ML23283A250: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:September 2023 Revision 23A NAC-UMS Universal Storage System Fuel Rod Side Drop | {{#Wiki_filter:September 2023 Revision 23A NAC-UMS Universal Storage System | ||
Non-Proprietary Docket No. 72-1015 Atlanta Corporate Headquarters: 2 Sun Court, Peachtree Corners, Georgia 30092 USA Phone 770-447-1144, www.nacintl.com of ED20230124 Page 1 of 2 Enclosure 1 Supporting Calculations for the NAC-UMS Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015) | |||
NAC International September 2023 of ED20230124 Page 2 of 2 List of Calculations | Fuel Rod Side Drop Error Correction Evaluation (CAR 23-01) | ||
Non-Proprietary | |||
Docket No. 72-1015 | |||
Atlanta Corporate Headquarters: 2 Sun Court, Peachtree Corners, Georgia 30092 USA Phone 770-447-1144, www.nacintl.com of ED20230124 Page 1 of 2 | |||
Enclosure 1 | |||
Supporting Calculations | |||
for the | |||
NAC-UMS Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015) | |||
NAC International | |||
September 2023 of ED20230124 Page 2 of 2 | |||
List of Calculations | |||
: 1. 71160-2026, Revision 1 | : 1. 71160-2026, Revision 1 | ||
: 2. EA790-2519, Revision 0 | : 2. EA790-2519, Revision 0 | ||
: 3. EA790-2520, Revision 1 | : 3. EA790-2520, Revision 1 to ED20230124 Page 1 of 2 | ||
NAC International September 2023 to ED20230124 Page 2 of 2 List of Changes for the NAC-UMS FSAR, Revision 23A Chapter/Page/ | |||
Description of Change Figure/Table Note: | Enclosure 2 | ||
Chapters 1 thru 10 - no changes Chapter 11 Page 11.2.16-1 | |||
Pages 11.2.16-2 | List of FSAR Changes | ||
Modified text in the first paragraph of section 11.2.16.2 where Page 11.2.16-9 | |||
Modified text and embedded table starting with the third Page 11.2.16-10 | for the | ||
Pages 11.2.16-12 thru 11.2.16-13 | |||
Page 11.2.16-15 | NAC-UMS FSAR Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015) | ||
Page 11.3-5 | |||
Chapters 12 thru 13 - no changes to ED20230124 Page 1 of 1 Enclosure 3 FSAR Changed Pages and LOEP for the NAC-UMS Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015) | NAC International | ||
NAC International September 2023 | |||
September 2023 to ED20230124 Page 2 of 2 List of Changes for the NAC-UMS FSAR, Revision 23A | |||
Chapter/Page/ Source of Change: Description of Change Figure/Table | |||
Note: The List of Effective Pages and the Chapter Table of Contents, List of Figures and List of Tables have been revised accordingly to reflect the list of changes detailed below, if needed. | |||
Chapters 1 thru 10 - no changes Chapter 11 | |||
Page 11.2.16-1 Revision 23A Modified text in Sections 11.2.16 and 11.2.16.1 where indicated. | |||
Pages 11.2.16-2 Replaced text including figures and embedded tables in its thru 11.2.16-8 Revision 23A entirety where indicated. | |||
Modified text in the first paragraph of section 11.2.16.2 where Page 11.2.16-9 Revision 23A indicated. | |||
Modified text and embedded table starting with the third Page 11.2.16-10 Revision 23A paragraph of section 11.2.16.2 where indicated Replaced text including embedded tables in its entirety where Page 11.2.16-11 Revision 23A indicated. | |||
Pages 11.2.16-12 thru 11.2.16-13 Revision 23A Text flow changes.1 Page 11.2.16-14 Revision 23A Modified the figure heading and replaced Figure 11.2.16-6. | |||
Page 11.2.16-15 Revision 23A Text flow changes. | |||
Page 11.3-5 Revision 23A Added references 63 thru 35 where indicated. | |||
Chapters 12 thru 13 - no changes to ED20230124 Page 1 of 1 | |||
Enclosure 3 | |||
FSAR Changed Pages and LOEP | |||
for the | |||
NAC-UMS Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015) | |||
NAC International | |||
September 2023 September 2023 Revision 23A NAC-UMS Universal Storage System | |||
ANALYSIS REPORTFINAL SAFETY | |||
Non-Proprietary | |||
Docket No. 72-1015 | |||
Atlanta Corporate Headquarters: 2 Sun Court, Peachtree Corners, Georgia 30092 USA Phone 770-447-1144, www.nacintl.com | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages | |||
Chapter 1 1.5-4........................................ Revision 11 1-i.............................................. Revision 3 1.5-5.......................................... Revision 8 1-ii.......................................... Revision 10 1.5-6 thru 1.5-7......................... Revision 0 1-1............................................ Revision 0 1.5-8.......................................... Revision 6 1-2............................................ Revision 5 1.5-9........................................ Revision 13 1-3............................................ Revision 8 1.5-10........................................ Revision 0 1-4 thru 1-6............................. Revision 15 1.5-11........................................ Revision 3 1-7............................................ Revision 8 1.5-12 thru 1.5-16..................... Revision 0 1-8 thru 1-9............................. Revision 15 1.5-17........................................ Revision 3 1.1-1.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-18 thru 1.5-20..................... Revision 0 1.1-2.......................................... Revision 4 1.5-21........................................ Revision 6 1.1-3.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-22........................................ Revision 4 1.1-4.......................................... Revision 0 1.5-23 thru 1.5-26..................... Revision 0 1.2-1.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-27........................................ Revision 3 1.2-2........................................ Revision 15 1.5-28........................................ Revision 8 1.2-3........................................ Revision 16 1.5-29........................................ Revision 0 1.2-4.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-30........................................ Revision 8 1.2-5 thru 1.2-10..................... Revision 15 1.5-31 thru 1.5-32..................... Revision 0 1.2-11 thru 1.2-12..................... Revision 6 1.5-33........................................ Revision 3 1.2-13........................................ Revision 8 1.5-34........................................ Revision 5 1.2-14 thru 1.2-20..................... Revision 6 1.5-35........................................ Revision 0 1.2-21 thru 1.2-22................... Revision 16 1.5-36........................................ Revision 3 1.2-23........................................ Revision 6 1.5-37 thru 1.5-38................... Revision 10 1.2-24...................................... Revision 15 1.5-39 thru 1.5-43..................... Revision 0 1.2-25........................................ Revision 6 1.5-44........................................ Revision 8 1.2-26...................................... Revision 15 1.5-45 thru 1.5-46..................... Revision 0 1.2-27........................................ Revision 6 1.5-47........................................ Revision 3 1.2-28...................................... Revision 10 1.5-48........................................ Revision 8 1.2-29........................................ Revision 6 1.5-49 thru 1.5-54..................... Revision 0 1.3-1........................................ Revision 15 1.6-1.......................................... Revision 8 1.3-2.......................................... Revision 5 1.7-1.......................................... Revision 3 1.3-3.......................................... Revision 4 1.7-2 thru 1.7-3......................... Revision 4 1.4-1 thru 1.4-2......................... Revision 0 1.8-1........................................ Revision 16 1.5-1.......................................... Revision 0 1.8-2........................................ Revision 15 1.5-2........................................ Revision 11 1.5-3.......................................... Revision 0 32 drawings (see Section 1.8) 1 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
2.3-20...................................... Revision 15 Chapter 2 2.4-1.......................................... Revision 3 2-i............................................. Revision 3 2.4-2 thru 2.4-4......................... Revision 0 2-ii............................................. Revision 6 2.5-1 thru 2.5-2......................... Revision 3 2-iii............................................ Revision 3 2-iv.......................................... Revision 11 Chapter 3 2-1............................................. Revision 8 3-i........................................... Revision 16 2-2........................................... Revision 15 3-ii........................................... Revision 15 2-3............................................. Revision 3 3-iii thru 3-v.............................. Revision 3 2.1-1........................................ Revision 15 3-vi.......................................... Revision 16 2.1.1-1 thru 2.1.1-4................... Revision 8 3-vii thru 3-viii.......................... Revision 3 2.1.2-1 thru 2.1.2-2................. Revision 15 3.1-1 thru 3.1-2......................... Revision 3 2.1.2-3....................................... Revision 8 3.1-3........................................ Revision 16 2.1.3-1 thru 2.1.3-4................... Revision 8 3.1-4 thru 3.1-7......................... Revision 3 2.1.3-5....................................... Revision 3 3.2-1.......................................... Revision 0 2.1.3-6....................................... Revision 8 3.2-2.......................................... Revision 3 2.1.3-7 thru 2.1.3-8................... Revision 3 3.2-3 thru 3.2-4....................... Revision 15 2.1.3-9....................................... Revision 5 3.3-1........................................ Revision 16 2.1.3-10 thru 2.1.3-14............... Revision 3 3.3-2 thru 3.3-15....................... Revision 3 2.2-1..................................... Amendment 1 3.3-16 thru 3.3-18................... Revision 16 2.2-2 thru 2.2-3......................... Revision 0 3.4.1-1.................................. Amendment 2 2.2-4.......................................... Revision 5 3.4.1-2....................................... Revision 4 2.2-5.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.1-3..................................... Revision 16 2.2-6 thru 2.2-10....................... Revision 0 3.4.1-4.................................. Amendment 2 2.2-11........................................ Revision 3 3.4.1-5....................................... Revision 3 2.3-1 thru 2.3-2....................... Revision 11 3.4.1-6 thru 3.4.1-8................... Revision 4 2.3-3 thru 2.3-4......................... Revision 3 3.4.1-9..................................... Revision 11 2.3-5 thru 2.3-8....................... Revision 15 3.4.1-10 thru 3.4.1-12............... Revision 3 2.3-9.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.2-1....................................... Revision 8 2.3-10........................................ Revision 0 3.4.2-2....................................... Revision 4 2.3-11........................................ Revision 5 3.4.3-1....................................... Revision 4 2.3-12...................................... Revision 11 3.4.3-2 thru 3.4.3-3................... Revision 3 2.3-13...................................... Revision 15 3.4.3-4....................................... Revision 0 2.3-14 thru 2.3-15................... Revision 11 3.4.3-5 thru 3.4.3-22................. Revision 3 2.3-16 thru 2.3-17................... Revision 15 3.4.3-23 thru 3.4.3-26............... Revision 6 2.3-18 thru 2.3-19................... Revision 11 3.4.3-27..................................... Revision 3 2 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
