ML20198G220
| ML20198G220 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 08/13/1997 |
| From: | Racquel Powell NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Michael Webb SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE |
| References | |
| FOIA-97-105 NUDOCS 9708150187 | |
| Download: ML20198G220 (4) | |
Text
- -
vi..uvut AH HtuuLAivay ovMwa us wrciniuvat wem i o ,s
..,g' r /\@ 0 FOlA 10s atscoNst mt
~
RESPONSE T@ FREEDbM OF ~PE I xle^an't (3rd)
- (e.e.e INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST oa't
.p3 ) 3 g l
posu NvMet maa.n-.t L% QUt bl 4 M l Maria Webb PAHT l.-AGENCY RLCOHDS HELL ASE D OH NOT LOCA1'E D tiet ched est t.onest No erney records subject to the request have been located.
No coditional apncy anoids subject to the reavest have been located Requested tecords are available through enother public distribution program. See Comments section.
l Arncy >ecords subiest to the request that are ktentihed in Appendia(es) C ate already avadable for pubhc inspec00n and ccipying at the XX NHC Public Document Room 2120 L Street, N W., Washington. DC.
Agency rnords subint to the request that are identified in Appendiales) are being made available for pubhc inspection and copying et the NHC Pubbe Document Room 21.O L Street, N W., Washington, DC, m a folder urnier this F OI A riurnber.
The nonproprietery version of the propesalls) that you agreed to accept m a telephone conversation with a member of my statf is now being made available for pubhc inspection and topying at the NHC Pubhc Documcat Roum,2120 L Street, N.W., Washmgton, DC, in a folder under this F 01 A number, Apncy records subjnt to the request that are identihed in Appendiales) may be inspected and copied at the N RC Local Pubhc Docurnent Rcom 6dentified in the Comtnents section.
Lnclosert is intc,rmation on how you may obtain access , and the charuns for copying records located at the NRC PubHc Document Room,2120 L 6treet, XX N.W,, Washmgton, DC.
yy Arney records subject to the request are encirtsed.
Rico de subjnt to the request have been refe.re ito another Federal apncybes) for review and direct response to you.
F ees You will be billed by the NRC for im tctahng $
l l
You will receive a refund from the N'lC in the amount of $
In view of NRC's response to this request, no f urther action is being taken on appeal letter dated , No.
PART 11. A-INFORMATION WITHHf LD F HOM PUBLIC DISC?,OSUHL Carttin Informadon in the requested records is being withheld f rom publ6c disclosure pursuant to the esemptions described in and for the reasons stated to Pert it. e, C, and o. Are waeu ta,utot Ni eturnait tmewtpenneswa w iscwea s.ubenu.ans ensesw.wa4 s w punin xx so::mont< no m ena tmodwa soc an ni4teaio, s tca t amaa nw nweic et maun a tomat ancar amdo wnnmuen COMMENTS The records identilied on enclosed Appendices C and D are responsive to your request. Appendix C records are publicly available at NRC's Public Document Room (PDR) for viewing and duplicating. You may obtain copies of any of these records by contacting the PDR directly. The records identified on enclosed Appendix D are being withheld in their entirety, m\
U L DIRL I MAHON ANQ PUBUCADONS 5tHUCES N ' L ACtOH ptiONotfARtMNO L
/ .
9708150187 970813
~
B- 05 PDR lk!k!k!!b,! 4
~
t , ole -. ins, est.
l RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST FOlA 105 (CONfINUAT1*;N) l M4 $M 1 PART a 5- APPilCAstt exsMPisoNS Records subject to the request that sto deactibed in the enclosed Ag pendin{es) - 0 .
are being withheld in their entirety or in port under the Eremption No.ts) and for the toeson(s) given below pursuant to 5 U.S C. b62(b) and 10 CF R 9.1,(s) of NRC regulations.
t 1te wioiheid efoemeuan en proseny cimited pursuant to isecutive Order. (tsemption il 1,. wite.of_a_ e,.tes .o.y ,o t_,em.i ..s_e. . e e,d --wee of ~.cm. p_ ,,
l h 3, ihe withheid information se specificelly enempted from pubhc disciosure by statute Indicated. (Isempoon 31 becuens 141 145 of the Atomic treigy Act. which swohibits the daciosure of Rostf acted Dete ce Forme *ty Reitneted Date 142 US C. I16t fl66L Section 147 of the Atomic Ene<gy Act, which prohibits the discionwe of Unciens 6ed Sebeuerde entsemeson (42 U.$ C. 21871.
E the wious int met.on is e vede m,ei w comm.,c .i , onancia, infum.ie ;..i is bone ww.m Iw o. .monisi indwed. te sempoon 4:
Ihe ef menon i. cons.de,ed to os conodont..i tiusem twonnet ><vi into<manon.
The informenon es consideeed to be poguetery mfmmaten pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790tdHti The mformation was sutumtted and recetved m conhdence pursuant to 10 CFR 2 790tdH21
)( 6, The withhod mfoemeen conoste of maveuency or **eegenev tecvos that e<e e ol evadebee th*ough d scoveer dierme hbgeteon it nempton 61. Apphcable Priviley:
u 6esiberanve whee eneds ce minum Peotm Disclosure in thee of predecisioner entwetv, the fuit e e me tocebi, anformation would inte,i*med witn the tend to p.enniticme inhebit intwm theeino iste inee opene,e and t'ans eschenge no tee.onebi, of idea,s essentisi to t seregabie f aciuei A portions because the toisese of the f acts wouid permit en enaweet mousev into the predecesenal pem est of the egency Attorney won peudat t pnviiege iDocuments twepaseo by en attorne, m e oniemplanen of i+weierm i Ano,nertoen ..ae,. (Conndenosi aimmumcai.n. i.etween en eno,ne, and he,e, chenu 6 the withheld informeion is esempted hom public d.scloswee tascause ne d'eciosure would resuit m a clean, unesteented invasion of gesso *.at pnvect it semption 6) w .n, c.m.nt p_ses . d .s b., w_._.
