ML041140203

NRC Comments on the Operating Test and ES-401-9 for the NRC Comments on the Written Exam and ES-401-4 - Record of Rejected K/As for the Clinton Initial Examination - January 2004

ML041140203
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	01/06/2004
From:	Lanksbury R NRC/RGN-III/DRS/OLB
To:
References
50-461/04-301 50-461/04-301
Download: ML041140203 (19)

Text

NRC COMMENTS ON THE OPERATING TEST AND ES-401-9 FOR THE NRC COMMENTS ON THE WRITTEN EXAM AND ES-401 RECORD OF REJECTED WAS FOR THE CLINTON INITIAL EXAMINATION -JANUARY 2004

Clinton JPM and Scenario Comments and RESOLUTION SYSTEM JPMS:

Overall Comments:

1) Spell out the KA, rather than just referencing the KA number.

2) Separate the Initial Conditions and Initiating Cue.

3) Only identify one KA for JPM task.

4) Need to identify the initial plant conditions.

RESET RECIRC FCV LOCKOUT

1) Simulator Setup: Why not raise locked flow controller servo error output such that if the operator improperly unlocks the FCV, there will be a significant flow / power increase?

2) Only two critical steps. (level of difficulty?)

3) JPM does not match A408, better fit to A208 RESOLUTION:

I ) If the servo error output is not zeroed there will be a power increase.

2) Level of difficulty accepted based on on-site validation.

3) KA Ability to manually operate Recirc from control room, acceptable MANUAL STARTUP LPCS LOGIC NOT AVAILABLE (alternate path)

1) Only provided Initiating Cue, need Initial Conditions (ie, of the plant)

2) Performance Step 8.1.3, is it critical that the operator identify failure of the LPCS pump to start after A&D pushbutton?

3) Step *4: a) JPM failure if operator opens valve when RCS pressure greater than 472 psig?

b) Rewrite sentence in COMMENTS:

4) Step *5: Why is this step critical? Necessary to obtain required flow?

5) Step 6: Critical to restore / maintain RPV level?

6) Terminating Cue: Is the task to start the LPCS pump and inject to RPV at full flow, or to restore and maintain RPV level with LPCS?

7) Multiple KAs identified. Only identify one (A403 doesnt fit).

8) Kind of minimal alternate path because, operator stays in same procedure RESOLUTION:

I ) Initial conditions added

2) Yes but the follow up actions are the critical steps.

3) In this JPM pressure will be - 400 psig.

4) a) Necessary to maximize flow per cue b) COMMENT incorrect as observed at OV, COMMENT deleted.

5)&6) At this point LPCS flow will be max which is the JPM task.

7) KA now 209001 A4.1 I ability to operate and/or monitor system flow.

8) Acceptable based on OV must change procedure sections base on identiwing equipment failure.

Page 1 of 6

Clinton JPM and Scenario Comments and RESOLUTION TURBINE ON LINE TESTS (alternate path)

1) Only provided Initiating Cue, need Initial Conditions (ie, of the plant)

2) Why is this JPM considered alternate path? The operator identifies failure of the 125 and 24 Vdc backup overspeed trip circuit to reset, informs the CRS, and stops the test.

RESOLUTION:

1)lnitial Conditions added.

2)Agree the JPM not alternate path, JPM document changed to Alternate path NO. ( Exam still has correct number of alternate path JPMs) 3)This JPM removed from SRO(U) test and replaced with, PERFORM CONTAINMENT HYDROGEN PURGE (plant, alternate path)

EQUALIZE AROUND AND OPEN MSlVs

1) Step 4, clarify if the operator is going to have to adjust pressure. Critical if pressure has to be adjusted.

2) Multiple KAs identified. Only identify one (A402 doesn't fit).

RESOLUTION:

1) Step made critical operator will have to adjust pressure.

2) KA changed to 239001 A4.01 ability to manually operate/monitor MSlVs from control room.

PERFORM CONTAINMENT HYDROGEN PURGE (plant, alternate path)

1) JPM identified as a plant JPM; however, the JPM lists simulator setup conditions.

