ML20236W345

Forwards Ltr Sent to Plant Requesting Mr Moes Package Store Be Removed from List of Potential Shelters in Beach Areas Near Plant.Discrepancies Author Found Listed in Encl Ltr. Served on 871026

ML20236W345
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	10/26/1987
From:	Mahoney D GUILFORD PACKAGE STORE, INC.
To:	Chilk S NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
References
CON-#487-4677 OL, NUDOCS 8712070411
Download: ML20236W345 (7)

Text

______

p-j

• F DOCKfiE0 '

?

y}

USNRC i

3

,,Ib 1

3tll LF0FDs F ACL. AGE STORE {ffl0E OF SECR b/B/A MR. M OE 5 r A C LtiGE 5 9,. M Ty G 4,se,nygeg,-

14 PLUM JSLAND BLVD.

NEl.JHUR t. MA 0.t950 1

l HL Si-iMdf..]

3 CH3 Li,, 9ECRETARf sucteAs sceuLArOn, commission SERVED OCT 26198J UARHJNGTON. D,r:

20S$5

!;EGAFDJNG DOO E T NDS.

50-443-OL/50-444-OL J

i A. r;T t JIn T O l i>L N'i l F 1 POTENTIAL SHELTERS IN THE HEACH AREAE, NEWAR ?,EAbF00K STATfDN DEnk HR S AMUf L Ji. CHILI WE THE QWHERS OF.bu1LFORD'S PACKAGE STORE, INC. D/B/A MR.

HDE ' 5 F Ek AGE ~TGRE, ArE OPPOSED TO OUR FLACE OF EUSiNESS BEING i

1 HEN 1IONED A5 A

HDTENTIAL 5HELTER IN DOCKET NOS. 50-443-OL/

• 0- 4 4 0-m EHi:LD5ED TOU WILL FIND A LETTER SENT TO EEAEROOK REQUESTING MR MGf c, s Arf k AAE S1 OF.E F0 BE REMOVED FROM THE L151ING.

W11HIN TH15 f.ETTEF TE A LIST OF DISCREPANCIES 5 THAT 1 FEEL ARE IMPORTANT LNOUGH TO FP INT; TO YOlJR A1(ENT10N, vOUR FROMCT ATTENTION ON THIS MATTER WILL BE APPRECIATED.

SINCERELt DANIEL F. MAQGNE'r 8712070411 871026'

)

i PDR ADOCK 05000443 P

PDR.

i

(

,)-

J d

.]

.-a f

j

[:

GUILFORD'S PACKAGE STORE,,1NC.,

D/B/A'MR..MOE'S PACNAGE STORE!?

14 FLUM ISLAND BLVD.

.NEWBUR't. MA 01950-

[

I

.1 SEAbROOL POWCR PL (4NT NEW HAMPSHIRE YANKEE CORP.

SEABROOL. NH

.\\

-ATTN:

DEBBIE VANDERBILT'

,9 COMMUNTIt AFFAIRS REf6HESENTATIVE.

l HEG ARDIlvG :

DOCKET NOS.

50-443-OL/50-444-OL A.

STUDr TO IDEIEtirf POTENTIAL SHELTERSLIN THE-[DEACH A$FAS NEAR SEABROOK STATION DEAR DEBBIE.

\\

l AFTER VARIOUS CONVERSATIONS WITH YOU AND.YOUR STAFF,; WE, THE l

OWNERS OF GUILFORD'S PACKAGE STORE.

INC. D/B/ALMR. MOE'S PACKAGE 1

STORE, FEEL A MEETING WITH YOU AND YOUR PLANT OFFICIALS WOULD'.NOT

"'i BENEFIT ANTONE

(,T ALL.

SINCE WE HAVE NOT'BEEN TOLD THE. TRUTH FROM THE BEGINNING, THEN WHAT WOULD ONE'BE LEAD,TO BELIEVE BYLTHE END RESULT OF SUCH A MEETING.

