste Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserte 809 eMail with 514/2004 Master, Richard Barbara Ripley; Mark DeWald, Lynn; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Mattson Elise N; communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 810 eMail 5/212004 Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Hayward, Julie; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Thomas, George Product Mattson; Richard Master 811 eMail with 5/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Hayward, Julie; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Thomas, George; Zoli, Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Mark Mattson; Richard Master 812 eMail with 4/3012004 Mark Mattson July Hayward DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment Barbara Ripley; Elise Communication Zoli 813 eMali with 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Zoli, Ellse N; Julie 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment Hayward Communication 814 eMail with 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Elise 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client attachment Zoli Communication 815 eMail with 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli. Elise N; Barbara Julie Hayward; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment Ripley DeWald Lynn; Arena, Communication Suzanne E 816 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client DeWald Lynn; Communication Richard Master Zoli, ElIse N 817 eMail with 4U28/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-ClIent Communication; Attorney Work attachment Richard Master, Zoli, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 818 eMail with 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment Ripley;- DeWald Lynn; Communication Richard Master 819 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, ElIse N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client Ripley; DeWald Lynn; Communication Richard Master 820 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Lynn Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client DeWald; Barbara G Communication Ripley I I I Page.69

0 No. Typ of Date Author/Sender

-Documen Reci.len CC Sublect privileged Asserted 821 eMail with 4/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mark T. Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Lynn DeWald; Product Barbara G Ripley 822 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 823 eMail with 4/27/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Richard Master, Zoli, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 824 eMail 4/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Elizabeth F; Bednar, Charlotte L; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley Lynn DeWald; Mark T. Product Mattson 825 eMall with 4/26/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Richard Master, Zoli, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson 826 eMail 4/26/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara G Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark T. Mattson; communications with ANR regarding Product Lynn DeWald; NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Richard Gerdus 827 eMail 4/23/2004 Barbara Ripley Richard Master; Mark George Thomas; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Elise N; Product 828 eMail with 4/21/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N;-Barbara Arena, Suzanne E; 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client attachment Ripley; DeWald Lynn Master, Richard Hydrothermal modeling Communication 829 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Product DeWald Lynn 830 eMail 4/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attomey-Client Ripley; DeWald Lynn Communication 831 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Attomey-Client Elise N; Barbara modeling Communication Ripley 832 eMail 4/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley 833 eMail 4/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Product 834 eMall with 4/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Barbara modeling Product Ripley. Thomas, iGeorge Page 70

0 0 No. Tveo Document Date AuthorlSender Recipent CC Subject Privllened Asserted 835 eMail 4/512004 ZoJ, Elise N: Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark T. Mattson NPDES; Versar Report 836 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark T. Mattson NPDES; Versar Report 837 sMall 415/2004 Zoll, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G Ripley; communications with ANR regarding Product Mark T. Mattson NPDES; Versar Report 838 eMail with 4/4/2004 Barbara G Ripley; DeWald Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Barb Paros George Thomas; Zoli, Product Elise N; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley 839 eMall with 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson Low, Christine Mark Hutchins; P. 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product attachment Harmon; Craig Swanson 840 eMail 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson Grachuk, Jeanine L G DeWald Lynn; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Elise N; Arena, Communication.

Suzanne E 841 eMall 3/29/2004 Grachuk, Jeanine L G Mark.T. Mattson Ph. Lynn DeWald; Zol, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work D. Elise N; Arena, communlcations with ANR regarding Product Suzanne E NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 842 eMail 3/29/2004 Grachuk, Jeanine L G Mark T. Mattson Ph. Lynn DeWald; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D Elise N; Arena, communications with ANR regarding Product Suzanne E NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 843 eMail 3/29/2004 Grachuk, Jeanine L G Mark Mattson; Elise DeWald Lynn; Arena, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Zoll Suzanne E communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES 844 eMail 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Elise N; Grachuk, communications with ANR regarding Communication Jeanine L G NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Page 71

0 0 N1o. Tvneof PrvisdAetd Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient cc Sublect Prviled Asserted 845 eMall with 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; P. Zoll, Elise N; Grachuk, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Harmon; Craig Jeanine L G Product Swanson; DeWald Lynn 846 eMail with 3/18/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Ripley; Mark Mattson; Product Thomas, George 847 eMail with 3/15/2004 Unda Pasldewicz Barbara Ripley; Craig Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Nichols; Chris Rose; communications with ANR regarding Product Connie Wells; NPDES McElwee David; George Thomas; Brian Cosgrove; Jay Thayer, DeWald Lynn; Robert Will; Zoll, Elise N 848 eMail with 3/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication attachment Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley; Thomas, . NPDES

_ _George 849 eMail 3/10/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Eiise N; Thomas, Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication George. communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Analysis relating to NPDES Permit 850 eMail 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, communications with ANR regarding Lynn NPDES 851 eMail 3/912004 Thomas, George Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication Lynn communications with ANR regarding NPDES' Hydrothermal modeling 852 eMall 3/9/2004 Zoli, Elise N+E929 Mark T. Mattson Lynn DeWald (E-mail) Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work 1;George Thomas (E- communications.with ANR regarding Product mail); Arena, Suzanne NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling E

Page 72

C 0 0 No. Type of1 Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect j Privileaed Asserted 853 email 31512004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; George communications with ANR regarding Thomas; Mark NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Hutchins; Craig Swanson 854 eMail 3/2/2004 Mark Mattson DaWald, Lynn; Elise Zoll Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication

_____Barbara Ripiey' 855 eMail 3/2/2004 DaWaid, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 856 email with 3/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication attachment Mark Mattson; communications with ANR regarding Barbara Ripley; Elise NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Zoli 857 eMail with 3/1/2004 Zoli, Elise N+E943 Mark T. Mattson; Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment George Thomas; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara G Ripley;, NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Mark T. Mattson 858 eMail 311/2004 Barbara Ripley George Thomas; Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Zoli, communications with ANR regarding Product Elise N; Mark Mattson NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 859 eMail with 2/29/2004 Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment George Thomas; communications with ANR regarding Product Barbara G Ripley; NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration Mark T. Mattson 860 eMail with 2/27/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product attachment Rlpley; George communications with ANR regarding Thomas NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 861 eMail with 2/27/2004 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Nichols, Craig; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication attachment Elise N; Mark Mattson; communications with ANR regarding Barbara Ripley; NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay;,Wender IV, Samuel 862 eMail with 2/25/2004 Mark Mattson Zo7i, ElIse N; Barbara Fisheries Datae Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product attachment Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Page 73

0 0 Type o N4. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Prlvllened Asserted 863 eMail with 2/24/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Fisheries Data; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication attachment Elise N; Barbara strategy for communications with ANR Ripley', Thomas, regarding NPDES George 864 eMail 2/23/2004 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson; Zoll, Arena, Suzanne E Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise Product 865 eMail 2/23/2004 Mark Mattson Zoii, Ellse N Fitzgerald, Robert H; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Arena, Suzanne E Product 866 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Zoli 867 eMail with 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication attachment Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley; Thomas, NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling George 868 eMail 2/18/2004 Linda Pasklewicz Barbara Ripley; Craig Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Nichols; Chris Rose; communications with ANR regarding Product Connie Wells ; NPDES McElwee David; George Thomas; Brian Cosgrove; Jay Thayer; DeWald Lynn; Robert Will; Zoll, Elise N 869 eMall with 2/13/2004 Linda Pasldewicz Barbara Ripley; Craig Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication attachment Nichols; Chris Rose; communications with ANR regarding Connie Wells; NPDES McElwee David; George Thomas; Brian Cosgrove; Jay Thayer; DeWald Lynn; Robert Will; Zoli, Elise N 870 eMail with 2/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Victoria Brown; Zoll, Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Gary communications with ANR regarding Product Franldin; Thomas, NPDES George; Thayer, Jay; McElwee, David Page 74

,1 0 Docurent Date Author/Sender ReciClen cc Sublect Privileed Asserted 871 eMail with 2/12/2004 Victoria Brown McElwee David; Gary Franklin; Craig Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment George Thomas; Jay Nichols; DeWald communications with ANR regarding Product Thayer Lynn; Zoli, Elise N NPDES 872 eMall with 2/10/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N: Mark Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication attachment Mattson; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley NPDES 873 eMail with 2/9/2004 Victoria Brown Barbara Ripley; Gary Franklin Fisheries data; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment McElwee, David; strategy for communications with ANR Product Thomas, George; regarding NPDES DeWald, Lynn 874 eMail 2/2/2004 Victoria Brown Nichols, Craig; Barbara Ripley; Gary Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; Franklin; Cosgrove, Product Thomas, George; Brian; John Dreyfuss; Thayer, Jay; DeWald, Williams, Robert Lynn; 875 eMail with 2/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Arena, Suzanne E Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication attachment Elise N; Barbara communications with ANR regarding Ripley NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 876 eMail with 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Ripley Product 877 eMail with 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment Ripley 878 eMall 2/2/2004 Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Mark Correspondence relating to strategy for Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson communications with ANR regarding Product NPDES; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 879 eMail 1/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson 880 eMall with 1/28/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn Barbara Ripley;, Elise Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product attachment Zoll communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Page 75

0 0)

No. Tyoo Document Date AuthorlSender Recipent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 881 eMail 1/20/2004 Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Brennan Jr, Robert L; Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald Lynn; Mark Arena, Suzanne E communications with ANR regarding Product Mattson NPDES 882 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 883 eMail 9/9/2004 Barbara Ripley Mason, Elizabeth F DeWald Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Attorney-Client Mattson ___Communication __

884 eMail 10/19/2004 Mark Mattson Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 885 eMail 10/20/2004 Mark Mattson Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 886 eMail 2/8/2006 Mark Mattson Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 887 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 888 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 889 eMail 5111/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; modeling Product Mark Mattson; Elise Zoll 890 eMail 5/10/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Elise modeling Product Zoll 891 email with 5/9/2006 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Elise George Thomas; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product attachment Zoll Hutchins modeling 892 eMail 4/25/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; George Chuck Barlow; 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas DeWald Lynn; Mark modeling Product

_ _ _ Hutchins 893 eMail 4/24/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Elise Chuck Barlow;, Hydrothermal modeling;316(a) Attorney Work Product Zo0l DeWald Lynn; Mark Demonstration Hutchins 894 eMail with 4/21/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Elise Dan YasJ; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product attachment Zoll Hutchins modeling 895 small with 4/21/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothefral Attorney Work Product attachment modeling 896 eMail 4/20/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 897 sMall with 4/19/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 898 eMail 4117/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 899 eMail with 4/16/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Mattson 900 eMail with 4/16/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Mattson 901 email with 4/15/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment I Page 76

0 Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect 1 Privileaed Asserted 902 eMail with 4/13/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Mattson 903 eMail 411312006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Susan 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Ward modeling 904 sMail 4/13/2006 Mark Mattson Wonder IV,Samuel Harms, Ed; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hutchins modeling 905 eMail 4/13/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_modeling 906 eMail with 4/13/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 907 eMail with 4/11/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 908 eMail 4111/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 909 eMail with 4/10/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 910 eMail with 4110/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 911 eMail with 4/9/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 912 eMail with 418/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 913 eMall 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 914 eMail 4/712006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 915 eMail with 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 916 eMail with 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 917 email with 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 918 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 919 eMail with 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product attachment modeling ___________________

920 eMail 4/5/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 921 email with 4/4/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product attachment Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 922 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 923 eMail with 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Mark Hutchins Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product attachment Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Page 77

0 0 Document Date Author/Sender Recipient - CC Sublect PrIvIleaed Asserted 924 eMall 3/2/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attomey.Work Product Fisherles data; Hydrothermal modeling 925 eMaJi 3/2/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product communications with ANR regarding NPDES 926 eMail with 12/23/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Yasl, Mark Hutchins Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product attachment Dan Hydrothermal modeling 927 eMail with 12/7/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product attachment communications with ANR regarding NPDES 928 eMail with 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product attachment communications with ANR regarding NPDES 929 eMall with 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley DeWald Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product attachment Hutchins NPDES Permit Hydrothermal modeling 930 eMail with 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product attachment NPDES Permit Hydrothermal modeling 931 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson MarkHutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 932 eMall 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 933 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 934 eMail with 12/1/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product attachment i modeling 935 eMail 12/1/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product NPDES Permit; Hydrothermal modeling 936 eMail 11/30/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product NPDES Permit, Hydrothenral modeling 937 eMail with 7/7/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to strategy for Attorney Work Product attachment communications with ANR regarding NPDES 938 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark MaGtson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 78

0 3 Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 939 eMall 716/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 940 emall with 7/5/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product attachment. Hydrothermal modeling 941 eMail with 7/11/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product attachment NPDES Permit Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 942 sMall with 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product attachment Hydrothermal modeling 943 eMail with 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Elise Zoll Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 944 sMall with 10/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli. ElIse N; Chuck Barlow; George Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Elizabeth Mason Thomas; Mark Hutchins; DeWald Lynn 945 eMail 10/13/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 946 eMail 10/13/2004 Mark Mattson Yasi, Daniel DeWald Lynn; Mark Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling 947 eMail 10/12/2004 Yasi, Daniel Mark Mattson DOWald Lynn; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Hutchins 948 eMail with 10/12/2004 Mark Mattson Yasi. Daniel DeWald Lynn; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Hutchins 949 eMail with 10/12/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product attachment modeling 950 sMall 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara Product Rlpley; Thomas, George 951 eMall with 10/1112004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoll, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work attachment Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley; Thomas, George 952 eMail 10/8/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Zoll, Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise N; Barbara Product Ripley; DeWald Lynn; George Thomas 953 eMail with 108172004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N; Barbara Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product attachment Ripley; DeWald Lynn; modeling George Thomas Page 79

0 Document Date Author/Sender Recipen CCc Subiect Privileged Asserted 954 eMail with 10/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication attachment 955 eMall 10/5/2004 DeWatd, Lynn Mark Hutchins Elise Zoll; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication Mattson 956 eMail 10/1U2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Analysis relating to NPDES Permit Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 957 eMail with 10/1/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product attachment NPDES Permit, Hydrothermal modeling 958 eMail with 9/23/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas DeWald Lynn; Zoll, 316(a) Demonstration; Analysis relating to Attorney Work Product attachment Elise N; Mark NPDES Permit; Hydrothermal modeling Hutchins 959 eMall 9/21/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_ _ _modeling 960 eMail 8/11/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Rsheries data Attorney Work Product 961 eMall 8/111/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 962 eMail with 8110/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 963 eMall with 8/8/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 964 eMail with 8/8/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 965 eMaIl with 8/8/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermanl modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 966 eMall with 8/712004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 967 eMall with 8/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 968 eMall 8/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 969 eMail with 8f7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 970 eMail 8/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 971 eMail with 8/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fishedres data Attorney Work Product attachment 972 eMail 8/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Mattson; Mark Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Hutchins 973 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data Aittrey Work Product 974 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 975 eMail with 8/6/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 976 eMail with 8/5/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Page 80

0 Typeo Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect Prlvileaed Asserted 977 eMail with 8/5/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Elise 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product attachment Zoli Hydrothermal modeling 978 eMail with 815/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Susan Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment Ward 979 eMalil 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley;, Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product DeWald Lynn; Elise Hutchins Zoli 980 sMall with 8/4/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald Lynn; Elise Barbara Ripley; Mark Fisherles data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment ZoOi Hutchins 981 eMail 8/412004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 982 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 983 eMail 8/3/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 984 email 8/312004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Att6mey Work Product 985 email with 8/2/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 986 eMail 81212004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 987 email with 8/1/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Mattson 988 eMail with 8/11/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 989 eMail 7/31/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 990 eMail 7130=2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 991 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Susan Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ward 992 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 993 email 7/30=2004 Mark Mattson MarkHutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 994 eMalil with 7/2912004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Sankar Subbayya; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment Mark Hutchins 995 eMail with 7/28/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment 996 eMail 7/27/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 997 email with 7/27/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Zoli, Elise N; George Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment Thomas; Mark Hutchins 998 eMail 7/27/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 999 eMail 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1000 eMail with 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Zoli, Elise N; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Hutchins; DeWald Lynn 1001 eMail 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Elise Zoll 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1002 email vftth 7125/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment 1003 eMail with U724/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment Page 81

( *r__..'J No. Type Document Date Author/Sender Recipient c*

C.bect Privileaed Asserted 1004 eMail 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1005 eMail 7/2412004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 1006 eMail 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1007 eMall with 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment 1008 eMail 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Mason, Elizabeth F; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Bargbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins; Craig DeWald Lynn; Swanson George Thomas 1009 eMail 7/23/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth-F;- Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins; Craig DeWald Lynn; Swanson George Thomas 1010 eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1011 eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald Lynn; Mark Hutchins; Craig George Thomas Swanson 1012 eMail with 7/22/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1013 eMail with 7/22/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment 1014 eMail with 7/20/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Craig 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product attachment Swanson 1015 eMail 5/17/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Craig Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Swanson-1016 eMail with 5/17/2004 Mark Mattson Mark-Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1017 eMail with 5/3/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Craig 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report Attorney Work Product attachment Swanson 1018 eMail with 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product attachment 1019 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1020 email with 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product attachment 1021 eMail 4/26/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay; L. Cable 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1022 eMail with 4/26/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1023 eMail with 4/24/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1024 eMail with 4/24/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1025 eMail with 4/24/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment I I I Page 82

C 0 0 NO- Teof TWO Document Date Author/Sender Recilent CC Sublect Privileaed Asserted 1026 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Mattson; Paul 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Undsay; Mark Hutchins 1027 eMall with 4/22/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1028 eMail with 4r22/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1029 eMail 4/22/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins _H__________'ydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1030 eMall with 4/22/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product attachment 1031 eMall with 4/22/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1032 eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Paul Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Undsay 1033 eMail 4114/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1034 eMail with 4/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1035 eMail 4114/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1036 eMall with 4/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1037 eMall 4/14/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1038 eMail with 4/13/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1039 eMall with 4/113/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1040 eMall with 4/13/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product attachment Demonstration 1041 eMail with 4/11/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment _

1042 eMail with 4/10/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1043 eMall 4/10/2004 Susan Ward Mark HutchIns Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1044 eMail 4110/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermaf modeling Attorney Work Product 1045 eMall with 4/10/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1046 eMail 4/9/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1047 eMail 4/8/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1048 eMail 4/8/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1049 eMail 4/8/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1050 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1051 eMail with 417/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1052 eMall with 417/2004 Susan Ward Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachme nt _I ___III Page 83

0 6 o.

Time of Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privilened Asserted 1053 eMail with 417/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product attachment 1054 eMail with 407/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1055 eMall 417/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Paul Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Lindsayatt 1056 eMail 417/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins; Paul Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Lindsay 1057 eMail 417/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1058 eMail with 4/6/2004 Paul Undsay Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachmentL 1059 eMail 4/5/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1060 eMail 4/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product at nMattson, 1061 eMail with 3/27/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachmentM 1062 eMail 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins . .ydrotherrmalmodeing Attomey Work Product 1063 eMall with 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas DeWald Lynn; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment Hutchins 1064 eMail with 3/25/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1065 eMail with 3/25/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1066 eMail with 3/25/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1067 eMall With 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product attachment 1068 eaial 3/25/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermall modeling Attorney Work Product Page 84

0 0 Privileae Lou for Documents Through October 23. 2006 This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) In connection with Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary No. Document Date Author/Sender Recivlent CC Sublect Privileaed Asserted 1 eMail With Attachment 3121/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 2 eMail With Attachments 312112004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 3 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 4 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004, Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 5 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 6 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 7 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 8 email 3/1812004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins H'drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 9 email 3/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 10 email 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 11 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 12 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modelino Attomey Work Product 13 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 14 eMail With Attachments 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 15 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 16 email 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 17 eMail With Attachment 3/15/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 18 eMail With Attachment 3/15/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 19 eMail With Attachments 3/15/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modelin Attorney Work Product 20 eMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 921 eMail With Attachment 311412004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 22 -Mail With Attachments 3/1412004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 23 email 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 24 eMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 25 eMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 26 email

  • 3/13/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 27 eMail With Attachment 3/11/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 28 eMail With Attachments 3/10/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 29 eMail With Attachments 3/9/2004 §usan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H rothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 30 eMail With Attachments 319/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 31 eMail With Attachment 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product z strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES I 1316(a) Demonstration ti-I h-i.

Page I LIBA/1739576_2.XLS 2~.

,F-'*-.

'~ ) .D Type Of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recflent CC SubIect Privileged Asserted 32 eMail With Attachment 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report

  • 33 eMail With Attachment 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report 34 eMail With Attachment 3/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 35 eMail With Attachment 3/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 36 eMail With Attachments 3f7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 37 eMail With Attachments 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; George Thomas; Mark Hutchins; Craig Swanson 38 eMail 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson cswanson; hutchins; Mark Grachuk, Jeanine 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Harmon LG 39 eMail With Attachment 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

_ with ANR regarding NPDES 40 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 41 eMall 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson Rick Simmons; Terry 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Euston; droyer; Alex Gonyaw; hutchins 42 eMail With Attachments 3/2/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 43 eMall 3/1/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 44 eMall 2/27/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 45 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attomei Work Product 46 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 47 eMail 2/13/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 48 eMail 5/31/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 49 eMail 5/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 50 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H/drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 51 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 52 eMail With Attachment 5/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomrey Work Product 53 eMail 4/26/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 2 LIBAN1739576_2.XLS

0 ,0 Type of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Subiect Privileged Asserted 54 eMail With Attachments 4/21/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 55 eMail With Attachments 4/20/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANIR 56 eMail 411912006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 57 eMall 4/1812006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 58 eMail 4/17/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 59 eMall With Attachment 4113/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 60 eMail 4/1312006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 61 eMail 4113/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 62 eMall 4/1112006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 63 eMall With Attachment 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins. Mark Mattson Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 64 eMail 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 65 eMall 4/10/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 66 eMail With Attachment 4/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I e6Hydrothermal modeling 67 eMall 4/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 68 eMail 4/8/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H drothermal modeling Attorne Work Product 69 eMail With Attachment 4/8/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 70 eMail With Attachment 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 71 eMall With Attachment 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hdrothermal modelinl Attorney Work Product 72 leMail With Attachment 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 73 eMall 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I_ Hydrothermal modeling 74 ,eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 75 eMail 4/5/2006, Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 76 eMall 3/30/20,06 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 77 eMall With Attachment 12/5/2005 Mark Hutchins; Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product 316(a) =strategy for communications Demonstration with ANR regarding NPDES; L 316(a) Demonstration 78 eMall With Attachment 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 79 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 80 eMail With Attachment 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

.316(a-) Demonstration 81 e'mail 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 82 eMall 12/212005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product I_ I__ I 1316(a) Demonstration I Page 3 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

L 0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subcect Privileged Asserted 83 eMail 11/30/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 84 email With Attachment 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 85 eMail With Attachment 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 86 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 87 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 88 eMail With Attachment 10/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communication

_with ANR

89. eMail With Attachment 10/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 90 eMail 10/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 91 eMail 8/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

__ 'modeling 92 eMail 8/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 93 eMail With Attachment 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 94 eMail 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 95 eMail 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_ modeling 96 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_ 'modeling 97 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 98 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 99 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 100 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 101 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 102 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 103 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 104 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 105 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 106 email With Attachment 817/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 107 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward; Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_modeling 108 eMail With Attachment 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration; Correspondence relating to

  • - -strategy for communications with ANR Page 4 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date sReci1snt Author/Sender CC Subject Privileged Asserted 109 eMail 816/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 110 eMail 8/4/2004

  • Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 111 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 112 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 113 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H drotherrnai modelinl Attorney Work Product 114 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modelinl Attorney Work Product 115 eMail With Attachment 8/2/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications 110_ MarkHutchins email 8/_/2004SusanWardwith ANR regarding NPDES 116 eMail 8/1/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 117 eMail 7/3112004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 118 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 119 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 10 sel7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrotherrnai modeiinl Attome Work Product 171 eMail 1/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 22 sal7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H rothermal modsiinl AttorneyWork Product 13 sal7/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H :rothermai modeiinl AttomeyWork Product 124 eMail With Attachment 7/27/2004 MarkHutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling AttomewWork Product 172 eMail 711/2004 Mark Hutchins uark Mattson H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 117 eMail 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H rothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 18 sMall 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 19 sMell 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 129 eMail 7/2612004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 130 eMail With Attachment 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 131 eMail With Attachment 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 13 eMail 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins . Susan Ward Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 124 eMail 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 125 sMall 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 126 ell 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson W Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 136 eMail 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 128 sMall 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1298 eMail 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modelinl Attomey Work Product 130 sMell 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1430 eMail WithAttach 7/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 143- eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1,34 eMail 7/2312004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 143 eMail 7/20/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product 3 7 M , Hydrothermal modeling AttorneyWorkProduct 153 eMail 7/242004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hy316(a)Demonstration; Attorney Work Product 1435 eMal With Attachment 4/29/2004 Mark Hutchins 138_______MarkHutchinsMarkMattson Mark Mattson HyHrothermal modeling Hydrothermal modeling AttorneyWorkProduct Attorney Work Product 146 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1417 sMa, Wih Attachment 2/2.812004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 5 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

(-N K) *T No. Document Date AuthorSender Recip ent CC Suboct Privileged Asserted 148 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 149 eMail 4127/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 150 eMail With Attachment 4/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 151 eMail With Attachment 4/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 152 eMail 4/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 153 eMail With Attachment 4/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 154 eMail 4/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 155 eMail 4/2312004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 156 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 157 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 158 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 159 eMail 4/22/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 160 eMail 4/22/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 161 eMall 4/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 162 eMail With Attachment 4115/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 163 eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 164 eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Llndsay Mark Mattson Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 165 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 166 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 167 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modelinl Attorney Work Product 168 eMail 4/1412004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 169 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 170 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 171 eMail 4/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modelin2 Attorney Work Product

.172 eMail 4/13/2004 Mark Hutchins .Susan Ward Hdrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 173 eMail 4/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 174 eMail 4112/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 175 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul.Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 176 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Llndsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 177 eMall 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 178 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 179 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H rothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 180 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 181 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson H rothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 182 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 183 eMail 4/8/2004 Mar Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 184 eMail 4(712004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hylrothermal modellni Attorney Work Product 1.85 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 186 eMail 4f7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 187 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 188 eMail 4f7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hylrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 189 eMail 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 6 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient cc Subect Privileged Asserted 190 eMail 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 191 eMail 3/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 192 eMail 3124/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product 193 eMail 311912004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 194 eMail 3/19/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 195 eMail _3118/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hy:rothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 196 eMail 3/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 197 eMail 3/17/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward H rothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 198 eMail _ _ 3/17/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 199 eMail 3/1612004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H/drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 200 eMali 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermai modeling Attorney Work Product 201 eMail 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothe'mal modeling Attorney Work Product 202 eMail 3/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 203 eMail 3/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermai modeling Attorney Work Product 204 eMail 3/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 205 eMail 3/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modelinl Attorney Work Product 206 eMail 3/1112004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermai modeling Attorney Work Product 207 eMail T3/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 208 eMail /31012004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 209 eMail 3/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 210 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 211 eMail 3/312004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 212 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrotherrnai modeling Attorney Work Product 213 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hdrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 214 eMail 3/312004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 3162a) Demonstration 215 eMail 3/1112004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 216 eMail 2/2712004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 217 eMail 2/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson H:drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 218 email 2/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modelingl Attorney Work Product 219 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 220 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

__316(a) Demonstration 221 eMail 1/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hy,drctherrai modeling 222 eMail 6/16/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; David Lewis; Wender IV, Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ricky Buckley, Ricky Samuel; permit appeal Buckle; Mark Mattson McElwee, David; Metell, Mike;.

Hoffman, John; Burke, Terence A; Rademacher, Norman L Page 7 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

t" 0

Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 223 eMail 5/5/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product permit appeal 224 eMail 4/26/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; E permit appeal Zoli; Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay 225 eMall 4/18/2006 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Zoll, Elise N; Mark permit appeal Mattson; Thomas, George; DeWald, Lynn 226 eMall 3/30/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Mark Mattson; Zoli, permit appeal Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Smith, Sharon 227 eMail 3/30/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn; McCullough, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara Travis; Burke, Ripley; Thomas, George; Terence A; Sloan, Thayer, Jay; McElwee, Robert D David 228 eMail 3/29/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay;, McElwee, Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication David McCullough, Travis; Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Wender IV,Samuel 229 eMail 3/29/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson Samuel strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 230 eMail 3/28/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 231 eMail With Attachment 3/24/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 232 eMail 3/22/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Lynn Elise Zoli; McCullough, 1_ 1_ ITravis 233 eMail 3/21/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson I 316(a) Demonstration AttomeyClient Communication Page 8 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

Type o No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciplent cSubect Privileged Asserted 234 eMail 3/19/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Thomas, George; Barbara Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; E Samuel Zoll; DeWald, Lynn 235 eMail 311812006 Barlow, Chuck D Thomas. George; Barbara Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; E Samuel Zoll; DeWald, Lynn 236 eMail 3/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Ripley Zoli, Elise N 237 eMail 3/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication Lynn Zoli, Elise N Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES:

Fisheries data 238 eMail 317/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Zoli, Elise N with ANR regarding NPDES 239 eMail 2/20/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, ElIse N; Barbara Williams, U Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Gwyn; Mason, Mattson Elizabeth F 240 eMail 2/14/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 241 eMail 211312006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 242 eMail 2/8/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Lynn;, Mark Mattson; Elise

_ _ __ _ _ _ _._ _ .Zoli. ,________'___.____ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

243 eMail 2/8/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli_

244 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 245 eMail 2t7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 246 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 247 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, ChuckD0 Mark Mattson; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication Ripley, DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Page 9 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Km T Pe of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Subject Privilened Asserted 248 eMail 2/6/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley;, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication Mattson; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 249 eMail 2/3/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley. DeWald, Lynn; Elise permit appeal Zoli 250 eMail With Attachment 1/31/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Mattson 251 eMall 1/27/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mark Mattson; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson Barbara Ripley; permit appeal Wendar IV, Samuel;Zoli, Elise N 252 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Zoli, strategy for communications Elise N; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES; Litigation strategy relating to

_permit appeal 253 eMail 12/2112005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Litigation strategy relating to

_ _permit appeal 254 eMail 12121/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 255 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Zoll, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 256 eMall 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Smith, Sharon strategy for communications Zoli, Elise N; McEIwee, with ANR regarding NPDES; David Fisheries data 257 eMall 12/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Zoli, Elise N Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications

_Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 258 eMail 12/8/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McEiwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thayer, Jay;, Mark strategy for communications

_Mattson; Barbara Ripley _with ANR regarding NPDES Page 10 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 © Typel No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC SubLect Privileged Asserted 259 eMail 121812005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thayer, Jay;, Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 260 eMail 12/8/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, McCullough, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Mark Mattson; Travis; Burke, strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay;, Terence A with ANR regarding NPDES e __a_ _ _ Buckley, Ricky N 261 email 12/812005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, McCullough, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Mark Mattson; Travis; Burke, strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay;, Terence A with ANR regarding NPDES

_ Buckley, Ricky N 262 eMail 12/712005 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay;, McElwee, Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Wander IV, Samuel; McCullough, with ANR regarding NPDES; DeWald, Lynn Travis; Burke, Fisheries data Terrence A 263 eMail 1217/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay;, McElwee, Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley, strategy for communications Wender IV, Samuel; McCullough, with ANR regarding NPDES; DeWald, Lynn Travis; Burke, Fisheries data Terence A 264 eMail 12/7/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Ripley Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 265 eMail 12/7/2005 Barlow, Chuck0D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, McElwee, David Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Tim Brush; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Wander IV, with ANR regarding NPDES Samuel; Farquharson, Don 266 eMail 12/6/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 267 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 268 sMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 11 LIBAN1739576_2.XLS

f 0 0 Typel No. Document Date AuthorLSender Reclpent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 269 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 270 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication.

Mattson; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 271 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 272 eMail 121112005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 273 eMail 11/30/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; David Rocchio strategy for communications Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay with ANR regarding NPDES 274 eMail 11/22/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 275 eMail 10/24/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara strategy for communications Ripley; Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES Thayer, Jay,McElwee, David 276 eMail 10/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 277 eMail 10/18/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson 278 eMail 10/18/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N , 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson Wender IV, Samuel; Thayer, Jay;, Georgian, Kathryn A; Mason, Elizabeth F

279 eMail 10/13/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 280 eMail 10/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attoey-Client Communication 281 eMail 10/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Peter Van Oat; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; David M. Rocchlo strategy for communications Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES I._

__ _ Mattson; Thayer, Jay I 282 eMail 10/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Yasi, Dan; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson Thomas, George strategy for communications t I_ with ANR regardiing NP.ES.

Page 12 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

No. Document Date AuthorlSender , Recipient CC SubAect Privileged Asserted 283 eMail 10/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay;, strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; McElwee, David; Thomas, George 284 eMail 10/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay, DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara strategy for communications Ripley; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George; Wender IV, Samuel _

285 eMail 10/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay;, with ANR regarding NPDES McElwee, David; Thomas, George 286 eMail 9/20/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George 287 eMail 9/20/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES George 288 eMail 9/9/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications McElwee, David; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES George; Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay 289 eMail 8/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley;, Thomas, George; Samuel; Mark strategy for communications McElwee, David Mattson; Peter with ANR regarding NPDES Van Oot 290 eMail 8/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Wender IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George 291 eMail 8/11/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Thomas, George; Samuel; Mark strategy for communications Barbara Ripley;, Peter Van Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES loot Page 13 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 t

ID No. Document Date Author/Sender Reclent CC Subcect PrivileAed Asserted 292 eMail 8/11/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; DeWald, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; Samuel strategy for communications Thomas, George; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES Ripley; Peter Van Got 293 eMail 8/11/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Wonder IV, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Lynn; Thomas, George; Samuel; Mark strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Peter Van Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES I _Oot 294 eMail 8/11/2005. Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson *_ _

295 eMail 7/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thayer, Jay;, Samuel strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Thomas, George 316(a) Demonstration 296 eMail 7/25/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay;, Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 297 eMail 7/20/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Ripley, Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay;, Mark Mattson 298 eMail 7/13/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Thomas, Wander IV, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication George; DeWald, Lynn; Samuel; Nichols, Mark Mattson Craig; Sloan, Robert D 299 eMail 7/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Thomas, Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication George; DeWald, Lynn; Samuel; Nichols, Mark Mattson Craig; Sloan,

  • __Robert D 300 eMail 6/6/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 301 eMail 5/6/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES Page 14 LIBN/1739576_2.XLS

Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privilegaed Asserted 302 eMail 4/29/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley; Nutter, Victor Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Mark Product Mattson; Thomas, George 303 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work David; DeWald, Lynn; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES; Thomas, George 316(a)-Demonstration 304 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley;, DeWald, Lynn; Elise Correspondence relating to Product Zoll; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 305 eMail 4/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Zoll, strategy for communications Product Elise N; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES 306 eMail 4/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product.

