ML060690164
| ML060690164 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Wolf Creek, Callaway  |
| Issue date: | 08/13/1984 |
| From: | Joseph Holonich, O'Connor P Division of Engineering |
| To: | Youngblood B Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| FOIA/PA-2006-0095 NUDOCS 8408200026 | |
| Download: ML060690164 (8) | |
Text
67C77;zgX AUG 13 W4 Docket Nos.: STN 50-482 and 50-483 MEMORANDUM FOR: B. J. Youngblood, Chief Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing FROM: Joseph J. Holonich, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing Paul W. O'Connor, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing
SUBJECT:
FORIHCOMING MEETING WITH UNION ELECTRIC COMPANY AND KANSAS GAS A ELECTRIC COMPANY DATE & TIME: Tuesday, August 14, 1984 1:30 p.m. - 5:00 p.m.
LOCATION: Phillips Building, Room P-422 7920 Norfolk Avenue Bethesda, Maryland PURPOSE: To appeal the staff's position on the SNUPPS Safe Shutdown Analysis (see enc'ited request).
PARTICIPANTS: NRC KG&E V.-Houston W. V. Johnston G. Rathbun, et, al.
T. Novak B. J. Youngblood UE V. Benaroya J. Holonich A. C. Passwatcr R. Eberly J. Wilson SNUPPS W. LeFave N. Fioravante M. Fletcher, et. al.
M. Murphy C. Ramsey MtQLUA1. UCM9D1X Joseph J. Holonich, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. I Division of Licensing Lz~aX~uxDD I t) t;l B4o92o00o2^6 840o8' 2 ,\.(PaulW. O'Connor, Project Manager CF ADOC CF t'E Licensing Branch No. I DIVIsion of Licensing
\Q cc: ee next page J1 h:kab nnor 08/T /84 08/jg/84
0'^ Pic,,
I I UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHIINOTON. D.C. 2055 I Dokt o. AUG13 1984 STN 50-482 and 50-483 MEMORANDUM FOR: B. J. Youngbloodr, Chief Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing FROM: Joseph J. Holonich, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing Paul W. O'Connor, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing
SUBJECT:
FORTHCOMING MEETING WITH UNION ELECTRIC COMPANY AND KANSAS GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY DATE & TIME: Tuesday, August 14, 1984 1:30 p.m. - 5:0t p.m.
LOCATION: Phillips Building, Room P-422 7920 Norfolk Avenue Bethesda, Marylaind PURPOSE: To appeal the staff's position on the SNUPPS Safe Shutdown Analysis (see enclosed request).
PARTICIPANTS: NRC KG&E W7Houston W. V. Johnston G. Rathbun, at. al.
T. Novak B. J. Youngblooi I UE V. Benaroya J. Holonich A. C. Passwater R. Eborly J. Wilson SNUPPS W. Lefave N. Fioravante M. Fletcher, et. al.
M. Murphy C. Ramsey de 5ZCRAII, I 4 Joseph 5. Ilolonich, Project Manager Licensing
- %A.. A - -- A Branch No. 1 Division or Licensing ,
Paul U. O'Connor, Pro ect Manager Licensing Branch No. n Division of Liconsing cc: See next page a -I0IIII
SNfU PPS Mr. D. F. Schnell Mr. Glen L. Koester Vice President - Nuclear Vice President - Nuclear Union Electric Company Kansas Gas and Electric Company P. 0. Box 149 201 North Market Street St. Louis, Missouri 63166 P. O. Box 208 Wichita, Kansas 67201 cc: Gerald Charnoff, Esq. Mayor Howard Steffen Thomas A. Baxter, Esq. Chamois, Missouri 65024 Shaw, Pittman, Potts i Trowbridge 1800 M Street, N. W. Jay Silberg, Esquire Washington, D. C. 20036 Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1800 M Street, H. W.
Kansas City Power A Light Company Washington, 0. C. 20036 ATTN: Mr. D. T. McPhce Vice President - Production Mr. Donald H. Capone 1330 Baltimore Avenue Manager - Nuclear Engineering Kansas City, Missouri 64141 Union Elect.ric Company P. 0. Box 149 Mr. Nicholas A. Petrick St. Louis, Missouri 63166 Executive Director, SNUPPS 5 Choke Cherry Road Ms. Mary Ellen Salava Rockville, Maryland 20850 Route 1, Box 56 Burlington, Kansas 66839 Fr. J. E. Birk Assistant to the General Counsel Eric A. Elsen, Esq.
Union Electric Comeany Birch, Horton, Bittner & Moore St. Louls, Missouri G31GG 1140 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.
