ML19331A432

Forwards Summary of Sj Gadler Participation in Midland Proceedings to Date Indicating Sj Gadler 720124 Improper & Unfair Implication Re Info Denial & Exclusion from Proceedings.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19331A432
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	01/31/1972
From:	Wessel M KAYE, SCHOLER, FIERMAN, HAYS & HANDLER
To:	Murphy A Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8007160976
Download: ML19331A432 (7)

Text

....

a o

a I

~-

.w-,-.

h

[

l I

to se 4 K AY E. SCH O LE R. Fa cn u An. H Avc & H Ata D LER M. # **

.a. u, f *Aleg Avf tis tC ral W funne tg ( e, 3 <,,

ei.1 nt.

. s. n4oo

,.. :L,'.? **

',**G.,

January 31, 1972

+-

. n.....

m.,=,

.. o q.).;.J.J..g:

E.,,F. i,l. i-j

~.:-

= v-:.=..

...e.

...,,,.,.,..n.,

. * ~

T ;.*,*.. **

. i'.".; T,N

- *=

.... ~.

• Y 3.

Me*" ** "' ' '

' ' f',*4 l

.'/

'. r t h u r

't. :!urphy. Esq.

y,

,. t[

Ch.sIrman N.

N A L.a m i e Safety and !.icensing Board 31.m b i a University School of I,aw 4 3 3

'.lu s t 116th Street

e w Y.i r k, :3. Y. 10027 In the :la t te r of Consurse rs Power company - 24td un (Plant, Units 1 and 2 1.o c ' a t ::o s..$0-329 and 50-310

Dear Chairman !!urphy:

Colonel Steve J.

Gadler's January 24, 1912 letter to the t'omnission, a copy of which was sent to the ilearing !!o a r d,

muroferly and unfairly implies that Colonel Cadler has bcun lentel information and excluded from the aJuinistrative proccas, and has not been fully and properly informed.

As the enclosed summary of the portinent record dis-c lo se s. Colonel ';adle r has been a participant in these proceedings almost f rors their inception. He has been more active than any individual

• . art, and has in fact participated more actively even than some tie attorneys for the parties.

.It is a fair infer nce from the record that Colonel Gadler's absence from the Janaary 19 nference was of his own doing.

}

.Rospectfully, s.

J

/*.

Jilton R.

L'u s s e l

't Rt! : s kl f

in c l o.a u r e i

cc:

fo all parties as per attached g

Certificate of Service l

I THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS I

P00RQUAUTYPAGES I

l be &

W*=

s

\\

l l

8007i)0 N f

?

....y

f a

-I m

.s p

1 m;g

-,- "ar CT.RT I r I 8:AT t: OF 'Wl:VICr I. filiton'R. Wessel, Esq., a messbur of the f i c us o f K.i y e,.'i c h u l e r,

f* 4 e e n.ni. II.a ys &' !!and le r, lle.o r inn counsel t o The Duw Chemtr.il Cenope.,y in thln natter. herchy certify in accordance with the provisions oi 10 C.F.R. 5 2.712(e)(2) that on January 31, 1972, I.scrved a copy of the 1ttached letter to Chairman Murphy by p o s t.1r.e prepaid-mail, upon the persons whose names',and J.ldresses

.i re liate 1 t>clows

s. un A r t heir W.

• !urphy. Esq., Chairman Secretary, D

'tomic Safety and Liccasing nosed UniscJ Staten Atoalc rnergy Co-. i l u l.

Coluubi.: !!niversity School of Law Washington, D.C.

20545

'.35 West 116th Street

..e w York, N.Y.

10027 United States Atomic Energy C.2 u n t, a l.,

Public Document Room Dr. Clark Coodman 1717 H Street, N.W.

University af !!ouston Washingeon.

D.C.

20545 3801 Ce11en Boulevard Houston, Texas 77004 37,,

jg,,y 3g,,y,g, 5711 Summerset Street Dr. David 8. Hall..

Midland, !!1chigan 48640

'as Alamos Scientific Laboratory David Coney. Esq.

I$. am New Mexico 87544 l

N Dearborn Street g

Algte A.

Wells, Esq., Chairman Chicago, Illinois 60602 Atomic Safety and Licensing Baard Panel J.S.

Atomic Encrgy Commission Irving Lika, Esq.

