ML020530398
| ML020530398 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Peach Bottom, Mcguire, Catawba, Surry, North Anna, Turkey Point, McGuire  |
| Issue date: | 01/08/2002 |
| From: | Division of Regulatory Improvement Programs |
| To: | |
| Hoffman, S T, NRR, 415-3245 | |
| References | |
| Download: ML020530398 (48) | |
Text
AGENDA NRC LICENSE RENEWAL MEETINGS WITH NEI AND THE LICENSE RENEWAL APPLICANTS JANUARY 8, 2002 (1:00 - 4:00 pm approx.)
I.
Meeting between the NRC License Renewal Steering Committee (LRSC) and NEI License Renewal Working Group 1:00 - 1:30 pm A. Status of applications (1) Hatch 1 & 2 (2) Turkey Point 3 & 4 (3) Surry 1 & 2 and North Anna 1 & 2 (4) McGuire 1 & 2 and Catawba 1 & 2 (5) Peach Bottom 2 & 3 (6) St. Lucie 1 & 2 B. License renewal interest - known submittals C. License renewal implementation guidance development (1) Emerging issues (2) Lessons learned process - document updates D. Lessons learned from application reviews (1) Environmental scoping meeting open house experience (2) License renewal appeals process (3) New lessons identified E. Summary F. Public participation Southern Nuclear Florida Power & Light Virginia Elec. & Power Duke Energy Exelon Florida Power & Light 1:30 - 2:15 pm NRC NRC n
Break I1. Meetings between NRC Management and License Renewal Applicants 2
A. Florida Power and Light Company -- Turkey Point 3 & 4 B. Virginia Electric and Power Company -- Surry 1 & 2 and North Anna 1 & 2 C. Duke Energy Company -- McGuire 1 & 2 and Catawba 1 & 2 D. Exelon Generation Company -- Peach Bottom 2 & 3 NRC NRC NEI LRSC All attendees
- 15 - 2:30 pm
- 30 - 4:00 pm Attachment I
Projected Schedule of License Renewal Applications Through FY05 F
1i FY° FY 03 FY 04 FY slo i
- IPIa, jISubmil, IQ 2Q3 4Q° I Q I2Q3 oQ 2Q I 3 4Q 1Q 1 20 1 3 4
If I
Q I Z 3Q ANO-1 Hatch Turkey Point I North Anna May-01 2
ISurry IMay-01l 3
ICatawba Jun-01_
4 McGuire Jn Peach, Bottom=,
Jul-01.
5 I.
.. B to 1 1 SttLucia I,!.ov2 I - l IFnrt U2lhnhnf Jan-U/
Jun-u.
3
,R_____________
Ju-4 1
I t
-A I inni Jul-02 4~~
-~nn r
5 i1 Summner A!-UIi~2zt IF Dresden 2,3 2__
2_
_uad.Cit
_1 E2 2
Quad Cities! 12 20--------------------Q II-I I
I I
I
+
l -1 t -I-I I
I I I, I ~ ~ I I
I I
I II I
I I
4 !
I I-I,-I II4-
-I 4-I--4 I
-t
-t-t ____
I-4-4-4t I
L....-....---J
-4----------I I-F U I
SI NineMilePoint 1,2 Oct-031 1
1 1
1 1-1 2
1Cook 1,2 Nov-03 1
I I
I 1
1 1 1 3
1Browns Ferry 2,3 Dec-031 4
- '"*1ick I
I II I
I I
5 JUnannounced Jan-04 I
I.-t-I Unannounced Oct-04 2
Davis-Besse Dec-04 3
Pilgrim Dec-04 4
Unannounced 2QE
=
5 Cooper Apr-I
ýLEGEND Changes."...,1.'
Assumptions
- 1. Schedules based on 25-month review without hearing.
