Text

Cycle 12 (U2C12) 90-Day Steam Generator Report for Voltage-Based Alternate Repair Criteria
	ML040710360
Person / Time
Site:	Sequoyah
Issue date:	03/09/2004
From:	Salas P; Tennessee Valley Authority
To:	; Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
	GL-95-005 SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev 0
	Download: ML040710360 (97)
	v • d • e

March 9, 2004 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Document Control Desk Washington, D.C. 20555 Gentlemen:

In the Matter of

) Docket No. 50-328 Tennessee Valley Authority

)

SEQUOYAH NUCLEAR PLANT (SQN) - UNIT 2 - UNIT 2 CYCLE 12 (U2C12) 90-DAY STEAM GENERATOR REPORT FOR VOLTAGE-BASED ALTERNATE REPAIR CRITERIA In accordance with SQN Unit 2 License Condition 2.C.(8)(b), and NRC Generic Letter (GL) 95-05,, Section 6.b, TVA is providing the 90-day steam generator report. The report contains results of voltage-based repair criteria that were applied during the U2C12 refueling outage steam generator inspections (end of cycle 12 operation). The voltage-based repair criteria are for axial outside diameter stress corrosion cracking (ODSCC) at tube support plate intersections.

The report contains a condition monitoring assessment that demonstrates that the Generic Letter 95-05 acceptance criteria are satisfied at the end of the Unit 2 operation cycle 12 and an operational assessment that demonstrates that the GL 95-05 acceptance criteria is expected to continue to be satisfied throughout Unit 2 cycle 13.

This letter does not contain TVA commitments. If you have any questions, please call me at (423) 843-7170 or J. D. Smith at (423) 843-6672.

Sincerely, Original signed by:

Pedro Salas Licensing and Industry Affairs Manager Enclosure

ENCLOSURE TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY SEQUOYAH NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 2 STEAM GENERATOR REPORT VOLTAGE BASED ALTERNATE REPAIR CRITERIA UNIT 2 CYCLE 12 90-DAY REPORT

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 1 of 95 Tennessee Valley Authority Condition Monitoring and Operational. Assessment=

GL-95-05 Alternate Repair Criterion End of Cycle 12 90 Day Report sequoyah unit 2 Report Number SG-SGDA-03-55 Revision 0 FINAL REPORT February 2004 Authors Names D.J. Ayres Verifier's Name T.P. Magee Acrjng Managers Name J.M. Wall SjBaturc f Date For Pages For Pages A11 U

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 2 of 95 Table of Contents 1.o 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 Glossary of Acronyms...........................................................................................

3 Introduction..........................................................................................................

.4 Summary and Conclusions..................................................................................

.5 EOC-12 Inspection Results..................................................................................

.6 3.1 Voltage Distributions at EOC-12 3.2 Voltage Growth Rates for Cycle 12 Comparison of Predicted and Measured Voltage Distributions at EOC-12.........21 4.1 Comparison of Voltage Distributions 4.2 Comparison of Voltage Growth Distributions Analysis Methods and Data Base for ARC Correlations.....................................

29 5.1 Tube Material Properties 5.2 Burst Correlation 5.3 Leak Rate Correlation 5.4 Probability of Leak Correlation 5.5 NDE Uncertainty 5.6 Upper Voltage Repair Limit 6.1 Analysis Approach 6.2 6.3 Operational Assessment: Tube Leak Rates and Burst Probabilities at EOC-13...............................................................................................................

41 7.1 Analysis Approach 7.2 BOC Voltage Distribution 7.2.1 POD 7.2.2 Tube Repairs Voltage Growth Rates for Cycle 13 Prediction of Voltage Distributions at EOC-13 Prediction of Tube Leak Rates and Burst Probabilities at EOC-13 Condition Monitoring: Tube Leak Rate and Burst Probabilities at EOC-12......... 35 Burst Probabilities and Leak Rates at EOC-12 Comparison with Prediction and Acceptance Criteria 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 Comparison with Acceptance Criteria References.......................................................................................................

..51 APPENDIX A Indication Lists APPENDIX B Verification Methodology Checklist

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 3 of 95 Glossary of Acronyms BOC EOC POD ODSCC SG TSP Beginning of operation cycle. The current inspection is just prior to BOC-13.

End of operation cycle. The current inspection is at EOC-12. The prior inspection results are from EOC-I 1. The end of the next cycle is EOC-13.

Probability of detection. This value is set equal to 0.60 for the GL-95-05 predictive analysis for the condition of the steam generators at the end of the next cycle.

Outside diameter stress corrosion cracking.

Steam Generator identifier. Specifically SG 1, SG 2, SG 3 and SG 4.

Tube support plate. The Generic letter 95-05 Alternate Repair Criterion applies to ODSCC in the tubes at the TSPs.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 4 of 95 1.O Introduction Sequoyah Unit 2 completed the twelfth cycle of operation and subsequent steam generator tube inspection in November 2003. Axial ODSCC has been confirmed within the TSP regions of the steam generators and is a current degradation mechanism at Sequoyah Unit 2. The alternate repair criterion (ARC) defined in NRC Generic Letter 95-05 (Reference 1) has been implemented at Sequoyah Unit 2 for several operational cycles (References 2, 3, 4, 5, 6).

This report provides a condition monitoring assessment that demonstrates that the GL 95-05 acceptance criteria are satisfied at the end of operational cycle 12 (EOC-12), and an operational assessment that demonstrates that the GL-95-05 acceptance criteria is expected to continue to be satisfied throughout operational cycle 13.

The operation cycle just completed, cycle 12, was 501.6 Effective Full Power Days (EFPD). The next cycle, cycle 13, is estimated to be 498.0 EFPD (Reference 7).

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 5 of 95 2.0 Summary and Conclusions Bobbin voltage indications of ODSCC at the tube support plates were detected and measured in all four steam generators. Based on this voltage distribution, using the methodology of References 1 and 8 and the correlation data of Reference 9, a condition monitoring evaluation including the computation of the probability of tube burst (POB) and the amount of leakage predicted for steam line break conditions at EOC-12 was performed. The acceptance criteria on POB and leakage are satisfied with significant margin. The number of indications detected was greater than predicted in the three SGs with the smaller number of indications, and the number of indications detected was less than predicted in the SG with the largest number of indications. The total number of indications was conservatively predicted. One large voltage indication of 9.76 volts in SG 3 exceeded the predicted maximum voltage. The maximum was conservatively predicted in the other three SGs. The probability of burst computed for all SGs was greater than the prediction, but still below the allowable value. This is due in large measure to the change in burst correlation used in the current analysis from the correlation used in the prediction. The leakage was conservatively predicted. The leakage results remain well within allowable limits.

For each indication detected, the change in voltage from the previous inspection was determined by historical review. The apparent growth rate per EFPY was determined for each steam generator, and was not significantly different from the apparent growth during cycle 11 except for the long tail caused by the growth of the 9.76 volt indication.

Since there were not significant differences in the voltage growth rates among the steam generators, except for the tail due to the one large indication, a bounding growth rate was selected to be used for all SGs which envelopes the growth used for the predictions for cycle 12 and the growth measured in cycle 12 for the operational assessment prediction for EOC-13. The prediction of the PO6 and leakage at steam line break conditions at EOC-13 was performed. The results indicate that the acceptance criteria of Reference 1 on POB and leakage at EOC-13 will continue to be satisfied.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 6 of 95 3.0 EOC-12 Inspection Results 3.1 Voltage Distributions at EOC-12 A summary of eddy current signal voltage distributions at the drilled support plates for all steam generators is shown in Tables 3.1 through 3.4 for steam generators 1 through 4 respectively. The full EOC-12 indication list is provided in Appendix A. These tables show the number of indications in each voltage range detected at EOC-12, and the number of indications removed from service due to tube repairs for any reason. The number of indications that remain in service for cycle 13 is the difference between the number detected and the ones removed from service. No tubes were unplugged with the intent to return them to service after in specti on.

The summary of all four-steam generators shows the following:

0 A total of 1545 bobbin signals were identified as TSP indications during the inspection which were called DSls.

0 Of the 1545 DSls, six (6) were equal to or greater than 2 volts.

0 The tubes with indications greater than 2 volts were plugged due to ODSCC at the support plates.

26 other indications were plugged preventatively or for reasons other than ODSCC at the support plates.