Washington, D. C. 20036 Mr. Howard Bundy Resident Inspector/Wolf Creek NPS Ms. Wanda Christy c/o U. S. NRC 515 N. 1st Street P. 0. Box 311 Burlington, Kansas 66839 Burlington, Kansas 66839 Ms. Majorie Reilly Mr. Michael C. Keener Energy Chairman of the League of State Corporation Commission Women Voters of University City, MO State of Kansas 7065 Pershing Avenue Fourth Floor, State Office Building University City, Missouri 63130 Topeka, Kansas 6612 Mr. Fred Lukey Mr. John fleisler Presiding Judge, Montgomery County U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Rural Route Resident Inspectors Office Rhineland, Missouri 65069 RR J1 Steedman, Missouri 65077 Professor William H. Miller Missouri Kansas Section, American Terri Sculley, Director Nuclear Society Special Projects Division Department of Nuclear Engineering Kansas Corporation Commission 1026 Engineerfng Building State Office Building, 4th Floor University of Missouri Topeka, Kansas 66612 Columbia, Missouri 65211
_t___
SNUPPS - 2. -
cc: Robert G. Wright Mr. Donald Bollinger, Member Associate Judge, Eastern Missoruians for Safe Energy District County Court 6267 Delmar Boulevard Cellaway County, Missouri University City, Missouri 63130 Route #1 Fulton, Missouri John H. Simpson, Esq.
Attorney for Intervenors Lewis C. Green, Esq. 4350 Johnson Drive, Suite 120 Green, Hennings & Henry Shawnee Mission, Kansas 66205 Attorney for Joint Intervenors 314 N. Broadway, Suite 1830 St. Louis, Missouri 63102 Mr. James G. Keppler U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mr. Earl Brown Region III School District Superintendent 799 Roosevelt Road P. 0. Box 9 Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 Kingdom City, Missouri 65262 Mr. John T. Collins Mr. Samuel J. Birk U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission R. R. J1, Box 243 Re ion IV Morrison, Missouri 65061 611 Ryan Plaza, Suite 1000 Arlington, Texas 76011 Mr. Harold Lottman Presiding Judge, Dasconade County Mr. Joe Mulholland Route 1 Manager of Power Supply & Engineering Owensville, Missouri 65066 Kansas Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
P. 0. Box 4877 A. Scott Cauger, Esq. Gage Center Station Assistant General Counsel for the Topeka, Kansas 66604 Missouri Public Service Comm.
P: 0. Box 360 C. Edward Peterson, Esq.
Jefferson City, Missouri 65101 Legal Division Kansas Corporation Commission Mr. John G. Reed Fourth Floor Route #I State Office Building Kingdom City, Missouri 65262 Topeka, Kansas 66612 Mr. Dan 1. Bolef, President Brian P. Cassidy, Regional Counsel Kay Drey, Representative Federal Emergency Management Agency Board of Directors Coalition Region I for the Environment J. W. McCormack POCII St. Louis Region Boston, Massachusetts 02109 6267 Delmar Boulevard University City, Missouri 63130
L SNUPPS Siandsodiod Nucleat Unil Powrr Plant Synem 5 Choae Cherry Rold Nieholas A. Petrick Rodvi. aY1rn4 ,oss Excutlve Diector t3114OSHO10 August 10, 1984 SUIRC 84- 0106 FILE: 0278 SUBJ: fire Protection Review Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comnission Washington, D. C. 20555 Docket Hos.: STH 50-4B2 and STH 50-483
Reference:
- 1. SLNRC 82-046, dated November 15, 1982: Same Subject
- 2. NUREG-0881, Supplement No. 3, dated August 1983: Safety Evaluation Report Related to Operation of Wolf Creek Generating Station,, Unit No. 1
- 3. OUREG-0830, Supplement No. 3, dated May 1984: Safety Evaluation Report Rielated to Operation of Callaway Plant, Unit No. 1
Dear Mr. Denton:
During a fire protection audit at the Wolf Creek Generating Ftation the week of July 30, 1984, the NRC audit team, from Region IV of the Office of Inspection and Enforcement (OIE), questioned the assumr 'ins of the control room fire hazards analysis for the SHUPPS plants - Callaway Plant Unit No. 1 and Wolf Creek Generating Station Unit J:o. 1. The NRC audit team also imposed a new control room fire scenario and requested to review SNUPPS design provisions or procedures which would demonstrate the capability to mitigate the new scenario. This new scenario requires imnediate evacuation of the control room by plant operators (who may be allowed to perfo m one or two quick actions in the course of departing) and causes immediate loss of fuiction or spurious operation (due to fire-induced electrical shorts, etc.) of any or all plant equlpment controlled from the control roof, i.e., complete and total loss of the control room.
