ML20207G258: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
StriderTol Bot insert
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:. ,           ._ _                            __
{{#Wiki_filter:.,
AUG 12 bbb                                             >
AUG 12 bbb HEMORANDUM FOR:
HEMORANDUM FOR:     Charles E. Rossi. Director                                               i Division of Operational Events Assessment. NRR                           ,
Charles E. Rossi. Director i
FROM:               Edward J. Butcher. Chief Technical Specifications Branch Division of Operctional Events Assessment. NRR                           ,
Division of Operational Events Assessment. NRR FROM:
On Wednesday. August 10. the staff met the NUMARC task group which is writing the new Standard Technical Specifications (STS) for the "Reactivity Control                   l Systems" and "Power Distribution Limits" sections of the STS. NUMARC proposed methods to address moderator temperature coefficient and hot channel factors in the new STS. and they presented an early list of potential technical changes to technical specifications requirements (Enclosure). The staff discussed and gave insight on each of these issues; it also reported on the progress of the proposed generic letter on cycle specific variables.
Edward J. Butcher. Chief Technical Specifications Branch Division of Operctional Events Assessment. NRR On Wednesday. August 10. the staff met the NUMARC task group which is writing the new Standard Technical Specifications (STS) for the "Reactivity Control l
Systems" and "Power Distribution Limits" sections of the STS. NUMARC proposed methods to address moderator temperature coefficient and hot channel factors in the new STS. and they presented an early list of potential technical changes to technical specifications requirements (Enclosure).
The staff discussed and gave insight on each of these issues; it also reported on the progress of the proposed generic letter on cycle specific variables.
The NUMARC task group, which was in the early draft stage for these sections, comrrented that the interaction with the staf f provided useful guidance for their work.
The NUMARC task group, which was in the early draft stage for these sections, comrrented that the interaction with the staf f provided useful guidance for their work.
NUMARC has established task groups to write each section of the new sis. The                   i staff expects to have similar meetings with the other task groups.
NUMARC has established task groups to write each section of the new sis. The i
staff expects to have similar meetings with the other task groups.
Original Signed By:
Original Signed By:
Edward J. Butchu                                 i Edward J. Butcher Chief                               ,
Edward J. Butchu i
Technical Specifications Branch                       -
Edward J. Butcher Chief Technical Specifications Branch Division of Operational Events Assessment. NRR
Division of Operational Events Assessment. NRR


==Enclosures:==
==Enclosures:==
4 (11 Handout from NUMARC:       Reactor Chapter Changes from STS                                 l (2) Meeting Attendance OISTRIBUTION: See attached                                                                     j l
4 (11 Handout from NUMARC:
l S
Reactor Chapter Changes from STS (2) Meeting Attendance OISTRIBUTION: See attached j
158':00E A:NRR       TSB: E:N                 C:TSB:00EA:NRR FMReinhart:pmc       RLEmch                   EJButcher                               /       i 08//1/88             08//L/88                 08//U88                                         l
S 158':00E A:NRR TSB: E:N C:TSB:00EA:NRR FMReinhart:pmc RLEmch EJButcher
                                                                                        }
/
g     (pl i
i 08//1/88 08//L/88 08//U88
i      pF* 3     ,
}
880G240037 PDR          880e12                                                               1, 1 REVGP ERGNUMRC                                                               A PDC                                                                   l j
i g
(pl pF* 3 i
880G240037 880e12 1,
1 PDR REVGP ERGNUMRC A
PDC l
j