Figures 3.1 through 3.4 show the voltage distribution of indications returned to service. Figure 3.5 shows the voltage distribution of the indications repaired.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 7 of 95 Table 3.1 EOC-12 Inspection Results for SG 1

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 8 of 95 Table 3.2 EOC-12 Inspection Results for SG 2

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 9 of 95 2.5 9.76 TOTAL 1

1 1

0 1

1 1

0 307 51 14 242 6

30 1 287

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 10 of 95 CY 12 Indications In Service Table 3.4 EOC-12 Inspection Results for SG 4 In Service RPC RPC RPC Returned to Confirmed or Not RPC Not Not Indications Service Tested Confirmed Confirmed Tested Repaired CY 13 CY 13 Voltage 1

Bin 0

11 73 1

0.4 0

11 1

10 10 1

72 1

72 71 (TOTAL 129 2

127 2

127 127 124 1

2 121 3

121 119 92 3

2 87 1

91 89 739 85 8

646 21 718 710

60 55 50 45 40 u)

S 0

3 35 W

c 0 30 15 10 5

0 SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 11 of 95 Figure 3.1 BOG1 3 Indications Returned to Service Voltage Distribution, SG 1 All Returned to Service OConf. Or not tested 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 Voltage 1.7

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 12 of 95 Figure 3.2 BOG1 3 Indications Returned to Service Voltage Distribution, SG 2 60 55 50 45 15 10 5

0 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 Volts I

.7

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 13 of 95 Figure 3.3 BOG1 3 Indications Returned to Service Voltage Distribution, SG 3 60 55 50 45 40 v )

S 0

.- jj 35 U

S 0

z 30

$25 20 15 10 5

0 3

z 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 Volts

140 120 100 rc 0

L 2 60 E

3 Z

40 20 0

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 14 of 95 Figure 3.4 BOG1 3 Indications Returned to Service Voltage Distribution, SG 4 All Returned to Service 0

Conf. Or not Tested 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 Volts

4 3

v, SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 15 of 95 Figure 3.5 EOC-12 Plugged Indications Voltage Distribution, All SGs

.I

.5

.9 mSG1 SG2 W SG3 SG4 1.3 1.7 Volts 2.1 2.5 II 3.6 II 9.8

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 16 of 95 3.2 Voltage Growth Rates for Cycle 12 The voltage growth for each indication detected at EOC-12 was determined by identifying the corresponding voltage at the previous inspection, EOC-11. The following process was used to determine the EOC-11 voltage:

0 If the indication was called a DSI at EOC-11, then the reported voltage is used.

0 If the indication was not called a DSI at EOC-11, then a re-evaluation of the historical data of the corresponding EOC-11 inspection result was made, 0

If the re-evaluation of the historical data did not detect an indication, then the previous cycle voltage was assumed to be 0.0 volts.

The distribution of voltage differences over the entire 501.6 EFPD cycle is shown in Table 3.5 for all four steam generators. A comparison of the growth rates for each steam generator on an EFPY basis is determined by dividing by the EFPY of Cycle 12. This comparison is shown in Figure 3.6a in the range of volts per EFPY <I.O in order to see the small differences. The extended tail of the growth for SG3 and SG4 due to the two largest voltage indications is shown in Figure 3.6b Also shown in Figures 3.6a and b is the Cycle 12 bounding curve, which bounds the growth for all four steam generators.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 17 of 95 r

Table 3.5 Voltage Changes from EOC-11 to EOC-12 Number of Indications Voltage Bin I

SG 1 SG 2 SG 3 SG 4

-0.5 or less

-0.4 2

8 2

1 2

3 3

0.5 0.6 4

6 7

12 2

1 5

6 0.7 0.8 3

6 1

3 1

1 1.I 1

1 1

1 1.3 1.7 2.7 7.8 1

1 1

1

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 18 of 95 1

0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 5f 0.5 0

0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0

Figure 3.6a Cycle 12 Growth, Volts per EFPY < 1.0 1

~

r i

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Volts per EFPY

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 19 of 95 1

0.999 0.998 0.997 0.996 k0.995 0

0.994 0.993 0.992 0.991 0.99 Figure 3.6b Cycle 12 Growth Tail

I---

-SG4 --

Bound I

I 1

I I

I

~

r 1

I 1

1.5 2

2.5 3

3.5 4

4.5 5

5.5 6

Volts per EFPY The voltage growth rates in volts per EFPY for all of the steam generators are shown in Table 3.6. The average growth rate is developed by computing the average voltage of all indications in a specific SG at BOC-12 and the average voltage of all indications in the same SG at EOC-12. The difference divided by the average at BOC-12 divided by the EFPY of cycle 12 times 100 is the average percent growth per EFPY. The one high voltage growth (change from 1.98 volts to 9.76 volts) indication in SG 3 results in an extended tail to the growth data.

This will be addressed in Section 4.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 20 of 95 Steam Generator 1

2 3

4 Table 3.6 Average and 95'h Percentile Cycle I 2 Growth Rates per EFPY Average BOC Percent 9sfh Percentile Average Voltage Voltage Growth Voltage Growth per Growth in Cycle 12 Average per EFPY EFPY in Cycle 12 0.064 0.485 9.6%

0.276 0.096 0.472 14.8%

0.31 5 0.070 0.61 7 8.3%

0.326 0.071 0.529 9.8 %

0.255

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 21 of 95 4.0 Comparison of Predicted and Measured Voltage Distributions at EOC-I2 4.1 Comparison of Voltage Distributions The voltage distribution measured at EOC-12 is compared to the voltage distribution predicted in Reference 6 for each steam generator in Figures 4.1 through 4.4. Steam generators SGI, SG2, and SG3 have more indications than predicted. Steam generator SG4, the SG with the largest number of indications has less than predicted. In all steam generators except SG 3, the maximum measured voltage is lower than the prediction.

Figure 4.1 EOC-12 Measured vs. Predicted Voltage Distribution, SG 1 60 55 50 45 40 v) c m

0

-(3 c

0 n

3 z

B 35 Z 30 z

E 25 20 15 10 5

0 0.1 Predicted I H Measuredl

~

0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 Voltage

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 22 of 95 Figure 4.2 EOC-12 Measured vs. Predicted Voltage Distribution, SG 2 60 55 50 45 40 cn c

0

.- 3 35

-0 c

0 = 30

& 25 3

Z 20 15 10 5

0 0.1

--I I

I Measured Predicted I 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 Volts 2.1 2.5 2.9

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 23 of 95 60 55 50 45 40 5 35 z

30 v) c 0

0

-0 C

0 a,

L 2 25 20 15 10 5

0 3

z Figure 4.3 EOC-12 Measured vs. Predicted Voltage Distribution, SG 3 I

0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 Volts

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 24 of 95 Figure 4.4 EOC-12 Measured vs. Predicted Voltage Distribution, SG 4 160 140 120 100 0

m 0

W c 0

n

.8d z 80 ii E 3 60 40 20 0

0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 3.3 3.7 Volts 4.2 Comparison of Voltage Growth Distributions The voltage growth distributions developed in Section 3.2 for Cycle 12, are compared with the corresponding growth distributions developed based on Cycle I 1 data and used for the predictions of Cycle 12 (Reference 6). This comparison is shown in Figures 4.5 through 4.8. The voltage tail of the Cycle 12 Bound (growth >I

.O volts per EFPY which extends to 5.7volts per EFPY) is not shown in order that the differences can be seen more clearly.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 25 of 95 1

0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 k0.5 0

0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0

Figure 4.5 Sequoyah Unit 2 Voltage Growth Per EFPY, SGI

<I

.O Volts I EFPY 1

1

--e Cycle 12 SGI t

+Cycle 12 Bound

-I;- Previous SGI Bound i

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Volts per EFPY For steam generator 1, the cycle 12 bounding curve will be used as a bounding curve. The long tail caused by the one large voltage growth indication of SG 3 will be included in the growth curves for all SGs.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 26 of 95 1

0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 k 0.5 0

0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0

Figure 4.6 Sequoyah Unit 2 Voltage Growth Per EFPY, SG2 c 1.0 Volts / EFPY

-I I

I 7 I

i j

i

+Cycle 12 Bound

-A-Previous SG2

- i Bound I

I I

I 0

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Volts per EFPY For steam generator 2, the cycle 12 bounding curve will be used as a bounding curve. The long tail caused by the one large voltage growth indication of SG 3 will be included in the growth curves for all SGs.

I

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 27 of 95 0.7 0.1 O

~

0 Figure 4.7 Sequoyah Unit 2 Voltage Growth Per EFPY, SG3 C 1.0 Volts I EFPY I

I 1 +

Cycle 12 SG3 I

i

+Cycle 12 Bound I

I I

-t-Previous SG3 I

1 Bound 0

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Volts per EFPY For steam generator 3, the cycle 12 bounding curve will be used as a bounding curve. The long tail caused by the one large voltage growth indication of SG 3 will be included in the growth curves for all SGs.

I

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 28 of 95 Figure 4.8 Sequoyah Unit 2 Voltage Growth Per EFPY, SG4

> 9.9>>10.6 Volts

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 39 of 95 140 120 100 cn c

0 5 80 U

c 0

rc 5 60 E

3 z

40 20 0

Figure 6.4 EOC-12 Voltage Distribution with NDE Uncertainty, SG4 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 3.3 3.7 4.1 Volts 6.2 EOC-12 Burst Probabilities and Leak Rates The predicted results from Reference 6 for each of the steam generators at EOC-12 are shown in Table 6.1. The leakage rate is the 9tjth percentile evaluated at 95% confidence. The burst probability is the probability of burst of one or more tubes at 95% confidence based on the number of trials.

SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 40 of 95 Burst 95/95 SLB Steam Number of Number of Max Number Probability Leak Rate, Gen.

Trials Indications Volts*

of Bursts 95% conf.

gpm 1

250,000 216.67 2.4 0

1.2 x IO-~

0.519 2

250,000 227.00 2.7 5

4.2 x I O - ~

0.634 3

250,000 259.00 2.9 8

5.8 x IO-~

1.05 4

250.000 1024.00 3.7 11 7.3 x I O - ~

3.40 1

Table 6.1 Predicted Results for EOC-12 from Reference 6

Note: The maximum voltage is defined as the voltage where the integration of the voltage distribution from the tail reaches 0.3 of an indication.
The Monte Carlo analysis results for each of the steam generators based on the measured voltage distribution at EOC-12 are shown in Table 6.2. Two hundred and fifty thousand Monte Carlo trials were performed for the burst and leakage predictions for each steam generator. The leakage rate is the 9fjth percentile evaluated at 95% confidence. The burst probability is the probability of burst of one or more tubes at 95% confidence based on the number of trials.
Table 6.2 Monte Carlo Analysis Results for Measured EOC-12 Voltage Distributions 6.3 Comparison with Acceptance Criteria The results indicate that the leakage predictions for EOC-12 were conservative for SGI,SG2, and SG4. The leakage result for SG3 was slightly greater (3%)
than predicted. The numbers of indications for SGI, SG2 and SG3 are greater than predicted, and the number of indications for SG4 is less than predicted. The total number of indications detected is less than the total number predicted. The POB for SGI, SG2, and SG4 are slightly higher than predicted, which is expected because of the database changes. The larger than predicted maximum voltage indication of SG3 resulted in a significant increase in POB compared to the prediction, but still less than the allowable value. All steam generators are below the burst acceptance criterion of 1.O x and the Sequoyah Unit 2 leakage criterion of 3.7 gpm. Therefore the acceptance criteria on POB and leakage continue to be satisfied.
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 41 of 95 7.0 Operational Assessment:
Tube Leak Rate and Burst Probabilities at EOC-13 7.1 Analysis Approach The BOC-13 voltage distribution is developed from the measured distribution by considering the POD and the indications that are removed from service. The EOC-13 voltage distribution is developed considering the NDE uncertainties and voltage growth during the cycle. The latest burst and leakage correlations, Reference 9, are used for the EOC-I 3 predictions. The burst probabilities and leak rates are computed using the computed EOC-13 voltage predictions to address the acceptance criteria at the end of the cycle. Calculation details are documented in Reference 13.
7.2 BOC Voltage Distribution The BOC-13 voltage distribution for each steam generator is determined from the measured EOC-12 voltage distribution. First, the number of indications potentially missed during the inspection and the number of new indications initiating during the Cycle 13, are considered by dividing the measured number of indications in each voltage range by the assumed POD. From this number of indications in each voltage range is subtracted the number of indications removed from service for any reason. This then gives the BOC-13 voltage distribution.
7.2.1 POD The POD used is the NRC accepted value of 0.6 for all voltages (Reference 1).
7.2.2 Tube Repairs Considering the repaired tubes and the POD, the BOC-13 voltage distribution for each SG is given in Table 7.1
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 42 of 95 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 Table 7.1 BOC-13 Voltage Distributions for all SGs 78.33 0.5 70 0.5 56.67 0.5 203.67 56.67 0.6 50.67 0.6 48.33 0.6 152.33 40.00 0.7 40 0.7 62.33 0.7 140 26.67 0.8 33.33 0.8 46.67 0.8 125.33 20 0.9 25 0.9 45 0.9 86.67 1
1.I 16.67 1
11.67 1
15 1
59 10 1. I 8.33 1.I 20 1.I 33.33 2.06 2.20 J
0.67 2.42 0.67 0.67 3.55 0.67 1
/TOTAL\\ 410.67 I
I 416.00 I I
505.67 I
I 1210.67 I 2.49 9.76 7.3 Voltage Growth Rate for Cycle 13 0.67 0.67 The voltage growth rates for cycles 11 and 12 were compared in Section 4 and a bounding rate was chosen for all steam generators. The voltage growth rate cumulative distribution used for the EOC-13 predictions for all steam generators is taken as the bounding envelope of all the SGs for cycle 12, and is shown in Table 7.2.
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 43 of 95 per EFPY 0
Table 7.2 Cumulative Distribution of Selected Voltage Growth per EFPY for EOC-13 Predictions Fraction 0.265873 1
I VoltageGrowth I Cumulative I
0.2 0.856678 r
0.3 0.4
~
0.1 0.9381 11 0.968254 0.65873 0.5 0.6 0.9801 59 0.980456 0.7 0.98371 3 0.8 0.9 0.990228 0.990228 1
0.993485
~
1.2 1.3 7.4 Prediction of Voltage Distributions at EOC-13 0.993485 0.996743 Using the number of indications from Table 7.1, the growth distribution from Table 7.2, and the proposed cycle length of 498 EFPD (Reference 7), the prediction of the EOC-13 voltage distribution is made for each steam generator.
The EOC-13 predicted voltage distributions for each steam generator are listed in Table 7.3 and shown in Figures 7.1 through 7.4. Calculation details are documented in Reference 13.
5.6 0.996743 5.7 1
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 44 of 95 SG 1 Voltage1 Number of Table 7.3 EOC-13 Predicted Voltage Distributions for all SGs (Part I of 2)
SG2 SG 3 SG 4 Voltage I Number of Voltage 1 Number of Voltage I Number of
~
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 I Bin-llndicationsl Bin-llndicationsl Bin llndicationsl Bin I Indications I 0.19 0.1 0.17 0.1 0.28 0.1 0.22 5.04 0.2 4.29 0.2 6.13 0.2 7.04 19.48 0.3 16.83 0.3 18.68 0.3 37.46 36.66 0.4 35.42 0.4 35.92 0.4 86.92 0.5 0.6 50.05 0.5 50.27 0.5 48.88 0.5 130.6 56.7 0.6 55.47 0.6 53.66 0.6 152.73 (Table 7.3 is continued on the next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 45 of 95 Table 7.3 EOC-13 Predicted Voltage Distributions for All SGs (Part 2 of 2)
60 55 50 45 40 35 z 30 5
225 20 15 10 5
0 tn c
0 0
m c
0 3
z SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 46 of 95 Figure 7.1 Predicted EOC-I3 Voltage Distribution, SGI 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 3.3 3.7 8.2 8.6 Volts
