ML20195F196

Rev 0 to Calculation 93C1783-13, Seismic Fragility (SPRA) Analysis,Beaver Valley Unit 1,Reactor Coolant Pump

ML20195F196
Person / Time
Site:	Beaver Valley
Issue date:	01/31/1994
From:	STEVENSON & ASSOCIATES
To:
Shared Package
ML20195F186	List: L-98-218, Forwards Response & Calculations in Response to 980728 NRC Ltr Which Requested Addl Info Re IPEEE for Bvps,Unit 2 ML20195F196 ML20195F211 ML20195F232 ML20195F244 ML20195F251
References
93C1783-13, 93C1783-13-R, 93C1783-13-R00, NUDOCS 9811190209
Download: ML20195F196 (14)

Text

'

4 O

Llgl,4!fL6.J.,c_

Calculation No.

9 c i7 s?- #7 Client:

D n r.,,, e i

Title:

CEIS AtrC FM A C I L IT Y (SPPA) A 4 zvioj @ r A vc a up le c y uppy 0 I RCAcTon e n o t A rr r PUMP l

Project:

G E A vt*<

1. LLE Y C E r i rm t Fr/ A c r t 17 t AWA L Yt t i Port in)DI v r o u A L.

ptaar c= X A m o N A T r o d.5 FOW g y7sgyp t gvf M TJ Method:

Acceptance Criteria:

Remarks:

(

-l REVISIONS

,/

No.

Description By Date Cht Date App.

Date 0

Initial lssue yh l 9 9

$gy j, 3 j.94 pg e, p.yt. 94 CALCULATION SE COVER CONTRACT NO.

i SHEET 92c/7F3

""" " d ' " '"

FIGURE 1.3

(

1-20 9811190209 981112 i

PDR ADOCK 05000412 p

PDR

CUENT d "*'

JOO fio. )

b

-_ SHEET

[

OF

/d

{

m cT b "i5^' b

• Wld

[3fM/* )

V

/Itobh5) b d 4 W [ {-*a )Y#C l~ I ' ~

e y

ma a i ri-n.

p a a.. a. s n

~

y a ca.*=:' k%"2::r'.

t...... -

& P"*P f C - P.1x 1.8,1 c 1

.il l,

6

$C b

.( AQm i.t I

. tdfI 5f

... a. M f. L/ d i' M.y % f yea.

f e

i!

.t 1. 9 L 1

~

JLm

_,. h ___yy_ _._..t/_) rstgtste. h _._

L.. n _

I h 1lSkl

, _jg_

a_L

.. _ u.

.. -.-.t-

_ ~. h t e_ __fr_.

war y.

gag 9 u.4 e e.4 g-6-

a-e*

_._.I._f, (.

hNi

.N,M._M M.. b+-=m.e-. - - -.

-wa.e-.w*M[

mg'

_ : l$2i S Y:a, = W I'._" S L Q Y_ KM M E '_ _ - _ _.___

% a;

• W biNk_

.fA** (~? H & T Q M L~ f _

p d u.,' d 4 _ O 4 ti w & z w & M M t.- L -

!i i

1 1.

.} _tdte f.e,e c A___ @ h_ _ W._ _.-fvi% 3 $'ppost

_L vy7

• yf -. -

42. ES $d:5f+.nm fM5kk?

1.1--

• ~-**-*~~-4.we e

.e%

.m WT

! (L...

U l5 k

Y ft

~

- - - - -. - ~ -.r s e + _. g.. mstip%.

o<yy1

. a+9we

--g l NlO4 &~ m2.4?c-A.lpart(WmjyW PgM'.

--91Eoz dAc. ~ ~ K.as]) q ylu. M d.e rs & & W % ~ot( m l

~

W

, p.r.--. sea waarmcist 'snaze -t.1wn 75^

e-f: w.

e f

g

~

w

7' 1*'/

Y b b I~

Joe No,h ' /7 E '

SHEET 2

CUENT OF /0 g

sugugcr.0 S r. *.'r fref.'lifs ':9P A,

/ M ww,,Es,Je,V.,L[c,, i,,.::. #:

i-n-ev irse v i. 7/.94

^

T g

5 e

\\

S, S., Q fp,,-(

g y, Stevenoots and Associates 7

N m ca.'s::m:0,'..

a:

./

NY hl SeISMk bG-e d_ Da-o$ m d (5, y tJq, %g flRGXj:;7G.ypAlii>nSh,atm.u 99 Qae p ipay ypa w gep% m s e :1.;;;

m

..,.-._____.__Lc':

i.

i----*, ---., N, b

. i 1 N/&r f'sa M.y, [ _k.$ U...._ _ ^

~._

~ ~ ~

,j, ft-j-

_...a__._.