Zoll, Elise N with ANR regarding NPDES 307 eMail 4/14/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 308 eMail 4/14/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 309 eMail 3/30/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Barbara strategy for communications Product Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 310 eMall 3/23/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Eise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES; Barbara Ripley Versar Report 311 eMail' 3/17/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley;, Correspondence relating to Product Thomas, George; McElwee, strategy for communications David; Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 312 eMail 3/16/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; McElwee, strategy for communications Product David; DeWald, Lynn; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Elise Zoll Page 15 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

C 0 Typel No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciplent CC Sublect Prlvlleaed Asserted 313 eMail 3/16/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley, McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work David; Thomas, George; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; DeWald, with ANR regarding NPDES Lynn; Elise Zoll 314 eMail 2/2/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Thomas, DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George strategy for communications Attorney Work Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 315 eMail 1/28/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Mark F strategy for communications Product Mattson; Barbara Ripley, with ANR regarding NPDES; Tim Brush ._ Fisheries data 316 eMail 1/28/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 317 eMail 1/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D. Mark Mattson; Barbara Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George strategy for communications Product Wender IV,Samuel; Elise with ANR regarding NPDES; Zoli; Thomas, George; Tim Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Brush , modeling 318 eMail 1/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Thayer, Jay; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Wender IV,Samuel; Thomas, George strategy for communications Product Elise Zoll; Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; Mark Mattson; Tim Brush Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 319 eMail 1/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara McCullough, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Mark Travis Correspondence relating to Product Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 320 eMail 11/4/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley;, Zoli, Elise Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mason, Elizabeth F; F Correspondence relating to Product DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES;

___Fisheries data 321 eMail 11/2/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Zoll, Elise N; Barbara 316(a). Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to Product DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES Page 16 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient Cc Subfect Privileaed Asserted 322 eMail 11/2/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to Product DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 323 eMail 9/16/2004 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Thomas, Report Product George; Barbara Ripley 324 eMal* 9120/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 325 eMail With Attachment 7/9/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data; Versar Report 326 eMail 717/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson Zoli, Ellse N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data; Versar Report 327 eMail With Attachments 777/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data; Versar Report 328 eMail 6/28/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson; DeWald, Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration Atto*ney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn Zoli, Elise N Product 329 eMail With Attachment 6/27/2006 Concannon, Sarah DeWald, Lynn; Mark Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Zoli, Elise N Product 330 eMail With Attachment 6/113/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson; Mark Zoli, Elise N; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Hutchins Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product DeWald, Lynn with ANR regarding NPDES 331 eMail 10/13/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Lewis, David R; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Zoli, Elise N; strategy for communications Barlow, Chuck D; with ANR regarding NPDES Gordon, Anne T 332 eMail 10/12/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Burke, Lewis, David R; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Terrence A; Zoll, Elise N; Scott Vance; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Mark Wender IV, with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Vekasy, Steve; Samuel; Metell, Thomas, George Mike 333 eMail 1017/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 17 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient Cc Sublect PriLvilegd Asserted 334 eMail 9/30/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Lewis, David R Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Matell, Mike; with ANR regarding NPDES Wender IV, Samuel; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Burke, Terence A 335 eMail 9/28/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication N; Lewis, David R Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Metell, Mike; with ANR regarding NPDES Wender IV, Samuel; Thomas, George; McElwee, David 336 eMail 7/10/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Wender IV, Samuel; strategy for communications Zoli, Elise N; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES; Ripley; Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Thomas, George 337 eMail With Attachment 6/28/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication D; Concannon, Sarah; Mark strategy for communications Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 338 eMail 6/28/2006 DeWald, Lynn Concannon, Sarah' Mark Barlow, Chuck D; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Zoll, Elise N modeling Product 339 eMail With Attachment 6/26/2006 DeWald, Lynn Fitzgerald, Robert H; Zoll, Elise N; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Williams, U strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; Gwyn; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbara Ripley Concannon, Sarah; Tabor, Anna-Marie; Mark Mattson Page 18 LIBA/1739576.2.XLS

0 *T TvoeofPriledAstd No. Document Date Autho!Sender Recipient CC Subject Privileged Asserted 340 eMail 6/18/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Williams. U Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work D; Thomas, George; Gwyn; Fitzgerald, strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; Barbara Robert H; with ANR regarding NPDES; Ripley; Wender IV, Samuel; Concannon, Fisheries data Mark Mattson Sarah; Tabor, Anna-Mare; Rademacher, Norman L 341 eMail With Attachment 6/16/2006 DeWald, Lynn David Lewis; Buckley, Ricky Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mark Mattson Samuel; Barlow, strategy for communications Product Chuck D; with ANR regarding NPDES McElwee, David; Metelf, Mike; Hoffman, John; Burke, Terence A4 Rademacher, Norman L 342 eMail 5/31/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 343 eMall 5/15/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product*

344 eMail 5/12/2006 DeWald, Lynn Rademacher, Norman L; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Wender IV, Samuel; Mark Hutchins strategy for communications Product Maguire, William F; with ANR regarding NPDES; Dreyfuss, John; Pittman, Hydrothermal modeling Bill; Thomas, George 345 eMail 5/12/2006 DeWald, Lynn Rademacher, Norman L; Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Wender IV, Samuel; Mark Hutchins Maguire, William F; Dreyfuss, John; Pittman, Bill; Thomas, George 346 eMail 5/11/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins; Thomas, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Mark Mattson; Product Elise Zoll 347 eMail 5/5/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoll Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work modeling Product Page 19 LIBA11739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect, Privileaed Asserted 348 eMail 5/5/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication D modeling;Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 349 eMail 5/5/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Versar Report 350 eMail 5/4/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 351 eMail 4/2412006 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Wender IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Rademacher, with ANR regarding NPDES Norman L; Zoll, Elise N; Thomas, George 352 eMail 4/20/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 353 eMail With Attachments 4/19/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work modeling Product 354 eMail 3/30/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Mark Mattson; Zoll, Wender IV, strategy for communications Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley;, Samuel with ANR regarding NPDES; Smith, Sharon Fisheries data 355 eMail 3/25/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

_modeling 355 eWail 3/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 357 eMail With Attachment 3/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration;

_Fisheries data 358 eMail 2/15/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli _with ANR regarding NPDES I Page 20 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 "rvoe of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciolent C Subject Privileged Asserted 359 eMail 2/14/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley, Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 360 eMail 2/8/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley;, Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 361 eMall With Attachment 2/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoll; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES;

_ __ __Hydrothermal modeling .__

362 eMail 12116/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 363 eMail 12/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson McElwee, David 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 364 eMail 12/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barbara Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley modeling Product 365 eMail 1218/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thayer, Jay;, Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 366 eMail 12/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Tim Brush; Mark Mattson; Communication regarding Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara NPDES permit Ripley; Wender IV, Samuel; Farquharson, Don 367 eMail 12/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 368 eMail 12/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES 369 eMail 12/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David with ANR regardingNPDES 370 eMail 12/4/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling Page 21 LIBN1739576_2.XLS

0 No. Document Date Author/Sender p Recipient CC SubLect PrlvlIeoed Asserted 371 eMail 12/4/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling 372 eMail 11/21/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David Barbara Ripley;, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 373 eMail 10/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; 31 6(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication.

ChChuck D; McElwee, David; David Rocchio Fisheries data Thomas, George; Thayer,

__ _eald__Jay;, Mark Mattson 374 eMail 10/18/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Wender Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication IV, Samuel; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay 375 eMail 8/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication Ripley Samuel; Mark Correspondence relating to Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George With ANR regarding NPDES 376 eMail 7/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay;, Samuel; Wender Correspondence relating to McElwee, David; Mark IV, Samuel strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George 377 eMail 7/2712005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay, Samuel McElwee, David; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 378 eMail 7/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication Ripley; Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to McElwee, David; Thayer, strategy for communications Jay;, Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 379 eMall 7/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, McElwee, David; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson Wender IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Nichols, with ANR regarding NPDES Craig; Thayer, Jay, Barbara Ripley 380 eMail 717/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 1316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product 381 eMail 17/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration lAttorney Work Product Page 22 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type* of" No. Document Date AuthorfSender ReciDlent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 382 eMall 6/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Eise N; Barlow, Chuck 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication 0; Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to Mattson; Thomas, George strategy for communications

_with ANR regarding NPDES 383 eMail 616/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elisa Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley;, Mark Correspondence relating to Product Mattson; Thomas, George strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 384 eMail 5/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck 0; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Correspondence relating to George; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding.NPDES 385 eMail 5/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Buckley, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ricky N; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley, with ANR regarding NPDES; Thomas, George Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

'__._modeling 386 eMail 4/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 387 eMail 3/31/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Elise Zoll; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling 388 eMail 3/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D; Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES; Barbara Ripley Versar Report 389 eMall 3/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbara Ripley 390 eMail. 3/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley;, McElwee, Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication David Mattson; Barlow, strategy for communications Chuck D with ANR regarding NPDES 391 eMall 3/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 392 eMail 3/11/2005 DeWa!d, Lynn Barbara Ripley;, McElwee, Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication David Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George; Barlow, with ANR regarding NPDES; Chuck D Hydrothermal modeling Page 23 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 © No. Document Date Author/Sender Reclllent CC Sublect Privilened Asserted 393 eMail 3/8/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Elise Zoii; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 394 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, Product George; Barbara Ripley; McElwee, David 395 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Elise Zoli; Barbara modeling Product Ripley;, Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Wender IV, Samuel 396 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 397 eMail 3/4/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley;, Elise Zoll; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; McEIwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Mark Mattson 398 eMail 3/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David; Barlow, Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thomas, George; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbara Ripley 399 eMail 3/1/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley;, with ANR regarding NPDES McElwee, David 400 eMail 2/15/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Wender IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Elise Zoli; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Barbara Ripley Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

_modeling 401 email 2/11/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I_ modeling 402 eMail 2/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 24 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

f-'*

0 No. Document Date AuhorSender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 403 eMail 1128/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES Tim Brush 404 eMail 1/24/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay; strategy for communications Wender IV, Samuel; Elise Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES; Zoli; Thomas, George; Tim Fisheries data; Versar Report Brush 405 eMail 1/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Wender IV,Samuel; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Tim Brush modeling; Versar Report 406 eMail 1116/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Product Barbara Ripley, Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES; George Versar Report 407 eMail 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Thomas, George; strategy for communications Product Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES Ripley; Elise Zoli 408 eMail 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; F strategy for communications Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Versar Report 409 eMail 1114/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, Wender IV, Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Mark Mattson; Samuel Product ElIse Zoli; Barbara Ripley 410 eMail 1/13/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Elise Zoll; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 411 eMail 1/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara McCullough, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Mark Travis; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Product Mattson George strategy for communications I_ I I with ANR regarding NPDES 412 eImail 12/29/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson q Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product Page 25 LIBA/1739576.2.XLS

C \K)

No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 413 eMail 12/22/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zol, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley;, Barlow, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Product Chuck D modeling 414 eMail 11/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Thomas, George; F strategy for communications Product Barlow, Chuck D; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson Fisheries data 415 eMail 10/22/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Correspondence relating to Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 416 eMail 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Hydrothermal modeling Product George 417 eMail 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbra Ripley; Thomas, Hydrothermal modeling Product George 418 email 10/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 419 eMail 10/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins Elise Zoli; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Fisheries data Product 420 eMail 10/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley;, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Alex Gonyaw; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 421 eMall 9/21/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Mark Product Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D 422 eMail 9/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attomey-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Report George; Barbara Ripley 423 eMail 9/14/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Elise Zoli; Mark Product Mattson; Barbara Ripley 424 eMail 8/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Mark T. strategy for communications Mattson Ph. D.; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES George 425 eM-ail 8/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli Mark T. Mattson Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Ph.D. strategy for communications

_with ANR regarding NPDES I Page 26 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Tyeof No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciplent CC 1Subect Privileged Asserted 426 eMail 811212004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 427 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 428 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-ClIent Communication Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara G. Ripley; Mark T. with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson Ph. D.; McEIwee, David 429 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli. Elise N; Mark T. Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Ph. D.; Barbara G. F strategy for communications Product Ripley;, Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES Barlow, Chuck D 430 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 431 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Product George; Barlow, Chuck D 432 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 433 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 434 eMail 813/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley;, Elise Zoli; E Mason; David Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Thomas, Rocchlo strategy for communications

__George with ANR regarding NPDES 435 eMail 7/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 436 email 7/20/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson F strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 437 eMail 7/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Master, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard; Barbara Ripley; Product Elise Zoli 438 eMail 7/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product Page 27 LIBA11739576_2.XLS

0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Recidpent CC Sublect Privileaed Asserted 439 eMail 6/2912004 DeWaid, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 440 eMail 6/212004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Product Mattson strategy for communications

_with ANR regarding NPDES 441 eMall 5/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Hayward, Julie; Thomas, Versar Report;316(a) Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Elise Zoli; Barbara Demonstration Product Ripley;, Mark Mattson; Richard Master 442 eMail 4/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Bill Richkus Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attomey'-Client Communication; Attorney Work Hayward, Julie; Report Product Mark Mattson; Barbara RIpley; Elise Zoii 443 eMail 4/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley Product 444 eMail 4/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Mark Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mattson 445 eMail 4/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Mattson modeling 446 eMail 3/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 447 eMall 3/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Eiise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley;, Thomas, strategy for communications Product George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 448 eMail 3/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 449 eMail 2/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 450 eMail 2/24/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 451 eMall 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley;, Thomas, Product George Hydrthermal 452 eMail 2123/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 28 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 No.- Document Date AuthorLSender Reciglent Sublect Privileged Asserted 453 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Versar Report Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley;, Thomas, Product George _

454 eMail 2/1112004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 455 eMail 2/1012004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley Report Product 456 eMail 2/912004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley E Correspondence relating to Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 457 eMail 1/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley;, 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Report Product 458 eMail 1128/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 459 eMail 1/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 460 eMail 1/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 461 eMail 1/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 462 eMail 1/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 463 eMail 1115/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Patrick, John 316(a) Demonstration Attorney WorkProduct 464 eMail 1/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 465 email 1/1212004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 466 eMail 1/8/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 467 eMail 1/7/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 468 eMail With Attachments 7/712006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal I _modeling 469 eMail With Attachments 7/6/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling ,.__

470 eMail With Attachment 7/6/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 471 eMail With Attachments 7/5/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark-Mattson 316(a)-Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling I Page 29 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

I ~

D TYmeof No ocmen Date Author/Sender Reci lent ccSuec Privileged Asserted 472 eMail With Attachments 6/30/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermeal modeling 473 eMail With Attachments 6/28/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 474 eMall 6/27/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling "

475 eMail With Attachment 6/27/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 476 eMall With Attachments 6/2312006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Chuck Barlow; George Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Thomas; Lynn DeWald; Williams, U Fisheries data; Hydrothermal David McEIwee; Barbara Gwyn; modeling Ripley. Concannon, Sarah Heaton; Tabor, Anna-Marie; Mark Mattson 477 eMail With Attachment 6/23/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 478 eMail With Attachment 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert'H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 479 eMail 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 480 eMall 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 481 eMail 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 482 eMall 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

  • Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

-_ * *_ modeling 483 eMail 6/20/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

_ _modeling 484 eMail 6/20/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration;. Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; K*yf dl;thethl modeling Page 30 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent OC Subject Privileged Asserted 485 eMall 2/1812005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 486 eMail 2118/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I_ _Hydrothermal modeling 48T eMal 2/1712005 Alex Gonyaw Brian Hanson Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 488 eMail 2/1412005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

___Hydrothermal modeling .

489 eMail 2/14/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 490 eMail 2114/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson John Pierce; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin 491 eMail 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 492 eMail 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 493 email 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 494 email 2/1112005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 495 eMail 2/10/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_0" 316(a) Demonstration 496 email 2/10/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

'_ 316(a) Demonstration 497 eMail 2110/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_._ 1316(a) Demonstration 498 email 219/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 499 eMail 2/8/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

,316(a) Demonstration 500 email 218/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 501 email 2/8/2005 Alex Gonyaw MarkMattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 502 eMail 2/1/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 503 eMail 2/1/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

. __ _316(a) Demonstration 504 eMail 1/31/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 1316(a) Demonstration 505 eMail 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Elise N. Zoi; Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration 506 Mall 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw M ark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1507 small 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_ 316(a) Demonstration Page 31 LIBAN1739576_2.XLS

0 Tvoeof No. Document Date AuthorRSender Recllent CC Subaect Prlvileaed Asserted 508 eMail 112812005 AJex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 509 eMail 1/27/2005 Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 0e316(a) Demonstration 510 eMail 1/21/2005

  • Aex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

" _316(a) Demonstration 511 eMail 1121/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_316(a) Demonstration 512 eMail 1/21/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 513 eMail 1/21/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

'_ _Hydrothermal modeling 514 eMail 1/19/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 515 eMall 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Elise N. Zoll; Lynn DeWald; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Product 516 eMail 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Lynn DeWald; Mark Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Product 517 eMall 10/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 518 eMall 10/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_316(a) Demonstration 519 eMail 10128/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

___Matthew Chan 316(a) Demonstration _

520 eMall 10/28/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling *__

521 eMail 10/2612004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson ElIse Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Michelle Comeau 522 eMail 5/21/2004 Alex Gonyaw Chris Gurshin Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Tim Brush; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Mattson 523 eMael 4/28/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

,_ _'_modeling 524 eMail 4/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 525 eMail 4/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal 526 Mattsonmodeling e~aff 4119/2004 Alex onya Mark e2Ma' 4'19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling Page 32 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

K>

Type of No. Document Date Authorlsender ReCOlent CC Sublect Prlvfleged Asserted 527 eMail 4/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 528 eMail 4/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I _Hydrothermal modeling 529 eMail 4/1.4/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 530 eMail 4/5/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 531 eMail 4/5/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Rick Simmons 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

__Fisheries data 532 eMail 4/2/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I _Fisheries data 533 eMail 4/1/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 534 eMail 3/31/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 535 eMail. 3/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 536 eMail 312912004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 537 eMail 3/25/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a)-Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 538 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 539 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 540 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 541 email 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 542 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 543 eMail 3/23/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 544 eMail 3/23/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Michelle 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Comeau "_ Hydrothermal modeling 545 eMail 3/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Chris Gurshin; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson Hydrothermal modeling 546 eMail 3/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Chris 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Gurshin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

__ modeling 547 eMail 3/17/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Michelle 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I Comeau _Hydrothermal modeling I Page 33 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date AuthorlSender f.Reclent CC Sublect Prcvileaed Asserted 548 eMail 311712004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 549 eMail 3/16/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 550 email 3/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 551 eMail 3/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product SHydrothermal modeling 552 eMail 3/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 553 eMail 3/11/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

  • Hydrothermal modeling 554 eMail 3/11/2004 Alex Gonyaw Terry Euston; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson; Rick Simmons; Hydrothermal modeling Doug Royer 555 eMail 3/9/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 556 email 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Terry 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Euston; Rick Simmons; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Doug Royer modeling 557 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Terry Euston; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Rick Simmons; Doug Royer 558 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product
1. 1_ 1 1 Fisheries data 559 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a),Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 560 eMail 3/2/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 561 eMail 3/2/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Terry Euston; Fisheries data Rick Simmons _.

562 eMail 311/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data email 2/23/2004 Alex Gonyaw Paul Hall Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 564 eMail 2/20/2004 Alex Gonyaw Rick Simmons; Doug Royer 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Tenry Euston; Alex Gonyaw 565 eMail 2/10/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Paul Hall Hydrothermal modeling Page 34. LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

(F"*.

0 TXas.of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recpent CC SubjLect Privileged Asserted 566 eMail 21912004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 567 eMail 2/9/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I _Hydrothermal modeling 568 eMall 2/5/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Jennifer Michelle Comeau 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Griffin Hydrothermal modeling 569 eMail 2/3/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 570 eMail 1/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald Fisheries data 571 eMail 1/26/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark-Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 572 eMail 1/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau Hydrothermal modeling 573 eMall 1/2212004 Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Matthew Chan; Hydrothermal modeling Brian Hanson; Mark Mattson; Michelle Comeau:

Tim Brush; Erik Fel'Dotto 574 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw DeWald, Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson Hydrothermal modeling 575 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 576 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 577 eMail 1/1912004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 3.16(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 578 eMail 1/17/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau; Hydrothermal modeling Brian Hanson;.

Matthew Chan; Tim Brush 579 eMail 1/16/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product 5__0_____,__Hydrothermal modeling 580 eMail 12131/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Lynn Tim Brush; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling 581 eMail 12/29/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Page 35, LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

/

0 0 N

Tv,,.of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 582 eMail 12129/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Matthew Chan; Hydrothermal modeling Jennifer Griffin;-

Michelle Comeau; Rick Simmons; Brian Hanson; Tim Brush 583 eMail 12118/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mike Riccl; Michelle Comeau; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson Brian Hanson; Hydrothermal modeling Jennifer Griffin; Matthew Chan; Tim Brush 584 eMail 12/12/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Michelle Comeau 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 585 eMail 12/10/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 586 eMail 12110/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 587 eMall 12/9/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Michelle Comeau 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_ _ _Hydrothermal modeling 588 eMall 12/8/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 589 eMail 12/8/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 590 eMail 12/11/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 591 eMall 11/20/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Michelle Comeau; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling 592 eMail 10/15/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 593 eMail 10/8/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey Work Product I _Hydrothermal modeling 594 eMail 10/3/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_595_____Hydrothermal modeling 595 eMail 10/3/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 596 eMall 9/30/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Fisheries data 597 eMall 9/1012003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I_ Fisheries data 598 eMail With Attachment 5115/2006 Mark Hutchins Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling Page 36 LIBA11739576_2.XLS

0 0 Tyve of No. Document Date AuthorLSender Reclpient CC Sub ect Privileaed Asserted 599 eMail 5/10/2006 MarkHutchins Thomas, George; Mark Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling

_ _ _ _ Elise Zoll 600 eMail With Attachment 5/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

, _Hydrothermal modeling 601. eMall With Attachments 4/21/2006. Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 602 eMail With Attachments 4/20/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 315(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 603 eMaJil 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward; Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 604 eMail With Attachment 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 605 eMail With Attachment 4113/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_ "__ Hydrothermal modeling 606 eMail With Attachment 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 607 eMail 4/10/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 608 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

  • Hydrothermal modeling 609 eMail 4/6/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 610 eMaJl 4/5/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

____________________________Hydrothermal modeling 611 eMail With Attachment 3/3012006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 612 eMall 3/2412006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 613 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothennal modeling 614 eMail 12/212005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product.

Hydrothermal modeling 615 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 616 eMail 6/29/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson _ _ Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 617 eMail 6/29/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothefrmal modeling Attorney Work Product 618 eMail 6/29/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson_ Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 619 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_Hydrothermal modeling 620 eMail 10/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal I I modeling _ _II Page 37 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 TNDypoe No. Document Date Author/Sender CC ccoln Ubect Privileged Asserted 621 eMail 811012004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 622 eMail 818/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Paul Lindsay 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 623 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 624 eMail 817/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward; Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 625 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

__Hydrothermal modeling 626 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 627 eMail 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

.Hydrothermal modeling 628 eMail 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_Hydrothermal modeling 629 eMail 5/1812004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 630 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 3116(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 631 eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

___Hydrothermal modeling 632 eMail 41712004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 633 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

-Hydrothermal modeling 634 email 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

__ Hydrothermal modeling 635 eMail 3/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_____Hydrothermal modeling 636 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mqtson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 637 eMail 3/19/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 638 eMail 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 1316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 639 eMail 3/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 640 email 3/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 641 eMail 3/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_ _ _ _Hydrothermal modeling 642 eMail 3/11/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling Page 38 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privileged Asserted 643 email 2/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 644 eMail 4/912002 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 645 eMail 6/19/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise Burke, Terence A; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Williams, U strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George; Gwyn; Tabor, with ANR regarding NPDES McEiwee, David Anna-Marie; Concannon, Sarah 646 eMail 4/28/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson modeling; Correspondence Product relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 647 eMail 4/26/2006 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck Barlow; strategy for communications David McElwee; with ANR regarding NPDES Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson;.

Jay Thayer 648 email With Attachments 4/25/2006 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to. Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Chuck D; Jay Thayer; Elise strategy for communications Communication Zoli; Mark Mattson; Wender with ANR regarding NPDES; IV,Samuel; McEIwee, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal David modeling 649 eMail 4/24/2006 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Jay Thayer; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck Barlow;, David strategy for communications McElwee; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Elise Zoli 650 eMail 4/18/2006 Barbara Ripley McEIwee, David; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Zoll, Elise N; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas; DeWald, Lynn 651 eMail 3/26/2006 Barbara Ripley Smith, Sharon; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, strategy for communications Chuck D; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 652 eMail 3/26/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 653 eMail 3/18/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Mark Mattson; Samuel strategy for communications Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn with ANR regarding NPDES Page 3.9 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC SubOect Privileged Asserted 654 eMail 3/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 655 eMail 3/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Chuck Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Barlow; Elise Zoli; Lynn Samuel; George strategy for communications DeWald Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES 656 eMall 3/7/2006 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D Zoli, Ellse N strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 657 eMail With Attachment 2/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow;, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 658 eMail With Attachment 2/15/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 659 eMail 2/1512006 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise.Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 660 eMail 2/14/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 661 eMail With Attachment 2/14/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 662 eMail 2/9/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 663 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

____with ANR regarding NPDES 664 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 665 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise Product Zoli 666 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoeli' I Iwith ANR regarding NPDES 667 leMail 2f7/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; DeWald, Lynn strategy for communications Product

_with ANR regarding NPDES Page 40 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

I 0 O Type of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciolent CC Sublect Prlvilened Asserted 688 eMal 216/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Product Elise Zol_

669 email With Attachment 2/4/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elilse strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 670 eMail 2/2/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Product Elise Zoli 671 eMail With Attachment 2t2/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 672 eMail With Attachment 202/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoll with ANR regarding NPDES 673 eMail 2/11/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 674 eMail 2/1/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 675 eMail 2/1/2006 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N Chuck Barlow;, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product

  • Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Pechulls, Kevin P;
  • Mason, Elizabeth F

676 email 1/31/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 677 eMail 1/31/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 678 eMail With Attachment 1/30/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 679 eMail With Attachment 1/30/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES;

_Hydrothermal modeling I Page 41 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

C 0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Relolent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 680 eMail 1/29/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 681 eMail With Attachment 1/29/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES' Hydrothermal modeling 682 eMail 1/28/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

___with ANR regarding NPDES 683 eMail With Attachment 1/27/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

_ _ _with ANR regarding NPDES 684 eMail 1/25/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

_with ANR regarding NPDES 685 eMail 1/25/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 686 eMall With Attachment 1/25/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 687 eMall 1/24/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling -

688 eMail 1/24/2006 Barbara Ripley MarkMattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling .

689 eMail 1/24/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 690 eMail 1/23/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling.

Page 42 LIBA/173957602.XLS

(

0 0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Rechlent CC Sublect Prlvlleoed Asserted 691 eMail 112312006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 692 eMail 1/20/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn DeWald strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 693 eMail 1/20/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 694 eMail 1/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 695 eMail 1/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 696 eMall With Attachment 1/13/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 697 eMail 1/9/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermnal modeling 698 eMail 12/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Jay Thayer Correspondence relating to Attormey-Client Communication; Attorney W~ork Lynn; Mark Mattson; Zoll, Smith, Sharon strategy for communications Product Elise N; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 699 eMail 12/19/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David 700 eMail With Attachment 12/18/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Peter Van Oct Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product David McElwee with ANR regarding NPDES II Page 43 LIB/B1739576_2.XLS

/ ,

(Th No. Document Date Author/Sender

  • Recipient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 701 eMail 12/15/2005 Barbara Ripley McElwee, David; Mark Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product Chuck Barlow with ANR regarding NPDES 702 eMail With Attachment 12114/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; McEIwee, David; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 703 eMall With Attachments 12/13/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications David McElwee with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 704 eMail 12112/2005 Barbara Ripley Sharon F Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn Product 705 eMail 12/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 706 eMail 12/8/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; David McEIwee; strategy for communications Product Jay Thayer; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 707 eMail 1218/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Jay Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thayer; David McElwee; McCullough, strategy for communications Product George Thomas; Wender Travis; Burke, with ANR regarding NPDES;

-. IV, Samuel; Lynn DeWald Terence A Fisheries data 708 eMail 12/2/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney.Work Mattson Product 709 eMail 1211/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Barlow, David Rocchio; Correspondence relating to Attomey'-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; McElwee, David; Peter Van Oot strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; R. Will with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 710 eMail 11/30/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; McElwee, David; David Rocchlo strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay with ANR regarding NPDES;

__Hydrothermal modeling 711 eMail 11/30/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; McElwee, David; David Rocchio strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Jay Thayer with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling _

Page 44 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 712 eMail 10/14/2005 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Peter Van Oat Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Jay Thayer; McElwee, Product David; Mark Mattson; George Thomas 713 eMail 10/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; David M. Rocchlo strategy for communications Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Thayer, Jay Hydrothermal modeling 714 eMail 10/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oat; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; David M. Rocchlo strategy for communications George Thomas; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Jay Thayer Hydrothermal modeling 715 email 10/5/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, David M. Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Jay Thayer; George Rocchlo; Peter strategy for communications Thomas; Mark Mattson; Van Oot with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David; Wender Hydrothermal modeling IV, Samuel 716 eMail 10/4/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Jay Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Thayer; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES; David; George Thomas; Hydrothermal modeling Wander IV,Samuel; DeWald, Lynn 717 eMail 10/3/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; George with ANR regarding NPDES; Thomas; Jay Thayer Hydrothermal modeling 718 email 9/28/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Barlow, Peter Van Oat Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Jay Thayer; George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas; Mark Mattson 719 email 9/19/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay, Peter Van Cot; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Mark David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Mattson; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George, 720 eMail 919/2005 Barbara Ripley Thayer, Jay;, Lynn DeWald; Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Mark David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Mattson; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES Page 45 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

I

(-N

©0 No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC SUblect Prlvilleaed-Asserted 721 eMail 9/9/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 722 eMail 9/9/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D; Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchlo strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Thomas, George; Thayýe, Jay 723 eMail 8/15/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Barlow; David McElwee; strategy for communications George Thomas; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Peter Van Dot 724 eMail 8/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Chuck D Samuel; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES George 725 eMail 8/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Wander IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; George Thomas 726 eMail 8/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; DeWald, Lynn; Samuel; Mark strategy for communications Thomas, George; Peter Van Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES Oot 727 eMail 8/5/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; David McElwee; Jay strategy for communications Thayer; George Thomas; with ANR regarding NPDES Mark Mattson 728 eMail 7/27/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay, Samuel; Wander strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark IV, Samuel with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George; George Thomas 729 eMail 7127/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Jay Thayer; strategy for communications McEIwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; George Thomas Page 46 PLBA/1739576_2.XLS

Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reclp0lent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 730 eMail 7/25/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Jay Thayer, George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas; Mark Mattson 731 eMail 71/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication Badlow; David McElwee; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; Jay Thayer; with ANR regarding NPDES George Thomas 732 eMail 7/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications George Thomas; McEIwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Jay Thayer 733 eMail 71/20/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; George Thomas; strategy for communications McEIwee. David; Jay with ANR regarding NPDES Thayer Mark Mattson 734 eMail 7/13/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES; Jay Thayer Hydrothermal modeling 735 eMail 7/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Jay Thayer, Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES; George Thomas Hydrothermal modeling 736 eMail 12/17/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 737 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product L Paul Lindsay Fisheries data 738 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_ _Fisheries data 739 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 740 eMail 8/4/2004 Sankar Subbayya MarkMattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_ _Fisheries data 741 eMail 8/3/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

. _ ___Fisheries data 742 eMail 914/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

-Hydrothermal modeling ,

743 eMail 5/10/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson; DeWald, Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoll Hydrothermal modeling Product Page 47 LIBA11739576_2.XLS

©- 0 Type of No. Document Date AuthorfSender Rechllent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 744 eMail With Attachments 4/26/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Daniel Yasi 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Hydrothermal modeling Product 745 eMail 3/22/2006 Thomas, George Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work McCullough, Travis; Elise Hydrothermal modeling Product Zoli; Mark Mattson; Smith, Terrence 746 eMail With Attachments 6/30/2003 Yasi, Daniel Thomas, George; Gary Vermont Yankee Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Franklin Mail 747 eMail 3/19/2006 Thomas, George Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Wender IV, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; Elise Samuel Zoll; DeWald, Lynn 748 eMail 3/18/2006 Thomas, George Barbara Ripley; Mark Wender IV, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Samuel Elise Zoll; DeWald, Lynn 749 eMail 12/4/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 750 eMail 10/2712005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley, Barlow, Chuck D; David Rocchio strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; Thayer, with ANR regarding NPDES Jay;, Mark Mattson 751 eMail 8/3/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 752 eMail 8/11/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 753 eMail 7/25/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 754 eMail 6/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, McElwee, David; 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Barbara Rlpley, Wender IV, Hydrothermal modeling Product Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson Samuel; Nichols, I Craigl 755 eMail 5/2.2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 75,6 eMail 5/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 757 eMail 5/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 758 eMail 3/3/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, McElwee, David; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Barbara Ripley;, David Rocchio strategy for communications Product Elise Zoll; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 759 eMall 2/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating.to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Product Barbara Ripley. with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 760 eMall 2/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D Product Page 48 LIBA/1739576 2.XLS

Tyo No. Document Date Author/Sender Realolent C Sublect 1leaed prcM Asserted 751 eMail 10/6/2003 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication Shuman, Eileen; Nichols, Craig; Elise Zoli 762 email With Attachment 10/13/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Mattson 763 eMail With Attachment 10/11/2006 Susan Ward Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 764 eMail With Attachment 7/5/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 765 eMail 7/5/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Fitzgerald, Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Robert H 766 eMail 6/22/2006 Zoll, Elise N Mark Mattson; Georgian, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Kathryn A Product 767 eMail 6/1912006 Zoil. Elise N Mark Mattson Concannon, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Sarah; Fitzgerald, Robert H 768 email 4/25/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; George Chuck Barlow; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attomey-Client Thomas Lynn DeWald; Communication Mark Hutchins 769 eMail 4/10/2006 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Buckley, Ricky N Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Barbara Ripley;, strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Wender IV, Samuel 770 eMail 2/17/2006 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Chuck Williams, U Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; DeWald, Lynn; Gwyn; Mason, strategy for communications Mark Mattson Elizabeth F with ANR regarding NPDES 771 email 1/21/2005 Zoll, Elise N Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Chuck strategy for communications Product Barlow with ANR regarding NPDES 772 eMail 1/21/2005 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; P. Almeag; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard Simmons strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 773 eMail 1/20/2005 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product Chuck Barlow iwith ANR regarding NPDES I Page 49 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

© Tyoe of No. Document Da/ e AuthorlSender M RekasIolent ccn r s lect PrivIlened Asserted 774 eMail 1/20/2005 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Gordon, Correspondence relating to Attorey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Anne T strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 775 eMail 1/19/2005 Zoli, Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Thayer, Jay;, Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley, DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay; Product Wender IV, Samuel; Elise Thomas, George Zoli; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; T 776 eMail 1/14/2005 Zoll, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; F Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley 777 eMail 1/14/2005 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; F Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley 778 eMail 10/8/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Elise Zoll; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara RIpley; Lynn Product DeWald; George Thomas 779 eMail 9/30/2004 Zoll, Elise N Thomas, George; Mark Barbara Ripley;, 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Elise Zoli; Product DeWald, Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Brown, Lois 780 eMail 9/14/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark Barlow, Chuck D 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 781 eMall 9/113/2004 Zol, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoii; Mason, Elizabeth Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Barlow, F Product Chuck D; Thomas, George;

  • __ _ _Barbara Ripley 782 eMail 8/1312004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark Mason, Elizabeth Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson F Product 783 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoll, Elise N Mark Mattson; Lynn Barbara Rilpley;, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Elise Zoll Mark Hutchins Product 784 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; George Chuck Barlow Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas; Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Chuck with ANR regarding NPDES

§arlow 785 eMail' 7/28/2004 Zoli, Else N Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Versar Report Attomey.Work Product Page 50 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Prlvlleaed Asserted 786 eMail 71/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; F Product Mark Mattson 787 eMail 7/27/2004 Zoll, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Elise Zoll; Barbara strategy for communications Product Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 788 eMail 7/2612004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-ClIent Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Richard Master; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 789 eMail 712112004 Zoll, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; F strategy for communications Product George Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES 790 eMail 5/27/2004 Zoll, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson; F Correspondence relating to Product Richard Master; George strategy for communications Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 791 eMail 5/18/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley;, Lynn Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson F; George Correspondence relating to Product Thomas strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 792 eMail 5/2/2004 Zoll, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Hayward, Julie; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George Report Product Richard Master 793 eMail 4/2812004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Richard Master; E Product Mark Mattson 794 eMail 4/27/2004 Zoll, Elise N Mark T. Mattson; Lynn Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Barbara G. Ripley F Product 795 eMail 4127/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mason, Elizabeth F; Bednar, Charlotte 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G. Ripley L; LynnDeWald; Product Mark T. Mattson 796 eMail 4/26/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley;, Mark Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Lynn DeWald; R. F Product I_ Gerdus 797 leMail 4/19/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Barbara Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; E Product Lynn DeWald I Page 51 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

(T D No. Document Date AuthorlSmnder Reciplent CC Sublect Prlvileged Asserted 798 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoll, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson E Product 799 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoll; Elise N Lynn DeWald; Barbara Arena, Suzanne Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson E Product 800 eMail 3/9/2004 Zoli, ElIse N Mark T. Mattson Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work George Thomas; strategy for communications Product Arena,-Suzanne with ANR regarding NPDES E

801 eMail 1/24/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark T. Brennan Jr, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara G. Ripley Robert L; Arena, strategy for communications Product Suzanne E with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 802 eMail 1/20/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Brennan Jr, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson Robert L; Arena, strategy for communications Product Suzanne E with ANR regarding NPDES 803 eMail 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli Lynn DeWald; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product Vekasy, Steve permit appea 804 eMail 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoll Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Vekasy, Steve strategy for communications I with ANR regarding NPDES 805 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli; Sam Wonder; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Lynn George Thomas strategy for communications DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 806 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Lynn strategy for communications DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES;

___316(a) Demonstration 807 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES Lynn DeWald 808 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES ILynn DeWald II 809 e*ail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Sam Wender CIrrespondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES Lynn DeWald Page 52 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

(

/

C 0 Type of No. Document Date AuthorlSender ReclDlent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 810 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn permit appeal;316(a)

Demonstration 811 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn permit appeal;316(a)

Demonstration 812 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley, DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 813 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley, DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 814 eMail 2/612006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 815 eMail 12121/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoll, Elise N McElwee, David 816 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 817 eMail 1212112005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley;- Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 818 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 819 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley;, Zoll, Elise N McElwee, David 820 email 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DoWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 821 eMail 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley 822 eMail 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley 823 eMail 1215/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley Page 53 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

C K) 0 Type of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reiolent Sublect prlvlleged Asserted 824 eMail I9/9/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay 825 email 9/9/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Peter Van Oat; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay 826 eMail 9/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 827 eMail 9/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 828 eMail 3/16/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Rlpley; Elise Zoll; Thomas, strategy for communications George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES DeWald, Lynn 829 eMail 3/16/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Elise Zoli; Thomas, strategy for communications George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES DeWald, Lynn 830 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 8,31 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D Fisheries data Attomey.Work Product 832 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 833 eMail 1/28/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product N; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, F strategy for communications George; Barbara Ripley;, with ANR regarding NPDES; Tim Brush Hydrothermal modeling 834 eMail 1128/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product N; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, F strategy for communications George; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; Tim Brush Hydrothermal modeling Page 54 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

C ( O Type Of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent ccCC SubLect Privileged Asserted 835 eMail 1/28/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product N; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, F strategy for communications George; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; TimBrush Hydrothermal modeling 836 eMall 1/28/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Zoll, Elise Mason, Elizabeth Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product N; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, F strategy for communications George; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; Tim Brush Hydrothermal modeling 837 eMail 1/2012005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; . Thomas, George strategy for communications Wender IV, Samuel; Elise with ANR regarding NPDES; Zoli; Tim Brush Versar Report 838 eMail 1/20/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Thayer, Jay;, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George strategy for communications Wender IV, Samuel; Elise with ANR regarding NPDES; Zoli; Tim Brush Versar Report 839 eMail 9/21/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 840 eMail 6/28/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product

_________________permit appeal 841 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N permit appeal 842 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N permit appeal 843 eMail 6/2712006 Mark Mattson Concennon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N permit appeal 844 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N permit appeal 845 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N permit appeal 846 email 6/2712006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N .permit appeal 847 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoll, Elise N permit appeal 848 email 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoll, ElIse N permit appeal 849 email 6/27/2006 Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N permit appeal

  • 8850 eMail 6/27/2006 Mark MattsoA Concannon, Sarah; Barlow, Chuck D; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product

__DeWald, Lybnn Zoli, Elise N permit appeal 851 email 10/1312006 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorey Work Product Page 55 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reclent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 852 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Rademacher, Norman L; Wender IV,Samuel; Maguire, William F; Dreyfuss, John; Plttman, Bill; Thomas, George 853 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Rademacher, Norman L; Wender IV,Samuel; Maguire, William F; Dreyfuss, John; Pittman, Bill 854 eMail 5/9/2006 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli George Thomas; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Hutchins Mark 855 eMail 2/15/2006 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; Hydrothermal modeling Elise Zoli 856 eMail 8/11/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Chuck D; McElwee, David; Samuel strategy for communications Thomas, George; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES Ripley, Peter Van Oot 857 eMail 814/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 858 eMail 7/12/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, Wender IV, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product David; Thomas, George; Samuel; Nichols, Barlow, Chuck D Craig; Barlow, Chuck D 859 eMail 5/12/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; David M. Rocchio; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications McEIwee, David Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 860 eMail 3/7/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 861 eMail 3/3/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoll Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 862 eMail 3/3/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 863 eMail 2/24/2005 Mark Mattson LEynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Barbara Ripley Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 864 eMail 2/14/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; Elizabeth Mason Page 56 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type Of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recplent CC Amw_ ___ Privilsoed Asserted 865 eMail 2111/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; Elizabeth Mason; Barbara Ripley 866 eMall 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoll Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 867 eMait 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DaWald; Elise Zoli Thomas, George; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; modeling Elizabeth Mason 868 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; Elizabeth Mason 869 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoll Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; Elizabeth Mason 870 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Thomas, George; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barlow, Chuck D; Elizabeth Mason 871 eMail 2/9/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 872 eMail 2/9/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoll Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 873 eMall 219/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 874 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product

_ _ __ _ Ripley- Chuck Barlow _,,

875 eMail 12/29/20,04 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 876 eMall 12/29/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoll Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 877 eMail 12/2912004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 878 eMail 1211612004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 879 eMail 12/16/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 880 eMall 12113/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 881 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 882 eMail 8/13/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 883 eMail 8/12/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoll Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

_with ANR regarding NPDES I 884 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Barbara Ripley, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product I__ I_ I_ I_Hutchins Mark I I Page 57 LIBA11739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC SubLect Privileged Asserted 885 eMail 8/312004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 886 eMail 7/1/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 887 eMall 6/28/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley. Elise Zoll 888 eMail 6/2/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley strategy for communications George Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 889 eMail 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson Julie Hayward Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley, Elise Zell 890 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney Work Product Report 891 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley 892 eMail 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald. Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 893 eMail 3/2/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley

,894 eMail 1/27/2004 Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 895 eMail 3/30/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 896 eMail 2/18/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 897 eMail 2/18/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 898 eMall 2/18/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 899 eMall 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Loin DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 900 eMall 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 901 eMail 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 902 eMall 2/1412005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 903 eMail 2/11/2005. Mark Mattson tex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 904 eMall 2/111/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 905 eMall 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 906 eMall 2/111/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 907 eMall 2/1012005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw H rothermal modeling Attomey.Work Product 908 eMall 2/10/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 909 WMall 2/10/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 910 eMail 2/9/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw .Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 911 eMail 2/8/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 912 eVail 2/8/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 913 eMail 2/8/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 914 eMail 2/812005 Mark Mattson llex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 915 eMail 12/112005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 91'6 eMail _ 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson , Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 58 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

q 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent Am "iecn PrIvilened Asserted 917 eMail 1/31/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 918 eMail 1/28/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 919 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 920 eMail 10/28/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product

_ _ _,_mchan 921 eMail 10/28/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product mchan Hydrothermal modeling 922 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Elise Zoll; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Michelle Comeau 923 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Elise Zoli; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin; Michelle Comeau 924 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau 925 eMail 10/25/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau 926 eMail 10/2512004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau 927 eMail 9/16/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 928 eMail 6/2/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw. Michelle Jennifer Griffin; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Comeau Tim Brush modeling 929 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw; Terry Euston; Sandi Sprague Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Doug Royer; Rick Simmons 930 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw; Tenry Euston; Sandi Sprague Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Doug Royer, Rick Simmons 931 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw; Michelle B Hanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Comeau 932 eMail 2/25/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_ _ _ _ _ _Hydrothermal modeling 933 eMail 215/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw;, Jennifer Michelle Comeau Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Griffin ..

