ML20098E385: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older edit
VisualWikitext
StriderTol Bot change
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 17: Line 17:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:R h
{{#Wiki_filter:R h
                                                                                    ~
September 26, 1984:
September 26, 1984:             j KELATJApRRESPONDEhGL L_.,-
j
(                                   UNITED STATES OF AMERICA                   00CKETEC C
~
KELATJApRRESPONDEhGL L_.,-
' (
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 00CKETEC C
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boar &4 SEP 27 P4:20 -
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boar &4 SEP 27 P4:20 -
In the' Matter of                           )             0FDCE OFSECRE~n
In the' Matter of
                                ~
)
                                                              )             GOCKiilNG i SERV!U METROPOLITAN' EDISON COMPANY,'ET AL.         ) Docket'No. 50-28Y 5h"
0FDCE OFSECRE~n
                                                            -) -(Restart-Management Remand)
~
(Three. Mile Island Nuclear                 )
)
Station,. Unit No. 1)                       )
GOCKiilNG i SERV!U METROPOLITAN' EDISON COMPANY,'ET AL.
                        ' LICENSEE'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW ITS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY ON LICENSEE'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND'FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO UCS On September 14, 1984,-Licensee filed a Motion to
) Docket'No. 50-28Y 5h"
                ' Compel Discovery on Licensee's First Set of Interrogatories and First Request for-Production of Documents to UCS.             In the interest of resolving their discovery differences, counsel for Licensee and UCS met on Friday, September 21, at which time an. agreement was reached that accommodates'the initial discovery: requests posed by both parties.           The enclosed
-) -(Restart-Management Remand)
                -le'tter from Licensee's counsel to counsel for UCS, which
(Three. Mile Island Nuclear
              -was reviewed and approved by Ms. Weiss, reflects the parties' agreement..
)
Station,. Unit No. 1)
)
' LICENSEE'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW ITS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY ON LICENSEE'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND'FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO UCS On September 14, 1984,-Licensee filed a Motion to
' Compel Discovery on Licensee's First Set of Interrogatories and First Request for-Production of Documents to UCS.
In the interest of resolving their discovery differences, counsel for Licensee and UCS met on Friday, September 21, at which time an. agreement was reached that accommodates'the initial discovery: requests posed by both parties.
The enclosed
-le'tter from Licensee's counsel to counsel for UCS, which
-was reviewed and approved by Ms. Weiss, reflects the parties' agreement..
In view-of the' agreement reached by Licensee and UCS, Licensee hereby requests.the Board's permission to l withdraw its September l'4 Motion to Compel.
In view-of the' agreement reached by Licensee and UCS, Licensee hereby requests.the Board's permission to l withdraw its September l'4 Motion to Compel.
Respectfully submitted, b             b.
Respectfully submitted, b
Deborah B. Bauser SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE 1800 M Street, N.W.
b.
l 8409280403 840926 Washington, D.C. 20036             -
Deborah B.
PDR ADOCK 05000289.
Bauser SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE 1800 M Street, N.W.
C                                          (202) 822-1215 PDR_                 Counsel for Licensee Enclosure
l 8409280403 840926 Washington, D.C.
        $d)'                                                                                     >
20036 PDR ADOCK 05000289.
(202) 822-1215 C
PDR_
Counsel for Licensee Enclosure
$d)'


14                                                                 Saptember 26, 1984 t i' z
14 Saptember 26, 1984 t i'
      \:                                                                       CDLKETED UNITED STATES OF AMERICA                 U3NRC NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
\\:
    ~
z CDLKETED UNITED STATES OF AMERICA U3NRC NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
                                                                          '84 SEP 27 P4:21 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD LFFf'J OF SE Cnt ?Fa .
'84 SEP 27 P4:21
00CKLIn!4G & SEN' In the Matter of                       )                     BRANCH
~
                                                          )
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD LFFf'J OF SE Cnt ?Fa.
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY, ET AL.   -)-Docket No. 50-289 SP
00CKLIn!4G & SEN' In the Matter of
                                                          ) (Restart-Management Remand)
)
                  .(Three Mile Island' Nuclear             )
BRANCH
Station, Unit No. 1)                   )
)
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY, ET AL.
-)-Docket No. 50-289 SP
) (Restart-Management Remand)
.(Three Mile Island' Nuclear
)
Station, Unit No. 1)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of " Licensee's Motion to
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of " Licensee's Motion to
                . Withdraw its Motion to Compel Discovery on Licensee's First
. Withdraw its Motion to Compel Discovery on Licensee's First
                - Set of Interrogatories and First Request for Production of Documents to UCS" and a {{letter dated|date=September 26, 1984|text=letter dated September 26, 1984}} from D. Bauser,~ counsel for Licensee, to E. Weiss, counsel for UCS were served this 26th day of September, 1984, by deposit in the U.S. mail, first class, postage prepaid, to the. parties on the attached Service List.
- Set of Interrogatories and First Request for Production of Documents to UCS" and a {{letter dated|date=September 26, 1984|text=letter dated September 26, 1984}} from D.
N         0 Deborah B. Bauser cc:-' Attached Service List
Bauser,~ counsel for Licensee, to E. Weiss, counsel for UCS were served this 26th day of September, 1984, by deposit in the U.S. mail, first class, postage prepaid, to the. parties on the attached Service List.
N 0
Deborah B.
Bauser cc:-' Attached Service List a
.-1-----
s-