                            .. _. =                         .                  -  - _ , - . .
=
I t
I t
.          DISTRIBUTION
DISTRIBUTION
* TIMurley             VStello. E00
* TIMurley VStello. E00 POR JHConran
                    ~
~
POR            JHConran
JHSniezek BBHayes OTSB Members CHBerlinger FJMiraglia MJClausen. OC OTSB P/F W0Lanning TTMartin JLieberman OE
;          JHSniezek             BBHayes               OTSB Members   CHBerlinger               ,
\\ 00EA R/F WKennedy 4
FJMiraglia           MJClausen. OC     . OTSB P/F       W0Lanning 4
-SAVarga WGMcDonald. 0 ARM NCentral Files OMCrutchfield WBKerr. SOBU/CR OTSB S/F:- (MEETING NOTICE)
TTMartin             JLieberman OE       \ 00EA R/F         WKennedy
-JGPartlow. OSP ELJordan. AE00 Regional Administrators 4
          -SAVarga               WGMcDonald. 0 ARM     NCentral Files                             .;
FJCongel PEBird r
OMCrutchfield         WBKerr. SOBU/CR       OTSB S/F:- (MEETING NOTICE) 4
FGillespie HLThompson, Jr. NMSS i
          -JGPartlow. OSP       ELJordan. AE00         Regional Administrators FJCongel             PEBird                                                           r FGillespie           HLThompson, Jr. NMSS                                             i JWRoe                 NRC Participants                                                 ,
JWRoe NRC Participants SRConnelly. O!A WCParler, OGC 4
SRConnelly. O!A                                                                         ,
SJChilk SECY BKGrimes LShao 3
.!        WCParler, OGC 4           SJChilk SECY                                                                           '
l i
BKGrimes LShao 3
l i                                                                                                   .
I f
I f
i 4
i 4
i                                                                                                   d r
i d
J t
r J
1 i
t 1
I i
i I
a t
i a
 
t 8 8-88 HAftDOUT FR0il flut! ARC:
  ..  -                                                                          Enclosure 1 8 8-88 HAftDOUT FR0il flut! ARC:
REACTOR CHAPTER CHANGES FROM STS 1.
REACTOR CHAPTER CHANGES FROM STS
Most reporting requirements will be moved to Administrative Control.
: 1. Most reporting requirements will be moved to Administrative Control.
2.
: 2. Actions to place the unit in a MODE in which the specificatico is not applicable will be explicitly stated.     (e.g., if Applicability is 2 50% of Rated Thermal Power, the Action could require reduction in Thermal Power to < 50% power.)
Actions to place the unit in a MODE in which the specificatico is not applicable will be explicitly stated.
: 3. Cross-references may be used instead of NOTES, e.g., for Physics Tests Exceptions.
(e.g., if Applicability is 2 50% of Rated Thermal Power, the Action could require reduction in Thermal Power to < 50% power.)
: 4. The initial flux maps at 75% power after refueling may be deleted as a spec requirement, because it is part of the startup physics tests.
3.
: 5. The 1.03 and 1.05 'incertainty factors applied to Flux Map peaking factors may be omitted and considered part of plant procedures.
Cross-references may be used instead of NOTES, e.g., for Physics Tests Exceptions.
: 6. The phrases "identify and correct the cause of the out-of-limit condition" is hard to include with Writer's Guide rules. A time limit cannot be specific.
4.
The initial flux maps at 75% power after refueling may be deleted as a spec requirement, because it is part of the startup physics tests.
5.
The 1.03 and 1.05 'incertainty factors applied to Flux Map peaking factors may be omitted and considered part of plant procedures.
6.
The phrases "identify and correct the cause of the out-of-limit condition" is hard to include with Writer's Guide rules. A time limit cannot be specific.
1
1
        !;ote: The fiUMARC task group presented these items for discussion.
!;ote: The fiUMARC task group presented these items for discussion.
l e
l e
I 4-
I 4-


    . i.                                      .
. i.
Enclosure 2 HEETING ATTENDEES Name               Af filiation Fran!* McPhatter         B&W Fuel Co.
HEETING ATTENDEES Name Af filiation Fran!* McPhatter B&W Fuel Co.
Mark Reinhart             NRC/NRR/0TSB Steven E. Farkas         LP&L/CE0G Les Bencini               Westinghouse Dan Foley                 C-E Robert Roehler           SMUD/B&WOG Brian Delano             B&W Fuel Co.
Mark Reinhart NRC/NRR/0TSB Steven E. Farkas LP&L/CE0G Les Bencini Westinghouse Dan Foley C-E Robert Roehler SMUD/B&WOG Brian Delano B&W Fuel Co.
Kulin D. Desai           NRC/NRR/0TSB Howard Richings           NRC/NRR/RSB Larry Phillips           NRC/NRR/RSB Daniel Fieno             NRC/NRR/P3B 1
Kulin D. Desai NRC/NRR/0TSB Howard Richings NRC/NRR/RSB Larry Phillips NRC/NRR/RSB Daniel Fieno NRC/NRR/P3B 1
I l
-}}
1
    - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _}}

