ML041060492

Initial Admin RO JPM 9011.0102

ML041060492
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	01/06/2004
From:	Delaney T, Pickley T, Ryan P Exelon Generation Co, Exelon Nuclear
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
50-461/04-301, JPM 9011.0102, Rev 03 50-461/04-301
Download: ML041060492 (27)

Text

CLINTON POWER STATION Job Performance Measure Perform the Restoration Section of CPS No. 9011.01 CONTROL ROD/POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY-Faulted JPM Number: 9011.0102 Revision Number: 03 Date: 07/15/2003 Developed By:

T Pickley 7/15/03 Instructor Date Validated By:

T. Delaney 10/16/03 SME or Instructor Date Review By:

P. K. Ryan 7/28/03 Operations Representative Date

JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE VALIDATION CHECKLIST NOTE: All steps of this checklist should be performed upon initial validation. Prior to JPM usage, revalidate JPM using steps 8 through 11 below.

1. Task description and number, JPM description and number are identified.

2. Knowledge and Abilities (K/A) references are included.

3. Performance location specified. (in-plant, control room, or simulator)

4. Initial setup conditions are identified.

5. Initiating and terminating cues are properly identified.

6. Task standards identified and verified by SME review.

7. Critical steps meet the criteria for critical steps and are identified with an asterisk (*).

8. Verify the procedure referenced by this JPM matches the most current revision of that procedure:

Procedure Rev. _____ Date _____________

9. Pilot test the JPM:

a. verify cues both verbal and visual are free of conflict, and

b. ensure performance time is accurate.

10.If the JPM cannot be performed as written with proper responses, then revise the JPM.

11.When JPM is revalidated, SME or Instructor sign and date JPM cover page.

SME/Instructor Date SME/Instructor Date SME/Instructor Date

CLINTON POWER STATION ADMIN JPM JPM NUMBER: 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 3 of 26 Revision Record (Summary)

1. Revision 00, This is a new RO Administrative JPM

2. Revision 01, Add Terminating Cue Update to the current revision of the procedure

3. Revision 02, Incorporating NRC validation comments

4. Revision 03, Update to the current revision of the procedure

CLINTON POWER STATION ADMIN JPM JPM NUMBER: 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 4 of 26 Operators Name:

Job

Title:

o RO o SRO JPM

Title:

Perform the Restoration Section of CPS No. 9011.01 CONTROL ROD/POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY-Faulted JPM Number:

9011.0102 Task Number and

Title:

901101.01, Complete control room actions to perform the Control Rod/Position Indication Operability K/A Number:

2.2.12 Importance:

3.0 Suggested Testing Environment:

Any Actual Testing Environment:

o Simulator o

Plant o

Control Room Testing Method: o Simulate Alternate Path / Faulted:

n Yes n

Perform Time Critical:

o Yes n

No Estimated Time to Complete: 17 minutes Actual Time Used:

minutes

References:

CPS No. 9011.01, CONTROL ROD/POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY, Revision 27d

CLINTON POWER STATION ADMIN JPM JPM NUMBER: 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 5 of 26 EVALUATION

SUMMARY

Were all the Critical Elements performed satisfactorily?

o Yes o

No The operators performance was evaluated against the standards contained in this JPM, and has been determined to be:

o Satisfactory o

Unsatisfactory Comments:

Evaluators Name:

Evaluators Signature:

Date:

CLINTON POWER STATION ADMIN JPM JPM NUMBER: 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 6 of 26 READ TO THE OPERATOR I will explain the initial conditions, which step(s) to simulate or discuss, and provide the initiating cues.

When you complete the task successfully, the objective of this Job Performance Measure will be satisfied.

SIMULATOR SET-UP CONDITIONS:

Not Applicable TASK STANDARDS:

CPS 9011.01 restoration section has been completed.

Misaligned control rod has been identified.

TOOLS, EQUIPMENT, OTHER SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS:

Marked up copy of CPS 9011.01 completed up to step 8.3.

Copy of an OD-7 Option 2, OD-7 Option 4 and an Official 3D Case.

PROCEDURAL/

REFERENCES:

CPS 9011.01, CONTROL ROD/POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY, Revision 27d EVALUATOR INSTRUCTIONS:

Amplifying cues are provided within the JPM steps.

Provide initial OD-7 and surveillance after reading the initiating cue.