1 January 7, 2002 R nhinr.'ln FYUO 1
2 3
FYOI 5
"7 zzIzzIzzzttzzt_11zZ1Z111Z1-IZZT-I I
'1 I
I Fort Gaihoun Jan-02 i U
d 3Q
'; l rle'
~.I "P
II I
I I
I I
II
- 5. IANO-2'
= 'II 6
1 BeaverValleyl1,2 Sep-041 -
I I
I I::VI'Y)
I I
E'Vt'Y'J r
RO r-
.j I*
Jrl.I A*I*
p%.4'* A I"
I-
LICENSE RENEWAL IMPLEMENTATION GUIDANCE DEVELOPMENT
"* Emerging issues "o Scoping of station blackout equipment "o Scoping of seismic II over I piping "o Aging management of non-environmental qualified cables "o Aging management of fire protection piping "o Aging management of concrete structures
"* Guidance document updates LESSONS LEARNED FROM APPLICATION REVIEWS
"* Environmental scoping meeting open house experience
"* License renewal appeal process 2
TURKEY POINT, UNITS 3 AND 4 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Issued safety evaluation report (SER) with open items Aging management review inspection 8/17/01 8/20-24/01 9/10-14/01 9/25/01 10/5/01 11/7/01 ACRS subcommittee meeting ACRS full committee meeting Applicant responded to SER open items 3
TURKEY POINT, UNITS 3 AND 4 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Issue final supplemental environmental impact statement (SEIS)
Complete final inspection Issue SER Receive Regional Administrator's recommendation ACRS subcommittee meeting ACRS full committee meeting Commission paper with staff recommendation Issue renewed license (if approved) 1/29/02 1/15/02 2/28/02 3/8/02 3/13/02 4/12/02 5/17/02 7/17/02 4
NORTH ANNA, UNITS 1 AND 2 SURRY, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Scoping and screening methodology audits complete Environmental scoping meeting (Surry)
Environmental scoping meeting (North Anna)
Issued env. requests for additional information (RAIs) (North Anna & Surry)
Issued safety RAls Received environmental RAI responses (Surry and North Anna) 9/14/01 9/19/01 10/18/01 10/17/01 11/26/01 12/10/01 5
NORTH ANNA, UNITS 1 AND 2 SURRY, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE MILESTONES Receive safety RAI responses (North Anna and Surry)
Complete scoping inspections Complete aging management review inspections Issue SEIS (Surry)
Issue draft SEIS (North Anna)
Issue SER with open items 2/8/02 2/15/02 5/31/02 4/26/02 5/17/02 6/10/02 6
MCGUIRE, UNITS 1 AND 2 CATAWBA, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Completed scoping methodology audit SEIS scoping period ended (McGuire)
Environmental scoping meeting (Catawba)
SEIS scoping period ended (Catawba)
Issued environmental RAIs (McGuire)
Issued environmental RAIs for Catawba Pre-hearing conference in Charlotte 10/19/01 10/21/01 10/23/01 11/22/01 11/26/01 12/12/01 12/18-19/01 7
MCGUIRE, UNITS 1 AND 2 CATAWBA, UNITS 1 AND 2 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Receive environmental RAI responses (McGuire)
ALSB decision on standing and contentions Issue safety RAIs Receive environmental RAI responses (Catawba)
Complete scoping inspection Receive safety RAI responses Issue draft SEIS (McGuire)
Issue draft SEIS (Catawba) 1/21/02 1/23/02 1/30/02 2/13/02 3/29/02 4/15/02 5/17/02 6/7/02 8
a
4 PEACH BOTTOM, UNITS 2 AND 3 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS RECENT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Deadline for filing hearing requests and petitions for intervention Environmental scoping meeting Issued revised schedule for 25 month review Completed scoping and screening methodology audit Issued environmental RAIs 10/1/01 11/7/01 11/16/01 12/7/01 12/20/01 9
PEACH BOTTOM, UNITS 2 AND 3 LICENSE RENEWAL STATUS FUTURE ACTIVITIES Receive environmental RAI responses Issue safety RAIs Receive safety RAI responses Issue draft SEIS Issue SER with open items 2/26/02 3/12/02 5/27/02 7/5/02 9/16/02 10 10
w LICENSE RENEWAL FPL TURKEY POINT AND ST. LUCIE PLANTS FPL AND NRC MANAGEMENT MEETING January 8, 2002
LICENSE RENEWAL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
"* September 25, 2001
"* October 4, 2001 - A
"* October 22, 2001 -
- ACRS subcommittee meeting CRS full committee meeting Issued License Renewal Application annual update
- November 7, 2001 - Issued response to new open item on concrete aging (NRC letter of October 30, 2001) 2 FIPL
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
- January 29, 2002 - NRC issue final EIS o February 28, 2002 - NRC issue SSER
- March 13, 2002 ACRS subcommittee site visit and meeting
- April 11-12, 2002 - ACRS full committee meeting 3
IV LICENSE RENEWAL IF:PL
SUMMARY
- TURKEY POINT
"* All open and confirmatory items resolved
"* All license renewal activities are on or ahead of schedule
"* NRC revised schedule indicates a Commission decision by July 17, 2002
- Improvement appears feasible 4
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
- November 29, 2001 - FPL issued the St. Lucie License Renewal Application (LRA)
- December 20, 2001 - Additional CD copies of the LRA provided to NRC