3.4.3-28..................................... Revision 4 4.1-2 thru 4.1-3......................... Revision 8 3.4.3-29 thru 3.4.3-98............... Revision 3 4.1-4.......................................... Revision 0 3.4.4-1....................................... Revision 0 4.1-5.......................................... Revision 4 3.4.4-2 thru 3.4.4-7................... Revision 3 4.1-6 thru 4.1-7....................... Revision 16 3.4.4-8 thru 3.4.4-19............... Revision 16 4.1-8.......................................... Revision 5 3.4.4-20..................................... Revision 3 4.2-1.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.4-21 thru 3.4.4-38............... Revision 0 4.2-2........................................ Revision 16 3.4.4-39 thru 3.4.4-48............... Revision 3 4.2-3.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.4-49 thru 3.4.4-51............... Revision 0 4.2-4.......................................... Revision 0 3.4.4-52 thru 3.4.4-64............... Revision 3 4.2-5.......................................... Revision 4 3.4.4-65..................................... Revision 0 4.2-6.......................................... Revision 0 3.4.4-66 thru 3.4.4-69............... Revision 3 4.2-7.......................................... Revision 7 3.4.4-70 thru 3.4.4-74............... Revision 0 4.3-1 thru 4.3-3......................... Revision 3 3.4.4-75 thru 3.4.4-77............... Revision 3 4.4-1........................................ Revision 16 3.4.5-1....................................... Revision 3 4.4.1-1....................................... Revision 3 3.5-1.......................................... Revision 4 4.4.1-2..................................... Revision 15 3.6-1.......................................... Revision 8 4.4.1-3....................................... Revision 7 3.6-2.......................................... Revision 4 4.4.1-4 thru 4.4.1-6................... Revision 0 3.6-3.......................................... Revision 8 4.4.1-7..................................... Revision 15 3.6-4 thru 3.6-5......................... Revision 3 4.4.1-8.................................. Amendment 2 3.6-6..................................... Amendment 1 4.4.1-9....................................... Revision 5 3.6-7 thru 3.6-8......................... Revision 3 4.4.1-10 thru 4.4.1-17............... Revision 3 3.7-1 thru 3.7-2......................... Revision 3 4.4.1-18................................... Revision 15 3.7-3 thru 3.7-4......................... Revision 8 4.4.1-19 thru 4.4.1-22............... Revision 3 3.8-1........................................ Revision 11 4.4.1-23................................... Revision 15 3.8-2 thru 3.8-20....................... Revision 9 4.4.1-24................................... Revision 16 3.8-21 thru 3.8-26................... Revision 11 4.4.1-25 thru 4.4.1-26............... Revision 3 3.9-1 thru 3.9-17..................... Revision 15 4.4.1-27..................................... Revision 4 4.4.1-28................................... Revision 16 Chapter 4 4.4.1-29..................................... Revision 3 4-i thru 4-ii............................... Revision 3 4.4.1-30..................................... Revision 4 4-iii.......................................... Revision 15 4.4.1-31 thru 4.4.1-34............... Revision 3 4-iv............................................ Revision 3 4.4.1-35................................... Revision 15 4-v.......................................... Revision 15 4.4.1-36..................................... Revision 3 4-vi............................................ Revision 8 4.4.1-37................................... Revision 16 4.1-1.......................................... Revision 3 4.4.1-38................................... Revision 15 3 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
4.4.1-39 thru 4.4.1-40............... Revision 3 5-ii........................................... Revision 15 4.4.1-41 thru 4.4.1-43............... Revision 4 5-iii............................................ Revision 8 4.4.1-44 thru 4.4.1-49............... Revision 3 5-iv............................................ Revision 3 4.4.2-1....................................... Revision 0 5-v........................................... Revision 15 4.4.3-1 thru 4.4.3-5................. Revision 16 5-vi thru 5-viii........................... Revision 8 4.4.3-6 thru 4.4.3-9................... Revision 3 5-ix thru 5-x............................ Revision 15 4.4.3-10................................... Revision 16 5.1-1........................................ Revision 12 4.4.3-11 thru 4.4.3-13............... Revision 3 5.1-2 thru 5.1-12....................... Revision 7 4.4.3-14 thru 4.4.3-15............... Revision 5 5.2-1 thru 5.2-36....................... Revision 8 4.4.3-16 thru 4.4.3-18............. Revision 16 5.3-1 thru 5.3-10....................... Revision 3 4.4.3-19 thru 4.4.3-20............... Revision 3 5.3-11 thru 5.3-12..................... Revision 4 4.4.3-21 thru 4.4.3-22............. Revision 16 5.3-13 thru 5.3-21..................... Revision 3 4.4.4-1....................................... Revision 0 5.3-22 thru 5.3-23..................... Revision 4 4.4.5-1....................................... Revision 8 5.3-24........................................ Revision 3 4.4.5-2 thru 4.4.5-3................. Revision 16 5.3-25 thru 5.3-26..................... Revision 4 4.4.5-4....................................... Revision 8 5.3-27 thru 5.3-32..................... Revision 3 4.4.5-5..................................... Revision 15 5.4-1 thru 5.4-4......................... Revision 3 4.4.6-1....................................... Revision 0 5.4-5.......................................... Revision 7 4.4.7-1....................................... Revision 3 5.4-6 thru 5.4-27....................... Revision 3 4.5-1.......................................... Revision 5 5.5-1.......................................... Revision 8 4.5-2 thru 4.5-3......................... Revision 4 5.5-2.......................................... Revision 3 4.5-4..................................... Amendment 2 5.5-3 thru 5.5-4......................... Revision 7 4.5-5.......................................... Revision 3 5.5-5 thru 5.5-7......................... Revision 3 4.5-6.......................................... Revision 4 5.5-8 thru 5.5-10....................... Revision 8 4.5-7.......................................... Revision 3 5.6-1..................................... Amendment 1 4.5-8.......................................... Revision 8 5.6.1-1....................................... Revision 4 4.5-9 thru 4.5-10....................... Revision 3 5.6.1-2.................................. Amendment 1 4.5-11 thru 4.5-16................ Amendment 2 5.6.1-3....................................... Revision 4 4.5-17........................................ Revision 7 5.6.1-4.................................. Amendment 1 4.5-18 thru 4.5-19..................... Revision 3 5.6.1-5....................................... Revision 4 4.6-1 thru 4.6-2......................... Revision 3 5.6.1-6 thru 5.6.1-8................... Revision 3 4.6-3.......................................... Revision 0 5.6.1-9 thru 5.6.1-10............ Amendment 1 4.6-4.......................................... Revision 8 5.6.1-11 thru 5.6.1-12............... Revision 8 5.6.1-13 thru 5.6.1-22.......... Amendment 2 Chapter 5 5.6.1-23 thru 5.6.1-24............... Revision 3 5-i............................................. Revision 8 5.6.1-25................................ Amendment 2 4 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
5.6.1-26 thru 5.6.1-27............... Revision 3 6.6.1-8....................................... Revision 3 5.6.1-28 thru 5.6.1-34.......... Amendment 2 6.6.1-9 thru 6.6.1-10............ Amendment 2 5.7-1 thru 5.7-2......................... Revision 0 6.6.1-11..................................... Revision 8 5.7-3.......................................... Revision 8 6.6.1-12 thru 6.6.1-14.......... Amendment 2 5.8-1........................................ Revision 15 6.6.1-15..................................... Revision 4 5.8.1-1 thru 5.8.1-4................. Revision 15 6.6.1-16 thru 6.6.1-21.......... Amendment 2 5.8.2-1 thru 5.8.2-15............... Revision 15 6.6.1-22..................................... Revision 3 5.8.3-1 thru 5.8.3-6................. Revision 15 6.6.1-23 thru 6.6.1-24.......... Amendment 2 6.7-1 thru 6.7-31..................... Revision 15 Chapter 6 6.8-1 thru 6.8-2....................... Revision 15 6-i........................................... Revision 3 6.9-1 thru 6.8-66..................... Revision 15 6-ii thru 6-x............................. Revision 15 6.1-1 thru 6.1-2......................... Revision 8 Chapter 7 6.1-3 thru 6.1-7....................... Revision 15 7-i thru 7-ii................................ Revision 4 6.2-1.......................................... Revision 5 7.1-1 thru 7.1-2......................... Revision 8 6.2-2 thru 6.2-3......................... Revision 3 7.1-3.......................................... Revision 4 6.3-1 thru 6.3-2......................... Revision 3 7.1-4.......................................... Revision 8 6.3-3........................................ Revision 10 7.1-5.......................................... Revision 4 6.3-4 thru 6.3-6......................... Revision 3 7.1-6.......................................... Revision 8 6.3-7.......................................... Revision 7 7.1-7 thru 7.1-9......................... Revision 4 6.3-8.......................................... Revision 4 7.2-1.......................................... Revision 3 6.3-9 thru 6.3-18....................... Revision 3 7.2-2.......................................... Revision 8 6.4-1.......................................... Revision 4 7.3-1.......................................... Revision 8 6.4-2 thru 6.4-13....................... Revision 3 7.4-1.......................................... Revision 8 6.4-14 thru 6.4-15................... Revision 15 7.5-1.......................................... Revision 4 6.4-16........................................ Revision 3 6.4-17........................................ Revision 0 Chapter 8 6.4-18 thru 6.4-40..................... Revision 3 8-i........................................ Amendment 1 6.5-1........................................ Revision 15 8-ii............................................. Revision 5 6.5-2 thru 6.5-49....................... Revision 3 8-1 thru 8-2............................... Revision 5 6.5-50 thru 65-81.................... Revision 15 8.1-1.......................................... Revision 8 6.6-1..................................... Amendment 2 8.1.1-1....................................... Revision 8 6.6.1-1 thru 6.6.1-2................... Revision 8 8.1.1-2....................................... Revision 5 6.6.1-3.................................. Amendment 2 8.1.1-3....................................... Revision 4 6.6.1-4....................................... Revision 4 8.1.1-4 thru 8.1.1-7................... Revision 8 6.6.1-5 thru 6.6.1-7................... Revision 8 8.1.1-8 thru 8.1.1-10................. Revision 5 5 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
8.1.1-11..................................... Revision 6 10.5-1................................... Amendment 1 8.1.2-1 thru 8.1.2-2................... Revision 8 10.6-1 thru 10.6-3................... Revision 15 8.1.3-1 thru 8.1.3-2................... Revision 8 10.7-1...................................... Revision 15 8.2-1.......................................... Revision 6 8.2-2.......................................... Revision 5 Chapter 11 8.3-1.......................................... Revision 4 11-i....................................... Amendment 1 8.3-2 thru 8.3-4......................... Revision 3 11-ii........................................... Revision 3 8.4-1.......................................... Revision 0 11-iii.......................................... Revision 5 11-iv..................................... Revision 23A Chapter 9 11-v........................................... Revision 3 9-i thru 9-ii.............................. Revision 15 11-vi..................................... Revision 23A 9.1-1.......................................... Revision 4 11-vii thru 11-x......................... Revision 3 9.1-2.......................................... Revision 8 11-1........................................... Revision 0 9.1-3.......................................... Revision 4 11.1.1-1..................................... Revision 6 9.1-4.......................................... Revision 5 11.1.1-2..................................... Revision 3 9.1-5.......................................... Revision 4 11.1.1-3 thru 11.1.1-6............... Revision 0 9.1-6........................................ Revision 10 11.1.2-1..................................... Revision 6 9.1-7 thru 9.1-20..................... Revision 15 11.1.2-2..................................... Revision 0 9.2-1.......................................... Revision 7 11.1.2-3..................................... Revision 3 9.2-2.......................................... Revision 9 11.1.3-1..................................... Revision 3 9.2-3.......................................... Revision 7 11.1.3-2 thru -11.1.3-3............ Revision 12 9.3-1.......................................... Revision 8 11.1.3-4 thru -11.1.3-16............ Revision 3 9.3-2.......................................... Revision 5 11.1.4-1 thru 11.1.4-2............... Revision 6 11.1.5-1 thru 11.1.5-2............... Revision 0 Chapter 10 11.1.6-1................................ Amendment 1 10-i thru 10-ii.......................... Revision 15 11.2-1................................... Amendment 1 10.1-1........................................ Revision 3 11.2.1-1 thru 11.2.1-7............... Revision 3 10.1-2........................................ Revision 6 11.2.2-1..................................... Revision 8 10.2-1 thru 10.2-2................... Revision 15 11.2.3-1..................................... Revision 3 10.3-1 thru 10.3-3................... Revision 15 11.2.3-2..................................... Revision 0 10.3-4........................................ Revision 0 11.2.4-1 thru 11.2.4-11............. Revision 3 10.3-5 thru 10.3-6..................... Revision 3 11.2.4-12................................. Revision 13 10.3-7........................................ Revision 0 11.2.4-13 thru 11.2.4-21........... Revision 0 10.3-8 thru 10.3-9..................... Revision 3 1.2.4-22 thru 11.2.4-24............. Revision 3 10.4-1 thru 10.4-2................... Revision 15 11.2.4-25................................... Revision 7 10.4-3 thru 10.4-5..................... Revision 3 11.2.4-26 thru 11.2.4-27........... Revision 3 6 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
