ML061300374
| ML061300374 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/10/2006 |
| From: | Daniel Frumkin NRC/NRR/ADRA/DRA/AFPB |
| To: | Jamar B Nuclear Energy Institute |
| References | |
| FOIA/PA-2009-0089 | |
| Download: ML061300374 (5) | |
Text
From:
Daniel Frumkin To:
btj@nei.org Date:
5/10/06 1:08PM
Subject:
NEI/NRC Fire Protection Issues Management Protocol Update Phone Call, May 2, 2006 Mr. Jamar, This email is to follow-up our May 2, 2006, phone call discussing the NEI/NRC Fire Protection Issues Management Protocol. For your reference, the guidelines for this protocol were originally discussed in a memorandum dated April 23, 2004, which can be found in NRC's document management system - ADAMS ML031210232.
During this phone call we discussed changes to the attached list of activities, and provided the current status for each activity. The current version of the list is attached. For your information, the previous list is in ADAMS, Accession No. ML060460411.
R. Wolfgang, R. Radlinski, A. Klein, and D. Frumkin participated in the phone call from the NRC. From industry and NEI: B. Jamar - NEI, M. Heatherly - TVA, R. Wilfred - STARS, J. Hicks
- TXU, B. Najafi - SAIC for EPRI, T. Gorman - PPL, C. Pragman - Exelon, R. Rickman - AEP, J.
Ertman - Progress, R. Richter - SCE, F. Garrett - APS, and D. Shumaker - PSE&G, participated.
The contents of this email will be made publicly available in the ADAMS document management system.
As discussed during the phone call, the next meeting on the issues management protocol will be a face-to-face meeting in approximately 3 months.
Sincerely, Daniel Frumkin Daniel M. Frumkin <DXF1@NRC.GOV>
Fire Protection Engineer U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission MS/O-11A11 Washington, DC 20555-0001 PHONE 301-415-2280 FAX 301-415-2300 CC:
Alex Klein; am@nei.org; Quynh Nguyen; Robert Radlinski; Robert Wolfgang; Sunil Weerakkody,
Mail Envelope Properties (44621DF2.E48 : 16 : 11800)
Subject:
NEI/NRC Fire Protection Issues Management Protocol Update Phone Call, May 2, 2006 Creation Date:
5/10/06 1:08PM From:
Daniel Frumkin Created By:
DXF1@nrc.gov Recipients Action Date & Time nei.org Transferred 05/10/06 1:08 PM am CC (am@nei.org) btj (btj@nei.org) nrc.gov OWGWPO02.HQGWDO01 Delivered 05/10/06 1:08 PM ARK1 CC (Alex Klein) nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 Delivered 05/10/06 1:08 PM QTN CC (Quynh Nguyen)
RFR1 CC (Robert Radlinski) nrc.gov TWGWPO02.HQGWDO01 Delivered 05/10/06 1:08 PM RJW1 CC (Robert Wolfgang)
SDW1 CC (Sunil Weerakkody)
Post Office Delivered Route nei.org OWGWPO02.HQGWDO01 05/10/06 1:08 PM nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 05/10/06 1:08 PM nrc.gov TWGWPO02.HQGWDO01 05/10/06 1:08 PM nrc.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 2656 05/10/06 01:08PM Working copy Issues Management Tracking List may 2006.wpd 35807 05/04/06 02:34PM Options Auto Delete:
No Expiration Date:
None Notify Recipients:
Yes Priority:
Standard Reply Requested:
No Return Notification:
None Concealed
Subject:
No Security:
Standard To Be Delivered:
Immediate Status Tracking:
Delivered & Opened
INDUSTRY/NRC FIRE PROTECTION ISSUE MANAGEMENT TRACKING LIST Active Items - Draft 8 - May 3, 2006 Tracking Issue/origin Priority NRC Position Industry Position Next Action Action Responsi-bility Action Due Date Notes/Applicable References NFPA 805/10 CFR 50.48(c) 805-8 NRC issue final reg guide for adoption of NFPA 805 licensing basis N - High I - High Minimize RG content -
include guidance in NEI 04-02 Agree with NRC position; RG should fully endorse NEI 04-02 NRC to Complete RG N
Spring 2006 DG-1.205, NEI 04-02, Rev. 1 805-9 Communication tools for 805 plants N-High I-High Letter from NEI with proposal NEI to prepare draft I
Fall 2006 FAQ Letter 805-10 The development of Fire PRA Peer Review Guide N-Med I-Med To be completed 6 months before 1st non-pilot scheduled to submit.
