ML17326A193: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 06/23/1999
| issue date = 06/23/1999
| title = Forwards 20 Revised & Eight New TS Nuregs,Nei TS Task Force (TSTF) Traveler Numbers TSTF-17,rev 2,TSTF-37,rev 2,TSTF-58, Rev 1,TSTF-59,rev 1,TSTF-107,rev 4,TSTF-169,rev 1,TSTF-197, Rev 2,TSTF-204,rev 1,TSTF-207,rev 3 & TSTF-230,rev 1
| title = Forwards 20 Revised & Eight New TS Nuregs,Nei TS Task Force (TSTF) Traveler Numbers TSTF-17,rev 2,TSTF-37,rev 2,TSTF-58, Rev 1,TSTF-59,rev 1,TSTF-107,rev 4,TSTF-169,rev 1,TSTF-197, Rev 2,TSTF-204,rev 1,TSTF-207,rev 3 & TSTF-230,rev 1
| author name = DAVIS J W
| author name = Davis J
| author affiliation = NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE (FORMERLY NUCLEAR MGMT &
| author affiliation = NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE (FORMERLY NUCLEAR MGMT &
| addressee name = BECKNER W D
| addressee name = Beckner W
| addressee affiliation = NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
| addressee affiliation = NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
| docket =  
| docket =  
Line 17: Line 17:
| stage = Other
| stage = Other
}}
}}
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:NUCLEARENERGYINSTITUTE JamesW.DavisDIRECTOROPERATIONS DEPARTMENT, NUCLEARGENERATION June23,1999Dr.WilliamD.Beckner,BranchChiefTechnical Specifications BranchOfficeofNuclearReactorRegulation U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission Washington, DC20555-0001
==SUBJECT:==
Forwarding ofRevisedTSTFsandNewTSTFsPROJECTNUMBER:689
==DearDr.Beckner:==
Enclosedare20revisedandeightnewTechnical Specification NUREGsNEITechnical Specification TaskForce(TSTF)Travelers.
Thisletteralsotransmits nineeditorial changesandthestatusofallcurrently pendingTechnical Specification Bulletins (TSBs).Revisedtravelers areTSTF-17,Rev.2,TSTF-37,Rev.2,TSTF-58,Rev.1,TSTF-59,Rev1,TSTF-107, Rev.4,TSTF-169, Rev.1,TSTF-197, Rev.2,TSTF-204, Rev.1,TSTF-207, Rev.3,TSTF-230, Rev.1,TSTF-262, Rev.1,TSTF-263,Rev.2,TSTF-265, Rev.1,TSTF-266, Rev.1,TSTF-273, Rev.1,TSTF-280, Rev.1,TSTF-283, Rev.1,TSTF-284, Rev.2,TSTF-309,Rev.2andTSTF-316, Rev.1.Thesetravelers weremodifiedasaresultoffeedbackanddiscussions withNRCstaff.Thenewtravelers areTSTF-333, Rev.0,TSTF-334,,Rev.
0,TSTF-335, Rev.0,TSTF-336, Rev.0,TSTF-337, Rev.0,TSTF-338, Rev.0,TSTF-339, Rev.0andTSTF-340, Rev.0.Alsoincludedinthistransmittal areeditsBWROG-ED-4, GEOG-ED-48, GEOG-ED-49, GEOG-ED-50, GEOG-ED-51, NRC-ED-13, NRC-ED-14, WOG-ED-18 andWOG-ED-19.
17761STREET,NWSUITE400WASHINGTON.
OC20006.3708 PHONE202.739.8105 FAX202.785.1898 jwdnei.or9 Hnc1osure 3
r Mr.WilliamD.Beckner,BranchChiefJune23,1999Page2TSBstatusisasfollows:oTSB-2,Rev.0hasbeenincludedinTSTF-310.
TSB-3,Rev.0hasbeenprocessed asNRC-ED-4.
TSB-7,Rev.0hasbeenincorporated withrelatedmaterialinTSTF-338.
TSB-12,Rev.0isincorporated byTSTF-263.
TSB-15,Rev0hasbeenincorporated inTSTF-340.
TSB-16,Rev.0hasbeenrejectedbyWOG.Duetomultipledesigns,thisisnotagenericchange.Thisissueshouldbeaddressed asnecessary onaplantspecificbasis.TSB-17,Rev.0isstillunderevaluation.
WOGisproviding adraftresolution ofthepressurizer levelpositionforreviewbyBWOGandGEOG.Thesteamgenerator levelportionrequiresevaluation whichwilllikelyextendbeyondthedeadlineforinclusion intoRevision2oftheITSNUREGs.TSB-18,Rev.0isunderevaluation whichwilllikelyextendbeyondthedeadlineforinclusion intoRevision2oftheITSNUREGs.TSB-19,Rev.0issimilartoTSTF-164.
TheTSTFrecommends approvalofTSTF-164ratherthanprocessing TSB-19.oTSB-20,Rev.0isunderevaluation byWOG.TSB-21,Rev0concerning ReactorCoolantSystemSpecificActivi:yLCO3.4.16isstillunderevaluation bytheTSTF.Additional dialogueisrequiredbetweentheTSTFandNRC.TheTSTFalsowithdraws TSTFs-270 and288andtheyhavebeenaddressed inTSTF-284, Rev.2.Also,asexplained inourmeetingJune16,1999,theTSTFrequestsyoureconsider yourrejection ofTSTF-41.Anupdatedprioritylistisalsoenclosed.
Pleasecontactmeat(202)739-8105orVinceGilbertat(202)739-8138ifyouhaveanyquestions orneedtomeetwithindustryexpertsontheserecommended changes.Sincerely, hv'P~~JamesW.DavisEnclosures c:DeborahL.JohnsonStewartL.MagruderNRR-DRPMTechnical Specification TaskForce e
(WOG-139, Rev.0)Indust.y/TSTF StandardTechnical Specification ChangeTravelerClarifytheIceBasket20BasketWeightCriteriaClassification:
1)CorrectSpecifications NUREGsAffected:
[1430~14311432it1433Q1434TSTF-335Description:
Theproposedchangewillmovethecriteriaforselecting anadditional 20icebasketsforweighingifoneofthcrandomlyselectedbasketsweightfallsbelowtheTechnical Specification (TS)requiredminimum&omthebasestotheTS.Surveillance Requirement (SR).Thiscriterion wasincludedintheTSSRinPhaseIIoftheWOGMeritTS'sandwasmovedtothebasesinPhaseIILAdditionally, thewordingoftheSRwillberevisedtoeliminate anyconfusion overtheTSSRstatement that"each"icebasketcontainsgreaterthanorequalto[1400]lboficesinceitwillprovide,asapartoftheTSSR,thestepstotakeifoneormorebasketsareidentified weighinglessthantherequiredminimumandthattheweightrequirements areforthebeginning oftheoperating cycle.Finally,thesurveillance
&equencywillberevised&om9monthsto18monthswhichwillthenbeinaccordance withthemajorityofthcicecondenser plantssurveillance frequencies.
Justification:
Thebasicrequirement fortheiceweightintheicecondenser istoensureasufficient massoficeisavailable tocondensethesteamproducedbyaLOCAthusensuringthepeakcontainment pressureismaintained belowdesignlimitsfollowing adesignbasisaccident(DBA).Aspecified valueoficeforeachicebasketisrequiredtoprovideanevendistribution oficeintheicecondenser.
Thcrequirement toweighadditional baskets&omthesamebayinwhichoneormoreicebasketswereidentified asbeingbelowtheminimumspecified weightensuresthatnolocalzoneexiststhatisgrosslydeficient inice.Suchazonecouldexperience earlymeltoutduringaDBAtransient, creatingapathforsteamtopassthroughtheicecondenser withoutbeingcondensed.
Placingthestatement requiring thesamplingof20additional basketsinabayintheTSSRdoesnotresultinareduction intherequirements associated withtheice,condenser.
Instead,thiswillensureacommonunderstanding andimplementation ofthe'requirements whenar.icebasketisidentified asbeingunderweight.
Atpresent,theTSSRonlystatesthat"eachbasketcontain>[1400]lbofice."NoguidanceisprovidedintheTSastowhatactiontotakeforanunderweight basket.Thepresentwordingcouldallowtheincorrect interpretation thattheicccondenser isinoperable whenasingleunderweight basketisidentified.
Placingthcpreviously described statement backintotheTSandrevisingtheremainder oftheSRtoclarifythewordingwouldensureaclearunderstanding oftheactionsnecessary foridentified underweight baskets.Theclarification thattheweightrequirement isapplicable tothebeginning ofthecycledoesnotchangethepresentintentoftheTSbutensuresthereisnoconfusion thattheweightdocumented intheSRistheweightrequiredatthebeginning ofthecyclesincetheweightattheendoftheoperating cyclemaybelessthanthisduetosublimation.
Thisdoesnotresultinachangetotheintentorimplementation oftheTSsinceasublimation allowance wasprovidedintheSRweightrequirement.
Theincreasetoan18month&cquencydoesnotresultinanoverallreduction intheend-of-cycle iccweightaslongaseitheraplantspecificanalysisshowsasufficient marginoficeintheicccondenser toaccountforsublimation ortherequiredminimumiceweightasspecified intheSRisadjustedupwardtoaccountfortheincreased sublimation time.Eitherofthesemethodswillallowforsublimation overthclongerSurveillance intervalwithoutadecrcascbelowtheminimumrequirediceweightattheendoftheoperating cycle.IndustryContact:Buschbaum, DennyNRCContact:Giardina, BobRevisionHistory(254)897-5851301-314-3152 dbuschbltuelectric.corn Ibb1nrc.govOGRevision0RevisionStatus:ActiveNextAction:NRCRevisionProposedby:SequoyahTravelerRev.2.Copyright (C)1998,ExcelServicesCorporation.