11.2.5-1..................................... Revision 0 11.2.12-22................................. Revision 3 11.2.6-1 thru 11.2.6-2............... Revision 3 11.2.12-23................................. Revision 0 11.2.6-3................................... Revision 13 11.2.12-24 thru 11.2.12-70....... Revision 3 11.2.6-4..................................... Revision 0 11.2.12-71............................... Revision 13 11.2.6-5..................................... Revision 3 11.2.13-1................................... Revision 6 11.2.7-1................................... Revision 16 11.2.13-2................................. Revision 13 11.2.7-2..................................... Revision 3 11.2.13-3................................... Revision 0 11.2.8-1..................................... Revision 5 11.2.14-1................................... Revision 8 11.2.8-2..................................... Revision 0 11.2.14-2................................... Revision 3 11.2.8-3 thru 11.2.8-5............... Revision 3 11.2.15-1 thru 11.2.15-2........... Revision 3 11.2.8-6..................................... Revision 5 11.2.15-3.............................. Amendment 1 11.2.8-7..................................... Revision 3 11.2.15-4.............................. Amendment 2 11.2.8-8 thru 11.2.8-10............. Revision 5 11.2.15-5 thru 11.2.15-6........... Revision 8 11.2.8-11 thru 11.2.8-12......... Revision 13 11.2.15-7 thru 11.2.15-13.... Amendment 1 11.2.9-1..................................... Revision 0 11.2.15-14 thru 11.2.15-17....... Revision 3 11.2.9-2 thru11.2.9-4................ Revision 3 11.2.15-18 thru 11.2.15-22.. Amendment 1 11.2.9-5................................... Revision 13 11.2.15-23 thru 11.2.15-24.. Amendment 2 11.2.9-6 thru 11.2.9-7............... Revision 3 11.2.15-25................................. Revision 4 11.2.10-1 thru 11.2.10-3........... Revision 0 11.2.15-26............................ Amendment 2 11.2.10-4................................. Revision 13 11.2.15-27............................ Amendment 1 11.2.11-1................................... Revision 0 11.2.15-28............................ Amendment 2 11.2.11-2 thru 11.2.11-4........... Revision 3 11.2.15-29................................. Revision 4 11.2.11-5 thru 11.2.11-7........... Revision 0 11.2.15-30 thru 11.2.15-31....... Revision 3 11.2.11-8 thru 11.2.11-11......... Revision 3 11.2.15-32................................. Revision 4 11.2.11-12................................. Revision 0 11.2.15-33 thru 11.2.15-35.. Amendment 2 11.2.11-13............................... Revision 13 11.2.16-1 thru 11.2.16-15.... Revision 23A 11.2.11-14................................. Revision 3 11.3-1........................................ Revision 3 11.2.12-1................................... Revision 0 11.3-2 thru 11.3-3..................... Revision 0 11.2.12-2................................... Revision 7 11.3-4........................................ Revision 3 11.2.12-3 thru 11.2.12-10......... Revision 3 11.3-5................................... Revision 23A 11.2.12-11 thru 11.2.12-12....... Revision 0 11.2.12-13 thru 11.2.12-14....... Revision 3 Chapter 12 11.2.12-15 thru 11.2.12-17..... Revision 12 12-i thru 12-ii....................... Amendment 1 11.2.12-18................................. Revision 0 12-1........................................... Revision 5 11.2.12-19 thru 11.2.12-20....... Revision 3 12-2 thru 12-3........................... Revision 8 11.2.12-21................................. Revision 0 12-4......................................... Revision 15 7 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
List of Effective Pages (continued) | |||
12A-1 thru 12A-2...................... Revision 3 12B-1 thru12B-2....................... Revision 3 12C-1......................................... Revision 0 12C-2......................................... Revision 8 12C1-1....................................... Revision 3 12C2-1....................................... Revision 8 12C2-2....................................... Revision 3 12C3-1 thru 12C3-8.................. Revision 0 12C3-9 thru 12C3-28................ Revision 8 12C3-29 thru 12C3-30............ Revision 13 12C3-31................................... Revision 14 12C3-32 thru 12C3-34.............. Revision 8 12C3-35 thru 12C3-37............ Revision 13 12C3-38 thru 12C3-40.............. Revision 8 | |||
Chapter 13 13-i thru 13-ii............................ Revision 0 13.1-1 thru 13.2-7..................... Revision 0 13.2-8........................................ Revision 3 13.3-1...................................... Revision 10 | |||
8 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System October 2005 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 5 | |||
Table of Contents (Continued) | |||
11.2.6.4 Corrective Actions................................................................................... 11.2.6-3 11.2.6.5 Radiological Impact................................................................................ 11.2.6-3 11.2.7 Maximum Anticipated Heat Load (133F Ambient Temperature)....................... 11.2.7-1 1.2.7.1 Cause of Maximum Anticipated Heat Load............................................. 11.2.7-1 11.2.7.2 Detection of Maximum Anticipated Heat Load...................................... 11.2.7-1 11.2.7.3 Analysis of Maximum Anticipated Heat Load....................................... 11.2.7-1 11.2.7.4 Corrective Actions................................................................................... 11.2.7-2 11.2.7.5 Radiological Impact................................................................................ 11.2.7-2 11.2.8 Earthquake Event.................................................................................................... 11.2.8-1 11.2.8.1 Cause of the Earthquake Event............................................................... 11.2.8-1 11.2.8.2 Earthquake Event Analysis..................................................................... 11.2.8-1 11.2.8.3 Corrective Actions.................................................................................11.2.8-11 11.2.8.4 Radiological Impact..............................................................................11.2.8-11 11.2.9 Flood....................................................................................................................... 11.2.9-1 11.2.9.1 Cause of Flood......................................................................................... 11.2.9-1 11.2.9.2 Analysis of Flood.................................................................................... 11.2.9-1 11.2.9.3 Corrective Actions................................................................................... 11.2.9-5 11.2.9.4 Radiological Impact................................................................................ 11.2.9-5 11.2.10 Lightning Strike..................................................................................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.1 Cause of Lightning Strike....................................................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.2 Detection of Lightning Strike..............................................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.3 Analysis of the Lightning Strike Event...............................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.4 Corrective Actions...............................................................................11.2.10-4 11.2.10.5 Radiological Impact............................................................................11.2.10-4 11.2.11 Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles...............................................................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.1 Cause of Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles................................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.2 Detection of Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles..........................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.3 Analysis of Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles............................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.4 Corrective Actions............................................................................ 11.2.11-13 11.2.11.5 Radiological Impact......................................................................... 11.2.11-13 11.2.12 Tip-Over of Vertical Concrete Cask...................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.1 Cause of Cask Tip-Over......................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.2 Detection of Cask Tip-Over................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.3 Analysis of Cask Tip-Over..................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.4 Analysis of Canister and Basket for Cask Tip-Over Event............. 11.2.12-11 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11-iii FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | ||
Table of Contents (Continued) | |||
11.2.12.5 Corrective Actions............................................................................ 11.2.12-71 11.2.12.6 Radiological Impact......................................................................... 11.2.12-71 11.2.13 Full Blockage of Vertical Concrete Cask Air Inlets and Outlets.......................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.1 Cause of Full Blockage.......................................................................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.2 Detection of Full Blockage..................................................................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.3 Analysis of Full Blockage...................................................................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.4 Corrective Actions...............................................................................11.2.13-2 11.2.13.5 Radiological Impact............................................................................11.2.13-2 11.2.14 Canister Closure Weld Evaluation.....................................................................11.2.14-1 11.2.15 Accident and Natural Phenomena Events Evaluation for Site Specific Spent Fuel...........................................................................................................11.2.15-1 11.2.15.1 Accident and Natural Phenomena Events Evaluation for Maine Yankee Site Specific Spent Fuel.........................................................11.2.15-1 11.2.16 Fuel Rods Structural Evaluation for Burnup to 60,000 MWd/MTU.................11.2.16-1 11.2.16.1 PWR Fuel Rod Evaluation..................................................................11.2.16-1 11.2.16.2 BWR Fuel Rod Evaluation.................................................................11.2.16-9 11.2.16.3 Thermal Evaluation of Fuel Rods.................................................... 11.2.16-15 11.3 References............................................................................................................................ 11.3-1 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11-iv FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System March 2004 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 3 | ||
List of Figures | |||
Figure 11.1.1-1 Concrete Temperature (°F) for Off-Normal Storage Condition 106F Ambient Temperature (PWR Fuel)........................................... 11.1.1-3 Figure 11.1.1-2 Vertical Concrete Cask Air Temperature (°F) Profile for Off-Normal Storage Condition 106F Ambient Temperature (PWR) | |||
