ML19320A337: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older edit
VisualWikitext
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:- - - - -        _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
{{#Wiki_filter:''5
          ''5       .
(
                        .        (                                         (                                                               l DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY 8805010 83 3                                                          !
(
LITTLE ROCK DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS POST OFFICE BOA es?
8805010 83 3 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LITTLE ROCK DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS POST OFFICE BOA es?
LITTLE ROCK. ARKANSAS 72203 R EPLY .'O ATTENTION OF                                                                                                               l l
LITTLE ROCK. ARKANSAS 72203 R EPLY.'O ATTENTION OF SWLED-PP 24 November 1972 i
SWLED-PP                                                         24 November 1972                                                       l i
Mr. D. R. Muller Asst. Director for Environmental Pro,1ects Atomic Energy Comission Washington, D. C.
Mr. D. R. Muller Asst. Director for Environmental Pro,1ects Atomic Energy Comission Washington, D. C. 20545
20545


==Dear Mr. Muller:==
==Dear Mr. Muller:==
In compliance with your request contained in letter dated 25 October 1972 (Your Docket No. 50-313), my comments on the Draft Environmental Statement for Arkansas Power and Light Company Ihclear One Unit 1 are inclosed.
In compliance with your request contained in letter dated 25 October 1972 (Your Docket No. 50-313), my comments on the Draft Environmental Statement for Arkansas Power and Light Company Ihclear One Unit 1 are inclosed.
                                                                                    )'
)
Sincerely, T
Sincerely, T
                                                                '' / 9
/ l
                                                      / l A,/N 1 Inc1 (dupe)
'' /
                                                  /Colonel, Corps of Engineers WE Comments District Engineer THIS DOCUMENT CONTA"!S                 Spo D
/
PAGES jfz3 '-
A,/N 9
POOR QUAUTY f?         9
1 Inc1 (dupe)
                                                                            ?V
WE Colonel, Corps of Engineers Comments District Engineer Spo THIS DOCUMENT CONTA"!S POOR QUAUTY PAGES jfz3 '-
                                                                                    ~
D f?
                                                                                          ?               $
9 sd:'l
?V
~
?
J. ' ;.
J. ' ;.
sd:'l v tP ,                     2 s
v tP,
D' MDS                               }
s 2
D'
}
MDS
(
(