UsebyExcelServicesassociates, utilityclients,andtheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission isgranted.Allotheruscwithoutwrittenpermission isprohibited.
etl5199 (WOO-139, Rev.0)TSTF-33'G Revision0RevisionStatus:ActiveNextAction:NRCRevisionDescription:
OriginalIssueOwnersGroupReviewInformation DateOriginated byOG:1I-Jun-99OwnersGroupComments(NoComments)
OwnersGroupResolution:
ApprovedDate:11-Jun-99 TSTFReviewInformation TSTFReceivedDate:11-Jun-99 DateDistributed forReview11-Jun-99 OGReviewCornpleted:
~BWOG~WOG~CEOGatr,BWROGTSTFComments:
(NoComments)
TSTFResolution:
ApprovedDate:15-Jun-99 NRCReviewInformation NRCReceivedDate:16-Jun-99 NRCComments:
(NoComments)
FinalResolution:
NRCActionpendingFinalResolution Date:Incorporation IntotheNUREGsFiletoBBS/LANDate:NUREGRevincorporated:
AffectedTechnical Specifications TSTFinformedDate:SR3.6.15.2IceBed(IceCondenser)
TSTFApprovedDate:SR3.6.15.2BasusIceBed(iceCondenser)
SR3.6.15.3IceBed(IceCondenser)
SR3.6.15.3BasesIceBed(Ice,Condenser)
TravelerRcv.2.Copyright (C)l998,ExcelServicesCorporation.
UscbyExce!Services associates, utilitydients,andtheU.S.hluclearRegulatory Commission isgranted.Allotherusewithoutwrittenpermission isprohibited.
6/IS/99 0
73!r-33<Attachment 1Technical Specification 3.6.15NoSignificant HazardsConsideration NOSIGNIFICANT HAZARDSCONSIDERATION DETERMINATION
[Utili,ty Name]hasconcluded thatoperation of[PlantName]Unit[I],inaccordance withtheproposedchangetothetechnical specifications foroperating license(s)],
doesnotinvolveasignificant hazardsconsideration.
[UtilityName]'sconclusion isbasedonitsevaluation, inaccordance with10CFR50.91(a)(1),
ofthethreestandards setforthin10CFR50.92(c).
A.Theroosedamendment doesnotinvolveasiificantincreaseintherobabilit orconseencesofanaccidentreviouslevaluated.
TheproposedTSamendments discussed belowcannotincreasetheprobability ofoccurrence ofanyanalyzedaccidentbecausetheyarenottheresultorcauseofanyphysicalmodification totheicecondenser structures, andforthecurrentdesignoftheicecondenser, thereisnocorrelation betweenanycrediblefailureandtheinitiation ofanypreviously analyzedaccident.
Regarding theconsequences ofanalyzedaccidents, theproposedamendment providesfortheactionsrequiredifoneozmoreicecondenser icebasketsaredetermined toweighbelowtheminimumspecified valuetobemadeapartoftheTSsurveillance requirement (SR)insteadofbeinglocatedinthebases.Thisensuresconsistent interpretation oftherequirements oftheTS.Theclarification oftheresponserequiredifoneormoreicebasketsinagivenbayisdetermined tobeunderweight ensuressufficient iceismaintained ineachbaytopreventearlymeltoutinalocalzonefollowing aDBAandthattherequiredoveralliceweightismaintained intheicecondenser.
Additionally, theclarification thattheweighi.requirement isapplicable tothebeginning ofthecycledoesnotchangethepresentintentoztheTSbutensuresthereisnoconfusion, sincetheweightattheendoftheoperating cyclemaybelessthanthatspecified intheSRduetosublimation.
Thisdoesnotresu'tinachange"otheintentorimplementation oftheTSsinceasublimation allowance wasprovidedintheoriginalSRweightrequirement.
Theseclarifications donotresultinanyaffectonplantequipment,'r operation andtheactionstakenauringtheimplementation oftherevisedTSwillbethesameaspriortotherevision.
Therefore, theclarification oftheserequirements willnotincreasetheconsequences ofanyaccidentpreviously evaluated.
Theproposedamendment alsorevisestheSurveillance frequency fromevery9monthstoevery18monthssuchthatitwillcoincidewithrefueling outages.Theoriginaliceweightrequirements fortheicecondenser surveillance includedaconservative allowance foricelossthroughsublimation toensurethedesignweightlowerlimitwasnotexceededduringtheSurveillance interval.
Verification thatsufficient iceismaintained intheicecondenser isperformed atthebeginning ofeachoperating cycletoensurethedesignminimumweightlimitisnotexceededattheendoftheinterval.
Therefore, increasing theSurveillance frequency doesnotaffecttheicecondenser operation oraccidentresponsesincesufficient iceismaintained toaddressthelimitingdesignbasisaccident(s)
(DBAs)andtheproposedamendment willnotincreasetheconsequences ofanyaccidentpreviously evaluated.
Theroosedamendment doesnotcreatetheossibilit ofanewordifferent kindofaccidentfromanaccidentreviouslevaluated.
Theinclusion oftheactionrequiredforanunderweight icebasketintheTSSR,insteadofinthebasesoftheTS,providesfortheconsistent interpretation oftherequirement.
Theclarification oftheresponserequiredifoneormoreicebasketsinagivenbayisdetermined tobeunderweight ensuressufficient iceismaintained ineachbaytopreventearlymeltoutinalocalzonefollowing,a DBAandthattherequiredoveralliceweightismaintained intheicecondenser.
Additionally, theclarification thattheweightrequirement isapplicable tothebeginning ofthecycledoesnotchangethepresentintentoftheTSbutensuresthereisnoconfusion, sincetheweightattheendoftheoperating cyclemaybelessthanthatspecified intheSRduetosublimation.
Thisdoesnotresultinachangetotheintentorimplementation oftheTSsinceasublimation allowance wasprovidedintheoriginalSRweightrequirement.
Theoperation andmaintenance oftheicecondenser anditsassociated equipment willnotchangeasaresultoftheseclarifications.
Therefore, theimplementation oftheseclarifications willnotcreate,thepossibility ofaccidents orequipment malfunctions ofanewordifferent kindfromanypreviously evaluated.
Theproposedamendment alsorevisestheSurveillance 75+F-3)xfrequency fromevery9monthstoevery18monthssuchthatitwillcoincidewithrefueling outages.Theoriginaliceweightrequirements fortheicecondenser Surveillance includedaconservative allowance foricelossthroughsublimation toensurethedesignminimumweightlimitwasnotexceededduring'theSurveillance interval.
Theproposedamendment ensuresanadequateamountoficeismaintained intheicecondenser byeitheranincreaseintherequirediceweighttoaddresstheincreased sublimation timeorbyaplantspecificanalysisjustifying theallowedweight,thusensuringthedesignweightlowerlimitisnotexceededattheendoftheinterval.
Theicecondenser servestolimitthepeakpressureinsidecontainment following aLossofCoolingAccident(LOCA)andsufficient icewouldbeavailable atalltimestokeepthepeakcontainment pressurebelowthedesignlimit.Therefore, increasing theSurveillance frequency willnotaffecttheicecondenser operation oraccidentresponsesincesufficient iceismaintained toaddressthelimitingDBAsandtheproposedamendment willnotcreatethepossibility ofanewordifferent kindofaccidentfromanyaccidentpreviously evaluated.
Theroosedamendment doesnotinvolveasiificant.reduction inamarinofsafetTheproposedamendment allowsfortheconsistent interpretation oftherequitedactionsifanicebasketisdetermined toweighlessthantherequiredminimum.Theinclusion oftheseactj.onsintheTSSRinsteadofintheTSbasesassuresthecorrectactionswillbetakenasintendedbytheTSs.Theclarification ofthe.responserequiredifoneormoreicebasketsinagivenbayisdetermined tobeunderweight ensuressufficient iceismaintained ineachbaytopreventearlymeltoutinalocalzonefollowing aDBAandthattherequiredoveralliceweightismaintained intheicecondenser.
Additionally, theclarification thattheweightrequirement isapplicable tothebeginning ofthecycledoesnotchangethepresentintentoftheTSbutensuresthereisnoconfusion, sincetheweightattheendoftheoperat'ing cyclemaybelessthanthatspecified intheSRduetosublimation.
Thisdoesnotresultinachangetotheintentorimplementation oftheTSsinceasublimation allowance wasprovidedintheoriginalSRweightrequirement.
Theproposedclarifications donotresultinorhaveanyaffectontheoperation ormaintenance ofanyplantequipments Y
/Thusthedesignlimitsforthecontinued safe'function ofthecontainment structure following aDBAarenotexceededduetothischangeandtherefore theproposedamendment doesnotinvolveareduction inamarginofsafety.Theicecondenser systemisprovidedtoabsorbthermalenergyreleasesfollowingaLOCAandtolimitthepeakpressureinsidecontainment.
Thecontainment analysisshowsthattheproposedamendment torevisetheSurveillance frequency fromevery9monthstoevery18monthswillnotresultinanincreasetothepeakcontainment pressurefollowing aLOCAsincetheminimumiceweightlimithasalsobeenadequately addressed ensuringthatsufficient iceisavailable attheendoftheSurveillance interval.
