ML20010G242: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
VisualWikitext
Created page by program invented by StriderTol
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:/           l
{{#Wiki_filter:/
      <s  .
W jOr${b)
W jOr${b) l l
<s l
CORSum8IS POW 8f                                                           3,,,,, m 0     0                                                         Vice President - Projects, Engineering l and Construction                       l
CORSum8IS POW 8f 3,,,,, m 0
            ' G"eneral offices: 1945 West Pernell Road, Jackson, MI 49201 * (517) 788-0453           80-Oh #4 September 4, 1981 I
0 Vice President - Projects, Engineering and Construction
Mr J G Keppler, Regional Director                                                       W       to     ,
' G"eneral offices: 1945 West Pernell Road, Jackson, MI 49201 * (517) 788-0453 80-Oh #4 September 4, 1981 I
Office of Inspection & Enforcement                                             g US Nuclear Regulatory Commission                                                 s                    .
Mr J G Keppler, Regional Director W
i
to Office of Inspection & Enforcement g
( g2 Region III                                                                                                                   l 799 Roosevelt Road                                                                               I           ;              l Glen Ellyn, IL 60137                                                         --
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission i
g,         4 7pg                          1 MIDLAND PROJECT -                                                                           'as%
s Region III 799 Roosevelt Road
DOCKET NOS 50-329 AND 50-330                                                   k\                        .D HELBA RESTRAINT DESIGN FILE:       0.h.9.h1 SERIAL: 13663                                                     4 l 8M l
(
I Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 g2 4 7pg g,
MIDLAND PROJECT -
'as%
DOCKET NOS 50-329 AND 50-330 k
.D
\\
HELBA RESTRAINT DESIGN FILE:
0.h.9.h1 SERIAL:
13663 4 l 8M


==Reference:==
==Reference:==
Line 32: Line 41:


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
l (1) Serial 8830, dated September 19, 1980 (2) Scrial 10070, dated December 1,1980 (3) Serial 11525, dat ed April 3,1981 This letter, as were the referenced letters, is an interim 50 55(e) report concerning HELBA restraint design. Attachment 1 provides a current status of the planned corrective actions.
(1) Serial 8830, dated September 19, 1980 (2) Scrial 10070, dated December 1,1980 (3) Serial 11525, dat ed April 3,1981 This letter, as were the referenced letters, is an interim 50 55(e) report concerning HELBA restraint design. Attachment 1 provides a current status of the planned corrective actions.
Another report, either interim or final, will be sent on or before December 1h, 1981.
Another report, either interim or final, will be sent on or before December 1h, 1981.
sfMa N-I             WRB/1r l
sfMa N-I WRB/1r l : MCAR-40, Interim Report #h, Au st 24, 1981 "High-Energy l
Attachment 1: MCAR-40, Interim Report #h, Au st 24, 1981                                       "High-Energy l                                     Line Break Analysis (HELBA) Pipe Whip Restraint Designs" CC: Director of Office of Inspection & Enforcement Att Mr Victor Stello, USNRC (15)
Line Break Analysis (HELBA) Pipe Whip Restraint Designs" CC: Director of Office of Inspection & Enforcement Att Mr Victor Stello, USNRC (15)
Director, Office of Management Information & Program Control, USNRC (1)
Director, Office of Management Information & Program Control, USNRC (1)
RJCook, USNRC Resident Inspectcr                                                                         //
RJCook, USNRC Resident Inspectcr
Midland Euclear Plant (1)                                                                               f 4'/
//
8109150477 810904 PDR ADOCK 05000329 S                         PDR                                                                       g ggg
Midland Euclear Plant (1) f 4'/
8109150477 810904 PDR ADOCK 05000329 S
PDR g ggg


l'
l' Serial'13663 80-04 #4 2
        .            Serial'13663 80-04 #4                                                                                                                                                                     2 CC:               CBechhoefer, ASLB FPCowan, ASLB RSDecker, ASLB AS&L Appeal Panel MMCherry, Esq MSinclair BStamiris CRStephens, USNRC WDPaton, Esq, USNRC FJKelly, Esq, Attorney General SHFreeman, Esq, Asst Attorney General WHE'arshall GJMerritt , Esq, TNK&J i
CC:
s
CBechhoefer, ASLB FPCowan, ASLB RSDecker, ASLB AS&L Appeal Panel MMCherry, Esq MSinclair BStamiris CRStephens, USNRC WDPaton, Esq, USNRC FJKelly, Esq, Attorney General SHFreeman, Esq, Asst Attorney General WHE'arshall GJMerritt, Esq, TNK&J i
 
s Serial 13663 gil05l0 Bechtel Associates Professional Corporation 80-04 #4 040244
Attachment 1 Serial 13663 gil05l0 Bechtel Associates Professional Corporation               80-04 #4 040244


==SUBJECT:==
==SUBJECT:==
MCAR 40 (issued 8/26/80)
MCAR 40 (issued 8/26/80)
High-Energy Line Break Analysis (HELBA) Pipe Whip Restraint Designs INTERIM REPORT 4 l           LATE:             August 24, 1981 PROJECT:         Consumers Power Company Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 Bechtel Job 7220 Introduction This reports the U.rrent sta us of MCAR 40 and actions taken since Interim Report 3.
High-Energy Line Break Analysis (HELBA) Pipe Whip Restraint Designs INTERIM REPORT 4 l
LATE:
August 24, 1981 PROJECT:
Consumers Power Company Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 Bechtel Job 7220 Introduction This reports the U.rrent sta us of MCAR 40 and actions taken since Interim Report 3.
Status of Action Items The MCAR 40 pipe whip restraint design reanalysis effort is continuing.
Status of Action Items The MCAR 40 pipe whip restraint design reanalysis effort is continuing.
In a large number of cases, engineering judgment and review of existing calculations were sufficient to ascertain he need for a dynamic (Phase II) analysis, and no distinct Phase I evaluation was performed.
In a large number of cases, engineering judgment and review of existing calculations were sufficient to ascertain he need for a dynamic (Phase II) analysis, and no distinct Phase I evaluation was performed.
Status of Restraints The attached table, originally included with Interim Report 2, provides the current status of those restraints potentially affected by the concern of MCAR 40. Where the need for Phase II analysis has been ascertained by engineering judgment and review of the existing calcu-lations, Phase I entries have been indicated as "no" because this conclusion would be expected if Phase I analyses had actually been pe rf ormed. Entries left blank indicate incomplete analyses. Some initial Phase II dynamic analysis has been performed using very con-
Status of Restraints The attached table, originally included with Interim Report 2, provides the current status of those restraints potentially affected by the concern of MCAR 40.
;              servative thrust force time-histories but this has proven to be inade-i quate for tue review effort. A more realistic methodology for modeling thrust forces '.s under development by the technical staff.
Where the need for Phase II analysis has been ascertained by engineering judgment and review of the existing calcu-lations, Phase I entries have been indicated as "no" because this conclusion would be expected if Phase I analyses had actually been pe rf ormed.
As discussed in Interim Report 2, the reanalysis is integrated into the normal HELBA production work. Therefore, a number of restraints have been eliminated frca the table ac no longer required due to pipe rerou-ting, etc. The total number of potentially affected restraints is thus reduced to 243 f rom the original 325. For the same reason, some of the
Entries left blank indicate incomplete analyses.
Some initial Phase II dynamic analysis has been performed using very con-servative thrust force time-histories but this has proven to be inade-i quate for tue review effort. A more realistic methodology for modeling thrust forces '.s under development by the technical staff.
As discussed in Interim Report 2, the reanalysis is integrated into the normal HELBA production work.
Therefore, a number of restraints have been eliminated frca the table ac no longer required due to pipe rerou-ting, etc.
The total number of potentially affected restraints is thus reduced to 243 f rom the original 325.
For the same reason, some of the