Fuel)...................................................................................................... 11.1.1-4 Figure 11.1.1-3 Concrete Temperature (°F) for Off-Normal Storage Condition -40F Ambient Temperature (PWR Fuel)........................... 11.1.1-5 Figure 11.1.1-4 Vertical Concrete Cask Air Temperature (°F) Profile for Off-Normal Storage Condition -40F Ambient Temperature (PWR Fuel)...................................................................................................... 11.1.1-6 Figure 11.1.3.1-1 Canister and Basket Finite Element Model.......................................... 11.1.3-4 Figure 11.2.4-1 Concrete Cask Base Weldment..........................................................11.2.4-13 Figure 11.2.4-2 Concrete Cask Base Weldment Finite Element Model......................11.2.4-14 Figure 11.2.4-3 Strain Rate Dependent Stress-Strain Curves for Concrete Cask Base Weldment Structural Steel.........................................................11.2.4-15 Figure 11.2.4-4 Acceleration Time-History of the Canister Bottom During the Concrete Cask 24-Inch Drop Accident With Static Strain Properties.............................................................................................11.2.4-16 Figure 11.2.4-5 Acceleration Time-History of the Canister Bottom During the Concrete Cask 24-Inch Drop Accident With Strain Rate Dependent Properties..........................................................................11.2.4-17 Figure 11.2.4-6 Quarter Model of the PWR Basket Support Disk..............................11.2.4-18 Figure 11.2.4-7 Quarter Model of the BWR Basket Support Disk..............................11.2.4-19 Figure 11.2.4-8 Canister Finite Element Model for 60g Bottom End Impact.............11.2.4-20 Figure 11.2.4-9 Identification of the Canister Sections for the Evaluation of Canister Stresses due to a 60g Bottom End Impact............................11.2.4-21 Figure 11.2.6-1 Temperature Boundary Condition Applied to the Nodes of the Inlet for the Fire Accident Condition.................................................... 11.2.6-4 Figure 11.2.11-1 Principal Dimensions and Moment Arms Used in Tornado Evaluation....................................................................................... 11.2.11-14 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-1 Basket Drop Orientations Analyzed for Tip-Over Conditions - | |||
PWR................................................................................................. 11.2.12-27 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-2 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - PWR....................... 11.2.12-28 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-3 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Canister.................. 11.2.12-29 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-4 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Support Disk - | |||
PWR................................................................................................. 11.2.12-30 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11-v FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | ||
List of Figures (Continued) | |||
Figure 11.2.12.4.1-5 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Support Disk Loading - PWR................................................................................ 11.2.12-31 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-6 Canister Section Stress Locations.................................................... 11.2.12-32 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-7 Support Disk Section Stress Locations - PWR - Full Model......... 11.2.12-33 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-8 PWR - 109.7 Hz Mode Shape......................................................... 11.2.12-34 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-9 PWR - 370.1 Hz Mode Shape......................................................... 11.2.12-35 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-10 PWR - 371.1 Hz Mode Shape......................................................... 11.2.12-36 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-1 Fuel Basket Drop Orientations Analyzed for Tip-Over Condition - BWR............................................................................. 11.2.12-54 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-2 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - BWR....................... 11.2.12-55 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-3 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Support Disk - BWR...................................................................................... 11.2.12-56 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-4 Support Disk Section Stress Locations - BWR - Full Model.......... 11.2.12-57 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-5 BWR - 79.3 Hz Mode Shape.......................................................... 11.2.12-58 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-6 BWR - 80.2 Hz Mode Shape.......................................................... 11.2.12-59 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-7 BWR - 210.9 Hz Mode Shape........................................................ 11.2.12-60 Figure 11.2.13-1 PWR Configuration Temperature HistoryAll Vents Blocked.......11.2.13-3 Figure 11.2.13-2 BWR Configuration Temperature HistoryAll Vents Blocked.......11.2.13-3 Figure 11.2.15.1.2-1 Two-Dimensional Support Disk Model.............................................11.2.15-9 Figure 11.2.15.1.2-2 PWR Basket Impact Orientations and Case Study Loading Positions for Maine Yankee Consolidated Fuel.............................. 11.2.15-10 Figure 11.2.15.1.5-1 Two-Dimensional Beam Finite Element Model for Maine Yankee Fuel Rod.............................................................................. 11.2.15-27 Figure 11.2.15.1.5-2 Mode Shape and First Buckling Shape for the Maine Yankee Fuel Rod........................................................................................... 11.2.15-28 Figure 11.2.15.1.6-1 Two-Dimensional Beam Finite Element Model for a Fuel Rod with a Missing Grid.......................................................................... 11.2.15-34 Figure 11.2.15.1.6-2 Modal Shape and First Buckling Mode Shape for a Fuel Rod with a Missing Grid.......................................................................... 11.2.15-35 Figure 11.2.16-1 Overall Model Plot for a Typical PWR Fuel Assembly....................11.2.16-6 Figure 11.2.16-2 Detailed View of the PWR 14x14 Fuel Assembly Model................11.2.16-7 Figure 11.2-16-3 ANSYS Model for the PWR Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation............11.2.16-8 Figure 11.2.16-4 Overall Model Plot for a Typical BWR Fuel Assembly................. 11.2.16-12 Figure 11.2.16-5 Detailed View of the BWR 10x10 Fuel Assembly Model............. 11.2.16-13 Figure 11.2.16-6 ANSYS Model for the BWR Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation......... 11.2.16-14 | |||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11-vi FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | ||
11.2.16 Fuel Rods Structural Evaluation for Burnup to 62,500 MWd/MTU | |||
This section presents a structural evaluation of PWR and BWR fuel rods with a maximum burnup of 62,500 MWd/MTU for normal and accident conditions of storage. | |||
During normal and off-normal conditions for the fuel in the canister, the loads applied to the fuel assembly are minimal and do not require further evaluation. The only significant axial loading the fuel assembly will experience is the 24-inch drop of the vertical concrete cask. The bounding lateral loading on the fuel assembly occurs during the tip-over accident condition. As presented in Section 11.2.16.1, the lateral loading and axial loading conditions are evaluated for PWR fuel rods considering a bounding configuration of a grid spacer missing for an unsupported fuel rod length up to 60 inches. Based on results of the drop analysis presented in the following sections, PWR fuel assemblies with one or more grid spacers missing or damaged for an unsupported fuel rod length up to 60 inches are, therefore, considered to be undamaged assemblies for loading within the UMS Universal Storage System. Section 11.2.16.2 presents the evaluation for the BWR fuel rods for the end drop and tip-over accident events. | During normal and off-normal conditions for the fuel in the canister, the loads applied to the fuel assembly are minimal and do not require further evaluation. The only significant axial loading the fuel assembly will experience is the 24-inch drop of the vertical concrete cask. The bounding lateral loading on the fuel assembly occurs during the tip-over accident condition. As presented in Section 11.2.16.1, the lateral loading and axial loading conditions are evaluated for PWR fuel rods considering a bounding configuration of a grid spacer missing for an unsupported fuel rod length up to 60 inches. Based on results of the drop analysis presented in the following sections, PWR fuel assemblies with one or more grid spacers missing or damaged for an unsupported fuel rod length up to 60 inches are, therefore, considered to be undamaged assemblies for loading within the UMS Universal Storage System. Section 11.2.16.2 presents the evaluation for the BWR fuel rods for the end drop and tip-over accident events. | ||
11.2.16.1 | |||
11.2.16.1 PWR Fuel Rod Evaluation | |||
End Drop Evaluation This section presents the buckling evaluation for the UMS Universal Storage System high burnup PWR fuel rods (peak rod average burnup of 62.5 GWd/MTU). In order to account for the cladding oxide layer, a conservative 120-micron thick layer is assumed to be removed from the reference clad in the rod structural evaluation. The 120-micron clad removal is conservative, as this value represents double the maximum oxide layer thickness listed for end-of-life PWR fuel rods in PNL-4835[62]. Applying a time-dependent oxide layer growth approximation to the PNL-4835-reported maximum thickness of 60 microns to account for an increase in burnup from standard (45 GWd/MTU) to high (62.5 GWd/MTU) yields a maximum end-of-life oxide layer in the range of 90 microns. As high burnup claddings are designed to reduce oxidation, actual layers are expected to be significantly lower (reported as low as 20 microns for >70 GWd/MTU M5 zircaloy clad). Therefore, a significant margin exists to the evaluated oxide layer levels. | |||
A 24-inch end drop of the concrete cask subjects the fuel rods to axial loading. The analyses in this section show that the maximum stresses in the high burnup PWR fuel remain below the yield strength in the design basis accident events and confirm that the fuel rods will return to their original configuration following the end drop event. | A 24-inch end drop of the concrete cask subjects the fuel rods to axial loading. The analyses in this section show that the maximum stresses in the high burnup PWR fuel remain below the yield strength in the design basis accident events and confirm that the fuel rods will return to their original configuration following the end drop event. | ||
NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal | 11.2.16-1 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | ||
11.2.16-2 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | |||
11.2.16-3 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | |||
Margin of Safety Against Case Maximum Stress Intensity (ksi) Yield Strength 1 25.4 +1.93 2 21.8 +2.41 3 41.9 +0.77 4 34.7 +1.14 | |||
The case using the 60-inch spacing in conjunction with the minimal cross-section (Case 3) is identified as the bounding case. All stresses were shown to be less than the yield strength. | |||
The results confirm that high burnup PWR fuel with a maximum distance of 60 inches from the bottom to the first grid will remain structurally adequate for the storage design basis cask end drop load conditions. | The results confirm that high burnup PWR fuel with a maximum distance of 60 inches from the bottom to the first grid will remain structurally adequate for the storage design basis cask end drop load conditions. | ||
Tip-Over Evaluation 11.2.16-4 | Tip-Over Evaluation | ||
11.2.16-4 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | |||
Stresses are evaluated against the cladding yield stress at a bounding fuel temperature of 752°F (400°C) to compute margins of safety. The minimum margins of safety in the three cladding materials all occur in the BW17x17 Mark C fuel rod and are summa rized in the following table. | |||