r M                                       SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMap Or pRorESSeONAL CORpORATsoNS 1800 M STREET. N. w.
r M
WASHINGTON. O. C. 20036 RAMSav D. POTTs. Mc             CHARLES e. TEMutN. at                 (    >                  JOMN M mrv 50N.H+             JCMN M MORE sTEuaRT L m                    STEpMEN e. MuTTLER. p C.                      "~~              GEORGE r AteRiGMT. JR **       wE=DEteN A. wwct GEORGE r. TR'TmAN.
SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMap Or pRorESSeONAL CORpORATsoNS 1800 M STREET. N. w.
ows RsOGE.* C.
WASHINGTON. O. C. 20036
W C. wiNTMROp N. enowN, Pc                                          OAveO J. CvhAM                 S TANL ET M. BARG STE p=E N O. pOTTS. P C.       J AME S e MAMLue. P C.                 TE LE CO *'E "          Jac A A. MORN
(
* ON            LE SUE 4. SMEN GERALO CMANNOrr, Pc .           RANDAL e. mELL. p C.                                           LoveSE A. M ATMEwS             veRG*NI A S. RuTLEDGE PM8Lup D. eOSTwiCK. p C.       RosERT E. ZAMLER. p.C                                           SETH M. MOOGAS8AN             EATHE RINE p CMEEE R.TiMOTM                       ROeERT s. ROneaNS. a t         Roa 522-eO99 & G22,#199        SM E IL A Mcc.MARvEv           TRAvi$T.eRowm.JR MANN GEORGE e.T     MANLON P C.
RAMSav D. POTTs. Mc CHARLES e. TEMutN. at JOMN M mrv 50N.H+
ROGERS.JR.,PA            EN M. LuCA S. p C.                                       OE v3 SA A. RiOGway STE SANDRA AMEN    e. ME'SCA E a=u rRED 4. uTTLE
JCMN M MORE GEORGE r AteRiGMT. JR **
* C.              STEvO DAv      M. RueEN$tEiN. P C.                 -
wE=DEteN A. wwct GEORGE r. TR'TmAN.
* E NNETH J MAumAN O**E JCMM e. RMtNELANDER. F C.       MAYiAS r. TRAveESO-O AZ pt                                     Dav'O L A ARENCE MILLER       E'L E E N 'M8"NDE PAMELA          A      RS'O'N mRuCE w. CMuRCM*LL P C.         VICTOR $A J. PERKINS
* C.
* C.               MAptFAX '00           rREDER*Cm L mLEIN LESut A. NaCMOLSON JR , PC     JCMN M. O NE sLL. J R., p C.                                   STEVEN P. 987Lg m             ALE
sTEuaRT L m STEpMEN e. MuTTLER. p C.
* ANDE R O. TOM ASZLZum MARTIN O. KRALL P C.           JAv A. EPSTIEN P C.                     (2024 e22 8072         RtCMARO J PA RRt NO                     EY J ^ G ELLEN A, FREDEL               JE'#"ENCE LAUR          w. CO'ee MENS JAv E, SFLeERG. D C.           JEFFERT L TAeLpN, p C.                                         RosERT C eOEMw                 OEME 4 w. L*NOE N eAReARA M. ROSSOTTI.
"~~
* C.       JACM MemAT. P C                               -                                                pM     p D. O GEORGE V. ALLEN. JR P.C.*       EuSABETM M. PENOLETON                                           M ARet M. DOLAND*             ,        g               e F RE D O RA SME R. p C.        MARRY M. GLAS$p EGEL                        TELEX                              LL            g ggg g 3,,g ,s,,,
OAveO J. CvhAM S TANL ET M. BARG Jac A A. MORN
R. MENLv wE ESTER. P C.         TMOM AS M. McCOR'Mecn                                           ? MOME.
* ON ows RsOGE. W C.
DaANE  ASsum C M'mLEv*          a,y, g     ,,g, g Lg y g g NATMANIEL P mREED. JR., PC      wgLL IAM p. mARR*               Sg.2693 (SMawLaw WSM1         L. OuA N E CM E t n           DAv80 R $4MR MARE AUGENeUCM p C.             CHARLES M. MONTANGE                                             M'Ch*AE L m. M AODE N         c poweg,n ynA,N ERNEST L eLAmE. JR., p c.       JEAN M. GALLoway*                   CAeLE "$MawLAw             M ANN AM E. M. LaE eE RM AN   gg,regu w gAupgguaq CARLETON S. JONES. P C.            HN L CARR. J R.                                             JuOeN A.SANDLE"               mENNETM A G
wiNTMROp N. enowN, Pc LE SUE 4. SMEN STE p=E N O. pOTTS. P C.
      'HOMa h A. maxTE R. P C.       JO.
