ML20206C343: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
VisualWikitext
StriderTol Bot insert
 
StriderTol Bot change
 
Line 17: Line 17:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .
{{#Wiki_filter:_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.
  .. .f p                                                               nocKET NUfA DER rnnn   v. UT(L...reas-------
.f p rnnn v. UT(L FAC.ggg3[g.47[-/ -
FAC.ggg3[g.47[-/                            -
nocKET NUfA DER
                                                                                                  ;0fM ii:0 ,
...reas------- -
HARMON, CURRAN & TOUSLEY 2001         '"'  '
;0fM ii:0,
suirs 430                        '88 NOV 14 A9:35 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20009 1125 GAIL McGREEVY HARMON                                                             Of f 'Cf. STELEPHONE '
HARMON, CURRAN & TOUSLEY 2001
DIANE CURRAN .                                                                   00CEE htao2) 328 3504 DEAN R. TouSLEY -                                                                         SF.MhPAX ANDREA C. PERSTER                                                                           (202) 328-6918 ANNE SPIELBERG*
'88 NOV 14 A9:35 suirs 430 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20009 1125 GAIL McGREEVY HARMON Of f 'Cf. STELEPHONE '
DIANE CURRAN.
00CEE htao2) 328 3504 DEAN R. TouSLEY -
SF.MhPAX ANDREA C. PERSTER (202) 328-6918 ANNE SPIELBERG*
* admitted only in Pennsylvania November 9',1988
* admitted only in Pennsylvania November 9',1988
:J Lando W. Zech, Jr. , Chairman Thomas M. Ro be r ts Kenneth M. Ca rt Kenneth C. Ro ge rs James R. Curtiss
:J Lando W.
Zech, Jr., Chairman Thomas M. Ro be r ts Kenneth M. Ca rt Kenneth C. Ro ge rs James R. Curtiss


==Dear Commissioners:==
==Dear Commissioners:==
 
On November 2,1988, pursuant to CLI-88-08, NECNP f iled with the Commission its "Contentions on Applicants' Decommissioning Plan, Motion for Stay of Low Power Operation, and Motion to Reopen the Re cord. "
On November 2,1988, pursuant to CLI-88-08, NECNP f iled with the Commission its "Contentions on Applicants' Decommissioning Plan, Motion for Stay of Low Power Operation, and Motion to                                                             "
He have since discovered that the pleading was incorrectly captioned as being before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board.
-              Reopen the Re cord. "           He have since discovered that the pleading was incorrectly captioned as being before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board.             I have notified Docketing and Service of this error and am enclosing a corrected first page.
I have notified Docketing and Service of this
{
l error and am enclosing a corrected first page.
{
{
l
I apologize for any inconvenience caused by this error.
{                        I apologize for any inconvenience caused by this error.
' n c e,r e ly,
                                                                  ' n c e,r e ly ,
f%
f%
Diane Curran cc:       Seabrook service list 8811160233 001109 PDR       ADOCK 05000443 0                       PDR _
Diane Curran cc:
                                                                                                                      .      bss3 J
Seabrook service list 8811160233 001109 PDR ADOCK 05000443 0
PDR bss3 J