Therefore, the PWR high burnup fuel rods remain structurally adequate during the cask tip-over accident event. | Therefore, the PWR high burnup fuel rods remain structurally adequate during the cask tip-over accident event. | ||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11.2.16-5 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | ||
Figure 11.2.16-1 Overall Model Plot for a Typical PWR Fuel Assembly | |||
See Figure 11.2.16-2 for PWR 14x14 Fuel Assembly Model | |||
11.2.16-6 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
Figure 11.2.16-2 Detailed View of the PWR 14x14 Fuel Assembly | |||
11.2.16-7 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
Figure 11.2.16-3 ANSYS Model for the PW R Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation | |||
11.2.16-8 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | |||
11.2.16.2 BWR Fuel Rod Evaluation | |||
This section presents the structural evaluations of the BWR high burnup fuel assemblies for the cask 24-inch end drop and tip-over accident conditions. The high burnup BWR fuel is considered to have a cladding oxide layer of 125 microns thick. A reduced cladding thickness is assumed due to the cladding oxide layer. | |||
End Drop Evaluation In the end drop orientation, the fuel rods are laterally restrained by the grids and come into contact with the fuel assembly base. The fuel assembly is considered to have an initial of bow of 0.157 inch [64]. The evaluation of the BWR fuel rod is based on the following representative samples of BWR fuel assemblies: | End Drop Evaluation In the end drop orientation, the fuel rods are laterally restrained by the grids and come into contact with the fuel assembly base. The fuel assembly is considered to have an initial of bow of 0.157 inch [64]. The evaluation of the BWR fuel rod is based on the following representative samples of BWR fuel assemblies: | ||
BWR Fuel | |||
BWR Fuel Cladding Cladding Fuel Rod Gap between fuel Assembly Diameter (in) Thickness Pitch assembly and fuel (in) (in) tube wall (in) 8X8 0.483 0.032 0.64 0.937 9X9 0.433 0.026 0.572 0.891 10X10 0.396 0.024 0.51 0.914 | |||
Review of the design basis fuel inventory indicates that the largest gap between the envelop of the fuel rods of a straight fuel assembly and the basket fuel tube inner wall could be 0.937 inch. | |||
In this evaluation, an assembly with an initial bow of 0.157 inch is permitted to displace an additional 0.78 inch to the full gap displacement of 0.937 inch. To implement a bow of 0.157 inch into the fuel assembly, the half symmetry ANSYS model corresponding to a row of fuel rods (Figure 11.2.16-4) is used. The clad is modeled with shell elements (see Figure 11.2.16-5). | In this evaluation, an assembly with an initial bow of 0.157 inch is permitted to displace an additional 0.78 inch to the full gap displacement of 0.937 inch. To implement a bow of 0.157 inch into the fuel assembly, the half symmetry ANSYS model corresponding to a row of fuel rods (Figure 11.2.16-4) is used. The clad is modeled with shell elements (see Figure 11.2.16-5). | ||
Each grid is modeled using brick elements to maintain the spacing between the fuel rods at the grid. The fuel tube is modeled using brick elements to restrict the lateral motion of the fuel assembly. Each of the fuel rods in the ANSYS model is simply supported at each end. A static force is applied to the ANSYS model at the grid nearest the axial center to develop a 0.157 inch lateral displacement. The purpose of the ANSYS model and solution is to provide the coordinates of the fuel clad for the LS-DYNA model. This is accomplished by obtaining a static solution with the ANSYS model, and then using the option to update the coordinates of the nodes based on the displacements from the solution. | Each grid is modeled using brick elements to maintain the spacing between the fuel rods at the grid. The fuel tube is modeled using brick elements to restrict the lateral motion of the fuel assembly. Each of the fuel rods in the ANSYS model is simply supported at each end. A static force is applied to the ANSYS model at the grid nearest the axial center to develop a 0.157 inch lateral displacement. The purpose of the ANSYS model and solution is to provide the coordinates of the fuel clad for the LS-DYNA model. This is accomplished by obtaining a static solution with the ANSYS model, and then using the option to update the coordinates of the nodes based on the displacements from the solution. | ||
NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11.2.16-9 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | ||
Case | |||
Three (3) LS-DYNA models are considered for the 24-inch cask end drop conditions. All models incorporate a bow of 0.157 inch. These cases envelope the range of the cross-sectional moment of inertia for the BWR fuel rods and the largest grid spacing of the fuel assembly are summarized in the following Table. | |||
Case Fuel Assembly Largest grid spacing (inch) 1 8x8 23.61 2 9x9 22.28 3 10x10 22.57 In each case the thickness of the clad was reduced by 125 microns (0.0049inch). Each case requires a separate ANSYS model and a LS-DYNA model to represent unique coordinates or boundary conditions. The LS-DYNA model employs the same nodes and elements as the ANSYS model (with the incorporation of the 0.157 inch bow). Elastic properties are used in the ANSYS model and the bilinear properties are employed in the LS-DYNA model. An initial downward velocity of 136 in/sec (corresponding to a 24-inch end drop of the storage cask) is assigned to all nodes in the model. The deceleration time history is applied to the nodes of the brick elements representing the fuel tube. The acceleration time history is obtained from the analysis for the 24-inch drop of the VCC in Section 11.2.4. The side walls of the fuel tube are restrained in the lateral direction to maximize the effect of the fuel rods impacting the fuel tube side wall. | |||
The LS-DYNA analyses for Cases 1 through 3 were performed for the duration of 0.08 second to capture the response of the fuel after the 0.02 second loading duration. Post-processing each analysis result identifies the maximum shear stress occurring at the shell surface. The maximum shear stress result from LS-DYNA is factored by two to determine the maximum stress intensity. | The LS-DYNA analyses for Cases 1 through 3 were performed for the duration of 0.08 second to capture the response of the fuel after the 0.02 second loading duration. Post-processing each analysis result identifies the maximum shear stress occurring at the shell surface. The maximum shear stress result from LS-DYNA is factored by two to determine the maximum stress intensity. | ||
The following table contains the maximum stress intensity and the margin of safety (M.S.) for All stresses are shown to be well below the yield strength. The results confirm | The following table contains the maximum stress intensity and the margin of safety (M.S.) for | ||
11.2.16-10 | |||
All stresses are shown to be well below the yield strength. The results confirm th at high burnup BWR fuel will remain structurally adequate for the storage design basis cask end drop load condition. | |||
11.2.16-10 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | |||
Tip-Over Evaluation | |||
11.2.16-11 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
Figure 11.2.16-4 Overall Model Plot for a Typical BWR Fuel Assembly | |||
Overall plot of BWR Model The model without the fuel clad | |||
Top lateral constraint | |||
Inside dimension for the fuel tube is 5.9 inches | |||
The sides of the Grid locations fuel tube measured from bottom of fuel rod (inch) | |||
8x8 9x9 10x10 | |||
18.75 18.36 2.15 | |||
38.90 38.51 18.80 | |||
59.05 58.66 38.95 | |||
79.20 78.81 59.10 | |||
99.35 98.96 79.25 | |||
119.50 119.11 99.40 | |||
139.65 139.26 119.55 | |||
163.25 161.54 139.70 | |||
162.27 See Figure 11.2.16-5 for BWR 10x10 2nd spacer grid | |||
1st spacer grid | |||
11.2.16-12 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A Figure 11.2.16-5 Detailed View of the BWR 10x10 Fuel Assembly Model | |||
Detailed view of the axial section of the fuel assembly | |||
The gap between the assembly and the side is reduced by 0.157 inch to simulate the bow in the fuel assembly. | |||
All shell elements were modeled at the midplane thickness of the clad. The LS-DYNA interface takes into account the thickness of the shell element when determining the contact. | All shell elements were modeled at the midplane thickness of the clad. The LS-DYNA interface takes into account the thickness of the shell element when determining the contact. | ||
Brick elements for the grid. | Brick elements for the grid. | ||
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | A small gap (0.01 inch) was modeled between the fuel rod and bottom brick elements | ||
Brick elements representing the sides of the fuel tube. | |||
The deceleration time history was applied to nodes of these brick The nodes in the elements bricks for the sides and the bottom are restrained in the lateral direction | |||
11.2.16-13 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A | |||
Figure 11.2.16-6 ANSYS Model for the BWR Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation | |||
11.2.16-14 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | |||
11.2.16.3 Thermal Evaluation of Fuel Rods The UMS system limits normal storage condition fuel cladding temperatures to levels below zirconium alloy or stainless steel cladding temperature limits; therefore, degradation is not expected to occur below this temperature in an inert gas environment. | |||
As shown in Chapter 4, fuel cladding temperature limits for PWR and BWR fuel rods have been established at 400°C (752°F) for normal and off-normal conditions of storage, including transfer operations, and 570°C (1,058ºF) for accident conditions. Chapter 4 demonstrates that the maximum fuel cladding temperatures are well below the temperature limits for all design conditions of storage. | As shown in Chapter 4, fuel cladding temperature limits for PWR and BWR fuel rods have been established at 400°C (752°F) for normal and off-normal conditions of storage, including transfer operations, and 570°C (1,058ºF) for accident conditions. Chapter 4 demonstrates that the maximum fuel cladding temperatures are well below the temperature limits for all design conditions of storage. | ||
THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System | 11.2.16-15 THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A | ||
: 56. ASME Section II Part D - Properties, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, United Engineering Center, 345 East 47th Street, New York, 1995/1995 Addenda. | : 56. ASME Section II Part D - Properties, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, United Engineering Center, 345 East 47th Street, New York, 1995/1995 Addenda. | ||
: 57. Impact Dynamics, eds. Z.A. Zukas et al, John Wiley & Sons, New York. | : 57. Impact Dynamics, eds. Z.A. Zukas et al, John Wiley & Sons, New York. | ||
Line 132: | Line 305: | ||
: 67. Bourdiliau, B, et al., Impact of Irradiation Damage Recovery During Transportation of the Subsequent Room Temperature Tensile Behavior of Irradiated Zirconium Alloys, JAI Vol. | : 67. Bourdiliau, B, et al., Impact of Irradiation Damage Recovery During Transportation of the Subsequent Room Temperature Tensile Behavior of Irradiated Zirconium Alloys, JAI Vol. | ||
7 No. 9. | 7 No. 9. | ||
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK}} | 11.3-5 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK}} |
Revision as of 10:40, 13 November 2024
ML23283A250 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | 07201015 |
Issue date: | 10/10/2023 |
From: | NAC International |
To: | Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards |
Shared Package | |
ML23283A248 | List: |
References | |
ED20230124 | |
Download: ML23283A250 (1) | |
Text
September 2023 Revision 23A NAC-UMS Universal Storage System
Fuel Rod Side Drop Error Correction Evaluation (CAR 23-01)
Non-Proprietary
Docket No. 72-1015
Atlanta Corporate Headquarters: 2 Sun Court, Peachtree Corners, Georgia 30092 USA Phone 770-447-1144, www.nacintl.com of ED20230124 Page 1 of 2
Enclosure 1
Supporting Calculations
for the
NAC-UMS Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015)
NAC International
September 2023 of ED20230124 Page 2 of 2
List of Calculations
- 1. 71160-2026, Revision 1
- 2. EA790-2519, Revision 0
- 3. EA790-2520, Revision 1 to ED20230124 Page 1 of 2
Enclosure 2
List of FSAR Changes
for the
NAC-UMS FSAR Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015)
NAC International
September 2023 to ED20230124 Page 2 of 2 List of Changes for the NAC-UMS FSAR, Revision 23A
Chapter/Page/ Source of Change: Description of Change Figure/Table
Note: The List of Effective Pages and the Chapter Table of Contents, List of Figures and List of Tables have been revised accordingly to reflect the list of changes detailed below, if needed.
