ML051190749

Dr. Harvin E-Mail Dated 4/28/05 Regarding Smoking Guns at Pseg.

ML051190749
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse, Salem, Hope Creek
Issue date:	04/28/2005
From:	Harvin N Leaders Worth Following
To:	Blough A NRC Region 1
Shared Package
ML051190714	List: ML051190722 ML051190733 ML051190749 ML051220266
References
Download: ML051190749 (5)

Text

From: <Drkymn@aol.com>

To: <ARB@nrc.gov>

Date: 4/28/05 4:00PM

Subject:

Re: "Smoking Guns at PSEG" Mr. Blough, Randy:

Yes, you may put my correspondence on ADAMS.

I do want to make it clear that I urged--and continue to urge--the NRC, and now the Government Accountability Office and the Inspector General's Office, to interview Mr. Brothers under oath, not just about ERB-related matters but about all matters related to the safe operation of Salem and Hope Creek.

Mr. Brothers is quite knowledgeable, having served at Salem/Hope Creek when it was being managed by PSEG and now being managed by Exelon. I believe he can point out misrepresentations made to regulators by PSEG and Exelon, he can point out weaknesses in the NRC regulatory oversight process, and he can make it clear why he believes safety culture and Safety Conscious Work Environment matters are not being genuinely supported by the NRC, INPO or in some cases utilities.

I do not agree with Mr. Brothers on everything. But I do consider him a man of courage and integrity, willing to tell the truth even when warned against doing so. I do not believe he will put the self-interest of his career before public safety. The time has come for his voice to be heard and for the truth to come out. I consider it the government's responsibility to avail itself of Mr. Brothers' knowledge, experience, evidence, and insight. It would be a travesty not to do so.

Sincerely, Nancy Kymn Harvin, Ph.D.

Leaders Worth Following In a message dated 4/26/2005 7:46:39 AM Eastern Standard Time, ARB@nrc.gov writes:

Kymn, You asked that we ensure that our NRC team this week, which is following up on PSEG's response to our letter about Executive Review Board (ERB) issues, be sure to talk to Mike Brothers, who has just recently resigned as a VP at Salem/Hope Creek. We agree that he has been a key person. We have initiated several discussions with Mr. Brothers on ERB issues, as early as January 7 and as recently as last Friday. The team onsite has the benefit of those, and will make a decision in-process as to whether to contact him again.

Thanks for informing me of your views. Looking at what you sent me, I believe it is appropriate to put your email, as well as this response, into ADAMS as publicly available documents, but only if you concur - - would you agree?

Regards, Randy Blough

NRC Region 1

>>> <Drkymn@aol.com> 04/25/05 10:24AM >>>

Mr. Blough

Randy, Based on our recent dialogue about Exelon's lack of support for genuine safety culture improvements at Salem and Hope Creek, I am sure you are not surprised to learn that Vice President Mike Brothers has resigned from PSEG Nuclear. As you know, Mike was in charge of the Safety Conscious Work Environment initiatives and felt virtually powerless, even though a Vice President.

I understand a three person NRC team will be at Salem/Hope Creek starting today to follow up on the Executive Review Board procedure violations and to interview people. I encourage you to be sure Mike is one of those people.

The NRC needs to face the real reasons behind Mr. Brothers' departure.

It's not because he has a better job offer somewhere else.

While it is not a resigning utility vice president's responsibility to "connect the dots" for the NRC, but Mike Brothers could clearly do so.

Does the NRC care enough to elicit the truth from him? And if you do, what will the NRC do with all the evidence he gives you?

I believe a cache of "smoking guns" is there for the taking at PSEG Nuclear.

But I, and countless others, have lost faith that the NRC cares. In fact, some think the NRC helps keep evidence "buried" and out of the public eye.

It's like the NRC finds the guns, wipes off all the fingerprints, and throws them in a dumpster.

Things are VERY awry at Salem and Hope Creek.

When is the NRC going to realize this and do more than turn a blind eye and a deaf ear to the people trying to shed light?

