|
|
| Line 17: |
Line 17: |
|
| |
|
| =Text= | | =Text= |
| {{#Wiki_filter:_. ._ _ _ . | | {{#Wiki_filter:}} |
| Part I of II .
| |
| O .
| |
| . Performance Indicators for Operating Comercial Nuclear Power Reactors Part I Quarterly Report May 1988 Data through March 1988 -
| |
| I Office for Analysis and Evaluation of Operational Data William Burton Patricia Lonneman Neil Naraine Thomas Wolf l
| |
| O 8907130457 ASO705 PDR M "ID #PDC
| |
| | |
| ABSTRACT l () This Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC/ Commission) report provides performance indicator data through March 31,1988 for 110 operating commercial nuclear power plants. The data are taken from licensee event reports submitted in
| |
| , accordance with 10 CFR 50.73, licensee telephone reports made to the NoC l Operations Center in accordance with 10 CFR 50.72, and licensee monthly operating report data submitted under 10 CFR 50. The report addresses six indicators that were initially approved for implementation in the NRC's performance indicator program: automatic scrams.while critical; safety system actuations; significant events; safety system failures; forced outage rate; and equipment forced outages per 1000 critical hours. The quarterly data for the seventh indicator, collective radiation exposure, are in the process of being obtained. Meanwhile, exposure data on an annual basis are provided in Part II of this report.
| |
| This report is in two parts. The first part provides the plant summary and analysis charts. The second part provides detailed data tables as well as a description of the report contents.
| |
| The NRC's performance 'odicator program provides an objective view of specific aspects of operational performance of plants and enhances the staff's ability to recognize changes in their safety performance. It is only a tool. In conjunction with other information, it provides an input to management decisions regarding the need to adjust plant-specific regulatory programs.
| |
| l O
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| pa arog f o,,
| |
| C j UNITED STATES
| |
| ,o 8 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
| |
| %, .".s ANNOUNCEMENT NO. 30 DATE: February 5, 1988 TO: ALL NRC EMPLOYEES
| |
| | |
| ==SUBJECT:==
| |
| GUIDANCE ON THE USE OF PERFORMANCE INDICATORS The Comission has approved the internal guidance for the use of perfomance indicators for operating power plants. All NRC employees shall adhere to the following guidance.
| |
| The performance indicator program provides an additional view of operational performance and enhances our ability to recognize areas of poor and/or declining safety perfomance of operating plants. However, it is only a tool and is to be used in conjunction with other tools such as the results of routine and special inspections and 3 ALP for providing input to NRC management decisions regarding the need to adjust plant-specific regulatory programs.
| |
| It should be recognized that performance indicators have limitations and are subject to misinterpretation. Therefore,cautioniswarrantedinthej interpretation and use of the data. The application of performance indicaters for purposes and in manners other than those stated above will be counter to the NRC objective of ensuring operational safety. To avoid such situations, the following specific directives are provided:
| |
| : 1. The performance indicator program for operating reactors is a single, coordinated, overall NRC program under the direction of AE00. NRC offices other than AE0D should not deviate from the NRC program without written pemission of the EDO or the Director, AE00. .
| |
| : 2. Performance indicators are intended as a tool for senior NRC management to monitor trends in overall perfomance for a given plant. The performance indicators for a given plant should be viewed as a set. When viewed as a set, the perfomance indicators provide an additional measure of plant operational perfomance.
| |
| O i
| |
| | |
| 1 i
| |
| l
| |
| : 3. Performance indicators are intended to be one of several tools for use by senior NRC management in decision making regarding plant a specific regulatory programs. Senior management in each NRC office
| |
| * W should have access to performance indicators for their assigned unit (s). However, no regulatory action should be taken on the basis of performance indicator program results alone.
| |
| : 4. Performance indicators should not be used for ranking nuclear power
| |
| . plants or presented in such a way as to imply "problem facility" status for individual plants.
| |
| : 5. The performance indicator program is separate and distinct from the Systematic Assessment of Licensee Performance (SALP) Program. Although the indicators have relationships in varying degrees to SALP functional areas, the indicators themselves should not be a factor in judgements about the effectiveness or rating in a particular SA!.P functional area.
| |
| In particular, it would be inappropriate to make reference to performance indicator program results in arriving at a SALP rating.
| |
| : 6. NRC senior management should bear in mind when evaluating performance indicator results that the indicators are assessment tools that aid in identification of unanticipated performance, and that the underlying causes should be carefully assessed, evaluated, and understood (factoring in other available information).
| |
| : 7. Quarterly compilations of performance indicator program results should be placed in the Public Document Room following dissemination to NRC management and the Commission.
| |
| It should be recognized that in conducting reviews, inspections and evaluations of plants it is often necessary to rely on. plant data. Such info,mation has been routinely used in our SALP, SER and Technical Evaluation reports. The forgoing policy is not intended to change this process. .
| |
| g .
| |
| ctorkejl Jr.
| |
| Executive 0 ector for Operations O
| |
| l l~
| |
| | |
| CONTENTS
| |
| () _PART I Page ' i i l ABSTRACT............................................................... j GUIDANCE ON THE USE OF PERFORMANCE INDICATORS.......................... 11 LIST OF FICURES........................................................ v 1 INTRODUCTION...................................................... 1 2 BACKGR0VND........................................................ 1 3 DEFINITIONS OF THE INDICATORS..................................... 1 3.1 Au toma ti c Scrams Whil e Cri ti ca1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 3.2 S a fe ty Sy s tem Ac tu a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 3.3 Significant Events........................................... 2 -
| |
| 3.4 S a fe ty Sy s tem Fa i l u re s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 ,
| |
| 3.5 Forced Outage Rate........................................... 2 3.6 Equi pment Forced Outages Per 1000 Critical Hours . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 3.7 Collective Radia tion Exposure. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
| |
| 2 3.8 Ad d i ti on a l No te s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 4 DISPLAY OF PERFORMANCE INDICATOR 0ATA............................. 3-I 4.1 P l a n t S u mma r i e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 4.2 Q u a r te r l y Da t a . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 t.3 Annual Industry Averages..................................... 4 l
| |
| O iv
| |
| | |
| 8.IST OF FIGURES (O
| |
| -/ PLANT SUMMARIES AND QUARTERLY DATA- PART 1 FIGURE 4.1 - ARKANSAS-1 FIGURE 4.2 - ARKANSAS 2 FIGURE 4.3 - BEAVER VALLEY 1 FIGURE 4.4 - BEAVER. VALLEY.2 FIGURE 4.5 - BIG ROCK POINT FIGURE 4.6 - BRAIDWOOD 1 FIGURE 4.7 - BRAIDWWOD 2 FIGURE 4.8 - BROWNS FERRY 1 FIGURE 4.9 - BROWNS FERRY 2 FIGURE 4.10 - BROWNS FERRY 3 FIGURE 4.11 - BRUNSWICK 1 FIGURE 4.12 - BRUNSWICK 2 FIGURE 4.13 - BYRON 1 FIGURE 4.14 - BYRON 2 FIGURE 4.15 - CALLAWAY FIGURE 4.16 - CALVERT CLIFFS 1 -
| |
| FIGURE 4.17 - CALVERT CLIFFS 2 FIGURE 4.18 - CATAWBA 1 FIGURE 4.19 - CATAWBA 2 FIGURE 4.20 - CLINTON 1 FIGURE 4.21 - COOK 1 FIGURE 4.22 - COOK 2 FIGURE 4.23 - COOPER STATION FIGURE 4.24 - CRYSTAL RIVER 3 FIGURE 4.25 - DAVIS-BESSE FIGURE 4.26 - DIABLO CANYON 1 FIGURE 4.27 - DIABLO CANYON 2 FIGURE. 4.28 - DRESDEN 2 -
| |
| FIGURE 4.29 - DRESDEN 3 /
| |
| FIGURE 4.30 - DUANE ARNOLD >
| |
| FIGURE 4.31 - FARLEY 1 FIGURE 4.32 - FARLEY 2 FIGURE 4.33 - FERMI 2 FIGURE 4.34 - FITZPATRICK FIGURE 4.35 - FORT CALHOUN FIGURE 4.36 - FORT ST. VRAIN FIGURE 4.37 - GINNA FIGURE 4.38 - GRAND GULF FIGURE 4.39 - HADDAM NECK FIGURE 4.40 - HATCH I FIGURE 4.41 - HATCH 2 FIGURE 4.42 - HOPE CREEK FIGURE 4.43 - INDIAN POINT 2 FIGURE 4.44 - INDIAN FOINT 3 FIGURE 4.45 - KEWAUNEE FIGURE 4.46 - LASALLE I FIGURE 4.47 - LASALLE 2 4.48 - LIMERICK O FIGURE 4.49 - MAINE YANKEE FIGURE FIGURE 4.50 - MCGUIRE 1 v
| |
| | |
| LIST OF FIGURES (CONTINUEDI PLANT SUMMARIES AND QUARTERLY DATA - PART 1 lll FIGURE 4.51 - MCGUIRE 2 FIGURE 4.52 - MILLSTONE 1 FIGURE 4.53 - MILLSTONE 2 FIGURE 4.54 - MILLSTONE 3 ,
| |
| FIGURE 4.55 - M0tlTICELLO I FIGURE 4.56 - NINE MILE PT. 1 1 FIGURE 4.57 - NINE MILE PT. 2 FIGURE 4.58 - NORTH ANNA 1 FIGURE 4.59 - NORTH ANNA 2 FIGURE 4.60 - OCONEE 1 FIGURE 4.61 - OCONEE 2 FIGURE 4.62 - OCONEE 3 FIGURE 4.63 - OYSTER CREEK FIGURE 4.64 - PALISADES FIGURE 4.65 - PALO VERDE 1 FIGURE .4.66 - PALO VERDE 2 FIGURE 4.67 - PALO VERDE 3 FIGURE 4.68 - PEACH BOTTOM 2 FIGURE 4.69 - PEACH BOTTOM 3 FIGURE 4.70 - PERRY FIGURE 4.71 - PILGRIM FIGURE 4.72 - POINT BEACH 1 FIGURE 4.73 - POINT BEACH 2 FIGURE 4.74 - PRAIRIE ISLAND 1 FIGURE 4.75 - PRAIRIE ISLAND 2 FIGURE 4.76 - QUAD CITIES 1 FIGURE 4.77 - QUAD CITIES 2 FIGURE 4.78 - RANCHO SECO FIGURE 4.79 - RIVER BEND FIGURE 4.80 - ROBINSON 2 FIGURE 4.81 - SALEM 1 FIGURE 4.82 - SALEM 2 FIGURE 4.83 - SAN ON0FRE 1 FIGURE 4.84 - SAN ONOFRE 2 FIGURE 4.85 - SAN ONOFRE 3 FIGURE 4.86 - SEABROOK FIGURE 4.87 - SEQD0YAH 1 FIGURE 4.88 - SEQUOYAH 2 FIGURE 4.89 - SHEARON-HARRIS FIGURE 4.90 - SHOREHAM FIGURE 4.91 - SOUTH TEXAS 1 FIGURE 4.92 - ST. LUCIE 1 FIGURE 4.93 - ST. LUCIE 2 FIGURE 4.94 - SUMMER FIGURE 4.95 - SURRY 1 FIGURE 4.96 - SURRY 2 FIGURE 4.97 - SUSQUEHANNA 1 FIGURE 4.98 - SUS 00EHANNA 2 FIGURE 4.99 - THREE MILE ISLAND 1 lll vi
| |
| | |
| LIST OF FIGURES / CONTINUED)
| |
| ()
| |
| PLANT SUMMARIES AND QUARTERLY DATA - PART 1 FIGURE 4.100 - TROJAN FIGURE 4.101 - TURKEY POINT 3 FIGURE 4.102 - TURKEY POINT 4 ~
| |
| ' FIGURE 4.103 - VERMONT YANKEE FIGURE 4.104 - V0GTLE FIGURE 4.105 - WASH. NUCLEAR 2 FIGURE 4.106 - WATERFORD 3 FIGUPE 4.107 - WOI.F CREEK FIGURE 4.108 - YANKEE-ROWE FIGURE 4.109 - ZION 1 FIGURE 4.110 - ZION 2 ANNUAL INDUSTRY AVERAGES FIGURE 4.111 - ANNUAL INDUSTRY AVERAGES (EXCLUDING PLANTS IN EXTENDED SHUTDOWN MODE) i O
| |
| vii
| |
| | |
| O THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK Viii O
| |
| | |
| N O ~
| |
| 1 INTRODUCTION This Nuclear Regulatory Comission (NRC/Comission) report presents perfomance indicator infomation for 110 operating reactors. There are seven indicators in the NRC Performance Indicator Program for Operating Comercial Nuclear Power Plants. They are (1) automatic scrams while critical, (2) safety system actuations, (3) significant events, (4) safety system failures, (5) forced outage rate, (6) equipment forced outages per 1000 critical hours, and (7) collective radiation exposure.
| |
| Quarterly data for all indicators except collective radiation exposure are given for each of the plants in the fom of charts and tables. The charts for each plant are provided in Part I, and the tables in Part II. The collec-tive radiation exposure data on a quarterly basis are being collected. In the meantime exposure data are being presented on an annual basis.
| |
| 2 BACKGROUND Since May 1986, an interoffice task, group has been working to develop an NRC program for using quantitative indicators of nuclear power plant safety perform-ance. In July and August of 1986, the group conducted a trial program for 50 plants testing 17 prospective performance indicators. For the most part, this trial program used data through calendar year 1985. The group then selected eight performance indicators to be recomended as the best set for initial implementation. The staff deleted one of these, corrective maintenance backlog, after considering industry coments.
| |
| In October 1986, a prototype report was prepared by expanding the trial program
| |
| , data to 100 operating reactors and including the data through the first half of 1986. The staff's recommended program, the tas' 1roup report, cnd the proto-type report were documented in SECY 86-317. "Pei srmance Indicators," dated' October 28, 1986. The Comission was briefed on the staff's recommended program in November 1986, and approved the implementation of the program in December 1986, instructing the staff to delete the enforcement action index from the set of indicators.
| |
| Since February 1987, the performance indicator reports are being provided to the senior management on a quarterly basis. This May 1988 issue of the quarterly report contains data through March 1988, i 3 DEFINITIONS OF THE INDICATORS 3.1 Automatic Scrams While Critical (Scrams)
| |
| This indicator is identical to the indicator, unplanned automatic scrams while critical, used by the Institute of Nuclear Power Oper6tions (INPO). In addition, the number of automatic scrams from above 15% power per 1000 critical hours and the number of automatic scrams while critical below 15% power are monitored.
| |
| | |
| -2 3.2 Safety System Actuations (SSA)
| |
| This indicator is identical to the indicator, unplanned safety system actuations, used by INP0 and includes actual and inadvertent actuations of Emergency Core Cooling Systems (ECCS), as well as actuat;ons of emergency ac power systems due to loss of power to a vital bus.
| |
| 3.3 Significant Events (SE):
| |
| These events are identified through detailed screening of operating experience by the Office of Nuclear Reacter Regulation (NRR) and the Office for Analysis and Evaluation of Operational Data (AE00), and include degradation of important safety equipment, unexpected plant response to a transient or a major transient, discovery of a major conditien not considered in the plant saff.ty 6nalysis, or degradation of fuel integrity, primary coolant pressure boundary, or important associated structures.
| |
| 3.4 Safety System Failures (SSF)
| |
| This indicator includes any event or condition that alone could prevent the fulfillment of the safety function of structures or systems. Twenty-four systems or subsystems are monitored for this indicator.
| |
| 3.5 _ Forced Outage Rate (FOR)
| |
| This indicator's definition is identical to the one used by INP0 and the NRC Grey Book (NUREG-0020). It is the number of forced outage hours divided by the sum of forced outage hours and generator on-line hours.
| |
| 3.6 Equipment Forced Outages Per 1000 Critical Hours (EFO):
| |
| This indicator is the inverse of the mean time between forced outages caused by equipment failures. The mean time is equal to the number of hours the reactor is critical in a period divided by the number of forced outages caused by equip-ment failures in that period.
| |
| 3.7 Collective Radiation Exposure This indicator is identical to the one used by INP0. It is the total dose at the station. The station total is divided by the number of units at the site contributing to exposure to obtain unit values.
| |
| 3.8 Additional Notes - Part II Part II of this report provides detailed tabular performance indicator data for each operating plant. In addition, an industry sumary table provides the moving average for the most recent two quarters (two-quarter period) and the moving 9
| |
| | |
| 1 O .
| |
| average for the four quarters that precede the two-quarter period (prior four-quarter period) for each performance indicator for each plant as well as the systematic assessment of licensee ' performance (SALP) ratings at the end of this report period for operations, maintenance, surveillance, and quality programs.
| |
| The data for this report were obtained from NRC sources and were reviewed by NRC personnel in headquarters and the regions for completeness and accuracy.
| |
| The data for the first quarter of 1988 will be reviewed again in preparation for the next quarterly report in order to ensure that late information, if any, -
| |
| i,s accounted fo,.
| |
| 4 DISPLAY OF PERFORMANCE INDICATOR DATA The performance indicator data are presented in this report by means of charts and tables as discussed in the following paragraphs.
| |
| 4.1 Quarterly Data Figures 4.1 through 4.110 provide detailed plant analysis charts of the quarterly data for each indicator for each plant. These charts also include the plant's critical hours to present a picture of the plant's operating history, industry mean values to provide a comparative performance level, and the four quarter moving averages to show trends. Bar charts for older plants include the older plant means; charts for newer plants include both the newer plant means and the older plant means. These plots give detailed visual pictures for indicators at given p,lants.
| |
| 4.2 Plant Sumnries Figures 4.1 through 4.110 also consist of two (or three) bar charts which I provide profiles of each plant's perfonnance indicator trends. The top chart of each figure shows the number of standard deviations by which the moving average for the most recent two-quarter period varies from the plant's own moving average for the prior four-quarter period. The bottom chart of each figure shows the number of standard deviations by which the plant's moving average for the most recent four quarters (current four-quarter period) varies from an industry mean. Older plants are compared to the older plant means.
| |
| Newer plants are compared to newer plant means. For the purpose of this report, plants that received full-power licenses in 1986 or earlier are considered older plants. The others are considered newer plants.
| |
| The figures for newer plants also have a chart display which compares the plants' current four-quarter period moving averages to the older plant means.
| |
| O
| |
| | |
| 4.3 Annual Industry Averages -
| |
| Beginning with this report, annual industry averages for each performance indicator are being displayed as bar charts. Figure 4.111 shows the industry averages excluding the plants that were in extended shutdown modes.
| |
| The methodology for counting safety system failures was changed in 1987.
| |
| Previously, failures were counted only if the licensee identified a failure by checking the appropriate box on the Licensee Event Report ILER), Beginning~in 1987, failures are identified by detailed review of the LERs. The solid black bar for safety system failures in Figures 4.111 reflects the old methodology while the cross-hatched bar reflects the difference due to new methodology. ,
| |
| I O
| |
| 1 1
| |
| 1 .. . . . - - ._. . . - _ - - - _ _ - _ . _ - - _ . . . . _ . .. .
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| -s-O .
| |
| e
| |
| . PLANT SUMMARIES AND QUARTERLY DATA
| |
| ~
| |
| I l
| |
| t f
| |
| i i
| |
| O
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.1 I
| |
| C: :3 :necc:or I 1
| |
| ARKANSAS 1 Leaend:-
| |
| o w % nt ^ *<c;e cr.ticci sus 86-2 to 88-1 4 0 *'te' % Averc9e g
| |
| 1 Automatic Scroms WNe Critcot ,
| |
| : 2. Scfety System Actuotons
| |
| - '250 - 22so
| |
| / T ~/ - 2xo \ / \ way 3-
| |
| / <
| |
| nso l
| |
| : 3. \
| |
| s /
| |
| /.
| |
| eso p
| |
| y}g
| |
| -/
| |
| $ \/ 5
| |
| - ** 1. 4,1
| |
| - ex -
| |
| 4
| |
| * 2
| |
| .=j s g 2- -
| |
| aj j
| |
| j;2- L 4=i j -
| |
| 3 t
| |
| ~3 ,. 2
| |
| ~3 j[k.m@--- g . h: 1 500 y - 500 g h$ f Y; - 250 N w - 250 o Y'- b-' l'1 2 o o M o 86k2 86 k 3kS6 e 8/-t 67k2 87'-3 67'-4 66-1 865 2 66L 3 86k4 61-1 Si-2 Si-3 Si-4 68-t year - weer Yew - Quarte
| |
| : 3. SWaficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety Systern Foltres
| |
| = 3- g 3-ik )k at at 3<2-g 'gt-l h h '- S' 1 2
| |
| , h 4 e6L 2 esL3 se'-4 si-i s?'-2 s7'-3 si-4 86'-i e6'-2 e6-3 e6L4 si-i si-2 sf-3 si-4 as-i Year - Quarter Year - Oa t er i
| |
| : 6. Ecuoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rcte (s) 1000 Critics Hotss e
| |
| 3 E. M h 2 E 2$ '-
| |
| t w- % !!
| |
| BS Jr 4 t;*-
| |
| 33 ' - k j h' .- w t- S to - ^ g''V s N
| |
| _0 92 0 46 In 49 o -
| |
| 4 f'*1 _
| |
| l o C '" 1 I .$ I ) I'l j 86-2 86-3 86'-4 8I-t '-2SI-387-468-1 86'-2 66-3 66-4 0 7- 8 8 7'-2 87-3 $ 7-4 84 -2 Yeor = Jter Yeor - Qwter e
| |
| O
| |
| | |
| TIGURE 4.1 ARKANSAS 1: Trends 77
| |
| * Declined improved Performance Indicators 03' f2 btr. vg nd k - ) ~
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - osa
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.57
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - o 69
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs /10 it Hr c.23
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0!0 0'.5 io US 2'.0 2.5 Devictions(Measured from Previous in Stondord 4 Otr. Plant )Mecns Devictions ,
| |
| ARK 4NSAS 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators 8' b " ^V9 P''f- Ab "' ^*9' P'''-
| |
| (4Ott. vg nd 5 $) - -0J2 8
| |
| : 2. Sclety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - cas
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ o.go
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c 66
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / g3]j_ o g,
| |
| -2.5-i.0 i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0 0 0 5 UO t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Meces (Measured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| O 7 0
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.2 1 - i tre e:tc< j ARKANSAS 2 Legend: c =e' *
| |
| * t ^ ' = >+
| |
| Crit.cci Hours g_) - 4 Ouorter Ucv>rvg Averc;e
| |
| : 1. AutofTCtic SCroms Whie Crit <Cl 2. SCfety System ACluotions i 4 2500 4 2500 1
| |
| - 2250 . *2SO
| |
| \ ''\ - m0-
| |
| *2 A / m0$ I 3- / '
| |
| 53.
| |
| 5 % / -
| |
| * 3 15
| |
| \
| |
| \/
| |
| 1 3
| |
| Ny ';j
| |
| . e00 *' .~y <I \/ . i:oD *'
| |
| m< -
| |
| v 1250 QSO
| |
| 'gt. -
| |
| ( -
| |
| o g 2. -
| |
| ji ,~
| |
| 1
| |
| @% 1 1 5
| |
| 1
| |
| ,~
| |
| T
| |
| [
| |
| 5
| |
| . 500 . 5:e i &l ! M - 250 s - 250 g
| |
| w +
| |
| M -e a$
| |
| v ty 0
| |
| p' 0
| |
| 0 86'-2 86-3 BN-4 SI-18/-2 BY-3 SY-4 Sd-t 8$-2 86-3 86-4 8/-t 87k2 87k3 87k4 88-t Yeor - Quorter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Si<pficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System Fokses
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| kk $k
| |
| -e
| |
| -< .* <1 3
| |
| 2 g2-1
| |
| ' ' ' 1 d d
| |
| ., 4 & :. '
| |
| ?
| |
| M
| |
| ~-g
| |
| (
| |
| % fg -
| |
| ss 0 0 3 ; ,
| |
| 84- 2 86-3 86-4 SI-t 87'-2 87k3 8i-4 86-1 86k2 84-3 86-4 Si-l 87k2 87-3 87'-4 88-1 Yeor - Oster Yeor - Quarter !
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outojes/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (t) 000 Cr tics Motts to 8 b 80 -
| |
| . 3*-
| |
| !EB eo ' 34 f4x 54
| |
| *we.
| |
| 82 -
| |
| 'O - 36
| |
| ]
| |
| s s
| |
| 7
| |
| ~
| |
| P. 2 t6 w-
| |
| ' h i,-.
| |
| 2, e a, rb# l,e i
| |
| ?
| |
| k n La E3 ,_.
| |
| c__4 24-2 86' 3 86-4 Si-187-287'-387-4 88-1
| |
| - 86-2 86-3 86-4 37-t 8712 87-3 87-4 88 -1 Yeor - Quorter Y eor - Quorter 3
| |
| | |
| 6 FIGURE 4,2 o ARKANSAS 2: Trends O Declined tenoroved Performance Indicators WN
| |
| : 1. Automoti Sgrom Cg_c ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . -2.s
| |
| : 3. Sigri'icont Events (2 Otr, Avg end 88-1) . o.58
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.$7
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 92
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs / it W eg,yj , n ,,
| |
| -2.5 -2.0 -i.5 -to -8.5 0'.0 OIS t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devict from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons Measured in Stondord Devictions) ;,
| |
| ARKANSAS 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators ,
| |
| 0.21 f4 t Avg nd S- ) - j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .c4e
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ogo
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . qs
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs / it Hr s ,
| |
| q9,
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-I.5 -I.0 -0.5 O!O O'.5 1'O t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Meons (Mecsured in Stenoord Devictions)
| |
| O 9
| |
| _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _n.
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.3 tndicotC(
| |
| BEAVER VALLEY 1 Legend: c'e* acnt Avec;e Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| """
| |
| * C*'t"
| |
| * M Av"ci'
| |
| , g l Automatc Scrorrs W51e Critical 2. Sofety Systern Actuations 4 IS00 4 aw0
| |
| . 2250 - 2250 r %
| |
| /'
| |
| 2000 ''
| |
| '\
| |
| : 3. 2000 f" it 3-
| |
| - ~
| |
| 3 t 3 b
| |
| t -
| |
| m '. j <f .
| |
| w '.
| |
| 250 f250 g2- -
| |
| 'o g 2 -
| |
| jj -
| |
| j g
| |
| '~
| |
| t
| |
| *b 3
| |
| :~
| |
| N - 20 3" - wo 3 s%
| |
| o o o
| |
| * o e$-2 8eL 3 86L 4 8Y-18 87-3 67'-4 SS'-l 8$-2 8N-3 yI-1 8 -3 8Y-4 8d-1
| |
| : 3. 5<pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Scfety System ron.ses
| |
| - 3- 3 3.
| |
| I jh
| |
| -t
| |
| -< <1 g2. g2.
| |
| '- t-W d ,'
| |
| N o 0 as-1 es-2 ee'-4 l-1 gegis a?'-4 eA-i seL sek es-4 i-i gai-3 af-4 2 3
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced Outoges/
| |
| S. Forced Outoge Rote (s) 1000 Critco Wxis M-h.-
| |
| g&
| |
| 3E 1=- 1!
| |
| 5<
| |
| h4 l b5 5"~
| |
| 1* ''-
| |
| l f
| |
| ' 2-iw 20 -
| |
| %.23e% '
| |
| 0 'L _' -
| |
| 0 9 EO_d '
| |
| seLa seis es-4g7-i sgsi-3 s7-4 ss-1
| |
| ~
| |
| 68-2 so-3 segi-i s ei-3 e?-4 es-i 10
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.3 q BEAVER VALLEY 1: Trends DecGrsed Irnproved Performance Indicators 2 htr. vg nd5 - 1
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- ose
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1)- 0 34
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs / , 1,
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -i0 .5 O!O O'.5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions (Measured frorn Previous in Stondord 4 Otr. Plont )Meons Devictions ,
| |
| BEAVER VALLEY 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^"
| |
| f4 0'tr vg 5$)- c.21
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg erx1 88-1) . tit
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ose
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1, , o.71
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ g3 , a y,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0-t5 -i.0 -d.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2!O 25 Devictions from Older Piont Meons (Meosured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| O 11
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.4 i
| |
| \rtcct or OE/A L.) V L t \A\/[~OV \/ALLP( w
| |
| ?
| |
| Leaend:
| |
| er moat ^ *'os*
| |
| Ne wer Piont Average Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1 e 4 Quor ter hng Average j t Automats Scrarns WNe Critical 2. Scfety System Actuot.ons 4 _
| |
| 2500 4 :soo w
| |
| p_ F ,p8 8 - 22so 22:a
| |
| '1' - acoo "
| |
| j f 3- 3- 1 g 200o sno
| |
| [v s - ino B
| |
| eco =' ~? '(a
| |
| /- 3 eco --
| |
| ~<
| |
| 1 1 -
| |
| y< c: . -
| |
| *2-
| |
| {h J. csoj
| |
| ^
| |
| og2- . J.,
| |
| g .J - -
| |
| tzso j -
| |
| h
| |
| *3 h
| |
| +T f
| |
| *}
| |
| ' - no
| |
| * h ?@lno '' -
| |
| _ , 3oo /f .-
| |
| 4 , 3ao
| |
| 's ~ w
| |
| - - tso ,,
| |
| ~~ L . ;r - 2so G
| |
| * o o o . -.
| |
| o 84-2 eels eel 4 si-i si-2 s43 si-4 es-i si-2ei-3 seL4 s/-i si-2 si-3 si-4 ss-i voor - Quarter - voor - ovarter
| |
| : 3. Si<pficant Events ,
| |
| 4 Scfety System Foiures
| |
| . 3- g 3-kh $h
| |
| -! -1 s 2<2- ,
| |
| g 2- g 3
| |
| $ $ ?
| |
| ' i.
| |
| t- .
| |
| y m
| |
| $ g^
| |
| n
| |
| $M n
| |
| [
| |
| eel2 eel 3 e6L4 ski si-2 ei-3 si-4 es'-i seL2 eS-3 ei-4 s7-i f voor - oucrter voor L2 sf-3 ter sf-4 es'-i i
| |
| : 6. Equ t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Cnteed Hours 10 0 s M
| |
| Eso. h 2 ,_
| |
| is . 5 t FI ' - }I ( 'f 2e tr'- /
| |
| .o - 4 -:
| |
| 3o =
| |
| N N b $,
| |
| to - .u- p__ x - ..
| |
| r Mr c
| |
| , ro;a _
| |
| m$
| |
| , _ m _ ,
| |
| so-2so-3se-4 sf-t 87-2 af-3 87 4 es-i so-2 so-3 ei-4 er-i i -2 f si-3 87-4 so-voor - Quarter Yect - Os t er 12 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.4 nv- BEAVER VALLEY 2: Trends Declined improved Performance Indicators f2 , Avg
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _o.n
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Qtr. Asg end 88-1) . i
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ it Hr ,
| |
| -2.5-10-l5 -iO-0.5 O!O O!5 l'O l'5 2!0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont M
| |
| . (Meosured in Stondord Devictions) eons ,
| |
| BEAVER . VALLEY 2: Deviations from Newer Plant Means B&w Avg. Pwf Above Avg. Puf.
| |
| Performance Indicators t Automoti Wh C tic -_ - t67
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . _t..
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilves (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ose
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . oo4
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tg/ it ,,,,
| |
| 8g j,
| |
| -2.5-io i5 -lo -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Ne er Plont Meons (Meesured in Stondord Cevictions)
| |
| O 13 rt
| |
| | |
| l 0
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| THIS 1
| |
| l PAGE l 1
| |
| 1 1
| |
| l LEFT 1
| |
| l l
| |
| INTENTIONALLY 1 i BLANK 1
| |
| 0 14
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.4 (CONTD)
| |
| O .
| |
| Note: This is o comparison of BEAVER VALLEY 2 (o newer plant) .
| |
| ogainst cider plant means.
| |
| BEAVER VALLEY 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^" -9J9 4 ktt Avg end -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotbns (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -4J6
| |
| : 3. Spficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .o.eg
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 0.55
| |
| : 5. Fo ced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 0.75
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,,y
| |
| -2.5-2LO-i5 -iO -d.5 0 0 0 5 t'0 15 2'O 25 Devictions from oeer Picnt Mecns (Meosured in Stoncord Devictions)
| |
| O 15 n
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.5 ind cat or l BIG ROCK -POINT Legend: Cicer mo ei 4 etese Criticci Hess 66-2 to 88-1 '-- 4 c a ter w~~,Aarege l
| |
| t Automatic Scrcrns wh* Critical ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions
| |
| . :so . :s s.'%,[. '#'N . 2000 s.''N.,.
| |
| , /'' ,, p. .
| |
| 2XC } '
| |
| It / - ~
| |
| 3 9 / -
| |
| =1
| |
| !!*t -
| |
| =: si -
| |
| =:
| |
| eso} %3a. mo }
| |
| lg1 . 1-i a
| |
| - a i
| |
| ,- / ,
| |
| -a 2s0 rso
| |
| % e.
| |
| e -
| |
| i 3 3 i sa-i ei-2 es.3 v.ored el-i er h-2 s?L s/-4 as-i eel: e4L ee- v oorSi-i
| |
| - h-2 tw si-3 si-4
| |
| : 3. 5<pficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Sc,fety System Foues
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| -i Ik
| |
| -i z<t-g 2<t.
| |
| g 1
| |
| t-J v
| |
| , , L sekt seks ay/-t geg-3 si-4 es-1 eekt esL3 4 7-1 ga?-3 sf-4 ta-i ;
| |
| : 6. Equ t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Pote (s) Critccs Hous 3 m- h it 4'~
| |
| 3!
| |
| f<! eo - s<
| |
| w me.
| |
| y
| |
| - -3 3 45 d"$""
| |
| 3 B
| |
| ! ID' 2 13
| |
| ~
| |
| _ n -
| |
| ... .y
| |
| , .3 a p-
| |
| , , _1 b lf O 86-2 86-3 88-4 SI-t af-2 ff=3 8f-4 68-i 84-286'-3864 67-1 47-2 87-3 87-4 $3-i Year - Qugter Y ear - Quarter 6 0 O
| |
| t w __ ______ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _
| |
| | |
| FCURC 4.5 I
| |
| BIG ROCK POINT: Trends !
| |
| O Declined improved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scroms While Criticol (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - s('g{g osa
| |
| : 2. Safeh System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - - 125
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| } _
| |
| o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.5s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -[fjf ' k 2.25 ,
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced (2 Outog/1000 Avg end Crit88-1)
| |
| Hrs. - o 20
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i5 -iO -d.5 0.0 0'S 1l0 1.'S 2IO 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont M (Measured in Stondord Devictions) eons BIG ROCK POINT: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic.Scroms WMe Criticol DO 128 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) " ggjQ
| |
| *~
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ;g om 2
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - p:f"'s on t bh
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 4:,Jf{'t:g t24
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 27 1
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced .t tg/ , _g
| |
| -2.5-$.0 l5 d 5 0 0 0'S 1 'O 15 20 25 C. evictions from Older Picnt Veens (Vecsu ed in Stoncord Dev ot. ors) 9 17 g
| |
| | |
| FGURE 4.6 C In6CClor BRAIDWOOD 1 . Legend: ceer a' cat avere;.
| |
| Newer Plent Averc;e crit Coi sovs 86-2 to 88-1 summma 4 Quort er I. awing Averoge t Automet'C SCrcrns Wht Crit' Col 8 2. 50fety System ActuCbof 3 e 2500 4__ :n
| |
| . 22 % _ ::N
| |
| , . 2000 .
| |
| : 3. 1 q
| |
| e
| |
| - im
| |
| : 3. -,
| |
| 2000
| |
| ,m [5 y 3 3 I 200 a' eco .-
| |
| ~
| |
| -< r j <I .
| |
| gt. f 1250 h 'o g 2 - 2% l ji ,_ t
| |
| ^
| |
| 1 y[ -
| |
| \. #b -
| |
| =3 i
| |
| ,_ l4
| |
| ~
| |
| s Mb i
| |
| s sec
| |
| % 500 .
| |
| Ad1~ M se'.2 e.'-3 eeLa el-i ai-2 s,-3 si.4 ed.:
| |
| esL2 88-3 ai-4 s/-t 8,.2 s,-3 e,-4 es-i i ~;"
| |
| Year - Quwter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. 5<pficant Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System rotures l
| |
| e 3- 3 3. 1 l
| |
| l hh jh i
| |
| -t
| |
| -< <t t
| |
| 32- '32. 1
| |
| * 8 m t
| |
| 3
| |
| $ [ ""
| |
| C 1 ;
| |
| V .
| |
| 0 '
| |
| oi seL2 ei-3 e6-4 81-1 si.2 ti.3 87-4 es-t e.k2 88 3 e.-e si-t af.2 si-3 si.e as.1 Year - Qwrter Yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 6. Eau t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (t) Critco Hours eo e 3 80 .
| |
| h h a-54 s.
| |
| 9 re 54
| |
| $ =$~
| |
| li5 ' ~ $,
| |
| r (i
| |
| ~
| |
| s ,. x g- & d: -
| |
| , L [3]
| |
| ~,
| |
| w .a
| |
| .-3e.,,-,,,....-3.,...., e..,e._, .. , , - , .
| |
| y eor - Qwrter v ear - b,. ,rt,er, . 3 ,, . . .. . ,
| |
| 3 t
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.6
| |
| 'n BRAIDWOOD 1: Trends
| |
| '%.) .
| |
| Declined improved Performance Indicators 2 Otr7Ivg !nd SN - tS
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FoDures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . om
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced it tg/ ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i.0 .5 O!O 05 i0 i52'.02.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons (Meeswed in Stondord Oevictions) ,
| |
| BRAIDWOOD 1: Deviations from Newer Plant Means Ben w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators 4 t vg end 5 f)- O.5 ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o.u
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.so
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c.ss
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -t4e
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ , of
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i.0-d.5 O!O 0 5 ic US 2!0 2 5 Devictions from Newer Pk:nt Meons (Mecsved in Stondord Deviations)
| |
| O 19
| |
| _ _ _a
| |
| | |
| O THIS .
| |
| PAGE LEFT l
| |
| lNTENTIONALLY !
| |
| l BLANK l
| |
| O 20 I
| |
| _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _.__ _ _ _________ _ _ ii
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.6 (CONTO)
| |
| O .
| |
| Note: This is a comparison of BRAIDWOOD 1 (o newer plant) -
| |
| ogoinst . older plant means.
| |
| BRAIDWOOD 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators Ahn t -us 4grtr. Ivg W8$$$)- ,
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuctions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -u4
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 4 42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilwes (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - CSS
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88 -1) - 2.86
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ Crit 8Qyj , 4 ,7
| |
| -2.5 -2' .0 -1.5 - t.0 .5 0'O O'.S t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Oider Piont veons (Mecsured in Stendard Devictions)
| |
| O 21 e
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.7 Q Indic0 tor j BRAIDWOOD 2 c e P et ^ = se j Legend:- -- Newer PICnt Ave cge
| |
| ~
| |
| 86-2 to 88-i crit,coi sous
| |
| - 4 Ovorter Moving Aver:*e a
| |
| y 1 AutomotC Scf 7715 WN4 Critc3 2. Sofety System Actwons
| |
| * :n . m
| |
| . :so ! . ::w ,
| |
| . - . :I 3-
| |
| 'm l 3. g g -
| |
| 3 gg . im j *'. 5$
| |
| e2 cw j %gt. .
| |
| um j
| |
| . ., . ,xo ,
| |
| - 7so 4 m
| |
| _ m
| |
| '- $- a *I
| |
| . 250 - . rso o 3 o -
| |
| o
| |
| .4 2 .e3 .e. .<-, ,-, ,-3 7-. -i l .e # 3 .e Y. ear .v.,- b-2 i
| |
| .i-3 .i.. S ,
| |
| tw Y ect - ter
| |
| : 3. Spficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses
| |
| . 3. 3 3-
| |
| -! -1 44 2*2-y2- g 5 5 1 .1 1 U
| |
| g g seL 2 66k3 06 5 . ti-1 Si-2 si-3 ti- a 68-1 842 66'-3 M-4 t?'-i 47 2 87-3 ef-4 68-i voor - Quarter Year- Mter
| |
| : 6. Eau nt rorced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (t) Crities Motts no e 3 So -
| |
| . 3*-
| |
| 2E i t .o . !!
| |
| h4 54 w me-m da 3 1 j ** - El w
| |
| s
| |
| :o -
| |
| .P. 2
| |
| ~
| |
| 0 -
| |
| o l 06 2 86-3 e 4 86-2 86-3 4y?-, gt?-3 87-4 18 -1 7-1 gs7-3 Bi-* SS-1
| |
| . 22 4
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| ( J 4 :- FIGURE 4.7 -
| |
| q v
| |
| BRAlDWOOD 2: Trends Performance Indicators D'Clia'd '*P' v'd 2 htr Avg end 8 $) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1),
| |
| . 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg and 88-1) .
| |
| S. Forced Outye Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipent Forced tgs/ itg ,
| |
| -2.5-10-i.S -I.0 .5 0.0 0:5 t'0 t'S 2:0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Moor.s (Moosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| BRAIDWOOD 2: Deviations from Newer Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators 4 t. Avg end $) - ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Act;otions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.4,
| |
| : 3. Significont Eves a .4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foavres (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tg/ Crit ,
| |
| -2.5-10 i.$ -i.0 -0.5 0.0 055 t'0 t'5 2$0 2.5 Devictions from Newar Plont Veens (Meosured in Stondord Cev otions)
| |
| O 23 0
| |
| | |
| 4 O
| |
| THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK O
| |
| u
| |
| | |
| FCURE 4.7 (CONT'0)
| |
| ,m
| |
| () .
| |
| Note: This is a comparison of BRAIDWOOD 2 (o newer plant) .
| |
| ogoinst older plant means.
| |
| BRAIDWOOD 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 4 tr. Avg end 8 )-
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Qtt. Avg end 88-1) . 046
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ ,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 I.5 I.0 -d.5 0 0 O!S l'O l'5 2IO 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Meons (Mecsured in Standard Devictions) 25 0
| |
| | |
| RGURE 4.0 i
| |
| C N e:t:<
| |
| BROWNS FERRY 1 -
| |
| Leaend: C:= a m "< -.-
| |
| cr,t;cci :vr s 86-2 to 88-1 """ ' C " t '' '''" " * *' P g i Automotc Scroms WW Critical 2. Sofety System ACtu tions 4 :sco e :sm
| |
| . :250 . ::so
| |
| - :mo y . :xo
| |
| : 3. g 3.
| |
| k ~
| |
| g ik ~
| |
| 3 at . . = --
| |
| i<t . .- -
| |
| 3<a.
| |
| g .
| |
| uso j 3pt. L .
| |
| eso j h
| |
| ~
| |
| ***y h l -
| |
| i.
| |
| . rso O* ]h i.
| |
| r=a0'
| |
| - . sm . vn
| |
| . :so S '
| |
| . :sc
| |
| , , , r r. ,
| |
| seLa uL 3 s. 3/-i ei- ev.3 ei-4 es-i uLa es-3 u-. ei-, i-, si.3 7.. u.i Tw - Quarter veer - t er
| |
| : 3. S.pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses
| |
| .3. g 3.
| |
| }k wt lk 3
| |
| 2 gt. L L 5 $ .." $
| |
| (
| |
| f 1 L i.
| |
| FQ g
| |
| +w J '
| |
| I gj ae- ee'-3 es-4 si-i si-2 si-3 si-4 es-i
| |
| , irG,/
| |
| ee'- ee'-3 seL4 ei-i st.: s7-3 si-4 so-i voor - Quartw voor - Quarter i
| |
| : 6. Eau nt Forceo Outoges/
| |
| : 5. For:ed Outoge Rote (t) Crit ca riotss D0 _. __ __ ..
| |
| S
| |
| ? '
| |
| 8
| |
| !b ,h h h l E '' -
| |
| i b
| |
| a f {
| |
| i a f k
| |
| ?!'
| |
| 5 at..
| |
| "kNn e. AP h y 4 5 g" '' <
| |
| y
| |
| ?'
| |
| i.
| |
| fi Q .,'
| |
| jI fh N h e [y*-
| |
| l jl '*'
| |
| 3 ) fy 2 z
| |
| II N 4 ;a
| |
| . . (I m
| |
| :o . . -
| |
| .o.
| |
| .- - - 'a-% ,
| |
| s %, m s ua w, mu s,
| |
| ,1 .
| |
| u-: es-3 u-. veo i,i.,- gt e,-37 e7-4 u-i u- u-3 u.... >-i - g 1-2 i,-. u-,
| |
| 1 l
| |
| m 1 a6 i
| |
| l l
| |
| t
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.0 r
| |
| BROWNS FERRY 1: Trends O DecGmd improved Pe'r formonCe IndICQtofS 2 t Avg end - -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o.se '
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foikres (2 Otr. Avg end 68-1) . o
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced tgs/ it Hr ,
| |
| -2.5-$.0-15 -lo-0.5 00 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from (Meosured Previous in Stondord Devictions 4 Otr. Plont )Meons BROWNS FERRY 1: Deviations .from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms WNie Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ' ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) o.n
| |
| : 3. S;gnif; cont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.r,a
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.se
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtog/ git ,
| |
| -2.5-10-15 -to-0.5 O!O O!5 t'0 t'5 20 25 Devictions from Older Plant Meons (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| O 27 o
| |
| | |
| AGURE 4.9 C tr< c::t er BRO \NNS FERRY 2 Legend: ----
| |
| ceer acri a e c;e Critical sus 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| * C " '" * " ' d'C!' g l Automot'c $crcrns Vrhb Gritcal 2. Safety System Actuot ons 4 2'00 4 2W
| |
| . 2250 2250
| |
| . 2000 3 ., d 00CC[~
| |
| I } 3.
| |
| 3 }} g. 3 500$ 3,I j, BCC !
| |
| 32- .
| |
| 1250 f %gt. . '250 000 3 ECO h- ,
| |
| ',5
| |
| # 3 [ M Q , ,
| |
| b
| |
| - 500
| |
| ] O T - 500
| |
| * . 250 . * *A 0 0 0 0 86-2 8AJ 665 4 81-18#-2 8I-3 SI-4 86ht Mk2 SN3 86-4 7-2 8 7-3 Si-4 SS-t Year = Quarter 47-1 [Mter Y ear -
| |
| : 3. Sig1fic,nt Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues e 3- 3 3. 1
| |
| -t -t i<2-s < 2.
| |
| g'-
| |
| :~
| |
| 1 - 1- [ '
| |
| E 86-2 86k3 86-4 BN-14?b2 81-3 SI-4 88 1 66k2 86k3 86-4 N 7 SS - 1 Yecr - Quarter YeorB -1
| |
| = {w-2ter87-3 87-4 1
| |
| : 6. Eau . nt Forced Outages /
| |
| S. Forcec Outcge Rote (s) Crit <cs ws no _ .
| |
| e
| |
| , y 5 '
| |
| s a0 . e 4 % G U gj ';2 .y h i % lI I $ 2 )*-
| |
| h+j?j "t Q 7 A "
| |
| >t60. I. t j'a
| |
| ~g -
| |
| R:i !f ;
| |
| g ;j s *to-s.s s-D[ , ., g y 9 ,' 9 ;4 A .n D n .
| |
| n ~~ e s ~ : :
| |
| '"i e.
| |
| i *y~
| |
| ;g . 3, k y s g{q Y * ~**''
| |
| ,_unn h ow m mum ,
| |
| u-2 -3 n- si , s1-2 41-3 ,-. u-, ,6-2 n-3 ,6-4 . ,- , , I- 2 .,- 3 7 - . u ,
| |
| Year = Qv:hier Yeor = Quar t er 23 l
| |
| l l
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.9 BROWNS FERRY 2: Trends O D'Cli"'d l*P' "'d Performance Indicat6rs t Automatic Scrws While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o 82
| |
| : 1. S gnificont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t72
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . as
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ot . Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| it
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtog/ .
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i0 -6.5 OIO OIS t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Qtr. Ploot Veons (Meosured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| BROWNS FERRY 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Ab ve Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators L Automotic Scroms While Criticel (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) " ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -t24
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -c42 l 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.4s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it i
| |
| tg/ ,
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.S -I.0 -0.5 0 0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2IO 2 5 Devictions from Oider Plant Meons (Measured in St(ndard Devictions) i O 29 i
| |
| t i
| |
| | |
| F FIGURE 4.10
| |
| - re !
| |
| BROWNS FERRY 3 Legend: ic cT Jbt A e:;e Cot,C ol ens 1 86-2 to 88-1 "" ' C" t "
| |
| * N **" 1' ,
| |
| g
| |
| : 1. Aut0mGtsC $0r@3 WN4 Crit'CCl 2. $Cfety System Actt.ctons 4 2$00 4 2$00
| |
| . 22M . 22M 20C0 ] .
| |
| ?Xo e{
| |
| : 3. g 3.
| |
| h B lh ~
| |
| g ft O
| |
| g 2 ., .
| |
| =;
| |
| 12$0 ij
| |
| $ 2.
| |
| =;
| |
| 2*c s
| |
| v
| |
| . ?$0 * . TW V7 1
| |
| O 1 d
| |
| ~
| |
| . sm . w0 2W 250 0 -
| |
| 0 0 x -
| |
| aN2 BN3 66' 4 81.t Si-2 Si.) 8,.s 88 1 O
| |
| td2 06h3 66
| |
| * 4 8/.1 Si.2 Si.3 ti 4 es.1 Ypor = QLorier Ypor = QLater
| |
| : 3. Siqnficant Events ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System roues ,
| |
| a 3. g 3.
| |
| k
| |
| -t -!
| |
| I o 2. 2 2 2 2.
| |
| . ~
| |
| W 2 4 3 NYpor . 8,.,= ,,.. ...3 .,.. .,
| |
| ..3'.....,1,.,,,.38,....,
| |
| Qtater Y eor = p t er i 6.Ece .nt r oceed outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (t) Critical Mos s o0 -
| |
| e l$ *
| |
| ?$ i h
| |
| '?
| |
| _ n .
| |
| 3 i g- =
| |
| ?
| |
| .0 .
| |
| y p,
| |
| g fC
| |
| ;'4 x:
| |
| m] k
| |
| [g p
| |
| i 4
| |
| s h 4.
| |
| 15 h j h ' i w 1, e
| |
| s a i e !!
| |
| =}<e %,
| |
| 'A 3
| |
| . a<
| |
| f l f4 %m- e.
| |
| 8 :m .+. <
| |
| , r< ,
| |
| *o -
| |
| ij wa y s 41
| |
| * Q' $
| |
| ti Wt i 5
| |
| - m j , l M. Q ,m % !
| |
| ~
| |
| . ?
| |
| ll h g IEllIcIlElIh IElIE itCIIEl g f 86296'386-4 . 8,.1 8,.3 8,.4 86-1 M-2 96 3 86 4 S, 1 (M 7 2 t,.3 t er 8, 4 SS.'
| |
| Y eor - ter Y eor --
| |
| 30 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.10 BROWNS FERRY 3: Trends -
| |
| 0 Performan'ce Indicators Declined irrecoved
| |
| .l 1 ;
| |
| 2 tr Avg e )-
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . .t;$
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foikres (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o.m S. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ itg
| |
| -2.5-2 0 -i.S -iO -6.5 0'0 0'S t'0 t'S 2'O 25 Devictions from Prev.ous 4 Otr. Pent ueons (Mecsured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| BROWNS FERRY 3: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators t Automotic Scroms While Critico)t(4 Otr. Avg end 88 ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . c.n
| |
| : 3. Sig6ficont Events (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - oss i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FoAres (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o.4 s S. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| i
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it toges/ .
| |
| -2.5 0 IS -i.0-6 5 0'0 OIS l'0 t'S 2'O 2 5 l l
| |
| victions from Oider Piont Veons (Meesured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| I O 31 t
| |
| _ _ _ __ _ _9
| |
| | |
| F!GURE 4.11 i
| |
| BRUNSWICK 1 Legend: =
| |
| $ Tet ^+m britiC 31 Hour s
| |
| - 4 cer t u %ng A + :9, I 86-2 to 88-1 I O t Automate Scrcres WP.le Critical ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations
| |
| . tM . tm ,
| |
| - # - M .*'
| |
| 3, 3_
| |
| 750 44 riso h
| |
| jh , .
| |
| at 'wh y <r
| |
| ', \ 3
| |
| . .s
| |
| ,<2.
| |
| p . 12$0 opt. 4 . e4 f3 1 "1 3 ff ;
| |
| "?
| |
| t ., ' ~
| |
| g~ t $ O -
| |
| *b j B- . = " r'g n % . =
| |
| h
| |
| ~ 2'*
| |
| 1
| |
| % . M 0 , , ,
| |
| 0 0 3 r 2- E o e6-2 36-3 es-4y?.i g'' er.3 e7-4 es.1 seks en) 36-4g/.i egei-3 e/-e se'-i 3 SipfeCorit Events 4. Sofety System Foues ,
| |
| -3. g 3.
| |
| 4 IE {}. y
| |
| -t 3< . 4 pa l r j'
| |
| , , , -- 9. _ , ,,
| |
| wA q 7 7 ,
| |
| g y , Q-f i ; ? ?
| |
| 1 m- , , . w e 36'-2 eA3 ede v s,i.t f
| |
| - L.2 e.,7-3 i ei-4 GNt est e6'-3 so-e 7 e,/.1 f
| |
| L.2 i,07 3 e7-4 es.1 ,
| |
| : 6. Ecp - t Forced Outoges/
| |
| S. Forced Outcne Rote (s) Critc:s this E ao - h e.
| |
| g&
| |
| 2&
| |
| !t h<t = . 34 35 $ I'-
| |
| i f ** - f 'a s
| |
| 4 m .
| |
| 05 e o' x , J m. o n _ (T o o 7 2 o'.) e?.e se i est so-3 es-4 sr.i a7 2 er.3 s?.. es.i 36 3 es.3 e6'
| |
| * e7-i voor *6,ater Y ear - Qwrter -
| |
| l t
| |
| 32 l
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| FOURE 4.11 BRUNSWICK 1: Trends -
| |
| e .-O ocho w oved
| |
| , Performance indicators 2ktrSIvg end Sh - 173
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- t4:
| |
| : 3. Sigrtficont Events (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . .c.54
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- c.71
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - g o.77 yr/. " 6. Equipment Forced tg/ it Hrs ,
| |
| _ 154 gA U \
| |
| -2.5-i.0-LS -i.0 -uS 03 0:5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Ott. P'cnt M .
| |
| (Mecsvred in Stonoord Devictions) eces ,
| |
| 4 BRUNSWICK 1: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. At>ove Avg. Perf.
| |
| . Performance IndicotorS
| |
| : 1. Automet'gSpy WNgcgg. ,,,
| |
| 1
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- .t24
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .ts2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foikses (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -tn
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- c.o?
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it teg/ , 43, l.3-i5 -to-U S O'O O!S t'0 t'5 210 15
| |
| -2.5 Dev4tions frem Oider Piont Veons (Mecsured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| O 33 a
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.12 c:I Q incicate< l BRUNSWICK 2 Legend: c'ee' ac t ^'e'm Criticcl Hours i
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| ^ Ouo't " Mo M ^ " 'c!* g 1
| |
| : 1. AutomCtic ScfCrns Whre CntM 2. Scfety System Acttotions 4 2500 4 :Scw)
| |
| - 2250 - 2:so
| |
| .sr l
| |
| 3- s%' -/ -
| |
| 33-s '
| |
| y
| |
| $) -
| |
| =$ ij -
| |
| =$
| |
| r 1
| |
| gt.
| |
| cso } 'g2- 1 -
| |
| :so }
| |
| ji "I i n 5 - _-m3 1
| |
| m 1 3 , ,' ,
| |
| ,~
| |
| Il
| |
| -4 9
| |
| ( -
| |
| 5m 250 I
| |
| i MF d
| |
| $\Q
| |
| ;g soo 250
| |
| @ 'e ,kY o m M ,, o o F '
| |
| e aA2 ei-3 se'-4 al-i si-2 si-a a7L4 as-i e6L2 esa si., ai-i s/-2 si-s a7'-4 sa'- i (
| |
| Year - Owter Yeer - ovarter
| |
| : 3. Sicrificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foltres
| |
| & i k
| |
| "I ') e+
| |
| y2-c2- f(h .L hb V k
| |
| : i. 1. h $%' '"
| |
| N / h I k E & l, o ni ~ Tr o @ hk sekt esL 3 66L 4 sl-1 si-2 87-3 ei-4 ad-i sit seks seks al-1 s/-2 si-3 si-4 es-i .
| |
| i 1sor - Qwter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eauoment Fcreed Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcx;e Fate (z) 1000 Crit.cd Hous 2 m- h it 3'~t ,
| |
| gI "- se !! E ae 21 -
| |
| tr*-
| |
| i 36
| |
| , 2 ,,
| |
| (
| |
| g 1 a &s
| |
| : - . ,- a m x'*'
| |
| i 20 -
| |
| %h i Nt J y
| |
| 2, A K u y
| |
| m'
| |
| ^
| |
| k*Bk" mo n, c u.
| |
| sa-i j es-2 ei-3 ei-4g -i sgsj-3 af-4 es-i si-2 e6-3 es,4gi-i ags;-3 s7'-4 y
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.12 oN.) BRUNSWICK 2: Trends D*Cii"*d '*0' "'d Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While C'itical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 058
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . j$f i
| |
| ~ms
| |
| : 3. Significant Ever.ts (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -249
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . oso
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.gi
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced tgs/ it , _g
| |
| -2.5-i.0-1.5-i.0-0.50.0 05 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devict' ns from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons osured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| BRUNSWICK 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ~
| |
| L Automoti Scroms While Criticol ys9' f4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - gp'ggf t28
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - tii
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -[;' k -122
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.48
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.71
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / itgg j _g
| |
| -2.5 -i.0 - i.5 -to -d.5 0 0 0'.5 t'0 1.'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Meons (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) b v
| |
| 35
| |
| . _ .- _ _ _ _ .- n_
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.13 m ino:cet y !
| |
| BYRON 1 Legend: Oicer P e t 4 Cnticci Hogs c;e 36-2 to 88-1
| |
| ""' 4 0*'t" h o9 ^"rc9' g
| |
| : 1. AutomCtic Scroms While Critic 01 2. Sofety System Actuations 4 2500 4 ;$oo
| |
| - 223o ' ;g
| |
| . $' \ A ~
| |
| \ s -
| |
| 2om ] g*~ \ / -
| |
| 2mo t I g' ~ '\v,/, ~,
| |
| nso} jg \./ -
| |
| esoj
| |
| !! - -; i;
| |
| *2-g2- - 125 o . i;5o ji 's..
| |
| ; j 's s.]
| |
| =3 1.,
| |
| ~
| |
| b i 1 .
| |
| 1
| |
| - 500 $ T - soo 0 ,
| |
| o o 86-266-3864 k SY-18/=2 SI-3 6/-4 86'-1 86b2 66b 3 86-4 8/=18/-2 8I-3 8/-4 6$-1 Yeor - Quorter Ysor - Quorter
| |
| : 3. Si<;pficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Folues .
| |
| 2 3 3- = 3- $
| |
| !k jk $
| |
| n
| |
| -t
| |
| ~<
| |
| -t< er e2- 4 *r-e d
| |
| : I '-
| |
| fi \
| |
| a s
| |
| !~
| |
| g d '% o s
| |
| [L e6b2 e6'-3 ei-4 al-1 / e6'-2 es' 3 e6L4 af-i ei-2 si-3 si-4 Si-i Year L-t ei-3 ter ei-4 es-1 Yeor - Quarty /
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (t) 1000 Critco Hours 3 so - h
| |
| . g .-
| |
| !E I 3e f <1 a - s<
| |
| bD IE'"
| |
| 1v .h d 24 h 2~
| |
| to - s h ~s h a 1 2 , oo -
| |
| l 86-286k386-4 ! Sd -1 Sf-2 Si-3 8f-4 8$-1 84-2 SS-3 86k 4 81-1 Si-2 87-3 SI 4 88 -1 Yeor - Quorter Yect - Quor ter 36
| |
| | |
| ~ -
| |
| FIGURE 4.13 n
| |
| s i BYRON 1: Trends v ,
| |
| ' Performance Indicators D'C'i"'d '*P' v'd
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical 0.5s (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1)- 1
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.5s
| |
| : 4. Safety System failures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 0.5s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.86
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs. 3 (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-i.0-t5 -to -0.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2C 23 Devictions (Measuredfrom Previous in Stondard 4 Otr. Piont )Means Devictions j B ( R O N 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators .
| |
| f4 tr. Avg e )- -oJ6 (
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - j 0.n
| |
| .e
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -ts2 .
| |
| : 4. Safety System failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.4s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 0.70
| |
| : 6. Ee,vipment Forced it 07' togs / 88 $) -
| |
| -2.5-2.0 ~I.5 -i.0 -d.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Meons (Measured in Stenderd Devictions)
| |
| : a V
| |
| 37 a
| |
| | |
| d FIGURE 4.14 u indic: tor l BYRON 2 Legend: c:cer Picnt A ere;e ;
| |
| --- Newer Plcnt Average criticci Hovs 86-2 to 88-1 - 4 Oucrter Moving Avereje t Automatic Scrarns Wh4 Criticci 2: Sofety System Actu: tons 4 2500 4 2S00
| |
| - 2250 2250
| |
| /
| |
| " ~
| |
| l 3.
| |
| $ /
| |
| - r7s0
| |
| * f 3~
| |
| /
| |
| /
| |
| i,30 '
| |
| 8 / s y!
| |
| l.
| |
| s '* # ' /
| |
| 's 200 '. j <! % .,, / . c00 .*
| |
| i g2- ) --
| |
| 1230 h o g2- ,] , -
| |
| A) t2*
| |
| j l! -
| |
| \ - "a i 750
| |
| * i $ -
| |
| ** i 750 S 4 1 ,'- O
| |
| / 2 v
| |
| : i. .
| |
| : i. y 0 0 0 86k 2 86k3 86-4 8/-t 8/-2 8I-3 8I-4 SS'-1 86'284-3864
| |
| - 5 8/=18/-2 8I-3 8I-4 85-1 Yect - Quorter Ys0r - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sigraficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety Sys'em Fokses
| |
| .'3. . 3.
| |
| -e -e 3*2-3 2<2 3
| |
| 2 1 1 1 [
| |
| 0 w
| |
| 86L 2 86k 3 k I
| |
| 86 4 8/-18/-2 8/-3 si-a 88'-t M 0 dhh( k 86'286386'-4
| |
| ^
| |
| 8/-i si-2 si-3 S -4i ss'-1 Yect - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (t) Crit <3 Hoys 00 8 I
| |
| 5 80 - g
| |
| *h D 60 - TU h
| |
| h4
| |
| ~,
| |
| si w x4 bb ~h 2_$ , 2J.
| |
| , & W w g 5 f ?
| |
| l 20 . p 3
| |
| 7 y'b m Q'':.,
| |
| ;7
| |
| -==-9 44 f
| |
| l 0 b A 0 86'-2 86k3 86'-4 87'-18I-28I-387'-4 88' 1 84-2 86'-3 s6'-4 87 1 Si-2 Si-3 si-4 *i -1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Onter i 38 t
| |
| | |
| -J FIGURE 4.14 BYRON 2: Trends
| |
| (')
| |
| v .
| |
| Performance Indicators D'C'i 'd l*Pr v'd
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical c.67 (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -t73
| |
| : 3. Sigrificant Events (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - -t72
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . o.go
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 12
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / git , n,,o
| |
| -2.5-i.0-I.5 -i.0 -d.5 0 0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Deviations (Measured from Previous in Standard 4 otr. Plant )Meons Devictions ,
| |
| BYRON 2: Deviations frorn Newer Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ''^ "
| |
| oJS 4 hr. Avg e -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . o.it
| |
| : 3. Significont aents (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.So
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o 69
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c.67
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-1.5-i.0-0.50.0 05 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Oevictions from Newer Plcnt Meons
| |
| ' (Measured in Stonderd Deviations) l (% ))
| |
| 39 l
| |
| t __
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| t O
| |
| i i
| |
| THIS 1 1
| |
| PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK l
| |
| l 0-40 I
| |
| | |
| L ,
| |
| . .g FIGURE 4.14 (CONTO)
| |
| El ,
| |
| L Note: This is. a comparison of BYRON 2 - (a newer plant) .
| |
| against older plant means.
| |
| t BYRON 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators f4Ot Avg 8 $) - -t92 .
