ML14132A130: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Adams
#REDIRECT [[W3F1-2014-0033, Core Operating Limits Report Cycle 20 Revision 0, Waterford Steam Electric Station, Unit 3]]
| number = ML14132A130
| issue date = 05/12/2014
| title = Core Operating Limits Report Cycle 20 Revision 0, Waterford Steam Electric Station, Unit 3
| author name = Jarrell J P
| author affiliation = Entergy Operations, Inc
| addressee name =
| addressee affiliation = NRC/Document Control Desk, NRC/NRR
| docket = 05000382
| license number = NPF-038
| contact person =
| case reference number = W3F1-2014-0033
| document type = Fuel Cycle Reload Report, Letter
| page count = 51
}}
 
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:EnteigyW3F1-2014-0033May12,2014U.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommissionAttn:DocumentControlDeskWashington,DC20555-0001
 
==Subject:==
CoreOperatingLimitsReport-Cycle20Revision0WaterfordSteamElectricStation,Unit3DocketNo.50-382LicenseNo.NPF-38EntergyOperations,Inc.17265RiverRoadKillona,LA70057-3093Tel5047396685Fax5047396698jjarrel@entergy.comJohnP.JarrellIIIManager-RegulatoryAssuranceWaterford3
 
==DearSirorMadam:==
Waterford3TechnicalSpecification6.9.1.11.3requiressubmittaloftheCoreOperatingLimitsReportforeachreloadcycleincludinganymid-cyclerevisionsorsupplementsthereto.AttachedistheWaterford3CoreOperatingLimitsReportforreloadcycle20.Ifyouhaveanyquestionsconcerningthissubmittal,pleasecontactJohnP.Jarrell,RegulatoryAssuranceManager,at(504)739-6685.Therearenonewcommitmentscontainedinthissubmittal.Sincerely,/JPJ/LLB
 
==Attachment:==
Waterford3CoreOperatingLimitsReportCycle20Revision0 NUCLEARQUAUTYRELATEDEN-Ll-106REV.13---En!ergyMANAGEMENT.MANUALINFORMATIONALUSENRCCorrespondenceATTACHMENT9.4NRCSuBMITrALREvIEwSheet1of2(Typical)Letter#:W3F1-2014-0033ResponseDue:5/14/2014
 
==Subject:==
CoreOperatingLimitsReport(COLR)-DateIssuedforReview:5/11/2014Cycle20Revision0.PerTS6.9.1.11.3includinganymid-cyclerevisionsorsupplementsthereto.CorrespondencePreparerIPhone#:LillianBrown!504-739-7384SectionILetterConcurrenceandAgreementtoPerformActionsPOSITIONINAMEActionSignature(concurrence,certification,etc.)(sign,interofficememo,e-mail,ortelecom)NANANACOMMENTSEnclosuretothiscorrespondencedoesnotrequirecertificationsincethereportwasreviewedandapprovedinaccordancewithanestablishedprocess.(ReferenceEN-LI-I06section5.3notes)ISectionIICorrespondenceScreeningDoesthislettercontaincommitments?If"yes,"identifythecommitmentswithdueYesEldatesinthesubmittalandinSectionIII.Whenfleetletterscontaincommitments,aNoPCRSLO(e.g.,LO-LAR,LO-WT)shouldbeinitiatedwithaCAassignedtoeachapplicablesitetoenterthecommitmentsintothesite'scommitmentmanagementsystem.DoesthislettercontainanyinformationoranalysesofnewsafetyissuesperformedatNRCYesElrequestortosatisfyaregulatoryrequirement?If"yes,"reflectrequirementtoupdatetheNoUFSARinSectionIII.Doesthisletterrequireanydocumentchanges(e.g.,procedures,DBDs,FSAR,TSBases,YesEletc.),ifapproved?If"yes,"indicateinSectionIllanactionfortheresponsibleNodepartmenttodeterminetheaffecteddocuments.(TheCorrespondencePreparermayindicatethespecificdocumentsrequiringrevision,ifknownormayinitiateanactionforreview.)Doesthislettercontaininformationcertifiedaccurate?If"yes,"identifytheinformationYesElanddocumentcertificationinanattachment.