ML19329F620: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:.__
{{#Wiki_filter:,
  'e m .  .
'e m.
      'j Y-       ..
'j Y-
              ,; ;--- r. ,               . , ,  }.y .       .a.   . ..                  +-                                    -                                            . . -
,; ;--- r.,
                                                    , ( Q **F                                                               ,    y               . d H. 8,*           .
}.y.
.a.
+-
, ( Q **F y
d H. 8,* : -
FiCDF.rtAL PC.n 's COMI.1:0310 !
FiCDF.rtAL PC.n 's COMI.1:0310 !
W/.:mt:4nro:4. D.C. 201'G IN ferrt.Y T43.FCft tot                                                   .
W/.:mt:4nro:4. D.C.
Fall-Ei; I .'                         gy ?.
201'G IN ferrt.Y T43.FCft tot Fall-Ei; I.'
c ~ s ~s Mr. J im ter R(f.cra                                                       i....
gy ?.
                                                                                                                      ~
I (o
                                                                                                                            .'o
~
                                                                                                                            ;            c         .
c ~ s ~s Mr. J im ter R(f.cra i...
I (o s
.'o c
Director,'1)!vinica of Radiological                                       u. # "~                       L '' ' ; 0 ,'.i and Envirou.tcuI:1 Pretcction                                           gr s .. ..       ,
s Director,'1)!vinica of Radiological
                                                                                                                                            ;*", C 3                 ,,.- .
: u. # "~
U. S . At. r; e 1:aer;;-f Coctrii s r. ion                                 v-     !              c.*         t-         ''*/
L '' ' ; 0,'.i and Envirou.tcuI:1 Pretcction gr s....
W'*'                                                    ' '''''#
;*", C 3 U. S. At. r; e 1:aer;;-f Coctrii s r. ion v-c.*
t a:,hington, D. C.         20545
t-
''*/
t a:,hington, D. C.
20545 W ' * '


==Dear Mr. Rop,==
==Dear Mr. Rop,==
Line 40: Line 47:
This is in respouse to your 1ctter of Ja.w.ary 7, ll)72, requenting, th co:aacnts of the Pcdcral Pouer. C<c,xnist ica on t.hc M.C'r. Draf t Detailed Siate:neut on Envircar..cntal Con..iderations Related La th.: Propoced I;.suance of a Construction Permi.t to the Consuucr:. Po..*cr Co.4pany for the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2.
This is in respouse to your 1ctter of Ja.w.ary 7, ll)72, requenting, th co:aacnts of the Pcdcral Pouer. C<c,xnist ica on t.hc M.C'r. Draf t Detailed Siate:neut on Envircar..cntal Con..iderations Related La th.: Propoced I;.suance of a Construction Permi.t to the Consuucr:. Po..*cr Co.4pany for the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2.
The encivned staf C repos.t prepared by the Connicsion's Murcan of Pouer evaluates the ;:etter neeris to be served by the facility; the availability of replacc :aut power fro.t others, if any; and the costs of such replacemaat poucr.
The encivned staf C repos.t prepared by the Connicsion's Murcan of Pouer evaluates the ;:etter neeris to be served by the facility; the availability of replacc :aut power fro.t others, if any; and the costs of such replacemaat poucr.
The report ille:strates the need for the :-;i.dlend Units 1 cud .
The report ille:strates the need for the :-;i.dlend Units 1 cud.
                            - 2 to provide an additional 1,301 : ecavatts of capacity for macting peak loads in years 1977 and 1978 on the Applicant's system and t.hc Michigan Pir.icr Pool which includes the Applicant.                                   ,,
- 2 to provide an additional 1,301 : ecavatts of capacity for macting peak loads in years 1977 and 1978 on the Applicant's system and t.hc Michigan Pir.icr Pool which includes the Applicant.
Very truly yours, n       ..    !*
Very truly yours, n
f **,    )';&,N /;k. * *.ast'*
)';&
,N /;k. * *.ast'*
f **,
gfj T. A. Phillips
gfj T. A. Phillips
                                                                                                                                                        - c.
- c.
                                                                  ,>      Chief, Eureau of Pouer                                     s,         .l. .I.'.l(/ ,-
Chief, Eureau of Pouer s,
                                                                                                                          ..e       ,-                      .,              y.
.l..I.'.l(/,-
Enclosurc                                                                             IQ,, .%' .. .                                                 ,-
..e y.
Staff report on the                                                               7                                                              ~
Enclosurc IQ,,.%'...
: c. i .b . .
~
Midicad Plant, Units                                                             ! *.i.    ! ,f. . , <. /-
7 Staff report on the
1 and 2                                                                         a H{             *.-~ 7' t, ::s                  s- 4 ',<.,,j< ; .
! *.i.,f c. i.b..
                                                                                                                            -\       -
Midicad Plant, Units
                                                                                                                                                        ,          w              a w;Q'. . ,.* .- .
<. /-
                                                                                                                                                                              +.
1 and 2 a H{
,                                                                                                                              #      N.                                 .          t
* ~ 7' 4 ',<.,,j< ;.
                                                                                                                                                ..          ..                    l l
t, ::s s-
                                                                                                    .                            / s'd
-\\
                                                                                                                                      /, 't' ;1 *. .s,it       . . ..              l-8007080                                                                                                                                 'Mi
w;Q'..,. -
                                                                                                                                                                  .; . .j
+.
                                                        .                                                                                                                          ;
w a
N.
t
/ /, 't ;1 *..s,it.
l l
s'd '
8007080
'Mi
.;..j


