ML20148S657

Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Changing NRC Emergency Planning Rules.Forwards App C Documents.App B & C Documents Available in Pdr.App D Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)

ML20148S657
Person / Time
Issue date:	01/28/1988
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
To:	Weiss E HARMON & WEISS
Shared Package
ML20148S660	List: ML20148S657
References
FOIA-87-813 NUDOCS 8802030105
Download: ML20148S657 (6)

Text

. _ ._. . __- - .- .. - - - - _ _ . .-

U 8. NUCLEAR CEGULATORY COMMIS540N w so.. .tu s ww.es.si

, j, ri FOIA-87-813 f.

X, RESPONSE T FREE OM OF e '

Q .I'**'

nimsi , .:

X l "'

\, ' C/

..../l INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST cm . , m. i . . . ., .

JAN1 L ~vm

. %uti.

d Ellyn Weiss Pant 1.-atCORDS mtLE ASID Om NOT LOCAito t$ce checaed bes.si N. . ac, wwas emi io u ==i m... t , iocc.a

N ec, meu umi io e ..w e e... t a we.4

_d o . worm -

ae t e.i c. .e.ai..s e Accw. _ D on.ac, c. e.n, .,*w. ', poeme r==w w tw ene e e. Nac P.ma.: ooev-.at moom.

a svmen txt to r.%. tm oc l X i.N w.w..  ;

I a,.ec, . we $,.m.. 4.o. Ace.,.. U i ut... ... e., -.3. ...m ,, we c e==, w ca.vce e e. N4e Po.c ex.-. i X toom. nit a se t. N w . wnwue oc. . . tonov wao. me po4a a -* w e.a .it., ram  ;

4 T% aonuc.e..., ne .< e. ,,x.c., .i t c . .r.w io .x.e c . ie. ur,vuw m . .-* v m. ma . ao. e.ae -+= ... w. e.c r===

.wa corce e e. Nac Poe.c cw.,-.m m.om. un w se t. N w . w eesi. oc . . 'eue wao.< m. soia ve- W m .

a.-.  !

Incice.d . efor-atica om ho. ,0. m., etyt.e .cc to .%d r. C*.ge. fo, copvq '. cord. pi.e.d sm t*. NRC Pvtd.c Cwo-.*1 mesm on M st t. N W . W..Negica, oC a ~, ,-o.

j u,*, io r. . , e. . cw a , .ev.c.e. er,. ,, Co e r. ..a ro - .-d

.-.m ex.o... .. y e e. -,. .-- {

ex,0. u-, io u .w . . e .- .. .~r, e.~, ,w i . . . e,oi - i. ,~

! Im vv. of NRc . t com io r-e f.3 i n. fo e., .ctom e t.eg t.6.n om ersom are.e ..$.4 r

{ PAnf II A-INFCmw ATION w1TMMELD FmOM PVOLIC DiSCLOSumt c.n. c. - = c ~ . .s . o. . e.m rs.a som os.c one %.m i. e so a ...we,. 4.une.s c w v. e. ...or. mi.4 e P., m. c.

1 toe. s. c. W D A% <ca s pomore e r. ex.-. e vo, wei we, o., e e. .cas e e.m t+ e ce t.no % ...m e, w Sc c. cwt on era coe,n e '

i

! x. ~ Nec P,,e*c occ -.at moom, un w si. i N w . w eregsw oc. c . ec.a. ono., ts. soia a mw w m.c n ~.

Copen.ats i l 4 ,

I I

4 J f I  !

i j i

i I

^

I

! t i t 4

l e

I i

I 8802030105 880128 PDR FOIA WEISS87-813 PDR 4/

SC 4 i C*a 6 Cics. Drys < c nass . . gaps d4 i <

l j

4 i

Nec PCmM 444,Pr$ p

} t sul-1 i

paseDOM OF NORMATION ACT CESPONSE FOm NUMettst 07"Ol3 Daft . . , .. __

PA..T lt 8-LPPUCAttE Pita gated ATIOest N W QC7 Accords oubrect to the request that are described in the enclosed Appendeces . O pre beeng ethheld h their entrety or h pM under FOM tiemptone and fc4 the tooeons set forth below pursuant to S U.S C. f 62tbl and 10 CF M 9 648) of NRC Rogw!stons.

l. The wthheld eformaton e pope % cieeeded pv ewsm r to taecetwe Order 12364 f tXtMPTON 11 2 The enthbeid rdorraeton reia'ee tcdoty to the raemed pe tonnel twies oN procedw r es et NmC. IDtMPTCN 21 3 The Wthecid Normeten e specshcapy eneagted from pwtdat desc4ewre Dt $tatute irdcated iDtMPTCN 3)

S ten 141146 of ee Ato*=c tway Act =Nh prehete ~ decncewee of Antmted Date er Fome% Pretncted Date 642 U $ C 21412106L Swton 147 of we Atom trergy Act =N*i Pohbts tne omte se unetended svegwede ieder-eten i42 V $ C 214h.