Bechtel Associates Professional Corporation MCAR 40 Interim Report 4 040244   August 24, 1981           0405i0 Page 2 restraints shown as requiring more detailed analysis and potential modification may require changes as a result of design evolution rather than the MCAR 40 investigation.
Bechtel Associates Professional Corporation MCAR 40 Interim Report 4 040244 August 24, 1981 0405i0 Page 2 restraints shown as requiring more detailed analysis and potential modification may require changes as a result of design evolution rather than the MCAR 40 investigation.
Submitted by:               M Jgf J.A. Clements Nuclear Systems Group Supervisor Approved by:         %                v_US L.H. Curti4 Proj.ct E   neer Concurrence by:           f2s~         -
Submitted by:
K."D.pY.ey Engineering Ma   er JAC/DDK/bjm(N) 8/7/2
M Jgf J.A. Clements Nuclear Systems Group Supervisor Approved by:
v_US L.H. Curti4 Proj.ct E neer Concurrence by:
f2s~
K."D.pY.ey Engineering Ma er JAC/DDK/bjm(N) 8/7/2


==Attachment:==
==Attachment:==
Status of Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40, 7 Sheets j                           dated 8/10/81 4
Status of Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40, 7 Sheets j
dated 8/10/81 4
k
k


MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2                                                         ,
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 STATUS OF PIPE WHIP RESTRAINTS AFFECTED BY MCAR 40
STATUS OF PIPE WHIP RESTRAINTS AFFECTED BY MCAR 40
* C:s
* C:s
                                                                                                                                .4>
.4>
Restr                                                     Mod.         Mod.           ='
Restr Mod.
System           Pipe                 Install Constr     Size OK     Loc OK Size OK   Loc OK Need ed Needed Loc        P%)
Mod.
ID           Restraint _   Bldg     (%)     Hold     Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase Il Size _
='
42-Inside                                                                                                                           Jr#
System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Need ed Needed ID Restraint _
Containment Dit return line   PR-610-2-6     Reactor   50       No     No         No DH   return line PR-610-2-7     Reactor   50       No     No         No DH   return line PR-610-2-8     Reactor   50       No     No         No DH   return line PR-610-2-lO     Reactor   50       No     No         OK                                     No DH   return line PR-610-2-11     Reactor   50       No     No         OK                                     No DH   return line PR-610-2-12     Reactor   50       No     No         No Dil return line   PR-610-2-14     Reactor   50       No     No         No Dl! return line   PR-611-2-3     Reactor   100       No     No         No                                           C)
Bldg
DH return line     PR-611-2-5     Reactor   100       No     No         No                                           J2" DII return line   PR-611-2-9     Reactor   100       No     No         OK                                     No   c=>
(%)
DH return line     PR-611-2-lO     Reactor   100       No                                                               (jj DI! return line   PR-611-2-12     Reactor     O       No     No         No                                           -
Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase Il Size _
Dil return line   PR-611-2-13     Reactor     O       No     No         No DH return line     PR-611-2-21     Reactor   100       No     No         No                                           CC3 MFW               PR-638-13-5     Reactor     O       No     No         No MFW               PR-638-13-6     Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-638-13-7     Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-638-13-9     Reactor     O       No     No         No MFW               PR-638-13-9     Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-638-13-14   Eeactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No HFW               PR-638-13-15   Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               P9-638-13-16   Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No M FW               PR w'8-13-17   Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-63L '1-18   Reactor     O       No     No         No MFW               PR-638-14 '9   Reactor     O       No     OK         OK                       No           No MFW               PR-638-13-20   Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-638-13-21   Reactor   NA       No     No         No MFW               PR-639-13-2     Reactor   100       No     No         No MFW               PR-639-13-16   Reactor   50       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-67)-13-17   Reactor   50       No     No         No MFW               PR-639-13-18   Reactor   30       No     No         No MFW               PR-639-13-29   Reactor   50       No     No         OK                                     No MFW               PR-639-13-35   Reactor   100       No     OK         OK                       No           No AFW               PR-638-14-4     Reactor     O       No     No         No AFW               PR-638-14-6     Reactor     O       No     OK         OK                       No           No AFW               PR-638-14-7     Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No AFW               PR-638-14-9     Reactor     O       No     No         No APW               PR-638-14-ll   Reactor     O       No     No         OK                                     No AFW               PR-638-14-12   Reactor     O       No     No         No Page 1
Loc P%)
* See Interim Report 2 under schedule for definitions of Phase I sud Phase II.                       8/10/81
42-Inside Jr#
1 Containment
)
Dit return line PR-610-2-6 Reactor 50 No No No DH return line PR-610-2-7 Reactor 50 No No No DH return line PR-610-2-8 Reactor 50 No No No DH return line PR-610-2-lO Reactor 50 No No OK No DH return line PR-610-2-11 Reactor 50 No No OK No DH return line PR-610-2-12 Reactor 50 No No No Dil return line PR-610-2-14 Reactor 50 No No No C)
Dl! return line PR-611-2-3 Reactor 100 No No No DH return line PR-611-2-5 Reactor 100 No No No J2" i
DII return line PR-611-2-9 Reactor 100 No No OK No c=>
DH return line PR-611-2-lO Reactor 100 No (jj DI! return line PR-611-2-12 Reactor O
No No No Dil return line PR-611-2-13 Reactor O
No No No DH return line PR-611-2-21 Reactor 100 No No No CC3 MFW PR-638-13-5 Reactor O
No No No MFW PR-638-13-6 Reactor O
No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-7 Reactor O
No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-9 Reactor O
No No No MFW PR-638-13-9 Reactor O
No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-14 Eeactor O
No No OK No i
HFW PR-638-13-15 Reactor O
No No OK No j
MFW P9-638-13-16 Reactor O
No No OK No M FW PR w'8-13-17 Reactor O
No No OK No MFW PR-63L '1-18 Reactor O
No No No MFW PR-638-14 '9 Reactor O
No OK OK No No MFW PR-638-13-20 Reactor O
No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-21 Reactor NA No No No MFW PR-639-13-2 Reactor 100 No No No MFW PR-639-13-16 Reactor 50 No No OK No MFW PR-67)-13-17 Reactor 50 No No No MFW PR-639-13-18 Reactor 30 No No No MFW PR-639-13-29 Reactor 50 No No OK No MFW PR-639-13-35 Reactor 100 No OK OK No No AFW PR-638-14-4 Reactor O
No No No AFW PR-638-14-6 Reactor O
No OK OK No No AFW PR-638-14-7 Reactor O
No No OK No AFW PR-638-14-9 Reactor O
No No No APW PR-638-14-ll Reactor O
No No OK No AFW PR-638-14-12 Reactor O
No No No j
Page 1
* See Interim Report 2 under schedule for definitions of Phase I sud Phase II.
8/10/81


MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 Pipe Whip Restrainta Affected by MCAR 40 (Continurd)                                                                                       c:) '
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 Pipe Whip Restrainta Affected by MCAR 40 (Continurd) c:) '
                                                                                                                                                                              .p .
.p.
Restr                                                     Mod. Mod.     C}
C}
System             Pipe               Install Constr       Size OK   Loc OK Size OK   Loc OK Needed Need ed       PNJ ID             Restraint   Eldg         (%)     Hold     Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size       Loc       42-4.~
Restr Mod.
AFW                             PR-638-14-15     Reactor                   No     No       No                                                 ,
Mod.
AFW                             PR-638-14-17     Reactor         O       No     OK       OK                         No       No AFW                             PR-638-14-18     Reactor       NA         No     No       No
System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed PNJ ID Restraint Eldg
,                                  AFW                             PR-638-14-19     Reactor         O       No     No     OK                                   N3 AFW                             PR-638-14-20     Reactor         O       No     No     OK                                   No APW                             PR-638-14-21     Reactor         0       No     No       No APW                             PR-638-14-23     Reactor         0       No     No       No AFW                             PR-638-14-24     Reactor         0       No     No     OK                                   No APW                             PR-638-14-25     Reactor         O       No     No     OK                                   No AFW                             PR-638-14-26     Reactor         O       No     No     OK                                   No     C='
(%)
                                                                                                                                                                          .C-AFW                             PR-639-14-2     Reactor     100         No     No       No                                       C)
Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 42-4.~
AFW                             PR-639-14-4     Reactor     100         No     No       No                                       ;fg AFW                             PR-639-14-5     Reactor     100         No     No       No                                       __,
AFW PR-638-14-15 Reactor No No No AFW PR-638-14-17 Reactor O
APW                             PR-639-14-6     Reactor     100         No     No     OK                                   No AFW                             PR-639-14-7     Reactor         O       No     OK     OK                         No       No   CZ)
No OK OK No No AFW PR-638-14-18 Reactor NA No No No AFW PR-638-14-19 Reactor O
AFW                             PR-639-14-8     Reactor       NA         No     No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-13     Reactor       NA         No     No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-34     Reactor     100         No     No       No APW                             PR-639-14-15     Reactor     100         No     No     OK                                   No APW                             PR-639-14-16     Reactor         0       No     No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-17     Reactor         0       No     No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-18     Reactor         0       No     No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-19     Reactor         O       No     OK       OK                         No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-20     Reactor         O       No     OK       OK                         No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-21     Reactor         0       No     No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-22     Reactor     100         No     OK       OK                         No       No AFW                             PR-639-14-24     Reactor                   No     No       No PRZR Relief                     PR-601-3-lO     Reactor         O       No     No       No PRZR Relief                     PR-601-3-14     Reactor         O       No     No       No PRZR Relief                     PR-601-3-16     Reactor         O       No     No       No PRZR Relief                     PR-602-3-lO     Reactor         O       No     No       No PRZR Relief                     PR-602-3-14     Reactor         O       No     No       No PRZR Relief                     PR-602-3-16     Reactor         O       No     No       No HPI,                 Normal MU PR-603-1-1       Reactor         O       No     No       No HPI,                 Normal MU PR-603-1-2       Reactor         O       No     OK       No                         No j                                   HPI,                 Normal MU Pt-603-1-3       Reactor         O       No     OK       No                         No HPI,                 Normal MU PM-603-1-9A     Reactor       NA                 No       No HPI,                 Normal MU PR-603-1-9B     Reactor         O       No     No     No HPI, Normal MU                 PR-604-1-15     Reactor         O       No     OK       No                         No i                                   HPI, Normal MU                 PR-604-1-21     Reactor         O       No     OK       No                         No HPI, Normal MU                 PR-604-1-23     Reactor         0       No     OK       No                         No Page 2 8/10/81
No No OK N3 AFW PR-638-14-20 Reactor O
No No OK No APW PR-638-14-21 Reactor 0
No No No APW PR-638-14-23 Reactor 0
No No No AFW PR-638-14-24 Reactor 0
No No OK No APW PR-638-14-25 Reactor O
No No OK No C='
AFW PR-638-14-26 Reactor O
No No OK No
.C-AFW PR-639-14-2 Reactor 100 No No No C)
AFW PR-639-14-4 Reactor 100 No No No
;fg AFW PR-639-14-5 Reactor 100 No No No APW PR-639-14-6 Reactor 100 No No OK No AFW PR-639-14-7 Reactor O
No OK OK No No CZ)
AFW PR-639-14-8 Reactor NA No No No AFW PR-639-14-13 Reactor NA No No No AFW PR-639-14-34 Reactor 100 No No No APW PR-639-14-15 Reactor 100 No No OK No APW PR-639-14-16 Reactor 0
No No No AFW PR-639-14-17 Reactor 0
No No No AFW PR-639-14-18 Reactor 0
No No No AFW PR-639-14-19 Reactor O
No OK OK No No AFW PR-639-14-20 Reactor O
No OK OK No No AFW PR-639-14-21 Reactor 0
No No No AFW PR-639-14-22 Reactor 100 No OK OK No No AFW PR-639-14-24 Reactor No No No PRZR Relief PR-601-3-lO Reactor O
No No No PRZR Relief PR-601-3-14 Reactor O
No No No PRZR Relief PR-601-3-16 Reactor O
No No No PRZR Relief PR-602-3-lO Reactor O
No No No PRZR Relief PR-602-3-14 Reactor O
No No No PRZR Relief PR-602-3-16 Reactor O
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-1-1 Reactor O
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-1-2 Reactor O
No OK No No j
HPI, Normal MU Pt-603-1-3 Reactor O
No OK No No HPI, Normal MU PM-603-1-9A Reactor NA No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-1-9B Reactor O
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-15 Reactor O
No OK No No i
HPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-21 Reactor O
No OK No No HPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-23 Reactor 0
No OK No No Page 2 8/10/81