3
3
    '    'o l lh
'o l lh
.r.
.r.
November 2,   1988 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE COMMISSION
November 2, 1988 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE COMMISSION
                                                                                                        )
)
In the Matter of                                                                         )
In the Matter of
                                                                                                      ')
)')
Public Service Company of                                                                 )
Public Service Company of
New Hampshire, et al.                                                                 )       Docket Nos. 50-443 OL-1
)
                                                                                                        )                     50-444 OL-1 (Seabrook Station, Units 1 & 2)                                                           )       ONSITE EMERGENCY
New Hampshire, et al.
                                                                                                        )         PLANNING & TECHNICAL
)
                                                                                                        )         ISSUES NEW ENGLAND COALITION ON NUCLEAR POLLUTION'S CONTENTIONS ON APPLICANTS' DECOMMISUIONING PLAN, MOTION FOR STAY OF LOW PONER OPERATION, AND MOTION TO REOPEN THE RECORD I. Introduction and Motion for Stav of Low Power ODeration The New England Coalition on Nuclear Pollution ("NECNP")
Docket Nos. 50-443 OL-1
submits below its contentions regarding Applicants' plan for decommissioning the Seabrook reactor following low power opera-tion. The contentions challenge the Applicants' decommissioning schedule, their estimates for the costs of decommissioning, and the lack of reasonable assurance that adequate funding will be available for decommissioning.
)
The issues raised in those contentions vividly underscore the fundamental folly of permitting Seabrook to operate at low power now, given the fact that the plant will not go to full power operation any timo soon, if at all. In light of the very short time period necessary to test the reactor, there is no u      great bonofit to be gained from rushing ahead with low power operation. On the other hand, the potential costs of low power operation are enormous -- millions of dollars in decontamination
50-444 OL-1 (Seabrook Station, Units 1 & 2)
)
ONSITE EMERGENCY
)
PLANNING & TECHNICAL
)
ISSUES NEW ENGLAND COALITION ON NUCLEAR POLLUTION'S CONTENTIONS ON APPLICANTS' DECOMMISUIONING PLAN, MOTION FOR STAY OF LOW PONER OPERATION, AND MOTION TO REOPEN THE RECORD I.
Introduction and Motion for Stav of Low Power ODeration The New England Coalition on Nuclear Pollution ("NECNP")
submits below its contentions regarding Applicants' plan for decommissioning the Seabrook reactor following low power opera-tion.
The contentions challenge the Applicants' decommissioning schedule, their estimates for the costs of decommissioning, and the lack of reasonable assurance that adequate funding will be available for decommissioning.
The issues raised in those contentions vividly underscore the fundamental folly of permitting Seabrook to operate at low power now, given the fact that the plant will not go to full power operation any timo soon, if at all.
In light of the very short time period necessary to test the reactor, there is no great bonofit to be gained from rushing ahead with low power u
operation.
On the other hand, the potential costs of low power operation are enormous -- millions of dollars in decontamination