Therefore, increasing theSurveillance frequency willnotaffecttheicecondenser operation oraccidentresponsesincesufficient iceismaintained toaddressthelimitingDBAsandthedesignlimitsforthecontinued safefunctionofthecontainment structure following aDBAarenotaffected.
Forthesereasons,theproposedamendment doesnotinvolveareduction inamarginofsafety.V.ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTCONSIDERATION Theproposedchangedoesnotinvolveasignificant hazardsconsideration, asignificant changeinthetypesoforsignificant increaseintheamountsofanyeffluents thatmaybereleasedoffsite,orasignificant increaseinindividual orcumulative occupational radiation exposure.
Therefore, theproposedchangemeetstheeligibility criteriaforcategorical exclusion setforthin10CFR51.22(c)(9)
~Therefore, pursuantto10CFR51.22(b),
anenvironmental assessment oftheproposedchangeisnotrequired.
InsertAl678.-3)sIceBedgceCondenser) 3.6.15SURILLANCEREUIREMENTS continued SURVEILLANCE FREQUENCY SR3.6.15.2Verifytotalweightofstoredice>=[2,721,600) lbby:4nof181DELETEa.Weighingarepresentative sampleof>=14'tsaneriibasketco]lbofice;atthebeginning ofeachoperating cycleb.Calculating totalweightofstoredice,ata95%confidence level,usingallicebasketweightsdetermined inSR'3.6.15.2.a.
SR3.6.15.3Verifyazimuthal distribution oficeata95%confidence levelbysubdividing weights,asdetermined bySR3.6.15.2.a, intothefollowing groups:f181a.Group1-bays1through8;b.Group2-bays9through16;andc.Group3-bays17through24.Theaverageiceweightofthesamplebasketsineachgroup&omradialrows1,2,4,6,8,and9shallbe>=[1400)lb.SR3.6.15.4Verify,byvisualinspection, accumulation oficeorfrostonstructural memberscomprising flowchannelsthroughtheicecondenser is(=[0.38)inchthick.9months(continued)
WOGSTS3.6-54Rev1,04/07/95 0
IBASES~~<i-335IceBed(IceCondenser)
B3.6.15SURVEILLANCE SR3.6.15.1(continued)
REQUIREMENTS temperature condition.
ThisSRmaybesatisfied byuseoftheIceBedTemperature Monitoring System.SR3.6.15.2InsertBTheweighingprogramisdesignedtoobtainarepresentative sampleoftheicebaskets.Therepresentative sampleshallinclude6baskets&omeachofthe24icecondenser baysandshallconsistofonebasket&omradialrows1,2,4,6,8,and9.Ifnobasket&omadesignated rowcanbeobtainedforweighing, abasket&omthesamerowofanadjacentbayshallewDeleteTherowschosenincludetherowsnearesttheinsideandoutsidewallsoftheicecondenser (rows1and2,andSand9,respectively),
wherehettransferintotheicecondenser ismostlikelytoinfluence sublimation.
Verifying thetotalweightoficeensuresthatthereisadequateicetoabsorbtherequiredamountofenergytomitigatetheDBAs.[nsertConeormorebasketsIfabasketisfoundtocontain([1400]lbofesentative sampleof20additional basketseashallbeweihed.Theaveraggeweih'ese21baskets(thediscrepant basketandthe20additional baskets)shallbe>=[1400]lbata95%confidence level.Weighing20additional barnebaymtheeventaSurveillance revealstetontains([1400]lbensuresthatnoocalzoneexiststhatisgrosslydeficient inice,Suchazonecouldexperience earlymeltoutduringaDBAtransient, creatingapathfor'teamtopass uhtheicebedwithout eincdened.eFrequency osmonthswasbasedonicestoragetestsandtheallowance builtintotherequiredicemassoverandabovethemassassumedisafetyanalyses.
inexperience hasverifiedthat,withthemonthFrequency, theweightrequireemaintained withnosignificant degradation betweensurveillances lDSeitDWOGB3.6-156continued Rev1,04/0//95
BASESM7/--)3$IceBedgceCondenser)
B3.6.15SURVEILLANCE SR3.6.15.3PSQUIREMENTS (Continued)
ThisSRensuresthattheazimuthal distribution oficeisreasonably uniform,byverifying thattheaverageiceweightineachofthreethaiousoficecondenser basiswithinthelimit.TheFreuencomonthswasbasedonicestoragetestsandtheallowance builtintorequiredicemassoverandabovethemassassumanalyses.
Operating experience hasverifiedthat,withthmonthFrequency, theweightrequirements aremaintained withnosignificant degradation betweensurveillances.
f181SR3.6.15.4ThisSRensuresthatthefiowchannelsthroughtheicecondenser havenotaccumulated anexcessive amountoficeor&ostblockage.
Thevisualinspection mustbemadefortwoormoreflowchannelspericecondenser bayandmustincludethefollowing specificlocatioiis alongthefiowchannel:a.Pastthelowerinletplenumsupportstructures andturningvanes;b.Betweenicebaskets;c.Pastlattice&ames;d.Throughtheintermediate floorgrating;ande.'hroughthetopdeckfloorgrating.Theallowable
[0.38]inchthickbuildupoffrostoriceisbasedontheanalysisofcontainment responsetoaDBAwithpartialblockageoftheicecondenser flowpassages.
Ifaflowchannelinagivenbayisfoundtohaveanaccumulation of&ostorice>[0.38]inchthick,arepreseritative sampleof20additional flowchannels&omthesamebaymustbevisuallyinspected.
Iftheseadditional flowchannelsareallfoundtobeacceptable, thediscrepant flowchannelmaybeconsidered single,unique,andacceptable deficiency.
Morethanonediscrepant flowchannelinabayisnotacceptable, however.Theserequirements arebasedonthesensitivity ofthepartialblockageanalysistoadditional blockage.
TheWOGB3.6-157continued Rev1,04/07/95
(/('3wInsertANOTE-Ifoneormorebasketsinanicecondenser bayarefoundtocontain<[1400]lbsofice,arepresentative sampleofatleast20additional baskets&omthesamebayshallbeweighed.Theaverageweightoficeinthebasketsweighedinthespecified bayshallbe>[1400]Ibsata[95]%confidence level.InsertBTheselection criteriaandmethodology fortheweighingof144icecondenser basketswasdocumented intwoSERsissuedforthelicensing oftheD.C.CookNuclearFacility.
ThefirstSER,issuedasSupplement 5oftheoriginalD.C.CookSERonJanuary16,1976(LetterN76007),addressed theweighingof96icebasketsanddefinedthestatistical methodsforanalyzing thedata.ThesecondSERwasissuedasletterN77016onFebruary16,1977andaddressed thereasonsforincreasing thesamplesizeto144icebaskets.InsertCThetotaliceweightdefinedinthisSRistheminimumrequirediceweightforthebeginning ofanoperating cycle.Asublimation allowance hasbeenprovidedtoensuresufficient iceisavailable attheendoftheoperating cyclefortheicecondenser toperformitsintendeddesignfunction.
ThisSRhasbeenmodifiedbyanotethatindicates ifoneormorebasketsarefoundtocontain<[1400]lbofice,arepresentative sampleofatleast20additional basketsfromthesamebayshallbeweighedandthattheaverageweightoficeinthebasketsweighedinthespecified bay(thediscrepant basket(s),
theremaining originally selectedbaskets,andthe20additional baskets)shallbe2[1400]lbata[95]%confidence level.InsertDTheaverageweightfigureof[1400]lbsoficeperbasketcontainseitheraconservative allowance foricelossthroughsublimation whichhasbeendetermined byplantspecificanalysisoradefined[15]%allowance.
Theminimumweightfigug'eof[2,721,600]
lbsoficealsocontainsanadditional fl]%conservative allowance toaccountforsystematic errorinweighinginstruments.
Intheeventthatobservedsublimation ratesareequaltoorlowerthandesignpredictions.
afterthreeyearsofoperation, theminimumicebasketweightsmaybeadjustedd0wilwai'd.
Attachment 3NKKG1432,Revision1Technical Specification 3.6.15RevisedPages SURVEILLANCE REUIREMENTS continued IceBedgceCondenser) 3.6.15SURVEILLANCE FREQUENCY SR3.6.15.2NOTEIfoneormorebasketsinanicecondenser bayarefoundtocontain([1400]lbsofice,arepresentative sampleof20additional baskets&omthesamebayshallbeweighed.Theaverageweightoficeinthebasketsweighedinthespecified bayshallbe~[1400]lbsata[95]%confidence level.Verifytotalweightofstorediceatthebeginning ofeachoperating cycleis>=[2,721,600]
lbby:[18]monthsa.Weighingarepresentative sampleof>=144icebasketsandb.Calculating totalweightofstoredice,ata95%confidence level,usingallicebasketweightsdetermined inSR3.6.15.2.a.
SR3.6.15.3Verifyazimuthal distribution oficeata95%confidence levelbysubdividing weights,asdetermined bySR3.6.15.2.a, intothefollowing groups;[18]months~~a.Group1-bays1through8;b.Group2-bays9through16;andc.Group3-bays17through24.Theaverageiceweightofthesamplebasketsineachgroup&omradialrows1,2,4,6,8,and9shallbe>=[1400]lb.WOGSTS3.6-54Rev1,04/07/95 IceBedgceCondenser) 3.6.15SURVEILLANCE REUIREMENTS continued SURVEILLANCE FREQUENCY SR3.6.15.4Verify,byvisualinspection, accumulation oficeor&ostonstructural memberscomprising Qowchannelsthroughtheicecondenser is<=[0.38]inchthick.9monthsSR3.6.15.5Verifybychemicalanalysesofatleastninerepresentative samplesofstoredice:a.Boronconcentration is>=[1800]ppm;and18monthsb.pHis>=[9.0]and<=[9.5].SR3.6.15.6Visuallyinspect,fordetrimental structural wear,cracks,corrosion, orotherdamage,twoicebasketsfromeachazimuthal groupofbays.SeeSR3.6.15.3.