(Attachment9.5mustbeused.)NoEN-LI-I06REV13 NUCLEARIQuALIrvRELATEDEN-LI-106REV.13EntergyMANAGEMENT1MANUALINFORMATIONALUSENRCCorrespondenceATTAcHMENT9.4NRCSUBMITTALREvIEwSheet2of2SectionIIIActionsandCommitmentsCommitmentsDueDateResponsibleDept.Note:Whenfleetletterscontaincommitments,aPCRSLOshouldbeinitiatedwithaCAassignedtoeachapplicablesitetoenterthecommitmentsintothesitescommitmentmanagementsystem.NANANARequiredActionsNote:ActionsneededuponapprovalshouldbecapturedintheappropriateactiontrackinqsystemNADueDateNAResponsibleDept.NAEN-LI-I06REV13 W3FI-2014-0033Page2cc:Mr.MarcL.DapasRegionalAdministratorU.S.NuclearRegulatoryCommissionRegionIV1600E.LamarBlvd.Arlington,TX76011-4511RidsRgn4MailCenternrc.govNRCSeniorResidentInspectorWater-fordSteamElectricStationUnit3Marlone.Davis@nrc.govChris.Speer@nrc.govNRC/NRRProjectManagerforWater-ford3Michael.Orenaknrc.govAlan.Wangnrc.gov AttachmenttoW3FI-2014-0033Waterford3CoreOperatingLimitsReportCycle20Revision0(Attachmentcontains46pages)
EngineeringReportNo,WF3-NE-14-00002Rev.0Page1of46EntergyENTERGYNUCLEAREngineeringReportCoverSheetEngineeringReportTitle:WSES-3Cycle20CoreOperatingLimitsReportEngineeringReportType:NewRevisionElCancelledElSuperseded[]Supersededby:_______________ApplicableSite(s)IP1P2ElP3ElJAFElPNPSElvvElwpoElANO1ANO2ElECHQGGNSElRBSElWF3PLPElECNo.4j4ReportOrigin:EntergyElVendorVendorDocumentNo.:Quality-Related:YesElNoPreparedby:C.G.Eastus/L-".E9t')Date:________ResponsibleEngineer(PrintName/Sign)DesignVerified:N.Pazooki/P--Date:________DesignVerifier-(frequired)rintName/Sign)Reviedby:L.E.MusterI4&Date:1//I)ReviewerPntNam1S?1)ApprovedbVFHSmith/,Date:.j/2'iJO(jSupervisor)anager(PnntName/Sign)
RevisionSummaryWF3-NE-14-00002,Revision0Page2of46Revision0Initialissueofthereport WF3-NE-14-00002,Revision0Page3of46TableofContentsRevisionSummary21.0ScopeandObjectives42.0InputDocuments43.0Assumptions44.0DetailedDiscussion45.0OperatingExperience46.0SummaryofResults47.0ConclusionsandRecommendations48.0References49.0Attachments5 WF3-NE-14-00002,Revision0Page4of461.0ScopeandObjectivesThisreportdescribesthedevelopmentoftheWaterford-3Cycle20(W3C20)CoreOperatingLimitsReport(COLR).ThereportisdevelopedbyupdatingthepreviouscycleCOLR(InputDocument(ID)2.1)withinformationfromtheW3C20ReloadAnalysisReport(ID2.2)andtheW3C20SetpointsDocument(ID2.3).2.0InputDocumentsTheinputdocumentsusedtodeveloptheW3C20COLRincludethefollowing:2.1."EntergyOperationsWaterford-3CoreOperatingLimitsReportforCycle19Revision2,"October24,2013.2.2.Letter,R.A.LoretztoC.Eastus,"WaterfordSteamElectricStationUnit3Cycle20FinalReloadAnalysisReport,"NF-WTFD-14-5,February17,2014.SeealsoEngineeringReportWF3-NE-14-000012.3.Letter,R.A.LoretztoC.Eastus,"StartupTestandSetpointsTransmittalforWaterlord-3Cycle20,"NF-WTFD-14-12,April11,2014.3.0AssumptionsHistorically,informationfortheCOLRupdateisincludedinthecyclespecificRARandthecyclespecificsetpointsanalysis.4.0DetailedDiscussionID2.2containsthenon-setpointsrelatedinformationnecessarytoupdatetheCOLR.ThedocumenthassectionsspecificallyaddressingtheinformationnecessarytoupdatetheCOLRbaseduponthecyclespecificanalysisperformedbythefuelvendor(Westinghouse).SetpointsrelatedchangesareprovidedinID2.3.Thereceivedinformationwasappliedto1D2.1.TheresultingW3C20COLRisfoundinAttachment9.1.5.0OperatingExperienceAPCRSsearchwasperformedlookingforissuesrelatedtothedevelopmentofaCOLRasdescribedhere.Nonewerefound.6.0SummaryofResultsUsingvendorprovidedinformation;theW3C19Rev.2COLRwasupdatedtoreflectCycle20information.7.0ConclusionsandRecommendationsTheW3C20Revision0COLRhasbeendevelopedandisacceptabletouse.8.0ReferencesNone WF3-NE-14-00002,Revision0Page5of469.0Attachments9.1W3C20Revision0COLR(usingformattingandnumberingappropriatefortheCOLR).
