|
|
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| {{Adams
| | #REDIRECT [[05000346/LER-1979-106-01, /01T-0:on 791112,design of 11 Seismic Hangers Not as Conservative as Required.Caused by Design Error.Hangers Modified Before Unit Returned to Operation]] |
| | number = ML19331B716
| |
| | issue date = 11/23/1979
| |
| | title = /01T-1:on 791112,while Performing Calculations for IE Bulletin 79-02,11 Seismic Hangers Found Not as Conservative as Required by Design Criteria.Caused by Design Errors by Itt Grinnell in Initial Calculations
| |
| | author name = Batch S, Dieterich K
| |
| | author affiliation = TOLEDO EDISON CO.
| |
| | addressee name =
| |
| | addressee affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
| |
| | docket = 05000346
| |
| | license number =
| |
| | contact person =
| |
| | document report number = IEB-79-02, IEB-79-2, LER-79-106-01T, LER-79-106-1T, NUDOCS 8008120655
| |
| | package number = ML19331B712
| |
| | document type = LICENSEE EVENT REPORT (SEE ALSO AO RO), TEXT-SAFETY REPORT
| |
| | page count = 1
| |
| }}
| |
| {{LER
| |
| | Title = /01T-1:on 791112,while Performing Calculations for IE Bulletin 79-02,11 Seismic Hangers Found Not as Conservative as Required by Design Criteria.Caused by Design Errors by Itt Grinnell in Initial Calculations
| |
| | Plant =
| |
| | Reporting criterion =
| |
| | Power level =
| |
| | Mode =
| |
| | Docket = 05000346
| |
| | LER year = 1979
| |
| | LER number = 106
| |
| | LER revision = 1
| |
| | Event date =
| |
| | Report date =
| |
| | ENS =
| |
| | abstract =
| |
| }}
| |
| | |
| =text=
| |
| {{#Wiki_filter:,
| |
| U.S. NUCLE AR REGULATCRY COMMISSION 60 FORM 36G m
| |
| LICENSEE EVENT REPORT c,
| |
| O, CONTROL BLOCK: l l
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| lh (PLE ASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED INFORMATl?N) 1 6
| |
| { l 0 l 11 l D l B l S l 1 l@l 0 l 0 l - l 0 l 0 l N l P l F l-l 0 l 3 l@l 4 l1 l 1l 1l 1l@l l
| |
| l@
| |
| 8 9 LICENSEE CODE 14 15 LICENSE NUMUEH 26 26 LICENSE TYPE Jo 57 CAT b6 0 rT d
| |
| [n] l L l@l 015 l 0 l - l 0 l 3 l 4 l 6 @l 1 l 1 l 1 12 l 7 l 9 l@l1 11 l 2 l 3 I 719 l@
| |
| 8 60 68 DOCKET NUVSER 68 tn EVENT OATE 74 75 REPORT DATE 80 EVENT OESCRIPTION AND PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES h
| |
| @ l While perfohiing calculations for I. E. Bulletin 79-02. ITT Grinnell personnel dis-I l
| |
| I
| |
| ( g l covered the design of 11 seismic hangers was not as conservative as was required On July 25 further I
| |
| ] l by the design criteria and assumptions used by ITT Grinnell.
| |
| l i
| |
| @ l analysis of base plate ficxibility found that the anchor bolts for pipe supports
| |
| (
| |
| i
| |
| @ l 41-118C-36-113, 33A-CCB-8-III,11-17, SR-31, SR-32, at',d SR-39, and for the common 1
| |
| l
| |
| @ l support structure for anchors A-55, A-61 A-79_, A-80, and A-83 had a factor of I@ l safety of less than 2. This finding is reportable under T.S. 6.9.1.8.i.
| |
| (NP-32-79-13 1
| |
| E CODE SUBCO E COMPONENT CODE SUSCOO"E SU E
| |
| l X lX l@ y@ l A lh l Sl Ul Pl Ol Rl Tlh Wh W h 8
| |
| 9 10 11 12 13 18 19 20 SEQUENTI AL OCCURRENCE REPORT REVISION LER EVENTYEAR REPORT NO.
| |
| CODE TYPE N O.
| |
| @ arg/RO l7 l9 l
| |
| [--l l 1l Ol 6l l/l Idl1l [T_]
| |
| [--]
| |
| (_1_}
| |
| RT 1
| |
| _ 21 22 23 24 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 KEN AC T O ON PL ANT 1E HOURS SB IT D FOf th 8.
