ML20210T891

Partially Withheld Memo Re Further Discussions W/Util QA Individual on Allegations of Intimidation of QA Personnel & Lack of Communication in QA Programs.Related Info Encl

ML20210T891
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	10/18/1984
From:	Cummins J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:	Westerman T NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
Shared Package
ML20210T887	List: ML20210T884 ML20210T891 ML20210T901
References
FOIA-86-379, FOIA-86-A-117 NUDOCS 8610090270
Download: ML20210T891 (3)

Text

_ _

October 18, 1984 MEMORANDUM FOR: Thomas F. Westerman Enforcement Officer, Region IV FROM: James Cummins SRI Construction CPSES

SUBJECT:

ALLEGATION FROM TUGCO

. On October 16, 1984, I was visited in th ruction resident inspector's trailer at CPSES by M in the TUGCO startup QA organi ion. Th s individual had visited me before o'n July 7, 1984, and on August 24, 1984, and his concerns had been treated as allegations and entered into the TRT allegation tracking system and subsequently reviewed by the TRT. On this visit, the individual stated that he was concerned about the following two areas:

e Overtones of intimidation.

, e Lack of communications in QA programs at CPSES.

He elaborated on this by saying that QA concerns do not get attention of management.

The individual was asked about confidentiality and said that he would like to maintain confidentiality but if it became necessary to resolve'his concerns he would be willing to speak out.

He mentioned deficiency report 84-012 which he had written (part of TRT review) and he was not satisfied with the ~

evaluation.

He provided me with'the attached memos and he implied that they were related to intimidation in some way.

I told the individual that either myself or somebody else from the Region IV office would get back to him. In the interim, I asked him to write out his concerns to assist us in our investigation.

9

• 8610070270 861001 "

PDR FOIA GARDE 86-A-117 PDR J. E. Cummins I Att,ach J nent q, gY

• " 'a > .Sa1.,:,CP,S,Ek [,,,,,,,,,,,,,, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , )i[, , N ,,,,,

JECummins: h,bjm[/1}

I

} cox ..g g ... ................. ....... ......... ... . .................. ..................... . .............. .................... '

DATE h . .n , ...., g n ..

M *onu sia no,eoi nncu ono OF0F0@0Ss0, DGECORD COPY .____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _

.  %.. w - - . -

g/g/g/gmusammmagggtskaaggramwwwawanam.uwwwwawawwaan="""".""""?""'""""'""""~ - -

. . ... . .. , . .~ .. ~ ~ ... .. ..

~*-

~ ~

~

s . -%'g . '. . ..e 2,g.. :iSpeed Leiter. .# .M.

• ,*- , . ' , . , . .(, ', .

. q.l.~ . , q - ~.* :. . .- .y

- .. .~

. .s q._: s : .g ~ ; ~ : .- vi . .-. ;;.. .. < v ,.t~::. .

,.;, ';;- ~ -

. s ,0..:: .,2.f.L .. n..' <4>

. <4, . -g.; Mew : r w  :.; r .i

- -e '

.e v. .- .g; r +-; $ ; v; .s

. l O & Q ia$5' $7~~T'.:. m- ffg Q g 's-  ;.  :-ify- l..h % 5 M t$N$ 5$*

. eub]E ct - -- - --

. ... .a .+m .:w..., y~..p m .,.1 a :  ;;.1 a.....  :- .. ,

. . . c ..-~ . . m-

.e. : : ~.,

. . . .. . . .. --  ;.c,:..:..e -

.. =

.a - . pg. >. . .,r.e M E. S-S. A. Ee . c,.&T W:. '.<  :-)~ a' s " . ' y

, r.: w .% h c ,t ,.:. m. g.. 'g

. . D at.e ,- 'c ..-. . *.19

- . .Mf; h . . v.a .. :..-. .:.. .. . . t. . . a w- . -.

. .,,s. .

• * , .

~4r.'% .n '~~' A *.2.~ .s h. m

..)