I40months AES7$(F-2)~IceBed(iceCondenser)
B3.6.15SURVEILLANCE REQUIREMENTS SR3.6.15.1(continued) temperature condition.
ThisSRmaybesatisfied byuseoftheIceBedTemperature Monitoring System.SR3.6.15.2Theweighingprogramisdesignedtoobtainarepresentative sampleoftheicebaskets.Therepresentative sampleshallinclude6baskets&omeachofthe24icecondenser bays'ndshallconsistofonebasket&omradialrows1,2,4,6,8,and9.Ifno%asket&omadesignated rowcanbeobtainedforweighing, abasket&omthesamerowofanadjacentbayshallbeweighed.Theselection criteriaandmethodology fortheweighingof144icecondenser basketswasdocumented intwoSERsissuedforthelicensing oftheD.C.CookNuclearFacility.
ThefirstSER,issuedasSupplement 5oftheoriginalD.C.CookSERonJanuary16,1976(LetterN76007),addressed theweighingof96icebasketsanddefinedthestatistical methodsforanalyzing thedata.ThesecondSERwasissuedasletterN77016onFebruary16,1977andaddressed thereasonsforincreasing thesamplesizeto144icebaskets.Therowschosenincludetherowsnearesttheinsideandoutsidewallsoftheicecondenser (rows.land2,and8and9,respectively),
whereheattransferintotheicecondenser ismostlikelytoinfluence sublimation.
Verifying thetotalweightoficeensuresthatthereisadequateicetoabsorbtherequiredamountofenergytomitigatetheDBAs,ThetotaliceweightdefinedinthisSRistheminimumrequirediceweightforthebeginning ofanoperating cycle.Asublimation allowance hasbeenprovidedtoensuresufficient iceisavailable attheendoftheoperating cyclefoitheicecondenser toperformitsintendeddesignfunction.
ThisSRhasbeenmodifiedbyanotethatindicates ifoneormorebasketsarefoundtocontain<[1400]lbofice,arepresentative sampleof20additional basketsfromthesamebayshallbeweighedandthattheaverageweightoficeinthebasketsweighedinthespecified bay(thediscrepant basket(s),
theremaining originally selectedbaskets,andthe20additional baskets)shallbe2[1400]lbata[95]%confidence level.Weighing20additional baskets&omthesamebayintheeventaSurveillance revealsthatoneormorebasketscontains<[1400]lbensuresthat'nolocalzoneexiststhatisgrosslydeficient inice.Suchazonecouldexperience earlymeltoutduringaDBAtransient, creatingapathforsteamtopassthroughtheicebedwithoutbeingcondensed.
TheFrequency of18monthswasbasedonicestoragetestsandtheallowance builtintotherequiredicemassoverandabovethemassassumedinthesafetyanalyses.
Theaverageweightfigureof[1400]lbsoficeperbasketcontainseitheraconservative allowance foricelossthroughsublimation whichhasbeendetermined byplantspecificanalysisoradefined[15]loallowance whichisafactorof[15]higherthanassumedfortheicecondenser design.
/~r/=-32S-Theminimumweightfigureof';2,721,600]
lbsoficealsocontainsanadditional
[1]%conservative allowance toaccountforsystematic errorinweighinginstruments.
Inthe'ventthatobservedsublimation ratesareequaltoorlowerthandesignpredictions afterthreeyearsofoperation, theminimumicebasketweightsmaybeadjusteddownward.
Operating experience hasverifiedthat,withthe18monthFrequency, theweightrequirements aremaintained withnosignificant degradation betweensurveillances WOGB3.6-156continued Rev1,04/07/95.
ASES/zan'--'35IceBedgceCondenser)
B3.6.15SURVEILLANCE SR3.6.15.3REQUIREMENTS (Continued)
ThisSRensuresthattheazimuthal distribution oficeisreasonably uniform,byverifying thattheaverageiceweightineachofthreeazimuthal groupsoficecondenser baysiswithinthelimit.TheFrequency of18monthswasbasedonicestoragetestsandtheallowance builtintotherequiredicemassoverandabovethemassassumedinthesafetyanalyses.
Operating experience hasverifiedthat,withthe18monthFrequency, theweightrequirements aremaintained withnosignificant degradation betweensurveillances.
SR3.6.15.4TliisSRensuresthattheflowchannelsthroughtheicecondenser havenotaccumulated anexcessive amountoficeorfrostblockage.
Thevisualinspection mustbemadefortwoormoreflowchannelspericecondenser bayandmustincludethefollowing specificlocations alongtheflowchannel:Pastthelowerinletplenumsupportstructures andturningvanes;b.Betweeriicebaskets;c.Pastlattice&ames;d.Throughtheintermediate floorgrating;ande.Throughthetopdeckfloorgrating.Theallowable f0.38]inchthickbuildupoffrostoriceisbasedontheanalysisofcontainment responsetoaDBAwithpartialblockageoftheicecondenser flowpassages.
Ifaflowchannelinagivenbayisfoundtohaveanaccumulation offrostorice)[0.38]inchthick,arepresentative sampleof20additional flowchannelsfromthesamebaymustbevisuallyinspected.
Iftheseadditional flowchannelsareallfoundtobeacceptable, thediscrepant flowchannelmaybeconsidered single,unique,andacceptable deficiency.
Morethanonediscrepant flowchannelinabayisnotacceptable, however.Theserequirements arebasedonthesensitivity ofthepartialblockageanalysistoadditional blockage.
TheWOGB3.6-157continued Rev1,04/07/95 Attachment 4NUREG1432,Technical Specification 3.6.15Information OnlyPages
ThisPageisForInformation OnlyandisNotPartoftheProposedTSTF3.6CONTAINMENT SYSTEMS3.6.15IceBedgceCondenser)
P(rc"33mIceBedgceCondenser)
B3.6.15LCO3.6.15TheicebedshallbeOPERABLE.
APPLICABILITY:
MODES1,2,3,and4.ACTIONSCONDITION REQUIREDACTIONCOMPLETION TIMEA.Icebedinoperable.
B.RequiredActionand~associated Completion Timenotmet.A.1RestoreicebedtoOPERABLEstatus.B.1BeinMODE3.48hours6hoursB.2BeinMODE5.36hoursSURVEILLANCE REUIREMENTS SURVEILLANCE SR3.6.15.1Verifymaximumicebedtemperature is(=[27]oF.FREQUENCY 12hours(continued)
WOGSTS3.6-53Rev1,04/07/95 (WOG-140, Rev.0)Industry/TSTF StandardTechnical Specification ChangeTravelerIcebedflowchannelblockagesurveillance requirement Classification:
3)ImproveSpecifications NUREGsAffected:
t1430~14311432!14331t1434TSTF-336Description:
TheproposedchangewouldrevisetheIceBedTechnical Specifications (TS)andassociated TSBasesinsurveillance requLrement (SR)3.6.15.4.
Theproposedchangereplacesthecurrentvisualinspection requirement thatusesa0.38inchice/frost buildupcriteria.
Theproposedchangeisavisualsurveillance programthatprovidesatleast95percentconfidence levelthatflowblockagedoesnotexceedthe15percentblockageofthetotalflowareaassumedintheaccidentanalyses.
Whereas,the0.38inchprogramrequiredinspection ofasfewastwofiowchannelspericecondenser bay,thenewprogramwillrequireatleast54(33percent)ofthe162flowchannelsperbaytobeinspected.
TheproposedchangerevisesSR3.6.15.4&equencyinterval&om9monthsto18monthsforfiowpassageinspection oftheicecondenser.
Thesurveillance isintendedtobeperformed following outagemaintenance asanasleftsurveillance.
Thischangealsoproposestorevisetheapplicability
&om"flowchannelsthroughtheicecondenser" to"fiowchannelsthroughtheicebed".'AproposedrevisiontotheTSBasesclarifies whichstructures aretobinspected.
Therevisionlimitsthestructures tobeinspected toonlyinclude"betweenicebaskets"and"pastlaniceframesandwallpanels".TheTSBasesrevisionalsoisexpandedtoexplainwhyotherstructures withintheicecondenser arenotinspected pertheSR.Theproposaldeletestheword"frost"&omtheSR.TheWestinghouse basesforfrostandiceasitappliestotheSRhavebeenaddedtotheTSBasestoexplainwhy&ostisnotanimpediment toair/steam flowthroughtheicecondenser.
Justification:
RecentindustryeventspromptedtheWOGIceCondenser Mini-Group (ICMG)toreviewicecondenser technical specifications toidentifyenhancements thatwouldprovidedirectcorrelation todesignbasesaccident(DBA)analyses.
DBAanalysesdemonstrate thatdesignlimitsforpressurization oflowercontainment subcomparunents andthesteelcontainment vesselwillnotbeexceededwith15percentblockageoftheicebedflowchannels.
ReviewofSR3.6.15.4determined thatthe0.38inchice/&ostbuildupcriteriadoesnotadequately provideforthefullintentofthesurveillance.