Not conditional on ANS Stnd NEI to create peer review guide for FP PRAS NEI to deliver draft to NRC I
Winter 06/07 On Schedule, with NSSS owners groups involved Circuit Failure CF-9 Additional clarification of circuit analysis terms N-High I-low Additional issues require clarification N
ML051650017, Scheduled to be issued 8/31/06 Fire Barrier Issues FB-4 Generic communication on Hemyc/MT test results N-High I-?
NRC will collect information regarding Hemyc/MT and other fire barries Responses requested by June 8, 2006 N
Ongoing GL Issued 06-04 Other Fire Protection Issues FP-7 Containment Oil Misting N - Med I - Med Potential non-compliance with III.O, if from RCPs.
Two plants have affected RCPs.
Two other plants may have other oil source Industry to survey and report NRC to provide specifics I
Summer 2006 FP-11 Instrument Tubing separation for III.G N-Low I-Low How widespread is assumption that instrument tubing is not required to be separate for Appendix R.
NRC position is that tubing, if affected by fire, could affect SSD should be protected NEI will survey to determine extent of assumption NEI to perform survey I
is performing a survey, starting 2/2006 Inspections and Self-Assessments
2 Tracking Issue/origin Priority NRC Position Industry Position Next Action Action Responsi-bility Action Due Date Notes/Applicable References I/SA-4 Develop SDP for Fire Brigades N - Low I - Low Preparing Complete draft and provide to industry for comment N
I/SA-5 Fire Drill Participation N-Low I-Low NRC has questions about what counts for drill participation NEI will develop white paper on this issue I
Late 2006 Manual Actions MA-3 Safe shutdown manual actions N - High I - Med Rule withdrawn 3/6/2006 NEI submitted a letter requesting clarifications on May 3, 2006 Issue regulatory issue summary as discussed in SECY-06-0010 N
Spring 2006 Federal Register 71 FR 11169, Letter, NEI to NRC Chairman (ML060620377), Letter, NRC Chairman to NEI (ML060660056)
NOTES:
Definitions 805 - issue related to NFPA 805 rulemaking or implementation CF - issue related to circuit failure issue closure, NEI 00-01, or associated circuit inspections FB - issue related to fire barriers FP - general fire protection issue INPO - issue related to INPO I/SA - issue related to fire protection inspections or self-assessments MA - issue related to manual actions
3 INDUSTRY/NRC FIRE PROTECTION ISSUE MANAGEMENT TRACKING LIST Completed Items - Draft 7 - January 31, 2006 Tracking Issue/origin Priority NRC Position Industry Position Next Action Action Responsi-bility Action Due Date Applicable References NFPA 805/10 CFR 50.48(c) 805-3 Processing of licensing basis issues (how issues are to be handled during transition) for licensees adopting NFPA 805 (issue needs more definition)
N - High I - High NRC will develop RG based on Rev 1 Rev. 2 in with NRC Will be managed with FAQ Process 805-9 Complete Feb. 28, 2006 Ltr to NRC ML060880050 Circuit Failure Fire Barrier Issues Other Fire Protection Issues Inspections and Self-Assessments Manual Actions NOTES:
Definitions 805 - issue related to NFPA 805 rulemaking or implementation CF - issue related to circuit failure issue closure, NEI 00-01, or associated circuit inspections FB - issue related to fire barriers FP - general fire protection issue INPO - issue related to INPO I/SA - issue related to fire protection inspections or self-assessments MA - issue related to manual actions