INITIAL CONDITIONS: 100% Power INITIATING CUE:

The plant is operating at 100% power. The A RO has completed CPS 9011.01 Control Rod/Position Indication Operability for the weekly surveillance with the exception of the restoration section. You have just relieved the A RO and are directed to complete the restoration section. Report when the task is complete.

START TIME:

CLINTON POWER STATION ADMIN JPM JPM NUMBER: 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 7 of 26

==============================================================

PERFORMANCE INFORMATION Critical steps are denoted with an asterisk (*) to the left of the step number and appear in BOLDED letters. Failure to meet the standards for a critical step constitutes failure of the Job Performance Measure. The sequence of steps is assumed unless denoted in the comments section of the JPM.

==============================================================

PERFORMANCE STEPS 1.

Obtain final PMS Control Rod Position printout: OD-7 Option 2, OD-7 Option 4, or Official 3D Case.

Standard Printout demanded.

CUE Give operator the OD-7 Option 2, OD-7 Option 4, or Official 3D Case when requested.

Comments SAT UNSAT Comment Number

• 2.

Compare the initial and final Control Rod Position printouts to verify proper rod positions.

Standard Operator performs review and identifies that rod 36-29 is at position 6 instead of position 4.

CUE Comments SAT UNSAT Comment Number

• 3.

Notify the SMngt that rod 36-29 is at position 6 instead of position 4.

Standard SMngt is notified CUE

Acknowledge notification of mis-positioned control rod.

Acknowledge entry into Inadvertent Rod Movement CPS 4007.02 Comments May state that entry into Inadvertent Rod Movement CPS 4007.02 is required SAT UNSAT Comment Number

CLINTON POWER STATION ADMIN JPM JPM NUMBER: 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 8 of 26 Terminating Cue:

9011.01, Restoration section has been completed and Shift Management has been notified of mis-positioned control rod.

STOP TIME:

K/A REFERENCE NUMBERS Importance Rating K/A SYSTEM NUMBER K/A NUMBER RO SRO GENERIC 2.2.12 3.0 3.4

CLINTON POWER STATION SYSTEM JPM JPM NUMBER 9011.0102 Rev. 03 Page 9 of 26 INITIATING CUE The plant is operating at 100% power. The A RO has completed CPS 9011.01 Control Rod/Position Indication Operability for the weekly surveillance with the exception of the restoration section. You have just relieved the A RO and are directed to complete the restoration section.

Report when the task is complete.

CONTROL ROD/POSITION INDICATION OPERABILITY SCOPE OF REVISION:

Incorporated PAC 0407-97: Editorial typo. Rev marks not retained.

Format/Organizational title updates, placekeeping aid enhancements, section 5.1 updated to include annunciator impact per 1005.01.

CR1-98-02-110 (MLSR Project):

Incorporated performance criteria and credit for ITS SR 3.9.5.1 MODE 5 control rod position checks.

Documentation content of canceled CPS 9011.01C001, Control Rod Operability Checklist incorporated into body of this procedure.

Incorporated PAC 0502-99, PDRs 99-0906 and 00-0298.



Added flags for critical steps.



Updates format, revised to make consistent with Limitations in CPS 3304.01, Control Rod Hydraulic & Control (RD).



Specific rev 27d [Sheffield]: CR 130905:

Added to review control rod database prior to movement of a single rod at elevated drive water pressure to establish what seal conditions are.

CONTAINS CRITICAL STEPS

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 10 of 26 CONTINUOUS USE ORIGINATOR Thomas J. Landin CLASS CODE: SNNN ITR: K. Zipprich APPROVAL DATE:

SEP 16 1998 CURRENT CHANGES TO GENERAL REVISION Change #

Date List of Affected Pages

27a 02/21/01 1, 4, 6, 7



27b 08/13/01 1, 3, 6



27c 01/02/02 1, 4



27d 02/05/03 1 and 7



CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 11 of 26 c

1.0 PURPOSE Provide instructions for verifying control rod insertion capability by inserting each applicable PARTIALLY or FULLY withdrawn control rod one notch and observing that the control rod moves, thereby ensuring the control rod is not stuck and is free to insert on a SCRAM.

Instructions are also provided to return the control rods to their original positions to verify each applicable control rod is operable and that the position indication for each applicable control rod is operable.

