ML022180672
| ML022180672 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Peach Bottom, Mcguire, Catawba, Saint Lucie, Surry, North Anna, Fort Calhoun, McGuire  |
| Issue date: | 07/23/2002 |
| From: | Hoffman S NRC/NRR/DRIP/RLEP |
| To: | |
| Hoffman ST, NRR/DRIP/RLEP, 415-3245 | |
| References | |
| Download: ML022180672 (35) | |
Text
AGENDA NRC LICENSE RENEWAL STEERING COMMITTEE MEETING WITH NEI AND THE LICENSE RENEWAL APPLICANTS July 23, 2002 (Times are approximate)
- 1. Meeting Between the NRC License Renewal Steering Committee and NEI License Renewal Working Group A. Status of applications (1) Surry 1 & 2 and North Anna 1 & 2 (2) McGuire 1 & 2 and Catawba 1 & 2 (3) Peach Bottom 2 & 3 (4) St. Lucie 1 & 2 (5) Fort Calhoun (6) H. B. Robinson 2 B. License renewal interest C. License renewal guidance development (1) Environmentally assisted fatigue (2) Station blackout scoping D.
Lessons learned from application reviews (1) Fort Calhoun lessons learned (2) Interim staff guidance process (3) Appeal process 1:00-1:30 p.m.
Virginia Elec. & Power Duke Energy Exelon Florida Power & Light Omaha Public Power District Carolina Power and Light NRC NEI/NRC 1:30-1:35 p.m.
1:35-1:50 p.m.
1:50-2:10 p.m.
NRC/NEI E. Public participation F. Summary Members of the public NRC 2:10-2:25 p.m.
2:25-2:30 p.m.
II. Meeting Between NRC Management and License Renewal Applicants A. Status of applications (1) Surry 1 & 2 and North Anna 1 & 2 (2) McGuire 1 & 2 and Catawba 1 & 2 (3) Peach Bottom 2 & 3 (4) St. Lucie 1 & 2 (5) Fort Calhoun 2:45-3:45 p.m.
Virginia Elec. & Power / NRC Duke Energy / NRC Exelon / NRC Florida Power & Light / NRC Omaha Public Power District/NRC B. Public Participation Members of the public 3:45-4:00 p.m.
C. Adjourn Dreart 4:00 p.m.
-'3f% n A C C*-.a, "
W..
.I I 1.II
- A^lh
LICENSE RENEWAL INTEREST Interest Chart Unique Applications Different designs at single site and 20 year exemption requests Millstone Units 2 & 3 Nine Mile Point Units 1 & 2 Browns Ferry Unit 1 I
Projected Schedule of License Renewal Applications Through FY05 FY 01 FY 02 FY 03 FY 04 FY 05 Slot Plant Submit 10Q 20 30 4Q 10 20 30 40 10 20_
30 40 10 20 130 4Q 10 20 30 140 FY01 1
North Annal,2 May-01 2
Surry1,2 May-01 3
Catawbal,2 Jun-01 4
McGuire1,2 Jun-01 5
Peach Bottom2,3 Jul-01 FY02,,..,,
I StLuciel,2 Nov-01 2
Fort Calhoun Jan-02 3
Robinson 2 Jun-02 4
Ginna Jul-02,I
- 5 Summer Au-0
-2 FY03 1
Dresden2,3 Jan-03 2
Quad CiliesI.2 Jan-03 3
Unannounced 30-40 4
FarleyI,2 SeD-03 5
ANO-2.
Sep-03 FY04 1
Nine Mile Point1.2 Oct-03 2
D.C. Cookl.2 Nov-03 3
Browns Ferry2.3 Dec-03 4
Brunswick 1.2 20 5
Millstone2,3 Jan-04 6
Beaver Valleyl,2 Sep-04 FY05 I
Unannounced Oct-04 2
Davis-Besse Dec-04 3
Pilriml Dec-04 j
4 Susquehannal 2 2Q0 I
5
[Unannounced 20 1
Assumptions
- 1.
Schedules Based on 25-month review without hearing.
