ML20100B721

Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-248,consisting of to B Lyons Re Filing of Quality Concern of Actions Taken by Vogtle Plant Review Board on 900208 at Meeting

ML20100B721
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	09/15/1995
From:	Mosbaugh A AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
References
OLA-3-I-MOS-248, NUDOCS 9601220216
Download: ML20100B721 (15)

Text

J4 % oyg

~ ~$,T-/240S88-2kT M. is mo C'

~fo :

bill 1 yon.s,

@sah4y oncern froy ra n (wrchndo??

l 95 c1T 20 P4 08 T on -flhny a Ovably Concern dh you gega(hy g

lle +1e Plad Sev:ew Soc [ od$$g,ino ochons laken by lhe g

klj j af meeb n390-15. O, +hal dde, % Pla,4 Review Boed tKonntn);n

' 8~ f,f

• voled in favo r of99peovalg(w4remporary moA;barl ion A-10-co which brecahed

+he in.0alld;on of 4he FQ VA R Hev skid, h s;d mdwa.de -}reafme,J [bheie $'^W# "pc<;oj I

l o f cu a i

'b u

'ueNo 6 non%.S, The Beacd,emapproval -% 4e mpo a<y mod;fi< bon 7

f b defde knowin

%4 he FAVA fil4rr Sk4 J./ not med fhe l

rey; e me nks 8eyIclory Cafe I.143., %e ASHE coSes s+dions.

o E s aok z, anj and a99; cable Qualit Axurance Preyam s. Qua7;ons f

q y

oak Eva n3 %

cov<>c rf' 3 PR6 meehn3reyard;n3 %e abovs non-congfiance s we<e no+ answered or -lhe ans.wers Pro v; dc8 io/;cafed %t ohpde safely, fech,. cal,, e,3;nece3 onS rry afory cong(;asce revu ws h ad l

ud-been a cco m9 ;>heh.

i The Pfa.h Rev.ew Board has d; verse membersh:p bwk a

brinj i,3 f y e rh a p on varie4y of ddfere,q g, sag, yo in a

ibe fable. A> a mem ber I a <teff %+ &reniayof hes be h;flererit viewpoin$s and %$ %ere may be differtoces

[g!

of profe>>ional opinion, 'This case is not one of profw;o,al h$

d;fferences..Tf is one,? adetsde co dvd of bo3;ne.5.5 ana y

ful5:nmany of -fhe P60'.s reseons:6;hhes under Techacal f

3gect&shon.s as de>celbed in adm; ne.Nea7;ve Pro teAvee

??,

ocooz -c

• Plan 3-Revi ow Ben.) - D.h es an A Re>PonsWl*lieb,

E)9ecially parnya ph 2.o ong pa,,,p6 3,3,

G I an, %

.senion nyresenlahve a,, he bearA rep <ex,hy

+he eyan occiy, feeh,,; cal, o,,A rey a4ary comphas ce areas l

of %* %g4fe.skaH.

I prese n 4ed +be fe}lowi,3 ;nformaiion lo he Boa <f reya < A;g resaIabovy, code, an/ gudly regare,en W ca b le 4o % ar,,y m,M: cdion A - eo-ooi :

f i

O \\/gfle is co+,,iHed fo Reg a b y Octe f H3 in J

chaght I.9 of %e FSAR o

@ The FAVA f:H,< skad was berg a/ded 4 ffic plad's 1

0*st.gn by a +emporary moliCicakten v.jer-prosdv<e

" Temporary tiokficaitons )

00307-C

,,,,,,4 The te s,,po rary m o Micd;o n h-90-00(

ls 5 s.

y eclaked '

a os / Ar h m d, desgn c

c (Gv;< w.s-a'l 3aldy e valvblon.>

rega; r+0 by yeecefum are I

003o7-c.

i The Qvafi4y A.uarance depadmes) and Vicc-Pre >\\ Aed-hen t1cGy have recedly.sleessd +<ed ;

femecea<y an0 venfee egn;pmed-des;g I;k,e fermanent.

^

The FAVA f:Ree skid 7.5 a

syefe," ha4l'inj ra$ionbhe maler;al in hp: hs

• as deSned in Jedion 8 4 R e3 vlatory 69de 1.i +3.

