ML18333A131: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 30: Line 30:
3,45/46  MR    E            Appendix B should be revised to          NA          Comment Appendix A and model 6 should be                    incorporate Model 6B                                            d.
3,45/46  MR    E            Appendix B should be revised to          NA          Comment Appendix A and model 6 should be                    incorporate Model 6B                                            d.
3.2.1  Applicability of the Original Model to 80 Years 4, 15    AN    E            "0.# inch" not "0.#" without any units  <--        Comment proprietary incorporate value      d.
3.2.1  Applicability of the Original Model to 80 Years 4, 15    AN    E            "0.# inch" not "0.#" without any units  <--        Comment proprietary incorporate value      d.
replaced
replaced BAW-2192 Sectio  Section Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                  Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er    (T) or                                            y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                        Comment r                                  E) with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,19    AB    E            #X1019 should be changed to            This        Comment
 
BAW-2192 Sectio  Section Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                  Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er    (T) or                                            y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                        Comment r                                  E) with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,19    AB    E            #X1019 should be changed to            This        Comment
                                               #.##X1019 or state #.##X1019 , which  section is  incorporate is approximately #X1019                appropriate d.
                                               #.##X1019 or state #.##X1019 , which  section is  incorporate is approximately #X1019                appropriate d.
ly marked as proprietary
ly marked as proprietary proprietary value replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,21    AB,MR  E            Suggest replacing "However, the 1/4t  This        Comment fluences" with "However, one quarter  section is  incorporate thickness 80-year fluence estimates    appropriate d.
                                                                                    <--
proprietary value replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,21    AB,MR  E            Suggest replacing "However, the 1/4t  This        Comment fluences" with "However, one quarter  section is  incorporate thickness 80-year fluence estimates    appropriate d.
are approximately #.# E+19 n/cm2 for  ly marked ONS, #.#0E+19 n/cm2 for Surry, and    as
are approximately #.# E+19 n/cm2 for  ly marked ONS, #.#0E+19 n/cm2 for Surry, and    as
                                               #.##E+19 n/cm2 for Turkey Point."      proprietary Text is from TR Appendix A, Page A-    <--
                                               #.##E+19 n/cm2 for Turkey Point."      proprietary Text is from TR Appendix A, Page A-    <--
: 4. Based on review of 1/4t ARTs for    proprietary TP and Surry (source references for    value the TRs), only TP3 and TP4 each have  replaced one weld with 1/4T fluence > #.# E19;  with #, see all remaining welds in the TR are less mark-up of than #.#E19 at 1/4t.
: 4. Based on review of 1/4t ARTs for    proprietary TP and Surry (source references for    value the TRs), only TP3 and TP4 each have  replaced one weld with 1/4T fluence > #.# E19;  with #, see all remaining welds in the TR are less mark-up of than #.#E19 at 1/4t.
BAW-2192 Sectio  Section Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                    Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er    (T) or                                              y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                          Comment r                                  E)
BAW-2192 Sectio  Section Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                    Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er    (T) or                                              y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                          Comment r                                  E)
DSE for values 4,25    AB,MR  T            Revise the sentence as follows. Plots    This        Comment of the normalized J versus crack        section is  incorporate extension (a) for models 4B and 6B      appropriate d.
DSE for values 4,25    AB,MR  T            Revise the sentence as follows. Plots    This        Comment of the normalized J versus crack        section is  incorporate extension (a) for models 4B and 6B      appropriate d.
Line 46: Line 41:
inch) and slightly more less            proprietary conservative (i.e., higher values of Jd) value at high crack extensions (> 0.# inch). replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,35-37  MR    E            In general bounds are either + #Se or +  This        Comment
inch) and slightly more less            proprietary conservative (i.e., higher values of Jd) value at high crack extensions (> 0.# inch). replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,35-37  MR    E            In general bounds are either + #Se or +  This        Comment
                                               #SE in this paragraph.                  section is  incorporate appropriate d.
                                               #SE in this paragraph.                  section is  incorporate appropriate d.
ly marked
ly marked BAW-2192 Sectio  Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                Comment                Proprietar    NRC n      Title        e      er      (T) or                                        y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                      Comment r                                    E) as proprietary proprietary value replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 3.2.2  Consistency with ASME Code, Section XI, Appendix K 5,44    MR,AN  E            Revise sentence--This method was    NA          Comment used in the TR.                                incorporate d.
 
