ML023260123
| ML023260123 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Peach Bottom, Mcguire, Catawba, Saint Lucie, Summer, Surry, North Anna, Ginna, Robinson, Fort Calhoun, McGuire, PROJ0690  (DPR-018, DPR-023, DPR-032, DPR-037, DPR-040, DPR-044, DPR-056, DPR-067, NPF-004, NPF-007, NPF-009, NPF-012, NPF-016, NPF-017, NPF-035, NPF-052) |
| Issue date: | 11/20/2002 |
| From: | NRC/NRR/DRIP/RLEP |
| To: | |
| Dudley N, NRR/DRIP/RLEP, 415-1154 | |
| References | |
| Download: ML023260123 (34) | |
Text
NorthAnna and SurryPowerStations LicenseRenewal Status November 4, 2002 I
Domin "on
November 2002 3Dominion LR Status Update Introduction
- Timely resolution of issues has continued to improve the schedule
- Ongoing open communications with NRC safety and environmental project managers 2
I
November 2002 LR Status Update mpleted Activities Since Last Meetina Sw
"° Responses to SER Open Items received on 7/25/02.
"* Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) comment period for North Anna ended on 8/01/02.
"* Optional Final Inspection Completed on 9/25/02.
3 Is
-*Dominiow Co
November 2002 LR Status Update
'VDominionr Near-Term Future Activities
, 11/05/02: Issue Final 0 1 SER for Surry & North Anna 2/05/02: Conduct ACRS Full Committee Meeting
"* 12/13/02: Issue Final SEIS to EPA (Surry & North Anna)
"* 12/13/02: Issue ACRS Letter
"* 01/20/03: Issue Regional Administrators Letter 03128/03: Decision by Director NRR 4
-I
.PDuke, McGuire - -Catawba A. Energy.
License Renewal "Duke/NRC Management Meeting November 4;,2002 I
Duke VEnergy.
r-y-.Safety Review
"* Previous management expectation - Duke and NRC Staff to seek the most efficient mean of comrnunication to resolve any Safety Evaluation Report open items
"* Expectation rmet th'rough active use,of telephone calls, e-mails; letters and weil-pianned face-to-face meetings to resolv6 op'en issues
., Duke recognizes and appreciates the time and energy ihn'ested by the NRC Staff, here
- Using these communication avenues has successfully advanced the safety review November 4,2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 2
1
P Duke OEnergy.
"* January 2002
"* June
"* August
"* September
"* October November 4,2002 SER Development Stats 273 formal RAIs 39 potential open & confirmatory items 19 open items, 27 new & confirmatory items 60% increase in number of items 1 additional new item, 47 total items Meetings 9/17, 9/18, 10/1 75%reduction in number of items 14 open items at time of ACRS meetings Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 3
P* Duke Energy.
Safety Review m Duke submittals of October 2, 2002 and October 28, 2002 addressed 46 of 47 issues by:
Providing additional technical information
- Crediting existing aging management programs
- Crediting new aging management programs and activities
"* Final item
"* Additional NRC Staff letter received in October 19, 2002
"* Clarifying teleconference on October 31, 2002
"* Duke response due by November 61h
"* An optional, third Region II inspection is scheduled for completion by November 29, 2002 November 4, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 4
2
[
vovember 4, 2uu0 uUke NLuclear License Renewal rroject SpDuke A
m Previous management expectation - Duke and NRC Staff to complete successful meetings with the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards (ACRS),
,, I
' I 1
°
- Met with the'license renedtal subco~nmitte6 of ACRS chaired by Dr. Bonaca on October 8, 2002-
] Duke agrees with ACRS that the NRC Staffs presentation wasd ell organlied and _'w611 or'-hestrated
- Technical presenters were.well prepared, and issues were presented and discussedl in'a'professidnal ma6nner among
'theparties m Both NRC Staff and Duke were represented by Dr. Bonaca at the full committee meeting on October 10, 2002 November 4, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Prq~ect 6
3
~Energy.
Safety Review
"* November 6 th response on final issue concludes' Duke's scheduled submittals
"* DiscussionPoints:
"* Steps to get to SER issuance in January?
" Status of Duke request that th s afety and environmental reviews specifically evaluate' 60-years of operation?
4 I* Duke oEnergy.
Environmental Review McGuire
"* Draft McGuire Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) issued May 6, 2002
"* Duke written comments provided August 2, 2002 Catawba
"* Draft Catawba Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) issued May 13, 2002
"* Duke written comments provided August 9, 2002 Overall
"* Formal Duke input is complete
"* Next Milestone is issuance of Supplemental Environmental Impact Statements for both McGuire and Catawba by January 17, 2003 November 4,2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 7
L* DUke OEnergy.
Hearing Process
"* Work has been on-hold on the remaining contention related to Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives
"* In August, the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board asked for NRC Commission input and guidance prior to continuing.
"* Next status call is scheduled for November 6th November 4,2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 8
5 P
Duke bEnergy.