9 The Reyldery f'oisikn

.sedlen C.I.I.I re t";res ihd

• The sy.slem3 3A,vid be desped ad 4e>4ed lo rey:< men}.s se+ 4er4h in to des an A i

Aandsch h>4e d a Toble n

.s w fe.,e,de/

n by yqvlakoyy pa;>ilton s

1. I.2 onJ 4 of %1s ynde."

_.____._m 1

I 4

0, i

i TABLEI l

EQUFMENT CODES CODES i,

i I

wends, EQUlFMENT Deatpa and Queldisastee insporties l

Fahstenesse Weser6ain med Presederes and Temens

~

8 Premure Vesels AMSE Code ASME Code ASME Code ASME Code 5

Section Vill. D.v. I Section il Sectaos IX 5ectase Vill. Dw. I 8

8 ASME Code ASME Code l

Atmo.phenc Tanks A5ME Code:

ASME Code Section Ill. (1am 3 Secnon il Section IX 5ectase Ill.Clas 3, or AFI 6$0 or apt 650, or AWWA D 100 or AWWA D LOO 3

8 8

ASME Code ASME Codr 8

A5ME Code 015 P51G Tanks ASME Coas section lil, Ga.s 3, Section il See 6es IX Secuse Ill. Clas 3.

8 ur API 620 or API 620 8

l Heat Eachampers ASME Code ASME Code ASME Code ASME Code

/

'Sectaos Vill. Dw. I section il Sectnee IX Secess Vlif. Der. I and TEM A i

Pipms and Vaives ANSI 831.1 ASTM and ASME Code ANSI 838.1 ASME Code Secteon IX i

Section it 1

8 l

Pump, Wu 6,twurs' ASME Code ASME Code ASMECode i

5 tan.sares*

5ect6se Il er Secuse IX Seemes Ill.Clas 3L,,

j Ws Im,e,s.o.1

.re ies e.s I

Standards I,

i

.,. se

., s, -

vemG ~fe.aar -

-. - a

.,-..,m...-

4 i

m

. e.e p

u.

1

>m c e

o m., u _ -

- m.

t.,e m.

m. -

4 d

Ry akery Wsi+io n C u.2 does l

4 8.8.3 ManuMen Ier pseamme.esemamens sounpemames meute ammfesa es es sogemousses of sin speedesmene i

Aus mamuists Ruand as tesene E W es ASIS Sment and I

Premme Veemi Cats.s,,,,,, g,,,,g,,gg,,,,,,ggg,,,

ease ses asessesh and passes pipe seiened not to emed.

MammMM esund me mpeanes -se me mem=ss pairinsd.

4 and memasses an.eromment et spas.es appessmens emnes I

senmal aumentmas and esenteseed opersnamed w_.

Masudasemess' meamstal saranseems ed sanophense w. sis l

I mesmesi speamsomens suset as these semessmed a she entus sueuumand to Tates I muy be poemedad a has ad sum maammut emus separen, j

l i

j l

i A-Ib

t T4 is %e policy of %e Cxogia Power Co mpaay A+ ".shovf a

• regs;rn en+5 in Rep a4 cry Gales Posihons l

am f.e/

a<e as

s6a(I ", in +ha+ % +y a<e a ee3 v fdo vy repirm ent.

Table i

preseks %e coles 4e wbich

\\

RaAwa>+e Syrfem>

ace 4o be O rsi9 " + Ao" ! " c Y

/

an/ +rsked. Y av:ewse w;% +6e board %r rey;<med.s fo<

prexure vezel>

as an ex n yle.

l Reg a4cvy Posi4)on C.G pasen4s 4he %h+y hxwance yey;rmehs h< rodwas+e nan agmedi SY3fems. S eci E call 9

y T reviewed +;% %e Boa <c(

\\

i$e m A. 2.3 oa,d 4. 2,3,)

er ameles, as 4

T provided lo the boa <d lhe le flo w:n3 n 5 cmaS;en I

0 l

Nyva'di.3, he co,plia.,ce of 46e PAVA S;Her Skid cmd

.sdeb a-d inge e<;ng en(vako,, d Te.,,pora,y11,2% hon the y

A -4o-col w;h 4be above-rege rne~il.s.