1988,copiEdfo[theforegoing I certify that on November 9, corrected page were served by first class mail" on' the following:
I certify that on November 9, 1988,copiEdfo[theforegoing corrected page were served by first class mail" on' the following:
s Atomic Safety and Licensing       A!!en Lampert
Atomic Safety and Licensing A!!en Lampert g y g 313 Hill-Whilton s
* g y g 313LJgoufit, Hill-Whilton Clark. Ilill-Whdton Board Panel                     Civil Defense Dire lando W. Zed                                                                                                    and McGuire Chairman                               US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Town of Brentomood 79 State Street Exeter, NII 03833.g 9.,
lando W. Zed Board Panel Civil Defense Dire LJgoufit, Clark. Ilill-Whdton Chairman US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Town of Brentomood and McGuire 79 State Street Exeter, NII 03833.g 9.,,g US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington,D.C 20555 MatthewT.Drock. -Q. Q, a),p;,Qeepuryport,MA 01 Washington, D.C 20555 p
Washington,D.C 20555
Docketing and Service Branch Thomas M. Roberts US Nuclear Regulatory Commision Shaines & McEachern Diar's Sidebotham Comminioner Washington, D C 20555 P.O. Box 360 RFD # 2 Box 1260 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Maplewood Avenue Putney,VT 05346 Wuhirgton, D.C 20$$5 Michael Santosuosso, Chairman Portsmouth, NII 03801 Board of Selectmen
                                                                                                              ,g US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C 20555 Docketing and Service Branch MatthewT.Drock.p -Q. Q, a),p; ,Qeepuryport,MA 01 US Nuclear Regulatory Commision   Shaines & McEachern                   Diar's Sidebotham Thomas M. Roberts                                                                                              RFD # 2 Box 1260 Washington, D C 20555             P.O. Box 360 Comminioner                                                                                                    Putney,VT 05346 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission                                         Maplewood Avenue Michael Santosuosso, Chairman    Portsmouth, NII 03801 Wuhirgton, D.C 20$$5 Board of Selectmen                     .
- J;mes R.Cu tas Jewell Street, RfD # 2 Sandra Gawris Comminioner South flampton, Nil 03842 RFD 1 Box 1154 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission East Kensington,NII 03827 Washington, D.C 20tSS Carol S. Sneider, Esquir' Diane Curran Anistant Attorney General Judith IL Mirner, Esq.
      - J;mes R.Cu tas                         Jewell Street, RfD # 2           Sandra Gawris South flampton, Nil 03842         RFD 1 Box 1154 Comminioner                                                                                                  -
Kenneth M. Carr 1 Ashburton Place,19th Iloor Silverstate, Gertner,e at Commissioner Boston,MA 02108 88 Brood Street Boston,MA 02110 US Nuclear Regulato,.'ommission Washi;gton, D.C 20535 Starley W. Knowles Board of Selectmen Thomas G. Dignan, Esq.
East Kensington,NII 03827 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C 20tSS                   Carol S. Sneider, Esquir'                                               Diane Curran Anistant Attorney General         Judith IL Mirner, Esq.
Kenneth C Pagers P.O. Dox 710 R.K. Gad !!, Esq.
1 Ashburton Place,19th Iloor     Silverstate, Gertner,e at Kenneth M. Carr Boston,MA 02108                   88 Brood Street Commissioner Boston,MA 02110 US Nuclear Regulato , .'ommission Washi;gton, D.C 20535                 Starley W. Knowles Board of Selectmen               Thomas G. Dignan, Esq.
- Commissioner North Itampton, bli 03826 Ropes it Gray 225 Franklin Street US Nuclear Regulaton Commiaion Washington, D.C,20535 J.P. Nadeau Boston,MA 02110 Town of Rye Alin 5, Rosenthal, Chairman 155 Washington Road Robert A. Backus, Esq.
P.O. Dox 710                     R.K. Gad !!, Esq.
2 Atonde Safety and Ltcensing Rp,NewIlampshire 03870 Bachs Meyer & Solomon 117 Lowell Street Appeal Board US NRC Senator Gordon J. Ilumphrey Manchester, Nil 03105 Washington D C 20555 US Senate Washington,D.C 20510 George Dana Bisbee, Esq.
Kenneth C Pagers North Itampton, bli 03826         Ropes it Gray
!!o*wro A WUber (Atta. Tom Durack)