WHE.N WE F1RST SPOKE, YOU MENTIONED "THERE WAS'A 'COMMUN'ICATION' PROBLEM BETWEEN M(SELF AND'THE PLANT STAFF; AND THAT'WHEN I/FIRST CAL' LEI" INDUIRING ABOUT A LIST MENTIONING MR. MOE'S AS A POSSIBLE. SHELTER I

WAS MISUNDERSTOOD.OR MISCOMMUNICATED WITH BY'THE STAFF." ' TH AT.

IS WHY I WAS TOLD,NO SUCH LIST EXISTED..

'I NNOW WHAT I SAID AND 3

l I din MENTION THE.LJORD " SHELTER" TO YOUR STAFF.

'AS FAR"ASiI'CAN l

5EE. THE S1AFF HAS THE COMMUNICATION PROBLEM.WITHIN SEABff00K.

i-

1ISELF, 1

NOT ONLt DID YOUR STAFF WITHIN THE PLANT TELL ME NO'.SUCH l

LIS1 EXISTED.

YOU SENT PARTICIA TORR.

A COMMUNITY 'AFFAlkS REPRESENTATIVE TO 'OUR PLACE OF BUSINESS'TO REASSURE. EVELYN R.

MAHONEY AND MYSELF THAT UO SUCH LIST EXISTED.

AGAIN,,I.WOULD LIKE q

TO POINT 0U1 THE WORDS " SHELTER LISTING" WERE MENTIONED;.

THE SIUDr_ ITSELF WAS CONDUCTED WITH THE PURPOSE dF' IDENTIFYING PDTENTIAL SHELLERS. THIS WOULD BE FINE IF IT ENDED'RIGHT THERE.

BUT IT DOES ND'i.

1 AGREE A STUDY CAN BE DONE ON'ANY TOPIC OR PLACE,yJBUT 4

u TO PRINT. PUBLISH, AND DISTRIBUTE A STUDY. INVOLVING BUSINESSES OTHER, j

THAN YOUR OWN FOR SEABROON"5 BENEFIT IS NOT JUST AT ALL.

,j IF IT IS ONLY A STUDY,.THEN WHY HAS IT BEEN SENT TO THE CIVItk 1

l DEFENSE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE AND FEMA 7 IS THE STUDf'TO DE REVIEWED B1-FURTHER GROUPS?

WHY?

IT'S JUST A STUDY FOR SEABROOK!

ALSO, WHY1

)

ARE CRITICS UPSET THAT FEMA WILL NOT HAVE TIME TO-REVIEW THE

[-

l STUDi?

FROM WHAT I HAVE FDJND WHILE REVIEWING THE STUDY,: SOMEONE.WITN 1

MORE EXPERIENCE SHOULD REVlEW IT WITH A FINE TOOTH COMB.

~

THE FOLLOWING LIST IS HOW WE FEEL ABOUT THE~ STUDY, AND WHATJ

'l I FIND TO BE THE MANT. DISCREPANCIES WITH IT:.

.p l

1)

TOTAL SDUARE FOOTAGE INCORRECT SEABROOK STATES' 1990 TAX ASSESMENT CARD STATES 1879 Lj a_._____

1-

(' '

yb "J

am

~~q y

4>

m.- y.

1 f

a ib A)-

.(-

.(

d, 9,

f,., -

9@!7 c

li i. E MRA SOUARE-FOOTAGE

. N}

4 WOULbN i IT BE MORE APPROPRI ATE:10,iMfDER ESTIMATE THAN

.. )

OVER ESTIMATE..OR IS THEE1. DEA HEA'E 10 MAKE..,THE STUDY MORE. IMPRESSIVE FOR THE CIVIL DEFENSE AMD-FEMA 1 M

,i O

y FOUAME FDfuAGE OF TASCMENT g

.SEABROOK.