                                      ... _-            ~ .     - _ . _ _
~.
MTDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2                                                             ,
MTDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 1
1 Pipe Whip Restraints Affseted by MCAR 40 (Continued)                                                                                     *
Pipe Whip Restraints Affseted by MCAR 40 (Continued)
                                                                                                                                            )
)
J:-
J:-
Restr                                                         Mod.       Mod.       Ci)
Restr Mod.
System           Pipe                 Install Constr           Size OK   Loc OK Size OK   Loc OK Needed Need ed           rg3 ID         Restraint       Bldg     (%)     llold         Phase I . Phase I Phase II Phase II Size         Loc       43, liPI, Normal MU   PR-604-1-24       Reactor   O       No           OK     OK                           No         No
Mod.
* ItPI, Normal MU   PR-604-1-26       Reactor   O       No           OK       No                         No llPI, Normal MU   PR-604-1-29       Reactor   U       No           No       No it PI , Normal MU PR-604-1-33A     Reactor   O       No           No       No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-33D     Reactor   O       No           No       No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-41       Reactor   NA       No           OK       No                         No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-44A     Reactor   NA       No           No       No
Ci)
      !!PI, Normal MU PR-604-2-44B     Raactor   NA       No           No       No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-45       Reactor   NA       No           No       No                                           C2?
System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed rg3 ID Restraint Bldg
(%)
llold Phase I. Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 43, liPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-24 Reactor O
No OK OK No No ItPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-26 Reactor O
No OK No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-29 Reactor U
No No No it PI, Normal MU PR-604-1-33A Reactor O
No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-33D Reactor O
No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-41 Reactor NA No OK No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-44A Reactor NA No No No
!!PI, Normal MU PR-604-2-44B Raactor NA No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-45 Reactor NA No No No C2?
3:-
3:-
Letdown           PR-603-3-2       Reactor   O       No           OK       No                         No               C)
Letdown PR-603-3-2 Reactor O
Letdown           PR-603-3-4       Reactor   O       No           OK     CK                           No         No     (g Letdown           P R -6'' 3 6 Reactor 100       No           No       No
No OK No No C)
                                                                                                                                  ~~*
Letdown PR-603-3-4 Reactor O
Letdown           PR-603-3-8       Reactor 100       No           OK       No                         No Letdown           PR-603-3-9       Reactor 100       No           OK       No                         No               CI)
No OK CK No No (g
Letdown           PR-603-3-10       Reactor   O       No           OK       No                         No Letuown           PR-603-3-22       Reactor   O       No           OK       No                         No Letdown           PR-604-3-7       Reactor   O       No           No       No Letdown           PR-604-3-9       Reactet 100       No           No       No Letdown           PR-604-3-)O       Reactor   NA         No         OK       OK                         No         No LetdoV4           PR-604-3 1R       Reactor 100       No           No       No Letdo*t           PR-604-3-48       Reactor .O         No         do       No Letdown           PC-604-3-50       Reactor 100         No         No       No Letdown           PR 404-3-52       Reactor   O         No         No       No Outside Containment AFW               PR-633-4-4       Aux       0         No         No       No APW               ?R-633-5-1       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-3-2A       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-533-5-2B       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-3       Aux       0         No         No       No AF'd             PR-633-5-5       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-6A       Aux     100         No         No       No APW               PR-633-5-6B       Aux     100         No         No       No APW               PR-633-5-7       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-8       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-9       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-10       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-11       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-12       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-633-5-13       Aux       0         No         No       No AFW               PR-o33-5-14       Aux       0         No         No       No Page 3 8/10/81
Letdown P R -6'' 3 6 Reactor 100 No No No
~~*
Letdown PR-603-3-8 Reactor 100 No OK No No Letdown PR-603-3-9 Reactor 100 No OK No No CI)
Letdown PR-603-3-10 Reactor O
No OK No No Letuown PR-603-3-22 Reactor O
No OK No No Letdown PR-604-3-7 Reactor O
No No No Letdown PR-604-3-9 Reactet 100 No No No Letdown PR-604-3-)O Reactor NA No OK OK No No LetdoV4 PR-604-3 1R Reactor 100 No No No Letdo*t PR-604-3-48 Reactor
. O No do No Letdown PC-604-3-50 Reactor 100 No No No Letdown PR 404-3-52 Reactor O
No No No Outside Containment AFW PR-633-4-4 Aux 0
No No No APW
?R-633-5-1 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-3-2A Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-533-5-2B Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-3 Aux 0
No No No AF'd PR-633-5-5 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-6A Aux 100 No No No APW PR-633-5-6B Aux 100 No No No APW PR-633-5-7 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-8 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-9 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-10 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-11 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-12 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-5-13 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-o33-5-14 Aux 0
No No No Page 3 8/10/81


MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 3 Pipe Whip Restraints Af fected by MCAR 40 (Continued)                                                                     **
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 3 Pipe Whip Restraints Af fected by MCAR 40 (Continued)
Restr                                                 Mod. Mod. CO3 Systen         Pipe               Install Constr     Size OK Loc OK Size OK   Loc OK Need ed Needed     pg)
Restr Mod.
ID         Restraint   Bldg     (%)       Hold   Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size       Loc     4 ,,
Mod.
No                                            #
CO3 Systen Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Need ed Needed pg)
AFh             PR-633-5-15A Aux         0         No   No
ID Restraint Bldg
* AFW             PR-633-5-15B Aux         0         No   No     No                                                       {i AFW             PR-633-5-16A Aux           0         No   No       No AFW             PR-633-5-16B Aux         0         No   No     No AFW             PR-633-5-18   Aux         0         No   No     No AFW             PR-633-7-1     Aux         0         No   No     No AFW             PR-634-5-1     Aux         0         No   No       No                                       C 1FW           PR-634-5-2     Aux         0         No   No       No                                       42-               l AFW             PR-634-5-3     Aux         0         No   No       No                                       c3 AFW             PR-634-5-4A   Aux         0         No   No       No                                       g AFW             PR-634-5-4B   Aux         0         No   No     No                                       ~
(%)
AEW             PR-634-5-6A   Aux         0         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-5-10   Aux       100         No   No       No                                       CE)
Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 4,,
AFW             PR-634-6-2A   Aux       100         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-6-3     Aux         0         No   No       Nc AFW             PR-634-6-4     Aux       100         No   No AFW             PR-634-6-7     Aux       100         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-6-8     Aux       100         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-6-9     Aux       100         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-6-10   Aux       100         No   No       No AFW             FR-634-6-11   Aux       100         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-o-12A Aux         100         No AFW             PR-634-6-12D Aux         100         No AFW             PR-634-6-15   Aux         0         No   No       No AFW             PR-634-8-4     Aux         0         No   No       No Main steam     PR-631-2-1     Aux       NA t
AFh PR-633-5-15A Aux 0
Main steam     PR-631-2-2     Aux       NA Main steam     PR-631-2-3     Aux       NA 1
No No No
Main steam     PR-631-2-4     Turbine   40         No Main steam     PR-631-2-5     Turbine   40         No Main steam     PR-631-2-6     Turbine   40         No Main steam     PR-631-3-1     Aux       95         No Main steam     PR-631-3-2     Aux       95         No Main steam     PR-631-3-3     Aux       95         No Main steam     PR-631-3-4     Turbine     O         No Main steam     PR-631-3-5     Turbine     O         No Maia steam     PR-631-3-6     Turbine     O         No i
{i AFW PR-633-5-15B Aux 0
Main steam     PR-632-2-1     Aux       95         no
No No No AFW PR-633-5-16A Aux 0
,  Main steam     PR-632-2-2     Aux       95         No                 .
No No No AFW PR-633-5-16B Aux 0
Main steam     PR-632-2-3     Aux       95         No Page 4 8/10/81
No No No AFW PR-633-5-18 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-633-7-1 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-634-5-1 Aux 0
No No No C
1FW PR-634-5-2 Aux 0
No No No 42-l AFW PR-634-5-3 Aux 0
No No No c3 AFW PR-634-5-4A Aux 0
No No No g
AFW PR-634-5-4B Aux 0
No No No
~
AEW PR-634-5-6A Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-634-5-10 Aux 100 No No No CE)
AFW PR-634-6-2A Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-3 Aux 0
No No Nc AFW PR-634-6-4 Aux 100 No No AFW PR-634-6-7 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-8 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-9 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-10 Aux 100 No No No AFW FR-634-6-11 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-o-12A Aux 100 No AFW PR-634-6-12D Aux 100 No AFW PR-634-6-15 Aux 0
No No No AFW PR-634-8-4 Aux 0
No No No Main steam PR-631-2-1 Aux NA t
Main steam PR-631-2-2 Aux NA Main steam PR-631-2-3 Aux NA 1
Main steam PR-631-2-4 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-631-2-5 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-631-2-6 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-631-3-1 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-631-3-2 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-631-3-3 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-631-3-4 Turbine O
No Main steam PR-631-3-5 Turbine O
No Maia steam PR-631-3-6 Turbine O
No i
Main steam PR-632-2-1 Aux 95 no Main steam PR-632-2-2 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-632-2-3 Aux 95 No Page 4 8/10/81


MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 O
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 O
Pipe Whip Restraints Aft'ected by MCAR 40 (Continued)                                                                                 4, O
Pipe Whip Restraints Aft'ected by MCAR 40 (Continued) 4, O
Restr                                                           Mod.           Mod.         N l           System           Pipe             Install Constr             Size OK   Loc OK Size OK   Loc OK Needed Need ed                 yp.
Restr Mod.
ID         Restraint     Bldg     (t)             Hold     Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size               Loc           4, Main steam     PR-632-2-4     Turbine   40                   No                                                                           e Main steam     PR-632-2-5     Turbine   40                   No Main steam     PR-632-2-6     Turbine   40                   No Main steam     PR-632-2 7     Turbine   40                   No Main steam     PR-632-2-8     Turbine   O                   No Main steam     PR-632-2-9     Turbine   O                   No
Mod.
                                                                                                                                        )
N l
Main steam     PR-632-3-1     Aux       95                   No                                                           d="
System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed yp.
Main steam     PR-632-3-2     Aux       95                   No                                                           C3 Main steam     PR-632-3-3     Aux       95                   No                                                           (J1 Main steam     PR-632-3-4     Turbine   O                   No                                                           __.
ID Restraint Bldg (t)
Main steam     PR-632-3-5     Turbine   O                   No CC3 Main steam     PR-632-3-6     Turbine   O                   No Main steam     PR-632-3-7     Turbine   O                   No
Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 4,
,      Main steam     PR-632-3-8     Turbine   O                   No Main steam     PR-632-3-9     Turbine   O                   No Main steam     PR-632-3-lO   Aux       90                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-1     Aux       90                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-2     Aux       90                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-3     Aux       90                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-4     Aux       90                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-5     Tunnels   O                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-6     Tunnels   O                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-7     Tunnels     O                 No Main steam     PR-660-1-8     Tunnels   O                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-9     Tunnels     O                 No Main steam     PR-660-1-lO   Tunnels     O                 No Main steam     PR-660-1-11   Tunnels     O                 No
Main steam PR-632-2-4 Turbine 40 No e
<    Main steam     PR-660-1-12   Tunnels     0                 No
Main steam PR-632-2-5 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-632-2-6 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-632-2 7 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-632-2-8 Turbine O
!    Main steam     PR-660-1-13   Aux       95                   No Main steam     PR-660-1-14   Tunnels     O                 No Main steam     PR-660-1-15   Tunnels     O                 No HPI, Normal MU   PR-603-8-1     Aux         0                 No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-1     Aux         0                 No No       ho HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-2     Aux         0                 No No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-3     Aux     100                   No   No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-4     Aux         0                 No   No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-5     Aux         0                 No   No       No HPI, Normal MU   PR-603-9-6     Aux         0                 No   No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-7     Aux         0                 No   No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-8     Aux         0                 No   No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-9A   Aux         0                 No   No       No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-11B   Aux         0                 No 8fSO/81
No Main steam PR-632-2-9 Turbine O
No
)
Main steam PR-632-3-1 Aux 95 No d="
Main steam PR-632-3-2 Aux 95 No C3 Main steam PR-632-3-3 Aux 95 No (J1 Main steam PR-632-3-4 Turbine O
No Main steam PR-632-3-5 Turbine O
No CC3 Main steam PR-632-3-6 Turbine O
No Main steam PR-632-3-7 Turbine O
No Main steam PR-632-3-8 Turbine O
No Main steam PR-632-3-9 Turbine O
No Main steam PR-632-3-lO Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-1 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-2 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-3 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-4 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-5 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-6 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-7 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-8 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-9 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-lO Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-11 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-12 Tunnels 0
No Main steam PR-660-1-13 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-660-1-14 Tunnels O
No Main steam PR-660-1-15 Tunnels O
No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-8-1 Aux 0
No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-1 Aux 0
No No ho HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-2 Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-3 Aux 100 No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-4 Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-5 Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-6 Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-7 Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-8 Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-9A Aux 0
No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-11B Aux 0
No 8fSO/81


MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2                                                                         ,
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 Cdh \\
Cdh \
Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40 (Continued) ge-C)
* Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40 (Continued)                                                                                           ge-       ,
IJ Restr Mod.
,                                                                                                                                                              C)
Mod.
Restr                                                                 Mod.       Mod.           IJ
System Pipe Install constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed 4?'
.                    System             Pipe             Install constr                     Size OK   Loc OK Size OK     Loc OK Needed Need ed               4?'
ID Restraint Bldg
ID             Restraint   Bldg         (%)     lloid             Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size           Loc             4.--
(%)
e              llPI, Normal MU     PR-603-9-12   Aux       100           No               No       No
lloid Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 4.--
* IIPI, Normal MU     PR-603-9-13   Aux           0       No               No       No llPI , Normal MU     PR-603-9-14   Aux           0       No               No       No II PI , Normal MU   PR-603-9-15   Aux           0       No               No       No llPI, Normal MU     PR-603-9-16   Aur           O       No               No       No IIPI, Normal MU     PR-603-9-17   Aux           0       No               No       No liPI, Normal MU     PR-603-9-28   Aux           0       No               No       No liPI , Normal MU     PR-603-9-29   Aux         NA IIPI , Normal MU     PR-604-6-1   Aux           0       No               No       No llPI, Normal MU     PR-604-6-3   Aux       100           No               No       No                                               C2 4:-
llPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-12 Aux 100 No No No e
IIPI , Normal MU     Pd-604-8-2A   Aux       100           No               No       No                                               C;)
IIPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-13 Aux 0
a                !!PI, Normal MU     PR-604-8-28   Aux       100           No               No       No                                               tyg IIPI , Normal MU     PR-604-8-2C   Aux         NA                                                                                       __,
No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-14 Aux 0
!              IIPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-1   Aux       100           No               No       No                                               C2) j               !!PI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-4   Aux       100           No               No       No llPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-17   Aux       100           No               No       No itPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-19   Aux       100           No               No       No ilPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-21A Aux             0       No               No       No 11PI , Normal MU     PR-604-9-21B Aux             0       No               Na       No llPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-23A Aux             0       No               No       No IIPI , Normal MU     PR-604-9-23B Aux             0       No               No       No i               IIPI , Normal MU     PR-604-9-24A Aux             0       No               No       No itPI, Normal MU     PR-604-4-24B Aux             0       No               No       No IIPI , Normal MU     PR-604-9-24C Aux             0       No               No       No IIPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-25   Aux       100           No               No       No itPI, Normal MU     PR-604-9-26   Aux           0       No               No       No
No No No II PI, Normal MU PR-603-9-15 Aux 0
[               Letdown             PR-603-15-1   Sux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-603-15-2   Aux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-603-15-4   Aux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-603-15-5   Aux           0       No               No       No 4
No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-16 Aur O
Letdown             PR-603-15-6   Aux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-603-15-7   Aux           0       No               No       No
No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-17 Aux 0
,                Letdown             PR-603-15-9   Aux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-603-15-lO Aux             0       No               No       No
No No No liPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-28 Aux 0
'                                                                                                                                                                          i 0                          No      No Letdown             PR-604-15-1   Aux                     No Letdown             PR-604-15-2   Aux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-604-15-3   Aum           O       No               No       No Letdown             PR-604-15-5   Aux           0       No               No       No Letdown             PR-604-15-6   Aux           0       No               No       No i               Letdown             PR-604-15-7   Aux           0       No               No       No Le tdown             PR-604-15-8   Aux           0       No               No       No Page 6 8/10/81
No No No liPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-29 Aux NA IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-6-1 Aux 0
No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-6-3 Aux 100 No No No C2 4:-
IIPI, Normal MU Pd-604-8-2A Aux 100 No No No C;)
!!PI, Normal MU PR-604-8-28 Aux 100 No No No a
tyg IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-8-2C Aux NA IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-1 Aux 100 No No No C2) j
!!PI, Normal MU PR-604-9-4 Aux 100 No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-17 Aux 100 No No No itPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-19 Aux 100 No No No ilPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-21A Aux 0
No No No 11PI, Normal MU PR-604-9-21B Aux 0
No Na No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-23A Aux 0
No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-23B Aux 0
No No No i
IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-24A Aux 0
No No No itPI, Normal MU PR-604-4-24B Aux 0
No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-24C Aux 0
No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-25 Aux 100 No No No itPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-26 Aux 0
No No No
[
Letdown PR-603-15-1 Sux 0
No No No Letdown PR-603-15-2 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-603-15-4 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-603-15-5 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-603-15-6 Aux 0
No No No 4
Letdown PR-603-15-7 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-603-15-9 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-603-15-lO Aux 0
No No No i
Letdown PR-604-15-1 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-604-15-2 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-604-15-3 Aum O
No No No Letdown PR-604-15-5 Aux 0
No No No Letdown PR-604-15-6 Aux 0
No No No i
Letdown PR-604-15-7 Aux 0
No No No Le tdown PR-604-15-8 Aux 0
No No No Page 6 8/10/81


  -  - - - . . . . .. . ~ . . . ~ . - . ~ .               -.  -, . . - .        ..    -      _ . - . - .        _ _ . . - - .. -        - . . . - . .              .- .+       .
- - -....... ~... ~. -. ~.
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2-                                                                             ,
.+
Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40 (Continued)
MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2-Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40 (Continued)
Restr                                                                           Mod.         Mod.
Restr Mod.
System                                       Pipe           Install Constr             azze OK         Loc OK Size OK           Loc OK Needed Needed                         #
Mod.
ID                                     Restraint Bldo_       (%)       Hold     Phase I Phase I Phase 11 Phase II Size                             Loc                 O N
System Pipe Install Constr azze OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Needed ID Restraint Bldo_
Letdown                                       PR-604-15-9 Aux               0       No       No           No                                                                       "y   i Total affected pipe whip restraints = 243                                                                                                                                             ar- '
(%)
DH: Decay heat MFW: Main feedwater AFW               Auxiliary feedwater PRZR                   Pressurizer HPI: High-pressure injection                                                                                                                                   e MU             Makeup                                                                                                                                           #
Hold Phase I Phase I Phase 11 Phase II Size Loc O
AUX: Auxiliary NA: Not available                                                                                                                                               O C.11 Page 7 8/10/81
N Letdown PR-604-15-9 Aux 0
                                                                                                -.          .-.}}
No No No "y
i Total affected pipe whip restraints = 243 ar-DH: Decay heat MFW: Main feedwater AFW Auxiliary feedwater PRZR Pressurizer HPI: High-pressure injection e
MU Makeup AUX: Auxiliary NA: Not available O
C.11 Page 7 8/10/81
.-.}}

Latest revision as of 06:00, 21 December 2024

Interim Deficiency Rept Re High Energy Line Break Analysis Restraint Design.Mcar 40 Pipe Whip Restraint Design Reanalysis Effort Is Continuing.Methodology for Modeling Thrust Forces Under Development.Next Rept by 811214
ML20010G242
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 09/04/1981
From: Jackie Cook
CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To: James Keppler
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
References
10CFR-050.55E, 10CFR-50.55E, 13663, 80-04-#4, NUDOCS 8109150477
Download: ML20010G242 (11)
v • d • e


Text

/

W jOr${b)

Restr Mod.