- 2.
Submittal dates based on fiscal year quarterly basis.
Border Fill Codes L
~J Reviews Completed for Application Reviews are Ongoing or Application Anticipated for Submittal July 16, 2002 2
LICENSE RENEWAL GUIDANCE DEVELOPMENT Environmentally assisted fatigue Station blackout scoping LESSONS LEARNED FROM APPLICATION REVIEWS Fort Calhoun Lessons Learned Lessons include Fort Calhoun review as well as earlier demonstration project Will issue interim staff guidance (ISG) summarizing lessons learned Agenda item at fall workshop (October 2002)
Interim Staff Guidance (ISG) Process Identify issue Develop ISG with stakeholder involvement CRGR review when guidance documents updated Appeal Process 3
NORTH ANNA UNITS 1 AND 2 SURRY UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL REVIEW STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Received responses to safety requests for additional information (RAIs) 2/5/02 Scoping inspection 2/8/02 Issued draft supplemental environmental impact statement (SEIS) 4/3/02 and 4/23/02 (Surry & North Anna)
Completed aging management review (AMR) inspection (Surry & North Anna) 5/17/02 Public meeting on Surry and North Anna draft SEISs 5/29/02 and 6/25/02 Issued safety evaluation report (SER) with open items 6/6/02 Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards (ACRS) subcommittee 7/9/02 meeting on SER with open items 4
NORTH ANNA UNITS 1 AND 2 SURRY UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL REVIEW STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Receive responses to SER open items Issue SER Complete final inspection ACRS full committee meeting on SER ACRS recommendation letter Issue Surry and North Anna final SEISs Staff recommendation on renewed license License renewal decision 8/22/02 11/5/02 11/29/02 12/5/02 12/13/02 12/13/02 3/29/03 7/4/03 5
MCGUIRE, UNITS 1 AND 2 CATAWBA, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Contentions admitted to hearing by Atomic Safety & Licensing Board (ASLB)
Staff appeal of ASLB decision on admissible contentions issued Commission accepted certified contention on terrorism for review Completed scoping inspection ASLB ruling on MOX reversed by Commission Safety RAI responses received Draft SEISs for McGuire and Catawba issued 5/6/02 and Public Meetings to discuss McGuire and Catawba draft SEISs 6/12/02 and 1/24/02 2/4/02 2/6/02 3/22/02 4/12/02 4/15/02 5/13/02 6/27/02 6
MCGUIRE, UNITS 1 AND 2 CATAWBA, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Complete AMR inspections Issue SER with open items ACRS subcommittee meeting on SER with open items ACRS full committee on SER with open items Receive responses to SER with open items Complete final inspection Issue SER Issue McGuire and Catawba final SEISs 7/26/02 8/12/02 10/2/02 10/9/02 10/25/02 11/29/02 1/6/03 1/17/03 7
PEACH BOTTOM, UNITS 2 AND 3 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Environmental RAIs issued Environmental RAI responses received Safety RAIs issued Scoping inspection completed Safety RAI responses received Draft SEIS issued 12/20/01 1/30/02 3/12/02 5/31/02 5/22/02 7/5/02 8
PEACH BOTTOM, UNITS 2 AND 3 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Public meeting to discuss draft SEIS Complete AMR inspection Issue SER with open items ACRS subcommittee on SER with open items ACRS full committee on SER with open items Receive responses to SER open items Complete final inspection Issue SER Issue final SEIS 7/31/02 8/9/02 9/16/02 10/30/02 11/7/02 11/29/02 1/2/03 2/6/03 2/7/03 9
ST. LUCIE NUCLEAR PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Environmental scoping meeting Scoping and screening methodology audit completed Environmental RAIs issued Environmental RAI responses received 10 4/3/02 4/18/02 5/7/02 6/25/02