Expectations m Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/Duke Management Meeting (January timeframe)
"* Successful completion of the Safety Evaluation Report by January 6, 2003
"* Successful completion of the Supplemental Environmental Impact Statements for both McGuire and Catawba by January 17, 2003 November 4, 2002 Duke Nudear License Renewal Project 9
I
- Exelkn, Nuclear Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station Exelon and NRC Management Meeting Fred Polaski November 4, 2002
- Exehen, Nuclear Peach Bottom LRA Review Schedule Milestone Target Date Actual Date Receive Peach Bottom LRA 07102/01 07/02/01 Draft SEIS to EPA 07/05/02 6124/02 Public Meeting to Discuss 07/31/02 07/31102 DEIS AMR Inspection Complete 08/09/02 08/15/02 SER with Open Issues 09116/02 09/16/02 ACRS Subcommittee 10/30/02 10/30/02 2
2 Exeln.
Nuclear Future Activities
"* November 29, 2002 - Provide Responses to SER Open and Confirmatory Items
"* December 9 - 13, 2002 - Final Region I Inspection
"* December 31, 2002 - Submit LRA Amendment
"* February 6, 2003 - SER Issued
"* February 7, 2003 - Final SEIS issued to EPA
"° February 19, 2003-Region I Administrator's Letter 3
Exel6n.
Nuclear Part 54 Project Performance
"* Schedule Adherence
- All dates met
"* Communications
- Good
"* Region 1 AMR inspection
- Good inspection
- Region found AMPs to be acceptable
3 Exelen.
Nudear Part 54 Project Performance (cont'd)
- Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good
- ACRS meeting went well Exelen.
Nuclear Part 51 Project Performance
- Schedule Adherence
- Good
- Communications
- Good
- Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good
Exelkn.
Nuclear Concerns Two open and confirmatory items not closed
- Exelon is working with the staff on these
"* Reactor vessel top guide cracking TLAA
"* Aging management of fuse clips/holders 4
Exelkn.
Nuclear Summary
- Good progress over last 3 months.
- 14 of 15 open items resolved - one to go
- One confirmatory item still to close
LICENSE RENEWAL ST. LUCIE PLANT FPL AND NRC MANAGEMENT MEETING November 4, 2002 FPL
LICENSE RENEWAL F--
COMPLETED ACTIVITIES
- July 1, 18, and RAIs (155 29,
- ST. LUCIE 2002 - NRC issued safety total)
- August 15-16 and September 4-5, 2002 FPL/NRC public meetings were conducted to review draft RAI responses 2
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES e September 26, October 3
- ST. LUCIE and 10, 2002 - FPL issued final responses to safety RAIs
- October 21-25, 2002 - NRC Region II scoping and screening inspection was completed
- No issues identified
- October 23, 2002 - Draft Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) issued
- Over 1 month ahead of schedule 3
I 11
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
° November 6-7, 2002 - FPL/NRC public meetings to discuss potential issues
- December 3, 2002 - NRC conducts public meetings on draft SEIS
- January 15, 2003 - End of draft SEIS comment period
° Weeks of January 13 & 27, 2003 - NRC conducts AMR inspection
- February 7, 2003 - NRC issues SER with Open Items 4
- FPL,
SUMMARY
- ST. LUCIE All license renewal activities are on or ahead of schedule
- On October 10, 2002, the NRC issued a revised schedule for the LRA review reflecting an October 3, 2003 decision date (22 month schedule)
- Frequent communications between FPL and NRC are occurring 5
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL S........
l I-
]
-r
-t
-i-LRA SECTION TURKEY DRAFT ST.