                                                                                                                                                      .~     t--**-*''**
.~
        '          f.   ^%.
t--**-*''**
                                                          '                                      ,.                    s:*          .- .
s:*
1                                   '
f.
                                                                                                                    /:                         *
^%.
                                                                                                              /b-
1
                                                                                                            .l.. . s... -,
/:
* r
/b-l.
                                                                                                            .f.. g.-
.f.. g.-
t..... .                    ? , .>                 .-
s.
PE1EilAh PtMER CO:';tISSION
r t.....
                                                                                                            \t U. . /.s
?,.>..'s ff
                                                                                                                                                  ..'s        ,      ff kh         ' /./ .                           /s;/
\\t U.
k./ ),
. /.
s.m ''           --
s PE1EilAh PtMER CO:';tISSION kh ' /./.
liUREAU OF FCUCR                                                              . ' - */
/s;/
                                                                                                                        ~R{ . _ , ( C. (W Report on the Midland Pinut Units No. 1 and No. 2                                           --
k./ ), '' - -
in Rulation to Pcr/cr !!cedo of Consuncrs Po::cr Co r.pany cnd the Nichi;u.a Poucr Pool O.. .Tanuncy 7,15//2, the Direct.c. , Divicion ' of nn liolen'icci ar.d
. ' - */
                          ):nviro:r.:: ate.1 Pcetret ion, U. S. Ato.iic Energy Cor.r.insion rer;vc::ted the cc:. wen t <
liUREAU OF FCUCR
of t he Pede.:r.1 Power Cc:s.:i::nica on AEC's Drnft Dctciiud State-ucnt on KuvJ ron..:2nt al Con:.iderations Rclated to the P: opot.cd Insucnce of a Constre.ction Perr.dt to the Consu:.. crc Powcr Coa.peny for th5 Midland Plnnt, Unit           1 and 2.
~R{. _, ( C. (W s.m Report on the Midland Pinut Units No. 1 and No. 2 in Rulation to Pcr/cr !!cedo of Consuncrs Po::cr Co r.pany cnd the Nichi;u.a Poucr Pool O...Tanuncy 7,15//2, the Direct.c., Divicion ' of nn liolen'icci ar.d
These cot:.1.:nt: update thou nubmitted by the Peacral Po.7cr Conraission on Sept.;cher 23, 1970. We u..dny:t.m::1 froa cas.licr cc,rrccpondence cud enviro::cattal docmranta filed by the Applicant thct the environr: ntal c:.pectn of i:hir, picnc : rc currently underp,oi.ng suppler sacal analysin in which tho M;C viches to considcc such fcetors as: the offect of delnya                                                                     ,
):nviro:r.:: ate.1 Pcetret ion, U. S. Ato.iic Energy Cor.r.insion rer;vc::ted the of t he Pede.:r.1 Power Cc:s.:i::nica on AEC's Drnft Dctciiud State-cc:. wen t <
in facilit.y operction upoa                 '
ucnt on KuvJ ron..:2nt al Con:.iderations Rclated to the P: opot.cd Insucnce of a Constre.ction Perr.dt to the Consu:.. crc Powcr Coa.peny for th5 Midland Plnnt, Unit 1 and 2.
i necdu to be nerved by the
These cot:.1.:nt: update thou nubmitted by the Peacral Po.7cr Conraission on Sept.;cher 23, 1970. We u..dny:t.m::1 froa cas.licr cc,rrccpondence cud enviro::cattal docmranta filed by the Applicant thct the environr: ntal c:.pectn of i:hir, picnc : rc currently underp,oi.ng suppler sacal analysin in which tho M;C viches to considcc such fcetors as:
                                                                          ~"d ic int erent, particularly the pc icr
the offect of delnya in facilit.y operction upoa
                                                                            ,, the cynilability of citernativa i                       acurece, if cuy, to :nct
~"d ic int erent, particularly the pc icr i
                                                                      .a der.'anda .on c tiraely baci.s ; and delay
necdu to be nerved by the
{t costs to th: 1.icensec cud to couruit.cra. Thus, our cea=:.:ats cro directed to -th: i.c po!ntn in a rci/ica of the need for tha ft.cility cs conce:ra the
,, the cynilability of citernativa i
  '                      cdequacy end relivbilJ ty of the Appliccut'c clectric sy:: tem can tha
acurece, if cuy, to :nct
                      -Michi;'.cn Pc.:er. Pcel, e cubrec,ioa of the E::ct Central Area heliability Cevucil O: CAR) of which the Applicant is a :.nr.hcr. This is in cecordt.nec
.a der.'anda.on c tiraely baci.s ; and delay
                      .with tb %tional Enviro:wcatal Policy Act of ;969 and the Guidelinc                                               of the Pre 3id nt's Cocncil on Environ:.: ental Canlit.y dcted April 23, 1971.
{
                                -lu propering this report, t$c Burcou of Pciter st.cff has considered the AEC's Dccit Datailed St.ctement.; .the Applict.nt's Enviro:nr.cutal Report and Sup;>1euent thereto; the Monthly Pcaer State::ents cuh:nitted to this Comincion by th? Applicant; ralcted reports t.. ado in response to the Cor.r iu::iva's Sectccient of. Policy n Adequocy cad Rc1!.chility of Electric Service (Order no. 383-2); cod the FPC stcff's indcpendent analysis of thcse docu::.: uts together uith related infornetion from. other FPC reports.
costs to th: 1.icensec cud to couruit.cra. Thus, our cea=:.:ats cro directed to -th i.c po!ntn in a rci/ica of the need for tha ft.cility cs conce:ra the t
y!eed for th' Pacilition The l11d'hmd Plcnt vill have tuo units. The 486-mencurtt Unit 1 is schet'uled for co:rcrercial service in early 1977, and the 815-megavatt Unit 2 it. reheduled for co::::cretal service in ently 1970. In additioa to :the plant. 's 'ulectric~ out.put, the Midicud Plant is decinned to furnish 4,050,0'"i Cu.pc. v.            ent'.c per l. cup of precces sec..:.: for cel.. to the Dz Ci n-d e..1                                                   ^
cdequacy end relivbilJ ty of the Appliccut'c clectric sy:: tem can tha
                -~
-Michi;'.cn Pc.:er. Pcel, e cubrec,ioa of the E::ct Central Area heliability Cevucil O: CAR) of which the Applicant is a :.nr.hcr.
This is in cecordt.nec
.with tb %tional Enviro:wcatal Policy Act of ;969 and the Guidelinc of the Pre 3id nt's Cocncil on Environ:.: ental Canlit.y dcted April 23, 1971.
-lu propering this report, t$c Burcou of Pciter st.cff has considered the AEC's Dccit Datailed St.ctement.;.the Applict.nt's Enviro:nr.cutal Report and Sup;>1euent thereto; the Monthly Pcaer State::ents cuh:nitted to this Comincion by th? Applicant; ralcted reports t.. ado in response to the Cor.r iu::iva's Sectccient of. Policy n Adequocy cad Rc1!.chility of Electric Service (Order no. 383-2); cod the FPC stcff's indcpendent analysis of thcse docu::.: uts together uith related infornetion from. other FPC reports.
y!eed for th' Pacilition The l11d'hmd Plcnt vill have tuo units.
The 486-mencurtt Unit 1 is schet'uled for co:rcrercial service in early 1977, and the 815-megavatt Unit 2 it. reheduled for co::::cretal service in ently 1970.
In additioa to :the plant. 's 'ulectric~ out.put, the Midicud Plant is decinned to furnish 4,050,0'"i ent'.c per l. cup of precces sec..:.: for cel.. to the Dz Ci n-d e..1
^
Cu.pc. v.
-~
s =py c t,. c.
s =py c t,. c.
* P
P
                                                                                            ,                  ..                                              ' ~ " "
' ~ " "


F
F n.
                                                ,                                                n.
,s
    ,s   $,.*                                      '
. 'ibe fulle..-l.y: tahals: tion t,0<.t t h.: c h.c t ri: :,yr t:.a loads t o be rect. e? by..;:e / ppl icct.t sat.1 th Ilichir, n Po.fer Pe:.1 'a chici tim. / ppliccat in a i.2./,er, na,! the reic: Je:h i" of t!'a ch.c'. j e c 1 o.n.put of the l' idle.nd O
                                                                                                          'ibe fulle..-l.y: tahals: tion t,0<.t t h.: c h.c t ri: :,yr t:.a loads t o be rect . e? by ..;:e / ppl icct.t sat.1 th Ilichir, n Po.fer Pe:.1 'a chici tim. / ppliccat in a i.2./,er, na,! the reic:
smit, to t he.
smit , to t he .
:.r.. ele z er erv.: c r.pr.cif ics on f.L<. trint r.v pc Af uy- /.p;ilicat 's v ed L.. :.or: :: c -p.,
Je:h i" of t!'a ch.c' . jOe c 1 o.n.put of the l' idle.nd
;ic..,, heal 's.;yr. tc..a t t th:. tit. : of t ive i t'77 rw 2:c, the 1977-7D s nt.r, th: M7G ctu.
:.r.. ele z er erv.: c r.pr.cif ics on f.L<. trint r.v pc Af uy- /.p;ilicat 's v ed L .. :.or: :: c -p., ;ic..,,
r. n : thc.17/ r:-79 t:Ir.t ne pet.h per ioh. The Co.u.on. ra P.. er Cte.;p. r.y.:nri Detroit Ed!r.ca Cr ronic co;.. rite Ll.c Michigen Pc.cr Po..).
1977-7D s nt.r, th: M7G ctu.
fr.c per ': lor d p rio::s unntioned i:rc t ha ca.t!.cipated initit 1 rcryice pcrieda of the n c.r unit.s, but tha lif:n of t' 2 6:cita 1:; c::pected to r
heal 's .;yr. tc..a t t th:. tit. : of t ive i t'77 rw 2:c , the Co.u.on . ra P..
be son. 3's yera er t are, :.cd t hey cec c::pecte/. ta ec.'.t.itut e a pro-per t. i oac.1 p ;r t ot the Applictr.t ', : ';t a l i.e.no/n tin c:.pc. cit'/ throur,hout thc.t p: r. 9d.
r . n : thc.17/ r:-79 t:Ir.t ne pet.h per ioh. The er   Cte   .;p. r.y .:nri Pc.cr Po..). fr.c per ': lor d p rio::s unntioned Detroit  Ed!r.ca Cr ronic co;. . rite Ll.c Michigen i:rc t ha ca.t!.cipated initit 1 rcryice pcrieda of the n c.r unit.s, but tha lif:n of t' 2r 6:cita 1:; c::pected to be son. 3's yera er t are, :.cd t hey cec c::pecte/. ta ec.'.t.itut e a pro-per t. i oac.1 p ;r t         ot the Applictr.t ' , : ';t a l i.e.no/n tin c:.pc. cit'/ throur,hout thc.t p: r. 9d.
Therefore, t hey vili ha depended um,a tra cupply pct. c.r to utect future deconds ovct : p;:riod of..nay yci.rn 14.ycud t he initial service need:s diceusscJ in this r;,pos:t.
Therefore, t hey vili ha depended um,a tra cupply pct. c.r to utect future deconds ovct : p;:riod of ..nay yci.rn 14.ycud t he initial service need:s diceusscJ in this r;,pos:t.
1977 Stur. r Per.h I.oed Peric d Censur. Orc Detroit Michigan Pt.? cr
1977 Stur. r Per.h I.oed Peric d Censur. Orc         Detroit         Michigan Pt .? cr             }:dison         Pu.te r Com.nny
}:dison Pu.te r Com.nny
                                                                                      - ~ . _              .C_o_r_.,ne n y Pool     '
.C_o_r_.,ne n y Pool
With MJdi:nJ bait ?!o . 1 (l. !:r. e c.. r..e t : ::)
- ~. _
::et 0.'; end:.u l t C:.;r city, Megtuctts                       7,635               10,702 Peck 1.ual,1:q;: vat t                                                                               18,417 5, (. . (;1/           8,7402./
With MJdi:nJ bait ?!o. 1 (l. !:r. e.. r..e t : ::)
Mer.er v:. M .rgi n, l''ac. a t t ,
c
14,3503 /
::et 0.'; end:.u l t C:.;r city, Megtuctts 7,635 10,702 18,417 Peck 1.ual,1:q;: vat t 5, (.. (;1/
2,025                 2,042         4,067 Kesetvc P. rgit., hrecnt of Pcah Locd                             35.1                 23.4           26.3 Witheat r.;dland Unit ?!a. 1
8,7402./
_ (4cp M- e..rts)
14,350 /
Met Dept.nciable C.>pccity, M cc.iatts                           7,149 Peck Load,1:,ccustts                                                               10,782            17,931 5,6101/               8,7402,/               3 Recerve Mar,:ia, W3 mntts                                       1,539 34,339,,,/
3 Mer.er v:. M.rgi n, l''ac. a t t,
Reserve Margin, Percent of Ped: Lo: d                                                 2 ,0',2        3,581 27.4                   23.4           25.0 1/ liteib' .; uct ?.a l e s O f 50 L;0,S,s.t/t t t s .
2,025 2,042 4,067 Kesetvc P. rgit., hrecnt of Pcah Locd 35.1 23.4 26.3 Witheat r.;dland Unit ?!a. 1
2,/ Re< uced by not purchases CO,'i ti:2.e.uta t t s .
_ (4cp M-e..rts)
Met Dept.nciable C.>pccity, M cc.iatts 7,149 10,782 17,931 Peck Load,1:,ccustts 5,6101/
8,740,/
34,339,,,/
2 3
Recerve Mar,:ia, W mntts 3
1,539 2,0',2 3,581 Reserve Margin, Percent of Ped: Lo: d 27.4 23.4 25.0 1/ liteib'.; uct ?.a l e s O f 50 L;0,S,s.t/t t t s.
2,/ Re< uced by not purchases CO,'i ti:2.e.uta t t s.
1/ Keduced by net purchases 555 tre;suctts.
1/ Keduced by net purchases 555 tre;suctts.
                                                                                                                                        -l 9
-l 9
l l
l 9
9