Mod.

='

System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Need ed Needed ID Restraint _

Bldg

(%)

Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase Il Size _

Loc P%)

42-Inside Jr#

1 Containment

)

Dit return line PR-610-2-6 Reactor 50 No No No DH return line PR-610-2-7 Reactor 50 No No No DH return line PR-610-2-8 Reactor 50 No No No DH return line PR-610-2-lO Reactor 50 No No OK No DH return line PR-610-2-11 Reactor 50 No No OK No DH return line PR-610-2-12 Reactor 50 No No No Dil return line PR-610-2-14 Reactor 50 No No No C)

Dl! return line PR-611-2-3 Reactor 100 No No No DH return line PR-611-2-5 Reactor 100 No No No J2" i

DII return line PR-611-2-9 Reactor 100 No No OK No c=>

DH return line PR-611-2-lO Reactor 100 No (jj DI! return line PR-611-2-12 Reactor O

No No No Dil return line PR-611-2-13 Reactor O

No No No DH return line PR-611-2-21 Reactor 100 No No No CC3 MFW PR-638-13-5 Reactor O

No No No MFW PR-638-13-6 Reactor O

No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-7 Reactor O

No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-9 Reactor O

No No No MFW PR-638-13-9 Reactor O

No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-14 Eeactor O

No No OK No i

HFW PR-638-13-15 Reactor O

No No OK No j

MFW P9-638-13-16 Reactor O

No No OK No M FW PR w'8-13-17 Reactor O

No No OK No MFW PR-63L '1-18 Reactor O

No No No MFW PR-638-14 '9 Reactor O

No OK OK No No MFW PR-638-13-20 Reactor O

No No OK No MFW PR-638-13-21 Reactor NA No No No MFW PR-639-13-2 Reactor 100 No No No MFW PR-639-13-16 Reactor 50 No No OK No MFW PR-67)-13-17 Reactor 50 No No No MFW PR-639-13-18 Reactor 30 No No No MFW PR-639-13-29 Reactor 50 No No OK No MFW PR-639-13-35 Reactor 100 No OK OK No No AFW PR-638-14-4 Reactor O

No No No AFW PR-638-14-6 Reactor O

No OK OK No No AFW PR-638-14-7 Reactor O

No No OK No AFW PR-638-14-9 Reactor O

No No No APW PR-638-14-ll Reactor O

No No OK No AFW PR-638-14-12 Reactor O

No No No j

Page 1

  • See Interim Report 2 under schedule for definitions of Phase I sud Phase II.

8/10/81

MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 Pipe Whip Restrainta Affected by MCAR 40 (Continurd) c:) '

.p.

C}

Restr Mod.

Mod.

System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed PNJ ID Restraint Eldg

(%)

Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 42-4.~

AFW PR-638-14-15 Reactor No No No AFW PR-638-14-17 Reactor O

No OK OK No No AFW PR-638-14-18 Reactor NA No No No AFW PR-638-14-19 Reactor O

No No OK N3 AFW PR-638-14-20 Reactor O

No No OK No APW PR-638-14-21 Reactor 0

No No No APW PR-638-14-23 Reactor 0

No No No AFW PR-638-14-24 Reactor 0

No No OK No APW PR-638-14-25 Reactor O

No No OK No C='

AFW PR-638-14-26 Reactor O

No No OK No

.C-AFW PR-639-14-2 Reactor 100 No No No C)

AFW PR-639-14-4 Reactor 100 No No No

fg AFW PR-639-14-5 Reactor 100 No No No APW PR-639-14-6 Reactor 100 No No OK No AFW PR-639-14-7 Reactor O

No OK OK No No CZ)

AFW PR-639-14-8 Reactor NA No No No AFW PR-639-14-13 Reactor NA No No No AFW PR-639-14-34 Reactor 100 No No No APW PR-639-14-15 Reactor 100 No No OK No APW PR-639-14-16 Reactor 0

No No No AFW PR-639-14-17 Reactor 0

No No No AFW PR-639-14-18 Reactor 0

No No No AFW PR-639-14-19 Reactor O

No OK OK No No AFW PR-639-14-20 Reactor O

No OK OK No No AFW PR-639-14-21 Reactor 0

No No No AFW PR-639-14-22 Reactor 100 No OK OK No No AFW PR-639-14-24 Reactor No No No PRZR Relief PR-601-3-lO Reactor O

No No No PRZR Relief PR-601-3-14 Reactor O

No No No PRZR Relief PR-601-3-16 Reactor O

No No No PRZR Relief PR-602-3-lO Reactor O

No No No PRZR Relief PR-602-3-14 Reactor O

No No No PRZR Relief PR-602-3-16 Reactor O

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-1-1 Reactor O

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-1-2 Reactor O

No OK No No j

HPI, Normal MU Pt-603-1-3 Reactor O

No OK No No HPI, Normal MU PM-603-1-9A Reactor NA No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-1-9B Reactor O

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-15 Reactor O

No OK No No i

HPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-21 Reactor O

No OK No No HPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-23 Reactor 0

No OK No No Page 2 8/10/81

~.

MTDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 1

Pipe Whip Restraints Affseted by MCAR 40 (Continued)

)

J:-

Restr Mod.

Mod.

Ci)

System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed rg3 ID Restraint Bldg

(%)

llold Phase I. Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 43, liPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-24 Reactor O

No OK OK No No ItPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-26 Reactor O

No OK No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-29 Reactor U

No No No it PI, Normal MU PR-604-1-33A Reactor O

No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-1-33D Reactor O

No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-41 Reactor NA No OK No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-44A Reactor NA No No No

!!PI, Normal MU PR-604-2-44B Raactor NA No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-2-45 Reactor NA No No No C2?