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 47 of 95 60 55 50 45 40 35
= 30 5
2 25 20 15 10 5
0 v) c 0
0
-0 c
0 3
z Figure 7.2 Predicted EOC-13 Voltage Distribution, SG2 I
0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 3.3 3.7 8.2 8.6 Volts
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 48 of 95 60 55 50 45 40 5 35 z
30 2 f 25 z
20 15 10 5
0 rn c 0
0 U
c 0
3 Figure 7.3 Predicted EOC-13 Voltage Distribution, SG3 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 3.3 3.7 8
8.4 9.5 Volts
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 49 of 95 180 160 140 120 v)
C 0
([I U
c 0
I) 3
.o 100 rc
& 80 E
Z 60 40 20 0
Figure 7.4 Predicted EOC-I 3 Voltage Distribution, SG4 0.1 0.5 0.9 1.3 1.7 2.1 2.5 2.9 3.3 3.7 4.1 4.5 4.9 8.2 8.6 9
Volts 7.5 Prediction of Tube Leak Rates and Burst Probabilities at EOC-13 The POB and leakage analysis results for predicted EOC-13 voltage distributions are shown in Table 7.4. Two hundred and fifty thousand Monte Carlo trials were performed for the burst and leakage prediction for each steam generator. The leakage rate is the 9!jth percentile evaluated at 95% confidence. The burst probability is the probability of burst of one or more tubes at 95% confidence based on the number of trials. Calculation details are documented in Reference
13.
Steam 1 Gen.
250,000 250.000 I
1 41 0.7 8.6 347 1.52 x lo-41 6 8.7 322 1.41 x lo SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 50 of 95 Table 7.4 EOC-13 Operational Assessment Predictions Number Burst Numberof I Numberof I Max I of I Probability Trials I Indications I Volts* 1 bursts I 95%Conf.
p250,000 I
505.7 I
10.4 1
727 1
3.09 x lo 250,000 1210.7 1
9.0 1
929 I
3.92~
lo-95/95 SLB Leak Rate, gpm 0.546 0.568 0.985 1.69
Note: The maximum voltage is defined as the voltage where the integration of the voltage distribution from the tail reaches 0.3 of an indication.
7.6 Comparison with Acceptance Criteria All steam generators are predicted to remain well below the burst acceptance criterion of 1.O x lo-*, and the Sequoyah Unit 2 leakage criterion of 3.7 gpm throughout operating cycle 13.
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 51 of 95 8.0 References
1.
NRC Generic Letter 95-05, Voltage-Based Repair Criteria for Westinghouse Steam Generator Tubes Affected by Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking, USNRC Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, August 3, 1995.
SG-96-08-010, Sequoyah Unit-2 Cycle 8 Alternate Plugging Criteria 90-Day Report, Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division, August 1996.
SG-98-01-002, Sequoyah Unit-2 Cycle 9 Alternate Plugging Criteria 90-Day Report, Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division, January 1998.
SG-99-07-009, Sequoyah Unit-2 Cycle 10 Voltage-Based Repair Criteria 90-Day Report, Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division, July 1999.
01 -TR-FSW-002, Rev. 0, Sequoyah Unit 2 End of Cycle 10 Condition Monitoring and Operational Assessment 90 Day Report GL 95-05 Alternate repair Criterion, Westinghouse Electric Company, January 2001.
6.
SG-SGDA-02-15, Rev. 0, Condition Monitoring and Operational Assessment: GL 95-05 Alternate Repair Criterion End of Cycle 11 90 Day Report Sequoyah Unit 2, Westinghouse Electric Company, July 2002.
Sequoyah Nuclear Plant - U2C12 Steam Generator Tube Integrity Inspection, Letter from D.L. Lundy to M.H. Cothron, November 26,2003, B38 031 126803.
WCAP-14277, Revision 1, SLB Leak Rate and Tube Burst Probability Analysis Methods for ODSCC at TSP Intersections, Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division, December 1996.
2.
3.
4.
5.
7.
8.
9.
EPRl Report NP-7480-L, Addendum 5, 2002 Database Update, Steam Generator Tubing Outside Diameter Stress Corrosion Cracking at Tube Support Plates -
Database for Alternate Repair Limits, October 2002.
10. Letter from A. Marion of NEI to B. Sheron of NRC dated March 15, 2002, Refining the Leak Rate Sampling Methodology for ODSCC ARC Applications (Generic Letter 95-05).
11. Letter from W. Bateman of NRC to A. Marion of NEI dated March 27, 2002, Refining the Leak Rate Sampling Methodology for Generic Letter 95-05 Voltage-Based Alternate Repair Criteria Application.
12. Westinghouse Letter LTR-SGDA-03-204, I Instructions for Running the Computer Code Cyclesim3, R. Keating, Westinghouse Nuclear Services Division, August 30, 2003.
13. Westinghouse Report, CN-SGDA-04-3, Rev. 0, Computation Details of GL 95-05 Analysis for Sequoyah Unit 2 EOC-12, January, 2004.
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 52 of 95 Row APPENDIX A Indication List Sequoyah Unit 2 GL-95-05 End of Cycle 12 Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug Steam Generator 1 2
2 10 H01 0.42 0.32 12 H02 0.44 0.4 3
3 3
3 16 H01 0.52 0.6 16 H02 1.6 0.93 SAI 20 H02 0.28 0.38 34 H01 0.6 0.61 I
3 I 42 I H01 I 0.23 I
0.22 I
1 1
5 5
5 5
33 H01 0.35 0.55 43 H02 0.42 0.31 46 H01 0.63 0.63 72 H02 0.53 1.05 SAI 1
5 1
80 I H02 I 0.39 1
0.42 I
(Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 53 of 95 Row 6
Steam Generator 1 (continued)
Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 2
H03 0.74 0.52 I SGI I I
I Volts I Volts I
i i
6 6
6 4
H01 0.53 0.45 15 H02 0.32 0.36 21 H01 0.69 0.58 9
10 10 92 H01 1.04 0.83 SAI 34 H01 0.46 0.42 36 H01 0.44 0.43 10 10 10 10 77 H04 1.31 1.04 SAI 11 58 H02 0.92 0.64 SAI H06 0.35 0.82 I
37 H01 0.34 0.65 70 H03 1.3 0.84 NDF 75 H02 0.48 0.47 75 H06 0.54 0.57 I 11 I 61 I H02 I 0.62 I
0.51 11 12
~
93 H02 0.42 0.65 6
H04 0.35 0.27 H01 0.57 0.39 0.37 0.2 14 H01 0.33 0.26 I
~ ~.
1 1
5 1 H01 I 0.33 1
0.38 I
(Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 54 of 95 16 17 17 Steam Generator 1 (continued) 86 H04 0.54 0.59 4
H01 0.53 0.7 4
H03 0.78 0.72 I
I Volts I Volts I 17
[
4 I H04 17 I 4 1 H06 0.31 0.24 0.43 0.44 17 16 H01 0.36 0.15 17 20 H01 0.61 0.6
, 17 21 H02 0.16 0.13 17 17 24 H01 0.69 0.39 33 H02 1.I 0.88 SAI 17 18 18 18 82 H05 0.28 0.26 8
H02 0.57 0.52 57 H01 0.28 0.22 82 H02 0.24 0.25 18 89 H05 19 8
H02 19 8
H05 I 19 I 51 I H01 I 0.83 I
0.75 I SAI I 0.54 0.58 0.64 0.1 0.44 0.31 19 19 H01 0.38 0.21 0.92 0.66 H01 0.57 0.5 45 H01 0.58 0.54 SAI 45 H02 0.62 0.5 19 19 (Table continued on next page) 66 H01 0.72 0.63 74 H02 0.28 0.22 21 21 21 21 8
H01 0.75 0.56 8
H02 0.82 0.62 78 H02 0.57 0.47 83 H02 0.34 0.35 SAI