              - w-e
- w-(
                                  '                                (
e LITTLEROCKDISTR[CT,CORPSOFENGINEERS COMMENTS CN THE DRAFT ENVIROIEENTAL STATEMENT FOR ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE UNIT 1 1.
LITTLEROCKDISTR[CT,CORPSOFENGINEERS COMMENTS CN THE DRAFT ENVIROIEENTAL STATEMENT FOR ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE UNIT 1         .
Footnotes should be used to show source of data or statements.
: 1. Footnotes should be used to show source of data or statements.
2.
: 2. Page 2-1, paracrauh P.1 - Site Iocation. The term " Arkansas River Shipping Channel" should be changed to " Arkansas River Navigation Channel."
Page 2-1, paracrauh P.1 - Site Iocation. The term " Arkansas River Shipping Channel" should be changed to " Arkansas River Navigation Channel."
3     Page 2-21, paracraph 2.5 - Hydrology,
3 Page 2-21, paracraph 2.5 - Hydrology, The operation of the powerplant at Dardanelle Dam is subject a.
: a. The operation of the powerplant at Dardanelle Dam is subject to change as required to meet future power demands and other water resources needs. Therefore,-the periods of thne when the generators are not in operation is subject to unpredictable variations.
to change as required to meet future power demands and other water resources needs. Therefore,-the periods of thne when the generators are not in operation is subject to unpredictable variations.
: b. The paragraphs on the effects of large floods contains the term " lake level" which is misleading. During floods of the magnitude described, conditions would be the same as a river in flood and there would be no lake. The elevations shown for the " lake level" should be described as the water surface elevation at the dam.
b.
: c. In regard to possible failure of Ozark Dam during a mwinn probable flood, there would be no impoundments for this condition and no increased flood height if such a failure occurred.
The paragraphs on the effects of large floods contains the term " lake level" which is misleading. During floods of the magnitude described, conditions would be the same as a river in flood and there would be no lake. The elevations shown for the " lake level" should be described as the water surface elevation at the dam.
: 4. Page 3-9 paragraph 3.3.3 - Unit-2 Heat-dissipation System. The statement that make-up water will be about 30 c.f.s. is not consistent with other parts of the report, notably page 8-11 which states that the water loss is 26 c.f.s. and page E-9 which states that the consumptive loss of water is 23,564 acre-feet annually (32 c.f.s.). The agreement with the Corps of Engineers is for payment of consumptive losses of 22 c.f.s. for Unit 1 and 14 c.f.s. for Unit 2.
c.
5     Page 3-11, paragraph 3.3.6 - Hydrologic Characteristics of Lake Dardanelle.
In regard to possible failure of Ozark Dam during a mwinn probable flood, there would be no impoundments for this condition and no increased flood height if such a failure occurred.
: a. The second sentence in regard to weekly flows should be changed to clarify the phase " considered on a monthly basis."                         *
4.
: b. The tabulation is based on partial records of the U.S. Geclogical Survey. It should be based on all these records or an explanation given for use of partial records.
Page 3-9 paragraph 3.3.3 - Unit-2 Heat-dissipation System. The statement that make-up water will be about 30 c.f.s. is not consistent with other parts of the report, notably page 8-11 which states that the water loss is 26 c.f.s. and page E-9 which states that the consumptive loss of water is 23,564 acre-feet annually (32 c.f.s.).
: 6. Page 8-12, paranrath 8.4 - Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources. The statement that the applicant will pay the Corps of Engineers $8,500 annaa11y is incorrect. The actual annual payment is
The agreement with the Corps of Engineers is for payment of consumptive losses of 22 c.f.s. for Unit 1 and 14 c.f.s. for Unit 2.
          $3,300 for Unit 1 and $7,300 for Unit 2, a total of $10,600.
5 Page 3-11, paragraph 3.3.6 - Hydrologic Characteristics of Lake Dardanelle.
a.
The second sentence in regard to weekly flows should be changed to clarify the phase " considered on a monthly basis."
b.
The tabulation is based on partial records of the U.S. Geclogical Survey. It should be based on all these records or an explanation given for use of partial records.
6.
Page 8-12, paranrath 8.4 - Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources. The statement that the applicant will pay the Corps of Engineers $8,500 annaa11y is incorrect. The actual annual payment is
$3,300 for Unit 1 and $7,300 for Unit 2, a total of $10,600.
(
(