J AME S e MAMLue. P C.
pe estop e MARvEv                             _                ANDREW 0. ELuS                Day,0 R      L g w. S A LL O SMELOON J. WEISEL. PA           RosERT M. GORDON                                 .             RfCM ARO A. SA M8             A pATR Cm LEoGMTON 684         8
GERALO CMANNOrr, Pc.
      ,, PATR8CM MsCEE V P C.         SONNst 5. GOTTUE e                   VIRGIN 6A OFF8CE           THOM A S E. CROCKE R. J R. a gNNETH O. Aut ReACM J. TMOM A S LE NM A PT.
RANDAL e. mELL. p C.
* C. MOWARD M. SMAFFE RMAN                                           VsCat R. MARDWG               AL AN O. W ASSE RM AN NO uL CM.        C.            TT & ANEheERG                                                  L N ORELL                    C    RO u A eEC*im 8 ""O#S     Ek, "X,..'. . C.*                                                                       '
TE LE CO *'E "
* E M S EV,.,8'n'E"                 ~e'E AN v'Ro'N'a 22m*           "'"N#M N      R T E "a*^""       *&"JT".!a'J"CCTETM'A'N
LoveSE A. M ATMEwS veRG*NI A S. RuTLEDGE PM8Lup D. eOSTwiCK. p C.
                                                                                    -
RosERT E. ZAMLER. p.C Roa 522-eO99 & G22,#199 SETH M. MOOGAS8AN EATHE RINE p CMEEE R.TiMOTM ROeERT s. ROneaNS. a t SM E IL A Mcc.MARvEv TRAvi$T.eRowm.JR GEORGE e.T MANLON P C.
* esor Aces.ngo .se D C JOMN r. DEALT *                                         +-~==-A
STE AMEN e. ME'SCA MANN EN M. LuCA S. p C.
OE v3 SA A. RiOGway ROGERS.JR.,PA STEvO M. RueEN$tEiN. P C.
* E NNETH J MAumAN SANDRA E a=u rRED 4. uTTLE
* C.
DAv O**E JCMM e. RMtNELANDER. F C.
MAYiAS r. TRAveESO-O AZ pt Dav'O L A ARENCE MILLER E'L E E N 'M8"NDE RS'O'N mRuCE w. CMuRCM*LL P C.
VICTOR $A J. PERKINS
* C.
MAptFAX '00 rREDER*Cm L mLEIN PAMELA A
LESut A. NaCMOLSON JR, PC JCMN M. O NE sLL. J R., p C.
STEVEN P. 987Lg m ALE
* ANDE R O. TOM ASZLZum JE'#"ENCE w. CO'ee S EY J ^ G MARTIN O. KRALL P C.
JAv A. EPSTIEN P C.
(2024 e22 8072 RtCMARO J PA RRt NO LAUR MEN ELLEN A, FREDEL JAv E, SFLeERG. D C.
JEFFERT L TAeLpN, p C.
RosERT C eOEMw OEME 4 w. L*NOE N eAReARA M. ROSSOTTI.
* C.
JACM MemAT. P C pM p D.
O GEORGE V. ALLEN. JR P.C.*
EuSABETM M. PENOLETON M ARet M. DOLAND*
g e
? MOM AS C M'mLEv*
g ggg g 3,,g,s,,,
MARRY M. GLAS$p EGEL TELEX LL F RE D O RA SME R. p C.
R. MENLv wE ESTER. P C.
TMOM AS M. McCOR'Mecn DaANE E. sum a,y, g
,,g, g Lg y g g wgLL AM p. mARR*
Sg.2693 (SMawLaw WSM1 L. OuA N E CM E t n DAv80 R $4MR NATMANIEL P mREED. JR., PC I
MARE AUGENeUCM p C.
CHARLES M. MONTANGE M'Ch*AE L m. M AODE N c poweg,n ynA,N ERNEST L eLAmE. JR., p c.
JEAN M. GALLoway*
CAeLE "$MawLAw M ANN AM E. M. LaE eE RM AN gg,regu w gAupgguaq HN L CARR. J R.
JuOeN A.SANDLE" mENNETM A G CARLETON S. JONES. P C.
JO. estop e MARvEv L g w. A LL O SMELOON J. WEISEL. PA RosERT M. GORDON ANDREW 0. ELuS Day,0 R
'HOMa h A. maxTE R. P C.
pe S
8 RfCM ARO A. SA M8 A pATR Cm LEoGMTON 684
,, PATR8CM MsCEE V P C.
SONNst 5. GOTTUE e VIRGIN 6A OFF8CE THOM A S E. CROCKE R. J R.
a gNNETH O. Aut ReACM J. TMOM A S LE NM A PT.
* C.
MOWARD M. SMAFFE RMAN VsCat R. MARDWG AL AN O. W ASSE RM AN 8 ""O#S k, "X,..'.. C.*
M S EV,.,8'n'E" NO uL CM.
C.
TT & ANEheERG L N ORELL C
RO u A eEC*im
"'"N#M R T E "a*^""
*&"JT".!a'J"CCTETM'A'N E
E
~e'E AN v'Ro'N'a 22m*
N
* esor Aces.ngo.se D C JOMN r. DEALT *
+-~==-A
: e. SCOTT CUSTER. JR R'CM Ap0 S BEATW CouhSEL wRsTE R S O* RECT DIAL NutanE R (202)822-1215 September 26, 1984 HAND DELIVERED Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire Harmon, Weiss & Jordan
: e. SCOTT CUSTER. JR R'CM Ap0 S BEATW CouhSEL wRsTE R S O* RECT DIAL NutanE R (202)822-1215 September 26, 1984 HAND DELIVERED Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire Harmon, Weiss & Jordan
                  -2001 S Street, N.W., Suite 430 Washington, D.C. 20009
-2001 S Street, N.W.,
Suite 430 Washington, D.C.
20009