4 The m8tNw4 WorWton e e 9000 escret er cervreroel er feenc.el rdormaten that e toeg vethPed for t*e receortel edeated IDtMPTCN 4)

The e8ermeten e tere =0e'ee to te cerA$oatael tiweeese (progretaryl information

. The ardormetaon e coresdered to be preorete*y Worgten pw%. e to to Csa 2 ?goidx11.

TM eiormten mee m.eewties ed twows e cordeence hom e fore.?n sow r ce pww.nt to 4 C8R 2 %dx2L

$ The *@hed eformaten corea's of etete&ency or et* cogency rwor@e that are not evadabae through dec4gery 4, rig btgeten. Ciecicew re wf peaceceenet rdormeNin procese Where rec 0rde tre 4e?Aend e thof e*trety, the fact are greatnf etdv vuowld tend to inhet tPe ocen estd hers escP4*9e of e$ses esse *tes to the dehte'ethe.uiv.,

- er, es ~por,some

,- et ~ o . te .ow - en

• * '

• d ' .sh

" " ~* y,osece

" * * *e*e.0,meten.T

• * * " * " ' ' " *e* e.

• *m* enereeece

' " " ' * ' ' ' *e g ge.,e.ee.e X

$ TPe methread eformeton e staattad bem pwtAc decicewre tecewee ate 6ecncow re would reew81 in a cleedly wneenereed etesen of persone! pr%ecy (DIMPTION $1

7. The m@nend informaten coreste of evoetgetory recorce corrseed %r lee ordorcementrpu posee eq e toeg ** tweed for the reeecndel coce+es (DtMPTCN h Decicewe e mow e d eter*ere me sa ordorcement pocondes tecewee e cow rev al the ecoce. enocten. ord bewe W en6ercorrerd e"orte and thwe eowed pote&y ##om IPern to tpe acten to eNeed pote%sd meer930eg er e weisten of NRC rgweemente kom eges*9ews tutWPTCN FLAH Dei.~wr e mow coret%te e Wenamed eveeen of ge sonal pe=eci tutMPTCN ficil TM rdormeoon careete e4 remse et newswM and other eeor*4 ten the escacewre et e*uce i op reveel u$oretes of corwPesatel tow rces. (DEMPTICN PsDil

(

l Pan? H C-Ot4YING Of f tC_lALS l t io to es. . 4M. t e. re e e e e, t e.,, cie  !

%,4 ree.e toore. i, ~ ~ee.e e hee.o.en ~es e~ed er u ,e,,,0.~,.o,,r.

%. ,41 n.ag~owen.er eor toi aispee, eeru ur,,est iconee wee or,~, C., es ,i,,n, e ees e,.n te,r e t~e e t-n I,e ,e.e.,e .-e.,e..

e o. -

en. ros. o se e. *~eveten. ~t se e,cesed to ~ t.xwe,e o.on.,e.esercoe.eoore

.co tde. os.em oo.

l Ot%Y L4G Of flCAAL TITLE of f <t stCOAD$ 0t% to APPILLAf t of FiCial j SKatteer 400 ,

5 John C. Hoyle Assistant Secretary App. D X i of tne comission l t

l t

l 1

?

1 PART H 0- APPtAL e60eefs The cond by each cenying oWcW identfed a Port m.C may to appeeied to the Acceae w o+f.ew *e sentfed a that section. Any such appeel rnwet be n l wnteg and must te made wthes E days of recep of the reeoonse. Agee;s must be ehessed es accroprsete to the teocutret Drector for Opersoons or to the Secteury of the Commenen. U.S. Nucieer Re that it is en ** Acceal from en kut.el FotA Dec=en.quietory Commesen. WuNewpen. DC 20666. and should creerty etete on the envWope end as t nec poses ese t'en 8 U.S. NUCit AR REGULATOaY COMMIS4404 se FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION 1

- Re: FO!A.87-813 APPENDIX _ B RECORDS MAINTAINED AMONG POR FILES NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

1. 10/21/87 Letter from Chairman Zech to Rep. Edward J. Markey, subject: "Proposed Rule on the Handling of Energency Planning Issues," Acc. No. 8711020067 i

P G

• Re: FOIA.87-813 APPENDIX C RECORDS MAlhTAINED IN THE POR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION

1. 10/22/87 Comissioner Carr's Office Telephone log (1 oage)

2. 10/29/87 Comissioner Carr's Staternent on the Emergency Planninq Rule (1 page) i i

i

}

i i

l l

1

t

! Re: F0!A.87-813 l

l .