Throughdiscussions withWestinghouse, theICMGhasdetermined thatthereisnodirectcorrelation betweentheexistingstandardTS0.38inchcriteriaforice/frost accumulation onflowareastructural membersandthepercentage ofoverallfiowblockageassumedintheplantanalyses.
However,theproposedchangeprovidesanacceptance criteriaof15percentblockage, whichisdirectlyrelatedtothisfunctional requirement.
Frost,asrecognized byWestinghouse, isnotanimpediment tosteamandairflow.TheWestinghouse definitions for&ostandicehavebeenaddedtotheBasesofSR3.6.15.4, andfrostspecifically excludedasflowchannelblockagetoprecludepotential declarations ofinoperability duetofrostratherthanice.IceCondenser operability isassuredbynumerousmeansduringoperations.
Theicebedtemperature ismonitored atleastonceeverytwelvehourstoensuretemperatures arelessthanorequalto27F.Thisisaccomplished inaconservative mannerbyreviewing numerouspointsthroughout theicecondenser toensureallpointsarelessthanorequalto27F.Inadditiontothesurveillance requirements, therearealarmsinthecontrolroomthatwillindicatetotheoperatorifanyofthepointsbeingrecordedreach27F.Also,weeklyoperatortoursrequiretheoperators towalkdownthere&igeration systemtoevaluateitsabilitytofunction.
Thisincludeswalkingdownthechillers, airhandlingunits,andglycolpumpstoensurethattheyareinproperworkingorder.Thetoursalsorequiretheoperators toinspecttheintermediate deckdoorstoensuretheyarenotfrozenshut.Thishelpstoensurethatnoabnormaldegradation oftheicecondenser isoccurring duetocondensation orfrozendrainlinesinlocalized areas.IceCondenser operability isdemonstrated bytheperformance ofvariousprocedures.
procedures verifytheicebedi>>nTravelerRev.2.Copyright (C)199g,ExcelServicesCorporation.
UsebyExcelServicesassociates, utilityclients.andtheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission isgranted.Allotherusewithoutwrittenpermission isprohibited.
6/15/99 r~~,
~~(WOG-140, Rev.0)TSTF-336goodphysicalcondition.
Procedures alsovalidateassumptions usedintheaccidentanalysis.
Theflowpassageinspection isperformed toensuretheabsenceofabnormalicebeddegradation aswouldbeindicated ifaccumulations exceedtheSRacceptance criteriaTherequesttoincreasethesurveillance interval&omninemonthstoeighteenmonthswouldrequiretheperformance ofsuchicebedmonitoring duringrefueling outages.ICMGmembersbelievethatindustryimprovements inicebedinspection results,duetomodifiedmaintenance techniques thathavebeenimplemented, provideadequateassurance thattheicecondenser canmeetandevenexceeditsdesignfunctionwithoutperforming thesurveillance onaninemonth&equency.
ExamplesofOperating Experience andIndustryconcerted improvements:
>Improvedcontrolofdoorsduringmaintenance including appropriate penetiations forhosestominimizeicecondenser heatandhumiditygains.>Improved management ofwallandfioorde&ostcycles(ifused,occursonlyduringoutages).
>Improved preventative maintenance programsonIceCondenser coolingsystems.>Increased priorityonrepairofIceCondenser coolingsystems.>Improvedtrainingandprocedures foremptyingandrefilling ofbaskets,andsubsequent cleanup.>Improvedtrainingandprocedures forflowpassagesurveillances.
>Proposedincreaseinminimumsamplesizerequirement forflowpassagesurveillance.
>Proposedsurveillance acceptance criterion thateffectively alignswithDBAanalysisforoperability determination.
Improvedcontrolofmaintenance haslimitedthoseactivities withthepotential forsignificant fiowchannelblockagetoduringrefueling outages.Verifying anicebedisleftwithlessthanorequalto15%flowchannelblockageattheconclusion ofarefueling outageassurestheicebedwillremaininanacceptable condition forthedurationoftheoperating cycle.Duringtheoperating cycle,anexpectedamountoficesublimates andreformsas&ostonthecoldersurfacesintheIceCondenser.
However,frostdoesnotdegradeflowchannelflowarea.Therefore, flowchannelblockagesurveillance shouldonlyberequiredattheconclusion ofscheduled refueling outages.Thesurveillance will'ffectively demonstrate operability foranallowed18monthsurveillance period.IndustryContact:Buschbaum, DennyNRCContact:Giardina, Bob(254)897-5851301-314-3152dbuschb1tuelectric.corn lbb1nrc.govRevisionHistoryOGRevision0RevisionStatus:ActiveNextAction:NRCRevisionProposedby:McGuireRevisionDescription:
OriginalIssueOwnersGroupReviewInformation DateOriginated byOG:1!-Jun-99 OwnersGroupComments(NoComments)
OwnersGroupResolution:
ApprovedDate:11-Jun-99 TSTFReviewInformation TSTFr'eceived Date:11-Jun-99 DateDistributed forReview11-Jun-99 OGReviewCompleted:
~BWOGPWOGPCEOGstrBWROGTravelerRev.2.Copyright (C)l99g,ExcelServicesCorporation.
UsebyExcelServicesassociates, utilityclients,andtheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission isgranted.Allotherusewithoutwrittenpcnnission isprohibited.
6/I5/99
~~
~~(WOG-140, Rev.0)TSTF-336OGRevision0RevisionStatus:ActiveNextAction:NRCTSTFComments:
(NoComments)
TSTFResolution:
ApprovedDate:15-Jun-99 NRCReviewInformation NRCReceivedDate:16-Jun-99 NRCComments:
(NoComments)
FinalResolution:
NRCActionPendingFinalResolution Date:Incorporation IntotheNUREGsFiletoBBS/LANDate:TSTFInformedDate:NUREGRevIncorporated:
AffectedTechnical Specifications TSTFApprovedDate:SR3.6.15.4IceBed(IceCondenser)
SR3.6.15.4BasesIceBed(IceCondenser)
Bkgnd3.6.15BaseslceBed(iceCondenser) 6/l5/99TravelerRev.2.Copyright (C)l998.ExcelServicesCorporation.
UsebyExcelServicesassociates, utilityclients,andtheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission isgranted.Allotherusewithoutwrinenpermission isprohibited.
~~
(5pF-334Attachment 1Technical Specification 3.6.15NoSignificant HazardsConsideration NOSIGNIFICANT HAZARDSCONSIDERATION DETERMINATION
[UtilityName]hasconcluded thatoperation of[PlantName]Unit[X],inaccordance withtheproposedchangetothetechnical specifications
[oroperating license(s)],
doesnotinvolveasignificant hazardsconsideration.
[UtilityName]'sconclusion isbasedonitsevaluation, inaccordance with10CFR50.91(a)(1),
ofthethreestandards setforthin10CFR50.92(c).A.Theroosedamendment doesnotinvolvea'siificantincreaseintherobabil'it orconseencesofanaccidentreviouslevaluated.
NeithertheTSamendment northeTSBaseschangecanincreasetheprobability ofoccurrence ofanyanalyzedaccidentbecausetheyarenottheresultorcauseofanyphysicalmodification toicecondenser structures.
Forthecurrentdesignoftheicecondenser, thereisnocorrelation betweenanycrediblefailureofitandtheinitiation ofanypreviously analyzedevent.Regarding theconsequences ofanalyzedaccidents, theicecondenser isanengineered safetyfeaturedesigned, inpart,tolimitthecontainment sub-compartment andsteelcontainment vesselpressures immediately following theinitiation ofaLOCAorHELB.Conservative sub-compartment pressureanalysisshowsthiscriteriawillbemetifthereduction intheflowareaperbayprovidedforicecondenser air/steam flowchannelsislessthanorequalto15percent,orifthetotalflowareablockedwithineachlumpedanalysissectionislessthanorequaltothe15percentassumedinthesafetyanalysis.
Thepresent0.38inchfrost/ice buildupsurveillance criteria.onlyaddresses theacceptability ofanygivenflow.channel, andhasnodirectcorrelation betweenflowchannelsexceeding thiscriteriaandpercentoftotalflowchannelblockage.
Infact,itwasnevertheintentofthecurrentSRtomakesuchacorrelation.
Ifproblemswereencountered inmeetingthe0.38inchcriteria, itwasexpectedthatadditional inspection and-analysis, suchasprovidedintheproposedamendment, wouldbeperformed tomakesuchadetermination.
Thus,theproposedamendment forflowblockagedetermination providesthenecessary assurance thatflowchannelrequirements aremetwithoutadditional evaluations, andthuswillnotincreasetheconsequences ofaLOCAorHELB.Theproposedamendment alsorevisesthesurveillance frequency fromevery9monthstoevery18monthssuchthatitwillcoincidewithrefueling outages.Theelimination ofthemid-cycle surveillance doesnotsignificantly increasethecons'equence ofanaccidentpreviously evaluated.
Improv'ed controlofmaintenance haslimitedthoseactivities withthepotential forsignificant flowchannelblockagetoduringrefueling outages.Verifying anicebedisleftwithlessthanorequalto15%flowchannelblockageattheconclusion ofarefueling outageassurestheicebedwillremaininanacceptable condition forthedurationoftheoperating cycle.Duringtheoperating cycle,acertainamountoficesublimates andreformsasfrostonthecoldersurfacesintheIceCondenser.
However,frostdoesnotdegradeflowchannelflowarea.Thesurveillance willeffectively demonstrate operability foranallowed18monthsurveillance period.Therefore, increasing thesurveillance frequency doesnotaffecttheIceCondenser operation oraccidentresponse.