7 [ ef,fr % K $ M M Y M ity-1 A _

_ Z Zl gwgwmmtw 4g Z 7 6 L u c,, g w; 4 - -

= n.s 6 3 M r A M- -

g: ;i i

}

Y -f-iMA Al-ykk b 75ciWAgb

~

4ddv*rQQ Q:p s:45 i yy}g-@pJigu il @ _ &<~jqGiG m A% M+

___.,tw_3_ A_ j_ g_ 4.eyg.4; 2 ~~, w.

m I

1. 1 1

. ' i ! ! i'm

_h Y Y

[

- -j..fi G Q /> n zgagg g ew;hm p:re sjwa j

zgm.f& yhggwinHp epgl &

.-..qrs

~

l

.Lc m uld.

K ytrum. J M.. 20 6-ncl Ej>L

~D M k}2k_hT f A hfR & "b M '-l ff " F ~

m--

.~

34das.LT%

A guqwtruewh%

-H

't.C' $

4 %

O '4 (Bt Y

w

-3. 7 L -. _ -

7.,(*, _ _f a

l7~] g g & & V 5 p e <. Y Y u v, f.- Wu o*l Wfy% Dff VN

l CUENT P

m. O S ' / 28 3 SHEET 2 OF IO g

m er Se.o d c p< w h ry SPRA>

/4ned<r>h, bank ~ ')dbc..An> 4 C & N ' ' ' "

en a - n - u y

//g3 ch Q(,,, f [4e m p_

f Stense and Asdum 3 c.t.T:' tit **."t#,.

A l

._ 2. __

.lll][ fit lb ecc ifshn rous m ay. >>wde pr-cwow>-0 T~h!Q*lmpWME~,1?iM1., L S i =.t.uT,.-c0 e r J~yL9. n 4Tip 6 Mi t z z g w a. w w g s_,h k

==*

~6

.m h

( =--- - + ys,-

w e~)

- y

_. -.. g._

j 'l; g {; p, l

' a _ _... _ _.

. _ _. __ _ _. __. _1._q l

T[T 4,,s._tilz p.o98 _ f,gj__ _,__

r og tc

---

m 7g. -

- H l l l l %m,a+E.ij; m g.- m.,, _

1

_o

,,,ii r

m f y di g-J AL-HUy_Y45I& WW16~

m = z, c s u a w,, ii F, w- -W a x.

s ym

y; 3A~Al if%P 4_

"1pgk by

~

6b 5

% %$4sbl, Tit

• W M M &udh psg y$ &ie4<&D?R?) ::__

Js;~r~

vf g: ' ' g _.

.. _ u,,, p m g. g gg m

1.,

+. _.. _

..2e%._ __ _u M widv6 l

7 j -2 + s 2 5 e i' rg; 3 9. -_.f>sh ee-~4 uwg e,!

5 #d' LA+LK.g:- 4 _ han k &..__.~. W__ _ -/* q "

N. [s-birX La B X,^.~-

J

&%~MKAM#Ly42p. 74 ~jw'd!y

Ee&,#WE LC-ei aus 4M ew K0.js.

74__

p gne% aJaLfm*K.y'LL4 % 3 p:%-

. =. _..

=

/

ls Mi %f/tM '

h 0 k.(Mk OC%

_)

i

-._-r w w w. m s-c w +tr a g*A

&4;

. - ~...

l

l JOO No. h 5 0 W 3 l

SF E OF /0 CUENT

- i g

SUWECT $e iS "' i Frei /, cy /.sps /. ;

f l

A s ly>;o, Bea Jd, I)dCey %' f

• A. h% ' '- 9" cPJr <J t-7 f - 14

+

l Stevenson and Associates

[ggffp t b d %.'P h 5:/

E c[..DOISU.N."7N.