Attachment9.1Waterford-3Cycle20COLRRevision0WF3-NE-14-00002,Revision0Page6of46 ENTERGYOPERATIONSWATERFORD3COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTFORCYCLE20REVISION0 WATERFORD3COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTCYCLE20,REVISION0INDEXPAGEI.INTRODUCTION5II.63.1.1.1COLR3/41-13.1.1.2COLR3/41-33.1.1.3COLR3141-43.1.2.9COLR3/41-153.1.3.1COLR3/41-183.1.3.6COLR3/41-253.2.1COLR3/42-13.2.3COLR3!42-43.2.4COLR3/42-63.2.7COLR3/42-123.9.1COLR3/49-1III.METHODOLOGIES38LISTOFEFFECTIVEPAGESRevision0Pages1-6,COLR3/41-1,1-3,1-4,1-15,1-18,1-25,2-1,2-4,2-6,2-12,9-1,andPages38-40AFFECTEDTECHNICALSPECIFICATIONSShutdownMargin-AnyCEAWithdrawnShutdownMargin-AllCEAsFullyInsertedModeratorTemperatureCoefficientBoronDilutionMovableControlAssemblies-CEAPositionRegulatingandGroupPCEAInsertionLimitsLinearHeatRateAzimuthalPowerTilt-TqDNBRMarginAxialShapeIndexBoronConcentrationWATERFORD3Page2CYCLE20REVISION0 LISTOFFIGURESPAGECOLRFigure1ShutdownMarginVersusColdLegTemperatureCOLR3/41-3ACOLRFigure2ModeratorTemperatureCoefficientVersus%ofCOLR3/41-4ARatedThermalPowerCOLRFigure3RequiredPowerReductionAfterSingleCEACOLR3/41-18ADeviationCOLRFigure4RegulatingCEAGroupInsertionLimitsVersusCOLR3/41-25AThermalPowerCOLRFigure5GroupPCEAGroupInsertionLimitsVersusCOLR3/41-25BThermalPowerCOLRFigure6NotUsedCOLR3/42-lACOLRFigure7NotUsedCOLR3/42-lBCOLRFigure8AllowableDNBRwithAnyCEACOperableCOLR3/42-6A(COLSSOutofService)COLRFigure8ASubsetofAllowableDNBRwithAnyCEACOperableCOLR3/42-6B(COLSSOutofService)COLRFigure8.1NotUsedCOLR3/42-6CCOLRFigure8.1ANotUsedCOLR3/42-6DCOLRFigure9AllowableDNBRwithNoCEAC(s)OperableCOLR3/42-6E(COLSSOutofService)COLRFigure9ASubsetofAllowableDNBRwithNoCEAC(s)OperableCOLR3/42-6F(COLSSOutofService)COLRFigure9.1NotUsedCOLR3/42-6GCOLRFigure9.1ANotUsedCOLR3/42-6HLISTOFEFFECTIVEFIGUREPAGESRevision0COLR3/41-3A,1-4A,1-18A,1-25A,1-25B,2-lA,2-1B,2-6A,2-6B,2-6C,2-6D,2-6E,2-6F,2-6G,2-6HWATERFORD3Page3CYCLE20REVISION0 LISTOFTABLESPAGECOLRTable1RequiredMonitoringFrequenciesforBackupCOLR3/41-15ABoronDilutionDetectionasaFunctionofOperatingChargingPumpsandPlantOperationalModesforKeffGreaterThan0.98.COLRTable2RequiredMonitoringFrequenciesforBackupCOLR3/41-15BBoronDilutionDetectionasaFunctionofOperatingChargingPumpsandPlantOperationalModesforKeffGreaterThan0.97andLessThanorEqualto0.98.COLRTable3RequiredMonitoringFrequenciesforBackupCOLR3/41-15CBoronDilutionDetectionasaFunctionofOperatingChargingPumpsandPlantOperationalModesforKeffGreaterThan0.96andLessThanorEqualto0.97.COLRTable4RequiredMonitoringFrequenciesforBackupCOLR3/41-15DBoronDilutionDetectionasaFunctionofOperatingChargingPumpsandPlantOperationalModesforKeffGreaterThan0.95andLessThanorEqualto0.96.COLRTable5RequiredMonitoringFrequenciesforBackupCOLR3/41-15EBoronDilutionDetectionasaFunctionofOperatingChargingPumpsandPlantOperationalModesforKeffGreaterThanorEqualto0.95.LISTOFEFFECTIVETABLEPAGESRevision0COLR3/41-15AthroughCOLR3/41-15EWATERFORD3Page4CYCLE20REVISION0 WATERFORD3COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTCYCLE20,REVISION0I.INTRODUCTIONThisCOREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORT(COLR)hasbeenpreparedinaccordancewiththerequirementsofWaterford3TechnicalSpecification6.9.1.11forWaterford3Cycle20.ThecoreoperatinglimitshavebeendevelopedusingtheNRCapprovedmethodologiesspecifiedinSectionIII.ThisisRevision0oftheCycle20COLR.ThemajorchangesbetweentheCycle20,Revision0,COLRandtheCycle19,Revision2,COLRarelistedbelow:Section3.2.7wasrevisedtoremoveaburnuprestrictionontheCOLSSOperableASILimitsfor50%powerconditions.WATERFORD3Page5CYCLE20REVISION0 IiAFFECTEDTECHNICALSPECIFICATIONSWATERFORD3Page6CYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTSHUTDOWNMARGIN-ANYCEAWITHDRAWN3.1.1.1TheSHUTDOWNMARGINshallbegreaterthanorequalto5.15%/xklkwhenTavgisgreaterthan200&deg;For2.0%Ak/kwhenTavgislessthanorequalto200&deg;F.