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -t24
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.55 5 Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.is
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Crit togs / 33T ij - -t94
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0'O O'.5 l'O t'5 2 0 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont Mecns (Mecsured in Stenderd Devictions)
| |
| {J.
| |
| 41
| |
| ;q.
| |
| | |
| e FIGURE 4,15 w'
| |
| Indicotcr CALLAWAY Legend: oieu mcrt 4 - c;e Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1 "" 4 0*r t " *'m ^* o it t Autornatic Scrorns Wh4 Critical ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety Systern Actuations g$og
| |
| , .50o 4
| |
| ;p M
| |
| h
| |
| - 2250 A
| |
| . ;50 k/ //
| |
| ~
| |
| b l 3-
| |
| [ ~
| |
| #3 ino ' gg 173 o '
| |
| l}3- -
| |
| ~
| |
| $g =$ =$
| |
| $1 pt-
| |
| ./ g 2 1250 f ij op2- /
| |
| /\
| |
| 'g
| |
| . r2n 3
| |
| 1-
| |
| % h Q % -
| |
| N g
| |
| - ,"50 y? jj 1-e
| |
| * t
| |
| =3 750 T O
| |
| I N - - 2 2 a o n a #
| |
| n o -
| |
| soi tesL 3 86L4 eI-1 s/-2 e7L3 si-4 s$-1 66L 2 seL3 e6L4 el-t /-2si-3e/-aea'-i ter Year - Quarter Year -
| |
| : 3. Sigificont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety Systern Fokres
| |
| - - : 3- A44 1& g& 4
| |
| -! g m
| |
| W
| |
| -< <! 3 m2- x2- % $
| |
| * 2 1- f 1-
| |
| ' [f&p ,
| |
| Q' Qi
| |
| =
| |
| 's4 % y
| |
| , h i \
| |
| g e o i
| |
| L k L 8I-1 si-2 SI-3 8/-4 88'-1 662663864 86L 2 Soh3 86-4 year -
| |
| 8I-1 12ger Si-3 SI-. 68-1 Year - Georter 6 Eau nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (*) Critico Mcus -
| |
| i e
| |
| E m- &
| |
| ~
| |
| h
| |
| &<t * - a<
| |
| b5 $5*'
| |
| Tj g
| |
| '- j ta
| |
| - 2- 1 20 -
| |
| 4 sp {is, ,g 4 w gww 3 es o
| |
| 'T,,A r1-,,,. , ,M o_ ?E +I s@
| |
| - ,-. ,,-, -, n, -. 1.,,,-, ,-,,,.. n ,
| |
| f ear - yter Yecr - Quarter 42 l
| |
| | |
| RGURE 4.15 l-l CALLAWAY: Trends Declined irnproved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - -238
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 3.75
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.ga
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foiives (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.33
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _3.77
| |
| : 6. Equipment _ Forced C it togs / , g, ,,
| |
| -2.5-i0-I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons (Meosured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| CALLAWAY: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^ -oJ2 4 o't . vg nd N#$) - j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .- -t.24
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.42 k N
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) f' -2.21 ,
| |
| : 5. F(vced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.52
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it teg/1000 sgTij - o 21 2
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 I.5 -i.0 -d.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Deviations from Okfer Plont Meons (Mecsured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| (3 O
| |
| 43 0
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.16 W IndiC 0t or CALVERT CLFFS 1 Legend: cee a' cat o vese Cntical Hours 86--2 to 88--1 """*"
| |
| ' 0' ''" MC"ia7 ^**'cj' g
| |
| t Autornatic Scrorns Wrik Critical 2. Sofety System Actwtons 4 2500 4 2:00
| |
| - 2250 - 2250 3 ,p*** - 2000 p,.<*' _ m 3_
| |
| * h 'q . 1750 g , 1750 2
| |
| e M.
| |
| 2 q$g p2- -a
| |
| : 2. _ CSO j
| |
| ,@M I -
| |
| coo 3 . Ox 3 R 3 .W v
| |
| ~
| |
| \
| |
| f:M - * -. -
| |
| # . 250 pg
| |
| % - 250 g .
| |
| g g g 8A2 86k 3 86-4 8/-t 8/-2 8/-3 8/-4 88-1 86' 2 8A3 86'-4 8/-i SY-2 8/-3 8/-4 88-1 Yeor - Ourter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sgrificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses a 3- 3 3. d k5 ws $5 w a k
| |
| s
| |
| ~A 34 g2-g2- h.
| |
| 5 ?t b t-i.
| |
| aw%gin t 1 +-
| |
| ^
| |
| U e 86L2 -86' 3 L86 4gi-t 8g8i-3 8/-4 85-i ri-2 86'-3 86g/-i gei-3 8/-4 88-i j
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced Outeges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rate (x) 1000 Cnted Hours CO 8 n S
| |
| ?, So . g 3E*
| |
| g'E 4' . 3!
| |
| I< * -
| |
| ~x b
| |
| g a<
| |
| w x*_
| |
| D w -r D 35 "~ k f5 2
| |
| to - ) --- 3>-
| |
| , z_ ?
| |
| - W>m^z ,
| |
| oc sm L mm -
| |
| 86k2 k 86 k3 86 e Si-i 87k2 Si-3SI-* 88-i 86'-286-3864 Si-t 8f-2 ei-3 Si-4 88'-1 Yeor - Quorter Yecr - Quor ter 44 I
| |
| | |
| M FIGURE 4.16 o CALVERT CLIFFS 1: Trends
| |
| \ .) ,
| |
| Performance Indicators 0*C'i"*d '*P' "*d
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical oM (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ og
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 141
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 'h v
| |
| as
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.82
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ , gy
| |
| -2.5-$.0-I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'O l'S 2'0 2.5 Cevictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) ,
| |
| CALVERT CLIFFS 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms While Critical 4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.86gp
| |
| 'l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . j o33 i
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -3.22
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.se
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it W tg/ g$,yj , g,,
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-i.5-I.0-0500 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2IO 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Veons (Measured in Stondord Devictions) 0\
| |
| v 45
| |
| _ _ _ _ _ _ n
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.17 1 1 ircC0 tor CALVERT CLIFFS 2 Legend: car mont **er=e Criticot Hoi.rs 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| - 4 0*'t"
| |
| * N ^"'oj' g
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms W?ile Crit'c d 2. Sofety System Actuctions 4 2SCO 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 - **!c
| |
| ***9.'' N - 2000 '*g..- '\ - z"
| |
| \ ~ 1750 \. - 1750 '
| |
| 3 "3 \ 3 3.<! - 1500 '
| |
| * j <! '\s' . SM 'o
| |
| *2- r;so g -
| |
| G$oh oy2- -
| |
| jj
| |
| - a i j -
| |
| - a
| |
| ,~ - , , , -
| |
| y "i(E -
| |
| WP"E - soo { . 300 0 - - - "
| |
| 0 0 --
| |
| 0 66L I 86L3 66 4L 8/-14/-2 8/-3 SI-4 88'- t 86L2 86 L 3k 56 4 8/-t ei-2 87b3 af 4 8$-t Yeor - Qu7ter Yeor - Quarter 1 SiqpifiCont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Folures a 3- g 3.
| |
| -e -t o" g
| |
| }"''
| |
| g?'" 5 15 l b5
| |
| \
| |
| ?
| |
| ss dw t
| |
| & 0 f ';i O .
| |
| Sh2 86' 3 86L 4 SY-1 SI-2 SI-3 8/-4 88-1 66L2 86'-3 86'-4 8/=1 Si-2 Si-3 8/-4 88 -1 Yeor - Qu7ter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (z) Crited Hous oo 8 3 80 -
| |
| o 3!
| |
| }<) x 6o - 6 B<
| |
| we-b ab b"
| |
| ? b "' {$
| |
| 6 w 2. N
| |
| % 09 0 94 0 d _
| |
| O 66' 2 86-3 86-4 87-1 of-2 si-3 87-4 88-t
| |
| - 56'-2 86-3 66'- 4 87-1 ei-2 87-3 67-4 SS - 1 Yeor - Qu& t ar Year - Quorter 46 1
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.17
| |
| -- .' CALVERT -CLIFFS 2: Trends
| |
| -( )
| |
| DecGned Irnproved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whibe Critical I (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -a3 l 2.. Scf ety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - $' O.58
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . $]E t41
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - hm 0.56
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) f'ff 'f -6.13
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ Cjit , g 3,
| |
| -2.5-2.0.-1.5 -i.0 -A.5 0.0 Oh t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons (Mecsured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| CALVERT CLIFFS 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| . Performance Indicators
| |
| ' Automatic Scroms While Criticoi
| |
| 'P (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.86 u l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ a33 a r
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - Ns! n)O -3.22
| |
| -s ; & f$ e
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.90
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.64
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it to g / 0 , 4 n,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -t5 -t0 -0.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t5 2.0 2.5 Devictions. from Oider Piont Meons (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) m 47 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.18 m incicetc7 l CATAWBA 1 Legend: c'er ~ "' ''e m i Criticcl Hours 86-2 to 88-i ==== 4 cuarte my ae ;e
| |
| : 1. AutomCtic Scrarns Whne CritiCd 2. Sofety System Actuot:Ons 4 ._
| |
| 2'00 4 2500 e
| |
| [h . 2250 - 2250 N
| |
| h) / - 2000 "c .%
| |
| y 3- '% '
| |
| g 3. 2000 }=
| |
| 750 5 -
| |
| g jh - 1750 N)t
| |
| _< .. - 2 00 -' '~5 y< - 300 m'
| |
| * I p2- b. - t250 o32- - f250 g -* :
| |
| :,' .. 3 . y n'" 1 5 1 ,t , i "
| |
| * d
| |
| ,- 1 M[j $(T4 .M - 500
| |
| ."S y 'c A
| |
| Q) g+'
| |
| . sco h T.
| |
| Lv Q :
| |
| - 250 g,\ . 250 o b a b L G 0 0
| |
| *' ' "l '' 0 86L2 86 L 3L86 4 81-18Y-2 8/-3 8/-4 86-1 86L 2 S6ka 86 L 4 Si-1 Si-2 ti-3 Si-4 85-t Year - Quarter Yeor - Qwrter 1 Si<pficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses a 3. g 3.
| |
| h
| |
| -t -t#
| |
| o# ,2 o 2 2
| |
| : 32. 32. ,
| |
| a 8 4
| |
| . h q4 + w4 *x x
| |
| ; e o s 1 4 86L2 86 L 3 86'-4 Sl-18Y-2 SY-3 Si-4 8$-1 86L 2 86L3 86 L 4 81-18Y-2 ei-3 si-4 SS-i Yeor - Quarter Year - Quo ter l
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outg Rote (t) 1000 Crit.<d Hours 10 0 8 90 80 .
| |
| j& 5 d
| |
| i~ ,
| |
| t a. 31 . . ,
| |
| h4 m 34 4 26 -
| |
| is ' <) t''
| |
| }e $ #
| |
| , j 40 - 2v 9 4 Q
| |
| : 2. 185 20 - :
| |
| -4 A ) s.ls g i }Y { e 5f 148 _-
| |
| p,
| |
| &yf;w A :
| |
| :h w-
| |
| ?'
| |
| e;.
| |
| 1
| |
| ..- -s
| |
| . {' y D% G c
| |
| .q @ 2 :
| |
| 1 p, L_Q s O ,9 s t] pg_-{="" { ""*(*]_
| |
| 86k 286386-4 L 87-18I-2 8f-3 Si-4 8$-1 k k 86286386'-4 Si-187-2 Si-3 Sf-4 88 -1 Yeor - Quorter Yeor - Quorter 48 1
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.18 l i
| |
| o CATAWBA 1: Trends V oectined improved
| |
| . Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical ' "%MW (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ~gq L73
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg eno 88-1) . .t73
| |
| : 3. S;gnificant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _o.go
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 6.62
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / _ 1,7
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 0:5 t'0 .t'5 2'.0 2.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Means (Measured in Stonderd Deviations) ,
| |
| CATAWBA 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators
| |
| ^'
| |
| * f4Otf.Av ( - 021
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (' Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.46
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 7tr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.98
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) , - 0.14
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -145
| |
| : 6. Equipnent Forced it tog / 3pj_ _339
| |
| -2.5-2.0 i.5 -to -d.5 0 0 r 5 LD t'5 2'O 2.5 Deviations from Old' r Plant Meons (Mecsured in Stonc/d Devictions) l O 49 t
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.19 Cr'::D indicator l CATAWBA 2 Legend: oicer Picat 4 erc;e Critical He tt s 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| """ 4 U" ' " * "3 ^ "' ' i." g i Automatic Scrcrrs WNie Critied 2. Sofety System Actucticca.
| |
| 4 230, 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| . 2000 ~ . 2mo -
| |
| . ' s' .
| |
| = h 3.
| |
| 3-
| |
| =Q3 l
| |
| j N ,- -
| |
| 3 g ,
| |
| ~.N , .a,\ -
| |
| Ji}e .
| |
| V _ em .-
| |
| s<e
| |
| * m2. * *
| |
| * a 2- .,2 .
| |
| cso h i2so }
| |
| ***}
| |
| ***}
| |
| ,~ - s ; q ,
| |
| 6 ,~ , , , a -
| |
| -a
| |
| ! ,,, ds k 1 - 500 Q 7 [ h' - 500 l ; # tj RN m yte ~
| |
| so g
| |
| a L x x u
| |
| E o
| |
| a u =
| |
| : s-ss in. o o o eA2 esL 3 aA4 s/-i ei-2 s/ , si-4 e41 8A2e63eA4L s/-i ei-2 ei-3 si-4 asii Year - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sgificant Events ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System Foltres
| |
| .3. g 3.
| |
| -e -e 2g < 2. ,
| |
| 3<2g h ' '
| |
| 1~ i~
| |
| o k k' if i
| |
| d' o --
| |
| dLkg i '"' * '' ''
| |
| 86E 2"k' L N3 86 5 4 SI-18Y-2 6/-? 6/-4 SS
| |
| * 86-2 86h 3 Sehe 81-18Y-2 S/-3 Si-4 88 -i ,
| |
| Yeor - Quarter Ytor - Quarter 8
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outo;e Rote (*) 1000 Crited Hours 10 0 e .,
| |
| . . p
| |
| , = . , ,
| |
| . s. u l
| |
| 5
| |
| =5
| |
| = .o i n& . 7, a 7
| |
| ~
| |
| E4 54 7 54 s .
| |
| 3: 4s
| |
| $ S c'- ~
| |
| 21 4o- A a 3, o j ^ ,e 0 w
| |
| s- 4
| |
| * L5 w
| |
| 2
| |
| 's a
| |
| EN P a ;
| |
| a e 20 - ih p% - '$k g k 1 '
| |
| f h y- g w er --. 5
| |
| * n5t+tW *
| |
| : il 1] hAR o a B t r
| |
| e6-2 si-3 e64 sf-t si-2 si-3 af-4 as-i e6-2 ess si-4 ai-i si-2 ei-3 s7-4 s4-i Yecr - Quarter Year - Oucrter 50 t,
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.19
| |
| -o CATAWBA 2: Trends
| |
| ] D*C'.'ned imoreved Performonc'e Indicotors
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticci (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i; tt5
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -173
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.se - '
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _i hlk[l[
| |
| ; da l S. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _o.23
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs / 0 it Hr
| |
| , j 9p sue
| |
| -2.5-i.0-I.5 I.0 -O.5 0.0 0 5 i0 i52'.02.5 .
| |
| Devictions (Measured from Previous in Stondord 4 Otr. Plant )Means Devictions ,
| |
| CATAWBA 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scrom? Whde Crit lcci 4 Otr. Avg end 38-1) - -dJ2 j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ _o.4 s
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avo end 88-1) - -o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo3ures (4 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) - c.2 ?
| |
| .__. g
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - _ t4 r-- mw ruew e
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| _ y,3,
| |
| -2.5-I.0 -i.5 I.0 -0.5 0 0 O!5 io US 20 2.5 Devictions from Older Ptont Meons (Meestted in Stoncord Devictions)
| |
| I v 51
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.20 c:=:3 incieeter l CLINTON 1 Legend: Cicer P!ont Average Ne ner Flont Average criticci sous 86-2 to 88-1 muummu 4 Quorter Moving Avery,e
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scroms WWle Criticol 2. Sofety System Actu0tions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| . 2250 ., 2:M e
| |
| g 83.
| |
| 5
| |
| 'no 2 3.
| |
| It 11 3
| |
| p 'g / - ''S ;
| |
| 31 i4 . co0 --
| |
| ? <!
| |
| . w-.
| |
| g2- ./- - 1250
| |
| 'g2- \, - C50 f3 l
| |
| "]
| |
| 750 -
| |
| 3 hk[
| |
| ij
| |
| "}
| |
| 750 -
| |
| ~
| |
| 500 --
| |
| . 500
| |
| ' 2M t # . 250 / 'f A -
| |
| 0 ! Y d O O N'I 0
| |
| b b 86206366'-46/-1 it 8/-3 8/-4 6$-1 86k 2 Sok3 86 i 4 8/-l ti-2 8/-3 ei-4 85-t Year - ter Yeor - Quarter 3 Sigificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fok.res
| |
| = 3- = 3- A1 f5 $
| |
| }$
| |
| wt u n W 5$
| |
| -4 .4 [h N
| |
| *t.
| |
| g gt. y {f 5 E 4
| |
| h/ h
| |
| '. E g
| |
| 1-
| |
| # f'jf-Q n > a A
| |
| $ $ h' a N 0 ,-- ' t , 7 , ,
| |
| , ES - 1 06-2 66-3 86.-4 87-1 87-2 67-3 61-4 W1 . 87 Year - 0;arter 86-2 66-3 S6"eor Y 157-2 Quarter 87-3 87-4 ;
| |
| : 5. Equement Fcreed Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcne Rcte (s) 1000 Crited Hours I' e0 8 -
| |
| * I
| |
| & M- t 6.
| |
| It f<! 60 - s<
| |
| hs I~
| |
| ij e- 37 8j s- T 1 w
| |
| } 2. ,,,
| |
| -- t 11
| |
| }[
| |
| -3 .
| |
| g jd N d n 2 i$$ ' _
| |
| so'-2 e6-3 L e6 4 si-i sf-2 si-3 ei-4 es-i e6-2 e6-3 e6-4 sf-i si-2 si-3 s7-4 so-i Year - Quarter Year - ovorter l
| |
| 52
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.20 o CLINTON 1: Trends
| |
| ~I .
| |
| Declined improved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti9 Scroms While Critical t2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - 0.69
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.go
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.58
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t22
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 2.79 I
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs /to it 88 ij - 3.76 f
| |
| l .
| |
| -2.5-io-15 -i.0 -d.5 0 0 0 5 l'O t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions (M90sured from Previous in Standard 4 Otr. Plont )Meons Devictions CLINTON 1: Deviations from Newer Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical 031 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 1
| |
| : 2. Sciety System Actuotions (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . o,it l
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end P8-1) - t
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o $o N
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 0.34
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ 33Q yj , g ,,
| |
| -2.5-iO -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Newer Plont Meons (Mcosured in Stonderd Deviations)
| |
| (a3 53 l
| |
| _c
| |
| | |
| O THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY I
| |
| BLANK O
| |
| 54 1
| |
| | |
| t FIGURE 4.20- (CONT'0)
| |
| Note: This is a comparison of CLINTON 1 (a newer plant) -
| |
| against older plant means.
| |
| CLINTON 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators ,
| |
| 1 Automctic Scroms WNie Critieni (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -2.46
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuctions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -t24 P
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (4 Ctt. Avg end 89-1) . o.9s
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilures (4 Otr. Avg 2nd 68-1) . - ta6
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.32
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs /10 ,
| |
| i.
| |
| ! -2.5 -1.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0'O O'.5 t'0 t'5 2!0 2.5 Deviations from Older Picnt Meces (Mecsured in Standard Deviations)
| |
| ?\
| |
| ! U 55 R._.
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.21 C"::-) indicctor COOK 1 Leaend: Older Picnt Avere;e Criticci Hovs 86-2 to 88-1 """ ' 0" t '' * *'W ^ "' 9' g
| |
| : 1. Autornctic Scroms WhW Crit. cot 2. Sofety Systeen Actuotons a 25cc 4 :w
| |
| . 2250 - 2250 el% \ r**** _
| |
| g 3 ''
| |
| * g 3 *g .h 3 .
| |
| \ [
| |
| 5h
| |
| - - 1750 gg j
| |
| - 1750
| |
| !!'g2- /, -
| |
| 1250 i;
| |
| og2-
| |
| / -
| |
| f250 f ji , K 1 i
| |
| *1 1
| |
| ,~
| |
| *5
| |
| \ _ .
| |
| U - SCO - 500
| |
| - 250 - 250 0
| |
| >" 0 0
| |
| \
| |
| 0 8A2 86h 3 68k 4 8/-18/-2 8/-3 8/-4 88-1 86L2 86k3 86 L 4 8/-l of-2 SI-3 Si-4 8d-1 Year - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. SipfiCont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Scfety Systern Foues e 3- 3 3-h jh at
| |
| -1 g2- y2. h is I- '-
| |
| - - - t 86b 2 Ceb3 de BN-l 8/-2 S/-3 8/-4 8$-1 f e-2 66'- J $be 8h=1 $/ 2 ti-3 N-4 84 - 0 l
| |
| Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Cwter
| |
| : 6. Lod .ent Forcyl OutcyJ
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcgs Rate (4) Criti.1 Mcus to- 4 - - - , _
| |
| b 80 - s-g&
| |
| #1 31 I<1 80 - a<
| |
| as tr'-
| |
| Tj ' - 32 j B k I'Y w 2- 165 7.39 Y
| |
| O- '1 f"' q 7
| |
| ;' h w b o
| |
| '* ' _j __
| |
| o C I"'l O 86286386-4 L L SY-1 Si-2 8/-3 Si-4 58-1 86'-286k386'-4 87'-1 Si-2 87i3 SI-4 $8 - 1 Yect - Quarter Yeor - Quorter I
| |
| 56 l
| |
| l l
| |
| t'
| |
| | |
| -l FIGURE 4.21 O C O O K 1: Trends V ,
| |
| Declined improved
| |
| - Performance Indicators i
| |
| t Automotic Scroms While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -1
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . s i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -
| |
| o.sa ,
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 47
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced tgs/10 it Hr
| |
| _ - ('- g, ,,
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -i.0 -0.5 O!O 05 UO 1.'52!O2.5
| |
| . Devictions (Measured from Previous in Stenderd 4 Otr. Picnt )Meons Devictions ;
| |
| COOK 1: Deviations from : Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators t Automotic Scroms While Critical -0.32 l
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg erd 88-1) - j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- ut
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg erd 88-1) .- -042 l
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fdres (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . g
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1)- 0.42
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tg/ it , g3 {
| |
| 2
| |
| -2.5 -2' .0 i.0 -0.5 0 0 O!S 1.'O i5 2'.02.5 Cevictions from Older Picot Meces (Mecsured in Stonderd Devictions) v 57 m
| |
| | |
| (
| |
| s' FIGURE 4.22 M ledCCtor !
| |
| Legend: ce'' ac < ^ -'c;*
| |
| COOK 2~ Criticcl Hotts 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| """" 4 0 " '" " "9 ^ "' i' g 1 Automatic Scroms WNe Cnted 2. Safety System Actuctions ;500 4 2500 4
| |
| . 2250 . 2250
| |
| /* / _
| |
| ,..' ,. ,yy h
| |
| : 3. \ gonn f' h 3- \ [ r g - 1750 gg \ . 1750
| |
| * JIe
| |
| .4
| |
| /g g2
| |
| _ em 3
| |
| - y <y \. ^.s . e. 3-
| |
| *2-p _
| |
| rao j sp2- Nj _
| |
| r250 )
| |
| jj ,'
| |
| i 1
| |
| ,~ t 1
| |
| ~
| |
| a d b >< . 500 [ . 500 g '. O O (
| |
| 88k2 86=*
| |
| ! SN4 8M-18Y-2 8Y-3 $Y-4 86-1 k 86'-256386-4 SI-1 Si-2 Gi-3 ei 4 88'- t Year - Qtorter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sgrnficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Falures .
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| kh $k
| |
| -)
| |
| w).
| |
| z<2-g 2< p 2.
| |
| $ 5
| |
| : v. t, f
| |
| Y1 s's N ,:
| |
| er y e se 5ap===mmeurus o ,
| |
| ,l , , % , ,
| |
| o__g_, ,
| |
| h'1 86-1 86-286386-4 8I-l Si-2 87-3 87-4 SS-1 f 86-2 86-3vu 86 8Y-1 ter h7-2 87-3 87-4 year - Otryter
| |
| : 5. forced Ovtop Rote (s) 6. Equb-ment Fcreed Orited Outoges/
| |
| Hours
| |
| : m. 8
| |
| $ BC - V 8 h
| |
| "1=_
| |
| f<
| |
| a<
| |
| - 6 34 85 b ij "- Ej 2" 6
| |
| t 23 1 w 2- 2
| |
| ~
| |
| o A 2 0 J 86L2 86k 3 86'-4 81-1 Si-2 8I-3 Gi-4 86-1 86-2 86-3 86'-4 8/-t 87-2 87-3 87-4 88 -1 .
| |
| Yeor - Quarter Yect - Quarter l J
| |
| sa 1
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.22 (Y . COOK 2: Trends V .
| |
| Performance Indicators D*Cli"'d '*Pr "'d
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scroms While Critical (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - o.5
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.58
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.sg
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.ce
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced tgs/ itg3Qsj- 0.75
| |
| -2.5-i.O-t5 -to -0.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'0 2.5 .
| |
| Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Pbnt Me::ns j
| |
| (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| COOK 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means ,
| |
| B&w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 4 Otr Avg end f) - - 139
| |
| [
| |
| : 2. Scfety S/stem Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ae.g
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) - on
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o og
| |
| : 6. Eq;pment Forced tog / it ,
| |
| -2.5-l.0-15 -to .5 0'O O'5 t'0 t '' . 'O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont : L: t (Meosured in Stondord Devit - M
| |
| ! v 59 L .- ,
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.23 m m e: tor I COOPER STATION Legend: c'ce meat s ere;-
| |
| Critical Hours j 86-2 to 88-1 """ 4 0" ' " * '' ^9 ^ "' c 7 h 1 Automatic Scrans WNie Critical 2. Sofety System Actwtaons 4 _
| |
| 2s00 4 *$00 2250 2250
| |
| .k[~
| |
| --*** . . 2000 2000}
| |
| 1- 3
| |
| =; y,- 2; g ,
| |
| ai
| |
| . s<i e 1 r,
| |
| a \_ -
| |
| g g2- [ .
| |
| us0) -
| |
| g 2. i'{\
| |
| # Qs 4 s
| |
| , ns0 3-3 ,d
| |
| - M3 W
| |
| .S m i. 34
| |
| .c y)
| |
| - M '3y 2 *r 6 P 79 -r t.
| |
| 1 y~ yg U t. d $ % (l{ N ^
| |
| ,,L
| |
| ~
| |
| ~
| |
| O egb ;_.s
| |
| ~
| |
| y h ib - h '[ k.i[
| |
| 4 a 3 y - 2= g _
| |
| % - 2w 0 0 0 N 0 86L2 86 b 3 She SI-1 $ Y-2 8 ~3 SI-4 SS-t L $ - Si-1 Si-2 SI-3 8be 68'-l 86286366'4 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quar ter 1 Sit;Flificarit Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses .
| |
| I m 3- 3 3.
| |
| k$ $$
| |
| -e
| |
| -4
| |
| -i
| |
| -4 g2. g2.
| |
| 31 -
| |
| 11
| |
| ? i 9/: I~~
| |
| 0 e r eel2e6'
| |
| - 3 Se' 4 8/-I uit 8f.3 8i-4 ed ' 8eit 86' 3 sA4 81-18/-7 8/-3 ei-4 Sa-i year - omrter
| |
| -Year - Duarter
| |
| : 6. Ecuomes Fuced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. e.orced Cutap Ro% (s) 1000 Criticr> Hoss 10 0 6 -
| |
| b M-2t'~
| |
| it
| |
| - !i
| |
| *><t e<
| |
| x b m4 b' b .,, 3 WI ' - 3
| |
| " w 2.
| |
| ~
| |
| d '"
| |
| s $ 3 N 0 IEa t1 0 . . _ _
| |
| k S6266-366'-4 8i-187-2 8f-3 8No 88'-I 96-296k3So-4 81 157-2 Si-3 $7-4 58 -1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quart er O
| |
| 60 l
| |
| a
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.23
| |
| . ,s e \
| |
| COOPER STATION: Trends Performance Indicators O'C'i"'d '*P' v'd
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms WNie Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 048
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 2.12
| |
| ~ 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)-
| |
| g t73
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o.97
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Crit tog / , y,
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -i.0 -d.5 0 0 0 5 t'0 t'5 250 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Pkant Meons (Meowured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| COOPER STATION: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators Babw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scrom WNie Critical (4 Otr. Avg cod 88-1)
| |
| * 0 21 f . , , o
| |
| : 2. Sfety System Acactions (4 Otr. Avg end 83-1) . .
| |
| ',f 3;j 24 aa
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (4 Otr. A<g end 88-1) . .3 f f oss
| |
| : s. -
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88 1) - [ o.9c
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg eno 88-1) . 023
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced it tg/ gg j- 0 58
| |
| -2 5 - LO -I.5 -I.0 -d.5 5[ 0 5 t'0 t'$ 2IO 25 evictions from Otder Plant Meons (Veosured in Stonderd Devictions) l C' 61
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.24 C Incicct or CRYSTAL RIVER 3 Leaend: av met wem Critical Mcus 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| '""" 4 0" ' ' " " '"'S "'' i' h
| |
| : 1. Autornatic Screrns Whne Crited 2. Sofety System Actuctions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| { ,
| |
| - 22fo 19 - 2250
| |
| / d - rao y g 3- om f / g i
| |
| b - W b l }3. / Ih'J ~
| |
| B N)1 / - eco -' j <! / 1 - 500 -'
| |
| \ *
| |
| < p : -
| |
| e 1250 j %g2- / $ -
| |
| $250 j
| |
| } pt-l fp "l ==
| |
| "3
| |
| ,~ p
| |
| ! j 9-
| |
| , - -3 500
| |
| .ff ,~ s 4*]
| |
| h
| |
| -3 500 r - % ;- p4,
| |
| ::o I!
| |
| Cr - 250 -
| |
| o _ d./ $ o a $h Y b o sekte6L 3 e$-4 si-i ai-2 a7-3 si-4 es-t esL2 es-3 ed 4 s/-i ai-2 s/-3 si-4 ss-i Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. 5<pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foives 3- g 3-
| |
| $h
| |
| -t -t s<t-g s<t-g y t-dh y +
| |
| 1-
| |
| /x~
| |
| h
| |
| : d. %
| |
| # 7w $
| |
| , %d-t a y
| |
| eel2seks e4L4 sf-i e/-2 si-3 si-4 es'-i ee'2esL- 3 46 ei-i L2s/-3si-4 s5-i
| |
| . a - Onter Year t er
| |
| : 6. Eqdcrnent Forced Outoges/
| |
| 5 Forced Outoge Rote (s) 1000 Critcal Hours to a
| |
| ? eo - i' $
| |
| 6.
| |
| }
| |
| t so - !!
| |
| h4 N 84 3E LA $*"
| |
| l
| |
| * 43 5A^f y M w 2- %
| |
| i 23 - if F 121
| |
| '3'
| |
| : ? $2 3
| |
| e u 'I . b m_ _
| |
| o _!_l b__a ?-1 56-286'386'-4815 - ' 2 Si-3 si-4 88-t
| |
| - ee-2 86-3 $6'-4 87-l of-2 ei-3 Sf-4 Sa - t Year - ter Year - Quarter 62 O >
| |
| 0
| |
| | |
| .5 FIGURE 4.24
| |
| < ; CRYSTAL RIVER 3: Trends Declined improved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 7.5
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -M5
| |
| /. Safety System foilures (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) . o.3o ,
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .- ho wh o.gg
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs / B8 )- J t.25
| |
| -2.5 -2.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 1l5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Meons (Meosured in f*ondord Devictions) 4 CRYSTAL RIVER 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means .
| |
| Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators I
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -0.32 [ j.
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 3.53
| |
| :. - ~n~
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -182 ; , [g% <g ,ND
| |
| _y <
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.2i
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - o.56
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it Hr tg/ _ _
| |
| -2.5 .0 IS -I.0 -0.5 0 0 0'5 t'0 t'5 2!O 25 evictions irem Older Plont Veons (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) 63 l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.25 i 7 i C Indic:t or !
| |
| DAVIS-BESSE Legend: car % nt A -ec;e lj Crit. col Hours 86-2 to 88-1 - 4 corter uom Aar y - g
| |
| : 1. Automot'c Scres Yvhie Critcol 2. SCfety System Actuctons 4 2500 4 2*.00
| |
| - 2250 . 2" M
| |
| ~,/ . 2000 ,,''g , gooo Y I p* ~ \_ of" l p'- [ / \. im {
| |
| at
| |
| -4
| |
| * 3 <1 \ ,/
| |
| *2-p 2 1,
| |
| d .
| |
| 1250 E o -p 2. . CSC e' -
| |
| *] j - es
| |
| @y .
| |
| . . 3 g
| |
| 1 %
| |
| 5 g i t i d
| |
| Yl , k%N . 500 l{p 'i? g , yo N,- I m ts- 4- $ %
| |
| h U h - N h j A - M 0
| |
| '''' ' ' ' I O O S E23 0 865 2 6653S6k e SI-l 4/=2 87k3 8/-4 6$-! 86k266k3 86 ke SY-1 SI-2 87-3 SI-4 85-1 Yeor = Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Si<pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fokres e 3. g 3.
| |
| Nh jh at -!
| |
| O o 2 2
| |
| $~E DE~ 7
| |
| # n
| |
| )$' II.l 4
| |
| '~
| |
| h kX. '"
| |
| * E N" y $7 %
| |
| s, e h.
| |
| 06ht 86k 3k66 4 6/-1 (I-2 8/-3 8/-4 SN-1_ d2 BN3 6A-4 SY-1 (I-2 Sf-3 SI-4 85-1 l Ytor = Qu7lar Ycor = vuarter
| |
| : 6. Eau . t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. rereed outoge Rote (t) Critcal Mcus v0 8 s x a Ns, E g
| |
| = - ,e $e 8-
| |
| . y *
| |
| ]h @y A
| |
| }}<}e .0.Qe a< b j$ h & $$* ~ b ij ''- I Fw
| |
| 'i Q s
| |
| l g
| |
| O '
| |
| .I jr '" 2 -
| |
| 20 . g - A d 2.*.
| |
| o ai m M $ C eq" A o_
| |
| -a U'
| |
| El N so-2 esk3 so-4 s1-i s7-2 ei-3 Si-4 as-i se-2 so-3 e6-4 ar-i 47 2 e7-3 a7-4 sa-i Ytor - Quarter Yeor - Quor t er u
| |
| O I
| |
| | |
| TIGURE 4.25 q DAVIS-BESSE: Trends V ,
| |
| Declined improved Performance Indicators t Automatic Scroms While Criticol (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 09
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Aq end 88-1) - ' o.se
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - -a58
| |
| : 5. Forced Oulage Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 75
| |
| : 6. Equiment Forced tgs/ it gg j, n ,,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-15 -to-0.5 0!O O!5 t'0 l'5 2'.0 2.5 Devotions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont M (Measured in Stendard Devictions) eons i
| |
| DAVIS-BESSE: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above A<g. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators t Automotic Scroms While Critical -432 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - g
| |
| : 2. Sofety Syste'- Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - q33
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 83-1) - c42
| |
| , 4. Sofety System Foikres (4 Otr. Avg end 83-1) - ASS
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ass
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ it ,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 to .5 0'O 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 25 Devictions from Oscer Picnt Meons (Meesured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| O 65
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.26 c::=) :nc.ccter l DIABLO CANYON 1 Legend: oicer P'cet Ave < se Criticci Hotss 86-2 to 88-1 "" ' 0" t " "0""9 ^ "'c i'
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scrcrns WNle Criticd 2. Sofety System Acttotions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 . 2250
| |
| / %.
| |
| - 2003 '' .# *\ . 2000 ~
| |
| : 3. 3. 3 I
| |
| a 15 -'N - **3 at \ _ is -= x _ .-a
| |
| -< ; 3 <e
| |
| *2.
| |
| y c . 1250 o p?. . Cto
| |
| . 1000 y . Coo 3 W v g- i 1 . 1
| |
| *g- 1 1 1 p N? - si H *% F s
| |
| _ Sm E
| |
| s 5
| |
| ? [%
| |
| . 530 0 0 -
| |
| 86-2 86L3 k 86 4 8/-18/-2 8/-3 8/-4 PS-1 83L 2 06L 3 66L4 8/-t ti-2 8f-3 8/-4 SS-t Yeor - OJarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. 5<7sficont Events 4. Safety Systern Fcaltres
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| -e
| |
| -< - . <1
| |
| * 2.
| |
| 2-4 ,.
| |
| 4 ,
| |
| a 7 o
| |
| \ $1 M-_ o. ]a$ :-
| |
| p h:
| |
| eel 2 seks ao'-4 si-t ai-2 8/-3 si-4 as-t askt es-3 eel 4 s/-1 si-2 ei-3 s7-4 sa'- 1 fear - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equbnt ForcedCrites HousOutoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcne acte (s) m e 2 80 -
| |
| "h
| |
| }<te-
| |
| !(
| |
| a<
| |
| y pe.
| |
| 2
| |
| *~
| |
| s
| |
| - 2_
| |
| m
| |
| % # 0 94
| |
| ; o m _ - . _ . -
| |
| a m o irt __ n kV eekt 66L3 86 4L 81-1 Si-2 Si-3 SI-4 es-1 86-2 86' 3 e6-4 81-t ei-2 sf-3 ti-4 86-1 l Year - Quctter Ycy - Quar ter O
| |
| 66 l
| |
| l l
| |
| 1 s
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.26 o DIABLO CANYON 1: Trends
| |
| () O'C!I"'d Performance Indicators ''"P' V'd l
| |
| ''^"
| |
| f2 f," vg d - $) - 0.23
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- t
| |
| : 3. Signifkont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.5e I
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.58
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 4 32
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced tg/ itg,yj , 3,3,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i. -I.0 -0.5 0 0 OIS t'0 t'5 2'.0 25 Devictions rorn Previous 4 Otr. Plant M (Meosured in Stondord Devictions) eans' I
| |
| L DIABLO CANYON 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical .
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 4J2 j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o.33
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1)- c.90
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.53
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced tgs/ it , g i
| |
| -2.5 -2' .0 I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0'o O'.5 t'0 t'5 2'0 2.5 Deviations from Older Plant Means (Measured in Standord Devictions) 67 t 0
| |
| | |
| FCURE 4.27 m vocat or DIABLO CANYON 2 Legend: c'ee Piont Ase :;e Criticcf Hour s 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| "" 4 0'"'" * "i ^"'Ci' g t Automatic Scrcrns WNW Critcol 2. Safety System Actuations 4 2500 4 ISCO 2250
| |
| 'd - 2250
| |
| ^
| |
| -3A v , , s. .- ,
| |
| 3- 3- dd e
| |
| [t e
| |
| at e
| |
| =,
| |
| en -=
| |
| it A t
| |
| 4 -
| |
| =; -
| |
| y <t m 4
| |
| .4 e m p2-d N
| |
| y'h s
| |
| 4 x
| |
| - 1250 o32-
| |
| - (P
| |
| % g d -
| |
| 1250 3 f
| |
| '~
| |
| f i*-%
| |
| h h i I "3
| |
| b f k [hI h [ t i tI
| |
| *3 Nb h()h t
| |
| I o y FI 4%Q- soo ks- $ 3 y;
| |
| 2 p
| |
| y y
| |
| x
| |
| - 500 O
| |
| 71 k'
| |
| 2 f ,
| |
| v%- '
| |
| N 3 0 L: :
| |
| , p -
| |
| 7'
| |
| - T% -
| |
| N 0
| |
| e6-2 e6' . 3 86-4 8/-l SI-2 6/-3 SI-4 66-I 86-2 e6-3 eNo SI-t Si-2 SI-3 Bi-4 to-1 Ytor - QuCrter Ycor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Si;pficent Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues
| |
| = 3- g 3- d *
| |
| }t wg jk N w) ,
| |
| i<g2 - p 2 2<s.
| |
| y y
| |
| $ I h
| |
| : s. ? s d
| |
| .s
| |
| : s. C#
| |
| - s W %
| |
| a A
| |
| E NA- ( ?'
| |
| )
| |
| V' g
| |
| J s -
| |
| s tq n
| |
| m-eelte6L3 eA4 al., i e6L 2 e6'-3 e64 e7-tsi-2ei-3si-4 ss' i rear b-2t eraf-3 ei-4 si-i voor - Quartw I
| |
| : 6. Eoui nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outogo Rote (s) Critcal Mcus oO e 90 E m. h ilt 2 }' ~
| |
| 3!
| |
| s t<I 80- 84 b5 3 % $
| |
| ,3 '~ -
| |
| , w 2-7 A o>
| |
| Y so-2e63se'-4 s1-i ai-2 s?-3 sf-4 a6-i e4-2e6-3ei-4 a7-i t i-2 si-3 87-4 sa-i Tear - QuCTter Y eor - VuCT t er 68 l
| |
| l i
| |
| | |
| . FIGURE 4.27
| |
| ,, DIABLO CANYON 2: Trends
| |
| (") ' D*C'i"*d i*P' "*d Performance Indicators f2 ht . vg nd 8h ) - 0 71
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - 2m
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o,4
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .
| |
| o.37
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced -
| |
| tg/ itg ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-t5 -t0 .5 0!0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devict'ecsured ns from Previous in Stondord 4 Otr. Piont )Meons Devictions DIABLO CANYON 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicotors
| |
| ^" f4 htr. vg end 8 $) - -0.32 ,
| |
| t
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _u4
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - -c.4 2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 8,8-1) . - o.34
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -te
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Crit tg/ _ g, t
| |
| -2.5-i.0-15 -i.0 -d.5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'5 2!0 2.5 Devictions from Oider Piont Meons (Mecsured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| O~ 69 i
| |
| | |
| ~
| |
| nGURE 4.28 c::::a ino;cetor DRESDEN 2 Legend: O!cer P;cnt Averp;e Lf atiCol Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| """ 4 0 *rt''
| |
| " 9 ^ve'Ote g
| |
| : 1. Autornotic Scrcrns WPile Critical 2. Sofety Systern Actwtions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| . 2250 . 2250
| |
| ' ~
| |
| jh - A / .
| |
| 2x0 j-20m 2 e 3. 3. /
| |
| bA / - 1750 3
| |
| g ,,,,,j i - 1750 g
| |
| g6 "/ *'. # M ',
| |
| k,I -
| |
| 2 CSO '2. c50 y2- - .
| |
| 000 3 . 000 3 W W
| |
| . 750 ~
| |
| ~ .
| |
| 730 } O t-h
| |
| )g#
| |
| $m g . 500 1
| |
| . 500 c I - . 250 . 2sv 0 2 N $ 0 n Y n SS-2 86'-3 86 L 4 8l-t 8Y-2 8Y-3 8Y-4 8S-t SS-2 86 L 3 86k4 8/-t 8i-2 87'-3 SI-4 Bd-t Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sipficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety Systern Fokres e 3- 3 3.
| |
| k
| |
| -e -t#
| |
| i o t t I~ $~ 7 7
| |
| }& ky 4
| |
| ''l P,
| |
| , f%-
| |
| 86-2 86L 3 86'-4 8/-t 8Y-2 87'-3 8i-4 8$-1 Year - Owrter 86'-2 86'-J 86 I's $
| |
| L 4 8/-t 8f-2 87k3OY-4ed-t Year - overter [
| |
| : 6. Eau .nt Forced Outogts/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) Cnted Hours to 8 b M-p 2 3' --
| |
| 21
| |
| &<t a . a4 b5 ~5''
| |
| ij 83 s ,34 1 6 .* g 2 EO - h * '*'
| |
| t22 g
| |
| y; 8
| |
| i' A. L2 t_s ind Q p, 2'5o11-a __"i'A t r_J 8eL2 86'- 3 SS-4 81-1 ' 2 8f-3 87 e 8$-t
| |
| - 86' 2 36-3 86'-4 Si-t si-2 ef-3 8f-4 es-i Year - ter Year - Quarter 70 O
| |
| l i i
| |
| | |
| . FIGURE 4.28 DRESDEN 2: Trends
| |
| /'^N '
| |
| O'Cli"'d '"Prov'd Performance Indicators ,
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticci (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.3
| |
| ~
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1. 4
| |
| .o.3o
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o st
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ , gg
| |
| -2.5-i.0-l5 -iO -0.5 O!O 0 5 io US 2'.0 2.5 Devictions (Meosured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Plont )Means 0 evictions DRESDEN 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^'
| |
| 4 Otr. Avg end . - -086 ,
| |
| l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- tn
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . q9e
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures ($ Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .q43 l
| |
| : 5. Fceced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0.27
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / it , g3
| |
| -2.5-i.0-t$ -to -U.5 0'O O'5 io i5 20 2.5 Deviations from Older Plont Means (Measured in Stondord Devictions) l O 71 i
| |
| t.
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.29 inecotec !
| |
| DRESDEN 3 Legend: o* Nat Ave se '
| |
| Critical Hour s 86-2 to 88-1 """ 4 0 " '" " ""9 **" 9' g t Automatic Scroms Whle Cntied 2. Sofety System Actuotk>ns 4 2500 4 290 k, - 22 % . 22 %
| |
| 3, s,.
| |
| 's .
| |
| m2 5 3. .'gs //N
| |
| .}
| |
| "5
| |
| ''' 3 11 } \/ -
| |
| 3 3}!
| |
| 4
| |
| . . e00 -. i <t
| |
| \/-
| |
| . so -.
| |
| p2- [, . QSO o32. . C50 i's '. . o00 3 * . 000 15 W 57 2 2 .a ; . r$0 O~ % . 150 s j Q')
| |
| t I ,~ u. i O h $$ h U . SCO [j a h . WO h T E -$$V. 2So !!? { . 2w 0 C 0 7 0 06-k2 06 k 3 N 8/-t 8/-2 8/-3 8Y-4 8$-1 66k2 66 k 3 8N4 8/-1 SY-2 8f-3 87'-4 85-1 Year - Quater Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Significont Events 4. Sofety System Foltres .
| |
| :4 :
| |
| +
| |
| 'f
| |
| . 3- 3 3. n jk N n}k
| |
| -t :
| |
| g<S* ,
| |
| $~ $ 9 ;
| |
| ?
| |
| t i 1 l'@l k
| |
| ~
| |
| U Y h,
| |
| % /
| |
| is f#C s y $/ 0?
| |
| n( k g: A g I hb v g $Y
| |
| ~
| |
| N2 86 k) 86 54 8/-1 SI-2 8/-3 8I-4 68' 1 .- 296 k386-4 SI-18 -28f-3SI-4 8$=1 /
| |
| Ycor - Quarter Yeor - Qu71er
| |
| : 6. EW nt Forced Ouioges/
| |
| : 5. Forced CJoy Rote (t) Crited Mcus to 8 3 So .
| |
| "s i 3' 3 11
| |
| ~f*I a . a<
| |
| 6 x4 3R b$ ab T ij" 4o -
| |
| j $
| |
| A 5 25 x 2 07 g~ Z d w -
| |
| N 169
| |
| $ # ^ bi 0 87
| |
| ?f b]
| |
| o N b N [L o d_ b+7 e65 2 66k3 66'-4 8/-t 8i-2 87'-3 Si-4 Bd-t 86'-2 96k3 86'-4 81-1 Si-2 ef-3 af-4 88-1 Ytor - Qugter Yeor - Quorter 72
| |
| | |
| i FCURE 4.29 !
| |
| I i
| |
| ~
| |
| n DRESDEN 3: Trends '
| |
| - L/ Decnned improved Performonce Indicotors l
| |
| t Automotic Scroms While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - .
| |
| '.c 163
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Sigraficont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.5e
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.7s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . t4,
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ git , g
| |
| -2.5-k.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Dev' itions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Veens (Meosured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| DRESDEN 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators f4 htr. Avg 8 )- 4 32 l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -
| |
| hg to
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 4 42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t r7 .;.! ,
| |
| S. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.28 i
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tg it Hr
| |
| -2.5 *i.0 i.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 15 Devictions from 06 der Plont Meons (Mecsured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| O 73 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.30 M indicctor DUANE ARNOLD Legend: Older P'Cnt Ave <cge CrillCOI Hours 86-2 tc 88-1
| |
| ""'
| |
| * C " ''' * *'N ***' i' h
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scf 3Tr5 Wt.M Critical 2. Sofety System Actuctions 4 25o0 4 2500 22so . rm 3, f., '\,, .-
| |
| * ~
| |
| 3, # '. . , , ,,
| |
| f l s.
| |
| mo . -_
| |
| . oso
| |
| * 3 N) - eco a' j <i . eco -a
| |
| ~<
| |
| usoj 4 32. , 2,., . eso j flp2. -
| |
| "3 ll k -
| |
| " i' 3,
| |
| -a ,. &. -
| |
| -a soo
| |
| - soo
| |
| {j
| |
| \/ . so - _-m o $ %
| |
| o o
| |
| *- o seLa es-s esL4 si-i ei-t ei-3 si-4 es-i s4L a seks yeor esL4-si-iei.:si-ssi-4 ovartw es-i year - ovarter 3 SipfiCont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System roitres
| |
| . 3. 3 s. 1 1 4
| |
| u p
| |
| -t e
| |
| y x
| |
| ~4 ~< %
| |
| si ,-
| |
| 11 ,-
| |
| ie 2 g tt ee~vt'
| |
| ; y en s ~ ~
| |
| $ ;g-o o sek2 seks sol 4 si-i ai-1 si-s si-4 se'- t as-2 se's so-4 si-i t -2
| |
| - i ei-s ei-4 ea-i Yeor
| |
| * Mter voor - Qwarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Critco riotis to a b 80 -
| |
| 3*-
| |
| : d. !!
| |
| i
| |
| -}<! .o _
| |
| w s<
| |
| me.
| |
| d u= v b 3$ ' ~ I) $
| |
| 2 2. to
| |
| :o . / ,
| |
| e
| |
| =7 I u si
| |
| ' - N#
| |
| # A o C S o.
| |
| es.: eels ee'-4 si-i si-t ei-s si-4 es-i so-a eel3 ee-4 si-i ai-2 si-s si-o so-i year - Quartw year - Quarter 74 O
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.30 I
| |
| . -t n DUANE - ARNOLD: Trends Declined improvea Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatie Scroms While Critical 5 i (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ; j 058
| |
| : 2. Sdety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- *
| |
| , f 0.58 j2
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0.30
| |
| ?
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . o.34
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ ggQy) , n ,3
| |
| -2.5-i.0-t5 -to -0.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Prev.ous 4 Otr. Plant Meons (Measured in Stonderd Deviations) .
| |
| DUANE ARNOLD: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means
| |
| ' Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf, Performance Indicators L Automatic Scroms While Criticol 128 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -046
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.ga
| |
| - 4. Sofety System foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _to
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . -t62
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Crit ,,,
| |
| tog / g8Qyj ,
| |
| -2.5- O -ts -to -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 t'5 2'.0 2 5 evictions frem Oider Plent Meons (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) 75 0
| |
| | |
| i 4
| |
| l FIGURE 4.31 C=:0 indicetor FARLEY 1 Legend: Oieer Pk=nt evercse Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| " 4 0 *' ' '' *v'N ^"' c1.e g
| |
| : 1. Autornotc Scres WNle Critical 2. 91fety Syst6.'n Actu3t'ces 4 2$o0 4 2W
| |
| - 2250 . 22$0
| |
| '*g, ' ..g''- - 2000 b ..y.
| |
| taco j h
| |
| - 1750 gg - 1750 fi*t-g
| |
| ==~
| |
| 230 ij
| |
| 'g2-e= ';
| |
| *230
| |
| "" I '
| |
| 3 3 3 h 3:. -
| |
| -3
| |
| - ,,0 3
| |
| ,~ ,-_3 ,~
| |
| 9 f(k h - soo , m h Ef k35 o K1 h .m k 0 0 0 86k2 86 L 3 eM-4 8/-18/-2 Si-3 8/-4 8$.1 k e 8/-1 Si-2 Si-3 87-4 86'- t 86'-2 86k) 86 Yeor - (kaarter Year - Quorter
| |
| : 3. Spficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety Systern Fokses
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| k w!
| |
| y?- y2.
| |
| : 1. 1-
| |
| \ %%
| |
| N 0 0 8A-2 86'-3 86-4 8/-18/-28/-3SI-488-1 k 8628$-38$-4 Bi-1 t i-2 Si-3 87ke 83'-t J Yeor = Qwler Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| S. Forced Outcge Rcte (s) Crited as to 8 3 S0 -
| |
| ;> 3"3 hI
| |
| * m
| |
| !I
| |
| *we-bb b gu f so - }
| |
| 6 w 1-138 to 20 -
| |
| g 1m 3 3
| |
| * g C .' li! h k
| |
| 86286-386'-4 8/-1Si-287k38f486-1 86L2 8S-3 86'-4 81-1 87'-2 8f-3 SI-4 88-1 Yeor - Quorter Yeor - Quarter 76 O
| |
| I
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.31 t
| |
| cs t
| |
| FARLEY li Trends V Declined imoroved
| |
| ?
| |
| Performance Indicotors Scroms WhDe Criticci
| |
| : 1. Automoti[2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - 09
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| +
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 4: Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.$a
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 167
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ it , gg
| |
| ~2.5-f.0-i5 -iO -0.5 0 0 0 5 t'0 15 20 2.5 Devictions (Meesured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Piont )Meons Devictions 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means
| |
| ^
| |
| FARLEY Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms White Critical 0.74 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - j
| |
| : 2. Sof aty System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- in
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o gg
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- ago
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 0.56
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ . gg
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -i5 -lo -d.5 0'O O!$ t'0 1.'S 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Older P!cnt Meces (Meesured in Stonderd Devictions) 77 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.32 frx!icatC#
| |
| FARLEY 2 Legend: CW PWt Avercge Crit col Hours 86-2 to 88-1 0" ' " " # 9 ^ "' .i' g
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whie Critical 2. Safety System Actuctens 4 2$co 4 2*co
| |
| - 22So 225o p.N. - .. .,
| |
| . tooo . movI g 3 3- *g ".
| |
| 'N*. *'
| |
| gg . 17 5 o g
| |
| . t7to at
| |
| - coo =- y <t . ue --
| |
| *2.
| |
| g . 12So o g 2. . 12So j
| |
| fj ,~
| |
| ?
| |
| L, ,
| |
| *1
| |
| -a . ,"
| |
| Wm -
| |
| *?
| |
| -3 R
| |
| Ib,
| |
| ( ,
| |
| 500 250 soo 25o o N '
| |
| o 0 U o 86L 2 M3 86L4 81=i Si-2 8/-3 Si-4 84'-i sei2 so-3 se'-4 87-1 SI-2 Si-3 8/-4 68'-l Year - Ourter Year - ouyter
| |
| : 3. 5pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fcilves
| |
| . 3. 3 3.
| |
| Eh jh at
| |
| -< - . <t g2. .
| |
| gt.
| |
| $ MA b
| |
| i-y i seL2 seks seL4 s!-t si-2 si-3 si-4 ei-i seit ei-3 36' 4 si-i sf-2 si-3 s7-4 es- t Year - Oucrter -Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (*) Cntco Hous oc a 3 ao _
| |
| h.-
| |
| gh "h
| |
| 3 B e-47 T 18 54 @ 54
| |
| , e --
| |
| ,4 x,
| |
| 1 g
| |
| m
| |
| ( h 22 r
| |
| w b m 2.
| |
| ~
| |
| % t ti .
| |
| , L o seL2 eeks seL4 ef-i si-2 si-3 a'L4 as'- t sekt seks ei-4 s7-i ai-2 ei-3 sf-4 es-t Ycor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter 78
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.32 n' FARLEY 2: Trends t
| |
| * v' Dec6ned improved Performance Incicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms While Critical
| |
| -048 7"
| |
| f2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1)-
| |
| : 2. Sofety Sy' stem Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . N)$k'hhh sq ;n '
| |
| -23
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| 'i
| |
| .: 4 .ff' i 14$
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o S7
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . '
| |
| 197 8
| |
| s
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced(2OutNr./1000 Crit. Hrs. C'';.%g;p#'k^{k' Avg end 88-1) -2.45
| |
| ; ag g -
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -to -U.5 0.0 0'5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Meons (Meesured in Stonderd Devictions) .
| |
| FARLEY 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical gf (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - d0 .74 j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o46 :
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t02
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o go w
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.si 4o
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / git . m,
| |
| -2.5-2' O- i 5 i0 -d.5 0 0 O!S l'O l'5 2IO 25 Devictions from 06cer Plont vecns (Measured in Stoncord Devictions) 79 t
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.33 M CCter FERMI 2 Legend: cuer Not A e m Crit, col Hot /s l 86-2 W 88--1 0 " ' ' '' * "' ^9 * * *' C 9.'
| |
| t Automatic Scrams WNe Criticci 2. Sofety System Actuations 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| - 2000 -
| |
| : 3. 2000 [7 I& - '*
| |
| 3 0( 3 - - '*
| |
| 3 N ! - eco -' j <! - eco ,*
| |
| 'g2. I'%. I ,
| |
| - C$o og2. j^ . CSo
| |
| }
| |
| /f
| |
| / d - "
| |
| *b 3 $
| |
| Y
| |
| '\,\ \ '
| |
| *3
| |
| ?
| |
| i-
| |
| /sf i i - ,- e i ..
| |
| 7 g s
| |
| NZ" N
| |
| b %4 N RN 7-mi m @
| |
| E*4 A' i . Soo
| |
| /
| |
| s A@h*f g .
| |
| A - 250 g / AV's - 250 o ! '
| |
| $c $ $ $ N o o _ _. b) $ $ o e6L2 seka seL4 el-187bt e7'-3 s?'-4 es-t sekt ae'- 3 Le6 4 al-i n?'-2 87L3 87-4 sa -i Ysor - Quarter Year - Quorter
| |
| : 3. 57iificont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fokses
| |
| , .y
| |
| +'
| |
| g g n 4 ,
| |
| g 3- d. 6 -
| |
| . 3.
| |
| fh wa jk w a M'
| |
| s;5 (c'
| |
| 4 s
| |
| .s.
| |
| 3E gE 7 / [ s D:
| |
| g2- g- 2 .
| |
| Z h z hb*
| |
| 'M h
| |
| :'< s
| |
| ~N kk g g k...';
| |
| p k r- w
| |
| & y bw f Q .'
| |
| b-: h
| |
| ? $ k o A E- o X @ @ " s ee'-2 e6 L 3 es-4 e/-i ' 2 - s7-3 e7'-4 as-i e6L2 e6L 3Le6 4 si-i '2
| |
| - si-3 a7'-4 se'- i '
| |
| Year - ter Year - t er
| |
| : 6. Equornent Forced Outoges/
| |
| S. Forced Outoge Rote (z) 1000 Critico Hours to a 7
| |
| W ::': g
| |
| ? 00 - l' f ,, g' 3 ''
| |
| j) !
| |
| hl 5 l T g<! 60. a
| |
| -l, s<
| |
| I ij a-u g
| |
| sm 44 g
| |
| s
| |
| * j
| |
| % e.,p j 3 45 I ';
| |
| * s, 4
| |
| 20 . pp
| |
| (-J p' l
| |
| p w 2. s
| |
| -1: tot -s 14 s
| |
| .s 5 '
| |
| gk-ad 1
| |
| u a , ,
| |
| p (tg e x_._
| |
| 3 se t' ~ ~ ,
| |
| Q o
| |
| ~
| |
| V ''
| |
| $6-2 86-3 66'-4 BY-i ' 2 8f=3 Si-4 80-1
| |
| - k 1 8Y-i 47'-2 $7'-3 87-4 S8 i 86-2863864 Year - ter Yeor - Quarter 80 O
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| e FIGURE 4.33 O FERMI 2: Trends V' ,
| |
| O'Cli"*d 3*C' "'d Perforrnance Indicators l
| |
| 2 htf vg nd 8 $) - 173
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| )' 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . i
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.32
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 2.9
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced t / it . 191
| |
| ~
| |
| -2.5-10-i.5-l.0-6.500 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions (Measured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Plant )Meons Devictions ,
| |
| FERMI 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means seiow Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^" f4 htf}vg eh 8f#f--t32 j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotbns (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.33
| |
| : 3. Spficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - .ta2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaves (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 2.9 ,
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 2.33
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tegs/ ,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -I 5 -i.0 -d.5 0'O 0 5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Meons (Mecsured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| O 81
| |
| | |
| f' FIGURE 4.34 C"-*"3 :rocctc< i FITZPA 1 RICK Leaend:~
| |
| ce met 4+m Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| .~
| |
| - ' 0*' t "
| |
| * c"1 Av " * $
| |
| : 1. Automctic ScfGfis Whde CritiCd 2. 'yJfety System ActWtcns 4 2$00 4 2500
| |
| - 23 - 2:50
| |
| .W''. .
| |
| i.W''. '
| |
| 2o00- ~5' J !s -
| |
| 2000h 4lp J- -
| |
| in - ,/ .
| |
| ~, ./ -
| |
| flg3- -
| |
| 20h il og2-
| |
| /5 -
| |
| e= ;
| |
| cs0 l 3
| |
| 1 ,~ <, , ecU "3!
| |
| - ji.
| |
| 6 r ,
| |
| 3 U a 500 Q pgP we y f g [g .
| |
| r N .
| |
| , h. &. _ - - -( ~,# ,
| |
| f % -
| |
| 86'-2 86k 3 8$4 8/-t 87k2 Si-3 SI-4 8$-1 86L 2 86k3 86 k 4 8/-1 Si-2 Si-J 87k4 86-1 Yeor - Qurter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. S5ficant Events 4. Sofety System Fonses e 3- 3 3- d h jh S
| |
| -t -t
| |
| '"
| |
| * 2 2 #
| |
| ,2- ,2 xr r s2-
| |
| -l
| |
| ) %
| |
| % 5
| |
| $9*
| |
| (
| |
| % ]% L o n .. .
| |
| 86k2 86 k 3 L86 4 SI-l Si-2 67k3 Si-4 86-1 Sek2 86L J 86ke 8/-1 L2 Si-3 8N4 68-l i Year - Canter Year - ter
| |
| : 6. Equ , nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Crited Hxrs a 8 b 80 - 8-g h h 1!
| |
| a<
| |
| h<! * - "me~-
| |
| 5m en Q eO l
| |
| s w
| |
| }
| |
| w 2-t1 % "'
| |
| e>o=
| |
| r1 A A h, n a O9 -; H9 8-286-384-4 87-i 81-2 Si-3 Si-4 se-i 8(-2 86-3 86-4 87-i it -2 87-3 87-4 ui Yeor - Mter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| \
| |
| O 82 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURL 4.34 FITZPATRICK: Trends O Declined improved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whi'e Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . , oso
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - osa 5.- Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 58-1) . o.53
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs / it Hr ,
| |
| g,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i.0 -d.5 0.0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 ns from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons Devicti[Meosured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| FITZPATRICK: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Perforrnance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti $ tom WN C ic ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . t24
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ose
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -o.u
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.4s
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Cnt tog / ,
| |
| 49
| |
| -2.5-i.0-t5 -i.0 -d.5 0 0 0l$ t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 0 evictions from Older Piont Meons (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| O 83 e
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.35 M !nd:Cctor l FORT CALHOUN Legend: - o w
| |
| * i s e:;e !
| |
| Critic al Hots s 86-2 to 88-1 - 4 corte wng nec;e g
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scram While Critical ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System ActLotons
| |
| - 2250 _ ::o f l 3.
| |
| ~
| |
| #3 I)3- -
| |
| mo , gg - ="
| |
| $I - =' il
| |
| =3 mo j 3;2- -
| |
| co j
| |
| }g:-
| |
| }
| |
| ~;o i 1
| |
| ~a t
| |
| ,. 2y -
| |
| - So
| |
| , < ~ , , - m ,
| |
| seL2 sek3 4 l-t 8 -3 ei-4 es-t geht sek3 se'gi-1 ei-3 ei 4 e5-1
| |
| : 3. Sgnficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foltres 2
| |
| - 3- 3-la it II 3
| |
| g2- g2- 3 m
| |
| x 7 9 vy 4
| |
| \ I D seL2 eel3seL4 s/-t ci-2 6/-3 si-4 es-1 sekt sek3 seL4 2 !! Y el-i ai-2 si-3 si-4 as-i Year - Oater year - Ontw C. Eau t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (z) Crita:a Motts 8 m- h 3'~
| |
| it . .t k<, e. ~ s4 ES 'E'-
| |
| 3$ "~ $
| |
| B
| |
| * w 2.
| |
| 2c -
| |
| , N -
| |
| seitee-3e6-4 s?-i e 7-2 s7-3 sv-4 ui seL2 se'-3 se-4 s?-i sv'-2 e?-3 of-4 so-t reer - ovar t w vo or - on tw O
| |
| e4 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.35 O
| |
| v FORT CALHOUN: Trends ,
| |
| Declined tenproved Performance Indicators 1 Automatic Scroms While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.5e
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) . tg
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tgs/10 ,
| |
| n
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -i.0 .5 0 0 O!5 iO f5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions (Meostsedfrom Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Piont )Meons Devictions .
| |
| FORT CALHOUN: Deviations from Older Piant Means Performance Indicators Bei w Avg. Perf, Above Aug. Perf.
| |
| L f4 tr Avg nd -J- 128 ;
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuot' o ns (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tn
| |
| : 3. Sigraficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . o.14
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Aq end 88-1) . o.79
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced to g / O it Hr
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-i.S I.0 .5 0'O O!5 io i$ 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Cider Plont Meons (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| O 85
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.36 I
| |
| F C""""1 IndiCCt or FORT ST. VRAIN -Legend: o *
| |
| * t m ere;*
| |
| Cruticct Hoss 86-2 to 88-1 ""
| |
| * 0" t " **'i ^ #'' i' g
| |
| : 1. Autortiot'C ScfGTts WPv4 Crit'col 2. Safety System Acti.ct>ons 4 2M 4 2W
| |
| - 22So - *:50 200o raco 5 f
| |
| : 3. f 3.
| |
| E a
| |
| eoo a' lh - '*
| |
| eco a' g
| |
| 5
| |
| .4 t -
| |
| 5 <1 uso j opt. 4 -
| |
| esoj lg2-i
| |
| ,~ ,
| |
| s .
| |
| ji ,
| |
| ?J
| |
| ~s
| |
| [
| |
| e' - ,
| |
| lE %
| |
| s Li-
| |
| '9h:
| |
| ,_.1 ,
| |
| ei- es3 ese si-i s/- si-3 si-4 ei-i ei-aee-3se'-4 ei-i e7-2 s7-3 s7-4 so-i Yeor - Quarter Y tar - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sgraficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Safetf system Foitres
| |
| .3- C 3-k$ .$.
| |
| -t ! 5 3d,-
| |
| 2*-t 2
| |
| 3 4
| |
| s s h
| |
| h e .
| |
| (
| |
| ee-aeAseeL4 s/-t si-2 si-3 si-4 si-1 s y +
| |
| Year - Quorts es-2 se' 3Teorse si-ttw b'-t s7 3 si. sa.i
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Critcal Meus x n x k 88 a
| |
| s so . ~ >9 $
| |
| = 3 ), _
| |
| it 3
| |
| * t .o . $eg -
| |
| 4 !!
| |
| at 30 i4b fI x
| |
| I f
| |
| hr [r, o
| |
| 4 o4 A- %
| |
| 1 5 1 94 x ? 4 y e :r 1
| |
| ?