@ The FhVA Alke,.skib's prem wnel and he.5yde.,,-

ofher pre.ssver rebaini ny componen are nof code

.sla ped vusels co mpon ed>. No ;rformcfion was er Prov; del to % % d %& %,y nef any of 14e Au Code ret a emed.s d Table I, This Hcivdes ASME sed;on E, 7lTr,.DC and Aust 63t.\\ Ts,a ;,elsdo ret-;rmeds 4-De>ig,, a, [ Q g d w Ho % tala_

h--W

l weIde< %(;%% a.,1 9,,ce d,es,,j r.,4,c;.,

and Ted;g.

The Shdup as No whe% e<

.Sfa$em hylwf bic

+e.03 had been compiske cf was r a is e A re >

a 1 eshon to %e boa <d.

The co mp(ello >,

of a

of % f:l'er codainer b Sn50 c hff U &dok NS 8esdn

5 1

l of ro H 9 6 fed in Section ittL havi g D6fn GS Ut Engi% +eriy Euaf wdto n reseense fo REA v'G-9037 cinkdll-23-1M[ed i3 ed as. jud;fceicn r

Paje 4 de rw I,, Thi3 for hoY meek;ngreqv;emEnh> b 863 ~ide UA3, No C

9ttJtcc8 ko $he bog *) *ihcN[Gi.s iAhormbion

%1as hf.sk ha$

hten PEkor m e h, &

l-MO pcbaSt Q

9b-6ccal7t, 0" $E% adk ino-; aNe0 +o ve 7.c> f.ssehdo u.,en kko,

h from 4hs ven fo e, A 3 yrem 6 y dms la fic +< dis <* co<"~ enleef in 8E A - VG-905 7 3ecy;on X ile m C. A/o Socvmeddion wa> fee.senl6d h the boaed ikd 14i.s % f had W n

.5a%ladov{y co4(s hd pcio<

to

+be P68 vob.

3

'ne FAVA fMc<.sysh6m is cons k Ne k oIm W exc)vaveIy of PVC pipig a<,/ Shy wkieh is -yet;6c, fly erok; b;frJ by 8 "laby 6"'le' 5

l.k3

.s+r;ow C l.L2

. There w

A e6ns ofevc 5511ihy,., valves an A 099m si m de Iy so ormc+

home && A exo;- w The e.,a r, -:.

os

g respo">E ko W ' % ' 905 Y S4sk%S review W.section 'il 0)

The a. iud d Pvc fc3 v>=f 73 nd edensive and i>

ro,,4 ar*ed en he FAVA Mer sk,it(. "

The _ sam e REA in

. set 4 ton I S4 des 'the FAVA Mer -- -

" voe has been kn9o<s.ih d;s conhnaed he 4o a

con ce rn raud rega rdi3 comgil asce w;%

fieylg4ery Gutdc f.to (ic.,se of Puc 9,pe) foe a pech on d 4he inktv connedt3 4tm g erav y ?"*'*b5 ho+>(adecti mdek; to hea< fref fofal lengh for f 6e f;Her ;nle and ed(et) en the FAVA f.%< Acl.

~ihe ea3 neesig revi<w and e,59 3 de4y m ( d.o-i

,ju>hfy % vse c6 PVC pi tn3 b e cause

& i 5" 9

1. .5ch ecfv le so anc(.$s,'4ahle. [or- -M;.s scevi ce ", pie,.e Ytycdcd (6ak,s",

beawh6 h avv bet n no

'% ideyded dose f, 4ke Pvc pp woJJ be J btIow 'fhe Ya$; bion 007Aje Ovebh c0 cmcl huafly i

the 'Pvc ppe we.A d v e be saaedeJ 4e n as>

ovajlabIr condi} ions s\\see +6e m an mu m p,en vee initi Pr* Dv'E h $hc NN Ib EO 5*

• f#'3 en3 neewing rev;ew o,d so,.59 M WAa4 the i

e<dsb;on

-fa:)

40 a ucen ere n.eny dhec l

• chn; <af inve.> haf wovId be need' d 4 aHe y f ;

e

+o dohfy the v>e d Fvc such as res;>}a,ce.4.

hammer,ivewu%cda ge p acy o va+e r g

c 5,,,

5!rts.>e$ fon Pff svgyok.5, $herm s]

t-xpan><o n au,

Becaux % ndenal e,J t ys;<al predie.s of Pvc h

a<e so d:R;<eJ t<an

.s4rel, the emivdion is x - Wi '

r o.

g

['

0%e<

e n c e.>

and omisic >

in %e e.,j w <ir,y j

anA JaNeky Fva[vsy;on fn.ak.e

-fhe dwdi% cafio n i

4 of aas9 aM dy of Puc 99,3 ined; A.