800

('

'IAX ASSESMENT. CARD 1258 THE PROBLEM HERE IS THAT THE TAX ASSESMENT: CARD 15 INCORRECT.

AND WE WERE NO FAWARE OF IT - NO. BASEMENT l' EXISTS UNDER,THE STORE OR COOLER MEASUREMENTSTAKENFROMINSIDEBUILDINb:

[>

7y.

3) 1 m.

<SDUARi FOOTAGE.OF STORE 540'

//

"'i y(( y! ?b. '

E @

F EQUAf!Fi FOOTAGE OF COOLER-360 Ot UM AL SOUARE FOOTAGE 900.

td

" l: !

4) j THERE I S' NOT 663 SQUARE FOOTAGE FOR SHELTEREES AS THE l.

STUDY STATES. ONLY 300.

j w,,.

p THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE THAT.COULD FIT.IN MR.

t@C 9 ' WOULD-1 l/

bE 16 AND NOT 66.

THESE FIGURES WERE ARRIVED M Bf THE

(.

FORMUL A : STATED IN SECT l. TON 3, PARAGRAPH 2 '.

r "THE NUMBER OF PER50t$THE CAN BE PROVIDED SHORT-TE%

/

5HELTER IN A GIVEN' AREU'AN TE ESTIMATED BYf ;D%V.TDINGOTHF s AVAILABLE SHELTER AfNEA 97 10 500ARE ' LEE 1. PEF,CiGON.

• Si WHICH.I'5.

THE VALUE USED IN THE RECEPTION 'AND -CARE' S

FACIL(TY/.5URVEY PROGRAd OF THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY l

MANAGEMENT. AGENCY (FORMERLY THE NATIONAL' ; SHELTER-STuon.a i

+

)

THC STUDY TAUUi ALL AVAILABLE SDUARE~' FOOTAGE FOR l

SHELTEREES ACCOMING TO 10-SOUARE ' FEE' RMR; PERSON.

l ON THE OTHEP HAND

.IT.

DIVIDES eALL' BUSINESS i

ESTABLISHMENT 5 W D "THREE. GENERAL CLA MES". WHICH*WOULD THEN CHANGE THE'i0 SQUARE FEET PER FF? WON TO.EITHER 15

~

OR 30 SQUARE FEE.T PER PERSON.

THISc1NFORMATION'IS'FOUND l

WITH)N THE FOOTNOTE ON PAGE 7 OF EfCIION 3.

L THIS WOULD MAKE THE TOTAL. SOUARE FOOTA$, AND THE TOTAL L

NUMBER OF 5HELTEREEE FOR THE PLUM 15LAMO AREA INCORRECT.

TAKING TABEL 7

FROM.THE STUD 1 JI HAVE-PUT ALL-ESTABLISHMENTS INTO THE "THREE' GENERAL CLASSES" ACCORDING TO SECT 10N 3 PAGES 5 AND 7, PARAGRAPH 3.

i NOTE:

THERE ARE FIVE PREMT$ES J DID NOT KNOW OF

'{

l, 0:tTCH CLASS TG PUT l.blDER.

FOR MAXIMUM AVAILABILITY TnEY CAN BE FOUND IN CLASS 2,

]

NOTED BY ASTERISL.

]

a CLAES 1 CLASS 2 CLASS 3 SHFl,L TER '

SHELTER SHELTER l

E.

L 3

l

-.~w 3 y; I

3 1

+

5 5

f. !

7 7-

}

).

, o q

AREA FT2 AREA FTE AREA FTPI~.4 i

j

.Q ' '

.p:

9 5I.. JAMES CHAPEL 4000 1J g

.q.. gp

- s GHELLFIRH

,jf f.j PURIFICAIIGN PLANTL**

3950

,e a

ISLAND SUB GHOP

'a P '/ 5 0 '

q SURFLAND Ball.