934 eMail 1/23/2004 Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 935 jeMail 4/712006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal mOdeling Attorney Work Product 936 eMqil 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark .Hydrotherinal modeling Attorney Work Product 937 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney YVork Product 938 eMall 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark I Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 59 LIBA1 739576_2.XLS

0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recllent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 939 eMail 417/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 940 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 941 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 942 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 943 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Attorney Work Product 944 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 945 eMail 4/11/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Doug Royer Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 946 eMail 3/30/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Doug Royer; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Rick Simmons 947 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Doug Royer; Sandi Sprague Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Rick Simmons; Alex Gonyaw 948 eMail 3/23/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Doug Royer; Sandi Sprague Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Rick Simmons; Alex modeling Gonyaw *___.

949 eMail 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Doug Royer; Sandi Sprague Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Rick Simmons; Alex Gonyaw 950 eMail 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Doug Royer; Sandi Sprague Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Alex Gonyaw, Rick Simmons 951 eMail 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Rick 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Simmons; Alex Gonyaw, Doug Royer 952 eMail 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Alex Gonyaw; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Rick Simmons; Doug Royer 953 eMail 2/25/2004 Mark Mattson Terry Euston; Rick Fisheries data;316(a) Attorney Work Product Simmons; Alex Gonyaw _ _ Demonstration 954 eMall 4/10/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 955 eMail 4/6/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 956 eMail 4/3/2006 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 957 eMail 4/3/2006 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 958 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 959 eMall 1212/2,005 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrotherrmal modeling AttorneyWork Product 960 eMail 11/30/2005 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 961 eMail 10/12/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 962 eMall 10/1/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 963 eMall 10/11/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attomrey Work Product 964 eMail 10/1/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 965 eMail 10/1/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 966 eMail 10/11/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Page 60 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0)

No. Document Date Author/Sender Reaplent C subjet Privlleged Asserted 967 eMail 912112004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 968 eMail 8/11/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 969 eMail 8/11/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 970 eMail 816/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 971 eMail 816/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 972 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 973 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 974 eMail 8/3/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 975 eMail 813/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 976 eMail 8/2/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling* Attorney Work Product 977 eMail 71/30/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 978 eMail 7/3012004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 979 eMail 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Elise Zoll Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 980 eMail 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson T Euston; D Royer Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

___Fisheries data 981 eMail 7/2412004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 982 eMail 7/22/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 983 eMail 7/22/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regacrding NPDES 984 eMail 7/20/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark; Craig 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Swanson 985 eMail 5/17/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark; Craig 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Swanson 986 eMail 513/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark; Craig 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney Work Product

_ Swanson Report 987 email 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Hutchins Mark; P. Harmon; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Craig Swanson; Lynn Grachuk, Jeanine DeWaid LG 988 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow; Elise Zoli; Lynn Samuel; George strategy for communications DeWald Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES;

-Hydrothermal modeling 989 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow; Elise Zoli; Lynn Samuel; George strategy for communications DeWald Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Page 61 LIBAN1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciplent CC Sublec Privileced Asserted 990 eMail 3/1712006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Wender IV, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow; Elise Zoli; Lynn Samuel; George strategy for communications DeWald Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 991 eMail 2/8/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications

.___with ANR regarding NPDES 992 eMail 2/8/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 993 email 26/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley, Chuck Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Elise Zoll with ANR regarding NPDES 994 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 995 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Elise Zoll with ANR regarding NPDES 996 eMail 2/3/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 297 eMail 2/3/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 998 eMail 2/3/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Barlow; Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli ._

999 eMail 2/2/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 1000 eMail 2/11/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1001 eMail 2/11/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

___with ANR regarding NPDES 1002 eMail 1/31/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES;

_ _ _ _ __ Hydrothermal modeling 1003 eMail 1/31/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 1004 eMail 1/3012006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 62 LaIBAL1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Tvpe of No. Document Date AuthorqSender *Recient CC SubLect Privileged Asserted 1005 eMail 1/24/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1006 eMail 1/20/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 1007 eMail 12/22/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

._ __ with ANR regarding NPDES 1008 eMail 12/22/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1009 eMail 12/2112005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1010 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1011 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

_with ANR regarding NPDES 1012 email 12/2112005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1013 eMail 12/13/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, McEiwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product David; Chuck Barlow; Lynn strategy for communications

_DeWaid with ANR regarding NPDES 1014 eMail 12/13/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product David; Chuck Barlow; Lynn strategy for. communications I DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES 1015 eMail 12/1312005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product David; Chuck Barlow; Lynn strategy for communications DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES 1016 eMail 12/6/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barlow, Chuck D; Analysis relating to NPDES McElwee, David; George Permit Thomas 1017 email 1216/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, David; George Thomas Page 63 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

OT 101 Type of No, Document Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Subiect Privileged Asserted 1018 eMail 12/6/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, David; George Thomas 1019 email 12/212005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attormey Work Product Lynn Fisheries data 1020 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn Fisheries data 1021 eMail 12/212005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn Fisheries data 1022 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley, DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn Fisheries data 1023 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_Lynn . Fisheries data 1024 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn _ _ Fisheries data 1025 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn Fisheries data 1026 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn Fisheries data 1027 eMail 11/30/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; David Rocchio strategy for communications McEIwee, David; Thayer, with ANR regarding NPDES; Jay Analysis relating to NPDES Permit; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1028 eMail 7/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Barlow, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; George Thomas; McElwee, David; Jay Thayer 1029 eMail 7/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Bariow, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Chuck D; DeWald. Lynn; George Thomas; McElwee, David; Jay Thayer 1030 email 7/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Bariow, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; George Thomas; McElwee, David; Jay Thayer 1031 eMail 7/11/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 11032 eMail 17/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Page 64 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

C 0 0 Type o No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recolent CC Sublect Prlivleged Asserted 1033 eMail 71812005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1034 eMail 7/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1035 eMail 5/24/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; Ellse Zoll; Barlow, strategy for communications Chuck D; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 1036 eMail 5/12I2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; David M. Rocchio; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications McElwee, David Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 1037 eMail 5/12/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley, DeWald, Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; David M. Rocchio; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications McElwee, David Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 1038 eMail 3/18/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barlow. Chuck D; strategy for communications Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; David McEIwee Fisheries data 1039 eMall 3/1/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

___modeling 1040 eMail 3/1/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1041 eMail 3/1/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1042 eMail 2/25/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald; Elise Zoli strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

,__modeling 1043 eMail 2/25/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald; Elise Zoli strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data Page 65 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Rechlent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1044 eMail 2111/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1045 eMail 212/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, DeWald, Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn Elise Zoll; strategy for communications Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 1046 eMall 1120/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; Wender IV, Samuel; strategy for communications Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George; Tim Brush 1047 eMail 7/21/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; George Versar Report; Attorney Work Product Thomas; Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Elise Zoli strategy for communications

_____with ANR regarding NPDES 1048 eMail 7/13/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli; Rich Masters Correspondence relating to Attomey Work Product Lynn DeWald strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES;

'_ 316(a) Demonstration 1049 eMail 7/612004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Analysis relating to NPDES

_Permit 1050 eMail 5/12/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1051 eMail 4/13012004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product

.1052 eMail 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1053 eMail 4130/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Elise Zoli; Julie 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1054 eMaIl 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley, Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product 1055 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, Lynn Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product DeWald; Richard Master Elise Zoli 1056 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley;, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product DeWald; Elise Zoli; George strategy for communications Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES; Analysis relating to NPDES I _Permit 1057 eMail 3/2/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Lynn Elise Zoli Fisherles data; Analysis Attorney Work Product DeWald relating to NPDES Permit 1058 eMail 2/9/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attomey WorkProduct 1059 eMail 2/2/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Lynn Fisheries data Attorney Work Product DeWald Pag 6 Pe6BA/1739576_2.XLS

/

0 0 Typeof No. Document Date AuthorlSender *Relolent CC Subject Privileaed Asserted 1060 eMail 9/10/2003 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Lynn Analysis relating to NPDES Permit; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR I_ regarding NPDES 1061 eMail 12/1612004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1062 eMail 815/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1063 eMail 8/3/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1064 eMail 8/3/2004 Mark Mattson Craigl Swanson Paul Lindsay Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1065 eMail 7/29/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1066 eMail 7/27/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Elise Zoli; George Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Thomas; Fisheries data Hutchins Mark 1067 eMail 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1068 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Hutchins Versar Report; Attorney Work Product Mark H1286FIsheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1069 eMail 1/22/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Paul Hall Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1070 eMail 11/20/2003 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Hutchins 1071 eMail 8/7/2003 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Lynn Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product DeWald; George Thomas 1072 eMail 6/24/2003 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark; Mark Harmon Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1073 eMail 4/27/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George Daniel Yasi; Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Hutchins Mark Fisheries data 1074 eMail 4/24/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas;.Eiise Zoli Entergy - Chuck Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Bariow; Lynn Fisheries data DeWald;

_ _Hutchins Mark 1075 eMail 4/21/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Elise Zoll Shaw Group Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product (S&W) - Dan Fisheries data Yazj; Hutchins Mark 1076 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 10M7 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Georgp Thomas I 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1078 eMail 3/241/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Croke, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I I IBryan modeling I Page 67 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 0 Type No. Document Date AuthorlSender Redolent CC,. Sublect Privileged Asserted 1079 eMail 3124/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Croke, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Bryan modeling 1080 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Croke, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Bryan modeling 1081 eMall 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Dan Yazi; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hutchins Mark modeling 1082 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Dan Yazi; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hutchins Mark modeling 1083 eMali 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Dan Yazi Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1084 eMali 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Dan Yazi Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1085 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Dan Yazi Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

___modeling 1086 eMall 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoll Dan Yazi Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1087 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Dan Yazi Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1088 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoll Dan Yazi Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1089 eMail 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Elise Zoli Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1090 eMail 3/21/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

___with ANR regarding NPDES 1091 eMail 3/21/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Croke, Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

__Bryan Fisheries data 1092 eMail 3/21/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Croke, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Bryan Fisheries data 1093 eMail 3/21/2006 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Croke, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Bryan Fisheries data 1094 eMail 3/21/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Croke, Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Bryan " Fisheries data 1095 eMail 1/9/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George Hydrothermal modeling; . Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1096 eMail 119/2006 Mark Mattson Thomas, George Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

  • __ _Fisheries data 1097 eMail 12/23/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, Hutchins Mark Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Lynn; Yasi, Dan Correspondence relating to strategy for communications vith ANR regarding NPDES 1098 eMail 10/19/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

__....with ANR regarding NPDES Page 68, LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

Th No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Subect Privileged Asserted 1099 eMail 1011912005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1100 eMail 8/3/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 1101 eMail 8/3/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas; George Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1102 eMail 8/3/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1103 eMail 202/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Barlow, Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck D 1104 eMail 2/212005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Barlow, Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck D 1105 eMail 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Barlow, Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck D _ "__

1106 eMail 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Barlow, Lynn DaWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck D 1107 eMail 2/212005 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Barlow, Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Chuck D 1108 eMail 11/16/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 1109 email_ 11/5/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George316(a) Demonstration 1109 eMail 115152004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data 1110 eMail 11/5/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling; Fisheries data 1111 eMail 1115/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product HydrotherMal modeling; Fisheries data 1112 eMail 11/5/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George DeWald, L~ynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1113 eMail 10/1/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

___with ANR regarding NPDES 1114 eMail 9/23/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll;

_______________________..___ lutchins Mark 1115 email 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hutchins Mark; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

____Lynn DeWald modeling 1116 eMail 6/3/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

_with ANR regardingrNPDES 1117 eMail 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product

__ __ Hutchins Mark __.

1118 eMail 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I_ _ IHydrothermal modeling Page 69- LI1BA/1739576.2.XLS

0 Tve f*

No. Document Date Author/Sender Recilent CC Sublect Privlleaed Asserted 1119 eMail 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Thomas, George; Zoli, Elise Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product N; DeWald, Lynn 1120 eMail 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1121 eMail 11/25/2003 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications I_ with ANR regarding NPDES 1122 eMail 10/24/2003 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley 1123 eMail 10/22/2003 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley 1124 eMail 10/212003 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES

.Craig Swanson 1125 eMail 9/29/2003 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 1126 eMail 9/29/2003 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Elise-Zoll Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1127 eMail 9/7/2006 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli _IFisheries data Attorney Work Product 1128 eMail 7/26/2006 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Chuck Barlow; Williams, U Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; Barbara Gwyn; Ripley; George Thomas; Concannon, David McElwee Sarah 1129 eMail 7/5/2006 Mark Mattson Zoll, ElIse N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1130 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll Concannon, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product

___Sarah 1131 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli Concannon, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Sarah 1132 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Elise Zoil Concannon, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Sarah 1133 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli Concannon, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Sarah 1134 eMail 6/19/2006 Mark Mattson . Elise Zoli Concannon, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Sarah

  • 1135 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Mattson Yasl, Daniel; Elise Zoll Senkel, Frank 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

,H:lydrothermal modeling 1136 IeMail 4/6/2006 Mark Mattson Yasl, Daniel; Elise Zoli Senkel, Frank 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling PageT70 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 q Type Document Date Author/Sender Recipient Cc Sublect Privileged Asserted 1137 eMail 41612006 Mark Mattson Yasi, Daniel; Elise Zoli Senkel, Frank 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

  • _- Hydrothermal modeling 1138 eMail 2/7/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1139 JeMail 2V712005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1140 eMail 2/2/2005 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1141 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, ElIse N "_,_Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1142 eMail 1121/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N ,_ Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1143 eMall 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1144 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1145 eMail 1121/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorne Work Product 1146 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barlow 1147 eMail 1/21/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Chuck Barlow 1148 eMail 1/20/2005 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N _Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1149 eMall 10/8/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoil; Barbara Ripley; Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; George Thomas 1150 eMall 10/8/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Hutchins Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; George Thomas 1151 eMail 9/14/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald Barlow, Chuck D Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1152 eMail 7/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Elise N Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1153 e-all 7/26/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley, George Thomas 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald 1154 eMail 7/2412004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Rip!ey; Lynn DeWald; F; Mark Hutchins; George Thomas Craig Swanson 1155 eMall 71/23/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley; Lynn DeWald; F; Hutchins Mark; George Thomas Craig Swanson 1156 eMall 7/22/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley;, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; George Thomas 1157 eMail 7/21/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley; George Thomas; Lynn DeWald Page 71 LIBAN1739576..2.XLS

f --=-*

Type Of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1158 eMail 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley Julie Hayward; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; Suzanne Arena 1159 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley, Lynn DeWald; E

_ _ _Richard Master 1160 eMail 4128/2004 Mark Mattson Zoll, Ellse N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley; Lynn DeWeld; E Richard Master 1161 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Lynn DeWald; Mason, Elizabeth 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara G. Ripley F 1162 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Rich Masters; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald Suzanne Arena 1163 eMail 4121/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley; Suzanne Arena; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald Master, Richard 1164 eMail 4/19/2004 Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Arena, Suzanne 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Ripley; Lynn DeWald E 1165 eMail 3130/2004 Mark Mattson Grachuk, Jeanine L G Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Zoli, Elise N; Arena, Suzanne E.

1,166 eJMail, 2/25/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1167 Memo July 2004 Approx Barbara Ripley _316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1168 Letter 2/9/2004 Barbara Ripley _316(a) Demonstration AttomeyWork Product 1169 eMail 4/2/2006 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Zoli, Elise N; J. strategy for communications Product Thayer David McElwee with ANR regarding NPDES, Litigation strategy relating to

.__permit appeal 1170 eMail 4/18/2006 Chuck Barlow David McElwee; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product Zoli, Elise N.; George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas 1171 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Chuck Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barlow, Zoli, Elise N.; Lynn DeWald; S. Wender; George Thomas 1172 eMail 2/3/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley, Chuck Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Barlow; Lynn DeWald; Z611, Elise N.

Page 72 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 Q Tvoe of No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1173 eMail 5/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Zoli, Elise N. Lynn strategy for communications Product DeWald; David McElwee with ANR regarding NPDES 1174 eMail 12/13/2005 Brad Fawley Barbary Ripley; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product John Marshall; strategy for communications Peter Van Oot with ANR regarding NPDES 1175 eMail 12/13/2005 Brad Fawley Barbara Ripley; John Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Marshal; Peter Van Oot strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1176 eMail 1216/2005 Nancy Malmquist Barbara Ripley; Bad Fawley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1177 eMail 1215/2005 Zachary Gates Barbara Ripley Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1178 eMail 12/1/2005 Chuck Barlow Barbara Ripley; Lynn 316(a) Demonstration. Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; David McElwee; Product Mark Mattson 1179 eMail 11/22/2005 Chuck Barlow Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald, Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley _

1180 eMail 11/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; George Thomas; Product Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; E.

Mason 1181 eMail undated Elise Zoli; Chuck Be Lynn DeWald; David Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work McEhwee; George Thomas; Product Mark Mattson 1182 eMail 1/20/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1183 Notes undated Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1184 Notes 10124/2004 Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1185 Notes undated Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1186 Notes undated Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1187 Notes undated Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1188 Notes undated Barbara Ripley 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1189 Notes 5/18/2005 Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1190 Memo 415/2006 Elise Zoli Chuck Barlow; George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas; Lyhn DeWald strategy for communications Product

____9_ _I Notes_5/8/2006with ANR regarding NPDES 1_

11911, FNoteS 15/8/2006 1_ 1 1Fisherles data IAttorney Work Product Page 73 LIBA/173957682.XLS

0 © Type Of No.

_ Document Date Author/Sender Recilient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1192 Memo 718/2005 Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1193 Table Spimg of 04 FIsheries data Attorney Work Product 1194 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1195 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1196 Map undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1197 Map undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1198 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1199 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1200 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1201 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1202 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1203 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1204 Chart undated _Fisheries ,__ data Attorney Work Product 1205 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1206 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1207 Memo undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1208 Notes 10/1212006 Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product I Fisheries data 1209 eMall With Attachment 8/24/2006 Jennifer Griffin Lynn DeWald Tim Brush; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Mattson; Steve modeling Leach 1210 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1211 Report 8/30/2006 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1212 eMail With Attachment 8/11/2006 Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Tim Brush; Steve Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

__Leach modeling 1213 eMail With Attachment 10/.3/05 Lynn DeWald Chuck Barlow, Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Mattson; strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1214 Chart undated Strategy relating to NPDES Attorney Work Product Permit 1215 Article undated Strategy relating to NPDES Attorney Work Product Permit 1216 Article 3/4/2005 Strategy relating to NPDES Attorney Work Product Permit 1217 Article undated Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product:. notes regarding

_ _fisheries data 1218 Memo undated I I I Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1219 Notes 2/9/2006 Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product with ANR regarding NPDES Page 74 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 TY~e of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Reciient CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1220 Memo/Chart 2/9/2006 Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney Work Product Permit 1221 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries date; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I_ modeling 1222 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1223 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1224 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1225 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1226 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

-__modeling 1227 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product nmodeling 1228 Notes 2/9/2006 Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_modeling 1229 eMail With Attachment Brian Hanson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1230 Notes 5-Nov Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product with ANR regarding NPDES 1231 Letter 3/7/2005 Lynn DeWald Brian Kooiker Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1232 Letter 7/6/2005 Ken Cox Brian Koolker Eric Palmer; Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product Carol Carpenter; with ANR regarding NPDES Gabe Gries; Melissa Grader 1233 eMall 11/17/2005 Brian Hanson Mark Mattson Tim Brush; Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney Work Product Jeanine Permit; Correspondence Grachuck relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries

,_______data 1234 Memo undated Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product with ANR regarding NPDES Page 75 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type Of No. Document Date AuthorlSender "Recilent CC Subject Privileaed Asserted 1235 Memo undated Correspondence relating to Attorney Work. Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1236 eMail 11/17/2005 Tim Brush Mark Mattson Jeanine Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Grachuck; Brian strategy for communications Hanson with ANR regarding NPDES 1237 Map 4-Jan Fisheries data; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration .

1238 Table 7/25/2004 Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work ProdUct 1239 Draft Letter 2/22/2005 Lynn DeWald Carol Carpenter; Brian Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product Kooiker with ANR regarding NPDES 1240 Table undated Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1241 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1242 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1243 Draft Letter 312/2005 Lynn DeWald Carol Carpenter, Brian Strategy for communications Attorney Work Product Koolker with ANR regarding NPDES 1244 Notes 3/4/2005 Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1245 Notes 3/4/2005 Research regarding fisheries AttomeyWork Product 1246 Article 3/4/2005 Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1247 Article 3/4/2005 Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1248 Article 3/4/2005 Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1249 Article 3/412005 Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1250 Article undated Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1251 eMail 1/20/2005 Mark Mattson Alan Palmer Rick Simmons Elise Zoli Communication regarding Attorney Work Product fisheries issues 1252 Article undated Research regarding fisheries Attorney Work Product 1253 eMail 3/7/2005 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Research regarding fisheries Attomey Work Product Barbara Ripley, Chuck Barlow 1254 Letter 1/28/2005 Ken Cox Lynn DeWald Gabe Gries; Redaction for work product Attorney Work Product Melissa Grader, notes regarding strategy for Carol Carpenter communications with ANR on

_ NPDES Permit_

Page 76 - LIBA/1739576.2.XLS

C, 0 0 Type of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recpolnt CC Sublect Privilsoed Asserted 1255 eMail 2/8/2005 Bev Berberich Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications

__with ANR regarding NPDES 1256 eMail 2/15/2005 Lynn DeWald Chuck Barlow; George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas; Samuel Wender; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbary RIpley;,.Lynn

__ DeWald 1257 eMail 2/11/2005 Mark Mattson George Thomas; Correspondence relating to Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck Barlow. strategy for communications Product Elizabeth Mason with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 1258 eMail 2/11/2005 AG Mark Mattson Jeanine Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Grachuck 1259 Draft Memo 2/114/05-2/15/05 ' Versar Report Attorney Work Product 1260 Draft Memo 2/11/2005 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney Work Product Report 1261. Draft Report 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1262 Graph 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product" 1263 Graph 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1264 Graph _2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1265 Graph 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1266 Graph . _ 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1267 Graph 2/1512005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1268 Graph 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson _Hydrotharmal modeling Attorney Work Product 1269 Graph 2115/2005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomey Work Product 1270 Graph 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1271 Graph 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1272 Table 2/15/2005 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1273 Notes undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attomrey Work Product 1274 Table undated *_Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1275 eMail 4/30/2004 AG Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1276 Chart 413012004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1277 Chart Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1278 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1279 eMall 4/14/2004 Paul Lindsay Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1280 Notes undated Fisheries data Attomey Work Product

.1281 Notes undated 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1282. Map undated Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1283 Draft Memo 4/16/2004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1284 Chart undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 12,85 .hart undated Fisheries data Attomey Work Product

.1286 Chars undated Attorney Work Product 1287 Draft Memo undated Fisheries data Attomey Work Product Page 77 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

I, 0 0 No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciolent CC Subea Prlvileled Asserted 1288 Draft Memo undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1289 Table undated , Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1290 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1291 Draft Memo 312512004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1292 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1293 EMail 3/19/2004 Mark Hutchings Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1294 Notes undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1295 Charts undated __Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1296 eMail 3/1612004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1297 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1298 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1299 Chart 3117/2004 Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1300 Chart 3/17/2004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1301 Chart 3/18/2004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1302 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1303 Notes 2/13/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) DemonStration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling;

____Fisheries data 1304 Draft Memo 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1305 Tables 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1306 Chart undated Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1307 Table undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1308 Table 2/6/2004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1309 Table Undated "_Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1310 Notes 3/9/2004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1311 Data set undated Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1312 Table 3/1/2004 Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1313 Map with Annotations undated Mark Mattson " _Fisheries data Attorney Work Product

.1314 Map undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attome}, Work Product 1315 Notes 11/3/2004 Mark Mattson .... _ Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1316 Table undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attomey Work Product 1317 SAS Output 10/3/2003 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1318 rable undated Mark Mattson _ Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1319 Table 10/3/2003 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1320 -Table undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1321 Table 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1322 Notes Feb-04 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

,___Fisheries data 1323 Table undated IMark Mattson I IFisheries data Attorney Work Product 1324 Letter 2/17/2004 Mark Mattson CH 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I__________ I_______

I__________ I_____ Fisheries I_ data __________________

Page 78 LIBAt1739576_2.XLS

C © 0 Tyeof No. Document Date Author/Sender Recipient Subiect PriviMeaed Asserted 1325 Memo 2/6/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1326 Table 2/2/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1327 Fax Cover Sheet 112912004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson _ Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1328 Table undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1329 Draft Letter 7112/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1330 Draft Letter 7/12/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1331 EMail 71/11/2005 Mark Mattson 3186a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1332 sMall 7/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1333 Draft Letter 7/11/2005 Mark Mattson _316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1334 j)raft Letter 7/11/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1335 Map undated Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1336 Memo 9/9/11997 D. Mason Mark Mattson; J. Bajek Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries

_ data 1337 Memo 9/9/1997 D. Mason Mark Mattson; J. Bajek Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1.338 Map undated Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1339 Notes 717/2005 Mark Mattson .Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_Fisheries data 1340 EMail 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchings 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1341 Table 7/5/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1342 Table 7/5/2005 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1343 Fax Cover Sheet 11/1/2004 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1344 Fax Cover Sheet 11/11/2004 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modelinig Attorney Work Product 1345 eMail 9/3/2004 Mark Mattson George Thomas Lynn DeWeld, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise Zoli; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Product

_____________Hutchings 1346 eMail 9/21/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchings 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1347 EMail 9/14/2004 Elise Zoll Lynn DeWald; Mark . Chuck Barlow 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Mattson 1348 eMail With Attachment Oct-04 Mark Mattson ElIse Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchings 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; George Thomas 1349 Fax Cover Sheet 7/19/2004 Ellse Zoli Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Product 1350 eMail 7113/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli; Richard Masters 316(a) Demonstration AttomreyWork Product Lynn DeWald; 1351 eMall With Attachment 7/2/2004 Mark Mattson Barbary Ripley Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Elise Zoli Page 79 LIBA/1739576 2.XLS

© 0 0 TV08eof No. Document Date Author/Sender Reclplent CC Subject Privileged Asserted 1352 Fax Cover Sheet 71812004 ElIse Zoli Lynn DeWald; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Mattson; Richard Masters 1353 Draft Report undated Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product I_ Fisheries data 1354 Draft Report Mar-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1355 Table undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

_ _modeling 1356 Table undated Mark Mattson Attorney Work Product 1357 Notes 2/19/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I_ modeling 1358 Table undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I_ _modeling 1359 Table undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1360 Tables 2/19/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1361 Letter 3112/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I_ _ modeling 1362 Draft Report Feb-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1363 Draft Report Feb-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1364 Draft Report Jan-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1365 Draft Report Jan-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1366 Draft Report 4-Jan Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

___modeling 1367 Draft Report Jan-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1368 Draft Report Jan-04 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product 1369_DraftLetter_. _2/24/2004_ Mark Mattson__modeling 1369 Draft Letter 212412004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

,___modeling 1370 SAS Output 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1371 SAS Output 1/6/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothertnal Attorney Work Product

_ _ ___modeling 13 Notes undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1373 SAS Output 11/6/2004 MarkMattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1374 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product I I Fisheries data Page 80 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 TVoe Of RecloentCC Sublect Privleaed Asserted No Document Date Author/Sender 1375 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1376 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product 7SFisheries data 1377 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1378 SAS Output 118/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1379 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1380 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1381 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

_Fisheries data 1382 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product

____________________________ ________________ __________Fisheries data 1383 SAS Output 1/8/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1384 Notes undated Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1385 Draft Report 1/9/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling; Versar Report 1386 Letter with Notes undated Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1387 Notes undated Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1 FE Fax 7/26/2004 Eric McClellan Mark Mattson H-,drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1389 Draft Report 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1390 Notes undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

,__ _modeling 113911Memo 8/1/2004 Mark Mattson; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Hutchins modeling 1392 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1393 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1394 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication modeling 1395 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication

_ __modeling 1396 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication modeling 1397 Chart undated Fisheries data; Hydrotherlmal Attorney Work Product

___97___Chartundated modeling Page 81 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

(

0 0 No. Document Date AuthorfSender ,Reciilent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1398 Chart undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attomey-Client Communication modeling 1399 Chart undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I __modeling 14 0 0 Data undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1401 EEmail 12/8/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson Versar Report Attorney Work Product 1402 Email 12/8/2004 Elise Zoli Lynn :DeWald Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication 1403 Data undated Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 14 04 Data 7/29/2004 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1405 Email 9/13/2004 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson; Lynn Elizabeth Mason Versar Report Attorney Work Product DeWald; Chuck Badow; Barbara Ripley; Trm Brush 1406 Memo 7/24/2004 Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1407 Memo 811312004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1408 Memo 8/1312004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1409 Email 3/24/2004 Elizabeth Mason Elise Zoli Aladdine Joroff; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Suzanne Anna; strategy for communications Bridget Horron; with ANR regarding NPDES Annette DiMil]io 1410 Memo 3/19/2004 Elise Zoll Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1411 IMemo 3/24/20U4 E.lse Zoll Steve Bethay; Jacob Michael Kansler Correspondence relating to Attorney WorK Product Scheffer; Joseph Egan Michael strategy for communications Baldazzi; John with ANR regarding NPDES Fulton; Chuck Barlow; Victor Nutter 1412 Email 3/23/2004 Elise Zoll Brent Dorey; Chuck Jay Scheffer; Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; Dara Gray;, John Julie Hayward; Permit Fulton; James Knubel; Lynn DeWald; Jim O'Leary; Jim Steels; Michael Rogers; John Cordo; John Kelly; Mike Kanswer; John McCann; Ken Suzzane Arena; Thesbald; O.H. Story; Pat RF; JR; David Brown; Phillip Spiro; Vic Himefarb Nutter Page 82 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 "rwe of No. Document Date AuthorlSender "Recipent cc Sublect Privilegaed Asserted 1413 eMall 311812004 Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; TG 1414 eMail 2V12/2004 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli; Analysis relating to NPDES Attomey-Client Communication Mark Mattson; George Permit Thomas 1415 Memo 3/12/2004 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Permit Product 1416 eMall 3/1612004 Elise Zoli Lynn DeWald David McElwee; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication

  • Suzanne Arena 1417 Memo 3/12/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1418 eMail 3/15/2004 Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication 1419 eMail 3/11/2004 TG Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication

_ _ _ _Barbara Ripley 1420 eMail With Attachment 3/9/2004 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication

  • George Thomas; Suzanne Arena 1421 eMail 3/8/2004 TG Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Barbara Ripley, Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson Permit 1422 eMail 3/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Mark Elise Zoll Fisheries data; Attomey-Client Communication Mattson Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1423 eMail 3/2/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson; Barbara Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 1424 Draft Letter 4-Feb Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1425 Report 2/4/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1426 eMail With Attachment 2/29/2004 Elise Zoli Lynn DeWald; George Susanne Arena Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas; Barbara Ripley, strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES Analysis relating to NPDES permit; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1427 eMail With Attachment 3/22/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley modeling; 316(a)

George Thomas Demonstration Page 83 LIBA/1739576 2.XLS

C© 0 No. ocument Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1428 eMail With Attachment 3/24/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson; Elise Zoil; Analysis relating to NPDES Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; TG Permit; Correspondence Product relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1429 Memo 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1430 Report 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1.431 Memo 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1432 Report 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1433 Report 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1434 Report 3125/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1435 Report 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1436 Report 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1437 eMail 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Eiise Zoll; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin 1438 Memo 3/26/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli 3161(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1439 Report 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 1440 Report 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal

  • _ modeling 1441 eMail With Attachment 3/23/2004 Linda Paskiewicz Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regardingNPDES 1442 eMail 3/23/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson; Elise Zoll; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 1443 eMail 3/23/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication

__ _ Barbara Ripley 1444 eMail 3/18/2004 Lynn DeWald Barbara Ripley; Jay Thayer; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Product Craig Nichols; David with ANR regarding NPDES Rocchlo; Chris Rose; Robert Will; Brian

_Cosgrove 1445 eMail 2/13/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson; Barbara Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thomas George Permit; Correspondence relating to strategy for communIcations with ANR regarding NPDES Page 84 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

( --.