Chapters 1 thru 10 - no changes Chapter 11
Page 11.2.16-1 Revision 23A Modified text in Sections 11.2.16 and 11.2.16.1 where indicated.
Pages 11.2.16-2 Replaced text including figures and embedded tables in its thru 11.2.16-8 Revision 23A entirety where indicated.
Modified text in the first paragraph of section 11.2.16.2 where Page 11.2.16-9 Revision 23A indicated.
Modified text and embedded table starting with the third Page 11.2.16-10 Revision 23A paragraph of section 11.2.16.2 where indicated Replaced text including embedded tables in its entirety where Page 11.2.16-11 Revision 23A indicated.
Pages 11.2.16-12 thru 11.2.16-13 Revision 23A Text flow changes.1 Page 11.2.16-14 Revision 23A Modified the figure heading and replaced Figure 11.2.16-6.
Page 11.2.16-15 Revision 23A Text flow changes.
Page 11.3-5 Revision 23A Added references 63 thru 35 where indicated.
Chapters 12 thru 13 - no changes to ED20230124 Page 1 of 1
Enclosure 3
FSAR Changed Pages and LOEP
for the
NAC-UMS Revision 23A (Docket No 72-1015)
NAC International
September 2023 September 2023 Revision 23A NAC-UMS Universal Storage System
ANALYSIS REPORTFINAL SAFETY
Non-Proprietary
Docket No. 72-1015
Atlanta Corporate Headquarters: 2 Sun Court, Peachtree Corners, Georgia 30092 USA Phone 770-447-1144, www.nacintl.com
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages
Chapter 1 1.5-4........................................ Revision 11 1-i.............................................. Revision 3 1.5-5.......................................... Revision 8 1-ii.......................................... Revision 10 1.5-6 thru 1.5-7......................... Revision 0 1-1............................................ Revision 0 1.5-8.......................................... Revision 6 1-2............................................ Revision 5 1.5-9........................................ Revision 13 1-3............................................ Revision 8 1.5-10........................................ Revision 0 1-4 thru 1-6............................. Revision 15 1.5-11........................................ Revision 3 1-7............................................ Revision 8 1.5-12 thru 1.5-16..................... Revision 0 1-8 thru 1-9............................. Revision 15 1.5-17........................................ Revision 3 1.1-1.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-18 thru 1.5-20..................... Revision 0 1.1-2.......................................... Revision 4 1.5-21........................................ Revision 6 1.1-3.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-22........................................ Revision 4 1.1-4.......................................... Revision 0 1.5-23 thru 1.5-26..................... Revision 0 1.2-1.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-27........................................ Revision 3 1.2-2........................................ Revision 15 1.5-28........................................ Revision 8 1.2-3........................................ Revision 16 1.5-29........................................ Revision 0 1.2-4.......................................... Revision 3 1.5-30........................................ Revision 8 1.2-5 thru 1.2-10..................... Revision 15 1.5-31 thru 1.5-32..................... Revision 0 1.2-11 thru 1.2-12..................... Revision 6 1.5-33........................................ Revision 3 1.2-13........................................ Revision 8 1.5-34........................................ Revision 5 1.2-14 thru 1.2-20..................... Revision 6 1.5-35........................................ Revision 0 1.2-21 thru 1.2-22................... Revision 16 1.5-36........................................ Revision 3 1.2-23........................................ Revision 6 1.5-37 thru 1.5-38................... Revision 10 1.2-24...................................... Revision 15 1.5-39 thru 1.5-43..................... Revision 0 1.2-25........................................ Revision 6 1.5-44........................................ Revision 8 1.2-26...................................... Revision 15 1.5-45 thru 1.5-46..................... Revision 0 1.2-27........................................ Revision 6 1.5-47........................................ Revision 3 1.2-28...................................... Revision 10 1.5-48........................................ Revision 8 1.2-29........................................ Revision 6 1.5-49 thru 1.5-54..................... Revision 0 1.3-1........................................ Revision 15 1.6-1.......................................... Revision 8 1.3-2.......................................... Revision 5 1.7-1.......................................... Revision 3 1.3-3.......................................... Revision 4 1.7-2 thru 1.7-3......................... Revision 4 1.4-1 thru 1.4-2......................... Revision 0 1.8-1........................................ Revision 16 1.5-1.......................................... Revision 0 1.8-2........................................ Revision 15 1.5-2........................................ Revision 11 1.5-3.......................................... Revision 0 32 drawings (see Section 1.8) 1 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
2.3-20...................................... Revision 15 Chapter 2 2.4-1.......................................... Revision 3 2-i............................................. Revision 3 2.4-2 thru 2.4-4......................... Revision 0 2-ii............................................. Revision 6 2.5-1 thru 2.5-2......................... Revision 3 2-iii............................................ Revision 3 2-iv.......................................... Revision 11 Chapter 3 2-1............................................. Revision 8 3-i........................................... Revision 16 2-2........................................... Revision 15 3-ii........................................... Revision 15 2-3............................................. Revision 3 3-iii thru 3-v.............................. Revision 3 2.1-1........................................ Revision 15 3-vi.......................................... Revision 16 2.1.1-1 thru 2.1.1-4................... Revision 8 3-vii thru 3-viii.......................... Revision 3 2.1.2-1 thru 2.1.2-2................. Revision 15 3.1-1 thru 3.1-2......................... Revision 3 2.1.2-3....................................... Revision 8 3.1-3........................................ Revision 16 2.1.3-1 thru 2.1.3-4................... Revision 8 3.1-4 thru 3.1-7......................... Revision 3 2.1.3-5....................................... Revision 3 3.2-1.......................................... Revision 0 2.1.3-6....................................... Revision 8 3.2-2.......................................... Revision 3 2.1.3-7 thru 2.1.3-8................... Revision 3 3.2-3 thru 3.2-4....................... Revision 15 2.1.3-9....................................... Revision 5 3.3-1........................................ Revision 16 2.1.3-10 thru 2.1.3-14............... Revision 3 3.3-2 thru 3.3-15....................... Revision 3 2.2-1..................................... Amendment 1 3.3-16 thru 3.3-18................... Revision 16 2.2-2 thru 2.2-3......................... Revision 0 3.4.1-1.................................. Amendment 2 2.2-4.......................................... Revision 5 3.4.1-2....................................... Revision 4 2.2-5.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.1-3..................................... Revision 16 2.2-6 thru 2.2-10....................... Revision 0 3.4.1-4.................................. Amendment 2 2.2-11........................................ Revision 3 3.4.1-5....................................... Revision 3 2.3-1 thru 2.3-2....................... Revision 11 3.4.1-6 thru 3.4.1-8................... Revision 4 2.3-3 thru 2.3-4......................... Revision 3 3.4.1-9..................................... Revision 11 2.3-5 thru 2.3-8....................... Revision 15 3.4.1-10 thru 3.4.1-12............... Revision 3 2.3-9.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.2-1....................................... Revision 8 2.3-10........................................ Revision 0 3.4.2-2....................................... Revision 4 2.3-11........................................ Revision 5 3.4.3-1....................................... Revision 4 2.3-12...................................... Revision 11 3.4.3-2 thru 3.4.3-3................... Revision 3 2.3-13...................................... Revision 15 3.4.3-4....................................... Revision 0 2.3-14 thru 2.3-15................... Revision 11 3.4.3-5 thru 3.4.3-22................. Revision 3 2.3-16 thru 2.3-17................... Revision 15 3.4.3-23 thru 3.4.3-26............... Revision 6 2.3-18 thru 2.3-19................... Revision 11 3.4.3-27..................................... Revision 3 2
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
3.4.3-28..................................... Revision 4 4.1-2 thru 4.1-3......................... Revision 8 3.4.3-29 thru 3.4.3-98............... Revision 3 4.1-4.......................................... Revision 0 3.4.4-1....................................... Revision 0 4.1-5.......................................... Revision 4 3.4.4-2 thru 3.4.4-7................... Revision 3 4.1-6 thru 4.1-7....................... Revision 16 3.4.4-8 thru 3.4.4-19............... Revision 16 4.1-8.......................................... Revision 5 3.4.4-20..................................... Revision 3 4.2-1.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.4-21 thru 3.4.4-38............... Revision 0 4.2-2........................................ Revision 16 3.4.4-39 thru 3.4.4-48............... Revision 3 4.2-3.......................................... Revision 3 3.4.4-49 thru 3.4.4-51............... Revision 0 4.2-4.......................................... Revision 0 3.4.4-52 thru 3.4.4-64............... Revision 3 4.2-5.......................................... Revision 4 3.4.4-65..................................... Revision 0 4.2-6.......................................... Revision 0 3.4.4-66 thru 3.4.4-69............... Revision 3 4.2-7.......................................... Revision 7 3.4.4-70 thru 3.4.4-74............... Revision 0 4.3-1 thru 4.3-3......................... Revision 3 3.4.4-75 thru 3.4.4-77............... Revision 3 4.4-1........................................ Revision 16 3.4.5-1....................................... Revision 3 4.4.1-1....................................... Revision 3 3.5-1.......................................... Revision 4 4.4.1-2..................................... Revision 15 3.6-1.......................................... Revision 8 4.4.1-3....................................... Revision 7 3.6-2.......................................... Revision 4 4.4.1-4 thru 4.4.1-6................... Revision 0 3.6-3.......................................... Revision 8 4.4.1-7..................................... Revision 15 3.6-4 thru 3.6-5......................... Revision 3 4.4.1-8.................................. Amendment 2 3.6-6..................................... Amendment 1 4.4.1-9....................................... Revision 5 3.6-7 thru 3.6-8......................... Revision 3 4.4.1-10 thru 4.4.1-17............... Revision 3 3.7-1 thru 3.7-2......................... Revision 3 4.4.1-18................................... Revision 15 3.7-3 thru 3.7-4......................... Revision 8 4.4.1-19 thru 4.4.1-22............... Revision 3 3.8-1........................................ Revision 11 4.4.1-23................................... Revision 15 3.8-2 thru 3.8-20....................... Revision 9 4.4.1-24................................... Revision 16 3.8-21 thru 3.8-26................... Revision 11 4.4.1-25 thru 4.4.1-26............... Revision 3 3.9-1 thru 3.9-17..................... Revision 15 4.4.1-27..................................... Revision 4 4.4.1-28................................... Revision 16 Chapter 4 4.4.1-29..................................... Revision 3 4-i thru 4-ii............................... Revision 3 4.4.1-30..................................... Revision 4 4-iii.......................................... Revision 15 4.4.1-31 thru 4.4.1-34............... Revision 3 4-iv............................................ Revision 3 4.4.1-35................................... Revision 15 4-v.......................................... Revision 15 4.4.1-36..................................... Revision 3 4-vi............................................ Revision 8 4.4.1-37................................... Revision 16 4.1-1.......................................... Revision 3 4.4.1-38................................... Revision 15 3