==Dear Ellyn:==
==Dear Ellyn:==
 
p This-letter confirms the agreement we reached on Friday to K
p K                              This-letter confirms the agreement we reached on Friday to respond further to each other's initici discrvery requests.                                                                   As a result of this agreement, Licensee will seek leave of the Board to withdraw its September 14, 1984 motion to compel.UCS to respond to Licensee's first set.of discovery requests.
respond further to each other's initici discrvery requests.
As a result of this agreement, Licensee will seek leave of the Board to withdraw its September 14, 1984 motion to compel.UCS to respond to Licensee's first set.of discovery requests.
In response to Licensee''s First Set of Interrogatories and First Request for Production of Documents to UCS, dated August 16, 1984, Licensee and UCS agree to the following:
In response to Licensee''s First Set of Interrogatories and First Request for Production of Documents to UCS, dated August 16, 1984, Licensee and UCS agree to the following:
Interrogatories U-4 and U-5.                                 UCS will identify the procedures, which UCS has stated to Licensee are the procedures referred to in UCS' (first) document production request #3, that form the basis for UCS' concern about training keeping pace with changing plant procedures.
Interrogatories U-4 and U-5.
UCS will identify the procedures, which UCS has stated to Licensee are the procedures referred to in UCS' (first) document production request #3, that form the basis for UCS' concern about training keeping pace with changing plant procedures.
L._.
L._.