Limitingicebedflowchannelblockagetolessthanorequalto150ensuresoperation isconsistent withtheassumptions ofthedesignbasisaccident(DBA)analyses.
Therefore, theproposedamendment willnotincreasetheconsequences ofanyaccidentpreviously evaluated.
Theroosedamendment doesnotcreatetheossibilit ofanewordifferent
'kindofaccidentfromanaccidentreviouslevaluated.
Forsuchapossibility toexist,therewouldhavetobeeitheraphysicalchangetotheicecondenser, orsomechangeinhowitisoperatedorphysically maintained.
NoneoftheaboveistruefortheproposedTSamendment andTSBaseschange.Thereisnochangetotheexistingdesignrequirements orinputs/results ofanyaccidentanalysiscalculations.
Theroosedamendment doesnotinvolveasiificantreduction inamarinofsafetDesignBasisAccidentanalyseshaveshownthatwith85percentofthetotalflowareaavailable (uniformly distributed),
theicecondenser willperformitsintendedfunction.
Thus,thesafetylimitforicecondenser operability isamaximum15percentblockageofflowchannels.
SR3.6.15.4currently usesaspecificvalueof0.38inchbuilduptodetermine ifunacceptable frost/ice blockageexistsintheicecondenser.
However,thisspecificvaluedoesnothaveadirectcorrelation tothesafetylimitforblockageoficecondenser flowarea.TheproposedTSamendment requiresmoreextensive visualinspection (33percentoftheflowarea/bay) thaniscurrently described (2flowchannels/bay) intheTSBasesforSR3.6.15.4, thusproviding greaterreliability anda s~
MISC-g)<directrelationship totheanalytical safetylimits.ChangingtheTStoimplement asurveillance programthatismorereli'able andusesacceptance criteriaoflessthanorequalto15percentflowblockage, asallowedbytheTMDanalysis, willnotreducethemarginofsafetyofanyTS.Theproposedamendment alsorevisesthesurveillance frequency fromevery9monthstoevery18monthssuchthatitwillcoincidewithrefueling outages.Verifying anicebedisleftwithlessthanorequalto15%flowchannelblockageattheconclusion ofarefueling outageassurestheicebedwillremaininanacceptable condition forthedurationoftheoperating cycle.Duringtheoperating cycle,acertainamountoficesublimates andreformsasfrostonthecoldersurfacesintheIceCondenser.
However,frosthasbeendetermined tonotdegradeflowchannelflowarea.Thus,designlimitsforthecontinued safefunctionofcontainment sub-compartment wallsandthesteelcontainment vesselarenotexceededduetothischange.ENVZRONMENTAL ZMPACTCONSZDERATZON Theproposedchangedoesnotinvolveasignificant hazardsconsideration, asignificant changeinthetypesoforsignificant increaseintheamountsofanyeffluents thatmaybereleasedoffsite,orasignificant increaseinindividual orcumulative occupational radiation exposure.
Therefore, theproposedchangemeetstheeligibility criteriaforcategorical exclusion setforthin10CFR51.22(c)(9).Therefore, pursuantto10CFR51.22(b),
anenvironmental assessment oftheproposedchangeisnotrequired.
Attachment 2NIUI&G1431,Revision1Technical Specification3.6.15MarkedUpPages S
ig7F-336IceBedgceCondenser) 3.6.15SURVEILLANCE REUIREMENTS continued SURVEILLANCE
'FREQUENCY SR3.6.15.2Verifytotalweightofstorediceis~[2,721,600]
lbby:9monthsWeighingarepresentative sampleof~144icebasketsandverifying eachbasketcontains~[1400)Ibofice;andb.Calculating totalweightofstoredice,ata95%confidence level,usingallicebasketweightsdetermined inSR3.6.15.2.a.
R3.6.15.3Verifyazimuthal distribution oficeata95%confidence levelbysubdividing weights,asdetermined bySR3.6.15.2.a, intothefollowing groups:9monthsLGroup1-bays1through8;b.Group2-bays9through16;andc.Group3-bays17through24.Theaverageiceweightot'nesamplebasketsineachgroupfromradialrows1,2,4,6,8,and9shallbe~[1400]lb.SR3.6.15.4Verisualinspection, accumulation oficonstructural memberscornrisinannsti:ruhtheiceXones18edis(15percentblockageofhetotalfloware~,WOGSTS3.6-54 InsertATheicebasketscontaintheicewithintheicecondenser.
Theicebedisconsidered toconsistofthetotalvolumefromthebottomelevation oftheicebasketstothetopelevation oftheicebaskets.Theicebasketspositiontheicewithintheicebedinanarrangement topromoteheattransferfromsteamtoice.InsertBThisSRensuresthattheflowchannelsthroughtheicebedhavenotaccumulated iceblockagethatexceeds15percentofthetotalflowareathroughtheicebedregion.Theallowable 15percentbuildupoficeisbasedontheanalysisofthesu~mpartment responsetoadesignbasisLOCAwithpartialblockageoftheicecondenser flowchannels, Theanalysisdidnotperformdetailedflowareamodeling, butlumpedtheicecondenser baysintosixsectionsrangingfrom2.75baysto6.5bays.Individual baysareacceptable withgreaterthan15percentblockage, aslongas15percentblockageisnotexceededforanyanalysissection.Toprovidea95percentconfidence thatflowblockagedoesnotexceedtheallowed15percent,thevisualinspection mustbemadeforatfeast54(33percent)ofthe162flowchannelspericecondenser bay.Thevisualinspection oftheicebedflowchannelsistoinspecttheflowarea,bylookingdownfromthetopoftheicebed,andwhereviewisachievable upfromthebottomoftheicebed.Flowchannelstobeinspected aredetermined byrandomsample.Asthemostrestrictive icebedfiowpassageisfoundatalatticeframeelevation, the15percentblockagecriteriaonlyappliesto"fiowchannels" thatcomprisethearea:a.betweenicebaskets,andb.pastlatticeframesandwallpanels.Duetoasignificantly largerflowareaintheregionsoftheupperdeckgratingandthelowerinletplenumsupportstructures andturningvanes,agrossbuildupoficeonthesestructures wouldberequiredtodegradeairandsteamflow.Therefore, thesestructures areexcludedaspartofaflowchannelforapplication ofthe15percentblockagecriteria.
Industryexperience hasshownthatremovaloficefromtheexcludedstructures duringtherefueling outageissufficient toensuretheyremainoperablethroughout theoperating cycle.Removalofanygross'icebuildupontheexcludedstructures isperformed following outagemaintenance activities.
Operating experience hasdemonstrated thattheicebedistheregionthatisthemostflowrestrictive, duetothenormalpresenceoficeaccumulation onlatticeframesandwallpanels.Theflowareathroughtheicebasketsupportplatformisnotamorerestrictive flowareabecauseitiseasilyaccessible fromthelowerplenumandismaintained clearoficeaccumulation.
Thereisnomechanistically crediblemethodforicetoaccumulate ontheicebasketsupportplatformduringplantoperation.
Plantandindustryexperience hasshownthattheverticalflowareathroughtheicebasketsupportplatformremainsclearoficeaccumulation thatcouldproduceblockage.
Normallyonlyaglazemaydeveloporexistontheicebasketsupportplatformwhichisnotsignificant toblockageofflowarea.Additionally, outagemaintenance practices providemeasurestocleartheicebasketsupportplatformfollowing maintenance activities ofanyaccumulation oficethatcouldblockflowareas.Frostbuilduporlooseiceisnottobeconsidered asflowchannelblockage, whereasattachediceisconsidered blockageofaflowchannel.Frostisthesolidformofwaterthatislooselyadherent, andcanbebrushedoffwiththeopenhand.
IceBed(IceCondenser)
B3.6.15B3.6CONTAINMENT SYSTEMSB3.6.15IceBed(lceCondenser)
ADD1944BASESBACKGROUND Theicebedconsistsofove,721,60 Iboficestoredinbasketswithintheicecondenser.
Itsprimarypurposeistoprovidealargeheatsinkintheevent-ofareleaseofenergyfromaDesignBasisAccident(DBA)incontainment.
Theicewouldabsorbenergyandlimitcontainment peakpressureandtemperature duringtheaccidenttransient.
Limitingthepressureandtemperature reducesthereleaseoffissionproductradioactivity fromcontainment totheenvironment intheeventofaDBA.Theicecondenser isanannularcompartment encfosing approximately 300ooftheperimeter oftheuppercontainment compartment, butpenetrating theoperating decksothataportionextendsintothelowercontainment compartment.
Thelowerportionhasaseriesofhingeddoorsexposedtotheatmosphere ofthelowercontainment compartment, which,fornormalunitoperation, aredesignedtoremainclosed.Atthetopoftheicecondenser isanothersetofdoorsexposedtotheatmosphere oftheuppercompartment, whichalsoremainclosedduringnormalunitoperation.
Intermediate deckdoors,locatedbelowthetopdeckdoors,formthefloorofaplenumattheupperpartoftheicecondenser.
Thesedoorsalsoremainclosedduringnormalunitoperation.
Theupperplenumareaisusedtofacilitate surveillance andmaintenance oftheicebed.nsertAThisarrangement enancestheicecondenser's primaryfunctionofcondensing steamandabsorbing heatenergyreleasedtothecontainment duringaDBA.IntheeventofaDBA,theicecondenser inletdoors(locatedbelowtheoperating deck)openduetothepressureriseinthelowercompartment.
