ML20009A181

Certifies 810701 Svc of Encl Tables of Contents for Previously Served Aamodt Findings of Fact,Conclusions of Law on Mgt Issues & Reply Findings to Staff & Licensee Findings on Mgt Issues,Principally Training

ML20009A181
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	07/01/1981
From:	Aamodt M AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
References
NUDOCS 8107090154
Download: ML20009A181 (6)

Text

. - -.

F. h t; ff'2[fb 1 United States of America S telear Regulatory Commission Iiefore the Atomic Safety and. Licensing Board In the Matter of Metropolitan Edison Company, Three Mile Island Nuclear Station, Un i t N o. 1, Do ck e t N o. 5C-289 (Restart) s This is to certify that Tables of Contents for previously served Intervenor Aamodt 's Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law on Management Issues, and' _Intervenor Aamodt 's Eenly Findin gs ' to Staff and Licensee Findings on Management Issues, PrincitalIy Training have been served by deposit in U. S. Mail this first day of July,1981, to e Service List 'ttached.

c LMv9tx/

It h-wi% b t

[

July 1, 1981

[

\\ v' i,=,f

\\

d6 (4

0-!

t%qe 3,eyg &

'g 3,

. t%

r__t

.g A > 01-

$,i:me de70198

%9 C

-w sa su g

mp x

%y.

i I)So3 s

ll/(

~

> 8107090154 810701 PDR ADOCK 05000289

'O-PDR'

' Intn W. Smith, Escuire John A. Invin, Esquire Chaiman Assistant Coursel Atcmic Safety and Licensing Pennsylvania Public Utility Ccmnission Board P.O. Box 3265 U.S. Nuclear Feculatory Comission Harrisburg, Perraylvania 17120 Washington, D.C.

20555 Karin W. Carter, Esquire Dr. Walter H. Jordan Bobert Adler, Esquire Atcmic Safety and Licensing Assistant Attorney General Board Panel 505 Executive House 881 West Outer Drive P.O. Box 2357 Cak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Harrisburg, Peresf vania 17120 l

• Dr. Linda W. Little John E. Minnich

- Atcrnic.Safaty and Licensing Chairan, Dauphin 03unty Board i

Board Panel of Grraissioners 5000 Hennitage Drive Dauphin County Courthouse Paleigh,. North Carolina 27612 Front and Fhrket Streets Farrisburg, Pennsylvania 17101 Jamas.R. Tourtellotte, Esquire

' Office of the B:ecutive Iegal Director Walter W. Cohen, Esquire U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Ccnnission Consumar Admcate Washington, D.C.

20555 Office of censurrer Admcate 1425 Straterry S uare

' Docketing and Service Section Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17127 Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Pegulatory Comission Washington,- D.C.

20555 Pobart 0,. Pol, lard _

609 bbnteelier Street Baltircre, Faryland 21218 Jordan D. Cunningham, Esquire 2320 North Second Street Chauncey Kepford Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110 Judith H. Johnsrud Environmental Coaliticn en Nuclear Pcwar

.'Fs. Icuise Bradford 433 Orlando Avenue

'IMI ALEBT State College, Pennsylvania 16801 315 Peffer Street Nrrisbumg, Pennsylvarda-17102 bhrvin I. Icais i

6504 Bradford 'Ibrrace

.Ellyn R. Weiss, Esquire Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19149 Harron & Weiss

~1725 Eye Street, N.W., Suite 506

~ ~

~

~~

Washington, D.C.

20006 Steven C. Sholly Union of Concerned Scientists 1725 9fe Street, N.W., Suite 601 Washington,- D.C.

20006 Gail Bradford ANGRY 245 West Philadelphia Street

York,- Pen sfIvania 17404 William S. JorDn, III, Esquire Harron & Weiss.

t 1725 E e Street, N.W., Suite 506 f

Washington, D.C.

20006.

I e

e s.

1 -

p.

t Intervenor Aamodt's Findings of Fact j

cotGto use.c-

, Conclusions of law on Management Issues

-4 I:

g jg81 $

b

.EUb.

I-Table of Contents cgn d N WM cggr.; t. k%*

O 6

Er~ "

Contents Findine Pane W

O u t l i n e*............................................ 1 1 i

• s 2.-. Fl.exibility of;NRC Requirements re Training Testing of Operators. on TMI-2 Events....

1 - 15 1

3.

Insufficiency of Licensee's Response to to Eligibility Requirements for NRC

.xamination............................. 16 - 25 2 2 4.