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
4.4.1-39 thru 4.4.1-40............... Revision 3 5-ii........................................... Revision 15 4.4.1-41 thru 4.4.1-43............... Revision 4 5-iii............................................ Revision 8 4.4.1-44 thru 4.4.1-49............... Revision 3 5-iv............................................ Revision 3 4.4.2-1....................................... Revision 0 5-v........................................... Revision 15 4.4.3-1 thru 4.4.3-5................. Revision 16 5-vi thru 5-viii........................... Revision 8 4.4.3-6 thru 4.4.3-9................... Revision 3 5-ix thru 5-x............................ Revision 15 4.4.3-10................................... Revision 16 5.1-1........................................ Revision 12 4.4.3-11 thru 4.4.3-13............... Revision 3 5.1-2 thru 5.1-12....................... Revision 7 4.4.3-14 thru 4.4.3-15............... Revision 5 5.2-1 thru 5.2-36....................... Revision 8 4.4.3-16 thru 4.4.3-18............. Revision 16 5.3-1 thru 5.3-10....................... Revision 3 4.4.3-19 thru 4.4.3-20............... Revision 3 5.3-11 thru 5.3-12..................... Revision 4 4.4.3-21 thru 4.4.3-22............. Revision 16 5.3-13 thru 5.3-21..................... Revision 3 4.4.4-1....................................... Revision 0 5.3-22 thru 5.3-23..................... Revision 4 4.4.5-1....................................... Revision 8 5.3-24........................................ Revision 3 4.4.5-2 thru 4.4.5-3................. Revision 16 5.3-25 thru 5.3-26..................... Revision 4 4.4.5-4....................................... Revision 8 5.3-27 thru 5.3-32..................... Revision 3 4.4.5-5..................................... Revision 15 5.4-1 thru 5.4-4......................... Revision 3 4.4.6-1....................................... Revision 0 5.4-5.......................................... Revision 7 4.4.7-1....................................... Revision 3 5.4-6 thru 5.4-27....................... Revision 3 4.5-1.......................................... Revision 5 5.5-1.......................................... Revision 8 4.5-2 thru 4.5-3......................... Revision 4 5.5-2.......................................... Revision 3 4.5-4..................................... Amendment 2 5.5-3 thru 5.5-4......................... Revision 7 4.5-5.......................................... Revision 3 5.5-5 thru 5.5-7......................... Revision 3 4.5-6.......................................... Revision 4 5.5-8 thru 5.5-10....................... Revision 8 4.5-7.......................................... Revision 3 5.6-1..................................... Amendment 1 4.5-8.......................................... Revision 8 5.6.1-1....................................... Revision 4 4.5-9 thru 4.5-10....................... Revision 3 5.6.1-2.................................. Amendment 1 4.5-11 thru 4.5-16................ Amendment 2 5.6.1-3....................................... Revision 4 4.5-17........................................ Revision 7 5.6.1-4.................................. Amendment 1 4.5-18 thru 4.5-19..................... Revision 3 5.6.1-5....................................... Revision 4 4.6-1 thru 4.6-2......................... Revision 3 5.6.1-6 thru 5.6.1-8................... Revision 3 4.6-3.......................................... Revision 0 5.6.1-9 thru 5.6.1-10............ Amendment 1 4.6-4.......................................... Revision 8 5.6.1-11 thru 5.6.1-12............... Revision 8 5.6.1-13 thru 5.6.1-22.......... Amendment 2 Chapter 5 5.6.1-23 thru 5.6.1-24............... Revision 3 5-i............................................. Revision 8 5.6.1-25................................ Amendment 2 4
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
5.6.1-26 thru 5.6.1-27............... Revision 3 6.6.1-8....................................... Revision 3 5.6.1-28 thru 5.6.1-34.......... Amendment 2 6.6.1-9 thru 6.6.1-10............ Amendment 2 5.7-1 thru 5.7-2......................... Revision 0 6.6.1-11..................................... Revision 8 5.7-3.......................................... Revision 8 6.6.1-12 thru 6.6.1-14.......... Amendment 2 5.8-1........................................ Revision 15 6.6.1-15..................................... Revision 4 5.8.1-1 thru 5.8.1-4................. Revision 15 6.6.1-16 thru 6.6.1-21.......... Amendment 2 5.8.2-1 thru 5.8.2-15............... Revision 15 6.6.1-22..................................... Revision 3 5.8.3-1 thru 5.8.3-6................. Revision 15 6.6.1-23 thru 6.6.1-24.......... Amendment 2 6.7-1 thru 6.7-31..................... Revision 15 Chapter 6 6.8-1 thru 6.8-2....................... Revision 15 6-i........................................... Revision 3 6.9-1 thru 6.8-66..................... Revision 15 6-ii thru 6-x............................. Revision 15 6.1-1 thru 6.1-2......................... Revision 8 Chapter 7 6.1-3 thru 6.1-7....................... Revision 15 7-i thru 7-ii................................ Revision 4 6.2-1.......................................... Revision 5 7.1-1 thru 7.1-2......................... Revision 8 6.2-2 thru 6.2-3......................... Revision 3 7.1-3.......................................... Revision 4 6.3-1 thru 6.3-2......................... Revision 3 7.1-4.......................................... Revision 8 6.3-3........................................ Revision 10 7.1-5.......................................... Revision 4 6.3-4 thru 6.3-6......................... Revision 3 7.1-6.......................................... Revision 8 6.3-7.......................................... Revision 7 7.1-7 thru 7.1-9......................... Revision 4 6.3-8.......................................... Revision 4 7.2-1.......................................... Revision 3 6.3-9 thru 6.3-18....................... Revision 3 7.2-2.......................................... Revision 8 6.4-1.......................................... Revision 4 7.3-1.......................................... Revision 8 6.4-2 thru 6.4-13....................... Revision 3 7.4-1.......................................... Revision 8 6.4-14 thru 6.4-15................... Revision 15 7.5-1.......................................... Revision 4 6.4-16........................................ Revision 3 6.4-17........................................ Revision 0 Chapter 8 6.4-18 thru 6.4-40..................... Revision 3 8-i........................................ Amendment 1 6.5-1........................................ Revision 15 8-ii............................................. Revision 5 6.5-2 thru 6.5-49....................... Revision 3 8-1 thru 8-2............................... Revision 5 6.5-50 thru 65-81.................... Revision 15 8.1-1.......................................... Revision 8 6.6-1..................................... Amendment 2 8.1.1-1....................................... Revision 8 6.6.1-1 thru 6.6.1-2................... Revision 8 8.1.1-2....................................... Revision 5 6.6.1-3.................................. Amendment 2 8.1.1-3....................................... Revision 4 6.6.1-4....................................... Revision 4 8.1.1-4 thru 8.1.1-7................... Revision 8 6.6.1-5 thru 6.6.1-7................... Revision 8 8.1.1-8 thru 8.1.1-10................. Revision 5 5
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
8.1.1-11..................................... Revision 6 10.5-1................................... Amendment 1 8.1.2-1 thru 8.1.2-2................... Revision 8 10.6-1 thru 10.6-3................... Revision 15 8.1.3-1 thru 8.1.3-2................... Revision 8 10.7-1...................................... Revision 15 8.2-1.......................................... Revision 6 8.2-2.......................................... Revision 5 Chapter 11 8.3-1.......................................... Revision 4 11-i....................................... Amendment 1 8.3-2 thru 8.3-4......................... Revision 3 11-ii........................................... Revision 3 8.4-1.......................................... Revision 0 11-iii.......................................... Revision 5 11-iv..................................... Revision 23A Chapter 9 11-v........................................... Revision 3 9-i thru 9-ii.............................. Revision 15 11-vi..................................... Revision 23A 9.1-1.......................................... Revision 4 11-vii thru 11-x......................... Revision 3 9.1-2.......................................... Revision 8 11-1........................................... Revision 0 9.1-3.......................................... Revision 4 11.1.1-1..................................... Revision 6 9.1-4.......................................... Revision 5 11.1.1-2..................................... Revision 3 9.1-5.......................................... Revision 4 11.1.1-3 thru 11.1.1-6............... Revision 0 9.1-6........................................ Revision 10 11.1.2-1..................................... Revision 6 9.1-7 thru 9.1-20..................... Revision 15 11.1.2-2..................................... Revision 0 9.2-1.......................................... Revision 7 11.1.2-3..................................... Revision 3 9.2-2.......................................... Revision 9 11.1.3-1..................................... Revision 3 9.2-3.......................................... Revision 7 11.1.3-2 thru -11.1.3-3............ Revision 12 9.3-1.......................................... Revision 8 11.1.3-4 thru -11.1.3-16............ Revision 3 9.3-2.......................................... Revision 5 11.1.4-1 thru 11.1.4-2............... Revision 6 11.1.5-1 thru 11.1.5-2............... Revision 0 Chapter 10 11.1.6-1................................ Amendment 1 10-i thru 10-ii.......................... Revision 15 11.2-1................................... Amendment 1 10.1-1........................................ Revision 3 11.2.1-1 thru 11.2.1-7............... Revision 3 10.1-2........................................ Revision 6 11.2.2-1..................................... Revision 8 10.2-1 thru 10.2-2................... Revision 15 11.2.3-1..................................... Revision 3 10.3-1 thru 10.3-3................... Revision 15 11.2.3-2..................................... Revision 0 10.3-4........................................ Revision 0 11.2.4-1 thru 11.2.4-11............. Revision 3 10.3-5 thru 10.3-6..................... Revision 3 11.2.4-12................................. Revision 13 10.3-7........................................ Revision 0 11.2.4-13 thru 11.2.4-21........... Revision 0 10.3-8 thru 10.3-9..................... Revision 3 1.2.4-22 thru 11.2.4-24............. Revision 3 10.4-1 thru 10.4-2................... Revision 15 11.2.4-25................................... Revision 7 10.4-3 thru 10.4-5..................... Revision 3 11.2.4-26 thru 11.2.4-27........... Revision 3 6