0 0 Type of No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1448 eMail 2/13/2004 Victoria Brown David McElwee; Brian Analysis relating to NPDES Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Cosgrove; David Rocchio; Permit; Correspondence Product Robert Will; Barbara Ripley; relating to strategy for George Thomas; Jay communications with ANR Thayer; Lynn DeWald; Elise regarding NPDES Zoll 1447 eMail with Attachments 2/13/2004 Lynn DeWald David McEiwee; Brian Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Cosgrove; David Rocchio; strategy for communications Product Robert Will; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES George Thomas; Jay Thayer; Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli 1448 eMall 2/12/2004 Mark Mattson Jeanine Grachuk Lynn DeWald; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll; Suzanne Arena 1449 eMail With Attachment 2/9/2004 Victoria Brown Barbara Ripley;, Lynn Gary Franklin Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; David McEiwee; strategy for communications Product David Rocchlo with ANR regarding NPDES 1450 eMail With Attachment 2/912004 Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product

__with ANR regarding NPDES 1451 eMall With Attachment 2/9/2004 Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson; Barbara Susanne Arena Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley, Elise Zoli strategy for communications

,____with ANR regarding NPDES 1452 eMail With Attachment 2/2/2400 Lynn DeWald David McElwee; Brian Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Cosgrove; David Rocchio; strategy for communications Product Robert Will; Barbara Ripley;, with ANR regarding NPDES George Thomas; Jay Thayer; Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli 1453 eMail With Attachment 2/2/2004 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Mark Versar Report. Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 1454 eMail 1/24/2004 Elise Zoll Lynn DeWald; Mark Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley Suzanne Arena Correspondence relating to Product strategy for communications

___with ANR regarding NPDES 1455 eMail 1/23/2004 Craig Nichols Barbara Ripley; Gary Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Franklin; Connie Wells; Don strategy for communications Leach; David McElwee; with ANR regarding NPDES Brian Cosgrove; Jay Thayer; Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Page 85 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date, Author/Sender Recient CC SubLect PrivileSed Asserted 1456 eMail 1/24/2004 Elise Zoli Lynn DeWald; Mark Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration; Attomey-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley Suzanne Arena Correspondence relating to Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1457 eMail With Attachment 1/2912004 Lynn DeWald Barbara Ripley;, Craig Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Nichols; Connie Wells; strategy for communications Chris Rose; Robert Will; with ANR regarding NPDES Paul Undsay; David McElwee; George Thomas; Brian Cosgrove; Jay Thayer Lynn DeWald 1458 eMail With Attachments 1/29/2004 Linda Paskiewlcz Barbara Ripley, C.Nichols; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David Ricchi0; Lynn strategy for communications DeWald; David Rocchio; with ANR regarding NPDES Robert Wills; Elise Zoll; J.

Cosgrove, J. Thayer, C.

Wells; D. Leach.

1459 eMall 2/28/2004 Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Analysis relating to NPDES Product Permit; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; Versar Report 1460 Barbara Ripley; Gary Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Franklin; Craig Nichols; strategy for communications Chris Rose; Connie Wells; with ANR regarding NPDES Don Leach; David McEIwee; Lynn DeWald; Brian Cosgrove; Greg Thomas; Elise Zoll; David Rocchlo 1461 eMall 1/20/2004 Elise Zoli Barbara Ripley, Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Suzanne Arena Analysis relating to NPDES Product Permit; Fisheries data; Hydrotherrnal modeling 1462 eMall 1/14/2004 Jeanine Grachuk Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise Zoli; Suzann Product Arena Page 86 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 Type o No. Document Date AuthorlSender Rechilent 92 Sublect Privileged Asserted 1463 eMail 111412004 Mark Mattson Jeanine Grachuk Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Elise Zoli; Product

, . ~Suzanne Arena, ,

1464 eMail 1113/2004 Jeanine Grachuk Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attomey-Client Communication; Attonmey Work Product 1465 eMail With Attachment 1/12/2004 Barbara Ripley Elise Zoll; Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1466 eMail With Attachment 1/12/2004 Barbara Ripley Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1467 eMail With Attachment 1/12/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins 1468 eMail With Attachments 1/12/2004 Lynn DeWald George Thomas; Jay 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thayer; Dave McElwee; Product Connie Wells; Craig Nichols; Victoria Brown; Elise Zoli, Barbara Ripley; Samuel Wender; Mike Disilets; David Rocchio 1469. eMail 1/25/2005 Craig Swanson Lynn DeWald Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication 1470 eMall 11/15/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomey-Client Communication 1471 eMail 10/30/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomey,-Client Communication

.1472 eMail 8/3/2004. Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attomn Work Product 1473 eMail 8/5/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1474 eMail 4/6/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1475 eMall 4/6/2004 Cral Swanson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1476 eMail 4/14/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1477 eMall 4/14/2004 Craig Swanson Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1478 eMall 3/2412004 Craig Swanson Paul Hall " Versar Report Attorney Work Product 1479 eMail 3/24/2004 Craig Swanson Sankar Subbayya Hydrothemral modeling Attorney Work Product 1480 3125/2004 Cralg Swanson Paul Hall Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product

,14*81 __ 312612004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson _Hydrothermal modeling Attor-nee,,Work Product 1482 1/28/2004 Craig Swanson Paul Hall Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1483 1/12/2004 Paul Hall Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1484 1/1212004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins 14851 1/12/2004 Paul Hall Craig Swanson ,_ 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1486 1/14/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Craig 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product

_ _ _ _ _ Swanson _

487 .1/2?/2004 Mark Matts9n Paul Hall Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1488 112712004 Mark Mattson Paul Hall Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 87 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

0 0 No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recleet CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1489 1128/2004 Paul Hall Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1490 112812004 Paul Hall Craig Swanson ,_ Hy7drothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1491 2/4/2004 Paul Hall Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1492 211712004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_Fisheries data 1493 312/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 1494 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson LynnDeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 1495 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 1496 3/5/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

__ Hydrothermal modeling 1497 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Craig Swanson; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product George Thomas; Mark Hutchins; Elise Zoli; Barbary Ripley 1498 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1499 . 3/11/2004 Mark Mattson Cral Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1500 eMail 3/1512004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attomrey Work Product 1501 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1502 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Crail Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1503 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I modeling "

1504 eMail 3/25/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 1505 eMail _3/3112004 Mark Mattson Crail Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1506 eMail _4/5/2004 Mark Mattson Crail Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1507 :eMail 4/6/2004 Mark Mattson Crail Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1508 email 4/8/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1509 eMail 4/13/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 151e0 Mail 4/14/2004 Sankar Subbayya Craig Swanson Fisheries data 6ttomey Work Product 1511 eMail 4/14/2004 Sankar Subbayya Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1512 eMail 71/20/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Hutchins Fisheries data 1513 eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley; Elizabeth Mason; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication George Thomas; Lynn Craig Swanson; DeWald Mark Hutchins Page 88 LIBA/1739576_2.XLS

.-I Tyne of No. Document Date AuthorlSender Recplen CC Subect Privlleaed Asserted 1514 eMail 7/23/2004 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson; Barbara Elizabeth Mason; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; George Thomas; Craig Swanson; Lynn DOWald Mark Hutchins 1515 eMail 7/2412004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Elizabeth Mason; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication George Thomas; Lynn Craig Swanson; DeWald Mark Hutchins 1516 eMail 7/2912004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication modeling 1517 eMail 8/3/2004 Mark Mattson Sankar Subbayya Craig Swanson; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication

___5_______a______ /3_/2004___ Mark_ ts aS oPaul Lindsay 1518 email 8/32004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication 1,519 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication 1520 eMail 815/2004 Sankar Subbayya Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 1521 eMall 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbeyya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 1522 eMall 8/5/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attorney,-Client Communication 1523 eMail 8/5/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson Craig Swanson Fisheries data Attomey-Client Communication 1524 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Paul Lindsay 1525 Pleading 5/1/2006 Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product notes 1526 Fax 4/27/2004 Elizabeth Mason Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1527 eMail 4/27/2004 Elizabeth Mason Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1528 Draft Report 4/271/2004 Elizabeth Mason Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 1529 Draft Report 412712004 Elizabeth Mason Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1530 eMail 4/19/2004 Elise Zoli Mark Mattson; Barbara Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Product modeling .

1531 eMail 4/1912004 Elise Zoll Barbara Ripley; Lynn Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication DeWald; Mark Mattson 1532 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley .

1533 eMail 4/17/2004 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product I IA Mark Mattson ._.__ __4_ ,

1534 eMail 4/18/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley ,_ ,_*_ _

1535 lotes undated Elise Zoli - _ _ _316,(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1536 Draft Letter 5/12/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1537 Report Apr-04 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product 1H ydrothermalrrodeling 1538 Screenshot undated 1316(a) Demonstration Attomey Work Product 1539 Draft Report undated I Fisheries data lAttorney Work Product Page89 LIBA/173957682.XLS

Type No. Document Date Author/Sender Reciplent CC Sublect Privileged Asserted 1540 Draft Report undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1541 Draft Report undated Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1542 Draft Report 5/12/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1543 Draft Report Apr-04 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson "_,_316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1544 Screenshot 5/10/2004 Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1545 eMail 4/2912004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Susanne Arena; Julie Hayward 1546 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1547 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Lynn DeWald; Elizabeth Mason 316(a) Demonstration;. Attorney Work Product I _ Barbara Ripley Fisheries data 1548 eMail 4/21/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Ripley; Richard Master 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product

___Lynn DeWald 1549 eMail 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson Julie Hayward Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli 1550 eMail 4128/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoll; Barbara Rlpley; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald 1551 eMail 4/29/2004 Julie Hayward Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; Lynn DeWald; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product I Suzanne Arena Samuel Wender 1552 eMail 4/30/2004 Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley: Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Lynn DeWald; Richard Master 1553 eMail 5/11/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley; Lynn Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product DeWald; Richard Master; Elise Zoll 1554 eMail 4/29/2004 Mark Mattson Barbara Ripley, Elise Zoll 316(a) Demonstratlon Attomey-Client Communication 1555 Discovery Request 12/12/2003 Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product notes 1556 Draft Comments 12/5/2005 Chuck Barlow _316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 1557 Data undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1558 Chart 12/5/2004 Mark Hutchilngs Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1559 eMail 4/6/2005 Elise Zoll Kevin Pechulls Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1560 eMail 3/10/2005 David McElwee Elise Zoli Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications 1561_Notes_ 5/1_2006 _ ChuckBaow _with ANR regarding NPDES 1561 Notes 5/1/2006 Chuck Barlow Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product notes 1562 Notes 12/10/2003 Chuck Barlow Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product

___________ ______________ ___________product notes _________________

Page 900 LIBA/1739576.2.XLS

No. Document Date Auth rSend r Reclplen CC Sublect PrivilegedAsserted 1563 eMail 4/26/2006 Lynn DeWald James Callaghan, James 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Rogers. Bill Pittrnan, Ed Harms. Samuel Wender, William Maguire, George Wlerzbowski, Norman Rademacher, Alan Robert Shaw 1564 eMall 11/10/2006 Ed Harms Tom Marstaller Ken Oliver, Bill Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Pittman, Samuel strategy for communications Wender with ANR regarding NPDES 1565 Notes undated Mark Mattson Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product notes 1566 Draft Letter 6/30/2006 Kelly Meadows Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 1567 eMail 2/13/2006 Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1568 Report undated Mark Hutchings Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1569 Notes 5/3/2006 Chuck Barlow Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product

_product notes 1570 Memo 10/30/2004 Barbara Ripley Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product notes 1571 Notes undated Chuck Barlow Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product product notes 1572 Letter with Notes 11/30/2005 Chuck Barlow Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product

,,,_p product notes 1573 Memo 8/30/2003 Mark Mattson _ Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1574 Report 219/2006 Mark Mattson _ _ Hydrothermal modeling Attoney Work Product 1575 Report 2/9/2006 Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 1576 Report Aug-04 Mark Mattson Hydrothernial modeling Attorney Work Product 1577 Notes 6/7/2004 Carol Carpenter Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 1578 Notes 6/2/2003 Mark Mattson Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product

_ _ _ _product notes ,_,_ _

1579 Notes 1/28/2005 Lynn DeWald Redaction for attorney work Attorney Work Product I product notes I Page 91 LIBA11739576_2.XLS

0 Privileae Loa For Documents Throuqh January 9. 2004

.m I m, , t1116/2004 This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with State of Vermornt .Public Service Board proceeding No. 6812.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date/Time Author/Sender Recipients Subject Privilege Asserted Document "__,

1 Various Drafts Various Various N/A Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

2 Communications Various N/A N/A Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, related to the 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, discovery report prepared in anticipation of litigation, requests in the and at the direction/request of CPG proceeding counsel.

3 Transmittal Various N/A N/A Transmittal in support Party/representative work product, Correspondance of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, demonstration report and at the direction/request of counsel some of which are attorney/client communication.

4 E-mail 1/09/04 M. Mattson L. DeWald Strategy in support of Attomey-client communication, 5:46 p.m. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

5 E-mail 1/07/04 M. Mattson L. DeWald, E. Zoli, B. Strategy in support of Attomey-client communication, 5:22 p.m. Ripley, J. Griffin, J. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, Grachuk report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel. tTI

(T 10 6 E-mail 1/07/04 E. Zoli L. DeWald, B. Ripley, Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, 8:34 a.m. S. Arena 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of

__counsel.

7 E-mail 1/06/04 B. Ripley L. DeWald, E. Zoli, S. Strategy in support of Attomey-client communication, 1:13 p.m. Arena 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

8 E-mail 1/02/04 L. DeWald M. Mattson, E. Zoli, Strategy in support of Attomey-client communication, 1:14 p.m. B. Ripley 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

9 E-mail 12/29/03 L. DeWald E. Zoli, Strategy in support of Attomey-client communication, 10:38 a.m. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of

_ _ _ counsel.

10 E-mail 12/29/03 L. DeWald E. Zoli Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, 8:52 a.m. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

-Th Privilege Log For Documents Throuqh December 26, 2003

____________________12/30/2003 This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with State of Vermont Public Service Board proceeding No. 6812.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. TyPe of Date/Time Author/Sender Recipients Subject Privilege Asserted Document 1 Communications Various N/A N/A Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, related to the 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, discovery report prepared in anticipation of litigation, requests in the and at the direction/request of CPG proceeding counsel.

2 Transmittal Various N/A N/A Transmittal in support Party/representative work product, Correspondance of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, demonstration report and at the direction/request of counsel some of which are attorney/client communication.

3 E-mail 12/22/03 L. DeWald B. Ripley Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, 9:23 a.m. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

4 E-mail 12/16/03 L. DeWald E. Zoli Strategy in support of Attorney-client communication, 8:29 a.m. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of

_counsel.

5 E-mail 12/15/03 L. DeWald M. Mattson, B. Ripley Strategy In support of Attorney-client communication, 9:28 a.m. 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Mr X~

0 0 Privileqe Loa For Documents Dated Pre July 1, 2003

________________9/28/2003 This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with State of Vermont Public Service Board proceeding No. 6812. 1 ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tyne of Date/Time Author/Sender Recipients Subject Privilege Asserted Document Party/representative work product, Data and strategy in prepared in anticipation of litigation, July 2002 - support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of I Various Drafts 4/29/03 Various Various demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Data and strategy in prepared in anticipation of litigation, Internal E-mail, 11/01/02 - support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 2 ASA, Inc. 7/30/03 Various Various demonstration report counsel.

Data, strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, Internal E-mail, 11/6/02 - of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 3 Normandeau 5/29/03 Various Various demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Checklists for Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, Responding to 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 4 Versar Comments 4/4/2003 N/A N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 5 Power Point N/A N/A N/A report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work. product, C. Swanson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 6/24/03 Hutchins Consulting, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 6 E-mail 11:59 a.m. M. Mattson P. Harmon -demonstration report counsel.

D Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 6/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 7 E-mail 10:09 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, C. Swanson, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/28/03 Hutchins Consulting, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 8 E-mail 3:34 p.m. M. Mattson P. Harmon report counsel.

Party/representative work product, C. Swanson, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/21/03 Hutchins Consulting, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 9 E-mail 3:00 p.m. M. Mattson P. Harmon report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/15/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 10 E-mail 10:37 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, C. Swanson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/14/03 Hutchins Consulting, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 11 E-mail 9:01 a.m. M. Mattson P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, P. party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/12/03 Consulting, E. Zoli, S. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 12 E-mail 12:26 p.m. L. DeWald Ripley, J. Hayward report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, P. Harmon, C. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/12/03 Swanson,. Hutchins of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 13 E-mail 9:44 a.m. L. DeWald Consulting demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/9/03 E. Zoli, B. Ripley, J. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 14 E-mail 5:19 p.m. L. DeWald Hayward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

0 q L. DeWald, B. Ripley, Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, C. party/representative work product, Swanson, M. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 511103 5:33 Hutchins, S. Arena, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 15 E-mail p.m. E. Zoli C. Wells report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/1/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 16 E-mail 4:38 p.m. L. DeWald E. Zoli, B. Ripley demonstration report counsel.

P. Harmon, Hutchins Party/representative work product, Consulting, C. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/1/03 Swanson, L. DeWald, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 17 E-mail 10:13 a.m. M. Mattson G. Thomas report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Hutchins Consulting, Communication and party/representative work product, C. Swanson, B. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/11/03 Ripley, M. Mattson, of 316(a). and at the direction/request of 18 E-mail 10:13 a.m. L. DeWald P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/11/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 19 E-mail 9:59 a.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, P. Attorney-client communication, Harmon, Hutchins Communication and party/representative work product, Consulting, C. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 5/1/03 Swanson, E. Zoli, J. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 20 E-mail 8:26 a.m. L. DeWald Hayward, B. Ripley demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/30/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 21 E-mail 8:00 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/30/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 22 E-mail 18:00 a.m. C. Swanson H. Kim report ' counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, Handwritten 4/30/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 23 Notes 12:00 AM N/A N/A report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 G. Thomas, E. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 24 E-mail 6:53 p.m. M. Mattson Shuman, L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, Hutchins Attorney-client communication, Consulting, C. Communication and party/representative work product, Swanson, E. Zoli, P. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 harmon, J. hayward, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 25 E-ma4:31 p.m. L. DeWald S. Arena demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal In support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 26 E-mail 4:29 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, L. Attorney-client communication, DeWald, B. Ripley, P. party/representative work product,.

Harmon, Hutchins Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 Consulting, C. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 27 E-mail 4:09 p.m. E. Zoli Swanson, S. Arena report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, E. Zoli, C. Swanson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 Hutchins Consulting, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 28 E-mail 4:07 p.m. M. Mattson B. Ripley, J. Hayward demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 29 E-mail 1:51 p.m. M. Mattson L. DeWald, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

2)\

Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, C. Swanson, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/29/03 Hutchins Consulting, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 30 E-mail 12:11 p.m. S. Arena E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/28/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 31 E-mail 3:01 p.m. P. Scott C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, E. Zoli, P. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/28/03 Harmon, C. Swanson, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 32 E-mail 2:53 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Arena, B. Ripley report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, C. party/representative work product, Swanson, P. Harmon, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/28/03 Hutchins Consulting, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 33 E-mail 2:53 p.m. L. DeWald B. Ripley report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, L. DeWald, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, C. Swanson, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/28/03 E. Zoli, P. Harmon, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 34 E-mail 2:32 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Arena, B. Ripley, report counsel.

M. Mattson, C. Attomey-client communication, Swanson, E. Zoli, P. party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins Communication in prepared In anticipation of litigation, 4/28103 Consulting, S. Arena, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 35 E-mail 1:27 p.m. L. DeWald B. Ripley demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, C. Attorney-client communication, Swanson, E. Zoli, P. party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/28/03 Consulting, S. Arena, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 36 E-mail 1:17 p.m. _L. DeWald B. Ripley report counsel.

0 Attorney-client communication, E. Zoli, L. DeWald, Strategy and party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/28/03 P. Harmon, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 37 E-mail 11:28 a.m. M. Mattson Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/26/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 38 E-mail 4:29 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, L. DeWald, E. Zoli, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/25/03 C. Swanson, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 39 E-mail 12:26 p.m. M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/25/03 support of 316(a) 40 and at the direction/request of E-mail 10:56 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/25/03 of 316(a) . and at the direction/request of 41 E-mail 10:29 a.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, C. Swanson, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, E. Zoli, B. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/25/03 Ripley, M. Hutchins, 316(a) demonstration 42 and at the direction/request of E-mail 9:52 a.m. L. DeWald P. Harmon report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/24/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 43 E-mail 9:47 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/23/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 44 E-mail 6:32 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

D Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/23/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 45 E-mail 5:38 p.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, G. Thomas, L. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/23/03 DeWald, E. Shuman, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 46 E-mail 11:53 a.m. M. Mattson C. Nichols demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/21/03 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 47 E-mail 6:02 p.m. M. Mattson Hutchins, L. DeWald report counsel, Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/21/03 M. Mattson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 48 E-mail 5:01 p.m. C. Swanson Hutchins report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, E. Zoli, M. Mattson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/21/03 B. Ripley, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 49 E-mail 4:01 p.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/21/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 50 E-mail 2:34 p.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/21/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 51 E-mail 1:20 p.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/21/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 52 E-mall 11:12 a.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

(

0 Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared inanticipation of litigation, 4/18/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 53 E-mail 5:32 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/18/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 54 E-mail 4:51 p.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 55 E-mail 4:20 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/18/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 56 E-mail 2:21 p.m. M. Hutchins P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/18/03 316(a) demonstration land at the direction/request of 57 E-mail 1:03 p.m. P. Harmon M. Hutchins report counsel.

B. Ripley, E. Zoli, C. Attomey-client communication, Wells, M. mattson, P. Communication and party/representative work product, Harmon, M. Hutchins, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 C. Swanson, G. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 58 E-mail 2:07 p.m. L. DeWald Thomas, S. Wender demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 59 E-mail 1:19 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 316(a) demonstration 60 and at the direction/request of E-mail 12:09 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report Icounsel.

\

0 0 Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 61 E-mail 11:03 a.m. M. Hutchins P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 62 E-mail 10:08 a.m. M. Mattson G. Thomas report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 63 E-mail 10:04 a.m. M. Mattson G. Thomas demonstration report counsel.

I Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared In anticipation of litigation, 4/17/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 64 E-mail 9.41 a.m. P. Harmon M. Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 65 E-mail 3:41 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/16/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 66 E-mail 1:31 p.m. C. Swanson H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/15/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 67 E-mail 4:10 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/15/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 68 E-mail 10:19 a.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

f 0

Attorney-client communication, B. Ripley, E. Zoli, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, M. Hutchins, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/15/03 C. Swanson, G. 316(a) demonstration 69 E-mail and at the direction/request of 10:06 a.m. L. DeWald Thomas report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald, E. Zoli, party/representative work product, M. Mattson, C. Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/15/03 Swanson, G. support of 316(a) 70 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:35 a.m. S. Arena Thomas, B, Ripley demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, S. Arena, E. Zoli, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, C. Swanson, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/15/03 M. Hutchins, G. support of 316(a) 71 and at the direction/request of E-mail 7:58 a.m. L. DeWald Thomas, B. Ripley demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/15/03 support of 316(a) 72 and at the direction/request of E-mail 7:44 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report. counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 of 316(a) 73 and at the direction/request of E-mail 5:54 p.m. 1H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 support of 316(a) 74 E-mail and at the direction/request of 5:19 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 316(a) demonstration 75 and at the direction/request of E-mail 4:41 p.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 316(a) demonstration 76 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:31 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14103 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 77 E-mail 12:58 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal In support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 of 31.6(a) and at the direction/request of 78 E-mail 12:10 p.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, B. Ripley, E. Zoli, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, P. Harmon, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 79 E-mail 12:00 p.m. L. DeWald Hutchins, S. Arena report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/14/03 316(a) demonstration and at thedirection/request of 80 E-mail 9:00 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 81 E-mail 1:19 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication In prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/13/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 82 lE-mail 1:12 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 83 E-mail 1:12 p.m. C. Swanson H. Kim report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/12/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 84 E-mail 10:32 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

0 0 L. DeWald, M.

Mattson, P. Harmon, Attorney-client communication, C. Swanson, E. Zoli, party/representativework product, B. Ripley, G; Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/11/03 Thomas, V. Brown, support of 316(a) and at the directionirequest of 85 E-mail 4:11 p.m. M. Hutchins C. Wells, demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/11/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 86 E-mail 12:58 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

M. Mattson, P.

Harmon, Hutchins Attorney-client communication, Consulting, E. Zoli, C. party/representative work product, Swanson, B. Ripley, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/11/03 G. Thomas, V. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 87 E-mail 9:24 a.m. L. DeWald Brown, C. Wells report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/10/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 88 E-mail 5:20 p.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, E. Zoli, Hutchins Consulting, P. Harmon, C. Attomey-client communication, Swanson, J. party/representative work product, Hayward, S. Wender, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/10/03 C. Wells, B. Ripley, 316(a) demonstration and at.the direction/request of 89 E-mail 3:41 p.m. L. DeWald V. Brown report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, Hutchins Communication and party/representative work product, Consulting, C. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/9/03 4:06 Swanson, E. Zoli, P. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 90 E-mail p.m. L. DeWald Harmon, B, Ripley demonstration report counsel,

(F...,-*

0 'I Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 419/03 4:04 M. Mattson, C. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 91 E-mail p.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/9/03 3:36 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 92 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

M. Mattson, P. Attorney-client communication, Harmon, Hutchins party/representative work product, Consulting, C. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/9/03 2:36 Swanson, E. Zoli, B. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 93 E-mail p.m. L. DeWald Ripley report counsel.

Party/representative work product, E. Shuman, L. Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, DeWald, G. Thomas, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 94 Letter 4/9/2003 M. Mattson S. Wender demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 95 E-mail 11:02 a.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

L. DeWald, B. Ripley, Attorney-client communication, P. Harmon, M. party/representative work product, Mattson, C. Swanson, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 9:50 Hutchins Consulting, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 96 E-mail a.m. S. Arena E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, L. DeWald, Hutchins Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 9:33 Consulting, B. Ripley, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 97 E-mail a.m. P. Harmon C. Swanson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 9:32 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 98 E-mail a.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

C 0 0 Attorney-client communication, P. Harmon, Hutchins Communication and party/representative work product, Consulting, C. transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 9:24 Swanson, E. Zoli, B. of 316(a) 99 E-mail and at the direction/request of a.m. L. DeWald Ripley demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 support of 316(a) 100 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:37 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

L. DeWald, E. Zoli, P. Attorney-client communication, Harmon, Hutchins party/representative work product, Consulting, C. Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/8/03 Swanson, B. Ripley, support of 316(a) 101 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:36 a.m. M. Mattson G. Thomas demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/7/03 support of 316(a) 102 E-mail and at the direction/request of 11:49 p.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald, demonstration report counsel.

E. Zoli, M. Mattson, Attorney-client communication, P. Harmon, Hutchins party/representative work product, Consulting, C. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/7/03 7:06 Swanson, B. Ripley, 316(a) demonstration 103 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. L. DeWald G. Thomas report counsel.

Party/representative work product, M. Hutchins, P. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/7/03 Harmon, L. DeWald, 316(a) demonstration 104 E-mail and at the direction/request of 10:23 a.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, P. Kinner report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/7/03 8:56 support of 316(a) 105 E-mail and at the direction/request of a.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

( 0 J. Hayward, S.

Wendr, E. Zoll, B. Attorney-client communication, Ripley, C. Wells, M. Communication and party/representative work product, Mattson, C. Swanson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 4/7/03 8:02 G. Thomas, Hutchins of 316(a) 106 and at the direction/request of E-mail a.m. L. DeWald Consulting demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, Letter of S. Wender, L. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 107 Transmittal 4/1/2003 M. Mattson DeWald, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, S. Wender, L. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 108 Letter 4/1/2003 M. Mattson DeWald, C. Swanson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, S. Wender, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 109 Letter 3/31/2003 M. Mattson DeWald, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/31/03 of 316(a) 110 E-mail and at the direction/request of 12:46 p.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

L. DeWald, P.

Harmon, Hutchins Attorney-client communication, Consulting, C. Communication and party/representative work product, Swanson, B. Ripley, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/31/03 J. Hayward, G. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 111 E-mail 11:25 a.m. M. Mattson Thomas demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, P.

Harmon, Hutchins Attorney-client communication, Consulting, C. party/representative work product, Swanson, B. Ripley, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/31/03 J. Hayward, G. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 112 E-mail 11:01 a.m. L. DeWald Thomas Ireport counsel.

C' 0 Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/28103 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 113 E-mail 4:07 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/28/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 114 E-mail 8:04 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/27/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 115 E-mail 4:50 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 3/27103 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 116 E-mail 4:07 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/27/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 117 E-mail 4:01 p.m. C. Swanson H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, P. Attomey-client communication, Harmon, C. Swanson, Communication and party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/27/03 E. Zoli, B. Ripley, J. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 118 E-mail 3:24 p.m. L. DeWald Hayward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 119 Memorandum 3/27/2003 C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 120 Memorandum 3/27/2003 C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

K> K>

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/26/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 121 E-mail 4:53 p.m. P. Harmon M. Mattson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/25/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 122 E-mail 9:42 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, On-line search in prepared In anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 123 Google Search 3/25/2003 C. Swanson N/A demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/24/03 E. Shuman, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 124 E-mail 4:31 p.m. M. Mattson DeWald, G. Thomas Idemonstration report counsel, Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 125 E-mail 3:40 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, P. Party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 Consulting, C. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 126 E-mail 12:14 p.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel, Attorney-client communication, E. Zoli, M. Mattson, Communication and party/representative work product, P. Harmon, Hutchins transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 Consulting, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 127 E-mail 11:46 a.m. L. DeWald Swanson, J. Hayward demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, party/representative work product, M. Mattson, P. Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 Harmon, C. Swanson support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 128 E-mail 11:39 a.m. L. DeWald Hutchins Consulting demonstration report counsel.

0 Km Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 129 E-mail 8:47 a.m. C. Swanson iL. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald, E. Zoli, B. party/representative work product, Ripley, M. Mattson, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 P. Harmon, C. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 130 E-mail 8:36 a.m. S. Arena Swanson, E. Buzuvis demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/21/03 M. Mattson, P. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 131 E-mail 8:36 a.m. L. DeWald Harmon, C. Swanson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/19/03 G. Thomas, L. of 316(a) 132 E-mail and at the direction/request of 10:04 a.m. M. Mattson DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald, E. Zoli, B. party/representative work product, Ripley, M. Mattson, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/18/03 P. Harmon, C. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 133 E-mail 2:46 p.m. S. Arena Swanson, E. Buzuvis demonstration report counsel.

E. Zoli, B. Ripley, G. Attorney-client communication, Thomas, M. Mattson, party/representative work product, P. Harmon, C. Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/18/03 Swanson, C. Wells, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 134 E-mail 11:01 a.m. L. DeWald J. Hayward, S. Arena demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/14/03 C. Swanson, S. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 135 E-mail 2:41 p.m. M. Mattson Garganese demonstration report counsel.

0 ©>

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, Letter of of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 136 Transmittal 3/14/2003 M. Mattson M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, Letter of of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 137 Transmittal 3/14/2003 M. Mattson D. Yasi demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, Letter of of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 138 Transmittal 3/14/2003 M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared In anticipation of litigation, 3/13/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 139 E-mail 3:03 p.m. D. Yasi M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/12/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 140 E-mail 4:52 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/10/03 L. DeWald, P. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 141 E-mail 9:30 a.m. M. Mattson Harmon, C. Swanson, demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/8/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 142 E-mail 11:33 a.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/8/03 M. Mattson, P. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 143 E-mail 10:35 a.m. L. DeWald Harmon, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/7/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 144 E-mail 10:13 a.m. R. Heun T. Opishinski demonstration report counsel.

0 0 Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in4anticipation of litigation, 3/7/03 4:48 of 316(a) 145 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/7/03 4:48 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 146 E-mail p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, H. Kim report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, Handwritten 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 147 Notes 3/6/2003 N/A N/A report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/5/03 of 316(a) 148 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:23 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/5/03 316(a) demonstration 149 and at the direction/request of E-mail 10:50 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/4/03 4:48 M. Mattson, C. of 316(a) 150 and at the direction/request of E-mail p.m. H. Palaia Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/4/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 151 E-mail 4:18 p.m. M. Mattson H. Palaia demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, P.

Harmon, Hutchins Party/representative work product, Consulting, C. Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/4/03 2:22 Swanson, J. support of 316(a) 152 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. L. DeWald Hayward, T. Brush demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, P. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/4/03 Harmon, Hutchins of 316(a) 153 and at the direction/request of E-mail 12:45 p.m. L. DeWald Consulting demonstration report counsel.

K. 0 0 Communication and Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, P. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/4/03 Harmon, C. Swanson, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 154 E-mail 12:45 p.m. L. DeWald Hutchins Consulting demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/4/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 155 E-mail 11:12 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/reppresentative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 3/3/03 5:23 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 156 E-mail p.m. T. Opishinski T. Brush demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 157 Scope of Work Mar-03 Normandeau N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/19/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 158 E-mail 7:06 p.m. M. Hutchins D. Yasi, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/19/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 159 E-mail 9:33 a.m. M. Mattson G. Thomas, D. Yasi demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/18/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 160 E-mail 2:14 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

E. Zoli, C.Wells, P. Attorney-client communication, Harmon, L. DeWald, party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/18/03 C. Swanson, S. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 161 E-mail, 2:07 p.m. M. Mattson Arena -report counsel.

P. Harmon, L.

DeWald, C. Wells, B. Attorney-client communication, Ripley, M. Mattson, party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/18/03 C. Swanson, S. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 162 E-mail 2:00 p.m. E. Zoli Arena demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald, C. Wells, Communication and party/representative work product, B. Ripley, E. Zoli, M. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/18/03 Mattson, C. Swanson, of 316(a) 163 E-mail and at the direction/request of 1:49 p.m. P. Harmon S. Arena demonstration report counsel. i Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/18/03 of 316(a) 164 and at the direction/request of E-mail 1:39 p.m. B. Ripley C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 P. Harmon, M. of 316(a) 165 E-mail and at the direction/request of 9:34 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson demonstration report counsel.

P. Harmon, L.

DeWald, C. Wells, B. Attorney-client communication, Ripley, M. Mattson, party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 C. Swanson, S. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 166 E-mail 6:24 p.m. E. Zoli Arena demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 P. Harmon, M. of 316(a) 167 and at the direction/request of E-mail 6:07 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson demonstration report counsel.

0 M. Desilets, K.

Bronson, M. Balduzzi, J. Thayer, G.

Thomas, C. Nichols, Attorney-client communication, B. Ripley, E. Zoli, C. Strategy and party/representative work product, Wells, M. Mattson, P. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 Harmon, C. Swanson, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 168 E-mail 5:34 p.m. L. DeWald S. Wender demonstration report counsel.

P. Harmon, M.

Mattson, Hutchins Consulting, C. Attorney-client communication, Swanson, E. Zoli, C. party/representative work product, Wells, B. Ripley, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 Hutchins Consulting, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 169 E-mail 5:17 p.m. L. DeWald S. Arena report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 170 E-mail 3:21 p.m. P. Harmon L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

L. DeWald, P.

Harmon, M. Mattson, Hutchins Consulting, Attorney-client communication, C. Swanson, E. Zoli, party/representative work product, B. Ripley, R. Gerdus, Communication in prepared In anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 M. Desilets, S. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 171 E-mail 2:14 p.m. C. Wells Wender demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, P.Harmon, L. Strategy and party/representative work product, DeWald, C. transmittal In support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 Swanson, Hutchins of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 172 E-mail 11:27 a.m. M. Mattson Consulting demonstration report counsel.

ci 0 Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 L. DeWald, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 173 E-mail 11:17 a.m. M. Mattson Swanson demonstration report counsel.

L. DeWald, P.

Harmon, M. Mattson, Hutchins Consulting, Attorney-client communication, C. Swanson, E. Zoli, party/representative work product, C. Wells, R. Gerdus, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 M. Desilets, S. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 174 E-mail 10:47 a.m. B. Ripley Wender demonstration report counsel.

P. Harmon, M.

Mattson, Hutchins Consulting, C. Attorney-client communication, Swanson, E. Zoli, C. Strategy and party/representative work product, Wells, B. Ripley, R. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 Gerdus, M. Desilets, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 175 E-mail 9:27 a.m. L. DeWald S. Wender demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/17/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 176 E-mail 8:25 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 2115/03 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 177 E-mail 12:55 p.m. P. Harmon Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/14/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 178 E-mail 7:23 p.m. M. Mattson H. Kim, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/14/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 179 E-mail 3:32 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

{-.

10 q Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/14/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 180 E-mail 2:09 p.m. C. Swanson P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product,.

transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/14/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 181 E-mail 1:37 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/14/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 182 E-mail 10:19 a.m. P. Harmon C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 183 Memorandum 2/14/2003 M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) 184 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:16 p.m. L. DeWald Mattson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 185 E-mail 4:30 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy In support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 186 E-mail 4:30 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 L. DeWald, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 187 E-mail 3:19 p.m. C. Swanson Mattson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

/

0 0 Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 L. DeWald, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 188 E-mail 3:12 p.m. C. Swanson Mattson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 L. DeWald, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 189 E-mail 3:11 p.m. C. Swanson Mattson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Startegy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 L. DeWald, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 190 E-mail 3:09 p.m. C. Swanson Mattson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 L. DeWald, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 191 E-mail 3:09 p.m. C. Swanson Mattson, E. Zoli demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 192 E-mail 1:32 p.m. C. Swanson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 193 E-mail 1:32 p.m. C. Swanson H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/13/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 194 E-mail 10:42 a.m. P. Hall C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/11/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 195 E-mail 8:24 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report =counsel.

0 0 Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, P. party/representative work product, Harmon, L. DeWald, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2111103 B. Ripley, C. Wells, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 196 E-mail 7:06 p.m. E. Zoli C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/11/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 197 E-mail 6:13 p.m. M. Hutchins S.VWard report counsel.