                                              .            (
(
AEC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 50 DOCXE" MATERIAL
(
(                                        l CONTROL NO:     6498 (TEMPORARY FORM)
l AEC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 50 DOCXE" MATERIAL (TEMPORARY FORM)
                    ~
CONTROL NO:
ENVIRO            l DA, Little Rock District             DATE OF DOC:                     DATE REC'D       LTR   EMO       RP2   MHER FROM:
6498 l
Littis Rock, Ark.                   72203                                                                                         '
ENVIRO
Donald G. Wainert 11-24-72                       11-27-72         I TO:                                                         ORIO               CC                             SENT AEC PD3         af     I l WHER                SENT LOCAL PDR       af     I
~
        -    u ,. _ nn u, m ,.                         ~1 signed                        1                                                      (
FROM:
CIASS:           , @ 0P INFO                           INPUT                   NO CYS REC'D               , DOCIET NO:
DA, Little Rock District DATE OF DOC:
2                             50-313 DESCRIP2 ION: Ltr trans the following:                                           ENCLOSURES:         Little Rock District, Corps of ]
DATE REC'D LTR EMO RP2 MHER Littis Rock, Ark.
72203 Donald G. Wainert 11-24-72 11-27-72 I
TO:
ORIO CC l WHER SENT AEC PD3 af I
SENT LOCAL PDR af I
~1 signed 1
(
u,. _ nn u, m,.
CIASS:
, @ 0P INFO INPUT NO CYS REC'D
, DOCIET NO:
2 50-313 DESCRIP2 ION: Ltr trans the following:
ENCLOSURES:
Little Rock District, Corps of ]
Engineers Comments on the Draf t 2nviro Stat.
Engineers Comments on the Draf t 2nviro Stat.
ment for Ark. One Unit         I....
ment for Ark. One Unit I....
l ACK10REDOED.
l ACK10REDOED.
l PLANT NAMES: Ark. One Unit I
PLANT NAMES: Ark. One Unit I l
                          -                                      FOR ACTION /INFORMATION                         DL 11-28-72                             I BUILER(L)                       %CHWENCER(L)                   SCHEMEL(L)                         KNIGIEON(E)
FOR ACTION /INFORMATION DL 11-28-72 I
W/ Copics                          W/Iopies C                      W/ Copies                         y/ Copies CLARK (L)                           STOLZ(L)                     ZIEMANN(L)                       FIOUNGBIDOD(E)
BUILER(L)
W/ Copies                           W/ Copies                   W/ Copies                         W/4 Copies GOLLER(L)                           VASSALID(L)'                 CHITWOOD(FM)                       REGAN(E)         ,
%CHWENCER(L)
W/ Copies                           W/ Copies                   W/ Copics                           W/ Copies                             ;
SCHEMEL(L)
* KNIEL(L)                             H. DEIRON                 . DICKER (E)                                                                 ]
KNIGIEON(E)
W/ Copics                           W/ Copies                   W/ Copies                           W/ Copies IIEERNAL DISTRIBUTION                                                           l CWREG FII D                             TECH REVIEW         VOLIRER                         MS                   WADE             E spra:A, run                           HEHDRIE             DENTON                                                 SHAFER         F&M pGC, ROOM P-506A                     SCHROEDI:R           GRIMES                             F&M                 BROWN           E MACCARY             GAM ELL                           SMILEY             46. WILLIAME E RUNIZING/ STAFF CASE               ,                  LANGE(2)           KASTNER                           NUSSBAUMER         W. GOULBOURNE L GIAMBUSSO                             PAWLICKI           BALLARD                                                 A/TIND SHAO               SPANGLER                           LIC ASST.           BRAITFAN BOYD-L(BWR) dEYOUNG-L(PWR)                         KNUTH                                               ' SERVICE L           SALTZMAN SKOVE0LT-L                           STELIO             ENVIRO                             MASON       L P. COLLINS MOORE               MULLER                             WILSON     L       PLANS HOUSTON             DICKER                             MAIGRET L           MCDONALD
W/Iopies W/ Copies y/ Copies W/ Copics C
                                                  - TEDESCO             KNIGIHON                           SMITH     L       DUEE BEG OPR F/ILE & REGION (2)                     IONG               'iOUNGBLOOD                         GEARIN     L                                 ,
CLARK (L)
MORRIS PROJ ILtDER                       DIGGS     L       INFO                     l JAINAS STELLE                           afBENAROYA                                               TEETS     L         C. MILES ~               l l LEE       L REGAN EXTERNAL DISTRIBUPION d-IOCAL PDR __Dardanelle, Ad.                         _
STOLZ(L)
1-DTIE(ABERNATIE)                               $1)             -NATIONAL LAB'S ORNL                       1-PDR-SAN /LA/NY 1-GERALD LELIDUCHE 1-NSIC(BUCHANAN)                                               -R.             CARROLL-0C   3 GT-B27[
ZIEMANN(L)
            , 1 ASLB_,YORE /SA M                                               bd.-R. CATLIN, E-256*-GT                         BROOKHAVEN NAT. LAB 1-CONSULANT'S                               1-AGMED(WALTER KOESTER, .
FIOUNGBIDOD(E)
WODWARD[H. ST.                                                                                                Em C 427, GT) 16-CYS ACBS HOLDING                                                 NEWMARK/BLUME/AGABIAN 1-RD. . . MULU3, . .F-309GT}}
W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies W/4 Copies GOLLER(L)
VASSALID(L)'
CHITWOOD(FM)
REGAN(E)
W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copics W/ Copies
* KNIEL(L)
H. DEIRON
. DICKER (E)
]
W/ Copics W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies IIEERNAL DISTRIBUTION l
CWREG FII D TECH REVIEW VOLIRER MS WADE E
spra:A, run HEHDRIE DENTON SHAFER F&M pGC, ROOM P-506A SCHROEDI:R GRIMES F&M BROWN E
RUNIZING/ STAFF MACCARY GAM ELL SMILEY
: 46. WILLIAME E CASE LANGE(2)
KASTNER NUSSBAUMER W. GOULBOURNE L GIAMBUSSO PAWLICKI BALLARD A/TIND BOYD-L(BWR)
SHAO SPANGLER LIC ASST.
BRAITFAN dEYOUNG-L(PWR)
KNUTH
' SERVICE L SALTZMAN SKOVE0LT-L STELIO ENVIRO MASON L
P. COLLINS MOORE MULLER WILSON L
PLANS HOUSTON DICKER MAIGRET L MCDONALD BEG OPR
- TEDESCO KNIGIHON SMITH L
DUEE F/ILE & REGION (2)
IONG
'iOUNGBLOOD GEARIN L
MORRIS JAINAS PROJ ILtDER DIGGS L
INFO l
STELLE afBENAROYA TEETS L
C. MILES ~
l l LEE L
REGAN EXTERNAL DISTRIBUPION d-IOCAL PDR __Dardanelle, Ad.
1-DTIE(ABERNATIE)
$1)
-NATIONAL LAB'S ORNL 1-PDR-SAN /LA/NY 1-NSIC(BUCHANAN)
-R. CARROLL-0C GT-B27[
1-GERALD LELIDUCHE 3
, 1 ASLB_, ORE /SA M bd.-R. CATLIN, E-256*-GT BROOKHAVEN NAT. LAB Y
WODWARD[H. ST.
1-CONSULANT'S 1-AGMED(WALTER KOESTER,.
16-CYS ACBS HOLDING NEWMARK/BLUME/AGABIAN Em C 427, GT) 1-RD... MULU3,..F-309GT}}