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-1CYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTSHUTDOWNMARGIN-ALLCEAsFULLYINSERTED3.1.1.2TheSHUTDOWNMARGINshallbemaintainedwithintheregionofacceptableoperationofCOLRFigure1.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-3CYCLE20REVISION0 54I0zC,)2ICOLRFigure16006ShutdownMarginVersusColdLegTemperature(AllCEAsFullyInserted)00100200300400500ColdLegTemperature(&deg;F)WATERFORD3COLR3/41-3ACYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTMODERATORTEMPERATURECOEFFICIENT3.1.1.3TheModeratorTemperatureCoefficient(MTC)shallbemaintainedwithintheregionofacceptableoperationofCOLRFigure2.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-4CYCLE20REVISION0 ModeratorTemperatureCoefficientVersus%ofRatedThermalPowera.&deg;-2xC-)-2.5-3-3.5-4-4.5010(0.0,0.5)0.50-0.5-1UnacceptableOperation___z:h-rAcceptableOperation:(0.0,39)(100,-3.9)UnacceptableOperation2030405060708090100%ofRatedThermalPowerCOLRFigure2WATERFORD3COLR3/41-4ACYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTBORONDILUTION3.1.2.9SeeCOLRTables1through5forrequiredRCSboronconcentrationmonitoringfrequenciesandChargingPumpoperationlimits.SURVEILLANCEREQUIREMENTSEachrequiredborondilutionalarmshallbeadjustedtolessthanorequalto1.75times(1.75x)theexistingneutronflux(cps)atthefollowingfrequencies:a.Nosoonerthanonehalfhouraftershutdownandnolaterthan1houraftershutdown.b.Atleastonceperone-half(1/2)hourifthereactorhasbeenshutdown>0.5hourbut<2hoursc.Atleastonceperhourifthereactorhasbeenshutdown2hoursbut<10hours.d.Atleastonceper5hoursifthereactorhasbeenshutdown>10hoursbut<25hours.e.Atleastonceper24hoursifthereactorhasbeenshutdown25hoursbut<21days.f.Atleastonceper7days,ifthereactorhasbeenshutdown21days.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-15CYCLE20REVISION0 COLRTABLEIREQUIREDMONITORINGFREQUENCIESFORBACKUPBORONDILUTIONDETECTIONASAFUNCTIONOFOPERATINGCHARGINGPUMPSANDPLANTOPERATIONALMODESFORKeffGREATERTHAN0.98Keff>0.98OPERATIONALNumberofOperatingChargingPums*MODE0123312hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**412hoursOperationnotallowed**58hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSfilled58hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSpartiallydrained6Operationnotallowed***ChargingpumpOPERABILITYforanyperiodoftimeshallconstituteOPERABILITYfortheentiremonitoringfrequency.**Theprecludednumberofchargingpumpsshallbeverifiedtobeinoperablebyrackingouttheirmotorcircuitbreakers.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-15ACYCLE20REVISION0 COLRTABLE2REQUIREDMONITORINGFREQUENCIESFORBACKUPBORONDILUTIONDETECTIONASAFUNCTIONOFOPERATINGCHARGINGPUMPSANDPLANTOPERATIONALMODESFORKeffGREATERTHAN0.97ANDLESSTHANOREQUALTO0.980.98Kff>0.97OPERATIONALNumberofOperatingChargingPumps*MODE0123312hours2.0hours0.5hoursOperationnotallowed**412hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**58hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSfilled58hours0.5hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSpartiallydrained6Operationnotallowed***ChargingpumpOPERABILITYforanyperiodoftimeshallconstituteOPERABILITYfortheentiremonitoringfrequency.**Theprecludednumberofchargingpumpsshallbeverifiedtobeinoperablebyrackingouttheirmotorcircuitbreakers.