2) Alternate path to stop one train and start the other?

RESOLUTION:

1) JPM document changed to show this as simulator JPM.

2) Goal is to Purge containment, when train A fails train B is used.

PARALLEL DG 1 B WITH OFFSITE POWER (alternate path, time critical?)

1) Is JPM Time Critical? If so, what is the reference and basis for the critical JPM time of 30 minutes?

2) Identify Initial Conditions (ie, of the plant).

3) Step 8.2.1 5.2 is critical (differential voltage=circulating current).

4) Step 8.2.15.3 is critical (want DG to assume load; if slower, DG could become the load).

5) Step 8.2.15.5.2 is critical (reverse power trip if don't get load on DG). Is reverse power trip modeled on simulator (fidelity)?

6) Why is CAUTION in the JPM?

7) Step 8.2.1 6.2 and.3 critical?

R ESO L U TI0 N:

I ) JPM not time critical.

2) Done.

3) Step 8.2.15.2 is critical

4) Step 8.2.15.3 is critical

5) Step 8.2.75.5.2 is critical. The reverse power trip is modeled on simulator.

6) The CAUTION is in the JPM for examiner info only.

Page 2 of 6

Clinton JPM and Scenario Comments and RESOLUTION

7) Step 8.2.16.2 and.3 are not critical as they will have no effect.

SHIFT OFFGAS POST TREATMENT PROCESS RADIATION MONITORS

1) Low level of difficulty, no good evaluation of operator competency.

2) Multiple KAs identified. Only identify one.

RESOLUTION:

JPM replaced with JPM Defeat RPS Logic Trips.

STARTUP THE CONTROL ROOM VENTILATION SYSTEM IN THE HIGH RADIATION MODE (alternate path, time critical)

1) A system KA should be used, not a generic one.

2) What is the reference and basis for the critical JPM time?

RESOLUTION:

1) KA changed to 290003 A4.01 ability to operate/monitor initiateheset system in control room,

2) Under LOCA conditions the filters in the Supply Air Train Filters will become exhausted in 20 minutes, therefore switch over to the minimum air damper must be done in 20 minutes of less.

VENTING CRD WITHDRAWAL LINES

1) Add ladder and key to unlock ladder to required equipment.

RESOLUTION:

1) Done THROTTLING ECCS INJECTION FLOW-HPCS (plant)

1) Identify the Initial Conditions.

2) KA is for operating HPCS for low RWL, but JPM is for throttling HPCS flow.

RESOLUTION:

I ) Initial Conditions added.

2) KA acceptable, JPM simulates actions after a LOCA water level recovew.

DC LOAD SHEDDING DURING A STATION BLACKOUT (plant) 1 ) JPM requires locating and opening breakers. Low level difficulty.

2) Multiple KAs identified. Only identify one.

RESOLUTION:

1) Level of difficulty acceptable based on On-site validation, need to enter 2 panels and correctly interpret to shed only Div 1 DC.

2) Done Page 3 of 6

Clinton JPM and Scenario Comments and RESOLUTION ADMINISTRATIVE JPMS:

CONTROL ROD / POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY (RO; faulted):

1 ) Time critical?

2) Only 3 steps to perform (two of which are critical), no real verifiable actions. 100% RTP and rod mispositioned one step, what is safety significance? Operator is handed the printouts.

Insufficient evaluation of operator analysis, diagnosis, and decision making. Only has to identify mispositioned rod and notify SM. Task is listed as completion of restoration and identification of misaligned rod. Recommend adding some verifiable operator actions or replacing JPM.

RESOLUTION:

I ) Not time critical.

2) JPM changed to find mis-positioned rod and reposition the rod.

COMPLETE AN SRV ACTUATION REPORT (RO, faulted):

1) Give Initial Conditions.

2) Only one critical step (8.1.l) to identify leaking SRV based on tailpipe temperature not returning to normal after actuation.

RESOLUTION:

1) Done

2) Three other steps are critical.

DETERMINE EFFECTS OF FAILED RELAY (electrical print reading):

(Containment Instrument Air Isolation valves will not close on RWL 1 signal)

1) Although only one critical step identified, may want to expand statement to include the critical elements that the operator has to identify to be successful.