| |
| f J. y M t .'' w 2-20 . G- % ' 4) a, N .,
| |
| e- 3>
| |
| ,7w 2
| |
| s T% ['
| |
| b:
| |
| e-0 i il '
| |
| o ',- '
| |
| 04-2 N3 86M sN-l ' 3- si-3 sI-5 08-1 $N286-3Bh-4 Si-1 7-2s7-3874 68-t Y eor - ter Year - (Uvarts 86 O
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.36 q
| |
| V FORT ST. VRAIN: Trends Dec6md improved Performance Indicators
| |
| ^"
| |
| [2$tr.Ivg nd 5$ #$)- -0.se
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr, Avg end 88-1) . .tt3
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t? 2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.go S. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.go 7 it ,
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtog/ ,
| |
| -2.5-f.0-tS -i:0 -d.S 0 0 O'S t'0 t'S 20 2.5 Deviot s from Previous 4 Otr. Plant V Measured in Stondorv 0 evictions) eens FORT ST. VRAIN: Deviations. from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^"
| |
| f4 btr Iv nd SN' $)-
| |
| - 0.21 j
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.46
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- t24 S. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ . 2g
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs / , ,g,
| |
| -2.5-I.0 -I S -I.0 -0.5 0'O 0 S t'0 t'5 2IO 2.5 Devictions from older Plant Meons (Mecsured in Stondord Devictions) 87 l
| |
| | |
| FGURE 4.37 P
| |
| C"':3 nd:cotc<
| |
| GINNA Leaend:-
| |
| a- a-t A ,.
| |
| Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1 '"" ' 0 " ' ' ''
| |
| * N ^ "' W
| |
| : 1. Automets Scrcm3 WWe Crit <d 2. Sofety System Actuatons 4 ., 2500 4 2W
| |
| . 2250 . 2254 g
| |
| 3
| |
| . 2000
| |
| : 3. -\ . 2000 Y
| |
| $g.
| |
| a . 1750 'g x
| |
| . 1750 f
| |
| ) -
| |
| *$ kf -
| |
| p2. f ,
| |
| c20j og2. .
| |
| nso j "3 l ~
| |
| *3 i- M i - ,-
| |
| w gN x T = m W-
| |
| ~ -
| |
| 0 n' ?
| |
| $$-2 06-3 84-4+ t l-187'-2 ti-3 47L4
| |
| ?0
| |
| $$-t 0 '
| |
| SM-2 M-3 8A-4 01-1 i-2 87-3 8'-4 SS-1 3
| |
| Year - Quarter Yeor - ter
| |
| : 3. 5pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues l
| |
| . 3. g 3. .2.
| |
| }k
| |
| -t jk
| |
| .*<t ..
| |
| gt. gt.
| |
| : 1. i. f'% ',
| |
| , ... m -
| |
| a es-2ai-3ei-4 st i '- 2 si-3 si-4 es-i e6 2 ee-3 es-4 e7-i '2Si-3s7-4 #8-t Y eor
| |
| * ter Yeor as ter
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outops/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rott (s) 1000 Critco tws to e
| |
| $ 90 .
| |
| ie 4'-
| |
| }1.o m
| |
| . a4
| |
| *m4 d" b -. a gu j oo - j 5
| |
| * . 2.
| |
| 0 .L 1 Z 96-2 96'-3 86-4 SY-1 SI-2 SI-3 87-4 68-9 64-2 96-3 84-4 87-1 (?-2 Sf=3 47-4 88 - t Ytor = Quart er Y por - Quar t er SS O
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.37 O GINNA: Trends Decimd inoroved Performance Indicators I
| |
| S
| |
| : 1. Automotif2 hroms WNie Criticottr. Avg end 85-1) " 0
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ,
| |
| o
| |
| , 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.,e
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end SS-1) . .u
| |
| : 6. Equ'9ment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -i0. i.5 OIO 0 5 t'0 t'5 2!0
| |
| * 2.5 Devictions from e revious 4 Ott, Picnt V (Meosured in Stondord Devictions) ecns ,
| |
| GINNA: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. At>ove Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| [4 . Iv d Sk - c14
| |
| /
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tn
| |
| . 3, Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.oe
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FoJures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ogo I 5. Forced Outog, Rots (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o.4e
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced C it tog / . e,3
| |
| -2.5-2' 0 -i.5 -iO -8 5 0'0 0'5 t'0 15 2'O 25 Devictions from 06cer Picnt veens (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) l ~
| |
| O l 89 h
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.38 Q Indicotor GRAND GULF Legend: Older Picnt Aver ge CritiCOI Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| " ' 0*' t " M*in9 ^*erc9? g 1 Automatic Scroms WW'e Cnticci 2. Scfety System Actetcis
| |
| '- -__ 2500 4 m
| |
| - 2?50 . 2250
| |
| : 3. \ 3
| |
| 'o= j g 3. \ , - == 1
| |
| - 1N gh 3 - f750 h
| |
| 500]
| |
| *2-e -
| |
| e50 ) 3 3., 2 . a e0 3 l
| |
| ~
| |
| h
| |
| #}
| |
| w ,
| |
| je -
| |
| ~3 5,- , , , , , - ~a .
| |
| l T se 7 F9 Qvf _ Sm Q _
| |
| ]4-g
| |
| - N -O - 250 m L h o 0 0 i 0
| |
| 66L286L3 86 LYect 4 8/-18/-2 8/-3 8/-4 8$-1 SA2 86L 3 86 4L 8/-1 Si-2 8i-3 8I-4 88-1 I
| |
| - Quarter Year - Quarter l
| |
| : 3. Si<pficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Folures .
| |
| . 3. g 3. 4
| |
| }k jE
| |
| -t
| |
| -1 g2- g2-
| |
| '' '~
| |
| /
| |
| V M
| |
| $ fd 0 h% 0 E 4 86L 2 86L3 86L 4 s/-i 87L2 8/-3 Si-4 84-1 8A2 86Li 86i 4 Si-s 8/-2 Si-3 8/-4 8s-i r Yeer - oucrter Yw - ovuter
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Fcreed Outcge Rote (s) 1000 Criticci Hxis oo 8 3 80 - h hh $
| |
| Et f<t 80 - a<
| |
| hs II ~
| |
| 1 j ** - I s 2~
| |
| 2 20 .
| |
| 5 9u '
| |
| 5 6 ,
| |
| O U 3 0 86k 2 86kJ86LYeor 4 8I-1 SI-2 Si-3 Si-4 es-1 86-2 86'-3 86'-4 ai-t ei-2 Si-3 8I-4 88-1 Yeor - Quorter
| |
| - Quorter 90 O
| |
| 8
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.38 GRAND GULF: Trends
| |
| {a3 Declined improved Performance Indi'cators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Sercms While Criticci (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - -2
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.58
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo3ures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- p
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rcte (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -t45 5'k
| |
| :ws%&'d h
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ S8Mj- ( -3.2
| |
| ' -- i , , , , i , ,
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -t5 -to -0.5 0.0 0.5 to 15 2.0 2.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Mecns (Mecsured in Standord Devictions) 1 GRAND GULF: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators B&w Ayg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| L Automotic Scroms While Critical ft (4 Otr, Avg end 88-1) - "l39 sqiM@)i'g% ,
| |
| 4
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -2.02
| |
| )"""'_"_
| |
| w -e4 'M$hN
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.98
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - L24
| |
| ! 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.45
| |
| : 6. Equ'oment Forced O(utooes/1000 Crit. Hrs.4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1)0.09 -
| |
| -2.5-iO-t5 0 5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Deviottens from Older Plent Means (Meosured in Stcndcrd Devictions) 91 1
| |
| 1 l
| |
| l c
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.39 I
| |
| C Indicotor HADDAM NECK Legend: Older Plont Avercge Critical Hous 86-2 to 88-1 4 0" ''" " " ^**' l' g
| |
| : 1. Autornatic ScrcrYis WN'e Critical 2. Sofety System Actu0 tons 4--- 2500 4 2500
| |
| - 2220 - 2250
| |
| /* tu " ,'** 2000 ~
| |
| ~,f 3 3 ,~* 3. /
| |
| ig . n ,-
| |
| ~, ,y .,- .
| |
| E!
| |
| ~< ,
| |
| -/ 2
| |
| . e00 ='
| |
| ]<! *
| |
| / _ 1500 '
| |
| *2-g - 1250 og2- .
| |
| r250f
| |
| . 1000 - 000 i . 750 ~ . 7'A 3
| |
| ~ "
| |
| $00 Sco
| |
| - 250 . 250
| |
| ('f d :
| |
| 0 d -
| |
| \!, 0 0 0 L L 86 2 86 3 O el-18N-2 8/-3 8/-4 8$-1 L L 862863864L 81-187k2 Si-3 8/-4 85-1 Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sgnificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. SOfety System Folues e 3- 3 3.
| |
| Ek jh at -!
| |
| 3<2- 2<. 2 2 lg} lgo.
| |
| } $ %
| |
| k I w g)
| |
| ; O 86L2 L86L3 86 4yl-t g8;-3 8f-4 8$-1 L j SeL2 86L3 e6 4yi-t eg-3 8/-4 as-i
| |
| : 6. Equiornem Need Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Fcrced Outoge Rote (s) 1000 (. o Hous n S k k 31 k<I a - s<
| |
| 2D IS'"
| |
| ~
| |
| E
| |
| ! n-a 2-2' Tt g
| |
| 0 bg I_i_2 ,
| |
| 0 $IS. - -
| |
| 8-38I-4 E!'- t 06k 2 tok) 84-4 /-t 87-3 87-4 86-1 86'-2S4386k 4 /-t $7 I
| |
| 92
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.39 I
| |
| ~'s-HADDAM NECK: Trends (G .
| |
| Declined improved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical -lgg (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - y
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ o stausmensatuam
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilures (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) . .t73 - g
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o,74 s
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced Outodr./1000 (2 Crit.88-1)
| |
| Avg end Hrs. - p" ' > 1 i
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -i.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5
| |
| . Devictions (Measured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Piont )Means Devictions HADDAM NECK: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Performance Indicators Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| : 1. Automat Scroms Whi;e Critical 4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0 32 !
| |
| i
| |
| /
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tii
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . { og
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o.21
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0.76
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced it tog / , q,,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 0.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Oider Plant Veons (Measured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| /"%
| |
| b 93
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.40 C Ir6 Cotor HATCH 1 Legend: c'eer e:cnt A erese Criticci Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| " 4 0 *' t '' ** ^ "' c i" g L Automotic Scrcyns WNie Criticd 2. Sofety System Actuations ggcc 4 2$00 4
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| *****ee
| |
| ~ ~
| |
| 3-
| |
| - 1750 fg 3.,
| |
| - 17* 0 h
| |
| 3 1 - co0 -- 314 uo -.
| |
| 2 2 450 p2- - 1250 o 2 -
| |
| 1 - om i 's' - om s I
| |
| ! : W . V i
| |
| : 750 * 'i 750 5
| |
| i - -
| |
| 1- -
| |
| 1 O g. 9 : O
| |
| {
| |
| 4
| |
| ,, j a 500 gg _; _
| |
| - sco 0 0 86b2 86 b 3 SN4 8/-t 8Y-2 8/=3 8/-4 8$-1 86b2 86b 3 66b e 8/-t SI-2 4/-3 SI-4 SS-i i Year - Gucrter Yeor - Quctter l
| |
| : 3. Siysficont Events ,
| |
| : 6. Safety Systern Folures a 3. e J-h
| |
| -1 -t*
| |
| Y o 2 2 2 5g* 5''
| |
| }7 j~~
| |
| $ hf $/f is s 4 %
| |
| 9-tc i v;rrs= $ #
| |
| % 'I $ V
| |
| , k Nil ~
| |
| 's -
| |
| , % f L L 4 s/-i si-2 s/-3 si 4 ea'- i 2 b L esb a6 3 Yeor i
| |
| e6 4- sl-1 ter b-2 ei-3 ei-4 ed-1 e6'-2 sais e6 Year - Quarter I
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| t 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) 1000 Crit <:d Hotts oO e- -.
| |
| n 8 6 ao - g h5 $
| |
| 0- 31
| |
| &<1 a<
| |
| b5 5'~
| |
| 3, $ ' ~ $ 2 ,,
| |
| - w 2- T'
| |
| *2 % o 92 y 2h r-~L - - -
| |
| & mom 3
| |
| , i 4 i . .F - ' '
| |
| o m -
| |
| ei-2 ei-3 eeLe s/-i ai-2 si-3 si-4 ss-i e6L 2 ei-3 e4-4 ai-i ei-2 si-2 si-4 ea-i Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quorter 94 1
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.40 I
| |
| f~''
| |
| \-
| |
| HATCH 1: Trends .
| |
| O'C'i"*d ''"Pr "*d Performance Indicators I
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical 09 (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - J s l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . kh oss se
| |
| : 3. Significant Events ,(2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 03a
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o.3q
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . d' h tJ
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs /1000 Crit. Hrs. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| W gggg 143
| |
| -2.5-i.0 i.0 .5 0.0 O!S t'0 l'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Mecns (Mecsured in Standard Deviations)
| |
| HATCH 1: Deviathons from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Autosnotic Scroms While Critical '
| |
| -oJ2 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.46
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| {f o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -to j f'
| |
| : 5. Forced Outage Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 039
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs / ag)j- 0.52
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -I.5 -to -0.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Oider Ptnt Mecns (Measured in Stondord Deviations) l 95
| |
| | |
| f~
| |
| F:GURE 4.41 r' i IrCCCtor HATCH 2 Legend: ee met Avem Critical Hotss 86-2 to 88 1
| |
| "" 4 0 *''" * *i"9 ^**' 9'
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scf&ns While Critical 2. Sofety Systern Actuatons
| |
| - 2250 . 2250
| |
| / .-
| |
| 2000 I '' * -
| |
| 3- D' . , 3 , g { 3.
| |
| 3h
| |
| ~
| |
| h 3 g
| |
| ) k) l \ - 1250 o - 1250 lgt.
| |
| f 4
| |
| "! lg2-I &
| |
| ( :
| |
| q 2: : g N:
| |
| 8 8 e
| |
| 0 i la-u)$ -bH 86L2 86L3 al l-1 87- 8538/-488-1
| |
| - =
| |
| 0 0 T
| |
| e6L 2 e6'L--3
| |
| =-Mi ~-
| |
| @e -
| |
| 4 i-i SI-3 s/-4 88-i 0
| |
| : 3. 5<pficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foltres b
| |
| a
| |
| .3- ,3. > 3 9
| |
| !h jh h h
| |
| -e -r & 5 ?
| |
| ,/A
| |
| ,- 2<'- t 2 2 a
| |
| * m
| |
| * r g g 7
| |
| $ b suh N$
| |
| g grg
| |
| +
| |
| xi ,, . ,
| |
| n*e so 5 !i im
| |
| * e .
| |
| I eel2 a6L3 es-4 sl-i ai-2 a/-3 ei-4 ei-i sei t e6L 3 e6-4 e/-i si-2 si-3 si- sa-i Year - Quarter Yeor - Oxrter
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (z) 6. Equgnt Forced Outoges/
| |
| Crited Hours 8 m- h ik 3'~h
| |
| $ is hi .0 ' fa b5 15 *
| |
| * tj ' - l 2 ,,
| |
| s
| |
| ' w 2- 7 04
| |
| % 0%
| |
| , rh El fil m _ .'-A ,
| |
| * F f dd o ei-2 ei-3 e6L 4 si-i si-2 si-3 s/-4 e6-i si-2ei-3ei-4 si-i ei-2 si-3 si-. es-i Yser - QUCrter Yeor - Quorter O
| |
| 96
| |
| | |
| 4 FIGURE 4.41 i
| |
| (')
| |
| s-HATCH 2: Trends ,
| |
| I Declined impeoved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical "
| |
| (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - o.71
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) .- 2.89
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ ,
| |
| o..,e
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 16 l ,
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . o 4o
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outcoes/1000 Crit. Hrs. 123 (2 Ott Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 1'O 1l5 2IO 2.5 Devict'eosured ns from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Plont )Meons Devictions i HATCH 2: Deviations from Olde'r Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 4 36M+s$
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 5' [
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ .t24 'E !s 5
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.98 y vmm ,,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . q gg4} -2.55
| |
| .. A sens
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . O.51
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs. @g 0%
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2'.0 -i.5 i.0 -d.5 0 0 O!5 1l0 l'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from OMer Plont Meons (Measured in Stondord Deviations)
| |
| O O
| |
| 97
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.42 C IndicClor HOPE CREEK Legend: Older Plont Avercge Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1 "" 4 0*r t" N'n9 ^* *r:9'
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scrorns Wnle Critied 2. Sofety System Actuations 4 2500 4 _ _
| |
| 2aco
| |
| - **" - 22 "
| |
| f
| |
| /'g 3 -
| |
| to *l tr ,'.. y -
| |
| 'p mf
| |
| : f. 3 3- /
| |
| h 3. j/
| |
| LB bg ,
| |
| - 1750 -g $ f 24
| |
| . 17w I <
| |
| - 600 I ,
| |
| h 8
| |
| 'g - 600
| |
| -j z e 2- S .- 1 x 3 l}et- h4,>f
| |
| \ - \ .
| |
| "1 w@k h -
| |
| "i ll Sh h M
| |
| h[{f-#
| |
| ,~ & M i 7M b ,~
| |
| ip -
| |
| 3 k- 5 --- -- l ,5 - "
| |
| { { ' 'h &
| |
| l
| |
| . 3 8 i ; 7 e6L2 esL3 seL4 el-i e/-2 si-3 ei-4 eel-t e.. W l
| |
| ~
| |
| E' sei2e6L3 se'-4 ei-t L2 ei-3 e/-s as-i 1" i Year - Qucrter Yecr - ter
| |
| : 3. Spficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fokses
| |
| =3- 3 3- 1"
| |
| }h jh
| |
| -e -r '
| |
| c.
| |
| z<t-g 3<2-g f b b ? h
| |
| - 1-f (
| |
| sq M
| |
| W de , d e 42 -
| |
| 2 & 4 @
| |
| 5 4
| |
| seL2 e6L3 eel 4 td-t s/-2 s/-3 s/-4 es-1 esL2se'-3 e6 L 4 e/-i ai-2 s/-3 si-4 es-i i Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ . _nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Critied Hours 1
| |
| - I
| |
| ? m- 8' h a3 h
| |
| l s ~
| |
| in l hA fE b5 $$ ~
| |
| l
| |
| , j 4o -
| |
| e ;g j 212 g,
| |
| "*~
| |
| 20 - - p % M ,,
| |
| y a vw m
| |
| - 85 [ b El [1 , tD r II l si-2 seLa seL4 s/-i e/ 2 si-3 87-4 sa-t e6L 2 66-3 64-4 si-i ei-2 si-3 sf-4 sa'- i l Year - Quarter Year - Quarter O
| |
| 98 l
| |
| | |
| . =. ..
| |
| FIGURE 4.42 U,n. HOPE CREEK: Trends ,
| |
| Declined improved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Autcmotic Scroms While Critical EE l EE (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) - x 0 89
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg eM 88-1) . 139
| |
| : 3. Sig.ificont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t72 .
| |
| NsRf5%k
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 2.t2
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 0.02
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog /10 it Hr
| |
| , , ,g
| |
| -2.5-iO-I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 -
| |
| Devictions (Measured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Piont )Meons Devictions 1 HOPE CREEK: Deviations from Older. Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical -o46 I (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| y- g u,y
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ggggy aws mw ,
| |
| 24
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - _o.43
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.23
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced 0 rit to g / - -o.57
| |
| -2.5 -10 I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Older Plont Veens (Measured in Standard Deviations) v
| |
| - 99
| |
| | |
| 1 1
| |
| FIGURE 4.43 I C IndiCCtCf
| |
| . INDIAN POINT 2 Legend: Oic- *t 4 - ;e CriticCl Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| '"" 4 0"' t " *''9 ^*"os' g
| |
| : 1. AutortctiC SCrcrfis VINie CritiCd 2. Scfety System Actuctbns 4 23m . 230e
| |
| . 2W . 2250 g
| |
| ,_ ./#\ -
| |
| my 1750
| |
| 'g tow ;
| |
| i750 '
| |
| a= I - a 3
| |
| . n< .
| |
| gt- h -
| |
| '230 h og -2 h - 1250 ji t- ~b n ' ' ' ~
| |
| "]O ji g'
| |
| . % y Q i' ~
| |
| ~a T
| |
| l \ E . 500 7 i" . 500 l 'y
| |
| '~
| |
| o t
| |
| * 0 0 --
| |
| 0
| |
| ."L2 86k J Soke /-1 86 7h3 8/-4 8$-1 - b k
| |
| 862863 4 - - -I-t 8/-387-4 88'-l
| |
| : 3. Si 71Bficant [ vents 4. Sofety System Fokses I
| |
| . 3- '. : 3. 3., 3 O=
| |
| e
| |
| # {t m3
| |
| 'fk' N %
| |
| I g 2 2 1 2 o 4
| |
| , 4 - 1 e k ge g 1- wm
| |
| # g%
| |
| $ h 4 l, k
| |
| 0 0.
| |
| 86k2 86b3 86 L 4 SY-187'-2 8/-3 8/-4 85-1 5 L 86286386'-4 81-1 8 7k 2 8 /-3 8 7'-4 88-i l Yeor - Qwrter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (t) Crit'cd Mcnts E 80 - E 3'~
| |
| ie 3e t
| |
| 47 b= .0 . a< c hs I D'" h gv g 40 - 3, y
| |
| j +
| |
| v h % ' ' "
| |
| ? 20s 20 - h, h_ ?
| |
| k- AAA-
| |
| + '
| |
| l1 4
| |
| dxm o
| |
| .._ 0 86L 2 L86 3 86-4g/-i g8j-3 Si-4 84-i 86L2 86L 3 86'-pgi-i Sgsj-3 87-4 Sa-i 10 0 O
| |
| i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.43 l
| |
| O INDIAN POINT 2: Trends ,
| |
| .oeclined improved Performance Indicctors
| |
| : 1. Automotig Scroms While Critical :':g%V (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 3 . o.71
| |
| ' 2. Sofety System Actuotices (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -249
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg en; 88-1) . g. ig
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . i S. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - .
| |
| k 0 82
| |
| : 6. Equvment Forced gtg/ git , g
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Means (Measured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| INDIAN POINT 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Ferf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticci 021 (4 Otr. Avg end 83-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t24 ftk 'k j
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t82
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 21
| |
| ,a
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg eno 88-1) . 0 70
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog /10 g3 j , g,73
| |
| -2.5-2.0-I.5 -I.0 -d.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont Meons (Mecsured .n Standord Devictions) 0 10 1 9
| |
| p , . , ----_v .y,.v -
| |
| m - --,- + _-
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.44 t-i indiC Ct or INDIAN POINT 3 Legend: ac- ae t -cse Criticot hours 86-2 to 88-1 - 4 Cart" Movi"9 ^verc3 h
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whle Crit.cd 2 Sofety System Actuctons ;gg 4 _
| |
| ;$co 4 m - 2250 - 2:50 M u.
| |
| m
| |
| **. - M - 20Co it - '*
| |
| . H -
| |
| 5 1 - . ~ -. y <t . w- .
| |
| .4 .
| |
| ' 2 -
| |
| t250 j 'pt. J -
| |
| eso j fpt-f ' -
| |
| =; i l -
| |
| a
| |
| ,- $+
| |
| Q Q.yN" i,!i l4n-Qg 7 e-
| |
| - sco a ,-
| |
| ps T' m
| |
| h*i_p.% _
| |
| ~
| |
| j ppi
| |
| -a soo y$
| |
| l b k %" W - M h $8
| |
| @ bi $
| |
| #~- , - 2M
| |
| @ (I o
| |
| : ifl " 7 "
| |
| o o i o e6-2 ee' 3 sele el-i sat si-3 Si-4 es-i
| |
| - e6 2 sols si-4 s/-i ai-2 ei-3 Si-4 es-,
| |
| 1 year - Quarter iear - overter
| |
| : 3. 5<pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses
| |
| . 3- 3 3.
| |
| jh
| |
| -1 -t t<2- 2 < 2.
| |
| f s g
| |
| i 1 o
| |
| $w a ta
| |
| ~
| |
| a M% e 08-2 86-3 SO4 8/-1 Y e6h 2 66L 3 $6he SI-I SI-2 Si-3 8A4 88-1 veor b-2in8A3 8N4 88'-t Year - ovarter
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Ferced Outoge Rote (s) DOO Coted Mcus oo e n f N
| |
| = " - e &
| |
| {
| |
| "}
| |
| 3 },~ $
| |
| !! ?
| |
| }<1 .o . 3< 4 2r tr'- 33, g:
| |
| 2 pk' 5}
| |
| : 1) ** i "
| |
| ! ,~ ? *
| |
| -l[h%*%
| |
| 2e - ~
| |
| ? 2' 2:
| |
| e \ w A % .
| |
| .x "3
| |
| % 'a
| |
| .-g 1 _mm 3 \
| |
| = =
| |
| E ?%
| |
| =
| |
| o o 861 2 06k J $6k e 6/-t Si-2 Si-3 6i . 68-1 86'-284L 366'4 67-1 Si-2 Si-3 Si-4 SS-t Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter 9
| |
| 10 2
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.44
| |
| ~(J - ,
| |
| INDlAN POINT 3: Trends .
| |
| O'C'i"*d ' 'mS' "'d Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scrcms While Critical !E (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - oJ
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Gir. Avg end 88-1)- 141 m--ad3
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 83-1) - 0.5a
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ;
| |
| 5
| |
| : 5. Forced Outege Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . j o4 a
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it ,,
| |
| toges/ ,
| |
| -2.5-k.0 -i.5 -i.0 -A 5 0.0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5
| |
| . Devictions from Previous 4 Ctr. Aont Mecns (Measured in Stoidord Devictions)
| |
| INDIAN POINT 3: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scroms 'Whih Critical 7. [
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 6 y) '<
| |
| w
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuctions (4 0'.r. Avg end 88-1) - -L24
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.42
| |
| : 4. Safety System foilures (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) . [ o.5$
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c e7
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / gt ,
| |
| -2.5-$.0-i.5 i.O -d.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from O! der Picnt Mecns i (Measured in Stonderd Cevictions)
| |
| ! 10 3 L_
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4A5 A Indicctor KEWAUNEE Legend: eee acnt ^sem Criticci Hours g 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| -- 4. cuarte um,og Avecge g
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scrams While Cnt.M 2. Safety System Actuotions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| / ' / -g
| |
| ~ "
| |
| 3 3- / \
| |
| g ; - 1750 h }3. / - 1750 NI - 15u0 '
| |
| = j<I \ - soo ='
| |
| g2- - 1250 'p2- - ?250
| |
| - V0015 W
| |
| - 000 3
| |
| .V
| |
| %7 N 1 1 9
| |
| ,' t t t q~
| |
| N- W soo T ? soo o b
| |
| .% Mk,h_o lid
| |
| - 23o o
| |
| 5 k - 250 o
| |
| 8)A-2 86 k 3 86'-4 87-t Si-2 Si-3 SY-4 88-1 86'-286-388-4 8/-1 Of-2 8f-3 8/-4 88-1 Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sicpficant Events 4. Sofety System Fo'ves 4 - 4 m 3- *3.
| |
| -1 -i s<2-g 3<2-y
| |
| . a 1
| |
| d t-
| |
| % d4 g n %
| |
| k k 86266386'-4 8/-1 !Li-2 8/-3 8i-4 SS'-l 865 288-388-48/-1Si-287-3SI-4 88-i Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (t) 1000 Criticd Hot.rs oo 8 3 80 -
| |
| h h 31 h<! m - s<
| |
| 2e tr' if w
| |
| '0- IS B
| |
| * w 2- 171
| |
| ~
| |
| I 0 0 8 86-2 86' 3 8A-4 Si-1 Si-2 8I-3 Si-4 88-1
| |
| - S6-2 S6 k ) 56-4 8/-187k2 Si-3 SI-* 83-1 !
| |
| Yey - Quarter Year - Quarter )
| |
| O ,
| |
| 10 4 1
| |
| 1 i
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.45
| |
| .ru y . KEWAUNEE: Trends ,
| |
| Declined improved Performance indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Criticci (2 Otr. Avg end 68-1) - o
| |
| : 2. Sofety System ActuSons (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . oss is
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| ~
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5-I.0-0.50.0 05 1.'O t'5 2'.0 2.5 Deviations (Measured from Previous in Stenderd 4 Otr. Plont )Meons Devictions 1
| |
| 4 KEWAUNEE: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical j (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -032
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.46
| |
| ;w :
| |
| : 3. Sigrificant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 3 o.se eo .
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Felures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ty
| |
| : 5. Forced Outege Rete (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.79 ,
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced tog / pt , g,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -I.5 -i.0 -d.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Means (Measured in Stondard Devictions) i m l
| |
| U.
| |
| I 10 5 1
| |
| | |
| i FIGURE 4.46 I
| |
| l C Indicotcf !
| |
| LASALLE 1 Legend: 0:eer Pent evercse Criticci Hours -
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| "" 4 0*' t" *"9 ^"': 3*
| |
| h
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whle Cntical 2. Scfety System Actuctions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| . 2250 - 2250
| |
| ~ *
| |
| : 3. ** 3
| |
| . \ g I3 4 . - '=
| |
| 3 u{ 3, N N - '''o
| |
| @j 1[ s, - == ; yj s. - em ;
| |
| . 1250 og2- - t2'o lg2-1
| |
| ,~ 1 l
| |
| l \ I! 1 I
| |
| 5*
| |
| ji ,- 1 1,
| |
| *" 3 d
| |
| lB e l: m81 - soo gg - 5=
| |
| 0 /* .
| |
| n o .
| |
| o 865286386-4 5 Si-18/-2 8Y-3 8/-4 86-1 86L286k 3 86-4 8/-18/-2 8I-3 Si-4 8$.1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 3. Sipficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses a 3- g 3-
| |
| -1 -t O o 1 2 e2- 3-2 - -
| |
| 1 1
| |
| d .
| |
| i 1
| |
| pg 1
| |
| / ',.
| |
| % w %
| |
| h' g ( 's- g E j $? hY N x l 86b2 86 5 3 de 8 -18/-2 Sk-3 SI-4 8$-1 k L 8/=1 86'-2863864 528I-3SI-4 88-1 f Yecr - Quarter Yecr - yter l
| |
| ' 6. Eodoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| l S. Forced Outoge Rote (*) 1000 Crited Hous i oo _ _ 8 l e l b M- @
| |
| h5 N Si
| |
| }<i = -
| |
| -' x 6 3<
| |
| we-O -* A 342
| |
| ~
| |
| E. . e 5 w
| |
| " n w 2- %
| |
| 20 - g n _m o o k
| |
| 86L 286386-4 87' 18I-2 SI-3 8I-4 88'-1 861 2 Sok) $6-4 87-1 * ' 2 Si-3 87-4 es-l Year - Qierter Yeor - 4 rter O
| |
| 10 6
| |
| | |
| FGURE 4.46 O
| |
| v LASALLE 1: Trends ,
| |
| Perforrnance Indicators O'CII"*d '"C' "'d
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 1 75
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2.0tr. Avg end 88-1) ; o
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.58
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr' Avg end 88-1) . .cy n:? :
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote.(2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 1 t28 it
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Ou, tog / - as7
| |
| -2.5 -$.0 -i.5 -t0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 l'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt Means (Measured in Stoncord Devictions)
| |
| LASALLE 1: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bel 'w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 4 kr. Avg nd 8 $) - -oJ2 l
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - yNN ut zQ%
| |
| : 3. Sigificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 9e
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Aig end 88-1' - .o,i4 l
| |
| 3
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rste (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - 031 Cjit g,,
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtog/ ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0 0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devotions from Older Plant Means (Veosured in Stonderd Devictions) 1 10 7
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.47 A IndicClor LASALLE 2 Legend: eee P'ent 4 vo;e Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| "" 4 0" ' " **9 ^ * " 4' g
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms Wh4 Critical 2. Safety System Acttotions 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 - 2250 3, 3
| |
| { 3, th p -
| |
| , ih - -
| |
| at
| |
| -< l
| |
| * s<i
| |
| * t g. 2 l _
| |
| cs0 )
| |
| r250 j lg2.
| |
| 3 ll "3O 3 y' t
| |
| ,~ t.
| |
| h'. . E _ s00 _ sco
| |
| . 250 A - 250 0 s A b'- 0 0 WL 0 86k2 86k J 86L4 8/-t SY-2 8Y-3 SI-4 SN-1 86'-2 86k3 86'-4 SI-I 9I-2 8Y-3 8I-4 88'- t Yeor - Quarty Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. SiqFificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foltres '
| |
| 3 s
| |
| O
| |
| . J. e 3. s h h %<
| |
| wt ma e
| |
| %A ;A f f*" E*~ if
| |
| ,~ ~ ,~ ""
| |
| Tr 77 7 s ~
| |
| g g. , u .. a o ___ 0 86k2 86 L 3 86'-4 Si-i si-2 8/-s Srk4 Si-i e6'-2 86 k sL86 4 8/-i 8/-2 8/-3 8f-4 Sa- ,
| |
| Year - Quarter year - overter
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (5) f000 Crited Hours um 8 _
| |
| b 80 -
| |
| p . 23'-
| |
| !I h<t a -
| |
| *x 48 s<
| |
| w we.
| |
| $D T -3 33 3$ "- k! '$ 3
| |
| . 2 a e
| |
| 20 m
| |
| i ,- >
| |
| 18 E" k-0 .'- 0 l 86'-2 86 k J $6'-4 8/=1 (I-2 SI-3 SI-4 88 1 86k 2 86-) 86-4 8/-1 Si-2 Si-3 8f-4 88-1 l Yeor - Quorter
| |
| * eor - Guarter 10 8
| |
| | |
| : FIGURE 4.47
| |
| .,m (s. s) LASALLE 2: Trends ,
| |
| Declined Irnproved Performance Indicotors
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticci @
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88- 1) - -c.Sa p;;
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.se
| |
| . 3. Signif; cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.sa
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foikses (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) k%, id'(%f['h* -4.o4
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced Outooes/1000 Cnt. Hrs. 0 'O (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i.0 -6.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions(Measured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Plont )Means Deviations LASALLE 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical f (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.21
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Ar.tuotions (4 Otr, Avg end 88-1) . o.33
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .0.42 j il
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -0.48
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) - ? o.21 4
| |
| p W
| |
| : 6. Equ' ment Forced gtogs/ C;it3g,7j , ,,,,
| |
| -2.5-$.0-I.5 -I0 -d.5 0.0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2.02.5 Deviations from Older Plont Maons (Measured in Stonderd Deviations) 10 9
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.48 Indicc!or ',
| |
| LIMERICK Legend: oc* P =t ^ *'c;*
| |
| Critical Hours s 86-2 to 88-1 ~'"''''"'"*^"''' W
| |
| : 1. Autornatic Scrorns Whle Critied ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety Systern Actuations
| |
| . 22so . 2250
| |
| ~~-
| |
| /.s 2000 ~ / P' 2000 f
| |
| : 3. h 3-
| |
| ~ ~
| |
| it -
| |
| 3 it 3
| |
| N-<
| |
| I - 500; $ <I 500 3 g2. j .
| |
| cSoj ' g 2. -
| |
| @f g 7 .
| |
| 3 g g -
| |
| 3
| |
| ~'
| |
| 750
| |
| . 750 j i.
| |
| , , Q -
| |
| 3
| |
| - - 500 g pl _ - W
| |
| %. 3 N _ 9A 3-n b o L $
| |
| sekte6L3 e6 L 4 s/-t ei-2 s/-3 s/-4 ed-i seL2 eels e6L 4 s/-i SI-2 si-3 s/-4 ed 1 Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. 5<pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fokses
| |
| .3. 3 3- A .1 5h jh k -
| |
| ) -I t '.D.
| |
| 2<'' i<'~
| |
| 5 a 2 S h. Q, #:
| |
| I* j 2
| |
| ? d hJ s t.
| |
| i-
| |
| [ sj dj p., f % ! .;
| |
| o o h l' -
| |
| l 66L 2 86-3 86 L 4 8/-t ' 2 8/-3 si-4 S$-1 86L 2 06'-3 86'-4 8/-t sj-2 Si-3 8/-4 88-1 Year - - ter '
| |
| Yeor - wter 4
| |
| : 6. Equ .nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcge Rote (z) Crited Hoas 10 0 0-- 6
| |
| ?
| |
| M.
| |
| =,
| |
| g 23'-
| |
| = i.
| |
| }}
| |
| ~
| |
| h5 - -
| |
| w we_ 3 fD e3 40 7u 3
| |
| w w 2.
| |
| 20 .
| |
| 6 o O ^
| |
| 6266386'4 k Si-t Si-2 SI-3 6f-4 SS-t $6k 2 $6'-3 86-4 Si-18I-2 SI-3 67-4 38-1 Yecr - Quarter Yeor - Quarter 9 "
| |
| 110 6~
| |
| | |
| l, FIGURE 4.48 i
| |
| gg 4i J LIMERICK: Trends .
| |
| Decnned improved Performance Indicators i
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms WNie Critical E OM (1 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| ' o.go
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0 82
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge' Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - _
| |
| o.82
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit. Hrs. 02 (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| i
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 O!S t'0 l'5 2'O 2.5 Devictior's from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt Means
| |
| . (Measured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| LIMERICK: Deviations from Older Plant Means 8el w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf, Performance indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms WNie Criticot 02f I f4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg :nd 88-1) . .t24 g_;p W
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . {'j o9g
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -t52 lHRew#----
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.76
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs. -
| |
| 0 90 (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - !
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 i.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 1'O l'5 210 25 Devictions from Oider Plant Veens (Measured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| U(*\
| |
| 111
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.49 C Ind1 Cot or l' MAINE YANKEE Legend: Oeer mont werose Critical Hotss 86-2 to 88-1 """ 4 0''''" % A"oS' l Autornotic Scrorns Whle Critical 2. Sofety Systern Actuatons 4 250o 4 250o
| |
| . 2250 - 225o
| |
| 'N / ., 2000 .
| |
| e l N v/* 2o3o f I ,3 - . _
| |
| o, y ,3. _
| |
| ,m ,
| |
| 4
| |
| ! eco m' j <! -
| |
| eco '.
| |
| . p 2 ..
| |
| 2 .
| |
| 1250 f a -p 2. _ mj g -
| |
| )) ,~ m i 1
| |
| *5
| |
| ! ji ,~
| |
| /
| |
| Nd
| |
| %\ , _ 500 . Soo 0
| |
| ! lh 2 b!*o - =
| |
| o
| |
| - =
| |
| o 3 86LYeor 86L 2 86L 4 Si-t t/-2 Si-3 8/-4 86-1 86L 2 86L3 L 86 4 Si-t Si-2 mi-3 Si-4 ea'-i
| |
| - QJorter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sigiricant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Folures a 3-
| |
| * 3.
| |
| h h
| |
| -e
| |
| -1 "g2. g2.
| |
| t 1 ,, L R
| |
| o o 86L 2 84-3 86 L 4 8/-l 8I-2 8/-3 Oi-4 8$-t 865 2 86b3 86'-4 4/-t Oi-2 Si-3 8/-4 88- t Year - Qutttor Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Critcd Hous t)o 8 8 80 . h
| |
| $h EU h
| |
| 3 60 5 St b5 $ $5* ~
| |
| ]u f.
| |
| N- M T
| |
| kg &&
| |
| ff 2.
| |
| / o es - ~r o
| |
| J, 2 - M- , $ ,
| |
| o fI ,di f A
| |
| - - ~ M 86-2 86k 3 86k e 87-1 SI 2 SI-3 8/-4 8d-1 86284-3 Seke Si-1 Si-2 Si-3 SI-4 55 -1 Y eor - Qwrter Year - Quarter 112 9
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.49 Q MAINE YANKEE: Trends improved-Declined Performance Indicotors
| |
| '1. Automotic Scroms Wh;ie Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o'
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c.5e
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 96
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced to g / 0 it ,
| |
| -2.5-d.0-i.5 -iO -d.5 0.0 0.5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictisns from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Means (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| MAINE YANKEE: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical 021 j
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - ut
| |
| : 3. Sigdficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 8J-1) . o.se
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| * o.go
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -o.93
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtogs/ git , ny
| |
| -2.5-5.0-[5 lo -0.5 0 0 OIS t'0 L'S 2l0 25 Dev;otions from OMer Piont Means (Vecsured in Stonderd Cevictions)
| |
| O 113
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.50 Indicator MCGUIRE 1 Legend: een ment ^verese Critical Hotts 86-2 to 88-1 '#"" 4 0 *rt" Mc"in9 Av"or l Autornotic Scrorns WNie Critical 2. Sofety Systern Acttotions 4 2s00 4 2sco
| |
| . 22co - 225o
| |
| - 2000 ~ f l - 2ooo 'r 5 g.3 - - nso k l3
| |
| - g, - l 2.-
| |
| s ; - use 2
| |
| N I -
| |
| eco . I ! O -
| |
| eco .
| |
| p2 N 2 125o j o3- 2 k- use j f.- \
| |
| l~
| |
| y #3 f \ h E
| |
| ~
| |
| *3
| |
| , , , , ,n -
| |
| -s ., , \ ,. g ,
| |
| ~a o I o o o seL2 es-3 e6'-4 s/-i ti-2 si-3 af-4 as-i se'-2 e6 k 3 es-4 el-i ai-2 ei-3 si-4 so-1 Year - Qucrter yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 3. Sipficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Softty Systern Foltres
| |
| $g
| |
| =
| |
| y
| |
| . 3- 3- :3 l I' 5' hd 4 -t 4 o*2-o"t-t p 2
| |
| 7 2
| |
| =
| |
| 2 %
| |
| k f f
| |
| .i x%
| |
| UI Ag v D\
| |
| d
| |
| ~ ~
| |
| p/
| |
| m -
| |
| 4 1 3 Ni 46 MYe & i" s o
| |
| o i
| |
| ' # b f--2 ti6 k3 86 b 4 8Y-16/-2 8/-3 8/-4 88-1 L k k 6/-t 8/-2 Si-3 ti-4 83 - t 862663664 Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Ecp nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Ferced Outcxpe Rote (s) Critk:d Hotis tuo a 3 80 - .-
| |
| h M gh 3 !
| |
| l <! M - $g a<
| |
| h$ .$~
| |
| l 2 92 34 s t a /
| |
| x$s$ *m e, s]
| |
| a ...
| |
| u N
| |
| Qf5%h''w k%p .y c ''3
| |
| , 1 1 E m
| |
| _t_ m 3 6- --
| |
| : h. 4 [~'] W Is. he s es-2 96-3 86'-4 6/-1 Si-2 Si-3 SI-4 SS-t Sok 2 86 k 3 Bi-4 81., Si-2 Si-3 SI-4 88 -i Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter O
| |
| 114
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.50 i
| |
| (aT MCGUIRE 1: Trends .
| |
| Performance Indicators O'Cf"'d '*P' "'d
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical %
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t73 g@d{MO''?f; f
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . o.s l
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . t
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o33
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.75
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ , g,,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-I.5 -to -0.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 1'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons '
| |
| (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| MCGUIRE 1: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators I
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Criticol -139 '
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 2.02
| |
| : 3. Syrelicont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.42
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.sj
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.42
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced it toys / ,
| |
| I
| |
| -2.5 -j.O I 5 -i.0 -d.5 0 0 0'S t'0 t'5 2'O 25 vevictions f rom Older Plant Meons (Measured in Stondo'd Devictions)
| |
| O li5
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.51 r-~~ 1 ino,cetor MCGUIRE 2 Legend: o'eer P'ont ^verose Critical Hotss 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| -- 4 cote % Avercge t Automatic Scrcrns Whle Critied 2 Sofety Systern Actuotions e tsoo 4 :soo
| |
| - 22so . 2:50 2o00 -'
| |
| l l i >-
| |
| 13
| |
| : s. ,s., .
| |
| \ .
| |
| , g .\...
| |
| : coo 1 e I - * -
| |
| * if t2so j o g 2. -
| |
| t:so j lp1
| |
| ,~
| |
| f, , ,
| |
| lj t .
| |
| *a i
| |
| ji ,"
| |
| "i
| |
| ~3
| |
| \E a V - soo . sco o e
| |
| (
| |
| b 1
| |
| [ h I
| |
| i
| |
| . 25o o o
| |
| }h.
| |
| [
| |
| u A
| |
| . 250 o
| |
| est eel 3 sele e/-, ai-2 ei-s ai-4 ee'-i eat esLs 044 el-, '- 2 si-2 si-e ss'-,
| |
| Yenr - Quarter Year - ter I
| |
| : 3. Sgrafcont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sa'ety System Fokses l
| |
| .3. , >- 2 l
| |
| }k jE i !
| |
| -1 -t ?
| |
| 2<1-
| |
| .y s<2-p m
| |
| , ta .
| |
| *f 5
| |
| ,. 1 , 2
| |
| ;g a" ,.
| |
| a .: / A g: [y iR$% 1 7 7 l
| |
| o 14 k $N
| |
| " L eel 2 06' 3 38L4 s/-, BI-2 Si-3 8/-4 88'- ,
| |
| - = o T '
| |
| i eekt 003004 81-1 a/ 2 Si-3 81-4 88-,
| |
| b i i
| |
| 'l l
| |
| Year - Quarter Year - Duarter l l
| |
| : 6. Equerv.snt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) 1000 Crited Mcus oo -- a n Y l
| |
| : m. g :
| |
| . g*- 1 "h
| |
| D h
| |
| .o l
| |
| ~
| |
| }<t so . ,8$
| |
| 3<
| |
| w me. 3 3 a3 I
| |
| 8m s -a h %. ..
| |
| Tj ' - h I
| |
| . E, },
| |
| * ,e - 23 y 2. '
| |
| "- s'?N t gy; t A : :' ..
| |
| 'n
| |
| < . , 4 %~ ..
| |
| Q ._-. ._ O O ._
| |
| o [.'_. L ~.
| |
| ec-, es, se- 1-, ,,-, ai-, si.. es., as-, as-, es . ei-, ,1., ,1-1 ei-. u.,
| |
| Yeor - Quarter Yect - Quarter 116 9
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.51 MCGUIRE 2: Trends
| |
| -(] Declined improved Performance Indicolors i
| |
| : 1. Automotig Scroms While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.71
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| . 3. Significent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tt3
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 3.7, g';
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Evg end 88-1) . o.73
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit. Hrs. 0 13 (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5-i.0 .500 0'5 t'0 1'S 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Mcons (Measured in Standard Deviations) ,
| |
| MCGUIRE 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticol <WG6
| |
| - Jg (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -l39 i
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ;, t3g
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _o.42 4 Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o.g4 l
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.64
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / , ,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0-I.5 -to -0.5 0 0 0 5 1'O t'5 2!O :5 Devictions from Older Ptont Meons (Measured in Standord Deviations)
| |
| O 117
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.52
| |
| -' 'ncic ct y !
| |
| MLLSTONE 1 Legend: -
| |
| ce* ment Avecse Critical Hoss 86-2 to 88-1 "" ' 0" t" " "i"9 ^'" 1' h
| |
| 1 Automatic Scrrs WN4 Critied 2. Sofety Systern Actuotions 4 2500 4 *$00
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| ^. . , . . ^.,-
| |
| i t,_
| |
| , f -
| |
| 2 0y y ,_ . .
| |
| ,m0 j ll -
| |
| =, p \
| |
| ~,
| |
| at u 1
| |
| a u <t a
| |
| O g2- \.'
| |
| - 1250 og2- . f2SO ji 9 1 9 i 1 y
| |
| 1
| |
| ~
| |
| i 9~
| |
| IR 2 - sm g - sm D j - 250 A %_ - 2so l 0
| |
| ti -< d 0 0 M2 0 BN2 SN3 86'-4 81 * *8/-38/-485-1 SN2 96-3 8$-4 8f-1 ei-2 Si-3 8I-4 88 -1 Yeor - Year - Qurirter
| |
| .- _'
| |
| * er
| |
| : 3. S s cont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foltres a 3- 3 3- 1
| |
| -t f
| |
| -1 ;
| |
| z<'~
| |
| s z<'~
| |
| I
| |
| ,s' T
| |
| 1 k%
| |
| V $,Ru
| |
| ~
| |
| N U /f' E '
| |
| O O 86L2 06 k 3 OS-4 61-18/-2 SY-3 . -4 8$-1 86k 2 66-3 86-4 8/-18,I-2 8f-3 8Y-4 68-1 Year - QWter Year - 4Arter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) Critcal Hoes oO 8 C
| |
| r m- F 8.
| |
| g ji i
| |
| .t<! 60 - 3<
| |
| 25 [5'-
| |
| 1 s
| |
| a 2-8 0 s _W 1 0 o-4 86'-2 66-3 80-4 8f-1 Si-2 6f-3 87-4 88 -1 66'-296b 386'-4 Sf-t Si-2 si-3 Gi-4 85-1 Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter O
| |
| 118
| |
| | |
| FIGLHE 4.52
| |
| .("~'
| |
| %_;i . MILLSTONE 1: Trends ,
| |
| f Performance Indicators Dec:ined irre oveo
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.69
| |
| ,1
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- I o.58
| |
| : 3. Sigenficont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o
| |
| : 4. Sofet'y System Fektes (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . us
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o s4
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tegs/ , o_g
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 -I.0 .5 0.0 O!$ t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plant Meons (Measured in Standard Devictions) .
| |
| MILLSTONE 1: Deviations frorn Older Phnt Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators ,
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticol i 'i (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.86 g
| |
| 7 Sofety System Actuations (4 Ott. Avg e:id 88-1) . o.n l
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o 4s A
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.so
| |
| : 6. Equ'pment Forced ptog/ gitg , g
| |
| -2.5-2'.0--i5-I.0-0.500 0'5 t'0 l'5 2!0 2.5 Deviobens from Oider Plont Means (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| O.a j 119 k a
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.53 1 1
| |
| O ind:C Ctor MLLSTONE 2 Legend: CWr Phnt Ave ge Criticot Hours 86-2 to 88 -1 - 4 C arter
| |
| * ns ^vecie h
| |
| : 1. Autornatic Scrcrvts WNle Crit'col 2. SCfety Systern Actuations
| |
| - 2250 - 2230
| |
| ,/ .
| |
| goco ~ **. _ g .,
| |
| 3 .
| |
| - 1730 f 3~
| |
| gg
| |
| ,T 3
| |
| 7.
| |
| 3 i?So h
| |
| 5 t ~ ~a - y <t %
| |
| & di 4
| |
| . w h.
| |
| *2-;
| |
| um ) g t- $ 4 -
| |
| c30 3 3
| |
| "] 3 hh f -
| |
| "i
| |
| * 5 N3
| |
| * + -
| |
| g~ l'"'"' _
| |
| t i i -
| |
| ,~
| |
| Si g\ ,jl. E- E - sm j '? - s=
| |
| G f')"
| |
| f k-
| |
| %'7 ll l')h#
| |
| '" ~'
| |
| (
| |
| - 250
| |
| ~
| |
| N
| |
| +
| |
| , :50 0 & L 0 0 o 86k2 86 L 3 86'-4 SI-187k2 Si-3 6/-4 86'-l Seit 86-3 86-k4 8I-1 si-2 87k J SI-4 88'-t Yeor - Quarter Ya - Quorter
| |
| : 3. 5<pfiCont Events 4. Sofety Systern rokses 3
| |
| e 3- a 3
| |
| -t -t
| |
| =<
| |
| 54
| |
| * g E
| |
| g2= (2 '
| |
| a- I ! ?
| |
| 1= . t, .h J
| |
| {%' rl
| |
| * V Q = 0 86k2 86k 3 86'-4 81-187-2 Si-3 SI-4 88'-1 86L286L3 66-4 Si-1 SI-2 87L3 Si-4 88-1 Yeor - OJtrter Yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 6. Equ t Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Fcreed Outcne Rote (t) Critccs Hours 00 8 l
| |
| 3 So = }
| |
| hh5m $
| |
| ia h4
| |
| ~
| |
| jE
| |
| = w,4-T b ** ~ b v= 2.s
| |
| ~
| |
| 2 fi w 2- '
| |
| ~
| |
| 1
| |
| =n a _.L C o N
| |
| 86-2 86-3 86-4 81-i ai-2 Si-3 8f-4 es-i 86- 1 86' 3 86' 4- 87-1 ti-2 Si-3 Si-4 Sa-i Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter l
| |
| 12 0
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.53 4:
| |
| O L ,I MILLSTONE 2: Trends .
| |
| Declined irnproved Performance Indicators
| |
| ~
| |
| : 1. Automotic Seroms While Criticol 173 (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.58
| |
| : 3. Sigdficont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures -(2 Otr: Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - 0 0 87
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it ',
| |
| togs / g$]j_ n ,3
| |
| -2.5-2.0-15-iO .500 05 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions (Meosured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Plont )Meons Devictions MILLSTONE 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators I
| |
| 4 Otr. Avg nd 8 - ) - -oJ6 J
| |
| _e
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t24 #
| |
| W W .
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 90
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Ikote (4 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - c.72
| |
| : 6. Equke.it Forced togs / C it . g
| |
| -2.5-2' .0-t5 -lo -0.5 0 0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Oncer Piont Means (Meosured in Stoncord Deviations)
| |
| O 12 1 i
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.54 C::::::3 indicat cc MILLSTONE 3 Legend: o eer Picnt everes.
| |
| Critical Hour s 86-2 to 88-1 -- 4 certer ue avercs.
| |
| 1 Automatic Scrcrns Wh4 Critied ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations .
| |
| k k . 22so . 2m 3, /\ 3 / -
| |
| 20m j g 3,
| |
| / -
| |
| noj It /
| |
| a .
| |
| - 'm 3 it s_ > - 'm 3
| |
| at T S - em "-
| |
| 3 <1
| |
| _ em "-
| |
| f
| |
| ~<
| |
| 'g2. hl-l ,
| |
| t2so j ' g 2. / .' 12.4 j jj j i / -
| |
| =3
| |
| ~a 1 i , -
| |
| s , , / ,
| |
| ,~
| |
| (
| |
| ,~
| |
| ( E ! 4 . soo N
| |
| 7 (h%
| |
| { M P kb
| |
| . 500 N
| |
| g i
| |
| 3sf g @ ?I"
| |
| $ h +
| |
| ;--:J to eel2e6L3 syl-i gs7'-3 ei-* es-1 sekt e6-3 Y-1 gs7'-3 er-. as-i
| |
| : 3. 5pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fai tres a J- 3 3.
| |
| j
| |
| -t -t z < 2. 3<2- ,
| |
| h ,h DN d d -*
| |
| p t.
| |
| 1 t. ,
| |
| q y
| |
| o N A 4
| |
| Y 2
| |
| o l e
| |
| x seL eels seg/-i sgs;La s7L. es-t 2
| |
| eeLseks%.g-igey'-ss7'..es-i 2
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) ,
| |
| 1000 Crited Mcus 3 m- h is 3'~t '
| |
| I<t m - a<
| |
| b5 5~
| |
| 3.$ ""
| |
| ,7 v w
| |
| }$ 2. ta3 g,3
| |
| * # N 129 gg I
| |
| , c ^ bT%WW ~
| |
| 8 h E o m _
| |
| o
| |
| #2s.,+j.,e,.;->s,-.es-,
| |
| u.2 u-, u,..j-, e,,,-> e. ' .. so-,
| |
| O 12 2
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.54
| |
| ^
| |
| MILLSTONE 3: Trends (v) ,
| |
| Decc.,ed imp <oved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Crit' col 0 87 (2 Otr. Avg end 88 1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety Systent Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .,
| |
| : 3. Sigrificant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . c33
| |
| : 4. Scfety System failures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -249
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . g34
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced togs / it , g ,,
| |
| l
| |
| ~2.5-$.0 -l5 iO -d.5 O!O 0.'5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions (Meesured from Previous in Standard 4 Otr. Piont )Meons Devictions MILLSTONE 3: Dev ations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 4 Otr Avg )- -2.99 l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t24
| |
| : 3. S;gnificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -ta2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg enc 88-1) - -o. i4
| |
| : 5. Forced outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88 1) . f 1.
| |
| o44 l 6. Equpment Forced it togs / - o4
| |
| -2.5-2.0-l5 -I.0 -d.5 0'O O'S t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from older Plant Meons (Meosured in Stondord Devictions) s 12 3 l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.55 C indicct er MONTICELLO Legend: Older Plont Avercge Critical Hotrs 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| "" ' C " ' ' '' "''9 * * * ' S '
| |
| h t Automot'c Scrcrns WNe Critical 2. Safety System Actuatons 4 2500 4 2500
| |
| - 225o . 225o
| |
| . 2000 " ''\ . 2000 "
| |
| h 3-f
| |
| [/\ - Ud g jh 3- [
| |
| - "M g
| |
| N <I - eco -' j <i .
| |
| eco '.
| |
| * I CSO g2- - 1250
| |
| 'y2- .
| |
| .> \ . 000 3 j . 000 3 q% % y 5 ** 4
| |
| % . 750 - . 750 ?
| |
| '~ ''
| |
| @ soo I k Soo Wy t
| |
| 1 a r3 '"
| |
| %Q- %
| |
| ~
| |
| p p @ j
| |
| ~
| |
| o o o k
| |
| - - o 8652 86 b 3 88-4 Sl-187-2 8/-3 8/~4 8$=1 SS-2 86 b 3 68-4 al-1 ti-2 6/-3 6/-* 88'-t Year - Qucrter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Spficant Evects 4. Sofety System Fczkres e 3. d a 3.
| |
| }k w&
| |
| M
| |
| +%
| |
| JE w$
| |
| o k 'E I
| |
| gE*~ [ I" 7 53
| |
| ' $ j3 5 f)
| |
| ++ F%
| |
| n i;_
| |
| (_
| |
| s :3 -
| |
| n M
| |
| W ^
| |
| P7" %:
| |
| 86L286L3 Soke SI-1 sY-2 8/-3 SI-4 8$-1 8N-2 86k 3 SS-4 8Y-1 SY-2 SY-3 Si-4 8$-I Year - Qucrter Yect - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) iCCO Critcal Hotss eo e i
| |
| 1 .
| |
| I 2 m- ,k ..
| |
| h h I<! a - a<
| |
| b5 5~
| |
| 33 "" 53 2 _
| |
| t 2-
| |
| *~
| |
| N ^
| |
| o A e. _ _ _ . o asl__ E3 > _a m e6-2 e6-3 es-. si-i ei-2 :)-3 s7-4 es -,
| |
| es-2 as-3 84-4 31-i s>-2 si-3 st_. so-,
| |
| Yeor - Qi.orter Year - Quarter 12 4 9
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.55 O
| |
| s.J MONTICELLO: Trends .
| |
| Performance indicators O'Cli"'d '*P' "*d 2 OtrYAvg end f) - 3
| |
| : 2. ' Sofety System Actuations (2 -Ott. Avg end 88-1) i
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ass
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FoGures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ': (h 173
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tg / it j3sMj - t35 I
| |
| -2.5-i.0-15 -io -d.5 O!O O!S l'O t'5 2'0 2.5 .
| |
| Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Pk:nt )Mecns (Measured in Standord Devictions 9
| |
| MONTICELLO: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical c.21 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - e
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ass
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 421
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 476
| |
| : f. Equipment Forced it g, ,
| |
| tog /10 ,
| |
| -2.5-k.0-15 -to -0.5 0 0 0.$ t'0 t'$ 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont Meons (Measured in Stencord Devictions)
| |
| O b
| |
| 12 5
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.56 Indicctor NINE MLE PT. 1 Legend: -- Criticci oteer ammt 4 ero;e Hevs 86-2 to 88-1 - 4 0 *' ' "
| |
| * N ^ "' *
| |
| : t. Autornatic Scrcrre Wh4 Critied 2. Scfety Systern Actuatens 4 2500 4 _
| |
| 2soo
| |
| - # . 2N mm :
| |
| 3.
| |
| 3.
| |
| x.'e .
| |
| g E
| |
| h g
| |
| eco a'
| |
| }h j
| |
| ~)
| |
| y<
| |
| (
| |
| R
| |
| '750 em .-
| |
| g
| |
| ..< m:
| |
| *2.
| |
| g ,
| |
| 125o j o32. j .
| |
| eso j by ha [d r h - IXC 3 3
| |
| k t* f y
| |
| (L.
| |
| / .m coo a 3
| |
| -0
| |
| & &> 7so -
| |
| 0 \1 _
| |
| : 1. # 4 1 W L ff 1J
| |
| $J $ - 500 J. 'w';
| |
| . 500 4 9 ,
| |
| n
| |
| ) , ,
| |
| 86L 2 86L 3 Se'-4 Sl-t ei-2 ti-3 8/-4 8$-1 865 2 Sok 3 eel 4 8/-t ' 2 Si-3 Si-4 84-i Year - Quarter Yeor - - ter
| |
| : 3. Signficent Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FoVes e 3 .. g 3.
| |
| -e -t z< g 2. 2g < 2.
| |
| 1b t
| |
| at
| |
| ?k
| |
| .$ $X R-x %een t~~y y 4 y
| |
| ;g i
| |
| S N 865286 k 3 86LYear 4 SM-l Si-2 87-3 8i-4 ed-1 k k L SI-t 8i-2 Si-3 8i-4 84'-1 862863864
| |
| - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ . nt Forcad Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) Crited Hous un 8
| |
| - s
| |
| & n- +@ g 8-
| |
| . g 2I g$ i II.D " ~ @- ll WD 14 E
| |
| ~
| |
| ,h f y ,
| |
| g ,, ,
| |
| r " 2~ a ,
| |
| % L. *<
| |
| J,. 1 sH.$
| |
| L in =
| |
| ,2 d
| |
| o o 8612 L86 3 86-4 81-1 Si-2 Si-3 Si-4 88 1 86L 286-386-4 81-1 Si-2 Si-3 Si-a SS-t Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter 12 6 9 ,
| |
| 1 I
| |
| W
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.56
| |
| (~1 NINE MILE PT. 1: Trends v .
| |
| Declined imoroved Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotig Scroms While Criticci (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -159
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) - -7.5
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t72
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.go
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . 7.C6 it
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Ou, tog / , 47,
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 I.0 .50'.0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2IO 2.5 Devictions from Pre.ious 4 Otr. Plant Means (Measured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| NINE MILE PT. 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Abo,e Avg. Perf, Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scrom's While Criticot (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 21
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg erd 88-1) . 3.54 e:
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -o.42 }
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - oso
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .ty
| |
| {
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it _g ,,
| |
| togs / $8]yj ,
| |
| -2.5-2.0 i.5 -5 0 -d.5 0 0 O!5 t'0 t5 2.02.5 Devictions from Older Picnt Meons (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| D Q
| |
| 12 7
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.57 i i IndiCClor Leoend: c'e" Peat NIME lN MLE PT* ?.-
| |
| 4 -
| |
| Newer Ptnt Avercge
| |
| ^'''oi' Critical Hours 86-2 to 88-1 - 4 Omrter ucving Aseroge t Automatic Scrcrns WNe Criticd 2. Sofety System Actwtions 4 2SCO 4 _
| |
| 2500
| |
| - 2230 g . ..so 25 2000 l 3 .,
| |
| - p 3- 3 3 2000f" y 3 5& T-
| |
| - '750 B
| |
| x&
| |
| 5o d
| |
| y 'V s - '750 3
| |
| NoI % ! - eco a' j <! 4' % . eco =-
| |
| m: Q 0g2- N *h 3
| |
| lg h ',,..
| |
| {$ { - - -
| |
| g 8/,j a
| |
| x y
| |
| *= 3lJ 3
| |
| Lt 4
| |
| n =
| |
| : mp
| |
| == 3
| |
| -a o o a 64L2 sek J 66L 4 t/-i 8/-2 4/-3 8/-4 es-1 sekt GA3 e.'-4 8/-i 6Y-2 Si-3 s/-. es-,
| |
| Year - Quarter '' eor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Si<rificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fakses
| |
| =
| |
| r(--s s
| |
| g u
| |
| 4 ),,
| |
| . J. g s. J. F' Ih jh +
| |
| N f2 Y e 3-at my u s s i
| |
| t <y 2. 3 < 2. y
| |
| : q. 4 ,s
| |
| " , a . p' f *f n s
| |
| & ~ K- {
| |
| 5 4
| |
| ?-
| |
| ,- N
| |
| %f p #N a:
| |
| ~
| |
| $p W f
| |
| ?,'
| |
| s a m m D
| |
| ? k Y as: seL3 aA4 s/-i ai-a ei-s si-4 es-i seLa oss es4 ei-i e/- si-s si- as-i year - QuartW Yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 6. Equ t Fcreed Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (*) Critcca Hours to a e
| |
| W. N ip 2 '-
| |
| e so . se !g!
| |
| h4 4 w a<
| |
| 8p A 34 3 j '* - V As 3j 'fm a d- E. 1 2
| |
| ~
| |
| f
| |
| * o IN$ h . ,
| |
| ... . /. , .... . . , . . . - , .. . . . . . . ...i....... -,
| |
| Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter 12 8 0
| |
| 1
| |
| | |
| a FIGURE 4.57 I
| |
| O
| |
| .q)
| |
| NINE MILE PT. 2: Trends ,
| |
| l Performance Indicators D*C'i"'d '*P' v'd 2 Otr. Avg end )- -3
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .ag
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88,-1) . . t72
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fohes (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 22 .