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-15BCYCLE20REVISION0 COLRTABLE3REQUIREDMONITORINGFREQUENCIESFORBACKUPBORONDILUTIONDETECTIONASAFUNCTIONOFOPERATINGCHARGINGPUMPSANDPLANTOPERATIONALMODESFORKeffGREATERTHAN0.96ANDLESSTHANOREQUALTO0.970.97Kff>0.96OPERATIONALNumberofOperatincjCharcjingPumps*MODE0123312hours3.0hours1.25hours0.5hours412hours1.5hoursOperationnotallowed**58hours1.5hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSfilled58hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSpartiallydrained6Operationnotallowed***ChargingpumpOPERABILITYforanyperiodoftimeshallconstituteOPERABILITYfortheentiremonitoringfrequency.**Theprecludednumberofchargingpumpsshallbeverifiedtobeinoperablebyrackingouttheirmotorcircuitbreakers.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-15CCYCLE20REVISION0 COLRTABLE4REQUIREDMONITORINGFREQUENCIESFORBACKUPBORONDILUTIONDETECTIONASAFUNCTIONOFOPERATINGCHARGINGPUMPSANDPLANTOPERATIONALMODESFORKeffGREATERTHAN0.95ANDLESSTHANOREQUALTO0.96O.96Keff>O.9SOPERATIONALNumberofOperatingChargingPumps*MODE0123312hours4.0hours2.0hours1.0hours412hours2.25hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**58hours2.0hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSfilled58hours2.0hours0.5hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSpartiallydrained6Operationnotallowed***ChargingpumpOPERABILITYforanyperiodoftimeshallconstituteOPERABILITYfortheentiremonitoringfrequency.**Theprecludednumberofchargingpumpsshallbeverifiedtobeinoperablebyrackingouttheirmotorcircuitbreakers.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-15DCYCLE20REVISION0 COLRTABLE5REQUIREDMONITORINGFREQUENCIESFORBACKUPBORONDILUTIONDETECTIONASAFUNCTIONOFOPERATINGCHARGINGPUMPSANDPLANTOPERATIONALMODESFORKeffLESSTHANOREQUALTO0.95Keff0.95OPERATIONALNumberofOperatingChargingPums*MODE0123312hours5.0hours2.0hours1.0hours412hours2.75hours1.0hoursOperationnotallowed**58hours3.0hours1.0hours0.5hoursRCSfilled58hours2.5hours0.75hoursOperationnotallowed**RCSpartiallydrained624hours2.25hours0.5hoursOperationnotallowed***ChargingpumpOPERABILITYforanyperiodoftimeshallconstituteOPERABILITYfortheentiremonitoringfrequency.**Theprecludednumberofchargingpumpsshallbeverifiedtobeinoperablebyrackingouttheirmotorcircuitbreakers.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-15ECYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTMOVABLECONTROLASSEMBLIES-CEAPOSITION3.1.3.1.aWithoneCEAtrippablebutmisalignedfromanyotherCEAinitsgroupbymorethan19inches,operationinMODES1and2maycontinue,providedthatcorepowerisreducedinaccordancewithCOLRFigure3.3.1.3.1.bWithoneormoreCEAstrippablebutmisalignedfromanyotherCEAsinitsgroupbymorethan7inchesbutlessthanorequalto19inches,operationinMODES1and2maycontinue,providedthatcorepowerisreducedinaccordancewithCOLRFigure3.NOTES1.Item3.1.3.1.acorrespondswithACTION"c"ofTechnicalSpecification3.1.3.1.2.Item3.1.3.1.bcorrespondswithACTION"d"ofTechnicalSpecification3.1.3.1.WATERFORD3COLR3/41-18CYCLE20REVISION0 3000Ea,Ia)Ca200ta,Ea)U&#xa3;1504-UDa,IRequiredPowerReductionAfterSingleCEADeviation*TimeAfterCEADeviation(Minutes)COLRFigure3*Whenthermalpowerisreducedto60%ofratedthermalpowerperthislimitcurve,furtherreductionisnotrequiredbythisTechnicalSpecification.6000153045WATERFORD3COLR3/41-18ACYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTREGULATINGANDGROUPPCEAINSERTIONLIMITS3.1.3.6TheregulatingCEAgroupsandGroupPCEAsshallbelimitedtothewithdrawalsequenceandtotheinsertionlimitsshownonCOLRFigure4(regulatinggroups)andFigure5(GroupP).WATERFORD3COLR3/41-25CYCLE20REVISION0 