ST. LUCIE NUCLEAR PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Issue safety RAIs Receive safety RAI responses Complete scoping inspection Issue draft SEIS Public meeting on draft SEIS Complete AMR inspection Issue SER with open items ACRS subcommittee on SER with open items ACRS full committee on SER with open items Complete final inspection Issue final SEIS 7/29/02 10/11/02 11/8/02 12/9/02 1/7/03 1/31/03 2/7/03 3/19/03 3/21/03 6/2/03 6/30/03 II
FORT CALHOUN STATION, UNIT 1 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Deadline for hearing requests and petitions to intervene Environmental scoping meeting SEIS scoping period ended Scoping and screening methodology audit 12 5/22/02 6/18/02 7/10/02 7/11/02
FORT CALHOUN STATION, UNIT 1 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Issue environmental RAIs Receive environmental RAI responses Issue safety RAts Complete scoping inspection Receive safety RAI responses Issue draft SEIS Complete AMR inspection Public meeting on draft SEIS Issue SER with open items 8/2/02 9/27/02 10/11/02 11/8/02 12/20/02 1/17/03 1/24/03 2/26/03 4/21/03 13
July 2002 LR Status Update Introduction
- Timely resolution of issues has continued to improve the schedule
- Ongoing open communications with NRC safety and environmental project managers 2
I
'Dominiem
July 2002 x'ominim LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Review Schedule Status - Completed Activities FAN PA.W" ft LEA RginV 0600 0g1 PAN Pumbod~ Ns
"-"O~WA*
Oflfl0l 7OflMl Defeb Eno howwo'eMg OWMI U0A¶ 46
-""Ms I~laSm IWISIM WMC Iin.,EM, RANS (SNry) 1Im1 IIWia New Ma.Sol*
Mk 11126M 114MA NMC Ims Sow RAs(No Xv 1i 20"41 I2W*
-- A f
mPAPID 1"a)
IznIM i~12P ft,&.
Rfspskf.E OfAN
.AN.)
mom2W IMOOM 3
I.
LR luly 2002 Dm"nnim L Statu aUdt Dominion LRA Review Schedule Review Schedule Status - Completed Activities MMM_
OW*WtW&I~t".f mom N~RN A
&~m b~ndm C~IU.OMIS MRPA WAN WA(A".v OM~
4 Od ElAN EPA""#E.
N*
MIf I7 A
AMR 6"p-UN OqANRIM1 YI7 RAk000t O
Nin WOM 008 421AM EAWOS SE.0 "
NRC MMl W
ftDk I=Wt Ds~N~am 00 (NsE* 1gw) 0S2=
WEE dOWefICuvuwt fetnWd a Onh=
?flZ ICRS &"-a.
I"-U W SIX 01 07/26M 7&=
4 2
July 2002 2Dominion LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Review Schedule Status - Future Activities End of Deis CA.www Pa."w 11NOM I aw.)
OIIS W1102 ACISh kiEw 0-11ft1-O SEA (X 011104M0 ISER Will by ftJS1 11I0&O2 00psofl FE,.I huewdi~o bR 11ri2m ACAS SIW OsW-110.wl~dlft W-10 Of_________vao F"RI SIM mid No EPA fSft")
123W2 FoolMI SE fwd 10 EPA (Holh AMl) 13FOW1 ACPS I.Uw' 1211112 121300" Regl'd AdfwfwIrw LOW 01r03 CS-ft m-sOwEW RW 0
0M13M 1
03102"1110_
Cow.mmw. D*OWdn l0704002"
" Revied 5
July 2002 LR Status Update
'Dominlon Completed Activities Since Last Meeting
- Region II Plant AMA Inspections Completed 4/29-5/3 5/13-5/17
- Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) issued 4/26/02 5/17/02
- Public meetings held to discuss DEIS:
Surrm 5/29/02 6/25/02 North Anna Surry Surry North Anna 3
North Anna 6
July 2002 Xomifl LR Status Update Completed Activities Since Last Meeting
"* Region II Plant AMA Inspection Report Issued Surry and North Anna 6/14/02
" SER with Open Items issued by NRC 6/6/02 o 8 Open Items and 15 Confirmatory Actions o Draft responses accepted by NRC Project Manager o Response to Open Items and disposition of Confirmatory Actions submitted to NRC in the week of 7/22/02
" ACRS Subcommittee review of SER with 01 completed on July 9,2002 7
July 2002 1Dominlim LR Status Update Issues
"* NRC Staff Changes "o Safety Project Manager "o Environmental Project Manager
"* SER Open Items o 2 expected and previously discussed o 6 newly identified
"* Feedback from ACRS Meeting 4
July 2002 LR Status Update Closing Remarks Final SER ACRS Letter Regional Administrator Letter Final SEIS Commission MDecision 10 5
July 2002 LR Status Update
-1,06minioM Near-Term Future Activities
- Issue NRC Final SER for Surry & North Anna (08/15/02)
- Conduct ACRS Full Committee Meeting (09112/02)
- Complete Optional Final Region II Inspection (Sept. 2002) 9
)D"inhiiiar
PhDuke aYEnery Previous Expectations m Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/Duke Management Meeting (July timeframe)
