ML033280753

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
NRC Comments to the Outline Submittal for the Prairie Island Initial Examination - September 2003
ML033280753
Person / Time
Site: Prairie Island  Xcel Energy icon.png
Issue date: 09/08/2003
From: Cooper P
Nuclear Management Co
To:
NRC/RGN-III
References
50-282/03-301, 50-306/03-301
Download: ML033280753 (1)


Text

Prairie Island 2003 Initial license Examination Outline Review Comments No.

Source Comment Resolution 1.

ES-401-2 Tier 1/Group 1 W/E11 Loss of Emergency Coolant Recirc - KA EK1.2 cannot be tied to 10CFR55.43 is there an SRO learning objective tied to this KA? ES-401 D.1.c Repicked KA and selected EA2.1 2.

ES-401-2 Tier 1/Group 2 000003 Dropped Control Rod - KA AK1.03 is not tied to 10CFR55.43 is there an SRO learning objective tied to this KA? ES-401 D.1.c Repicked KA and selected AA2.03 3.

ES-401-2 Tier 2/Group 1 012 Reactor Protection - K.302 is not tied to 10CFR55.43 is there an SRO learning objective tied to this KA? ES-401 D.1.c Repicked KA and selected G 2.2.25 4.

ES-401-2 Tier 2/Group 1 064 Emergency Diesel Generator -

K6.07 is not tied to 10CFR55.43 is there an SRO learning objective tied to this KA? ES-401 D.1.c Repicked KA and selected G 2.2.22 5.

ES-301-1 SRO Admin Topic Conduct of Operations - JPM Review A Temporary Procedure Change. K/As associated with reviewing procedure changes fall under the area of equipment control not conduct of operations - NUREG 1122, Rev 2. Page 2-5 KA 2.2.6 Reselected JPM Obtain and verify a controlled procedure copy - New JPM KA G 2.1.21 6.

ED-D-1 Scenario A Whats the purpose of Event 6? Its not taken credit for on ES-301-5. If the steam line rupture is inboard of the MSIVs then not being able to shut them will not change the mitigation strategy.

Event 6 forces the crew into a response not obtained and results in changing to procedure ECA 2.1 7.

ES-D-1 Scenario C/ES-301-5 Do not list the ATWS as a Major event if you are going to take credit for it as a component failure. ES-301 D.5.d Will make editorial change.

Prairie Island 2003 Initial license Examination Outline Review Comments 8.

2003 Audit Exam Scenario Summary Why is DI-46158C, MSIV fails, repeated in the audit exam and on Scenarios A and B?

There are different actions required from the crew between Scnarios A&B in the Exam.