The SNUPPS design and procedural controls for mitigation of postulated control room fires are described In the "SNUPPS Control Room Fire Hazards Analysis" report which was submitted by Reference 1. This analysis clearly states that immediate evacuation and conflagration of the control room or immediate loss of function and/or spurious function of control systems are not assumed In the SNUPPS plants. Based on the 1 _11 __ __
I- - o I
i 0
'.LNRC 84- 0106
,age 2.
/ construction of the cabinets and size of the postulated credible fires, the analysis supports the passage of some small amount of time (greater than four minutes) before the adverse consequences of fire damage occur.
Prior to submittal of Reference 1, the assumptions of the SNUPPS anal-ysis were presented in detail and discussed at'a meeting with the appropriate review branches of the'Office of Nuclear; Reactor Regulation
! (ONRR) on October 19, 1982. The purpose of this meeting was toascer-tamn the acceptability of the assumptions especially those concerning magnitude of the fire, definition of acceptable repair activities, and time to respond prior to the assumption of fire damag e effects. Based on the control room fire hazards analysis and feedback from the meeting with NRC staff, the SNUPPS Utilities modified the design of the SNUPPS plants to incorporate isolation switches to preclude the need to make repairs to certain electrical control circuits. The NRC staff in References 2 and 3 concluded that the SNUPPS Control Room Fire Hazards Analysis was acceptable.
At the recent Wolf Creek Audit,, the audit team stated that they did not reject the SNUPPS Control Room Fire Hazards Analysis or the plant procedures which are based on that analysis. However, the audit team indicated that the control room fire concern would be an audit "open item" until such time as Kansas Gas and Electric Company produces a procedure to shut the plant down using a new fire scenario. Since this procedure cannot be produced until a new analysis is performed, hardware modifications are analyzed fnd operator response requirements are studied, the existing analysis for credible fires has, in effect, been rejected.
A meeting between the SNUPPS Utilities and the NRC staff was held on August 10, 1984 to discuss the postulated control room fire. The NRC staff stated that the concern was not the development of a new procedure but independence of the SNUPPS alternate shutdown equipment from the control room. The NRC staff did not consider the imposition of imme-diate evacuation and immediate electrical damage resulting from 4n exposure fire to be a new position and stated that the SNUPPS Control Room Fire Hazards Analysis was not clear regarding the assumption of some time delay before the adverse consequences of fire damage occur.
The SNUPPS Utilities stated that the previously approved analysis is clearly based on the assumption of time delay prior to damage and that the Imposition of immediate damage represents a new regulatory position for the SNUPPS plants.
To date, the SNUPPS fire protection design has been subjected to a licensing review and four siue audits/walkdowns: ONRR, 10/17-20/1983, Callaway; ONRR, 2/7-8(84, Wolf Creek; OE, 3/84-4/84, Callaway; OlE, 7/30-813/84, Wolf Creek. Bei:ause of the SNUPPS design provisions for fire protection (for example, separate train-related cable spreading rooms), these extensive NRC reviews have resulted in few plant modifi-cations to meet regulatory positions. Nevertheless, the SNUPPS Util-ities agreed to install certain plant design changes (control room isolation switches, additional sprinkler heads in two plant areas,
-FM
,1<.SLNRC 84-0106 Page 3.
a control room ventilation system smoke detector and a cable tray fire stop) to resolve NRC review concerns. Even prior to installation of these design changes the overall S1UPPS plant fire protection design
-provided a level of protection-for public health and safety sybstan-
.tially above acceptable levels.
The new control room fire position presented by the audit team at Wolf Creek represents a significant change In the previously approved regu-latory position regarding control room fires in the SNUPPS plants.
Therefore, the SNUPPS Utilities request that this new regulatory posi-tion be reviewed in accordance with the provisions of 10 CFR Part 50.109. In addition, the SNUPPS Utilities request a meeting with appropriate NRC management in accordance with the procedures for dis-position of backfitting requirements which have been implemented by the Offices of Inspection and Enforcement and Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
Very truly yours, Nicholas A. Petrick MHF/nIdl2al4&15 cc: D. F. Schnell UE G. L. Koester KGE D. T. MkPhee KCPL J. Nellser/8. Little USNRC/CAL H. Bundy USNRC/WC
- 8. L. Forney USNRC/RIII
- 0. R. Hunter USNRC/RIV V. Stello, Jr. USNRC
-04_40,v
SLNRC 84- 0106 Page 4 bcc: F. D. Crawford KCPL D. W. Capone -UE 1M.L. Johnson KGE J. A. Bailey KGE/IIC M. A. Hannah KGE D. E. Shsfer UE A. C. Passwater VE S. E. Miltenberger UE/CAL F. T. Rhodes KGE/IIC
- 3. H. Smith B L. R. Benson v J. 0. Cermak AfF 1I__