      - Commissioner US Nuclear Regulaton Commiaion                                           225 Franklin Street Boston,MA 02110 Washington, D.C,20535                 J.P. Nadeau Town of Rye 155 Washington Road               Robert A. Backus, Esq.
2       Alin 5, Rosenthal, Chairman Rp,NewIlampshire 03870           Bachs Meyer & Solomon Atonde Safety and Ltcensing 117 Lowell Street Appeal Board                                                           Manchester, Nil 03105 US NRC                             ,
Senator Gordon J. Ilumphrey Washington D C 20555                   US Senate Washington,D.C 20510               George Dana Bisbee, Esq.
Geoffrey M. Iluntington, Esq.
Geoffrey M. Iluntington, Esq.
        !!o*wro A WUber                        (Atta. Tom Durack)
Office of the Attorney General Atomic Sa(ety and Ucensing Appeal Board Senator Goroon J. Ilumphrey StateIlouse Annex U.S. NRC 1 Eagle Square, Ste 507 Concor$ Nil 03301 Washington, D.C 20535 Concord,NII 0.401 Richard A. Ilampe. Esq.
Office of the Attorney General Atomic Sa(ety and Ucensing Senator Goroon J. Ilumphrey       StateIlouse Annex Appeal Board 1 Eagle Square, Ste 507           Concor$ Nil 03301 U.S. NRC Washington, D.C 20535                   Concord,NII 0.401 Richard A. Ilampe. Esq.
Sheldon J. Wolfe. Chairman Cahin A. Canney llampe and McNicholas Atomic Safety and ucensing Doard City Manager 35 Pleasant Street US Nuclear Regulatory Commission City 11:11 Concord,NII 03301 Washington, D C 20555 126 Daniel Street Portsmouth, Nil 03801 Gary W. llotmes, Esq.
Cahin A. Canney                   llampe and McNicholas Sheldon J. Wolfe. Chairman City Manager                     35 Pleasant Street Atomic Safety and ucensing Doard City 11:11 Concord,NII 03301 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission
llotmes & Ellis Dr. Ernmeth A. (mebke Atomk Safety and ucensing Doard Charles P Graham, Esq 47 Winnacunnent Road 5500 fnendship Doulenrd McKay, Murphy and Graham flampton, NII 03842 Apertment 1923N 100 Main Street Chevy Chase, MD 20815 Amesbury, MA 01913 Williva Armstrong Civd Defense Director Dr. Jerry llartar Alfred V.Sargent, Chairman 10 Front Street Atomic Safety and ucensing Board Coard of Selectmen Eseter, Nil 03833 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Tomit of Salisbury, MA 01950 Mrs. Anne E. Goodman Washington, D.C 20$35 Rep. Roberta C Pevear Daard of Selectmen Atomic Safety and ucenssng Drinksiter Road 1315 New Market Road Appeal Doard Panel flampton Falls, Nil 03M4 Durham, Nil 03842 US Nuclear Regulatory Comminion Walism S. tord. Selectman Washington, D C 20555 Phillip Ahrens Esq.
,        Washington, D C 20555                   126 Daniel Street Portsmouth, Nil 03801             Gary W. llotmes, Esq.
Ausstant Attorrey General Toen Hall-Fnend Street State llouse, Station #6 Amesbury, MA 01913 Augusta, MI! 04333 Jane Doughty Gregory A. Derry F2q.
llotmes & Ellis
SAPL Office of General Counsei 5 Market Street US Nucieat Regulatory Commission Portsmouth,NII 03801 Washington, D C 20535
;        Dr. Ernmeth A. (mebke Charles P Graham, Esq             47 Winnacunnent Road Atomk Safety and ucensing Doard McKay, Murphy and Graham         flampton, NII 03842 5500 fnendship Doulenrd
%}}
'        Apertment 1923N                         100 Main Street Amesbury, MA 01913               Williva Armstrong Chevy Chase, MD 20815 Civd Defense Director Alfred V.Sargent, Chairman       10 Front Street Dr. Jerry llartar                                                        Eseter, Nil 03833 Atomic Safety and ucensing Board       Coard of Selectmen US Nuclear Regulatory Commission       Tomit of Salisbury, MA 01950 Mrs. Anne E. Goodman Washington, D.C 20$35 Rep. Roberta C Pevear             Daard of Selectmen Drinksiter Road                   1315 New Market Road Atomic Safety and ucenssng                                                Durham, Nil 03842 Appeal Doard Panel                   flampton Falls, Nil 03M4 US Nuclear Regulatory Comminion Phillip Ahrens Esq.                Walism S. tord. Selectman Washington, D C 20555 Ausstant Attorrey General         Toen Hall- Fnend Street State llouse, Station #6           Amesbury, MA 01913 Augusta, MI! 04333 Jane Doughty Gregory A. Derry F2q.             SAPL Office of General Counsei         5 Market Street US Nucieat Regulatory Commission   Portsmouth,NII 03801 Washington, D C 20535
  %}}

