ML20245K097

Requests Utils Latest Estimate Evacuation Time for Public Disclosure.Response Requested by 890717

ML20245K097
Person / Time
Site:	South Texas
Issue date:	06/28/1989
From:	Boley K Public Citizen's Critical Mass Energy Project
To:	Dick G NRC
References
NUDOCS 8907050008
Download: ML20245K097 (6)

Text

_ _ _ - _ _

2 ,

t .,

I. .

L q L

PUBLIC CITIZEN Buyers Up D Congress Watch O Critical Mass O Health Research Group D Lftigation Gruap J

l June 28, 1989 JG). 4f f 497 George Dick gr Project Manager for South Texas U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ,

i Washington, DC 20555

Dear George Dick:

In its Nuclear Power Safety Report for 1987,-Public Citizen's Critical Mass Energy Project published Evacuation Time Estimates (ETEs) for almost every commercial reactor site in the country. The data was culled from the NRC's Public Document Room dockets and from NUREG/CR-1856, dated 1981. Most of the ETEs in the PDR were from the early '80s. We are writing you now to update that information'for the South Texas site specifically.

Public Citizen is a non-profit research and advocacy organization founded in 1971 to address a wide range of consumer and environmental issues. The Critical Mass Energy Project is the energy policy arm of Public Citizen.

Because ETEs are usually calculated by contractors for individual utilities and can utilize many different methods and include numerous evacuation scenarios, Public Citizen has chosen one standard approach for comparing ETEs. We are interested in knowing the utility's latest estimate for the amount of time it will take to fully notify and evacuate-all civilians within any segment of the 10-mile zone around South Texas on a regular weekday, during daylight hours, with fair weather.

This standardized figure is provided in Appendix M (enclosed) of our report. We would greatly appreciate your verifying the ETE and the population data (if possible) and responding to our query.

It is important that all ETEs be dated so that our readers will know when it was calculated. This is especially important with older estimates and sites that are in rapidly changing areas.

If you do not have the latest ETE for South Texas, please  !

call your contact at the site and ask for it. For documentation purposes, please provide us with the time of your call and the name of the person that gave you the ETE and its date. Finally, if possible, please ask that the contact send the cover sheet of the ETE document with the pertinent page.

8907050008 890628 PDR ADOCK 05000498 F PNV 215 Pennsylvarda Ave. SE D Washington, DC 20003 D (202) 546-4996 f

.o ., -

Thank you very much for your help in this matter. Please respond by July 17, 1989. We appreciate your cooperation in helping the public stay informed of the status of their neighboring nuclear power stations.

Sincerely,  ;

enneth Boley Nuclear Safety Analyst Critical Mass Energy Project of Public Citizen Enclosure t

. l 1

1 l

1 y i fl l

5 e

id I

.l

.i

\

Evacuation Time Estimate (ETE) Update '

For South Texas l If'the data on the enclosed Appendix M is accurate for this site, ~

l

. please so indicate and skip to number 5. Is the data in Appendix M correct? YES / NO If no:

1. Estimated time for full notification and evacuation of all civilians within any sector of the 10-mile zone surrounding the reactor site on normal weekday, daylight' hours, fair weather:

hours t

2. Date of above ETE calculation: , 19__

i

3. Name of firm (contractor) that calculated the above ETE:

4. Population within 10 miles of the site:

}

__ people in permanent population 1 people in transient population (summer tourists, etc.)

Date when this population data was current

5. Name, title, and affiliation of contact at South Texas that provided the above information:

6. Date on which the above information was provided by contact listed in number 5 above:

, 1989

7. Is contact ( __ ) or NRC representative ( .__ ) sending documentation to Public Citizen?

YES__ / UO__

8. Your name and title:

Thank you very much for your help in this endeavor. Please return this form by July 17, 1989 to:

Kenneth Boley Public Citizen 215 Pennsylvania Ave., SE Washington, DC 20003 l

U s , h YS D I , CC S TP SO l

el l ox o ,I,LA NL ,

I O

MS

, ,I Lbi otF rC ,HOLi i

b d s c a

eY O NM T

,CAn

,YWIN W i Lh a N

, niY

,s

, A V ,re EP i pi d ,Msl eve R vroo,t rd ,il ,11a ee lO s

I p a

BNECrg er ,Go,y ae ,I p eolN ,li AF EO l evoror l vewuponoH onse li n k v i ,R a ,N ,t un ,tk grB s ,leMt Etdo np ,dl ni R

