ML14154A061

M140603: Slides - Briefing on Results of Agency Action Review Meeting (AARM)

ML14154A061
Person / Time
Site:	Browns Ferry
Issue date:	06/03/2014
From:	NRC/OCM
To:
References
M140603
Download: ML14154A061 (62)

Text

NuclearBrowns Ferry Nuclear PlantJune 3, 2014Joe GrimesChief Nuclear Officer Discussion PointsNuclearOpening RemarksPerformance ImprovementsTransition To ExcellenceSustained ExcellenceClosing RemarksJoe GrimesKeith PoisonKeith PoisonDavid CzufinJoe Grimes lear Opening RemarksNuclearBrowns Ferry Nuclear Plant:; Has demonstrated performance improvement.0 Is in transition from performance improvement toexcellence.) Will sustain excellence through the performance ofthe site leadership team and the support of the TVAfleet.STVA is committing the necessary resources toachieve sustained excellence at Browns Ferry andacross the nuclear fleet..3 Performance ImprovementsNuclearRecent success as Browns Ferry drives toward sustainedexcellence:.; Improved Safety Culture> Closed Red Finding and Confirmatory Action Letter> Completed Successful U3R16 outage> Personal safety and human performance> Dose: 164 Rem against an original goal of < 200 Rem> Demonstrated conservative nuclear safety decision making> Achieved Improved Safety Systems Equipment Reliability4 Performance ImprovementsNuclearSAFETY SYSTEMS RELIABILITY PLAN1200-I.....IRemaining Work Orders..... 1 .. .T[iUUU IBM00i 7-Fquipmert tmprawm,-rtsInchode:DC7 Gowmor Upgrod#,sDC? Powrr Pack Upg'ad-D(I I lit, P 01/ J)ýyj rlide-HP CI Merha 11HPO 5*,VýVrl V(;ýVf' fjM', ;, 1,1CS Vota, R,,kx rmc, r,400-200-00N0NNCM)f.)0NN0NI Target Remaining Finishes Target Endy Finishes W Transition To ExcellenceNuclearIRelated ExistingPerformance DeficienciesU Analysis and Action IDevelopment Implementation* Identification, Assessment, & Correction of Performance Deficiencies (IA&CPD)** Independent Nuclear Safety Culture Assessment (INSCA)** National Fire Protection Association 805: Performance-Based Standard for Fire Protection for Light Water Reactor Electric Plants (NFPA 805) uAJ Transition To ExcellenceNuclearSIntegrated Excellence Plan developed to drive continuednuclear safety culture improvement and ensure sustainedperformance improvement.Procedure and WorkInstruction UpgradeSOperational FocusSWork Management~Equipment ReliabilitySTraining Sustained ExcellenceNuclear;Governance,Oversight, Execution, and SupportEquipment ReliabilityIndependent Oversight8 NClosing RemarksNuclear;TVA's goal is sustained excellence at all of itsnuclear stations.wTVA has demonstrated meaningful performanceimprovement at Browns Ferry.;TVA understands the issues and challenges tomaintain sustained excellence at the station.)TVA is committed to providing the resources neededto achieve sustained excellence at Browns Ferry andacross the nuclear fleet.9 List of AcronymsNuclearIACPDINSCATVAU3R16Identification, Assessment & Correction ofPerformance DeficienciesIndependent Nuclear Safety Culture AssessmentTennessee Valley AuthorityUnit 3 Refuel Outage 1610