3:-

Letdown PR-603-3-2 Reactor O

No OK No No C)

Letdown PR-603-3-4 Reactor O

No OK CK No No (g

Letdown P R -6 3 6 Reactor 100 No No No

~~*

Letdown PR-603-3-8 Reactor 100 No OK No No Letdown PR-603-3-9 Reactor 100 No OK No No CI)

Letdown PR-603-3-10 Reactor O

No OK No No Letuown PR-603-3-22 Reactor O

No OK No No Letdown PR-604-3-7 Reactor O

No No No Letdown PR-604-3-9 Reactet 100 No No No Letdown PR-604-3-)O Reactor NA No OK OK No No LetdoV4 PR-604-3 1R Reactor 100 No No No Letdo*t PR-604-3-48 Reactor

. O No do No Letdown PC-604-3-50 Reactor 100 No No No Letdown PR 404-3-52 Reactor O

No No No Outside Containment AFW PR-633-4-4 Aux 0

No No No APW

?R-633-5-1 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-3-2A Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-533-5-2B Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-3 Aux 0

No No No AF'd PR-633-5-5 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-6A Aux 100 No No No APW PR-633-5-6B Aux 100 No No No APW PR-633-5-7 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-8 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-9 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-10 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-11 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-12 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-13 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-o33-5-14 Aux 0

No No No Page 3 8/10/81

MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 3 Pipe Whip Restraints Af fected by MCAR 40 (Continued)

Restr Mod.

Mod.

CO3 Systen Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Need ed Needed pg)

ID Restraint Bldg

(%)

Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 4,,

AFh PR-633-5-15A Aux 0

No No No

{i AFW PR-633-5-15B Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-16A Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-16B Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-5-18 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-633-7-1 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-634-5-1 Aux 0

No No No C

1FW PR-634-5-2 Aux 0

No No No 42-l AFW PR-634-5-3 Aux 0

No No No c3 AFW PR-634-5-4A Aux 0

No No No g

AFW PR-634-5-4B Aux 0

No No No

~

AEW PR-634-5-6A Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-634-5-10 Aux 100 No No No CE)

AFW PR-634-6-2A Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-3 Aux 0

No No Nc AFW PR-634-6-4 Aux 100 No No AFW PR-634-6-7 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-8 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-9 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-6-10 Aux 100 No No No AFW FR-634-6-11 Aux 100 No No No AFW PR-634-o-12A Aux 100 No AFW PR-634-6-12D Aux 100 No AFW PR-634-6-15 Aux 0

No No No AFW PR-634-8-4 Aux 0

No No No Main steam PR-631-2-1 Aux NA t

Main steam PR-631-2-2 Aux NA Main steam PR-631-2-3 Aux NA 1

Main steam PR-631-2-4 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-631-2-5 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-631-2-6 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-631-3-1 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-631-3-2 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-631-3-3 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-631-3-4 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-631-3-5 Turbine O

No Maia steam PR-631-3-6 Turbine O

No i

Main steam PR-632-2-1 Aux 95 no Main steam PR-632-2-2 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-632-2-3 Aux 95 No Page 4 8/10/81

MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 O

Pipe Whip Restraints Aft'ected by MCAR 40 (Continued) 4, O

Restr Mod.

Mod.

N l

System Pipe Install Constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed yp.

ID Restraint Bldg (t)

Hold Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 4,

Main steam PR-632-2-4 Turbine 40 No e

Main steam PR-632-2-5 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-632-2-6 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-632-2 7 Turbine 40 No Main steam PR-632-2-8 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-632-2-9 Turbine O

No

)

Main steam PR-632-3-1 Aux 95 No d="

Main steam PR-632-3-2 Aux 95 No C3 Main steam PR-632-3-3 Aux 95 No (J1 Main steam PR-632-3-4 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-632-3-5 Turbine O

No CC3 Main steam PR-632-3-6 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-632-3-7 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-632-3-8 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-632-3-9 Turbine O

No Main steam PR-632-3-lO Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-1 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-2 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-3 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-4 Aux 90 No Main steam PR-660-1-5 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-6 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-7 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-8 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-9 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-lO Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-11 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-12 Tunnels 0

No Main steam PR-660-1-13 Aux 95 No Main steam PR-660-1-14 Tunnels O

No Main steam PR-660-1-15 Tunnels O

No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-8-1 Aux 0

No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-1 Aux 0

No No ho HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-2 Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-3 Aux 100 No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-4 Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-5 Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-6 Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-7 Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-8 Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-9A Aux 0

No No No HPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-11B Aux 0

No 8fSO/81

MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2 Cdh \\

Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40 (Continued) ge-C)

IJ Restr Mod.

Mod.

System Pipe Install constr Size OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Need ed 4?'

ID Restraint Bldg

(%)

lloid Phase I Phase I Phase II Phase II Size Loc 4.--

llPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-12 Aux 100 No No No e

IIPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-13 Aux 0

No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-14 Aux 0

No No No II PI, Normal MU PR-603-9-15 Aux 0

No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-16 Aur O

No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-17 Aux 0

No No No liPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-28 Aux 0

No No No liPI, Normal MU PR-603-9-29 Aux NA IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-6-1 Aux 0

No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-6-3 Aux 100 No No No C2 4:-

IIPI, Normal MU Pd-604-8-2A Aux 100 No No No C;)

!!PI, Normal MU PR-604-8-28 Aux 100 No No No a

tyg IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-8-2C Aux NA IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-1 Aux 100 No No No C2) j

!!PI, Normal MU PR-604-9-4 Aux 100 No No No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-17 Aux 100 No No No itPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-19 Aux 100 No No No ilPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-21A Aux 0

No No No 11PI, Normal MU PR-604-9-21B Aux 0

No Na No llPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-23A Aux 0

No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-23B Aux 0

No No No i

IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-24A Aux 0

No No No itPI, Normal MU PR-604-4-24B Aux 0

No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-24C Aux 0

No No No IIPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-25 Aux 100 No No No itPI, Normal MU PR-604-9-26 Aux 0

No No No

[

Letdown PR-603-15-1 Sux 0

No No No Letdown PR-603-15-2 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-603-15-4 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-603-15-5 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-603-15-6 Aux 0

No No No 4

Letdown PR-603-15-7 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-603-15-9 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-603-15-lO Aux 0

No No No i

Letdown PR-604-15-1 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-604-15-2 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-604-15-3 Aum O

No No No Letdown PR-604-15-5 Aux 0

No No No Letdown PR-604-15-6 Aux 0

No No No i

Letdown PR-604-15-7 Aux 0

No No No Le tdown PR-604-15-8 Aux 0

No No No Page 6 8/10/81

- - -....... ~... ~. -. ~.

.+

MIDLAND UNITS 1 AND 2-Pipe Whip Restraints Affected by MCAR 40 (Continued)

Restr Mod.

Mod.

System Pipe Install Constr azze OK Loc OK Size OK Loc OK Needed Needed ID Restraint Bldo_

(%)

Hold Phase I Phase I Phase 11 Phase II Size Loc O

N Letdown PR-604-15-9 Aux 0

No No No "y

i Total affected pipe whip restraints = 243 ar-DH: Decay heat MFW: Main feedwater AFW Auxiliary feedwater PRZR Pressurizer HPI: High-pressure injection e

MU Makeup AUX: Auxiliary NA: Not available O

C.11 Page 7 8/10/81

.-.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20010G242&oldid=4644721"