            . q   . '          .              - . - - . . . -                            . . . .              . . . . . ,          . . .  ~ . . . .          .
q
4                                               .
~....
                                                                                .                                                          A           "-
4 A
3
3
      ^
^
1977-741 \!!r.tw. Penh Pe~ !od f                                                                                                                         -
1977-741 \\!!r.tw. Penh Pe~ !od f
Consu:c::m           D stroit       1:irchigem Power                 1;dicoa         Po or             <
Consu:c::m D stroit 1:irchigem Power 1;dicoa Po or C owu:n.}
C owu:n.}             C ria.newf   ~  =-Pool I
C ria.newf
l!.I ( h Mid1 a.i l U.. 2.t ::o. 1                                                                   .              ,
=-Pool
(41:6 ::~.,c ::..:' :) -_         .
~
                                        !!e t -ikpenda.,)e C.' . . city, ::agmia tto                                               7,635               10,762         18,417 Pech 1. cad, ::, c. .u.t.; a                                                               5,6401/                 8,325       14,1651/
I l!.I ( h Mid1 a.i l U.. 2.t ::o. 1 (41:6 ::~.,c ::..:' :) -_
R c :.c rv. Mar:31n, ;:wm:tts                                                               1,795                 2,457           4,252 1:cacrve Ihrcin,1:. recut of l'er.k Lord                                                     30,7                   29.5         '30.0 1?ithout Midlend ihit No. I (s y.s. s   ....,.. , . . . t. ...s,,.,_,
!!e t -ikpenda.,)e C.'.. city, ::agmia tto 7,635 10,762 18,417 Pech 1. cad, ::, c..u.t.; a 5,6401/
                                                                        .      ..r                                                                                                    -
8,325 14,1651/
9                     .
R c :.c rv. Mar:31n, ;:wm:tts 1,795 2,457 4,252 1:cacrve Ihrcin,1:. recut of l'er.k Lord 30,7 29.5
Het D.:pa.idchle C:preity, 'Med. watts                                                       7 , 14 9           10,702           17,931 Pech Lo .d, ::.w..trtu:                                                                     5,84 01j              8,325         14,1651/
'30.0 1?ithout Midlend ihit No. I (s y.s. s.,..,... t... r
Re:wrve Ibegin, :: .: c.. tac ts.                                                           1,309                 2,457           3,766 Rest.rve bre.in, l'orcent of Per.h Lot.d                                                     22.4                   29.5           26.6 a
...s,,.,_,
9 Het D.:pa.idchle C:preity, 'Med. watts 7, 14 9 10,702 17,931 1j Pech Lo.d, ::.w..trtu:
5,84 0 8,325 14,1651/
Re:wrve Ibegin, ::.: c.. tac ts.
1,309 2,457 3,766 Rest.rve bre.in, l'orcent of Per.h Lot.d 22.4 29.5 26.6 a
71ucludes n :t cc.lce of 50 u23cesets.
71ucludes n :t cc.lce of 50 u23cesets.
l
l
;                                          ,i     .                                          -1978 Sur.-:.cr Peak 1. cad Period .          - - -
,i 1978 Sur.-:.cr Peak 1. cad Period Concuir.crs D:t roit.
Concuir.crs         D:t roit.       Michigen Pea.ic r             I:dicon         Pc.icr Cor;1gny             Cor nen /       Pool liit:a 1:1<114 ad Uni tt Nos. 1 & 2
Michigen Pea.ic r I:dicon Pc.icr Cor;1gny Cor nen /
_ Q ,30) r .ar. .-t t:0                                                               -
Pool liit:a 1:1<114 ad Uni tt Nos. 1 & 2
Net De. pend: bic Cepecity, Megatacts                                                                           10,762          19,?32 l
_ Q,30) r.ar..-t t:0 Net De. pend: bic Cepecity, Megatacts Peck Lond, Mc3c,1ctts 8,450,/
Peck Lond, Mc3c,1ctts                                                                       8,450,/
10,762 19,?32 6,451:
6,451:               8,93C3j       15,381Af Receeve Marrin, Pg:..eatts                                                                 1,999                 1,052           3,851 i
8,93C3j 15,381Af l
Reserve :::rLin, Percent of Peak Load                                                         31.0                   20.7 i                                                                                                                                                                            25.0 liithcot Mt.dlcud Units I:os. 1 & 2                                                                                                     *
Receeve Marrin, Pg:..eatts 1,999 1,052 3,851 i
( 1,3 01_ .m.       ..  .: ra t M..
Reserve :::rLin, Percent of Peak Load 31.0 20.7 25.0 i
Nei: D.*pendabla Cc;.acit y, Megmretts                                                       7,149               10,702           17,931 l
liithcot Mt.dlcud Units I:os. 1 & 2
'                                      Penh 1.osd, Mo.;.aw; tu                                                                     6,451?:/             8,9303 /       15,381N Her.erve 1: art:in, F .gu.er.tts                                                               698               1,052 2,550 neserve 1hrcin, Percent of Pat.k Load                                                         10.8                   20.7           16.6 Applicant's Stot ed Mceded Reserve M uatt . (18 percent of paah lor.d)lI ega- 1,161                                                                   1,607           2,763 Her.erve Defleicacy, M<.;;:.we.tts                                                             463                         _        218
( 1,3 01_.m..: ra t M..
                                      .gf . . .. .; 3.     ;-     . ..    .
Nei: D.*pendabla Cc;.acit y, Megmretts 7,149 10,702 17,931 l
                                                                                            .      ; . .a e c. i t.: .: . e ser t ;. W K,purcca.: of par k lor.d r.. ce:,;s..ry to. .i. st.::n adequcto aya ter.: relichili;y.
Penh 1.osd, Mo.;.aw; tu 6,451?:/
2 / 1scludc.a act r.aica of.4813 ccchatta.                                                                                 :                            '
8,930 /
S / 1.e::uc ed Ly ' net purcht.sen 1.125 rr 3ge;;atta.                                                                                         -        ,
15,381N 3
Her.erve 1: art:in, F.gu.er.tts 698 1,052 2,550 neserve 1hrcin, Percent of Pat.k Load 10.8 20.7 16.6 Applicant's Stot ed Mceded Reserve M uatt. (18 percent of paah lor.d)lI ega-1,161 1,607 2,763 Her.erve Defleicacy, M<.;;:.we.tts 463 218
.gf.....; 3. ; -
;..a e c. i t.:.:. e ser t ;. W K,purcca.: of par k lor.d r.. ce:,;s..ry to..i. st.::n adequcto aya ter.: relichili;y.
2 / 1scludc.a act r.aica of.4813 ccchatta.
S / 1.e::uc ed Ly ' net purcht.sen 1.125 rr 3ge;;atta.
t
}//1; educed by uct purchor;co 644 taesonitta.
t
t
                                      }//1; t        educed by uct purchor;co 644 taesonitta.                                                            ,