Latest revision as of 19:55, 1 January 2025

Responds to AEC 721025 Request.Forwards Army Corps of Engineers Comments on Des.Lists Inconsistencies & Misstatements & Inadequacies Re Hydrology,Heat Dissipation Sys & Resource Commitments
ML19320A337
Person / Time
Site: Arkansas Nuclear 
Issue date: 11/24/1972
From: Weinert D
ARMY, DEPT. OF, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
To: Muller D
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 8005010833
Download: ML19320A337 (3)
v • d • e


Text

5

(

(

8805010 83 3 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LITTLE ROCK DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS POST OFFICE BOA es?

LITTLE ROCK. ARKANSAS 72203 R EPLY.'O ATTENTION OF SWLED-PP 24 November 1972 i

Mr. D. R. Muller Asst. Director for Environmental Pro,1ects Atomic Energy Comission Washington, D. C.

20545

Dear Mr. Muller:

In compliance with your request contained in letter dated 25 October 1972 (Your Docket No. 50-313), my comments on the Draft Environmental Statement for Arkansas Power and Light Company Ihclear One Unit 1 are inclosed.

)

Sincerely, T

/ l

/

/

A,/N 9

1 Inc1 (dupe)

WE Colonel, Corps of Engineers Comments District Engineer Spo THIS DOCUMENT CONTA"!S POOR QUAUTY PAGES jfz3 '-

D f?

9 sd:'l

?V

~

?

J. ' ;.

v tP,

s 2

D'

}

MDS

(

- w-(

e LITTLEROCKDISTR[CT,CORPSOFENGINEERS COMMENTS CN THE DRAFT ENVIROIEENTAL STATEMENT FOR ARKANSAS NUCLEAR ONE UNIT 1 1.

Footnotes should be used to show source of data or statements.

2.

Page 2-1, paracrauh P.1 - Site Iocation. The term " Arkansas River Shipping Channel" should be changed to " Arkansas River Navigation Channel."

3 Page 2-21, paracraph 2.5 - Hydrology, The operation of the powerplant at Dardanelle Dam is subject a.

to change as required to meet future power demands and other water resources needs. Therefore,-the periods of thne when the generators are not in operation is subject to unpredictable variations.

b.

The paragraphs on the effects of large floods contains the term " lake level" which is misleading. During floods of the magnitude described, conditions would be the same as a river in flood and there would be no lake. The elevations shown for the " lake level" should be described as the water surface elevation at the dam.

c.

In regard to possible failure of Ozark Dam during a mwinn probable flood, there would be no impoundments for this condition and no increased flood height if such a failure occurred.

4.

Page 3-9 paragraph 3.3.3 - Unit-2 Heat-dissipation System. The statement that make-up water will be about 30 c.f.s. is not consistent with other parts of the report, notably page 8-11 which states that the water loss is 26 c.f.s. and page E-9 which states that the consumptive loss of water is 23,564 acre-feet annually (32 c.f.s.).