Latest revision as of 02:16, 7 December 2024

Forwards Corrected First Page to New England Coalition on Nuclear Pollution 881102 Contentions on Applicant Decommissioning Plan,Motion for Stay of Low Power Operation & Motion to Reopen Record.Svc List Encl
ML20206C343
Person / Time
Site: Seabrook  
Issue date: 11/09/1988
From: Curran D
HARMON, CURRAN, SPIELBERG & EISENBERG, LLP., NEW ENGLAND COALITION ON NUCLEAR POLLUTION
To: Carr K, Curtiss J, Roberts T, Rogers K, Zech L
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
References
CON-#488-7482 CLI-88-08, CLI-88-8, OL-1, NUDOCS 8811160233
Download: ML20206C343 (3)
v • d • e


Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.

.f p rnnn v. UT(L FAC.ggg3[g.47[-/ -

nocKET NUfA DER

...reas------- -

0fM ii
0,

HARMON, CURRAN & TOUSLEY 2001

'88 NOV 14 A9:35 suirs 430 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20009 1125 GAIL McGREEVY HARMON Of f 'Cf. STELEPHONE '

DIANE CURRAN.

00CEE htao2) 328 3504 DEAN R. TouSLEY -

SF.MhPAX ANDREA C. PERSTER (202) 328-6918 ANNE SPIELBERG*

J Lando W.

Zech, Jr., Chairman Thomas M. Ro be r ts Kenneth M. Ca rt Kenneth C. Ro ge rs James R. Curtiss

Dear Commissioners:

On November 2,1988, pursuant to CLI-88-08, NECNP f iled with the Commission its "Contentions on Applicants' Decommissioning Plan, Motion for Stay of Low Power Operation, and Motion to Reopen the Re cord. "

He have since discovered that the pleading was incorrectly captioned as being before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board.

I have notified Docketing and Service of this

{

l error and am enclosing a corrected first page.

{

I apologize for any inconvenience caused by this error.

' n c e,r e ly,

f%

Diane Curran cc:

Seabrook service list 8811160233 001109 PDR ADOCK 05000443 0

PDR bss3 J

3

'o l lh

.r.

November 2, 1988 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE COMMISSION

)

In the Matter of

)')

Public Service Company of

)

New Hampshire, et al.

)

Docket Nos. 50-443 OL-1

)

50-444 OL-1 (Seabrook Station, Units 1 & 2)

)

ONSITE EMERGENCY

)

PLANNING & TECHNICAL

)

ISSUES NEW ENGLAND COALITION ON NUCLEAR POLLUTION'S CONTENTIONS ON APPLICANTS' DECOMMISUIONING PLAN, MOTION FOR STAY OF LOW PONER OPERATION, AND MOTION TO REOPEN THE RECORD I.

Introduction and Motion for Stav of Low Power ODeration The New England Coalition on Nuclear Pollution ("NECNP")

submits below its contentions regarding Applicants' plan for decommissioning the Seabrook reactor following low power opera-tion.

The contentions challenge the Applicants' decommissioning schedule, their estimates for the costs of decommissioning, and the lack of reasonable assurance that adequate funding will be available for decommissioning.

The issues raised in those contentions vividly underscore the fundamental folly of permitting Seabrook to operate at low power now, given the fact that the plant will not go to full power operation any timo soon, if at all.

In light of the very short time period necessary to test the reactor, there is no great bonofit to be gained from rushing ahead with low power u

operation.

On the other hand, the potential costs of low power operation are enormous -- millions of dollars in decontamination

I certify that on November 9, 1988,copiEdfo[theforegoing corrected page were served by first class mail" on' the following:

Atomic Safety and Licensing A!!en Lampert g y g 313 Hill-Whilton s

lando W. Zed Board Panel Civil Defense Dire LJgoufit, Clark. Ilill-Whdton Chairman US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Town of Brentomood and McGuire 79 State Street Exeter, NII 03833.g 9.,,g US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington,D.C 20555 MatthewT.Drock. -Q. Q, a),p;,Qeepuryport,MA 01 Washington, D.C 20555 p