I
('
(' SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMep Or p*0FtselONAL CORPORAtlONS l
SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMep Or p*0FtselONAL CORPORAtlONS Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire September 24, 1984 Page 2 Interrogatory U-6.
Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire September 24, 1984 Page 2 Interrogatory U-6.                       UCS agrees to identify by name the individ-uals to whom UCS generally referred in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-6, as well as the members of management UCS believes erred in their judgment to place the individuals in their respective positions within GPUN, to the extent UCS knows.
UCS agrees to identify by name the individ-uals to whom UCS generally referred in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-6, as well as the members of management UCS believes erred in their judgment to place the individuals in their respective positions within GPUN, to the extent UCS knows.
Interrogatories U-9, U-10, U-ll, U-14 and U-15. UCS presently
Interrogatories U-9, U-10, U-ll, U-14 and U-15.
      'does not intend to pursue the issue of the adequacy of the TMI-l licensed operator training curriculum, either during dis-covery or during the evidentiary proceeding. UCS will supple-ment the answers to Interrogatories U-9, U-10, U-11, U-14 and
UCS presently
      .U-15 by October 15 if that intention should change.
'does not intend to pursue the issue of the adequacy of the TMI-l licensed operator training curriculum, either during dis-covery or during the evidentiary proceeding.
Interrogatory U-17. UCS will provide specific page citations to the decisions and transcripts generally referred to in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-17.
UCS will supple-ment the answers to Interrogatories U-9, U-10, U-11, U-14 and
Interrogatory U-19.                         UCS will specify the exams to which it re-ferred generally in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-19.
.U-15 by October 15 if that intention should change.
Interrogatory U-24.                         UCS will identify with specificity any and all statements in the RHR Report on which its concerns about the TMI-l licensed operator training program are based which were not identified in UCS' previous response to Interrogatory U-24.
Interrogatory U-17.
Supplementation of Interrogatories.                         UCS recognizes its obliga-tion to supplement its answers to Licensee's interrogatories, particularly those responses which state only that UCS has not yet reviewed a document, or had not completed.its review.                         See UCS' response to Interrogatories U-4, U-16, U-lC, U -20, U-2 5, U-26, U-27 and U-28.
UCS will provide specific page citations to the decisions and transcripts generally referred to in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-17.
Interrogatory U-19.
UCS will specify the exams to which it re-ferred generally in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-19.
Interrogatory U-24.
UCS will identify with specificity any and all statements in the RHR Report on which its concerns about the TMI-l licensed operator training program are based which were not identified in UCS' previous response to Interrogatory U-24.
Supplementation of Interrogatories.
UCS recognizes its obliga-tion to supplement its answers to Licensee's interrogatories, particularly those responses which state only that UCS has not yet reviewed a document, or had not completed.its review.
See UCS' response to Interrogatories U-4, U-16, U-lC, U -20, U-2 5, U-26, U-27 and U-28.
In response to Union of Concerned Scientists' First Set of Interrogatories to General Public Utilities, dated August 28, 1984, Licensee and UCS agree to the following:
In response to Union of Concerned Scientists' First Set of Interrogatories to General Public Utilities, dated August 28, 1984, Licensee and UCS agree to the following:
Interrogatory 2(a).                         Licensee will determine the availability of the CVs referred to in its September 12 response.
Interrogatory 2(a).
Interrogatory 2(c). Licensee will ask each of its prospective witnesses to identify the name(s) of previous cases, other than the restart proceeding, in which the individual previously has testified, and the subject-matter of the individual's testimony.
Licensee will determine the availability of the CVs referred to in its September 12 response.
Interrogatory 2(c).
Licensee will ask each of its prospective witnesses to identify the name(s) of previous cases, other than the restart proceeding, in which the individual previously has testified, and the subject-matter of the individual's testimony.


4.
4.
( SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PAmfNERSHip OF pmOFEte40NAL CompONATIONS Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire September 24, 1984 Page 3 Interrogatory 2(d). Licensee will provide to UCS a list of documents reviewed by its witnesses, other than those documents not-readily subject to discovery under 10 C.F.R. 52.740(b)(2).
(
Licensee also will identify the individuals with whom Licens-ee's witnesses have consulted in order to prepare testimony and the subject of the consultation, unless such identification will disclose counsel's work product. See 10 C.F.R.
SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PAmfNERSHip OF pmOFEte40NAL CompONATIONS Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire September 24, 1984 Page 3 Interrogatory 2(d).
Licensee will provide to UCS a list of documents reviewed by its witnesses, other than those documents not-readily subject to discovery under 10 C.F.R. 52.740(b)(2).
Licensee also will identify the individuals with whom Licens-ee's witnesses have consulted in order to prepare testimony and the subject of the consultation, unless such identification will disclose counsel's work product.
See 10 C.F.R.
52.740(b)(2).
52.740(b)(2).
Interrogatory 2(f). Licensee will identify the documents relied upon by its witnesses but not referred to in their tes-timony which are used in connection with forming the opinions contained in such testimony.
Interrogatory 2(f).
<        ' Interrogatory 2(g).                   Licensee will identify the topics to be covered in each of its witnesses' testimony.
Licensee will identify the documents relied upon by its witnesses but not referred to in their tes-timony which are used in connection with forming the opinions contained in such testimony.
Interrogatory 3(e).                     Licensee will ensure that its response to Interrogatory 3(e) includes any currently licensed TMI-l opera-tor who failed a qualification exam since the TMI-2 accident.
' Interrogatory 2(g).
Interrogatory 5.                 Licensee will identify the documents avail-able to UCS which identify who prepared the exams encompassed by Ir.terrogatory 5 and who graded those exams.
Licensee will identify the topics to be covered in each of its witnesses' testimony.
Interrogatory 13.                   Licensee will verify that its September 12 response to Interrogatory 13 is complete.
Interrogatory 3(e).
Licensee will ensure that its response to Interrogatory 3(e) includes any currently licensed TMI-l opera-tor who failed a qualification exam since the TMI-2 accident.
Interrogatory 5.
Licensee will identify the documents avail-able to UCS which identify who prepared the exams encompassed by Ir.terrogatory 5 and who graded those exams.
Interrogatory 13.
Licensee will verify that its September 12 response to Interrogatory 13 is complete.
UCS and Licensee will provide answers to the above-specified and agreed upon interrogatories by Friday, September 28, with the exceptions of UCS Interrogatories 2(d),
UCS and Licensee will provide answers to the above-specified and agreed upon interrogatories by Friday, September 28, with the exceptions of UCS Interrogatories 2(d),
(f) and (g), which Licensee will provide to UCS by Oct6ber 15.
(f) and (g), which Licensee will provide to UCS by Oct6ber 15.
Ellyn,.I appreciate your cooperation in settling our dif-ferences on our respective discovery requests. I also note here that you reviewed this letter in draft, so that it consti-tutes a mutual understanding of our agreement.
Ellyn,.I appreciate your cooperation in settling our dif-ferences on our respective discovery requests.
I also note here that you reviewed this letter in draft, so that it consti-tutes a mutual understanding of our agreement.
Sincerely, Deborah B. Bause}}
Sincerely, Deborah B. Bause}}