- December 27, 2001 - NRC notice of receipt of the:
LRA published in the Federal Register 5
W LICENSE RENEWAL FPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
- January 17, 2002 - NRC/FPL meeting
- Overview of the St. Lucie LRA
- January 2002 - NRC complete sufficiency review and provide review schedule 6
SUMMARY
- ST. LUCIE
- Frequent communications between FPL and NRC are occurring 7
w LICENSE RENEWAL FPL TURKEY POINT AND ST. LUCIE PLANTS FPL AND NRC MANAGEMENT MEETING January 8, 2002
LICENSE RENEWAL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
- September 25, 2001
- October 4, 2001 - A
- ACRS subcommittee meeting CRS full committee meeting
"* October 22, 2001 - Issued License Renewal Application annual update
"* November 1, 2001 - Issued FPL comments on SER and responses to Open/Confirmatory Items
"* November 7, 2001 - Issued response to new open item on-concrete aging (NRC letter of October 30, 2001) 2 IPL
w LICENSE RENEWAL FPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - TURKEY POINT
"* January 29, 2002 - NRC issue final EIS
"* February 28, 2002 - NRC issue SSER
"* March 13, 2002 - ACRS subcommittee site visit and meeting
"* April 11-12, 2002 - ACRS full committee meeting 3
W LICENSE RENEWAL IF:PL
SUMMARY
- TURKEY POINT 9 All open and confirmatory items resolved
- All license renewal activities are on or ahead of schedule
- NRC revised schedule indicates a Commission decision by July 17, 2002
- Improvement appears feasible 4
LICENSE RENEWAL FPL COMPLETED ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
- November 29, 2001 - FPL issued the St. Lucie License Renewal Application (LRA)
- December 20, 2001 - Additional CD copies of the LRA provided to NRC
- December 27, 2001 - NRC notice of receipt of the LRA published in the Federal Register 5
V LICENSE RENEWAL FPL UPCOMING ACTIVITIES - ST. LUCIE
- January 17, 2002 - NRC/FPL meeting
- Overview of the St. Lucie LRA
- January 2002 - NRC complete sufficiency and provide review schedule review 6
FPL LICENSE RENEWAL iFPL
SUMMARY
- ST. LUCIE
- Frequent communications between FPL and NRC are occurring 7
rim R no nit License Renewal Management Meeting SurryPower Station NorthAnna Power Station January 08, 2002 1
Topics e Milestone Review Schedule Review Status e Environmental Review Status e Closing Remarks 2
OVDominion January 2002 LR Status Update
- Safety
January 2002 LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Milestone Review Schedule - Completed Activities 3
- Dominion Milestone Target Date Actual Date Receive SPS and NAPS LRAs 05/29/01 05/29/01 FRN Published for LRA Receipt 06/28/01 06/28/01 FRN Published for Hearing Opporunity 07/27/01 07/27/001 Deadline for filing hearing requests 08/27/01 08/27/01 Environmental scoping meeting (Surry) 09/19/01 09/19/01 Environmental scoping meeting (North Anna) 10/18/01 10/18/01 NRC Issues Env. RAIs (Surry) 11/09/01 11/09/01 NRC Issues Safety RAIs 11/26/01 11/26/01 NRC Issues Env. RAIs (North Anna) 12/07/01 12/07/01 Dominion Responds to Env. RAIs (Surry) 12/21/01 12/10/01 Dominion Responds to Env. RAIs (North Anna) 01/21/02 12/10/01
January 2002 LR Status Update Dominion LRA Review Schedule Milestone Review Schedule - Future Activities Milestone Target Date Actual Date Dominion Responds to Safety RAIs 02/08/02 Scoping Inspections Complete 02/15/02 Draft SEIS to EPA (Surry) 04/26/02 Draft SEIS to EPA (North Anna) 05/17/02 AMR Inspections Complete 05/31/02 Public Meeting to Discuss DEIS (Surry) 06/06/02 SER w/O0 issued by NRC 06/10/02 Public Meeting to Discuss DEIS (North Anna) 06/27/02 End of DEIS Comment Period (Suny) 07/18/02 ACRS Subcommittee review of SER 01 07/24/02 End of DEIS Comment Period (North Anna) 08/08/02 FDominion 4
January 2002 LR Status Update
- ,Dominion Dominion LRA Review Schedule Milestone Review Schedule - Future Activities Milestone Target Date Actual Date Responses to SER 01 Received 08/22/02 ACRS full committee review of SER 01 09/04/02 SER issued by RLSB 11/05/02 Optional Final Inspection complete 11/29/02 ACRS full committee review of SER 12/04/02 Final SEIS issued to EPA (Surry) 12/13/02 Final SEIS issued to EPA (North Anna) 12/13/02 ACRS Letter 12/20/02 Regional Administrator's Letter 01/20/03 SER issued as NUREG 01/28/03 Commission Paper w/Staff Recommendations 03/14/03 Commission Decision 06/27/03 5
IN0 January 2002 tDominion*
LR Status Update Safety Review Completed Activities
- September 10 -1.4, 2001 - Scoping/Screening Methodology Audit
- September 19, 2001 - North Anna Plant Walk-through with Region II Inspectors during U 1RO
January 2002 D-1uominion LR Status Update Safety Review Completed Activities
- October 12, 2001 - Letter revising LRA review schedule in accordance with a 25-month review plan issued to Applicant because no petitions to intervene or requests for hearings filed.