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 55 of 95 SGI Volts Volts Row Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 22 9
H01 0.4 0.32 Steam Generator 1 (continued)
RPC Plug SAI 23 23 23 24 22 10 H02 0.59 0.37 1
22 11 H03 0.35 0.21 9
H02 0.23 0.1 I 20 H02 0.42 0.44 32 H04 0.26 0.32 9
H01 0.32 0.33 I
22 I 19 I HOI 1
0.22 1
0.41 I
24 24 22 21 H01 0.46 0.35 NDF 22 31 H01 0.22 0.19 21 H01 0.56 0.38 21 H02 0.69 0.91 22 33 H02 0.57 0.47 22 46 H04 0.45 0.23 22 48 H01 1.17 0.75 SAI
~
24 24 22 68 H02 0.21 0.16 23 7
H01 0.89 0.98 23 9
H01 0.24 0.26
~
22 H01 0.38 0.4 29 H01 0.76 0.63 SAI 24 29 24 34 H02 0.64 0.46 H01 0.69 0.51 26 26 36 H02 1.57 0.5 SAI Plug ~
64 H01 0.57 0.45 (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 56 of 95 I SGI 1 I
Volts 1
Volts I
Row Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug L
27 16 H02 0.25 0.19 27 27 27 18 H01 0.18 0.16 18 H02 0.24 0.22 24 H02 0.28 0.27
~
27 27 27
~
1 31 H03 0.55 0.58 48 H01 0.48 0.4 1 48 H02 1.11 0.77 SAI 28 28 28 56 H02 0.66 0.77 NDF 77 H02 0.47 0.34 79 HOI 0.29 0.21 (Table continued on next page) 29 29 30 30 52 H02 1.05 1.4 SAI 56 H03 0.47 0.35 24 H06 0.46 0.43 41 H02 0.74 0.62 30 62 H02 30 82 H01 30 82 H02 0.39 0
0.5 0.43 0.9 0.74 31 31 19 H03 0.55 0.19 64 H03 0.36 0.2
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 57 of 95 36 47 36 54 Steam Generator 1 (continued)
H02 0.27 0.56 H02 0.3 0.3 36 62 H02 0.69 36 62 H03 0.53 H02 0.5 0.55 0.45 0.43
SG-SG[
I SGI I
)A-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 58 of 95 I
Volts I Volts I
Row 37 37 Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug 60 H05 0.62 0.25 61 H02 1.12 0.98 SAI 37 38 61 H03 0.29 0.26 24 H02 0.26 0.2 40 40 24 H01 0.48 0.48 24 H02 0.71 0.54 40 40 40 25 H01 0.48 0.31 25 H02 0.48 0.57 25 H04 0.35 0.39 40 40 26 H01 0.26 0.28 26 H04 0.57 0.28 40 40 40 26 H05 0.42 0.44 27 H02 0.25 0.21 51 H03 0.89 0.99
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 59 of 95 1 SG2 I Steam Generator 2 1
Volts 1
Volts 1
Row 2
Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 14 H02 0.53 0.59 2
2 22 H02 0.33 0.24 37 H02 0.21 0.08 I
1 2
1 48 1 H01 I 0.37 I
0.35 I
~
2 2
42 H01 0.31 0.19 45 H02 0.94 0.74 2
2 2
49 H01 0.48 0.25 50 H02 0.53 0.32 55 H01 0.7 0
2 2
(
2 1
77 I H01 I 0.32 1
0.3 55 H02 0.6 0.53 58 H01 0.75 0.91 2
2 1
2 1
84 I H01 I 0.41 I
0.41 I
58 H02 1.36 1.02 SAI 73 H01 0.47 0.57 2
2 73 H02 0.54 0.37 76 H02 0.61 0.72 1
3 1
42 I H02 I 1.57 I
1.69 I SAI 1 2
2 82 H04 0.7 0.55 83 H01 0.62 0.62 1
3 1
76 I H02 I 0.49 I
0.57 I
(Table continued on next page) 2 2
2 2
85 H01 0.8 0.78 85 H02 0.55 0.51 87 HOI 0.72 0.7 88 H01 0.56 0.66 2
3 3
3 94 H02 0.33 0.76 5
H02 0.42 0.39 30 H02 0.46 0.36 37 H02 1.19 1.11 NDF 3
3 49 H02 0.54 0.29 72 H01 0.42 0.46
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 60 of 95 Row 4
Steam Generator 2 (continued)
Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 22 H02 0.68 0.22 SG2 I I
1 Volts 1
Volts I i
i 4
4 50 H01 0.65 0.46 54 H02 0.59 0.68 4
4 4
J 56 H02 1.01 0.83 SAI 61 H04 0.35 0.52 64 H01 0.49 0.63 (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 61 of 95 11 65 11 88 12 44 Steam Generator 2 (continued) i H02 1.11 0.49 SAI H02 0.46 0.41 H02 0.6 0.58 12 12
.~
t 59 H02 0.35 0.2 90 H02 0.33 0.32 13 21 H02 14 48 H01 14 48 H02 0.39 0.36 SAI 0.98 0.82 0.96 0.92 14 14
.~
84 H01 0.82 0.69 90 H01 0.35 0.34 SAI (Table continued on next page) 15 36 H01 0.67 15 49 H02 0.42 15 54 H02 0.73 0.58 0.55 0.82 15 15 87 H02 0.3 0.32 89 H01 1.25 1.15 SAI
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 62 of 95
~~
~
16 r 3 3 H03 I 0.42 18 I 7 I H02 I 0.96 Steam Generator 2 (continued) 0.48 1
0.54 1 NDF 1 Row 1 Col 1 Locn 1 EOC-12 I EOC-11 1 RPC 1 Plua I 19 20 69 I HOI I 0.74 0.35 33 I H04 1 0.23 0.18 20 20 20 43 H05 0.64 0.54 44 H02 0.31 0.26 49 H01 0.37 0.45
~-
20 49 20 52 1
H02 0.28 0.63 H01 0.48 0.34 H01 0.35 0.34 0.29 0.38 0.37 0.32 20 20 20 J
56 H02 0.71 0.41 57 H01 0.41 0.43 58 H01 0.56 0.51 22 22 34 H01 0.47 0.4 37 H05 0.3 0.2 I 23 I 55 1 H01 I 0.29 I
0.32 1
22 23 23 23 58 H01 0.55 0.36 17 H02 0.58 0.46 22 H02 0.63 0.43 44 H01 0.69 0.69 I 24 I 43 I H02 I 0.81 I
0.93 I
23 23 44 H05 0.35 0.36 49 H01 1.42 1.07 SAI 23 24 24 24 72 H02 0.25 0.2 37 H02 0.77 0.71 37 H04 1.18 1.39 SAI 38 H02 0.42 0.21 (Table continued on next page) 24 24 60 H02 0.74 0.72 SAI 87 H01 0.71 0.5 24 25 25 87 H04 0.3 0.3 9
H07 0.29 0.36 22 H02 0.46 0.33 25 25 26 26 I
56 H03 0.7 0
SAI 72 H02 0.51 0.5 59 H01 0.59 0.69 59 H02 0.33 0.49
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 63 of 95 Steam Generator 2 (continued)
(Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 64 of 95 Row 33 Steam Generator 2 (continued)
Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug 25 H01 0.47 0.42 I SG2 I I
I I
I Volts I
Volts I
(Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 65 of 95 Row 41 41 41 Steam Generator 2 (continued)
Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 34 H02 1.81 1.32 NDF 37 H04 0.15 0.09 39 H02 0.26 0.19 I SG2 I I
i i
I Volts I Volts I
41 41 41 43 H02 0.65 0.59 50 H01 0.62 0.47 50 H02 0.5 0.25 41 41 1
54 H01 0.36 0.19 54 H02 0.51 0.43 I 41 I 54 I H03 [
0.39 I
0.27 I
41 41 55 H03 0.59 0.48 67 H01 0.48 0.66 44 44 39 H02 0.29 0.3 52 H02 1.22 1.17 SAI 45 45 45 45 39 H03 0.24 0.21 39 H04 0.26 0.3 51 H02 0.81 0.56 52 H02 0.59 0.32
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 66 of 95 1
2 2
Steam Generator 3 79 H03 1.36 1.4 NDF 16 H01 0.5 0.54 25 H03 0.36 0.41 SG3 I I
I Volts I Volts I 2
2 2
31 H03 0.58 0.5 35 H01 0.77 0.85 NDF 38 H02 0.17 0.24 2
2 2
3 39 H02 0.61 0.63 73 H02 0.37 0.57 79 H01 0.48 0.59 1
H01 0.49 0.31 3
3 3
2 H01 0.32 0.31 5
H01 0.91 0.76 10 H01 1.42 1.22 SAI 3
3 3
11 H01 0.8 0.46 29 H01 0.83 0.84 49 H02 0.12 0.28 1
5 1
1 I H02 I 1.21 1
0.84 I SAI I 3
3 H01 0.67 0.65 1.76 1.59 0.92 0.5 51 H02 0.71 0.51 94 H02 0.22 0.58 I
3 4
4 4
94 H04 0.15 0.98 34 H01 0.32 0.29 51 H01 0.66 0.57 55 H02 0.45 0.56 1
1 1
6 1
50 I H01 1 0.18 1
0.24 I
(Table continued on next page) 6 6
10 H01 1.06 0.55 SAI 38 H01 1.13 0.73 SAI 6
6 38 H03 0.31 0.63 48 H01 1.6 1.24 SAI
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 67 of 95 SG3 Volts Volts Row Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 7
14 H01 0.84 0.52 7
14 H02 0.38 0.23 Steam Generator 3 (continued)
RPC Plug SAI 7
1 24 7