M. Mattson, P. Strategy and Party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/11/03 Consulting, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 198 E-mail 1:54 p.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, P. party/representative work product, Harmon, L. DeWald, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/11/03 B. Ripley, C. Wells, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 199 E-mail 10:46 a.m. E. Zoli C. Swanson report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, E. Zoli, P. Harmon, L. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/11/03 DeWald, B. Ripley, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 200 E-mail 10:30 a.m M. Mattson. C. Wells, C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 2110/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 201 handwritten notes 2:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/10/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 202 E-mail 1:53 p.m. R. Heun L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/10/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 203 E-mail 5:41 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

(

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/10/03 316(a) demonstration 204 and at the direction/request of E-mail 4:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 2/9/03 2:18 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 205 handwritten notes p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/9/03 1:53 316(a) demonstration 206 and at the direction/request of E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/8/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 207 E-mail 7:34 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/8/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 208 E-mail 11:43 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/7/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 209 E-mail 6:10 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/7/03 M. Mattson, C. support of 316(a) 210 and at the direction/request of E-mail 7:23 a.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 211 E-mail 4:58 p.m. IM. Hutchins M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

©)

M. Mattson, P.

Harmon, Hutchins Attorney-client communication, Consulting, E. Zoli, C. party/representative work product, Swanson, C. Wells, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/03 B. Ripley, J. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 212 E-mail 3:40 p.m. L. DeWald Hayward, S. Wender report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 213 E-mail 10:01 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 214 E-mail 9:53 m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 215 E-mail 8:56 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 8:03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 216 E-mail p.m. S. Ward S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 217 E-mail 6:47 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 4:56 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 218 E-mail p.m. H. Kim C. Swanson report counsel.

Partyfrepresentative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 4:38 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 219 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson H. Kim report counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 220 E-mail 3:32 p.m. M. Mattson H. Kim report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 1:19 M. Mattson, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 221 E-mail p.m. H. Kim Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/5/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 222 E-mail 10:28 a.m. M. Hutchins P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/4/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 223 E-mail 12:59 p.m. M. Mattson G. Thomas demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 214/03 L. DeWald, R. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 224 E-mail 12:59 p.m. D. Yasi Pariseau report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/4/03 6:56 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 225 E-mail P.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/4/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 226 E-mail 10:38 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/4/03 3:47 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 227 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/4/03 2:48 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 228 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

(_

T ý 0

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 6:36 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 229 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 5:57 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 230 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, M. Mattson, P. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 5:15 Harmon, L. DeWald, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 231 E-mail p.m. E. Zoli S. Arena demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 5:12 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 232 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 5:06 M. Mattson, S. Arena of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 233 E-mail p.m. E. Zoli L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 3:01 of 316(a) and .at the direction/request of 234 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 2:58 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 235 E-mail p.m. P. Harmon M. Hutchins report. counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 of 316(a) and atthe direction/request of 236 E-mail 1:56 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

C 0 0 Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 237 E-mail 1:52 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 P. Harmon, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 238 E-mail 1:23 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 239 E-mail 12:44 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 240 E-mail 12:13 p.m. P. Hall R. Heun demonstration report counsel.

B. Ripley, E. Zoli, M.

Mattson, P. Harmon, Attomey-client communication, C. Swanson, C. party/representative work product, Wells, J. Hayward, S. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3103 Wender, V. Brown, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 241 E-mail 11:14 a.m. L. DeWald G. Franklin report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/3/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 242 E-mail 10:31 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson ;demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation,.

2/3/03 9:31 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 243 E-mail a.m. M. Hutchins Mattson demonstration report counsel.

C. Swanson, P. Communication and Party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/2/03 9:52 Consulting, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 244 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson DeWald, demonstration report counsel.

C' Strategy and Party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/2/03 6:13 L. DeWald, P. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 245 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson Harmon, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/2/03 6:13 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 246 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/2/03 4:19 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 247 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/2/03 L. DeWald, P. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 248 E-mail 3:46 p.m. M. Mattson Harmon, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 249 Memorandum 2/2/2003 M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 250 Memorandum 2/2/2003 M. Mattson M. Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/1/03 5:31 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 251 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/1/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 252 E-mail 2:58 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report . counsel.

0 0 Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, M. Mattson, P. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/1/03 Harmon, E. Zoli, C. 316(a) demonstration 253 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:09 a.m. L. DeWald Wells, C. Swanson report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 L. DeWald, P. 316(a) demonstration 254 and at the direction/request of E-mail 8:10 p.m. M. Mattson Harmon, E. Zoli report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 316(a) demonstration 255 E-mail and at the direction/request of 5:57 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 of 316(a) 256 E-mail and at the direction/request of 5:48 p.m. H. Kim M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared.in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 316(a) demonstration 257 and at the direction/request of E-mail 4:27 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 316(a) demonstration 258 and at the direction/request of E-mail 3:24 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson, H. Kim report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 of 316(a) 259 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:23 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 1/31/03 Hutchins Consulting, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 260 handwritten notes 3:22 p.m. L. DeWald S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 261 E-mail 3:12 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 262 E-mail 12:04 p.m. M. Mattson H. Kim, C. Swanson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/31/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 263 E-mail 7:43 a.m. R. Heun H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 264 E-mail 6:25 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 G. Thomas, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 265 E-mail 5:08 p.m. M. Mattson DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Strategy and party/representative work product, P. Harmon, Hutchins transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 Consulting, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 266 E-mail 5:01 p.m. M. Mattson Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 267 E-mail 4:12 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03* of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 268 E-mail 4:07 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 M. Mattson, C. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 269 E-mail 3:15 p.m. R. Heun Swanson report counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 316(a) demonstration 270 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:12 p.m., M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support-of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 M. Mattson, C. 316(a) demonstration 271 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:48 p.m. H. Kim Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 316(a) demonstration 272 and at the direction/request of E-mail 12:41 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, J. Hayward, P. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 Harmon, M. Mattson, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 273 E-mail 11:38 a.m. E. Zoli L. DeWald, S. Arena report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/30/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 274 E-mail 10:38 a.m. M. Hutchins M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/29/03 316(a) demonstration 275 and at the direction/request of E-mail 6:59 p.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/29/03 of 316(a) 276 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:12 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/29/03 M. Mattson, M. of 316(a).

277 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:08 p.m. S. Ward Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/29/03 316(a) demonstration 278 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:30 p.m. .C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/29/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 279 E-mail 5:20 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1(29/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 280 E-mail 9:20 a.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy In support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/29/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 281 E-mail 7:51 a.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald report counsel.

'Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 282 Memorandum* 1/29/2003 M. Mattson, R. Heun L. DeWald report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Draft data transmittal in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 283 Fax 1/29/2003 P. Harmon M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, Handwritten 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 284 Notes 1/29/2003 N/A N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product,.

Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/28/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 285 E-mail 11:30 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/28/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 286 E-mail 8:44 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 287 E-mail 7:15 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

0 ,1 ~

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 288 E-mail 1:20 p.m. R. Heun H. Kim report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 289 E-mail 1:20 p.m. H. Kim R. Heun report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 M. Mattson, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 290 E-mail 11:44 a.m. C. Swanson DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 M. Mattson, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 291 E-mall 11:44 a.m. C. Swanson DeWald -:demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 M. Mattson, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 292 E-mail 11:44 a.m. C. Swanson DeWald demonstration report counsel..

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of.litigation, 1/27/03 M. Mattson, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 293 E-mail 11:42 a.m. C. Swanson DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product,.

transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 M. Mattson, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 294 E-mail 11:42 a.m. C. Swanson DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 M. Mattson, L. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 295 E-mail 11:42 a.m. C. Swanson DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 296 E-mail 11:03 a.m. L. DeWald Mattson report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/27/03 M. Hutchins, C. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 297 E-mail 10:55 a.m. M. Mattson Swanson report counsel.

'Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/26/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 298 E-mail 12:38 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/26/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 299 E-mail 11:53 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/25/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 300 JE-mail 3:57 p.m . Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/25/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 301 E-mail 11:56 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/25/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 302 E-mail 11:27 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/24/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 303 E-mail 6:48 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/24/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 304 E-mail 6:32 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/23/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 305 E-mail _11:20 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

(

O, 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/23/03 316(a) demonstration 306 E-mail and at the direction/request of 11:02 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/23/03 316(a) demonstration 307 E-mail and at the direction/request of 10:58 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/23/03 316(a) demonstration 308 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:51 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/23/03 316(a) demonstration 309 and at the direction/request of E-mail 3:50 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative, work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/23/03 316(a) demonstration 310 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:51 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of :prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/22/03 316(a) demonstration 311 E-mail and at the direction/request of 7:13 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/22/03 316(a) demonstration 312 E-mail and at the direction/request of 5:08 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/22/03 316(a) demonstration 313 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:44 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/22/03 M. Mattson, C. 316(a) demonstration 314 E-mail and at the direction/request of 11:36 a.m. P. Hall Swanson report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/22/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 315 E-mail 11:24 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/21/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 316 !E-mail 10:17 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/21/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 317 E-mail 8:27 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/21/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 318 E-mail 5:27 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/21/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 319 E-mail 5:21 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/21/03 of 316(a): and at the direction/request of 320 E-mail 12:22 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/21/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 321 E-mail 12:17 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/20/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 322 E-mail 6:30 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/20/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 323 E-mail 5:31 p~m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/20/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 324 E-mail 4:54 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/20/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 325 E-mail 4:07 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/20/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 326 E-mail 3:55 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/20/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 327 E-mail 10:01 a.m. M. Mattson D. Yasi, E. O'Brien demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/19/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 328 E-mail 8:33 p.m. S. Ward M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/19/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 329 E-mail 6:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1119/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 330 E-mail 6:19 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/19/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 331 E-mail 5:34 p.m. M. Hutchins M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/19/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 332 E-mail 5:20 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

f

\

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 333 E-mail 10:31 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 334 E-mail 5:53 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 335 E-mail 5:09 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 336 E-mail 3:25 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 337 E-mail 3:06 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 338 E-mail 2:41 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 339 E-mail 2:26 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/18/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 340 E-mail 1:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared In anticipation of litigation, 1/17/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 341 E-mail 4:49 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

K-, 0 0 Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/17/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 342 E-mail 12:15 p.m. M. Mattson D. Yasi, E. O'Brien demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared In anticipation of litigation, 1/17/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 343 E-mail 11:35 a.m. M. Mattson D. Yasi, E. O'Brien report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 344 E-mail 7:05 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1116/03 H. Kim, C. Swanson, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 345 E-mail 5:16 p.m. M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 M. Mattson, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 346 E-mail 3:58 p.m. H. Kim Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 347 E-mail 3:50 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 348 E-mail 3:38 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 349 E-mail 3:28 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 350 E-Mail 3:22 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report -counsel.

cm 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration 351 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:14 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration 352 and at the direction/request of E-mail 3:09 p.m. M. Mattson H. Kim, C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/16/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 353 E-mail 3:02 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/15/03 of 316(a) 354 and at the direction/request of E-mail 5:57 p.m. M. Mattson H. Kim, demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/15/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 355 -E-mail 9:17 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/14/03 316(a) demonstration 356 and at the direction/request of E-mail 4:50 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/14/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 357 E-mail 4:41 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, E. Zoli, M. Mattson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/14/03 P. Harmon, J. of 316(a).

358 and at the direction/request of E-mail 3:56 p.m. L. DeWald Hayward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/14/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 359 E-mail 7:47 a.m. C. Swanson T. Opishinski demonstration report counsel.

(~

Party/representative work product, prepared in'anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of 360 Fax 1/14/2003 R. Heun M. Mattson Draft data transmittal counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 361 E-mail 3:37 p.m. T. Opishinski C. Swanson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/13/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 362 E-mail 3:05 p.m. M. Mattson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 363 E-mail 12:22 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/13/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 364 E-mail 12:15 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy In support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 365 Progress Update 1/13/2003 Normandeau N/A re port counsel.

Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, 366 Fax and at the direction/request of 1/13/2003 M. Mattson P. Harmon Draft data transmittal counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/12/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 367 E-mail 4:56 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/12/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 368 E-mail 1:05 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

© Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/11/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 369 E-mail 12:34 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/11/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 370 E-mail 10:50 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, M. Mattson, P. party/representative work product, Harmon, G. Thomas, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 E. Zoli, J. Hayward, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 371 E-mail 2:12 p.m. L. DeWald C. Wells report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 372 E-mail 12:58 p.m. H. Kim R. Heun report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 373 E-mail 12:27 p.m. H. Kim R. Heun report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 374 E-mail 12:22p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 375 E-mail 12:16 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 376 E-mail 12:16 p.m. R. Heun H. Kim, M. Mattson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal In support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 377 E-mail 11:22 a.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

(

(

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/10/03 316(a) demonstration 378 and at the direction/request of E-mail 10:04 a.m. M. Mattson P. Harmon, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/9/03 3:56 316(a) demonstration 379 and at the direction/request of E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/9/03 316(a) demonstration 380 and at the direction/request of E-mail 12:11 p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy-in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/9/03 9:32 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 381 E-mail a.m. C. Swanson M. Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 9:49 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 382 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 7:19 316(a) demonstration 383 E-mail and at the direction/request .of p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 6:21 316(a) demonstration 384 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 5:22 316(a) demonstration 385 and at the direction/request of E-mail p. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 5:17 of 316(a) 386 E-mail and at the direction/request of

]P.M. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 5:09 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 387 E-mail p.m. C. Swanson M. Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 3:16 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 388 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 389 E-mail 12:56 p.m. S. Ward S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 390 E-mail 11:48 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, C. Swanson, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/8/03 8:38 Hutchins Consulting, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 391 E-mail a.m. M. Mattson P. Harmon demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/7/03 6:20 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 392 E-mail P.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/7/03 6:03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 393 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/7/03 4:48 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 394 E-mail P.m. M. Hutchins Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 395 Progress Update __1/7/2003 N/A N/A report counsel.

C) '

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/6/03 4:54 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 396 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/6/03 2:43 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 397 E-mail p.m. R. Heun P. Hall, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/6/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 398 E-mail 12:58 p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/6/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 399 E-mail 11:44 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/6/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 400 E-mail 11:29 a.m. C. Swanson M. Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/5/03 8:38 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 401 E-mail P.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/5/03 7:27 of 316(a) 402 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/5/03 7:23 316(a) demonstration 403 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/5/03 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 404 E-mail 6:27 p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

I J

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/3/03 6:21 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 405 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/3/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 406 E-mail 12:54 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/3/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 407 E-mail 12:52 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/3/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 408 E-mail 12:30 pm. R. Heun C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/3/03 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 409 E-mail 12:30 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/3/03 9:25 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of.

410 E-mail a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, R. Heun demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/2/03 3:39 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 411 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1/2/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 412 E-mail 10:18 a.m. P. Harmon M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/31/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 413 E-mail 3:53 p.m. M. Mattson M. Hutchins, S. Ward report counsel.

©m 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/31/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 414 E-mail 3:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/31/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 415 E-mail 3:08 p.m. M. Hutchins M. Mattson, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/31/02 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 416 E-mail 3:04 p.m. M, Hutchins Mattson, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, H. Kim, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/31/02 M. Hutchins, S. 316(a) demonstration and atthe direction/request of 417 E-mail 1:50 p.m. C. Swanson Sankaranarayanan report counsel.

C. Swanson, Party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 H. Kim, S. 316(a) demonstration 418 and at the direction/request of E-mail 5:23p.m. M. Mattson Sankaranarayanan report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared In anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 C. Swanson, M. support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 419 E-mail 4:43 p.m. R. Heun Mattson demonstration report counsel.

C. Swanson, Party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 H. Kim, S. 316(a) demonstration 420 and at the direction/request of E-mail 1:16 p.m. M. Mattson Sankaranarayanan report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 421 E-mail 11:39 a.m. M. Hutchins Mattson report counsel.

( f ~

\ j Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 422 E-mail 11:31 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 423 !E-mail 10:38 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

. Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/30/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 424 E-mail 8:37 am. C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work pr6didtlt Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/27/02 M. Mattson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 425 E-mail 5:17 p2m. C. Swanson Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/27/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 426 E-mail 12:27 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/26/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 427 E-mail 5:50 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/26/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 428 E-mail 3:37 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/26/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 429 E-mail 2:29 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, R. Heun report counsel.

Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, S. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/20/02 Sankaranarayanan, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 430 E-mail 2:25 p.m. C. Swanson M. Hutchins, H. Kim report counsel.

(-V

© Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 431 Progress Update 12/26/2002 ASA, Inc. N/A report counsel..

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 432 Progress Update 12/26/2002 ASA, Inc. N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared In anticipation of litigation, 12/24/03 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 433 E-mail 11:54 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

C. Swanson, M. Strategy and Party/representative work product, Mattson, S. transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 12/23/02 Sankaranarayanan, J. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 434 E-mail 11:53 a.m. M. Hutchins Patel, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/23/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 435 E-mail 11:04 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, S. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/23/02 Sankaranarayanan, J. of 316(a) 436 and at the direction/request of E-mail 10:53 a.m. C. Swanson Patel, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/22/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 437 E-mail 3:29 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/21/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 438 E-mail 12:01 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/20/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 439 E-mail 12:18 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

C q

  • Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/20/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 440 E-mail 4:13 p~m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

C. Swanson, Strategy and Party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/20/02 H. Kim, J. Patel, S. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 441 E-mail 3:15 p.m. M. Mattson Sankaranarayanan demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/20/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 442 E-mail 11:08 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, Letter of C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 443 Transmittal 12/20/2002 M. Mattson Hutchins, L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/19/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 444 E-mail 6:20 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel, Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/18/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 445 E-mail 5:20 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 446 Letter 12/18/2002 N. Castanet M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 447 Letter 12/18/2002 S. Wender, L. DeWald M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 12/17/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 448 handwritten notes 12:57 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/17/02 M. Mattson, C. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 449 E-mail 10:21 a.m. L. DeWald Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/16/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 450 E-mail 7:09 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 12/16/02 316(a) demonstration 451 and at the direction/request of handwritten notes 5:21 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/16/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 452 E-mail 5:25 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/16/02 M. Mattson, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 453 E-mail 4:41 p.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/16/02 M. Mattson, C. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 454 E-mail 4:39 p.m. L. DeWald Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/16/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 455 E-mail 2:29 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson, J. Patel demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/16/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 456 E-mail 10:24 a.m. S. Farrell J. Patel, C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 457 Letter 12/16/2002 M. Mattson N. Castanet demonstration report counsel.

©T ©)

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/15/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 458 E-mail 1:08 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/14/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 459 E-mail 7:55 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/14/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 460 E-mail 7

17 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/14/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 461 E-mail 12:57 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/14/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 462 E-mail 12:35 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 463 E-mail 11:32 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 464 E-mail 10:44 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

IParty/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 465 E-mail 9:14 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 466 E-mail 7:23 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration 467 and at the direction/request of E-mail 6:22 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration 468 and at the direction/request of E-mail 6:06 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 S. Farrell, C. 316(a) demonstration 469 E-mail and at the direction/request of 5:15 p.m. J. Patel Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration 470 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:57 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration 471 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:24 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, R. Heun report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration 472 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:17 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) 473 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:50 p.m. R. Heun Mattson, J. Patel. demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, H. Kim, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 J. Patel, S. 316(a) demonstration 474 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:43 p.m. C. Swanson Sankaranarayanan report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 of 316(a)

.475 E-mail and at the direction/request of 1:56 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, R. Heun demonstration report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 476 E-mail 11:33 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/13/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 477 E-mall 8:44 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 478 Memorandum 12/12/2002 M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 12/12/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 479 handwritten notes 5 :2 2 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/12/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 480 E-mail 2:58 p.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, R.H., B.H., M.C., support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 481 Communication 12/12/2002 TBD J.G., M.M. demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/12/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 482 E-mail 12:18 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/12/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 483 E-mail 12:18 p.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/11/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 484 E-mail 5:00 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

(*_*.

0 Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/11/02 support of 316(a) 485 and at the direction/request of E-mail 1:41 p.m. C. Swanson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/11/02 of 316(a) 486 E-mail and at the direction/request of 11:37 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/11/02 of 316(a) 487 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:57 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/11/02 316(a) demonstration 488 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:10 a.m. C. Porembski C. Swanson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/11/02 of 316(a) 489 E-mail and at the direction/request of 7:32 a.m. C. Porembski C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/10/02 316(a) demonstration 490 E-mail and at the direction/request of 8:57 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/10/02 316(a) demonstration 491 and at the direction/request of E-mail 7:01 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/10/02 of 316(a) 492 and at the direction/request of E-mail 7:00 p.m. S. Ward M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/10/02 316(a) demonstration 493 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:35 p.m. M. Hutchins M. Mattson report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/10/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 494 E-mail 5:46 p.m. M, Mattson M. Hutchins, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared In anticipation of litigation, 12/9/02 support of 316(a) and at the. direction/request of 495 E-mail 2:20 p.m. M. Hutchins L.. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/8/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 496 E-mail 5:00 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/8/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 497 E-mail 3:32 p.n. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/8/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 498 E-mail 1:50 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1217/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 499 E-mail 7:14 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 500 E-mail 7:13 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 501 E-mail 7:01p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7102 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 502 E-mail 6:44 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

\" /

0 Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared inanticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 of 316(a) 503 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:27 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 of 316(a) 504 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:26 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 of 316(a) 505 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:24 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 of 316(a) 506 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:13 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 of 316(a) 507 E-mail and at the direction/request of 2:12 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 of 316(a) 508 JE-mail and at the direction/request of 2:11 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 316(a) demonstration 509 E-mail and at the direction/request of 1:26 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/7/02 316(a) demonstration 510 E-mail and at the direction/request of 11:47 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02. 316(a) demonstration 511 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:17 p.m.__ M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

(

C)

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 512 E-mail 11:15 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 7:24 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 513 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 6:37 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 514 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 6:27 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 515 E-mail p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 516 JE-mail 5:13 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 517 E-mail 4:54 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, L. DeWald, B. Hobbs, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 2/6/02 3:40 G. Thomas, Hutchins of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 518 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson Consulting, S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, M. Hutchins, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 519 Letter 2/6/2002 B. Hobbs, L. DeWald Mattson, G. Thomas report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 520 E-Mail 12:32 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson report counsel.

/

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 1215/02 C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration 521 and at the direction/request of E-mail 12:31 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 316(a) demonstration .and at the direction/request of 522 JE-mail 12:26 p.m. M. Hutchins C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 C. Swanson, M. .1316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 523 E-mail 12:20 p.m. M. Hutchins Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 524 E-mail 11:45 a.m. M. Mattson M. Hutchins, S. Ward report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 of 316(a) 525 E-mail and at the direction/request of 11:11 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 C. Swanson, of 316(a) 526 and at the direction/request of E-mail 9:23 a.m. M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, M. Mattson, M. Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/5/02 Hutchins, Hutchins 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 527 E-mail 9:16 a.m. S. Ward Consulting report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/4/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 528 E-mail 4:15 p.m. M. Mattson M. Hutchins, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work. product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/4/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 529 E-mail 3:22 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/4/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 530 E-mail 11:21 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/4/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 531 E-mail 10:19 a.m. M. Mattson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 532 E-mail 8:02 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 533 E-mail 5:15 p.m. M. Mattson M. Hutchins, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration 534 and at the direction/request of E-mail 4:14 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 535 E-mail 2:47 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 536 E-mail 1:47 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.*

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 537 E-mail 1:37 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 123/W02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 538 E-mail 12:04 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3102 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 539 E-mail 11:20 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/3/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 540 E-mail 10:31 a.m. L. DeWald M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy and data in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 541 Memorandum 12/3/2002 C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, E-mail with 12/2/02 316(a) demonstration 542 and at the direction/request of Ihandwritten notes 4:51 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 543 E-mail 4:00 p.m. S. Ward S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 544 E-mail 3:04 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 545 E-mail 1:03 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 546 E-mail 12:24 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 547 E-mail 12:22 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

(

©m 01C Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 548 E-mail 12:21 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 549 E-mail 12:18 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative Work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 550 E-mail 12:17 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 551 E-mail 12:16 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 552 E-mail 12:15 p.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 12/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 553 E-mail 11:29 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 554 Fax 12/2/2002 R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/27/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 555 E-mail 6:15 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/27/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 556 E-mail 5:25 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

(

C, Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/27/02 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 557 E-mail 4:11 p.m. R. Heun Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/27/02 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 558 E-mail 3:30 p.m. L. DeWald Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11127/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 559 E-mail 1:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/27/02 C.Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 560 E-mail 9:46 a.m. L. DeWald Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 561 E-mail 6:33 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 562 E-mail 5:27 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 563 E-mail 4:28 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) 564 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:48 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 565 E-mail 11:40 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 566 E-mail 8:18 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 567 E-mail 8:17 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 568 E-mail 8:16 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 569 E-mail 8:15 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 570 E-mail 8:14 a.m. R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/25/02 T. Isaji, C. Swanson, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 571 E-mail 3:58 p.m. H. Kim S. Sankaranarayanan demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/25/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 572 E-mail 3:36 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, T.. Isaji, C. Swanson, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 11/25/02 S. Subbayya, J. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 573 E-mail 3:09 p.m. H. Kim Patel, P. Hall demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/25/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 574 E-mail . 9:03 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

(

C Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal .in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/25102 L. DeWald, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 575 E-mail 8:24 a.m. C. Swanson Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/25/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 576 E-mail 7:59 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 577 E-mail 5:54 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 578 E-mail 5:04 p.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representativework product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 579 E-mail 2:22 p.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 580 E-mail 1:25 p.m. H. Kim C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 581 E-mail 10:58 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 582 E-mail 9:58 a.m. L. DeWald C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 583 E-mail 8:24 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

I (T D Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/22/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 584 Progress Update 12:00 AM N/A N/A report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/21/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 585 - E-mail 10:42 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/21/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 586 E-mail 5:52 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/21/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 587 E-mail 4:52 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/20/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 588 E-mail 8:23 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 11/20/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 589 E-mail 6:12 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 11/20/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 590 E-mail 6:00 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/20/02 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 591 E-mail 3:25 p.m. D. Scott Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/20/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 592 E-mail 3:41 p.m. D. Scott C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

0 0 Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared inanticipation of litigation, 11/20/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 593 E-mail 12:16 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/19/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 594 E-mail 5:30 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/19/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 595 E-mail 4:59 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/19/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 596 E-mail 4:37 p.m.. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/19/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 597 E-mail 3:37 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 11/19/02 C. Swanson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 598 E-mail 3:11 p.m. R. Heun Mattson, T. Brush demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11119/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 599 E-mail 12:27 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/19/02 of 316(a) 600 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:45 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/18/02 of 316(a) 601 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:20 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

C Communication and Party/representative work product,.

transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/18/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 602 E-mail 9:31 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/18/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 603 E-mail 8:32p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/18/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 604 E-mail 5:32 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal In support prepared in.anticipation of litigation, 11/18/02 .of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 605 E-mail 5:23 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/18/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 606 E-mail 3:12 p.rm. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/16/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 607 E-mail 12:56 a.m. T. Opishinski C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/15/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 608 E-mail 2:26 a.m. T. Opishinski C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/15/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 609 E-mail 9:43 p.m. T. Opishinski C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/15/02 R. Heun, A. Gonyaw, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 610 E-mail 9:05 p.m. T. Opishinski T. Brush, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

0 0 Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/15/02 of 316(a) 611 and at the direction/request of E-mail 11:06 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/14/02 of 316(a) 612 and at the direction/request of E-mail 12:41 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/14/02 of 316(a) 613 E-mail and at the direction/request of 12:05 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/14/02 of 316(a) 614 E-mail and at the direction/request of 12:00 AM P. Harmon L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/13/02 of 316(a) 615 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:30 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/13/02 M. Mattson, C. of 316(a) 616 and at the direction/request of E-mail 3:49 p.m. R. Heun Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/12/02 of 316(a) 617 and at the direction/request of E-mail 7:02 p.m. M. Mattson L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/12/02 of 316(a) 618 and at the direction/request of E-mail 10:22 a.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, 11/12/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 619 E-mail 10:10 a.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/11/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 620 E-mail 6:53 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/11/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 621 IE-mail 7:23 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/8/02 5:11 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 622 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/7/02 1:04 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 623 E-mail p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/7/02 3:44 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 624 E-mail p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, B. Hobbs, L. DeWald, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, M. Hutchins, C. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 625 Letter 11/7/2002 M. Mattson Swanson report ccounsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 626 Memorandum 11/7/2002 C. Swanson M. Mattson report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/6/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 627 E-mail 12:09 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/6/02 9:32 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 628 E-mail a.m. M. Mattson S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

0 D Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/6/02 316(a) demonstration 629 Scope of Work and at the direction/request of 12:00 AM Norrnandeau N/A report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 6:01 of 316(a) 630 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 5:05 of 316(a) 631 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 111/5/02 5:01 of 316(a) 632 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 4:10 of 316(a) 633 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 2:51 of 316(a) 634 E-mail and at the direction/request of P.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 1:35 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 635 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 1:28 T. Opishinski, H. of 316(a) 636 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. C. Swanson Rines demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/5/02 1:28 of 316(a) 637 E-mail and at the direction/request of p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

x~J Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/4/02 5:56 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 638 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/4/02 5:55 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 639 E-mall p.m. T. Opishinski C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal In support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/4/02 5:53 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 640 E-mail p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/4/02 5:45 T. Brush, P. Harmon, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 641 E-mail p.m. R. Heun M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/4/02 9:44 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 642 E-mail a.m. L. Bruster M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 643 E-mail 9:17p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 11/2/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 644 E-mail 5:49 p.m. C. Swanson T. Opishinski demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 645 Memorandum 11/1/2002 M. Mattson Entergy report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 646 Memorandum 11/1/2002 M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

K)==

©D Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10131/02 of 316(a) 647 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:10 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/31/02 of 316(a) 648 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:09 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/31/02 of 316(a) 649 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:19 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/31/02 of 316(a) 650 E-mail and at the direction/request of 3:33 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/31/02 of 316(a) 651 and at the direction/request of E-mail 2:17 p.m. C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/30/02 of 316(a) 652 E-mail and at the direction/request of 6:11 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/30/02 of 316(a) 653 E-mail and at the direction/request of 4:22 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/30/02 of 316(a) 654 E-mail and at the direction/request of 12:46 p.m. M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/30/02 of 316(a) 655 E-mail and at the direction/request of 12:34 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

©) 0 Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/30/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 656 E-mail 11:34 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/29/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 657 E-mail 11:58 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/29/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 658 E-mail 1:12 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/29/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 659 E-mail 12:29 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 660 Memorandum 10/29/2002 E. Zoli C. Wells, V. Brown report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/28/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 661 E-mail 4:50 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/28/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 662 E-mail 4:49 p.m. M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/28/02 of 316(a). and at the direction/request of 663 E-mail i3:09 P.M. M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/28/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 664 E-mail 11:18 a.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

©> O Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/27/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 665 E-mail 8:11 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/26/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 666 E-mail 5:21 p.m. M. Hutchins S. Ward demonstration report counsel.

Attomey-client communication, Communication and party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/25/02 M. Mattson w/ of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 667 E-mail 3:43 p.m. attachment by E. Zoli S. Ward, M. Hutchins demonstration report counsel.

M. Mattson, P.

Harmon, T. Brush, J. Attorney-client communication, Hayward, L. DeWald, Communication and party/representative work product, S. Wender, R. transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/25/02 Gerdus, C. Wells, V. of 316(a). and at the direction/request of 668 E-mail 3:43 p.m. E. Zoli Brown, B. Hobbs demonstration report counsel..

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/23/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 669 Notes 12:00 AM N/A N/A report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, T. Brush, P. Harmon, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/14/02 M. Mattson, P. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 670 E-mail 4:05 p.m. R. Heun Kinner, P. Hall demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, L. DeWald, T. Brush, transmittal In support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 10/8/02 P. Harmon, D. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 671 E-mail 9:17 a.m. M. Mattson Mathur demonstration report counsel.

Communication and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, 8/29/02 of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 672 E-mail 11:33 a.m. R. Heun L. DeWald demonstration report counsel.

0 0 Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 8/7/02 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 673 E-mail 6:02 p.m. M. Mattson M. Hutchins, S. Ward report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 674 E-mail undated M. Mattson C. Swanson report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 675 E-mail undated M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 676 JE-mail undated M. Mattson C. Swanson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, L. DeWald, P. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 677 E-mail undated M. Mattson Harmon, C. Swanson, demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy In support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 678 E-mail undated M. Mattson R. Heun, L. DeWald report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 679 E-mall undated M. Mattson L. DeWald, T. Brush, report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, M. Mattson, M. of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 680 E-mail undated C. Swanson Hutchins, H. Kim demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 681 E-mail undated C. Swanson M. Mattson, R. Heun demonstration report counsel.

3 Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 682 E-mail undated C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 683 E-mail undated C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Strategy and Party/representative work product, transmittal in support prepared In anticipation of litigation, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 684 E-mail undated C. Swanson M. Mattson demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in suppoit of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at thedirection/request of 685 E-mail undated R. Heun P. Hall. report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 686 JE-mail undated R. Heun P. Hall, M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 687 E-mail undated R. Heun M. Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 688 E-mail undated R. Heun Mattson report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Transmittal in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 689 E-mail undated R. Heun C. Swanson demonstration report

~Party/representative counsel. work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 690 E-mail undated R. Heun L. DeWald .report counsel.

U Party/representative work product, Communication in prepared in anticipation of litigation, support of 316(a) and at the direction/request of 691 E-mail undated R. Heun T. Opishinski demonstration report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, C. Swanson, M. 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 692 E-mail undated L. DeWald Mattson, B. Hobbs report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 693 E-mail undated L. DeWald R. Heun report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 694 E-mail undated H. Kim R. Heun report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 695 E-mail undated P. Hall R. Heun report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 696 E-mail undated P. Harmon R. Heun, L. DeWald report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 697 E-mail undated N/A P. Hall report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 698 Progress Update undated Normandeau N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of

.699 Progress Update undated ASA, Inc. N/A report counsel.

(* ,, (~N)

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 700 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of Progress Update undated ASA, Inc. N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 701 Progress Update undated N/A N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 702 Progress Update undated N/A N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 703 Progress Update 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of undated N/A N/A report counsel.

Party/representative work product, Strategy in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, 316(a) demonstration and at the direction/request of 704 Progress Update undated N/A N/A Ireport :counsel.

U

(.

0 0

" Privilege Log For Documents with. Handwritten Notations 9/16/2003 This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with State of Vermont Public Service Board proceeding No. 6812.

P.Nv'V resrves

= - the

=- ricvht -to simnnement

- - - amend or dlarifi, this loe as necessary No Type of Date/Time Author Recipients. Subject Privilege Asserted Document 1 Electronic Mail 8/26/03 M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting, C. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, Swanson, E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

2 Electronic Mail 8/25/03, 5:45 M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting, C. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, p.m. Swanson, E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

3 Electronic Mail 8/21/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 3:50 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel, 4 Electronic Mail 8/12/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 8:35 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

5 Draft 8/8/03 P. Hall N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 6 Electronic Mail 8/8/03, 6:02 M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting, E. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, p.m. Zoli, C. Swanson 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Note: In this privilege log, we have identified each electronic communication ("e-mail"), facsimile, draft and handwritten document separately. We reserve the right in any supplementation of this log to utilize generic categories, as we have done above for referenced documents.

0~

-4.

Page 1

f 7 Electronic Mail 8/8/03, 5:59 0 0T L. DeWald Hutchins Consulting, Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, p.m. M. Mattson, C. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, Swanson, E. Zoli, B. demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Ripley the direction/request of counsel.

8 Notes 8/2/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report preparedin anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

9 Electronic Mail 8/1/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:06 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

10 Electronic Mail 7/30/03, 3:40 C. Swanson G. Thomas, L. DeWald Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

11 Electronic Mail 7/29/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:51 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

12 Electronic Mail 7/26/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 7:22 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

T3 Electronic Mail 7/25/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 5:52 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

14 Electronic Mail 7/21/03, 12:43 M. Mattson S. Ward, E. Zoli, L. Request for information in Attorney-client communication, p.m. DeWald adcance of meeting in support party/representative work product, of 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at report the direction/request of counsel.

15 Electronic Mail 7/14/03, 5:05 M. Mattson P. Harmon, Hutchins Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, p.m. Consulting, C. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, Swanson, E. Zoli demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

16 Electronic Mail 6/20/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 5:58 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 2 ai

17 Electronic Mail 5/15/03, 7:40 0

L. DeWald J. Hayward, M. Notes in support of 316(a) Attorney-client communication, a.m. Mattson, P. Harmon, demonstration report party/representative work product, M. Desilets prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

18 Electronic Mail 5/15/03, 11:35 P. Harmon M. Mattson Notes in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, a.m. demonstration report prepared in anticipation .of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

19 Electronic Mail 5/12/03, 12:26 L. DeWald M. Mattson, P. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, p.m. Harmon, C. Swanson, 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting, E. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Zoli, B. Ripley, J. the direction/request of counsel.

Hawyard 20 Draft 5/9/03 Versar, Inc. Vermont Agency for Draft Final Third-Party Party/representative work product, Natural Resources, Review of Hydrothermal prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Department of Modeling and 316(a) the direction/request of counsel Environmental Demonstration Documents Conservation with subsequent handwritten notes 21 Electronic Mail 5/1/03, 10:14 M. Mattson C. Swanson, M. Strategy and notes in support Party/representative work product, a.m. Hutchins, P. Harmon of 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at report the direction/request of counsel 22 Draft 4/29/03 ENVY Versar Draft commentsto Versar Party/representative work product, review in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration the direction/request of counsel.

