ML060580187

E-mail from D. Vito of USNRC to Various, Regarding Usc Ltr 0 Ucs Issues for Tomorrows Meeting

ML060580187
Person / Time
Site:	Salem, Hope Creek
Issue date:	12/02/2004
From:	Vito D NRC Region 1
To:	Blough A, Cobey E, Ray Lorson, Elizabeth Wilson NRC Region 1
References
FOIA/PA-2005-0194
Download: ML060580187 (4)

Text

-Marc Ferdas - Fwd: Re:UCS Itr - - ucs issues for tomorrow's meeting - -Action requested Page 1

/

From:

David Vito l To:

A. Randolph Blough; Ernest Wilson; Eugene Cobey; Raymond Lorson Date:

12/2/04 8:29AM

Subject:

Fwd: Re:UCS Itr - - ucs issues for tomorrow's meeting - - Action requested

- SENSITIVE ALLEGATION INFORMATION -

- PROTECT ACCORDINGLY -

Randy, I have gotten input from Dan, Lisa J. and Andrea K., and the consensus is that we should put an item from the letth intoAMS with regard to the Notification ihat purportedly may have been a precursor to the 10/10 event. "'Dr. K.jhad mentioned this in considerably less detail previously and we informed her that we were looking at any Notifications that may relate to the event as part of the then ongoing SIT. Since we now have more specific detail about the subject matter of the Notification, and I 'm not sure the SIT has looked at it (although I would assume they probably did), I agree that calling this an allegation woudl appear to be appropriate at this time. If you have other knowledge, i.e. that the SIT had already identified the Notification, reviewed it, and rendered conclusions about it, we could still keep the issue out of the Allegation process on that basis (and make it an RA Action Item to respond). If I don't here anything contrary from you/DRP by the end of today (12/2)., I will draw up an Allegation Receipt Report for this.

>>> A. Randolph Blough 12/01/04 12:58PM >>>

Ltr from UCS asserting that

1) our delay in completing investigation has wrongedI-larvinland chilled others

2) PSEG's mgt handling of the outage and R/S plan, in the days immediately after the 10/10 scram, has harmed SCWE seriously.

Ernie - - i will need your advice on how to handle this question tomorrow night Ray/Gene - - i will need the residents' and SIT's take on the assertion about HC decision-making. we can discuss a bit tomorrow.

We know UCS also sent the Itr to PSEG - - i will get their take on it and find out if anything they are saying tomorrow will help address this.

Dave Vito - - do we need to enter as an allegation or simply a RA action item to respond.

Cyndy - - please initiate an the RA action item, if needed, based on Dave's reply.

thanks.

randy CC:

Andrea Kock; Anne Passarelli; Brian Holian; Bruce Boger; Carl Mohrwinkel; Clare Goodman; Cornelius Holden; Cynthia Carpenter.: Cynthia O'Daniell; Daniel Holody; Daniel Orr; Darrell Roberts; Diane Screnci; Doug Weaver; Edwin Gray; George Malone; James Clifford; James Wiggins; Jeffrey Teator; Joel Wiebe; John Grobe; John Jolicoeur; Julius Persensky; Lawrence Doerflein; Leanne Harrison; Lisamarie Jarriel; Marc Ferdas; Mel Gray; Richard Crlenjak; Samuel Collins; Scott Barber; Sharon Johnson; Stephen Pindale; Stuart Richards; Theodore Wingfield; Thomas Madden; Wayne Lanning

Mail Envelope Properties (41AF18C7.13:5: 21: 34876)

Subject:

Fwd: Re:UCS ltr - - ucs issues for tomorrow's meeting - - Action requested Creation Date:

12/2/04 8:29AM From:

David Vito Created By:

DJV@nrc.gov Recipients kplpo.KPDO CEO CC (Cynthia ODaniell)

WDL CC (Wayne Lanning) nrc.gov chpo.CHDO JAG CC (John Grobe) nrc.gov kpl-po.KPDO AEP CC (Anne Passarelli)

ARB (A. Randolph Blough)

BEH CC (Brian Holian)

DJH CC (Daniel Holody)

DPS CC (Diane Screnci)

EHG CC (Edwin Gray)

EPW (Ernest Wilson)

EWC (Eugene Cobey)

GJM2 CC (George Malone)

GSB CC (Scott Barber)

JAT CC (Jeffrey Teator)

JDO CC (Daniel Orr)

JSW4 CC (Joel Wiebe)

JTW1 CC (James Wiggins)

LMH1 CC (Leanne Harrison)

LTD CC (Lawrence Doerflein)

MSF2 CC (Marc Ferdas)

MXG3 CC (Mel Gray)

RKL (Raymond Lorson)

RVC CC (Richard CrIenjak)

SJC1 CC (Samuel Collins)

SLJ CC (Sharon Johnson)

SMP CC (Stephen Pindale)

TVW CC (Theodore Wingfield)

i
- I-,.,,

[.cAtemp\\GWJ0000I.TMP

<<PAage `22 cAtemp\\GW}O0001.TMP Page 2 I nrc.gov owf2_po.0WFNDO ALK CC (Andrea Kock)

BAB2 CC (Bruce Boger)

CAM CC (Carl Mohrwinkel)

CPG CC (Clare Goodman) nrc.gov owf4_po.0WFN_DO CAC CC (Cynthia Carpenter)

CFH CC (Cornelius Holden)

DJR CC (Darrell Roberts)

JWC CC (James Clifford)

LUJ CC (Lisamarie Jarriel)

SAR CC (Stuart Richards) nrc.gov owf5_po.OWFN_DO DWW CC (Doug Weaver)

JRJ1 CC (John Jolicoeur) nrc.gov twf5-po.TWFNDO JJP2 CC (Julius Persensky)

TJM CC (Thomas Madden)

Post Office Route kpl-po.KPDO chlpo.CHDO nrc.gov kpl-po.KPIDO nrc.gov owf2_po.OWFNDO nrc.gov owf4_po.0WFNDO nrc.gov owf5_po.OWFNDO nrc.gov twf5_po.TWFNDO nrc.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 2953 12/02/04 08:29AM Options Expiration Date:

None Priority:

Standard Reply Requested:

No Return Notification:

None Concealed

Subject:

No

uteip\\GWjOOOO1.TMP Page 3S d

Security:

Standard