1 25 H02 0.73 0.42 H02 0.49 0.35 7
7 42 H04 0.24 0.23 56 H01 0.37 0.36 7
7 7
7 (Table continued on next page) 72 H01 0.55 0.45 72 H02 0.78 0.94 73 H02 0.26 0.21 91 H02 0.6 0.45 a
a 8
8 64 H01 0.44 0.46 69 H01 0.9 0.73 70 H03 0.3 0.21 70 H05 0.19 0.18
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 68 of 95 9
9 9
11 Steam Generator 3 (continued) 50 H01 0.77 0.5 51 H01 1.06 1.29 SAI 52 H01 0.5 0.49 6
H01 0.43 0.71 11 11 16 H06 0.17 0.18 17 H02 1.I4 1.03 SAI 2.49 0.25 0.33 0.54 0.5 13 13 3
H01 0.62 0.5 3
H02 0.37 0.46 I 13 I 7 I H01 I 0.39 I
0.32 I
- 13 13 10 H02 0.54 0.44 24 H01 1.16 0.72 NDF (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 69 of 95 Steam Generator 3 (continued)
(Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 70 of 95 Row Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug I
20 12 H01 0.82 0.61 20 28 H01 1.22 1.37 SAI 20 29 H01 1.42 1.07 SAI Steam Generator 3 (continued) 01 01 1.12 0.78 SAI 1.63 1.35 SAI 2 0 7 39 I H01 I 1
20 I 42 I H06 I 0.31 I 2 0 1 3 2 1 t 0.73 SAI 0.25 01 I 0.99 I
0 20 20 80 H03 0.77 0.48 80 H06 0.34 0.2 20 21 I
I 20 I 47 I H01 I 1.21 1
1.21 I NDF I 88 H01 0.6 0.44 15 H02 0.29 0.22 I 2 1 1 8 1 I t p-pq 22 68 I 2 3 1 4 4 1 ).
24 24 16 24 21 t
24 21 I 2 4 1 2 5 1 t 01 1.15 1.17 SAI 02 0.85 0.82 03 0.2 0.19 I01 I 0.49 I
0.44 I
I I
~
~
01 1.09 1
SAI 01 0.6 1.12 (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 71 of 95
~
SG3 Row Col 25 14 Steam Generator 3 (continued)
Volts Volts Locn EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug H04 0.56 1.1 25 25 18 H01 0.86 1.1 24 H01 0.26 0.3 25 25 25 26 H02 1.06 1.09 SAI 35 H01 0.35 0.7 49 H01 0.73 0.44 25 26 72 H02 0.14 0.16 9
H01 0.66 0.87 26 26 12 H01 0.18 0.27 17 H02 0.43 0.18 27 27 27 1
67 H02 0.23 0.45 68 H02 0.36 0.48 68 H05 0.28 0.18 28 26 28 84 29 14 I
H01 0.78 1.02 H01 0.5 0.49 H01 0.71 0.84
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 72 of 95 32 32 Steam Generator 3 (continued)
Volts I
20 H01 0.3 0.39 21 H01 0.32 0.22 32 32 23 H01 1.39 1.63 SAI 25 H02 0.43 0.28 32 33 H02 0.64 0.87 32 34 H02 0.46 0.47 32 42 H02 0.7 0.53 (Table continued on next page)
NDF
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 73 of 95 36 36 Steam Generator 3 (continued) 38 H02 0.6 0.97 40 H04 0.29 0.4 Volts 1
~~
36 37 53 H03 0.39 0.45 26 H02 0.38 0.39 I
8
~
37 31 H03 0.66 37 67 H02 0.31 0.66 0.29 I 37 I 68 I H02 I 0.55 1
0.59 I
38 38 22 H01 1.18 0.95 SAI 25 H01 0.44 0.4 I 38 1 25 I H03 I 0.63 I
0.54 I 38 38 36 H02 0.68 0.79 NDF 40 H03 0.6 0.55 38 38 46 H02 0.36 0.45 58 H02 1.24 1.43 NDF
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 74 of 95 Row 39 Steam Generator 3 (continued)
Col Locn EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug 26 HOI 0.4 0.33 1 SG3 1 I
i i
I Volts I Volts I 39 39 39 26 H02 0.95 1.17 26 H03 0.62 0.42 52 H02 0.45 0
39 40 68 H04 0.62 0.38 24 H02 0.53 0.6 40 40 40
~
24 H03 0.66 0.6 41 H03 0.34 0.25 69 H02 0.37 0.36
-~
~
41 30 H01 41 30 H03 0.44 0.76 0.27 0.32 41 41 42 43 H01 1.13 1.09 44 H02 1.44 46 HO I 0.72 0.48 36 H04 0.33 0.49 68 H02 0.59 0.95 33 H01 0.15 0.19 44 H04 0.29 0.39 43 43 50 H04 0.34 0.46 59 H01 0.46 0.6
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 75 of 95 2
2 Steam Generator 4 74 H02 0.7 0.68 75 H01 0.42 0.39 I Volts I Volts I
~
2 2
76 H01 1.37 1.15 SAI 84 H01 0.34 0.28 3
3 3
3 18 H02 0.9 0.69 25 H01 0.73 0.8 25 H02 0.69 0.7 25 H03 0.5 0.47 1
3
)
34 I H02 1 0.29 I
0.33 1
3 3
43 H01 0.74 0.63 71 H01 0.81 0.71 1
3 71 H02 0.18 0.25 3
72 H01 I
.I4 0.97 SAI 3
88 H01 0.6 0.52 Plug (Table continued on next page) 3 3
88 H02 0.45 0.38 92 H01 0.49 0.55 NDF
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 76 of 95 ROW 4
Steam Generator 4 (continued)
COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 8
H06 0.41 0.34 1 SG4 1 I
1 Volts I
Volts I
i i
4 4
12 H02 0.62 0.31 14 H06 0.51 0.43 4
4 4
19 H02 0.51 0.43 22 H02 0.34 0.37 23 H01 0.8 0.62 4
4 4
25 H01 0.61 0.44 27 H01 0.4 0.42 28 H01 0.39 0.32 4
4 4
40 H01 0.83 0.74 47 H02 0.49 0.68 74 H03 0.5 0.68 4
4 77 H01 0.36 0.42 78 H01 0.71 0.42 (Table continued on next page) 4 4
78 H02 0.28 0.3 82 H01 1
0.79 SAI 4
4 4
90 H06 0.41 0.43 91 H01 0.25 0.68 92 H03 0.79 0.88 4
4 93 H02 0.33 0.32 94 H01 1.07 0.86 SAl
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 77 of 95 5
5 Steam Generator 4 (continued) 1 H01 0.26 0.14 1
H02 0.29 0.18 1 SG4 1 I
1 Volts 1
Volts 1
I ROW COI SuDt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC PIUQ
~
5 5
~
6 H03 0.41 0.36 Plug 26 H01 0.64 0.42 1
5 1
6 I H02 I 0.18 I
0.22 1
I Plug
~
5 5
~
30 H01 0.74 0.81 33 H01 0.7 0.69 1
I 1
5 1
28 I H01 1 1.15 1
1.09 1 SAI I 5
5 5
5 71 H01 0.83 0.74 74 H01 0.7 0.61 76 H01 0.35 0.45 78 H02 0.4 0.44 5
79 5
80 5
83 5
89 H01 0.36 0.56 H01 1.11 1.17 SAI H01 0.41 0.87 H01 0.83 0.89 5
5 1 5 1 93 I H01 I 0.75 I
0.88 I
91 H01 0.88 0.88 92 H01 0.67 0.66 (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 78 of 95 6
6 Steam Generator 4 (continued) 18 H03 0.59 0.4 23 H02 0.76 0.64 I SG4 I 1
1 Volts I Volts I I
1 ROW COI SuDt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plun 6
6 6
1 6
1 2
I H02 I 0.57 I
0.37 1
76 H01 0.49 0.42 78 H01 0.42 0.35 80 H01 0.86 0.33 6
6
~
~~~
81 H02 0.29 0.29 84 H01 0.55 0.36 6
6 6
87 H02 0.69 0.66 87 H03 0.22 0.25 88 H01 0.96 0.99 SAI 6
6
.~
~~
89 H02 0.73 0.27 Plug 89 H03 0.99 0.62 Plug (Table continued on next page) 6 6
~
90 H01 0.91 0.59 90 H02 0.4 0.48
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 79 of 95 7
7 7
Steam Generator 4 (continued) 18 H02 0.53 0.53 46 H01 0.49 0.47 48 H01 1.65 1.56 SAI I SG4 I I
I Volts I
Volts I i
i 7
7 I ROW I COI I Supt 1 EOC-12 I EOC-11 I RPC Plug J I
51 H01 1.41 1.22 SAI Plug 54 H01 1.02 0.87 NDF 7
7 7
55 H01 0.94 0.74 56 H01 0.54 0.43 58 H01 0.8 0.53 SAI 7
7 8
59 HOI 0.75 0.79 64 H01 0.29 0.33 3
H02 1.03 0.68 SAI 8
8 1
8 1
4 I H02 [
0.35 I
0.28
[
~
3 H03 0.71 0.64 3
H04 0.26 0.21 8
8 8
H02 0.26 0.27 12 H01 0.53 0.39 8
8 8
8 12 H03 0.53 0.54 17 H02 0.98 0.97 25 H01 0.62 0.66 27 H01 0.65 0.35 SAI 8
8 a
8 27 H03 0.99 0.61 SAI 28 H01 0.53 0.5 SAI 29 H01 0.53 0.33 30 H01 0.54 0.63 8
8 8
8 31 H01 0.81 0.71 32 H01 1.03 0.83 SAI 33 H01 0.51 0.48 34 H01 1.19 1.42 SAI 1
1 8 1 40 I H01 1 0.42 I 0.43 I L
8 36 H01 0.49 0.76 8
37 HOI 1.59 1.65 SAI 8
38 H01 0.47 0.55 8
8 1
I 8
I 45 I H01 1 0.38 I
0.32 I
(Table continued on next page) 39 H01 0.58 0.45 39 H03 0.29 0.26 8