January 2002 Dotmiion LR Status Update Safety Review Completed Activities
° November 14, 2001 - Fifth set of formal RAIs issued to Applicant (received 11/20/01) (2 RAIs)
° November 26, 2001 - Final set of RAIs issued to Applicant (received 12/5/01) (34 RAIs)
January 2002 SDominion LR Status Update Safety Review Future Activities
"* January 15, 2002 - Submit responses to remaining formal RAIs (53 RAIs), except those related to Criterion 2 scoping and low voltage instrument cable (5 RAIs).
"* February 8, 2002 - Submit responses to formal RAIs related to Criterion 2 scoping and low voltage instrument cable (5 RAIs).
9
January 2002 Dominion LR Status Update Environmental Review Completed Activities
- September 19, 2001 - Surry Public Env. Scoping Meeting September 19&20, 2001 - Surry Environmental Site Audit October 18, 2001 - NAPS Public Environmental Scoping Meeting October 17&18, 2001 - NAPS Environmental Site Audit October 17, 2001 - SAMA RAIs issued to Applicant (17 15 requiring response)
,p January 2002
-Dominion LR Status Update Safety Review RAI Categorization 85 80 78 Category I - Appropriate RAI 75 Category 2 - Admin. Error in LRA 70 Category 3 - Technical Error in LRA 65 60 Category 4 - Info. Provided in LRA 55 Category 5 - Info. Should not be in LRA 50 Category 6 - Challenges the Adequacy of 45 the CLB 40 Category 7 - Technical Error in RAI 35 30 25 20 15 10 C
.3 4
C 1
Category I Category 2 Category 3 Category4 Category 5 Category 6 Category 7 11 a.
Safety Review Category 5 RAIs o Category 5 - Information Should Not be in the LRA OE Methodology (1)
UFSAR Tables (1)
Code Edition (1)
(RAI 3.1.1.2-1)
(RAI 4.7.4-1)
(RAI B2.2.12-2)
JI*Dominion January 2002 LR Status Update 12
January 2002 LR Status Update Safety Review Category 6 RAI Category 6 - Challenges the Adequacy of the CLB SBO Scoping(1)
(RAI 2.5-1)
."Dominion 13
NwJanuary 2002 fDonminion LR Status Update Closing Remarks
"* Communication dialog has been excellent and timely.
"* Teleconference/review process has reduced the actual number of formal RAIs issued to 36% of the potential RAIs.
"* The LRA review schedule is being maintained.
14
IH*
January 2002 ODominion LR Status Update Closing Remarks
- Five Challenging Issues SBO Scoping Fire Protection Programs Instrument Cables Concrete Aging Criterion 2 Scoping
- Upcoming Milestones RAI Responses Scoping Inspections 15
I Duke EEnergy.
McGuire - Catawba License Renewal Duke/NRC Management Meeting January 8, 2002 I
P Duke Energ..
Accomplishments
"* September 19, 2001 - NRC/Duke Management Meeting
"* September 24 & 25, 2001 - McGuire Environmental Scoping Site Audit & Public Meetings
"* October 16-18, 2001 - Safety Scoping & Screening Methodology Audit completed
"* October 22 & 23, 2001 - Catawba Environmental Scoping Site Audit & Public Meetings
"* December 18 & 19, 2001 - ASLB Prehearing Conference in Charlotte January8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 2
2 P* Duke 6VEnergy.
Safety Review
"* Good communications continue to advance the application review
"* Topical telecons covering draft RAls have been helpful in understanding perspectives and clarifying information requests
"* NRC staff questions indicate the thoroughness of their review
"* Some staff positions (particularly some of those addressed in letters to NEI) appear to be new interpretations and will require more plant-specific and industry-wide dialogue
"* All formal safety RAIs to be issued by the end of January January8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 3
I.