                        . ~ -
,c
                                                                                                                                          .      ,c
. ~ -
: s. .
: s..
: a. .                                .R                                                r l
: a..
                                                                                          ,4-                                  . .
.R r
l                  -
l':78-79 U ini er P: .th Pt rir 1 Conanacrs        Datroit        Ifichigan Po'er            Edir.on        Pe.tcr
!                                                                                                .c.c..m.e,s e n y C w.v.e v      Pool Ilit h ::idien 1 Uoita ::on. IL 6 2 i
f1.W. ?.t.        .rc t i r,)
j                                                                          ,
l                                      liet Depc .d ble Crpmicy, Mc3.,ratts                          8,450        10,782        19,232 Pen 1.ond , Lr.r.rr t rv                                      6,6911/      8,835          15,5261/
nencava :::qdn, M a . rates                                    1,759        1,947          3,706 Re.terve 1.rirgin, Petcent of Peak Lot.d 26.3          2230          23.9
!                                      Without M:dler..I linite Nos. 1&2                                                                          '
l
l
                                            -,301 (1       : * :r ::.t t d
,4-l l':78-79 U ini er P:.th Pt rir 1 Conanacrs Datroit Ifichigan Po'er Edir.on Pe.tcr
* l                                      i;ct D:pendabic Cepecity, Megnv Ltc                           7 ,149       10,782         17,931 l                                       Pe t.h t wd , 1:e3.wo t t :                                   6,6911/       0,835         15.5201/
.c.c..e,s e n y C w.v.e v Pool
!                                      Reacrve it rnin, lin.: actto                                     450       1,947           2,405 l
.m Ilit h ::idien 1 Uoita ::on. IL 6 2 f1.W. ?.t.
\
.rc t i r,)
necorve 1:4r;.in, Percent of Pe.:h Load                           6.8         22.0           15.0~
i j
Applier:nt ':, Statut li.'edc d Re:; cree, Maga-er.t t: (10 pcrecut <.f pcnh lodd)                           1,204         1,590         2,795 lu cerve 1:criciency, M ;nwart;                                   746         --
l liet Depc.d ble Crpmicy, Mc3.,ratts 8,450 10,782 19,232 Pen 1.ond, Lr.r.rr t rv 6,6911/
390 t
8,835 15,5261/
1/ Includes nat 8aled of 4S1 2.n;:cwatts.
nencava :::qdn, M a. rates 1,759 1,947 3,706 Re.terve 1.rirgin, Petcent of Peak Lot.d 26.3 2230 23.9 Without M:dler..I linite Nos. 1&2 l
The ndeeuacy' cad reliebility of the Applicent't. cyctem and tha Detroit Ed;; on Cr,.g. cay's systo.., sihich corprisc. th' Mich.' gen Pcr.?cr Pool l
(1
are increct.ingly depandent uten the tir.oly cad conti:v.ed operation of luene i.ccl.a.;r units. The 3,.'.50 :.ge. stts of cepecity the Applicent pit.n; to have in cparation to ::cet the 1978-79 winter pcck includei
-,301 : * :r ::.t t d l
;                                      the tuo liidland units, totaling 1,'301 :q;x.rctts , and the 700-m3cuate Pal;r:ndos eni:..
i;ct D:pendabic Cepecity, Megnv Ltc 7,149 10,782 17,931 l
The 2,00.1 ::: ;uicces., of capacity of these three units reprer.c nt. 73.7 Parcent of tha Applicant's gencrctfng capacity. Ecccuse               '
Pe t.h t wd, 1:e3.wo t t :
of th: reint ive efficiencies cad econo::lic; of sce.lc in the' oporation of . thene .1e rgo unitn , it '.reuld n:t h; nc.ren.1 to c::pec t these units to-be schede;cd o.:t -oi-curvice for roatinq or norr.acl r.s.intenanco during t hace p.rlods, enartcquently the for:ced .outa3e of .ny of these units durin:: th.nc periods han a p; oportionally 1.:rco effcet upon the system's ths.lity to wit.hntand second or third con:.Juc.encics. '.Jhc 31.0 percent (1,9t'9 mg.r.inttc) reserve margin the Applicant indic sten for the 1973 nuatur pech is cc...pletely vested in the .two Midiat.d units and the Palisades unit.
6,6911/
0,835 15.5201/
Reacrve it rnin, lin.: actto 450 1,947 2,405 l
necorve 1:4r;.in, Percent of Pe.:h Load 6.8 22.0 15.0~
\\
Applier:nt ':, Statut li.'edc d Re:; cree, Maga-er.t t: (10 pcrecut
<.f pcnh lodd) 1,204 1,590 2,795 lu cerve 1:criciency, M ;nwart; 746 390 1/ Includes nat 8aled of 4S1 2.n;:cwatts.
t The ndeeuacy' cad reliebility of the Applicent't. cyctem and tha Detroit Ed;; on Cr,.g. cay's systo.., sihich corprisc. th' Mich.' gen Pcr.?cr Pool l
are increct.ingly depandent uten the tir.oly cad conti:v.ed operation of luene i.ccl.a.;r units. The 3,.'.50 :.ge. stts of cepecity the Applicent pit.n; to have in cparation to ::cet the 1978-79 winter pcck includei the tuo liidland units, totaling 1,'301 :q;x.rctts, and the 700-m3cuate Pal;r:ndos eni:..
The 2,00.1 ::: ;uicces., of capacity of these three units reprer.c nt. 73.7 Parcent of tha Applicant's gencrctfng capacity.
Ecccuse of th: reint ive efficiencies cad econo::lic; of sce.lc in the' oporation of. thene.1e rgo unitn, it '.reuld n:t h; nc.ren.1 to c::pec t these units to-be schede;cd o.:t -oi-curvice for roatinq or norr.acl r.s.intenanco during t hace p.rlods, enartcquently the for:ced.outa3e of.ny of these units durin:: th.nc periods han a p; oportionally 1.:rco effcet upon the system's ths.lity to wit.hntand second or third con:.Juc.encics.
'.Jhc 31.0 percent (1,9t'9 mg.r.inttc) reserve margin the Applicant indic sten for the 1973 nuatur pech is cc...pletely vested in the.two Midiat.d units and the Palisades unit.