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tgs/ itg ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -I.0 -U.5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Ote. Piont Meons (Veosured in' Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| NINE MILE PT. 2: Deviations fro'rn Newer Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Autornotic Scroms Whk Critical -coe (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - we
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .cso
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FoVes (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . [,'f ] .
| |
| ~:
| |
| . ~ . .
| |
| 2.39
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . 2 '.5 ~' 'I. -
| |
| es ... mv% L
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i5 -I0 -d 5 0.0 O!5 1'O t'5 IO 2 5 Cevictions from Newer Pcnt Meons (Meosured in Stond::rd Devictions) u/
| |
| 12 9 l
| |
| | |
| O THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY .
| |
| BLANK O
| |
| 13 0
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.57 (CONTD).
| |
| O v -
| |
| f Note: This is a comparison of NINE MLE PT. 2 (a newer plant) against older plant means.
| |
| I t
| |
| NINE MILE PT. 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means .
| |
| Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| '# - 152 f4 otr7/vg end - /
| |
| : 2. Sofety Systen. Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 2.02
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -a42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foikses (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .$.66
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 164
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tng/ ,,
| |
| -2.5-2'.0 -i.5 -lo -0 5 EO O'S io t'5 2!O 25 Devictions from Older Plont Meces '
| |
| (Mecsved in Stondord Devicticns)
| |
| O 13 1
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.58 indicct or NORTH ANNA 1 Legend: oicer Pont 4 erc9e Cnticol Hour 3 -
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1 === 4 Owr t er % Averc;c t Automatic Scrorns WNe Cnticot 2. Sofety Systern Actuotsns 4 tso. 4 2500
| |
| - 2250 - 22so e 3-2Mo x g I 3- \
| |
| -xg Bg - neo 3
| |
| jg - oso Ni
| |
| \, -
| |
| eco '. j <t -
| |
| eco '.
| |
| *t-e og2- 1250- )
| |
| t230 f (I
| |
| f3 N @gl ~
| |
| ") l}
| |
| ~
| |
| "]
| |
| i .. , ..
| |
| I 250 m g k"d 7# l -
| |
| , & 3 w , ,
| |
| X [y ml A ,
| |
| ee'2eskaeeL4si-tei-2si-3si-4se-1 sekt ee'-3 seL4 s/-i ai-2 ai-3 si-4 es-i Year - Quarter year - Quarter
| |
| : 3. 5pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foues
| |
| . 3- 3- ,.3 3
| |
| IE
| |
| -t
| |
| }k
| |
| -t<
| |
| -< ~t 3pt- g-1 s 13 ]3 2 i j '-
| |
| rjd%i o
| |
| y$$ eg'' "
| |
| o m ?
| |
| Jr tV sekt seks ee'-4y/-t gai-3 si-4 es-i seL2 e6L3 /-t gai-3 ai-4 as-t
| |
| : 6. Ecp Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rcte (t) Critco Hours oo a
| |
| $ M-e-
| |
| 2 It .
| |
| E W !!
| |
| F<t oo -
| |
| ~x A
| |
| j a<
| |
| w me- 3M
| |
| $b I wh ~
| |
| g 40 - 37 37 :b i
| |
| a ! . . 'l
| |
| * di e p Y w 2- A 1 79 2o - p a ,g (' f ty @'
| |
| o . . ;
| |
| ee-2 so-3 so-4 87 1 ...-287-387-4 ee-I eS-266-3eS-4 si-1 (f-2 Of-3 SI-4 Be-t f eQr - ter "edr - WU7 t er O
| |
| 13 2
| |
| | |
| FGURE 4.58
| |
| ^'
| |
| llv) NORTH ANNA ~1: Trends .
| |
| Declined tmproved Performance Indicotors
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critkol (2 Otr. Avg erri 88-1) - -LS
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -
| |
| i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo;ivres (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . o.4 i
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o 29
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / it ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0!O O!5 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devict' s from Previous 4 Otr. Plant M Measured in Stondord Devictions) eens NORTH ANNA 1: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators 4 tr Avg -)- -t39 i
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0.46
| |
| : 3. Sigtsficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -ts2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o. i4
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -2.06
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Crit togs / gg j, ,t,,
| |
| -2.5-2LO-t5 -to -0.5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Ner Plant Veons (Measured in Stondord Deviations)
| |
| O 13 3
| |
| | |
| FGURE 4.59 w Ir6C Ct Cr NORTH ANNA 2 Legend: c*r a*t ^ve m CritiCCl Hour 3 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| "" ' 0 *' ' " "''9 ^*"*
| |
| t Automatic Scrams WNe Crit'ed ,
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuot ons is Si - 22so - 2250 y
| |
| g/ - 20cc
| |
| ,_ \,,, N - m 3_
| |
| -
| |
| * I h
| |
| * h h g @/ g
| |
| ! I's -
| |
| OCO[ k! PM -
| |
| Soo!
| |
| gt- -
| |
| t250 f a 2-4 k -
| |
| CSo f ji t_
| |
| N T
| |
| m 750 5 O
| |
| 11 y
| |
| 1.
| |
| ?
| |
| 5 d
| |
| W
| |
| - 750 3
| |
| O Q:
| |
| - 500 mee - 2
| |
| { ,
| |
| - 250 y %
| |
| - 250 o o o o sekt seks eel 4 sl-1 ' 2 si-3 ei-4 ed-t sek2 66' 3 seL4 sY-1 ei-2 si-3 si-* sd-i Year - - ter Yey - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Spficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitses
| |
| . 3- 3- ,2-3 h jk !
| |
| w) w} &
| |
| n 2<t-y 3<t-g h
| |
| , 1%Ll es-2 seks eel 4 s/-t 7L2 si-3 s/-4 e$-1 Year - Qucrter
| |
| , M r4 ee'-2 seks 86-4 si-t s7L2 of-3 si-4 as-i Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eats nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rate (s) Critccs Motts ico a 2 so - h e-
| |
| .
| |
| * g 15 E It h*t a - s<
| |
| 55 25*-
| |
| ?$~
| |
| B w w 2.
| |
| ~
| |
| ^ o ne
| |
| .pI
| |
| ~
| |
| o o bl '
| |
| ai-2 es-3 as-4 si-i si-2 of-3 si-4 es-i se-2ee-3 eel 4 si-i et-2 si-3 of-4 as-i Year - Quarter Year - Quyter O
| |
| 13 4
| |
| | |
| J FIGURE 4.59 O NORTH -ANNA 2: Trends O -
| |
| Performance indicators O'C'I"'d ''"O' "'d
| |
| :1. Automoti Scroms While Critical f2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 3.75-
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t72
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . (73
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced t / it Hr
| |
| - o
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -iS -lo -0.5 O!O 0 5 1'O 1l5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions (Meosured from Previous in Stonderd 4 Otr. Plont )Veens Devictions NORTH ANNA 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^" 128 i ff4 tr Avg - -
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .t24 1
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitures (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . .o. a
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 83-1) . o.79
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it E tog / , gg
| |
| -2.5-i o -iS -to .5 0'0 0'.5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Oeer Pbnt Meons (Meoswed in Stoncord Devictions)
| |
| O 13 5
| |
| | |
| RGURE 4.60 c:- J m,cetcc OCONEE 1 Legend: O'oer-aicat 4 e ca+
| |
| Critical Hovs 86-2 to 88-1 1
| |
| ' 0 " ''' " 'N ^"'C1' h l AutCectic ScrQTts Wh4 Criticci 2. SQfety System Actuotcos 4 2$30 4 2:00
| |
| - 2250 - 225o f l
| |
| / . 2
| |
| : 3. /
| |
| - '=
| |
| . it
| |
| : 3. *N.
| |
| / -
| |
| '~ g bt
| |
| - soo a' 5 <1 s./
| |
| .f . eco *'
| |
| *2.y .
| |
| uw } % g 2. w}
| |
| coo 3
| |
| - 1000 3 .
| |
| 3 3 ia *5
| |
| *O ,,
| |
| . 500 . 5c0
| |
| - 250 - 250
| |
| , l s '
| |
| e6L 2 seks ee'-4 s/-i s'-2 sf-3 ei-4 es'- t seL2 se'-3 seLa si-t si-2 si-3 si-4 es-i Year - Quctter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. SpfiCont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety system roues
| |
| . 3. 3 3.
| |
| }h jh
| |
| -t -t i<g2. 2 < 2. ,,2 3] lgj .?
| |
| 1 1 1
| |
| * I 9 1
| |
| (
| |
| ~
| |
| f4 7/ p '""ta[
| |
| y )6 9 M % s e 3 y \d - 3%%
| |
| } '
| |
| seit seL3 eel 4 s/-i ' 2 s/-3 af-4 es-t seL2e6L3 seL4 s/-t si-2 si-3 si-4 as-i Y ear - ter Ye:ir - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Oucge Rote (s) Critco Hours 00 8 2 m. h
| |
| ' 3E &
| |
| 31 . s2 h<t oo- 34 -
| |
| i h$ 5' ?
| |
| ~ '
| |
| 2 65 1 '
| |
| 20 -
| |
| M&4 ~
| |
| ~ *
| |
| , 4 12 0 #
| |
| - C~T;r% ,, '
| |
| a Z il 1 _.L __ a u E3 O N.
| |
| sek t 8613 as-4 s/-t Of-2 SY-3 af-4 es-t ee-2 ee-3 ee-4 si-t 07-2 87-3 s7-4 es-t Yeor - Chacrter Year - Quarter 13 6 9
| |
| | |
| RGURE 4.60 O OCONEE 1: Trends V .
| |
| Performance Indicators O'C'I"'d '"P' v'd
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms WNie Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuot'ons (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o I .
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o.62
| |
| : 6. Equipenent Forced tg/ it Hr , gg
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -i.0 -d.5 O!O O'5 t'0 US 2!O 2.5 .
| |
| , Devictions (Meosured from Previous in Stonderd Devictions 4 Otr. Pbnt )Mecns d
| |
| OCONEE 1: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms WNie Critical I f4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)" L28 1
| |
| : 2. Sofety Syntam Actuotions (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . tn
| |
| : 3. Sigrificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety Systen Foilures (4 Ot . Avg end 88-1) . o2i
| |
| : 5. Forced ikt:ge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0 77
| |
| : 6. Equipment rorced to / t , 37,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 -l.0 0.5 0'O C'S t'0 i5 2!O 2.5 i Cevictions from Older Plont Meons (Meosured in Stondord Devictions) 13 7
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.61 C Ind:cotor OCONEE 2 Legend: c ~ * "t ^ " s-Critical Hog s 86-2 to 88-1 "" ' 0 "'" * "9 **" ~>
| |
| : 1. AutMeiC Scres Whe Critical 2. Sofety System ActuGtrons 4 2500 4 2!co
| |
| . 2250 . 2250
| |
| .- . .. ~' .
| |
| p 3- ** y 3. . h 5 - N j) - 1750 3 fj) -
| |
| =$ ij - ea 5 y2- . C30 og2- . CSO I'k
| |
| ~
| |
| $ 1 t
| |
| "]d $
| |
| ,~ t
| |
| \~- ** 3b '
| |
| 5
| |
| \B M 1 . 500 g . sco 250 250 g - .
| |
| 4 F'" -' '" " l *'
| |
| 0 it 0 0 O 86k2 86L3 66 4 lt 8k3Si-48$.1 86k 2 8N3 86 k 4 l-1 8 -3 8/-4 88-t
| |
| : 3. spficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foiures e 3. g 3.
| |
| -t -t 34 2< ,
| |
| 5~ $' T
| |
| $ $ k i; i '-
| |
| pjW '
| |
| g n 8652 SN3 86 k 4 SI-18I-2 8/-3 SY-4 Bd-1 86k 2 86k3 86'-4 81-1 Si-2 Sf-3 SI-4 88'-1 Ysor - Quyter YeQr - Qucrter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outogrs/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcne Rote (s) Cntco Hous p 33 '-
| |
| ?t ia E<t m - s< '
| |
| 42 6 5, "5'- T
| |
| .a
| |
| '0 -
| |
| f h a
| |
| *~
| |
| 12.
| |
| t 3 2 . .
| |
| ~ M-( S
| |
| * 0 = N - 0 L PN2 86'-3 86-4 7'- t _ ti-3 af 4 85-1 86-2 86- 3 86 7-t 87-3 87-4 as.t 13 8 9
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.61 C NEE 2: Trends O Declined improved
| |
| ! Performance Indicators I
| |
| (
| |
| 2 Qtr, Avg 8
| |
| - 141
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Ott.. Avg . end 88-1) . 4 90
| |
| ' 3. Significent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - t
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . g7 Y
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 2,t t
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it Hr tg/ _ _
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -t5 -to -0.5 0'.0 0 5 t'O 1!5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons
| |
| , (Mecsured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| OCONEE 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| ^"
| |
| f4 tf. vg end 5 - 07'
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.n
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -c.4 2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Todures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.n
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.76
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it g togs / ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0 10 -d.5 0'O O'.5 t'0 t'5 2.0 2.5 Devrotions from Older Plont Meons (Meosured in Stondord Deviations) 13 9 l
| |
| l
| |
| _j
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.62 i
| |
| M Indic0 tor OCONEE 3 Legend: Older P:ent Avercge Critical Hours
| |
| ~ ***'''"'*3***'%'
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1 llk 1 Automatic Scrons Who Criticd 2. Sofety Sy5 tem Actuotcris
| |
| . 2250 __
| |
| _ :2M
| |
| . 2000 "c / . teco ''
| |
| s 3. g 3. /
| |
| 5g . nso g . i7so NI . eco *' "y <) . eco *'
| |
| ~<
| |
| 'gt. .
| |
| 125o j %gt. .
| |
| esoj ji -
| |
| N3 i
| |
| ji ,-
| |
| N3 i
| |
| . soo # . sm 230 A m k - -
| |
| 0 0 0 , i i @ i i i 0
| |
| so-2 es-3 ag/-i gay-3 87-4 es-i es-2 so-3 ee-4y?-i gay-3 e7-. es-i
| |
| : 3. 5pficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokses
| |
| . 3. 3 3; f k [i
| |
| -t f5
| |
| -t*
| |
| l
| |
| +
| |
| ;N o*t-g o
| |
| gt.
| |
| t g
| |
| : 1. t. q'
| |
| ~ '
| |
| N V! g 3; h
| |
| o m m M o es-tseLaeeL4el-i 't ei-3si-4 es-i seLa ee'- 3 e -i 't si-3 si-4 es-i Year - ter Y ear - ter
| |
| : 6. Equernent Forced Outoges/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcge Rote (s) 000 Crited Hours co a b W-3*-
| |
| at !!
| |
| st oo.
| |
| o< a<
| |
| b5 5~
| |
| ,s i .o . 32 I3 2
| |
| g 3 :-
| |
| m ,,, e ,,,
| |
| e._ o 3 s.,., es;..
| |
| . . 3 e ., e ,s;.3 .i.. .o., e .
| |
| 7.. .e . i i
| |
| 14 0 O
| |
| | |
| 4 4
| |
| FIGURE 4.62
| |
| (~') 'OCONEE 3: Trends .
| |
| v O'CII"'d ''"P' "'d Performance Indicators t Automatic Scroms WNie Criticol (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.se
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tn
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . cag
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . c s4
| |
| : 6. Eqvpment Forced gtgs/ jit , ,,,
| |
| -2.5-h.0-i5 -io -0.5 0'O 055 t'0 t'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Means
| |
| )
| |
| (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| OCONEE 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators t Automotic Scroms WNie Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - L29 -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tu
| |
| : 3. Sigraficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o. i4
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.$6
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs / , g3
| |
| -2.5 -2'.0 10 -6.5 0'O O'5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from onder Picnt Mecns (Measured in Stcndord Devictions)
| |
| ~
| |
| O 14 1
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.63 c:: ::3 inoicator OYSTER CREEK Legend: Cicer P:ent Avercge Critical Hogs i-- 4 cuarter %n; Aseroge 86-2 to 88-1 @
| |
| 1 Automotic Scoms WNW Critical 2. Safety System Actuabons 2230 . 2m
| |
| . 20W . 2000
| |
| : 3. 3.
| |
| g . W 'g ., 1750 m a- ..^ a ba 5
| |
| .1 /./ .
| |
| y< .
| |
| 'gt. . 1250 og2. . 1250 ji ,~ t
| |
| *b i 1
| |
| ,~ e t a
| |
| b
| |
| . sao P 7 - 500 g ~
| |
| S4 ~
| |
| 0
| |
| \
| |
| , 7,
| |
| .)
| |
| ^ . ,' , ,
| |
| 0 0 y , ',- , , , ,
| |
| 3 86-2 86-3 86-4 t/-t 8/-2 47-3 t?-4 88-1 m2 66-3 e6-4 6/-t 87-2 87-3 87-4 mt Year - QJarter Yew - Quarter )
| |
| : 3. Sigrvficant vents ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Folures '
| |
| l l
| |
| 1 e 3. 3 3. 3 d 3 ,.3 l o**- / D
| |
| [
| |
| 3 s s'- ; g n: *
| |
| } v A ,,
| |
| h f' F L M h '"
| |
| h i $ j 0
| |
| 2 N
| |
| M
| |
| $3 k% E 0 k%@
| |
| Ij M
| |
| :'s Q t #
| |
| ^'#'
| |
| 9 r
| |
| V i: ; s 86L 2 8A3 6A4 SY-t '28/-J8/-4 e6-1
| |
| - 86-2 86L36A447-1 '247-347-4
| |
| - sa-t , ,
| |
| . Year - ter Yeor - ter i
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outo;e Rote (s) Critc3 Hous W 5 _
| |
| $ 90 - ..
| |
| ,I .
| |
| N. u- h
| |
| ! 60. e. 1i 54 I
| |
| h4 E ' -
| |
| 2s "
| |
| et 't'-
| |
| S g e 3
| |
| " u
| |
| !g 40.
| |
| ,o - s Q
| |
| Ch + '
| |
| to 9
| |
| ,e 7 : i'- r~
| |
| a.
| |
| q m A 5 1
| |
| l 0m .
| |
| 1 4 S 0 i fI .
| |
| es2esae6-4 al-t s7-2 si-3 s7-4 as-t e6-2 e6-3 e6-4 af-t si-2 a7-3 s?-4 sa-Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter 14 2 O
| |
| | |
| ! FIGURE 4.63 OYSTER CREEK: Trende
| |
| :(] O'Cli"'d '*P'
| |
| "'d Performonce Indicoters 2 htr vg end 8 - - 141
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 3. Spficont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . jt73
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . t
| |
| : 5. r oiced Outoge Rote (2 Qh Avg end 88-1) . o..o
| |
| : 6. Equcment Forced tog /1000 it Hrs ,
| |
| 4
| |
| -2.5-kO-ip d5 0'O O'S t'0 t'$ 2'O 25 Devictions rrom Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons (Meosured in Standord Devictions) .
| |
| OYSTER CREEK: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators tr. vg end
| |
| - 07' f4 ;
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions (4 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) . (n
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -ta2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foavres (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .ts2
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .ts
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / C itgs,y)
| |
| W _ ,,,,
| |
| et on f er P t eo (Meosured in S tondord Devictions) 14 3
| |
| -- - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ - -_ __ D
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.66 C Ir@cotor PALISADES Legend: * *-i - - m Cnticci Hours 86--2 to 88-1
| |
| "" ' U" ' " * ' 9 ^ * " "' h 1 1 Automatic Scroms WNW Clifcd ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actmtrons
| |
| . _ 3 . _ 1 I ,2. _ }.
| |
| s- g _}
| |
| {3 .
| |
| h 0001 Nj i- Mi
| |
| : s. y .
| |
| .) syi. ,
| |
| 4 .
| |
| e3
| |
| "]e $ J
| |
| ~
| |
| "3
| |
| ,~ / - ./ -
| |
| ~a L1= :?
| |
| l~l,u..3.;<.,e,.j....w., ,
| |
| @gs4::?
| |
| u., u. +;<., e,.;.. .. . a.,
| |
| : 3. 5<pficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues I
| |
| b 3
| |
| e 3. 3 3.
| |
| h {h
| |
| -t -t Sn 17 s< 3 - s<g t- ti.
| |
| s 5 f 3
| |
| $ $ 2 .
| |
| 4 *
| |
| ' ,. 9 p H Y
| |
| MQ]g>i q w i s.
| |
| 0 $ U" o ee- ets g l. g ej.s e,'-. es.,
| |
| ook, es'-3 ag1.i e sj..i..sa.i i
| |
| : s. rorcM Outg Rote (s) WC-t d s l '
| |
| s .. 5 it 3'~t i gI "- ~
| |
| $a
| |
| .II . .
| |
| gi y l j$ *- % f,$ '2'
| |
| . . .; e r w , ,e g_
| |
| N3 b
| |
| , % .as ., e ,.;.. .... _ ,
| |
| s , )
| |
| _, .. 3.;,m ,... .... . . . .
| |
| I O
| |
| 14 4
| |
| | |
| + , ,
| |
| . 5; u
| |
| FtGURE 4.64 PALISADES: Trends O Declined improved Performance Indicators 2 Qtr. vq 8- - 4 54
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) . 0 54
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fc,aures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . as
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . g4
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtogs/ git qs, gg
| |
| -2.5-i.0-15 I.0 4 5 0'O O!S t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt V (Veosured in Stondord Devictions) eons PALISADES: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicaters 8** ^"9 P"f - ^* * ** 9 P" '-
| |
| 4 t vg 8
| |
| - 074 l
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _t:4
| |
| : 3. Sigrsficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .c42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - u 21
| |
| : 5. Fceced Outoge Rcte (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . - ts,
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced gtg*/:C it eggyj , ,t,,
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -to -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from oncer Plont Veens (Meeswed in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| O 14 5
| |
| | |
| FCURE 4.65 C inciccter PALO VERDE 1 Legend: Otcer Picnt Averc;r Critical Hows 86-2 W M-1
| |
| - 4 cuarter uowng Avercse g
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scrorns Whle Criticd 2. Sofety System ActuotDns
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| ~ "
| |
| 3 q
| |
| : 3. [ . -
| |
| ,m , gl ,3 - / -
| |
| im ;
| |
| I j<) eco -'
| |
| _< j eco '. -
| |
| g/ 1250, f og2- -
| |
| 1250 j lpt.
| |
| ] /- !
| |
| g (( $
| |
| s , ,~ , , - s E M EB . /- soo : g 7 - 3co
| |
| ~ ~ ~
| |
| k / \;
| |
| eel 2 seL3 l-1 sy'-3s/-4es-t seL2 eel 3 /-i a sy'->Si-4 ss-i
| |
| : 3. Sipficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fok.res e 3. g 3-
| |
| -e
| |
| -4
| |
| -1 g2. 3<2-y l.
| |
| ' t-0
| |
| -p d2863 L sI
| |
| /-t M
| |
| 6 -3 8/-4 ad-1 o-
| |
| $h eel286L3 dl'' s ''
| |
| l-1 e
| |
| %=,_
| |
| 8-38/-4 85-1
| |
| =
| |
| : 6. Equi vnent Fcreed Outoges/
| |
| : 5. 4 Outcge Rote (s) ,
| |
| 000 Critied Mca.rs 2ao. h
| |
| ,)
| |
| 3$.-
| |
| l ]$ !!
| |
| $<!=- a<
| |
| 25 ''
| |
| h $5'-
| |
| 1] '- l * " lj '#
| |
| [- i l
| |
| s "
| |
| l " 1 R
| |
| S\ f 2 !. w 2. #g i r2 w-l r w NL
| |
| % 9 'W 4
| |
| ;; ~ 1 w ^ : aN Aw, EE 1
| |
| * r o & 5 E t% n R o
| |
| * V' t5 sekt e6 L 3 sg/-i agsy-3 s/-4 sa'-i seit esL3ee-4gi-isgsi->si-4 ea-i 14 6 i
| |
| l l
| |
| n .
| |
| | |
| p, FIGURE 4.65 n
| |
| v PALO VERDE 1: Trends -
| |
| 0*C6" 'N ' V'd l Performance -Indicators l
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical ^-"344WCy (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 2.as ggtgg
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end P8-1) - -0.58
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- os
| |
| : 4. : Sofety System Foilures (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) og
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -ass -'
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 O!O O!5 t'0 t'5 2!O 2.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Means I
| |
| (Mecsured in Stondord Devictions) 1 PALO VERDE 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ~ ' c21 l
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.23
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 042
| |
| : 4. Safety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - hhh 124
| |
| :m% a
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) t44 hh
| |
| : 6. Equ'pment Forced it tg/10 .
| |
| -2.5-E.0 i5 I.0-0.5 0 0 0 5 1'O t'5 2!O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont Veons (Measured in Standard Devictions) 4 v
| |
| 14 7
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.66 f"'"""1 Indicctor PALO VERDE 2 Legend: Oncer Pk3nt Average Critical Hows 86--2 to 88--1 '"'''" ' 0" ' ' '' * ("i"9 ^ * *' S' l Automatic SCfcYns While Criticd 2. Sofety Systern Actuctions
| |
| - 2250 - 2250
| |
| ~
| |
| 3, 3
| |
| ~
| |
| 3 b It j - '=
| |
| 3 o{ 3, -
| |
| !!p2 - =- . 21
| |
| - =;
| |
| 3 t250 j og2- , 4 cSo j f3 l i
| |
| ~
| |
| "] l$ s. . f{
| |
| ~
| |
| *" 5 l
| |
| NE i j I U
| |
| i
| |
| ~
| |
| *5 ,, i Y
| |
| i
| |
| \7p $
| |
| ~
| |
| Soo
| |
| _ __ l ! _ 500 _
| |
| ' - 2 \ L - 7"4 I$ e o i + _ h % o o } ,"
| |
| EN 1 o aekt eel 3 Le6 4 l-tgayLs/-4cd-t 3 esL 2 86L 3 esjayi-1 goi-3 si-4 ea'-i
| |
| : 3. Scrificont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety Systern Fokses
| |
| .3. ,3 g 3.
| |
| }h jh
| |
| -1 -1
| |
| -< g4 ,
| |
| g.2 : g2.
| |
| $ i p'' 5 N i i.
| |
| ,\ d@'y I '
| |
| wi O__& h _? %
| |
| O L L 962863 l-18 8-38/-488-1 86'286'3864 8/-18
| |
| - - 8/-36,L488'-t i
| |
| : 6. Ecp mt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Octoge Rate (s) ,
| |
| Cnticd H:vs 8 eo . h 33 '-
| |
| "s i
| |
| In >
| |
| i<t w . s<
| |
| b5 $5'~
| |
| b T j '* - N" *E s
| |
| 5-%em l g d
| |
| g g
| |
| + 2 g
| |
| , I $ 6 !li S , $~525 1
| |
| .2 #3 %,., e,.;-3 . .. t , .2 #3 a-, e,,3-3. .. -,
| |
| 14 8 O
| |
| | |
| RGURE 4.66 I
| |
| O PALO VERDE 2: Trends v .
| |
| Performance Indicotors 0*C'i"'d 'roProv'd
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticol' (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 03
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .i
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ,
| |
| .os
| |
| : 4. Sofety System foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -
| |
| 0.52
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 127
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/
| |
| , n 3,
| |
| -2.5-iO-i.5 -I.O -0.5 O!O O!5 1.'O I'5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Means
| |
| , (Measured in Standard Devictions) i
| |
| : PALO VERDE 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Performance Indicators Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -CJ2 lN i b
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88 -1) - -t24
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.98
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 60
| |
| : 6. Equicment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit. Hrs. t'j)RM l (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - gg: 0 69 l
| |
| ^
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -i.5 -i 0 -d.5 0.0 O!5 1.'O 1.'5 2.02.5 1
| |
| Devictions from older Plont Meons l
| |
| (Meosured in Stonderd Devictions) l O.
| |
| 14 9 l
| |
| t
| |
| | |
| FIGURE 4.67 C Indicctor PALO VERDE 3 Legend: oeer e'ent rose Newer Plont Averc;e criticol Hotts .
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1 4 Quarter McNing Average L Automatic Scrcrns Whle Critical 2. Sofety Systern Acttotons 4 2$o0 e . ;3on
| |
| . 2250 . 2250
| |
| ~
| |
| 3- 3.
| |
| I - =
| |
| 3 .o -
| |
| =' e= '
| |
| 3)t -
| |
| ij -
| |
| t25o j pt. .
| |
| 1250 j li g 2 - .
| |
| ji ,.
| |
| na3 i
| |
| ji ,.
| |
| 750 3 i
| |
| g - 500 _ soo
| |
| - 250 . ?!o 0 -
| |
| o o o 86'-2 N 3 Y-1 87k3 SI-4 88-1 d2 8A3 86b e /-I 8 -3 Si-4 38'- t
| |
| : 3. 5<;pificant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foltres
| |
| . J. e 3.
| |
| -i -i
| |
| -4 g2- 'g 2.
| |
| 4
| |
| . 33 1 1 a
| |
| w f 0 E
| |
| I 8/-3 8Y-4 88 , i 86'-2 86b3 1-1 8Y-3 87b. ed-1 b -
| |
| 86286'36 -1
| |
| : 6. EQLi nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (z) Criticd Hows 3 So _ fr 6.
| |
| !! 43
| |
| }<! So- a<
| |
| 35 IE' ~ b
| |
| !, $ " - $ kk,
| |
| - w 2. T 20 - # Q-a a Sc2843g.;<-1gg-38,-.t, Sc2 # 3 g .j <-, e g -3 St-. e ,
| |
| 15 0 e
| |
| o =
| |
| | |
| , F&PE 1.67
| |
| ,o y_ PALO. VERDE 3: Trends
| |
| - i Performance Indicctors De**d - *c' *
| |
| * d l
| |
| 1.- Automatic Scroms WhPe Criticot (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .- !
| |
| . 2. .Sofety System Actuotions-(2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 3 'S;gmficont ~ Events (2 Otr. ' Avg end 88-1) - 0 I~
| |
| t
| |
| : 4. Sciety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . i .
| |
| : 5. Forced Ouioge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| ~
| |
| : 6. Equcment Forced Outoces/iOOO Crit.' Hrs.
| |
| (2 dtr Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -t5 i.0 -O 5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2 5 0 evictions from Previous 4 Otr P!cnt vecns (Measured in Standard Devicticns)
| |
| PALO VERDE 3: Deviations from -Newer Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticol 0.93 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 127
| |
| : 3. Signfi:ent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr.. Avg end 88-1) - 0 87
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote _(4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . o so
| |
| : 6. Equ'oment Forced it tg/ g3Qy) , ,te,
| |
| -2.5-2.0 I.5 i.0 -0.5 0'O O'.5 1'O t's 2 0 2 5 Devictions from Newer Plcnt Veons (Mecsured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| O
| |
| : m. g w- r--
| |
| e "gy a''9- ed.,%->y -y,y yv. +.g--g*1~9 e y e p-y,y
| |
| | |
| l l O THIS PAGE LEFT
| |
| 'l INTENTIONALLY BLANK 15 2
| |
| | |
| - - -.3-- - _ - _ _ ,
| |
| 1
| |
| ;, 6CyRE w (ccN D)
| |
| ;h Note: This is o compcrison of PALO VERDE 3 (a newer plant) against- older plant means, PALO VERDE 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means B&w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticol cat (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofity System Actuctions (4 Otr. Avg end .88-1) ut
| |
| - 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - oss
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (4 Otr, Avg end 88-1) . o go
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 33
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -26
| |
| -2.5 -2' .0 - 1.5 I.0 -d.5 0'O O'S l'O l'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont Mecris (Mecsured in Stondord Cevetions) l 15 3 l
| |
| k . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ , ..-__ _,_. ,.__... .. _ .. _ ,__ __.
| |
| | |
| St-E a.63 L- 1 ; ;'. '
| |
| ,_ ' ' Jsg', _1
| |
| _y ,
| |
| )
| |
| ; ~ - - . :. 'w~ '
| |
| J -. ''d ') ! '. c-y6-
| |
| ,m ; , q m ' .
| |
| . (V /i 4 ' ~~ar '
| |
| yV' ,'
| |
| , L ,9 L ; i 1
| |
| -- Ur t ;i 9/s
| |
| " # C"' t '' ";''''"'*
| |
| M -- 2
| |
| * O 88--1
| |
| : 1. AutomCtic SCfr$ hNe Cr.t<Of 2 Sofety System A;tuct. Ors 4 2500 4 ;5:c I !
| |
| - 225o _ :- : ,I
| |
| - 2000 4 2xc ~
| |
| 3- =
| |
| W 3- ..~... t 5 - '7so 3 g} ..-
| |
| .) q 7s ( '
| |
| S}t - em -a y< \.
| |
| .1 w -e
| |
| '32- -
| |
| eso) 32. \ 4:53 3 000 3 Occ h a s . ,
| |
| 1 i t-
| |
| ~
| |
| b '
| |
| ]
| |
| b )
| |
| 0 f , 5 ) ,
| |
| 0 Qul e f' ' 5' $2 7'-267-387-4 58 - t 87 88 -8 e6-2 86 W2 86-3 8 ' . e>or 1 97-2 87-3 87-4 ovarter ' We eor 87 'Duarter
| |
| : 3. SPficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues
| |
| .s e
| |
| i e 3. g 3- .-
| |
| h jh e me
| |
| -1< 4 x2- x2-1 k 2,,,
| |
| 1 2 k.
| |
| . 3. .
| |
| ~ '" '
| |
| >v 1 M A
| |
| %a N i
| |
| % % p 7
| |
| $ ?$ Q
| |
| . ,' m m 0 - _ 7" . o ; , 1
| |
| ; i W2 86-3 We 8f-t 8Y-2 8Y-3 8Y-4 88'-1 86'-2 W3 86-4 8/-187- 97387-4 88-1 Ye& - Quarter Ye& - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (t) O Crited Hous 00 0
| |
| - e s 80 . g 1 1*- 3e e< . a<
| |
| ~x w x4-ds s T.j'-
| |
| v
| |
| - 24 % w 2.
| |
| ~ # N t 17
| |
| ^ !
| |
| 1 %
| |
| FR:e
| |
| ('N Orrg h m
| |
| [g
| |
| . , Ec]__ m+ .
| |
| 86-2 W3 We 87 1 J7-2 87-3 87 4 SS- 1 W2 86-3 86-4 87-t 87-2 87-3 87-4 86-1 (,.
| |
| Yeor - Qucrter f ear - rter l 15 4 g
| |
| 1 I
| |
| | |
| - - .~ , ~
| |
| 4 Q?5 A.55 PEACH BOTTOM 2: Trends
| |
| ._O .~
| |
| CeClined in' Pro ve0 Performance' indicctors .
| |
| . l. Automotic Scrcms Wh.le Criticci 3 (2 - Otr. Avg .end 88-1) F .
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuctions (5 Otr, Avg end 88-1) . . .o gg
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 'Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.58
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . l oh ,
| |
| : 5. Forced Os tage Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| 6 l Ecuipme , Forced Outogs/1000 (2 Crit.88-1)
| |
| Avg end Hrs. - '
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i5 -io -0 5 0.0 0 5 t'0 t'5 2'O 25 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr, Plant Meons (Meesured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| PEACH. BOTTOM 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means
| |
| . Performance Indicators ee6w Avg. Inf. Above Avg, Perl .
| |
| : 1. Automoti(- Scroms while Criticot4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sgfety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -0.46 1
| |
| : 3. Sigmficent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.se
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .m
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rcte (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Oytoge/1000
| |
| (
| |
| Crit.88-1)
| |
| Avg end Hrs. -
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-15-{0-0.50'O Devictions from Oldy05 l'O Means Plont I'5 2'O 25 (Meesured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| O 'ss 4
| |
| | |
| u .n . .u .
| |
| ,s . , , , nn-- -, !
| |
| _ecend:
| |
| 1
| |
| & /-' (v n HV i ; O cv1 s :a =-- :.
| |
| . . . . cr,te:, - u s
| |
| "" 4 0';'t''
| |
| V ~i "'
| |
| 36-2 to 88-1
| |
| : 1. Automot'< Scr rs Who Cr: tac 0! 2 SCfety System Actuct.cos l 4 2s:o 4 : :
| |
| .so !
| |
| - 2250 ; :.s. l' l
| |
| - two . .
| |
| 3- 53- /. ] 2>x *
| |
| ~10 ' )
| |
| .\ l. nso y} .'\
| |
| \
| |
| 5}9
| |
| ..~
| |
| ' ./
| |
| . - eco
| |
| * ~t y< .f \
| |
| ] 1 02> El
| |
| * 2, t
| |
| >2. I 2
| |
| ..so } 3>2- s usa ? h Eh $ $ (? -
| |
| c" i l \ l= \ \
| |
| # d '53 3;
| |
| ," r-- $ $ 4 - 750 3 , , ,
| |
| t I 7 j s:c
| |
| } $q 3 - soo ::s g l m - A 4 1
| |
| $' v 3 g - 25o pg ht 4l :sa I o
| |
| * 2 l lt o o 1 ei I3 l so-2 e6-3 e6-4 si-t ai-2 si-3 ei-4 sa-i e6-2 e6-3 86-4 si-' si-2 s7-3 s7-4 ss-i !
| |
| Yeor - Quar ter Yeor - OArter
| |
| : 3. S5f: cont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Folves
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| h jh at -1 3<2-y 7
| |
| : 32. y a w 4 9 h
| |
| =
| |
| # x(t s
| |
| n t n % 9 l- t- -
| |
| 7
| |
| {6 1
| |
| $ ., g o S " o- %
| |
| 86'-2 SN3 86'-4 Si-l 8/-2 6/-3 s/-4 es-t 46'-2 86-3 86'-4 Si-t 6f-2 87-3 87-4 58 -1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau ent Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Critco Hous 00 8 n C z., ao - -1r 6 "h 31 h
| |
| E<t a - a<
| |
| 25 IS ~ 3 53
| |
| , e- se 5 8 % 24s B w -
| |
| w w 2-y? %
| |
| to - p is $ }
| |
| ;'- f~ % s k-S A q -h y h@ .~
| |
| ,1, @ it e o L
| |
| L 56'-286386-4 Si-1 Si-2 ti-3 87-4 S5 1 l 86-2 66-3 56'-4 S/-t Si-2 Si-3 Si-4 es-1 Yeor - Quor t er Yeor - Querter 15 6 g
| |
| i l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| ~ l we a s3
| |
| : g. LPEACH' BOTTOM. 3i Trenas x~ ; .
| |
| Cectined Jerceovee '
| |
| Performa'nce Indicator's d
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticel ; !
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg ecd $8-1) - ,
| |
| 5
| |
| ' .i :
| |
| j
| |
| ' 2L Safety System Actuotsns (2 Otr. Avg end . 88-1)' .o gg kkk.
| |
| we a. ,
| |
| : 3. Sigenficont Events '(2 OtrI-- Avg end 88-1) - o S8
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fcitures (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . g 3g
| |
| : 5. Forced Outege Rote (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) _
| |
| : 6. Equ'oment Forced Outo es/1000 Crit Hrs (2 dtr, Avg end 88-1) - -
| |
| 1
| |
| -2.5-2.0 i5 I.0-0.500 05~ l'O 15 2.0'25-Devictions (Measured from Previous in Standard Devictions 4 Qtr. Piont )Means
| |
| ~
| |
| PEACH BOTTOM 3: Deviations frorn Oider - Plant -Mean's y
| |
| Below Avg Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| ' Performance Indicctors I
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whde Cr;tical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| 2, Sofety System Actuotions' (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 33
| |
| ~
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 'o se R
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ' .om
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5- 0-I4 -1.0 -d.5 0.0 0'5 t'0 1'S 2'O 2 5 eviations from O! der Pen' Means (Measured in Standord Deviations)
| |
| ~
| |
| 15 7 O(3.
| |
| : s. -
| |
| L l-t-
| |
| L
| |
| | |
| o m . ,
| |
| . v.-
| |
| , ._; _ sav , i
| |
| ._ y ~.
| |
| , . . .v . --,, : :. o
| |
| , ._ . . i s ! ,
| |
| j .rtu :es 36-2 to 88-1 !
| |
| "" 'L"~*'i*=~
| |
| l.
| |
| t Autom: tic Scres WNe Cr t<d 2 Safety System Actuct.rs 4 2500 4 . :s:o 1
| |
| - 2250 3:A 2xo j e j ::cc 1 l 3-2.'-
| |
| 1 a !
| |
| 1750 -5 a i?M : i 3
| |
| -6P 3 l 3 j so "x dt em a- ~!
| |
| y
| |
| -4 j
| |
| [' 4 /-, . - - o; d 5 ;5g }
| |
| ,,2,,,
| |
| 32- '2
| |
| , 7: 3o} 3 2-3 +
| |
| R a
| |
| F 7,\c I
| |
| / j; g fa -
| |
| a., i i
| |
| * 75o e * ??. s /
| |
| * 79 M . -'y g 1, t t O .l c x , t ,/ i O
| |
| ,- t- e s
| |
| ,9 .w 2 M.mk -
| |
| s e
| |
| s - WO ,.x % - - $00
| |
| % [4 \ #O ts 3
| |
| / 4 .n
| |
| 'S .
| |
| %" ? - 250 ,/ 'if. y ,
| |
| - 250
| |
| / i'$ %l % s . &. .a i : 1. S. 4 0 1 0 0 0 86-2 86-3 86'-4 a7-16i-2 S i-3 87-4 88-1 58-2 66'-3 86'-4 67'-1 87-2 ti-3 8 7-4 Ss - 1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quar t y
| |
| : 3. Skpficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System Foves n .t 2 I
| |
| +
| |
| +
| |
| gx ,s 4
| |
| .s. e p x
| |
| . 3- g 3- ?'N 't g +
| |
| } 1 % x t O}f 2)1 'l ? $ + L 3*, 2 , 2 2",- 2 A 'n 4 e p e , e ? E Y & 8 1 4 it
| |
| * 4 # .
| |
| s & $ % g d 4 4 b $'s g -- a 4- A 4 i- ,s ' , m% 4 i- $
| |
| a ?a%, y M' -
| |
| e
| |
| $9 % '> k:: 2 / R t m s :
| |
| .x k '2 ,;,# 5+ Q .v 4, ,
| |
| % .74 .y } ? 'l V c % $' t7 3 o
| |
| +
| |
| k fB N "
| |
| o h,I@ @ $ @ l ss-2ei-3 as-4 sf-t si-2 si-3 si-4 es-i as-2 es-3 se-4 af-t si-2 a7 3 si sa i Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. F w nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outege Rote (s) Crded hours 00 8 3 80 ,
| |
| * 6-
| |
| . 3 Jf !!
| |
| f f<e w . a<
| |
| ~> s>4-
| |
| * es D 40 - a Y Y 3 x, 2a
| |
| " W w 2-
| |
| ~
| |
| d o O ss-2 si-3 se'-4 sf-i si : si-3 sf-4 as-i so-2 as.3 se-4 si-i si-2 si-3 s7-4 se-i Yeor - Quarter Yect - Quar ter ,
| |
| 15 8 g
| |
| | |
| r 7_;:: 4.C
| |
| _ PERRY 1: Trenas
| |
| ( ,ss
| |
| ~
| |
| Performance Indicators C'** 1 W roved
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms hie Crit;.31 '- -
| |
| . f2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| vs fn ..Q'173 y +
| |
| ~ .6
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotons (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o ja l 6 .,
| |
| t 3J Signficant Cvents (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .i g}gj 4 Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 253 'k ff hbf 5, forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ 'Z9n j 2 51 4-
| |
| ._ mxM l
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit - Hrs. ;
| |
| (2 dtr. Avg enc 88-1) - -'53 y;
| |
| -2 5-2.0 -i5 -iO -0.5 0 0 0'S t'0 t'$ 2'O 2.5 Cevictions from Previous 4 Otr. Pent Meons (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| PERRY 1- Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance !ndicotors
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms wr9e Criticol (4 Otr. Avg eno 38-1) - -l39 Ff21Wl .' ;
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuatons (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.46
| |
| : 3. Sigmficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)'- -322
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr, Avg end 88-1) . 5 66
| |
| : 5. forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -oos j
| |
| . i
| |
| - i
| |
| ^
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outcoes/1000 Crit. Hrs. @
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -024 f
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 lo -0.5 0'O 0 5 t'0 1'S 2'O 25 Devictions from Oider Piont Meces (Meosited in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| [) 15 9
| |
| | |
| I l
| |
| r 3;=E :..='
| |
| ' ~2:
| |
| m c. .g ,
| |
| )
| |
| L I H<p7 O^Onp* : :a' y' a,e- 4 1
| |
| ,L_. v_ siiv: : --r v-
| |
| . t:: :ss s'
| |
| i g _g g gg,_ j summmu 4 Omrte' % r; b e' :e i Autorn0 tic Scrorrs Wh4 Cr,t<=l 2 Safety System Act At Ors "
| |
| 4 2500 4 .
| |
| - 2:50 ::M i
| |
| T
| |
| - 2N $ A 4 00C ) !'
| |
| W 3 g g 3 Sg - t750 g jg -
| |
| '7x]l
| |
| ! 1500 ' ,E" ;
| |
| * y <! e
| |
| .< 2 Iry .j l
| |
| *2-y d x
| |
| - 4 50 o -y 2,
| |
| [
| |
| -j s:t - 7$0=a~ lj 3 4=3:
| |
| t-O f t. 1
| |
| $h
| |
| ' r$a G$
| |
| m ,
| |
| Q m sm
| |
| , - soo -
| |
| S ? ,
| |
| k 86-286386'-4 S Y-1 87k287'-387-4 88-1 86'-2 86-3 86-4 8 7' t 8 7'-2 87'-3 8 7'-4 to t Year - Quarter feor - %crter 3 Sgnficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System Fokses
| |
| . 3. g 3.
| |
| *! l *!
| |
| ~
| |
| O g- 2 2 2 g- " 7
| |
| ~5 ~O
| |
| * a k ht 2
| |
| , , , I_ o )
| |
| * '" k [ q y u D N 1[ [f D [,
| |
| .n Ni k',,'
| |
| ?"
| |
| % e l
| |
| w $* #
| |
| 1
| |
| $ 's
| |
| {
| |
| i 0 @ i
| |
| -w-i 1 0 ,
| |
| s
| |
| , , t
| |
| ; Pm r
| |
| 06b 286L386ko 87-187i287-387-4 86-1 86-2 86-3 86-4 6Y -187-2 87-3 87-e 6-1 Yeor - Quyter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Cutoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) Critccs Ws 00 $
| |
| s 7
| |
| A s So - u'[
| |
| - 6
| |
| $h nh 5}4 .- si '
| |
| ~g ~yo. +h a #
| |
| 40 . 5 3
| |
| s .} ,- r,n
| |
| :o
| |
| :e 0 -} .
| |
| 0 . ; .- .
| |
| 86-286386-4k al-t 87L 2 87'-3 87-4 86-1 84-2 86-3 86-4 87-1 87-2 87'-3 87.4 88 -1 Yect - Qwter Yeor - Quarter 16 0 g
| |
| | |
| 1
| |
| :-3 ; .~
| |
| _ _. 1
| |
| ' MGRIM: Trerds Dee! ired Improsed Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scrcms 'AhFe Cnt:ccl t (2 otr. Avg enc 88-1) - i
| |
| - l 2 3cie'y System Actuct.cns (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . og j 1 I i
| |
| 3 Significcet Events (2 Otr. Avg end 38-1) - .o33 jh i
| |
| : 4. Scfety System Fclures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . QQ
| |
| < w as o7 j i
| |
| 5 Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88 li . !
| |
| },
| |
| 6 Ecupment forced Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs. li (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| i
| |
| -2.5 i5 -i O -d 5 0.0 0'S l 'O 15 20 25 Cevictions from Previous 4 Otr. P:cnt Vecns (Mecsured in Stendctd Cevect.cns)
| |
| PILGRIM: Deviations from Older Plant Means eelow Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf, Performance Indicators 1 Scroms Whhe Criticci l Automoti[4otr Avg end 88-1) ~ )
| |
| l
| |
| - t
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) k on I
| |
| 3 Signficent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0A2 28 o
| |
| e
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fcitures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ! 0 21
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr, Avg end 88-t) ., l 1
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit Hrs (4 Ctr. Avg end SS-1) '
| |
| -2.5-i0 i 5 -io -0.5 0 0 0 5 1'o 1!5 2'O 25 Cevictions from Older Plcnt Mecns (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) l (o. :si i
| |
| | |
| x- ,
| |
| t r:-
| |
| w 1i JL Ai- ,.,n.~. ..~. ..:
| |
| ;aa - nrs v, 1i u t ,M \v i i ._ m v r
| |
| 36-2 to 88-1 " 4 C " t '' W ^ i ; r : i' g
| |
| t Automatic Scroms Ane Cr to 2 Scfety System Actuct ens 4 250o 4 :n:
| |
| - - 22so j::n f-.___., , 7
| |
| /., _ - .
| |
| f 3- g
| |
| / .
| |
| 2000 3 1
| |
| y 5 3.
| |
| 3 R,
| |
| \
| |
| ! ;: 'I
| |
| , ' eso *
| |
| ?
| |
| eg e - T7% , j \ ,/
| |
| / o ~35 .
| |
| \ i x
| |
| E t / eco *' / i !
| |
| u " 'l
| |
| -< < <t l \ j *
| |
| * l uso j 3:2- i j :x 3 ;
| |
| m3.2. \ - .
| |
| t.y \ - un n if
| |
| \5 ,,; - uo , <
| |
| y 3 j. 4i
| |
| - d '50 6j
| |
| ,- i i i 750 6 -
| |
| , i i sj
| |
| } ',%
| |
| @ 9 4 lQ I
| |
| % [ ' ,
| |
| y snw : w . I F - *" "
| |
| h ,
| |
| iiimm 0 - . -
| |
| 0 0 -
| |
| 0 86'-2 86-3 86'-4 8Y-16f-2 Bi-3 Si 4 88-1 86'-2 86-3 66-4 S/-i Si-2 Si-3 87-4 so-1 reor - ontw vw - owtw i, 3 5gnficent Events 4 Safety Sys'em Foues !
| |
| I y 3- g 3-
| |
| !b 3k
| |
| -t
| |
| -t v x2- I 3<2a, i
| |
| je 3 i h
| |
| L: 'm n F
| |
| n 66h2 86b386-4 81-1 SY-2 87-3 8I-4 86'-t $652 66 S 3 86-4 87-i 8Y-2 Si -3 87-. SS-i rw - owtv rw - Dwtv l
| |
| 6.Ecw nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcne Rote (s) Criticc3 Hotts to 8
| |
| - C 5 M- 8 6-
| |
| "k E
| |
| t k
| |
| iu s, g,e- B"
| |
| -6"m =4- l ds -.- i i.l.*~ l I
| |
| 5 6 m 2-l 20 - .
| |
| ^ l h o I l
| |
| , A -
| |
| i
| |
| {
| |
| so-2 e6L3 e4-4 8/-i ei-2 si-3 si-4 as' i s6'-2 s6-3 e6-4 Si-i si-2 si-3 sf-4 ss-i
| |
| ! year - oata vu - owtr 4 l
| |
| 16 2 g l
| |
| l t
| |
| r
| |
| | |
| s-
| |
| 'FGJE m 4
| |
| } ':
| |
| eu!N t- .,E.ic,,
| |
| ~.
| |
| x- e %n 1: trencs i
| |
| U' Performance Indicaters Dec%d in reve ,
| |
| i i
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Whde Cntice! l' .
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 l
| |
| t
| |
| : 2. Sofety system Actuotions (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) - -125
| |
| : 3. 5,gnificont - Events (2.0tr.'. Avg end 88-1) - o S8 m 1 4 Sofety System Foilures (2.0tr. Avg end 88-1) . o.53
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -006
| |
| : 6. 'Equ'o ment forced Ouicces/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) - , <
| |
| 0 54
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5 I.0 - 5 0.0 O!5 t'O i 5 . 2'O 2.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Ptont Meons (Measured in Stonderd 0 evictions)
| |
| F :
| |
| POINT BEACH 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means >
| |
| Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| - l' Performo.ne Indicators 1 Automatic Scroms while Critical -
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 02:
| |
| y
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| ] o.33
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . IEEE oc,6 I d lE 9
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| g o 93
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.t?
| |
| : 0. Equ~pment forced Ovtooes/1000 Crit. Hrs 0M (4 Gtr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2LO-t5 i.0 -0.5 0 0 0 5 l'0 l'5 2'O 25 Devictions from C4 der Picnt Veens (Measured in Stonderd Cevictiong i
| |
| 16 3
| |
| | |
| : [; : ~ s - 7T -
| |
| l I
| |
| ^- - "
| |
| m, .* , - ,= -
| |
| _zmcrm*
| |
| 6 , .,.,;.- : , .., ... ,
| |
| J 'v: i i 1 1. L a H ,v i _ ,
| |
| -g~. ...-... .
| |
| * ,, - 3 ,. 5 t
| |
| - 4 L:'te' h r; L e' : ;e 36 -2 to 88-1 l
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scrcrrs Whe Critico 2 Sc'ety System Actxt,Cr$ ;
| |
| - 1200 ':*o
| |
| '"~~s, . '; - . , ,,,,,,...-, ,
| |
| I . 2 coo , i ., f ;xg 5 e
| |
| $ 3- I !, 3. ! ,
| |
| 5
| |
| / .
| |
| e t / - oso - ' i eso s;
| |
| 3 .l-
| |
| -/ soo ,
| |
| 3 3 .g, .1
| |
| / \ .f 1 -2ee '
| |
| -4 y <, ,
| |
| 3 y" I
| |
| ,,f
| |
| - 450 a y 2. ,/ ;,
| |
| 8
| |
| , qn ^j ,i i/
| |
| Coo 5 j 3 '\ '/ ] occ s'3 t
| |
| * t_ - y '
| |
| ~
| |
| b .
| |
| $CO
| |
| * Soo f~$ -
| |
| - 250 ,4 :so i N o 2 '- ''
| |
| o o lo .
| |
| 86-2 SN3 66'-4 87'-t 6Y-2 87-3 SI-4 88-1 86h256i3 86'-4 Si-1 SI-2 S i -3 G i -4 68-1 '
| |
| Yect - Quarter Yeor - Quar ter l
| |
| r 1 Sicpficant Events ,
| |
| 6 Scfety System Foues l
| |
| m 3- g 3 h
| |
| -t wi<
| |
| g2- y 2.
| |
| -1 i
| |
| 1 ', t. .
| |
| $] '
| |
| ~
| |
| o #
| |
| o
| |
| $6L2 90 3 86k4 SY-18/ -2 8/-3 8I-4 65-1 h L 5 81-1 Si-2 67-3 Si-4 $8-1 862863864 Yeor - Qi.cr ter Yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 6. Ecuoment Forced Cutcaes/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) 1000 Cr. tics Heus '
| |
| loo 8
| |
| ? 80 - F 3 6.
| |
| 0 5
| |
| x ] eo _ I,)
| |
| B*
| |
| -E4 w dt 3. 4 ;
| |
| '0 - !
| |
| 1a .
| |
| 5 l w w 2. .
| |
| t 2o .
| |
| , 2 2 N i o - o ;
| |
| $6-2 86-3 86-4 87-i i-2 Si-3 ei-4 se'-i 86-2 86' - 3 s6-4 s7-i s7-2 si-3 8f-4 Sa - i l year - Quar te '
| |
| Y ear - ter 16 4 l
| |
| 1
| |
| | |
| V / .f
| |
| .' I l h%
| |
| s T GL ~ 4.73 p.
| |
| L :
| |
| POINT BEACH 2: Trencs P-rformance. Indicators' C'C'ir'd ""O'0"*0 6-1, Automatic Scroms Wh4 Critical- f.
| |
| (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - g,gg-s
| |
| %$ggig?-
| |
| s
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o gg -
| |
| : 3. Signf~ coot Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o *,s
| |
| ' 4, Sofety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| 0.54
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ! ' i
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs. 0 (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| ~
| |
| -2 5-2.0 -i5 -i 0 -0.5 0.0 0'S l'O '' t'5 2'O 2.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons (Mecsured in Standard Ceviations)
| |
| POINT BEACH 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Perforrnance Indicators
| |
| : 1. A.itomatic Scroms Whele Critical (4 Otr. Avg *N 88-1) - 0.74 2 Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tn
| |
| : 3. S;gnficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o42 4 Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - om
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o,72 i
| |
| I
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs. OM (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 i.5 iO -d 5 0'O O'S t'0 1'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Older Plant Veons (Meosured in Stondord Deviations) 16 5 I
| |
| | |
| . ,, t . ..
| |
| s .
| |
| .m , ! ,
| |
| #hj j "~ ' N.
| |
| a'-'I w - l i.j iJ !
| |
| Lh )h -
| |
| '.] [
| |
| I?
| |
| .~,,'..,..,,'
| |
| 36-2 to 88-1
| |
| " ' 0 "''
| |
| * 7 ' *': ~
| |
| g t Autornctic Scroms m* Cr t:co 4
| |
| : 2. Scfety System Actxtes
| |
| :so:
| |
| 4 2x0
| |
| } z:u
| |
| - 2:50 i !
| |
| - 2000 ~ / 42w],
| |
| 3- 3. ? -
| |
| W ,
| |
| f -%
| |
| '%~
| |
| \ . 1750 5 55 .\% /
| |
| *l i
| |
| J w: #e !:
| |
| \
| |
| 31< eco *-
| |
| ,2 -
| |
| \. -
| |
| \
| |
| . eso
| |
| ? <!
| |
| o ,2 .
| |
| \, !,/ 1 i
| |
| am 11 fi il
| |
| \
| |
| V - 1000 3 j V
| |
| - oco 3 j
| |
| ~i
| |
| * 7'A ~w '
| |
| - 750 i V!
| |
| 1 - dd d V 1 1 r .
| |
| 66-2 86-3 86ke 81-187'-2 Si-3 87'-4 88 -1 $6'-2 $6'-3 86-4 Si-1 $7-2 Bi-3 af 4 'J - i Yeor - Garter Year - Q;crter ,
| |
| 1 Seficant Events ,
| |
| 6 Scfety System roves a 3. g 3.
| |
| -t -t 4 g<2- g l y2- -
| |
| 2- I 1 1
| |
| ?
| |
| I 0 0 ,
| |
| 96-2 86-3 86-4 87-187-287-38?-4 88-1 66-2 96-3 86-4 8 7-1 S P-2 $7-3 '7-4 SS-1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter .
| |
| 6 Equ et Forced Cotoges/
| |
| S. Forced Outoge Rote (t) Crited Hous to 8 3 80 - h e
| |
| . 30-oc g 00 - u h4 54 x we-da t i Eh um
| |
| ** b a f 5 '
| |
| 20 -
| |
| 32-t
| |
| $8-2 36-3 56'-4 8/-t Si-2 8f-3 Si-4 to-1 Yect - Qutyter
| |
| ~r' S6-2 4-368'-4 S1-19f-2 ef.) $7-4 58 - 1 Yeor - Garter 1
| |
| 16 6 l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| ? ax :.u I
| |
| PRA RE ISLAND' h Trends
| |
| (
| |
| ~'j De*ed i m cued Performance Indicotcrs -
| |
| i
| |
| : 1. AutCmotic SCrcms Whk Criticql - Wygygwytt% t (2 Ott. Avg ' end 88 1) - g" ggggf'ghQt73
| |
| __s. . . .
| |
| j
| |
| . 2. Safety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 14 -
| |
| fx
| |
| . f-3 Sigtsficoet Events (2 Ctr. Avg end SP-1) . o l 4..'Sofety System Fa4ures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)'- -2
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rate (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - '0 63
| |
| : 6. Equ:cment Forced Outores/1000 Crit Mrs , *
| |
| (2 dtr. Avg end 88- 4) - ;. OM
| |
| -2.5-iO-15 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 0'5 t'0 l'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. P'ent Meces (Measured in Standord Devicticras) i PRAIRIE ISLAND 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic 'croms Wh4 Criticot 034 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .g4
| |
| : 3. Stificoat Events (4 Otr. Avg end 68-1) - 0 46 ,
| |
| l
| |
| : 4. Sclety System Fe4/es (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ' o.14
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - c.79
| |
| : 6. Equiperent Forced Outcoes/1000 Crit. Hrs 0 90
| |
| . (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2LO -i.5 -to -U.5 0'O O!S L'O l'52025 Devictions from Older Piont Vecns (Mecsured in Stondcrd Devictions) 16 7
| |
| /
| |
| | |
| I EGLFE 4.75 j- , -..- - -...
| |
| m .- . -
| |
| r a -m n
| |
| N tN N,. ,I \ I. ) blgkb .(,_ LOCOOC$ f et,c;:~: -:s s ' '' E m
| |
| 86-2' to 88-1 '"" 4 0- " " ''c' N ^''': P g
| |
| : 1. Automate Scrcrrs WNe Criticca 2. Sofety System Actu:tes l 4 2500 4 2soo I
| |
| _ 225o . 2:50
| |
| -- ,, . - - - - ~ ~ ~ .
| |
| s - 2000 , g . . coo ;
| |
| 3- 3. \ / *
| |
| \ '* '
| |
| ~
| |
| \/ .\
| |
| "" 3 ,
| |
| 3I.
| |
| \
| |
| v _ =3 = x3 <[, v . . e .
| |
| j
| |
| *2-p 2 . g3o ,e. g \
| |
| . q3a j coo 3 coo 3
| |
| 'j v
| |
| W
| |
| =3 ,.
| |
| >= 3
| |
| . soo - wo S y . 250
| |
| . 250
| |
| -o o o o
| |
| * sekt ei-3 88-4 af-1 si-2 si-3 si-4 se'-1 ei-2 se'-3 88-4 si-t si-2 si-3 si-4 sa-t Year - Quarter Year - Ovarter i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fotues '
| |
| 3 sgnificant Events ,
| |
| . 3. g 3-t me a<
| |
| : 3. g2.
| |
| e 86-2 8M-3 86 L 4 Si., ai-2 Si-3 SY-4 sekt o
| |
| 86L 2 86L384 x
| |
| L 4 8/-t Bi-2 Si-3 ai-4 68 -1 veor - brter fear - Quorter
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forceo outcge Rote (s) 1000 Critccs Hours to a 3 ao .
| |
| 3'~
| |
| e 11
| |
| ><1 .o - a<
| |
| b5 $t**
| |
| g 44 .
| |
| 5
| |
| - w 2-20 .
| |
| N o L o si-2seisei-4 si-i i es-2 es.3 si-4 af-i ei-2 si-3 sr-4 ss-,
| |
| year L-2iersi-3 si-4 se'-i year - ouar ter 16 8 g 1
| |
| | |
| ~ ~
| |
| rwE us i PRA!RE ISLAND 2: Trena's
| |
| .l s
| |
| - t")
| |
| Performance Indicators O'C 6"d *'S d C - i 1 Automatic Scroms Whae Criticci j (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 ;
| |
| : 2. Screty System Actuctons (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 3. Signficant Events (2 ' Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fobres (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -te
| |
| : 5. Forces Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 -
| |
| 6 Equement Forced Outeres/1000 Crit. Hrs. o (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| I
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -l5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 1l5 2IO 2.5 Devictions frcm Previous
| |
| . (Measured 4 Otr, in Stondord Plant )Meons Devictions PRAIRE ISLAND 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means S&w Avg. Perf.- Above Avg _ Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms WNie Critical 129 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| ' 2. Safety. System A:tuot'ons (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - tn
| |
| : 3. S;gnificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 98
| |
| '4. Sof ety System Febres (4 Otr. Ava end 88-1) - 0.55
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 039
| |
| : 6. Equipenent Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs. 0 90 (4 Gtr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-i5 0.5 0'O O!5 t'0 I'S 2'O 25 Devictions from Oder Plant Meons (Meosured in Standord Deviations) r
| |
| . O
| |
| | |
| -~J.~. .: --D
| |
| ,. ; . m m. ; , - m .
| |
| ^!!'
| |
| j
| |
| . ,N. ) ll l ,
| |
| f LbhbbC$ '2i' w e d 21 -/s 1 'C !?
| |
| 36-2 tO 88-1
| |
| - ' C";" " ''o 7 2+'=*
| |
| g l
| |
| l 4
| |
| : 1. AutomClic $0rcrrs WNe Criticci 2. Scfety Systern A0twtors !
| |
| 2500 4 0500 ,
| |
| . 2250 ::p
| |
| ... .' l. to ; , .
| |
| j j:,3 l
| |
| ' ,~ A 1750 " e
| |
| .s ns
| |
| -\ s at
| |
| ~< \
| |
| = p< -\
| |
| i
| |
| -y2- d 4 50 oy2. ! ,I. . :50 j;+ e I
| |
| / .
| |
| - \ l -l
| |
| [ ~ DOC B hh \ j A CCC 3 -
| |
| , m \ -
| |
| -! r ,- i! 6il
| |
| ~ a r . u \l 1m s
| |
| \" . 250 _ 250 I
| |
| ~. s s 0 -
| |
| 0 0 0 86-286'3864 87-t 87'-2 87'-3 8 7-4 68'-1 86'-2 86'-3 86- 4 Oi-1 SN2 87-3 87-4 SS-i Year - Ovorter Year - Cvy ter
| |
| : 3. Smf; cont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foves 3 3 a 3. g 3.
| |
| as h Ih as k
| |
| -I ~E W o t.
| |
| m ,
| |
| , a i@ M .'g g
| |
| + a , xy r-w ,
| |
| g 7 2Jq m 'i
| |
| %a r?*
| |
| y% g&q
| |
| +y W d x y f y
| |
| 0 , , , , , , ,
| |
| 0-- T . . ; 1 .
| |
| i 66-2 86-3 86-4 8/-187-287-387-4 88-1 86-2 W3 86-4 87-16h2 8 7-3 G7,4 88 1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Ovarter
| |
| : 6. Ecuoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) 1000 Cr>tecs Hotis ,
| |
| 00 $
| |
| e [
| |
| 6 L
| |
| 5 80 -
| |
| *6. $
| |
| g <. . -
| |
| 2.
| |
| w.
| |
| e s s B" s
| |
| * 4 we. 'N
| |
| 'm w
| |
| , oo . c 0a L W w 2.
| |
| **^
| |
| % ;x o _L d - 0 E 86-2 86-3 66'-4 SY-1 87'-2 87'-3 87'-4 68-1 86'-2 86'-3 66-4 Si-187'-287-387-4 68 - t Yect - Quorter Year - Quarter 17 0 h
| |
| | |
| r ouPE :.7s
| |
| . -[- ,
| |
| OUAD CITES 1: Trends Declime imeros,ed
| |
| ' Performonce Indicators .
| |
| ' 1. Automotic Scroms Whde Critical (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ;
| |
| 09 j I
| |
| 2.' Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) o
| |
| : 3. S;gruf: cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) o
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - 197 l'
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced to s/ 0 C it y '{ ' _;,,
| |
| -2.5-i.0-t5 -to -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 1'52!02.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr Plant Means (Measured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| OUAD CITES 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Pui. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical 128 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) "
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . tn
| |
| : 3. 3;gnif; cont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 8.8 -1) . oss
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - -h?
