COMSECY-19-0006, Enclosure 4 - Draft Analysis of Indeterminate Exercise Outcomes
| ML19058A255 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/21/2019 |
| From: | Rebecca Richardson Security Performance Evaluation Branch |
| To: | |
| Keene, Todd 287-0790 | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19038A485 | List: |
| References | |
| COMSECY-19-0006 | |
| Download: ML19058A255 (1) | |
Text
Analysis of Indeterminate Exercise Outcomes Number of Year Indeterminate Summary Exercises These exercises were indeterminate due to: excessive safety or 2006 4 administrative holds; insufficient exercise control; or extreme malfunctions of exercise simulation systems.
These exercises were indeterminate due to insufficient exercise 2007 5 control and/or administrative holds.
These exercises were indeterminate because of insufficient exercise 2008 4 control and/or administrative holds.
These exercises were indeterminate because of insufficient exercise 2009 4 control or excessive administrative holds.
These exercises were indeterminate because of drill artificialities, 2010 4 insufficient exercise control, responder actions, and/or safety concerns for the exercise participants.
These exercises were indeterminate because of drill artificialities and 2011 2 exercise control issues.
These exercises were deemed indeterminate because of site 2012 2 controller training and controller performance failures.
These exercises were deemed indeterminate because of site 2013 2 controller training and controller performance failures.
This exercise was deemed indeterminate because the licensee failed to identify in their protective strategy the location of a responder that 2014 1 had been planned and practiced, resulting in the neutralization of adversaries.
These exercises were deemed indeterminate because site responders neutralized adversaries using practices unanticipated by the design of the protective strategy, site responders demonstration 2015 4 of use-of-force was inconsistent with the licensees protective strategy, exercise controllers failed to control drill artificialities, or because of anomalies with the control of the exercise and performance related to the sites protective strategy implementation.
This exercise was deemed indeterminate because of significant controller performance issues. Specifically, the licensee failed to 2016 1 properly control the exercise, which resulted in the NRC inspection teams inability to assess the licensees capability to implement its protective strategy.
2017 0 This exercise was indeterminate because of drill artificialities and 2018 1 exercise control issues.
Enclosure 4