Washington, D.C.

20545 Reilly Like & Schneider 200 West Main Street Myron M.

Cherry, Esq.

Babyl,on, New York 11702 109 No. Dearborn Street Chicago, Illinois 60602 Roberc Newton, Esq.

U.S. Atomic Energy Co r.mi s s io n Suite 1005 Washington, D.C.

20545 Thomas F.

Engelhardt..Esq.

Honorable Vern Miller Regulatory Staff Attorney General U.S.Atcmic Ene_rgy, Commission Washington, D.C. 20545.-

Topeka, Kansas 66601 Honorable Villiam H. Ward William J. Cinster. Esq.' -

Assistant Attorney General Suite 4 !!arrill Building Saginaw, Michigan 48602 Topeka, Kansas 66601 Jac:e s A. Jtendall, E'sq.

Nathaniel H. Goodrich. Esq.,

5 rhSg v Road Atomic Safety an ic n ing Board Midland, Michigan 48640 U.S. Atomic Energy o mission Robert Lowenstein, Esq. _

Lowenstein, Newman and Reis, Washington, D.C.

20545 David E. Kartalia, Esq.,

1100 Connecticut Avenue,.N.W.

Washington, D.C.

20036 Counsel for AEC Regulatory Staff U.S. Atomic Energy Canaission l' John K.

Restrick,'Est,...

Washington, D.C.

20545 212 Vest Michigan,Aveuef,.

i l

l Jackson, Mi chigan.4 9201 f-

• Howard J. Vogel, Esq.

- *1 '

814 Flour Exchange Building 88poHs, Monesota MW is Ke r

I 1910 N Street, N.W. ' Q. n

[I,h '

' ' Washington, D.C. 2 0 0 3 6 ','. A gI

' Richard C. Smith,'EsqYl[1'

/C'

{. Smith & Brooker tr?

703 Washington Avenue b" :

h.e

-"7.,

Ray City, Mic11ghn < U n' P

u.

. Stanley T. Robinson $ Esq... Chief.

T

/

Public Proceedings Branch,.

.e/

l office of the Secretary.of the Y

Commission

,/7 3,( (,<, g 7 /-.t,-?.,.,

j U.S. Atomic Energy Co'amission i

Washington, D.C.

20545 J

nilton R.

wessel G.;W. t i

k L

.Ne a.

.~

t

.. M t.w.'

dWttL : -

N i

4 I

I t

i

)

i i

.;r== %.

fe' 1J 4'

(

1) g y y y ~.

i Z;r. 3 3o M.In.XI., sl,G,. -

.~

+

i Januar: 11, 1972 l

Y 5'

\\

!!c no r..,J un Su:.n a r i ;:li.n Pa r t i e i;.t t o:t by Stevt J.

Cadler in P r o..<.. l i r L:

Date t,

Steve J. Cadler has been g hy u J cally pri r cu t at most of t l.u Con f e ri.ncc a and I oarint;s to date, ig ne r a l l y

>: i t t i n ;.1 t farleton's counsci table w i t h :' t s u r... Ginster and/or Like.

are a part of The following specific reference.

the r e c., r d :

f:n c cher 13, 1970 Telegran, ' adJer to im C, reque. t i n r.

perniuulon tu al.

.i l i :. l i c.1

.q.p.

i n. n e..

i Irt e e:d. e t 26, 197C Letter, G.alle r t u !. ': t:, t e f e r r i n;- to f:o v c. r..b u r 13 t e l e,: r..:i.i n d t e l e p t.o ni c 'i l l the p r ev i c.u n J..y..ii;a i n r e<lue n t i n n l i r:i t ml a git.t a r an c e,

opportunity to

.ah e n Ja:iua ry f, 1971 Letter, Eartalia tu (: nill e r, ststing that December 23 lettsr I r, be t n;.

auf.m J t t e d to lic.arin:; Coord for itu c o nn id e rci c ion.

January 13, 1971 Letter, Cadlur to Kartalia, renewing request for linited appearanco and chargin effort at censorship.

.f s uu r y 21, 1971 Discussion anoso; c.iu n t.e l and Cha i naan Murphy with rispect to G ail l e r requent.

A!;C Staff tirur aes of fe ring Gad:s r

, alternative of ::ul.ui t t i n g a uri' ten statement or nakin;; an oral statinent.