Insufficiency-of NRC Licensing Examination to Measure Licensee's Restonse to lessons

^

learn ed from th e A c cid en t............... 2 6 - 4 0 4

5.

Insufficiency _ of Licensee to Provide Trained Operators to Mest Manning Re-R e qu i r e m e n t s............................ 41 - 5 4 6

6 Insufficiency of Li.censee to Train and Test Operators for Emergency Response... 55 - 60 6

7.

Insufficiency of Licensee's Simulator Training................................ 61

~73 8

8.

Insufficiency of Attitude of Licensee's Personnel...............................

74 - 77 8

9.

Insufficiency of Management of TMI Train-ing Department.......................... 78 - 87 9

10.

Insufficiency of Faculty of TMI Training Department.............................. 88 - 90 9

11.

In sufficiency of On-si te Managem ent...... 91 -100 11 12.

Insufficiency of Operator Accelerated R etrainin g rro gram (O A RP)................ 101-109 12 13.

Con clu s i o n s o f Law................................. 14 14.

Other Conclusions of Law

a. Relative to Commission Order Item follows 111(e)............................

15 2

b. Relative to 10 CFR 55.8.............. f ollows

~

22 3

• Outline needs page number i

hm

n.

Contents Finding Face __

14.,0ther Conclusions of law, contd.

c.

Relative to 10 CFR 55.8...............follows 25 3

s d.

Relative to 10 CFR 55.8 follows 36 3

e.

Relative to Aamodt Contention 2.......A11 the above f.

Same as e.............................follows t

40 5

g.

S am e a s e.............................. f o l l o w s 54 6

h.

Same as e.............................follows 60 7

i.

Same as e.............................follows 72 8

j.

Sr.ce as e.............................follows 77 9

k.

Samejas e.....,........................follcws 89 11

.,1.

S am e a s e.............................. f o l l o w s 109 14 ii s e+

' hj, F ' ' W X intervenor Aamodt 's Heply Findings to Staff and Licensee Findines on g

,f gg W anacement Issues, Fr!ncipally Iraining g

61981

• 6)-

vrac

'U~l Table of _ Con ten ts

--D

-to cP.3 s -th f

..A

..,r...-+

. ",.Due 8

^

i..*"

Contents Fa c e

?/.

@et1of..................................................

111

'xf

- mgeb S t a f f C o n c l u s i o n s o f La w....................................... 1 Staff Findings:

31 - 34 Staff 's Us e of In correct Standards........

2 33, 34 Staff's Findings in Error Relative to 1;UREG - 0731..................................

5?

33 Open Items that Letract from Staff's Conclusions 33, 34, 55 108-109 Staff's Scanty Findings Relative to Training of non-Licensed Personnel...................

8 27, 29, 106 Staff's Unsupported Finding of Licensee's Su ffi ci en cy to Co pe with Em ergen ci es......... 10 35 - 50 Staff's Findings Relative to Licensee's Training of Licensed Personnel...............

12 49 Staff's Find.ings Relative to Comnetenc.y of

~

r -

15 Licensed Guerators...........................

i 43 Simulator Training...........................

19 44 Mind Set, Emergencies........................

20 45 Effect of Communciations Eurdens on Operator Ferformance.................................

20 46 Stress Effects on Licensed Operators........

21 47, 48 Aamodt Testimony............................

23 50 Aamodt Contention 2..........................

25 iicensee Findings:

43 Shift Technical Advisor......................

26 41 Manning - Control Room Operators.............

26 48 O p e ra t i n g En g i n e er s.......................... 28 59 Chemistry Department.........................

25 60 Eanagemen t and Tec'mical Capability.........

28 118 Training....................................

30

• See * *. next page 1

Contents t

race Licensee Findings, contd.:

119, 120 Director of Training and Education........

31 124 Supervisor of Operator Training...........

35 s

126 - 130 Auxiliary Operators Training and Program..

36 131 - 144 Reactor Operator Training.................

37 145 Senior Reactor Operator Training..........

38A t

146 - 151 Operator Accelerated Retraining Frogram...

38A 169 - 181 Licensee's Consultants....................

39 186 - 208 Aamodt Contention 2.......................

42

%greeieht-Between Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and Licensee *.'.

43

• • To be served tith Introd'uction, by U.

S. Nail on July 3, 1981 or in person at Harrisburg Hearing Romm on _ July _ 7, 1981, 11 8

me