ML20005G059
| ML20005G059 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 01/02/1990 |
| From: | Bechhoefer C Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| References | |
| CON-#190-9649, REF-QA-99990004-900102 89-582-01-SC, 89-582-1-SC, EA-87-223, LBP-89-39, NUDOCS 9001180061 | |
| Download: ML20005G059 (3) | |
Text
pp -
E-g-A _
COLKETED UNITED STATES OF AMERICA U$NRC NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ~
ATOMIC' SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD W JAN -3 All 59-Before Administrative Judges:
crrfCf DF SECilflARY DOCKEilNG A 5[i(VIC[
(
Charles Bechhoefer, Chairman BRANCH Dr. Jerry R.
Kline e
Frederick J.
Shon-SERVED JAN 031990 Docket No. 9999004 In the Matter of.
(General License WRANGLER LABORATORIES, Authority of 10 C.F.R.
LARSEN LABORATORIES, S 40.22)
ORION CHEMICAL COMPANY AND JOHN P.
LARSEN E.A.87-223 l
ASLBP No. 89-582-01-SC J
i January 2, 1990 l
ERRATA (Initial Decision)
In the Licensing Board's Initial Decision, LBP-89-39, l
dated December 22, 1989, please insert a heading at the top of page 82, reading "E.
Penalties for Violations".
In L
i addition, at page iii of-the Table of Contents, substitute page 82 for page 81 for the above item.
A corrected copy of page 82 is enclosed.
FOR THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 0
AA/
Charles Bechhoefer,ghairman ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE 1'
1 Bethesda, Maryland l
January 2, 1990 l
Q(J )4 90011eOO61 900102 C
RE04 GA999 EXIWRANG 99990004 PDR J
W,,.
' g' -
-6 w; ;<
w 8
y c-c',-
i
- 82 D
E-i k
E.
Penalties for Violations r
98.
The NRC Staff.did not categorize the' level of severityjof~any of the individual alleged violations which-lg collectively: led to the Revocation Order (Flack-Response to Board Questions, at 2-4, Question 2).
In 1982, the Staff-described the=" receipt and use" of source material beyond
[
the limits of 10.C.F.R. S 40.22 as a Severity Level III (Supplement VI): violation, the alleged " refusal" to make records of transfer of source-material available to an'NRC l
inspector as a Severity Level IV (Supplement VI) violation-j i
'd
-improper disposal of source material asa Severity Level IV (Supplement VI) violation, and the failure to keep complete records of the-receipt of source material as a Severity Level IV (Supplement VI)' violation '(Staff Exh.
1, at Exhibit 3,
pp. II-36:and II-37).
The Staff described the "most l
significant" of the 1982 violations as those involving the receipt and use of' excessive amounts of source material and the failure to make available records of source material transfer (id, at Exhibit 3,
- p. II-36).
99.
None of the proven violations as set forth herein
+
L individually meets the criteria of severity Levels I or II t
(Supplement VI).
We find that the most severe of any of the proven violations is severity Level III (Supplement VI).
i 1
1 d
)
i
MO:: 'R
['
m UN7TED STATES OF AMERICA
' NUCLEAR RESULATORY COMMISSION in the' Matteriof 1
i WRANGLER' LAB., LARBEN LAB.-. ORION 1
DocFet No. (s) 9999004 CHEMICAL COMPANY AND' JOHN P.'LARSEN I
-(General Lic. Auth, cf 101CFR 40.22.
t r
E. A.87-223)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE i
I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing ERRATA (Initial Decision) 1/2 have been servec upon the following persons by U.S. mail, first class, except.
as<otherwise noted and in accordance-with the recuirements of 10 CFR Sec. 2.712.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Administrative Judge Board' Charles Bechhoefer.Chatrean U. S. Nucl ear i<egul at or y Commission Atomic Saf ety and Licensing Board Washington, DC-20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commissten-Washington, DC 20555 Admintstrative Judge Administrative Judge Jerry R. Kline Frvderick J. Shen Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC ~20555-John P. Larsen Office of the General Counsel Orion Cnemical Company U.S. Nuclear.Reculttory Commission 652 South, 650 East Washington, DC 20555 Orem, UT 84057 Dated at Rockvillu, Md. this 3 day of January 1990 d
i i
Office of the Secretary of the Commission l
l