23 Draft 4/29/03 M. Mattson N/A Draft comments to Versar Party/representative work product, review in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration the direction/request of counsel 24 Draft 4/28/03 ENVY N/A Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 3

(

0 0 25 Draft, includes 4/24/03 E. Zoli, L. N/A Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, combined DeWald, L. 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, comments of Mattson, M. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at various parties Hutchins, P. the direction/request of counsel.

Harmon, C.

Swanson 26 Notes 4/24/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 27 Draft, includes 4/22/03 E. Zoli, L. N/A Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, combined DeWald, M. 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, comments of Mattson, M. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at various parties Hutchins, P. the direction/request of counsel.

Harmon, C.

Swanson/

Goodwin Procter Draft 28 Draft 4/21/03 Draft document N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, prepared by 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at ASA, Inc.; the direction/request of counsel.

unclear who made the notes 29 Fax 4/17/03, 5:11 M. Mattson M. Mattson, P. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, p.m. Harmon, C. Swanson, 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, Normandeau, ASA, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Inc. the direction/request of counsel.

30 Electronic Mail 4/17/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 12:10 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

31 Electronic Mail 4/16/03, 3:41 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 32 Electronic Mail 4/15/03, 4:11 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 4

33 Notes 13 4/14/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 34 Notes 4/7/03 N/A N/A Notes supporting 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 35 Draft 4/7/03 Versar, Inc. Vermont Agency for Draft third-party review of Party/representative work product, Natural Resources, hydrothermal modeling report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Department of and 316(a) demonstration the direction/request of counsel Environmental with notes by M. Mattson Conservation 36 Draft 4/4/03 N/A N/A Draft response to comments Party/representative work product, provided by Versar on 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration the direction/request of counsel 37 Notes 4/4/03 N/A N/A Versar comments and Party/representative work product, technical data in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 38 Draft 3/28/03 Versar, Inc. N/A Draft Versar, Inc. Progress Party/representative work product, Report and notes in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at of 316(a) demonstration the direction/request of counsel reports 39 Draft 3/28/03 Versar, Inc. N/A Draft Summary of Monthly Party/representative work product, Impingement of Fish on prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Circulating Water Traveling the direction/request of counsel Screens in support of 316(a) demonstration reports 40 Notes 3/26/03 N/A N/A Notes and technical data in Patty/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 41 Draft 3/25/03 R. Estabrook B. Kooiker Draft comments of 316(a) and Party/representative work product, hydrothermal modeling with prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at subsequent handwritten notes the direction/request of counsel Page 5

'-N 42 Electronic Mail 3/18/03, 2:47 D

S. Arena L. DeWald, E. Zoli, B. Notes concerning conference Attorney-client communication, p.m. Ripley, M. Mattson, P. call in support of 316(a) party/representative work product, Harmon, C. Swanson, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Normandeau, E. the direction/request of counsel.

Buzuvis 43 Notes 3/7/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 44 Notes 3/7/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 45 Draft 3/7/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 46 Notes 3/6/03 N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 47 Cover Letter of 2/18/03 Normandean E. Zoli Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, Transmittal Associates inc. 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

48 Drafts 2/14/03 M. Mattson Comments on draft by Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, B. Hanson 316(a) demonstration-report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

49 Electronic Mail 2/14/2003, M. Mattson C. Swanson, H. Sook Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 7:23 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

50 Notes 2/14/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 51 Draft 2/10/03 N/A Prepared for ASA, Inc. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation; and at the direction/request of counsel Page 6

ff.,.*..

52 Electronic Mail 2/9/03, 11:43 C. Swanson 0

H. Sook Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, a.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at thedirection/request of counsel 53 Electronic Mail 2/8/03,10:44 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, a.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 54 Electronic Mail 2/8/03, 6:34 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 55 Electronic Mail 2/7/03, 5:11 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 56 Draft 2/7/03 Normandeau N/A Draft 316(a) Demonstration Party/representative work product, Associates inc. with notes prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 57 Power Point 2/5/03 Normandeau N/A Draft/Notes Party/representative work product, and Notes Associates inc. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

58 Draft 2/5/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 59 Notes 2/5/03 N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 60 Notes 2/5/03 N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 61 Fax 2/5/2003 P, Heun M. Mattson Notes and figures regarding Party/representative work product, tail race depths in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

62 Electronic Mail 2/4/03, 2:48 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 7

(

63 Notes 2/4/03 N/A 0 ,K--

N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

" ____the direction/request of counsel 64 Fax 2/3/2003 R. Heun M. Mattson Notes regarding depths, Party/representative work product, temperature and fish ladder in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 65 Fax 2/3/03, 9:44 R. Heun M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, a.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

66 Electronic Mail 2/3/03, 9:27 C. Swanson H. Sook, P. Hall, J. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, a-m. Patel 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 67 Electronic Mail 2/3/03, 5:37 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 68 Electronic Mail 2/3/03,4:13 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 69 Notes 2/3/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 70 Notes 2/3/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 71 Draft 2/3/03 N/A Prepared for ASA, Inc. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 72 Fax 2/3/03 R. Heun M. Mattson Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product,.

demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 73 Memorandum 2/2/03 M. Mattson C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 8

D3 74 Draft February-03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 75 Notes 1/31/03 N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 76 Notes 1/31/03 N/A N/A Notes from conference call in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 77 Notes 1/31/2003 N/A N/A Data and notes regarding Party/representative work product, Fishway operation period prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

'(1997-2002) the direction/request of counsel.

78 Fax 1/31/03, 9:00 E. Zoli C. Swanson, L. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, p.m. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

79 Electronic Mail 1/31/03, 8:01 M. Mattson S. Ward, Hutchins Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. Consulting 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

80 Electronic Mail 1/31/03, 4:57 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 81 Electronic Mail 1/31/03, 3:28 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 82 Electronic Mail 1/30/03, 3:39 M. Mattson S. Ward, M. Hutchins Tabular summary of technical Party/representative work product, p.m. data and notes in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 83 Electronic Mail 1/30/03, 3:07 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 84 Electronic Mail 1/30/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 11:42 a.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

  • _"_.._ fthe direction/request of counsel.

Page 9

(,....

85 Notes K) 0 1/30/03 N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 86 Draft 1/30/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

87 Notes 1/29/03 N/A N/A Data-and notes-in.support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 88 Draft 1/29/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 89 Draft 1/29/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 90 Fax 1/29/03, 8:25 E. Zoli M. Mattson, S. Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, p.m. Schuyler, L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

91 Electronic Mail 1/29/03, 7:45 C. Swanson H. Sook, S. Ubbayya Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, a.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel 92 Electronic Mail 1/29/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:21 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

93 Notes 1/28/03 N/A N/A Notes concerning meeting in Attorney-client communication, support of 316(a) party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_ the direction/request of counsel.

94 Draft 1/28/03 Prepared by N/A Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, Normandeau; 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, unclear who prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at made comments the direction/request of counsel.

95 Electronic Mail 1/27/03, 11:03 L. DeWald C. Swanson, M. Notes concerning meeting in Party/representative work product, a.m. Mattson support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

Page 10

K) 96 Electronic Mail 1/25/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representativework product, 2:57 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel..

97 Electronic Mail 1/25/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 10:57 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

98 Notes 1/23/03 N/A N/A Notes from conference call Party/representative work product, among unidentified parties in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel, demonstration report 99 Electronic Mail 1/23/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 7:51 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

100 Draft 1/23/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 101 Electronic Mail 1/22/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 6:13 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

102 Electronic Mail 1/22/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:09 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at I _ the direction/request of counsel.

103 Electronic Mail 1/21/03, 12:23 M. Mattson C. Swanson, H. Sook Data and strategy in support Party/representative work product, p.m. of 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_report the direction/request of counsel 104 Electronic Mail 1/21/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product,,

7:28 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

105 Electronic Mail 1/21/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 5:17 p.m. M. Hutchins 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

106 Electronic Mail 1/21/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:27 p.m. 316(a) demonstrationreport prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at I I_ the direction/request of counsel.

Page 11

(

107 Electronic Mail 1/20/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 01 5:31 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

108 Electronic Mail 1/20/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:32 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

109 Electronic Mail 1/20/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 10:45 a.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

110 Electronic Mail 1/18/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 9:32 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

111 Electronic Mail 1/18/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:54 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

112 Electronic Mail 1/18/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:06 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel.

113 Electronic Mail 1/17/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 5:04 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel.

114 Electronic Mail 1/17/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 3:50 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

115 Electronic Mail 1/16/03, 5:16 M. Mattson H. Sook, C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 116 Electronic Mail 1/16/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:51 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

117 Electronic Mail 1/16/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:39 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

__ the direction/request of counsel.

118 Electronic Mail 1/16/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:28 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel.

Page 12

0 119 Electronic Mail 1/16/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:23 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation; and at the direction/request of counsel.

120 Electronic Mail 1/16/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 2:15 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

121 Electronic Mail 1/15/03, 5:58 M. Mattson H. Sook, C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 122 Draft 1/15/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

___the direction/request of counsel 123 Draft 1/14/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 124 Electronic Mail 1/14/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 3:51 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

125 Electronic Mail 1/14/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 3:42 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

126 Electronic Mail 1/13/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 3:42 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

127 Progress Report 1/13/03 Comments to N/A Internal Analysis, thermal and Attorney-client communication, draft by M. hydraulic evaluations party/representative work product, Hutchins prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

128 Electronic Mail 1/10/03, 12:16 R. Heun H. Sook, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 129 Electronic Mail 1/10/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 6:05 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 1_ _ _the L__ direction/request of counsel.

Page 13

(-.--..

0 130 Electronic Mail 1/10/03 Hutchins S. Ward Thermal data with notes/ Party/representative work product, 11: 17 a.m. Consulting calculations in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

131 Electronic Mail 1/8/03, 5:22 M. Mattson C. Swanson, M. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. Hutchins, P. Harmon 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 132 Electronic Mail 1/8/03, 4:17 M. Hutchins C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 133 Electronic Mail 1/8/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 6:20 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

134 Electronic Mail 1/8/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 4:58 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

135 Electronic Mail 1/8/03 M. Mattson S. Ward Data regarding temperature Party/representative work product, 3:26 p.m. M. Hutchins duration in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

136 Electronic Mail 1/8/03 M. Mattson C. Swanson, P. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, Harmon, Hutchins 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Consultin the direction/request of counsel 137 Electronic Mail 1/7/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 5:03 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

138 Draft 1/7/03 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 139 Electronic Mail 1/6/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 3:55 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Wthe direction/request of counsel.

140 Electronic Mail 1/3/03 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 5:22 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Ithe direction/request of counsel.

Page 14

C 0 0 141 Draft January-03 ASA, Inc. Normandeau Hydrothermal Modeling of Party/representative work product, the Cooling Water Discharge, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at data.and notes in support of the direction/request of counsel.

316(a) demonstration report 142 Electronic Mail 12/30/02, M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 10:32 a.m. 316(a) demonstration repQrt prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 143 Electronic Mail 12/30/02 M. Mattson S. Ward Thermal data with notes/ Party/representative work product, 3:29 p.m. calculations in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

144 Electronic Mail 12/26/02, 4:51 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel 145 Draft 12/26/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

  • __the direction/request of counsel 146 Electronic Mail 12/23/02, M. Hutchins C. Swanson, M. Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 10:53 a.m. Mattson, S. Ubbayya, J. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Patel the direction/request of counsel 147 Notes 12/19/02 N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 148 Draft 112/19/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 149 Notes 12/18/02 N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 150 Electronic Mail 12/17/02 M. Hutchins page 2 of 2 Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 151 Electronic Mail 12/13/02, 5:06 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 15

C 0 0 152 Draft 12/11/02, N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 12:01 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 153 Notes 12/10/02 N/A N/A Notes regarding update in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

154 Electronic Mail 12/7/02, 6:14 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 155 Electronic Mail 12/6/02, 5:28 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of ýParty/represenative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 156 Electronic Mail 12/6/02, 4:14 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel 157 Electronic Mail 12/6/02, 3:55 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report- prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 158 Notes 12/6/02 M. Hutchins and L. DeWald; B. Hobbs, Notes from meeting in Party/representative work product, M. Mattson G. Thomas support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

159 Electronic Mail 11/27/02, 5:15 M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 160 Electronic Mail 11/27/02, M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 12:43 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 161 Electronic Mail 11/26/02, 5:36 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 162 Electronic Mail 11/25/02,2:36 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 163 Notes 11/25/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 16

0 164 Notes 11/23/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 165 Electronic Mail 11/22/02, 4:55 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_ the direction/request of counsel 166 Electronic Mail 11/20/02, 5:00 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 167 Draft 11/14/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 168 Notes 11/11/02 N/A N/A Data summary in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel 169 Notes 11/11/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 170 Notes 11/11/02 N/A N/A Meeting notes with Party/representative work product, unidentified parties regarding prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at tasks and priorities in support the direction/request of counsel.

of 316(a) demonstration report 171 Notes 11/11/02 N/A N/A Notes regarding temperature Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

172 Notes 11/10/02 - N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 1/28/03 316(a) demonstration report. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Note: This is a pack of the direction/request of counsel sequential notes, some of which incorrectly identify the year 2002 instead of 2003 Page 17.

0 173 Draft 11/8/2002 N/A N/A Memo regarding thermal data Party/representative work product, and notes in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report. the direction/request of counsel.

174 Draft 11/7/2002 N/A N/A Draft of proposed schedule Party/representative work product, for Normandeau Assoc. Inc. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at to prepare 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 175 Electronic Mail 11/7/02, 2:47 P. Harmon L. DeWald Strategy and notes in support Party/representative work product, p.m. of 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at report the direction/request of counsel 176 Draft 1/7/02 C. Swanson M. Mattson Memorandum: data and notes Party/representative work product, in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 177 Draft 11/7/02 C. Swanson M. Mattson Draft Thermal Monitoring Party/representative work product, and Modeling of Discharge prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at into Connecticut River the direction/request of counsel 178 Draft 11/6/02 Normandeau E. Zoli Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

179 Fax 11/4/02 M. Mattson B. Hobbs, L. DeWald Attached is thermal data with Party/representative work product, notes in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

180 Draft 11/1/02 C. Swanson M. Mattson Draft Thermal Monitoring Party/representative work product, and Modeling of Discharge prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at into Connecticut River the direction/request of counsel 181 Notes 11/1/02 N/A N/A Notes from conference call Party/representative work product, with M. Mattson, C. Swanson prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

& Henry of ASA, Inc. the direction/request of counsel.

182 Fax 11/l/02; M. Mattson T. Brush, R. Heun Schematic for S4 current Party/representative work product, 1:06 p.m. meter deployment in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Connecticut River in support the direction/request of counsel.

of 3 16(a) demonstration report Page 18

0 183 Draft 10/31/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

184 Fax 10/31/02 M. Mattson C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 185 Fax 10/31/02 M. Mattson L. DeWald Data and Strategy in support Party/representative work product, of 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at report the direction/request of counsel.

186 Fax 10/31/02 M. Mattson C. Swanson Attached is thermal data with Party/representative work product, notes in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

187 Fax 10/31/02, 4:44 B. Hobbs M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

188 Notes 10/30/02 N/A N/A Notes regarding budget in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

189 Fax 10/29/02 M. Mattson C. Swanson Notes regarding Macroinvest Party/representative work product, study in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

190 Fax 10/29/02 M. Mattson B. Hobbs Draft Analysis of Recirc gate Party/representative work product, usage at NY for summer and prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at winter NPDES compliance the direction/request of counsel.

periods 1997-2001 in support of 316(a) demonstration report 191 Fax 10/29/02, 4:26 M. Mattson C. Swanson Draft of data and notes in Party/representative work product, p.m. support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 192 Electronic Mail 10/29/02, M. Hutchins S. Ward Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 12:12 p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 19

0 0 193 Electronic Mail 10/28/02, 2:10 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 194 Electronic Mail 10/28/02 M. Hutchins S. Ward, M. Mattson Electronic Mail regarding Party/representative work product, 2:09 p.M thermal calculations in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 195 Notes 10/25/02 N/A N/A Notes from conference call in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

196 Fax 10/24/02, 6:29 M. Mattson C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, p.m. 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

197 Notes 10/23/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of, Attorney-client communication, and concerning meeting in party/representative work product, support of, 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

198 Fax 10/4/02 N/A N/A Notes regarding estimate of Party/representative work product, reserves capacity in support prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at of 316(a) demonstration the direction/request of counsel.

I report 199 Notes 9/10/02 N/A N/A Notes regarding temperature Party/representative work product, data at different stations in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 200 Notes 4/30/02 N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 201 Draft 3/1/78 N/A N/A Draft 316 Demonstration with Party/representative work product, undated handwritten notes, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at March draft with subsequent the direction/request of counsel handwritten notes Page 20

C' _ _ _ _ _ ©Y 202 Notes 12/13/? N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Patty/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 203 Notes 7/29/? N/A N/A Notes supporting 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 204 Notes 7/15/? N/A N/A Notes and technical data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 205 Notes 1/22/? N/A N/A Meeting notes and data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 206 Notes 27-Dec N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 207 Notes 24-Dec N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 208 Notes 15-Dec N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 209 Notes 10-Dec N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 210 Notes 3-Dec N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 211 Notes 26-Nov N/A N/A Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 212 Notes 18-Nov N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 213 Notes 12-Nov N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 21

K)

(l )

214 Notes I -Nov 0

N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 215 Notes 7-Nov demonstration report the direction/request of counsel M. Mattson N/A Notes in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

216 Notes 5-Nov N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 217 Notes 4-Nov N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 218 Fax 31-Oct M. Mattson C. Swanson Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 219 Notes 30-Oct N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 220 Notes 26-Oct N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 221 Notes 25-Oct N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 222 Notes 24-Oct N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 223 Notes 23-Oct Normandeau N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

224 Notes 26-Aug N/A N/A Notes supporting 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 225 Notes 8-Aug N/A N/A Notes support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 22

226 Notes 7-Aug N/A N/A Notes from conference call Party/representative work product, 0

related to 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration the direction/request of counsel 227 Notes 1-Aug N/A N/A Notes from conference call Party/representative work product, related to 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration*. the direction/request of counsel 228 Notes 31-Jul N/A N/A Notes supporting 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 229 Notes 24-Jul N/A N/A Notes and strategy from Party/representative work product, meeting concerning 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 230 Notes 21-Jul N/A N/A Notes and strategy from Party/representative work product, conference call concerning prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 231 INotes 16-May N/A N/A Notes supporting 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 232 Notes 10-May N/A N/A Data, notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 233 Notes 30-Apr N/A N/A Notes and strategy in Party/representative work product, preparation of a meeting prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at concerning 316(a) the direction/request of counsel demonstration report 234 Notes 29-Apr N/A N/A Notes from conference call in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.,

235 Notes 28-Apr N/A N/A Notes and strategy from Party/representative work product, conference call concerning prepared, in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 236 Notes 25-Apr N/A N/A Notes in support of 316(a) Attorney-client communication, demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

-the direction/request of counsel.

Page 23.

l*

0 237 Notes 23-Apr N/A N/A 0

Notes in support of 316(a) Attorney-client communication, demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

238 Notes is-Apr N/A N/A Notes from meeting in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

239 Notes 25-Mar N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 240 Notes 6-Mar N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report . the direction/request of counsel.

241 Notes 7-Feb N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 242 Notes 31-Jan N/A N/A Meeting notes and data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 243 Notes 30-Jan N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 244 Notes 29-Jan N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 245 Notes 28-Jan N/A N/A Notes and strategy in support Attorney-client communication, of 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

246 Notes 28-Jan N/A N/A Notes concerning meeting in Attorney-client commnunication, support of 316(a) party/representative work product, demonstration report, with prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at business cards the direction/request of counsel.

247 Notes 8-Jan N/A N/A Meeting notes and data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, andat demonstration report the direction/request of counsel Page 24

248 Notes 1-Jan N/A N/A 0 0 Meeting notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 249 Notes August N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 250 Referenced various various various N/A Party/representative work product, Documents prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 251 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

252 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

253 Draft N/A ASA, Inc. N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

254 Draft N/A ASA, Inc. N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

255 Draft N/A ENVY N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

256 Draft N/A ASA, Inc. N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

257 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

258 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 25

259 Notes N/A 0

N/A N/A Notes concerning meeting in Attorney-client communication, support of 316(a) party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

260 Figures with N/A N/A N/A Notes relating to meetings Attorney-client communication, handwritten and schedules in support of party/representative work product, notes 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

1261 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes relating to meeting in Attorney-client communication, support of 316(a) party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

262 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

2631Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

264 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

265 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Attorney-client communication, 316(a) demonstration report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

266 Notes N/A N/A N/A Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

267 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes Re: intake total and Party/representative work product, related data in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request. of counsel.

268 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes Re: initial temperature Party/representative work product, at various times in support of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 316(a) demonstration report the direction/request of counsel.

Page 26

,© 269 Diagram N/A N/A N/A Diagram of bug collection Party/representative work product, device and related notes in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 270 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes Re: cost estimate for Party/representative work product, line depressors in connection prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at with 316(a) demonstration the direction/request of counsel.

_report 271 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes regarding 90-99 Party/representative work product, weather data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

272 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes regarding temperature Party/representative work product, data at different stations in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 273 Notes N/A N/A N/A Barely legible notes regarding Party/representative work product, temperature date at different prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at stations in support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 274 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes regarding initial Party/representative work product, temperature at various times prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at m support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 275 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes regarding contact Party/representative work product, information for working prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at parties for in support of the direction/request of counsel.

316(a) demonstration report 276i Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

277 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 27

(

278' Notes N/A N/A D

N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 279 Notes N/A N/A N/A Date and notes support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 280 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 281 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 282 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 283 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 284 Draft N/A N/A N/A Draft memorandum regarding Party/representative work product, memorandum 30 V.S.A. Section 24B prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at with notes criteria with notes in support the direction/request of counsel.

of 316(a) demonstration report 285 Draft N/A N/A N/A Memo regarding compliance Party/representative work product, with Termal standards with prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at notes in support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration report 286 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 287 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 28

K' ©J 0 288 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 289 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 290 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in.anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 291 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 292 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_ _the direction/request of counsel 293 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 294 Draft N/A N/A. N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 295 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 296 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 297 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 298 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

___ _the direction/request of counsel 299 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 29

(

300 Draft N/A N/A N/A

© Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 0

316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 301 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

302 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 303 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data-and notes in-support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 304 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared-in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 305 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 306 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_ _ _ the direction/request of counsel 307 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_ the direction/request of counsel 308 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 309_ _ the direction/request of counsel 309 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 3_ __0_ _ the direction/request of counsel 310 Draft N/A ASA, Inc. N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 311 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared'in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 30

312 Draft N/A N/A 0

N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 313 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 314 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 315 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 316 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 317 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 318 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration-report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 319 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 320 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 321 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 322 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 323 Notes

  • N/A N/A N/A Technical data and notes in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel Page 31

C 0 324 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data and notes in support of Party/representative work product, 316(a) demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 325 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 326 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 327 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 32B Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 329 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 330 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the. direction/request of counsel 331 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 332 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 333 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 334 Draft N/A ASA N/A Draft Quality Check on the Party/representative work product, Thermistor Temperature Data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at in support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel demonstration report Page 32

K) 335 Draft N/A N/A N/A Draft scope of work in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 336 Draft N/A N/A N/A Draft Comments on the Draft Party/representative work product, Third-Party Review of prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Hydrothermal Modeling and the direction/request of counsel 316(a) Demonstration Documents 337 Draft N/A S. McCormick, N/A Draft Review of Proposed Party/representative work product, A. Haro Thermal Limits - Summer prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Period in support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel demonstration reports with subsequent handwritten notes 338 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation,, and at the direction/request of counsel 339 Draft N/A N/A N/A. Draft summary response to. Party/representative work product, ANR letter of 7/11/03 in prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel demonstration report 340 Draft N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

341 Draft N/A ASA N/A Draft response to comments Party/representative work product, provided by Versar on 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration the direction/request of counsel 342 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 343 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel Page 33

(

344 Notes N/A N/A N/A 0

Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 345 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 346 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel 347 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 348 Notes N/A N/A N/A Data in support of 316(a) Party/representative work product, demonstration report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 349 Notes N/A N/A N/A Meeting notes and technical Party/representative work product, data in support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 350 Draft N/A N/A N/A Draft Review of Proposed Party/representative work product, Thermal Limits - Summer prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Period in support of 316(a) the direction/request of counsel demonstration reports 351 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes and technical data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 352 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes and technical data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 353 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes and technical data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at demonstration report the direction/request of counsel 354 Notes N/A N/A N/A Notes and technical data in Party/representative work product, support of 316(a). prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Idemonstration report the direction/request of counsel Page 34

0 Privilege Log: Electronic Mail Communications This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with State of Vermont Public Service Board proceeding No. 6812. ENVY reserves the ri ýht to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No Date/Time Sender Recipients'. Subject Privilege Asserted Various Communication among ENVY attorneys Attorney work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation Various Communication among ENVY consultants Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

1 7/14/03 1:17 PM M. Mattson P. Harmon; Hutchins Correspondence received Attorney-client communication, Consulting; C. Swanson, E. from ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Zoli demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel 2 7/10/03 4:36 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; C. Wells; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, J. Thayer; S. Wender with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

3 7/9/03 9:32 AM L. DeWald C. Wells; J. Thayer; E. Zoli; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, B. Ripley with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

4 7/9/03 7:52 AM L. DeWald C. Wells; J. Thayer; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 1 00

,.j 5 6/26/03 12:44 PM D. Leach L. DeWald; B. Ripley; G. Strategy for comimunication Attorney-client communication, Thomas; D. McElwee; E. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Zoli; E. Buzuvis; S. Wender; demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the M. Desilets; J. Hayward; M. direction/request of counsel.

Mattson; B. Pittman; C.

Nichols 6 6/26/03 9:49 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; G. Thomas; D. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, McElwee; E. Zoli; E. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Buzuvis; S. Wender, M. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Desilets; J. Hayward; M. direction/request of counsel.

Mattson; B. Pittman; D.

Leach 7 6/24/03 11:42 AM L. DeWald G. Thomas; B. Ripley; E. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Zoli; E. Buzuvis; M. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Mattson demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

8 6/9/03 9:23 AM E. Buzuvis B. Ripley; L. DeWald; E. Legal authority for 316(a) Attorney-client communication, Zoli; J. Grachuk demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

9 5/29/03 1:18 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

10 5/29/03 12:35 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

11 5/27/03 1:42 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

Page 2 A

12 5/27/03 1:26 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; S. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Arena with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

13 5/23/03 2:30 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli Cost estimate for services to Attorney-client communication, address ANR review party/representative work product, prepared comments on 316(a) in anticipation of litigation, and at the demonstration direction/request of counsel.

14 5/21/03 2:08 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald Cost estimate for services to Party/representative work product, address ANR review prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at comments on 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration 15 5/20/03 9:22 AM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

16 5/19/03 5:53 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley-, E. Zoli; M. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Mattson with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

17 5/19/03 4:49 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; S. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Arena with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

18 5/19/03 10:02 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald Cost estimate for services to Party/representative work product, address ANR review prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at comments on 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration 19 5/17/03 8:09 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley 316(a) demonstration, data Attorney-client communication, request party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the I_ _direction/request of counsel.

Page 3

20 5/16/03 10:01 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

21 5/16/03 9:34 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

22 5/15/03 3:00 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; S. Arena Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

23 5/14/03 4:07 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

24 5/14/03 3:59 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

25 5/13/03 2:48 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; P. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Harmon timeline party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

26 5/12/03 9:52 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; G. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Thomas analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_ _direction/request of counsel.

27 5/4/03 4:39 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, process party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 4 A

28 5/2/03 3:44 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

29 5/2/03 8:47 AM B. Ripley E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

30 5/1/03 5:34 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; M. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Mattson; J. Craig Swanson; process party/representative work product, prepared M. Hutchinson in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

31 5/1/03 4:38 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, process party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

32 5/1/03 4:27 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, process prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

33 5/1/03 10:07 AM S. McAvoy L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, response to Versar review prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

34 4/29/03 6:53 PM M. Mattson G. Thomas; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstation, Party/representative work product, thermal modeling prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

35 4/29/03 4:31 PM L. DeWald M. Mattson; Hutchins 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Consulting; C. Swanson; E. analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared Zoli; P. Harmon; J. recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward; S. Arena direction/request of counsel.

36 4/29/03 4:09 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; L. DeWald; B. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Ripley; P. Harmon; Hutchins response to Versar review party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; C. Swanson; S. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Arena direction/request of counsel.

Page 5

37 4/29/03 4:03 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, response to Versar review prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

38 4/29/03 1:51 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; E. Zoli; P. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Harmon; Hutchins analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; C. Swanson recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

39 4/28/03 10:06 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; E. Zoli; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Hutchins Consulting; C. analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared Swanson; P. Harmon; B. recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the Ripley; S. Arena direction/request of counsel.

40 4/28/03 3:37 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; M. Mattson; S. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Arena, response to Versar's party/representative work product, prepared comments in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

41 4/28/03 1:40 PM E. Zoli B. Ripley; L. DeWald; M. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Mattson; S. Arena temperature data party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

42 4/28/03 10:52 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; M. Mattson; B. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Ripley with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the

___direction/request of counsel.

43 4/28/03 9:48 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; M. Mattson; B. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Ripley; E. Buzuvis; S. Arena analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_ __ __ _direction/request of counsel.

44 4/25/03 4:10 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, trend Attorney-client communication, analysis party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 6 A

9 45 4/25/03 4:00 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, trend Attorney-client communication, analysis party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

46 4/25/03 1:17 PM L. DeWald S. Arena 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

47 4/25/03 12:27 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; E. Zoli; C. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Swanson; Hutchinson analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared Consulting recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

48 4/23/03 11:56 AM M. Mattson G. Thomas; L. DeWald; E. 316(a) demonstation, Party/representative work product, Schuman; C. Nichols thermal modeling prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

49 4/22/03 4:30 PM G. Thomas M. Mattson; L. DeWald; E. 316(a) demonstation, Party/representative work product, Schuman; C. Nichols thermal modeling prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

50 4/17/03 2:50 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, response to Versar's party/representative work product, prepared comments in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

51 4/17/03 11:30 AM G. Thomas L. DeWald; M. Mattson 316(a) demonstation, Party/representative work product, thermal modeling prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

52 4/16/03 3:05 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

53 4/14/03 4:47 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; M. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Mattson; C. Swanson; M. temperature data party/representative work product, prepared Hutchinson in anticipation. of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

Page 7,

f 54 4/11/03 8:17 AM C. Wells B. Ripley; L. DeWald; M. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Mattson; Hutchins with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; P. Harmon; C. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Swanson; J. Hayward; S. direction/request of counsel.

Wender; V. Brown 55 4/10/03 3:44 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli; M. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Mattson; Hutchinson with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; P. Harmon; C. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Swanson; J. Hayward; S. direction/request of counsel.

Wender; C. Wells; V. Brown 56 4/10/03 3:42 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; M. Mattson; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Hutchinson Consulting; P. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Harmon; C. Swanson; J. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward; S. Wender; C. direction/request of counsel.

Wells; B. Ripley; V. Brown 57 4/8/03 8:36 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald; E. Zoli; P. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Harmon; Hutchinson analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; C. Swanson; B. recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the Ripley; G. Thomas direction/request of counsel.

58 4/7/03 11:31 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

59 4/7/03 10:06 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; M. Mattson; P. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Harmon; Hutchinson analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; C. Swanson; B. recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the Ripley; G. Thomas direction/request of counsel.

Page 8 A

)_.

60 4/7/03 10:33 AM C. Wells L. DeWald; E. Zoli PSB litigation strategy Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

61 4/7/03 9:17 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; C. Wells PSB litigation strategy Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

62 4/7/03 8:02 AM L. DeWald J. Hayward; S. Wender; Z. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Zoli; B. Ripley; C. Wells; analysis of Versar party/representative work product, prepared M. Mattson; P. Harmon; recommendation in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hutchinson Consulting; C. direction/request of counsel.

Swanson; G. Thomas 63 3/24/03 8:50 AM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

64 3/22/03 1:40 PM L. DeWald Z. Zoli; S. Arena; J. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Hayward; B. Ripley analysis of Versar progress party/representative work product, prepared report in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

65 3/21/03 4:42 PM P. Harmon L. DeWald; M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, response to Versar progress prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at 66__ _report the direction/request of counsel.

66 3/21/03 3:21 PM P. Harmon L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representatiVe work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

67 3/21/03 2:53 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 9

(

~N2 0 68 3/21/03 12:11 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

69 3/21/03 11:46 AM L. DeWald, E. Zoli; M. Mattson; P. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Harmon; C. Swanson; with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Hutchinson Consulting; J. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward ' direction/request of counsel.

70 3/21/03 11:38 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; J. Hayward 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar progress report party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

71 3/21/03 9:59 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; J. Hayward 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

72 3/20/03 12:44 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

73 3/20/03 10:16 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; C. Wells; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

74 3/20/03 10:10 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; C. Wells; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

75 3/19/03 7:25 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; C. Wells; B. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Ripley; E. Buzuvis; S. Arena with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 10 A

76 3/19/03 1:05 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; S. Arena; C. Wells; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, B. Ripley with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

77 3/19/03 10:04 AM M. Mattson G. Thomas; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hourly flow data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

78 3/18/03 2:03 PM G. Thomas M. Mattson; L. DeWald; E. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, Zoli; J. Hayward C. Nichols strategy party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the I _direction/request of counsel.

79 3/18/03 10:43 AM E. Zoli B. Ripley; L. DeWald; G. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, Thomas; M. Mattson; P. strategy party/representative work product, prepared Harmon; C. Wells; J. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward; S. Arena direction/request of counsel.

80 3/18/03 9:58 AM B. Ripley L. DeWald; G. Thomas; E. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, Zoli; M. Mattson; P. strategy party/representative work product, prepared Harmon; C. Wells; J. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward direction/request of counsel.

81 3/18/03 9:50 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; S. Arena; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, E. Buzuvis Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

82 3/18/03 9:29 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; C. Wells; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, S. Arena; E. Buzuvis Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

83 3/17/03 4:28 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli; C. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Wells; S. Arena with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Idirection/request of counsel.

Page 11

84 3/17/03 3:34 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; C. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Wells; S. Arena Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at .the direction/request of counsel.

85 3/17/03 2:44 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; C. Wells; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, S. Arena Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

87 3/12/03 1:31 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

88 3/12/03 10:10 AM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli; S. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Arena; J. Hayward; C. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Wells; G. Thomas; C. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Nichols; S. Wender direction/request of counsel.

89 3/12/03 9:38 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; S. Arena; B. Ripley; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward; C. Wells; G. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Thomas; C. Nichols; S. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Wender direction/request of counsel.

90 3/11/03 11:01 AM H. Palaia L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

91 3/11/03 10:58 AM H. Palaia L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

92 3/10/03 9:31 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald; P. Harmon; C. 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, Swanson prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 12

93 3/4/03 5:41 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; J. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Hayward Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

94 3/4/03 4:02 PM L. Cable L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, thermal modeling plan prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

9,95 3/3/03 7:17 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel..

96 2126/03 2:56 PM E. Zoli J. Hayward; B. Ripley; M. 3 16(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Mattson; L. DeWald; S. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Arena in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

97 2/26/03 1:48 PM E. Zoli B. Ripley; J. Hayward; S. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Arena; L. DeWald; M. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Mattson; in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

98 2/21/03 10:51 AM E. Zoli B. Ripley; C. Wells; S. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Arena Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

  • __direction/request of counsel.

99 2/21/03 10:23 AM E. Zoli M. Mattson; S. Arena 316(a) demonstation, RIS Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

  • direction/request of counsel.

100 2/20/03 5:11 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration, study Attorney-client communication, DeWald plan party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 13

C) 101 2/20/03 3:35 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration, study Attorney-client communication, DeWald; S. Arena plan party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

102 2/20/03 3:14 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; C. Wells; S. Arena; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, L. DeWald; E. Buzuvis with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

103 2/19/03 7:08 PM G. Thomas S. Schuyler; D. Yasi; M. 316(a) demonstration, ASA party/representative work product, prepared Mattson Evaporative Study in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

104 2/19/03 5:34 PM D. Yasi M. Mattson; G. Thomas; G. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Franklin; Hutchins evaporation report party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; E. O'Brien; V. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Chepeleff; J. Downing direction/request of counsel.

105 2/19/03 5:09 PM M. Mattson D. Yasi; G. Thomas; M. 3 16(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Hutchins evaporation report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

106 2/19/03 10:23 AM M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting; L. 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, DeWald data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

107 2/19/03 10:08 AM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar review party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

108 2/18/03 2:07 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration, study Attorney-client communication, DeWald; C. Wells; B. plan party/representative work product, prepared Ripley; Hutchins in anticipation of litigation, and at the Consulting;!C. Swanson; S. direction/request of counsel.

Arena Page 14

109 2/18/03 1:49 PM P. Harmon L. DeWald; C. Wells; E. 316(a) demonstration, study Attorney-client communication, Zoli; B. Ripley; M. Mattson; plan party/representative work product, prepared Hutchins Consulting; C. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Swanson; S. Arena direction/request of counsel.