The agreement with the Corps of Engineers is for payment of consumptive losses of 22 c.f.s. for Unit 1 and 14 c.f.s. for Unit 2.

5 Page 3-11, paragraph 3.3.6 - Hydrologic Characteristics of Lake Dardanelle.

a.

The second sentence in regard to weekly flows should be changed to clarify the phase " considered on a monthly basis."

b.

The tabulation is based on partial records of the U.S. Geclogical Survey. It should be based on all these records or an explanation given for use of partial records.

6.

Page 8-12, paranrath 8.4 - Irreversible and Irretrievable Commitments of Resources. The statement that the applicant will pay the Corps of Engineers $8,500 annaa11y is incorrect. The actual annual payment is

$3,300 for Unit 1 and $7,300 for Unit 2, a total of $10,600.

(

(

(

l AEC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 50 DOCXE" MATERIAL (TEMPORARY FORM)

CONTROL NO:

6498 l

ENVIRO

~

FROM:

DA, Little Rock District DATE OF DOC:

DATE REC'D LTR EMO RP2 MHER Littis Rock, Ark.

72203 Donald G. Wainert 11-24-72 11-27-72 I

TO:

ORIO CC l WHER SENT AEC PD3 af I

SENT LOCAL PDR af I

~1 signed 1

(

u,. _ nn u, m,.

CIASS:

, @ 0P INFO INPUT NO CYS REC'D

, DOCIET NO:

2 50-313 DESCRIP2 ION: Ltr trans the following:

ENCLOSURES:

Little Rock District, Corps of ]

Engineers Comments on the Draf t 2nviro Stat.

ment for Ark. One Unit I....

l ACK10REDOED.

PLANT NAMES: Ark. One Unit I l

FOR ACTION /INFORMATION DL 11-28-72 I

BUILER(L)

%CHWENCER(L)

SCHEMEL(L)

KNIGIEON(E)

W/Iopies W/ Copies y/ Copies W/ Copics C

CLARK (L)

STOLZ(L)

ZIEMANN(L)

FIOUNGBIDOD(E)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies W/4 Copies GOLLER(L)

VASSALID(L)'

CHITWOOD(FM)

REGAN(E)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copics W/ Copies

  • KNIEL(L)

H. DEIRON

. DICKER (E)

]

W/ Copics W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies IIEERNAL DISTRIBUTION l

CWREG FII D TECH REVIEW VOLIRER MS WADE E

spra:A, run HEHDRIE DENTON SHAFER F&M pGC, ROOM P-506A SCHROEDI:R GRIMES F&M BROWN E

RUNIZING/ STAFF MACCARY GAM ELL SMILEY

46. WILLIAME E CASE LANGE(2)

KASTNER NUSSBAUMER W. GOULBOURNE L GIAMBUSSO PAWLICKI BALLARD A/TIND BOYD-L(BWR)

SHAO SPANGLER LIC ASST.

BRAITFAN dEYOUNG-L(PWR)

KNUTH

' SERVICE L SALTZMAN SKOVE0LT-L STELIO ENVIRO MASON L

P. COLLINS MOORE MULLER WILSON L

PLANS HOUSTON DICKER MAIGRET L MCDONALD BEG OPR

- TEDESCO KNIGIHON SMITH L

DUEE F/ILE & REGION (2)

IONG

'iOUNGBLOOD GEARIN L

MORRIS JAINAS PROJ ILtDER DIGGS L

INFO l

STELLE afBENAROYA TEETS L

C. MILES ~

l l LEE L

REGAN EXTERNAL DISTRIBUPION d-IOCAL PDR __Dardanelle, Ad.

1-DTIE(ABERNATIE)

$1)

-NATIONAL LAB'S ORNL 1-PDR-SAN /LA/NY 1-NSIC(BUCHANAN)

-R. CARROLL-0C GT-B27[

1-GERALD LELIDUCHE 3

, 1 ASLB_, ORE /SA M bd.-R. CATLIN, E-256*-GT BROOKHAVEN NAT. LAB Y

WODWARD[H. ST.

1-CONSULANT'S 1-AGMED(WALTER KOESTER,.

16-CYS ACBS HOLDING NEWMARK/BLUME/AGABIAN Em C 427, GT) 1-RD... MULU3,..F-309GT

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19320A337&oldid=4783299"