BAW-2192 Sectio  Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                Comment                Proprietar    NRC n      Title        e      er      (T) or                                        y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                      Comment r                                    E) as proprietary
                                                                                    <--
proprietary value replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 3.2.2  Consistency with ASME Code, Section XI, Appendix K 5,44    MR,AN  E            Revise sentence--This method was    NA          Comment used in the TR.                                incorporate d.
3.2.3  Selection of Service Level A and B
3.2.3  Selection of Service Level A and B
Transients 6, 47    MR,AN  E            Symbol "F" for fahrenheight missing            Comment incorporate d.
Transients 6, 47    MR,AN  E            Symbol "F" for fahrenheight missing            Comment incorporate d.
3.2.4  Evaluation of Extended Beltline Materials
3.2.4  Evaluation of Extended Beltline Materials BAW-2192 Sectio    Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                  Proprietar    NRC n        Title        e      er    (T) or                                              y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                          Comment r                                    E) 7,34    MR,AN  E            Revise text as follows "For Surry and    NA          Comment TP, not..." The lower transition weld                incorporate was not evaluated for Surry                          d.
 
BAW-2192 Sectio    Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                  Proprietar    NRC n        Title        e      er    (T) or                                              y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                          Comment r                                    E) 7,34    MR,AN  E            Revise text as follows "For Surry and    NA          Comment TP, not..." The lower transition weld                incorporate was not evaluated for Surry                          d.
3.2.5.1 Material Chemistry NA      RH    NA          No comments                              No proprietary data 3.2.5.3 Mechanical Properties 8, 36    MR,AN  E            "it is conservative" instead of "is                  Comment conservative"                                        incorporate d.
3.2.5.1 Material Chemistry NA      RH    NA          No comments                              No proprietary data 3.2.5.3 Mechanical Properties 8, 36    MR,AN  E            "it is conservative" instead of "is                  Comment conservative"                                        incorporate d.
3.2.6  Confirmator y
3.2.6  Confirmator y
Calculations 8, 43    MR    T            Please restrict the                      NA comparison/independent evaluation to the NUREG/CR-5729 cooper-fluence model to the plants within the scope of the TR. Suggest adding "; this independent evaluation using the NUREG/CR-5729 copper-fluence model is restricted to the plants within scope of the TR."
Calculations 8, 43    MR    T            Please restrict the                      NA comparison/independent evaluation to the NUREG/CR-5729 cooper-fluence model to the plants within the scope of the TR. Suggest adding "; this independent evaluation using the NUREG/CR-5729 copper-fluence model is restricted to the plants within scope of the TR."
9, 4    AN    E                                                    The "blue    Comment (top) curve  incorporate appears to  d.
9, 4    AN    E                                                    The "blue    Comment (top) curve  incorporate appears to  d.
be gray in color in the figure
be gray in color in the figure BAW-2192 Sectio  Section Page/Lin  Review  Technical                  Comment              Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er      (T) or                                        y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                      Comment r                                    E) 9, Figure MR    E            Figure 1 is missing from the figure The J-R      Comment 1                            heading                            lower        incorporate bound        d.
 
BAW-2192 Sectio  Section Page/Lin  Review  Technical                  Comment              Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er      (T) or                                        y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                      Comment r                                    E) 9, Figure MR    E            Figure 1 is missing from the figure The J-R      Comment 1                            heading                            lower        incorporate bound        d.
curve is proprietary so this Figure should be marked as proprietary.
curve is proprietary so this Figure should be marked as proprietary.
Reference BAW-2192P, Supplemen t 1, Revision 0, Figure 5-1
Reference BAW-2192P, Supplemen t 1, Revision 0, Figure 5-1 BAW-2178 Sectio  Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                Proprietar    NRC n      Title        e      er      (T) or                                            y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                        Comment r                                      E) 1.0  Introduction 1, 14    MR    E            Title for BAW-2178, Supplement 1,      NA        Comment Revision 0, should be "Levels C & D"              incorporate vs "..Level C & D" The title is correct            d.
 