Latest revision as of 21:29, 6 December 2024

Summary of 880810 Meeting W/Numarc Task Group Re New STS for Reactivity Control Sys & Power Distribution Limits. Handout & List of Attendees Encl
ML20207G258
Person / Time
Issue date: 08/12/1988
From: Butcher E
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Rossi C
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8808240037
Download: ML20207G258 (4)


Text

.,

AUG 12 bbb HEMORANDUM FOR:

Charles E. Rossi. Director i

Division of Operational Events Assessment. NRR FROM:

Edward J. Butcher. Chief Technical Specifications Branch Division of Operctional Events Assessment. NRR On Wednesday. August 10. the staff met the NUMARC task group which is writing the new Standard Technical Specifications (STS) for the "Reactivity Control l

Systems" and "Power Distribution Limits" sections of the STS. NUMARC proposed methods to address moderator temperature coefficient and hot channel factors in the new STS. and they presented an early list of potential technical changes to technical specifications requirements (Enclosure).

The staff discussed and gave insight on each of these issues; it also reported on the progress of the proposed generic letter on cycle specific variables.

The NUMARC task group, which was in the early draft stage for these sections, comrrented that the interaction with the staf f provided useful guidance for their work.

NUMARC has established task groups to write each section of the new sis. The i

staff expects to have similar meetings with the other task groups.

Original Signed By:

Edward J. Butchu i

Edward J. Butcher Chief Technical Specifications Branch Division of Operational Events Assessment. NRR

Enclosures:

4 (11 Handout from NUMARC:

Reactor Chapter Changes from STS (2) Meeting Attendance OISTRIBUTION: See attached j

S 158':00E A:NRR TSB: E:N C:TSB:00EA:NRR FMReinhart:pmc RLEmch EJButcher

/

i 08//1/88 08//L/88 08//U88

}

i g

(pl pF* 3 i

880G240037 880e12 1,

1 PDR REVGP ERGNUMRC A

PDC l

j

=

I t

DISTRIBUTION

  • TIMurley VStello. E00 POR JHConran

~

JHSniezek BBHayes OTSB Members CHBerlinger FJMiraglia MJClausen. OC OTSB P/F W0Lanning TTMartin JLieberman OE

\\ 00EA R/F WKennedy 4

-SAVarga WGMcDonald. 0 ARM NCentral Files OMCrutchfield WBKerr. SOBU/CR OTSB S/F:- (MEETING NOTICE)

-JGPartlow. OSP ELJordan. AE00 Regional Administrators 4

FJCongel PEBird r

FGillespie HLThompson, Jr. NMSS i

JWRoe NRC Participants SRConnelly. O!A WCParler, OGC 4

SJChilk SECY BKGrimes LShao 3

l i

I f

i 4

i d

r J

t 1

i I

i a

t 8 8-88 HAftDOUT FR0il flut! ARC:

REACTOR CHAPTER CHANGES FROM STS 1.

Most reporting requirements will be moved to Administrative Control.

2.

Actions to place the unit in a MODE in which the specificatico is not applicable will be explicitly stated.

(e.g., if Applicability is 2 50% of Rated Thermal Power, the Action could require reduction in Thermal Power to < 50% power.)

3.

Cross-references may be used instead of NOTES, e.g., for Physics Tests Exceptions.

4.

The initial flux maps at 75% power after refueling may be deleted as a spec requirement, because it is part of the startup physics tests.

5.

The 1.03 and 1.05 'incertainty factors applied to Flux Map peaking factors may be omitted and considered part of plant procedures.

6.

The phrases "identify and correct the cause of the out-of-limit condition" is hard to include with Writer's Guide rules. A time limit cannot be specific.

1

!;ote: The fiUMARC task group presented these items for discussion.

l e

I 4-

. i.

HEETING ATTENDEES Name Af filiation Fran!* McPhatter B&W Fuel Co.

Mark Reinhart NRC/NRR/0TSB Steven E. Farkas LP&L/CE0G Les Bencini Westinghouse Dan Foley C-E Robert Roehler SMUD/B&WOG Brian Delano B&W Fuel Co.

Kulin D. Desai NRC/NRR/0TSB Howard Richings NRC/NRR/RSB Larry Phillips NRC/NRR/RSB Daniel Fieno NRC/NRR/P3B 1

-