Thisallowsairandsteamtofiowfromthelowercompartment intotheicecondenser.
Theresulting pressureincreasewithintheicecondenser causestheintermediate deckdoorsandthetopdeckdoorstoopen,whichallowstheairtoflowoutoftheicecondenser intotheuppercompartment.
Steamcondensation withintheicecondenser limitsthepressureandtemperature buildupin(continued)
WOGSTSB3.6-151 S0 IceBed(IceCondenser)
B3.6.15BASESSURVEILLANCE SR3.6.15.3REQUIREMENTS(continued)
ThisSRensuresthattheazimuthal distribution oficeisreasonably uniform,byverifying thattheaverageiceweightineachofthreeazimuthal groupsoficecondenser baysiswithinthelimit.TheFrequency of9monthswasbasedonicestoragetestsandtheallowance builtintotherequiredicemassoverandabovethemassassumedinthesafetyanalyses.
Operating experience hasverNedthat,withthe9monthFrequency, theweightrequirements aremaintained withnosignificant degradation betweensurveillances.
SR3.6.15.4nsertBcontinued)
OGSTSB3.6-157 I
IceBed(IceCondenser)
B3.6.15BASESSURVEILLANCE REQUIREMENTS SR3.6.15.4(continued)
SR3.6.15.5Verifying thechemicalcomposition ofthestorediceensuresthatthestoredicehasaboronconcentration ofatleast[1800]ppmassodiumtetraborate andahighpH,p[9.0]andg[9.5],inordertomeettherequirement forboratedwaterwhenthemeltediceisusedintheECCSrecirculation modeofoperation.
Sodiumtetraborate hasbeenproveneffective inmaintaining theboroncontentforlongstorageperiods,anditalsoenhancestheabilityofthesolutiontoremoveandretainfissionproductiodine.ThehighpHisrequiredtoenhancetheeffectiveness oftheiceandthemeltediceinremovingiodinefromthecontainment atmosphere.
ThispHrangealsominimizes theoccurrence ofchlorideandcausticstresscorrosion onmechanical systemsandcomponents exposedtoECCSandContainment SpraySystemfluidsintherecirculation modeofoperation.
TheFrequency of[18]monthswasdeveloped considering thesefactsa.Longicestoragetestshavedetermined thatthechemicalcomposition ofthestorediceisextremely stable.b.Operating experience hasdemonstrated thatmeetingtheboronconcentration andpHrequirements hasneverbeenaproblem;andc.Someonewouldhavetoenterthecontainment totakethesample,and,iftheunitisatpower,thatpersonwouldreceivearadiation dose.SR3.6.15.6ThisSRensuresthatarepresentative samplingoficebaskets,whicharerelatively thinwalled,perforated cylinders, havenotbeendegradedbywear,cracks,corrosion, orotherdamage.Eachicebasketmustberaisedatleast12feetforthisinspection.
TheFrequency of(continued)
WOGSTSB3.6-158
~ViAttachment 3NIUI&G1431,Revision1Technical Specification 3.6.15RevisedPages
IceBedgceCondenser) 3.6.15SURVEILLANCE REUIRElvKNTS continued SURVEILLANCE FREQUENCY
'R3.6.15.2Verifytotalweightofstorediceis~[2,721,600]
Ibby:9monthsaoWeighingarepresentative sampleof~144icebasketsandverifying eachbasketcontains>[1400]lbofice;aildb.Calculating totalweightofstoredice,ata95%confidence level,usingallicebasketweightsdetermined inSR3.6.15.2.a.
R3.6.15.3Verifyazimuthal distribution oficeata95%confidence levelbysubdividing weights,asdetermined bySR3.6.15.2.a, intothefollowing groups:'monthsa.Group1-bays1through8;b.Group2-bays9through16;andc.Group3-bays17through24.Theaverageiceweightofthesamplebasketsineachgroupfromradialrows1,2,4,6,8,and9shallbep[1400]lb.SR3.6.15.4Verify,byvisualinspection, accumulation oficeonstructural memberscomprising flowchannelsthroughtheicebedisz15percentblockageofthetotalflowarea.18monthsWOGSTS3.6-54(continued)
C'I CPcs-)34IceBed(iceCondenser)
B3.6.15'3.6CONTAINMENT SYSTEMSB3.6.15lceBed(IceCondenser)
BASESBACKGROUND UTheicebedconsistsofover[2,721,600]
Iboficestoredin1944basketswithintheicecondenser.
ItsprimarypurposeistoprovidealargeheatsinkintheeventofareleaseofenergyfromaDesignBasisAccident(DBA)incontainment.
Theicewouldabsorbenergyandlimitcontainment peakpressureandtemperature duringtheaccidenttransient.
Limitingthepressureandtemperature reducesthereleaseoffissionproductradioactivity fromcontainment totheenvironment intheeventofaDBA.Theicecondenser isanannularcompartment enclosing approximately 300ooftheperimeter oftheuppercontainment compartment, butpenetrating theoperating decksothataportionextendsintothelowercontainment compartment.
Thelowerportionhasaseriesofhingeddoorsexposedtotheatmosphere ofthelowercontainment compartment, which,fornormalunitoperation, aredesignedtoremainclosed.Atthetopoftheicecondenser isanothersetofdoorsexposedtotheatmosphere oftheuppercompartment, whichalsoremainclosedduringnormalunitoperation..
Intermediate deckdoors,locatedbelow.thetopdeckdoors,formthefioorofaplenumattheupperpartoftheicecondenser.
Thesedoorsalsoremainclosedduringnormalunitoperation.
Theupperplenumareaisusedtofacilitate surveillance andmaintenance oftheicebed.lTheicebasketscontaintheicewithintheicecondenser.
Theicebedisconsidered toconsistofthetotalvolumefromthebottomelevation eftheicebasketstothetopelevation oftheicebaskets.Theicebasketspositiontheicewithintheicebedinanarrangement topromoteheattrains'.rfromsteamtoice.Thisarrangement enhancestheicecondenser's primaryfunctionofcondensing steamandabsorbing heatenergyreleasedtothecontainment duringaDBA.IntheeventofaDBA,theicecondenser inletdoors(locatedbelowtheoperating deck)openduetothepressureriseinthelowercompartment.
Thisallowsairandsteamtoflowfromthelowercompartment intotheicecondenser.
Theresulting pressureincreasewithintheicecondenser causestheintermediate deckdoorsandthetopdeckdoorstoopen,whichallowstheairtoflowoutoftheicecondenser intotheuppercompartment.
Steamcondensation withintheicecondenser limitsthepressureandtemperature buildupin(continued)
WOGSTSB3.6-151 CA7 IceBed(IceCondenser)
B3.6.15BASESSURVEILLANCE REQUIREMENTS SR3.6.15.4(continued) throughout theoperating cycle.Removalofanygrossicebuildupontheexcludedstructures isperformed following outagemaintenance activities.
Operating experience hasdemonstrated thattheicebedistheregionthatisthemostflowrestrictive, duetothenormalpresenceoficeaccumulation onlatticeframesandwallpanels.Theflowareathroughtheicebasketsupportplatformisnotamorerestrictive flowareabecauseitiseasilyaccessible fromthelowerplenumandismaintained clearoficeaccumulation.
Thereisnomechanistically crediblemethodforicetoaccumulate ontheicebasketsupportplatformduringplantoperation.
Plantandindustryexperience hasshownthattheverticalflowareathroughtheicebasketsupportplatformremainsclearoficeaccumulation thatcouldproduceblockage.
Normallyonlyaglazemaydeveloporexistontheicebasketsupportplatformwhichisnotsignificant toblockageofflowarea.Additionally, outagemaintenance practices providemeasurestocleartheicebasketsupportplatformfollowing maintenance activities ofanyaccumulation oficethatcouldblockflowareas.Frostbuilduporlooseiceisnottobeconsidered asflowchannelblockage, whereasattachediceisconsidered blockageofaflowchannel.Frostisthesolidformofwaterthatislooselyadherent, andcanbebrushedoffwiththeopenhand.SR3.6.15.5Verifying thechemicalcomposition ofthestorediceensuresthatthestoredicehasaboronconcentration ofatleast[1800]ppmassodiumtetraborate andahighpH,p[9.0]andg[9.5],inordertomeettherequirement forboratedwaterwhenthemeltediceisusedintheECCSrecirculation modeofoperation.
Sodiumtetraborate hasbeenproveneffective inmaintaining theboroncontentforlongstorageperiods,anditalsoenhancestheabilityofthesolutiontoremoveandretainfissionproductiodine.ThehighpHisrequiredtoenhancetheeffectiveness oftheiceandthemeltediceinremovingiodinefromthecontainment atmosphere.