RESOLUTION:

I ) JPM expanded and critical steps identified.

PREPARE AN EVENT NOTIFICATION WORKSHEET (ENW) FORM

1) This JPM requires no analysis, diagnosis, or decisions. The required information is given in the INITIAL CONDITIONS. All the applicant has to do is plug the information into the worksheet and call the NRC. Replace or enhance procedure.

2) KA is "Knowledge of emergency communications systems and techniques." Recommend problem with normal communications, need to use alternate means or the like.

3) Can probably get a better admin JPM for the SROs.

RESOLUTION:

1/2) JPM rewritten so information to fill out ENW form comes from logs and NARS form.

3) This will be an RO only JPM.

Page 4 of 6

Clinton JPM and Scenario Comments and RESOLUTION DETERMINE AN EP PARS WITH SUBSEQUENT WIND DIRECTION CHANGE (SRO, time critical 14 min):

1) The JPM focuses the applicant in on Section 9, then a single parameter (wind) is provided which focuses the applicant on the wind direction change. JPM does not require sufficient evaluation of applicants ability to analyze, diagnose, or make a decision. At least make the applicant fill out the whole form based on initial conditions, then supply another set of readings and let the applicant identify any significant, required changes (ie, wind direction).

RESOLUTION:

1) JPM changed to Complete a NARS Form and make the required notifications.

REVIEW A COMPLETED CONTROL ROD / POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY SURVEILLANCE (SRO, faulted):

1) This is same as the RO JPM. Same comments. Why isnt step 3 critical in this JPM? Need to have SRO apply TS LCOs or the like.

RESOLUTION:

1) Same changes made to this JPM as to RO version.

DETERMINE EMERGENCY JOB DOSE AND SELECT WORKER FOR JOB:

1) Insufficient analysis, diagnosis, and decision making. At least provide a dose history for each worker, include contamination factor(s), differentiate between administrative and CFR limits(?). KA is knowledge of radiation exposure limits and contamination control / including permissible levels in excess of those authorized.

RESOLUTION:

1) This JPM was replaced with a new JPM Muthorize an emergency dose for a life saving operation.

REVIEW A COMPLETED SRV ACTUATION REPORT (SRO, faulted):

1) Basically, same as the RO JPM. Same comments.

2) Two KAs listed, pick one to apply to the JPM.

RESOLUTION:

I ) There will be errors in both the actuation type and the conclution.

2) KA is 2.1.32 ability to explain/apply system limits.

REVIEW AND APPROVE A SAFEGUARDS EVENT NOTIFICATION WORKSHEET (ENW)

FOR SECURITY THREAT (faulted):

1) The reviewer has a 50-50 chance of getting the reportability correct (either 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> or Log Only) which is provides insufficient test of the applicants analysis, diagnosis, and decision making. Replace or enhance.

RESOLUTION:

I ) This JPM was replaced with Determine actions required for a security threat.

Page 5 of 6

Clinton JPM and Scenario Comments and RESOLUTION SCENARIO 1 :

Event 6 was on the last NRC exam it should be replaced.

RESOL UTiON:

1) This event was deleted and a normal event added to replace it.

SCENARIO 2:

Event 4 a control drifts out is to much like event 2 an uncoupled rod in scenario 1 (uses same procedures)

RESOLUTION:

I ) This event was replaced with an inadvertent Recirc Flow Control Valve closure.

Page 6 of 6

ES-401 Written Examination Form ES-401-9 Review Worksheet

3. Psychometric Flaws Stem Cues T/F Cred. Partial Focus Dist.

4. Job Content Flaws Job-Minutia

1. /

Back-Link units ward 3

5. Other Q= SRO WA Only

6.

7.

U/WS Explanation X

1N 2N H

H RO EXAM QUESTIONS 1 THROUGH 75 First, the correct answer C requires that the candidate remember without the aid of a procedure that DC load shed must be completed within one hour.

Second, distractor D, could be correct. With a loss of all AC power an1 therefore a loss of control room ventilation why couldnt reaching the habitability limit be possible?