1 p. w_e_,..me_ _s.,e of .o..de _p.d f. e.._s, _.ted . . . e ., , n , ,
,_.e _. . .on... be e. p.m.d . mte. t..e w. .n e em._. e b.c.u 6, ..u .e.e.-. s. .e_ .m f_e .,
enforcement ethuts. and thus could possibly el6ow for p.ents to take action te this6d potential wooeiptuit g or e veistion of NRC requwements from 6nvest3sters ([ nommion 7 ( AH 04closwe would conistitute en unee< rented invasion of pe sonal povecy. (I'mempuen 7(Cil the wifo# met on consists of names of md.wedua's and othet m'ormation the det Mure of whirh (ould etesonabi, tee esoet ted to seveal eden 0 bet of (onodenbat soweces. (t semptiert 7 (Dil 01nt H l PART 14 C-DENYINo OFFICIALS Pwouant to 10 Cf R 9 75thi and os 9 251c) of the U 5. Nuclear Resulatory Commma.pn tegulat ons. it het been dete' mined that the info' met +on withheld 4 esempt f*pm pro-dutbon on staciosure. emt that its product on or d sciosure es comeery to the publ*c mtvest. The r" sons <tiponuble for the deniet are those othciais identified below as denyme ott.cmis and the Director, D> vie.on of Freedom of Informeoon and Pubhcationi Services. Off.cs of Admm>sdabon for any demais that may be epocated to the isecutive Director for Op*<ebons it 00i.
'l Of NYING Of f tCIAL 18 f L L >Of FICL 141 CORDS Of NilD APPt LL A1i OS fICI AL too sec e m o Annette Vietti-Cook,' Assistant Secretary App, D/1 X Carl J. Paperiello Director. NMSS App. D/2 X Stephen G. Burns Associate General Counsel A pp . D/3 & 4 X l for Hearings, Enforcemen't l and Administration -
l _
PART N. O- APPEAL RIGHTS The denier 4 y each stenying officiel identihed in PF1 tl.C may be oppea'ed to the Appence Otocmi ident f.ed there. Any such appeal must be made in woting withm 30 deve of receipt of this response. Appuis must be odomised, as appropnate. to the I neoutive Director lov Opersbons. to the Secretary of the Commessen, or to the inspector Gene'el U 5. Nuclear Repletory Commissen, yvenhmaton. DC 20666. and should cleany state on th. envelope and m the letter that it 6s en " Appeal from en inmal FOI A Decioovi."
N".C FORM 464 (Part 2) (191) U S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMfSSION
'oWPA REX)EST SHAW PITTMAN m No; f F MS' POT 13eTIOW' RIDGE LWefWd:
~ ~. - .m on _ ,m m m, 498-f 7 - -
,, _po e /
2100 N Street. N W.
mancm oc lam.itts 202 M 18000 reWmile 202 NIE01 New hk Virginia March 12,1997 Mr. Carlton C. Kammerer, Director Freedom ofInformation & Publications Services U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mall Stop T-6E4 Washington, D.C. 20555 0001 Re Freedom ofInformation Act (FOIA) Request
Dear Mr. Kammerer:
Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Q 552 (a)(3) and 10 C.F.R. 6 9.23,I am requesting the following materials:
- (1) Any and all records which constitute, refer and/or relate to the byproduct materials license issued by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) pursuant to Section lle.(2) of the Atomic Energy Act (AEA) to Envirocare of Utah, Inc. for its Clive, Utah site.
(2) Any and all records which constitute, refer and/or relate to any allegations conceming Larry F. Anderson, former Director of the Utah Division of Radiation Control.
I agree in advance to pay the fees associated with this request.
Please contact me at 202-663-8302, if necessary.
Thank you for your prompt auention to this request. I look forward to your -
response within ten (10) days, as required by FOI A and NRC regulations.
Very truly yours, .
htuviot).L4b4 Mabia D. Webb Legal Assistant g p 1TIA M q.
e
~ .
Ret F01A-97-le5 APPENDIX C DOCUMENTS MAINTAINED AT THE PDR NUMBEM DATE DESCRIPTION /ACC. NO.
l 1.. various Printout Listing of Envirocare Documents.
4 I
e 4
4* <*
Ret FOIA-97-195 APPENDIX D DOCUMENTS BEINf WITHNELD IN THEIR ENTIRETY NUMBER DATE- DESCRIPYION/ EXEMPTION /PAGES
- 1. undated Draft letter to Fawn Sh1111nglaw from John Hoyle responding to her request for review of Director's Decision with OGC comments, (1 page) - EXEMPTION 5, PREDECISIONAL.
- 2. undated Draft letter from Hugh Thompson to Thomas Cochran on Director's Decision-on Natural Resources Defense Council's 10 CFR 2.206 Petition, (3 copies, 19 pages each) j - EXEMPTION 5, PREDECISIONAL.
- 3. 1/10/97 E-Mail from C. Renmer to S.
Chidakel on ARB on Envirocare, (1 page) - EXEMPTION.5, ATTORNEY-WORK PRODUCT, PREDECISIONAL.
- 4. 2/28/97 Note from J. Goldberg to Emile Julian on Request for Review of DD 97-02 (Envirocure), (1 page) -
EXEMPTION 5, ATTORNEY-WORK PRODUCT, PREDECISIONAL.
s E