BAW-2178 Sectio  Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                Proprietar    NRC n      Title        e      er      (T) or                                            y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                        Comment r                                      E) 1.0  Introduction 1, 14    MR    E            Title for BAW-2178, Supplement 1,      NA        Comment Revision 0, should be "Levels C & D"              incorporate vs "..Level C & D" The title is correct            d.
for BAW-2178PA, Revision 00 3.1  Summary of the TR Content 2, 44    MR    T            The TR was performed in accordance      NA        Comment with ASME Section XI, 2007 Edition,                incorporate with 2008 Addenda; however, a                      d.
for BAW-2178PA, Revision 00 3.1  Summary of the TR Content 2, 44    MR    T            The TR was performed in accordance      NA        Comment with ASME Section XI, 2007 Edition,                incorporate with 2008 Addenda; however, a                      d.
reconciliation to the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI is discussed in Section 2.2 of the TR. This reconciliation should be acknowledged in the SE since 10 CFR 50 Appendix G requires that the current 10 CFR 50.55a Edition of ASME Section XI shall be used, which is the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI. Note same comment for BAW-2192.
reconciliation to the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI is discussed in Section 2.2 of the TR. This reconciliation should be acknowledged in the SE since 10 CFR 50 Appendix G requires that the current 10 CFR 50.55a Edition of ASME Section XI shall be used, which is the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI. Note same comment for BAW-2192.
3,12    MR    E            Open parenthetical (since              NA        Comment incorporate d.
3,12    MR    E            Open parenthetical (since              NA        Comment incorporate d.
3.2.1 Applicability of the Original Model to 80 Years
3.2.1 Applicability of the Original Model to 80 Years BAW-2178 Sectio    Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                Proprietar    NRC n        Title        e      er      (T) or                                          y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                        Comment r                                      E) 3, 46    MR    E            Change preposition--"4B of 80 years"  NA        Comment to 4B for 80 years                                incorporate d.
 
BAW-2178 Sectio    Section    Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                Proprietar    NRC n        Title        e      er      (T) or                                          y Marking  Resolution Numbe                Number          Editorial (                                        Comment r                                      E) 3, 46    MR    E            Change preposition--"4B of 80 years"  NA        Comment to 4B for 80 years                                incorporate d.
3.2.3.1 Selection of Level C and D
3.2.3.1 Selection of Level C and D
Transients 4, 45    MR    E            SRP 3.9.3, Revision 1 is referenced by NA        Comment RG 1.161. SRP 3.93 currently at Rev              incorporate 3                                                d.
Transients 4, 45    MR    E            SRP 3.9.3, Revision 1 is referenced by NA        Comment RG 1.161. SRP 3.93 currently at Rev              incorporate 3                                                d.
Line 78: Line 61:
3.2.3.2 Level C and D Service Loadings 7, 32    MR    E            "would resulted" should be would have            Comment resulted                                          incorporate d.
3.2.3.2 Level C and D Service Loadings 7, 32    MR    E            "would resulted" should be would have            Comment resulted                                          incorporate d.
3.2.6  Confirmator y
3.2.6  Confirmator y
Calculations
Calculations BAW-2178 Sectio  Section Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                    Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er      (T) or                                              y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                            Comment r                                  E) 9, 44-50 MR    T            Please restrict the                      Appropriate Comment comparison/independent evaluation to    ly marked  incorporate the NUREG/CR-5729 cooper-fluence                    d.
 
BAW-2178 Sectio  Section Page/Lin Review  Technical                  Comment                    Proprietar    NRC n      Title      e      er      (T) or                                              y Marking  Resolution Numbe            Number          Editorial (                                            Comment r                                  E) 9, 44-50 MR    T            Please restrict the                      Appropriate Comment comparison/independent evaluation to    ly marked  incorporate the NUREG/CR-5729 cooper-fluence                    d.
model to the plants within the scope of the TR. Suggest to revise the sentence starting "The staff also" to read "The staff used the copper-fluence fracture toughness model for Linde 80 welds from NUREG/CR-5729 for comparison to B&W OG Model 4B; this independent evaluating using the NUREG/CR-5729 copper-fluence model is restricted to teh plants within the scope of the TR.
model to the plants within the scope of the TR. Suggest to revise the sentence starting "The staff also" to read "The staff used the copper-fluence fracture toughness model for Linde 80 welds from NUREG/CR-5729 for comparison to B&W OG Model 4B; this independent evaluating using the NUREG/CR-5729 copper-fluence model is restricted to teh plants within the scope of the TR.
                                               }}
                                               }}