This surveillance satisfies ITS SR requirements:

3.1.3.2, Insert each FULLY withdrawn control rod one notch (7 days) 3.1.3.3, Insert each PARTIALLY withdrawn control rod one notch (31 days)

D 3.9.5.1, Insert each withdrawn control rod one notch (7 days - MODE 5) 2.0 DISCUSSION/DEFINITIONS 2.1 FREQUENCY <<LBD-1>>

2.1.1 Normal Frequency (MODEs 1, 2):

7 Days - for FULLY withdrawn control rods with THERMAL POWER > LPSP of the RPCS 31 Days - for PARTIALLY withdrawn control rods with THERMAL POWER > LPSP of the RPCS 2.1.2 Other Triggers:

a)

Within 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> from discovery of any withdrawn control rod that is stuck (will not insert by either CRD drive water or scram pressure) - for all control rods either PARTIALLY or FULLY withdrawn, concurrent with THERMAL Power > the LPSP of the RPCS.

D b)

MODE 5 when control rod withdrawn triggered via CPS 9000.01D002, Control Room Operator Surveillance Log - MODE 4,5 DATA SHEET (7 day frequency).

2.2 Individual sections or an individual step or individual steps within a section of this procedure may be performed independently for PMT or other maintenance activities. Those steps within a section that are not performed should be marked N/A. When only parts of a section are performed, it is the responsibility of the SMngt and the performer to ensure that all necessary prerequisites, precautions and limitations are met for those steps that will be performed. Additionally, the impact of NOT performing the remaining steps must also be understood.

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 12 of 26 2.0 DISCUSSION/DEFINITIONS (cont'd) 2.3 All applicable control rods (control rods not required to have their directional control valves disarmed electrically or hydraulically) will be moved at least one notch to verify proper rod motion and position indication response. Control rod exercising should be performed by a single notch insertion and single notch withdrawal, in as short a time as possible.

3.0 RESPONSIBILITY Operations Department Head is responsible for the implementation of this procedure.

4.0 PRECAUTIONS 4.1 Plant evolutions which may result in reactivity changes should be avoided during performance of this surveillance.

4.2 Document control rod movement per CPS 9000.09, CPS Control Rod Manipulation Logs.

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 13 of 26 5.0 PREREQUISITES INITIAL

5.1 This procedure contains critical steps. A Critical Step is "Any action that, when performed improperly, will lead to an unintentional change that adversely impacts plant, system, or personnel". Performance of this procedure requires screening for a High Risk/High Production Risk/Risk Sensitive activity IAW WC-AA-104 and any existing requirements for Command and Control Standards. Critical steps are indicated by a {CS} in the left margin."

5.2 In conjunction with the SMngt, review the following impact statements to determine required plant status to perform this test:

OPERABILITY IMPACT:

ITS LCO 3.1.3 - Control Rod Operability SYSTEMS AFFECTED:

D AFFECTED ANNUNCIATORS AND COMPUTER POINTS: None RPS TRIP: N/A CRVICS ISOLATION: N/A REQUIRED OPERABLE CHANNELS: N/A D

PLANT/SYSTEM CONDITIONS REQUIRED TO CONDUCT TEST When in MODEs 1, 2: Power  low power set point (LPSP) of the Rod Pattern Control System (RPCS).

When in MODEs 1, 2: For control rods not FULLY withdrawn, MAPRAT, 0.96. If MAPRAT > 0.96 a power reduction will be required prior to testing control rods that are not FULLY withdrawn.

COINCIDENT CHANNELS TO PREVENT ACTUATION: N/A SM / DL SMngt Test Performer D

5.3 MODE 1, 2: Reactor power ( LPSP).

_90_ %

__DL__

[N/A when in MODE 5.]

5.4 SM/CRS permission to perform this surveillance.

__SM__

SMngt XX:XX

/ XX/XX/XX Time/Date

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 14 of 26 6.0 LIMITATIONS 6.1 IF a control rod (or gang) is found out of sequence, THEN enter CPS 4007.02, Inadvertent Rod Movement.

6.2 In the event of accidental insertion of more than one notch, withdrawal should be by single notch to avoid any possible over-notching on the withdrawal.

D 6.3 MODEs 1, 2: MAPRAT shall be, 0.96 when exercising PARTIALLY withdrawn control rods. This limitation does not apply to FULLY withdrawn control rods.



6.4 The Rod Withdraw Limiter (RWL) function of the Rod Control and Information system establishes a 4 notch withdraw limit when reactor power is between the Low Power Set Point (LPSP) and the High Power Set Point (HPSP), and a 2 notch withdraw limit when power is above the HPSP. The purpose of the RWL is to prevent fuel damage, caused by rod withdrawal which would uncover fuel that has been operating at a relatively low power level. The limit is set at 2 or 4 notches (as applicable) from the position of the control rod, the first time a Withdraw signal is applied after the rod is selected.