                                                                - .-          .. ._            -. ~ -            -_    . _ .      -. .                ._          -
-. ~ -
u
u s.
                  .            s .
t.
: t. .
E h ::idr;g;m p<.. ar pool 'c 197a pinnned espabili t y of 19,232 n.est..it.tts includes ebaut 10,I:!.1 u c.. watts of nce generc.tinp, capelly; S,460 : agnvatts foncil-fueled, 3,l'd r.:. p. ct tc uuelect-ees.c4 cud 1,072. pu,nped storene.
                            .        ..                                                                                                                                      E
~
        .;
hyd>:ccl.cct:ric cay:P.y.
          ,                                  h ::idr;g;m p<.. ar pool 'c 197a pinnned espabili t y of 19,232 n.est..it.tts includes ebaut 10,I:!.1 u c.. watts of nce generc.tinp, capelly; S,460 : agnvatts                                                       !
Thc 2.*l.9 pcrecat ( *<,706 ::.c;,tc. l. t t s ) res e rve r.argin e.5 tha.it ed to c?.3 ts.i n a t the ti:::o of the 1970-79 trinter penh tiill be dependent upon t he ti:. ly co.aczeici c.perctica of planned neu nuclear generating capacJ ty for US p:> rect.t of cap eity recorvca.
foncil-fueled, 3,l'd                                                   ~
1 The recurve t.o:1.i'us indicated in the feregoing tchulntions cud, t.cnt etc grosu in thrt th y incle:03 cl } tr.// ne ct for Sch:'dH}Cd 7.10inten*nce, forced OutnjuG, CVr4CS in } ectl Iorecce tin 3, c;.Cupt
r.:. p. ct tc uuelect- ees.c4 cud 1,072. pu,nped storene.
* C.a".1 \\tect' Cr, and CPIOui"G u
hyd>:ccl.cct:ric cay:P.y. Thc 2.*l.9 pcrecat ( *< ,706 ::.c;,tc. l. t t s ) res e rve r.argin e.5 tha.it ed to c?.3 ts.i n a t the ti:::o of the 1970-79 trinter penh tiill be dependent                                               !
rc:.m ve regulrc:.aatn. Leent c:;p.u ien:c trith n:.:: 1.rgo generatin; uaits, houcver, iv.dicates thct Iroqucnt fe::ced curenen or such units is to hc er.pected dtrcin ; t.hc initial :.onths of tht.ir op:.rctic.n.
upon t he ti: . ly co.aczeici c.perctica of planned neu nuclear generating capacJ ty for US p:> rect.t of cap eity recorvca.
The /.pplicant reporta thtt the Pool considers ccps. city reccrves of 18 percent of peah load neccu:.ary to inaurc :.dcc;uate cyctem relichility.
1 The recurve t.o:1.i'us indicated in the feregoing tchulntions cud, t.cnt etc grosu OutnjuG, CVr4CS in thrt th y incle:03 cl } tr.// ne ct for Sch:'dH}Cd 7.10inten*nce, forced in } ectl Iorecce tin 3, c;.Cupt
~
* C.a".1 \tect'u Cr, and CPIOui"G rc:.m ve regulrc:.aatn. Leent c:;p.u ien:c trith n:.:: 1.rgo generatin; uaits,
.TE.g.y s ig j'iv,.5__i_ofi },l_tL3:.
                            '        houcver, iv.dicates thct Iroqucnt fe::ced curenen or such units is to hc                                                               .
*Aro 2.3 piin, sini;1c circuit, 045 Itilcyoit linea vill deliver the cuerp,y P.enerate.1 by the !!idicnd Picnt point na ti c c:<intir." 1.ulh pc.'e. ne ta. h.to the Titt.bre.c.accc Subatetica, a c
er.pected dtrcin ; t.hc initial :.onths of tht.ir op:.rctic.n. The /.pplicant reporta thtt the Pool considers ccps. city reccrves of 18 percent of peah load neccu:.ary to inaurc :.dcc;uate cyctem relichility.                                                                           ~
%c /.ppliceat secten the route 4
;                                  .TE.g.y s ig j'iv,.5__i_ofi } ,l_tL3:.                                                                                    .
in ovec icud principully cuand by the pcw Chuical Co:..pany, and dec:: not por:+ thre.gh noca stIth netic,nol, hictbric, scenic or recreational valuc.
                                            *Aro 2.3 piin, sini;1c circuit, 045 Itilcyoit linea vill deliver the                                                         '
cuerp,y P.enerate.1 by the !!idicnd Picnt 4
point na ti c c:<intir." 1.ulh       ;        pc.'e. ne ta. h.to     c      the%c Titt.bre.c.accc     Subatetica,
                                                                                                                        /.ppliceat secten         the route   a in ovec icud principully cuand by the pcw Chuical Co:..pany, and dec:: not por:+ thre.gh noca stIth netic,nol, hictbric, scenic or recreational valuc.
The /.ce).<er.nt further statea thet all trannn:iccion linas ascceinted with the p: oject hcve been routed,- do.igned and vill be constructed and nacintain:d nccordin:, to Environr:ntal Crf teric for Electric Trcns:aission Systdro de.velcrc:I by the United Str.tes ibportn ants of Interior and
The /.ce).<er.nt further statea thet all trannn:iccion linas ascceinted with the p: oject hcve been routed,- do.igned and vill be constructed and nacintain:d nccordin:, to Environr:ntal Crf teric for Electric Trcns:aission Systdro de.velcrc:I by the United Str.tes ibportn ants of Interior and
                                  /.griculture; Scenie , cud P.rnd     nun..: Juid:.lince for the Prot <etica of 2:nturci, Historic                                 ,
/.griculture; rnd Juid:.lince for the Prot <etica of 2:nturci, Historic Scenie, cud P. nun..:
Licual Valuca in the Ecsign cud .T.ocation of Rir. hts-of-
Licual Valuca in the Ecsign cud.T.ocation of Rir. hts-of-
                                .Ucy and Trancmincion Facilitics publiched by the rederal Pcuer Ccw:nirsion.
.Ucy and Trancmincion Facilitics publiched by the rederal Pcuer Ccw:nirsion.
Alt eracten to tha prm.oted Fr.cil.itice i                                                                                                                                                               .
Alt eracten to tha prm.oted Fr.cil.itice i
In picaning and beyond,                  to rect 1.ts p::nor neads for the 1977 c.nd 1978 peri.od tim /ipplicant considered that there vere no citos for bnce lond     hydroelectric
In picaning to rect 1.ts p::nor neads for the 1977 c.nd 1978 peri.od and beyond, tim /ipplicant considered that there vere no citos for bnce lond hydroelectric develop..ent availabic, that conhustica turbines are
                                ,coc.t ly to operat.c cod rhnt it <1<v 9 develop..ent    availabic, that conhustica turbines are not ec.nider th:::n ca bccc load                               .
,coc.t ly to operat.c cod rhnt it <1<v 9 not ec.nider th:::n ca bccc load genart.LinL facili tics, and that it did uce foresec purchaced availnble at a cost cowparable to its own baso load gencration.1cuar The /.pplicant studied the econoc.ics of nuclear vernus fossil-fired base' lond generation and states that the econcmic benciits fr.vored the nucle tv-fueled for.ilitics to mtet its incroccin; lond oblisstions.
genart.LinL facili tics , and that it did uce foresec purchaced 1cuar availnble at a cost cowparable to its own baso load gencration.
In orcivin;; ct this decision, it considered natural gas to be onavMicbte in tha' cas..u.I;;y u @..d cod oil to 12 :a. ore ce t 1:. nl 1r 07 te
The /.pplicant studied the econoc.ics of nuclear vernus fossil-fired base' lond generation and states that the econcmic benciits fr.vored the
..a l
.                              nucle tv-fueled for.ilitics to mtet its incroccin; lond oblisstions. In orcivin;; ct this decision, it considered natural gas to be onavMicbte in tha' cas..u.I;;y u @..d cod oil to 12 :a. ore ce t 1: . nl 1r 07 te
_                                                                                                          ..a l
l 1
l 1
          ... -                            - . . . . - - . ~ .                             -        -    --
-.... - -. ~.
                                                                                                                                                                                \
\\


(,         .
m.
m..
(,
                                                        >                                          n
n
                                                                              - 6 .-
- 6.-
s ubjs.c t. rc nventer prteurenant difticultica th.a cc.cl. 'jhc Midiced Plant ja a dual perpe." na:1rar p.anc, recHe:: cupplyin, :.sch-:medcd baru J oad .
s ubjs.c t. rc nventer prteurenant difticultica th.a cc.cl.
gensation, it f r. Ac.i;,ned to cl .o supply pro: cts st er.m for the Do.t
'jhc Midiced Plant ja a dual perpe." na:1rar p.anc, recHe:: cupplyin, :.sch-:medcd baru J oad gensation, it f r. Ac.i;,ned to cl.o supply pro: cts st er.m for the Do.t
.I Cl.et.:len t Oc.qcof. Thia prtriision vill en.-bic Doa Che: icel to cortplctely c lor.u du.in irr r:uch Ic s offic! cut, fonoil fuel..barnin; pl:.nt. Comparl. son by the Applict.nt of ;. mn1 cos t:, (pensent wrth :.t 0.75 percent :.unval discot.nt) el epara-ir..'. coup::rnb)c.. sized, ningh. purpoco, plc.nts over cn
.I Cl.et.:len t Oc.qcof. Thia prtriision vill en.-bic Doa Che: icel to cortplctely c lor.u du.in irr r:uch Ic s offic! cut, fonoil fuel..barnin; pl:.nt.
.                            cut Iv.c:cd life of 40 >ct.rc indiccted for thr* nucler.r p!':'.t                   . tocc.1 cporal in0 cor.tn of ;.Na,rs.'s,000, :.nd for the cuni-fired pinnt totr.1 oparctin*; costs o f $703,0X',000.                                                                               ,
Comparl. son by the Applict.nt of ;. mn1 cos t:, (pensent wrth :.t 0.75 percent :.unval discot.nt) el epara-ir..'. coup::rnb)c.. sized, ningh. purpoco, plc.nts over cn cut Iv.c:cd life of 40 >ct.rc indiccted for thr* nucler.r p!':'.t tocc.1 cporal in0 cor.tn of ;.Na,rs.'s,000, :.nd for the cuni-fired pinnt totr.1 oparctin*; costs o f $703,0X',000.
ou tuci.;h i t !. hiM:er  De.,e   1caerc uop:r.:i:iua cc.p3Lrl      re.          cc str. for the v.ucicer plant graatly
De.,e 1caer op:r.:i:iua cc str. for the v.ucicer plant graatly ou tuci.;h i t !. hiM:er cc.p3Lrl c u re.
;
u.cd for.meleer plcuts a fu:.1 cost of 1.% uillt.Tha Applicut, in c'v.".lepin ; total co:ts, per hilowctu hour plu:,
u .cd for .meleer plcuts a fu:.1 cost of 1.% uillt.Tha Applicut, in c'v.".lepin ; total co:ts, 0.50 uti):4                                                                 per hilowctu hour plu:,
0.50 uti):4 par hilc.natt hour for operating t.nd T..aintcucnee capcuces.
par hilc.natt hour for operating t.nd T..aintcucnee capcuces. For coal-fired plcnto, it used 5.70 Lad 0.80 rni)1s pc r hilcr.:ct.t hour, respectively.
For coal-fired plcnto, it used 5.70 Lad 0.80 rni)1s pc r hilcr.:ct.t hour, respectively.
Act urdig thr.t the Mid1nna Pict.:
Act urdig thr.t the Mid1nna Pict.: hr.d i.een decisned no a cingle purpoac p)nat for nupply:n.; 1,301 v.ctsustts of electrieni capacity and no process the entit.}
p)nat                                                hr.d i.een decisned no a cingle purpoac cremu, for nupply:n.; 1,301 v.ctsustts of electrieni capacity and no process the entit.} ctate are cctin.ated by the Applicaut to bc about
: cremu, ctate are cctin.ated by the Applicaut to bc about
                            $466,000,000 (abwt $300 per hihnenct) including a coolire. tewer.                                 The capital co.:t of a cecoc:cble-nited cocl tu::ig, plant is entir.:sted to ho
$466,000,000 (abwt $300 per hihnenct) including a coolire. tewer.
                            $390,0t:0,000 (c. bout $300 per hilwatt, including $35 per hilowctt f nulfur dioxide rcr..ovel cegui;>:acnt) .                .
The capital co.:t of a cecoc:cble-nited cocl tu::ig, plant is entir.:sted to ho
or rangeThese of costs ccpitcl,   fucl,toand ri.!. creed       the.opcrating Feccral Po:   unit costs :.re vJthin the general 7 r Cor.::ission by others for co.nparable nit.untivuc.                                        .
$390,0t:0,000 (c. bout $300 per hilwatt, nulfur dioxide rcr..ovel cegui;>:acnt).
These costs r.uzt ultiuntely be borne by 1.hc concur.ar                                       c:On th3 bcsis, tb they becomo a pert of the cout of cicetric energy. Also cny inercacco in costs which might result siullerly fro::, del .ys.
including $35 per hilowctt for These ccpitcl, fucl, and opcrating unit costs :.re vJthin the general range of costs ri.!. creed to the. Feccral Po:7 r Cor.::ission by others for co.nparable nit.untivuc.
borne  by the f u consuinrc.
These costs r.uzt ultiuntely be borne by 1.hc concur.ar c:On th3 bcsis, tb they becomo a pert of the cout of cicetric energy. Also cny inercacco in costs which might result fro::, del.ys. f u constrection of the propocc.d :? cilitics would be siullerly borne by the consuinrc.
constrection of the propocc.d :? cilitics would be was not subniitted by the Appliccat, Info =Ation on coti:nated costs.of delays regnrd.                                             therchre, no ce2.:. cuts are made in thr.:
was not subniitted by the Appliccat, Info =Ation on coti:nated costs.of delays regnrd.
_ Conc lu: !ons I andThe  2 isst4.if considers i,cnded    to assist th:t. the capecity repeccented by the Midland Unitc' Pool'8                                    in rcctin3 the Applicant's and the Michigen 1977 and 1973 :.uu: car and uinter packs and to provide rearonabic res:in :nt?.:..
therchre, no ce2.:. cuts are made in thr.:
f'r (..'cpaey c.nd relichiiity of electric service.                       prudenc and rc . pens-:. hic operations of a pvrec syntea unct includc provisions                              for loan of capacity Jua to screed out:3c                   of generating capreity, occurence of lon.In bi.ht.;- chen those forecast, oparrting mart. ins required to fulfill
_ Conc lu: !ons The st4.if considers th:t. the capecity repeccented by the Midland Unitc' I and 2 is i,cnded to assist in rcctin3 the Applicant's and the Michigen Pool'8 1977 and 1973 :.uu: car and uinter packs and to provide rearonabic res:in :nt?.:.. f'r (..'cpaey c.nd relichiiity of electric service.
,                        obligt.tions to pr.rticipant in the interconnected 1.yster., cnd oparnting laarnins to prov.'.rie for fic.sibility in the ellocation of lord to c onc::cting teceurcer, becce.:c of abnormal bulh power system conditions .                              The neu Midland units vill be.1.p to steet those chjectiven of tbc Mich!nen syste::                               3.
and rc. pens-:. hic operations of a pvrec syntea unct prudenc loan of capacity Jua to screed out:3c includc provisions for of generating capreity, occurence of lon.In bi.ht.;- chen those forecast, oparrting mart. ins required to fulfill obligt.tions to pr.rticipant in the interconnected 1.yster., cnd oparnting laarnins to prov.'.rie for fic.sibility in the ellocation of lord to c teceurcer, becce.:c of abnormal bulh power system conditions onc::cting Midland units vill be.1.p to steet those chjectiven of tbc Mich!nen syste::
                                                                              . . . L.' +, . !                   .. -
The neu 3.
                                                                                      .*.e   , ..        .  .
L.'
j,
+,. !
                                                                                  . , , .      .......}}
.*.e j,
m
.}}