ThispHrangealsominimizes theoccurrence ofchlorideandcausticstresscorrosion onmechanical systemsandcomponents exposedtoECCSandContainment (continued)
WOGSTSB3.6-158 Page1of2Tennessee ValleyAuthority SEQUOYAHNUCLEARPLANTWATTSBARNUCLEARPLANTCC:Mr.J.A.ScaliceChiefNuclearOfficerandExecutive VicePresident Tennessee ValleyAuthority 6ALookoutPlace1101MarketStreetChattanooga, Tennessee 37402-2801 Mr.KarlW.Singer,SeniorVicePresident NuclearOperations Tennessee ValleyAuthority 6ALookoutPlace1101MarketStreetChattanooga, TN37402-2801 Mr.JackA.Bailey,VicePresident Engineering
&Technical ServicesTennessee ValleyAuthority 6ALookoutPlace1101MarketStreetChattanooga, TN37402-2801 Mr.RichardT.Purcell,SiteVicePresident WattsBarNuclearPlantTennessee ValleyAuthority P.O.Box2000SpringCity,TN37381Mr.MasoudBajestani SiteVicePresident SequoyahNuclearPlantTennessee ValleyAuthority P.O.Box2000SoddyDaisy,TN37379GeneralCounselTennessee ValleyAuthority ET10H400WestSummitHillDriveKnoxville, TN37902Mr.N.C.Kazanas,GeneralManagerNuclearAssurance Tennessee ValleyAuthority 5MLookoutPlace1101MarketStreetChattanooga, TN37402-2801 Mr.MarkJ.Burzynski, ManagerNuclearLicensing Tennessee ValleyAuthority 4XBlueRidge1101MarketStreetChattanooga, TN37402-2801 Mr.PedroSalas,ManagerLicensing andIndustryAffairsSequoyahNuclearPlantTennessee ValleyAuthority P.O.Box2000SoddyDaisy,TN37379Mr.D.L.Koehl,PlantManagerSequoyahNuclearPlantTennessee ValleyAuthority P.O.Box2000SoddyDaisy,TN37379SeniorResidentInspector SequoyahNuclearPlantU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission 2600IgouFerryRoadSoddyDaisy,TN37379CountyExecutive HamiltonCountyCourthouse Chattanooga, TN37402-2801 Mr.PaulL.Pace,ManagerLicensing andIndustryAffairsWattsBarNuclearPlantTennessee ValleyAuthority P.O.Box2000SpringCity,TN37381Mr.WilliamR.Lagergren, PlantManagerWattsBarNuclearPlantTennessee ValleyAuthority P.O.Box2000SpringCity,TN37381
~~Page2of2LTennessee ValleyAuthority
.~SEQUOYAHNUCLEARPLANTWATTSBARNUCLEARPLANTcc:SeniorResidentInspector WattsBarNuclearPlantU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission 1260NuclearPlantRoadSpringCity,TN37381CountyExecutive RheaCountyCourthouse Dayton,TN37321CountyExecutive MeigsCountyCourthouse Decatur,TN37322Mr.MichaelH.Mobley,DirectorTNDept.ofEnvironment
&Conservation DivisionofRadiological Health3rdFloor,LandCAnnex401ChurchStreetNashville, TN37243-1532 McGuireNuclearStationCC:Ms.LisaF.VaughnLegalDepartment (PBO5E)DukeEnergyCorporation 422SouthChurchStreetCharlotte, NorthCarolina28201-1006 CountyManagerofMecktenburg County720EastFourthStreetCharlotte, NorthCarolina28202MichaelT.CashRegulatory Compliance ManagerDukeEnergyCorporation McGuireNuclearSite12700HagersFerryRoadHuntersville, NorthCarolina28078J.MichaelMcGarry,III,EsquireWinstonandStrawn1400LStreet,NW.Washington, DC20005SeniorResidentInspector c/oU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission 12700HagersFerryRoadHuntersville, NorthCarolina28078Dr.JohnM.BarryMecklenberg CountyDepartment ofEnvironmental Protection 700N.TryonStreetCharlotte, NorthCarolina28202Mr.StevenP.ShaverSeniorSalesEngineerWestinghouse ElectricCompany5929CarnegieBlvd.Suite500Charlotte, NorthCarolina28209Ms.KarenE.LongAssistant AttorneyGeneralNorthCarolinaDepartment ofJusticeP.O.Box629Raleigh,NorthCarolina27602L.A.KellerManager-NuclearRegulatory Licensing DukeEnergyCorporation 526SouthChurchStreetCharlotte, NorthCarolina28201-1006 ElaineWathen,LeadREPPlannerDivisionofEmergency Management 116WestJonesStreetRaleigh,NorthCarolina27603-1335 Mr.RichardM.Fry,DirectorDivisionofRadiation Protection NorthCarolinaDepartment ofEnvironment, HealthandNaturalResources 3825BarrettDriveRaleigh,NorthCarolina27609-7721 Mr.T.RichardPuryearOwnersGroup(NCEMC)DukeEnergyCorporation 4800ConcordRoadYork',SouthCarolina29745Mr.H.B.BarronVicePresident, McGuireSiteDukeEnergyCorporation 12700HagersFerryRoadHuntersville, NC28078-8985 IC CatawbaNuclearStationCC:Mr.GaryGilbertRegulatory Compliance ManagerDukeEnergyCorporation 4800ConcordRoadYork,SouthCarolina29745Ms.LisaF.VaughnLegalDepartment (PB05E)DukeEnergyCorporation 422SouthChurchStreetCharlotte, NorthCarolina28201-1006 AnneCottington, EsquireWinstonandStrawn1400LStreet,NWWashington, DC20005NorthCarolinaMunicipal PowerAgencyNumber11427Meadowwood Boulevard P.O.Box29513Raleigh,NorthCarolina27626CountyManagerofYorkCountyYorkCountyCourthouse York,SouthCarolina29745PiedmontMunicipal PowerAgency121VillageDriveGreer,SouthCarolina29651Ms.KarenE.LongAssistant AttorneyGeneralNorthCarolinaDepartment ofJusticeP.O.Box629Raleigh,NorthCarolina27602ElaineWathen,LeadREPPlannerDivisionofEmergency Management 116WestJonesStreetRaleigh,NorthCarolina27603-1335 NorthCarolinaElectricMembershi'p Corporation P.O.Box27306Raleigh,NorthCarolina27611SeniorResidentInspector U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission 4830ConcordRoadYork,SouthCarolina29745VirgilR.Autry,DirectorDivisionofRadioactive WasteManagement BureauofLandandWasteManagement Department ofHealthandEnvironmental Control2600BullStreetColumbia, SouthCarolina29201-1708 L.A.KellerManager-NuclearRegulatory Licensing DukeEnergyCorporation 526SouthChurchStreetCharlotte, NorthCarolina28201-1006 SaludaRiverElectricP.O.Box929Laurens,SouthCarolina29360Mr.StevenP.ShaverSeniorSalesEngineerWestinghouse ElectricCompany5929CarnegieBlvd.Suite500Charlotte, NorthCarolina28209Mr.G.R.PetersonSiteVicePresident CatawbaNuclearStationDukeEnergy~',orooration 4800ConcordRoadYork,SouthCarolina29745-9635 4h' CatawbaNuclearStationCC:Mr.T.RichardPuryearOwnersGroup(NCEMC)DukeEnergyCorporation 4800ConcordRoadYork,SouthCarolina29745RichardM.Fry,DirectorDivisionofRadiation Protection NorthCarolinaDepartment ofEnvironment, Health,andNaturalResources 3825BarrettDriveRaleigh,NorthCarolina27609-7721 CC:RegionalAdministrator, RegionIIIU.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission 801Warrenville RoadLisle,IL60532-4351 AttorneyGeneralDepartment ofAttorneyGeneral525WestOttawaStreetLansing,Ml48913TownshipSupervisor LakeTownshipHallP.O.Box818Bridgman, Ml49106U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission ResidentInspector's Office7700RedArrowHighwayStevensville, Ml49127JeremyJ.Euto,EsquireIndianaMichiganPowerCompanyNuclearGeneration Group500CircleDriveBuchanan, Ml49107Mayor,CityofBridgmanP.O.Box366Bridgman, MI49106SpecialAssistant totheGovernorRoom1-StateCapitoiLansing,Ml48909DonaldC.CookNuclearPlantUnits1and2DrinkingWaterandRadiological Protection DivisionMichiganDepartment ofEnvironmental Quality3423N.MartinLutherKingJrBlvdP.O.Box30630CPHMailroomLansing,Ml48909-8130 GordonArentDirector, Regulatory AffairsIndianaMichiganPowerCompanyNuclearGeneration Group500CircleDriveBuchanan, Ml49107DavidA.LochbaumUnionofConcerned Scientists 1616PStreetNW,Suite310Washington, DC20036-1495 A.Christopher Bakken,SiteVicePresident IndianaMichiganPowerCompanyNuclearGeneration GroupOneCookPlaceBridgman, Ml49106MichaelW.RencheckVicePresident, NuclearEngineering IndianaMichiganPowerCompanyNuclearGeneration Group500CircleDriveBuchanan, Ml49107Mr.RobertP.Powers,VicePresident IndianaMichiganPowerCompanyNuclearGeneration Group500CircleDriveBuchanan, MI49107
'-0'\0}}

Latest revision as of 15:22, 7 January 2025

Forwards 20 Revised & Eight New TS Nuregs,Nei TS Task Force (TSTF) Traveler Numbers TSTF-17,rev 2,TSTF-37,rev 2,TSTF-58, Rev 1,TSTF-59,rev 1,TSTF-107,rev 4,TSTF-169,rev 1,TSTF-197, Rev 2,TSTF-204,rev 1,TSTF-207,rev 3 & TSTF-230,rev 1
ML17326A193
Person / Time
Issue date: 06/23/1999
From: Jennifer Davis
NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE (FORMERLY NUCLEAR MGMT &
To: Beckner W
NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
References
PROJECT-689, RTR-NUREG-1430, RTR-NUREG-1431, RTR-NUREG-1432, RTR-NUREG-1433, RTR-NUREG-1434 NUDOCS 9907120272
Download: ML17326A193 (65)
v • d • e


Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML17326A193&oldid=5072402"