RegulatingCEAGroupInsertionLimitsVersusThermalPower108"10090807060a)0D50Ea40.I-30201000-30IIGroup6Group503060906090120150RegulatingCEAGroupPosition(Inches)COLRFigure4120-J150WATERFORD3COLR3/41-25ACYCLE20REVISION0 GroupPCEAGroupInsertionLimitsVersusThermalPowerI00E0)I-80703010090108"120"605040201000153045607590105120135GroupPCEAGroupPosition(Inches)COLRFigure5150WATERFORD3COLR3/41-25BCYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTLINEARHEATRATE3.2.1Thelinearheatrateshallbemaintained:a.12.9kW!ftwhenCOLSSisinserviceb.13.2kW/ftwhenCOLSSisoutofserviceInaccordancewithTechnicalSpecification3.6.1.5Actiona,withtheminimumcontainmentaverageairtemperaturelessthan95&deg;Fbutgreaterthanorequalto90&deg;F,thelinearheatrateshallbemaintained:a.12.7kW/ftwhenCOLSSisinserviceb.13.0kW!ftwhenCOLSSisoutofserviceWATERFORD3COLR3/42-1CYCLE20REVISION0 COLRFigure6(NotUsed)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-lACYCLE20REVISION0 COLRFigure7(NotUsed)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-1BCYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTAZIMUTHALPOWERTILT-Tq32.3ThemeasuredAZIMUTHALPOWERTILTshallbemaintained0.03.WATERFORD3COLR3/42-4CYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTDNBRMARGIN3.2.4TheDNBRmarginshallbemaintainedbyoneofthefollowingmethods:a)WhenCOLSSisinserviceandneitherCEACisoperable:maintainCOLSScalculatedcorepowerlessthanorequaltoCOLSScalculatedcorepoweroperatinglimitbasedonDNBRdecreasedby13%RATEDTHERMALPOWER.b)WhenCOLSSisoutofserviceandatleastoneCEACisoperable:operatewithintheregionofacceptableoperationshownonCOLRFigure8(or8Aasappropriate),usinganyoperableCPCchannel.c)WhenCOLSSisoutofserviceandneitherCEACisoperable:operatewithintheregionofacceptableoperationshownonCOLRFigure9(or9Aasappropriate),usinganyoperableCPCchannel.NOTESThevariousDNBRlimitlinesshownbetweentheverticalASIlimitlinesat+/-0.12and+/-0.22onFigures8,8A,9,and9ArepresenttheminimumCPC-calculatedDNBRvaluerequiredforoperationinthepowerrangedisplayedintheareaaboveeachline.OperationatlowerpowerlevelsrequiresthatalargerDNBRvaluebemaintained.Forexample,withASIequalto-0.12andacorepowerof85%,CPCcalculatedDNBRmustbeaminimumof2.62withanyCEACOperable.At79%powerandthesameASIvaluewithanyCEACOperable,thecalculatedDNBRmustbeatleast3.12.At65%powerandthesameASIvalue,DNBRmustbeaminimumof4.28.At90%powerandanASIvalueof+0.08,DNBRmustbenolessthan2.37.2.TheverticalASIlimitlinesshownat+/-0.12and+/-0.22onFigures8,8A,9,and9AmaybeconsideredasextendingbeyondthemaximumDNBRvalueontheYaxisofthecharts.Therefore,whenmonitoringDNBRwiththesefigures,complianceisachievedatallpowerlevelsshownonagivenfigurewhenDNBRisgreaterthanthelargestDNBRvalueontheverticalscale.3.Figure8AisprovidedtoofferbetterresolutionforthefourpowerrangesinthelowerportionofFigure8.Figure9AisprovidedtoofferbetterresolutionforthefourpowerrangesinthelowerportionofFigure9.4.EquationsareprovidedonFigures8,8A,9,and9AtoassistindeterminingDNBRlimitsintheslopedportionsoftheplots.WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6CYCLE20REVISION0 zEEC)0C)CoreAverageASI(COLRFigure8)CYCLE20REVISION0AllowableDNBRwithAnyCEACOperable(COLSSOutofService)------Accptabie-Operation----20%SPowerS100%(-0.04,7.94)(-0.12,7.65)\1.50-0.3-0.2-0.10.00.10.20.3WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6A SubsetofAllowableDNBRwithAnyCEACOperable(COLSSOutofService)CoreAverageASI(COLRFigure8A)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6BCYCLE20REVISION0AcceptableOperation70%5PowerS100%=(1.400xAOl)+.2004.003.75-----F.