ST. LUCIE RAIs NUMBER LRA SECTION TITLE POINT RAIs LUCIE RAIs ISSUED 2.1 Scoping and Screening Methodology 2
2 3
- 2.2 Plant Level Scoping Results 0
3 2
- 2.3 Scoping and Screening Results-26 77 37 Mechanical Systems
- 2.4 Seoping and Screening Results-927 12 Structures SScoping and Screening Results-0 3
1 2.5 Elee/I&C Systems 3.2 AMR Results-Engineered Safety 8
1 2
Features Systems 3.4 AMR Results-Steam and Power 8
7 4
Conversion Systems 3.5
~AMR Results-Structures and Structural 2
41 3.5 ~Components 2
41 3.6 AMPR Results-Electrical and I&C 12 2
4 Time-Limited Aging Analyses 14 23 15 gng Tyaa g Po~a ams8 TOTAL SAFETY RAIs 216 301 155 TOTAL ENVIRONMENTAL RATs 10 11 9
TOTAL ALL RAIs 226 312 164
- = Sections being reviewed by contractors 7
-r St. Lucie RAI Categorization and Comparison to Turkey Point Appropriate Admin Error Technical RAI In LRA Error in LRA Info provided In LRA info Should Challenge to Technical not be in CLB Error in RAI LRA 8
IPL 80.0%
70.0%
60.0%
50.0%
40.0%
30.0%
20.0%
10.0%
0.0%
I*
FPL LICENSE RENEWAL r--.-¶trin-nFWr' r,
St. Lucie Units I and 2 License Renewal Breakdown of Category 1 RAls Total No. of Cat. 1 RAIs=I 11 Aging effects and operating experience Plant design details Program details and operating experience Calculation details Aging Management Scoping and Screening Reviews Aging Managerr Programs tent TLAAs 9
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 6
0 I I I
- FRL,
SUMMARY
"* Public meetings to review draft RAIs and draft RAI responses very effective
"* Significant benefit in referencing GALL in the area of aging management programs
"* Providing references and comparisons to GALL in LRA component table listings was of little value to the St. Lucie review 10
SUMMARY
- For the license renewal process to remain stable and predictable, key aspects need to emphasized
- The CLB remains valid
- Component active/passive determinations
- LRA level of detail versus scope of NRC regional inspections
- Limited review required for programs consistent with GALL
- GALL is one way, not the only way 11 1
Immmr O=1ha Publf c Power Fort Calhoun Station License Renewal OPPD/NRC Management Meeting November 4, 2002 Omaha Public Power Oistnci c o p i h e t 0"73PZC
- 7. 00Accomplishments
- Scoping Inspection ongoing this week
2
-m m
Safety Review
- Will bin RAIs consistent with industry criteria
3 Kupp Omaha Public Power Expectations Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/OPPD Management Meeting (February timeframe)
- OPPD to respond to Safety RAIs
- OPPD submit annual update
-NRC issues Draft SEIS
- AMR Inspection
_===
-ý m
mm Omaha Public Powr Distnct Closing remarks Appear to be achieving the reduction of review time NRC Review Fees for ANO-1 and Ft Calhoun LRA (excluding ER) al Billing Quafler
' 2",: ' H. B. Robinson Plant
-CP&L and NRC Management Meeting November 4,2002 CP&L License Renewal I Completed Activities
- June 17, 2002 --Application Received
- Sept. 17-20, 2002 - Scoping-And Sbrbeening Methodology Audit Complete
- Sept. 24-26, 2002 - Environmental Site Visit.
& Environmental Sc'oping Public Meeting"
- Oct. 2, 2002 - SAMA Site Visit
- Oct. 25, 2002 - Environmental Scoping Period Ended
- No Intervention CP&L 2
Enc'losure 8 1
License Renewal I Upcoming Activities
"* Dec. 2, 2002 - Environmental RAI's to Applicant
"* Jan. 20, 2003 - Response to Environmental RAI's
"* Feb. 11, 2003 - Safety RAI's to Applicant
"* April 28, 2003 - Response to Safety RAI's
"* April 4, 2003 Scoping Inspection Complete
"* May 16, 2003 - NRC Issues Draft SEIS
"* July 11, 2003 - AMR Inspection Complete
,3 CP&L 3
License Renewal I Summary
"* All License Renewal Activities Are On Or Ahead Of Schedule
"* Frequent Communications Between CP&L And NRC Are Occurring SCP&L 4
.'/ I V.C. Summer Nuclear Station SCE&G and NRC Management Meeting "11-4-02
V.C. Summer License Renewal Schedule Event Original Schedule Actual Schedule License Renewal Application Received 8/6/02 8/6/02 NRR Environmental Site Scoping Meeting at VCS 9/4/02 9/4/02 FRN published moi Receipt & Availability 9/5/02 9/5/02 LR Application Training Meeting at NRR 9/24/02 9/24/02 SuLtficiency Review Completion 10/5/02 9/27/02 Federal Register Notice Published for Acceptance / Opportunity for Hearing 10/7/02 10/4/02 FRN published for Intent / Environmental Scoping Meeting 10/25/02 10/25/02 Deadline for Filing Requests & Petitions for Intervention 11/6/02 Scoping Methodology Bagman Meeting 11/14/02 Envii onmental Site Meeting 12/10/02 Enwvronmental Scoping Meeting 12/12/02 Environmental Scoplng Period Ends 12/27/02
V.C. Summer Nuclear Station Completed Activities Since Last Meeting Status Update 11-04-2002
"* August 6, 2002
"* September 12, 2002
- Seternber 24, 2002
- September 27, 2002
- October 1, 2002'-',
- October 4, 2002
- October 25, 2002 LR Application Submitted Submitted LRA Criteria 2 Supplement Presdentation on LRA Contents Sufficiency Review Completed ProVided LRA Basis Documentation FRN Published for Acceptance /
Opportunity for Hearings FRN Published for Intent /
. Environmental S coping Meeting
V.C. Summer Nuclear Station Near-Term Future Activities Status Update 11-04-2002
"* November 14, 2002
"* December 10, 2002
"* December 11, 2002
"* January 28-31, 2003 Scoping Methodology Meeting Environmental Site Meeting Environmental Scoping Meetings Scoping Methodology Audit
d V.C. Summer Nuclear Station Summary / Issues Status Update 11-04-2002
- Excellent Interface with NRC Project Management