N eildthf op us no ,rsbeyno sad ooaoovd i t oaLdLi r a g a e e s d ei Y n o w a ,l L egmnehn sL riatkt ak nt r e ra uehvhkil m eralhr neh ek t s - aacucl ncinbdl nrd gwanccrxl wectit awnwcerue u .hreoounol eeeoaoe asmeoieaier ath ah eisir ooh RECBDSRFARCBNRTSMC LOODRVMBWNGLOPBCNMORGFSP 15657 389837 32256 54 451 54513772 1131 334 3 6 432a49874412788217055 36l 2236 343 6414265 241421*

88305.**

45531 339336

. . .

• S.0306008 2 06430020008806980500 67480443 4 042806542043499383623 1 1 1 1 s

t e 264811519042553826797 4 2323931871 565 40736731790 4

633426413265513151 2 5 536164 a 21 5262 m N O 4840835422847579931 7553585257673581 96727850203410298201 4 22229690804 361 51541631954541 76 LI i

t AT TA 36,2125,131318,4,6,47,1,31 159471 5 0 1'

, , , 5,9,17,0,1440,30,30,0,0,4,219,88,1, 7 81984615921 56650358317781730590524 s OL TU P

34 1

343612246 1

117471 75 1141 0 1

231 3

1 877925 1 1 74 3 1

MExe YNO BEI O

P

'T N 35 34 03900695478 3211 45 1245 74 3

3 5

0 90584261 2 5634163 68132 41!1 1 524 252 i I T d m KSA NNL AAU ni RRP eT p

TO P

pn TO N

00 00 50025092900 00064577801 00 00 0

2 010335092 9 75671535 05889 36372 0606 9607

,6,0 7,5,1, 8, 4 0,0,0, 7838,8,4,15,8, 1

0, 4, Ao 7, 9, 4, 7,1,0,6, 1 1 NI ET 63

, , , , ,31 , , ,

1 891 341 68631 3 5 1 0 529 52 3321 3 01 03 i I A 124 421 5 2- 2 SL 9 2438 2 27 t NU a AP RO u TP c N 75864734 69496387 4064 8 1953170252232265801501 a YNI TO 3 5335464 516544 2151 2 5426164 565 32 4262137 v BET NA E KAL N MU ARP REO PP N

TO NI 484 5833923657579931 75 4325026567300363581031 ET 96717895726519298281 5 57658155801 73365584476 N A A L 3220,6,5,37946,7,454,0,2,36,51,2,31 20,3540,39,8,721, 1 1

, ,6 8,4,7 MU 5296701591235368 24 221 2 1815 9901 5 569745201734860058012 11 1 371 73 11 3 7 241 16241 23 573 R P 1 E O 2 1 1 P P

• 3 *

• t t

• s - * *

• n

• yn f r* n *

• n

• ei y f e o i

l o r* vey d i l

• t e o* k l P r i l k na k n e

• P e l i sn o c ur f c ki* 1 k o a e a dek C* R sa* n i oV l e eo e* - n el en rsd sVk oFc y

• eC r rh uN R a co i ePes k a nl l n*Cer at an l B nA 2t l . G

• r esecY eoel A O

T srowsw wrbo ra oe y- a at m Cnnoli rt cM eraV d

neRdnsnaewt et sl d e e i p CS adah aurl r eisi h ees C av i wnol v a n k ps i b snl mz A k agaourl l ti ooyvaear rt . .nadt pdw nndceiaCaenul t et nti o S miGl nnr osl l E

R r eirrryaaal oor ai r u a e i tt i raaoneaaiacioiocyaa ABBBBBBCCCCCCCDDDDFFF FF GGHHHI KLLLMNNMNNOOPP '

8 fF

l l

a d s m kN S Rert P *ia i hf nest e- o c Ei  : G  : oedo Yo ln eH r - neiIa1 *t u vc 1 wk - n ai en a *e 2dcesc t a aa S e3 nn a *r - oslh o t ct E 1 N kt I r l a m i ue A u e s i **n