-----3.50(+0.12,3.33)3.25(+0.03,3.33)(.0.12,3.12)cceptableOperation80%5Power100%zEEC.)0C.)4.003.753.503.253.002.752.502.252.001.751.50(.0.12,2.62)(.12,2.81)AcceptableOperation90%5PowerS100%DNBR=(0.750xASI)+2310(+0.08,2.37)(+0.12,2.37)(.0.12,2.22)AcceptableOperation(.0.12,2.04)(+0.12,2.17)ONBR=(O.5420ASI)*2.105UnacceptableOperation3.002.752.502.252.001.751.50-0.2-0.10.00.10.2 COLRFigure8.1(NotUsed)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-60CYCLE20REVISION0 COLRFigure8.IA(NotUsed)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6DCYCLE20REVISION0 IxzEEciaciAllowableDNBRwithNoCEAC(s)Operable(COLSSOutofService)AptbIeOpertiofl20%5Power50%20%SPower<50%(+0.15,7.94-_________(-0.04,7.94)(+0.12,7.94)---------(-0.12,7.65)-fl.,fi,,,,AcceptableOperation20%SPower5100%8.25=8.007.75-7.507.257.006.756.506,256.008.258.007.757.507.25___________loNeR=(3.778eASh+8001,j(+0.22,7.34)(-0.22,7.26)X+I)'AcceptableOperation50%5Power5100%CoreAverageASI(COLRFigure9)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6ECYCLE20REVISION0 WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6FCYCLE20REVIS!ON0(-0.12,5.28)SubsetofAllowableDNBRwithNoCEAC(s)Operable(COLSSOutofService)AcceptableOperation50%Power100%05,5.48)IDNBR=(2765xAS)*56191(+0.12,5.48)5.755.505.255.00flL_L.ejJLdLJIiJJtIdLIttIt-70%PowerS100%DNBR=(1.923xASI(*4.0915755.505.255.004.754.504.25E4.00CC-)a.3.75C.)3.503.253.002.752.502.254n1,4.11)(-0.12,3.86)(+0.12,4.11)AcceptableOperation90%5Power5100%1.254.003.753.503.253.002.752.502.25xASI(+2941(+0.12,3.00)(-0.12,2.80)l1176Acceptableoperati::(+07,2.79)(+012(-0.12,2.60)UnacceptableOperation-0.2-0.10.00.10.2CoreAverageASI(COLRFigure9A)
COLRFigure9.1(NotUsed)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6GCYCLE20REVISION0 COLRFigure9.IA(NotUsed)WATERFORD3COLR3/42-6HCYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTAXIALSHAPEINDEX3.2.7TheAXIALSHAPEINDEX(ASI)shallbemaintainedwithinthefollowinglimits:COLSSOperable-0.16ASIS+016forTHERMALPOWERS50%ofRATEDTHERMALPOWER-0.265ASP5+0.26forTHERMALPOWERSfrom20%to<50%ofRATEDTHERMALPOWERCOLSSOutofService-0.125ASI5+012forTHERMALPOWERS50%ofRATEDTHERMALPOWER-0.22ASI5+0.22forTHERMALPOWERSfrom20%to<50%ofRATEDTHERMALPOWERWATERFORD3COLR3/42-12CYCLE20REVISION0 COREOPERATINGLIMITSREPORTBORONCONCENTRATION3.9.1WhileinMode6,theRCSboronconcentrationshallbemaintainedsufficientlytoensurethatthemorerestrictiveofthefollowingreactivityconditionsismet:a.EitherKeffof0.95orless,orb.Aboronconcentrationofgreaterthanorequalto2050ppm.WATERFORD3COLR3/49-1CYCLE20REVISION0 III.METHODOLOGIESTheanalyticalmethodsusedtodeterminethecoreoperatinglimitslistedabovearethosepreviouslyreviewedandapprovedbytheNRCin:1."QualificationofthePHOENIX-P!ANCNuclearDesignSystemforPressurizedWaterReactorCores,"WCAP-11596-P-A,June1988;"ANC:AWestinghouseAdvancedNodalComputerCode,"WCAP-10965-P-A,September1986;and"ANC:AWestinghouseAdvancedNodalComputerCode:EnhancementstoANCRodPowerRecovery,"WCAP-10965-P-AAddendum1,April1989.(MethodologyforSpecifications3.1.1.1and3.1.1.2forShutdownMargins,3.1.1.3forMTC,3.1.3.6forRegulatingandGroupPCEAInsertionLimits,3.1.2.9BoronDilution(CalculationofCBCandIBW),and3.9.1BoronConcentration).2."C-EMethodforControlElementAssemblyEjectionAnalysis,"CENPD-190-A,Revision0,January1976.(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.3.6forRegulatingandGroupPCEAInsertionLimitsand3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTilt.)3."ModifiedStatisticalCombinationofUncertainties"CEN-356(V)-P-A,Revision1-P-A,May1988.