Third, distractor A, could be correct. Is the bypass of RClC leak detection isolation automatic? If not why is A incorrect?

RESOLUTION:

1) This is consistent with plant expectations.

2) Clinton has a dedicated blackout power supply for control room ventilation.

I

3) Distractor A changed X

S I

Instructions

[Refer to Section D of ES-401 and Appendix B for additional information regarding each of the following concepts.]

1.

2.

3.

Enter the level of knowledge (LOK) of each question as either (F)undamental or (H)igher cognitive level.

Enter the level of difficulty (LOD) of each question using a 1 - 5 (easy - difficult) rating scale (questions in the 2 - 4 range are acceptable).

Check the appropriate box if a psychometric flaw is identified:

The stem lacks sufficient focus to elicit the correct answer (e.g., unclear intent, more information is needed, or too much needless information).

The stem or distractors contain cues (Le., clues, specific determiners, phrasing, length, etc).

The answer choices are a collection of unrelated true/false statements.

More than one distractor is not credible.

One or more distractors is (are) partially correct (e.g., if the applicant can make unstated assumptions that are not contradicted by stem).

Check the appropriate box if a job content error is identified:

The question is not linked to the job requirements (Le., the question has a valid WA but, as written, is not operational in content).

The question requires the recall of knowledge that is too specific for the closed reference test mode (i.e., it is not required to be known from memory).

The question contains data with an unrealistic level of accuracy or inconsistent units (e.g., panel meter in percent with question in gallons).

The question requires reverse logic or application compared to the job requirements.

5.

5.

Check questions that are sampled for conformance with the approved WA and those that are designated SRO-only (WA and license level mismatches are unacceptable),

Based on the reviewers judgment, is the question as written (U)nacceptable (requiring repair or replacement), in need of (E)ditorial enhancement, or (S)atisfactory?

7.

At a minimum, explain any U ratings (e.g., how the Appendix B psychometric attributes are not being met).

?

Form FS-401-9 (R8. Si)

3. Psychometric Flaws I

4. Job Content Flaws

5. Other

6.

7.

Q= SRO u/E/s Explanation WA Only U

S First, if there are two DC power source for SRVs or no DC is needed to operate SRVs and that is all that is needed to get this question right, then LOD=l.

Second, to know distractors "B" & "C" are wrong the candidate must remember that RClC and the a temperature transmitter on RWCU is R nowledge expected without the use of plant documents?

RESOLUTION:

1 Answers changed to require more knowledge.

21 Question consistent with site expectations.

owered from DC bus A rather than busses B or C. Is this level of Ainutia X

L -

H 4 -

2 I

I 4

S H

4 3 -

4 -

2 X

First, add suppression pool and RClC suction tank level so there is a bases in the stem for distractor "D" being wrong.

Second, change the rector pressure in the stem to 375 pisg so that grater than a 100drg cool down has already occurred and it can not be argued that distractor "C" is also correct.

RESOLUTION:

1 Done 21 Agree that "C" is wronge as is for stated stem conditions.

L -

H -

L I P I L -

H?

L 3 -

2 E

S Does the Clinton SAT based training pro ram require ROs to know EOF bases? At most sites this would be an S80 question.

Why does the site feel this question is Cog Level L?

RESOLUTION:

1) At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of bases of EOP anged Cog Level to L.

1#

2N 3N 4B -

5N 6N 7 8 -

8N Q

_I 9N

!ON tQ

!IN -

!2B

1.

LOK F/H) -

H?

L H?

L H

3. Psychometric Flaws

4. Job Content Flaws

7.

6. I

5. Other rlinutia u/E/s I Explanation E

S Does the Clinton SAT based training pro ram require ROs to know EOP bases? At most sites this would be an S i 0 question, Why does the site feel this question is Cog Level L?

RESOLUTION:

1) At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of bases of EOP

$?&anged Cog Level to L.

Does the Clinton SAT based training pro ram require ROs to know EOP bases? At most sites this would be an S i 0 question.

Why does the site feel this question is Cog Level L?