IF a control rod is inserted with the intent of leaving the rod at the new inserted position, OR power condition have changed significantly (RR flow changes or Xenon transient) since the control rod was inserted, THEN prior to withdrawing that control rod, deselect and reselect the control rod, to establish the RWL notch limits.

IF a control rod is inserted with the intent of returning the control rod to its original position for notch testing, THEN withdrawing the control rod to its original position in the continuous withdraw mode is permitted, AND is within the design basis of the RWL as long as power condition have not changed significantly.

Control rods should be deselected, any time that MCR personnel are NOT actively engaged in control rod movement activities. <<CM-1>>

7.0 MATERIALS/TEST EQUIPMENT - None

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 15 of 26 8.0 PROCEDURE Initial

8.1 Obtain a Plant Monitoring System (PMS)

Control Rod Position printout, using either: OD-7 Option 2, OD-7 Option 4, or Official 3D Case.

__DL__

8.1.1 From the OD-7 edit or Official 3D Case, determine which control rods are not required to be tested because they are not withdrawn.

__DL__

8.1.2 Identify any control rods which are disarmed.

__DL__

8.1.3 Identify any control rods which are PARTIALLY withdrawn.

__DL__

NOTE When exercising PARTIALLY withdrawn rods during the monthly test, a P/ should be used before initials to differentiate between partially withdrawn and fully withdrawn rods.

In this manner, the MODE 1, 2 requirement to limit MAPRAT, 0.96 can be more readily determined.

8.1.4 On the CORE MAP (page 7):

Mark disarmed control rods with DA.

__DL__

Mark FULLY inserted control rods with N/A.

__DL__

Mark partially withdrawn control rods with P/

(if exercising PARTIALLY inserted rods).

__DL__

Mark partially withdrawn control rods with N/A (if not exercising PARTIALLY inserted rods).

__N/A__

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 16 of 26 D

NOTE Drives with new seals should not be moved per single notch with elevated drive water pressure, due to increase potential for double-notching. Consult control rod database for seal condition MODE 1 or 2:

Individual and/or ganged rod movement may be used to perform this surveillance.

FULLY withdrawn control rods are not required to be performed until 8 days 18 hours2.083333e-4 days <br />0.005 hours <br />2.97619e-5 weeks <br />6.849e-6 months <br /> after the control rod is fully withdrawn and THERMAL POWER is > LPSP of the RPCS.

Rods at position 46 for cooling shall be considered FULLY withdrawn and subject to the 7 day frequency. These rods may be required to be returned to position 48 first to perform the surveillance.

PARTIALLY withdrawn control rods are not required to be performed until 38 days 18 hours2.083333e-4 days <br />0.005 hours <br />2.97619e-5 weeks <br />6.849e-6 months <br /> after the control rod is withdrawn and THERMAL POWER > LPSP of the RPCS.

MODE 5:

Individual rod movement shall be used to perform this surveillance.

Withdrawn control rods are not required to be performed until 7 days after the control rod is withdrawn.

8.2 Exercise of FULLY (PARTIALLY)

Withdrawn Control Rods Initial D

8.2.1 MODEs 1, 2 PARTIALLY withdrawn rods only (N/A for FULLY withdrawn rods or MODE 5):

Verify MAPRAT, 0.96.

__0.821_____ MAPRAT

__DL__

If MAPRAT  0.96, then a power reduction shall be required to achieve MAPRAT, 0.96 prior to testing any PARTIALLY withdrawn control rods.

{CS}

8.2.2 Select and insert the desired rod(s) one notch, noting proper position indication tracking.

___X___

Place Keeping Aid

{CS}

8.2.3 Withdraw the selected rod(s) one notch to original position.

___X___

Place Keeping Aid a)

Observe proper rod position indication tracking to the original rod position.

___X___

Place Keeping Aid b)

Check off the selected rod(s) after the rod(s) is tested by initialing the rod(s).

___X___

[Document on CORE MAP]

Place Keeping Aid

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 17 of 26 8.2.4 Repeat steps 8.2.2 and 8.2.3 for each FULLY (PARTIALLY) withdrawn control rod.

___X___

Place Keeping Aid 8.3 RESTORATION Initial

8.3.1 Obtain a PMS Control Rod Position printout:

OD-7 Option 2, OD-7 Option 4, or Official 3D Case.