Duke FEnergy.
Environmental Review
"[ Good communications with NRC project manager led to successful site visits and public meetings for both plants
"* Environmental RAIs have been issued with responses due to support site-specific Supplemental Environmental Impact Statements
"* McGuire responses 1/2102
"* Catawba responses 2/13/02
"* Separate resolution timeframe agreed to for SAMA RAI responses, supporting both Duke and NRC resource needs January 8,2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project 4
F Duke OEnergy.
Hearing Process
"* The Atomic Safety and Licensing Board held a pre-hearing conference in Charlotte on December 18-19, 2001
"* Both the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League and the Nuclear Information and Resource Service along with Duke and the NRC staff participated in this conference
"* The ASLB is expected to provide additional direction to these proceedings by the end of January January8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project I
Duke Energy-Expectations m Expectations to be accomplished by next NRC/Duke Management Meeting (March timeframe)
"* Duke to prepare responses to environmental, SAMA and safety RAIs, submit to NRC by agreed upon dates
"* NRC and Duke find a way to have constructive dialogue on the staff position papers that also supports the Duke RAI response schedule
"* Work with Region II to prepare for scoping/screening inspection in March January 8, 2002 Duke Nuclear License Renewal Project
.5 6
13
Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station 1
Exelon and NRC Management Meeting James Meister Fred Polaski January 8, 2002 Purpose of Meeting
"* Update NRC management on progress of Peach Bottom LRA review.
"* Inform NRC management of any significant issues.
"* Provide performance expectations for next two months.
'2
4' 2
Peach Bottom LRA Review Schedule Milestone Target Date Actual Date Receive Peach Bottom LRA 07/02/01 07/02/01 FRN Published for LRA Receipt 08/01/01 07/25/01 FRN Published for Hearing Opportunity 08/31/01 08/31/01 Deadline for filing hearing requests 10/01/01 10/01/01 Environmental Scoping Meeting 11/07/01 11/07/01 NRC Issues Env. RAIs 12/28/01 12/20/01 Exelon Responds to Env. RAIs 02/26/02 NRC Issues Safety RAls 03/12/02 Exelon Responds to Safety RAIs 05/27/02 NRC Issues SER 02/06/03 NRC Issues Final SEIS to EPA 02/07/03 3
Completed Activities
- September 5, 2001 - NRC Issued Sufficiency Letter and Established Deadline for Filing Petition to Intervene
- September 24-25, 2001 - NRC Visit to Discuss Scoping Methodology and Electrical Issues
" October 22, 2001 -NRC Meeting to Discuss Scoping Methodology
"* October 30, 2001 - NRC RAIs on Scoping Methodology
"* November 7, 2001 - NRC Environmental Scoping Meetings
" November 8-9, 2001 - NRC Environmental Site Audit 4
3 Completed Activities (continued)
" November 16, 2001 - Exelon Transmitted Responses to RAIs on Scoping Methodology
" November 15, 2001 - NRC Scoping Methodology Document Collection Visit
" November 16, 2001 - NRC Transmitted Revised 25-month Review Schedule
" November 26, 2001 - NRC Transmitted Letter Requesting Information Related to Keeney Transmission Line and Delaware Feeder Canal
"* December 4-7, 2001 - NRC Scoping Methodology Audit
"* December 20, 2001 - NRC Issued Environmental RAIs Future Activities
- February 26, 2002 - Exelon Provides Responses to Environmental RAIs
- March 12, 2002 - NRC Issues Safety RAIs
4 Part 54 Project Performance
"* Schedule Adherence
- All dates met
"* Communications
- Good
"* Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good Part 51 Project Performance
"* Schedule Adherence
- All dates met
"* Communications
- Good
"* Interactions between NRC/National Lab reviewers and Exelon
- Good
5 Concerns
"* Emerging industry issues are challenging the stability and predictability of the license renewal process, and may impact the Peach Bottom Application
"* Perception that NRC technical staff believe that all GALL programs are required to manage aging effects 9
Summary
- Communications and interactions have been good. NRC Project Managers doing good job.
- License Renewal standardization and predictability is being challenged.
10