Latest revision as of 06:59, 13 December 2024

Motion to Withdraw 840914 Motion to Compel Discovery on First Set of Interrogatories & First Request for Production of Documents to Ucs,Based on Parties Agreement Per Encl .Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence
ML20098E385
Person / Time
Site: Crane 
Issue date: 09/26/1984
From: Bauser D
GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP., SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
SP, NUDOCS 8409280403
Download: ML20098E385 (5)
v • d • e


Text

R h

September 26, 1984:

j

~

KELATJApRRESPONDEhGL L_.,-

' (

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 00CKETEC C

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boar &4 SEP 27 P4:20 -

In the' Matter of

)

0FDCE OFSECRE~n

~

)

GOCKiilNG i SERV!U METROPOLITAN' EDISON COMPANY,'ET AL.

) Docket'No.50-28Y 5h"

-) -(Restart-Management Remand)

(Three. Mile Island Nuclear

)

Station,. Unit No. 1)

)

' LICENSEE'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW ITS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY ON LICENSEE'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND'FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO UCS On September 14, 1984,-Licensee filed a Motion to

' Compel Discovery on Licensee's First Set of Interrogatories and First Request for-Production of Documents to UCS.

In the interest of resolving their discovery differences, counsel for Licensee and UCS met on Friday, September 21, at which time an. agreement was reached that accommodates'the initial discovery: requests posed by both parties.

The enclosed

-le'tter from Licensee's counsel to counsel for UCS, which

-was reviewed and approved by Ms. Weiss, reflects the parties' agreement..

In view-of the' agreement reached by Licensee and UCS, Licensee hereby requests.the Board's permission to l withdraw its September l'4 Motion to Compel.

Respectfully submitted, b

b.

Deborah B.

Bauser SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE 1800 M Street, N.W.

l 8409280403 840926 Washington, D.C.

20036 PDR ADOCK 05000289.

(202) 822-1215 C

PDR_

Counsel for Licensee Enclosure

$d)'

14 Saptember 26, 1984 t i'

\\:

z CDLKETED UNITED STATES OF AMERICA U3NRC NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

'84 SEP 27 P4:21

~

BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD LFFf'J OF SE Cnt ?Fa.

00CKLIn!4G & SEN' In the Matter of

)

BRANCH

)

METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY, ET AL.

-)-Docket No. 50-289 SP

) (Restart-Management Remand)

.(Three Mile Island' Nuclear

)

Station, Unit No. 1)

)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of " Licensee's Motion to

. Withdraw its Motion to Compel Discovery on Licensee's First

- Set of Interrogatories and First Request for Production of Documents to UCS" and a letter dated September 26, 1984 from D.

Bauser,~ counsel for Licensee, to E. Weiss, counsel for UCS were served this 26th day of September, 1984, by deposit in the U.S. mail, first class, postage prepaid, to the. parties on the attached Service List.

N 0

Deborah B.

Bauser cc:-' Attached Service List a

.-1-----

s-

r M

SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMap Or pRorESSeONAL CORpORATsoNS 1800 M STREET. N. w.