The hvida.,3 9a y % a c9ead hcak geenv<e of aber i

{

1/5 f ij Pr Aarry FAVA. The FAVA.:4,id i

relief vafve.

As a resd+

}

doo nd conha;n a

l 0f +4:.s, Pac pipe cadd be.svbGec{ed 40 eucess i

P<exu< e con Jilt on >

faom

+%<m al espansion,

l

?<o.,

rod;o )y41' e4F ys19 and fro.,

w raov>

l c

Pa rNj opratien 3, bsure rafing e4 WC PWe

%ges/es rap;dly af ILo *F.* Amba 6nk a Akion in, de i

AR6 app oocl> iM)

I' vel O*;na *h! 3"'"m *-

l 0

~ihe FAJS fd4e< p<env<r vene( (a, r,en%d ake l

1s ud p<deded by a

rdef v'dve, Wo esgla;nanon l

wa> prov;ded in %e engiseer;,3, evdua0;en or.

l in fw% v Ques 4;cn;g e]

Sc3 cte>; p e n3, m es, a3 4. ~b y his i3 accepfa h le. A> >% a heve l

%e ageea<.s 4o be con dih o s % d c w ic(

l

.5uh eek % e pesur e vene

' lo exevivc prenv<f5 3

ove r -

Preavee P'N'c h *" 'Y Adeqde l

prenv<e vene(>

is a rey'<^rd of A>HE Code secIio n W.

l Sc5 en p ee<> 3 pekresed 44r egime l

and so,59 afefy evaivahi on Ge hFAo!A f,W :

h he pre.sence of a Md.

On 4s Is9 oue call in a

r M e P6 B

.5C) enjee-;,ij a d a.;#e f f 4 d ' # o engru.e, )

or nere.se.>kfive of N;r A.,4,3,eng;,,e,7,3, g,.9 n-ih

\\

i L

had eve e

~ walked Aa,, * %FXVA i

seen o,-

i M;l Cird han/.

M ere as it m,y h e l

aam4abt<

ia cec 4an, ci,cv,,A a,,ce, 4,

y. t. <,,, a,

e ngiwrg ruiewp.b4 v;,w;,3 #e ef#e,4 G,,

33 o d g+efacien3 ; G wid n.4 he ou@ 7 d ra* h l

foc~ PAVA sh S. The slo / we pro curved do no an here Ll.

fanka* kS b9&dh5 thong,ihm do nb eM nom or edWi ajo A4 45 dis 0"***A I4'#h 8

aJ h;h r l

Ova (hy As>vea,ce eroyam we rih Eed.

exauw no cf A 3 4he re viewsr co uld n.4 A now

"' A a* y certwy wad w asb.:14 co,h nr3, c,,6g J;or G=d (on dih on of N h15/ Wah.

l 9

So eng,me;ny ad,,ikr0 ou %c ne9%e hne Jy 6ne j

cnI( Mr tkey had n 4 dew, o l

co v ari.so n "

of fA,. sob c r,po eds w;fh o

co Res a 4 deq>

Shu n/o ds a~d ce y r me nh. M.

ce,4 oi d in A e,y,,,9 ;

a.> b.,;Ii-d r..i are 33 eval vdion. Th ere only a sr.,p fe.

P e I p.s h,,, '

j j

A p>4 on wa3 mixa a3 4 whAer- %e hak cen> hs-GA freviou5 PyIneeA n3 review Yaki ahlo n typ.5vre Oh Ne hlGh, hee er was i

Pr* v> Ae A o,,ly %ak-V 's cohv1h);on w a s S n.al\\.

i

{

Look,ag d pay 4 e$ %

S,5,+, ev.GJ;s, l

4e d 4 i,/ W e f5,4 re iew3 e g o.w re w o n h v

l can.u acceJ.

A-/h

l T

qued,anel how % en3:nre<ing o,d saMy 8.