"* Duke to complete responses to safety RAts and submit to NRC by agreed upon date Responses submitted 4/15/02
"* NRC Staff to issue draft Supplement Environmental Impact Statements and conduct successful public meetings Both SEISs issued ahead of schedule Four successful meetings held
"* Duke to work with NRC Region II to prepare for aging management review inspections in July Final week of AMR inspection ongoing Jidy 23, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 2
,A En Duke McGuire - Catawba 0 Energy.
License Renewal Duke/NRC Management Meeting July 23, 2002
2 P
Duke rEnergy.
Safety Review
"* Duke responses to the 273 RAIs submitted April 15, 2002 with additional follow-up on June 26, 2002
"* Application Annual Update submitted June 25, 2002
"* NRC potential open item (POI) letter with 29 open items and 10 confirmatory items received June 26, 2002
"* Duke POI responses provided on July 9, 2002
"* Safety Evaluation with Open Items due August 12, 2002
"* Open communications continue to advance the application review July 23, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 3
PhDuke aVEner-.Inspections
"* Region II inspections are being conducted in support of Application review
"* Scoping and screening inspection was completed March 22nT
"* Aging Management Review inspection
"* Week of July 8th at McGuire
"* Week of July 22nd at Catawba
"* Public exit is scheduled for July 26th
"* An optional third inspection would occur this fall July23, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 4
3 P! Duke aEnergy.
Environmental Review McGuire
"* Draft McGuire Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) issued May 6, 2002
"* McGuire public meetings completed May 12, 2002
"* Written comments on the McGuire SEIS (due August 2) will be provided as scheduled Catawba
"* Draft Catawba Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS) issued May 13, 2002
"* McGuire public meetings completed May 27, 2002
"* Written comments on the Catawba SEIS (due August 9) will be provided as scheduled July 23, 2002 Duke Nuclear ixcense Renewal Poect 5
PkDuke 4Energy Hearing Process
"* Work continues on the remaining contention related to Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives
"* Most recent teleconference among all participants with the aim of assuring continued progress was held July 1Oth
"* Next call is scheduled for July 29th
"* Additional actions to address the SAMA contention will be defined following the call Ju 23,2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Proqect 6
4 FkDuke OEnergy.
Expectations m Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/Duke Management Meeting (October timeframe)
"* Duke and NRC Staff to seek the most efficient means of communication to resolve any Safety Evaluation Report open items
"* Duke and NRC Staff to complete successful meetings with the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards July 23, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 7
I Exelon.
Nuclear Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station Exelon and NRC Management Meeting James Meister Fred Polaski July 23, 2002 Exeln.
Nuclear Peach Bottom LRA Review Schedule Milestone Target Date Actual Date Receive Peach Bottom LRA 07102101 07102/01 FRN Published for LRA Receipt 08/01/01 07/25/01 FRN Publisbd for Hearing Opporusnity 05/31101 09/31)01 Deadline for filing hearing requests 10101/01 10/01/01 Environmental Scoping Meeting 11/07/01 11/07/01 NRC Ussuu Env. RAIs 12/28101 12/20101 Exelon Responds to Env. RAls 02/26102 01/30102 NRC Issues Safety RAls 03/12/02 03/12102 Exelon Responds to Safety RAIs 05/27/02 05/22102 Scoping Inspection Complete 06/24/02 4/24102 Draft SEIS to EPA 07/05102 6/24/02 2
2 Exekn Nuclear Completed Activities
- April 24, 2002 - Scoping Inspection Exit Meeting
- April 29 through May 22, 2002 - Exelon Transmitted 9 letters responding to RAIs on the Part 54 application Exelkn.