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . oss
| |
| . 6. Equoment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit. Hrs -283 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5 .0 I.5 -i.0 -0.5 0'O O'.5 t'0 t'5 2'0 25 eviations from Older Pbnt Veons (Mecsured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| O V
| |
| 17 1 l
| |
| : r. . . . _ . - .
| |
| | |
| : GJE a ~~
| |
| I - m .n :
| |
| ' *2. -'
| |
| i !,
| |
| e}
| |
| j l ' i ; b" m C .m Q r n * ' aa --,
| |
| 1,.. .
| |
| ') W v) v i i ! .-L. J l ''V-
| |
| {',-
| |
| % z,_ -Y 86-2 to 88-1 """ 4 C "' "' ' ' " ^ i " ''
| |
| * g i
| |
| i Automot;c Scres ANe Crit col
| |
| : 2. Scfety System Actzt ors -
| |
| 2500 :sc !
| |
| - 2250
| |
| , , 2 2*A ,
| |
| s /\ -
| |
| 2cm j '\, ,,, J2xe; I 3- t 3- -. ? i l
| |
| s 1750
| |
| * i g *.\ /
| |
| \ . 1750 - SL 38 \
| |
| /
| |
| \. ., eco - !
| |
| I II
| |
| \
| |
| j s
| |
| p2- \ d ,1 - a 2.
| |
| ] 'w$: !
| |
| 2
| |
| > a _ '000250 3 f ' '
| |
| j Coo 3
| |
| : p?. y a t
| |
| . j.. -4. 750 - ?sc v!
| |
| ' M ;M:=.{
| |
| : t. d O t, ,
| |
| # ' " I o g o _
| |
| lo
| |
| *I-2 66'-3 $6-4 87-l 6f-2 Si-3 SI-4 88-t 96-2 66-3 86'-4 87-9 87-2 87-3 87-4 S8- l Yeor - Quorter reor - Quorter i
| |
| 3 Sicpficent Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System F1,.ses p
| |
| ::k
| |
| .s_ g 3. 1 %'
| |
| jk
| |
| }k wB w3
| |
| ? 3
| |
| -d ~4 $ % '
| |
| 2 m2. 3 2. $ f:
| |
| D, Q&s 4x 1 1 1 [ ,,,,
| |
| w W
| |
| m n g +
| |
| O__ ;
| |
| O j.
| |
| S6-286-386-487-187 287-387-4 88-l S6-2 W3 66 4 87-187-28'.387.4 ss.i ,
| |
| Year - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau rn Forced Outogest'
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcx)e Rxe (t) Crites Hours 00 6
| |
| $ 8o -
| |
| $S g% ..
| |
| aO g O
| |
| ~
| |
| h4 $4 as tr'-
| |
| Tj * - 5 j !
| |
| s sp w 2. '=_
| |
| M. - U cy
| |
| ^^
| |
| a b -
| |
| i -
| |
| b o
| |
| -t l
| |
| i
| |
| . .. . . ., .... 7.. 7.. -, .6. . . . 6-voor
| |
| . . , .- , b<a.ter. . <.
| |
| : 7. .
| |
| rear - Qw t.r i 17 2 h
| |
| | |
| l
| |
| '-.,:5:_--
| |
| l
| |
| _ _ _ . . _ _ l V, v, , e t./ - v . > ; ._ 2 4:
| |
| .fs
| |
| !TerCS 1
| |
| .( O* d"* d
| |
| 'D E6f fCrmCnce indiCCtOrs *0f0VS 1 Automet e Screms wne Cnt,cci (2 Cte. Avg e-d SS-1) -14' yggg$;g.
| |
| gg;,
| |
| 2 ' ihte System Actuatcqs (2 Ctr Avg end 38-1) ,, ,' 4 ,373 3 S;gnif cont Events (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . g l l i t
| |
| 4 Scfety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .i P I
| |
| : 5. Forced Outege Rete (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) . og l l l
| |
| : 6. Equ,pment Fcrced Outoces/1 COO Crit Mr s.
| |
| (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) - -C C !
| |
| -2.5-2.0-15-10-0.500 0.5 10 t5 20 2.5 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt M (Measured in Stondord Devictions) ecns QUAD CITES 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators B&w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Per f, {
| |
| I i-
| |
| ' ^? "Mll l Automatic(4Scroms Otr. AvgWhele endCritico
| |
| $3-1) - '92 ? T *'' 'p' j' ', l
| |
| . c ;
| |
| : 2. Scfety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . t24 C# *s
| |
| - . 4.-
| |
| . 3. S'qnificont Events (4 Qtr. Avg end 88-1) . og i 4 Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .tp
| |
| : 5. Forced Ortoge Rete (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o 43
| |
| : 6. Fouwmer-t For:ed Ouoges/1000 Crit Mrs ~C 01 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-iO -t$ d 5 0 0 0'5 t'0 1.'5 2'O 25 Devictions frem Oeer Plent Meons
| |
| ! (Veosured in Stendord Ceviatiens) i L
| |
| O 17 3 yry.. ~- - - ~- -1 , - . , , - , -.w, ,.3, ,+.r-..w , - . , - ,,,.,y,p..w,-,m.,-e n r.-.m ,m -wsm--
| |
| | |
| F'Oleg 4,73 3,s m: ,m n~n .'**
| |
| b '\s
| |
| * ~
| |
| i \ ! 'd a r , :: -:/s 86-2 to 88-1 t Av,omet< Scres Whe Cr:he:8 2. Sofety System Actu:tces
| |
| . rzo . :sa ,
| |
| I
| |
| - 22so . ::w g i
| |
| g 3. 2o0o3g 3 .' . 2w -) l' 3g . 175o gg . ??M
| |
| : a. .y- ,.
| |
| .4 pt- - CSo
| |
| =! 5 .1 o ,m t .e
| |
| ]o- =
| |
| A c% h ,
| |
| j . am i 1 J=;!
| |
| 1-
| |
| . 73o 4 0 J-) 1 1 l 5 '
| |
| J,wi No
| |
| . Soo .
| |
| 9 o
| |
| . 2So g h - 2M o o o o s-, g 3 .c. .<-,.,-i.,-3.,-. -, -, g 3 -. .i-, . Y- 2 . ,- 3 7 -. --, -
| |
| Yeor - Mter Ye7 - Quy t er
| |
| : 3. 5pficant Events 4. Sofety System FoVes 7 m l~ b,
| |
| .3. g 3. N 1 ,.3,. 3 l}
| |
| 08 {} 4
| |
| } @ w 2 ,
| |
| +
| |
| 's
| |
| -4 3 4 , 3 4 ,
| |
| $' 5'" ""
| |
| ? } l
| |
| , 4
| |
| ' t.. , + , n( 54 y 4 4 e
| |
| @ 4 * % v 'g se g 3 m dN , M $ @
| |
| * t'? ?N hv A e6-2 86-3 66-. SI-l ti-2 SY-3 Si-4 65-1 06' 2 803 SN4 81-1 ti-2 6f-3 Si-o es-t Ysor - Qwrter Yeor - 4arter
| |
| : 6. Equ .nt Forced CLtpges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (t) CritcrJ Hou oo e x
| |
| 3 m. O h j} 3 }..
| |
| t e- !!
| |
| b t*
| |
| g..
| |
| gg x
| |
| ; .o .
| |
| v
| |
| '8 n_ .
| |
| "'~
| |
| 0 0 T , ; : .
| |
| l
| |
| . s? i 7-2 e7-3 e7-* sa-i i . . ,
| |
| se : so-3 e6-4 l e6-3 so-3 e6-4 es-t s>-2 s7-3 a7-4 as-i j rear - Qurter v oor - t er l
| |
| i 17 4
| |
| ______ _____.______x___._.__._.__._.__
| |
| | |
| , RANCHO SECO: Trencs
| |
| .\
| |
| [ l'
| |
| 'b PerformonCe Indicotors Cectined e:ra e s 1 Automot;c Scroms whie Criticot (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ,
| |
| ""T" 2 S:fety System Actuotens (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o $3
| |
| : 3. S;gmficant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . j'j*h o Ss !
| |
| Et i 4 Sof ety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - f; 122 l
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| l l
| |
| 6 Equcment r rced o Outoges/1000 Crit Hrs j (2 utr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2 5-2.0-i.5 -iO -d 5 0 0 0 5 t'0 15 2!O 25 Devictions from Prevous 4 Otr. P!cnt Means (Mecsved in Standard 0 evictions)
| |
| RANCHO SECO: Deviations from Older Plant Means Beiw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performonce Indicators I
| |
| : 1. Automatic Soroms Wh*le Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.n
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -ts2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 2 55 5 Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) - l
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forceo Outooes/1000 Crit Mrs (4 Gr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-15-10-0.50'0 0'S t'0 l'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Older Plont Meons (Mecsured in Stondord Devictions) b t
| |
| 17 5 i V t
| |
| L . __ . . _ . . _ _
| |
| | |
| r ,c:E 4. 3
| |
| ! i ,
| |
| D './ L i N!:D U
| |
| . ie' D:\?L. i J L' < .: ~ .= v' -
| |
| --'*~'
| |
| : :e = :-
| |
| ,,,c, .
| |
| . r . .,
| |
| ammmm 4 O s:,t e, v y; a , v :'e 8c-2 to 88-1
| |
| : 1. Automatk Scres Wh'e Critsect ,
| |
| : 2. Scfety System Actxtices ,,
| |
| 9 @
| |
| 2:so I
| |
| J::so s.
| |
| r
| |
| .y y
| |
| et
| |
| : 3. Q ;
| |
| i j
| |
| N s
| |
| ,'\ F-8 -
| |
| '~f nl 3. .',
| |
| [''' \
| |
| ! 1
| |
| ' f
| |
| ~,,
| |
| et< % s'4 !; so -
| |
| j <a i
| |
| i:
| |
| sc e .:
| |
| : u. ,
| |
| a O
| |
| mr. /-
| |
| f' -
| |
| .s.. . t2so 4m 2. , .
| |
| c.sotI l
| |
| =
| |
| \l y .-
| |
| .e . !
| |
| ?
| |
| ?
| |
| . oco 3 d '
| |
| s l .
| |
| oco 3 a
| |
| l e i i i
| |
| ,- \~ !e ' m l sg a
| |
| ./ 7 m . . soo .
| |
| o o si- ee-3 ei-.,si-i s gi.,i-2 si-. es-i e6-2 ei-3 es-4.,87-5 yi.7-8, s'-* sa-i -
| |
| v 1 - -
| |
| j 3 Scpficont Events 4 Sofety System Fyues 4 *,
| |
| T
| |
| .s. >
| |
| : 1.
| |
| }k wa *
| |
| $k a) o"t-e L et- ? ?
| |
| 2
| |
| $ $k M. l b8 4 u j hw%
| |
| I i, i ' i.
| |
| f
| |
| ~z" )j 9 %
| |
| %g K j ,
| |
| f a *- .
| |
| ., ,s., .;-.,si-, v. -
| |
| ist,i-, si-. .s-,
| |
| L-, si-s .i , se-.,si-i
| |
| : v. - L-11 e,i->
| |
| t .1-. .i-,
| |
| : 6. Equ et Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Crit 43 ws co e e s
| |
| ~
| |
| 5 m. $
| |
| . 2 '' L
| |
| *z g. t a g ec . iva.
| |
| I S' 54 A-
| |
| , U w me. Q 33 4 -. a d
| |
| 2e
| |
| '- I
| |
| = l l
| |
| 8 2* $
| |
| H l
| |
| 20 .
| |
| , 2. 4 iu -
| |
| 4 in
| |
| 'P%
| |
| GM- N *". gj Im3 i
| |
| > i e d ( s Mi 4 ~
| |
| L'1 pE 2 (. o C .2 a l-
| |
| ~
| |
| I es.: as-s es-. s7-i ai-2 si-3 ei-. so-i so- es 3 ee-. ar-i s?- s >-3 e r-* sa.i l Tecc - oucrter Y** - 0" t F I
| |
| i 17 6 i
| |
| l l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| r3.c. - ;
| |
| s 2 ./EP 3 ENC. Trenas Cedred ec,e
| |
| - PerformorCe IndicoterS ^
| |
| i 1 AutomCt,+ Scro?S Wh4 Criticci WW !
| |
| [2 Ctr Avg end SS-1) - '[M'~~h'"ydffy -289
| |
| )
| |
| t 2 S:fety System Act ect.Cns (2 Otr A vg end 89- 1) . -125 'h 'f b ! ,
| |
| 3 Sigsf>ccet Events (2 Ctr Avg end 88- 1) . S if o gg ,
| |
| = '
| |
| 4 S:fety System Fcitures (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) . us h ,
| |
| l 5 Forced Outege Rete (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) - - t2 2 6 s s ,. m_ ,.y ,
| |
| 6 Equpment Forcea tegs/1000 Cr t 'y ; '( ,,,
| |
| -2.5-20-i5 500 0'S l'O 1'5 20 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr Plant Meons (Measured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| RIVER BEND: Deviations from Older Plant Means !
| |
| I Performance Indicators B&w Avg. Perf Above Avg Perf.
| |
| f l.
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms while Critical F s !
| |
| f4 Otr. Avg eN 88-1) - -139 i
| |
| ~"
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuctons (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) . t 0 33 1.u
| |
| : 3. S;gnificent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System rodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o 4 s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o49 l LU .
| |
| : 6. Equpment Ferced Outodws/000 Crit Hrs fg[l'fffjgf (4 tr Avg end 88-1) -l-gggagdg'9 M -3''
| |
| l l
| |
| , , , , ,,,< f
| |
| -2.5-20-15-10-0500 05 10 15 20 25 i De Actions from Older Plont Means (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| I \ 17 7
| |
| \ l
| |
| ~./
| |
| s
| |
| | |
| f T GF 1.3 '
| |
| i i n > - :: :'
| |
| 'M ,-,\mq 's b li ; b V Z L9genC: ?:e' : :" '-*'::-
| |
| .rt:: -ns 86-2 to 88-1 " ' C " '' * "i '''':it t Automate Scroms Who Cnt col 2. Sofety System Acts :t ons -
| |
| 2%o 4 :m
| |
| .s d w . 22w , 22n c 4 .
| |
| ..N 2 coo 7 . ..._.. .. 'i '4-,-
| |
| ~g .
| |
| } 3. ;
| |
| e sy a.
| |
| V- /\\ - nw } yp \ . .s - w-Se ,w h \ l \\ 1,2, ,
| |
| -< fe-a 5 <,
| |
| \ /
| |
| *t- e 4 .
| |
| 2mj int- t
| |
| / \ ] tw ] i s q coo a j ]< wo 3 3 & -
| |
| *i g y a% W f i
| |
| &N '" 3 I 'M 3l Ql-
| |
| ,~ i f ,~
| |
| ] f\ '
| |
| 4 - 20
| |
| '" ^
| |
| .,. T . wo j
| |
| b o
| |
| h
| |
| -v .
| |
| = 0 o -- : o ('
| |
| 66-286k366-4 SI.i 87k2 87'-3 SY-4 86'-1 86k266386-4 0)-1Sf-2 SI-3 si-4 So-vw - ovarte Yw - ovarte
| |
| : 3. SP : fcont Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System Foues y 4 ',
| |
| s [ [
| |
| e 3. 3 3. T 3' i'i h jh h v5
| |
| -t -t4 _*
| |
| 34 jff r t $f ;
| |
| j$ $ Y 4
| |
| / hj g g ~:
| |
| 86b2 BN3 86be 8 -187' 2 8N-3 87k4 86-1 66L 2 86b366 L 4 SI-1 ' 2 SI-3 87ke SS-I Year - GkArter Year - ter
| |
| : 6. End nt Forced Outoys/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Cnt<ct w s to a b 80 -
| |
| i''t it s<t e a- a< ,
| |
| 3m et *me. -
| |
| 3 03 g s lh n
| |
| s
| |
| } 2-
| |
| ~
| |
| 3 1
| |
| ' i o - - o -
| |
| k k 96296386-4 SY-1 SI-2 87k3 87ke 86-1 L 96286-386-4 87'-1 (7'-2 97k3 87- 4 SS - i l Yeor - Quarter Yeor - pte i
| |
| )
| |
| 1 17 8 3
| |
| . : T.
| |
| ! ; j
| |
| | |
| l Ow:E 4.30
| |
| /
| |
| g.
| |
| RC3!NSON 2: Trends De @ ed tmorovec
| |
| -. Performance Indicators
| |
| - 1. Automotic Scroms Whie Crit.cci I (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - ($ o46 .
| |
| M '.
| |
| 2 Scfety System Actuotces (2 Ctr, Avg end 88-1) . .t25 3 Signf. cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o i !
| |
| 4 Sofety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o. s
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1)--t92
| |
| : 6. Equverent Forced Out /1000 Crit Hr s. O !
| |
| (2 fr! Avg end 88-1) - p d'i
| |
| -2 5-iO -iS -io -0.5 0 0 O!S l'O 1'S 2'O 25-
| |
| * Devictions from Preven 4 Otr. Plant Meons "
| |
| (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| ROBINSON 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators B&vi Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| : 1. Automoti S f4 broms WW Criticoitr Avg end -139 88-1) - l.
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 33 .
| |
| l l
| |
| : 3. S;gnficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ges
| |
| (
| |
| 4 Sofety System rodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 42s l 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1'. . .o33 l
| |
| [
| |
| : 6. Equir. ment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit Mr s.
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t07 l'
| |
| -2.5-2LO-i5 -lo -d.5 0'O O'S t'O l'5 20 25 Devictions from Oider Piont Meer s (Meosured in Stonderd Devictions) f i
| |
| 17 9
| |
| 'N i
| |
| | |
| F G',FE 4.3' i i *C :: ,*
| |
| ,)b ~
| |
| l l t- O OC'. f'# !^
| |
| wr 1+::+ ~C ar s t I' 86-2 to 88-1 "" ' 0 "0" " * " i * '' ''
| |
| l Autornctic Scres WNe Crit'col 2. Sofety System Actu tes
| |
| '500 4 :so 2n l ::so
| |
| -S ,. g l l
| |
| - 2000 ~ .
| |
| ..", ,:m e 3- 3. < r y) s 5 .%
| |
| - "So / 1 - "so -
| |
| 5 '
| |
| S}t
| |
| ? .' - eas a 5 <1 .-
| |
| \: - u. .
| |
| g' 4
| |
| m2. -
| |
| usoj om2- { :w 1
| |
| ~
| |
| *3 "3
| |
| ,~ 5-$ i /i - 3 2, / - '50 3
| |
| $j j E - 500 / 500 l
| |
| k ) h
| |
| - 2M
| |
| :so 0 h : , Y i 84-2 64-3 86-4 87-i 87-2 87-3 67-4 88-i
| |
| #2 0 0 , . . .
| |
| 66-2 86-3 86-4 0'-i 97-2 s7-3 87-4 SS-i 2
| |
| Year - Quarter Year - Quarter 3 5.pficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues
| |
| . 3- 3 3-hk jh
| |
| -t -t gt- 1 mt. L L ji j ji j 3 , a s
| |
| 4 V
| |
| ~
| |
| d -
| |
| f?
| |
| d =
| |
| pa , N '""
| |
| g W
| |
| s I I o N ll
| |
| .I estsoL eA2essei-4 si-i ei.: ei-3 si-4 es-i 3 eA4 si-i ai-2 si-3 si-4 sa i Year - ourter Yec - Quarter 6 Eau; ment Forced Outoqrs/
| |
| $. Forced Outo;p Rote (s) rX)0 Critsa ws oo E 80 - h s-
| |
| .. g 3e i bt
| |
| }<t eo - a<
| |
| d$ ,$ ~ 3 53 40 - 3 os y
| |
| } 23
| |
| - 2 5 '' s 22 .
| |
| 7 y %
| |
| s W N_ WW o O .: ""1 o O & ~
| |
| si es-a so-3 ei-4 si-i s?-2 si-3 si-4 sa-i si.: eds esia.ar omrter Y i af si-3 si-4 ei-i Y ear - ovarter 18 0 l.
| |
| | |
| G j 2.31 9._P A '-
| |
| Ireras DecWd me ,e:
| |
| Performance Indiccters _,
| |
| 1 Automouc Scroms WMe Critstol G (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0 58 g l 1 !
| |
| 2 Scfety System Actsetses (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . o :
| |
| i,
| |
| : 3. S'genficont Events (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) . .t72 ;
| |
| i 4 Sclety System Foiivres (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o $o i i
| |
| I f Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) _ o tt l
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it togs / , .g,
| |
| -2.5 -iO -i.5 -i O -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 l'5 20 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr Piont Means (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| SALEM 1: Deviations frorn Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Criticci '
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o 21 2 Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ui
| |
| : 3. Sigenficent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o 42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foikres (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -to
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c es
| |
| : 6. Equ9 ment Forced it Hr tg/ _ , ,,
| |
| -2.5-2' 0 -iS d.5 0'O O'S t'0 l'5 20 25 Devictions from Oider Plont veons (Measured in Stondord Devictions) i 18 1 i
| |
| | |
| Id,,5 d.32 i --
| |
| ), l
| |
| _ Z $ $ 0. fE*' Y' *** /
| |
| '. rit 07 -:g s 86-2 to 88-1 ""
| |
| * 10' "' *^3 " '' ;
| |
| * t Automot< Scrores we Cr.tes 2. Safety System Actet ors e 2500 *
| |
| ,m i
| |
| ' /
| |
| - 22 %
| |
| race v , i .. /
| |
| f::u iI g 3 i s
| |
| ,'s /
| |
| j 3. \ ! 1::.:o # t 5
| |
| 1
| |
| , - nso \ , ui
| |
| ,s a I i i si A} wl O '
| |
| ,'N
| |
| ,/
| |
| . eco a" j! ,\ i !.
| |
| j Lc ~a i
| |
| * 2
| |
| \
| |
| \
| |
| 4 . 1 i -
| |
| yI- ''
| |
| \
| |
| . t2So og2- ,/ / d '"M 3
| |
| } th e}-s, \,.
| |
| s i.j -
| |
| m H. n/ v d,'ecai. .
| |
| ,~ 's a , .
| |
| '* 5 , ,
| |
| 1SooS3 9
| |
| % kYh $
| |
| a E-h q :s Soo y 4M V q ', y v 8 y .
| |
| . rw g . :w n
| |
| * A $ g o n
| |
| 66.-2 96'-3 SN4 GI-1 Bi-2 Si-3 Si-4 86-1 86'-3 66-3 66-4 SY-1 (7-2 87-3 si a wt Y07 - Qucrter Y97 - Quarter 3 5pficent Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues
| |
| \
| |
| .3.
| |
| * 3.
| |
| h h
| |
| -e -t*
| |
| **t.
| |
| -y o
| |
| 3 3.
| |
| 2
| |
| .e 2
| |
| .g :
| |
| k u "
| |
| t g ,
| |
| i e i i g i i --
| |
| 0 b, , !c!: , ,
| |
| 86-3 4-3 54 87-167 2 87-3 87-6 W1 Ysor - Quater
| |
| , 7 1 0
| |
| N7 7 , ,
| |
| W3 W3 66-4 87-t 87-2 87-3 s? e w t Yeor - Quorter
| |
| - [
| |
| 6 Eau nt Forced out:nes/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) Crites r+xis 00 $
| |
| 7
| |
| - M-3..
| |
| ! 4G . !
| |
| * h4 34 x
| |
| w
| |
| *me.
| |
| w a g 40 .
| |
| w #
| |
| 0 11 h
| |
| * 2- -
| |
| w 4' 2o . 8 ist
| |
| & m 7 , e. s 'O' o b .,=-.
| |
| o
| |
| .,_3.,.,,,... ...3 6-, -, 6-3 . .,., . - , , , . , , , - . . . ,
| |
| Y tor = Qutr t er Ye7 - ter 18 2
| |
| * S$
| |
| ~3, - -
| |
| /
| |
| -i FenCs
| |
| > d .g vi
| |
| , J:
| |
| / - ,,
| |
| {
| |
| PerformCoCe Indicators CCC'NO 'G rose:
| |
| i 1 Automotic Scroms WMe Criticci E - -
| |
| w (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 3 .
| |
| 1 Scfaty System Actuot;ons (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - o i 3 S;gof<ont Events (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) - -o ss 4 Sofety ' System Feues (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .tsi 7 l 5 Forced Outoge Rete (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . 'i ,72 6 Ecupment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit Mrs 0 76 (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - L y
| |
| -2.5-iO -1.5 -lo -O 5 0 0 0'S t'0 1.'S 2!O 2.5 0 evictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Mecns (Meosured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| SALEM 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf, PerformonCe Indicators
| |
| : 1. AutomoN Scroms WNie Critical OJ' (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) *
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotons (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . .'
| |
| in
| |
| .'(
| |
| 3 S.gnficont Events (4 Otr. Avg enc 88-1) . -is2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foues (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - - tit
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . oJ4
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outooss/1000 Crit Mrs 0 28 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2' 0 10 -0 5 0'O O'S t'0 t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Oider Piont Means (Measured in Standord Dev otions) 18 3 m
| |
| i t
| |
| | |
| I Ch5 4.3)
| |
| ' I **20''
| |
| g g , g ,--% - g
| |
| ) ,l $ l \ b '
| |
| -
| |
| * C "" '' " ;" i ' ' ' '
| |
| * 86-2 to 88-1 I
| |
| L AutorNt'c Sctm Whe Crit <of 2, Sofety System Actuot*CFs !
| |
| 4 2$o0 4 290 l
| |
| - 2250 - 2:M f .s
| |
| ,. ,- '\ / \
| |
| - ~
| |
| "" j g ,- ,- '\ l \ "}
| |
| ,t
| |
| /
| |
| / i -
| |
| 3 31 / \ / \
| |
| 3 f l
| |
| . 600 =' g <i .l
| |
| \
| |
| s f \ - SCoe ',ei s
| |
| \ l N, l; \,
| |
| g2-7'I :
| |
| l \
| |
| 410 h og2- ,
| |
| 's / \
| |
| 9 50 } '
| |
| -3 .: -
| |
| xxc a '
| |
| . \:' . oce .
| |
| 5 h$ 3 s
| |
| ~ 3 ,'
| |
| m3
| |
| : ): 9 - 500 - soo 0 0 0 0 7 7 , 7 7 , ,
| |
| 66-2 66-3 66-4 67-187-2 87-3 87-4 W1 66-2 Bo-J ee
| |
| * 8/-t if-2 ti-3 ei-4 $8-1 Yeor - Mter Y et,- - Quarter
| |
| : 3. $sgraficQnt [ vents ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System IOVes e 3. 3 3.
| |
| It it
| |
| -i -i g<2- 2 3 _
| |
| 3-b 5 f ., j t-
| |
| :fj .
| |
| So-2 86-3 86-4 87-147-2 67-3 67-4 St W2 66-3 e6-4 s/-1 ' 2 ti.) ai-4 se-t Ysor = QiJrter Ysur - ter
| |
| : 6. (ou mt Forceo oi toges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Critics Ws to a 3 so - h s-
| |
| . 3
| |
| ~5 r' s .I si
| |
| }4 dE u .5'
| |
| _b_
| |
| est es.3 eeLe si-i si-2 af-3 d.4 sa-, est e6-3 se'-4 87-1 ti-2 a7 3 47-4 sa. i Y p3r
| |
| * M t er f eor - Quar ter lb4
| |
| | |
| s.=i : 5.3 6, SAN CNCFRE 1: Trer.cs -
| |
| D)
| |
| (
| |
| Performance Indicotors 0*c"'d *:'$<*:
| |
| 1 Automotic Scroms Whe'e Critical (2 Ctr. Avg eN 88-1) - @j jg 0 58 l l 2 Sofety System Actuot'c es (2 Ctr. Avg end 88 1) - o I I
| |
| 3 Signficent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o g t !
| |
| l t 4 Sofety System Fofures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| .o sa S>
| |
| i 1 5 r rced o Outoge Rote (2 Otr Avg end 88-1) . &. oi Mrs 6 Equipment Forced Outogs/1000
| |
| '2 Crit 88-1) .
| |
| Avg end c se
| |
| -2 5-iO -I.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 O!5 1'O l'5 2'O 2.5 Devict ns from Previous 4 Otr. Piont M Meesured in Stondord Devictions) eans SAN ONOFRE 1: Devictions frorn Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf, Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicotors L Automotic Scroms WNie Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 128 2 Sofety System Actuotions (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . Ut
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o ,e
| |
| : 4. Sof ety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o.S$
| |
| S. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.74 ,
| |
| : 6. Equ9 ment Forced gtg/ p Hr , g,,
| |
| -2.5-io-i.S -to -0.5 O'O O!5 t'0 t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from 06 der Plont Means (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) f%
| |
| 18 5 (v) e
| |
| | |
| F G..:E 4 36
| |
| ^
| |
| 2 ::: .
| |
| ^pN. A' j -~~ra. .,, .- ~. .
| |
| 3 r-*. l N V!9Vii n [ D ix [F . J_ CyO- v. -!,"l --, ,.', , s s ~ -
| |
| 36-2 to 88-1 """
| |
| * 0 " t '' "* * ' i " '' : i '
| |
| t Automate Scroms *Ne Crit. cot 2. 59ety System Acteters 4
| |
| y Im 4 :m I:*
| |
| /*
| |
| - 22 % ]::n I
| |
| ~
| |
| ., s .. ** *\, f e>-
| |
| ,2
| |
| 'm 13- s.
| |
| 1, ,*m c.
| |
| s <
| |
| \ j - gg . i 3
| |
| .4 e} j x
| |
| \\
| |
| /
| |
| ?
| |
| - m 3
| |
| * it4 \e Ju l i e i
| |
| gI- ,.
| |
| b f - 'IM 0 m I- -
| |
| ':M J V at / - ac i l
| |
| }j / \ / J ao 3
| |
| ,~ ? -y , ,
| |
| \/ - mj ,~ \/ mj
| |
| % 2 1 m 'l m 3 }
| |
| y
| |
| - 250
| |
| - 2M 0
| |
| if Yh ,
| |
| b2 86-3 8A-4 $7-147 2 87=3 87-4 68-1 0 0 24'-2Sh=356-4 47-I $7-2 67-3 9 #-4 86 -1 s- 0 Yeor - Quylgr Y por - ' . varter
| |
| : 3. SP cont fi Everts ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System ro ues
| |
| . 3. g 3-h
| |
| -t -t 3<l-a ;<2, m
| |
| 1 1 1 0 M 0 e6' 2 66'.) 96-4 47'-I SI-2 87'-3 SI-4 06-1 86k2 86b 3 06ke 87-1 (7'-2 87'-3 87 -* S6- t f eor - QJster Y eor - Wy t er 6 Eomnt forces Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (z) I000 Criteol ws to -,. e
| |
| $ 90 -
| |
| . g*-
| |
| 1E 1 t<ex 60 -
| |
| s<
| |
| w me.
| |
| er b g 40 - h 2
| |
| ,,. . 2- mys .,
| |
| c o % r -ri ..
| |
| J 4 h
| |
| %M '
| |
| 0 OO . --- 0 es-2 66-3 66 4 8 7'- t 8 7'-2 0 7-3 0 7'-4 so-1 06'-2 96-3 so-4 5 7-1 8 7-2 t'-3 5 7-4 Se i Year - Qurter Y ear - Quy t er 18 6
| |
| | |
| A
| |
| ' 2 r G:.:E 2 54 7 OWN _Uh.,. ur ,% : iPenCS Performance Indic0 tors C'C6"*d **'l t Automet.c Scrocrs Wh4 Criticci Le t i (2 Ctr. Avg ew 88-1) - f
| |
| [pg%v"$.' l 4
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuctons (2 Otr. A<g end 88-1) - o i
| |
| : 3. Signficent Events (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . :* a sa ;
| |
| a
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Feues (2 ctr Avg end 88-1)- o ,
| |
| i I
| |
| 5 Forces Outoge Rete (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) . .: 'I
| |
| : 6. Equ9 ment Forced Cutooes/1000 Crit Mrs **
| |
| j (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - l
| |
| -2.5-10 -i5 -iO -0.5 0'0 N,> t'0 t'5 2'O 2.5
| |
| * ns from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt Meons Devictsfueosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| =
| |
| SAN ONOFRE 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means 1
| |
| l
| |
| ; Performance Indicators 8@w Avg Perf. Above Avg Perf 1 Automatic Scrores WhN Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 126 2 Safety System Actuatens (4- Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - ui ;
| |
| : 3. S'gmficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o42
| |
| : 4. Scfety System Fo&es (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . i;4
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o s4 it g
| |
| : 6. Equ9 ment Forced gtog/ ,
| |
| -2.5 .0 -t$ 0 5 0'0 O!S l'0 '.'S 2'O 2 5 victions from Oider Plont Mecns (Measured in Stondord Deviatior s) '
| |
| (A) 18 7 _
| |
| i U
| |
| t
| |
| | |
| cs .: -. -
| |
| =. c.
| |
| I -w 'n< '.!
| |
| I, , n r-- - . -
| |
| f u p' 5 i _eCe 'C: :e : :- : .e .;e s -
| |
| :. ! 3 :,
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1 " ' C " t '' " :"i " ' ' *
| |
| : 1. AutomCtc Scrort's Whe Critcol 2, $0'ety System ACluct+0r$ i 4 2$00 4 1500
| |
| - 22w .,l 2 2 w i
| |
| - s,
| |
| - 2000
| |
| /,,- 2x0 5 '
| |
| 3- .\ 3- ,
| |
| / 1 8' N ,, t?M ,%
| |
| i' J t'g
| |
| * 31
| |
| .4
| |
| \'s - ew *!
| |
| 5 <t
| |
| \\
| |
| l
| |
| / b 2!' ^
| |
| '32-
| |
| .1 ( - tw j r 4 32. \ j - ;w j ,s y a
| |
| - OCO 3 [ - OX 3 l W <
| |
| : j. /
| |
| M t
| |
| \ t t f i t
| |
| ,- ,- i
| |
| . e.. ' ,M g g y .s' _
| |
| V '
| |
| j M - 2w N
| |
| , = = s a . , s t1 1,2w 862 E3 86-4 SI-I 87 2 07'-3 87'-4 $8-1 96-2 64-3 86-4 87'- 7-287-387'-4 58 -1 fect = Quarter Yeor a ter 3 SP icontf Events ,
| |
| 4 Sc'ety System Foues
| |
| .3- g 3-11 it
| |
| -t -t i<2-m s<2-2 m
| |
| 3:
| |
| 53 3
| |
| ,- t ,
| |
| cu \h
| |
| , a ~~
| |
| o 2 %
| |
| E2 8N3 DN4 8I-t 87 2 87'-3 47'-4 as-t 64L 2 M-3 e6-4 81-1 87' 2 87-3 97-4 68 - t Yeor = barter Ysor - Quarter 6 Esa nt Forced Out:yes/
| |
| : 5. Freet Outcge Rote (s) Critt.ar %rs 00 - 8 I
| |
| E =- k 3i .0.
| |
| a }8-t<t m a<
| |
| *me-83 '
| |
| so -
| |
| 7v 5
| |
| ~ . 2-w
| |
| : 2. 3 - ,
| |
| *WA' --
| |
| 96 2 64-3 M-a SI t 37' 2 87-3 47'-4 es-t M-2 M-3 86-4 87 t 8 7'-2 4 7- 3 8 7-4 $8 t Year - Quarter v por - Quar t er Ibb
| |
| | |
| k -
| |
| ~G, E 4 35 f
| |
| . SAN ONOFRE 3: Trencs Derformance IndiCCtOrS Dechd Woe l
| |
| 1 Scroms WNe Ct.ticot !
| |
| Automctif2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| ~
| |
| o !
| |
| : 2. 5:!ety System Actwotioes (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o se I
| |
| : 3. Signficent Events (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . o se ,
| |
| i 4 Sofety System Feitures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o i 1
| |
| : 5. Fe<ced Owto;e Rote (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) . 3 95 6 Ecu.pment r occes gt ,,g togs / ,
| |
| -2.5-i0-t5 -to .5 0 0 OIS t'0 l'5 2'O 2.5 Devicti ns from Meosured Previous in Stondord 4 Ctr. Piont )Meons Devictions SAN ONOFRE 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means B&w Avg Perf. Abon Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators ,
| |
| l 1 Automatic Scroms WMe Criticot 0 21 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuot'o ns (4 Otr. Avg end 63-1) - -o46
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo. lures (4 Otr. Avg end 83-1) - 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 04:
| |
| : 6. Equ'oment Forced tog / gtg, , ,,,
| |
| -2.5-2' .0-15 -to -d 5 0'0 O!S t'O l'5 2.0 25 Devictions from 04 der Piont Mears (Meesur ed in Stonderd Devictions) f
| |
| ..m
| |
| | |
| r&PE 4 =3 f n- , ,,nn . , M *: -
| |
| _scerc: .w.- :- -
| |
| s-v> _.ss s gv: r4 -
| |
| .,4,. : : . ....::,
| |
| .r.w 86-2 to 88-1 - 3 weC'i*'e*r v:v#; 2.e :;e l Autom3t< Scrats Ah4 Crit <ct 2. Scfety System Actuct 75 ,
| |
| a 2510 4 Mc
| |
| . 22$0 m 2:M j I 3
| |
| . 2000 g 3. 3. 1 ] 2xc^)!5 l s - '* jf 3
| |
| S}t - a-* , ] "s*:o 3 l
| |
| .4
| |
| *2.y -- . f2$0 5 <e o y 2. 1 ]
| |
| y ':M
| |
| * t l
| |
| w
| |
| , . EXC 3 OCC 3 4 > t
| |
| )
| |
| t t
| |
| , 3c0 m .- .
| |
| h I --- --
| |
| . 503
| |
| . 2$0 _
| |
| l _
| |
| h% . :M o o 0 0 84-2 88-J 66 L 4 t/-1 Si-2 ti-3 ti-o $6'-l 66-2 66 k ) 66-4 41-1 ?-2 6?-3 ti e so t Year = Qwrter Yeor - tF 3 $stytfecc9t [ vents 4 50fety System IOkte$
| |
| 4 4
| |
| * e 3. 3 3.
| |
| Yk fh at
| |
| -< . <t m2. m2.
| |
| a 1 1 v
| |
| s g
| |
| x~
| |
| 96k 2 06k 3 eM s/-t 4 -2 t/-3 ti-4 e6-1 g _3 v %.W
| |
| _m 1 k L 41-1 (Y-2 Si-3 Si-* 88-t 942663044 Year = QArtF Y #0F
| |
| * Qu7 t #f
| |
| : 5. rerced outop Rate (3) 6. CouEnt Forced ct,tca outages w s /
| |
| 00 0 ,
| |
| 3 80 .
| |
| 2.-
| |
| JE &
| |
| FI ' -
| |
| ge II I
| |
| :r-so .
| |
| 2e 5
| |
| w 20 , __
| |
| .F. - - - - - - - - - -
| |
| ~ .
| |
| g . . - -
| |
| 0 96-2 ei-3 86h ti-l SI-2 Si-3 ti-* a6'. 84-2 96-3 66'-4 ti-I t?-2 t?-3 ti-o Ss-t l YeQr - b tF Y tO'
| |
| * M i t' l
| |
| 1 19 0 l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| ~ 2.;C :. . ? 5 SEAEROOK: Trencs W)
| |
| 'O # D '0**
| |
| Performance IndiCatCr5 1 Aut omot9 [
| |
| (2Scroms Ctr AvgWN4 endCritical 88-1) - '
| |
| 2 Sciety System Actuotions (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1)- r ii i st$h44' *'AMif'NAA@MM:SA i
| |
| I 3 Signhcont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| I 0
| |
| 4 Sofety System Foiivres (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . i
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . l
| |
| : 6. Coucment Forced Oute es/1000 Crit Mrs (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-i 0 IO -d.5 0 0 0'S t'0 1'5 2'O 25 Devictions (Mecsured from Previous in Stondord 4 Otr. Pb9t )Meons Devictions SEABROOK: Devictions from Newer Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg Perl.
| |
| Performance Indicators I L Automatic Scroms WMe Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sciety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _o n 3 S.gmficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . i 4 Sofety System FoAres (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . os7 5 Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outooes/1000 Crit Mrs (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - .,
| |
| -2.5 -i 0 -t5 0 5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'5 2!O 25 Devictions from Newer Pent Meons (Mecsured in Standard Dev ot.ons) 19 1
| |
| | |
| O THIS
| |
| \ l l
| |
| PAGE l LEFT
| |
| ! INTENTIONALLY i
| |
| l BLANK l
| |
| | |
| ~ 1.:E H - ::'c : .
| |
| t >
| |
| \g Note: This is o comporison of SEABROOK (o newer plant)
| |
| * ogcinst older plant means.
| |
| SEABROOK: Deviations from Older Plant Means !
| |
| l Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg Perf, Performance Indicotors i
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms WNe Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)-
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctses (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -202
| |
| : 3. Signficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ou
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o go t i !
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - .,
| |
| 2 5-2'.0-1.5 -lo -0.5 0'O O!5 1.'O l'5 2'Ok5 Devictions from owr Pbnt Veons (Measured in Stondord Devictions) 19 3 i
| |
| 1 I
| |
| 4
| |
| | |
| I O')[, d 3 7 I
| |
| i . . . - . . , j SECUCYAH 1 Lecend: s::, i,,=
| |
| :m' 4 : 24 1
| |
| 1
| |
| ""'
| |
| * C''"'''"' 'd'"*
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1 l AutortCtc Sceps WP e CritiCd i 2. 50f ety System ActAtes I
| |
| * 2%0 * ,.%0 ,
| |
| I
| |
| . tre q ::n ,
| |
| :xe v ' !
| |
| - 2c00 .
| |
| e 3. 3. 1 II I hf . 1750 jp '
| |
| . I?M l 3e . ex -.
| |
| i <t '-r , . .x - ,
| |
| *2-y - '2% 3 m 2. s . 'Wj j
| |
| ~ -
| |
| f5 ~1 -
| |
| == 3 4 ,
| |
| == 3 2" . m=O ,
| |
| . .w 2 I
| |
| : t. t. f f1 J sn J
| |
| - zo :~
| |
| ?
| |
| ?y - W .e s ..,,
| |
| . 250 , . .s- \ g s a M 0 0 0 0 W2 86-3 96-4 87-I 87-2 87-3
| |
| ,,W' 97-4 $6-2 96-3 96-4 87-1 87-2 07-3 37
| |
| * 68-i ftor - Quor ter v eor - Quor ter 3 S.pficont Events 4. Safety System Foves 4 4 __
| |
| >./ <
| |
| 4 d
| |
| . 3. g 3. 4 p o a
| |
| -t -t ? <! ,
| |
| g<'" p '
| |
| 2 g<'~ s 5 C A ))
| |
| h
| |
| - f ('i l
| |
| '. '- A,4 &%
| |
| )
| |
| 't 4 .
| |
| i ; j W 0 . ,., 0 , , . , ,
| |
| 86L2e6' - 3 gehe Sl-t 87-2 07-3 87-4 e6-t 96-2 84-3 06-4 47-1 at-2 87-3 67-4 88 - t voor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Ovtape Rote (s) Crit c al Pt>.t s o0 < s
| |
| $ M<
| |
| . g..
| |
| 3 m g
| |
| * w R4 54 e
| |
| g- 4 y a. I w
| |
| 5
| |
| * w 2-3, 0 L- O' C 96-2 06-3 06-4 SI-t t i-2 ti-3 ti 4 90'-1 Y ear - OJ7 t er 96-2 96-3Y ear 6N4 01 1 (M terf-2 87-3 ti-4 88 - t 19 4
| |
| | |
| ~ 3.:E * .i?
| |
| SECLOYAH 1: Treras
| |
| '~
| |
| PerfCrmCnce IndiC0 tors * **
| |
| : t. Autemet.c Screms wve Crit. cat '
| |
| (2 Ctr. Avg end SS-l) -
| |
| 2 Sefery System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . p{f ts
| |
| : 3. S;gnficent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 4 Sofety System Foilures (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . o;o }
| |
| l
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . l l
| |
| 6 Equ'9ment Forced Outcaes/1000 Crit Mr s.
| |
| (2 dtr Avg end 88-1) - ,
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i 5 -IO - 5 0 0 0'S l'O 1.52!02.5 Oevetions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| SEQUOYAH 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators B'' * **9 P'''' *b "' **9' #''''
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms Wh4 Cr tical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sciety System Actuctions (4 Ctr, Avg end 88-1) . o.33 i
| |
| ! 3 S;gnficont E ents (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ose
| |
| : 4. Safety System rodures (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . 393 i
| |
| l 5. Forced Outog Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equvment Foretd Outooes/1000 Crit Mrs (4 Ctr Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| l l -2.5-10 I5 5 0 -d S O'O O'S l'O l'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Oider Piont Meons (Meosured in Standard Devictions) s
| |
| (' 19 5 l
| |
| t
| |
| | |
| rose 4 SS l i '
| |
| : c. , s , , , - 1 i X v tj .i T'/- , n 2 Legenc: : :*- = :- : . e -
| |
| coew-us 36-2 to 88-1 - 4 C uc'"' * #1 "'' m
| |
| , i 4
| |
| 1 Abt0motic SCf 7s Whe Crrtica 2. SCI ety Sy?'.em ACt'J:t Ces !
| |
| 7500 4 two 22w l s ::w 2*o 5 )::oc 5 e>-
| |
| '* a i >-
| |
| l''2
| |
| !I -
| |
| 5 1}
| |
| 3t
| |
| - se -*
| |
| i<! J .uo* "s :
| |
| *2-m - CSO o=2- -
| |
| :Mj '
| |
| - 000 lb C@ 5 f
| |
| W = *
| |
| =3 ,~
| |
| , , , - ~ 3
| |
| - W5 . WC tw 66-2eek3664 i 87-1 17-2 07-3 Si-4 $6-1
| |
| ,, , - m 96-2 96k3 66-4 87- t 5 7'-t 57-3 0 7-4 es-t
| |
| *A Yw - Quarty Year - Quarter 3 Sof+ cont Events 4. Sofety System Faues r;
| |
| : s1
| |
| ;' j' e 3. g 3. 8' , c
| |
| }k
| |
| -1 jk r *
| |
| -< -t ma- 'ma. 2 g m.
| |
| ~
| |
| o o b k k &
| |
| sek t bek) 06L 4 t/-I ti-2 Si-3 SI-4 06'-1 Sekt 86L3 86-4 ti-l of-2 87-3 47-4 Sa - t Year - %arter Year - ovar t y
| |
| : 6. Ecp . nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| 5 Fcreed Outcge Rate (1) Critica Mcxis o0.. e
| |
| $ 00.
| |
| 15 g..
| |
| a
| |
| .t
| |
| }<e so . a<
| |
| m w me.
| |
| 3 g 40 . h w E B
| |
| ' I-w 0 - - - 0
| |
| ; .6-i .6- 3 t. , <- , .,- > 7 - 3 . f-.
| |
| .6-i .6- 3 6-. 7 - , . ,- > t , - 3 . ,- 4 .,
| |
| Ytar - QAy ty T por - Quar t y
| |
| | |
| v <\
| |
| l
| |
| = ?. . = i 1 55 1 p;
| |
| s.
| |
| b w,w~: n n 2: irencs f
| |
| \ >
| |
| Cec 6ned Mw
| |
| . Perfcrmcnce indicctorS i
| |
| l Automoti[2 broms While Criticaltr. Avg end 58-1) "
| |
| i i
| |
| i 2 Sa'ety System Actuotons (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i o
| |
| i 3 Signf<cnt Events (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) - o-l'
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo.lvres (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t21 $h' n l'
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Ecu'cment r c<ced Outcoes/1000 Crit Mrs (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) "
| |
| -2.5-iO-i.5 -IO -0 5 0 0 0'S l'O l'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. P'ent Meons (Meosured in Stondord Devk:tict's)
| |
| SEQUOYAH 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means i
| |
| Performance Indicotors 8' D* ^*9' P''' ^D" ^''9 P" ' ' l t
| |
| t Automets Scroms vwe Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 4 46 4,
| |
| : 3. Signficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . one
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foikses (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -462
| |
| : 5. Forced Outege Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced s Mrs tgr /1000 CritAvg end 88-1) -
| |
| ' 1
| |
| -2.5- O to -0.5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'S 2'O 25 J' evictions from Older Plont Veons (Meossed in Stonderd Dev:otiers) j:
| |
| 's !
| |
| 19 7
| |
| | |
| ~ GuE 4.39 u .' : :::e' :- :- - : e :+
| |
| ' l '
| |
| ,w sF.v- @i s Q ;,'o i4 j---j.a @- ;s- -
| |
| , 90 enc:
| |
| .,,,,,2..-.
| |
| . 2,.....
| |
| I *2 36-2 to 88-1 l - C'"2 4 a ' rte v av,r.; . ,e :;e
| |
| : 1. Autometc Scres 454 Crit eci 2 Safety Sy>:em A.euct ors 4 _
| |
| - :ye 4 _
| |
| :sc ,
| |
| A x
| |
| . so )::w !
| |
| a
| |
| : 3. h-ih
| |
| : 3. #
| |
| i~.
| |
| ~, n .r . ,,;
| |
| at 4 .w -* ;
| |
| .4 0
| |
| m2.
| |
| /
| |
| ..-[ .. __
| |
| TM 3 <5 5 m 2. y 2
| |
| ]64
| |
| 'w}'
| |
| *' j 44 3 \ ! 000 3 1 .
| |
| h ,
| |
| # /d 79 j }*'- m x wi I
| |
| :-h .. w"
| |
| .t, , , ,
| |
| /3 4 _A m
| |
| p o u S t.:
| |
| / 4 4 M -f . !w A L '. i . !w 0 l1 i
| |
| . - 0 0 h s >.- O i
| |
| ;-1 S7-3 67-4 W:
| |
| W2 96-3 W4 97-1 -2 57-3 87-4 88 - t W2 66-3 W4 SF-1 Yeor - ter Year -- ter 3 Scpficant Events 4 4 Scfety System Foues 4
| |
| .3. g 3. 1 kk 3h we wt -
| |
| 3"2-gy 3*2-1 -
| |
| 2
| |
| .. r--
| |
| 2 93 3 9 9 ,#"""
| |
| )L L 4 f
| |
| ' p'4 - . -
| |
| 1 s. f fN- a s; .
| |
| o _
| |
| o 86k 2 BE 3 year ai-4 8 -i k2 87k 3 I/-4 Si-t 8E! SE3 e6-4 87-1 8752 87-3 07-4 98 -1 year - ovarter
| |
| - ter
| |
| : 6. Eau nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outo7e Rate (t) Cr:tca ms to a
| |
| $ M-3h 3*-h 3
| |
| g!
| |
| w l <!
| |
| =
| |
| 80 - s<
| |
| * m 4 .,
| |
| d2 3
| |
| ~
| |
| M 2 64 g T 2)
| |
| '83 m p zo . ,20 .- s..
| |
| ^
| |
| ~i "
| |
| ~
| |
| ?
| |
| 3 . - -,,,,.;,,
| |
| 7 ,
| |
| e6-2 64-3 We 81-1 i-287-387-4 WI 96'2 06 366'-4 t ?-t (i-2 47-3 67-4 84 -i Y eor - t er 7 ear = uvorter 19 3 8
| |
| e
| |
| | |
| ~ 3.~ ~ s.i ?
| |
| f 3h5457 4 HA55lS l: IT'erC$
| |
| PerIormonce !nciccters C"N '''0 '' ' ' :
| |
| t Scroms he Criticci ;
| |
| : 1. Automotif2 Ctr, Avg end 38-1)-
| |
| f[w7 2 Sciety System Actuotons (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . M o 33 d ;
| |
| : 3. S;9sf; cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .tn N6hh
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foivres (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . o 5 Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ctr, Avg end $8-1) . 146
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoms/1000 Crit Mrs ' ' " ty (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) - ' 01 y
| |
| -2.5-iO-i5 -I.0 -0 5 0 0 0'$ l'0 1'S 20 2.5 0 evictions from Previous 4 Otr P'o:at Means (Meosured in Stondord Deviot ors) l' SHEARON HARRIS 1: Deviations from Newer Plant Mecns t sebw Avg. PFL Above Avg Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicotors
| |
| : 1. Automotip Scroms Wh4 Criticol 03S g4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 08-1) . au
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .aso
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -o. is
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o so
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit Mrs OM (4 ctr. Avg end 88-1) - ,
| |
| i l
| |
| -2 5-10-I5 -i.0 -d S O'O O'S t'0 l'$ 20 25 Devictions from Newer Plont Meces (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) 19 9 C
| |
| t
| |
| | |
| 1
| |
| : e I
| |
| THIS PAGE i
| |
| LEFT i
| |
| INTENTIONALLY ;
| |
| I J
| |
| BLANK l
| |
| l 1
| |
| l
| |
| \
| |
| l l
| |
| i 200 O
| |
| J
| |
| , , , , - . - - - - - - , - - - c,,,--_.,... . -- - ,-.. _ - _ -. -
| |
| | |
| r G.FE 4.53 (cc'c) l I
| |
| i
| |
| ,u L
| |
| s P
| |
| d Note: This is' a compcrison of SHEARON HARRIS 1 (o newer picnt) ogcinst older plant means.
| |
| t SHEARON HARRIS 1: Deviat:ons from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators O'D* ^*9 '"I' ^ " " AV9' F"''
| |
| l Automote SQroms WM Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88 - 1) --192
| |
| : 2. Sclety System Actuctiorwi (4 Ctr. Avg erg 88-1) . .t24
| |
| : 3. Signf' cont Events (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.42
| |
| : 4. Sciety System Foikres (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t f7
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ctr. Avo end 88-1) - ces
| |
| : 6. Equ'oment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs - M1 (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) - .s i
| |
| f
| |
| -2.5-2 0 -i.$ -i 0 -0.5 0 0 0'S 10 :.5 2'O 25 Dev4tions from >cer Plant Ve: s (Me:wed in Ste ndard Devst' ens) i L
| |
| , 201 i
| |
| 9
| |
| $, E
| |
| ._- ,--, .-, ..-, , , , - ._.s - ...-.,_..,.,_,-__,__.__----,..-m,-,-.-.. -. - _. - ,_- _.- .- ,
| |
| | |
| o T CPE 4.}C 1 i i : ::n:r i _ __ j
| |
| %W ,b O Jt' E':*f 4.f'::t i - - *O
| |
| * O *n (**
| |
| a r
| |
| j ._s i i V' i#'%/ L_ L M .
| |
| y, , ,, ; .c - 2 , ,, y, 86-2 to 88-1 "*
| |
| 3'st,,,1,y 1,y y, g
| |
| I t Autometc Scroms Whe Critical 2. Sofety System Actuct;or's
| |
| . 4. 2sco 4 :s:o .l I
| |
| _ 225o -
| |
| d 2:w l'
| |
| ., 2crso " - .
| |
| Uco Y
| |
| -C x
| |
| 3-
| |
| _ ,,,o
| |
| ?5 3
| |
| 3-
| |
| _m[? i-I Soo} .O! * *A4 !
| |
| o _ .
| |
| ,2x j - ,,- J .: ';
| |
| 3,,.
| |
| 2000 3 -
| |
| wo 3 W V 1so * '50 S 1-
| |
| .# \. g
| |
| ,,,_['
| |
| h __ _ y.
| |
| n /
| |
| /
| |
| 66L2 86
| |
| \. b L 3 68-4 8/-i Si-2 Si-3 Si-4 8e-1 2*
| |
| n n
| |
| /
| |
| \
| |
| .b n 86-2 66-3 86-4 8/-i 4.i-2 Si-3 af-4 88'-i n
| |
| Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quorter 3.. Sicpficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fokres
| |
| . 3. 3 3-
| |
| :k4 E
| |
| =
| |
| jh wi
| |
| -. 4
| |
| * ,2.
| |
| x2.
| |
| = =
| |
| b
| |
| : i. i-3
| |
| \ g n o JR e4.2 e6 L 3 ed-4 8/-i si-2 89-3 8/-4 si-i soi2 4-3 e6'-4 af-t 6i-2 s/-3 8/-4 ss-i Year - ovorter Yw - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau .nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. rorced Outoge Rote (s) CritcG rhrs t)o 8
| |
| $ So -
| |
| . a .-
| |
| h 8 80 . -3!
| |
| h4 B4
| |
| , w x4-
| |
| % ed U g so .
| |
| o B
| |
| w ,, 2-to . - - - - -
| |
| n 0 * . -
| |
| 96'-2 66'-3 S6-4 SI-i i 66'-2 96-3 86-4 81-1 Si-2 8/-3 si-*
| |
| YW - Quarter s-1 rw L-2 ler si-3 Si-* 66-i 202 g
| |
| | |
| SHCREHAM: Trenas
| |
| ~
| |
| Declined weroved -
| |
| ?
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| :1. Automatic Scroms WNie Criticci ,
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o l
| |
| # l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotsns (2 Ote. Avg and 88-1)- j
| |
| [f 3 Sigrvficont Events (2 Otr/ Avg end 88-1) o 4.. Sofety System Failures (2 Oti. Avg end 88-1) - o .2 5 Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - o-
| |
| ' ~
| |
| : 6. Equ;pment Forced Outcoes/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| -2.5-5.0 -i.5 -iO .5 0 0 0'S l'0 t'5 2!0 25 Deviations from Previous 4 Otr. Went Mece:
| |
| (Measured in Standord Deviabces)
| |
| SHOREHAM: Deviations from Newer Plant Means Below Avg. Perf, Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotif4 Scrc.ns WNie Critiw)lOtr. Avg end 88 122 e
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) . oss !
| |
| l
| |
| : 3. S;gnificont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - os?
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - tts
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it ,9 toges/ ,
| |
| I l
| |
| -2.5-2.0 i.5 i.0 -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 t5 2.0 25 Devicticns from Newer Stent Means (Measured in Standord Devictices) 23 O
| |
| r
| |
| | |
| O THIS l
| |
| PAGE l
| |
| LEFT INTENTIONALLY i
| |
| BLANK 1
| |
| l 204
| |
| | |
| .p , ,
| |
| Fs:#E 4.90 (CCNID)'
| |
| 1 f)gs<-
| |
| -s 4
| |
| 4 Note: This js a compar; son of -SHOREHAM-(a newer picnt) '
| |
| against older plant means.
| |
| (
| |
| SHOREHAM: Deviations from Older Plant Means
| |
| - Below Avg. Perf, 'Above Avg Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic .Scroms WMe Criticql 128 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Ott; Avg end 88-1) . om
| |
| : 3. S;gnficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . I o'98 l
| |
| ~
| |
| 4 Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr,- Avg end 88-1) . o go
| |
| ; .. 5. Forceo Outoge Rote (4 Otr Avg end 88-1) - o.79
| |
| : 6. Equ'pment Forced t togs / gg j_ g 9n 4
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -i 5 -I.0 -d.5 0 0 CIS l'O l'5 2'O 25 Deviations from Older Picnt Vecns (Meosured in Stonderd C' evictions) 205 9
| |
| ?
| |
| + , - e-, , .- - , - , . . n , r r,- , a,.,--- ,,..-..v..,,w-n,,,n,-..-, ,r..--n-,.--,,, ---,,,-,,.,-g-
| |
| : e. -- ,.
| |
| *y,"; +3 t
| |
| i- J ^
| |
| m c.
| |
| - +L1
| |
| -. . m ', !
| |
| ; ;e,' ; ;-.
| |
| iL /s,[s 'g I O m , . q 'J '
| |
| s f i! ,I J- [
| |
| ~*Y" JVV v r
| |
| ,eae" ,ca: , ,t< :;e
| |
| ') Cf.t:C Ci WJ s yG Q & ._ { muME 4 f.ucr t er MOvirg A,e':;e AutomClic Scrcres Whe Crit-cc! 2. Scfet/ System Actuctecrs 4 2wo e :m l '
| |
| 22w , 22 9 I
| |
| - 2mo " 2xc $
| |
| 3.
| |
| . eso 2 l3 1 J uv s- t B $ # -l S t . u-
| |
| * j <B 9: , <
| |
| g2 - - - . . - - - - - . nso 2 ,2. .L -
| |
| ew } l
| |
| * . oco 3 A occ 3_ l 2 w c , <
| |
| 7so O* i i. . 7w 2V 1 d 1 [ O o o o E o e6'-2 so-3 e64 Si-i ei-2 ei-3 si-4 so-i e62 e6-3 s6-4 Si-t si-2 si-3 8f-4 si-1 Yeor - QXrter Yeor - Quorter 1 Skynficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foues g
| |
| k NN
| |
| .s e 3. g 3. 3 $
| |
| h jh at -e '4
| |
| .y @v g<, .<
| |
| o wg ga y.
| |
| h,. k l j! F fk 1., 1 ex s [ s O i ~ 0 i i , . . I .
| |
| I i , i , ,
| |
| 86-2 % -3 86-4 87-1 87-2 87-3 67-4 . 68 -1 66-266 366-4 87-1 87-2 87-3 57-4 86-1 Yeor - Quarter Year - QArter 6 Eau nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced oute Rate (s) critical Hotrs 10 0 8
| |
| ~
| |
| 1 -
| |
| [ 6-sh ah.
| |
| i
| |
| ". So hE x
| |
| k
| |
| $ w B E me.
| |
| 8x w =
| |
| ~
| |
| }va e 0 h w 2-20 .
| |
| . - - - - ~ - - -
| |
| = ~
| |
| o E o j
| |
| $6'-2 66-3 66'-4 8/-18i-2 Si-3 SI-4 88 -1 86'-266-38o4 87'-t Si-2 8I-3 87-4 98-1 l Yecr - Qucrter Y eor - O ster )
| |
| .I l
| |
| 206 g 1
| |
| | |
| GME 4.91 SOUTH TEXAS 1: Trenas.
| |
| Performance -Indicoters Ce*ed *:r <e:
| |
| I-
| |
| . 1. A'utornatic Scroms WMe Criticet -4
| |
| . (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ~ f l
| |
| : 2. Safetf. system Actuotions (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) . f f
| |
| : 3. SigNficant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 4. .Sofety System FoJures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge' Rete (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ .
| |
| -1
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced Outodes/1000 (2 tr Avg end Crit. 88-1) Hrs -
| |
| -2.5 -$.0 -I.5 -i.0 -d 5 0.0 0'S l'0 l'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4- Otr. Plant Meons (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| SOUTH TEXAS 1: Deviations from New~er Plant Mear,s Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System. Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 2D
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr.' Avg end 88-1) - i 1
| |
| : 4. Sofety Syst*m Fodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.79
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced togs /1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| Avg end ' 88- 1) -
| |
| -2 5-2.0 -I.5 -i.0 .5 0'O O!S l'O l'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Newer Picnt VeOns (Meosured in Stonderd Osv;otions) 207
| |
| ~ s- ss - +,:,=-,w,- .m,, ,- e-,m, --,-w-.n.-,e-m..n-,,-------.,w v. , ,~,1,. , .,ee, - - - , . = ~ - ~, --e ,
| |
| | |
| O THIS PAGE LEFT l INTENTIONALLY l
| |
| BLANK l
| |
| l 1
| |
| l l
| |
| i O
| |
| 208 m --r-- . .. ,., , _ , , _
| |
| | |
| F:GL;E .:31 (COM0;
| |
| .,a ,
| |
| t .
| |
| . Note: This .is a comparison of SOUTH TEXAS 1 (o newer prant) ogoinst older plant means.
| |
| SOUTH TEXAS 1: Deviations from Older , Plant Means' Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 1.~ Automotic Scror: s WNe Critical (4 0tr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Safety System Actuations (4 Otr. Ava end 88-1) . -tus ,
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 ott, Avg end 88-1) . 09a
| |
| - 4. ' Sofety System Fo3ures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .' -144
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| : 6. Equipenent Forced it togs / .
| |
| , -2.5-$ 0-15 -to -d.5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'5 2'O 2 5 l- Devictions from Older Picnt Veens I
| |
| (Measured in Stondord Devictrorts)
| |
| {
| |
| l
| |
| () 209 l
| |
| o l
| |
| l t
| |
| | |
| l r a.=E a
| |
| %s ! f . . . sv r "- p : :e :- 2. . e -
| |
| i . L V :v , L._ ,-- i '
| |
| --Y- y, ,,
| |
| ,3
| |
| " 4 C ' 2' t '' ''#'' '
| |
| I ' '' 2#
| |
| 36-2 to 88-1 t Autornetr: Scrcrrs we Crit cci i 2. Scfety System Actuctiors 4 2500 4 :s:o 1
| |
| - nw w 3-i
| |
| \
| |
| 22o .
| |
| h 3-
| |
| . ]': =ma !? ,
| |
| f...
| |
| e af \ s
| |
| "" 3 15 / -
| |
| ''*!i n 1
| |
| _ 13
| |
| * s <e .\-\ /
| |
| / _ m=I *~
| |
| -< \ i-
| |
| * \ .,'. - 25o 2- \/ . nu 1 a b - t 2
| |
| ~- _ om , \/ _ ao 3
| |
| }4 m
| |
| .7 ,a fM ~
| |
| 3 7
| |
| ' ~
| |
| 2 1
| |
| 3'/
| |
| 1 y :
| |
| 500 sic m s. -::. .
| |
| s 34 . .
| |
| g m x 's 5 A w a''"
| |
| ,{ g' - 250 jg( f 4 - - 2M
| |
| -c Hs n n n n 86-2 ML3 8N4 6/-f 37k2 67kJ 87'-4 88-1 86-2 S6'-3 Mks 87'-1 Si-2 67-3 67-4 SS - t Yeor - Quarter Yeor -- Quyter
| |
| : 3. SP cort fi Events ,
| |
| 6 Safety System Fali.res
| |
| : 3. ,.3 a 3. g m.
| |
| h jh m.
| |
| AY a
| |
| g4 d :t}
| |
| 32- 3 2- 3 M
| |
| s
| |
| ' ===
| |
| '' '~ ) hR q g #
| |
| 0 l
| |
| h i 1 1 .
| |
| 86-2 86-3 84-4 87-187-2 67-3 67+ e 88-1 O i , ,
| |
| A
| |
| ,i1 86-2 86-3 86-4 67-1 87-2 67-3 67-4 68 -1 i . .
| |
| Year - Quyter Yeor - OArter
| |
| : 6. Eod nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Crited Hours oo 6 -
| |
| - E s *- F t 6.
| |
| f<t eo -
| |
| a<
| |
| %4_
| |
| A me so -
| |
| gu 5
| |
| 1'
| |
| 'S' 20 _
| |
| o A '
| |
| o N $
| |
| 86-296k 386'-4 Si-t 87-2 Si-3 87-4 58-1
| |
| ~
| |
| 66-2 Mk3 8614 87-1 Si-2 87-3 67'-4 86-1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Osarter I
| |
| 2 10 g
| |
| l 1
| |
| | |
| e ~G R .*>32 h
| |
| ST LUCiE 1: Trends
| |
| ~ # Performance IndicoterS Oe Ged- - impeme:
| |
| ~
| |
| : 1. Automotig Scroms Whi% Criticci s2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - -e 41 f z
| |
| : 2. Sciety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) , a
| |
| : 3. Sigrvficant Events. (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o $-
| |
| i
| |
| . 4. Screty System foihses (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ o.9 E
| |
| 5 Forced Outoge Rcte (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ ( h's -4 52 2
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forceo Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs pg' $T I (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - -oss g_ q
| |
| -255-2 0 i.5 -i.0 -d 5 0 0 0'5 t!O t'5 2'O 25 'I '
| |
| Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt Meons (Measured in Stonderd Cevictions)
| |
| ST. LUCIE 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 1, Automotic Scroms While Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) --192
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg. end 88-1) . .o.46
| |
| : 3. Sigraficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) 0 93 4.' Safety System Foikses (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . - 0.14
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . g 0 48 s
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced(4Cutokr./1000 Crit MrsAvg end 88-1) -o S5-(.
| |
| 1
| |
| -2.5-2'.0 iO -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 1'5 2!O 25
| |
| .Devictions from C4 dei Piont Veens (Measured in Standord Devictions) 2 11
| |
| | |
| _-a .-: .::
| |
| c- , ,
| |
| s . , j l s ._
| |
| . .:. v ~ : :. : :-- :#: .
| |
| : u. a s s .-
| |
| . a> . z -m'- ,,
| |
| I 36-2 to 88-1
| |
| """ 4 C "'t''
| |
| "''i'""
| |
| g t Auternetic S:rorm me Crit'c:l 2. Scf ety System Actu:t crs 4 :sco 4 :=
| |
| I
| |
| - 22so J : ::
| |
| p l--~ _. 3 -
| |
| 2xo.=i f- - .,. -s
| |
| /
| |
| J:xc =, I 5
| |
| 3-
| |
| \ - '7% '
| |
| g y}
| |
| 3.
| |
| l
| |
| .i
| |
| \ l a
| |
| J, "to ] l 3}e
| |
| - 3= -*
| |
| 3 <1
| |
| \
| |
| \
| |
| / m =* I I y 2- [ .>., - CSo o ~y1 - l \ ;l N ';*A } '
| |
| ~ l 1 2 -
| |
| j l
| |
| /m 1 i ,
| |
| "* 3 i / V 1'"a o1 3
| |
| l 4
| |
| f J: '
| |
| ah 5 7=
| |
| 500
| |
| ~s -
| |
| ,~
| |
| 7 q ;05 1
| |
| h { - tso 3 - 250
| |
| '" ' ~
| |
| 0 0 0 0 86-2663S4-4 k af-t SN-2 9/-3 SI-4 88-t 66-2 86-3 66'-4 Sf*1 Si-2 87-3 87-4 Ba - t fear - Quort6r Yeor - Qv:rter
| |
| : 3. S.graficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System Foues a 3. g 3-at h f 2<2-m 2<2-m
| |
| ]b] ]b] '
| |
| t- t-0
| |
| * 0 i , , . . . . . .
| |
| 86-2 86-3 86-4 8/-187-26,-387-4 88-I 6
| |
| 66-2 66-3 86-4 87-1 87-2 87-3 87-4 88 -1 Year - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Evoment Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Ovtage Rots (t) X)OO Critcol Hotr$
| |
| C0 8 7
| |
| * M~
| |
| ~ 6 E O dg g
| |
| u
| |
| ~}<00- a<
| |
| *me-8m b El ' - I r w 2.
| |
| 22
| |
| '7 l
| |
| O- e w
| |
| : e _t __._
| |
| > 2
| |
| **>= - , .
| |
| m - -, m e l 86'-296-366k4 6Y-1 ' 2 Si-3 8i-4 36'-1
| |
| - S6'-286-3864 L 81-19f-2 Si-3 87-4 ES - I Y por - ter Yw - Quartof 212 g
| |
| | |
| .. . ~. _ m - . . _ .
| |
| YGURE 93 '
| |
| 1 p
| |
| ST LUCIE 2: Trends Decticed imero~eo
| |
| ' Performance Indicators 1, Automatic Scroms Whi!e Critico(
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ]
| |
| g 05
| |
| {
| |
| [.
| |
| i
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuatens (2 Otr. Ava end 88-1) . N
| |
| $k4
| |
| ,o"a '
| |
| l 1 Significant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo; lures (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) o
| |
| : g. l S. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 'f.f)' ., m ('Q'j'y'%
| |
| ,., m'f -65 i nw t k.