Fvniviion cov1A lyo's a l b ' " i"3 +4 e lo M la k i

4g Oval:4y A550<an ce Pr. yam o

• A + d e u j n.,

l conh<veton a d 4 e.s k3 of % sktd. No provided %

rey:rmed.s d l

ann * <s we<c l

M e h i a b le Q v d i 4 y Avva-ce Proyan.s is se+ 44h in fbe F54R

. sed; on

/7.z k,,8 f4ru _ sed;on M.

A

<cdv dien in awh a ble Ova (;4y %.,c&

P<q ra ms ran only be done w.% 9 to r ee<m;nio, of +6e A/6C.

i l

9, The Cadily Anv<a,ce Mmayv slaled lo k

av M y M a,cs.

bee.J tha4 s.-e 4; ses a

froya m could be use) le duhfy 14cco d at-

?

con la st& wi+h Codn on.d some41mo role comglio,ce could be v>ea MMy ceds;, ;fe,,

l o4 non-cmb a ce +i%

C0ah4 Assovece p<oyams, l 1

\\

bu4 he dsdn'4 xe how we 'd d J udify a l<<k

\\

of b.%.

• n,,. + ma<ai w \\

e eaa.

4 i

Tn somma<y

+6, Bea d iyored y-ecal no(.9,cc;te l

as self os nesde ve infor,a ios espoule.,3 l

guadio v,.>

r*rlabon., code, p<oceducal, ed osa(,4y Annce y,3,,,

^

an d,n,~

a r,r 4 e y e,.av y,,,o a A ic d ;o n Come(i""ce o a m aI

~

A - To -ml, The Bew&

.serm+cf +o be pc,,s> veeg by +s, l

fast %d %e vendev, hacry Fava,was on sF e and ready 4.

re tutal) 4he.Ai A. Th, vote w e co h d -fer

?%?*Y

• deg.t 8 h ned-issuc.>

• a.+;"1 h o~

pe,4 ne,c de m,e J a b n. Tbe vde was cake 4

-(cv in bt 0C6 Ch b~ re og Ob Ethi on bom NC d

vie c6a;<ma n and was ag eved 5 k.t in & m O femeravy' meds-b< bion A-90-w I, r+y atory a,c(

Since Raht, Sy>hms

hoo, l

qali4y nivrmeds W A s.n cc 4ki> Te,,9entay des 3nhed ' 3ckly Rela 4cA " t%s l

tied;ficaion was v A f[I y c o n (G r q #

j IJ A

)

.* f i

4 4

d4. / n

Subseqvcd k

-lhe Pno meeliy d 2-g-go I hav+

r+ vie wel odd:];on d in fo rmdton ed dnwn O khihi O '14 COHCfvaigny suehh rf.,$vNEhy foM(frr7h Os

[6 }fow.5 Davenk: r4 e c:rcala< %o-18 :

to cf 6 50.59 Sedr4y Evalvdion.s,

$0e Chong f>

habio#ChiVV Wak6 Tredment.sp%.

" edi on, eeSe<r,,cc-

[0%loison i Fro,

Ctsca;on >

ib madE bo Permanenk o< b~ eor *<Y Sf>bmh wMch implies bak reyd<mNd>

06tP(y GToelly do

++m pove. y sybtna, Conc lu.> ion :

Fyo,

%E hie 4 ice " gchion,' " % W~

Po h a s b le> CFR 20,30 50,71 MS '**

s N fed $i$y ees,ical Spee;(icdien>, o,J 4ecF T

eno(E~;wlu( 9ec a,ies Ik> S4 ~do-d) i wp(. ca%." Be cavre c4 kk, eval 8 a-c d fadure mode > tcs-Hi.ny in 5 9 ea ying

% pdedaf fa,y,L oavenJs do ~, % b4/in cnd relas+ 6 vwd:AS O ce mud be a4Lexed. These have hok bren $*e vio4.$ 60lveJJ6h N("&

f khE $*cht bl('b y &

loke r&,

V*E 0

Dys4rms is vt<y

[ow.

---

A:Ib

l Do<vdr fomro O<aff. sos 9 Pe))c yh

,a W3ACI25.

_ qbhkeme,h and Pceceda<s) a bcfosion s 5Safefy Evoluchea in A vo-m is inadequde and

% <s-fon e %

FA vA BHe

.skJ o.,4 :43 oge.-dio, r+Presed:, an 'unrewewed.sddy ques 4;cn.