8 8
41 H01 0.73 0.71 42 H01 0.65 0.7 44 H02 0.28 0.33
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 80 of 95 8
8 8
Steam Generator 4 (continued) 48 H01 0.76 0.59 SAI 50 HOI 0.5 0.33 52 H01 0.89 1.08 I SG4 I 1
1 Volts 1
Volts 1
I ROW COI SuDt EOC-I2 EOC-11 RPC PIUU 8
8 8
8 53 H01 0.75 0.92 Plug 55 H01 0.53 0.68 56 H01 0.57 0.42 SAI 59 H01 0.91 0.51 8
8 1
8 1
60 1 H01 1 1.33 I 1.3 I SAI 1 67 H03 0.43 0.53 71 H01 0.64 0.76 8
8 t
8 I 73 I H03 I 0.6 I
0.62 I
78 H01 0.7 0.67 78 H03 0.53 0.48 9
9 9
22 H02 1.07 0.8 SAI 23 H01 0.37 0.48 24 H01 0.73 0.91 1
9 25 H01 0.38 0.42 9
28 H02 0.36 0.54 9
29 H01 0.47 0.7
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 81 of 95 ROW 9
Steam Generator 4 (continued)
COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug 30 HOI 0.88 0.82 9
31 H01 0.32 0.35 9
33 H01 0.39 0.54 9
9 J
43 H01 0.79 1.06 44 H01 0.92 1.05
~
9 9
(
9 1
61 I H01 I 0.46 I
0.35 I
~
46 H03 0.45 0.75 47 H01 0.53 0.42 SAI 9
9 9
9 48 H01 0.83 0.7 48 H03 0.63 0.33 53 H01 0.75 0.54 57 H01 1.02 0.69 SAI 9
9 70 HOI 0.57 0.46 74 H04 0.34 0.36 9
9 83 HOI 0.3 0.54 89 H02 0.71 0.46 10 10 10 10 (Table continued on next page) 3 H02 0.64 0.47 NDF 31 H01 0.34 0.41 35 H01 0.73 0.37 52 H01 0.44 0.36 11 11 11 11 42 H01 0.39 0.29 68 H07 0.42 0.39 69 H03 0.31 0.07 75 H02 0.71 0.38 11 12 12 12 84 H04 0.64 0
2 H02 1.11 0.96 SAI 15 H04 0.36 0.36 18 H02 0.73 1.01 12 12 12 21 H01 1.12 0.6 SAI 21 H02 0.74 0.75 23 H01 0.6 0.71 12 12 24 H01 1
1.02 SAI 24 H02 0.83 0.42
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 82 of 95 12 12 12 Steam Generator 4 (continued) 26 H01 0.3 0.31 26 H02 0.3 0.38 27 H01 0.39 0.44 I SG4 I I
I Volts I
Volts I I
I ROW COI SuDt EOC-12 EOC-I1 RPC Plug 12 12 32 HOI 1.12 0.64 SAI 35 H01 0.46 0.46 12 12 36 H01 0.56 0.6 36 H02 0.32 0
12 12 12 A
38 H01 0.4 1 0.31 38 H05 0.36 0.1 1 39 H01 0.41 0.4 12 12 39 H06 0.36 0.19 40 H01 0.65 0.48 12 12 12 I 12 I 62 [ H01 [
0.66 I
0.62 1
41 H01 0.7 0.79 41 H03 0.41 0.51 43 H01 1
1.37 SAI 12 12 12 12 44 H01 0.9 0.82 59 H01 0.42 0.54 59 H05 0.36 0.27 61 H01 0.64 0.73 12 12 63 H01 0.72 0.7 71 H01 0.73 0.56 I 12
] 83 I H01 I 1.21 1
0.91 1 SAI I 1
12 12 72 H01 2.42 1.95 SAI Plug 74 H01 0.62 0.5 L
12 74 H02 0.22 0.16 12 75 H01 0.74 0.65 12 76 H01 1.14 0.85 SAI 12 12 81 H01 1 0.81 0.6 82 H01 I 0.66 0.38 13 13 15 H02 0.52 0.73 29 H02 0.43 0.58 13 32 13 33 H02 0.27 0.43 Plug H01 0.4 0.32 13 13
~
~~~~
39 H02 0.36
[
0.33 41 H03 0.55 1
0.34 13 13 42 H01 0.89 0.78 43 H03 0.65 0.32 SAI
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 83 of 95 1 SG4 1 I
Volts I
Volts 1
ROW I
13 COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 44 H01 0.64 0.77 13 1 46 H01 0.43 0.36 1
13 I 46 H03 0.27 0.21 44 13 45
~ H02 0.31 0.4 H01 0.66 I
0.92 13 13 13 14 68 H02 0.39 0.24 77 HOI 0.5 0.43 82 H02 0.65 0.22 22 H01 1.06 0.87 SAI 14 14 57 H01 I
.22 1.11 SAI 59 H01 0.49 0.5 14 I 60 14 1 77 H01 0.31 0.26 H01 0.95 0.67 14 14 (Table continued on next page) 77 H02 0.39 0.26 SAI 81 H02 0.37 0.32 14 14 14 83 H01 0.54 0.4 86 H01 0.74 0.61 NDF 88 H01 0.68 0.68 14 14 14 88 H03 0.67 0.4 89 HOI 0.95 0.95 90 H01 0.93 0.81 15 15 50 H02 0.53 0.46 51 H01 0.89 0.7
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 84 of 95 SG4 Volts Volts ROW COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug Steam Generator 4 (continued) 15 15 15 16 65 H01 0.51 0.43 66 H01 0.28 0.2 67 H01 0.57 0.46 35 H01 0.34 0.37 16 16 16 43 H01 0.26 0.3 45 H01 0.37 0.4 80 H03 0.5 0.5 16 91 17 9
I 17 I 13 I H02 I 0.54 1
0.69 I
H01 0.56 0.41 H02 0.12 0.08 17 17 17 17 I 17 1 27 I H01 I 0.62 I
0.56 I
20 H01 0.71 0.75 Plug 20 H02 3.55 0.9 SAI Plug 21 H04 0.58 0.49 26 H02 1
0.57 SAI 17 I 29 17 1 30 H01 0.25 0.25 H01 0.23 0.14 17 17 17 31 H04 0.51 0.64 32 H01 0.41 0.25 NDF 55 H01 0.43 0.34 (Table continued on next page) 17 17 56 H01 0.7 0.71 56 H02 0.3 0.3 17 17 17 17 57 H01 0.53 0.41 58 H01 0.51 0.25 58 H03 0.39 0.29 61 H01 0.61 0.49
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 85 of 95 SG4 ROW 18 Steam Generator 4 (continued)
Volts Volts COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 11 H04 0.19 0.18 18 18 18 18 18 15 H02 0.17 0.1 15 H03 0.25 0.29 15 H04 0.18 0.36 16 H05 0.44 0.27 21 H01 0.52 0.56 18 18 21 H02 0.47 0.59 32 H03 0.46 0.38 I
I 18 I 40 I H01 I 0.36 I
0.16 I
18 18 18 33 H05 0.48 0.32 36 H03 0.39 0.33 38 H03 0.4 0.31 18 18 18 I 19 I 42 I H01 I 0.31 I
0.16 I
61 H01 0.86 0.72 64 H01 0.43 0.36 67 H01 0.7 0.7 18 19 69 H02 0.39 0.24 35 H01 0.62 0.34 19 19 43 H02 0.4 0.29 51 H01 0.87 0.59 19 I 53 I H04 19 I 63 1 H01 0.26 0.33 0.8 0.48 L
19 71 H01 0.73 0.46 19 76 H02 0.35 0.39 19 84 HOI 0.94 0.86 (Table continued on next page) 19 19 87 H03 0.33 0.13 90 H02 0.3 0.25 20 20 20 19 H02 0.42 0.28 20 H04 0.26 0.28 25 H01 I
.04 0.43 SAI
. 20 20 25 H02 0.48 0.44 26 H02 0.92 0.8 20 20 31 H03 0.37 0.29 32 H01 0.38 0.41
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 86 of 95 SG4 Volts Volts ROW COI Supt EOC-I2 EOC-11 20 33 H01 1.19 0.66 RPC Plug SAI Plua 20 20 20 20 20 34 H01 0.28 0.28 34 H02 0.73 0.78 39 HOI 0.9 0.76 39 H03 0.29 0.21 40 H01 1.01 0.23 SAI 20 20 I 20 I 44 1 H02 I 0.59 1
0.4 1
40 H05 0.25 0.21 42 H01 0.4 0.36
- 20 44 H03 0.69 0.54 20 46 H01 0.75 0.59 20 46 H02 0.89 0.96 20 46 H03 0.48 0.46 20 20 20 20 47 H01 0.4 0.4 SAI 47 H02 0.39 0.56 47 H03 0.49 0.33 48 H01 1.11 1.2 SAI 1 20 1 49 I H01 1 0.28 I
0.26 I
20 20 50 H01 0.79 0.93 51 H01 0.77 0.8 20 20 52 H01 0.88 0.98 53 H03 0.39 0.36 20 54 20 55 20 56 H01 0.75 0.65 H02 0.51 0.3 H01 0.39 0.44 1 20 1 61 1 H01 I 0.48 I
0.47 1
20 20 57 H01 1 0.47 I
0.3 SAI 58 HOI 1 0.48 1
0.53 H01 0.55 0.52 H02 0.28 0.3 0.59 0.5 I
20 59 20 60 H01 0.88 0.64 H01 1.04 1.08 SAI (Table continued on next page) 20 20 62 H01 0.36 0.41 63 H01 0.91 0.72 20 20 69 H01 1.43 1.39 SAI 70 H02 0.91 0.68
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 87 of 95 Steam Generator 4 (continued)
(Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 88 of 95 ROW 23 23 Steam Generator 4 (continued)
COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 73 H02 0.92 0.81 73 H06 0.3 0.23
~
23 23 74 H01 0.71 0.95 75 H01 0.78 0.96 23 23 23 86 H01 0.61 0.6 86 H03 0.27 0.24 NDF 87 H01 0.79 0.63 24 24 24 I
46 H01 0.57 0.48 46 H02 0.54 0.14 NDF 52 H02 0.65 0.62 1 25 I 43 I H01 I 0.74 I
0.33 I
24 25 62 H02 0.25 0.19 40 H01 1
0.84 SAI I 25
[ 53 I H01 I 0.96 I
0.93 I
25 25 41 H01 0.92 0.86 42 H01 0.91 0.61