Latest revision as of 15:02, 2 February 2020

Comment Resolution Table for BAW-2192, Supplement 1, Revision 0 and BAW-2178, Supplement, Revision 0
ML18333A131
Person / Time
Issue date: 12/07/2018
From: Dennis Morey
NRC/NRR/DLP/PLPB
To: Nowinowski W
Westinghouse
Drake J
Shared Package
ML18333A124 List:
References
BAW-2178, BAW-2192
Download: ML18333A131 (8)
v • d • e


Text

COMMENT RESOLUTION TABLE BAW-2192, Supplement 1, Revision 0, Low Upper-Shelf Toughness Fracture Mechanics Analysis of Reactor Vessels of B&W Owners Reactor Vessel Working Group for Level A&B Service Loads & BAW-2178, Supplement 1, Revision 0, Low Upper-Shelf Toughness Fracture Mechanics Analysis of Reactor Vessels of B&W Owners Reactor Vessel Working Group For Level C&D Service Loads BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 1.0 Introduction 1, 12 MR E Title for BAW-2192, Supplement 1, NA Comment Revision 0, should be "Levels A & B" incorporate vs "Level A&B" The title is correct for d.

BAW-2192PA, Revision 00 1, 31 MR E n/cm2 should be n/cm2 NA Comment incorporate d.

2.0 Regulatory Evaluation 1, 39 AN E "Regulation at" should be Regulation Comment in" incorporate d.

2, 19 MR E NUREG-2192 (SRP-SLR), NA Comment Section 4.2.2.1.2 provides guidance for incorporate USE vs NUREG-2191, which d.

references Section 4.2.2.1.2 of the SRP-SLR 3.1 PWROG Evaluation

BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 2, 44 MR T The TR was performed in accordance NA Comment with ASME Section XI, 2007 Edition, incorporate with 2008 Addenda; however, a d.

reconciliation to the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI is discussed in Section 2.2 of the TR. This reconciliation should be acknowledged in the SE since 10 CFR 50, Appendix G requires that the current 10 CFR 50.55a Edition of ASME Section XI shall be used, which is the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI.

2, 46 AN E E: "essentially identical to" instead of Comment "are identical in" incorporate d.

3,35 MR E Suggest TR Sections 5.3 and 5.4 NA Comment versus TR Section 5.4. Section 5.3 incorporate presents flaw extension results and 5.4 d.

flaw stability results.

3,45/46 MR E Appendix B should be revised to NA Comment Appendix A and model 6 should be incorporate Model 6B d.

3.2.1 Applicability of the Original Model to 80 Years 4, 15 AN E "0.# inch" not "0.#" without any units <-- Comment proprietary incorporate value d.

replaced BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,19 AB E #X1019 should be changed to This Comment

  1. .##X1019 or state #.##X1019 , which section is incorporate is approximately #X1019 appropriate d.

ly marked as proprietary proprietary value replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,21 AB,MR E Suggest replacing "However, the 1/4t This Comment fluences" with "However, one quarter section is incorporate thickness 80-year fluence estimates appropriate d.

are approximately #.# E+19 n/cm2 for ly marked ONS, #.#0E+19 n/cm2 for Surry, and as

  1. .##E+19 n/cm2 for Turkey Point." proprietary Text is from TR Appendix A, Page A- <--
4. Based on review of 1/4t ARTs for proprietary TP and Surry (source references for value the TRs), only TP3 and TP4 each have replaced one weld with 1/4T fluence > #.# E19; with #, see all remaining welds in the TR are less mark-up of than #.#E19 at 1/4t.

BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E)

DSE for values 4,25 AB,MR T Revise the sentence as follows. Plots This Comment of the normalized J versus crack section is incorporate extension (a) for models 4B and 6B appropriate d.

show that the model curves are very ly marked similar, with model 6B being slightly as more conservative (i.e., lower values of proprietary Jd) at smaller crack extensions (<0.1 <--

inch) and slightly more less proprietary conservative (i.e., higher values of Jd) value at high crack extensions (> 0.# inch). replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 4,35-37 MR E In general bounds are either + #Se or + This Comment

  1. SE in this paragraph. section is incorporate appropriate d.

ly marked BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) as proprietary proprietary value replaced with #, see mark-up of DSE for values 3.2.2 Consistency with ASME Code,Section XI, Appendix K 5,44 MR,AN E Revise sentence--This method was NA Comment used in the TR. incorporate d.

3.2.3 Selection of Service Level A and B

Transients 6, 47 MR,AN E Symbol "F" for fahrenheight missing Comment incorporate d.

3.2.4 Evaluation of Extended Beltline Materials BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 7,34 MR,AN E Revise text as follows "For Surry and NA Comment TP, not..." The lower transition weld incorporate was not evaluated for Surry d.

3.2.5.1 Material Chemistry NA RH NA No comments No proprietary data 3.2.5.3 Mechanical Properties 8, 36 MR,AN E "it is conservative" instead of "is Comment conservative" incorporate d.

3.2.6 Confirmator y

Calculations 8, 43 MR T Please restrict the NA comparison/independent evaluation to the NUREG/CR-5729 cooper-fluence model to the plants within the scope of the TR. Suggest adding "; this independent evaluation using the NUREG/CR-5729 copper-fluence model is restricted to the plants within scope of the TR."

9, 4 AN E The "blue Comment (top) curve incorporate appears to d.

be gray in color in the figure BAW-2192 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 9, Figure MR E Figure 1 is missing from the figure The J-R Comment 1 heading lower incorporate bound d.

curve is proprietary so this Figure should be marked as proprietary.

Reference BAW-2192P, Supplemen t 1, Revision 0, Figure 5-1 BAW-2178 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 1.0 Introduction 1, 14 MR E Title for BAW-2178, Supplement 1, NA Comment Revision 0, should be "Levels C & D" incorporate vs "..Level C & D" The title is correct d.

for BAW-2178PA, Revision 00 3.1 Summary of the TR Content 2, 44 MR T The TR was performed in accordance NA Comment with ASME Section XI, 2007 Edition, incorporate with 2008 Addenda; however, a d.

reconciliation to the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI is discussed in Section 2.2 of the TR. This reconciliation should be acknowledged in the SE since 10 CFR 50 Appendix G requires that the current 10 CFR 50.55a Edition of ASME Section XI shall be used, which is the 2013 Edition of ASME Section XI. Note same comment for BAW-2192.

3,12 MR E Open parenthetical (since NA Comment incorporate d.

3.2.1 Applicability of the Original Model to 80 Years BAW-2178 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 3, 46 MR E Change preposition--"4B of 80 years" NA Comment to 4B for 80 years incorporate d.

3.2.3.1 Selection of Level C and D

Transients 4, 45 MR E SRP 3.9.3, Revision 1 is referenced by NA Comment RG 1.161. SRP 3.93 currently at Rev incorporate 3 d.

5, 10 MR E "transient" should be transients NA Comment incorporate d.

3.2.3.2 Level C and D Service Loadings 7, 32 MR E "would resulted" should be would have Comment resulted incorporate d.

3.2.6 Confirmator y

Calculations BAW-2178 Sectio Section Page/Lin Review Technical Comment Proprietar NRC n Title e er (T) or y Marking Resolution Numbe Number Editorial ( Comment r E) 9, 44-50 MR T Please restrict the Appropriate Comment comparison/independent evaluation to ly marked incorporate the NUREG/CR-5729 cooper-fluence d.

model to the plants within the scope of the TR. Suggest to revise the sentence starting "The staff also" to read "The staff used the copper-fluence fracture toughness model for Linde 80 welds from NUREG/CR-5729 for comparison to B&W OG Model 4B; this independent evaluating using the NUREG/CR-5729 copper-fluence model is restricted to teh plants within the scope of the TR.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18333A131&oldid=2398071"