'f,

./

t

,j h

e' AND..TACI ' E 2100 f

f

-)

MR,, MOE'5 PACKAGE STORE 2.900 l

(NOT $990) l

, t.

t US GOVERNMENT 3'

i

.f RESERVATION 1910 Y

CITGG SERh'.1CE STATION j,~

t 1560 d, y J

i PLUM ISLAND

)

VO!.UNTEER FIRE 1

STATION 1560 i;

.g

- /

i SNACK BAR/

l g

PARKING OFFICE 1520 THF LIGHTHOUSE 1440 1

4 DICK'S VARIETY 9

1330 Y

I-(

4 C's DIAkt hAR 1320 l

]

.f'

)

OCEAN FRONT DECK 1270 CAPTAIN C'S 1200 D

1 PLUM ISLAND TOWN HAl.L 1160-1 PAUL L PATI'S BEACHCOMBER REST./LDUNGE 1140.

PJ'S VAICT) 1100 i

Jw PLUM ISLAND l

i COMFORT STATION 230'

~

GRAND TOTAL - 5HELTER AREA FT2'PER CLASS 10420

,12 B i O,

.L J210 J

7

' N

), q ?;

c AVAILABLE FRACTION OF TOT 44

. j-3 AREA - NOT ALREADY OCCUPIED

,[,

g, s

L

)

9d 3

.l Sil n

s

-r

.:.x a

j 2

,s.

i.

q.

=-

By [NTERNAl FEATURES 2/3 1/2-lb AVAILADLE AREA FOR SHELTEREES 6946.67-

'6405 2403.33

.,h AVAILABLE ARFA FOR SHELTEREES

-DIVIDED BY SOUARE FEET PER l

PERSON 15 10:

30 TOTAL NUMBER.OF.SHELTEREES

/..

PER CLASS 463.11 640.50 80.11-

?

o TOTAL NUMBER OF SHELTEREES.

^"ye FOR THE PLUM 1SLAND AREA 1183.72 NOT 1790 AS.THE STUDY INDICATES i u

(

TOTAL, NUMBER UF SHELTEREES LEFT WITH ;UT SHELTER 606.28 s'

5) IF AN ACTUAL VISUAL INSPECTION WAS DONE, AND IF SOMEONE

g.,

i SPOKE TO US THESE DISCREPANCIES WOULD HAVE BEEN CORRECTED I

BEFORE THE STUDY WAS COMPLETED.

LOOKING AT SECTION 2.

PAGE P.

THE-STUDY STATES ~" DISCREPANCIES WEPE NOTED", THIS I FIND IMPOSSIBLE SINCE ERRORS STILL ARE SHOWN.

t

6) IF EEABROOK IS AWARE NOT AL~L THE'INFORMATION IN THE STUDY 15 CORRECT, THA1 NOT ALL SOUARE FOOTAGE CAN BE USED FOR l

7 SHELTEREES, THEN WHY HAVEN'T. THE DISCREPANCIES-BEEN CORRECTED BEFORE SENDING T H E ' S T U D Y. D U T.'

TO THE CIVIL DEFENSE AND EEMA?

IgAYING WE ARE.

WITH

'A NUCLEAR REACTOR THAT' HAS THE POSS[BILITf 'OF GOING ASTRAY. -NOT A COMPUTER WHERE'YOU SlART UP A N.D WORK OUT THE BUGS AFTER IT HAS BEEN OPERATING.

vi j

7) '5HE PUILDING WHICH HOU.SES MR. MOE'S IS 60'TO 70 YEARS OLD, WE l -

LTD NOT KNOW PEOP'LE WERE CONSIDERING RADIATION, FALL OUT BAQK THEN.

q

8) WAS 17 EVE'R CONSIDERED THAT BUSINESS OWNER'S WOULD NOT STAY DEHIND IN THE EVENT OF AN ACCIDENT, LEAVING THE-l POTENTIAL SHELTER NOT AVAILABLE.