8.3.2 Compare the initial and final Control Rod Position printouts to verify proper rod positions.

8.3.3 Notify the SMngt of the completion of this test.

/

Time/Date 9.0 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA 9.1 Operability Requirements - Failure to meet the Acceptance Criteria shall constitute a failure to comply with the applicable LCO. ITS should be immediately reviewed to identify Action Statements needed for implementation. Refer to Supplemental Review Sheet for applicable LCOs.

9.1.1 All withdrawn control rods not required to have their directional control valves disarmed electrically or hydraulically are inserted at least 1 notch.

9.1.2 The indicated control rod position changes during movement of the Control Rod Drive.

9.2 Other Requirements - None 10.0 FINAL CONDITIONS The control rods are returned to their original positions.

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 18 of 26

11.0 REFERENCES

11.1 CPS 4007.02, Inadvertent Rod Movement 11.2 CPS 9000.01D002, Control Room Operator Surveillance Log - MODE 4,5 Data Sheet 11.3 CPS 9000.09, CPS Control Rod Manipulation Logs 11.4 LBD-1: ITS SR 3.1.3.2, SR 3.1.3.3, SR 3.9.5.1 11.5 USAR 3.1.2.3.2.1, 4.6.3.1.1.5 11.6 GE Control Rod Drive Design Spec Data Sheet 22A5395 AE 11.7 GE Letter GGJ-88-100 dated 7-29-88

11.8 CM-1: CR 1-99-04-097 12.0 APPENDICES - None D

13.0 DOCUMENTS - None

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27d Page 19 of 26 CORE MAP DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 16-53 20-53 24-53 28-53 32-53 36-53 40-53 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 12-49 16-49 20-49 24-49 28-49 32-49 36-49 40-49 44-49 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 08-45 12-45 16-45 20-45 24-45 28-45 32-45 36-45 40-45 44-45 48-45 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 04-41 08-41 12-41 16-41 20-41 24-41 28-41 32-41 36-41 40-41 44-41 48-41 52-41 DL DL DL DL P/ DL DL P/ DL DL P/ DL DL DL DL DL 04-37 08-37 12-37 16-37 20-37 24-37 28-37 32-37 36-37 40-37 44-37 48-37 52-37 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 04-33 08-33 12-33 16-33 20-33 24-33 28-33 32-33 36-33 40-33 44-33 48-33 52-33 DL DL DL DL P/ DL DL DL DL P/ DL DL DL DL DL 04-29 08-29 12-29 16-29 20-29 24-29 28-29 32-29 36-29 40-29 44-29 48-29 52-29 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 04-25 08-25 12-25 16-25 20-25 24-25 28-25 32-25 36-25 40-25 44-25 48-25 52-25 DL DL DL DL P/ DL DL P/ DL DL P/ DL DL DL DL DL 04-21 08-21 12-21 16-21 20-21 24-21 28-21 32-21 36-21 40-21 44-21 48-21 52-21 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 04-17 08-17 12-17 16-17 20-17 24-17 28-17 32-17 36-17 40-17 44-17 48-17 52-17 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 08-13 12-13 16-13 20-13 24-13 28-13 32-13 36-13 40-13 44-13 48-13 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 12-09 16-09 20-09 24-09 28-09 32-09 36-09 40-09 44-09 DL DL DL DL DL DL DL 16-05 20-05 24-05 28-05 32-05 36-05 40-05

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27c Page 20 of 26

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27c Page 21 of 26 CONTROL ROD OPERABILITY CHECKLIST CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN 9.1 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA ITS LCOs:

3.1.3 3.9.5 ORM ORs:

None ODCM ORs:

None As applicable:

Initiated Condition Report __________

(yes/no)

Initiated Maintenance Request (MR) No. __________________

9.2 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA As applicable:

Initiated Condition Report __________

(yes/no)

Initiated Maintenance Request (MR) No. __________________

COMMENTS/DEFICIENCIES REVIEW AND APPROVAL Surveillance Coordinator ____________________________________________

(Signature)

(Date)

CPS 9011.01 Rev. 27c Page 22 of 26 PAGE 1, INITIAL CLINTON CYCLE 6 SEQUENCE NO 23 CORE PARAMETERS 3D MONICORE today-2xxx xx:xx CALCULATED POWER MWT 3125 PERIODIC LOG today-2xxx xx:xx PRINTED POWER MWE 1062 CASE ID FMLD1950708205855 FLOW MLB/HR 75.844 CALC RESULTS RESTART FMLD1950708195845 FPAPDR 0.824 LPRM SHAPE - FULL CORE SUBC BTU/LB 23.49 Keff 1.0000 PR PSIa 1027.9 XE WORTH % -2.52 LOAD LINE