110 2/18/03 12:56 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; S. Arena 316(a) demonstration, study Attorney-client communication, plan party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

111 2/18/03 11:35 AM G. Thomas M. Mattson; D. Yasi 316(a) demonstration, ASA Party/representative work product, Evaporative Study prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

112 2/17/03 6:24 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; L. DeWald; P. 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, Harmon; S. Arena revisions party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

113 2/17/03 5:41 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; S. Arena 316(a) demonstration, study Attorney-client communication, plan party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

114 2/17/03 5:34 PM L. DeWald M. Desilets; K. Bronson; M. NPDES permit amendment Attorney-client communication, Balduzzi; J. Thayer; G. proposal party/representative work product, prepared Thomas; C. Nichols; B. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Ripley; E. Zoli; C. Wells; M. direction/request of counsel.

Mattson; P. Harmon; C.

Swanson; S. Wender 115 2/17/03 5:18 PM L. DeWald P. Harmon, C. Wells; E. NPDES permit amendment Attorney-client communication, Zoli; B. Ripley; M. Mattson; proposal party/representative work product, prepared Hutchins Consulting; C. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Swanson; S. Arena direction/request of counsel.

Page 15

116 2/17/03 11:28 AM M. Mattson P. Harmon; L. DeWald; C. 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, Swanson; Hutchins prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Consulting the direction/request of counsel.

117 2/17/03 11:17 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald; C. Swanson Cost estimate for services to Party/representative work product, address ANR review prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at comments on 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration 118 2/17/03 10:48 AM B. Ripley L. DeWald; P. Harmon; M. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Mattson; Hutchins with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Consulting; C. Swanson; E. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Zoli; C. Wells; R. Gerdus; direction/request of counsel.

M. Desilets; S. Wender 119 2/17/03 10:21 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, study Party/representative work product, plan prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

120 2/16/03 1:59 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report, Party/representative work product, temperature data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

121 2/16/03 1:54 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report, Party/representative work product, temperature data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

122 2/15/03 4:42 PM M. Mattson P. Harmon; L. DeWald; E. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Zoli party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

123 2/15/03 4:26 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; J. Cosco 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 16

0

/

124 2/15/03 2:02 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; C. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Wells with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

125 2/14/03 2:32 PM S. Arena M. Mattson; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, DeWald party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

126 2/14/03 12:10 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

127 2/14/03 12:10 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; P. Harmon; S. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

128 2/14/03 12:07 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, DeWald; S. Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

129 2/14/03 10:50 AM M. Mattson E. Zoli; L. DeWald; P. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Harmon; S. Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_ _ _direction/request of counsel.

130 2/14/03 10:49 AM M. M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Hutchinson hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

131 2/14/03 10:07 AM M. Mattson E. Zoli; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, DeWald; S. Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 17

0 132 2/13/03 4:01 PM E. Zoli P. Harmon; L. DeWald; M. 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, Mattson; S. Arena revisions party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

133 2/13/03 3:21 PM P. Harmon E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

134 2/13/03 3:17 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; L. DeWald; S. 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, Arena; E. Buzuvis revisions party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

135 2/13/03 2:19 PM S. Arena L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

136 2/13/03 1:01 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

137 2/13/03 12:05 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

138 2/13/03 10:28 AM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

139 2/13/03 8:51 AM D. Yasi M. Mattson; L. DeWald; G. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Thomas evaporation report prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

140 2/13/03 8:32 AM J. Anderson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at L_ the direction/request of counsel.

Page 18

0 141 2/12/03 6:58 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

142 2/12/03 5:38 PM P. Harmon E. Zoli; L. DeWald; M. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Mattson party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_ _ _direction/request of counsel.

143 2/12/03 5:31 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

144 2/12/03 3:51 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; C. 316(a) demonstration Attorney-client communication, Wells process party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

145 2/12/03 2:47 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

146 2/11/03 7:07 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; L. DeWald; B. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Ripley; P. Harmon; C. party/representative work product, prepared Wells; C. Swanson in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

147 2/11/03 11:37 AM M. Mattson E. Zoli; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, DeWald; B. Ripley; C. revisions party/representative work product, prepared Swanson; C. Wells in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

148 2/11/03 10:46 AM E. Zoli M. Mattson; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-clientcommunication, DeWald; B. Ripley; C. party/representative work product, prepared Wells; C. Swanson in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 19

0 7)

,....j 149 2/11/03 10:30 AM M. Mattson E. Zoli; P. Harmon; L. De 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, Wald; B. Ripley; C. Wells revisions party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

150 2/10/03 10:02 AM E. Zoli M. Mattson; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, DeWald; B. Ripley; C. revisions party/representative work product, prepared Wells in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

151 2/5/03 4:14 PM S. Arena L. DeWald; C. Wells Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

152 2/3/03 5:34 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report, Attorney-client communication, revisions party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

153 2/3/03 5:15 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; P. Harmon; L. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, DeWald party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

154 2/3/03 5:06 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; L. DeWald; S. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

155 2/3/03 3:13 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 20

0 156 2/3/03 11:14 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley, E. Zoli; M. 316(a) demonstration Attorney-client communication, Mattson; P. Harmon; C. planning meetings party/representative work product, prepared Swanson; C. Wells; J. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward; S. Wender; V. direction/request of counsel.

Brown; G. Franklin 157 2/3/03 7:58 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration data Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

158 2/2/03 9:52 PM M. Mattson C. Swanson; P Harmon; 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, Hutchins Consulting; L. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at DeWald the direction/request of counsel.

159 2/2/03 6:13 PM M. Mattson Hutchins Consulting; L. 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, DeWald; P Harmon; C. prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Swanson the direction/request of counsel.

160 1/31/03 5:13 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

161 1/31/03 9:00 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; C. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Wells; J. Hayward; S. Arena Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

162 1/31/03 8:26 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; C. Wells; E. Zoli; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

163 1/30/03 5:08 PM M. Mattson 0. Thomas; L. DeWald; P. 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, Harmon data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 21

q 164 1/30/03 11:38 AM E. Zoli J. Hayward; P. Harmon; M. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Mattson; L. DeWald; S. party/representative work product, prepared Arena in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

165 1/30/03 10:05 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; M. Mattson; S. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

166 1/29/03 6:39 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, data Attorney-client communication, request party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

167 1/29/03 10:52 AM E. Zoli M. Mattson; G. Thomas; C. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Wells; S. Arena cooling tower performance party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

168 1/27/03 11:45 AM C. Swanson M. Mattson; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

169 1/27/03 11:44 AM C. Swanson M. Mattson; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

170 1/27/03 11:43 AM C. Swanson M. Mattson; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

171 1/27/03 11:42 AM C. Swanson M. Mattson; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

172 1/22/03 10:03 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; J. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Hayward Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

__direction/request of counsel.

Page 22

173 1/22/03 9:38 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

174 1/21/03 12:36 PM L. DeWald P. Harmon; M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

175 1/20/03 5:10 PM L. Cantrell L. DeWald NPDES permit strategy and Party/representative work product, proposed power uprate prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

176 1/20/03 2:51 PM B. Ripley B. Ripley; C. Wells; E. Zoli; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward; L. DeWald; S. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Schuyler demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

177 1/17/03 10:10 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; M. Mattson; B. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Ripley; S. Arena; E. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Buzuvis; J. Hayward; S. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Wender direction/request of counsel.

178 1/16/03 4:07 PM M. Mattson P. Harmon; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

179 1/16/03 3:11 PM M. Mattson P. Harmon; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

180 1/16/03 1:10 PM E. Zoli B. Ripley; L. DeWald; J. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Hayward; S. Wender; M. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Mattson; S. Arena; C. Wells; demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the E. Buzuvis direction/request of counsel.

Page 23

U 181 1/16/03 1:05 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; J. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Hayward; S. Wender; M. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Mattson; S. Arena; C. Wells; demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the E. Buzuvis direction/request of counsel.

182 1/16/03 12:23 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; J. Hayward; B. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Ripley; S. Wender; M. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Mattson in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

183 1/16/03 12:22 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; J. Hayward; B. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Ripley; S. Wender; M. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Mattson; S. Arena; C. Wells; in anticipation of litigation, and at the E. Buzuvis direction/request of counsel.

184 1/16/03 11:35 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; J. Hayward; B. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Ripley; S. Wender; M. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Mattson; S. Arena; C. Wells; in anticipation of litigation, and at the E. Buzuvis direction/request of counsel.

185 1/15/03 5:25 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; M. Mattson; P. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, Harmon; J. Hayward; S. strategy party/representative work product, prepared Arena in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

186 1/15/03 5:24 PM M. Mattson P. Harmon; Hutchins 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Consulting; L. DeWald hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

187 1/15/03 3:05 PM B. Ripley B. Ripley; C. Wells; E. Zoli; Strategy for communication Party/representative work product, J. Hayward; L. DeWald; S. with ANR regarding 316(a) prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Schuyler demonstration the direction/request of counsel.

188 1/15/03 11:10 AM M. Mattson P. Harmon; M. Hutchins 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative workproduct, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 24

189 1/1 5/03 10:29 AM B. Ripley E. Zoli; C. Wells; J. Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, Hayward; L. DeWald; S. review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared Schuyler; S. Arena in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

190 1/15/03 8:39 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; I. Hayward; S. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Arena; B. Ripley, E. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Buzuvis; S. Wender in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

191 1/14/03 5:05 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; M. Mattson; J. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Hayward; B. Ripley; S. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Arena; E. Buzuvis in anticipation of litigation, and at the

.___direction/request of counsel.

192 1/14/03 4:16 PM E. Zoli B. Ripley; L. DeWald; C. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Wells; J. Hayward; S. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Schuyler; S. Arena; E. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Buzuvis direction/request of counsel.

193 1/14/03 3:57 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; M. Mattson; P. 31.6(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Harmon; J. Hayward Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

194 1/14/03 3:52 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; C. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Wells; J. Hayward; S. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Schuyler; S. Arena demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

195 1/14/03 12:32 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; C. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Wells; J. Hayward; S. Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared Schuyler; S. Arena in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

196 1/14/03 12:16 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; C. Wells; E. Zoli; 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward; S. Schuyler Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

Page 25

197 1/14/03 11:03 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; S. Arena 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

198 1/14/03 10:22 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; S. Arena 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

199 1/14/03 9:25 AM B. Ripley B. Ripley; C. Wells; E. Zoli; Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward; L. DeWald; S. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Schuyler demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

200 1/13/03 3:06 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

201 1/13/03 10:06 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; C. Selection of Versar to Attorney-client communication, Wells; S. Wender; J. review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared Hayward; G. Thomas; B. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hobbs; M. Mattson; P. direction/request of counsel.

Harmon; C. Nichols; S.

Arena 202 1/13/03 9:57 AM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli; C. Selection of Versar to Attorney-client communication, Wells; S. Wender; J. review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared Thomas; B. Hobbs; M. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Mattson; P. Harmon; C. direction/request of counsel.

Nichols; S. Arena Page 26

203 1/13/03 9:54 AM L. DeWald E. Zoli; B. Ripley; C. Wells; Selection of Versar to Attorney-client communication, S. Wender; J. Hayward; G. review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared Thomas; B. Hobbs; M. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Mattson; P. Harmon; C. direction/request of counsel.

Nichols; S. Arena 204 1/10/03 2:38 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; M. Mattson; P. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, Harmon; G. Thomas; J. strategy party/representative work product, prepared Hayward; C. Wells; V. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Brown; S. Schuyler; S. direction/request of counsel.

Arena 205 1/10/03 2:12 PM L. DeWald M. Mattson; P. Harmon; G. 316(a) data Attorney-client communication, Thomas; E. Zoli; J. party/representative work product, prepared Hayward; C. Wells in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

206 1/10/03 2:09 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; S. Arena NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, strategy party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

207 1/10/03 1:58 PM M. Mattson S. Schuyler; L. DeWald Cost estimate for services to party/representative work product, prepared prepare 316(a) in anticipation of litigation, and at the demonstration direction/request of counsel.

208 1/10/03 12:3 8 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, strategy party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the I_ direction/request of counsel.

209 1/9/03 6:54 PM E. Zoli M. Mattson; L. DeWald; S. 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, Arena party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

Page 27

2101 1/9/03 11:53 AM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; J. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Hayward; C. Wells with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

211 1/8/03 2:36 PM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; J. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Hayward with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

212 1/8/03 2:23 PM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli; J. 316(a) demonstration, Attorney-client communication, Hayward; C. Wells Versar scope of work party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

213 1/2/03 5:19 PM M. Mattson E. Zoli 316(a) demonstration report Attorney-client communication, content party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

214 12/31/02 1:17 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; J. Hayward; B. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Ripley; S. Arena with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

215 12/31/02 11:32 AM E. Zoli B. Ripley; L. DeWald Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the

_direction/request of counsel.

216 12/31/02 11:16 AM B. Ripley E. Zoli; L. DeWald; S. Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, Arena review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 28

/

217 12/31/02 11:11 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley; S. Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, Arena review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

218 12/30/02 3:44 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; B. Hobbs Thermal plume modeling Party/representative work product, scenarios prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

2191 12/20/02 1:11 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald Selection of consultant to Party/representative work product, review 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

220 12/16/02 10:59 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Ripley Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

221 12/16/02 9:54 AM B. Ripley L. DeWald; E. Zoli; C. Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, Wells; J. Hayward review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

222 12/13/02 6:16 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

223 12/13/02 5:33 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, information needs for prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at thermal modeling the direction/request of counsel.

224 12/9/02 4:20 PM L. DeWald B. Ripley; E. Zoli; C. Wells Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

2251 12/9/02 2:22 PM J. Childs L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 29

2261 12/9/02 1:21 PM J. Childs D

L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

227 12/9/02 1:06 PM J. Childs L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

228 12/9/02 12:32 PM L. DeWald C. Nichols; G. Thomas; S. Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, Wender; E. Zoli; C. Wells; review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared V. Brown; B. Ripley; D. in anticipation of litigation, and at the Leach; B. Hobbs; J. direction/request of counsel.

Hayward 229 12/8/02 5:12 PM J. Childs L. DeWald; B. Hobbs; G. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Thomas; M. Mattson; hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Hutchins Consulting the direction/request of counsel.

230 12/8/02 5:09 PM J. Childs L. DeWald; B. Hobbs; G. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Thomas; M. Mattson; hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Hutchins Consulting .the direction/request of counsel.

231 12/8/02 5:05 PM J. Childs L. DeWald; B. Hobbs; G. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Thomas; M. Mattson; hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Hutchins Consulting the direction/request of counsel.

232 12/8/02 5:00 PM J. Childs L. DeWald; B. Hobbs; G. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Thomas; M. Mattson; hydrothermal analysis prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Hutchins Consulting the direction/request of counsel.

233 12/6/02 4:23 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; C. Wells; B. Ripley; Selection of consultant to Attorney-client communication, J. Hayward review 316(a) demonstration party/representative work product, prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

234 12/6/02 3:40 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; B. Hobbs; G. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, Thomas; Hutchins hydrothermal modeling prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at Consulting; S. Ward assumptions the direction/request of counsel.

Page 30

235 12/3/02 12:36 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

236 11/27/02 12:53 PM G. Thomas C. Wells; B. Hobbs; B. VY EPU Environmental & Attorney-client communication, Cosgrove; D. McElwee; M. CPG meeting to discuss party/representative work product, prepared Potkin: W. Stone: J. Bonner: NPDES and CPG effort in anticipation of litigation, and at the L. DeWald: J. Hayward; S. direction/request of counsel.

Wender; G. Franklin; S.

Schuyler; V. Brown; E. Zoli; P. Boemig 237 11/26/02 4:58 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

238 11/26/02 12:14 PM L. DeWald E. Zoli; V. Brown; S. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Wender; J. Hayward; B. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Hobbs; G. Thomas; R. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Gerdus; C. Wells; E. direction/request of counsel.

Buzuvis; S. Arena 239 11/26/02 11:24 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; V. Brown; S. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Wender, J. Hayward; B. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Hobbs; G. Thomas; R. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Gerdus; C. Wells; E. direction/request of counsel.

Buzuvis; S. Arena 240 11/20/02 2:34 PM J. Anderson B. Slifer; D. Yasi; L. 316(a) demonstration, plant Attorney-client communication, DeWald; B. Williams; M. data party/representative work product, prepared Benoit; B. Hobbs; P. Perez in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

241 11/19/02 2:31 PM J. Anderson M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at

_the direction/request of counsel.

Page 31

242 11/18/02 4:31 PM J. Anderson M. Mattson; L. DeWald; S. 316(a)demonstration,_plant Party/representative work product, Ward data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

243 11/18/02 4:30 PM J. Anderson M. Mattson; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

244 11/18/02 9:41 AM J. Anderson M. Mattson; L. DeWald; L. 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, Edward data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

245 11/18/02 9:17 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

246 11/18/02 8:12 AM J. Anderson M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

2471 11/15/02 1:06 PM M. Mattson J. Anderson 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

248 11/13/02 3:43 PM J. Anderson M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

249 11/13/02 3:38 PM J. Anderson M. Mattson 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

250 11/12/02 7:02 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; P. Harmon Selection of consultant to Party/representative work product, review 316(a) demonstration prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

251 11/12/02 6:36 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald; J. Anderson; S. 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, Ward; Hutchins Consulting data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

252 1 /l 2/02 5:45 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald. 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, hydrothermal modeling prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at assumptions the direction/request of counsel.

Page 32

253 .11/12/02 7:39 AM J. Anderson M. Mattson; L. DeWald 0

316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

254 11/8/02 11:13 AM M. Mattson P. Harmon; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, Party/representative work product, representative important prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at species the direction/request of counsel.

255 11/7/02 6:21 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald Cost estimate for services to Party/representative work product, address ANR review prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at comments on 316(a) the direction/request of counsel.

demonstration 256 11/5/02 5:20 PM E. Zoli L. DeWald; B. Hobbs; C. Strategy for communication Attorney-client communication, Wells; D. McElwee; D. with ANR regarding 316(a) party/representative work product, prepared Mathur; G. Franklin; J. demonstration in anticipation of litigation, and at the Hayward; M. Mattson; P. direction/request of counsel.

Harmon; R. Felumb; R.

Gerdus; S. Wender; S.

Schuyler; T. Brush; V.

Brown; S. Arena; C. Wells; V. Brown 257 11/5/02 5:10 PM E. Zoli B. Hobbs; C. Wells; D. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, McElwee; 1). Mathur; G. strategy party/representative work product, prepared Franklin; J. Hayward; L. in anticipation of litigation, and at the DeWald; M. Mattson; P. direction/request of counsel.

Harmon; R. Felumb; R.

Gerdus; S. Wender; S.

Schuyler; T. Brush; V.

Brown; S. Arena 258 11/4/02 5:49 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

Page 33

259 11/4/02 4:58 PM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, 0

request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

260 11/4/02 4:54 PM M. Mattson B. Hobbs; L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, data Party/representative work product, request prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

261 10/30/02 8:49 AM M. Mattson L. DeWald 316(a) demonstration, plant Party/representative work product, data prepared in anticipation of litigation, and at the direction/request of counsel.

262 10/24/02 5:47 PM E. Zoli B. Hobbs; C. Wells; D. NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, McElwee; D. Mathur; G. strategy party/representative work product, prepared Franklin; J. Hayward; L. in anticipation of litigation, and at the DeWald; M. Mattson; P. direction/request of counsel.

Harmon; R. Felumb; R.

Gerdus; S. Wender; S.

Schuyler; T. Brush; V.

Brown; S. Arena 263 10/4/02 11:58 AM E. Zoli L. DeWald; S. Arena NPDES/316(a) legal Attorney-client communication, strategy party/representative work product in anticipation of litigation Page 34

Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding Privilege Log for Documents Determined Relevant and Responsive to NEC Contentions Initial Disclosure, October 23, 2006 Date From To Document Title Privilege Asserted 11/03/2005 R. L. NPDES required sampling Work Product. Prepared at the request of Buckley DeWald for permit renewal counsel in anticipation of litigation.

t~i1 400474951vl

Privilege Lon for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvoe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privile-ge Asserted Document 1 eMail With Attachment 3/2112004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 2 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 3 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 4 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 5 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product -. ii 6 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product I.

7 eMail With Attachments 3/21/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 4.

8 eMail 3/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 9 eMail 3/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product

'S 10 eMail 3/17/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 11 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - I, 12 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - *4 13 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - f4 14 eMail With Attachments 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - 4' 15 eMail With Attachment 3/16/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 16 eMail 3/16/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 17 eMail With Attachment 3/15/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - 4' 18 eMail With Attachment 3/15/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - 4, 19 eMail With Attachments 3/15/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - a, 20 JeMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 21 _ eMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins iHydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - I.

22 eMail With Attachments 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - I' 23 eMail 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product

  • I, 24 eMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - IL 25 eMail With Attachment 3/14/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - *8 26 eMail 3/13/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - I, 27 eMail With Attachment 3/11/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 28 eMail With Attachments 3/10/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins. Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product -. 1/

29 eMail With Attachments 3/9/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - I' 30 eMail With Attachments 3/9/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 31 eMail With Attachment 3/9/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications - I, with ANR regarding NPDES 316(a) Demonstration

~.Ii Page 1

Th Privilege Loc for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tyeof Date Author/Sender Rcient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 32 eMail With Attachment 319/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report 33 eMail With Attachment 3/8/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Report 34 eMail With Attachment 3/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 35 eMail With Attachment 3/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 36 eMail With Attachments 3/7/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling ?W 04 37 eMail With Attachments 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; George Thomas; Mark Hutchins; pre-Craig Swanson 38 eMail 3/5/2004 Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; Mark Grachuk, Jeanine L 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Hutchins: Mark Harmon G 39 eMail With Attachment 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 40 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 41 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Mattson Rick Simmons; Terry 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Euston; Doug Royer; Alex Gonyaw; Mark Hutchins 42 eMail With Attachments 3/2/2004 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling I 43 eMail 3/1/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Page 2 V

K)J Privilege Loci for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 44 eMail 2/27/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Fisheries data Attorney Work Product - I, 45 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product -I 46 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 47 eMail 2/13/2004 Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 48 eMail 5/31/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES -~'~ S/o6) 49 eMail 5/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward I Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 50 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward I Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 51 eMail 5/12/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson _Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 52 eMail With Attachment 5/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 53 eMail 4/26/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product -'4 54 eMail With Attachments 4/21/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 55 eMail With Attachments 4/20/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration; ~8 Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR 56 eMail 4/19/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - 1' 57 eMail 4/18/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - (I 58 eMail 4/17/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - It 59 eMail With Attachment 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 60 eMail 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 61 eMail 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - ~1 62 eMail 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 63 eMail With Attachment 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - 4I 64 eMail 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 65 eMail 4/10/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - ii 66 eMail With Attachment 4/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

- Ii Hydrothermal modeling 67 eMail 4/9/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - it Page 3

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 68 eMail 4/8/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 69 eMail With Attachment 4/8/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 70 eMail With Attachment 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 71 eMail With Attachment 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 72 eMail With Attachment 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product SIA 73 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 74 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 75 eMail 4/5/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product .44 76 eMail 3/30/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 77 eMail With Attachment 12/5/2005 Mark Hutchins; Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 78 eMail With Attachment 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 79 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 80 eMail With Attachment 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 81 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 82 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 316(a) Demonstration 83 eMail 11/30/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 84 eMail With Attachment 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 85 eMail With Attachment 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 86 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 87 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 88 eMail With Attachment 10/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communication with ANR Page 4

0 Privilegie Loq for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tyoe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 89 eMail With Attachment 10/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ct Hydrothermal modeling 90 eMail 10/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 91 eMail 8/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 92 eMail 8/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 93 eMail With Attachment 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product

  • It modeling 94 eMail 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - U 95 eMail 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 96 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product a' modeling 97 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 98 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - CL 99 eMail With Attachment 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 100 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 101 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - 'S 102 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product - IC 103 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 104 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 105 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling" Attorney Work Product Ic 106 eMail With Attachment 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling - LI 107 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward; Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 108 eMail With Attachment 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration; Correspondence relating to strategy for communications .

with ANR 109 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 'I 110 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 111 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modelin Attorney Work Product II Page 5

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subect Privilee Asserted Document 112 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 113 eMail 8/4/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 114 eMail 8/412004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 115 eMail With Attachment 81212004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications It with AN R regarding NPDES 116 eMail 8/1/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product tt 117 eMail 7/31/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 118 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 119 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 120 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 121 eMail 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 122 email 7/30/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 123 _email 7/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 124 eMail With Attachment 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 125 email 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 126 email 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 127 email 7/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 128 email 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 129 email 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 130 eMail With Attachment 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 131 eMail With Attachment 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 132 email 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 133 email 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 134 email 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 135 email 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 136 email 7124/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 137 email 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 138 email 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 139 email 7/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 140 eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 141 eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 142 eMail 7/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 143 eMail 7/20/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling Page 6

C Privile-ge Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 144 eMail 5/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 145 eMail With Attachment 4/29/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 146 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 147 eMail With Attachment 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 148 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 149 eMail 4/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 150 eMail With Attachment 4/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 151 eMail With Attachment 4/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 152 eMail 4/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 153 eMail With Attachment 4/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 154 eMail 4/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 155 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 156 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 157 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 158 eMail 4/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 159 eMail 4/22/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 160 eMail 4/22/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 161 eMail 4/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 162 eMail With Attachment 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Paul Lindsay, 163 - eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 164 eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 165 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 166 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 167 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 168 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 169 eMail _ 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 170 eMail 4/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 171 eMail 4/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 172 eMail 4/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 173 eMail 4/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 174 eMail 4/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 175 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 176 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 177 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 178 eMail 4/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 179 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 7

0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Reci*ient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 180 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 181 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 182 eMail 41812004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 183 eMail 4/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 184 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 185 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 186 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 187 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 188 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 189 eMail 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 190 eMail 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 191 eMail 312612004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 192 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Attorney Work Product 193 eMail 3/19/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 194 eMail 3/19/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 195 eMail 3/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 196 eMail 3/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 197 eMail 3/17/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 198 eMail 3/17/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 199 eMail 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 200 eMail 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 201 eMail 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 202 eMail 3/14/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 203 eMail 3/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 204 eMail 3/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 205 eMail 3/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 206 eMail 3/11/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 207 eMail 3/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 208 eMail 3/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 209 eMail 3/9/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 210 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 211 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 212 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 213 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 214 eMail 3/3/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 215 eMail 3/1/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 216 eMail 2/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 217 eMail 2/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 8

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tyrpe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 218 eMail 2/27/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 219 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 220 eMail 2/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 221 eMail 1/23/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 222 eMail 6/16/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; David Lewis; Wender IV,Samuel; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ricky Buckley; Ricky McElwee, David; permit appeal Buckle; Mark Mattson Metell, Mike; Hoffman, John; Burke, Terence A; Rademacher, Norman L 223 eMail 5/5/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product permit appeal 224 eMail 4/26/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; E permit appeal Zoli; Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay 225 eMail 4/18/2006 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Zoli, Elise N; Mark permit appeal Mattson; Thomas, George; DeWald, Lynn 226 eMail 3/30/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Mark Mattson; Zoli, permit appeal Elise N; Barbara Ripley; Smith, Sharon 227 eMail 3/30/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn; McCullough, Travis; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara Burke, Terence A; Ripley; Thomas, George; Sloan, Robert D Thayer, Jay; McElwee, David Page 9

0 0 Privilege Loa for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvpe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 228 eMail 3/29/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay; McElwee, Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication David McCullough, Travis; Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Wender IV,Samuel 229 eMail 3/29/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Wender IV,Samuel Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 230 eMail 3/28/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald, Lynn strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 231 eMail With Attachment 3/24/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 232 eMail 3/22/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Mark Mattson; Elise 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Lynn Zoli; McCullough, Travis 233 eMail 3/21/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication 234 eMail 3/19/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Thomas, George; Barbara Wender IV,Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; E Zoli; DeWald, Lynn 235 eMail 3/18/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Thomas, George; Barbara Wender IV, Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; E Zoli; DeWald, Lynn 236 eMail 3/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Mark Mattson; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication I Ripley Elise N Page 10

( ~\

K) I Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7, 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 237 eMail 3/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Mark Mattson; Zoli, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Lynn Elise N Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 238 eMail 3/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Zoli, strategy for communications Elise N with ANR regarding NPDES 239 eMail 2/20/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Williams, UGwyn; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Mattson 240 eMail 2/14/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 241 eMail 2/13/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Aft 13 alff-strategy for communications imn A&ý with ANR regarding NPDES ap

ý1' ocýt-ýc 242 eMail 2/8/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli 243 eMail 2/8/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli 244 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 245 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES Page 11

Privilege Loci for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 246 eMail 2/7/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 247 eMail 217/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 248 eMail 2/6/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 249 eMail 2/3/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Elise permit appeal Zoli 250 eMail With Attachment 1/31/2006 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Zoli, Elise N; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Mattson 251 eMail 1/27/2006 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mark Mattson; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson Barbara Ripley; permit appeal Wender IV,Samuel; Zoli, Elise N 252 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson; Zoli, strategy for communications Elise N; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 253 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal Page 12

F" L.J Privilegie Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 254 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 255 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 256 eMail 12/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Thayer, Jay; Smith, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Sharon strategy for communications Zoli, Elise N; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES; David Fisheries data 257 eMail 12/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Zoli, Elise N Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 258 eMail 12/8/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thayer, Jay; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 259 eMail 12/8/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thayer, Jay; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 260 eMail 12/8/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, McCullough, Travis; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Mark Mattson; Burke, Terence A strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay; with ANR regarding NPDES Buckley, Ricky N 261 eMail 12/8/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, McCullough, Travis; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Mark Mattson; Burke, Terence A strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay; with ANR regarding NPDES Buckley, Ricky N Page 13

K) 0 Privile-ge Log for Documents Throuqh December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 262 eMail 12/7/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay; McElwee, Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Wender IV,Samuel; McCullough, Travis; with ANR regarding NPDES; DeWald, Lynn Burke, Terrence A Fisheries data 263 eMail 12/7/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay; McElwee, Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Wender IV,Samuel; McCullough, Travis; with ANR regarding NPDES; DeWald, Lynn Burke, Terence A Fisheries data 264 eMail 12/7/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 265 eMail 12/7/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, McElwee, David Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Tim Brush; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Wender IV, with ANR regarding NPDES Samuel; Farquharson, Don 266 eMail 12/6/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES;

_Fisheries data 267 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; A"A Fisheries data ajeýý 266 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 269 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 14

0 D Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 270 eMail 12/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 271 eMail 12/512005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 272 eMail 12/1/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 273 eMail 11/30/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; David Rocchio strategy for communications Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay with ANR regarding NPDES 274 eMail 11/22/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 275 eMail 10/2412005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara strategy for communications Ripley; Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES Thayer, Jay; McElwee, David 276 eMail 10/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 277 eMail 10/18/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson 278 eMail 10/18/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Buckley, Ricky N ; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson Wender IV,Samuel; Thayer, Jay; Georgian, Kathryn A; Mason, Elizabeth F

Page 15

0 Privilege Loa for Documents Throuqh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvpe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 279 eMail 10/13/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 280 eMail 10/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication 281 eMail 10/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication e64r4 Lynn; McElwee, David; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Thayer, Jay 282 eMail 10/5/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Yasi, Dan; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson George strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 283 eMail 10/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; McElwee, David; Thomas, George 284 eMail 10/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Thayer, Jay; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Barbara strategy for communications Ripley; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George; Wender IV, Samuel 285 eMail 10/4/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay; with ANR regarding NPDES McElwee, David; Thomas, George 286 eMail 9/20/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George 287 eMail 9/20/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Peter Van Cot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES George Page 16

0 Privi ege Log for Documents Throuaqh December 7, 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 288 eMail 9/9/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications McElwee, David; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES George; Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay 289 eMail 8/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David Peter Van Oot with ANR regarding NPDES 290 eMail 5/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Wender IV,Samuel; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George 291 eMail 8/11/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Peter Van with ANR regarding NPDES Oot 292 eMail 8/11/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; DeWald, Wender IV,Samuel Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Thomas, George; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES Ripley; Peter Van Oot 293 eMail 8/11/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Peter Van with ANR regarding NPDES Oot 294 eMail 8/1/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson Page 17

(

0 q Privile-ge Loc for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 295 eMail 7/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Wender IV, Samuel Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thayer, Jay; strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Thomas, George 316(a) Demonstration 296 eMail 7/25/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 297 eMail 7/20/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Thayer, Jay; Mark Mattson 298 eMail 7/13/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Thomas, Wender IV, Samuel; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication George; DeWald, Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Mark Mattson Sloan, Robert D 299 eMail 7/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McEtwee, David; Thomas, Wender IV, Samuel; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication George; DeWald, Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Mark Mattson Sloan, Robert D 300 eMail 6/6/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 301 eMail 5/612005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Product ____

Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 302 eMail 4/29/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Nutter, Victor Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; Mark Product Mattson; Thomas, George Page 18

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 303 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work David; DeWald, Lynn; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES; Thomas, George 316(a) Demonstration 304 eMail 4/27/2005 Barlow, Chuck D McElwee, David; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Elise Correspondence relating to Product Zoli; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 305 eMail 4/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson; Zoli, Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product Alt Elise N; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES 306 eMail 4/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product Zoli, Elise N with ANR regarding NPDES 307 eMail 4/14/2005 Barlow, Chuck 0 Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 308 eMail 4/14/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 309 eMail 3/30/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Barbara strategy for communications Product Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES Page 19

K>

Privilege Loci for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvpe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privileg e Asserted Document 310 eMail 3/23/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES; Barbara Ripley Versar Report Tf-f--

311 eMail 3/17/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to Product Thomas, George; McElwee, strategy for communications David; Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 312 eMail 3/16(2005 Barlow, Chuck 0 Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; McElwee, strategy for communications Product David; DeWald, Lynn; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Elise Zoli 313 eMail 3/16/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work David; Thomas, George; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; DeWald, with ANR regarding NPDES Lynn; Elise Zoli 314 eMail 2/2/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Thomas, DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George strategy for communications Attorney Work Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 315 eMail 1/28/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas, George; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; Tim Brush Fisheries data 316 eMail 1/28/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 20 J7

0 K)

Privilege Loc for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 317 eMail 1/21/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Barbara Thayer, Jay; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George strategy for communications Product Wender IV,Samuel; Elise with ANR regarding NPDES; Zoli; Thomas, George; Tim Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Brush modeling ~_-o~c(

j 318 eMail 1/19/2005 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Thayer, Jay; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Wender IV,Samuel; Thomas, George strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli; Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; Mark Mattson; Tim Brush Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 319 eMail 1/12/2005 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Barbara McCullough, Travis 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Product Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 320 eMail 11/4/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to Product DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 321 eMail 11/2/2004 Barlow, Chuck D Zoli, Elise N; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to Product DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 322 eMail 11/2/2004 Barlow, Chuck 0 Barbara Ripley; Zoli, Elise 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mason, Elizabeth F; Correspondence relating to Product DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 21

K> /

Privileqe Loa for Documents Througqh December 7, 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 323 eMail 9/16/2004 Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Thomas, Report Product George; Barbara Ripley 324 eMail 9/20/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 325 eMail With Attachment 7/9/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data; Versar Report 326 eMail 7/7/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data; Versar Report 327 eMail With Attachments 7/7/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data; Versar Report 328 eMail 6/28/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson; DeWald, Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn Zoli, Elise N Product 329 eMail With Attachment 6/27/2006 Concannon, Sarah DeWald, Lynn; Mark Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Zoli, Elise N Product 330 eMail With Attachment 6/13/2006 Concannon, Sarah Mark Mattson; Mark Zoli, Elise N; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Hutchins Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product DeWald, Lynn with ANR regarding NPDES 331 eMail 10/13/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Lewis, David R; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Zoli, Elise N; strategy for communications Barlow, Chuck D; with ANR regarding NPDES Gordon, Anne T 332 eMail 10/12/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Burke, Lewis, David R; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Terrence A; Zoli, Elise N; Scott Vance; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; Mark Wender IV, Samuel; with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Vekasy, Steve; Metell, Mike Thomas, George Page 22

0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 333 eMail 10/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 334 eMail 9/30/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Lewis, David R Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Metell, Mike; with ANR regarding NPDES Wender IV,Samuel; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Burke, Terence A 335 eMail 9/28/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Buckley, Ricky N; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication N; Lewis, David R Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Metell, Mike; with ANR regarding NPDES Wender IV,Samuel; Thomas, George; McElwee, David 336 eMail 7/10/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Wender IV,Samuel; strategy for communications Zoli, Elise N; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES; Ripley; Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Thomas, George 337 eMail With Attachment 6/28/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication D; Concannon, Sarah; Mark strategy for communications Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 338 eMail 6/28/2006 DeWald, Lynn Concannon, Sarah; Mark Barlow, Chuck D; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Zoli, Elise N modeling Product Page 23

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 339 eMail With Attachment 6/2612006 DeWald, Lynn Fitzgerald, Robert H; Zoli, Elise N; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Williams, U Gwyn; strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; Concannon, Sarah; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbara Ripley Tabor, Anna-Marie; Mark Mattson 340 eMail 6/118/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Williams, U Gwyn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D; Thomas, George; Fitzgerald, Robert strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; Barbara H; Concannon, with ANR regarding NPDES; Ripley; Wender IV,Samuel; Sarah; Tabor, Anna- Fisheries data Mark Mattson Marie; Rademacher, Norman L 341 eMail With Attachment 6/16/2006 DeWald, Lynn David Lewis; Buckley, Ricky Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Metell, Mike; Hoffman, John; Burke, Terence A; Rademacher, Norman L 342 eMail 5/31/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product A,a 40A1112-13 0-71 343 eMail 5/15/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work exAAA, [S Product 344 eMail 5/12/2006 DeWald, Lynn Rademacher, Norman L; Mark Mattson; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Wender IV, Samuel; Hutchins strategy for communications Product Maguire, William F; with ANR regarding NPDES; Dreyfuss, John; Pittman, Hydrothermal modeling Bill; Thomas, George Page 24