I dm %s concIv>;en buause

-fai(v e modes y,,obs,);4,., o-f 4;)s ce, ang a,nse p,ce.,. d' failv res have "O b+

andy sed

, reviewed [aTh'W d16e Iicen ciy has;.s.

becaux com ;asce

\\

I wi%

EsAR commi46& Re. L; des, cadu cad sh,cids and

<My Au we., ce pmew wo ime(icikIn 4he h <en.si%

basss i4Self.

Whofexte devealion was n a h(va fe fy odl< css 16ese imhe d-

lem3, $6s mo0s 5e akio n is'unre<; tmh.

d A. - Ik'

4 i

1 l

been4 :

A -4o- 0o1 FAVA Tevorauy N4ft cdion

)

(ChC$0 SIC V1 : 0n 2 -12

%*J h6 n,W 49 y me&4; cahon was male odive by 44*

sh;B sugervi. soy, 2,s&ded d vev;4ied.

.T( % VAv4 slad re getseds an +rev;ewb

\\

bah 4y gut.rion ad Sincs %e skA is in>N(fed, we now are now in as Un anal red cand; hon 69 erusrion, Ms y

tegess+d.s a dc# cier con /ihon m/may

{

be. repohable 14 dekr,; ne) h he sy nthea, 4

i

g t

A ddik,aJ co..de. a%.

%iahon d A5HE CoAe>

o.,d

%(i4y h>>v<a ce lo line P esykm re@r men 4> ""Y be a

con ce<n bkc ~t ch &

in C6 &oeg ia h kovbe).

%ess celss 0 3

8 o oe NuJe a-Tn>v <er>

oh yc,k. ;.1 aft,ae<?

by code and %hty P,c3,om jo,,4 ;a,,ce.

I Pla.,i Alsed>ch e ProceAwe

&co z-C wo

it *SI rev;>e$

ho inciv/ e aofd;ft onal clesc,$*

en Y

e e

on he he Aliv d pan-vna,,,im os decisow'4.3.c.z. l t

j Th>

sn4;on Nas nb bun comphed o as i

Several rneeb.J5 have kn ceLdef suce k nm-vuelvh on,,,. am,the ik m w.,

vna m>movs are a./

no a

has byen prese nleA.

8A[

2 l+-fo J

(

A-YY

mmu As adChna; baek <ou,8, se F^vA -Ci He<

s had been pces.,vsf y 2nk Hej a.,/

of e n k & ;,,

4ke plal w;%d any fe,pomq mg.;,g ;,

-for abou2 6 <"mfhs.

~

The need Sc< such a 4114ec E<sh ca~e in't "E! V n w g (seeaga u p.,ye., L,p ea da ce in den 6a-a>+e,rse,asicy nf ntA esy <> pn e( ag ibey we<e clox lo exceedan3Nobium 95 disc boy 64 The IMfee was 9<ocurre) do %:4 Matun Aachapes.

Mer d -> d.xoveces there "o < der of rnay&fe '

we<e erro<> in 46e p;atum d;> chay 1 4 ralwidrons due oh wrony

&na:ron men; al con cen&akie n So O F vie Nliee hui v5 9e>9;fe Sh;S, %6 fYav~

No Pcocare a

0 1

sh:hrt Co.,,

M o k es 95 confkved e,d h e e n9,os;s

• o N 35 thkGo. %s khe.5dYsa<c t rr ov.S were cor<eheR, M&u n u L,d> ha ve n d been a 9-d ie >,.

The 9-oblems wkh lhe FAVA.n(W r,ob <>,edig f r b i S 4 lie d appheade rey]a ro y tvgaemer>

was by 4he Hdea's a,d Pcocurrne,4 revsew yeues wbo knu %

%s $wbl m 4o %e sNcd;on d v,cn,9mef Quam Azurece. Bo>ed w +6ex ca,cerny s n

y 41(4e< m>

re n,ovea Fom serv;ce. a J et%4.s. 4, t

ay>4s -, +W m d re tu rneds 4 sun.

procure a

t I,, A,

i>>+a. -A ~

a ass

-> i,; bled 4, oh

~ bik takn 4o u sefaR %

ms, n a en sin *+ona cu