Docketing and Service Branch Thomas M. Roberts US Nuclear Regulatory Commision Shaines & McEachern Diar's Sidebotham Comminioner Washington, D C 20555 P.O. Box 360 RFD # 2 Box 1260 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Maplewood Avenue Putney,VT 05346 Wuhirgton, D.C 20$$5 Michael Santosuosso, Chairman Portsmouth, NII 03801 Board of Selectmen

- J;mes R.Cu tas Jewell Street, RfD # 2 Sandra Gawris Comminioner South flampton, Nil 03842 RFD 1 Box 1154 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission East Kensington,NII 03827 Washington, D.C 20tSS Carol S. Sneider, Esquir' Diane Curran Anistant Attorney General Judith IL Mirner, Esq.

Kenneth M. Carr 1 Ashburton Place,19th Iloor Silverstate, Gertner,e at Commissioner Boston,MA 02108 88 Brood Street Boston,MA 02110 US Nuclear Regulato,.'ommission Washi;gton, D.C 20535 Starley W. Knowles Board of Selectmen Thomas G. Dignan, Esq.

Kenneth C Pagers P.O. Dox 710 R.K. Gad !!, Esq.

- Commissioner North Itampton, bli 03826 Ropes it Gray 225 Franklin Street US Nuclear Regulaton Commiaion Washington, D.C,20535 J.P. Nadeau Boston,MA 02110 Town of Rye Alin 5, Rosenthal, Chairman 155 Washington Road Robert A. Backus, Esq.

2 Atonde Safety and Ltcensing Rp,NewIlampshire 03870 Bachs Meyer & Solomon 117 Lowell Street Appeal Board US NRC Senator Gordon J. Ilumphrey Manchester, Nil 03105 Washington D C 20555 US Senate Washington,D.C 20510 George Dana Bisbee, Esq.

!!o*wro A WUber (Atta. Tom Durack)

Geoffrey M. Iluntington, Esq.

Office of the Attorney General Atomic Sa(ety and Ucensing Appeal Board Senator Goroon J. Ilumphrey StateIlouse Annex U.S. NRC 1 Eagle Square, Ste 507 Concor$ Nil 03301 Washington, D.C 20535 Concord,NII 0.401 Richard A. Ilampe. Esq.

Sheldon J. Wolfe. Chairman Cahin A. Canney llampe and McNicholas Atomic Safety and ucensing Doard City Manager 35 Pleasant Street US Nuclear Regulatory Commission City 11:11 Concord,NII 03301 Washington, D C 20555 126 Daniel Street Portsmouth, Nil 03801 Gary W. llotmes, Esq.

llotmes & Ellis Dr. Ernmeth A. (mebke Atomk Safety and ucensing Doard Charles P Graham, Esq 47 Winnacunnent Road 5500 fnendship Doulenrd McKay, Murphy and Graham flampton, NII 03842 Apertment 1923N 100 Main Street Chevy Chase, MD 20815 Amesbury, MA 01913 Williva Armstrong Civd Defense Director Dr. Jerry llartar Alfred V.Sargent, Chairman 10 Front Street Atomic Safety and ucensing Board Coard of Selectmen Eseter, Nil 03833 US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Tomit of Salisbury, MA 01950 Mrs. Anne E. Goodman Washington, D.C 20$35 Rep. Roberta C Pevear Daard of Selectmen Atomic Safety and ucenssng Drinksiter Road 1315 New Market Road Appeal Doard Panel flampton Falls, Nil 03M4 Durham, Nil 03842 US Nuclear Regulatory Comminion Walism S. tord. Selectman Washington, D C 20555 Phillip Ahrens Esq.

Ausstant Attorrey General Toen Hall-Fnend Street State llouse, Station #6 Amesbury, MA 01913 Augusta, MI! 04333 Jane Doughty Gregory A. Derry F2q.

SAPL Office of General Counsei 5 Market Street US Nucieat Regulatory Commission Portsmouth,NII 03801 Washington, D C 20535

%

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20206C343&oldid=4053334"