.a yOPPD'sFort Calhoun StationDriving toSustained ExcellenceJune 3, 2014 Focus Areas" Our Commitment -Gary Gates" Plant Status -Lou Cortopassi" Engineering Products -LouCortopassi" Plan for Sustained Improvement-Tim Hanley" Closing Remarks -Gary Gates2 Our Commitment* OPPD and our Board remaincommitted to continued safeoperation of the plant and drivingto sustained excellence* Key lessons learned3 Plant Status" Safety Culture" Industrial Safety and HumanPerformance" Plant Performance4 Engineering Products* Observations, Trends andPost-Restart Actions for.-Corrective Action Products-10 CFR 50.59 Evaluations-Operability Evaluations-Design and Licensing Basiscontrol and use5 Plan for Sustained Improvement" Proven Exelon process forperformance improvement-Integration-Management Model-Fleet Resources* Continue to drive to sustainedexcellence6 Closing Remarks7 US.NRCBriefing on the Resultsof the Agency ActionReview MeetingMichael JohnsonDeputy Executive Director for Reactorand Preparedness ProgramsJune 3, 2014 Objectives* Review agency actions for materialand reactor licensees" Coordinate agency actions* Review Reactor Oversight Processself-assessment* Review industry trends2 Licensed Activities Safe andSecure" Agency actions were appropriate forlicensees with significant performanceissues" No significant adverse trends and nosignificant adjustments recommendedfor the Materials and Waste Programs" No significant adverse trends and nosignificant adjustments recommendedfor the Reactor Oversight Process3 Agenda* Materials and Waste PerformanceTrends -Laura Dudes, FSME" Industry Trends Program andReactor Oversight Process Self-Assessment -Allen Howe, NRR" Reactor Licensee Discussions-Browns Ferry -Victor McCree, RII-Fort Calhoun -Marc Dapas, RIV4 Materials Performance TrendsLaura Dudes, DirectorDivision of Materials Safety andState AgreementsFSME51 Performance Evaluation Process* Systematic review to identifysignificant:-Operational performance trends-Licensee performance issues-NRC program issues/gaps6 Performance Criteria* Strategic outcomes" Performance measures" Trending review of Nuclear MaterialEvents Database (NMED) data" Abnormal occurrences" Significant enforcement actions" Agency Action Review MeetingCriteria7 No Significant PerformanceTrends Identified1000* 415 NMEDevents* 10 AbnormalOccurrences* Event numberssmall comparedto the millionsof uses8488wew~40z6"441520002!004 2006 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013Fiscal Year1NRC AS -4TOWFigure 1. All NMED Events (5,634 total) from SECY 14-0035, "Annual Report tothe Commission on Licensee Performance in the Materials and Waste ProgramsFiscal Year 2013"8 Radiography Events Special Study9 Met Strategic Goals* Two nuclear materials licenseesmet the Agency Action ReviewMeeting discussion criteria" Materials program met safetyand security performancemetrics" No significant trending issues" No significant NRC programissues10 Reactor AssessmentsAllen Howe, Deputy DirectorDivision of Inspection andRegional SupportOffice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation11 Industry-Wide Safety PerformanceMaintained" No long-term industry trendsidentified with existing data-Ongoing review* No short-term industry performancelimits exceeded* No events exceeded limits withinBaseline Risk Index for InitiatingEvents12 Industry Trends ProgramImproves" Considering all oversightcornerstones" Using additional PerformanceIndicator information" Evaluating incorporation of newreactors performance data13 Oversight Process Is Effective* Met performance goals andachieved intended outcomes" Appropriately focused resourcesbased on performance" Impact of furlough14 Oversight Process Deviation" Action Matrix Deviation-Perry (Jan. 2013)" Plan to add flexibility to guidance* Revised guidance based on lessonslearned from 2012 deviations15 Oversight Activities* Internal and External Activities-Oversight Enhancement Project-Independent Review-Other evaluations* Incorporated safety culture commonlanguage into oversight process* Provided recommendations for risk-informing new reactors16 Future Oversight Improvements* Evaluate feedback and implementappropriate oversightimprovements* Explore improvements to theoversight self-assessment process* Continue emphasis on stakeholderinvolvement* Transition from constructionoversight to operating oversight17 Review of Browns FerryPerformanceVictor McCreeRegional Administrator, RII18 BackgroundUnit I Multiple/Repetitive DegradedCornerstone Column (Column 4), sincefourth quarter 2010-Red Finding (LPCI valve) closed-Confirmatory Action Letter (CAL)closed-Unit 1 remains in Column 4 due toadditional Action Matrix inputs19 Background (cont.)* Unit 2 Degraded CornerstoneColumn (Column 3), since fourthquarter 2012Inspection Procedure (HP) 95002Supplemental Inspection completedUnit 2 remains in Column 3 due toadditional Action Matrix inputs20 Background (cont.)