.L LIdNS: d S ~ d % d u.< brh # p & Q 3 3f,~~ tie

]

/ ~~'~

7y l -

il 9

l L&i-l t..._d'..__.._..

i I L.

- +..

l==_ .pg) te a p. _ _ a _ _ F L k 2_ x. o.lE

= 0.l.,_

y L8jLx 3,S f...

1.._-

!.4 1 a%.

u Of4 h

D.~y e Vahs he't k Q & -S M W f tA f***f V

, w n m m u ua r w w.n n mma i g,=am wi n

r=----

.ii 75 Qri*Q Wik:V S h $"h

?l 2 ; 'i ' _.. _ _

~. _

b ALLedWM&! !! !

! : i t iiiii: :

s iil l l

A

.h h

Whr ; :_Q.)

'utT'ii,!

1.

. h N b_ k Of

..1 C

L l M rp' f f,..L A 3ke E Z[ M E %.4 L l

a

, _ = _ _ _.

b S

l>

ylsgpp g g w w+s p w ;zq:

,

j ; r g q } ' i K. s e 7UMKTkhgy

-y; g. p g; M. D.nL_.o. a _Awp.ed,-.-

y

,y a. g_. a m._ _. _,

g. a. __

s j

--. p.-

Ef 7.;g-y, g g;iiaMa w k m Ryas

~

I i,

)

bY 0 ' O &h 0.O

_I F

5 reepm_FiMf??

-L t

p.__ _Nerffc d_ C&ges/~ _2AyeW 1::1~3WiRKe fEGfient~tA hubr~ JK %.:

1 1

PLG J.,e.

IF E. E r.

m. # : M 3 CUENT weer E or /o g

weer % s~ u Pnt;+i l.S M. A A <, s f < >., '., i ea Lx b L'd 0y 'J ' "

• I hfN'j,%

S T

lx nenan wG. x pw.~

v n,.- a uan, n c.*,1MT,',*2::1!..

.-.2 _.

4 y

g.

g.,TT, u a s s A ape R w A A % 1:

i

.i l l g-~p:.feAET52RITMEG;_....._ g'_ _._

w/

-;~~.------

'~~'

- ~ ~ - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -

- ^ *

^ ~

' ' ^ ~

_ h )Ej:v h _ 4 9. %i i Ljdp7h %

, aj.

uasa uzg:

i 1

t_

-l.- L '~ -. fA1D MRS. W. -. -.C%f

4i3pp%p$'=9

9M,FM' 9'n& :wamy

_1 kAcL-ph[ g.

.L ioii>iL W %% L-t iii.

k, f

9. W 5 - -

.. L - - - - -

I L

l I__[! _.

/%d2Ergi

~

a.s

-. -l, p--

g-I t

I

_ m_ _ _ _

Ecd

. _ = -. -. _. - - - - -

=-.

rj f Q % waa% M & $ $

auk MWEEeEpKWkwdh K~&

h $hfh[KM:bf f

m w-w mN.,an7,,

V pwsi a <. ~ ~

sm.s mi

=

M.ML4+

A-

.O '.

bYf g

g yp

.n

• P

}

[ Ih]

.$$hNY h - - y L.- _.-_4-- g y,,, a 9,y),wa,.Q;

{

f s

i !!iu@a, snur.rs.<'N Ai d p

_ _ f,,y ' "..

- -bk I

1 V

l

fl* G 'I*' t > ZYE E 5 pg m,0 ? C i ? $

y y m CUENT f

suexcrSeikh FMiktv ' PRA, N 'n t-ot-9 v halwa,8ed WUmiludn'-

v en u,-,i. u y

^x g

steve =on and A==ata ge o c.# <

c,,, (. 1 p,,,,ju e a.eceera..

z i

T ; p f s 5, W r a *e d e m m & M, <,, 4 g 3

>..w-.--.

~~

N.

_Q T, '...

ut n al-

---

+

A

\\

-f a n.)

~~&_~5_Q&_&_ ~

~

Q&Q~ykpe

, 7;7q,7_

LLllbe& T5ftu"wdEC&, l+N: M & p q 'esG &.