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit Hrs. OC:NG'e (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ~2 6 iA04 e a < % A %m 2.0-15-i.0 .50.0 05 1.'O l'5 /0 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Meons (Measured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| ST. LUCIE 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance indicators 7
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical i (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -032 ;
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ut 3 Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) o.98
| |
| - 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- -
| |
| c.46 '
| |
| i- 6. Equipment Forced Outcoes/1000 Crit. Hrs. -0 58 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - '
| |
| -2.5-2' O /t5 50-0.5 00 O!5 t'O l'5 2'O 25 Dev:otions from CHder Piont veces (Veosured in Standard Devictions) r h
| |
| l' 213 l
| |
| l l
| |
| l L
| |
| I L
| |
| : s. - :-
| |
| m . ,, 4 . - - .
| |
| Jwi; <- j <;\' /j - H '
| |
| ; _ @ C 9 '. ] :
| |
| ~:t'
| |
| ,,t:: - : .e s 2 :' ' 2 e' ?
| |
| 2 ===== 4 C m e- V:, r; .r--
| |
| aJ au to vc_,I t Automets Scrorns Awe Cr1tcol 2. Sofety System Actxtions 4 :soo 4 :we l I
| |
| _ 22so . ::s: ,
| |
| ..-.~, ...--- ,,~.., 9 g .- 4 :w: ; i 2o0ej g
| |
| , 17$. R N D,
| |
| [ c%
| |
| - So '*
| |
| o
| |
| *g-\ '
| |
| d %X *'
| |
| 3 j
| |
| -< k <! I j
| |
| g a
| |
| g2- .'. -
| |
| :w j sg2- .2. / J:so j j "I / "1 ff
| |
| ~
| |
| k $ }$
| |
| (*m IM h *3
| |
| \
| |
| s/ ;(.
| |
| g/- s
| |
| +
| |
| 4e g- y s _ wo 3 _ . .,
| |
| gs ; w - -
| |
| s.
| |
| v y ;:
| |
| - 2w haR- V - zw O . . 4 ; . ;
| |
| *r* o 0 ,
| |
| j , , ,
| |
| o 86-2 86-3 86-4 87-1 87-2 87-3 87-4 88-1 86-2 86 -3 86 -4 87-1 87-2 87-3 87-4 88-t Yeor - Quarter Year - Quar ter fi
| |
| : 3. SP cont Events ,
| |
| 4 Scfety System Foues e 3. g 3.
| |
| -e -i z -p< I- ;<2-p mm 2
| |
| k g pg
| |
| ? a
| |
| [
| |
| $$-2 86-3 $N-4 81-18I-2 SI-3 SI-4 86-1 8$-2 86b 3 9$-4 81-1 Si-2 9* 3 SI-4 88 -1 Yeor - Quorter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Equ .nt Forced Outorps/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcge Rote (t) Cotcol Mcus to 8
| |
| $ 80 -
| |
| 3 2.- i
| |
| =& in
| |
| = 6~
| |
| h4 $E
| |
| - ,4_
| |
| E v
| |
| '*- I
| |
| =
| |
| 3
| |
| - w 2- 1,86 m gg
| |
| ,ew --
| |
| sg o 46 K. -
| |
| we -,8 P -
| |
| 3 $ $
| |
| o
| |
| ,$_' d O _ m.m b g [ C U- N' ' bRC
| |
| $61 2 to-3 8614 87-1 Si-2 Si-3 SI-4 88-1 k 86286-386'-4 Si-1 $1-2 97-3 57-4 S8-1 Yeor - Quorter Yeor - Quorter 214 l
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| l 1
| |
| | |
| FGW 4.94 SUMMER: Trends
| |
| # Performance 1 indicators' _
| |
| C'C'i"*d IrrP' **
| |
| * d t Autcmotic Scroms WNie Cntiev T (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -0J g-
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuatons (2 Otr, Avg end 88-1) _ o 53
| |
| )
| |
| ^ '
| |
| : 3. Signifs mt Events (2 Ctri Avg end 88-1) ,. o ,
| |
| l
| |
| : 4. Safety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - C.30 !
| |
| i
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| , - 0.12 I
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced Outooes/1000 Cnt. Hrs. 0 66 (2 Qtr, Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-i.0-i.5 UO -0.5 0 0 O!S L'O t!5 2IO 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt Meons (Measured in Stonderd Deviot.cns)
| |
| SUMMER: Devictions frorn Older Plant Means l Bei w Avg. Perf. . Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Wh4 Critical (4 Otr. Avg 'M 88-1) - - L39
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 33
| |
| : 3. Significant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ose
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -o.u a
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 ' Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 0 50
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / Cjit , ,
| |
| -2.5-i 0-i.5 -i0 -0.5 0'O O'S I'O t 'S i.0 25 Devictions from Older pient veons (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| =
| |
| O i
| |
| | |
| # G PE AM i i : : r --
| |
| am:v s a., v: t : " . , e. . .- . : -- 1, . - .
| |
| , I --g.~. :
| |
| I c.t :: -:ss 36-2 to 88-1 """ 4 R" "
| |
| * 7 "
| |
| O 1 Automot< Scrcrrs ANe Cr: tied 2. Scfety System Act At Oos '
| |
| * 4 500 4 _
| |
| , ;sc- '
| |
| s i
| |
| - 22so ja o
| |
| , 3_ ,--
| |
| *' ~
| |
| 2 *5 l 3_ ,
| |
| -... 4M} j
| |
| -g nso ' J ,7so
| |
| : 52. /
| |
| /e\
| |
| Ji< / - w 3* je 4 e ..,'\ Ju l #
| |
| g .- < s ,
| |
| x2- \ . '250 3 ,2
| |
| \\
| |
| / 2so 1 fI 3' i 3 \./
| |
| - ms 2 if m
| |
| '\ .
| |
| v
| |
| - ac 3 2
| |
| i
| |
| - 7so 5 6 _ 7c5v
| |
| ,~ i i i u ,~ a
| |
| [M ~
| |
| - sco _ soc i
| |
| ? $ - 250 Y J :so o ,,
| |
| 2 e o $ l3 l e6-2 es-3 e6-4 s7-i s?-2 s7-3 ar- s8-1 e6-2 e6-3 e6-4 s7-i s7-2 s7-3 er-. s8-i Y ear - Qwtr Year - owtr 3 Sepficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Scfety System Folures
| |
| . 3- .,3 g 3.
| |
| ik T JE 21
| |
| -< i 4
| |
| -t<
| |
| x2- h s2. 2 2 2
| |
| =
| |
| j y g
| |
| k- -
| |
| e g
| |
| = > + w $'
| |
| ' i M "
| |
| R\
| |
| ))
| |
| i- i-
| |
| "^ jfl* $*
| |
| 51
| |
| , 3 % ,
| |
| o e6'-2 es'- 3 e6-4 s/-i t -2i s/-3 si-4 as-i 802 e6-3 e6'-4 si-i s?-2 s7'-3 ai-4 sa-t Yeor - Qucrter Yeor - Qtsorter
| |
| . 6. Ecu .nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (z) Crited Hours ico a 3 So . -6 h
| |
| a<t e a-ha<
| |
| "h *m4-asr
| |
| * g *o - 3, v
| |
| % j'
| |
| '% g ,,, 'y , e,8"',
| |
| ' se % -IN ~
| |
| z.,
| |
| o ,
| |
| b 86- 4 96-3 66-4
| |
| [ $ hS El 87-1 S7-2 87-3 87-4 88-5 o f , f!
| |
| I 66-2 06-3 86-4 07-1 67-2 SI-3 87-4 58'- t I# s~1 Ytor - Quarter f ec* - Quarter 216
| |
| | |
| F.GUPE 4.95 c SURRY 1: Trends
| |
| .(
| |
| D'C'ined ''"crovec =
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms We Critical (2 Otr. A q eno 88-1) - 0 ,
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 3. Signficont Esents (2 Otr. Avg end , 3-1) -
| |
| [h in.
| |
| o ss i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System feitures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ o I !
| |
| : 5. Forced Outage Rete (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ o;3 u
| |
| 5
| |
| : 6. Equperent Forced (2 Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs.. Avg end 68-1) 4 24-
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -I.5 -I.0 -0.5 0.0 OIS I'O l'5 2'O 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. P!cnt Mecns (Measured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| .SURRY 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf, Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 4 32
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - tu
| |
| : 3. Signficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -3 22
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . _ o,34
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -0.50
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / , , ,
| |
| -2.5-5 0-i.5 iO -0 5 0 0 O!5 1'O t'5 IO 25 Devictions frorn Cdder Plont vecns ,
| |
| I (Meosited in Stenderd Cevictiers) l l
| |
| l 217 l
| |
| l
| |
| [:
| |
| | |
| TGLOE a M l
| |
| n _ l ~ ; .: .
| |
| 3; " ,,s' -,,Y ' '
| |
| i usCerC:
| |
| : :e : :~ :.-p
| |
| ;r:t c: -:s s
| |
| .i gg g gg-, j == 4 R tv '.-1:,r; ..e :;e t Automatic Scroms ANe Cr.tcos 2. S9ety System Actet ces l 4 No 4 .*. .
| |
| - 2250 ::M
| |
| , , g
| |
| * - 2000 ~g ,.q J 2cco= { t a 3 - 3- I gg - 1750 1
| |
| 3A e ], M A !
| |
| -5 3 35 I )
| |
| Mt - son *' "y <5 l u '% >
| |
| ~<
| |
| * l
| |
| 'm2- '250 ox2- W]'
| |
| sx,f.
| |
| D ! -
| |
| k :
| |
| om n
| |
| * ~4 i l
| |
| - 750 7M i '
| |
| ~ ~ "
| |
| - SCO Mc 2" --
| |
| 250 y:M A)x 0
| |
| 0 0 f N - - -
| |
| l0 t
| |
| j
| |
| , , . . T , . 7 , , .
| |
| 56-2 66-3 86-4 67-1 s7-2 s?-3 s?-4 88-1 86-2 $6-3 86-4 87- t 8 7-2 8 7-3 87-a SS- t Yect - Quar ter Yect - Quarter
| |
| : 3. Sapficant Events ,
| |
| : 4. Safety System Foues
| |
| . 3- g 3-ik jk at -t 2<2-w s<2-x 2
| |
| in
| |
| +
| |
| N b
| |
| w
| |
| +W d
| |
| Ik! h b , s e4-2 e6'.3 es si.i ei-2 si-3 ei-4 ss' i 84 2 es-3 ei-4 ei-$ i-2 si-3 si-4 es-i veo - ovarter Yeor - tF
| |
| : 6. Eau ent Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (s) Critcol ws oO - .--. s _
| |
| m e7 .
| |
| E 80 .
| |
| ~
| |
| h
| |
| $$ h h "1"-
| |
| 3 8p II3 w 4-I p 3, $ " ' --! $
| |
| * w 2- l3 20 - A '
| |
| 4 ,
| |
| 5 7 M oII . ts
| |
| * g ? 3 g) ro7 .
| |
| r1 ~
| |
| si-2 ei-3 e6 4 s?'-t si-2 87'-3 si-4 es-i e6-2 ei-3 si-4 al-1 si-2 si-3 87'-4 ea i veor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter 218 g
| |
| | |
| v RGLRE G 6 3
| |
| .. SURRY 2: Trends p.
| |
| Performance indicaters C'0'i* d O 'Cv'0 t
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scrorrs WMe Criticci AGws (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - gg '' '
| |
| : 2. Sofety' System Actuotbns (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) . .t25
| |
| - i q .-
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| .o gg (
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0 53
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) o g3 s k l
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outogr./1000 (2
| |
| Crit.88-1)
| |
| Avg end Hrs. - q 0.52
| |
| -2.5-$.0-t5 -lO -0.5 0.0 O!5 t'0 t'5 2'O -2.5 0 evictions from Previous 4 Otr. Plont Meces (Measured in Stanctord Devictions) 1 SURRY 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| l
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms Whie Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.74 2 Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.33
| |
| +
| |
| : 3. Sigmficant Events (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - -0.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety' System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o,7o
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs. l o.70 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - j
| |
| -2.5-2 0-15 -iO -0.5 0'O O!5 t'0 t'5 20 25 De Actions from Older P!cnt veces (Measured in Standard Cevtotions) (
| |
| l T 219
| |
| | |
| w ,,, . . -).
| |
| i i 1
| |
| ~
| |
| ^; ^^
| |
| c ,. -^ * * , ,i l r ,4 . - [ ' ,, " ', .
| |
| O [n 7
| |
| )!j ) V V[ .7,b, '
| |
| ; ; ; t-' t i
| |
| ' s-(' , , " : s > '
| |
| m 4 C Ar t e' V : < c 1.e' 0 ;t g
| |
| q v6-2 to 88-1 t AutornCtc Scroms Who Cf.t'C'.) e 2. SCfet/ System A 0tat CFS 4-_ 2*A0 4 ISX ,
| |
| I t
| |
| - 22so ;
| |
| b::w
| |
| ,,*'''s=.
| |
| ~
| |
| - ?XC ~ ''
| |
| ., XC i
| |
| ? s
| |
| / - "" f /.
| |
| e 3- / 3. i it / -
| |
| , 3 it i / s. ! -
| |
| 'I d} #
| |
| \ . 500 ~ j! / \ / .,* A0 *
| |
| ~<
| |
| o ,2.
| |
| \
| |
| \ - mso
| |
| * A 3 ,2. /
| |
| l r
| |
| /
| |
| - sw ;I
| |
| = i \ l g= i 1
| |
| - 000 3 ', / .m3 ,
| |
| }s 'i 3 \1 rs l"* dli
| |
| , V ,
| |
| 6 2 ,~
| |
| ,~
| |
| Y - 500 No l IF - 25o ]:w i o _A .
| |
| E o o !c 1
| |
| $6-2 66-3 S6'-4 Si-t 8f-2 6f-3 8f-4 68-1 86-2 $6-3 66-4 87' t 87-2 9 7-3 8 7'-4 88-1 Yecr - Quorter Yeor - Qwr t er
| |
| : 3. Smficont Events ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety Systern Foues
| |
| .3- 3- L iE OB jk w&
| |
| L4
| |
| ~A ~E b e2- e8- d t 1 y e 2
| |
| m t-M
| |
| .4
| |
| .i.
| |
| .. - ? u ~
| |
| J
| |
| & b $
| |
| &s 4 m w M.9 86'-284-3864 L ei-1 ei-2 8/-3 8/-4 EA-1 802 803 86'-4 8i-1 Si-2 ei-3 87-4 88-i Yeor - Quctter Year - Quorier
| |
| : 6. Ecu nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Out<ge Rote (s) Crit cal Hovs a I 8
| |
| $ $0 - -h 6~
| |
| 3 b a
| |
| t co - 3!
| |
| B" h4, m._
| |
| ~
| |
| 41 E b ** - 4 a
| |
| vm y 3 -
| |
| w PL W 2 i.,s t U Q"f
| |
| ~
| |
| d [ h IC4 o 0 d gg 0 = . .
| |
| 86-2 S6-3 86-4 87-t 97-2 Si-3 ei-4 88'-t 66-280366-4 Si-t Si-2 87-3 87 4 88-'
| |
| Yeor - Qwrter Yeor - Qwrt er 220 g
| |
| | |
| - ~
| |
| JGURE 4.97 SUSOUEHANNA 1: Trenas Perforrnance Indicaters De*ed mecac i
| |
| : 1. Autor*4 tic Scroms Wh;ie Critical 9 I (2 Otte Avg end 88-1) - -o S8 :(y' 4 i
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuctions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o lr .
| |
| t
| |
| : 3. S;gnificant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o ss
| |
| 'i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures -(2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . oss
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 227
| |
| : 6. Equbment For:ed Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o S8
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0.0 0'S t'0 l'5 2'0 2.5 0 evictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont vecns (Measured in Stoncord Deviations)
| |
| -SUSOUEHANNA 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means j i Perforrnance Indicators 8'D* Av9 P'f f- AbC*' A"9 M
| |
| ' t. Automotig Scroms Whie Critical (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o 21
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - UI ,
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System FcAures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o2t
| |
| : 5. Forced Outogs Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.23
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit Hr s. 0 *.
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| -2.5-2 0-i5 !O -d.5 0'O C 5 l'0 t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Oider Picnt Means (Meosured in Storuced Devictions) 221
| |
| | |
| -e
| |
| & *. ~*,-j :
| |
| i e
| |
| M A A g m a
| |
| s/ hj *\! .,g.
| |
| I } O^Ced- -a, ; --- . ; e
| |
| .- ' e* i N 1 N r.
| |
| s - -f f '
| |
| s V, sV Vu; .:.- ! --r- ~-
| |
| . . . . . . . . ;,'e- ; yjg j
| |
| 3'**' '~2" 36--2 to 88--l "#''I t Automctic Scrans Whe Cr tect 2 Scfety System Actuctors 4 :wo 4 :xe
| |
| - 2250 ::50 ;
| |
| j' . . . . - .
| |
| g *%.... .
| |
| 23:o. }. j e
| |
| g, .oco 3 g 3- ,
| |
| s r' a -i j eA ] j tN g i, 5h / -
| |
| M!
| |
| \ [ . tMO a' h <!
| |
| \
| |
| ,/ - *XC e ,
| |
| i
| |
| \
| |
| 3 2- / i250 .3 te. a / , ese 3
| |
| \-g.\//
| |
| . i. t .
| |
| W 3 h \. i w 0"C ~$ I V 3 V i 4i
| |
| ] ,
| |
| 750 j ,
| |
| a ''A "
| |
| 1- i 1- - ,,
| |
| j *cc
| |
| $ - 500 U' j :*x 1%
| |
| - 250 o AC _
| |
| o o _
| |
| .fr ho ei-2 64-3 56'-4 81-187-2 Si-3 Si-4 SS-1 88-2 84-3 86-4 87-1 $7-2 67-3 87-4 68-1 Yeor - Quorter Yeor - Quarter
| |
| : 3. 5gnficont Events 4. Sofety System roues
| |
| . 3- g 3-
| |
| -t
| |
| . <t ..
| |
| m2.
| |
| 'mI- b +. g s M a 4m k h A
| |
| Sh fhvf h 't
| |
| .gs 9 ? ;'i e s +i 0 a a e .
| |
| 0 96-2 66kJ 86'-4 8/-i 6 /-2 SI-3 Si-4 88-1 86h 2 86-3 86L4 31-187-2 ti-3 Si-4 as-t Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quorter
| |
| : 6. Equ .nt Forced Outogss/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (t) Crit col Hou s M 6
| |
| ^
| |
| !, 80 -
| |
| s-s 3
| |
| }<' '
| |
| s<!
| |
| u no.
| |
| ee D g 40 .
| |
| e 3 2s w 2-20 "
| |
| 7 w
| |
| @m n . n w t ry
| |
| .''5 g o ._
| |
| so-2 si-3 ei-4 s/-i si-2 87-3 s/-4 se'-1 e6-2 so' 3 so'-4 a7 i si-2 sf-) a7-4 sa. i Year - Quarter Y eor - Qw tc l 222 g
| |
| l l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| m ,
| |
| nau=E :.as or ,
| |
| f SUSOUEHANNA 2: Trencs y.
| |
| ! A - Performance indicators ~ C'C'i''ed irrecoved 4
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms While Critic 0i $44 !
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - gj% o S4 i 2 Sclety Sys' tem Actuctices (2 Ott. Avg end 88-1) o ga
| |
| ~ 3. Significont Events - (2 Otri Avg . end 88-1) - -02 t
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Failures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o 3o l
| |
| Sf Forced Outege Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 2.26 f;} '
| |
| : 6. Equbment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o 58
| |
| -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -I.0 -d.5 0.0 0'5 1l0 l'5 2!0 2 5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt Mecns (Measured in stonderd 0 evictions)
| |
| . .t s SUSOUEHANNA 2: Deviations frorn Older Plant Mecns l eeow Avg. Tserf. Above Avg. Perf {i Performance Indicators .
| |
| l I tm i
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scroms WMe Criticot 0 74 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - l
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.33
| |
| ~
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o42 4 Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - - o.14
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge' Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0.50
| |
| : 6. Equhment Forced it tog / , og
| |
| -2.5-2'.0-i.5 I.0-0.50.0 05 t'0 t'5 2'O 15 Devictions from Older Plcnt vecns (Measured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| G 223 L U
| |
| | |
| '--J.~- ~.:
| |
| ~
| |
| T; .~."""*F i i7 '
| |
| e.
| |
| ~e
| |
| ' . r'' r r--
| |
| 6', t i tm-
| |
| :y- i
| |
| , _cuc C. -
| |
| ~
| |
| -:j3 m
| |
| * C ,2'' F ''2. rg 1.1' -
| |
| _j 1 AutOrM t'c $crorns WNe Crit.Cd 2 SCfety 3ystem A Otuctors a *S00 s 2502
| |
| +xl..
| |
| i,
| |
| : f. ..._.._.
| |
| l 2000 ** I\ 2XC ~ l
| |
| $ 3- /'g .
| |
| 1750 3-
| |
| / k .- l 4l
| |
| '752 ~ j s
| |
| j} \
| |
| /
| |
| i f g 5
| |
| \
| |
| 3}9 <
| |
| - uo -* i <t k t
| |
| , -i 2 CM \s 3. / l '255 l p2- : .d. - oy2-4 s- - -, \ .I - ,;
| |
| 3 ,
| |
| . 3 1 i
| |
| ," b I t 5 , i \ K 5 h .\ S C , So, 't '\ I'j
| |
| "_1 go 2% - 50 N -
| |
| 86'-2 66-3 86'-4 8/-167-2 8i-3 Si-4 88'- t 06-286i 386-4 8/1S7-287'-387'-4 88-1 YeOr - Quarter Year - Cuarter 4 Sofety Systern Foues !
| |
| : 3. Sviificont Events ,
| |
| = 3- 3 3-5 h$
| |
| wt -t<
| |
| 3 <m 2. -
| |
| =2-a a : v'
| |
| ' t-
| |
| : i. .'
| |
| , $W 862 esis ese f ,
| |
| e6' 2 86 I
| |
| i ) 86-4 Si-i ai-2 si-3 Si-4 ss-i s
| |
| Yeor al.e Qwter Si-2 si-3 si-4 Sa'- i Ye0r - Quarter 6 Co.i nt Forced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Cutoge Rote (s) Crit <GI Hour s 00 6 1
| |
| 3 ao - ,-
| |
| e
| |
| " ,a ,~ at Ia e
| |
| }i w
| |
| $4 a
| |
| , 34-3 h 'O ' h.
| |
| 5 w w 2.
| |
| 20 - ns 122 1 ]m o m
| |
| " G I 56'-2 96' 3 56-4 8/-l 8f-2 Si-3 Si-4 88-1
| |
| - 86'-286366-4 8'-t $7-2 Sf-3 57-4 84 - 1 Yeor - Quarter Y eCr - Qw t er 224
| |
| : s. . . . -- - .. - .
| |
| recust .us THREE MILE LIS. 1: Trenas
| |
| . Performance : Indicators O'C""d *' "*d 1
| |
| : 1. / Automatic Scroms WNte Crit :ol W rf gg (
| |
| (2 Otr Avg end 88 .1) - 09 1 3
| |
| 2 Sofety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - OM i 1 3.- Signficant. Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -t72 ,
| |
| 4 ' Sofety System Fcaures .(2 Ote. Avg end 88-1) - og .
| |
| 5 Forced .Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Aig end 88-1) _ o 37
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (2, Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 4 27
| |
| -2.5-5.0-i5-iO-0.50.0 055 t'0 t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Previous 4 ctr. Piont M (Measured in Stonderd Deviations) eans THREE MILE IS.1: Deviations from Older Plant Mecns Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf, Performance Indicoters
| |
| : l. Automotic Scroms WMe Criticol
| |
| - (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o.J2
| |
| : 2. Scfety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - tn
| |
| : 3. Sigrsficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 4 42
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 124
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) _ 0 43
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit, Hrs. 0.70 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| l
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i$ lo -d.5 0'O OIS t'0 i5 2IO 2.5 Devictions from Older Plant Means (Measured in Stonderd Devictions) 4 225
| |
| | |
| --v . ~ '._~ . ...a i ::-
| |
| -m,^
| |
| * _..e.~.
| |
| a.
| |
| ; , , v. p , y -- - v.
| |
| t
| |
| .*: - : J .*
| |
| 86-2 to 88-1
| |
| " # #7 " 2 "
| |
| t Avtonctic Scrorrs We Cr.t<of 2. S'fety Sy stem Actu t cas 4 :500 4 ::ce j
| |
| - 2:w _ :::.: l
| |
| -.~.,
| |
| 2w0 - :n -
| |
| p 3.
| |
| t
| |
| : 3. < . .. _ \. .
| |
| 4 5
| |
| '750 I . 4 i'w "
| |
| i
| |
| - 4 -3 / j s d!< -,/ . u' a ?! < f i
| |
| 3
| |
| / 4we .
| |
| 3 2_ .
| |
| :50 f a32_ [ b;l
| |
| :Mj 3 \ _ '=0, i 3 1
| |
| /!
| |
| } ,
| |
| i m , , .i -
| |
| 3 6 ,-
| |
| , , /, I 'S A 5
| |
| g u e
| |
| a sm a
| |
| . s: lsx s _ m:
| |
| h l $ h' ' *g
| |
| /
| |
| & n w s- }, s
| |
| +_
| |
| ''/ "+'
| |
| 0 'Y
| |
| - E '
| |
| 0 0 i I I-'I O
| |
| t$-2 86-3 86-4 Si-1 Si-2 Si-3 ei-4 88-1 86-286386'4-L Si-197k2 ti-3 6f-4 88-1 Ytor - Quorter Yeor - Quarter 3 Signficant Events 4. Sofety System Fokses i ;
| |
| e 3. a 3. ')
| |
| $E jE '
| |
| -1 -! t.
| |
| -< ~< w e
| |
| 3 2- 32.
| |
| 7,.
| |
| 3 W
| |
| # v v
| |
| i- d -
| |
| h 1- hk h:) r2 5:.
| |
| k'r1T
| |
| . a 8, a s-
| |
| !% M .k f @ x 0 0 -
| |
| 98-2 86'- 3 86'-4 8Y-t ni-2 6/-3 SI-4 88'- 1 86-2 86-3 86'-4 Si-l 8f-2 SI-3 Si-4 88-1 Year - Duarter Yeor - 0.e t er
| |
| : 6. Equ nt Forced Outages /
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rote (t) Critco Meus oO s
| |
| - E 5 80 - g
| |
| ~
| |
| $R b "jx
| |
| } )".
| |
| "- i s
| |
| 6 'w4-O' ='
| |
| 40 . j 7u Z 5
| |
| * 22 w 2- t?)
| |
| 20 . 7 7 4
| |
| " *1 6
| |
| 0 --- -
| |
| 0 h, -
| |
| 86-2 86-3 88-4 87-167-2 of-3 8f-* 88-1 86-2 86-3 86-4 8/167-2S-387-4 f 88 ,
| |
| Y tor - Quarter Y eor - Quar t er 226 g
| |
| | |
| h TrL:E .t.'GO f.c TROJAN: Trends
| |
| .a 1.
| |
| V Performance Indicators C' ** d '"C'** C l !
| |
| 1 L Automatic ' $croms WN'4 Critical .' d l[{Mpi i
| |
| a- (2 Ctn Avg end 88-1) - gj; 0 58 i
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ' ){j{tgj.
| |
| : 3. Sigenficant Events (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - 1
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.e .
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 4 63 it
| |
| : 6. Equ;pment Forced Ou, tog /10 0 , ,
| |
| -2.5-iO-i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0'O O'5 l'O l'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. P'ont Meons (Meosured in Standard Devictions)
| |
| TROJAN: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Ped. Abme Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance' Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Wh4 Cntical E l j
| |
| (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 21 .
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.4 s
| |
| : 3. SigNficent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -o42
| |
| : 4. Sof ety System Foilures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -oA3 '
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 23
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs o (4 Otr. Avg end 88 1) -
| |
| P
| |
| -2.5-fe.0-15 viottons from -i.0Older-5 5Plcnt 0 0Veens 0'S t'0 th 2 0 2 5 (Measured in Stondord Devictions) ,
| |
| 227
| |
| | |
| #- #,"1 ..
| |
| ~. .m.,,
| |
| wg ;
| |
| ,,m .,
| |
| y m p.y ,~
| |
| st .. ,
| |
| c .m c e''v.
| |
| M. ' ., ; ,-, ;' ,'',.
| |
| r Qj .fNL I s,j ! i 'j -v y fI0; "O / s gg g g_j 4 17 t e" Y h ' ; 1.e':;?
| |
| : 1. AutOMCt!C SCTFs ON4 CGt <CI 2. 30f ety System A0 t VCt >0 Fs 4 - 2500 4 . M0
| |
| - 22$0 q I!!C 2'JOO ~ d :XC ~;
| |
| g 3 \ 3-7 j 3 x. -
| |
| -e i - uso a -3 -
| |
| im .
| |
| s 3l
| |
| =<
| |
| ! \ - 500 a' k <! '\ - M~ e
| |
| -g g i m2- 1 1 c
| |
| A r:soj 3 e2- g 2
| |
| n: 3 '
| |
| :- , - coo n \\ - m,>
| |
| W-
| |
| / W l
| |
| j .h ~
| |
| ~
| |
| ,_ g-5 ? \ i /
| |
| 5 ,- i
| |
| \ & /, -
| |
| * 3l j 2: (2 / -
| |
| sm 2SO
| |
| ' t
| |
| /7 -
| |
| 42M m
| |
| : a , \ .
| |
| A I,
| |
| $6-2 66
| |
| * 84-4 SI-i Si-2 SI-3 87 . 8$-I $6-2 fi-3 96-4 O f-t 9 7-2 67-3 87-4 34 1 Yeor - QuartF Year - Quar t r
| |
| : 3. Supficant Eveats ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System Foues I
| |
| . 3- d 3 J- 4 d
| |
| }E @ jk p
| |
| -1 4 -t ~
| |
| 3*2-
| |
| .,2, 3*,-e g -
| |
| 2 av
| |
| ~3 I %* f
| |
| $ @f % &
| |
| k '-
| |
| y h hd E-N.I
| |
| *N o
| |
| Eh.k -- %_
| |
| o
| |
| . m
| |
| : e. e $
| |
| 5 a l' lt4 es-2 e6-3 e6-4 si-i si-2 si-3 si-4 ed-t e6L 2 e6'-3 as-4 s?-tsi-2 si-3ei-4 mi Year - Qwter Year - ovarter
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outoges/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcge Rote (s) D00 Crited Hou s vo . 8 l c
| |
| .- i .27 o
| |
| :t i
| |
| w a- I e, t! "- $i a #r lI34- 5 i d .e. ; 9 -- ~ y 1o
| |
| "- A 8
| |
| . p s 4 s
| |
| s nV ,
| |
| ?
| |
| - w 2- in 20 - ''
| |
| d ';
| |
| h s 3 e s s a
| |
| . T.
| |
| gva #
| |
| b'{- 1 -
| |
| p' 9 4 O 3 b_ -a3
| |
| * 0* 1 t*..
| |
| 36-286386-4 si-t e7-2 Si-3 ai-4 88-1 86-2 86-3 56-4 Si-t Si-2 af-3 87-4 18-1 Yeor - Quarter Yeor - Quarter 228 g
| |
| | |
| FGLtE 4.'01 TURKEY POINT 3: Trends f_
| |
| \
| |
| '' Performance Indicctocs D***'
| |
| W o'e:
| |
| I :
| |
| Scroms whi'e Criticci '
| |
| t Automatif2 Otr. Avg enc $$~1) - s
| |
| ;({ 09 2 ' Scfety System Actuctsns (2 Gt. Avg end 88-1) . o f i
| |
| 3 Signficant Events (2 Otr. Avg end 89-1) - m j 4 Sofety System Folures (2 Otr. Avg end 80-1) _ de
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr Avg er,d 88- 1) _h: i -e3 6 Equipment Forc<.d Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs. .
| |
| (2 Otr. .tvg end 88-1) - - to t s I
| |
| ' ~
| |
| -2.5-2.0-t5 I O -0.5 0.0 0'S t'0 15 250 2.5 Deviotrpns from Previous 4 Otr. P:cnt Meces (Mecsured in Stencord Devictices)
| |
| TURKEY POINT 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Pe f.
| |
| Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automoti Scroms Wh4 Criticot g 4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - : '
| |
| E74 l
| |
| : 2. 50fety System Actuctsns (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -t24
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .tS2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foikses (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -o 4e
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -2 29 i
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / 0 rit H , ,g
| |
| -2.5 0 -i 5 -I.0 -5.5 0 0 0'S t'0 1'S 20 25 evictions f rom Older Pent Means Mecsured in Standord Devictions)
| |
| / 229
| |
| | |
| a ,
| |
| -t ,c.
| |
| w,
| |
| '*,(v ' ,N* , - ,
| |
| : :e ~'
| |
| d K 'i r [
| |
| j --
| |
| l
| |
| _6 C 9 'EC :
| |
| c.,, , ': ; ': ,, 3 t' ; '
| |
| ' M --2 6 88 - 1
| |
| - 4 C"''''*"i'''''
| |
| g t Autometc Secrrs Abe Crotcoi 2. S fety system Ac'et,o s 4 2m . :sec
| |
| - 22w . 22w i i
| |
| 2000 3 2XQ T 3!
| |
| 3- 3. A l.
| |
| [.. /\
| |
| 3?
| |
| t I
| |
| ~. ' '\\ f l - ""- w-
| |
| * a it U ,
| |
| l ,
| |
| l.\
| |
| /
| |
| .i 1* Ti
| |
| ; s.:o - 1
| |
| ~< : < <t 1
| |
| \ i >
| |
| / / 1:,iI m2. t - r2w o,2. !
| |
| yb
| |
| / b i i Ij 1
| |
| -/ - tm 3 Jj / :
| |
| ! , J uc 3 !
| |
| , , l - ~ 5 P t-
| |
| ,/ \/ Ja= i !
| |
| i
| |
| ' ' 500 / I i. .4 %3 a
| |
| g ?c -
| |
| ' I:n
| |
| / @
| |
| a
| |
| \/ - 2so a
| |
| / V o o / o si-2 d-3 si-4 a/-iai-2si-3ai-4 88 -i d-2 ei-3 m-4 s7-t p-2 s7-3 s7-a es-i veer - Quyter year - warter 3 Snpf. cont Events 4. Scfety System Foues
| |
| {
| |
| . n 1 g 3 h jh N
| |
| -t e2- ;
| |
| 1 e2- g 1 #2 4
| |
| . se L m- 'fs h
| |
| [
| |
| Y=d b 1 1- 1
| |
| {h .
| |
| / I* w
| |
| : c' '' W f
| |
| % 5 g' s A , s s 1<,Y s . .
| |
| 1 im - [d s 00
| |
| , o 96-2 96-3 W4 th-t 87'-2 $I-3 6 -4 88-1 86-2 66-3 86-4 85-1 97-2 67-3 87'-4 68 -1 voor - %arter rear - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau ent Forced Cutoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (s) Cr,t ca Motis 10 0 8, ,_
| |
| 3 80 - e-
| |
| , g
| |
| *d 01 a:
| |
| g 4! # - ,
| |
| g!
| |
| v 5 7 54 x h.
| |
| h me-d"u .z ib ** b b r n 3 -
| |
| N
| |
| (
| |
| M d w 2.
| |
| , s ,
| |
| 0 ,
| |
| 0 86-2 Si-3 66-4 81-1 Si-2 Si-3 Si-4 88-1 86-2 66-3 We 61 i 87-2 67-3 87-4 SS-t Y eor - Quar t er Y eor - Quorter I.
| |
| 230 g
| |
| : n. .
| |
| . .c notPI Co2 o ;
| |
| ( _p-
| |
| 'TURKEV POINT 4: Trenas
| |
| '' C'** d ' " * ' **d
| |
| ' Performance indicaterS l l :
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms, Wh4 Critical Q4 !
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end d8-1) ~ %jfWjgg'M 1
| |
| l
| |
| ).
| |
| 21 Sofety System Actuctions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- 0 !
| |
| 1 3 S,gnf; cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ; j;. og l
| |
| ^
| |
| u' a'::. :.: i
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fo4ures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0 46 j
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 42
| |
| : 6. Equ'oment Forced Outoces/1000 Crit. Ws. o 93 (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - s
| |
| -2.5-2 0-I.5 -lo -d.5 0.0 0'S t'0 1'5 2IO 25~
| |
| 0 evictions from Previous 4 Otr. Picnt veces (Mecsured in Stondord Oevictionsi TIJRKEY POINT' 4: Deviations trom Older Plant Means Bel w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf Performance Indicators
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms Wh4 Critical %%
| |
| (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - , 3 gf 125
| |
| : 2. Scfety 3ystem Actuctions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .
| |
| 1 ti
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . ta2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fortures I4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .tpa
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 3.94
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit. Hrr o 26 (4 Otr. Avg end 88.); -
| |
| 2' 0 -i5 IO -0.5 0'O O'S t'0 15 20 25 Devictions from Older Plcnt Vecas (Measured in Standord 0 evictions)
| |
| .O 231 V
| |
| l L _ .. -_. - _ _
| |
| | |
| ' u , * *. ~.w:.-
| |
| ~
| |
| r ~ ~.s 4rs -- ,
| |
| <. ; - - - - i f ~---
| |
| j /lk !N, ) h' j , f I ~--
| |
| e
| |
| ... ,,* ; :,r s a .g _ o. to va p _., ;
| |
| - 4 byte V:s ; 1. e : ;e l
| |
| t Automctic Scres one Creted 2. Sciety System Actu:t ces a :sao . :sco
| |
| - 2250 J :::a
| |
| ,- q '
| |
| I, - 2000*i \ '
| |
| :Xo 1-9 3. i 3- -
| |
| %g I g / - '750 K 5
| |
| / .
| |
| '\
| |
| '/
| |
| j '": *
| |
| ! 3 3 ,
| |
| a' s:c '
| |
| f St -\ 'i - sao *'
| |
| i <t \, e
| |
| ~< \
| |
| g2- i/4 -
| |
| mj 3p2- ,
| |
| \ d.saj Il 1- ,
| |
| / \/ s
| |
| ~
| |
| o*3,
| |
| ,, O lj 5
| |
| J w- 3 t ,.
| |
| 1 ~, 2 q, _.
| |
| 1 1 Ji y _a g ,,, 500
| |
| - :x J ecc 0
| |
| i =
| |
| Q MW '
| |
| + .
| |
| o o ! e d %.
| |
| a
| |
| ::o j
| |
| ^
| |
| 86'-2 66-3 66-4 01-18-267-387'-4 88'- t f M-2 86'- 3 $6-4 81-1 GI-2 8f-3 07-4 $8 - ,
| |
| Yew - Quarter reor - Qu t er 3 S$ficent Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System Foues
| |
| 'x a 3. g 3.
| |
| -t -t s
| |
| t<2-3 3<2-x 2 2 b
| |
| f.
| |
| gb i yi k i l ym )r/
| |
| i
| |
| ,- : .- : a -
| |
| ( ;
| |
| l s-c y N x ,
| |
| g M - 2 s- 3 .<. . ,
| |
| 94 c s m l
| |
| M-2 a-3 85-i v-2 c'-3 8v-. .,
| |
| L,-27-307-.
| |
| M-, I reor - Quarter rn tr
| |
| : 6. ":au . nt Forced Outas/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outage Rote (t) Crit <c Ws 00 8 b M-z
| |
| . 2*-
| |
| z!*- 3!
| |
| }< s<
| |
| 2D $5 ~
| |
| ; ao - i e
| |
| s I w 2- t to -
| |
| ~
| |
| \
| |
| 2 o - -1 o o 56-2 86'- 3 66- 4 87-18 f-2 07-3 87-4 88-1 M-2 66-3 M-e 87-187-2 87-3 87-4 68 t Yew - Quarter Yev - Mter 232 g
| |
| | |
| % (
| |
| - 7:cc=E 4.:03 p
| |
| j# % .
| |
| VERMONT YANKEE. Trends t
| |
| -D}'- Performance Indiccters ce *ed wormo
| |
| : 1. Avtomotk Scroms Whde Cribcol MWJ#g i (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) " ~1 phM.. .
| |
| 2 . Scfety System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - jgh osa !
| |
| - I
| |
| : 3. S.garicont Events (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o sa !
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fodvres (2 Otr. Avg end 88 al) ) t 5 i
| |
| : 5. forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o.4 $
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoges/1000 Crit. Hrs.
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 0
| |
| -2.5-iO -l5 -I.0 -0.5 0 0 0'S 1.'O t'5 2'O 25
| |
| - Deviations from previous 4 Otr. Pter.t Meons (Measured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| VERMONT YANKEE: Deviations from Older Plant Means-Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators-1 Automotic Scroms Whde Critical-(4 Otr. Avg eM 88-1) - -4 32
| |
| : 2. Sof ety System Actuotbns (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . g,33 ;
| |
| : 3. S;g6ficent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -
| |
| ose
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foilures (d Otr. Avg end 85-1) . -ts2
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - on
| |
| : 6. Ecuipment Forced 4O(utooes/1000 Crit, HrsGtr. Avg end 88-1) - 0 90
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 i.5 IO -0.5 0'0 OIS l'O l'5 20 25 Deviations from Older Plant vecns (Measured in Stondord Devictiers) 233
| |
| | |
| 6 .
| |
| - g,"--
| |
| .y+
| |
| ^
| |
| 9 lf t t
| |
| -wa~Q?$* av- 'va ' 29' , - * ;.y y i
| |
| Js/.+7 --
| |
| '.e,.e _' mA. c :e S C'*
| |
| -% -- 2 ''o v8 -1 - 4 cote "' v2
| |
| ., ; 4.e ;e I
| |
| : 1. Autornots Scror"s h "* N +Cd t 2 D ety System A0tvCt Fs t a 'M 4 ;Mo i 5 -
| |
| 2:so :.s s
| |
| $ J.
| |
| ,' s .p, noo 3 g g 3-l I
| |
| :a:; j gg 3; .6'.
| |
| ??W s
| |
| g%
| |
| J*N f j
| |
| A s
| |
| /p b, boo ,B _g V-... I J; Yg h .).
| |
| - y, : 41 # l
| |
| ( q p
| |
| * 4 /
| |
| y2 - _ _ _ ,,
| |
| _fp"J
| |
| [.:
| |
| -[ ,.7,., -
| |
| Oso.) o=2.
| |
| j
| |
| - ';s0 ) I!
| |
| -i j
| |
| ,A's
| |
| ,\ . 000 3 w
| |
| j$
| |
| Z .
| |
| /. -
| |
| EC 3, l
| |
| $'l Y f
| |
| ., 7s0 ~ ! a 7% 1 1, N g
| |
| ,, k '.
| |
| , g E ., j
| |
| _ l g, *
| |
| [ )[.'
| |
| - :so N y:M
| |
| , m . -
| |
| , , i, W2 W 3 86 4 81-1 of-2 Si-3 Si-4 88 1 66'-2 S6' 3 86-4 87-1 Si-2 $7 3 ei-4 88-1 Yeor - Quarter feor - Quort er
| |
| : 3. Sipficont Events 4 Safety System Fol tres 4 4 s
| |
| E m 3 S 3-kt h t
| |
| f
| |
| <t
| |
| -. 4 w.
| |
| t:'
| |
| m2_ m2. Y {Y.
| |
| a b c '
| |
| 1- .
| |
| 1 s N g'"'
| |
| R -% / 5 s s J
| |
| k
| |
| , y -r _ o .
| |
| 9 8 t 86-2 *N-3 de 8f-1 S 87'-J 87-4 W1
| |
| -2 i M'
| |
| * 56 .k3 66'-4 S Y-1 87k2 ti-3 Sf-4 83 - t Year - Quarter Y ear - M ter
| |
| : 6. Equornent Forced Ot.toges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rate (t) DOO Crited Hours 00 8 I
| |
| e +
| |
| Oo =
| |
| s 1} ,
| |
| 2 2,
| |
| }'-
| |
| kE,~ 4, 5E me a[
| |
| a D **
| |
| 35 ' ~ h!
| |
| gg
| |
| , 2. rs l w_ -- _
| |
| y .. -
| |
| g 4
| |
| &['_r ._ _
| |
| res pe2
| |
| , RO 96-2 96-3 66'-4 Si-1 ' 2 Si-3 Si-a es-1
| |
| - 86-2 86-3 84-4 11.1 87-2 Sf-3 87-4 88 -i Yeor - t er Year - Quar ter I
| |
| 234 g
| |
| | |
| 79;E sc4 VOGTLE 1: Trends
| |
| :fT _
| |
| k' Performance ' Indicators O'C6**d **' " C i
| |
| : 1. Automot;c Scroms Wnve Critical i (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) " pjy j g Eh}'M 122 i
| |
| 2: Scfety System Actuctions (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o l t
| |
| l
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . o f I
| |
| i 4 Sof ety System e -;ures '(2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ' g f' gp
| |
| ' l
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rate (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . .o ;9
| |
| : 6. E,uoment Forced Outoges/OOO Crit Mrs fy 0~
| |
| (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - '"
| |
| -2.5-i.0 -i.5 -i.0 -0.5 0 0 0'5 t'0 1'5 2'.0 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Pk:nt Meens (Meesured in Stonderd Devictions)
| |
| VOGTLE 1: Deviations from Newer Plc t Means Bei w Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Perforrnonce Indicators I-
| |
| : 1. Autor cti(c Scroms While Critical 4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| - t82
| |
| : 2. Sofety System ActWtions (4 Ctt. Avg end 88-1) . 127
| |
| : 3. SigCcont Events (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - -2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaves (4 Ctr Avg end 88-1) . .c g$
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .o.q
| |
| : 6. Equement Forced Outcoes/1000 Crit. Hrs. ~187 (4 Gtr. Avg end 88-1) "
| |
| ' -2.5-2.0 -i.5 -I.0 -0.5 0'O O'.5 t'O l'52.025 Devictions from Newer Plant Meces (Meosured in Stonctord Devictiors) 235
| |
| | |
| O THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK l
| |
| l l
| |
| 236 l
| |
| | |
| o
| |
| =O.=~ ' :. 'C : . ;;CNT o)
| |
| J-Note: This is o comparison of VOGTLE 1 (o newer plant) against older plant means.
| |
| VOGTLE 1: Deviations from Older Plant Mecns Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 4 Olk. vg end 8- ) -9 92
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) i ii
| |
| : 3. Signficont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -ta2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -255 t t l I'
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) a ge j i
| |
| ?
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced tgs/ t I
| |
| -2.5-2'.0 i.5 -lo -0.5 0'O O!5 t'0 15 20 25 Devic'.ic ' from Older Plant Meons (Measured in Stoncord Devictions) s
| |
| | |
| 2 i , .. --- ,
| |
| r-- ,. .. . ,
| |
| t o ..'
| |
| x -
| |
| v' . <va.
| |
| , ll --
| |
| - r -
| |
| '_cC9"C:
| |
| : :e : :-* L e >
| |
| 3,_,.-
| |
| 4 L: rte v s. m L v :
| |
| gg q g gg_j 1 Autom:t c Scrorrs we Cr.ticci : S:fety Sy st ~m i:tuct rs 4 :wo 4 _ :sx
| |
| - ::w a :- ,
| |
| (*~ ~ =
| |
| j----... .
| |
| e3-5L 3 2 . - I'Mg} IA 3. !
| |
| (
| |
| i 4 ''M
| |
| ^=-)
| |
| 6 < \ 6 s . 4 b& I l * - i.40 *' #
| |
| k' l N *2
| |
| ~< : h <l i g ;" ,l3-a 3 2. . -
| |
| aw j 3 32. / l :n 3'-
| |
| QW-M,-
| |
| 3 - ow . / / m; 11 I . ,, 1v l1 l1 ~ .1;
| |
| ,- PN t ts
| |
| * - ,- 1, i
| |
| 5 M r1 1
| |
| N5gr -$ $ - 500 wW
| |
| * ^
| |
| \ f - 2%
| |
| ggy :M o
| |
| " '- 4 _
| |
| o 3 1 '
| |
| E 3 86-2 m3 34-4 8 7- t 6f-2 8 ?-3 87-4 mi S6k 2 m- ) 86'-4 87-i Sf -2 87-3 87-4 +1 Yeor - Quarter vece - Qvyter i
| |
| 3 S oficont Events ,
| |
| 4 Safety System Foues l l
| |
| . 3- g 3.
| |
| Ik jk at -t 3*2-m -
| |
| 2 o'2.
| |
| x 2
| |
| g 55 ,t 5 ,
| |
| i- 4 y i- ,1 x.
| |
| l fl k ?
| |
| 0 . 1 1 9 e4-2 m3 se-4 87-i er-2 e7-3 s?-4 es-i 0
| |
| Y. .
| |
| m 2a6-3 + 4 ei-i ei-2 e7-3 at-4 sa-i Yeor - ouarter Year - ovarw
| |
| : 6. Equnrrent Fcreed Outoges/
| |
| S. Forced Outcyp Rote (t) I)OO Critica sus oo e E 80 . h ;l 5
| |
| *5a w~
| |
| 2&'- '
| |
| .a k'
| |
| -}J 54 w x4 8x
| |
| .g oo - 6j*
| |
| f Sa
| |
| 'O' '
| |
| . s
| |
| ~ 2~ r 'S'
| |
| ~
| |
| 20 - ),,
| |
| + 1 N
| |
| = me Y LS um lw '
| |
| , b b b [] $ $ 3
| |
| ,)UT:'
| |
| m'-s es-3 we s7-i af-2 s7-3 si-4 sa-i so-2 sa'-3 es-4 e7-t t i-2 87-3 e?-* ss $
| |
| t eor - Duartw Yeor - over ty 238
| |
| | |
| TGj .:. 05 .
| |
| iNASH. NUCLEAR 2: Trenas Ceclined trmeo,ec Perforrnonee IndicotorS t Automatic Scroms WW4 Critical gste .
| |
| (2 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - Kg 0 89
| |
| {
| |
| t
| |
| : 2. Sofety .'ystem Actuotoons (2 ' Ctr. Avg end 89-1) f @ ,,3
| |
| : 3. S;gnificent Events (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) . .tg 4 Safety System Fodures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o 37 ,
| |
| l
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (2 Ctr Avg end 88-1) a .o go
| |
| : 6. Equoment Forced Outoaes/1000 Crit. Mrs +
| |
| (2 Otr. Avg en$ 85-1) - h u
| |
| 0 45
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i.5-i0-0500 055 1'O 15 20 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Ott, P!cnt Means (Meosured in Stondord Devictions)
| |
| WASH. NUCLEAR 2: Deviations from Older Plant Mecns l Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf. !
| |
| Perforrnance Indicators f.
| |
| 4 tr. Avg d 8 - ) - -192
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -d.4 6
| |
| : 3. Signficent Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .te2
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . 0 90
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o46
| |
| : 6. Equpment Forced it W tg/ , , _g, I '
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 -t5 -i 0 -U.5 0 0 0'5. t's t'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Ner Plant Mears (Measured in Stc.ndord Ceviations) 239
| |
| | |
| v . ,*1
| |
| -- .w0 3
| |
| -- cm, -
| |
| uS COI 3. '2' ~
| |
| /
| |
| i
| |
| : 6 r' ' F f' ,** ; -) , ,-
| |
| v -
| |
| ,. - -. ,'3-' ' ' ~
| |
| mn co-2 to c8-1
| |
| - m 4 : sy ! ** Qy n-' L,**' ~ ~ ~a g
| |
| 4 t Autometc Scroms Ahe Cr d 2s00 4 2 Scfety Syste Actet vs'
| |
| :w:
| |
| Iw I,,,
| |
| I:o00 ~ e ,! ; ' I g 3.
| |
| s, g/ '% ***.
| |
| g 3_ . ,i, ..~~~ p i
| |
| $%5 \ /9 y Y750 -A \ j t ric
| |
| * f 35
| |
| '
| |
| * s e i 3 l
| |
| MI 4 \- /
| |
| x S ~i ~I Y< \.*'' / d u ',
| |
| , a: .3, 1 l'-d 95o j o32- 2,.
| |
| j ,aq
| |
| ''. .3. 2 - . , ,
| |
| 4j 5
| |
| s
| |
| - roo 3 ao 3 3
| |
| i 2 ?. s 7sc 50 :
| |
| t 3 ''' ~
| |
| ' ' ' - O-
| |
| * s- 1 *
| |
| \ y l N
| |
| ~
| |
| " ~ " ,
| |
| l y p
| |
| ' ~ '' " I l . s $ .'l TEE 0 0
| |
| $ l'3-t 0 36-2 86'-3 96-4 87 1 e7-2 37-3 37-4 88 -1 86'-2 66- 3 66-4 87 t g?-2 57-3 37-4 68 -1 I
| |
| Year - byte t w w:r tu l
| |
| I 3 5<pficant Eve"ts 4 Scfety system raun 4 -.- 4
| |
| .3- g 3.
| |
| -t -t g4 x2. m2.
| |
| a ga
| |
| )$ $ i, 1- -
| |
| 1.,
| |
| N %
| |
| i..
| |
| o sh o . ;
| |
| M l' 86-2 66-3 66-4 67-197-28'-387-4 88 -1 86-2 66-3 66-4 87-1 87-2 87-3 87-4 88-1 Yeor - hty Yeor - Cur t F
| |
| : 6. Ecumnt Forced Cbtoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcqe Rote (t) 000 Critc3 Motis co 8.,
| |
| b M-2bo zUb o g g 00 - o e4, w B*
| |
| -me-S3 2um8 '* - b a
| |
| B
| |
| * . 2-
| |
| % 0 S4 M
| |
| , 2.
| |
| A clntfU7n .
| |
| E, My i .El M o u rn ;
| |
| ~
| |
| Se-2 96-3 $6' 4 81-1 87'-2 87-3 87-4 88-1 86-2 86'-3 96-4 8f-187-2 87-3 87-4 SS - 1 Yeor - Quarter Year - Quor ter 240
| |
| | |
| r+
| |
| . , cvE 4.:c6 "M- ...,~m i;
| |
| y) x l#ATERFORD .3: Trends CecWd wroad Perforrnonce Indicators 1
| |
| L l
| |
| .t SCroms Whi'e Critical LAM -WJ% I $
| |
| t Automotif2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - gj$4dy- Mt j
| |
| .i
| |
| ~i
| |
| - 2...Sofety System Actuotions '(2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o ,
| |
| l
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o l l
| |
| : 4. Safety System Failures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) .
| |
| .q 57 I
| |
| : 5. Forced Cutoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . . o.12
| |
| : 6. Coupment ' Forced u, tog /
| |
| it Hr g ;
| |
| -2.5-10 -1' 5 -t' o -U.5 do d.5 t'0 t5 2'O 25 0 evictions (Measured from Previous in Stoncord 4 Otr. P:ent )Means Devictions
| |
| . WATERFORD 3: Deviations from Older Plant Means B&w Avg. Puf. Abon Avg. PFf.
| |
| Performance Indicators 1
| |
| t Automotig Scroms WMe Critical g4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) --192
| |
| \
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) ut
| |
| : 3. S;gnificant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - oss
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foitures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - oso
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- o.o?