~~
25 25 I 25 I 83 I H01 I 0.75 I
0.51 47 H05 0.44 0.15 50 H01 0.28 0.26 25 25 1
26 I 19 I H02 I 0.73 I
0.73 I
53 H02 0.19 0.23 58 H01 0.62 0.52
~-
25 25 25 25 60 H01 0.76 0.61 60 H02 0.36 0.2 67 H04 0.39 0.27 80 H02 0.72 0.65 25 26 85 H01 0.59 0.6 14 H03 0.59 0.79 26 26 19 H03 0.42 0.31 20 H02 0.48 0.42 26 26 21 H03 0.33 0.31 27 H03 0.37 0.5 26 26 36 H01 0.67 0.57 47 H03 0.27 0.29
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 89 of 95 SG4 ROW Steam Generator 4 (continued)
Volts Volts COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 26 26 26 62 H01 0.44 0.46 64 H01 0.46 0.39 65 H02 0.91 0.53 SAI 26 26 I 26
[ 71 I H01 I 0.47 I
0.46 I
68 H01 1.29 1.13 SAI 69 H01 0.77 0.66 26 26 I 26 I 85 I H01 I 0.32 I
0.32 I
72 I H01 0.36 0.09 73 I H02 0.83 0.62
~
27 15 27 18 27 22 27 45 H02 0.82 0.84 H02 0.36 0.33 H04 0.3 0.21 H01 0.58 0.63 27 27 27 46 H01 0.57 0.53 53 H01 0.34 0.2 62 H01 0.57 0.67 1
27 I 67 I H02 I 0.61 1
0.36 I
27 27 63 H01 0.71 0.65 63 H02 0.65 0.56 27 27 27 27
[ 27 I 72 [ H03 [
0.57 I
0.45 I
65 H02 0.6 0.59 65 H03 0.4 0.29 66 H02 0.47 0.34 66 H04 0.29 0.31 27 27 69 H01 1 0.9 0.69 70 H01 I 1.74 1.41 SAI Plua 27 27 71 H01 1.49 1.31 SAI 72 H02 0.51 0.48 27 27 (Table continued on next page) 73 H02 1.58 0.91 SAI 73 H03 0.43 0.33 27 74 27 74 H01 0.81 0.85 H02 0.64 0.47 27 75 H01 1.15 27 75 H02 0.78 27 75 H03 0.41 1.15 SAI 0.75 0.28 27 27 27
~
1 76 H02 0.29 0.17 77 H01 0.81 0.7 77 H02 0.67 0.65 27 27 77 H03 0.96 0.85 78 H01 0.48 0.54
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 90 of 95 Steam Generator 4 (continued)
I :::
1 Col I s I
Volts I
Volts I
I I
dpt I EOC-12 1 EOC-11 I RPC 1 Plug 02 0.95 0.79 02 0.73 0.77 I 2 7 1 8 0 1 t p q q 27 84 I 2 8 1 2 8 ) t 02 0.48 0.36 02 0.39 0.42 01 0.45 0.52 p F f q 28 48 02 0.31 0.22 01 0.71 0.63 28 63 03 0.49 I
0.19 1
02 0.43 0.36 02 0.44 0.3 p-p-p 28 66 t
0.58 0.85 0.65 0.54 1.31 I
1.49 I SAI I 01 0.76 0.65 02 0.43 0.33 05 0.47 0.41 01 0.37 0.43 I02 0.4 0.94 01 1.01 0.84 SAI 01 0.85 0.78 02 0.83 0.84 03 0.41 0.56 I 2 8 1 7 3 1 ). 01 0.75 0.8 02 0.28 0.32 03 0.83 1.2 I
05 0.43 0.44 01 0.95 0.48 (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGI ROW 28
)A-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 91 of 95 COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 75 H02 0.78 0.55
~~~~
28 28 76 H01 I 0.27 0.26 76 H02 1 0.4 0.35 28 28 1 28 1 77 I H01 I 0.8 I
0.65 I
78 H01 0.68 0.71 79 H03 0.49 0.37 28 28 28 80 H03 0.54 0.42 81 H01 0.37 0.32 81 H02 0.55 0.49 28 28 H06 0.78 0.65 0.41 0.37 0.2 81 1 H03 0.64 0.61 82 I H02 0.75 0.82 31 31 31 31 39 H01 0.47 0.41 40 H02 0.35 0.39 54 H01 0.48 0.55 55 H02 0.57 0.56 31 31 31 31 59 H07 0.36 0.39 71 H01 0.92 0.69 SAI 71 H02 0.74 I
.04 71 H03 0.54 0.7 (Table continued on next page)
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 92 of 95 32 32 Steam Generator 4 (continued) 64 H01 0.58 0.55 64 H02 0.69 0.6 32 32 32 1
65 H01 0.35 0.34 65 H02 0.35 0.41 66 H01 0.57 0.6
-~
32 67 32 67 H02 1.08 0.83 SAI H03 0.48 0.49 32 32 32 I 32 I 71 I H01 I 0.29 I
0.39 I
68 H02 0.61 0.5 69 H01 0.87 0.66 70 H01 0.73 0.43 32 32 (Table continued on next page) 70 H02 0.71 0.8 70 H03 0.27 0.26 32 32 32 32 71 H03 0.36 0.29 74 H01 0.7 0.49 75 H04 0.5 0.51 77 H04 0.5 0.43
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 93 of 95 SG4 ROW Steam Generator 4 (continued)
Volts Volts COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 35 35 35 33 H03 0.26 0.2 35 H02 0.26 0.18 38 H03 0.52 0.3 35 35 46 H06 0.36 I
0.28 62 H02 0.37 I
0.3 35 35 35 66 H02 0.65 0.81 69 H01 0.25 0.26 73 H02 0.46 0.5 36 36 36 24 H04 0.48 0.14 47 H01 0.29 0.32 48 H02 0.53 0.33 1
38 1 30 1 H02 1 0.35 I 0.39 1
1 36 67 36 68 36 72 H06 0.15 0.25 H02 0.32 0.51 H01 0.36 0.37 37 37 (Table continued on next page) 62 H04 0.31 0.31 63 H01 0.54 0.31 37 72 H01 0.51 38 24 H03 0.45 38 26 H02 0.42 38 26 H04 0.23 0.56 0.39 0.41 0.16 38 38 32 H02 0.38 0.39 34 H02 0.37 0.42 38 38 H04 38 72 H02 38 74 H03 0.32 0.33 0.78 0.57 0.61 0.31
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev. 0 Page 94 of 95 ROW 39 Steam Generator 4 (continued)
COI Supt EOC-12 EOC-11 RPC Plug 27 H03 0.48 0.32 39 39 39
~
37 H03 0.42 0.45 41 H03 0.28 0.19 42 H03 0.57 0.48 39 39 42 H04 0.3 0.33 49 H02 0.69 0.51 40 42 43 45 67 H01 0.36 0.27 38 H02 0.61 0.42 65 H01 0.32 0.28 51 H04 0.52 0.31
SG-SGDA-03-55, Rev, 0 Page 95 of 95 Verification Method (One or more must be completed by each verlfler) 1 Independent review of document. (Briefly explain method of review below or attach.}
2 Verlficatim performed by alternative calculations as indicated berow.(')
a.
b.
C.
d.
Cornoarisan to test results.
Comparison to a sufficient number of simplified calculations which give persuasive support to the original analysis.
Comparison to an analysis by an alternate verified method.
Comparison to a similar verified design or Calculation.
APPENDlX B Initial If Performed TPM-Verification Methodology Checklist I
1 e.
Comparison tu measured and documented plant data for a comparable design.
1 1
I c
I I
I 1
-~
~
I I f.
Comparfson to published data and correlation's confirmed by experience in the Ind ustrv.
I 3 I Completed Group Specific Verification Checklist. (Optional, attach if used.)
- 7
~
1
-~
~
I 4 I Other (Describe)
(1) For independent verification accomplished by comparisons with results of one or more alternate calculations or processes, the comparison should be referenced, Shown below, or attached to the checklist.
Verificatlon: The verifier's signature (or Electronic Approval) on the cover sheet indicates that all comments of necessary corrections ldentlfled during the review of this document have been inoorparatgd as required and that this document has been verified using the method(s) described above. For multiple verifiers, indicated appropriate methods@) by initials. If necessary, technical comments and responses (if required) have been made on rhe "Additional Verifiers Comments" page.
Additional petails of Verifier's Rrtyiew I have read the document and have checked critical calculations, Design inputs were selected correctly and were used correctly. Significant assumptions are identifiied and are resonable. The method used in consistent with GL 95-05. The results are reasonable and are consistent with previous CMOA results.

ML040710360

Text

Navigation menu

Search