• o as B

• c e

• l s d

• n t R l a -

is O e n 1

• T oo O a d i nu K r -

m r - l e Tc A 2 ie N E m D

• s ei t s ,3 S

,3 P P i E H O E m si 2 1 1O 0 2 1 P R a t n 49 0 0R 48 42 6 396657 91352 22 322472 UM id t

e mi ,5 ,0 ,8 ,0 EM ,4,0 ,5,45,0,1,2,1,2,5,1,1,3,8,4,5,8,7,2 ,6 ,2 ,8,6,1,0,1,1,8 L A AN s av 74 87A 09 07503696352488791 5 985449496 TE t i 08 0 2M 15 012036064031659755 0 75469004 I N n ed 10 4 0: 46 680989946921945206 8225241 27 OT o su N t a Al PP a r OE R v oE PRA a uv UMN i na LAK l dc AN a u TE B b 5 a I NY l 2t 361763 1 215 e i 521 4 336244213 OT No 1857091 86402970680 591724333 N i un n c l T PT N ei OR R am ,1 ,1 PA C re UN 3 1 1 s' PE LS 22 21 18 6 1 6 41 22' 1 1 85 AI os ,1,4 ,1,6 ,9,5 ,5 ,2 ,1 ,7 ,1 ,3 ,4 ,1,6,3 ,3 ,2 ,0 ,1,4 ,5 ,5 ,5 ,3 ,2,2 TE P wt ,1,3 ,3 ,9 I N u ei 02 49 48 741082555377000095 0720 2028 OT b rm 1 0 28 30 540020400325000003 0033 0875 N l a 98 08 90 030040400505000009 0045 0518 i Pt c l P

a .e OT D n PRR o t UAA c O LNN u St ASK m i h TI e t e I EB n er 4522644534 51211 3 3252 5 2 ONY t sw 597171 41 22361 28766 8506 4389 NT "i

R s P o e ,4 ,4 O o (J P uf 6 1 2 2 3 1 1 1 UT

.m lr 61 31 66 12 61 396653132682 331422223 11 LO yo m ,4 ,4 ,0 ,7 ,0 ,6 ,0,7,6,7,3,2,5,7,6,7,4,7,0,46,2,3,8 ,1,6 ,0 ,8,1,2,4 ,5 ,8 AT TA 1 06 27 97 71601 8418891887900 957441415 I L 9N 98 20 55 562066564456659759 078869870 O 8R 38 48 46 610929346426945205 826024635 N 1 C

)'

. s' N 4625731 2 2 5 421 4 436344113 U 258361744598996653 060087215 R

E G

/

C 2 1 R 1 5 12 523366860363256 43321 4536 1

• 1 8 06

• 38001001033420 0 537080170 5

,6 A" 11 6 25551211 695570174168300 415267950 51 4632 354 63242 L

n A

n a

l y CPBNRWBMPHBNCFNCsWHBSMMMPNL hiueiar ioaeeooehaiaaaoialoa s itr wcy aarrr wl r waal rt cl nnyr n i ct l hnt mtrwputht mtorinimt c s asiOl etil iiom it Cisnanetoha g fnrasl, ascrbPl al nv s N o

,o eti go lea nbe nb neg ire,eaou m

p wtPt OE FA f

,d o b F ,d u ,k t i i l omt N ,a re , lon oo R l r oL or r

g Pe oeol o L i,c ,h err utI l r, e PE IL,d ,n n ,s W , ,o O, c Ng n A w S ,e C ,a t ,n ,e g,e , ,s Ny OS A R WA, P PT MK G P

,s C ,e DS C I A U ASL AV A F T ECLA M O LC A T V L NC A N H AE A A TN IT OE NR

I T

7

, P.

0

m. .

I E C B

o .

3._ x J

5

,8 3

W..

NA E =

a s

h G

~

i n Y g,

PM... -

RL-t e,R

,n ,

~

I OJ A .%

C.

2 0 E S .v C

0 1

3 TS .

WU a .

s S oG re o

h . SOr i otg nNuhe g ute t chrD

__ ol i neTPc aerk rxo D aj CRse e c

.=

_ g t 2 u 0 l M 5 a a 5 t 5 o n

a " .i( --

r y

g e

r

~ 9 any,y _

i e C ga o f m o i

g. m.o m r i

s s '

_._, i o

n _

o ', i -

e -

t wlan.&

i i

sdf.#'

wh,i%**

yp n-uagp.. -

e -

n i @- -

c a u c

a swwc - w -

. I,