WASHINGTON. O. C. 20036

(

RAMSav D. POTTs. Mc CHARLES e. TEMutN. at JOMN M mrv 50N.H+

JCMN M MORE GEORGE r AteRiGMT. JR **

wE=DEteN A. wwct GEORGE r. TR'TmAN.

  • C.

sTEuaRT L m STEpMEN e. MuTTLER. p C.

"~~

OAveO J. CvhAM S TANL ET M. BARG Jac A A. MORN

  • ON ows RsOGE. W C.

wiNTMROp N. enowN, Pc LE SUE 4. SMEN STE p=E N O. pOTTS. P C.

J AME S e MAMLue. P C.

GERALO CMANNOrr, Pc.

RANDAL e. mELL. p C.

TE LE CO *'E "

LoveSE A. M ATMEwS veRG*NI A S. RuTLEDGE PM8Lup D. eOSTwiCK. p C.

RosERT E. ZAMLER. p.C Roa 522-eO99 & G22,#199 SETH M. MOOGAS8AN EATHE RINE p CMEEE R.TiMOTM ROeERT s. ROneaNS. a t SM E IL A Mcc.MARvEv TRAvi$T.eRowm.JR GEORGE e.T MANLON P C.

STE AMEN e. ME'SCA MANN EN M. LuCA S. p C.

OE v3 SA A. RiOGway ROGERS.JR.,PA STEvO M. RueEN$tEiN. P C.

  • E NNETH J MAumAN SANDRA E a=u rRED 4. uTTLE
  • C.

DAv O**E JCMM e. RMtNELANDER. F C.

MAYiAS r. TRAveESO-O AZ pt Dav'O L A ARENCE MILLER E'L E E N 'M8"NDE RS'O'N mRuCE w. CMuRCM*LL P C.

VICTOR $A J. PERKINS

  • C.

MAptFAX '00 rREDER*Cm L mLEIN PAMELA A

LESut A. NaCMOLSON JR, PC JCMN M. O NE sLL. J R., p C.

STEVEN P. 987Lg m ALE

  • ANDE R O. TOM ASZLZum JE'#"ENCE w. CO'ee S EY J ^ G MARTIN O. KRALL P C.

JAv A. EPSTIEN P C.

(2024 e22 8072 RtCMARO J PA RRt NO LAUR MEN ELLEN A, FREDEL JAv E, SFLeERG. D C.

JEFFERT L TAeLpN, p C.

RosERT C eOEMw OEME 4 w. L*NOE N eAReARA M. ROSSOTTI.

  • C.

JACM MemAT. P C pM p D.

O GEORGE V. ALLEN. JR P.C.*

EuSABETM M. PENOLETON M ARet M. DOLAND*

g e

? MOM AS C M'mLEv*

g ggg g 3,,g,s,,,

MARRY M. GLAS$p EGEL TELEX LL F RE D O RA SME R. p C.

R. MENLv wE ESTER. P C.

TMOM AS M. McCOR'Mecn DaANE E. sum a,y, g

,,g, g Lg y g g wgLL AM p. mARR*

Sg.2693 (SMawLaw WSM1 L. OuA N E CM E t n DAv80 R $4MR NATMANIEL P mREED. JR., PC I

MARE AUGENeUCM p C.

CHARLES M. MONTANGE M'Ch*AE L m. M AODE N c poweg,n ynA,N ERNEST L eLAmE. JR., p c.

JEAN M. GALLoway*

CAeLE "$MawLAw M ANN AM E. M. LaE eE RM AN gg,regu w gAupgguaq HN L CARR. J R.

JuOeN A.SANDLE" mENNETM A G CARLETON S. JONES. P C.

JO. estop e MARvEv L g w. A LL O SMELOON J. WEISEL. PA RosERT M. GORDON ANDREW 0. ELuS Day,0 R

'HOMa h A. maxTE R. P C.

pe S

8 RfCM ARO A. SA M8 A pATR Cm LEoGMTON 684

,, PATR8CM MsCEE V P C.

SONNst 5. GOTTUE e VIRGIN 6A OFF8CE THOM A S E. CROCKE R. J R.

a gNNETH O. Aut ReACM J. TMOM A S LE NM A PT.

  • C.

MOWARD M. SMAFFE RMAN VsCat R. MARDWG AL AN O. W ASSE RM AN 8 ""O#S k, "X,..'.. C.*

M S EV,.,8'n'E" NO uL CM.

C.

TT & ANEheERG L N ORELL C

RO u A eEC*im

"'"N#M R T E "a*^""

  • &"JT".!a'J"CCTETM'A'N E

E

~e'E AN v'Ro'N'a 22m*

N

  • esor Aces.ngo.se D C JOMN r. DEALT *

+-~==-A

e. SCOTT CUSTER. JR R'CM Ap0 S BEATW CouhSEL wRsTE R S O* RECT DIAL NutanE R (202)822-1215 September 26, 1984 HAND DELIVERED Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire Harmon, Weiss & Jordan

-2001 S Street, N.W.,

Suite 430 Washington, D.C.