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No.I TDopent Datee Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 345 eMail 5/12/2006 DeWald, Lynn Rademacher, Norman L; Mark Mattson; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Wender IV, Samuel; Hutchins Maguire, William F; Dreyfuss, John; Pittman, -11e~

Bill; Thomas, George 346 eMail 5/11/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins; Thomas, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Mark Mattson; Product Elise Zoli 347 eMail 5/5/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work modeling Product 348 eMail 5/5/2006 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication D modeling;Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 349 eMail 5/5/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Versar Report 350 eMail 5/4/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 351 eMail 4/24/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Wender IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Rademacher, with ANR regarding NPDES Norman L; Zoli, Elise N; Thomas, George 352 eMail 4/20/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES Page 25

l ID Privilece Log for Documents Throuch December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subbect Privilege Asserted Document 353 eMail With Attachments 4/19/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work modeling Product 354 eMail 3/30/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Thayer, Jay; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Mark Mattson; Zoli, Wender IV,Samuel strategy for communications Product Elise N; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; Smith, Sharon Fisheries data 355 eMail 3/25/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications vith ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 356 eMail 3/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson _Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 357 eMail With Attachment 3/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Li 316(a) Demonstration; Fisheries data 358 eMail 2/15/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 359 eMail 2/14/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 360 eMail 2/8/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES Page 26

)

© Privilege Loq for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 361 eMail With Attachment 2/7/2006 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Product pre- Oe6l Hydrothermal modeling 362 eMail 12/16/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 363 eMail 12/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson McElwee, David 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 364 eMail 12/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barbara Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley modeling Product 365 eMail 12/8/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; Thayer, Jay; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 366 eMail 12/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Tim Brush; Mark Mattson; Communication regarding Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara NPDES permit Ripley; Wender IV, Samuel; Farquharson, Don 367 eMail 12/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 368 eMail 12/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES Page 27

/

U Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 369 eMail 12/5/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES 370 eMail 12/4/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication: Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling 371 eMail 12/4/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling 372 eMail 11/21/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 373 eMail 10/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; David Rocchio Fisheries data Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay; Mark Mattson 374 eMail 10/18/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Wender Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication IV,Samuel; Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Thayer, Jay 375 eMail 8/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Wender IV,Samuel; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Ripley Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Thomas, George strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Page 28

0 Privilecie Loa for Documents Throuah December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 376 eMail 7/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Wender IV, Samuel; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; Wender IV, Samuel Correspondence relating to McElwee, David; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George 377 eMail 7/27/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Wender IV, Samuel 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George 378 eMail 7/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Thomas, George; Correspondence relating to McElwee, David; Thayer, strategy for communications Jay; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 379 eMail 7/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, McElwee, David; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson Wender IV,Samuel; strategy for communications Nichols, Craig; with ANR regarding NPDES Thayer, Jay; Barbara Ripley 380 eMail 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 04W' 381 eMail 7/7/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product . * / -

382 eMail 6/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication D; Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to Mattson; Thomas, George strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 383 eMail 6/6/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elisa Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Mark Correspondence relating to Product Mattson; Thomas, George strategy for communications with AN R regarding NPDES Page 29

0 0 Privilegie Logq for Documents Througqh December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 384 eMail 5/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Correspondence relating to George; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPOES 385 eMail 5/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Buckley, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Ricky N; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; Thomas, George Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 386 eMail 4/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 387 eMail 313112005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication ytda-4awp1h George; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David Hydrothermal modeling 388 eMail 3/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn 7oli, Elise N; Barlow, Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work D; Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES; Barbara Ripley Versar Report 389 eMail 3/23/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George; McEtwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbara Ripley 390 eMail 3/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David Mattson; Barlow, strategy for communications Chuck D with ANR regarding NPDES 391 eMail 3/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product -

with ANR regarding NPDES Page 30

(/- 1 0 I0 Privilege Log for Documents Throuah December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy NuclearVermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 392 eMail 3/11/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; McElwee, Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David Mattson; Thomas, strategy for communications George; Barlow, with ANR regarding NPDES; Chuck D Hydrothermal modeling 393 eMail 3/8/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; strategy for communications Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 394 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; Mark Mattson; Thomas, Product George; Barbara Ripley; McElwee, David 395 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Elise Zoli; Barbara modeling Product Ripley; Thomas, George; McElwee, David; Wender IV, Samuel 396 eMail 3/7/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 397 eMail 3/4/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara David M. Rocchio Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; McElwee, David; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES )Zrm 398 eMail 3/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn McElwee, David; Barlow, Thayer, Jay; David Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thomas, George; M. Rocchio strategy for communications Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Barbara Ripley 399 eMail 3/1/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES McElwee, David Page 31

0 D Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privil ege Asserted Document 400 eMail 2/15/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Wender IV, strategy for communications Samuel; Elise Zoli; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Barbara Ripley Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 401 eMail 2/11/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling OZXXIO 402 eMail 2/2/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 403 eMail 1/28/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Elise Zoli; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES Tim Brush 404 eMail 1/24/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Thayer, Jay; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Thomas, George strategy for communications Wender IV,Samuel; Elise with ANR regarding NPDES; Zoli; Thomas, George; Tim Fisheries data; Versar Report Brush 405 eMail 1/19/2005 DeWald, Lynn Wender IV,Samuel; Thayer, Jay Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Product Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Tim Brush modeling; Versar Report Page 32

0 0 Privilege Loc for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 406 eMail 1/16/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D: Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Product I

Barbara Ripley; Thomas, with ANR regarding NPDES; George Versar Report rK Q4Y4 407 eMail 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Thomas, George; strategy for communications Product Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara with ANR regarding NPDES Ripley; Elise Zoli 408 eMail 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Versar Report 409 eMail 1/14/2005 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, Wender IV, Samuel Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Mark Mattson; Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley rc 2X61 410 eMail 1/13/2005 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES 411 eMail 1/12/2005 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara McCullough, Travis; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Mark Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Product Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 412 eMail 12/29/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 413 eMail 12/22/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Barlow, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Product Chuck D modeling Page 33

(

k 0

Privilege Loci for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 414 eMail 11/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Thomas, George; strategy for communications Product Barlow, Chuck D; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson Fisheries data 415 eMail 10/22/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Correspondence relating to Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES c~o~Ney 416 eMail 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Hydrothermal modeling Product George 417 eMail 10/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbra Ripley; Thomas, Hydrothermal modeling Product George 418 eMail 10/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 419 eMail 10/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins Elise Zoli; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Fisheries data Product 420 eMail 10/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work 421 eMail 9/21/2004 DeWald, Lynn Alex Gonyaw; Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; Thomas, George; Mark strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Versar Report Product Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product I

Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D 422 eMail 9/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Report George; Barbara Ripley Page 34

0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 423 eMail 9/14/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Elise Zoli; Mark Product Mattson; Barbara Ripley 424 eMail 8/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 425 eMail 8/13/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 426 eMail 8/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 427 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 428 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara G. Ripley; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; McElwee, David 429 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Mark Mattson; Elizabeth F. Mason Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G. Ripley; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George; Barlow, Chuck D with ANR regarding NPDES 901 430 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 431 eMail 8/5/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Product George; Barlow, Chuck D Page 35

0 0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 432 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 433 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 434 eMail 8/3/2004 DeWald, Lynn Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli; Elizabeth Mason; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Mark Mattson; Thomas, David Rocchio strategy for communications George with ANR regarding NPDES 435 eMail 7/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 436 eMail 7/20/2004 DeWald, Lynn Zoli, Elise N; Barbara Elizabeth F. Mason Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 437 eMail 7/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Master, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard; Barbara Ripley; Product Elise Zoli 438 eMail 7/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 439 eMail 6/29/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work 7bve2~

Product 440 eMail 6/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Elise Zoli; Mark Correspondence relating to Product Mattson strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Page 36

t 0 0 Privilege Loci for Documents Throuaqh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 441 eMail 5/2/2004 DeWald, Lynn Hayward, Julie; Thomas, Versar Report;316(a) Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George; Elise Zoli; Barbara Demonstration Product Ripley; Mark Mattson; Richard Master 442 eMail 4/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Bill Richkus Thomas, George; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Hayward, Julie; Report Product Mark Mattson; Barbara Ripley; Elise Zoli 443 eMail 4/16/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Suzanne Arena 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley Product 444 eMail 4/6/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Mark Elise Zoli 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Mattson 445 eMail 4/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Hutchins; Mark Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product Mattson modeling 446 eMail 3/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 447 eMail 3/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 448 eMail 3/1/2004 DeWald, Lynn Thomas, George; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 449 eMail 2/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 450 eMail 2/24/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, strategy for communications Product George with ANR regarding NPDES;

- rt 2x-ý Fisheries data Page 37

C -0/

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 451 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Product 12.,o George 452 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 453 eMail 2/23/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Thomas, Product George 454 eMail 2/11/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 455 eMail 2/10/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley Report Product 456 eMail 2/9/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 457 eMail 1/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Report Product 458 eMail 1/28/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 459 eMail 1/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 460 eMail 1/27/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 461 eMail 1/26/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Barbara Ripley 462 eMail 1/19/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Alex Gonyaw Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 463 eMail 1/15/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Patrick, John 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 464 eMail 1/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 465 eMail 1/12/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 466 eMili 41812004 DeWald, Lynin MarY Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Page 38

L

\ .

0 O Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tyeo Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 467 eMail 1/7/2004 DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product modeling 468 eMail With Attachments 7/7/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 469 eMail With Attachments 7/6/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 470 eMail With Attachment 7/6/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 471 eMail With Attachments 7/5/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 472 eMail With Attachments 6/30/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 473 eMail With Attachments 6/28/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 474 eMail 6/27/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 475 eMail With Attachment 6/27/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 476 eMail With Attachments 6/23/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Chuck Barlow; George Zoli, Elise N; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Thomas; Lynn DeWald; Williams, U Gwyn; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal David McElwee; Barbara Concannon, Sarah modeling Ripley Heaton; Tabor, Anna-Marie; Mark Mattson Page 39

Privilege Loaq for Documents Through December 7, 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. TVye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 477 eMail With Attachment 6/23/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 478 eMail With Attachment 6122/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 479 eMail 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 480 eMail 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 481 eMail 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 482 eMail 6/22/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 483 eMail 6/20/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 484 eMail 6/20/2006 Fitzgerald, Robert H Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 485 eMail 2/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product -a Fisheries data; Hydrothermal f rv--

modeling 486 eMail 2/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product aj::)O(;

I _Hydrothermal modeling 487 eMail 2/17/2005 Alex Gonyaw Brian Hanson Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 488 eMail 2/14/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 489 eMail 2114/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration-, Attorney Work PTodUct I I I I Hydrothermal modeling ""

Page 40

©)

Privilege Lon for Documents Throuah December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 490 eMail 2/14/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson John Pierce; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Pre 491__________ email__ 2/11/2005 Mark MattsonJennifer Griffin ____________ modelingAttorneyWorkProduct 491 eMail 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 492 eMail 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson JenniferGriffin Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 493 eMail 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modelingn Attorney Work Product 494 eMail 2/11/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 495 eMail 2/10/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 496 eMail 2/10/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 497 eMail 2/10/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 498 eMail 2/9/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 499 eMail 2/8/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 500 eMail 2/8/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 501 eMail 2/8/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 502 eMail 2/1/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 503 eMail 2/1/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 504 eMail 1/31/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 505 eMail 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Elise N.Zoli; Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin Demonstration 506 eMail 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 507 eMail 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 508 eMail 1/28/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product I Demonstration 509 eMail 1/27/2005 Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product I I I Demonstration I Page 41

7 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7, 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 510 eMail 1/21/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 511 eMail 1/21/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 512 eMail 1/21/2005 AlexGonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 513 eMail 1/21/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 514 eMail 1/19/2005 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 515 eMail 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Elise N. Zoli; Lynn DeWald; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson Product 516 eMail 1/18/2005 Alex Gonyaw Lynn DeWald; Mark Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Elise Zoli Demonstration Product 517 eMail 10/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 518 eMail 10/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Demonstration 519 eMail 10/28/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling; 316(a) Attorney Work Product Matthew Chan Demonstration 520 eMail 10/28/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 521 eMail 10/26/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Elise Zoli; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin; Hydrothermal modeling Michelle Comeau 522 eMail 5/21/2004 Alex Gonyaw Chris Gurshin Jennifer Griffin; Tim 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Brush; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Mattson 523 eMail 4/28/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 524 eMail 4/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I _ IFisheries data Page 42

0 ýD Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 525 eMail 4/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product 526 eMail 4/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product f?~.

Hydrothermal modeling 527 eMail 4/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 528 eMail 4/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Lynn DeWald 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 529 eMail 4/14/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 530 eMail 4/5/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 531 eMail 4/5/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Rick Simmons 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 532 eMail 4/2/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 533 eMail 4/1/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 534 eMail 3/31/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 535 eMail 3/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 536 eMail 3/29/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 537 eMail 3/25/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 538 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 539 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 540 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 541 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

-Hydrothermalmodeling -

Page 43

/-

0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7, 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 542 eMail 3/24/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 543 eMail 3/23/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 544 eMail 3/23/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Michelle 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Comeau Hydrothermal modeling 545 eMail 3/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Chris Gurshin; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson Hydrothermal modeling 546 eMail 3/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Chris 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Gurshin Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 547 eMail 3/17/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Michelle 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Comeau Hydrothermal modeling 548 eMail 3/17/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 549 eMail 3/16/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 550 eMail 3/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 551 eMail 3/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 552 eMail 3/15/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_Fisheries data 553 eMail 3/11/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 554 eMail 3/11/2004 Alex Gonyaw Terry Euston; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson; Rick Simmons; Hydrothermal modeling Doug Royer 555. eMail 3/9/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 556 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Terry 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Euston; Rick Simmons; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Doug Royer modeling 557 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Terry Euston; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Rick Simmons; Doug Royer Page44

I

©>

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 558 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 559 eMail 3/8/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 560 eMail 3/2/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 561 eMail 3/2/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Terry Euston; Fisheries data Rick Simmons 562 eMail 3/1/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I Fisheries data 563 eMail 2/23/2004 Alex Gonyaw Paul Hall Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 564 eMail 2/20/2004 Alex Gonyaw Rick Simmons; Doug Royer 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Terry Euston; Alex Gonyaw 565 eMail 2/10/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Paul Hall Hydrothermal modeling 566 eMail 2/9/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 567 eMail 2/9/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 568 eMail 2/5/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Jennifer Michelle Comeau 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Griffin Hydrothermal modeling 569 eMail 2/3/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I_ Hydrothermal modeling 570 eMail 1/2912004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_Lynn-DeWald Fisheries data 571 eMail 1/26/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 572 eMail 1/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau Hydrothermal modeling Page 45

/ \

0 C)

Privilege Log for Documents Througqh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 573 eMail 1/22/2004 Alex Gonyaw Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Matthew Chan; Hydrothermal modeling Brian Hanson; Mark Mattson; Michelle Comeau; Tim Brush; Erik Fel'Dotto 574 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw DeWald, Lynn; Mark 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson Hydrothermal modeling 575 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 576 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 577 eMail 1/19/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 578 eMail 1/17/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Jennifer Griffin; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Michelle Comeau; Hydrothermal modeling Brian Hanson; Matthew Chan; Tim Brush 579 eMail 1/16/2004 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 580 eMail 12/31/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Lynn Tim Brush; Jennifer 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Griffin Hydrothermal modeling 581 eMail 12/29/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Hydrothermal modeling _

582 eMail 12/29/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Matthew Chan; Hydrothermal modeling Jennifer Griffin; Michelle Comeau; Rick Simmons; Brian Hanson; Tim Brush Page 46

( ____

O Privilege Loa for Documents Throuaqh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Typof Date Author/Sender ent cc Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 583 eMail 12/18/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mike Ricci; Michelle Comeau; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mark Mattson Brian Hanson; Hydrothermal modeling Jennifer Griffin; Matthew Chan; Tim r! L Brush 584 eMail 12/12/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Michelle Comeau 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 585 eMail 12/10/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 586 eMail 12/10/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 587 eMail 12/9/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Michelle Comeau 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling Attorney 568 eMail 12/8/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 589 eMail 12/8/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 590 eMail 12/1/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 591 eMail 11/20/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson Michelle Comeau; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Jennifer Griffin Hydrothermal modeling 592 eMail 10/15/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 593 eMail 10/8/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 594 eMail 10/3/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 595 eMail 10/3/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 596 eMail 9/30/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson; Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product DeWald Fisheries data 597 eMail 9/10/2003 Alex Gonyaw Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 598 eMail With Attachment 5/15/2006 Mark Hutchins Lynn DeWald Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

__ -------- _ _ __ IHydrothermal modeling I

,1<

Page 47

r 0 (D Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7, 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 599 eMail 5/10/2006 Mark Hutchins Thomas, George; Mark Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Elise Zoli 600 eMail With Attachment 519/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I _Hydrothermal modeling 601 eMail With Attachments 4/21/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 602 eMail With Attachments 4/20/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 603 eMail 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward; Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product f2-1 Hydrothermal modeling 604 eMail With Attachment 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 605 eMail With Attachment 4/13/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Susan Ward 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling _

606 eMail With Attachment 4/11/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 607 eMail 4/10/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 608 eMail 4/7/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 609 eMail 4/6/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 610 eMail 4/5/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product 611 email___________

With Attachent 3Hydrothermal modeling 611 eMail With Attachment 3/30/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 612 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 613 eMail 3/24/2006 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 614 eMail 12/2/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 615 eMail 7/6/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 616 eMail 6/29/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 617 eMail 6/29/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 618 .eMail 6/29/2005 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 619 IeMail 10/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I HHydrothermal modeling Page 48

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 620 eMail 10/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 621 eMail 8/10/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 622 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson; Paul Lindsay 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 2~c~

623 eMail 8/8/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 624 eMail 8/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Susan Ward; Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 625 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 626 eMail 8/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product

_Hydrothermal modeling 627 eMail 7/26/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 628 eMail 7/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product I _Hydrothermal modeling 629 eMail 5/18/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 630 eMail 4/28/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 631 eMail 4/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 632 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 633 eMail 4/7/2004 Mark Hutchins Paul Lindsay Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 634 eMail 4/6/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 635 eMail 3/25/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 636 eMail 3/24/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 637 eMail 3/19/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 638 eMail 3/16/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product Page 49

(*

0 Privilegie Logq for Documents Throuqh December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 639 eMail 3/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 640 eMail 3/15/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 641 eMail 3/12/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 642 eMail 3/11/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 643 eMail 2/13/2004 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 644 eMail 4/9/2002 Mark Hutchins Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 645 eMail 6/19/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Burke, Terence A; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Williams, U Gwyn; strategy for communications Product Mattson; Thomas, George; Tabor, Anna-Marie; with ANR regarding NPDES McElwee, David Concannon, Sarah 646 eMail 4/28/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling; Correspondence Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product 5-relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 647 eMail 4/26/2006 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck Barlow, strategy for communications David McElwee; with ANR regarding NPDES Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson; Jay Thayer 648 eMail With Attachments 4/25/2006 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client Chuck D; Jay Thayer; Elise strategy for communications Communication Zoli; Mark Mattson; Wender with ANR regarding NPDES; IV,Samuel; McElwee, Fisheries data; Hydrothermal David modeling 649 eMail 4/24/2006 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Jay Thayer; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck Barlow; David strategy for communications McElwee; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES Elise Zoli Page 50

C © Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 650 eMail 4/18/2006 Barbara Ripley McElwee, David; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Zoli, Elise N; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas; DeWald, Lynn 651 eMail 3/26/2006 Barbara Ripley Smith, Sharon; Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Attorney-Client Communication UZI; Chuck D; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 652 eMail 3/26/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Zoli, Elise Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication N; DeWald, Lynn; Mark strategy for communications Mattson; Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 653 eMail 3/18/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Thomas, Wender IV,Samuel Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication George; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn with ANR regarding NPDES 654 eMail 3/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 655 eMail 3/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Chuck Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow;, Elise Zoli; Lynn George Thomas strategy for communications DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES 656 eMail 3/7/2006 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Mark Mattson; Zoli, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D Elise N strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 657 eMail With Attachment 2/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Page 51

0 f

Privilege Log for Documents Throuah December 7, 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 658 eMail With Attachment 2/15/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 659 eMail 2/15/2006 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 660 eMail 2/14/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work 2

DeWald; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 661 eMail With Attachment 2/14/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES

'~.2ai~

K 662 eMail 2/9/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 663 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 664 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 665 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise Product

_Zoli I Page 52

0 Privilege Loa for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilegqe Asserted Document 666 eMail 2/8/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 667 eMail 217/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; DeWald, Lynn strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 668 eMail 2/6/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Mark 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; DeWald, Lynn; Product Elise Zoli 669 eMail With Attachment 2/4/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Barbara Ripley Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 670 eMail 2/2/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow, Lynn 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Product Elise Zoli 671 eMail With Attachment 2/2/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 672 eMail With Attachment 2/2/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES 673 eMail 2/1/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Page 53

0 Privilege Log for Documents Throuqh December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 674 eMail 2/1/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Product Pre 675 eMail 2/1/2006 Barbara Ripley Zoli, Elise N Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark strategy for communications Product Mattson; Pechulis, with ANR regarding NPDES Kevin P; Mason, Elizabeth F 676 eMail 1/31/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Elise Zoli strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 677 eMail 1/31/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Elise Zoli; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 678 eMail With Attachment 1/30/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Elise strategy for communications Product Zoli with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 679 eMail With Attachment 1/30/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 680 eMail 1/29/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES Page 54

C0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 681 eMail With Attachment 1/29/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES' Hydrothermal modeling 682 eMail 1/28/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 683 eMail With Attachment 1/27/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 684 eMail 1/25/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 685 eMail 1/25/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 686 eMail With Attachment 1/25/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 687 eMail 1/2412006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal Attorney Work Product I

modeling Page 55

0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tv*e of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 688 eMail 1/24/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 689 eMail 1/24/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling DK' 1%510 690 eMail 1/23/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 691 eMail 1/23/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Workd Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 692 eMail 1/20/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Mark Mattson; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication DeWald strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling Page 56

(Th Privilege Loq for Documents Througqh December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 693 eMail 1/20/2006 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications with AN R regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 694 eMail 1/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 695 eMail 1/17/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Product with AN R regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 696 eMail With Attachment 1/13/2006 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 697 eMail 1/9/2006 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Lynn DeWald; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 698 eMail 12/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck 0; DeWald, Jay Thayer; Smith, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Zoli, Sharon strategy for communications Product Elise N; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Page 57

6Th Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tv*e of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 699 eMail 12/19/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David 700 eMail With Attachment 12/18/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Product David McElwee with ANR regarding NPDES 701 eMail 12/15/2005 Barbara Ripley McElwee, David; Mark Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product Chuck Barlow with ANR regarding NPDES 702 eMail With Attachment 12/14/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 703 eMail With Attachments 12/13/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow* Mark Mattson; strategy for communications David McElwee with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 704 eMail 12/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Sharon Francis Mark Mattson; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald, Lynn Product 705 eMail 12/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 706 eMail 12/8/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; David McElwee; strategy for communications Product Jay Thayer; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling Page 58

0 0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date AuthorlSender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 707 eMail 12/8/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Jay Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thayer; David McElwee; McCullough, Travis; strategy for communications Product George Thomas; Wender Burke, Terence A with ANR regarding NPDES; IV, Samuel; Lynn DeWald Fisheries data 708 eMail 12/2/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Mark Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 709 eMail 12/1/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Barlow, David Rocchio; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; McElwee, David; Peter Van Oot strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; R. Will with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data; Hydrothermal modeling 710 eMail 11/30/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; McElwee, David; David Rocchio strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Thayer, Jay with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 711 eMail 11/30/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; McElwee, David; David Rocchio strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Jay Thayer with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 712 eMail 10/14/2005 Barbara Ripley Chuck Barlow; DeWald, Peter Van Oot Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Jay Thayer; McElwee, Product David; Mark Mattson; George Thomas 713 eMail 10/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Peter Van Cot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Thayer, Jay Hydrothermal modeling Page 59

( ) /0 Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal.Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 714 eMail 10/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications George Thomas; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES; Mattson; Jay Thayer Hydrothermal modeling 715 eMail 10/5/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, David M. Rocchio; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; Jay Thayer; George Peter Van Oot strategy for communications Thomas; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES; McElwee, David; Wender Hydrothermal modeling IV,Samuel 716 eMail 10/4/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; Jay Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Thayer; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES; David; George Thomas; Hydrothermal modeling Wender IV, Samuel; DeWald, Lynn 717 eMail 10/3/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Peter Van Cot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; George with ANR regarding NPDES; Thomas; Jay Thayer Hydrothermal modeling 718 eMail 9/28/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Barlow, Peter Van Cot Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Jay Thayer; George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas; Mark Mattson 719 eMail 9/19/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Thayer, Jay; Peter Van Cot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Mark David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Mattson; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas, George 720 eMail 9/9/2005 Barbara Ripley Thayer, Jay; Lynn DeWald; Peter Van Cot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow, Chuck D; Mark David M. Rocchio strategy for communications Mattson; McElwee, David with ANR regarding NPDES Page 60

0 10 Privilege Log for Documents Througqh December 7, 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 721 eMail 9/9/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 722 eMail 9/9/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Barlow, Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay 723 eMail 8/15/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; David McElwee; strategy for communications George Thomas; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Peter Van Oot 724 eMail 8/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D Mark Mattson; strategy for communications Thomas, George with ANR regarding NPDES 725 eMail 8/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Wender IV,Samuel; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES George Thomas 726 eMail 8/12/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; McElwee, Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication David; DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mattson strategy for communications Thomas, George; Peter Van with ANR regarding NPDES Oot 727 eMail 8/5/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow* David McElwee; Jay strategy for communications Thayer; George Thomas; with ANR regarding NPDES Mark Mattson Page 61

Privilege Loaq for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 728 eMail 7/27/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Wender IV,Samuel; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Thayer, Jay; Wender IV,Samuel strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Thomas, George; George Thomas 729 eMail 7/27/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; Jay Thayer; strategy for communications McElwee, David; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; George Thomas 730 eMail 7/25/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Jay Thayer; George with ANR regarding NPDES Thomas; Mark Mattson 731 eMail 7/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Lynn DeWald; Chuck Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; David McElwee; strategy for communications Mark Mattson; Jay Thayer; with ANR regarding NPDES George Thomas 732 eMail 7/21/2005 Barbara Ripley Mark Mattson; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; DeWald, Lynn; strategy for communications George Thomas; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Jay Thayer 733 eMail 7/20/2005 Barbara Ripley Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Lynn; George Thomas; strategy for communications McElwee, David; Jay with ANR regarding NPDES Thayer; Mark Mattson 734 eMail 7/13/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn Barlow, Chuck D; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McElwee, David; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Jay with ANR regarding NPDES; Thayer Hydrothermal modeling Page 62

© 7 N

)

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log Was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvpe of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 735 eMail 7/12/2005 Barbara Ripley DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Chuck D; McElwee, David; strategy for communications Jay Thayer; Mark Mattson; with ANR regarding NPDES; George Thomas Hydrothermal modeling 736 eMail 12/17/2004 Craig Swanson Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration Attorney Work Product 737 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Paul Lindsay Fisheries data 738 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 739 eMail 8/5/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 740 eMail 8/4/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 741 eMail 8/3/2004 Sankar Subbayya Mark Mattson Craig Swanson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Fisheries data 742 eMail 9/4/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Hydrothermal modeling 743 eMail 5/10/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson; DeWald, Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Elise Zoli Hydrothermal modeling Product 744 eMail With Attachments 4/26/2006 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Daniel Yasi 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Hydrothermal modeling Product -

745 eMail 3/22/2006 Thomas, George Barlow, Chuck D; 316(a) Demonstration: Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work McCullough, Travis; Elise Hydrothermal modeling Product Zoli; Mark Mattson; Smith, Terrence 746 eMail With Attachments 6/30/2003 Yasi, Daniel Thomas, George; Gary Vermont Yankee Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Franklin Mail 747 eMail 3/19/2006 Thomas, George Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Wender IV, Samuel Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Ripley; Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn 748 eMail 3/18/2006 Thomas, George Barbara Ripley; Mark Wender IV, Samuel Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Elise Zoli; DeWald, Lynn Page 63

%.J Privilege Log for Documents Throuaqh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privilege Asserted Document 749 eMail 12/4/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 750 eMail 10/27/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; David Rocchio strategy for communications Product McElwee, David; Thayer, with ANR regarding NPDES Jay; Mark Mattson 751 eMail 8/3/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 752 eMail 8/1/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 753 eMail 7/25/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 754 eMail 6/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, McElwee, David; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; Wender IV,Samuel; Hydrothermal modeling Product Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson Nichols, Craig 755 eMail 5/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 756 eMail 5/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 757 eMail 5/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product 758 eMail 3/3/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, McElwee, David; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; David Rocchio strategy for communications Product Elise Zoli; Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 759 eMail 2/28/2005 Thomas, George DeWald, Lynn Mark Mattson; Elise Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Zoli; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data 760 eMail 2/2/2005 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barlow, Chuck D Product 761 eMail 10/6/2003 Thomas, George Mark Mattson DeWald, Lynn; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication Shuman, Eileen; Nichols, Craig; Elise Zoli 762 eMail With Attachment 10/13/2006 Susan Ward Mark Hutchins; Mark Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Mattson 763 eMail With Attachment 10/11/2006 Susan Ward Mark Mattson Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product Page 64

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Typo Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 764 eMail With Attachment 7/5/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Correspondence relating to strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Hydrothermal modeling 765 eMail 7/5/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Fitzgerald, Williams, U Gwyn Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Robert H 766 eMail 6/22/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Georgian, 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Kathryn A Product 767 eMail 6/19/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson Concannon, Sarah; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Fitzgerald, Robert H 768 eMail 4/25/2006 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; George Chuck Barlow; Lynn Hydrothermal modeling Attorney Work Product; Attorney-Client 769 eMail 4/10/2006 Zoli, Elise N Thomas DeWald, Lynn; Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Ripley; DeWald; Mark Hutchins Buckley, Ricky N Correspondence relating to strategy for communications Communication Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product "iff-50-Co Thomas, George; Mark with ANR regarding NPDES Mattson; Wender IV, Samuel 770 eMail 2/17/2006 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Chuck Williams, U Gwyn; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication Barlow; DeWald, Lynn; Mason, Elizabeth F strategy for communications Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 771 eMail 1/21/2005 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Lynn; Mark Mattson; Chuck strategy for communications Product Barlow with ANR regarding NPDES 772 eMail 1/21/2005 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; P. Almeag; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Richard Simmons strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES Page 65

Privile-ge Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. "ryeof Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subect Privilege Asserted Document 773 eMail 1/20/2005 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product p-Chuck Barlow with ANR regarding NPDES 774 eMail 1/20/2005 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Gordon, Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Anne T strategy for communications Product with ANR regarding NPDES 775 eMail 1/19/2005 Zoli, Elise N Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Thayer, Jay; Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; DeWald, Lynn; Thomas, George Product Wender IV, Samuel; Elise Zoli; Thomas, George; Mark Mattson 776 eMail 1/14/2005 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley 777 eMail 1/14/2005 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Fisheries data Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barlow, Chuck D; Product Elise Zoli; Barbara Ripley 778 eMail 10/8/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Elise Zoli; Mark Hutchins 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara Ripley; Lynn Product DeWald; George Thomas 779 eMail 9130/2004 Zoli, Elise N Thomas, George; Mark Barbara Ripley; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Elise Zoli; DeWald, Product Lynn; Nichols, Craig; Brown, Lois 780 eMail 9114/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark Barlow, Chuck D 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 781 eMail 9/13/2004 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Elise Zoli; Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mark Mattson; Barlow, Product Chuck D; Thomas, George; Barbara Ripley Page 66

D

(

K)

Privilege Loci for Documents Throunh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 782 eMail 8/13/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson Product 783 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Lynn DeWald; Elise Zoli Barbara Ripley; Mark Hutchins Hydrothermal modeling Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Product

)R 784 eMail 8/4/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; George Chuck Barlow Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Thomas; Lynn DeWald; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson; Chuck with ANR regarding NPDES Barlow 785 eMail 7/28/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson Fisheries data; Versar Report Attorney Work Product 786 eMail 7/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Product Mark Mattson 787 eMail 7/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Mark Thomas, George Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Elise Zoli; Barbara strategy for communications Product Ripley with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 788 eMail 7/26/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Richard Master; strategy for communications Product Mark Mattson with ANR regarding NPDES 789 eMail 7/21/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara Ripley; strategy for communications Product George Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES 790 eMail 5/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Barbara Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson; Correspondence relating to Product Richard Master; George strategy for communications Thomas with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report Page 67

© Privilege Loaq for Documents Through December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tvye of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 791 eMail 5/18/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Mason, Elizabeth F; 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson George Thomas Correspondence relating to Product FL strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 792 eMail 5/2/2004 Zoli, Elise N DeWald, Lynn; Barbara Hayward, Julie; 316(a) Demonstration; Versar Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson; Thomas, George Report Product Richard Master 793 eMail 4/28/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Richard Master; Product Mark Mattson 794 eMail 4/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark T. Mattson; Lynn Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Barbara G. Ripley Product 795 eMail 4/27/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mason, Elizabeth F; Bednar, Charlotte L; 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Barbara G. Ripley Lynn DeWald; Mark Product T. Mattson 796 eMail 4/26/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Mark Mason, Elizabeth F 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Lynn DeWald; R. Product Gerdus 797 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark Mattson; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Product Lynn DeWald 798 eMail 4/19/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Arena, Suzanne E 316(a) Demonstration Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson Product 799 eMail 4/5/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Barbara Arena, Suzanne E Versar Report Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Ripley; Mark Mattson Product 800 eMail 3/9/2004 Zoli, Elise N Mark T. Mattson Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work George Thomas; strategy for communications Product Arena, Suzanne E with ANR regarding NPDES Page 68

0 Privileqe Log for Documents Throuqh December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tve of Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 801 eMail 1/24/2004 Zoli, Elise N Lynn DeWald; Mark T. Brennan Jr, Robert Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work Mattson; Barbara G. Ripley L; Arena, Suzanne strategy for communications Product E with ANR regarding NPDES; Versar Report 802 eMail 1/20/2004 Zoli, Elise N Barbara Ripley; Lynn Brennan Jr, Robert Correspondence relating to Attorney-Client Communication; Attorney Work DeWald; Mark Mattson L; Arena, Suzanne strategy for communications Product E with ANR regarding NPDES 803 eMail 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli Lynn DeWald; Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product Vekasy, Steve permit appeal 804 eMail 3/23/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli Lynn DeWald; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Vekasy, Steve strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 805 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Elise Zoli; Sam Wender; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Lynn George Thomas strategy for communications DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 806 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow, Elise Zoli; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Barbara Ripley; Lynn strategy for communications DeWald with ANR regarding NPDES; 316(a) Demonstration 807 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with AN R regarding NPDES Lynn DeWald 808 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES Lynn DeWald Page 69

K O

Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7. 2006, Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Tye of Date Author/Sender Recia[Ie CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 809 eMail 3/17/2006 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow; Sam Wender Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Elise Zoli; strategy for communications Barbara Ripley; with ANR regarding NPDES Lynn DeWald 810 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn permit appeal;316(a)

Demonstration 811 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Litigation strategy relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn permit appeal;316(a)

Demonstration 812 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 613 eMail 2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 814 eMail

/

2/6/2006 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara 316(a) Demonstration; Attorney Work Product Ripley; DeWald, Lynn Litigation strategy relating to permit appeal 815 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 816 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 817 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 818 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David 819 eMail 12/21/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara DeWald, Lynn; Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Ripley; Zoli, Elise N McElwee, David Page 70

0-Privilege Log for Documents Through December 7, 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipent CC Subiect Privilege Asserted Document 820 eMail 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES; Fisheries data Pit 821 eMail 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product.

Lynn; Barbara Ripley 822 eMail 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley 823 eMail 12/5/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; DeWald, Fisheries data Attorney Work Product Lynn; Barbara Ripley 824 eMail 9/9/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay 825 eMail 9/9/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Peter Van Oot; Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Barlow, Chuck D; David M. Rocchio strategy for communications DeWald, Lynn; McElwee, with ANR regarding NPDES David; Thomas, George; Thayer, Jay 826 eMail 9/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES 827 eMail 9/8/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D DeWald, Lynn Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product strategy for communications with ANR regarding NPDES Page 71

(IL K) 0 Privilene Log for Documents Throuqh December 7. 2006. Part One This privilege log was prepared by counsel to Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee (ENVY) in connection with the Entergy Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding.

ENVY reserves the right to supplement, amend, or clarify this log, as necessary.

No. Type o Date Author/Sender Recipient CC Subject Privileqe Asserted Document 828 eMail 3/16/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Elise Zoli; Thomas, strategy for communications George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES DeWald, Lynn 829 eMail 3/16/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D; Barbara Correspondence relating to Attorney Work Product Ripley; Elise Zoli; Thomas, strategy for communications George; McElwee, David; with ANR regarding NPDES DeWald, Lynn 830 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D Lynn DeWald Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 831 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Barlow, Chuck D Fisheries data Attorney Work Product 832 eMail 3/4/2005 Mark Mattson Chuck Barlow Fisheries data Attorn

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML070220411&oldid=2580102"