Latest revision as of 05:42, 31 December 2024

Responds to AEC 720107 Request for Comments Re Des.Rept Illustrating Need for Facility Encl
ML19329F620
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 02/09/1972
From: Phillips T
FLORIDA POWER CORP.
To: Rogers L
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
Shared Package
ML19329F616 List:
References
NUDOCS 8007030408
Download: ML19329F620 (7)
v • d • e


Text

,

'e m.

'j Y-

,; ;--- r.,

}.y.

.a.

+-

, ( Q **F y

d H. 8,* : -

FiCDF.rtAL PC.n 's COMI.1:0310 !

W/.:mt:4nro:4. D.C.

201'G IN ferrt.Y T43.FCft tot Fall-Ei; I.'

gy ?.

I (o

~

c ~ s ~s Mr. J im ter R(f.cra i...

.'o c

s Director,'1)!vinica of Radiological

u. # "~

L ' ; 0,'.i and Envirou.tcuI:1 Pretcction gr s....

", C 3 U. S. At. r; e 1
  • aer;;-f Coctrii s r. ion v-c.*

t-

*/

t a:,hington, D. C.

20545 W ' * '

Dear Mr. Rop,

crs:

This is in respouse to your 1ctter of Ja.w.ary 7, ll)72, requenting, th co:aacnts of the Pcdcral Pouer. C<c,xnist ica on t.hc M.C'r. Draf t Detailed Siate:neut on Envircar..cntal Con..iderations Related La th.: Propoced I;.suance of a Construction Permi.t to the Consuucr:. Po..*cr Co.4pany for the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2.

The encivned staf C repos.t prepared by the Connicsion's Murcan of Pouer evaluates the ;:etter neeris to be served by the facility; the availability of replacc :aut power fro.t others, if any; and the costs of such replacemaat poucr.

The report ille:strates the need for the :-;i.dlend Units 1 cud.

- 2 to provide an additional 1,301 : ecavatts of capacity for macting peak loads in years 1977 and 1978 on the Applicant's system and t.hc Michigan Pir.icr Pool which includes the Applicant.

Very truly yours, n

)';&

,N /;k. * *.ast'*

f **,

gfj T. A. Phillips

- c.

Chief, Eureau of Pouer s,

.l..I.'.l(/,-

..e y.

Enclosurc IQ,,.%'...

~

7 Staff report on the

! *.i.,f c. i.b..

Midicad Plant, Units

<. /-

1 and 2 a H{

  • ~ 7' 4 ',<.,,j< ;.

t, ::s s-

-\\

w;Q'..,. -

+.

w a

N.

t

/ /, 't ;1 *..s,it.

l l

s'd '

8007080

'Mi

.;..j

.~

t--**-***

s:*

f.

^%.

1

/:

/b-l.

.f.. g.-

s.

r t.....

?,.>..'s ff

\\t U.

. /.

s PE1EilAh PtMER CO:';tISSION kh ' /./.

/s;/

k./ ), - -

. ' - */

liUREAU OF FCUCR

~R{. _, ( C. (W s.m Report on the Midland Pinut Units No. 1 and No. 2 in Rulation to Pcr/cr !!cedo of Consuncrs Po::cr Co r.pany cnd the Nichi;u.a Poucr Pool O...Tanuncy 7,15//2, the Direct.c., Divicion ' of nn liolen'icci ar.d

):nviro:r.:: ate.1 Pcetret ion, U. S. Ato.iic Energy Cor.r.insion rer;vc::ted the of t he Pede.:r.1 Power Cc:s.:i::nica on AEC's Drnft Dctciiud State-cc:. wen t <

ucnt on KuvJ ron..:2nt al Con:.iderations Rclated to the P: opot.cd Insucnce of a Constre.ction Perr.dt to the Consu:.. crc Powcr Coa.peny for th5 Midland Plnnt, Unit 1 and 2.

These cot:.1.:nt: update thou nubmitted by the Peacral Po.7cr Conraission on Sept.;cher 23, 1970. We u..dny:t.m::1 froa cas.licr cc,rrccpondence cud enviro::cattal docmranta filed by the Applicant thct the environr: ntal c:.pectn of i:hir, picnc : rc currently underp,oi.ng suppler sacal analysin in which tho M;C viches to considcc such fcetors as:

the offect of delnya in facilit.y operction upoa

~"d ic int erent, particularly the pc icr i

necdu to be nerved by the

,, the cynilability of citernativa i

acurece, if cuy, to :nct

.a der.'anda.on c tiraely baci.s ; and delay

{

costs to th: 1.icensec cud to couruit.cra. Thus, our cea=:.:ats cro directed to -th i.c po!ntn in a rci/ica of the need for tha ft.cility cs conce:ra the t

cdequacy end relivbilJ ty of the Appliccut'c clectric sy:: tem can tha

-Michi;'.cn Pc.:er. Pcel, e cubrec,ioa of the E::ct Central Area heliability Cevucil O: CAR) of which the Applicant is a :.nr.hcr.

This is in cecordt.nec

.with tb %tional Enviro:wcatal Policy Act of ;969 and the Guidelinc of the Pre 3id nt's Cocncil on Environ:.: ental Canlit.y dcted April 23, 1971.

