ML053140107
| ML053140107 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 11/10/2005 |
| From: | Daniel Frumkin NRC/NRR/ADRA/DRA/AFPB |
| To: | Marion A Nuclear Energy Institute |
| Frumkin D | |
| References | |
| Download: ML053140107 (5) | |
Text
From:
Daniel Frumkin To:
Alex MARION Date:
11/10/05 9:28AM
Subject:
Fire Protection Issues Management Protocol Meeting
- Alex, Attached is the NRC's working copy of the FP Issues Management List. Let's talk at the beginning of the year to schedule a meeting here at the NRC for early 2006.
This email and the attachment will be put on the docket.
Dan Daniel M. Frumkin <DXF1@NRC.GOV>
Fire Protection Engineer U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission MS/O-11A11 Washington, DC 20555-0001 PHONE 301-415-2280 FAX 301-415-2300 CC:
Weerakkody, Sunil
Mail Envelope Properties (43735903.380 : 16 : 3753)
Subject:
Fire Protection Issues Management Protocol Meeting Creation Date:
11/10/05 9:28AM From:
Daniel Frumkin Created By:
DXF1@nrc.gov Recipients Action Date & Time nei.org Transferred 11/10/05 9:29 AM am (Alex MARION) nrc.gov owf2_po.OWFN_DO Delivered 11/10/05 9:28 AM SDW1 CC (Sunil Weerakkody)
Opened 11/10/05 9:29 AM Replied 11/10/05 9:29 AM Post Office Delivered Route nei.org owf2_po.OWFN_DO 11/10/05 9:28 AM nrc.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 1265 11/10/05 09:28AM Working copy Issues Management Tracking List.wpd 69974 11/10/05 09:24AM Options Auto Delete:
No Expiration Date:
None Notify Recipients:
Yes Priority:
Standard Reply Requested:
No Return Notification:
None Concealed
Subject:
No Security:
Standard To Be Delivered:
Immediate Status Tracking:
All Information
3 INDUSTRY/NRC FIRE PROTECTION ISSUE MANAGEMENT TRACKING LIST Active Items - Draft 6 - Nov 10, 2005 Track-ing Issue/origin Priority NRC Position Industry Position Next Action Action Responsi-bility Action Due Date Applicable References NFPA 805/10 CFR 50.48(c) 805-3 Processing of licensing basis issues (how issues are to be handled during transition) for licensees adopting NFPA 805 (issue needs more definition)
N - High I - High Addressed in 69 FR 33685 and DG-1139 Addressed in public comments on DG-1139 (NEI #4). More details required in DG-1139 and/or NEI 04-02 To be included in NEI 04-02 and NRC R.G.
N, I Dec 2005 DG-1139, NFPA 805, 69 FR 33685, NEI 04-02 805-8 NRC issue final reg guide for adoption of NFPA 805 licensing basis N - High I - High Minimize RG content -
include guidance in NEI 04-02 Agree with NRC position; RG should fully endorse NEI 04-02 NRC to Complete RG Address ACRS Comments N
Spring 2006 DG-1139, NEI 04-02 Circuit Failure CF-7 Release report on NEI 00-01 pilots to NRC N - Med I - Low Determine if summary of report can be provided in the near future I
NEI follow up.
CF-8 RIS for clarification of circuit analysis terms N - High I - Low Positions stated in RIS Varies Incorporate stakeholder comments and finalize RIS NRC proposed RIS to address endorsement of NEI 00-01 for non-805 plants. RIS 2005-03 provides endorsement for 805 plants. RG to address.
Public meeting planned.
N Draft RIS ML051110160 CF-9 Additional clarification of circuit analysis terms N-High I-low Additional issues may require clarification NRC to determine if additional clarifications are needed N
Complete Draft issued Oct 2005, Final expected Spring 2006 Fire Barrier Issues
Track-ing Issue/origin Priority NRC Position Industry Position Next Action Action Responsi-bility Action Due Date Applicable References 4
FB-4 Generic communication on Hemyc/MT test results N-High I-?
NRC will collect information regarding Hemyc/MT and licensees will act to ensure compliance is met NRC to issue draft generic communication on Hemyc/MT N
ongoing Fire protection web site has been updated with applicable references.
FRN published July 25 for public comment - Comment period is closed ML051990212 Other Fire Protection Issues FP -1a CO2 System Lockouts N-Med I-Low NRC to respond to NEI white paper Review NRC comments and determine if further action is warranted I
NRC comment issued July 20 ML05174005 FP-2 Industry response to NRC position on NEI 02-03 N - Med I - Med Preparing Complete and submit I
Winter 2005 NEI 02-03, Rev 0 NEI to follow up.
FP-4a Epoxy coating/flame spread N-Low I-Low NRC to respond to NEI white paper N
FP-7 Containment Oil Misting N - Med I - ?
Potential non-compliance with III.O, if from RCPs.
Two plants have affected RCPs.
Two other plants may have other oil source Industry to survey and report NRC to provide specifics during public meeting I
Winter 2005 FP-8 Mrule consideration of fire N-High I-?
Maintenance Rule evaluations should consider fire risk NRC to provide specifics I Jan 2006 FP-9 Fire hydrants grease may cause corrosion NRC to issue IN N
Winter 2005/
2006 FP-10 Site FP Engineers Cleared for Safe-Guards Info licensees have the authority to clear FP Engineers since they would appear to have "a need to know". Apparently this is not being done, note various conflicts between security and FP.
Track-ing Issue/origin Priority NRC Position Industry Position Next Action Action Responsi-bility Action Due Date Applicable References 5
FPX FP Security Interface The inspectors observed new security barrier features that may impact the fire protection program by potentially hampering timely deployment of fire equipment, personnel and other fire protection features.
The development of Fire PRA Peer Review Guide NRC would like to use the IMP to organize development of peer review guide NEI to create peer review guide for FP PRAS by 12/31/2006 Inspections and Self-Assessments I/SA-4 Develop SDP for Fire Brigades N - Med I - Low Preparing Complete draft and provide to industry for comment N
Manual Actions MA-3 Alternate shutdown manual actions N - High I - Med Proposed rule issued; public comment received. NRC will evaluate and provide position in final rule Same feasibility criteria as IP 71111.05T (March 2003) should apply Proposed rule issued; public comment received.
Final rule in development N
Winter 2005/
2006 FRN Vol. 70 No. 43 pg 10901 NEI ltr 5/23/05 NOTES:
Definitions 805 - issue related to NFPA 805 rulemaking or implementation CF - issue related to circuit failure issue closure, NEI 00-01, or associated circuit inspections FB - issue related to fire barriers FP - general fire protection issue INPO - issue related to INPO I/SA - issue related to fire protection inspections or self-assessments MA - issue related to manual actions