_j, ! !i ;

,.,,;i..,

I E

i 1

b.,.

u.Waid@aki

-1" l

.. r7-

- - - -H

i,iiin

1, ;

E Y... E'

$21Lft' Sf W h M n :s f

}A[sq&g f %3sM:A. f:$ 2ziza

~

a c y m % gs s. ~

w _ m, AtiAglRpiuA K. -- @^Meti.D7%

ata_r4 % LE Q;.f 4 W ~: 7 y x s a k w 7

n i, i iit i. ;

o.2 Q u.oA

_.3.._-

~

i^^

3.> R.,. D M & h k b no b / % ; / N W ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~' ' ~_ _ _

_ _~_~ _ __~

-7____-

f

~JWk2% C -.

St

[f+hYh b2,l9b.*YNA$?y.. _

, YLAL--

n i g A.._ -._.ny be y n d o L by w in

• • Gh" ~ i BiiQEDEaxeid% Team n &ld b g

-3 p

3 I

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ * -

G. b 4 o ~dep s

I

--____. _- jw d b..

l

, s t.

ny J~ _&_CWrnmencht AM in A

% 't u _ $.

~

en

.m.

e*e.r-,e

\\

... ~

j l

l l

F M Tne, M EE

,co H e d.

7 3ggy7 og fe cutNT g

eua,eer Set:nde F une l' 'i i SPKA )

g'N t - H - N Q

fese. lyn, Bes.uc,. JQ wtt-cc ea w i - n. e y

sun, wta. < p..s y

~.-~ ~.

^

a ca.' = C 2 t:W,-

d-.

?ShI, M..F?f%$'.** :

~

J_o >(thL S? 2N. l'eI$f$$ Mt f5'.5bd N

-_1l L i&L_$3 b.- k i l !

J.4 A2 b__3.. x 2 M '.._ _;.4.,f..k'S_%V.acs)-..A9 _-bha _ M ("mw" L&__.

il

.ie s

3 l

i

- -. Y. _

O... _ (

.s L._.._.d-.._.

-_4 p_,

1heL&f.GL d @L MP" M'AfM S"[ N f

• II \\ :

i : 1 ; i i i t : i i

pbimMh ! 8ed El[hdp. ].2, ~,5,q 6 _" M_"!

i l

, r. - L_1 J _.. _....

! 5.,

My_t.,! _

.J i ! :

i r'9 t.e. x.bl a__

..-M a. _s.

l \\ hu l

! yc s,7

-, e, I LL:

_a i I

I

/d._

MA e...g_..__M e.., _. _. _

p ra n q c g p su wp u w : : :

q.y

~h o r s i ~N w 2k u w / & 5e si-h.i! b$%t.---ht2NYtS. iY.-

iii I

Jj i >;1 i ! ! !

'k eb Wg_,h $ 3.)-

._- - _1 qC L

+

y (tA, s. A h i, d s d E 1: a w a a m s t e A M.

i, i t

i

}/8 1,7ba tk. N 552

~b <MM

,,. n'.,

I

___e y' m m.___ _ __.._.a. L

' __i

,y g m'1 g

e

- q Ce ~ju d~U-M -.

L T T ~ ~

T 1.L.. -

~

., a_ _

>c<

u_

w.-

Q

*- ) s a-n

,1

d. 4_._.-_..

._ _ _r m a_n e r =. M.r vA.

vf_

sA

_ _ h_ _ w. a t _a w._sy.

3 u -. --... _ _

-0 0 [4 -O *

• 3 -(- 2. 3 8 --/)

r 0 n-5

-Os N_...yTm u t. f 4. M M*A 5)l 1.

__.-, - N. _._ - -. -+hL__w w.-Ve t s

CUENT M'

JOBNo. 9 U / M 3 SHEET OF /O SUBxci -

' S * * '- ?*05N Y ? IfA S )

/lnd

>io,8ee Jc5 tAJAc3 Um W " C h f ~l

~

y e

T h

wk c.s + pw.. in V

w.- ~~.

N 3 c.a....i u...m,.i.

=

,e l

I i !. ' '

I

, h u J (i l : h

___ _L! !!

i ;

w m'

n.Du{! i a_L5gphs_)u:

1

_a i

t.

i i

I.

i

.f F ) ! L 4

i I _iI l

1 l

! I i It i li!

1 d.