| |
| 5 PPLIER MANUF ACTUR E R (f._l h d h (35_C_.jh (_Zjh l1 dl 6l Rl 4l lY,._,}h
| |
| ( H_}h
| |
| (_Ajh l T l ? l 6 l 7 lh 33 34 36 3
| |
| 40 43 42 43 44 47 CAUSE DESCRIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS h hy TTT r rf nnn11 in thn infrin1 en1cn1neinnel HIOll The occurronco unn e n n e.o d by donfon nrrnre l@ l of the stresses and deficctions in these hanners. The affncend hangers 4ere modifi., b e
| |
| lg;7; l prior to the unit returning to operation. The items reported July, 1980, were the re-l 1
| |
| \\
| |
| They will be modified i
| |
| g l sults of a change in the classification of rigid base plates.
| |
| 1g l prior to startup from this refueling outage and Attachment I will be updated when thatl 80 8 t work is complete.
| |
| f
| |
| 'YdiUS sPowEn oTHER STATUS D hlNhhRY DISCOVERY DESCRIPTION S
| |
| NA l
| |
| l D lhl During analysis of I.E. Bulletin 79-02 l
| |
| ({sj Wh l 0l 0l 0lhl ACTIV11Y CONTENT LELE ASED OF RELE ASE AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY LOCATION OF RELEASE l
| |
| NA l
| |
| l NA 3 j_Z_]@ W @l 8 9 to it 44 45 80 PERSONNEL EXPOSUHES NUM8 E R TYPE
| |
| | |
| ==DESCRIPTION==
| |
| l 0910 l 01 01@l.z_J@l NA IES PERSONNE L INJU otSCniPfiONh NuMsER l
| |
| LLtl lo lo 101@l NA 80 8 9 11 12 LOSS OF OR DAVACE TO FACILITY TYLE
| |
| | |
| ==DESCRIPTION==
| |
| l I19l U hl NA 80 8 9 10 NRC USE ONLY Q
| |
| rust:CiTv
| |
| *SCOTl206s5 i i i iiiiiiiiii ii Z
| |
| h NA 68 69 80 S a g to 419-7 59-5000. rve. ?vs/793 Stan Batch / Ken Dictorich PHONE:
| |
| N AME OF Pn[PAnr.n
| |
| | |
| TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY DAVIS-BESSE NUCLEAR POWER STATION UNIT ONE SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FOR LER NP-32-79-13 DATE OF EVENT: November 12, 1979 FACILITY: Davis-Besse Unit 1 IDENTIFICATION OF OCCURRENCE:
| |
| Design of eleven seismic supports was not as conserva-tive as required.
| |
| l Conditions Prior to Occurrence:
| |
| The unit was in Mode 5, with Power (MWT) = 0, and Load (Gross MWE) = 0.
| |
| Description of Occurrence: While performing calculations for IE Bulletin 79-02, ITT Grinnell personnel discovered the design of eleven seismic hangers was not as conder-i vative as was required by the design criteria used by ITT Grinnell.
| |
| Four of the hangers did not meet the NRC. criteria for pipe support operability. On five other supports, the slenderness ratio exceeded the design criteria of 200 used by ITT Grinnell. The remaining two supports were analyzed to have a maximum deflection of approximately.5 inches which could result in stresses on the piping in excess of the design criteria of ITT Grinnell. These analyses were performed assuming the worst case design base earthquake loading.
| |
| On July 25, 1980, while performing the base plate flexibility analysis, pipe supports 1
| |
| 41-HBC-36-H3 on service water, 33A-GCB-8-H1 on decay heat, and H-17, SR-31, SR-32, and SR-39 on main feedwater were analyzed. The results showed that the anchor bolts had a factor of safety less than two.
| |
| Also the common support structure (i.e., one support for five anchors) for anchors A-55 high pressure injection, A-61 low pressure injection, A-79, A-80, and A-83 i I containment spray was analyzed for base plate flexibility. The results showed that the anchor bolts had a factor of safety less than two.
| |
| Further information on the affected hangers is contained on Attachment 1.
| |
| Since more than one part of a redundant system was affected, this incident is being reported in cecordance with Technical Specification 6.9.1.8.1.
| |
| These design deficiencies were discovered while the unit was in cold shutdown during a unit outage.
| |
| i Designation of Apparent Cause of Occurrence:
| |
| The cause of this occurrence was design errors by ITT Grinnell in the initial calculations of the stresses and deflections in these hangers. These design errors were discovered while calculating base plate forces cad moments for the analysis required by IE Bulletin 79-02.
| |
| The errors in the original design were random and not due to a general deficiency in the original design method.