SUMMARY

CORE MWD/sT 20850.8 XE/RATED 1.00 CORE POWER 89.9%

CYCLE MWD/sT 8741.6 CORE FLOW 89.8%

MCPR 1.268 LOAD LINE 100.0%

CORRECTION FACTOR: MFLCPR= 1.000 MFLPD= 1.000 MAPRAT= 0.999 OPTION: ARTS DUAL LOOP MANUAL FLOW MCPRLIM= 1.240 MOST LIMITING LOCATIONS (NON-SYMMETRIC)

MFLCPR LOC MFLPD LOC MAPRAT LOC PCRAT LOC 0.978 37-28 0.912 17-22-18 0.821 7 5 0.798 41-28-16 0.976 39-26 0.912 7 5 0.817 15-30-16 0.798 19-28-16 0.975 41-28 0.912 41-28-16 0.817 11-22-13 0.797 7 5 0.973 11-28 0.902 19-28-16 0.816 19-26-16 0.791 39-22-20 0.940 13-32 0.896 15-38-18 0.813 19-30-15 0.782 9-22-13 0.939 9-26 0.895 21-26-16 0.803 7-26-12 0.779 11-20-13 0.937 11-20 0.893 17-26-16 0.802 9-36-13 0.779 17-26-16 0.930 39-22 0.889 9-22-13 0.798 11-30-11 0.777 11-28-15 0.927 7-28 0.889 11-20-13 0.796 9 5 0.776 13-32-16 0.923 9-22 0.888 13-32-16 0.795 39-22-20 0.774 47-26-12 SEQ. B-2 C=MFLCPR D=MFLPD M=MAPRAT P=PCRAT *=MULTIPLE CORE AVE AXIAL 53 NOTCH REL PW LOC 00 0.238 25 49 02 0.446 24 L 04 0.804 23 45 06 0.963 22 08 1.056 21 41 P 10 1.158 20 L 12 1.191 19 37 18 C4 18 14 1.163 18 16 1.182 17 33 18 1.220 16 L 20 1.215 15 29 4 4 22 1.187 14 24 1.212 13 25 26 1.207 12 L 28 1.181 11 21 18 4 18 30 1.170 10 32 1.166 09 17 D 34 1.131 08 L 36 1.085 07 13 38 1.072 06 40 1.050 05 09 42 0.998 04 L M 44 0.920 03 05 L L L L L L 46 0.749 02 04 08 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52 48 0.237 01 CORE AVERAGE RADIAL POWER DISTRIBUTION RING # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 REL PW 0.890 1.084 1.113 1.102 1.155 1.145 0.727

9011.0101 Job Performance Measure (JPM)

Page 23 of 26 PAGE 2 CLINTON CYCLE 6 INSTRUMENT READINGS/STATUS SEQUENCE NO 23 CALIBRATED LPRM READINGS 8-JUL-1995 20:58 CALCULATED CALIBRATED LPRM READINGS today-2xxx xx:xx CALCULATED today-2xxx xx:xx PRINTED 47D 40.1 49.8 55.7 45.9 30.2 CASE ID FMLD1950708205855 C 57.0 59.8 60.3 64.5 43.0 LPRM SHAPE - FULL CORE B 61.2 63.6 60.9 69.2 41.9 A 51.1 54.9 49.5 63.0 27.7 # OF TIPS REJECTED: 1 39D 35.4 51.3 58.4 61.1 57.5 46.0 FAILED SENSORS:

C 55.8 62.7 60.3 59.6 66.5 67.9 LPRM ( 2 SIGNAL FAILED)

B 60.0 65.2 60.7 57.0 66.7 70.2 615A 3815D A 52.7 61.1 50.4 44.4 54.7 63.8 LPRM ( 0 PANACEA REJECTED)