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ gggj, n g7
| |
| -2.5-2' .0 --t5 d.5 0'O OIS t'0 15 2!O 25 Devictions from Older Plont Means (Measured in Stoncord Deviations) i
| |
| *g- 241
| |
| .i
| |
| | |
| m
| |
| ~ , , ,. - - , . . -
| |
| ' ^;
| |
| , , - . . .+mn ,,
| |
| j j j {u:l F-i
| |
| *. ] L*r- \.
| |
| I i LSh$ CI . . . .
| |
| 3
| |
| ;^*
| |
| -,s 1+f M
| |
| ~
| |
| p 0_.9 p0 pq_I m 4 C A't ?' V 2. " 2 1 ;.*
| |
| v s w
| |
| : 1. Automctic Scrorts Whe Cr t.c3 ,
| |
| : 2. S:'ety System A:tu:t crs
| |
| - 22M 2 *3 f' "^'
| |
| ,,,, y ;g -r , /\t f ~~' j ;g . j 3-
| |
| . 17M 2 y 3-l ,,'\
| |
| t 1 ew
| |
| * s
| |
| /
| |
| s' g+ 3 36 g
| |
| ! .l 3
| |
| ! / / - eco - ~It i #
| |
| ! d 5>) ~
| |
| 'h 2 - L .' L.f:h :: \
| |
| l -
| |
| '2% h % 2-l L\ L j' k ':u ,$
| |
| F
| |
| ~, - ~n W 5> i \ .l
| |
| ' ~ ,
| |
| e
| |
| /
| |
| ' s
| |
| --s ' a -
| |
| '" ~s i .
| |
| 4 '
| |
| s
| |
| +-6 b -
| |
| 1 2M
| |
| ,- 2 2
| |
| . i'
| |
| 'h QQ '
| |
| j s% ]i*f" 3 l
| |
| ?y j2W j
| |
| d -
| |
| 1 V I4 o
| |
| @s __ V_ o o s .
| |
| 4 234-3 %'-4 9' ' 47'-2 87'-3 67'-4 SS-t 86'-2 s6 -3 66 -4 t?-i 97-2 87-3 8 7-4 *S - L v w - Quar t e r ear - Oa'r 3 SP ; cont f Events 4 Sofety System Foues a 3. g 3.
| |
| -t -t 0 o 2 2 p2- p1- 5 -
| |
| I A 1- .E. 1- E [ d
| |
| /
| |
| l &
| |
| * l' ~
| |
| ~
| |
| 0 0
| |
| Y f x
| |
| q g
| |
| ^
| |
| 86-2 86'-3 96-4 8Y-18/
| |
| * SI-3 Sf-4 86-1 iA-2 86-3 86-4 81-16f-2 SI-3 87-4 P8-1 Y ear - Qu t er Y eor - Quar t F
| |
| : 6. Ecporvent Ferced Outoges/
| |
| : 5. Forced Outcge Rcte (t) 1000 Cr:tco Motts oc s
| |
| ? k
| |
| * eo
| |
| * 2 s~
| |
| i n.
| |
| a6 8k o!
| |
| -E*I e - a*
| |
| d, ..,..
| |
| y so -
| |
| v 31 }
| |
| 5 5 2-L'!
| |
| 'A!
| |
| n -,
| |
| . 774 '"9%M*885 as) o A LI a, tr o
| |
| =_ IEl O si-2 e6-3 e6-4 ei-i ai-2 )-3 as'-4 as-, e6-2 e6-3 e6'-4 e7-1 sf-2 sf-3 87-4 as-i voor - ovartw vear - ovarte 242
| |
| | |
| J k
| |
| 7;GLPE 4.707 -
| |
| 'WCLF CREEK: Trends
| |
| 'O. Performcnce Indicators C'?*d '"C ' "
| |
| : 1. Automote roms WMe Critical yyg (2 tr. Avg end 88-1) - 332 . g;7gg ga c
| |
| ~
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (* Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . .ox
| |
| : 3. Sig6f> cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| 'kk o t.a .
| |
| 4 Sofety System Foitures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . \1A om
| |
| ' 5. Forced Outo;; Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . -tn
| |
| * I
| |
| : 6. (quement Forced Outo-es/1000 Crit. Hrs. l" -l (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) ~ #fky
| |
| $@%vm l l
| |
| -2.5-2.0-I5 -IO -0 5 OIO OIS l'O 1.5 20 2.5 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Ptnt Veers (Measured in Stoncord Devictions)
| |
| WOLF CREEK: Deviations from Older Plant Means Bebw Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf, Performance Indicators 1 S ,
| |
| Automoti[4 broms WMe Criticaltr. Avg end 88-1) - -246
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1) . 2 c2
| |
| : 3. Sigmficent Events (4 Ctr. Avg end 88 :) . o gg
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foaures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .O.48 t
| |
| : 5. Forsed Outoge Rote (4 Ott. Avg end 88-1) . .o.go
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced tog / Cjit ,
| |
| -2.5-2' 0 I.5 -iO -0.5 0'O Oh I'O 15 20 25 Devictions from Older Pbnt Veens (Meossed in Stonderd Devictions) 243
| |
| | |
| r y,-, -- ~-
| |
| .mq-rm r.- .
| |
| - , ,j- ,
| |
| ( d ,e _Rf 'i L O ^ O '^ r' ' C.;e* O ;- + 4 , 3. - 2
| |
| , , -_, ..,.,L ! ' s (/ ,j ',,f !
| |
| , L- v y ~ s. ,
| |
| -. ,,t ; -- j $
| |
| S A , ")
| |
| -# *O Q9 vo_1 8MMEN 4 C Or t er WN ' } 4. ?' 2 1 Autometc Scres Ave Critco: 25m 4 2 Safety system Actxticas
| |
| :s:e i
| |
| 22M 4; N ,
| |
| gc~'
| |
| . - - . -+% . . . . . . , , - . . , , ,
| |
| - 2cCO : q p
| |
| =
| |
| f 3. 3. -k /
| |
| l .7w ss0 _ nM 1 / l 3 -3 ) i 1 3}
| |
| t
| |
| - eco d' i <t
| |
| \s ,i Ju~} e O
| |
| m2. 1 / 2 CM -f om2 f OM j - ;
| |
| l;g - e -
| |
| j 3- / " ?, ,i ."?!
| |
| / ry -
| |
| O e V I . '30 %
| |
| O ' ''V I
| |
| t% v1(-
| |
| : t. .
| |
| d,4M y 1 500 t.
| |
| 4 } SM gNg
| |
| . 4 e h s a . 23c Q? 1Q j:x e
| |
| + '-
| |
| . o L 1 J, .
| |
| 86-2 W ) 86'-4 $7 1 $7-2 $7-3 87-4 WI
| |
| ~
| |
| 86-2 S6'-3 $6-4 Si-1 $7-2 87-3 ST-4 88 -9 l Ye7 - Quarter Yey - Quar t y 1 Spf+ cont Eveats ,
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Foives e 3. g 3.
| |
| -t -t
| |
| .4 g4 m2- m2. -
| |
| * U ;
| |
| ; . +''
| |
| 1 t- l
| |
| , ;hge h
| |
| I 0 o W2 86'-3 S6-4 81-167'-2 6f-3 SI-4 W1 66-2 66'-3 66-4 8p-1 a7'-2 Si-3 87-4 88 - t voor - ouartv Year - buarter
| |
| : 6. Eau ntCr,tco r orcedMoes outose/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcge Rote (s) 1 m 8
| |
| ^ k e
| |
| 5 so .
| |
| 3 3 Ek k~ .
| |
| s 4t So _
| |
| !! l B* t
| |
| -3 m *>4
| |
| -p U U
| |
| 4o - 6 7w
| |
| * , 2.
| |
| 8
| |
| % i c,e~ o s, ~n,W 2 o n F1 e p 3 C m --' '
| |
| : a. m- - pg j rj F o_= em _2 c~ _- a o -
| |
| 06'-2 W3 86-4 87-1 87'-2 37'-3 87'-4 W1 56-2 W 3 96-4 81-1 87-2 87'-3 87'-4 88 I Y ear - Quar ter Yeor - Quarter 244 l
| |
| l l
| |
| t r
| |
| l l
| |
| | |
| N1 4 ncCPE: 4.:ca
| |
| %"i ,' ,_ _
| |
| 3 ..
| |
| }
| |
| YANKEE -ROWE: Trends f'y U: Performance Indicators C '** d I";'0**0
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scroms WNe Cnticot
| |
| ' (2 Otr. Avg u,d 88-1) - 0
| |
| : 2. Sof ety' System Actuotions (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . (- ff o jo - i
| |
| : 3. Signficent Events (2 Ott, Avg end 88-1) - o 4 Sofety System Foues (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1)
| |
| : 5. Forced - Outoge Rete (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . : 0.07 !
| |
| . .l
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced Outoces/900 Cnt. Hrs M (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) * *0 90w: @f ~. t
| |
| -2.5-2.0-i5 -I.0 -0.5 0 0 0'S ~ 1l0 t'S 2'.02.5
| |
| ' Devictions from Prevous 4 Otr. P'cnt Vecos (Measured to Ston&d Cevictiers)
| |
| YANKEE-ROWE: Deviations from ~ Older Plant Means Performance indicators Bebw Avg. Puf. Abon Avg. Puf. ,
| |
| : 1. Automotic Scrcms WMe Criticol (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -032
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions (4 Ctr. Avg end 88-1)- -046
| |
| : 3. Significent Events (4 Otr. Avg end SS-1) .
| |
| - o 9a
| |
| : 4. Sofety System Fohes (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c.90
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c $2
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tog / ,
| |
| -2.5-2' O-i5 I.0 -d.5 0'0 0'S l'0 I!5 2'O 25 Deviations from Oder Plent Mecns (Mecstred in Stondord Devic'icns) 245 f
| |
| .., m,- ,m-.v - , . . . . - , , - . , , . . ,-
| |
| | |
| s~- .~s l
| |
| I 1 4 .-.--
| |
| N' 4 ,e , C P C v' ~ 39- : , -
| |
| * L , .m
| |
| * I ul I {s\
| |
| ; il -
| |
| ',rit 0 ;i *0 r 5 o- ,, m 4 Cv: te V3 ; t.e*:;e A_7 tv p2_1
| |
| ' Automat c Scrores Abe Crited 2. Safety System Actwt ces 4 :sco 4 30c l WA p.-
| |
| - 22M ,,,,,,,,,
| |
| ,\
| |
| j j j -
| |
| 2 coo j 3-
| |
| [ 4:xoI l 3- g s
| |
| ?
| |
| I fj s - '750 y r=A j
| |
| - 3 -3 .'
| |
| dI ' 1 5 200 =' j w "% l j <! i
| |
| \
| |
| _< g O
| |
| w2- o ba2d t' d CM $ * ,j b
| |
| 750 .h l
| |
| - M3 I 4W3
| |
| .4 V i
| |
| ; ee i,- e
| |
| : f. ,w 4 500 L
| |
| - 150 ; :50
| |
| .I 2:: 0 0
| |
| \? f 0 l 0 ~
| |
| 86-2 66 - 3 66 -4 SY-t si-2 Sf-3 8/-4 88-1 66-256-3864 8i-1 ef-2 Lf-3 87 4 68 -1 Year - Quarter Year - QArter
| |
| : 3. S71if' , cont Eveats ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System Foiaes
| |
| . 3. g 3-k$ 5 g2. g2- J
| |
| '- A f
| |
| l f, 7 A Ny
| |
| _ #$y - ,
| |
| + 1 t
| |
| - s' Lo e6-2 ess ei-4 si-i ai-2 si-3 ei-4 s8-i e6'-2 e6' 3 e6'-4 ai-i ai-2 si-3 e7-4 so-i Yeor - Quarter Year - Quarter
| |
| : 6. Eau nt Forced Cbtoges/
| |
| 5 Forceo Outcge Rote (2) Critical Hous ice 9 M-3 3*-
| |
| ac ! so . 31
| |
| }<
| |
| ~>
| |
| a<
| |
| *x4 b ee g 43 .
| |
| o B
| |
| * 2.
| |
| 1 % l_M _ .- o y, m , 2 i I
| |
| 0 :_ o - -
| |
| $6-2 86-3 56'-4 8/-1 ti-2 Si-3 87-4 88-1 96-2 66-3 86-4 87-1 Si-2 ti-3 87 4 58 -1 Yeor - Oater Year - Quarter 246 1
| |
| | |
| ::GM cC3 y
| |
| Z!ON 1: Trends-Performcnce Indicators O'C*d - i'Wo*
| |
| i
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical av (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -054 JM
| |
| = ,
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotbns (2 Qtr. Avg end $8-1) . gg o .j !
| |
| - (p <
| |
| i 3.' S;gnif; cont Events (2' Ctr. Avg end 88-1) - o S8 t
| |
| 4 Sof ety System Foiiures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . ..{ o ga -{ ~
| |
| m I 5: Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - 4 36
| |
| : 6. Equement' Forced it 0
| |
| togs / , ,
| |
| -2 3-10 -i.5 -I.0 -d.5 0.0 0'S 1/0 1'5 2'O 25 Devictions from Previous 4 Otr. Piont Meons (Measured in Stondord Cevictions)
| |
| ZION 1: Deviations from Older Plant Means Performance Indicators O'D* AV9' Nf ^D " ^"9 #'''-
| |
| : 1. Automatic Scroms While Critical c2s (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotions '(4 Otr. Asg end 88-1)- c.33
| |
| : 3. Significont Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - -o42
| |
| . 4. Sofety System Fodures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1)- ci$
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rote (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - c.72
| |
| : 6. Equipment Forced it tg/ , g3, i-
| |
| -2.5-io-i.5 MO -d,5 0'O O'S l'O l'5 2'O 2 5 Oevictions from Oider Piont
| |
| * Aeons (Mecsured in Stondvd Devictions) l
| |
| | |
| - w-i , ; - - .
| |
| ! i amg : --,
| |
| I
| |
| .' . ,\ '
| |
| * I * ,a ;,e~ ,
| |
| l_
| |
| ^
| |
| !& Jl 'e -2~'' '
| |
| ',* } . ,,
| |
| a ,-0 a ,< 0 y2_1 ===mus 4 Cv:r t er v:, r; v :e v ,
| |
| t Autometc Scres Ahe Cr,tcot 2 Scf ety System a:txt cas 4 :sco 4 ::x l
| |
| 22 9 a ::sc
| |
| ,- ....* { j
| |
| ~., - foco ~ e '~.,, '-
| |
| sI :3x { ;
| |
| )
| |
| : 3. /, f 3-j 'sc ^?
| |
| SL / - i?so ,
| |
| 5 / 3 3 31 d{
| |
| ~<
| |
| i / - soo *"
| |
| $ <I !
| |
| e . 90 ~^ l
| |
| * { [ j' y 2-a
| |
| [ t -
| |
| Gso~h oy2- \
| |
| \
| |
| 4i ':53 } '
| |
| - DOC 3 h~ \ l N GG 3 m 4 \ ,
| |
| t a% 1*i I 2 '% 7so v2 { j i 1 7 / i- 1 1 / l r - SCO 8
| |
| : . !G-x /& ! b fA \. fl - 2w ' k so 1 l$ .k o ' 0 0 l3 '
| |
| 7 , . . . . , .
| |
| 86-2 W3 $6-4 57-1 87-2 57-3 87-4 68-i 86-2 86-3 84-4 07-i 97-2 87-3 87-4 68 -i voor - Quarty YeOr - Quart er 3 SP cont 0 Evects ,
| |
| 4 Sofety System roues
| |
| . 3- 3 3.
| |
| lk jk at
| |
| -t e-m2- 2 2
| |
| -x2 ,
| |
| m>
| |
| f f g.i N4M t-n
| |
| ~4 sh o . .
| |
| 56-2 86kJ 86ke 07-t 87'-2 07-3 87'-4 86-1 e6'-2 86' -
| |
| 3 86'-4 47-i 87-2 87-3 07-4 86 -i yeor - Quertv v eor - ovar tw
| |
| : 6. Ecp t Forces %toges/
| |
| 5 Forced Outcge Rote (s) Cr.tco Moos oo a
| |
| ? M- E ;
| |
| 5
| |
| * }* eo ~ l} '
| |
| $E a
| |
| j
| |
| -[4 74 dy g to -
| |
| o 5
| |
| w w 2.
| |
| ~
| |
| % o_os;;;
| |
| o s
| |
| _ - W s
| |
| o
| |
| =
| |
| e6-2 e6-3 e6-4 s,-i a7-2 ni-3 ei-4 as-i e6'-2 e6'-3 86-4 e r-i ai-2 sf-3 87-4 sa-i year - Duartw Y eor - buar tv vs q l _
| |
| | |
| ~
| |
| r F G RE. 4.UC
| |
| -ZION 2: Trends-
| |
| * ' C'0 *.d "'C"O Performance Indicaters #
| |
| i
| |
| : t. Automotic $croms whPe Cribcol (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuotior s (2 Otr Avg end 88-1)- o 1
| |
| 3 Signf; cont Events (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o 4 Sofety System FoBures (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . o l .
| |
| l I f
| |
| : . 4yYd?T"* g 5 Forced Outoge Rote (2 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - ki%r*;t,w. ... -231 vg a s .
| |
| 6 Equement Forced Outenes/1000 Crit. Mrs.
| |
| (2 dtr. Avg end 88-1) - -C M
| |
| -2.5-i.0-iS lo -d.5 OLO OIS t'0 1'5 2'O 25 0 evictions from Previous 4 Ote. Piont veons '
| |
| (Measured in Stonderd Cevktions)
| |
| ' ZION 2: Deviations from Older Plant Means Below Avg. Perf. Above Avg. Perf.
| |
| Performance Indicators t
| |
| ; 1. Automatic fatoms Whae Critical 128 (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - >
| |
| : 2. Sofety System Actuations (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - tu 3 Sigenficant Events (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) . .
| |
| og 4 Sofety System Fo. lures (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) a o so
| |
| : 5. Forced Outoge Rete (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) - o30 !
| |
| : 6. Eavgment Forced Outooes/1000 Crit. Hrs, 03' j (4 Otr. Avg end 88-1) -
| |
| f-
| |
| -2.5-2' 0 i $ -IO -0 5 0'O O'S 1l0 15 20 25 Ouctions from Oider Piont ueons
| |
| . (Mecsured in Stendord Cevictions) 249 l
| |
| ,-,.,,,,_ , m_ , , , . - _ - -
| |
| . , . . . _ , . , , , , , . , - , , . . ,.-.,.,,,.-_,,m.--r,_q y , 7_-,w . --. - -- em-, - - - -
| |
| | |
| I f t' -
| |
| O THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK 9
| |
| 0 0
| |
| | |
| 951 - '
| |
| O
| |
| :+
| |
| , ANNUAL INDUSTRY AVERAGES t
| |
| e h
| |
| k 9
| |
| [
| |
| i O .
| |
| l 1
| |
| | |
| r L E .:
| |
| i AnnUCl nCMif j d/6f0COS Excluding P!Cnts Snutdan G34 to G57 I
| |
| L Aviernctc Recctor 7rts l Ane Cr4tco 2. Sc'ety systern Actet.c s l l l \
| |
| i : i l y6. -3.
| |
| I s 24 s 22 0
| |
| 0 4 41 1 j'_ 'a b2_ 2 22 l
| |
| ; 3
| |
| : 2. 1 0--- . . . .
| |
| 0- .
| |
| 584 1985 1986 1987 1984 1985 1936 '987 i
| |
| Yeer Yece 4 3. Sigrnficont Events 4. Scfety System Fou .5 C
| |
| I 2 !
| |
| a 3. 56.
| |
| t 2 l g 2* l T, *e 4~ !
| |
| E' g, ,
| |
| 3 54 I@ l
| |
| _ 0 G84 G85 G86 G87 G84 $85 1986 GS7 i Year Year l
| |
| l l
| |
| J l
| |
| l 252 1
| |
| l l
| |
| l l l l
| |
| | |
| =' M i s ''1 Annual ;ncustry A. erages .
| |
| E*.clucing Plants 5' n ut00wn NS4 to 1937 l
| |
| 6 E;v: ment Force: LE::ges/
| |
| 5 F:<ced Outcge R::e (s) ,
| |
| CCO Cr tco mss i i 7" 35 _ !
| |
| $ I i
| |
| 3.
| |
| f30 5 h l 3 25 - o ,
| |
| 7 20 _ 2
| |
| .l
| |
| $ h_ ,
| |
| " 15 .
| |
| t n "8 is h is e.
| |
| a 1984 1985 1956 $87 1984 1985 1986 1957 Year Year 7 Pocation Exposae (Man-REM / Year)
| |
| ' 80U -
| |
| 2 q m 3
| |
| y 600 _ sr, w
| |
| i
| |
| }
| |
| x w.
| |
| 6 i D I E 200.
| |
| 1984 G85 1986 1987 Year l
| |
| i i
| |
| l 25.3 I
| |
| i J
| |
| | |
| .,.I
| |
| \<
| |
| Part II of II O
| |
| Performance Indicators for Operating Commercial Nuclear Power Reactors Part II J
| |
| _ Quarterly Report, May 1988 Data through March 1988 Office for Analysis and Evaluation of Operational Data William Burton Patricia Lonneman Neil Naraine Thomas Wolf O
| |
| m.
| |
| | |
| pv ABSTRACT This Nuclear Regulatory Comission (NRC/ Commission) report provides per#ormance indicator data through March 31,1988 for 110 operating comercial nuclear power plants. The data are taken from licensee event reports submitted in accordance with 10 CFR 50.73, licensee telephone reports made to the NRC Operations Center in accordance with 10 CFR 50.72, and Itcensee monthly operating report data submitted under 10 CFR 50. The report addresses six indicators that were initially approved for implementation in the NRC's performance indicator program: automatic scrams while critical; safety system actuations; significant events; safety system failures; forced outage rate; and equipment forced outages per 1000 critical hours. The quarterly data for the seventh indicator, collective radiation exposure, are in the process of being obtained. Meanwhila, exposure data on an annual basis are provided in Part II of this report.
| |
| This report is in two parts. The first part provides the plant sumary and analysis charts. The second part provides detailed data tables as well as a description of the report contents.
| |
| The NRC's performance indicator program provides an objective view of specific .
| |
| aspects of operational performance of plants and enhances the staff's ability to recognize changes in their safety perfomance. It is only a tool. In conjunction with other information, it provides an input to managemen'.
| |
| decisions regarding the need to adjust plant-specific regulatory programs.
| |
| O i
| |
| | |
| CONTENTS PART II Page L I ST O F T A B L E S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1 1 5* DETAILED DEFINITIONS OF INDICATORS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 5.1 Au toma t i c Sc rams Whi l e Cri t i ca 1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 5.2 S a f e ty Sy s t em A c tu a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 5.3 Si g n i f i c a n t Eve n ts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
| |
| 5.4 S a f e ty Sy s t e m F a i l u re s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... . . . . . . . 4. . . . . . . . . . . 2 5.5 Fo rc ed Ou ta g e R a t e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 5.6 Equipment Forced Outages per 1000 Critical Hours. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
| |
| 5.7 Collec t i ve Radia t ion Exposure. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5 . . . . . 5 6
| |
| PRECAUTIONS........................................................ 5 7 ANNUAL COLLECTIVE RADIATION E7POSURE DATA.......................... 6 8
| |
| C OM P U T A T I O N A L N 0 T E S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 9 REVISION OF DATA CONTAINED IN THE FEBRUARY 1988 REPORT............. 7 10 TABULAR LISTING OF PL ANT EVENTS - FOURTH QUARTER 1987 AND FIRST QUARTER 1988.................................................... 11 11 TABULAR LISTING OF RADIATION EXPOSURE, OVERALL INDUSTRY SUvPARY, AND CRITICAL HOURS DATA..........................................[ ]
| |
| * Sections 1 through 4 are in Part I cf this report.
| |
| O 11 I
| |
| | |
| il LIST OF TABLES - PART il
| |
| ) PEVISIONS TO FEBRUARY 1988 REPORT TABLE 9.1 - REVISIONS TO AUT0HATIC SCRAMS WHILE CRITICAL TABLE 9.2 - REVISION TO SCRAMS ABOVE 15% POWER PER 1000 CRITICAL HOURS TABLE 9.3 . REVISIONS TO SCRAMS SELOW 15 POWER TABLE 9.4 - REVISIONS TO SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS TABLE 9.5 - REVISIONS TO SIGNIFICANT EVENTS TABLE 9.6 - REVISIONS TO SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES TABLE 9.7 REVISIONS TO FORCED OUTAGE RATE PLANT EVENTS - FOURTH QUARTFR 1987 AND FIRST QUARTER 1988 TABLE 10.1 - ARKANSAS 1 TABLE 10.2 - ARKANSAS 2 TABLE 10.3 - BEAVER VALLEY 1 '
| |
| TABLE 10.4 - BEAVER VALLEY 2 TABLE 10.5 - BIG ROCK POINT TABLE 10.6 - EP.AIDWOOD 1 TABLE 10.7 - BRAIDWD00 2 1 TABLE 10.8 - BROWNS FERRY 1 TABLE 10.9 - EROWNS FERRY 2 TABLE 10.10 - BROWNS FERRY 3 TABLE 10.11 - BRUNSWICK 1 TABLE 10.12 - BRUNSWICK 2 -
| |
| TABLE 10.13 - EYRON 1 !
| |
| TABLE 10.14 - BYRON 2 TABLE 10.15 - CALLAWAY TABLE 10.16 - CALVERT CLIFFS 1 TABLE 10.17 - CALVERT CLIFFS 2 TABLE 10.18 - CATAWBA 1 TABLE 10.19 - CATAWBA 2 TABLE 10.'0 - CLINTON 1 TABLE 10.21 - CC0K 1 TABLE 10.22 - C004 2 TABLE 10.23 - COOPER STATION TABLE 10.24 - CRYSTAL RIVER 3 TABLE 10.25 - DAVIS-BESSE TABLE 10.26 - DIABLO CANYON 1 TABLE 10.27 - DIABLO CANYON 2 TABLE 10.28 - DRESDEN 2 TABLE 10.29 - DRESDEN 3 TABLE 10.30 - DUANE ARNOLO iii
| |
| | |
| ^
| |
| (
| |
| LISTOFTABLES-PARTII(CONTINUE 01 PLANTEVENT!i-FOUpTH_ QUARTER 1987ANDFIRSTQUARTER1988(CONTINUED)
| |
| TABLE 10.31 - FARLEY 1 TABLE 10.32 - FARLEY 2 TABLE 10.33 - FERMI 2 TABLE 10.34 - FITZPATRICK TABLE 10.35 - FORT CALHOUN TABLE 10.36 - FORT ST. VRAIN TABLE 10.57 - GINNA TABLE 10.38 - GRAND GULF TABLE 10.39 - HADDAM NECK TABit 10.40 - HATCH 1 TABLE 10.41 - HATCH 2 TABLE 10.42 - HOPE CREEK' TABLE 10.43 - INDIAN POINT 2 TABLE 10.44-- INDIAN POINT 3 TABLE 10.45 - XEWAUNEE TABLE 10.46 - LASALLE 1 TABLE 10.47 - LASALLE 2 TABLE 10.48 - LIMERICX TABLE 10.49 - MAINE YANKEE TABLE 10.50 - MCGUIRE 1 TABLE 10.51 - MC6UIRE 2 TABLE 10.52 - MILLSTONE 1 TABLE 10.53 - MILLSTONE 2 TABLE 10.54 - MILLSTONE 3 TABLE 10.55 - MONTICELLO TABLE 10.56 - NINE HILE PT.1 TABLE 10.S7 - NINE MILE PT. 2 ~
| |
| TABLE 10.53 - NORTH ANNA 1 TABLE 10.59 - NORTH ANNA 2 TABLE 10.60 - OCONEE 1 TABLE 10.61 - OCONEE 2 TABLE 10.62 - OCONEE 3 TABLE 10.63 - OYSTER CREEK TABLE 10.64 - PALISADES TABLE 10.65 - PALO VERDE 1 TABLE 10.66 - PALO VERDE 2 TABLE 10.67 --PALO VERDE 3
| |
| -TABLE 10.68 - PEACF B0TTOM 2 TABLE 10.69 -. PEACH BOTTOM 3 TABLE 10.70 - PEPRY TABLE-10.71 - PILGRIM TABLE 10.72 - POINT BEACH 1 TABLE 10.73 - POINT BEACH 2 TABLE 10.74 - PRAIRIE ISLAND 1 TABLE 10.75 - PRAIRIE ISLA.10 2 TABLE 10.76 - QUAD CITIES 1 O
| |
| iY
| |
| | |
| , ~ .
| |
| kg ' -
| |
| LIST OF TABLES - PART II (CONTINUED)
| |
| () PLANT EVENTS - FOURTH-QUARTER 1987 AND FIRST QUARTER 1988 (CONTINUED)
| |
| TABLE 10.77.- QUAD CITIES 2 TABLE 10.78 - RANCHO SECO
| |
| " TABLE 10.79 - RIVER-BEND TABLE 10.80 - ROBINSON 2 TABLE 10.81 - SALEM 1 TABLE 10.82 - SALEM 2 TABLE 10.83 - SAN ON0FRE 1 TABLE 10.84 - SAN ONOFRE 2 TABLE 10.85 - SAN ON0FRE 3 TABLE 10.86 - SEABROOK TABLE-10.87 - SEQUOYAH 1 TABLE 10.88 - SEQUOYAHt2 TABLE 10.89 '' EARON HARRIS TA8LE 10.90 - $HORELAM TABLE 10.91 - SOUTH TEXAS TABLE 10.92 - ST. LUCIE 1 TABLE 10.93 - ST. LUCIE 2 TABLE 10.94 - SUMMER TABLE 10.95 - SURRY l TABLE 10.96 - SURRY 2 TABLE 10.97 - SUSQUEHANNA 1 TABLE 10.98 - SUSQUEHANNA 2 TABLE 10.99 - THREE MILE ISLAND 1 TABLE 10.100 - TROJAN TABLE 10.101 - TURKEY POINT 3 TABLE 10.102 - TURKEY POINT 4
| |
| * TABLE 10.103 - VERMONT YANKEE TABLE 10.104 - V0GTLE -
| |
| TABLE 10.105 - WASH. NUCLEAR 2 TABLE 10.106 - WATERFORD 3 TABLE 10.107 - WOLF CREEK TABLE 10.108 - YANKE -R0WE TABLE 10.109 - ZION 1 TABLE 10.110 - ZION 2 V
| |
| | |
| LIST OF TABLES - PART II (CONTINUED)
| |
| O COLLECTIVE RADI ATION EXPOSURE, PERFORMANCE INDICATORS, AND CRITICAL HOURS TABLE 11.1 - COLLECTIVE RADIATION EXPOSURE - ANNUAL DATA TABLE 11.2 - COLLECTIVE RADIATION EXPOSURE - THREE YEAR MOVING AVERAGE TABLE 11.3 - OVERALL INDUSTRY
| |
| | |
| ==SUMMARY==
| |
| | |
| . TABLE 11.4 - AUTOMATIC SCRAMS WHILE CRITICAL TABLE 11.5 - SCRAMS ABOVE 15% / 1000 CRITICAL HOURS
| |
| . TABLE 11.6 - SCRAMS BELOW 15% POWER TABLE 11.7 - SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS TABLE 11.8 - SIGNIFICANT EVENTS TABLE,11.9 - SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES TABLE 11.10 - FORCED OUTAGE RATE TABLE 11.11 - EQUIPMENT FORCEO OUTAGES / 1000 CRITICAL HOURS TABLE 11.12 - CRITICAL HOURS-e e
| |
| vi
| |
| | |
| I p)
| |
| L 5- DETAILEC DEFINITIONS OF INDICATORS The definitions of the seven indicators currently in the program are:
| |
| 5.1 Automatic Scrams while Critical (Scrams)
| |
| (1A) Total Scrams Total scrams are the number of unplanned automatic scrams while the reactor is critical. This indicator is the same as the corresponding INP0 indicator.
| |
| Examples of the types of scrams included in the total are those that result from unplanned transients, equipment failures, spurious signals, or human error.
| |
| Also included in the total number of scrarts are those that occur during the execution of procedures in which there is a high chance of a scram occurring, l but the occurrence of the scram is nnt planned. Scram data are primarily derived from Licensee Event Peport (L6R) information and are supplemented as necessary from 10. CFR 50.72 reports. The reactor is considered "critical" if the report states so. Otherwise, criticality is detennined from the review of the information (18) Scrams Above 15 Percent Power per 1000 Critical Hours I This subset of total scrams includes the automatic scrams occurring above 15 percent reactor power per 1000 hours of critical operation.
| |
| (IC) Scraras at or Below 15 Percent Power I This subset of total scrams includes the automatic scrams occurring while the reactor is at or below 15 percent power.-
| |
| 5.2 Safety System Actuations (SSA)
| |
| Safety system actuations are actuations of the emergency core cooling system (ECCS, actual or spurious) and the emergency ac power system (actual, in response _to low voltage on a safety bus). This indicator is the same as the corresponding INP0 indicator. Input fnr this indicator is derived from LERs and is supplenented by 10 CFR 50.72 reports.
| |
| In determining wha: items should be included in the data for this indicator, the fvilowing conventions are used:
| |
| Only actuations of the high pressure injection system, low pressure injection system, or safety injection tanks are counted for pressurized water ceactors (PWRs). For boiling water reactors (BWRs), only actuations of the high pressure coolant injection system, the low pressure coolant injection system, the high pressure core spray system, or the low pressure
| |
| , core spray system are counted. No actuations of the reactor core isolation cooling system are counted.
| |
| Actuations of emergency ac power systems that result from loss of power to i
| |
| Q,s a safeguards bus are captured primarily on the basis of indication:, of inw
| |
| ( voltage signals in the emergency power system.
| |
| l 1
| |
| l These data are available as supplemental indicator data 9 Tables 11.5 and 11.6.
| |
| | |
| s .
| |
| -2 Actuations of any of the equipment associated with the tpecific ECCS or O
| |
| emergency ac power system are considered-necessary 3d sufficient to constitute a data count. For example, if only a valve in a system is commanded to move to its emergency operational position, this is counted as-an actuation. A pump does not have to be coninanded to go to its emer-gency mode of operation, or fluid does not need to be injected for an occurrence to be counted.
| |
| Only-one ECCS actuation is counted in any one occurrence, even if multiple ECCS systems actuate during the occurrence. For example, actuation of both
| |
| '5e high pressure injection and the low pressure injection systems at a PPR during the same occurrence counts as only a single ECCS actuation for that occurrence.
| |
| Only one Emergency Diesel Generatur (EDG) actuation is counted in any one occurrence, even _if multiple EDGs ictuate during the occurrance. For example, actuation of all four EDGs at a unit counts as only a single EDG actuation for that occurrence.
| |
| Occurrences involving actuations of both an EDG on a dead bus and an ECCS are given a count of two, ola for the EDG actuation and one for the ECCS
| |
| , actuation.
| |
| At multi-unit sites that share equipment (e.g., swing EDG or shared buses),
| |
| actuations are counted and assigned to the unit at which the actuation signal or loss of power originated. If the signal source cannot be determined to be associated with one unit, the actuation is assigned to both units. .
| |
| 5.3 Significant Events SE)
| |
| Significant events are those events identified by NRC staff through the detailed screening and evaluation of operating experience. The screening process includes the daily review and discussion of all reported operating reactor events and operational data, such as special tests being conducted or construc-tion activity.
| |
| An event identified from the screening process as a candidate significant event
| |
| . is further evaluated to determine if an actual or potential threat to the health
| |
| , and safety of the public is involved. Specific examples of the types of criteria are summarized as follows:
| |
| (1) Degradation of impcrtant safety equipment. Events that will be considered
| |
| 'under this classif: cation include situations where either there existed the potential for er there was an actual reduction in the operational capability of equipw nt. One example is, identification of a couraen catise failure mechanism which could cause redundant components or multiple inde-pendent componct.*s to fail in response to a test or actual demand signal.
| |
| This category would not include such items as a missed surveillance test during which the equipment was suosequently tested and determined to be operable. h
| |
| | |
| -1 l
| |
| ( ,/
| |
| (2) Unexpected plant response to a transient. Events that will be considered under this classification include situations in which changes in reactor parameters represent unanticipated reductions in margins of safety. For example, a rapid plant cooldown following a reactor trip exacerbated by a balance-of-plant malfunction or an undesirable systems interaction. This category would not include minor differences in predicted and observed conditions that can be reasonably explained by iristrument errors or modeling techniques and simplifying assumptions.
| |
| (3) Degradation of fuel integrity, primary coolant pressure boundary, or important associated structures. Events considered under this category
| |
| ~
| |
| would include those of similar character to events identified in item 1, above, related to the fuel, Reactor Coolant System (RCS), containment, or important plant structures. -
| |
| (4) Scran with complication. The event is an RPS actuation, when critical, followea by an equipment failure, malfunction, or perNnnel error. The failure, malfunction, or error is generally not to P clude those that cause the transient that leads to the RPS actuatior 3r those that directly cause the scram. Failures that both cause the scram and reduce the capability of the mitigating system (e.g., electric power, instrument air, other auxiliary support functions, or deficient procedures) will be coun ted.
| |
| Examples of eg'uipment failure / malfunctions include:
| |
| : a. Mitigating system failures - loss of redundancy due to single fail-ure, reduced capacity, or margin. This includes components or trains out of service for maintenance,
| |
| : b. Failure adding to complexity of event - erroneous control system
| |
| ~ responses, electrical switching difficulties, mitigating system and key plant parameter instrumentation malfunctions / failures.
| |
| : c. Additional event initiators - stuck-open primary or secondary relf ef/
| |
| safety valves, pipe breaks, and operating wrong equiprnent/ trains.
| |
| Examples of personnel errors include:
| |
| : a. improper control or termination of mitigating system
| |
| : b. misdiagnosis of the event or failure to follow procedures In addition to the situatiuns described in items 1-4, above, other broad categories considered as significant events include:
| |
| (5) Unplanned release of radioactivity. Events considered under this category include an unplanned release of radioactivity that had the potential for exceeding or actually exceeded the limits of the Technical Specifications or the regulations.
| |
| | |
| 'f' Operation Outside the Limits of the Technical Specifications. Events that O
| |
| will ha considered under this classification include situations for which planc operation was conducted inconsistent with the license requirements.
| |
| This category would apply to risk-sionificant deviations and most likely would not include an incident involving a missed surveillance, small errors in setpofmts, or other administratively inoperable conditions.
| |
| (7) Other. For example, a series of events or recurring incidents that when considered collectively represent ineffective corrective actions, or a deficiency in the plant hardware or administrative programs.
| |
| 5.4 Safety System Failures (SSF)
| |
| Safety syrtem failures are any events or conditions that, by themselves, could prevent fulfillment of the safety function for structures or systems, If a system consists of multiple redundant subsystem or trains, failure of all trains constitutes a safety system failure. Faf'ure o' one of two or more trains is not counted as a safety system failure. The definition for the indi-cator parallels NRC reporting requirements in 10 CFR 50.72 and 10 CFR 50.73.
| |
| The following list gives the major systens and subsystems which are monitored for this indicator:
| |
| Reactor Trip System and Instrumentat on Engineered Safety Features Instrumentation Recirculation. Pump Trip Actuation Instrumentation (BWR)
| |
| Accident Monitoring Instrumentation Radiation Monitoring Instrumentation Reactor Coolant System Safety Valves Emergency Core Cooling Systems Auxiliary (and Emergency) Feedwater System (PWR) l Reactor Core Isolation Cooling System (BWR)
| |
| Isolation Condenser (8WR) l Standby Liquid Control System (BWR)
| |
| Fain Steam Line Isolation Valves Como0 neat Cooling Water System Essential or Emergency Service Water Ultimate Heat Sink Control Room Emergency Ventilation System Onsite Emergency AC and DC Power and Associated Distribution Containment and Containment Isclation Containment Coolant Systems Residual Heal Removal Systems Combustible Gas Control Fire Detection and Suppression Systems low Temperature 0,erpressure Protection (PWR)
| |
| Spent Fuel Systems Essential Compressed Air Systems e
| |
| | |
| ,m LI 5.5 Forced dutace Rate (FOR)
| |
| Forced outages are those required by the end of the weekend following the discovery of an off-normal condition. The forced outa0e rate is the number of forced outage hours divided by the sum of unit service hours (i.e., generator i on-line-hours) and forced outage hours. This indicator is the same as that I used by INPO and in the NRC monthly operating report. The data are generally obtained from the monthly operating reports. In some cases when the reports are 'not available, the data are obtained directly from the licensees. J 5.6 Equipment Forced Outages per 1000 Critical Hours (FF0)
| |
| This indicator is the number of forced outages caused by equipment failures per 1000 hours of reactor operation while critical. It is the inverse of the mean time between forced outages caused by equipment failures. The inverse number was adopted to facilitate calculation and display. The source of these data is the same as that for the forced outage rate.
| |
| 5.7 Collective Radiation Exposure This indicator is the total radiation dose at the site for a given period. To obtain unit valves, the site total is divided by the number of units at the site contributing to the radiation exposure. This indicator is the same as that of INP0. 1987 value are preliminary, pending NRC staff review.
| |
| 6 PRECAUTIONS The data for this report were obtained from NRC sources and were reviewed by NRC personnel in headquarters and the regions for completeness and accuracy.
| |
| The data for the first quarter of 1988 will be reviewed again in preparation for the next quarterly report in order to ensure that late infomation, if any, is accounted for.
| |
| Although certain NRC performance indicators are the same as those used by INP0 as overall perfors ice indicators, the criteria for including the data in the calculations for industry aver.Je are not the same in all cases. For example, INP0 does not include scram values for a plant with cumulative capacity factor of less than 25 percent during the time period being considered in calculating Therer' ore, the the industry average. The NRC does not exclude such plants.
| |
| industry average values of the comon indicators are likely to te different.
| |
| Tables 10.1 to 10.110 provide tabular listings for each plant of Automatic Scrams While Critical, Safety System Actuations, Significant Events, and Safety System Failures for the first quarter of 1988.
| |
| For equipment forced outages per 1000 critical hours, the results for plants with a small number of . critical hours in a quarter can be distorted. For this report, the degree of distortion has been reduced by using at least a minimum value of 200 critical hours in the calculations for any'given quarter.
| |
| O V
| |
| | |
| g 7 . ANNIJAL COLLECTIVE RA0!ATION EXPOSURE DATA Table 11.1 provides the annual cumulative doses in person-rem for 1981 through 1987. Table 11.2 provides the 1-year moving averages of the data in Table 11.)
| |
| for the 3-year periods ending with 1983, 1984, 1985, 1986, and 1987. Data on a quarterly basis are being obtained.
| |
| 8 COMPUTATIONAL NOTES The following computational notes describe some of the detailed methods used in calculations and displays for this report.
| |
| 8.1 The report addresses plants licensed to operate in the first quarter of 1988 or earlier. The data extend through the first quarter of 1988.
| |
| 8.2 Blanks are used under the following conditions for newer plants:
| |
| (1) For all indicators until an operating license is fin :it received, (2) For scrams until critical hours are first reported, or (3) For forced outages until power generation is first reported; thereaf ter, numerical values are used. For example, plants shut dow,1 for an entire quarter after achieving initial criticality have zeroes recorded-for scrams rather than blanxs.
| |
| 8.3 Blanks are not used in calculating averages and standard deviations. l Zeroes ao count in such calculations.
| |
| 8.4 For the plant sumaries ? Figures 4.1 - 4.110 of Part I),
| |
| (1) The top chart, "Trends," is based on the following numbers:
| |
| (a) The plant's moving average for the to-quarter period I (b) The plant's moving average for the prior four-quarter period lif there are not at least two quarters'of data for this mLving average, no value is displayed on the chart), and i
| |
| (c) A standard deviation baseo on the plant's current four-quarter period data (if the standard deviation is zero, an average of values for older or newer plants, as appropriate, is used);
| |
| (2) The bottom chart, "Deviations from Older Plant Means" and/or "Deviations from Newer Plant Means," uses the following numbers:
| |
| (a) Moving average of the plant's current .four-quarter period (if there are not at least two quarters for this, no value is displayed on the chart),
| |
| g
| |
| | |
| f3 L.)
| |
| (b) Average of the current four-quarter period moving averages for older plants or newer plants (outliers more than 2.5 standard deviations from the mean on the first calculation were discarded and the mean and standard deviation were recomputed), and I
| |
| (c) Standard deviation based on the current four-quarter piiriod moving averages for older or newer plants (outliers were discarded as discussed above); and (3) Moving averages laverage of four quarterly values) are used throughout rather than calcul 'ing true means (e.g., annual averages) for ratios such as equipment rurced outages per 1000 critical hours.
| |
| 8.5 The following parameters were used for detailed plant analysis charts of each plant's quarterly data (Figures 4.1 through 4.110 of Part I).
| |
| (1) Older plant averages are the averages of older plant values calculated quarter by quarter.
| |
| (2) Newer plant averages are single numbers that span all quartces, the average of all new plant values in the data set.
| |
| 8.6 For certain plants in long-term shutdown, such as Browns Ferry, Sequoyah, Pilgrim and Ranche Seco, Scrams, Forced Outage' Rate, and Equipment Forced Outages bars were suppressed in the plant summary charts.
| |
| 9 REVISION OF CATA CONTAINED IN THE FEBRUARY 1988 REPORT An intentive review of data sources and application of detailed screening -
| |
| criteria have resulted in some changes to the data previously reported in the February 1988 issue of the report. These changes are summarized in Tabics 9.1 through 9.7. In aggregate, they do not significantly alter the overall picture presented in the earlier report.
| |
| l n
| |
| v
| |
| | |
| O TABLE'9.1 Revisions to Automatic Scrams While Critical (Table 11.4 of the Fourth Quarter, 1987 Report)
| |
| Unit Year-Quarter Old Value Revised Value Catawba 1 87-3 2 1 Catawba 2 86-2 1 2 Shearon Harris 87-4 0 1 TABLE 9 2 Revisions to Scrams Above 15%/1000 Critical Hours (Table 11.5 of the . Fourth Quarter, 1987 Report)
| |
| Unit Year-Quarter Old Value Revised Value Cat 0wba T 86-2 0 1 TABLE 9.3 Revisions to Scrams below 15% Power (Table 11.6 cf the Fourth Quarter,1987 Report)
| |
| Unit _ Yea r-Qua rte r Old Value Revised Value Calvert Cliffs 1 86-4 1 0 Catawba 1 87-3 1 0 Shearon Harris 87-4 0 1 Table 9.4 Revisions to Safety System Actuations (Table 11.7 of the Fourth Quarter,1987. Report)
| |
| Unit Year-Quarter Old Value Revised Value ,
| |
| Beaver Valley 1 86-2 1 0 Browns Ferry 1 86-2 0 2 Browns Ferry 2 87-1 0 1 Catawba 1 86-3 0 1 Catawba 1 86-4 2 1 Catawba 2 86-4 0 1 Clinton 87-3 1 0 l Cooper 86 .? 0 1 l
| |
| Cooper 86-3 0 5 Cooper 86-4 0 1
| |
| . Cooper 87-1 2 3 l Cooper 87-2 0 2
| |
| ) Dresden 2 86-2 1 0 Fermi 2 87-2 1 0 Fitzpatick 87-2 1 2 Hope Creek 87-1 1 2 Indian Point 2 87-4 4 2 Indian Point 3 87-? 1 2 Nine Mile Pt. 2 86-4 3 4 Nine Mile Pt. 2 87-1 0 1 North Anna 2 87-4 2 3
| |
| | |
| i . .
| |
| -(a)
| |
| Palo Verde 1 Prairie Island 1 87-1 87-1 1 0 0 1 Quad cities 1 86-4 1 0 Rancho Seco 86-4 0 1 Shearon Harris 86-4 3 4 Surry 1 86-4 1 0 Surry 1 87-3 2 0 Wash. Nuclear 2 86-2 2 1 Waterford 3 87-1 1 0 Wolf Creek '87-3 1 2 Zion 1 86-3 1 0 Zion 1 86-3 2 1 Table 9.5 Revisions to Significant Event frequency (Table 11.8 of the Fourth Quarter,1987 Report) -
| |
| Unit Year-Quarter Old Value Revised Value Cook 1 87-3 0 1 Cook 2 87-3 0 1 Nine Mile Point 1 87-4 0 1 Table 9.6 Revisions to Safety System Failures (Table 11.9 of the Fourth Quarter,1987 Report)
| |
| Unit Year-Quarter. Old Value Revised Value Browns Ferry 1 87-3 1 2 Browns Ferry 3 87-3 1 2 Byron 1 87-3 1 ~ 0 Callaway- 87-2 1 3 Diablo Canyon 1 87-4 1 0 Fort Calhoun 87-3 0 1 Ginna 87-4 0 1 Hatch 1 87-2 3 2 Indian Point 3 87-5 0 1 LaSalle 2 87-4 5 4 Linerick 87-4 3 2 McGuire 2 87-3 0 1 Nine Mile Point 2 87-4 7 9 North Anna 2 87-3 1 3 Oconee 1 87-2 0 1 Oconee 2 87-2 0 1 Oconee 3 87-2 2 3 Oyster Creek 87-3 1 2 Perry 87-3 7 8 Perry 87-4 6 5 Quad Cities.1 87-4 2 3 Salem 1 87-4 1 2 Salem 2 87-4 3 4 San Onofre 1 87-3 0 1 Seabrook 87-3 0
| |
| - 'v O' Fequoyah 2 87-3 5 6 1
| |
| Thearon Harris 87-3 1, 3' l l'uth Texas 87-4 3 4 l Surry 1 87-4 1 2 )
| |
| | |
| > . ._.__g... ..____ , ._.... _ .._. _ .. _ . _ _. _ _ .. . ._....._ ..,. .. .. ._ _ _ ._-_ _ _
| |
| e- a
| |
| ''- - 10'-
| |
| I TABLE 9.7. Revision To Forced Outage Rate (Table 11.10 Of The Fourth Quarter' O'
| |
| -1987 Report)
| |
| . Unit'. Year-Ouarterly - Old Value Revised Value Duane Arnold . 87-4 98 26 1
| |
| e 8
| |
| l-l i
| |
| l l-i t
| |
| i O
| |
| t vv y -49
| |
| * s %* e y f Dw1- 4 +ry m w e eye , n ge w ow t y e r-e yy ee eew wtw w www e go-ww**Mt me-****W-we --
| |
| | |
| 6 0 THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY SLANK l
| |
| | |
| 4 12 -
| |
| THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK e
| |
| l O
| |
| 1 1
| |
| l
| |
| : 10. TABLES OF PLA'1T EVENTS FOURTH QUARTER 1987 FIRST QUARTER 1988 O
| |
| O
| |
| | |
| 6 6
| |
| THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK i .
| |
| l l
| |
| I 0
| |
| t t
| |
| | |
| l l
| |
| TABLE 10.1
| |
| . ARKANSAS 1
| |
| . (J <
| |
| l PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE I
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 02/17/88 LERs 31388003 50.72s: 11529 POWER:
| |
| DESC: A RCD GROUP DROPPED DURING RPS TESTING CAUSING A LOW PRESSURE SCRAM. FAILURE WAS UNKNOWN.
| |
| SSF 03/31/88 LERs 50.728: 11909 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: CONTROL BUILDING / CONTROL COMPLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CCMTROL SYSTEM DESC: DAMPER LOCATED DOWNSTREAM 0F THE COMON DISCMARGE HEADER FOR THE AIR MANDLING UNITS FOR BOTH CONTROL ROOMS FOUND CLOSED. DEGRADED FLOW LESS TNAN IS REQUIREMENTS TYPE 86 2' 86 3 86 4 87-1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 l SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.46 0.00 13.89 0.00 0.00 0.46 0.00 0.46 l SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0
| |
| (
| |
| TOTAL SCRAMS 1 0 1 0 0 2 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 FORCED CUTAGE* RATE (%) 1 0 79 11 0 4 1 2 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRiflCAL HOURS 0.46 0.00 0.00 2.07 0.00 0.92 0.64 0.46 CRiflCAL HOURS 2173 1564 72 1935 2183 2177 1561 2152 0 15
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.2 ARKANSAS 2 PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SCRAM 11/14/87 LERf 36887008 50.728: 10682 POWER:
| |
| DESC: MAIN TURBINE TRIPPED DUE TO MIGN V!BRATIONS DUE TO SETPolNT SET TOO LOW.
| |
| - PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 88A 03/10/88 LER# 50.72#: 11707 PWER DESC: LOSS OF 10F 4 VITAL INVERTORS CAUSED DG TO START BUT TRIPPED FOR UNKNOWN REASON. HPCI WAS BLOCKED BUT SOME OF THE VALVES SWAPPED SSA 03/10/88 LERf 50.728: 117C7 POWER:
| |
| DESC: LOSS OF 1 0F $ VITAL INYERTORS CAUSED DG TO START SUT TRIPPED FOR UNKNOWN REASON. HPCI WAS BLOCKED BUT SOME OF THE VALVES SWAPPED SSF 03/31/88 LERf 50.728: 11909 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: CONTROL BUILDING / CONTROL COMPLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: DAMPER LOCATED DOWNSTREAM OF THE COMMON DISCMARGE HEATER FOR THE AIR HANDLING UNITS FOR BOTH CONTROL ROCNS FOUND CLOSED. DECRADED FLOW LESS THAN TS REUQlREMENTS TTPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HCURS 1.15 2.36 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.51 0.46 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 3 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 SAFETY STSTEM FAILURES 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 3 18 5 0 36 12 1 0 EQUIP. FORLED CUTAC'S/1000 CRITICAL HOURS 1.15 2.36 0.48 0.00 0.71 1.02 0.46 0.00 CRITICAL l CURS 1738 423 2093 2160 1413 1956 2186 1028 O
| |
| 16
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.3 BEAVER VALLEY 1 O,
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 NONE TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87-4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.00 1.19 0.00 0.94 1.56 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 2 2 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 0 23 1 2 3 0 0 1 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL NOURS 0.00 0.00 0.46 0.47 1.56 0.00 0.00 0.00 calilCAL MOURS 1104 842 2182 21<6 1278 2208 1727 744 a
| |
| 1 i
| |
| O 17 1
| |
| | |
| l 1
| |
| TE*LE 10.4 BEAVER QLLEY 2 O, ,
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 ;
| |
| SCRAM 10/08/87 LERs 41287026 50.728: 10248 POWER:
| |
| DESC: RECIRC VALVES OPINED CAUSING FF/SF MISMATCH AND LOW SG LEVEL TRIP DUE TO MFP FLOW SENS!hG LINES BEING REVERSED.
| |
| SCRAM 10/14/87 LERs 41287028 50.728: 10322 POWER:
| |
| DESC: ENC PRESSURE SWITCH BLED DOWN CAuslNG TURBINE TRIP.
| |
| SCRAM 10/15/87 LER8 41287029 50.728: 10339 POWER:
| |
| DESA ERRATIC BEHAVIOR OF FRV'S CAUSED NIGN SG LEVEL AND TUR81NE TRIP.
| |
| SSA 10/24/87 LERf 41287032 50.728: 10446 POWER:
| |
| DESC DURING LOAD REJECTION TEST, 4KV 80$ FAILED .0 TRANSFER, 3 RCPS TRIPPED - LOW SG LEVEL AND DG STARTED TO REENERG12E BUS j
| |
| SCRAM 10/24/87 LER8 41287032 50.728: 10446 POWER:
| |
| DESC: DURING LOAD REJECTION TEST, 4KV BUS FAILED To TRANSFER, 3 RCPS TRIPPED - LOW SG LEVEL AND DG STARTED TO REENERGIZE BUS SCRAM 10/29/87 LERs 41287034 50.728: 10$04 POWER:
| |
| DESC: MFP TRIP CAUSED RX TRIP.
| |
| SCRAM 11/10/87 LERs 41287035 50.728: 10640 POWER:
| |
| DESC: FAULTY VALVE IN CONDENSATE POLISHER SYSTEM CAUSED CONDENSATE LOW FLOW CAUSING MFP TRIP AND SUBSI XlENT RX TRIP SSA 11/17/87 LERf 41287036 50.728: 10700 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TECN TRl* PED POWER 70 TURBINE ROTOR POSITION MODULE CAUSING TUR8INE TRIP AND RX TRIP SE 11/17/87 LER# 41287036 50.728: 10700 POWER: 98 DESC: PERSONNEL INDUCED TUR8INE TRIP WITN FAILURE OF AUTO TRANSFER RESULTED IN SCRAM WITN LOSS OF OFFSITE POWER (17 sic)
| |
| SCRAM 11/17/87 LER8 41287036 50.728: 10700 POWEtt DESC: TECN TRIPPED POWER TO TURBINE ROTOR POSITION MCDULE CAUSING TURBINE TRIP AND RX TRIP l
| |
| FI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSA 01/27/'d LER8 41288002 50.728 11311 POWR DESC: 4KV tus LOCKED 0UT ON OVERCURRENT DURING TESTING CAUSING RCP TO TRIP CAUSING RX TplP.
| |
| SCRAM 01/27/88 LEts 41288002 50.728: 11331 POWER:
| |
| DESC: 4tV BUS LOCKED 0UT ON OVERCURRENT OURING TESTING CAUSING RCP TO TRIP CAUSING RX TRIP.
| |
| SSA 02/01/88 LER8 41288004 50.728 11385 POW R:
| |
| DESC: 4KV BUS INADVERTENTLY DEENERGlZED DURING TROUBLESHCOTlWG.
| |
| l 18 9
| |
| l l
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.4 (CONT.)
| |
| BEAVER VALLEY 2 (CONT.)
| |
| Oe TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA NA NA 8.29 3.50 0.56 SCRAMS <151 POWER NA NA NA NA NA 2 1 0 TOTAL SCRAMS NA NA NA NA NA 7 7 1 MFETY SYSTEN ACTUAfl0NS NA NA NA NA 0 3 2 2 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS NA NA NA NA NA 0 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEN FAILURES NA NA NA NA 0 2 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) NA NA NA NA NA 29 27 4 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA NA NA 13.27 4.67 1.12 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA NA NA 603 1714 1785 l
| |
| l O 19 ,
| |
| i 1
| |
| -- . . _ . _ . . . . _ _ . _ _ _ ._ ., _ . . _ _ __ . _. _ _ _ _ . , . _ _ _ . , . _ _ _ _ , _ , , _ _ . _ _ .i
| |
| | |
| 1 TABLE 10.5 BIG ROCK POINT O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSA 02/05/88 LERf 15588002 50.728: 11424 POWER:
| |
| DESC: 2 SECOMO LOSS OF STATION POWER NECES$1TATED A MANUAL TRIP DURING MAIN GENERATOR SYNCHRON!ZATICN TO GRID.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87-2 87 3 87 4 88-1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURt 0.00 0.51 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATID S 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) 0 12 0 0 4 6 9 8 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00
| |
| * 02
| |
| . 0.00 3.45 0.63 2.13 1.56 1.00 CRITICAL HOURS 2183 1%3 2209 579 1597 2117 1921 1997 i
| |
| O 20 l
| |
| | |
| a TABLE 10.6 BRAIDWOOD 1 PI EV3NTS FOR 87-4 SCRAM 10/09/87 LERf 45687057 50.728: 10266 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TESTING TURBINE WHEN GOVERNOR VALES CLOSED UidtXPECTEDLY CAUSING RX TRIP SSF 11/06/87 LERf 45687c3C 50.728: POWER: 61 SYSTEM: CONTROL SUILDING/ CONTROL COMPLEX ENVIR00 MENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: DOTM TRAINS OF THE CONTROL ROCM EMERGENCY VENTILAfl0N SYSTEM IN0PERA8tE DUE TO AN ERROR IN A DESIGN CHANGE.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSA 01/25/88 LERf 45688002 50.728: 11315 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TECH CAllBRATED WRONG PRESSURE TRANSMITTER CAUSING MIGN CONT PRESSURE TRIP WITH St.
| |
| SE 03/23/88 LERf 50.728: POWER:
| |
| DESC: MIXING OF GREASES IN GEAR BOXES OF MOTOR OPERATORS COULD LEAD TO MOTOR OPERATOR FAILURE TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87-1 87-2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA NA 0.00 0.94 0.50 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER NA NA NA NA 1 2 0 0 TOTAL $ CRAMS NA NA NA NA 1 3 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS NA NA 0 0 0 2 0 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS NA NA 0 1 0 0 0 1 SAFETY *YSTEM FAILURES NA NA 2 3 0 1 1 0 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) NA NA NA NA NA 56 11 74 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL HOJRS NA NA NA NA NA 1.89 1.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA NA 369 1060 2000 86 O 21 l ,
| |
| i l 2
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.7 BRAIDWOOD 2 Ol PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NCNE 1
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSA .01/29/88 LERf 45788004 $0.728: 11363 POWER:
| |
| DESC: ESF SUS VOLTAGE POTENTIAL TRAiv5FORMER FUSES WERE PULLED IN ERROR CAUSING THE BUS TO DEENERGl2E.
| |
| SE 03/23/88 LERf 50.728: POWER:
| |
| DESC: MIXING OF GREASES IN GEAR BOXES OF Mot 0R OPERATOR $ COULD LEAD TO MOTOR OPERATCW FAILURE TTPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87-1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA kA NA NA NA NA SCRANS <15% POWER WA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA TOTAL SCRAMS NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS NA NA NA NA NA NA 0 1
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 1 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA EQUIP. FORCED CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL HQ)R$ NA NA NA NA NA 'A
| |
| . NA NA CRITICAL HCURS NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 22 O
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.8
| |
| - BROWNS FERRY 1 P.T EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSF 01/20/88 LER# N)./28; 11274 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: EMERGENCY /STANOIf GAS TREAf4Li SYSTEM DESC: ALL THREE TRAINS OF $/s GAS TREATMENT SYSTEM DECLARED IN0PERA8LE 00E TO FAILURE TO MEET COLD OPS TEST AS REQUIRED BY T.S SSA 01/22/88 LERf 25988005 50.728: 11293 POWER:
| |
| DESC: A PENETRATION WALKDOWN CREW OPENED A DOOR 70 A PT COMPARTW.NT CAUSING THE FUSES TO BE PULLED AND A LOW VOLT SIGNAL.
| |
| SSF 03/03/88 Leas 50.728 11660 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: RESIDUA'. HEAT REMOVAL SYSTEM (SWR) (SPECIAL NON EIIS CODE DESC: DESIGN DEFICIENCY EXISTS IN RMR PUMPS AUTO START LOGIC.
| |
| TYPE 86-2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87-2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 2 0 0 1 0 0 0, 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ,
| |
| SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 2 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23
| |
| | |
| l l
| |
| TABLE 10.9 BROWNS FERRY 2 PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 .
| |
| SE 11/02/87 LERs N/A 50.728: 10542 POWER: 0 DESC: SELF SUSTAINING,$ ELF PROPAGATING CABLE TRAY FIRE INSIDE CONTAIMMENT. FIRE LASTED 33 MINUTES PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSF 01/20/88 LERs 50.728: 11274 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: EMERGENCY / STANDBY CAS TREATMENT SYSTEM DESC: ALL THREE TRAINS OF S/B GA3 TREATMENT SYSTEM DECLARED IMOPERABLE DUE TO FAILURE TO MEET COLD OPS TEST AS REQUIRED BY T.S SSF 03/03/88 LERs 50.72s: 11660 POWER: 0 SYSTEM RESIDUAL HEAT REMOVAL SYSTEM (BWR) ISPECIAL MON Ells CODE DCSC: DEslGN DEFICIENCY EXISTS IN RNR PUMP AUTO START LOGIC.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRANS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 0 0 1 3 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 2 0 3 0 2 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) 100 100 100 it,0 100 100 100 100 EQUIP. FORCE 0 OUT AGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00' O.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HQ)RS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
| |
| 24
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.10 BROWNS FERRY 3
| |
| . ,m PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSA 10/19/87 LERf 29687005 50.728: 10395 POWER:
| |
| DE SC: TWO DECP@ED LINES VCLTAGE RELAYS FAILED CAUS'NG AN EDG ACTUATION PI EVE 1;TS FOR 88-1 SSF 01/20/88 Leas 50.728: 11274 POER: 0 EYSTEM: CMERGENCY/STANORY CA! TREATMENT SYSTEM DESC: ALL THREE TRAINS OF S/B GAS TREATMENT SYSTEM DECLARE ' I A1PERAPLE D'A 10 FAILURE To MEET COLD OPS TEST AS REQUIRfD BY 1.S <
| |
| s SSF 03/03/88 LERf 50.728: 11660 POWER: 0 SYSTEM RESIDUAL HEAT REMOVAL SYSTEM (BWR) (SPECIAL NON Ells CODE DESC DESIGN DEFICIENCY EXISTS IN RNA PUMP AUTO START LOGIC.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 5 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HaA$ 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0. 't SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAi!ONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 t!GWIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 2 1 2 0 2 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 EQUIP. FORCED CUTACES/1000 CRiflCAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C
| |
| l l
| |
| l i
| |
| O 25
| |
| | |
| l TABLE 10.11 !
| |
| 1RUNSWICK 1 O
| |
| PI 3 VENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/09/87 tERs 50.72s: 10259 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: N:GM PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC: DURING PERFORMANCE OF HPCI SYSTEM OPERASILITY TEST A LEAK WAS DISCOVERED ON A WELD 0F THE HPCI PUMP DISCHARGE CHECK VALVE. SYSTEM DECLARED IMOPERABLC SSF 12/31/87 LERs 32587023 50.728: 11095 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: NIGM PRESSURE COOLANT lisJECTION SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC MPCI DECLARED IN0PERA8Ll VMEN THE STEAM SUPPLY VALVE FAILED TO OPEN DURING A SURVEILLANCE TEST. CAUSE BEING INVESTIGATED PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SE 02/19/88 Lias 32588006 50.728: 11545 P0 4R: 0 SYSTEM: DC POWER *YSTEM CLASS 1F DESCt (LECTRICAL SWITCMGEAR, MOTOR CONTROL CENTERS AND PANEL BCARDS FABRICATED WITN $1LICON BRONZE CARRIA0E BOLT *. TMAT WERE OVER TORQUED AND ARE SUOJECT TO IGSC SSF #2/19/88 LERs 32588006 50.728: 11545 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: DC POWER SYSTEM CLASF 1E DESC: SOLT MEAD FAILURES IN SUS /8AR CCaNECTIONS OF ELECTRICAL SWITCH 8OARDS DISCOVERED POTENTI ALLY RENDE91NG INOPERABLE:
| |
| UNI) 1 MPCI, UNIT 2 RCIC, 80P CONTROL POWER, LOSS OF UNIT 2 ECW PLMP AUTO STAR TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88-1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.47 1.00 0.46 0.00 0.00 0.47 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 2 2 1 0 1 1 0 0 SAFfiY SYSTEM ACTUAll0NS 1 3 0 1 1 2 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENi2 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 1 1 3 2 2 2 1 70RCED CUTACE RATE (%) 8 13 4 0 33 4 0 0 EQUIP. FORCED CUTAGES/1000 CdiflCAL r.JJR$ 0.47 1.00 0,92 0.94 2.56 0.47 0.00 0.00 CalflCAL HCJR$ 2122 2004 2163 1064 391 2125 2209 1531 s
| |
| 26 e
| |
| | |
| i TABLE 10.12
| |
| - BRUNSWICK 2 I)
| |
| G' PI EVENTS ?Ok 87-4 SSF 11/25/87 Leks 50.72st 10791 POWEtt 78 SYSTEM: NIGN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC HPCI CHANNEL A 'AIGN STEAM FLOW TRANSMITTER FAILED ITS CHANNEL CNECC. CHANNEL PLACED IN A f tlPPED CONDifl0N AhD MPCI SYSTEM DECLARED IN0PERA8LE PI EVENTS FOk 88-1 SE 01/02/88 Lens 32488001 50.7u: 11109 POWEA: 51 DESC: PRIMARY CONTAINMEhi ISOLAil0N VALVES IN TWO ORAIN f tANSFER LINES FAILED TO CLOSE SSF 01/02/88 LEts 32488001 50.72s: 11109 POWER: 55 SYSTEM: CONTAINMENT ISOLATION CONTROL SYSTEN DESC: FAILURE OF FOUR CONT ISOLAfl0N VALVES TO CLOSE ON AN ACTUAL CONT ISOL S.GNAL. FAILLAs CF THESE VLVS TO CLOSE REPRESENTED A FAILUtf 0F BOTM REDUNCANT SAFETY DIVISION OF THE CONF Isot. SYSTEM SE 02/19/88 LEts 32588006 50.72s: 11545 POWER: 0 l
| |
| SYSTEM: DC POWER SYSTEM CLASS 1E I
| |
| DESC CLECitICAL SWliCMCEAR, MOTOR CONit0L CENTERS AND PANEL BOARDS FABRICATED WITN SILICON BRONZE CARRIAGE BOLTS iM4T VERE OVER TOROUED ANC ARE SUBJECT 70 ICSC ,
| |
| 88F 02/19/88 LEts 32588006 50.72s: 11745 PCWER: 0 SYSTEM: DC POWER SYSTFM CLASS 1E JESC BCLT MEAD FAILL,tES IN BUS /BAR CONNECTIC4S OF ELECTRICAL SVliCMBOARDS DISCOVERED POTENTI ALLY RENDERING INOPERA8LE:
| |
| UNif 1 MPCI, UNIT 2 RCIC, BOP, CONit0L POWER, LOSS OF UNIT 2 ESW PUMP AUTC STAtt SE 03/19/88 LEts 50.728: 11802 POWER: 0 DESC: r0 Nit 0L 20D OtlVE LINE LEAKS TYPE 86 2 84 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CtlTICAL MOUts 3.46 0.48 0.00 :.11 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL fCRAAS 1 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 SAFEff SYSTEN r.CTi# Tii n 1 1 2 2 0 0 0 0 l
| |
| l SIGNIFICANT EWNTS 0 0 0 1 0 G 0 3 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURE 4 0 0 0 6 2 0 1 2 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (1) 54 2 3 16 4 0 0 0
| |
| ( 0.47 0.00 41.67 l 10VlP. FotCED CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL HCURS 3.46 0.48 0.54 2.78 0.00
| |
| ! CtITICAL Matut$ 28v 2093 1851 1801 2110 2208 2209 24
| |
| {
| |
| 1 1
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| l (
| |
| 27 l
| |
| l l
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| l
| |
| \
| |
| TABLE 10.13 i
| |
| I BYRON 1 O,
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1
| |
| - NONE TYPE 66 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87-2 07 3 87 4 88 1 SCRMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HCuts 0.00 0.59 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,41 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 0 0 4 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 SAFE *Y SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 FORCEO QUTAGE RArt (%) 0 24 2 0 0 5 0 0 EQUIP. FORCED CUT AGES /1000 CRITI*.AL MOURS 0.00 0.59 0.46 0.00 0.00 0.47 0.00 0.00 CRiflCAL MOURS 21&3 1691 2169 1058 815 2128 2209 2184 i
| |
| i O
| |
| 28 t.