1

9) IF AN ACCIDENT OCCURED ON A' SUNDAY LIQOUR STORES ARE NOT OPEN IN MASS., ARE WE.' SUPPOSE TO'GIVE SEABROOK A KEY TO-

{

,h OPEN THE DOORS FOR THE SHELTEREES?

i

{

10) AS OWNERS OF THE BUSINESS AND PROPERTY WE SHOULDLHAVE j

BEEN CONSULTED BEFORE THE STUDY WAS DONE.

4

1. .j TO CONCLUDE WE ARE ASNING FOR A' WRITTEN STATEMENT -FROM-SEABROOh 5TATING MR.

MOE'S HAS BEEN REMOVED FROM THE. POTENTIAL 4

SHELTER LISTING.

ALSO,- THAT THE STATEMENT BE-SENT TO ALL:

1; PAR TIES. WHO HAVE THE LISTING SO THAT THEY ARE AWARE WE OPPOSE BUCH'A LUDICROUS IDEA.

TWO WEEKS. TIME FOR SUCH: A STATEMENT'.IS y[

s 3

4 W

4

a',

a l

ADtDUA1E f DUR PROT 1PT ACT]ON ON THIS WILL BE APPRECI ATED.

SINCERELY DANIEL F, MAHONEY C/C.:

CITIZEN'S WITHIN THE 10 MILE RA]JIOUS NRC FEMA C3Vll DEFENSE OF NEW HANPSHIRE CIVIL DEFENSE OF MASS.

ATTORNEY GENERAL'S GOVOIJOR ' SUNUNU GOVONOR-DUKASIS F505 ION GLOTE DA I L'f NEWS CH AiJNEL.

4, S,

L7

)

9

• 9 8

e t

e S

a 8

9 5

b <;..-

l a

TO:

Mr.' Terry Harpster,' Director ofLEmergency; Planning; l

New; Hampshire Yankee Corporation Seabrook, New Hampshire

'RE:' STATEMENT ~CONCERNING~USE OF; PREMISES AS< SHELTER IN SUPPORT-;

-0F SEABROOK: STATION: EMERGENCY RESPONSE'PLANNINGL lI am owner Of: j%,, g [f *. //L W O & ? & n )!

r-

/

f It=.hasbeen. brought,to>my atten. tion that my.. premises-has be'en listed as'a potentia 11public: shelter for'use,in1the event?,

of an. emergency;at.Seabrook Station r'equiring the'shelteringLof ~

the.public: ins."A-STUDY TO IDENTIFY' POTENTIAL SHELTERS INuTHEL BEACH AREA NEAA SEABROOK' STATION",Lprepared/by.Stoneland Webster'!,

Engineering. Corporation 1for NewLHampshire~ Yankee.(RevisionT1,-

~

August 1987).

g I am. writing to.make it clear thatLI was not consulted prior to the inclusion o.f my ' premises in theElist of: potentiali L

shelters, and that I do'not' intend to make my premises L

available for use as a' shelter;in.theLevent:of an. emergency at-Seabrook Station.

i I request that New Hampshire Yankeelremove my premises from any list of potential shelters. developed a_s: part ofcany.

L

~

emergency response plans in1 connection.with.New: Hampshire Yankee's efforts to obtain an operating license for)Seabrook~

Station from the Nuc1 par Regulatory,Co.mmission'.

'I willLnot permit its use for.gshleltering purposes.

_ A,/n /I7 ibi./l h? ]? l/l,,,

Dat~e Owney/ Agent-

[

/V J A,,, O h, j J f Z Address-5.$,

h u..

9.r~i 77 Docket Nos. 50-4'43-OL/50-444-OL1 l

cc:

Mr. Samuel'.3. Chilk,.< Secretary

-20555" Nuclear Regulatory Commission.,' Washington,'D.C.

Mr. Edward Thomas,. Reg'ional. Director Federal Emergency Management-Agency.

j 442 McCormack POCH, Boston'.MA :02109:

i l:

j o

4 o