OTHER SENSORS ( 0 TOTAL) 31D 39.9 51.6 55.8 56.0C 55.7 48.5 SUB RODS C 63.7 71.1 68.3 63.1 72.6P 70.4 NONE B 69.6 71.2 66.7 59.2 72.9 73.4 A 67.6M 69.0 61.1 45.4 71.1 71.8 T = TIP RUN RECOMMENDED C = MFLCPR LOCATION 23D 40.0 54.3 58.1 57.9 59.5 48.0 M = MAPRAT LOCATION C 62.2 67.3D 63.7 59.2 66.8 69.0 D = MFLPD LOCATION B 67.1 67.1 61.4 56.9 66.6 71.1 P = PCRAT LOCATION A 66.5 58.6 48.7 44.2 55.6 66.1 * = MULTIPLE LIMIT 15D 28.5 46.2 55.5 57.2 0.0 39.4 C 42.4 63.6 62.8 59.1 65.4 59.1 B 43.2 68.6 61.9 57.4 67.6 62.2 A 0.0 61.7 49.9 44.3 64.3 50.4 07D 29.1 39.3 40.7 36.6 C 41.4 58.6 56.6 54.5 B 42.3 64.8 61.8 58.3 A 31.2 57.2 55.6 48.4 06 14 22 30 38 46 CORE

SUMMARY

CORE POWER 89.9% CALC SUB FLOW 91.3% DP MEAS PSI 15.52 CORE FLOW 89.8% OPER SUB FLOW -1.2% DP CALC PSI 20.52 LOAD LINE 100.0% FLOW BASIS MEAS FEEDWTR FLOW MLB/HR 13.5 APRM CALIBRATION A B C D READING 100.4 100.6 100.2 100.2 AGAF 0.994 0.992 0.997 0.997 TIP RUNS RECOMMENDED STRINGS: NONE UNIT 1, PAGE 1 OF 1 INITIAL Positions OD-7, CONTROL ROD NOTCH POSITIONS, NEW SCAN OPTION 2 53 48 48 48 48 48 48 48

9011.0101 Job Performance Measure (JPM)

Rev. 27d Page 24 of 26 49 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 45 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 41 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 37 48 48 48 48 18 48 4

48 18 48 48 48 48 33 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 29 48 48 48 48 4

48 48 48 4

48 48 48 48 25 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 21 48 48 48 48 18 48 4

48 18 48 48 48 48 17 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 13 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 9

48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 5

48 48 48 48 48 48 48 4

8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52

9011.0101 Job Performance Measure (JPM)

Rev. 27d Page 25 of 26 PAGE 1, FINAL CLINTON CYCLE 6 SEQUENCE NO 23 CORE PARAMETERS 3D MONICORE today-2xxx xx:xx CALCULATED POWER MWT 3125 PERIODIC LOG today-2xxx xx:xx PRINTED POWER MWE 1052 CASE ID FMLD1950708205855 FLOW MLB/HR 75.844 CALC RESULTS RESTART FMLD1950708195845 FPAPDR 0.824 LPRM SHAPE - FULL CORE SUBC BTU/LB 23.49 Keff 1.0000 PR PSIa 1027.9 XE WORTH % -2.52 LOAD LINE

SUMMARY

CORE MWD/sT 20850.8 XE/RATED 1.00 CORE POWER 89.9%

CYCLE MWD/sT 8741.6 CORE FLOW 89.8%

MCPR 1.268 LOAD LINE 100.0%

CORRECTION FACTOR: MFLCPR= 1.000 MFLPD= 1.000 MAPRAT= 0.999 OPTION: ARTS DUAL LOOP MANUAL FLOW MCPRLIM= 1.240 MOST LIMITING LOCATIONS (NON-SYMMETRIC)

MFLCPR LOC MFLPD LOC MAPRAT LOC PCRAT LOC 0.978 37-28 0.912 17-22-18 0.821 7 5 0.798 41-28-16 0.976 39-26 0.912 7 5 0.817 15-30-16 0.798 19-28-16 0.975 41-28 0.912 41-28-16 0.817 11-22-13 0.797 7 5 0.973 11-28 0.902 19-28-16 0.816 19-26-16 0.791 39-22-20 0.940 13-32 0.896 15-38-18 0.813 19-30-15 0.782 9-22-13 0.939 9-26 0.895 21-26-16 0.803 7-26-12 0.779 11-20-13 0.937 11-20 0.893 17-26-16 0.802 9-36-13 0.779 17-26-16 0.930 39-22 0.889 9-22-13 0.798 11-30-11 0.777 11-28-15 0.927 7-28 0.889 11-20-13 0.796 9 5 0.776 13-32-16 0.923 9-22 0.888 13-32-16 0.795 39-22-20 0.774 47-26-12 SEQ. B-2 C=MFLCPR D=MFLPD M=MAPRAT P=PCRAT *=MULTIPLE CORE AVE AXIAL 53 NOTCH REL PW LOC 00 0.238 25 49 02 0.446 24 L 04 0.804 23 45 06 0.963 22 08 1.056 21 41 P 10 1.158 20 L 12 1.191 19 37 18 C4 18 14 1.163 18 16 1.182 17 33 18 1.220 16 L 20 1.215 15 29 4 6 22 1.187 14 24 1.212 13 25 26 1.207 12 L 28 1.181 11 21 18 4 18 30 1.170 10 32 1.166 09 17 D 34 1.131 08 L 36 1.085 07 13 38 1.072 06 40 1.050 05 09 42 0.998 04 L M 44 0.920 03 05 L L L L L L 46 0.749 02 04 08 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52 48 0.237 01 CORE AVERAGE RADIAL POWER DISTRIBUTION RING # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 REL PW 0.890 1.084 1.113 1.102 1.155 1.145 0.727