-lu propering this report, t$c Burcou of Pciter st.cff has considered the AEC's Dccit Datailed St.ctement.;.the Applict.nt's Enviro:nr.cutal Report and Sup;>1euent thereto; the Monthly Pcaer State::ents cuh:nitted to this Comincion by th? Applicant; ralcted reports t.. ado in response to the Cor.r iu::iva's Sectccient of. Policy n Adequocy cad Rc1!.chility of Electric Service (Order no. 383-2); cod the FPC stcff's indcpendent analysis of thcse docu::.: uts together uith related infornetion from. other FPC reports.

y!eed for th' Pacilition The l11d'hmd Plcnt vill have tuo units.

The 486-mencurtt Unit 1 is schet'uled for co:rcrercial service in early 1977, and the 815-megavatt Unit 2 it. reheduled for co::::cretal service in ently 1970.

In additioa to :the plant. 's 'ulectric~ out.put, the Midicud Plant is decinned to furnish 4,050,0'"i ent'.c per l. cup of precces sec..:.: for cel.. to the Dz Ci n-d e..1

^

Cu.pc. v.

-~

s =py c t,. c.

P

' ~ " "

F n.

,s

. 'ibe fulle..-l.y: tahals: tion t,0<.t t h.: c h.c t ri: :,yr t:.a loads t o be rect. e? by..;:e / ppl icct.t sat.1 th Ilichir, n Po.fer Pe:.1 'a chici tim. / ppliccat in a i.2./,er, na,! the reic: Je:h i" of t!'a ch.c'. j e c 1 o.n.put of the l' idle.nd O

smit, to t he.

.r.. ele z er erv.: c r.pr.cif ics on f.L<. trint r.v pc Af uy- /.p;ilicat 's v ed L.. :.or: :: c -p.,
ic..,, heal 's.;yr. tc..a t t th
. tit. : of t ive i t'77 rw 2:c, the 1977-7D s nt.r, th: M7G ctu.

r. n : thc.17/ r:-79 t:Ir.t ne pet.h per ioh. The Co.u.on. ra P.. er Cte.;p. r.y.:nri Detroit Ed!r.ca Cr ronic co;.. rite Ll.c Michigen Pc.cr Po..).

fr.c per ': lor d p rio::s unntioned i:rc t ha ca.t!.cipated initit 1 rcryice pcrieda of the n c.r unit.s, but tha lif:n of t' 2 6:cita 1:; c::pected to r

be son. 3's yera er t are, :.cd t hey cec c::pecte/. ta ec.'.t.itut e a pro-per t. i oac.1 p ;r t ot the Applictr.t ', : ';t a l i.e.no/n tin c:.pc. cit'/ throur,hout thc.t p: r. 9d.

Therefore, t hey vili ha depended um,a tra cupply pct. c.r to utect future deconds ovct : p;:riod of..nay yci.rn 14.ycud t he initial service need:s diceusscJ in this r;,pos:t.

1977 Stur. r Per.h I.oed Peric d Censur. Orc Detroit Michigan Pt.? cr

}:dison Pu.te r Com.nny

.C_o_r_.,ne n y Pool

- ~. _

With MJdi:nJ bait ?!o. 1 (l. !:r. e.. r..e t : ::)

c

et 0.'; end:.u l t C:.;r city, Megtuctts 7,635 10,702 18,417 Peck 1.ual,1:q;: vat t 5, (.. (;1/

8,7402./

14,350 /

3 Mer.er v:. M.rgi n, lac. a t t,

2,025 2,042 4,067 Kesetvc P. rgit., hrecnt of Pcah Locd 35.1 23.4 26.3 Witheat r.;dland Unit ?!a. 1

_ (4cp M-e..rts)

Met Dept.nciable C.>pccity, M cc.iatts 7,149 10,782 17,931 Peck Load,1:,ccustts 5,6101/

8,740,/

34,339,,,/

2 3

Recerve Mar,:ia, W mntts 3

1,539 2,0',2 3,581 Reserve Margin, Percent of Ped: Lo: d 27.4 23.4 25.0 1/ liteib'.; uct ?.a l e s O f 50 L;0,S,s.t/t t t s.

2,/ Re< uced by not purchases CO,'i ti:2.e.uta t t s.

1/ Keduced by net purchases 555 tre;suctts.

-l 9

l 9

q

~....

4 A

3

^

1977-741 \\!!r.tw. Penh Pe~ !od f

Consu:c::m D stroit 1:irchigem Power 1;dicoa Po or C owu:n.}

C ria.newf

=-Pool

~

I l!.I ( h Mid1 a.i l U.. 2.t ::o. 1 (41:6 ::~.,c ::..:' :) -_

!!e t -ikpenda.,)e C.'.. city, ::agmia tto 7,635 10,762 18,417 Pech 1. cad, ::, c..u.t.; a 5,6401/

8,325 14,1651/

R c :.c rv. Mar:31n, ;:wm:tts 1,795 2,457 4,252 1:cacrve Ihrcin,1:. recut of l'er.k Lord 30,7 29.5

'30.0 1?ithout Midlend ihit No. I (s y.s. s.,..,... t... r

...s,,.,_,

9 Het D.:pa.idchle C:preity, 'Med. watts 7, 14 9 10,702 17,931 1j Pech Lo.d, ::.w..trtu:

5,84 0 8,325 14,1651/

Re:wrve Ibegin, ::.: c.. tac ts.

1,309 2,457 3,766 Rest.rve bre.in, l'orcent of Per.h Lot.d 22.4 29.5 26.6 a

71ucludes n :t cc.lce of 50 u23cesets.

l

,i 1978 Sur.-:.cr Peak 1. cad Period Concuir.crs D:t roit.

Michigen Pea.ic r I:dicon Pc.icr Cor;1gny Cor nen /

Pool liit:a 1:1<114 ad Uni tt Nos. 1 & 2

_ Q,30) r.ar..-t t:0 Net De. pend: bic Cepecity, Megatacts Peck Lond, Mc3c,1ctts 8,450,/

10,762 19,?32 6,451:

8,93C3j 15,381Af l

Receeve Marrin, Pg:..eatts 1,999 1,052 3,851 i

Reserve :::rLin, Percent of Peak Load 31.0 20.7 25.0 i

liithcot Mt.dlcud Units I:os. 1 & 2

( 1,3 01_.m..: ra t M..

Nei: D.*pendabla Cc;.acit y, Megmretts 7,149 10,702 17,931 l

Penh 1.osd, Mo.;.aw; tu 6,451?:/

8,930 /

15,381N 3

Her.erve 1: art:in, F.gu.er.tts 698 1,052 2,550 neserve 1hrcin, Percent of Pat.k Load 10.8 20.7 16.6 Applicant's Stot ed Mceded Reserve M uatt. (18 percent of paah lor.d)lI ega-1,161 1,607 2,763 Her.erve Defleicacy, M<.;;:.we.tts 463 218

.gf.....; 3. ; -

..a e c. i t.
.:. e ser t ;. W K,purcca.: of par k lor.d r.. ce:,;s..ry to..i. st.::n adequcto aya ter.: relichili;y.

2 / 1scludc.a act r.aica of.4813 ccchatta.

S / 1.e::uc ed Ly ' net purcht.sen 1.125 rr 3ge;;atta.

t

}//1; educed by uct purchor;co 644 taesonitta.

t

,c

. ~ -

s..
a..

.R r

l

,4-l l':78-79 U ini er P:.th Pt rir 1 Conanacrs Datroit Ifichigan Po'er Edir.on Pe.tcr

.c.c..e,s e n y C w.v.e v Pool

.m Ilit h ::idien 1 Uoita ::on. IL 6 2 f1.W. ?.t.

.rc t i r,)

i j

l liet Depc.d ble Crpmicy, Mc3.,ratts 8,450 10,782 19,232 Pen 1.ond, Lr.r.rr t rv 6,6911/

8,835 15,5261/

nencava :::qdn, M a. rates 1,759 1,947 3,706 Re.terve 1.rirgin, Petcent of Peak Lot.d 26.3 2230 23.9 Without M:dler..I linite Nos. 1&2 l

(1

-,301 : * :r ::.t t d l

i;ct D:pendabic Cepecity, Megnv Ltc 7,149 10,782 17,931 l

Pe t.h t wd, 1:e3.wo t t :

6,6911/

0,835 15.5201/

Reacrve it rnin, lin.: actto 450 1,947 2,405 l

necorve 1:4r;.in, Percent of Pe.:h Load 6.8 22.0 15.0~

\\

Applier:nt ':, Statut li.'edc d Re:; cree, Maga-er.t t: (10 pcrecut

<.f pcnh lodd) 1,204 1,590 2,795 lu cerve 1:criciency, M ;nwart; 746 390 1/ Includes nat 8aled of 4S1 2.n;:cwatts.

t The ndeeuacy' cad reliebility of the Applicent't. cyctem and tha Detroit Ed;; on Cr,.g. cay's systo.., sihich corprisc. th' Mich.' gen Pcr.?cr Pool l

are increct.ingly depandent uten the tir.oly cad conti:v.ed operation of luene i.ccl.a.;r units. The 3,.'.50 :.ge. stts of cepecity the Applicent pit.n; to have in cparation to ::cet the 1978-79 winter pcck includei the tuo liidland units, totaling 1,'301 :q;x.rctts, and the 700-m3cuate Pal;r:ndos eni:..