* Unit 3 Regulatory Response Column(Column 2), since second quarter2012-Previous IP 95001 SupplementalInspection completed-Unit 3 remains in Column 2 due toWhite Emergency Preparedness Finding21 Current Plant Status* Unit I -At power since March 2013after degraded vacuum relatedscram" Unit 2 -At power since May 2013following refueling outage" Unit 3- At power since May 2014after a scram from a testing issue22 Browns Ferry Operated Safely" NRC conducted Baseline,Supplemental and CAL Closureinspections in 2013* NRC inspections identifiedimprovements in stationperformance" NRC inspections identified improvedunderstanding of the importance ofa strong safety culture23 Completed InspectionProcedure 95003* NRC identified no findings ofgreater-than-Green significance* CAL issued to establish basis forclosure of Red FindingShort term (Tier 1) actionsLonger term (Tier 2) actions forcontinued performanceimprovement24 Completed CAL Closure Inspection* Confirmed adequacy of TennesseeValley Authority (TVA) actions toaddress all Tier I items* No findings were identifiedP Closed Red Finding and CAL25 Substantive Cross-Cutting IssuesClosed" Closed two long standingSubstantive Cross-Cutting(SCCI) based on results ofSupplemental Inspection" Closed one SCCI based onCAL closure inspection" No new SCCIs openedIssuesIP 95003results of26 Open Confirmatory Orders* 2009 Confirmatory Order forDiscriminationTVA continues to implement actionsassociated with the ConfirmatoryOrder27 Open Confirmatory Orders (cont.)* 2014 Confirmatory Order forIOCFR50 Appendix R OperationsMinimum Staffing Level-Associated with White EmergencyPreparedness Finding-SLIII 50.9 (Inaccurate Information)-SLIII 50.90 (Improper License Change)28 Going Forward* Perform IP 95001 SupplementalInspection for EmergencyPreparedness White Finding* Perform inspections to verifyadequate implementation ofConfirmatory Order actions29 Going Forward (cont.)* Perform baseline inspections toverify adequate implementation ofTier 2 actions* Assess licensee performance forexpected Performance Indicatorchanges30 Review of Fort Calhoun StationPerformanceMarc DapasRegional Administrator, RIV31 Fort CalhounStation*Regulatory Oversight*Restart Readiness Decision*Going Forward32 Regulatory Oversight" Yellow Finding -inadequate floodprotection (Oct. 2010)-Transition to Reactor Oversight Process(ROP) Action Matrix Column 3" Shutdown for refueling outage(Apr. 2011)" Missouri River flood (May 2011)" Electrical switchgear fire (June 2011)33 Regulatory Oversight (cont.)* White Finding -reactor protectionsystem failed contactor (July 2011)* Transition to ROP Action MatrixColumn 4 (Sept. 2011)* CAL issued (Sept. 2011)-post flooding recovery actions34 Regulatory Oversight (cont.)" Transition to Inspection ManualChapter 0350 Process (Dec. 2011)* Omaha Public Power District/ExelonServices Agreement (Jan. 2012)" Commission briefing (Feb. 2012)" Red Finding for switchgear fire(Apr. 2012)35 Regulatory Oversight (cont.)* Revised CAL Issued (June 2012)-added restart checklist-contained IP 95003 key attributes* Commission briefing (June 2012)" Restart Checklist Basis Documentissued (Nov. 2012)36 Regulatory Oversight (cont.)" Commission briefing (Jan. 2013)* Revised CAL issued (Feb. 2013)-Added 3 Restart Checklist items* Commission briefing (May 2013)37 Restart Readiness Decision* Restart Checklist inspectionactivities completed (Dec. 2013)23,000 hours0 days <br />0 hours <br />0 weeks <br />0 months <br /> of NRC inspection,assessment, and licensing activities* Comprehensive corrective actionsindependently verified* CAL closed (Dec. 2013)" Post-Restart CAL issued (Dec. 2013)38 Going Forward* Conduct baseline and area-specificinspections-Safety CultureCorrective Action Program-Evaluation of degraded/non-conforming conditions39 Going Forward (cont.)* Continue routine public meetingsto provide for open andtransparent oversight process* Performance assessment fortransition to normal level ofregulatory oversight'40 References* SECY-14-0035, "Annual Report to the Commission onLicensee Performance in the Materials and WastePrograms Fiscal Year 2013"http://www.nrc.gov/readinq-rm/doc-collections/commission/secys/2014/2014-0035scy.pdf* SECY-14-0042, "Fiscal Year 2013 Results of theIndustry Trends Program for Operating PowerReactors"http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/commission/secys/2014/2014-0042scy.pdf* SECY-14-0047, "Reactor Oversight Process Self-Assessment for Calendar Year 2013"http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/commission/secys/2014/20144-0047scy.pdf41 List of Acronyms* CAL -Confirmatory Action Letter* FSME -Office of Federal and StateMaterials and EnvironmentalManagement Programs* IP -Inspection Procedure* LPCI -Low Pressure Core Injection" NMED -Nuclear Material EventsDatabase* NRC -U.S. Nuclear RegulatoryCommission42 List of Acronyms (cont.)" RII -Regional Office II* RIV- Regional Office IV" ROP -Reactor Oversight Process" SCCI -Substantive Cross-CuttingIssue* SECY- Office of the Secretary" SL -Severity Level43 OPTIONAL BACKGROUNDSLIDE44 Watts Bar 2 Milestones* Advisory Committee on ReactorSafeguards Meeting (Aug./Sept. 2014)* Commission Meeting (Oct. 2014* Commission Vote Paper -Issuance ofOperating License (Nov. 2015)* Final Readiness Letter and decision onFull Power License (Feb. 2015)* Commercial Operation (Dec. 2015)45