RESOLUTION:

1) At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of bases of EOP ste s.

2) ehanged Cog Level to L.

E S

L H

L -

3 4

3 -

Does the Clinton SAT based training pro ram require ROs to know EOP bases? At most sites this would be an S i 0 question.

RESOLUTION:

I At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of bases of EOP steps.

S I

H H

L -

H 2

3 3 -

4 S

Difficulty 1 (direct lookup on EOP-1A)

RESOLUTION:

Agreed this is more than direct look up.

U S

Does the Clinton SAT based training program require ROs to know EOP at this level of decision making? At most sites this would be an SRO question.

RESOLUTION:

At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of bases of EOP steps.

I U

S No reference is supplied, doesnt the candidate need a Power vs Flow map to know distractor 6 is wrong.

RESOLUTION:

A power/flow,ma is provided also it is expected that operators know 138mlbs is limit orstability region H

2

Inly U

S Does the Clinton SAT based training pro ram require ROs to know EOP bases? At most sites this would be an SkO question.

3. Psychometric Flaws I

4. Job Content Flaws

5. Other I 6. I

7.

Explanation jtem

-0cus -

H 3

L 2

H?

2 L

H 3

L 2

H 3

H 3

H?

2 H

L 3

H 4

H 4

H 3

H 3

H 3

H 2

RESOLUTION:

At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of bases of EOP steps.

I I

I s I Why does the site feel this question is Cog Level L?

Changed cog level to L.

The question is about MAX SAFE water levels not the Secondary containment drain system.

Resolution:

Accepted site position that key to this question is that the sump pump capacity is exceeded and therefore the KA is correct.

I s I S

I s I Why does the site feel this question is Cog Level H? The question appears to be a normal cooldown is in rogress and the operator throttles the return valve, what is the effect?

RESULUTION:

Agreed with site that 2 pieces of knowledge are necessary to answer the question. (Effect on Rx and effect on heat exchanger)

P I I s I P I P I I s I

3. Psychometric Flaws I

4. Job Content Flaws

,IO,ther SRO I uE/s

6. I

7.

Explanation lack- *

- I P I S

S H

H 4

3 For distractor A it seems very unlikely an one would choose a LPCS pump starting at 12:E to cause a 1204 A h

RESOLUTION:

In distractor A time changed to 12:01:46 I P I 13N H

3 S

S t4N 15N -

16N Q

L H?

H -

S Why does the site feel this question is Cog,Level H? The uestion is similar to asking what is the effect of the failure of the SGTS heaters.

RESOLUTION:

Accepted site position that knowledge of plant condition must be combined with knowledge of system desian.

L I P I 17N Q8N 19M Q

H L -

S S

H?

L Why does the site feel this uestion is Cog Level H? The question is similar to asking A 125V DE ground will cause....

I I s I RESOLUTION:

Changed cog level to L.

508 Q

L 3

I P I 51 N 52N H?

H L

2 3

S Why does the site feel this question is Cog Level H? The question is similar to asking on a loss of CCW that would trip the compressors first?.

RESOLUTION:

Accepted site position that knowledge of,plant condition must be combined with knowledge of system desian.

53N L -

4 -

I P I

6. I

7.

UIUS Explanation S

S Add noun names the valves in stem.

RESOLUTION:

OK as is these valves are always referred to by number.

S I

S S

S I

S I

U S

Does the Clinton SAT based training program require ROs to know this?

At most sites this would be an SRO question.

RESOLUTION:

At Clinton RO SAT training requires knowledge of T. S. Safety Limits.

S I

U S

Third: The reference doesnt seem to require manual unseating, a requirement stated in the answer listed as correct.

Forth: The reference requires the valve to be electrically stroked.

U S

This question the same as a JPM to be given on this test.

RESOLUTION:

The question was replaced.

76N H

2 77N H

2 X

X

3. Psychometric Flaws

4. Job Content Flaws I 5. Other

6. I

7.

dinutia -

Explanation uE/s I E I First: Are we sure that the words MANUAL CLOSURE will be S

interpreted as closing the MOV using the handwheel?