(MethodologyforSpecification3.2.4.cand3.2.4.dforDNBRMarginand3.2.7forASI.)4."CalculativeMethodsfortheCELargeBreakLOCAEvaluationModelFortheAnalysisofC-EandWDesignedNSSS,"CENPD-132,Supplement3-P-A,June1985.(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTiltand3.2.7forASI.)5."CalculativeMethodsfortheABBCESmallBreakLOCAEvaluationModel,"CENPD-137-P,August1974;Supplement2-P-A,April1998.(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTiltand3.2.7forASI.)6."TechnicalDescriptionManualfortheCENTSCode,"WCAP-15996-P-A,Revision1,March2005.(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.1and3.1.1.2forShutdownMargins,3.1.1.3forMTC,3.1.3.1forMovableControlAssemblies-CEAPosition,3.1.3.6forRegulatingandGroupPCEAInsertionLimits,and3.2.4.bforDNBRMargin)WATERFORD3Page38CYCLE20REVISION0 7."ImplementationofZIRLOMaterialCladdinginCENuclearPowerFuelAssemblyDesigns,"CENPD-404-P-A,November2001.(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTilt,and3.2.7forASI).8."QualificationoftheTwo-DimensionalTransportCodePARAGON,"WCAP16045-P-A,August2004.(MethodologyforSpecifications3.1.1.1and3.1.1.2forShutdownMargins,3.1.1.3forMTC,3.1.3.6forRegulatingandGroupPCEAInsertionLimits,3.1.2.9BoronDilution(CalculationofCBC&IBW),3.2.4.bforDNBRMarginand3.9.1BoronConcentration).9."ImplementationofZirconiumDiborideBurnableAbsorberCoatingsinCENuclearPowerFuelAssemblyDesigns,"WCAP-16072-P-A,Revision0,August2004(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTilt,and3.2.7forASI).10."CE16x16NextGenerationFuelCoreReferenceReport,"WCAP-16500-PandFinalSafetyEvaluationforWestinghouseElectricCompany(Westinghouse)TopicalReport(TR)WCAP-16500-P,Revision0,"CE[CombustionEngineering]16x16NextGenerationFuel[(NGF)]CoreReferenceReport,"(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTilt,3.2.4.b,3.2.4.c,and3.2.4.dforDNBRMargin,and3.2.7forASI).11."OptimizedZIRLOTM,"WCAP-12610-P-AandCENPD-404-P-AAddendum1-A,July2006.(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTilt,and3.2.7forASI.)12."WestinghouseCorrelationsWSSVandWSSV-TforPredictingCriticalHeatFluxinRodBundleswithSide-SupportedMixingVanes,"WCAP-16523-P-ARevision0,August2007;andFinalSafetyEvaluationforWestinghouseElectricCompany(Westinghouse)TopicalReport(TR),WCAP-16523-P,"WestinghouseCorrelationsWSSVandWSSV-TforPredictingCriticalHeatFluxinRodBundleswithSide-SupportedMixingVanes,"(MethodologyforSpecification3.2.4.b,3.2.4.c,and3.2.4.dforDNBRMargin.)13."ABBCriticalHeatFluxCorrelationsforPWRFuel,"CENPD-387-P-ARevision0,May2000.(MethodologyforSpecification3.2.4.b,3.2.4.c,and3.2.4.dforDNBRMarginand3.2.7forASI.)WATERFORD3Page39CYCLE20REVISION0 14."CalculativeMethodsfortheCENuclearPowerLargeBreakLOCAEvaluationModel-Improvementto1999LargeBreakLOCAEMSteamCoolingModelforLessThan1in/secCoreReflood"CENPD-132,Supplement4-P-A,Addendum1-PandFinalSafetyEvaluationforWestinghouseElectricCompany(Westinghouse)TopicalReport(TR)CENPD-132Supplement4-P-A,Addendum1-P,"CalculativeMethodsfortheCE[CombustionEngineering]NuclearPowerLargeBreakLOCAEvaluationModel-Improvementto1999LargeBreakLOCAEMSteamCoolingModelforLessThan1in/secCoreReflood,"(MethodologyforSpecification3.1.1.3forMTC,3.2.1forLinearHeatRate,3.2.3forAzimuthalPowerTilt,and3.2.7forASI).15."ApplicationofCESetpointMethodologyforCE16x16NextGenerationFuel(NGF),"WCAP16500P-A,Supplement1,Revision1,December2010.(MethodologyforSpecification3.2.4.b,3.2.4.c,and3.2.4.dforDNBRMargin.)WATERFORD3Page40CYCLE20REVISION0}}

Latest revision as of 01:59, 19 August 2019

Redirect to:

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML14132A130&oldid=1879998"