Nuclear Future Activities
"* July 31, 2002 - Public Meeting to Discuss Draft SEIS
"* August 15, 2002 - Public Exit Meeting on the AMR Inspection
"* September 16, 2002 - SER with Open Items Issued
"* September 26, 2002 - End of Draft SEIS Comment Period
"* October 30, 2002 - ACRS Subcommittee to Review SER with Open Items
3
- Exelkn, Nuclear Part 54 Project Performance
"* Schedule Adherence
- All dates met
"* Communications
- Good
"* Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good Exelon.
Nudear Part 51 Project Performance
- Schedule Adherence
- All dates met
- Communications
- Good
- Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good 6
Exel--n.
- Nuclea, Concerns Emerging industry issues are challenging the stability and predictability of the license renewal process 7
Exelon
- Nuclea, Summary
- Communications and interactions have been good. NRC Project Managers doing good job.
- License Renewal standardization and predictability has not been achieved.
4
LICENSE RENEWAL IF:PL TURKEY POINT AND ST. LUCIE PLANTS FPL AND NRC MANAGEMENT MEETING July 23, 2002
SUMMARY
- TURKEY POINT On June 6, 2002, NRC issued renewed licenses for Turkey Point Units 3 and 4 2
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE 9 April 16-18, 2002 - NRC completed the onsite scoping and screening methodology audit
- Two RAIs and one confirmatory item identified
- April 30, 2002 - Environmental scoping period ended e May 7, 2002 - NRC issued environmental RAIs (9 total, all related to SAMAs) ahead of scheduled due date of May 19, 2002 3
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE May 15-16 and June 10-11, 2002 - FPL/NRC meetings were conducted to review draft RAIs
"* June 25, 2002 - FPL issued responses to environmental RAIs ahead of scheduled due date of July 19, 2002
"* July 1, 2002 - NRC issued first two sets of formal RAIs (97 total) 4
LICENSE RENEWAL F::PL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE 0 July 29, 2002 - NRC issues rest of safety RAIs o August-September 2002 review
- FPL/NRC meetings to draft RAI responses
- October 21-25, s
2002 - NRC Region 1I scoping and screening inspection o December 9' 2002 - NRC issues draft SEIS 5
SUMMARY
- ST. LUCIE
"* All license renewal activities are on or ahead of schedule
"* Frequent communications between FPL and NRC are occurring
"* FPL will provide feedback on the St. Lucie safety RAIs at the next NRC Steering Committee Meeting 6
I E!PP Fort Calhoun Station License Renewal OPPD/NRC Management Meeting July 23, 2002 Accomplishments
"* Revised LRA linking Sections 2 and 3 submitted
"* 25 month schedule issued
"* Environmental Scoping Audit and Public Meetings
"* Scoping and Screening Methodology Audit
"* Provided initial responses to Safety RAIs Safety Review
- Draft responses provided to three sets
- Excellent communication on draft RAls have enabled agreement on RAI content and responses
- Position on ISG issues
- Will bin RAIs consistent with industry criteria
2 HPPB Environmental Review
"* Excellent communication during scoping audit allowed closure of most issues
"* Formal issue of RAI questions (primarily SAMA-related) probably this week
..PP.
Expectations
- Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/OPPD Management Meeting (October timeframe)
- NRC Staff to issue Environmental and Safety RAIs
- OPPD to respond to Environmental RAIs
- OPPD to submit request for fee reduction based on generic benefit of SRP format review Closing remarks
- OPPD will continue to work closely with NRC management to achieve the reduction of review time projected for an LRA using the SRP format
,