H 4

L 2

L 3

H 3

H 2

L 3

L?

2 H

Second: How does the candidate know this is a SMB-00 MOV? (What is a SMB-00 MOV)

I Le., there may be no right answer, or A may be correct, or possibly D is correct.

RESOLUTION:

Answers reworded to address comments.

S I

First; LOK a pears to be H re uires knowledge of EOP entry conditions and knowle8ge of how to use %OPs.

Second; This is more of an SRO only question 1 Changed co level to H.

21 At Clinton R 8 SAT training requires thid level of knowledge of EOPs SRO EXAM QUESTIONS 76 THROUGH 100 distractors are non-plausible based on given power fluctuations.

RESOLUTION:

Question replaced.

~

S

3. Psychometric Flaws I

4. Job Content Flaws

5. Other I 6.

7.

Explanation Remove Immediately from correct answer, not a procedural immediate xtion.

3ESOLUTION:

9one 9dd procedure numbers to distractors C and D RESOLUTION:

Done Sorrect the Explanation of the correct answer a 4 not an 8 hour9.259259e-5 days <br />0.00222 hours <br />1.322751e-5 weeks <br />3.044e-6 months <br /> qotification is required in all cases.

RESOLUTION:

Done Delete the art of the question that asks if a the plant is in a Station Blackout. !his makes it easy to eliminate 2 distractor.

RESOLUTION:

Ouestion revised.

Ainutia

1. / I units E

S E

S E

S E

S S

E S

S E

S E

S U

S S

79N H

H H

L 3

2 2

3 83N 84B 85N -

H H -

H 2

2 -

3 The stem condition focusing contain unnecessa information eliminate statement about how pressure is being controllex RESOLUTION:

Stem changed.

Change stem to make it clear that 115 and 130 deg F is the indicated temperature RESOLUTION:

Change made.

86B H

2 Change the action order of the distractors and modify the stem accordingly RESOLUTION:

Change made.

How does the question meet the WA? WA refers to loss of CRD pumps and the relationship between Rx pressure and rod insertion capability.

The question focuses on the bases of scram insertion times.

RESOLUTION:

Question accepted based on the fact that the answer is related to CRD performance with or without operating CRD pumps.

87N 888 -

L H

3 2 -

89N 90M 91N 92N 9:N 948 95N TIF H

3 H

2 X

H 3

L 3

H?

3 H

L 2

X L

2

red.

Dist. -

X

'artial

4. Job Content Flaws I 5. Other L

S -

S U

S E

S U

S

7.

Explanation Not SRO only. It is an abnormal operating procedure performed by an RO. The RO must have knowledge of his actions and why.

RESOLUTION:

Question replaced with a new question with a different randomly selected KA.

Cue given in the stem in parentheses (recommended min temp 85F), is this required? Also, choices C and D ap ear non-plausible, for nothing in TIS notes the requirement to verify D g l C to start.

RESOLUTION:

Cue removed from stem.

Distractor C changed.

Distractor D credible because the requirement to verify DG 1C to start would be correct if only one other DG was inop.

Part (2) of stem should read what procedure should be entered instead of what action. The choices reflect procedure and not an action.

RESOLUTION:

Changes made.

Cog level L memory of TIS bases.

RESOLUTION:

Agree cog level H must understand TIS bases and action to correct based on current plant conditions.

The answer choices are written verbatim from the procedure, with selected all capital lettering on select answers, gives potential cues and s ecific determiners, contrary to Appendix B sections C.1.g. Reword thc c R o i c e s RESOLUTION:

Done Why is choice C incorrect? Also, consider adding another t pe of interlock bypass that is incorrect, otherwise the only interloct bypass is the correct answer which a pears to be a specific determiner, contrary tc Appendix B section C.2.m f2) & (6).

RESOLUTION:

Distractor C changed to correct both comments.

Choices C and 0 not plausible, if you halt fuel load why would you continue fuel load in other quadrants in the core? Unrealistic, unless provide a condition that you would perform choices C or D. In addition, during fuel loading if any problem occurs ou always would stop fuel load. Choice A is a fail safe answer, can Le argued to be always correcl RESOLUTION:

Stem conditions changed to make C and D Dlausible and the correct answer that fuel loading can continue in quadrant A.

iometric Flaws

red.