MME

@f3

_.[h.S f ~....

i r I R l

i i i

i -

! ! )y_j_.

k, U[

VtLPfd b[gl Iii 1 1. i. t

!.;. i i l 4__i_.a<. : i r,

2-bp

,i

.. W.

_. m

!s

~

i i.

t i

i

'T _

-.c J Af @n ! i i

'ris i

LL.

1: i i

ke&'fht"

$p-kS. kk,. b _

I.

i I

.N.. b$

,i 1 L i iii i

1

'5^ f L

NVrI W

Ddl 00 Ve d jb j ~C o ? } k 6 te +vt" I. I,. i

~

i osl

0. 0 l

I

! l

i i ! l f

a.

iai.

i i

i._

jN Delf N i : I ; ! !

i.

I t

I Il

?

j II flreJM%

~ ~~T i

~

~ ~ ~

!1!

i oo o 55 !

jf l

i II l i

'I i

i.

l MO dQA l! I a _i _.

.._._.0__

3a /S_d_

0 i !

t I!

I I l ! ! !

~

! IVQ-lb 6'Adf6,l l

/_ t L

i e.2._.-

. o... o.-._

I tC&d7Ph._ MI

/%

gT, 1

t4 0> 0... _... _.

L

~ _ _. _ _..-_

L._

.W

_., ~., _ _. -..

! I I !

M 6

me

+M bu==epe.'-A" ON"*'"**h

• * + -

.g

~.=*='-*4**-

i i i j

l 1 ;,

.stcew

' e WM o

.9 e.o i ;

5 E.C.$

_f.

--- y f*;

.N

-.. - - - ~. - - - - - - -..

- ~

+

I" SHEET 9

OF /O CUENT I-JOO No.

sen.:< fel,+i ' SPR A \\

g

_r W-A u %, a,8 u k, V &. usM

• l y ', r- * "

l g/

y gh g,,, (M, g p,f,,, y g g

Stmma and Amwiata A

E ca.h"Jii"OffA',-

. 4_._. __ _.

1

.u

...... _ L _f L

5

. Ed-.T Ef.__. -Ay..-.

_l~J 7

i. M e b. M h A 12Z T EFy E& g _ @ @,y_}C...?~h k.O* -.

k.t.-. k k., -....

k 5 0 t

.-)

! \\J\\

l.

. ^

..H cLp f,,, m h fs.--

rmn u_,

' M,.

Y i staL t,Asa_!,s?R4,_cwmreM4i._.. _-. _ - ._- _._

I 'rr m

I I l

I i

i l

i H,CL_BEs,' =f.__L_4..L%'WG_m!_[=l'b...L 5.

.E _. 4.

E, x,p'b. li65..(_4l.. L_ -2...+o. goo),-

E t

_._._.___..__i...

i i

I i l i 1

l 1 j i i

i 4

t i i

i l l

} i l

! = h7dl lafj!

. i j

m Il7kfMf5}!S@iff'*!

I 4

LQ.A.aCL% !,R""?P*M 67. -

l l.

spi i i o m_ mz_ z u:z c% wl+I a

i u.

o i

t i

i

= HGLPFgf, TxP-[EDL]_m. - - <

l-l H'c y v

i I

[Pj s

t j

IL h.yf,._:_)f@_.4)..<

h,uy

_t.

_5

.. ~. - -

I i.:

y y ;

h

!>ii,1,,

i I !

IT y

! i !

i i i :

I i :

m fT

~

~

_4. -_.. _ _ %a_ m ye -

2

! Ih M'tfk&*M-L d I !

I i ! !

il

.-Qi g

- 0 S. -.,.

yd b ~k..)..

sL. =

c D-1

___Qu g

g -.. - -. - -.

WV

,q ctp pg- +hpff Exp lo 5-] = 1.ol L.

~^

v

-y i

i 7_

.. - - - - - - - - - -.. - - ~ ~..

.t

-~

~~n p:s - ^ '

CUENT I' J ## ' '- C C t-JOBPb.

SHEET /O OF /O h

$e;$r., le Yrn <pil* i

(. WRA'- i o

/*>180 4, $eo l e,,

jc p J, u d. tt 4_ m M W H5 I~~W 7

y g w,_,,, _,

T IN a.- a uan.