Saginau objects to orel s t a t e r:i n t.

Chairman takuu e.st tu r unde r ad vi::c t: en t.

January 22, 1971

' Letter, Kart.alla tu fadler,al.cf..a; t '.. I

.Chairnan har taken matter under

..J v ir.s u u n t f

?

f-i

(

e c'

1 -- - -

r l

m.m -

1 m

e-I.

i I

1 i

i I

i I

Tc l+ r u.a ry 9, 1971 Letter, Ch a i r n ra n t u r pli v to f. vl i e r,

a. t. i t l i, -

thar !:n a r d w!!] I n c. o r i' a i

f-an. writt n statcaent Ga.!!es i

.ia ii f tu' r.cor e s, if r e.i d.

!'c k r u a r y 15, 1971

1. c t t e r, Cadler to L.ha i rt.a n h r r ic. o b -

j e c t i n t; to toand'r re f u::al to p..+.;t oral p re r:c n t a t i o n a n d c L.a r r. f n;;.I I t i r: i natton because of Ca!!cr o p p o '. I t i o n tu nuclear plants.

A;ril 21, 1971 Letter, Cadle r

t. r.. r t a t i a, reni r i nt:

request and char;ito etfort by A1. C to disenfranchise citizens.

April 22, 1971 Letter. Lynn S.

Castiar, S t e ve n..on f.

Castner, t o ";e n a t o r !!u m p h r e y, ndetoing that he represents Cudler arid requesting astistance in oht.iining p e r ta l :.. l o n fur Gadler to ter,tify as re q ac.s t ed.

Letter, Centner, to Chi i a n :n fin rphy,

enclosint; c op l e.- of e..elfer c os.rin n ic a t i t n, stating that a eritti i. tater nt uv u l.1 be unsaticfactory nd i s !. i n g.or op-portunity t o na'.e o s.. I p re:u n t a t luu.

April 25 1971 Letter, Karta11a to r.a d l e r, acLauuled ;ing i

receipt of Cadler April 21 letter and ccferring to Chairman's rcLruary 9 I c t s i. e qs dispositive.

Letter, Congressman Fraser to Chairman Seaborg, advising that Cadler's attorney, Lynn S.

Ca.tnnr. h.m p r. ni ut e el r:adler's request, a r. d aullar, that AEC p t s.:t L i 11 nite, appearance.

May !., 1971 Letter, Chairnaa tiells t o Con;;re.t s: a n Franer, a.!v i a i n t, that leraser lett"r is being transnitted to Chit i rma.a..asphy.

Letter, Senatur lia r t to Cha:rnan !!u r p h y,

advisiug t 'i n t he ha-reec1ved a letter fio Castner auJ a r t i n 4; whethsr tho' veull be any prel'ta ps rni t t it.

C.i.11. c tv r.a k e a limited appearance.

2 tA

___.JL

,3-4 I

h.

.m _.

~

6 t

-e m

- -~*

_,n..

e 4

9 4

b.

4, 1971 ( r e n f *.1 )

I.r t t s r. Ch.a l l es a n !a t pl.*;

to C.. t. e r, advinin, ul Lo lt

.o;he s I r ;

f++ e s Ir f u el d.,j. ton.

e n.1

..e tur f n. :

1..

nnd f' e !le r t !.., t

i. ': n'* s of t6 har i vi}l r t.i d any al t.i t e. e n t

.uh til t.e d.

?!.s.- 6 I?71 Lutter, Senator Ilunchrey to Co n.;re s s i on a l 4

L t.- i s o n, cr.closin; Cautner letter and requesting a report.

ta y 11, 1971 Letter, t;hairnan Urll. to F.. n a t i. r H u np h r u -

enclosing copies of Chair =an 5:u r ;> h y ' s letter to ::r. Castner.

a" 13 1971 Letter, C h a f r e.r. U 11s to Scnator it.a r t.

enclosing copy of Chairaan ';urphy's l

letter t o !!r. Cantner.

I J u ;' e

?,

1971

}!a p le t on counsci. serve by call c lic i r "S t a t ent.n t of Le pl suJ/or Factual Can-

.t e n t i o n s.

Dr. Chas.

k'. iluv. r and Stev J Cadler aru l i.: t e d.tc the only two ex; :r t witnesses

1. h e a...f 11nw:. :

be called.