The 2,00.1 ::: ;uicces., of capacity of these three units reprer.c nt. 73.7 Parcent of tha Applicant's gencrctfng capacity.

Ecccuse of th: reint ive efficiencies cad econo::lic; of sce.lc in the' oporation of. thene.1e rgo unitn, it '.reuld n:t h; nc.ren.1 to c::pec t these units to-be schede;cd o.:t -oi-curvice for roatinq or norr.acl r.s.intenanco during t hace p.rlods, enartcquently the for:ced.outa3e of.ny of these units durin:: th.nc periods han a p; oportionally 1.:rco effcet upon the system's ths.lity to wit.hntand second or third con:.Juc.encics.

'.Jhc 31.0 percent (1,9t'9 mg.r.inttc) reserve margin the Applicant indic sten for the 1973 nuatur pech is cc...pletely vested in the.two Midiat.d units and the Palisades unit.

-. ~ -

u s.

t.

E h ::idr;g;m p<.. ar pool 'c 197a pinnned espabili t y of 19,232 n.est..it.tts includes ebaut 10,I:!.1 u c.. watts of nce generc.tinp, capelly; S,460 : agnvatts foncil-fueled, 3,l'd r.:. p. ct tc uuelect-ees.c4 cud 1,072. pu,nped storene.

~

hyd>:ccl.cct:ric cay:P.y.

Thc 2.*l.9 pcrecat ( *<,706 ::.c;,tc. l. t t s ) res e rve r.argin e.5 tha.it ed to c?.3 ts.i n a t the ti:::o of the 1970-79 trinter penh tiill be dependent upon t he ti:. ly co.aczeici c.perctica of planned neu nuclear generating capacJ ty for US p:> rect.t of cap eity recorvca.

1 The recurve t.o:1.i'us indicated in the feregoing tchulntions cud, t.cnt etc grosu in thrt th y incle:03 cl } tr.// ne ct for Sch:'dH}Cd 7.10inten*nce, forced OutnjuG, CVr4CS in } ectl Iorecce tin 3, c;.Cupt

  • C.a".1 \\tect' Cr, and CPIOui"G u

rc:.m ve regulrc:.aatn. Leent c:;p.u ien:c trith n:.:: 1.rgo generatin; uaits, houcver, iv.dicates thct Iroqucnt fe::ced curenen or such units is to hc er.pected dtrcin ; t.hc initial :.onths of tht.ir op:.rctic.n.

The /.pplicant reporta thtt the Pool considers ccps. city reccrves of 18 percent of peah load neccu:.ary to inaurc :.dcc;uate cyctem relichility.

~

.TE.g.y s ig j'iv,.5__i_ofi },l_tL3:.

  • Aro 2.3 piin, sini;1c circuit, 045 Itilcyoit linea vill deliver the cuerp,y P.enerate.1 by the !!idicnd Picnt point na ti c c:<intir." 1.ulh pc.'e. ne ta. h.to the Titt.bre.c.accc Subatetica, a c

%c /.ppliceat secten the route 4

in ovec icud principully cuand by the pcw Chuical Co:..pany, and dec:: not por:+ thre.gh noca stIth netic,nol, hictbric, scenic or recreational valuc.

The /.ce).<er.nt further statea thet all trannn:iccion linas ascceinted with the p: oject hcve been routed,- do.igned and vill be constructed and nacintain:d nccordin:, to Environr:ntal Crf teric for Electric Trcns:aission Systdro de.velcrc:I by the United Str.tes ibportn ants of Interior and

/.griculture; rnd Juid:.lince for the Prot <etica of 2:nturci, Historic Scenie, cud P. nun..:

Licual Valuca in the Ecsign cud.T.ocation of Rir. hts-of-

.Ucy and Trancmincion Facilitics publiched by the rederal Pcuer Ccw:nirsion.

Alt eracten to tha prm.oted Fr.cil.itice i

In picaning to rect 1.ts p::nor neads for the 1977 c.nd 1978 peri.od and beyond, tim /ipplicant considered that there vere no citos for bnce lond hydroelectric develop..ent availabic, that conhustica turbines are

,coc.t ly to operat.c cod rhnt it <1<v 9 not ec.nider th:::n ca bccc load genart.LinL facili tics, and that it did uce foresec purchaced availnble at a cost cowparable to its own baso load gencration.1cuar The /.pplicant studied the econoc.ics of nuclear vernus fossil-fired base' lond generation and states that the econcmic benciits fr.vored the nucle tv-fueled for.ilitics to mtet its incroccin; lond oblisstions.

In orcivin;; ct this decision, it considered natural gas to be onavMicbte in tha' cas..u.I;;y u @..d cod oil to 12 :a. ore ce t 1:. nl 1r 07 te

..a l

l 1

-.... - -. ~.

\\

m.

(,

n

- 6.-

s ubjs.c t. rc nventer prteurenant difticultica th.a cc.cl.

'jhc Midiced Plant ja a dual perpe." na:1rar p.anc, recHe:: cupplyin, :.sch-:medcd baru J oad gensation, it f r. Ac.i;,ned to cl.o supply pro: cts st er.m for the Do.t

.I Cl.et.:len t Oc.qcof. Thia prtriision vill en.-bic Doa Che: icel to cortplctely c lor.u du.in irr r:uch Ic s offic! cut, fonoil fuel..barnin; pl:.nt.

Comparl. son by the Applict.nt of ;. mn1 cos t:, (pensent wrth :.t 0.75 percent :.unval discot.nt) el epara-ir..'. coup::rnb)c.. sized, ningh. purpoco, plc.nts over cn cut Iv.c:cd life of 40 >ct.rc indiccted for thr* nucler.r p!':'.t tocc.1 cporal in0 cor.tn of ;.Na,rs.'s,000, :.nd for the cuni-fired pinnt totr.1 oparctin*; costs o f $703,0X',000.

De.,e 1caer op:r.:i:iua cc str. for the v.ucicer plant graatly ou tuci.;h i t !. hiM:er cc.p3Lrl c u re.

u.cd for.meleer plcuts a fu:.1 cost of 1.% uillt.Tha Applicut, in c'v.".lepin ; total co:ts, per hilowctu hour plu:,

0.50 uti):4 par hilc.natt hour for operating t.nd T..aintcucnee capcuces.

For coal-fired plcnto, it used 5.70 Lad 0.80 rni)1s pc r hilcr.:ct.t hour, respectively.

Act urdig thr.t the Mid1nna Pict.: hr.d i.een decisned no a cingle purpoac p)nat for nupply:n.; 1,301 v.ctsustts of electrieni capacity and no process the entit.}

cremu, ctate are cctin.ated by the Applicaut to bc about

$466,000,000 (abwt $300 per hihnenct) including a coolire. tewer.

The capital co.:t of a cecoc:cble-nited cocl tu::ig, plant is entir.:sted to ho

$390,0t:0,000 (c. bout $300 per hilwatt, nulfur dioxide rcr..ovel cegui;>:acnt).

including $35 per hilowctt for These ccpitcl, fucl, and opcrating unit costs :.re vJthin the general range of costs ri.!. creed to the. Feccral Po:7 r Cor.::ission by others for co.nparable nit.untivuc.

These costs r.uzt ultiuntely be borne by 1.hc concur.ar c:On th3 bcsis, tb they becomo a pert of the cout of cicetric energy. Also cny inercacco in costs which might result fro::, del.ys. f u constrection of the propocc.d :? cilitics would be siullerly borne by the consuinrc.

was not subniitted by the Appliccat, Info =Ation on coti:nated costs.of delays regnrd.

therchre, no ce2.:. cuts are made in thr.:

_ Conc lu: !ons The st4.if considers th:t. the capecity repeccented by the Midland Unitc' I and 2 is i,cnded to assist in rcctin3 the Applicant's and the Michigen Pool'8 1977 and 1973 :.uu: car and uinter packs and to provide rearonabic res:in :nt?.:.. f'r (..'cpaey c.nd relichiiity of electric service.

and rc. pens-:. hic operations of a pvrec syntea unct prudenc loan of capacity Jua to screed out:3c includc provisions for of generating capreity, occurence of lon.In bi.ht.;- chen those forecast, oparrting mart. ins required to fulfill obligt.tions to pr.rticipant in the interconnected 1.yster., cnd oparnting laarnins to prov.'.rie for fic.sibility in the ellocation of lord to c teceurcer, becce.:c of abnormal bulh power system conditions onc::cting Midland units vill be.1.p to steet those chjectiven of tbc Mich!nen syste::

The neu 3.

L.'

+,. !

.*.e j,

m

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19329F620&oldid=4752129"