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.14
| |
| . f.3 BYRON 2 PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SCRAM 10/01/87 LERs 45587018 50.72s: 10179 POWER:
| |
| ' DESC: LOW SG LEYEL SCkM AFTER AFW TRIP. CAUSE UNKNOWN.
| |
| SSA 10/02/87 Ltti 4558/010 50.728: 10186 POWER:
| |
| DESC: OPERATOR $ OPENED WRONG DISCONNECTS AND CAUSED A LOSS OF SlfE POdER.
| |
| SE 10/02/87 LER8 45587019 50.728: 10186 POWER: 0 DE%: Loss 0F ALL OFFSITE POWER TO UNIT 2 F0k 10 NOURS DUE To OPERATOR ERROR SCRAM 10/02/87 LEta 45587019 50.72s: 10187 POWR DESC: FRV LEArtf CAUSED LEYEL TO INCREASE AND TURBINE TRIP ON MIGN LEVEL SSA 12/02/87 LER8 45587020 50.7287 10847 POWER:
| |
| DESC $1 ACCLMULATOR VALVES NOT SLOCG BEFORE BEING ENERGIZED, THIS CAI.' SED THE VALVES TO OPEN ON INJECiloN.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 02/12/88 LER# 45588001 50.72f: 11496 POWER:
| |
| DESC: AF?tt MFP TRIP. TURBINE RUNBACK STOPPED BEFORL REACHING DESIRED SETPOINT CAUSING RX TRIP.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCF.w$ >15% POWER /1000 ChsTICAL HOURS NA NA NA 0.58 1.26 0. F.8 0.65 0.46 SCRAMS <15% POWER NA NA N% 3 0 0 1 0 TOTAL SCRAMS NA NA kA 4 2 1 2 1 SAFE 1Y SYSTEM ACTUAi!DNS NA NA 0 0 0 1 2 0 SIGNIFICAWT EYENTS NA NA 0 0 0 0 1 0 SAFiTY SYSTEM FAILURES NA NA 0 1 2 0 0 0 FORCD DJTACE RATE (%) NA NA NA 5 7 21 4 1 EQUIP. FORCED CUTA0ES/1040 CRif!CA8 HOURS NA NA NA 0.00 2.51 2.72 1.29 0.46 Cal!* CAL HOURS H MA NA 1723 1592 1468 1549 2170 i
| |
| l J i 20
| |
| | |
| 4 TABLE 10.15 CALLAWAY O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSF 10/05/87 (ERs 50.728: 10223 POWER: 999 SYSTEM: CONTROL BUILDING / CONTROL COMPLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: 90TN TRAINS OF TME CONTROL ROOM EMERGENCY VENTILATION /ISOLATICN SYSTEM MAY MAVE BEEN 00S AT YARIOUS TIMES $1NCE PLANT RECIEVED LOW POWER OPERATING LICENSE SSA 10/23/87 LERf 48387030 50.728: 10431 POWER:
| |
| DESC: $WITCMYARD BRERER TRIPPED OPEN; UNKNOWN CAUSE; CVlt & cpl $ ACTUATED; MANUALLY STARTED EDG B & FUEL BUILDING VENT; EDG A LOAD SMEDDING POWERED DCW FOR REFUELING SSA 10/29/87 Leks 48387030 50.M f: 10511 POWER:
| |
| DESC: PERSONNEL OPENED WRONG BREAKER DURING TEST LOST 4 KV SUS
| |
| * EDG SLOCKED CONTAlWMENT PURGE ALREADY ISOLATED -
| |
| CREVIS ALREADY IN SERVICE LOSS CRARGING PUMP LOSS RMR TRAIN (NOT NEEDED)
| |
| SSF 11/04r87 Leks 48387C31 50.72s: 10568 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: LOW PRES $W2 SAFETY INJECTION SYSTEM (PWR,)
| |
| DESC: TWO St ACCLMAATORS WERE $1pOLTANt0USLY INOPERABLE. TECH. SPEC 3.0.3 ENTERED SCPAM 11/08/87 LEts 48387032 50.72# 10613 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TESTING MSIV CAUSED SG LEVEL OSClLLATIONS ANO R4 TRIP. TESTING WAS NOT DONE IN MODE 3 PER PROCEDURE.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 -
| |
| SCRAM 01/04/88 LERs 48388001 5 0. 72 s: 11117 POWER:
| |
| DESC: DURING TROU8LESM00 TING ff. 4FW MYDRAutic PANEL, SIGNAL SET TO IsotATION VALVE CAUSING LOW SG LEVEL TRIP.
| |
| SSF 01/07/88 LERf 48388002 9.72#: POWER: 100 SYSTEM RESIDUAL NEAT REMOVAL SYSitM (PWR) (SPECI AL NON Ells CODE DESC: BOTM TRAINS OF RNR WERE RF"7ERED IMOPERABLE DURING VENTING EVOLUTION, RO INADVERTENTLY CLOSED WRONG VALVE AWD IMMECIATELY ATTEMPTED T3 RE OPEN IT RESULTING IM MOV SKR TRIP SSF 02/02/88 LERf 50.72fs 11397 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: ESSENTIAL SERVICE WATER SYSTEM DESC: LICENSEE DECLARED BOTM Tb!NS OF ESW SYSTEM INOPERABLE. BLOC.: WALLS BETWEEN PUMPS AND ASSOCI ATED SWITCHGEAR WERE 015 COVERED TO EXCEED DESIGN WALL MEIGHT SSA 02/13/88 IER8 48388004 50.728: 1i500 POWER:
| |
| DESC: $! FLCW DUE TO EXCES$1VE FEEDING OF SG'S WITH AFW CAUSED LCW STEAM LINE PRES $URE.
| |
| SCRAM 02/13/88 (Ets 48388004 50.72f s 11499 POWER:
| |
| DESC INSTALLED JLMPER CAME LOOSE VMICM CAUSED A TURBINE TRIP /RX TRIP.
| |
| l l
| |
| l
| |
| ' O 30
| |
| | |
| , a TABLE 18.15 (CONT.)
| |
| CALLAWAY (CONT.)
| |
| oc. ; O TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >151 POWER /1000 CRITICAL M0JR$ 1.94 0.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.%
| |
| SCRAMS <15% POWEt 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 TOTAL SCtAMS 4 2 0 0 0 0 1 2 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIout 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM *AILURES 1 0 0 0 3 3 2 2 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (I) 19 5 0 1 3 0 5 6 EQUIP. ForLEO W /CES/1000 CRITtcAL MOURS 2.58 1.87 0.00 1.40 0.81 0.r1 0.89 0.00 CRITICAL NOURS 1548 2135 2209 2138 ~1240 16 1126 2078 e
| |
| k r
| |
| 4 a
| |
| I O 31 g ,- -.,,,,y ,- .w. . . . - - , . , , , , . . , -- . _ - . , - - - _ - . - , . . , -
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.16 CALVERT CLIFFS 1 O
| |
| PI BVENTS FOR 87-4 l SCRAM 11/11/87 Leas 31787015 50.72#: 1 % 56 POWEt DESC SUSMING OR TRANSFORMER FAILED DW To SEVEtt WEATHER CAU$1NG A TG TRIP AMD RX SCRM PI EVENTS FOR SG-1 I i
| |
| NONE j TYPE 86-2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 ActMs >15% PWER/1000 CRITICAL MCuts 0.00 0.46 3.58 0.00 0.00 1.61 0.50 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL sctAMs 0 1 2 0 0 3 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 3 1 0 0 SIGulilCANT EYEWis 0 1 0 1 2 1 0 0 SAFEff SYSTEM !\lLURES 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 1 2 6 13 62 16 11 1 EQUIP FORCED CUTAl,ES/1000 CRITICAL POURS 0.46 0.46 0.00 0.52 0.00 1.07 0.50 ').00 CRITICAL MOURS 2183 2170 559 1909 857 1866 1983 2184 l
| |
| l 32 l
| |
| 1 1
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.17 CALVERT CLIFFS 2 PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SCRAM 12/21/87 LERs 31887009 50.728: 11039 POWER: i DESC: TUR8INE/ GENERATOR TRIP
| |
| * CAUSE UNKNOWN. j l
| |
| i PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 01/22/88 LERs 31888002 50.728: 11290 POWER:
| |
| DESC ELECTRICIAN TRIPPED A BREAKER CAUSING A LOSS OF AN INSTRtMENT SUS AND A LOSS OF MFP CONTROL LOW SG LEVEL Trio.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 - 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.47 0.51 0.00 0.58 0.00 0.47 0.48 0.72 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 1 1 0 1 0 2 1 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EYfhTS 0 1 0 1 2 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (X) 2 12 0 1 0 1 6 1 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /9000 CRITICAL HOJR$ 0.93 2.03 0.00 1.15 0.00 0.94 1.44 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 2142 1973 2208 1733 0 2121 2085 1382 l
| |
| O 33 L
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.18 CATAWPA 1 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSA 11/17/87 Leas 41387042 50.728: 10699 POWER: '
| |
| DESC: DURING TESTING, TECHNICIAN SMotTED A W!tt TO GROUhD CAUSING A RELAY To it!P, DEENERGIZING THE BUS. EDG STAtfED, LOAD CENTEtt D1D NOT SEQUENCE ON PROPERLY 88F - 12/01/87 LERs 50.728: 10842 POWER: 0 SYSTEM CONit0L BUILDING / CONTROL COMPttX ENVIR W WTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC TRAIN A CREV TAKEN OUT OF SERVICE FOR MAINTENANCE WHILE TRAIN 8 DID NOT MEET OPERA 81LITY Rf0UltEMENTS OF TECM. SPECS.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 CSA 01/23/88 Leas 41388014 50.728: 11304 Pvt:
| |
| DESC: RCS PRECSURE INCREASED WITMOUT THE SG PRESSURE BE]NG INCREASED BY THE OPERAfDR, TMIS CAUSED P 11 TO UNFLOCK AND THE ACTUAil0N 88F 02/29/88 LEts s.1388013 50.728: POWEtt 100 SYSTEM: CONTAINMENT SPRAY SYSTEM (PWR)
| |
| DESC: ONE TRAlu 0F CONTAlWMEWT SPRAY WAS TAKEN CUT OF SERVICE FOR MAINTENANCE. THE SMIFT SUPERVISOR ALLOWED CAtl8tATION CF THE OTHER TRAIN NOT RECOGNIZING TMF TECH. SPEC. REQUltMENTS FOR OPERABILITY SSF 03/10/88 Leas 50.72s: 11711 POWER: 83 SYsfEM: AUXILIAty/EMERGlWCY FEfDWATER SYSTEM (PW )
| |
| DESC: ALL AFW PUMPS DECLARED IMOPERA8LE BECAUSE OF DEGRADED FLOW CONDITIONS. PROBABLE CAtlSF ls ASIAfic CLAMS IN SQiH TRAINS OF WUCLEAR SEty!CE WATER TO AFW SYSTEM TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87-4 88 1 SCRANS >15% POWER /1000 CalflCAL MoutS 2.48 2.84 0.00 0.55 0.47 0.49 0.00 0.00 ,
| |
| SCRAMS <151 POWER 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 5 2 0 1 1 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAf!ONS 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 1 0 2 1 0 1 2 FotCED CUTAGE RATE (1) 30 33 2 18 1 9 90 15 EQUIP. FotCED CUTAGES/1000 CalTICAL MOURS 3.11 4.26 1.85' 4.41 0.47 1.48 8.77 1.05 CR1i! CAL MOUtS 1610' 704 1080 1816 2116 2029 114 1398 l
| |
| 34 O
| |
| 1
| |
| | |
| a ,
| |
| TABLE 10.19 es CATAWBA 2
| |
| \
| |
| (V PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSF 12r01/87- LERs 61387044 50.728: 10842 POWER: 75 SYSTEM: CCNTROL BUILDING / CONTROL CDePLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC TR/IN A CREV TAKEN CUT OF SERVICE FOR MAINTENAWCE WHILE TRAIN 8 DID NOT MEET OPERA 81LITY REQUIREMENTS OF TECH. SPECS.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSA 01/20/89 LERs 41488001 50.728: 11270 POWR DESC: PERSoh=EL ERROR AND MANAGEMENT DEFICIENCY CAUSED LOSS OF ESSENTIAL BUS AND D.G. START.
| |
| SSA 02/09/88 Leas 41488003 50.728: 11460 POWER:
| |
| DESC: FOLLOWING TE$ilNG, TME TEST SWITCM WAS RETURNED 70 NORMAL WITHOUT RESEfilNG THE INITIATING $1GNALS.
| |
| SE 03/09/88 Ltts 50.728: 11704 POWER: 21 DESC: DEGRADATION OF SERVICE WATER SYSTEM SY MARINE SHELLFISH MAKES FEEDWATER SYSTEM INOPEtABLE SCRAM 03/09/88 LERs 50.728: 11704 PcWER:
| |
| DESC: FRV "8" FAILED OPEN VMEN PLACED IN AUTO CAUSED Ml SG LEVEL
| |
| * MFW ISOLA 110N . RX TRIP ON LOW SG LEVEL.
| |
| a SSF 03/10/88 LERs 50.728: 11711 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: AUXILIARY / EMERGENCY FEEDWATER SYSTEM (PWR) ,
| |
| DESC: ALL AFV NMPS DECLARED INOPERAstt BECAUSE OF DEGRADED FLOW CONDITIONS. PROBA8LE CAUSE IS ASIATIC CLAMS IN BOTH TRAINS OF NUCLEAR SERVICE WATER TO AFW SYSTEM TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 2.39 0.83 1.90 1.63 0.00 1.32 0.00 2.65 SCRAMS <15% POWER 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 2 1 2 3 0 2 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 2
| |
| $1GulFICANT TVENTS 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 86 45 54 15 14 33 6 60 EQUIP. FORCEL OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 4.79 0.83 4.85 11.99 1.55 3.30 0.52 2.0 CRITICAL MOURS 418 1209 1052 1836 1941 1515 1923 3 78 3
| |
| (O 35
| |
| | |
| c TABLE 10.20 CLINTON 1 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 8 CRAW 10/02/87 LERs 46187060 50.728: 10193 POWER:
| |
| DESC: NON LICENSED OPERATOR INCCattECTLY DE ENERGl2ED DC POWER PANEL FW LEvtl $1GNAL LOST RX LEVEL INCREASED.
| |
| SSF 10/26/87 Leaf 46187062 50.728: 10466 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: MAlW STEAM ISOLATION VALVES (SPECIAL NON Ells C2 E DESC Pt! MARY CONTAINMEhi LEAKAGE RATES OF THE MSIVS EXCEEDED T.S. LIMlis AND THE ASSLMPTIONS OF FSAR. CAUSE Afit!BUTED TO VAtl0L5 ANOMALIES IN THE SEATING SURFACES DUE TO CCMPONENT WEAR SSA 11/02/87 LER8 46187064 50.728: 10546 POWER:
| |
| DESC: FAULTY PROCEDURE AND PERSONNEL ERROR CAUSED WILE REMOVING RELAY CAUSED LOSS OF 4160V BUS 88F 11/09/87 Leas 50.728: 10625 POWER: 999 SYSTEM INSTRtrENT AND UNINTERRUPTIBLE POWER s'9?EM . CLASS 1E DESC: INSPECTION DISCOVERED THAT VARIOJS ELECTRICAL JUNCilN BOXES 00 NOT HAVE WEEP HOLEC TO ALLOW WATER TO DRA! ' 0;i. THIS POTENTIALLY AFFECTS SAFETY RELATED COMPONEN,f$
| |
| s SSF 11/24/87 LERf 46187067 50.728: 10789 POWER: 27 SYSTEM: REACTOR CORE ISOLATION COOLING s'iSTEM (SWE)
| |
| DESC: WIRE ON DELTA TEMP TRIP MCDULE BROKE OR CAME LOO >E CAUSING RCic to ISOLATE. LICENSEE WILL FUtiMER INVEstlGATE AkD REPAlt WIRE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 88F 02/26/88 LERs 50.72#: 11611 PCWEtt 100 SYSTEM: REACTat Coat ISOLAi!ON COOLING SYSTEM (SWE)
| |
| DESCt NPCS INOPERA8LE FOR MAINTENANCE. RCIC DECLARED INOPERAILE WEN RCIC $1EAMLINE FLW INSTRUMENT FAILED CMAkhEL CHECK.
| |
| 88F 03/16/88 Leas 50. 72#1 11768 POWER: 90 SYSTEM: FIRE PtofECTION SYSTEM (CHEMICAL)
| |
| DESC: DESIGN ERROR PREVENTED EDG VENT FANS FROM TRIPPING ON A FIRE SIGNAL. A FIkE Wout0 MAVE NOT BEEN ExilhGUISMED.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86-4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >151 PoJER/1000 CattICAL HOURS NA NA NA 0.00 0.56 2.68 0.85 0.00 SCRAMS <151 POWER NA NA NA 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS NA NA NA 0 1 5 1 0 SAFET) ' STEM ActuaTIONS NA 0 1 2 2 0 1 0 St. ''tCANT EVENTS NA 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETT ss .EM FAILUaES NA 1 0 0 1 3 3 2 FCatCED OUTAGE RATE (S) NA NA NA NA 37 18 2 0 EQUIP. FotCED OUT AGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS NA NA NA NA 1.11 1.61 0.85 0.00 Calt! CAL HOJR$ NA NA NA 509 1799 1869 1173 1875 36 0
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.21 COOK 1 PI EVENT 8 FOR 87-4 8 CRAN 10/13/87 LEts 31587021 50.72s: 10305 POWEtt DESC TURSINE SMAFT OklVEN Oil PUMP FAILED TO SUPPLY 0!L TO TutSths AND MFP CAU$tD MFP DISCHARGE VALVE TO SHUT.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 8 CRAM 01/13/88 LEts 31588001 50.728: 11204 POWEtt DESC: TECM CAUSED RX f tlP SKR TO OPEN WMEN INSTALLING TEST EQUIP CAuslNO RX f t!P.
| |
| TY)E 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CA;TICAL MOURS 0.73 1.10 0.46 0.00 0.57 0.00 0.48 0.47 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 1 3 1 0 1 0 1 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 1 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE *. ATE (%) 37 20 1 0 17 0 1 1 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CtlTICAL M0Jts 0.73 1.65 0.46 0.00 2.29 0.00 0.48 0.00 CtlTICAL Ha>RS IM7 1822 2157 2160 1749 0 2092 2132 l
| |
| l r
| |
| I O 37 l
| |
| | |
| l
| |
| <l l
| |
| l l
| |
| TABLE 10.22 COOK 2
| |
| )
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSA 10/02/87 Leas 31687011 50.72s 10196 POWEtt DESC: THE SOLID STATE CONikol SYSTEM CAUSED AM SI SIGNAL AJ IT WAS REltNtNED TO SERVICE DUE TO AN INCORRECT SWifCN ALICU8ENT SCRAM 10/10/87 Leas 31687013 50.728: 10273 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TURBiht TRIP CAUSED RX ft!P 00E 10 A CONSERVtTIVE SET POINT.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 08-1 NONE TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% PCWER/1000 CalTICAL HOUns 0.00 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.60 1.73 0.00 0.00
| |
| $CAAMs <15% PCWER 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 0 2 2 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAf!ONS 0 0 0 C 0 1 1 0 stCNIFICANT EVENTS 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILUPEs 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) 0 3 0 0 2 23 11 0 EQUlP. FORCED OUTACES/1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.60 2.59 0.00 0.00 CalflCAL MOJR$ 0 19W 2209 1479 1679 1158 1966 2184 O
| |
| 38
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.23 COOPER STAT. TON b
| |
| y/
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 01/28/88 LEtf 29ea8002 50.728: 11356 POWER:
| |
| DESC: REACTOR REclRC MG SET SPEED CONTROL SYSTEM MALFUNCTIONED INCREASING RECitC FLOW CAU$ LNG HIGN APRM NICH FLUX ft!P.
| |
| SSA 03/16/88 LEtf 50.728: 11770 POWER:
| |
| DESC: OVERCUttENT COW 0lil0N ON 4160 VAC Bus CAUSED DIESEL START.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 Cs.ITICAL HOUts 0.00 0.4. 0.00 1.49 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.77 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 4 1 0 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 1 5 1 3 2 2 0 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 P. 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 0 2 0 5 11 0 0 17
| |
| ' QUIP. FotCED OUTAGES /1000 Ct!TICAL Mouts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.50 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.77 Ct!TICAL MOUts 2183 2177 78 2009 1998 2208 2209 1297 I
| |
| l
| |
| (
| |
| e I
| |
| i O 3,
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.24 CRYSTAL RIVER 3 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 8*s-4
| |
| $8A 10/14/87 LEtf 30287021 50.726: 10326 PUWER:
| |
| DESC LO$f POWER TO THE VlTAL SUS $t$ Dut!NG MAINTENANCE. NOT STATED IF DG $HOULD KAVE STARTED, BUT 17 $MOAD MAVE.
| |
| CSA 10/16/87 LEts 30287025 50.72#: 10365 POWER:
| |
| DESC: tt$T OFFSITE POWER WMEN LINES M tf GaQJWOED WITA A METAL POLE. ONE PERSON DIED, A SECOND SEtl0U$LY BURNT.
| |
| SE 10/16/s7 LEts 3028t'25 50.72#: 10365 POWER: 0 DESC: OFF$lTE POWER LO$f FOR CVER ONE HOUR WHEN CCNTRACT Pit $0Ni EL INADVERTANTLY SMotTED STARTUP TRANSFORMER SSA 10/26/87 LEts 30287027 50.728: 10456 POWEtt DESC: ' A' CC ACTUATED WMEN TECHNICIAN INADVERTENTLY VALVLD OUT WRONG TRANSMITTER WITN ONE CHANNEL ALREADY f tlPPED DUE 10 MAINTENA>CE SS7 11/11/87 LEt# $0.72fs 10652 POWER: 999
| |
| $YSTEM: EMERGENCY ON$1TE POWER SUPPLY $YSTEM DESC: Ett0R DISCOVERED IN THE EDG LCADING CALCULAtl0NS. INCORRECT POWER FACTOR WAS USED IN THE CALCULATIONS VulCH RE$ULTED IN EDCS NOT HAVING $UFFICIENT RESERVE CAPACITY AND 30 MIN. EMERG. RATING EXCEEDED SSA 11/20/87 LEff 30287030 50.728: 10734 POWER:
| |
| DESC: MlGN Pit $$Utt INJECTION $1GNAL WAS RECEIVED FOR AN UNKNOWN REASON.
| |
| SSA 12/05/87 LEt# 30287028 50.724: 10878 POWE R:
| |
| DESC: RETUtislNG > R TO VITAL SUS CAUSED MPS! AND LPSI ACTUATION $1GNAL BUT BKa$ WERE RACKED CUT DG STARTED.
| |
| SSA 12/05/87 LEtf 30287028 50.728: 10878 POWER:
| |
| DESC: RETURNING POWER TO VITAL Bus CAUSED MPSI AND LPSI ACTUATION SICkAL BUT BKR$ WEtt RACKED OUT DG STARTED.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SE 02/28/88 Leas 30288006 50.728: 11626 POWEt t 45 DE$C Tuttikt it!P FAILURE SCRAM 02/28/88 LEts 30288006 50.728: 11626 POWER:
| |
| DESC MFW TRANSlENT OCCuttED VMEN REDUCING RX P %Et CAU$1NG TRIP ON MIGN RX COOLANT PRES $URE.
| |
| l l
| |
| l 40 O
| |
| l I
| |
| | |
| +
| |
| * I TABLE 10.24 (CONT.)
| |
| CRYSTAL RIVER 3 (CONT.) l O 1 YrPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAmt >151 Pow a/1000 CaiTICAL N0utS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.f4 1.34 0.00 0.52 Sca w <15% PcWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 1 SAFETT SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 1 0 0 0 0 0 6 0
| |
| $1GulflCAuf EVEuf$ 0 S 0 0 0 0 1 1 SAFETT SYSTEM FAILUREC 0 0 0 1 0 2 1 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 89 0 40 24 0 7 0 5 EeulP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CalTICAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 1.68 1.21 0.00 1.34 0.00 0.52 Ct!TICAL HOURS 20 2208 1193 1657 2183 1494 0 1913 4
| |
| O 41 1
| |
| | |
| 1 TABLE 10.25 DAVIS-BESSE PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSF 10/16/e7 LEts 34687013 50.728: PoAt: 81 SYSTEM: CONit0L BUILDING /CCNTROL COMPLEX ENVit0NMENTAL CONTROL $1 STEM DESC: 80TM TRAINS OF CREYS WERE FOUND lNOPERAILE. CREYS TRAIN A WAS REMOVED FRCN SERylCE FOR PLANNED MAINTENANCE. TRAIN 8 BECAME IMOPERA8LE VMEN PWER las LOST DUE TO PERSONNEL ERROR SCRAM 12/07/87 Leas 34687015 50.728: 10892 POWER:
| |
| DESC: LOW ait PRESSURE CAUSED REDUCED EFFICIENCY MIGH RX POWEt TRIP PI EVENTS FOR 38-1 SSF 03/04/88 Leas 34688007 50.728: 11668 POLER: 61 SYSTEM: CLOSED /CCMPONENT COOLING WATER SYSTEM DESC: DECAY MEAT COOLER CCW OUTlif VALVES AND THE CCV NX SERVICE WATER QJTLET VALVES WERE DECLARED INT
| |
| * DUE TO POS Coeq0N MCDE FAILutt (Wout0 NOT Fall CPEN CM ESF AS). RENDERED BOTN TRAIN 9 DMR !NOP TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >14% POWER /1000 CRITICAL NGJR$ 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.99 0.00 1.03 0.46 J.00 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 SCRAMS <151 POWER 0 0 1 2 0 2 i 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACiUAfl0NS 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 2 2 0 0 0 1 1 100 100 92 9 0 14 2 0 FORCED OJT AGE RAlt (1)
| |
| EQU;P. FORC!D OUT AGES /)D00 CRiflCAL NOURS 0.00 0.00 16.85 0.99 '. 54 0.52 0.46 0.00 CRiflCAL HQ)R$ 0 0 173 2016 1301 1933 2176 1661 0
| |
| 42
| |
| * e TABLE 10.26 DIABLO CANYON 1 i
| |
| N/
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SCRAN 12/13/87 LEts 27587023 50.72#: 10959 POWER:
| |
| DESC DUt!NG MFW SYSTEM TElflNG, A TEST BUTTON WAS PU$NED CAUSING A MFW PUMP TalP AND A SCRAM ON LOW LEVEL.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAN 01/08/88 LEts 27588002 50.'.2s: 11168 POWER:
| |
| DESC LOOP LOW FLOW DURING TRAN$MITTER ft' JING FLU $N FOLLOWING TRANSMITTER REPAlt DUE TO AN INADEQUATE PROCEDURE.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRANs >15% POWER /1000 Ct!TICAL Mouts 0.00 0.70 0.00 1.49 0.47 0.00 0.47 0.65 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 1 3 1 0 s 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 slGNIFICANT EVEuff 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 0 4 0 10 3 0 7 4 EQUIP. FotCED CUTAGES/1000 CliflCAL HOJts 0.00 0,00 0. *A 0.99 0.94 0.00 0.47 0.00 CAIT1 CAL NOURS 2183 1429 227 2013 2134 2208 2121 1531
| |
| ' O' 43 i
| |
| . . . , . , - _ , , , _~, - -
| |
| | |
| O
| |
| * TABLE 10.27 DIABLO CANYON 2 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSF 11/18/87 LEts 50.728: 10704 POWER: 100 SYSTEM REACTOR BUILDING ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: FMIVS WAS RUNNING IN NORMAL MG)E AND STOPPED FOR NO APPARENT REASCW. CAUSE UNDER INVESTIGATION. FHBVS DECLARED INCPERA8LE PI ESENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 03/03/88 Leks 50.72s: 11661 POWER:
| |
| DESC: Wh 1.E CALIBRATING ONE SEISMIC CMANNEL ANOTHER CMANNEL IN TEST WHEN RX TRIP OCCURRED.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87-4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CalTICJ'. ec)RS 0.94 1.41 0.00 0.49 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.47 SCRAMS <151 POWER 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 2 4 0 2 1 1 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 3 3 1 1 1 2 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 3 0 1 0 FORCED C1JTAGE RATE (1) 5 5 0 15 90 0 7 3 Ecu!P. FORCED QJTAGES/1000 CalTICAL M0JR3 0.94 0.94 0.00 1.46 0.00 0.00 0.49 0.47 CRITICAL HOUds 2119 2121 2209 2061 72 2208 2058 2117 u
| |
| A 44 O
| |
| | |
| d TABLE 10.28 DRESDEN 2 U
| |
| 'PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/01/87 LEts 23787029 50.72s: 10182 POWEtt 97 SYSTEM: NIGN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECil0N SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: Dut!NG PERFotMANCE OF MONTMLY SURVIILLANCE TEST THE NPCI SYSTEM DEVELOPED A STEAM LEAK IN THE VICINITY OF THE NPCI TutOINE SMAFT SEAL. MPCI DECLARED IMOPERA8L 98F 10/04/87 LEts 50.728: 10215 POWR: 99 SYSTEM: LOW PRES $URE COOLANT INJECTIf4 SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: LPCI SUCil0N VALVE FAILED TO OPEN DURING CPERASILITY TEST. PLANT ENTERED LCO TO TEST OPERASILITY OF VAtt0US OTHER SYSTEMS AND ONE CONTAINMENT FAN COOLING SERVICE WATER PUMP FAILED. LPCI REST 0tED 4 NR SCRAM 10/20/87 Leks 23787032 5 0. 72s: 10401 POWEtt ,
| |
| DESC: SPURIOUS MSIV CLOSURE SIGNAL C M ED MSIV CLOSURE AND RX TRIP.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 NONE TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOUts 0.00 0.95 0.00 0.00 0.61 1.22 0.46 0.00 SCRAMS #15% POWEt 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 3 0 0 1 2 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAf!0NS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EYENTS 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILUtES 0 0 0 0 2 1 2 0 FotCED OUTAGE ItATE (%) 34 8 0 0 6 18 3 0 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRiflCAL NCut$ 0.00 1.43 0.00 0.00 0.61 1.22 0.00 0.00 CalTICAL Mout$ 1512 2097 1434 0 1649 1637 2183 2184 t
| |
| l l
| |
| I O 45 ,
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.29 DRESDEN 3 0
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR SS-1
| |
| - NONE TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCnAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 1.?? 1.99 0.54 0.48 1.38 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <155 POWFt 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 TOTAL SCR4MS 0 1 4 1 1 2 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILutES 0 1 0 2 0 7 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 0 25 13 6 16 39 0 0 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL MCURS 0.00 '
| |
| 3 0.50 1.69 0.97 2.07 0.00 0.00 Ct!TICAL Mouts 0 e60 2006 1778 2067 1649 2209 2066 46 0
| |
| | |
| i TABLE 10.30 DUANE ARNOLD (D
| |
| Q/
| |
| PI EVENT 8 FOR 87-4 887 12/02/87 LEts 50.72s: 10853 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: MAIN $ TEAM !sotATION VALVES (SPECIAL NON Ells CtcE DESC: MSIV LEAG GE CONTROL $f8 TEM IN0PERA8LE PI EVENT 8 FOR 88-1 88F 01/11/88 LEts 50.72s: 11182 POWEtt 100 SYSTEM: NIGN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC: NPCI DECLARED INOPERA8LE, FAILED MONTMLY SURVEILLANCE TEST. SU$PECTED SPUtlCU$ INSitUMENT FAILURE / SIGNAL.
| |
| SSF 01n1/88 LEts 50.728: 11192 POWER: 101 SYSTEM: REACYOR cote ISOLAfl0N COOLING SYSTEM (8WR)
| |
| DESC: WlfM NPCI IN0PERA8LE (RE 11192), RCIC DECLARED INCPERA8tE WHEN STEAM SUPPLY VALVE MOV BKt tilPPED.
| |
| SSF 01/11/88 LEts 50.728: 11192 POWEt 100 SYSTEM: NIGN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (BVit)
| |
| DE$C: NPIC WAS DEC'.At[D INOPERABLE WNEN If ISOLATED DutING SURVEILLANCE. SU$PECTED C0VERLOR P"C'. EMS.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL Nouts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 P.00
| |
| $ctAMS <15% POUEt 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 .
| |
| TOTAL SCRAMS 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 l $1GNIFICANT EVENfs 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 l SAFETY SYSTEM FAILUtts 2 1 3 1 2 1 1 3
| |
| ! 6 0 10 0 98 0 26 0 FotCED OUTAGE RATE (1)
| |
| EQUIP, FotCED OUTAGES /1000 CilflCAL NOUt3 0.00 0.00 1.80 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.55 0.00 CaITICAL NoutS 1903 2014 166) 1694 83 2069 1822 2154 l
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| l l
| |
| O 47 l
| |
| 6
| |
| | |
| 1 l
| |
| l TABLE 10.31 FARLEY 1 1
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 l I
| |
| 88F 10/13/s' Leas 34887018 50.72s: POWER 17 SYSTEMI CONTAINMENT CCMSU$fl8LE GAS CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: DRAWING ERROR RESULTED IN BOTN MYDROCEN CDe81NERS IN0PERA8LE T.S. 3.0.3 ENTERED.
| |
| i PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 1 NONE TYPE 86 2 86-3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% PGM1/1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.46 0.92 0.00 0.94 0.51 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOT AL SCR AMs 1 2 0 2 1 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
| |
| $IGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 1 3 0 3 1 0 11 0 EQUIP. FORCED CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL HCL 1ts 0.46 1.39 0.00 1.40 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 216S 2166 816 2136 1957 2208 2007 2041 48 0
| |
| t
| |
| | |
| \
| |
| . i TABLE 10.32 FARLEY 2 PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSA 11/11/87 Lits 36487005 50.728: 10648 POWER:
| |
| DESC: W0tCER OPENED FEEDER BREACIR 10 STA7 TUP TRANSFORMER CAU11NG LOW VOLT CONDITION.
| |
| SSA 11/15/87 Leks 36487006 50.72s: 10688 PowR:
| |
| DESC: CONNECTING MMR$ TO TERMINALS, DURING TESTING, RESULTED IN STARTING EDG SWING UNIT.
| |
| SE 11/22/87 Leas 3 %87010 50.72s 10803 POWR: 0 DESC: 2200 GAL $ PILL FRCM RUPTURED PCESSURIZER RELIEF TANC RUPTURE DISC DUE TO OPERATOR ERROR VMILE TESTING RNR SCRAM 12/03/87 LERs 36487009 50.72fs 10865 POWER:
| |
| DESC: OPERATOR ERROR IN NOT MAINTAINING SG LEYEL A80VE 25% DURING MAlhTENANCE AT LOW POWER.
| |
| SE 12/09/87 LERs 36487010 50.72s: 10919 POWER: 33 DESC: UNISOLABLE LEAC IN RCS (COLD LEG SAFETT lNJECil0N)
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 88F 02/18/88 LERs 36488002 50.72s: POWER: 100 SYSTEM: CONTAthMdNT COM8USTIBLE GAS CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: BCT TRAINS OF THE PENETRAfl0N ROOM FILTRATION SYSTEM WERE MADE INOPEkABLE DURING FIRE DAMPER TEST!hG.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 '87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.90 0.48 0.00 0.55 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% FoWER 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 2 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 SAFETT SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 2 6 0 if 0 0 67 0 EQUIP. FORCED CUTAGES/1000 CalTICAL Mouts 0.00 0.95 0.00 1.11 0.00 0.00 2.91 0.00 CRITICAL MOURS 1110 2100 2209 1803 2183 2208 344 2184 i
| |
| i l
| |
| O 49 l
| |
| l l
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.33 FERMI 2 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSF 10/17/87 LERs 50.72s: 10376 PwEt: 50 SYSTEM: PRI ERY CONTAINMENT / UNDETERMINED SYSTEM DESC: INADEQUATE PROCEDURAL GUIDANCE RESULTED IN AN IMPRC#ER VALVE LINE UP FOR MAINTENANCE ON CONTAINMEhi ISOLATION VALVES.
| |
| TNi$ CONDITION RESULTED IN THE POTENTIAL LOSS OF PRIMARY CONTAlW>2NT INTEGRIT SCRAM 12/31/87 LER8 34187054 50.728: 11100 POWER:
| |
| DESC: RX LEVEL RAISED CAUSING TURI!NE TRIP.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSA 01/10/88 LERf 34188004 50.728: 11178 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TUR8tNE DRIVEN FEEDWATER Pt.MP TRIPPED DUE TO A POWER SUPPLY FAILURE CAUSING A Lost 0F FEEDWATER.
| |
| SCRAM 01/10/88 LERf 34188004 50.728: 11178 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TURBINE DRIVEN FEEDWATER P(MP TRIPPED DUE TO A POWER SUPPLY FAILURE CAUSING A LOSS OF FEEDWATER.
| |
| SSF 02/22/88 LER8 50.728: 11578 POWER: 80 SYSTEM: NICN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTN (BWR)
| |
| DESC: MPCI ISOLATED ON HIGN STFAM FLOW. PLANT ENTERED 14 CAY LCO. CAUSE UNKNOWN.
| |
| SSF 02/26/88 LERR 50.728: 11612 POWER: 79 SYSTEM: EMERGENCY ONSITE POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM CESC: ALL 4 DEISEL GENERATORS WERE DECALRED INOPERABLE. DEGRACED TESilliG MAD NEVER SEEN PERFORMED, No PROCEDWE Ex!$f t.
| |
| SSF 02/29/88 LEts 34188008 5 0. 72#: 11633 POWE R: 0 SYSTEM: MAIN STEAM ISOLAfl04 VALVES [SPECI AL NON Ells CCCE DESC: Att FOUR M11V'S FAILED THEIR LLRT.
| |
| YYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HQJRS 0.00 0.00 1.22 1.49 1.71 1.54 0.50 0.88 bCRAMS <15% P wER 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 TOTAL SCRMS 0 1 1 2 2 2 1 1 LAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 SIGNIFICANT EYENTS 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0
| |
| * 0 3 4 4 1 3 SAFE!Y SYSTEM FAILURES 1 1 FORCED QJTAGE RATE (%) NA 98 91 % 66 76 12 6 EQUIP. FORCED OJTACES/1000 Crit! CAL NOURS NA 3.45 4.86 1.49 2.tv 1.54 0.00 0.00 CRif! CAL NOURS 0 580 823 1345 ii68 649 1986 831 50 0
| |
| | |
| l
| |
| } g i
| |
| r TABLE 10.34 b
| |
| . n FIT 2 PATRICK PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 8CRAX 11/08/87 LER4 33387018 50.728: 10618 POWER:
| |
| DESC: RECIRC MG SET INCREASED CAUSED INCREASE IN RECIRC FLOW CAUSING MIGH APRM FLUX TRIP.
| |
| SCRAN 12/09/87 LEts 3:387020 50.72s: 10917 PcWER:
| |
| DISC SPut!OUS LOW RX LEVEL TRIP WHILE WORKING ON MIGH RX LEVEL TRANSMITTERS.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 80-1 SSF 03/10/88 LERs 33388001 50.728: 11712 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: MICM PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: NPCI WAS DECLARED IMOPERA8LE WHEN IT FAILED TO START VMILE PERFORMING A SURVEILLANCE. STEAM SUPPLY VALVE MOTOR WAS DESTROYED BY EXCESSIVE CUURENT AS A RESULT OF A PROCFDURE DEFICIENCY TTPE 86-2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SC/AMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.47 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.61 1,47 0.93 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 1 1 0 0 1 3 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 0 0 LAFETY SYSTEM A,CTUAfl0NS SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 2 2 2 0 0 3 0 1 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 5 2 2 0 2 11 3 0 i
| |
| EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.47 0.50 0.00 0.61 1.47 0.47 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 2105 2124 2015 356 1645 2041 2148 1802 O 51 k
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.35 FORT CALHOUN O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1
| |
| . NONE TYPE 86 c 8A 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 A7 3 87 4 88 1 SCRMS >15% POWER /1tiOO CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 FCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETT SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 SAFETT SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 FORCEO GJTACE RATE (%) 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 EQUID. FORCE 0 CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL HCURS 0.00 0.94 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 2183 2129 2209 1571 621 2208 2209 2184 52 e
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.36 FORT ST. YRAIN PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SE 10/03/87 LERf 26787023 50.728: 10200 POWER: 26 DESC: LOSS OF BOTN MElllM PRIMARY COOLANT LOOPS SUSSEQUENT 70 FIRE CAUSED BY MYDRAULIC FLUID ON STEAM LINES SSA 10/30/87 LER# 2678/025 50.728: 10527 POWER:
| |
| DESC: CONTRACTOR CLOSED COVER CAUSING 00CLMENT NOLDER 70 CONTACT RELAY BUS BAR, FIRE WATER DELUGE, TRANSFORMER GREAKERS TO OPEN, AND EDG STAR SSA 12/07/87 LER8 26787028 50.728: 10901 POWER:
| |
| DESC: DURING RELAY TESTING, THE WRONG LEADS WERE LIFTED CAUSING AN AUX TRANSFORMER TRIP, Loss CF 0FFSITE POWER, Aho EDG STAR SCRAM 12/25/87 LER8 26787031 50.728: 11065 POWER:
| |
| DESC: OPERATOR ALLOWED TEMP TO INCREASE TO SCRAM SETPolNT CAuslNG TRIP.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 NONE TYPE 86-2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL Hour $ 0.73 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.58 0.00 2.02 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 ,
| |
| SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 0 SIGN!FICANT EVENTS 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 50 100 100 100 24 73 89 4 EQUIP. FORCED OJTAGES/1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.58 2.84 4.04 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 1366 0 0 0 1710 703 495 2149 53
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.37 GINNA O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSF 12/18/87 LERf 24487007 50.72# POWER: 100 SY STE*t NIGN PRESSURE SAFETY INJECTION SYSTEM (PWR)
| |
| DESC: DESIGN INADEQUACY IN THAT A CCm0N MCCE FAILURE RENDERS BOTN TRAINC of CORE COOLING, FOR THE CONDITION OF HIGH HEAD RECIRCULATION, IMOPERA8LE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 03/10/88 LERs 50.728: 11717 PCWER:
| |
| DESC: PERSONNEL ERROR WHILE CONTROLLING SG LEYEL AT LOW POWER CAUSE0 LOW SG LEVEL TRIP.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.44 0.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.86 SCRAK' <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
| |
| $1GNIFICAhi EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 3 0 0 1 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 0 2 1 0 0 0' 0 17 EQUIP. FORCE 0 CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.86 CRITICAL HOURS 2183 2176 2188 1415 2183 2208 2209 1166 54 O
| |
| l
| |
| | |
| ' FABLE 10. 3 8 q GRAND GULF V
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SSA 12/08/87 LER8 41687023 50.728: 10904 POWER:
| |
| DESC: DURING RESTORAfl0N AFTER TESTING AND OUT of SEQUENCE STEP CAUSED LOAD SHEDDING AND f.G START PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 01/10/88 LERs 41688002 50.728: 11181 POWER:
| |
| DESC: MAIN TRANSFORMER TRIPPED ON PHASE DIFFERENTIAL FAULT.
| |
| SSA 01/20/88 Leas 41688006 51.728: 11269 POWER:
| |
| DESC: FAILED GASKET ON CONDENSOR CAUSE3 WATER TO BE SPRAYED ON A LEVEL SWITCM WHICH CAUSED CONDENSATE TRIP CN F#LSE HofbtLL LOW LEVEL AND SUBSEQUENT LOW RX LL'V!L TRIP SCRAM 01/20/88 LER8 41688006 50.728: 11269 POWER:
| |
| DESC: FAILED CASKET ON CON 0ENSOR CAUSED WATER 70 BE SPRAYE0 ON A LEVEL SWITCH VNICN CAUSED CONDENSATE TRIP ON FALSE NOTbtLL LOW LEVEL AND SUBSECVENT LOW RX LEVEL TRIP SCRAM 03/15/88 LERs 50.72#: 11760 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TRIPPED ON MIGH REACTOR LEVEL FOR UNKNOWN REASON.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HCURS 0.00 1.39 0.00 0.00 0.46 0.47 0.00 1.52 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 2 0 0 1 1 0 3 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 3 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 5 13 0 0 1 6 0 11 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL NOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00, 0.46 0.00 0.00 1.52 CRITICAL NOL25 2097 1437 167 2026 2157 2119 891 1970 0 55
| |
| | |
| l 1
| |
| TABLE 10.39 l
| |
| l HADDAM NECK PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE I PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 l
| |
| SSF 01/14/88 LERs 21388001 50.728: 11218 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: CONTAINMENT ISOLATION CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: THE S/G SLOW ISOLATION VALVE CONTROL CIRCUIT WAS IMPROPERLY DEllCNED IN THAT THESE VALVES WOULD WOT HAVE CLOSED DURING A DBA IF CERTAIN LOSS OF AC CONDITIONS PRECEDED THE EVENT SSF 02/25/88 LERs 21388004 50.728: POWER: 0 SYSTEM: REACTOR POWER CONTROL SYSTEM DESC RECENT TEJTING REVEALFO THAT TWO 0F THE 45 CONTROL RCD POSifl0N INDICATION ORAWERS WQ)LD N01 PROVICE A RE0VIRED thPUT TO TME RPS IF THE AS50CIATED CONTROL ROD NAD CROPPED SCRAM 03/19/88 LERs 50.728: 11759 PDAR:
| |
| DESC IRM SPIKE WHILE SHUTTING DOWN.
| |
| SCRAM 03/22/88 LERs 50.72s: 11824 POWER:
| |
| DESC: SPURIG't SPIKE ON IRM DURING PMYSICS TESTING CAUSED TRIP.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 k 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.50 0.00 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMt <15% POWER 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 TOTAL SCRAMS 3 0 1 0 1 0 0 2 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUA! IONS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETT SYSTEM FAILURES 2 1 0 0 0 1 0 2 FORCED OJTAct RATE (%) 12 26 15 1 2 0 0 0 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL H0JRS 1,54 2.38 0.00 0.46 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HGJR$ 1297 1679 1998 2160 2149 420 0 258 56 O
| |
| l l
| |
| | |
| I l
| |
| TABLE 10.40 g HATCH 1 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/05/87 LERs 50.72s: 10217 POWER: 999 SYSTEM: EMERGENCY ONSITE POWER SUPPtY SYSTEM DESC: 1B DG TRIPPED DURING SURVEILLANCE TEST. PLANT ENTERED LCO DUE TO 1A DG ALSO BEING 00s.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 38-1 88F 01/29/88 LFR8 50.728: 11368 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: N!GN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: HPCI DECLARED IMOPERABLE. THE BARC8:ETRIC CONDENSOR LEVEL FLOAT WAS STICKING RESULTING IN FAILURE OF CONCENSATE PUMP START 88F 02/12/88 LER# 36688007 50.728: 11497 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: PRIMARY CONTAINMENT / UNDETERMINED SYSTEM DESC: 12 CONTAINMENT ISOLATION VALVES (TORUS) FOR THE AIR LINES 70 VACW M BREAKER CYLINDERS FAILED LLRT. FSAR ICEWilFIES THE VACUUN BREAKER CYLINDERS AS THE FIRST BOUNDARY FOR CONTAINMENT ISOLATION SCRAM 02/26/88 LER8 50.728: 11610 POWER:
| |
| DESC: MAIN GENERATOR GROUND DETECil0N RELAY TRIP CAUSED TURBINE TRIP.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 PS 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITnCAL HOURS 1.53 0.47 0.48 0.94 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.47 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 2 1 1 2 0 2 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 1 0 0 0 0 2 0 0
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 1 1 1 0 2 2 1 2 FORCED OUT/GE RATE (%) 12 1 1 3 5 3 0 2 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 2.29 0.47 0.48 0.47 0.00 0.92 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 1311 2132 2078 2136 678 2169 2209 2144
| |
| ~O 57
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.41 HATCH 2 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 11/04/87 LERs 50.728: 10567 POWER: 85 SYSTEM CONTAINMENT CCM80$ilBLE CAS CONTROL SYSTEM DESC DOTM TRAINS OF THE DRYWELL MYDROGEN RECOMe!NER SYSTEM IN0PERA8LE. TRAIN 3 WAS TAGGED OUT FOR MAINTENANCE. EDG SUPPLYING EMERGENCY POWR FAILED A SURVEILLANCE TEST MAKING TRAIN A IMOPERA8LE S8F 11/19/87 LERs 36687017 50.72s: 10717 POWER: 85 SYSTEM: MIGN PRESSURE C00'. ANT INJECTION SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC: HPCI DECLAAED INOPERABLE WHlu !T FAILED TC REACH RATED F'.0W DURING SURVEILLANCE. LICENSEE BELIEVES PRO 8LEM IS WITH FLOW CONTROLLER PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSF 01/06/88 Leas 36688001 50.722: 11136 POWER: 75 SYSTEM: MICM PRESSURE CCOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC INADEQUATE PROCEDURE CAUSED MIS ASSEMBLY OF VALVE RESULTING IN kPCI INCFERASILITY. RCic WAS CUT OF SERVICE FOR PLANNED KAINTENANCE, PLANT ENTERED T.S. 3.0.3 SSF 01/20/88 LERs 50.728: 11275 POWEL: 0 SYS?EM: MAIN STEAM ISOLAfl0N VALVES [SPECIAL NON Ells CODE DESC: INBOARD AND OUTBOARD MSIV'$ ON THE "B" MAIN STEAM LlkE EXCEEDING LLRT LIMITS AS PER T.S.
| |
| SSF 02/12/88 LERs 36687007 50.72s: 11497 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: PRIMARY CONTAINMENT / UNDETERMINED SYSTEM DESC: 12 CONTAINMENT ISOLATION VALVES (TORUS) FOR THE Alt LINES TO VACUUM SREAXER CYL!kOERS FAILED LLRT. FSAR IDENTIFIES THE VActAm BkEAKER CYLINDERS AS THE FIRST SOUNDARY FOR CONTAINMENT ISOLATION SCRAM 03/18/88 LERs 50.728: 11789 POWER:
| |
| DESC: PROCEDURE INADEQUACY FOR PLACEMErF 0F JUMPERS CAUSED TURBINF STOP VALVES TO SMUT.
| |
| 88F 03/21/88 Leas 50.72#: 11817 POWER: 18 SYSTEM MICH PRESSURE C00LANI INJECTiou SYSTEM (8WR)
| |
| DEscr MPCI DECLARED INOPERABLE. MPCI TURBINE EXN. VALVE WAS CNERMAULED AFTER LLRT, PLANT ENTERED PRIM. CONTAthMENT LCO.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS *151 PCWER/1000 CRITICAL MOURS 1.47 1.14 0.00 0.47 0.46 1.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <151 POWER 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 TOTAL SCRAMS 3 3 0 1 1 2 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 1 1 1 1 2 0 0
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 3 2 0 2 3 2 4 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (S) 5 8 9 1 2 6 0 6 EQUIP. FCftCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.98 2.29 1.74 0.00 0.46 1.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL MOURS 2036 1750 574 2141 2165 2005 2209 616 58 O
| |
| | |
| l-l TABLE 10.42 l HOPP CREEK b
| |
| %/
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 l
| |
| SR 10/10/87 LE N 35547047 50.725: 10275 PMR 10 DESC: SCRAM WITN SAFETY RELIEF VALVE STUCK OPEN DURING iUtWILLANCE TESTING SCRAM 12/n8/87 LERs 35487051 50.728: 10906 P0kTR DESC: SPURICUS NIGN RAD SIGNAL CAUSED 1/2 SCRAM WHILE TESTING MAD ANOTHER 1/2 SCRAM $1GNAL LOCKED IN.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 88F 03/20/88 LERs 50.72s: 118s9 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: PLANT PROTECTION SYSTEM DESC: A N0!SE SPIKE ON AN IRM CHANNEL FAILED TO GIVE A FULL Sr2AM $1GNAL AS li SHOULD MAVE. CAUSE NOT YET DETERM!kED.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCtAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.87 1.34 0.50 0.00 1.68 0.62 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 1 5 0 0 0 0 G 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 1 6 2 1 0 3 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 11 10 3 2 0 5 0 0
| |
| $1CNIFICANT EVENTS 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 1 1 3 1 2 2 0 1 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) NA 63 29 9 0 7 22 0 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITIC?a MOURS NA 2.62 0.00 0.50 0.00 1.12 2.49 0.00 CRITICAL MOURS 32 1144 1494 1989 2183 1788 1609 1045 0 59
| |
| | |
| . 1 TABLE 10.43 l 11TDIAN POINT 2 O;
| |
| l PI E7ENTS FOR 87-4 SSA 11/05/87 LERf 24787013 50.728: 10715 POWER:
| |
| DESC: EDG START ON LOSS OF 0FFSITE POWER, EDG WAS CUT of SERVICE AT THE TIME SSA 11/05/87 LER8 24787013 50.718: 10715 POWR DESC: EDG START ON LOSS OF OFFSITE POWR, EDG WAS CUT OF $1RVICE AT THE TIMd PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SE 01/03/88 LERs 50.72s: 0 POWER: 0 DESC: STEAM GENERATOR ALLOWED TC DRY CUT IN V10LAfl0N OF PROCEDURES. PLANT MANAGEMENT NOT INFORMED Bf OPERATORS SSA 01/17/88 LER8 24788001 53.728: 11250 POWER:
| |
| DESC: AS A POST MAINTENANCE TEST, THE SG ATMOSPMERE RELIEF VALVE WAS OPENED CAUSING A Si $1GNAL ON SG LOW PRESSURE.
| |
| SCRAM 01/25/88 LERs 24788002 50.72# 11313 POWER; DESC TOO LOW 0F SETPCINT ON IRM 15% .YS. 25% CAUSED RX TRIP.
| |
| SE 02/12/88 LEts N/A 50.72#: O PCMR : 0 DESC: POTENTI AL CCMMON MODE FAILURE UF SERVICE WA1ER SISTEM TYPE te 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87-3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL H3>RS 3.11 0.92 1.02 0.52 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 l
| |
| TOTAL SCRAMS 2 2 2 1 1 0 0 1 l
| |
| SAFETT SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 2 ? 0 1 0 0 2 1
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 2 2 2 L 0 0 0 2 SATETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 0 0 3 3, 0 0 0 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) 35 3 12 3 3 0 0 2 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRIT
| |
| * CAL HCURS 4.67 0.46 2.04 0.00 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL Hauts 643 2174 1964 1924 2119 2208 % 1673 O
| |
| 60 l
| |
| l 1
| |
| | |
| 1 l
| |
| TABLE 10.44 f, INDIAN POINT 3 (v)
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 SCRAM 12/22/87 lea 8 28687012 50.728: 11050 POWER:
| |
| DESC DUtlN0 LOOP LOW FLOW SURVE!LLANCE TEsilWG, A SIGNAL CAUSED A SCAAM.
| |
| 1 PI BVENTS FOR SS-1 SCRAM 03/31/58 LERf 50.728: 11907 POWEtt DFSC: MFP #32 TRIPPED FOR UNDOWN REASON CAUSED TURBihE TRIP, WICH CAUSED SC SWELL AND RX TRIP ON HIGH SG LEVEL.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >151 POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 1.99 2.72 0.46 1.01 1.52 C.00 0.46 0.46 SCRAMS <15% POWEt 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 TCTAL SCRAMS 4 2 1 2 2 0 1 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 1 0 0 1 2 1 0 0
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILutts 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 10 70 1 4 3 0 2 1 EQUIP. FotCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 3.32 6.80 0.00 1,51 1.52 0.00 0.00 0.93 CRIT l CAL HOURS 1508 736 2193 1983 659 674 2180 2158 1
| |
| O 61
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.45 KEWAUNEE O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 03/02/88 LER8 50.728: 11654 power:
| |
| DESC: 4180V Sus SARS SHORTED CAUSING RX TRIP.
| |
| 83A 03/28/88 LEts 50.72#: 11884 power:
| |
| DESC: DURING DG LOAD SHED AND SEQUENCING TESTING RECEIVED UNANTICIPATED $1 ACTUATIONS.
| |
| TYI 2 86 2 86 3 86 4 o71 87 2 87-3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 1.14 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.47 0.45 0.00 0.68 SCRAMS <15% POWER 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 3 0 0 0 1 1 0 i SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILUtts 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 FORCED OUTAGE RAYE (%) 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 EQUIP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 1.71 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.45 0.00 0.68 CRITICAL M0JR$ 1752 2208 2209 1314 2136 2202 2209 1478 62 O
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.46 LASALLE 1 3
| |
| (d PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/16/87 LER8 50.728: 10361 POWER: 90 SYSTEM FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM (WATER)
| |
| DESC: BOTN TRAINS OF THE FIRE SUPPRESSION $YSTEM lil0PERABLE.
| |
| CCF 12/16/87 LER8 37387039 50.728: 10996 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: REACTOR CORE ISOLATION COOLING SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: RCIC SYSTEM BECAME IMOPERA8LE WHEN THE WATER LEG PtmP SEARING FROZE SCRAM 12/16/87 LERs 37387038 50.72#: 109a3 POWER:
| |
| DESC: FW HEATER PROBLEMS CAUSED MFP TRIP Aho RX TRIP.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SSF 02/22/88 LERS 37388001 50.728: 11577 PCWER: 96 SYSTEM: REACTOR CORE nJ0LATION COOLING SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: RCIC REACTOR MICH LEitL SWITCH FAILED (2 0F 2) LOGIC. RCIC DECLARED INOPERABLE.
| |
| I TYPE 86-2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87-2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITIGAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.46 1,71 0.72 0.00 0.47 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 0 1 3 1 1 1 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAT!Dhs 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 0 1 1 2 0 1 2 1 FORCE 0 CUTAGE RATE (%) 0 0 3 22 5 17 3 0 EQUIP. FORCED CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.42 0.72 0.00 0.47 0.00 CRITICAL MOURS 0 240 2156 1753 1391 330 2135 1730 t
| |
| i 63
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.47 LASALLE 2 O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/16/87 LERf 50.728: 10361 POWER: 90 SYSTEM: FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM (WATER)
| |
| DESC: 80TM TRAINS OF THE FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM IMOPERA8tE S S F -10/21/87 LERf 50.728: 10417 POWER:
| |
| SYSTEM: REACTOR CORE ISOLAfl0N COOLING SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC: FAILED MAIN STEAM LINE DELTA PRE 3SURE STATIC 'O' RING SWITCM RClc 88F 11/19/87 LER8 50.728: 10719 POWER: %
| |
| SYSTEM: REACTOR, CORE ISOLATION COOLING SYSTEM (CWR)
| |
| DESC: RCic DECLARED INOPERABLE BECAUSE THE STAfic "0" RING O!FFERENTIAL PRESSURE SWITCM WAS FOLWO To MAVE A FAILED DI APHRAM.
| |
| SSF 11/23/87 LERf 50.728: 10769 POWER: %
| |
| SYSTEMJ REACTOR CORE !$0LAfl0N COOLING SYSTEM (SWR)
| |
| DESC: RCIC WAS CECLARED IMOPERASLE AFTER IT WAS 0!$ COVERED DURING SURVE!LLANCE TESTING THAT THE STATIC 'O' RING FOR THE MIGH STEAM FLCW !$0LAfl0N FUNCTION MAD A FAILED DI APHRAM PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SE 03/09/88 Ltts 88 003 0 50.728: 11701 POWER: 85 DESC: UNSTABLE CORE PCPM OSCILLAfl0NS RESULTED FRCM AN ATVS TRIP OF 80!M RECIRCULATION PLMPS SCRAM 03/09/88 LEte 37488003 50.728: 11701 POWER:
| |
| DESC: TECM OPENED VRONG YALVE ON INSTRtMENT RACK CAUSING PERIURBAfl0N ON ATWS SWITCHES CAUSING RECIRC PUMPS TO TRIP CA,5!hG COLD WATER INFLOW CAUSING MICH APRM TRIP TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 85 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL MOURS 1. 73 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.35 0.00 0.00 0.50 SCRAM 3 <15% PCWER 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUATIONS 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 SIGulFICANT EVENit 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 SAFETT SYSTEM FAILURES 1 1 0 0 0 1 4 0 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 49 0 0 0 20 0 0 10 EQUIP. FORCED CUTAGES/1000 CRITICAL MOURS 0.86 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.35 0.00 0.00 0.50 CRITICAL MOURS 1157 1192 2209 66 298 2208 2209 1983 64 0
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.48 LIMERICK V
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/02/87 LER8 50.728: 10197 POWER: 83 SYSTEM: EMERGENCY ONSITE POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM DESC: DESIGN REVIFV DISCOVEREC NON 0 LISTED FLOW SWITCHES IN THE FIRE IdATER SYSTEM FOR THE EDG ROOMS VNICH COULD MAVE RESULTED IN THE INADVERTANT TRIPPIN0 0F THE EDG 88F 12/08/87 (ER8 35287066 50.728: 10908 POWER: 99 SYSTEM: NIGN PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: DURING PERFORMANCE OF MPCI SURVEILLANCE TEST THE OVERSPEED MECMANISM BEGAN 10 SPURIOUSLY ACTIVATE. CAUSE BEllEVID 10 BE A MECM. FAILURE OF A SPRING IN THE MANUAL CVERSPEED TRIP MECMANISM PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 88F 02/29/88 LERf 35288006 50.728: PC?tt 100 SYSTEM: FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM (WATER)
| |
| DESC: THREE FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS REQUIRED SY TECH. SPECS. UE:E DECALRED IN0PERA8LE DUE 10 DESIGN DEFICIENCIES. ThESE SYSTEMS PROVIDE WATER SYSTEM SEPARAfl0N BETWEEN REDUNDANT SAFE SHUTDOWN SYSTEM SEF 03/09/88 LEts 35288007 50.728: 11706 POWER: 100 SYSTEM: MICM PRESSURE COOLANT INJECTION SYSTEM (BWR)
| |
| DESC: MPCI DECLARED IMOPERABLE VMEN TWO PUMP CISCMARGE PRESSURE TRANSMITTERS FAILED DURING SURVE!L'.ANCE TESTING.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3- 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 ,
| |
| SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CRITICAL HOURS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.56 0.00 0.00 SCRAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 1 0 0 0 1 2 0 0
| |
| $!GNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES 1 0 0 0 3 1 2 2 FORCED OUTAGE RATE (1) 0 10 0 6 0 2 0 0 EQUIP. FORCED OJTAGES/1000 CRITICAL HCURS 0.00 0.50 0.00 0.48 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CRITICAL HOURS 1104 2009 2209 2064 1073 781 2209 2184 O 65
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.49 MAINE YANKEE O
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 NONE PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 01/05/88 lea # 30988001 50.728: 11124 POWEtt DESC NTR DRAIN PtMP it!PPED CAUSED MFP it!P AND TuttlNE TRIP /tX TalP.
| |
| TYPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CalTICAL HOURS 0.95 0.57 0.46 0.00 0.00 0.90 0.00 0.46 SCRAMS <15% POWR 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 2 1 1 0 0 1 0 1 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTUAfl0NS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
| |
| $1GNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILURES O' 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 FORCED CUTAGE RATE (%) 3 2 1 0 36 5* 0 1 EQUIP. FORCED CUTACES/1000 CalTICAL wouRS 0.95 0.57 0.92 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.46 CRITICAL NCURS 2115 1757 2184 2064 336 1114 2209 2168 66 9
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.50 MCGUIRE 1 b ;
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/01/87 LEts 36987023 50.72s: 10183 POWER: 0 SYSTEM: CONTROL 8'JILDING/ CONTROL COMPLEX ENV!t0NMENTAL CONit0L SYSTEM DESC: 30TN TRAINS OF THE CONTROL 20CM VENilLATION AND CNILLED WATER SYSTEM IMOPEltABLE DJ 70 EQUlPMENT FAILURES.
| |
| 88F 10/02/87 Leas 36967024 50.728: POWEtt 0 SYSTEM REACTOR CONTAINMENT BUILDlWG DESC: REACTOR BUILDING EQUIPMENT MATCN WAS IMPROPERLY CLOSED DURING FUEL RELOADING - DUE 70 INADEQUATE PROCEDURAL INSTRUCTIONS AND INSUFFICIENT ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROL S8F 11/05/87 LEts 3o967026 50.728: POWEtt 0 SYSTEM: CONit0L BUILDlWG/ CONTROL CCMPLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: CONit0L ROOM PRESSURE FO.m0 TO BE BELOW TECM SPEC LIMITS. CAUSED 4Y DEGRADAfl0N OF 000: SEALS WMICH WERE NOT INCLUCED IN THE PM PROG #AM SSF 11/25/87 Leas 36987031 50.72s: POAt t 95 SYSTEM: CLOSED /CCMPONENT COOLING WATER SYSTEM DESC: 80TN TRAINS OF COMPONENT COOLING WA1Et SYSTEM WERE DECLARED INOPERABLE. TRAIN 'B' WAS DECLARED INOPERABLE DUE TO FOULING ON THE NUCLEAR SERVICE WATER SIDE. TRAIN 'A' FAILED WNEN AN MOV FAILED To OPEN SCRAM 12/28/87 Leas 36987036 50. 72 s: 11078 POWER:
| |
| DESC FAULTY DRAWING CAUSED LOW SG LEVEL $1GNA'. Dut!NG MAINTENANCE.
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAN 01/07/88 LEts 36988001 50.728: 11151 POWEtt DESC: MAIN GEN EXCITER FAILED CAUSING TUR$1NE ft!P/tX TelP.
| |
| SSA 03/23/88 LEts 50.72s: 11833 POWEtt DESC RX TRIP C.i 51 SIGNAL WHEN $1 CABINET DOOR $ NUT. SAFETY INJECTION START WMEN 000R SMUT.
| |
| SCRAM 03/23/88 Lens 50.728: 11833 POWEt:
| |
| DESC: RX TilP ON SI SIGNAL VMEN SI CABINET DOOR SMUT. SAFETY INJECTION START WHEN 000: SMUT.
| |
| TTPE 86 2 86 3 86 4 87 1 87 2 87 3 87 4 88 1 SCRAMS >15% POWER /1000 CalTICAL HOURS 0.00 2.26 0.00 0.47 0.46 0.00 0.86 0.93 StatAMS <15% POWER 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 TOTAL SCRAMS 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 2 SAFETY SYSTEM ACTuATIONS 1 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 SAFETY SYSTEM FAILutES 1 1 2 2 0 2 4 0 FotCED OUTAGE RATE (%) 2 65 34 4 1 12 4 2 EQUlP. FORCED OUTAGES /1000 CalTICAL MOURS 0.94 2.26 0.68 2.82 0.46 1.44 0.86 0.f3 CalTICAL HOURS 1066 442 1467 2128 2158 1390 1160 2146 O '
| |
| 67
| |
| | |
| TABLE 10.51 MCGUIRE 2 O
| |
| PI E7ENTS FOR 87-4 88F 10/01/87 Leas 36987023 50.72#: 10183 POWEN 95 SYSTEMI CONTROL BUILDING / CONTROL CCMPLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL tv$ TEM DESC 90TM TRAINS OF THE CONTROL ROOM VENTILATION AND CMILLED WATER SYSTEM INOPERABLE DUE TO UNRELATED EQUIPMENT FAILutES.
| |
| UNIT ENTERED LCC $/D TERMINATED WHEN TRAlW A DECLARED OPERABLE S8F 11/05/87 Leas 36987026 50.728: POWEn: 0 SYSTEM: CONTROL BUILDING / CONTROL COMPLEX ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL SYSTEM DESC: CONTROL ROCM PRESSURE FOUND TO BE BELOW TECN. SPEC. LIMITS. CAUSED BY DECitADATION OF 000t SEALS WHICM WEtt NOT INCLLDED IN THE PM PROGRAM 8 CRAM 11/05/87 LEts 37087019 50.728: 10579 POWER:
| |
| DESC: Tutt!NE RUNBACE TO 45% DUE TO TRIPPED MFP. CTNER MFP TalPPED CAUSING RX f t!P 04 LOW SG LEVEL.
| |
| SCRAM 11/30/87 Leks 37087021 50.72s: 10821 PaWEn:
| |
| DESC: FAULTY RELAY CAUSED LOSS OF STATOR COOLING MAIN GtkERATOR ftlP RX ft!P.
| |
| 88F 12/02/87 LERs 50.72#: 10843 MWER: 0 SYSTEM: CLOSED / COMPONENT COOLING WATER SYSTEM DESC: REVIEW OF PAST TEST DATA ON REDUNDANT CCW MX'S DISCOVERED THAT BOTN Nxt WEtt Uhn0WINCLY INOPERABLE At THE SAME flWE DUE TO DEGRADED NEAT TRANSFER CAPABILITIES CAUSED BY $1LT ACCLMAAfl0 I
| |
| PI EVENTS FOR 88-1 SCRAM 01/12/88 LEts 37088001 50.72s: 11195 PcwEn:
| |
| DESC: Alt SUPPLY VALVE RES VALVE TO FRV FAILED CAUSING LCW SG LEVEL
| |
| * OPERATott f alp TURBlhE CAUSthG A 2x inlP.}}
| |