"r.

r;a.il e r is descrih d e

" Steve J.

Gadler of St. Paul,

'linnesota is a rej;is te re d pr o f es sional engineer in the State of St i n n e s o t a.

!!c is a mcaber of the National Societ:

of Trof u r:c ional Euntnect. and the

!!in n e r:o t a ;ucloty of Prufen.tunal Enginc.rs.

lit: 19 a senior nont.cr nf the Society of rieetrical and Electronic En::ineer s.

11c is a me nt.c r of the ?tinnesota Pollution Centrol Agency.

lle has participated in other AEC S AIT.l i

..':n Llc :51;m Luaru proceedingr."

Junc 25, 1971 Ilearing transcript, pp.2437-39.

P a r i n r.

cross-exanination as to whe t; nr che

?tidland reactor is "nore l i k e l :. to leak radioactive ;; a s e s " than other typec of rcactorr. !! r. Ginster adviso. Dr. :la ll

.that ":f r. Cadlcr of i t.c It inn c e-e t.

Air Polluttun Control r.. : t - s j o ri la one of fi l s sourec: vi in t ori tlur.

1 t

)

e h

-6e4 p

• -w wse 6i 1

p il

-e

. +. _ -

n w

i

\\

f f

7 l

i July 7,

1971

!!u a r in;; t ran wr i.t. pp. 263).u0.

!! r.

t Deme t r i o's. as s..c i a t e

r. o u n s e l f i.r M.a p l e t o n, indic.it. s that the "spleton Intervenorn may winh to "nfrer..u c testimony un the e f f e e. t of a 1.i s k of electromagnetic conpatability on the environnent should the plant bu cuilt".

In response to que::tionn by D r :.. !!a ll shd Goodman. !!r. Gadler r c i e r.. to the alleged serious nature of the probicia.

" pollution of the f requency spt et rum."

the effect of the detonation of a b o t.i b over Johnson Island, the "innlantaneoun flash" resultJng frun nuclear devices being exploded in space, and similar

}

matters.

I j

July 9 1971 Mapleton deftndants submit thuir offer of proof with rerpert to their Con-centions 1 through VI.

!!r. Gadisc is f

listed as o n c.

of their nine expert vitncuson, ident i f ying; h iti an f ul l oti:.

"llo is a rc,;istered profenninnal engineer in the State of ninnenota.

}!u lu a r" c r o f the htional SocicLy of prof

.tunal Engineers and the Minneso Society of P r a f o u r. i o n al Enginecrs. Ile in a senior taenbar of the Society of Electrical and Electron Engineers. Ile is a member of the Minnesut. 'rllutlen Control Agency.

lie has par..cipated in other AEC SAFETY AND.ICENSING BOARD proceedings Itearing tranceript, pp.2892-93.

Neither Mr. Ginster nor !!r. Dcmetriou is present at the !!carin);. !!r. Cadler states that the !!aple ton Intervenors wish to cross-exanine.

lica ring tranaiript, p.2937 A f t e r !!r.

ainster appearn, he not:

that he had in t e n rie d to an.L !!r. Gadle r to n:: stut n n.!

telephone hi; office, but will do no himself.

I f

4, i

.. L 4:.u.j.

- - " ~ ' -- - ~

i i

4 i

a

s a

m r

g e

m 1

i 6i July 14, 1971 lle.n r inr. t ra n t.c r i p t. p.3509.

f tr. t.1 k e adviser that ci,l unc t (;.a d l e r !..e-r.n n e to tho.tirport to pick up li r. 1: p.. :. i n,.

!!.s ple t on v i t u r.

Novenhva 23, 1971 licaring transcript ep.5019-25.

It r.

Kartali.a r e f e r a.

to c on ve r :...t l on :s s*l t ts

}t s. Cadler, as consultant io t lic

}!apleton Intervenors, regardinr. Infern.l discovery at Idahu Falls.

Decenhcr 27, 1971 llovard J. Vogol, new counsel for Cadler, serves by mail Petition to Ia..rrent.

January 19, 1972 lir. Cadle r no t present at conference, and arCument of his Pe t J. s io n to Intervene adjoined because !! r. Vor. e l had not been furnished specific notice (Tr. 3229-30).

t l

1 i

i j

1 I

l 1

5 i

e m.

e eaw.=

s e

m i

I

!