How many more "departures" (inappropriate terminations, firings, resignations) need to happen for the NRC to realize another Davis-Besse is evolving before your very eyes?

Why, when the NRC staff repeatedly said they were looking for a "smoking gun," does the NRC ignore the facts--forced shutdowns, pipe breaks, safety systems malfunctioning, training on probation, fraudulent maintenance

records, managers risking everything to make public the site's nuclear safety

issues,

four Chief Nuclear Officers and four Site Vice Presidents in less than two years?

When taken together, these facts are compelling evidence of a utility on the verge of disaster. Even INPO's own research makes this case. Smaller issues than this halt Acela runs. Smaller issues than this ground a 747.

Smaller issues than this now cancel a NASA space launch.

Are we really going to wait for an "event" that, according to industry statistics, is just around the corner?

Do you really want to do that to our country, our industry, the American people?

Do you, Randy? If you cannot get sufficient support from Region 1, I urge you--for the sake of all of us--to go direct to the Commissioners, the Government Accountability Office, the Inspector General's Office. I am copying them on this letter to alert them to this situation and to ask for their support.

None of us can win this battle alone. A few people, willing to buck the system, can turn the tide. Public safety must be first.

We're counting on you, Randy.

Sincerely, Kymn Nancy Kymn Harvin, Ph.D.

Leaders Worth Following cell 267 312 1252 CC: <tonya_baker@biden.senate.gov>, <carolyn.casey@carper.senate.gov>,

<jill.lipoti@dep.state.nj.us>, <dmw@gao.org>, <Cindy_Bethell@lautenberg.senate.gov>,

<karen.long@mail.house.gov>, <kate.rohrer@mail.house.gov>,

<leslie.potter@mail.house.gov>, <michal.freedhoff@mail.house.gov>, <BCD@nrc.gov>,

<GAM@nrc.gov>, <njd@nrc.gov>, <gbj@nrc.gov>, <exm@nrc.gov>, <jmer@nrc.gov>,

<pbl@nrc.gov>, <htb@nrc.gov>, <gam@nrc.gov>, <bcd@nrc.gov>, <dlochbaum@ucsusa.org>

Mail Envelope Properties (427140BA.3D7 : 10 : 29655)

Subject:

Re: "Smoking Guns at PSEG" Creation Date: 4/28/05 3:59PM From: <Drkymn@aol.com>

Created By: Drkymn@aol.com Recipients nrc.gov kp1_po.KP_DO ARB (A. Randolph Blough) nrc.gov owf5_po.OWFN_DO NJD CC (Nils Diaz)

EXM CC (Edward McGaffigan)

JMER CC (Jeffrey Merrifield) nrc.gov OWGWPO02.HQGWDO01 GBJ CC (Gregory Jaczko) nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 PBL CC (Peter Lyons) nrc.gov twf2_po.TWFN_DO HTB CC (Hubert Bell)

GAM CC (George Mulley) nrc.gov ch_po.CH_DO BCD CC (Billy Dickson) ucsusa.org dlochbaum CC mail.house.gov michal.freedhoff CC leslie.potter CC kate.rohrer CC karen.long CC lautenberg.senate.gov Cindy_Bethell CC gao.org dmw CC dep.state.nj.us jill.lipoti CC

carper.senate.gov carolyn.casey CC biden.senate.gov tonya_baker CC Post Office Route kp1_po.KP_DO nrc.gov owf5_po.OWFN_DO nrc.gov OWGWPO02.HQGWDO01 nrc.gov TWGWPO01.HQGWDO01 nrc.gov twf2_po.TWFN_DO nrc.gov ch_po.CH_DO nrc.gov ucsusa.org mail.house.gov lautenberg.senate.gov gao.org dep.state.nj.us carper.senate.gov biden.senate.gov Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 5687 04/28/05 03:59PM TEXT.htm 7562 Mime.822 15297 Options Expiration Date: None Priority: Standard Reply Requested: No Return Notification: None Concealed

Subject:

No Security: Standard