/Ai _ x.e samanw- > w :-

QQN 1N M ,

ji M'j . ' -

i *N v p g @ g ji M M % % g g ;i k ; g e" g _ .:4

? g g a- g gU g W , f 1 y +2 gg

.,,@.:: .: ;., c:.

'e

. x..:MW, .. . N. , p*-i .i .. '.r. .)...~. We.,5.:

. . ,. 5. . . . , . ..

. . .:..:.:.W.*.

. . . . . ._a. ~

. c.. , ,2.w'-::

, , , , , . f. as.

-. *.~ . . . , ...

....[ . .. .

,k w #,<M M / 4.422 1 '

g 6 ,;s,z ; & g[ g w ~ 7_

+ -

W ~h.

Qghg g i f =? +.b " g j /

E,*: ..%  :%. >' A ",- J~

• f- l:

3

.f. . . . $. ,. . ..,pif p TAL2Vu .s 2 d(f:Wss2bsia-- . ~'

y .' .$'da '$ A.u) s

+ * ~

e. p g l g e y j pg; C p;;; Q 7. ~;R:p '~ 7:Y l

) [,

~.

.a. .:y. : - n M.L;.~~~

. ~. u.. ~..

m, . . . .,.;-X.- .a.; 'e : :. :~ * .-..

~~'.*,"*;;4.$p':.%y'%,f,M'.*

i, ;Q:ge,$;:w&g... . . . ?. '. y. Signed .: . :;};;.%,  %. :.c  : i .a -

. .. . , , - ~

d,E.R...M;.a$.W.e@heMu.

.s EN)b.kOY, 75IN,p!.'*.'y'U&%.'..*;:~~Y-%~@:.,MM.c..

.- ~ ArtL. %  :.

.O.

.s. ,, . .

5 .

n.

N,;fM%*%'*$a

?. ;.;,.m@, OWC-

.F?k%*

'Zsif..06.9 .

' # h . @ @ ? @ % . W 5 Ti G M W >.^

k 6 . M % i U. V l :l k % % . $ :M.YW

......:-.,r,..,,..,...s r..'.

- . ,  : . . . , . . . . z.

,e.s ,r;.

4. .~p. .A.

.c , v.i.. . .- ,

..... .;.~..

a,...n.;. &a- .~sy  :.'. M #q.2., gc. s%, .*. :^- %.r

. ,i..

,.~..

n%..

..- . :.. - g .  ; .

.r . 4Q,,s. . a. . . . .. . . .. .- -

.s . . -'*%

.*J '* - . . .s . ,.*

s. .4 . a.- . s '. , -

. * ..g, % .

,, f .7 .!uf .V.YG no..:,

-* ,* .* : . Q_ g gy ._

6.f$.'hh ^ : ' W' E$$ --

R{$g W_ W w..* y* e, - - -

.* . r. . .,. rs C[Le f g/. .;0 g g . 9 -

"**@g.

, . . t - M.,'*. .i j'. "E * .

g

. s y. y: . ,... . apt::,.s

.a. w .

s . . .

e n

. . . . ~ .

M Signed f Elh . i

h. 2*. ei.m.*h. I..% g N ,*.7_J,N . Q. ~ E*

s .I._. r..t. . REC _IPIENT . RET.AIN WHITE C .-

s. . .. .. "7 "'

.- w :...

.... .. .. u . .

~ . - . .. . . . . .

iy ' '

TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY OFFICE MEMORA ND UM October 12, 1984 C. Welch .

Glen Rose. Texas To

. CSTS Personnel Move It is requested that proposed move of CSTS personnel be postponed until in-progress investigation is completed. ~~_

d ' Y TJ/eg cc: T.*Vega D. N. Chapman .

O%

e 9

0

.e mo *. e e E 9 e %

F e

4 T> /2.

. L yA ,  : . .. b.- h s i5 & cm.2. , . , , ,. .y. . ,

. . ,; ,; 1