| |
| Items reported July 25, 1980,- were the result of a change in the design criteria as to what constitutes a rigid base plate. The base plates for these supports were 1
| |
| originally analyzed as rigid base plates and under the new criteria are now considered flexible.
| |
| LER #79-106 n,
| |
| .,,n
| |
| -----v-.,.
| |
| ,r w
| |
| a--,
| |
| ,m,,,-
| |
| n-pe e-,
| |
| --,--g=
| |
| wem mm
| |
| | |
| TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY DAVIS-BESSE NUCLEAR POWER STATION UNIT ONE PAGE 2 SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION FOR LER NP-32-79-13 Analysis of Occurrence:
| |
| There was no danger to the health and safety of the public cr to station personnel. These supports are not required for normal system performance but are required only to protect the systems from a worst case condition of maximum carthquake loading.
| |
| The affected systems have been re-analyzed taking into account the non-conservative cupport designs.
| |
| These analyses show that all affected safety systems would have performed their safety function if a design basis accident had occurred.
| |
| | |
| ==Corrective Action==
| |
| All affected hanger modifications were completed by 1200 hours en November 15, 1979, prior to the unit returning to operation.
| |
| Details on the work performed, the applicable facility change request (identical to work order number), and the location of hanger is contained in Attachment 1.
| |
| l t
| |
| The design of all Q-listed supports attached to concrete on 2 " and larger piping l;
| |
| (over 1000 supports) have been reviewed during work performed while responding to j
| |
| IE Bulletin 79-02.
| |
| Supports on piping smaller than 2b" were not designed by ITT
| |
| ~
| |
| Crinnell.
| |
| The following items reported July 25, 1980, will be modified by the following FCRs:
| |
| 41-HBC-3 6-1123 by FCR 80-093 supplement 14 33A-GCB-8-111 by FCR 80-088 supplement 12 1
| |
| SR-32 & SR39 by FCR 80-125 supplement 2 H-17 & SR31 by FCR 80-125 supplement 3 A-55, A-61, A-79, by FCR 80-089 supplement 9 A-80, A-83 These discrepancies will be corrected prior to startup from the current refueling outage. Attachment I will be updated when that work is complete.
| |
| Failure Data:
| |
| There has been one previously reported similar occurrence, see Licensee Event Report NP-32-79-08.
| |
| LER #79-106 m m
| |
| | |
| ATTACHMENT 1 LICENSEE EVENT REPORT NP-32-79-13 FCR/W.O.
| |
| HANGER NO.
| |
| LOCATION CONTROLLING ITEM WORK PERFORMED 79-379 41-HBC44-HS Service Water Supply to Emer-SF < 2 1/4" x 5" cover bar welded to gency Core Cooling Room. Cooler channel 1-3 79-380 33A-HCB2-H44 Borated Water Storage Tank SF < 2 3" x 3" x 3/8" angle iron added Supply to E=crgency Core Cooling System 1 79-331 34-CCBS-H17 Containment Spray Pump 1-1 Deflection ~.5" Mded 2-1/2" pipe and 3/4" x.
| |
| discharge x 7" Cusset plates 79-381 34-HCC38-H19 Containment Spray Pump 1-1 Deflection ~.5" Added 2-1/2" pipe and 3/4" x 5" Recirculation Test Line x 7" Gusset plates 79-387 34-EBD19-H79 Main Steam (upstream of Slenderness ratio > 200 1/2" x 4-1/2" stiffener bar MS-107A) added to I-beam, replaced kickers with W4 x 13 I-beam 79-388 6C-EBD14-H43 Auxiliary Feed Pump 1-2 Slenderness ratio > 200 Replaced kicker with 4" x 4" x Discharge 3/8" structural tubing 79-389 31-CCB21-H22 Letdown Delay Coil SF < 2 1/2" x 5" cover bar added 79-390 33A-GCB4-H5 High Pressure Injection Slenderness ratio > 200 3/8" x 3-1/2" bar added to 1-2 Suction flanges 79-391 34-6CB S-il2 Containment Spray Pump 1-2 Slenderness ratio > 200 3/8" x 4-1/2" stiffener plate Discharge added to kicker 3/8" x 4-1/2" stiffener plate 79-392 36-HBC39-H8 Component Cooling Water Slenderness ratio y 200 Supply to Letdown Coolers added to kicker 79-393 41-HBC36-H26 Service Water Outlet of SF < 2 1/4" x 2-3/4" stiffener plate Component Cooling Water added, W6 x 15 beam added Heat Exchanger 1-3 LER #79-106
| |
| }}
| |
| | |
| {{LER-Nav}}
| |