- l l APPEN0!x 0  ;

RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD - Exemption 5 NUM8ER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION

1. 10/15/87 Memorandum to Comissioner Rogers from Myron Karman, I subject: "SECY-87-257 - Emergency Planning Rule "  !

(1 page)

(

2. 10/20/87 Chainnan Zech's Vote Sheet on CR-87-167, subject:

Letter to Rep. Markey regarding comunications related i to the Comission's Proposed Rule on the Handling of Emergency Planning Issues," (1 page) l

3. 10/20/87 Comissioner Robert's Vote Sheet, subject: Same as Absve, I (1page)  !

4. 10/20/87 Comissioner Bernthal's Vote Sheet, subject: Same as Above.

(2pages) j 5, 10/20/87 Comissioner Carr's Vote Sheet, subject: Same as Above,  !

(2pages) [

6. 10/20/87 Comissioner Roger's Vote Sheet, subject: Same as Above.

(1 page) 7, 10/21/87 Note to Comissioner Carr from George Felgate, subject: i "Emergency Package," (1 page)

8. 10/27/87 Memorandum to Comissioner Rogers from Gail Marcus, subject: "Proposed Changes to Emergency Planning Rule Package," (1 page)

9. 10/27/87 Memorandum to Comissioner Rogers from Gail Marcus, subject: Affinnation Session for Emergency Planning,"

(1 page)

10. 10/28/87 Memoranduai to Willian Parler from Comissioner Rogers, subject: "Briefing on the Emergency Planning Rule,"

(1 page) l

11. 10/29/87 Chaiman Zech's Vote Sheet on SECY-87-257 - Emergency Planning Rule," (3 pagts)

12. 10/29/87 Comissioner Robert's Vote Sheet - subject: Same as Above.

(1 page) 13, 10/29/87 Comissioner Bernthal's Vote Sheet - subject: Sane as Above.

(3pa9es) 14 10/29/87 Comissioner Carr's Vote Sheet - subject: Same as Above.

(1 page) 15g 10/29/87 Comissioner Roger's Vote Sheet - subject: Same as Above.

(4pages) l l _

~

Re: FOIA.87-813 APPENDIX D RECORDS TOTALLY WITHHELD - Exemption 5 NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION & EXEMPTION 16.

Comissioner Carr and Staff's corrents on a Draft of the Final Energency Planning Rule, (41 pages)

i HARMON & WEISS 200 5 STatt?. N w SUITE 430 WASHINOTON, D.C. noooo 112s O AIL McGetty, wanwoq TELtemONE ELLvN m *tl3S 18048330 3S00 OtANC CgemaN OtANm TCUSLtv AN0mta C. PtmSTte oa"='"

kkbr mme

' ACI REQ o n UESIt-)- f L$

D of Rules and Records b b"]"k Of fice of Administration U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cormission Washington, D.C. 20555 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST

Dear Sir / Madam,

Pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act, I hereby request copies of the following:

1. All letters, memoranda, notes of telephone conversations or any other communication to any or all of the Commissioners or their offices or assistants regarding the proposal to change the NRC emergency planning rulers (published for comment at 52 Fed.

Reg. 6980 and promulgated at 52 Fed. Reg. 4 2,0 7 8) received from Oc tobe r 1, 19 87 t o Oc t o be r 31, 193I7.

2. All letters, memoranda, notes of telephone conversations or other communications to the of fice of the Executive Director for Operations or the of fice of General Counsel regarding the proposal to change the NRC energency planning rules (published for corzent at 52 Fed. Reg. 6 9 80 a nd pr omu l g a t ed a t 5 2 F ed . J_teg. e 42,078) received form October 1,1987 to October 31,19E

3. Any and all letters, memoranda, notes of telephone con-versations or any other comnunications between NRC and FEMA regarding the interpretation and/or implementation of the NRC's new emergency planning rule (adopted at 52 Fed. Reg. 42,076) dated from September 1,1987 to the present.

Your response within ten days will be appreciated.

Very truly yours a

Ellyn R. Weiss g>'y'O}c{,@c;<f ,

.. - - _.