9011.0101 Job Performance Measure (JPM)

Rev. 27d Page 26 of 26 PAGE 2 CLINTON CYCLE 6 INSTRUMENT READINGS/STATUS SEQUENCE NO 23 CALIBRATED LPRM READINGS 8-JUL-1995 20:58 CALCULATED CALIBRATED LPRM READINGS today-2xxx xx:xx CALCULATED today-2xxx xx:xx PRINTED 47D 40.1 49.8 55.7 45.9 30.2 CASE ID FMLD1950708205855 C 57.0 59.8 60.3 64.5 43.0 LPRM SHAPE - FULL CORE B 61.2 63.6 60.9 69.2 41.9 A 51.1 54.9 49.5 63.0 27.7 # OF TIPS REJECTED: 1 39D 35.4 51.3 58.4 61.1 57.5 46.0 FAILED SENSORS:

C 55.8 62.7 60.3 59.6 66.5 67.9 LPRM ( 2 SIGNAL FAILED)

B 60.0 65.2 60.7 57.0 66.7 70.2 615A 3815D A 52.7 61.1 50.4 44.4 54.7 63.8 LPRM ( 0 PANACEA REJECTED)

OTHER SENSORS ( 0 TOTAL) 31D 39.9 51.6 55.8 56.0C 55.7 48.5 SUB RODS C 63.7 71.1 68.3 63.1 72.6P 70.4 NONE B 69.6 71.2 66.7 59.2 72.9 73.4 A 67.6M 69.0 61.1 45.4 71.1 71.8 T = TIP RUN RECOMMENDED C = MFLCPR LOCATION 23D 40.0 54.3 58.1 57.9 59.5 48.0 M = MAPRAT LOCATION C 62.2 67.3D 63.7 59.2 66.8 69.0 D = MFLPD LOCATION B 67.1 67.1 61.4 56.9 66.6 71.1 P = PCRAT LOCATION A 66.5 58.6 48.7 44.2 55.6 66.1 * = MULTIPLE LIMIT 15D 28.5 46.2 55.5 57.2 0.0 39.4 C 42.4 63.6 62.8 59.1 65.4 59.1 B 43.2 68.6 61.9 57.4 67.6 62.2 A 0.0 61.7 49.9 44.3 64.3 50.4 07D 29.1 39.3 40.7 36.6 C 41.4 58.6 56.6 54.5 B 42.3 64.8 61.8 58.3 A 31.2 57.2 55.6 48.4 06 14 22 30 38 46 CORE

SUMMARY

CORE POWER 89.9% CALC SUB FLOW 91.3% DP MEAS PSI 15.52 CORE FLOW 89.8% OPER SUB FLOW -1.2% DP CALC PSI 20.52 LOAD LINE 100.0% FLOW BASIS MEAS FEEDWTR FLOW MLB/HR 13.5 APRM CALIBRATION A B C D READING 100.4 100.6 100.2 100.2 AGAF 0.994 0.992 0.997 0.997 TIP RUNS RECOMMENDED STRINGS: NONE UNIT 1, PAGE 1 OF 1 Final Positions OD-7, CONTROL ROD NOTCH POSITIONS, NEW SCAN OPTION 2 53 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 49 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48

9011.0101 Job Performance Measure (JPM)

Rev. 27d Page 27 of 26 45 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 41 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 37 48 48 48 48 18 48 4

48 18 48 48 48 48 33 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 29 48 48 48 48 4

48 48 48 6

48 48 48 48 25 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 21 48 48 48 48 18 48 4

48 18 48 48 48 48 17 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 13 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 9

48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 5

48 48 48 48 48 48 48 4

8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52 (Signature)

(Date)