20009

Dear Ellyn:

p This-letter confirms the agreement we reached on Friday to K

respond further to each other's initici discrvery requests.

As a result of this agreement, Licensee will seek leave of the Board to withdraw its September 14, 1984 motion to compel.UCS to respond to Licensee's first set.of discovery requests.

In response to Licensees First Set of Interrogatories and First Request for Production of Documents to UCS, dated August 16, 1984, Licensee and UCS agree to the following:

Interrogatories U-4 and U-5.

UCS will identify the procedures, which UCS has stated to Licensee are the procedures referred to in UCS' (first) document production request #3, that form the basis for UCS' concern about training keeping pace with changing plant procedures.

L._.

('

SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PARTNERSMep Or p*0FtselONAL CORPORAtlONS Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire September 24, 1984 Page 2 Interrogatory U-6.

UCS agrees to identify by name the individ-uals to whom UCS generally referred in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-6, as well as the members of management UCS believes erred in their judgment to place the individuals in their respective positions within GPUN, to the extent UCS knows.

Interrogatories U-9, U-10, U-ll, U-14 and U-15.

UCS presently

'does not intend to pursue the issue of the adequacy of the TMI-l licensed operator training curriculum, either during dis-covery or during the evidentiary proceeding.

UCS will supple-ment the answers to Interrogatories U-9, U-10, U-11, U-14 and

.U-15 by October 15 if that intention should change.

Interrogatory U-17.

UCS will provide specific page citations to the decisions and transcripts generally referred to in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-17.

Interrogatory U-19.

UCS will specify the exams to which it re-ferred generally in its September 4 response to Interrogatory U-19.

Interrogatory U-24.

UCS will identify with specificity any and all statements in the RHR Report on which its concerns about the TMI-l licensed operator training program are based which were not identified in UCS' previous response to Interrogatory U-24.

Supplementation of Interrogatories.

UCS recognizes its obliga-tion to supplement its answers to Licensee's interrogatories, particularly those responses which state only that UCS has not yet reviewed a document, or had not completed.its review.

See UCS' response to Interrogatories U-4, U-16, U-lC, U -20, U-2 5, U-26, U-27 and U-28.

In response to Union of Concerned Scientists' First Set of Interrogatories to General Public Utilities, dated August 28, 1984, Licensee and UCS agree to the following:

Interrogatory 2(a).

Licensee will determine the availability of the CVs referred to in its September 12 response.

Interrogatory 2(c).

Licensee will ask each of its prospective witnesses to identify the name(s) of previous cases, other than the restart proceeding, in which the individual previously has testified, and the subject-matter of the individual's testimony.

4.

(

SHAw, PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE A PAmfNERSHip OF pmOFEte40NAL CompONATIONS Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire September 24, 1984 Page 3 Interrogatory 2(d).

Licensee will provide to UCS a list of documents reviewed by its witnesses, other than those documents not-readily subject to discovery under 10 C.F.R. 52.740(b)(2).

Licensee also will identify the individuals with whom Licens-ee's witnesses have consulted in order to prepare testimony and the subject of the consultation, unless such identification will disclose counsel's work product.

See 10 C.F.R. 52.740(b)(2).

Interrogatory 2(f).

Licensee will identify the documents relied upon by its witnesses but not referred to in their tes-timony which are used in connection with forming the opinions contained in such testimony.

' Interrogatory 2(g).

Licensee will identify the topics to be covered in each of its witnesses' testimony.

Interrogatory 3(e).

Licensee will ensure that its response to Interrogatory 3(e) includes any currently licensed TMI-l opera-tor who failed a qualification exam since the TMI-2 accident.

Interrogatory 5.

Licensee will identify the documents avail-able to UCS which identify who prepared the exams encompassed by Ir.terrogatory 5 and who graded those exams.

Interrogatory 13.

Licensee will verify that its September 12 response to Interrogatory 13 is complete.

UCS and Licensee will provide answers to the above-specified and agreed upon interrogatories by Friday, September 28, with the exceptions of UCS Interrogatories 2(d),

(f) and (g), which Licensee will provide to UCS by Oct6ber 15.

Ellyn,.I appreciate your cooperation in settling our dif-ferences on our respective discovery requests.

I also note here that you reviewed this letter in draft, so that it consti-tutes a mutual understanding of our agreement.

Sincerely, Deborah B. Bause

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20098E385&oldid=4315443"