Dist. -

4. Job Content Flaws I 5. Other 330 3& -

1. 30 questions initally reviewed

• 30 questions reviewed for correct KA 8 30 question reviewed for reference verification

6.

7.

u/E/s Explanation I

U S

Again specific determiner, contrary to Appendix B section C.2.m(6), i.e.,

the correct answer is the only one choice different structure than the rest. Also, the correct answer IS the only choice that notes RClC leak is unisolable, whereas, the other three the RClC leak is isolated. Make one other choice with RClC leak unisolable.

RESOLUTION:

Changes make.

U S

I Again specific determiner, contrary to Appendix B section C.2.m(6), Le.,

the correct answer is the only one choice different structure than the rest, Le., longer than the other choices. In addition, the format of the choices are set similarly as choices A or 8, or all of the above. It does not have the wording all of the above but the last choice is the combination of all the other choices. Per Ap endix B section C.2.b of NUREG 1021 it is to be avoided. Also, the 80TE in the stem appears unnecessary, why do we need it? It also appears to create a potential a cue to select the correct choice, Le., ALL the components needed to authorize access.

RESOLUTION:

Distractors changed to address concerns.

NRC copy #I w

C Randomly Selected K/A 300000K5.13 295016AA1.02

~

295036EK2.02 300000K4.01 239002A2.05 2.1.30 as applied to 295006 2.1.30 as applied to 29501 8 300000A3.02 2.4.31 290002K1.03 245000A1.06 295009AK3.01 295026EK2.04 295016AA1.03 295016AA2.05 2.4.49 as applied to 295003 215001A2.08

_ - _ L ~

Reason for Rejection Due to insufficient sampling of the K2 category (only one randomly selected) this WA was randomly deselected to allow the addition of a K2 item.

This specific WA is not relevant at Clinton Power Station (CPS), the reactodturbine pressure regulating system is not operated during Control Room Abandonment. Replaced with AA1.08 by random selection from the remaining WA statements in the 29501 6 A1 area.

No interrelationship exists between a Secondary Containment High Sump/Area Water Level and the Post Accident Sampling System at CPS, replaced with EK2.01 by random selection from the remaining WA statements in the 295036 EK2 area.

No psychometrically viable question could be developed. Randomly selected K4.03 from the remaining two WAS in the K4 area to replace the deselected WA.

No psychometrically viable question could be developed valves do not close in response to low pressure. Randomly selected A2.03 from the five remaining WAS in the A2 area. A2.03 selected.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by 2.1.30 as applied to 295006.

Replaced with 2.1.32 as applied to 295006.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by 2.1.30 as applied to 29501 8.

Replaced with 2.4.30 as applied to 295018.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this KIA and limited applicability to 10 CFR 55.43. Replaced with 300000A2.01.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this WA and limited applicability to 10 CFR 55.43. Replacement WA is 2.4.22 No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this WA and limited applicability to 10 CFR 55.43. Replaced with 290002A2.06.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this WA and limited applicability to I O CFR 55.43. Replacement WA is 2.1.32 as applied to 245000.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this KIA and limited applicability to 10 CFR 55.43. Replacement WA is 295009AA2.01.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this WA and limited applicability to 10 CFR 55.43.

to 295026.

No SRO ONLY knowledge required by this WA and limited applicability to 10 CFR 55.43. Replacement WA is 295016AA2.05.

No pyschometrically viable question consistent with CPS procedures.

Replacement WA is 295016AA2.02.

Deselected due to limited SRO applicability at CPS. Replaced by random selection with 2.2.22 as applied to 295003.

Deselected because only the Reactor Engineers perform operations with the TIPS. The TIPS are stored in the RPV and there are no containment isolations associated with them. Replaced by random Replacement KIA is 2.4.4 as applied selection with 239003A4.03.

NUREG-1021, Draft Revision 9 28 of 34

NUREG-I 021, Draft Revision 9 28 of 34