%' cjn a6+ Sww V

e\\

g ca.'rtiffal3.',

/

[R@p: 7 {1 _ _

ggrgymagam % r,e y o,-l j,, 7 54 1;o, A -))2eeb fos W,. h.Spe @ u_h p-.

24 h _f5,-}k#[.I.b._ _. _ _. _....... _. _

rk ikiXf ~Ei~js~y,8% T:L u

- f.W )$ O bh..p k%E.k...

.[ h. _&4 C tu b C t' l$Il. _. _ _.

...l.

N-b_

~)S$,..

Wh&dBennhTrGiktas)"

i v

=-

k-

$.$$,5(n N ' I $. W. -..

-.. _ _ ~

u'.N, N l

Y Y

Y'-

.L L

YWp-u, n: u,,, w,.cawww r i i i i

Ih 'd~ b N @,1 M1L.v PadWaR ~ Ml' l

16 i ; i p& 6e al~iCWTPG=$%l-NuMgsb

- - - +

- i i

l

^

ki &> '

i t

i i

i i

i i : iiTr

-.).-., &kW l IA]

l

. _ -.__.. y--

b i i !

a_1.

. _I4. NIO %LIN. W i_h; ;i i. :hdie% N Ae i

W

+

?.'

i i li i i i i #ii i

s g haf w o A E G / F E fi tf ftRTS*%'9'?

p

_s.}Repd[Kw.an0L;XegeG3N" MM%y 'W )

r j g_9 w.g g___ %.

- ( wg.cfwa

.I

-w

=

.. =

j I

%e%-,+

-A.,..-

.-....e..

a---

t t_- _ _ _ _.

_ _... ~ _

i L--..._.

_~.,h...,...s~

~.

[

l

~.

i f

i e

i 1

4 i

l ATTACHMENT C i

i Description of Stevenson & Associates l

Program TANKV

1 s

Computer Software Systems and Services TANKV Software System The TANKV software system calculates the seismic response of vertical cylindrical liquid storage tanks and estimates their seismic capacity in terms of seismic margins. These calculations give a High-Confidence-Low-Probability-of-Failure Seismic Margin Earthquake (HCLPF SME) capacity of the tank following the Conservative Deterministic Failure Margin (CDFM) approach. The results can also be used to estimate seismic fragility capacity and design code capacity of the tank. TANKV is designed to perform an interactive analysis of vertical cylindrical liquid storage tanks subjected to base seismic excitations. Some -

Program Features and Capabilities include:

a SuppliedDatabase Containing:

a ASME Materials and Material Propertles m Anchorage Materials andDetalls a Various Types ofInput Response Spectra l

n Properties forMany Common Llquids a Ability for USER Additions to the Database a

l m Capability to Evaluate Anchored or Unanchored Tanks e

a Capability to Evaluate Bottom Vollft andLiquidHold-down Forces

= Consideration of Flexible Founaation and Tank Interaction l

a Capability to Evaluate Roofed and Unroofed Tanks

" #A#

Y'

1. "0 itj;g*l,".** 6c'?.C *.* t :py}

y

'u*""-

The following provides a basic description of the program technical basis. The seismic analysis of vertical cylindrical liquid storage tanks consists of two phases: a seismic response analysis and a seismic capacity assessment. The response analysis in TANKV is mostly based on works of Veletos and Haroun and Housner. The capacity assessment is primarily based on the work of Kennedy. For anchored tanks small displac3 ment theory is used to compute the liquid hold-down forces. For tanks with minimum anchorage and for unanchored tanks, the use of small displacement theory to evaluate liquid hold-down forces will result in excessively conservative HCLPF's. Therefore for these tanks a more appropriate upper bound theory is used for the evaluation.

The program is presently operable on PC under DOS (version 2.0 or higher) and Microsoft Windows. The program is highly user friendly, with a screen menu driven input system.

for more information.........

4 Write....

Stevenson and Associates 9217 Midwest Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44125 Call....(216) 587-3805 Fax....(216) es2-6273

i 4

i i

1 1

1 4

f i

ATTACHMENT D i

e l

HCLPF Calculations for BVPS-2 l

Flat Bottom Tanks i

4 1

}

i i

3 i

i i

e i

..