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
11.2.5-1..................................... Revision 0 11.2.12-22................................. Revision 3 11.2.6-1 thru 11.2.6-2............... Revision 3 11.2.12-23................................. Revision 0 11.2.6-3................................... Revision 13 11.2.12-24 thru 11.2.12-70....... Revision 3 11.2.6-4..................................... Revision 0 11.2.12-71............................... Revision 13 11.2.6-5..................................... Revision 3 11.2.13-1................................... Revision 6 11.2.7-1................................... Revision 16 11.2.13-2................................. Revision 13 11.2.7-2..................................... Revision 3 11.2.13-3................................... Revision 0 11.2.8-1..................................... Revision 5 11.2.14-1................................... Revision 8 11.2.8-2..................................... Revision 0 11.2.14-2................................... Revision 3 11.2.8-3 thru 11.2.8-5............... Revision 3 11.2.15-1 thru 11.2.15-2........... Revision 3 11.2.8-6..................................... Revision 5 11.2.15-3.............................. Amendment 1 11.2.8-7..................................... Revision 3 11.2.15-4.............................. Amendment 2 11.2.8-8 thru 11.2.8-10............. Revision 5 11.2.15-5 thru 11.2.15-6........... Revision 8 11.2.8-11 thru 11.2.8-12......... Revision 13 11.2.15-7 thru 11.2.15-13.... Amendment 1 11.2.9-1..................................... Revision 0 11.2.15-14 thru 11.2.15-17....... Revision 3 11.2.9-2 thru11.2.9-4................ Revision 3 11.2.15-18 thru 11.2.15-22.. Amendment 1 11.2.9-5................................... Revision 13 11.2.15-23 thru 11.2.15-24.. Amendment 2 11.2.9-6 thru 11.2.9-7............... Revision 3 11.2.15-25................................. Revision 4 11.2.10-1 thru 11.2.10-3........... Revision 0 11.2.15-26............................ Amendment 2 11.2.10-4................................. Revision 13 11.2.15-27............................ Amendment 1 11.2.11-1................................... Revision 0 11.2.15-28............................ Amendment 2 11.2.11-2 thru 11.2.11-4........... Revision 3 11.2.15-29................................. Revision 4 11.2.11-5 thru 11.2.11-7........... Revision 0 11.2.15-30 thru 11.2.15-31....... Revision 3 11.2.11-8 thru 11.2.11-11......... Revision 3 11.2.15-32................................. Revision 4 11.2.11-12................................. Revision 0 11.2.15-33 thru 11.2.15-35.. Amendment 2 11.2.11-13............................... Revision 13 11.2.16-1 thru 11.2.16-15.... Revision 23A 11.2.11-14................................. Revision 3 11.3-1........................................ Revision 3 11.2.12-1................................... Revision 0 11.3-2 thru 11.3-3..................... Revision 0 11.2.12-2................................... Revision 7 11.3-4........................................ Revision 3 11.2.12-3 thru 11.2.12-10......... Revision 3 11.3-5................................... Revision 23A 11.2.12-11 thru 11.2.12-12....... Revision 0 11.2.12-13 thru 11.2.12-14....... Revision 3 Chapter 12 11.2.12-15 thru 11.2.12-17..... Revision 12 12-i thru 12-ii....................... Amendment 1 11.2.12-18................................. Revision 0 12-1........................................... Revision 5 11.2.12-19 thru 11.2.12-20....... Revision 3 12-2 thru 12-3........................... Revision 8 11.2.12-21................................. Revision 0 12-4......................................... Revision 15 7
FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Effective Pages (continued)
12A-1 thru 12A-2...................... Revision 3 12B-1 thru12B-2....................... Revision 3 12C-1......................................... Revision 0 12C-2......................................... Revision 8 12C1-1....................................... Revision 3 12C2-1....................................... Revision 8 12C2-2....................................... Revision 3 12C3-1 thru 12C3-8.................. Revision 0 12C3-9 thru 12C3-28................ Revision 8 12C3-29 thru 12C3-30............ Revision 13 12C3-31................................... Revision 14 12C3-32 thru 12C3-34.............. Revision 8 12C3-35 thru 12C3-37............ Revision 13 12C3-38 thru 12C3-40.............. Revision 8
Chapter 13 13-i thru 13-ii............................ Revision 0 13.1-1 thru 13.2-7..................... Revision 0 13.2-8........................................ Revision 3 13.3-1...................................... Revision 10
8 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System October 2005 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 5
Table of Contents (Continued)
11.2.6.4 Corrective Actions................................................................................... 11.2.6-3 11.2.6.5 Radiological Impact................................................................................ 11.2.6-3 11.2.7 Maximum Anticipated Heat Load (133F Ambient Temperature)....................... 11.2.7-1 1.2.7.1 Cause of Maximum Anticipated Heat Load............................................. 11.2.7-1 11.2.7.2 Detection of Maximum Anticipated Heat Load...................................... 11.2.7-1 11.2.7.3 Analysis of Maximum Anticipated Heat Load....................................... 11.2.7-1 11.2.7.4 Corrective Actions................................................................................... 11.2.7-2 11.2.7.5 Radiological Impact................................................................................ 11.2.7-2 11.2.8 Earthquake Event.................................................................................................... 11.2.8-1 11.2.8.1 Cause of the Earthquake Event............................................................... 11.2.8-1 11.2.8.2 Earthquake Event Analysis..................................................................... 11.2.8-1 11.2.8.3 Corrective Actions.................................................................................11.2.8-11 11.2.8.4 Radiological Impact..............................................................................11.2.8-11 11.2.9 Flood....................................................................................................................... 11.2.9-1 11.2.9.1 Cause of Flood......................................................................................... 11.2.9-1 11.2.9.2 Analysis of Flood.................................................................................... 11.2.9-1 11.2.9.3 Corrective Actions................................................................................... 11.2.9-5 11.2.9.4 Radiological Impact................................................................................ 11.2.9-5 11.2.10 Lightning Strike..................................................................................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.1 Cause of Lightning Strike....................................................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.2 Detection of Lightning Strike..............................................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.3 Analysis of the Lightning Strike Event...............................................11.2.10-1 11.2.10.4 Corrective Actions...............................................................................11.2.10-4 11.2.10.5 Radiological Impact............................................................................11.2.10-4 11.2.11 Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles...............................................................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.1 Cause of Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles................................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.2 Detection of Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles..........................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.3 Analysis of Tornado and Tornado Driven Missiles............................11.2.11-1 11.2.11.4 Corrective Actions............................................................................ 11.2.11-13 11.2.11.5 Radiological Impact......................................................................... 11.2.11-13 11.2.12 Tip-Over of Vertical Concrete Cask...................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.1 Cause of Cask Tip-Over......................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.2 Detection of Cask Tip-Over................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.3 Analysis of Cask Tip-Over..................................................................11.2.12-1 11.2.12.4 Analysis of Canister and Basket for Cask Tip-Over Event............. 11.2.12-11
11-iii FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
Table of Contents (Continued)
11.2.12.5 Corrective Actions............................................................................ 11.2.12-71 11.2.12.6 Radiological Impact......................................................................... 11.2.12-71 11.2.13 Full Blockage of Vertical Concrete Cask Air Inlets and Outlets.......................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.1 Cause of Full Blockage.......................................................................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.2 Detection of Full Blockage..................................................................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.3 Analysis of Full Blockage...................................................................11.2.13-1 11.2.13.4 Corrective Actions...............................................................................11.2.13-2 11.2.13.5 Radiological Impact............................................................................11.2.13-2 11.2.14 Canister Closure Weld Evaluation.....................................................................11.2.14-1 11.2.15 Accident and Natural Phenomena Events Evaluation for Site Specific Spent Fuel...........................................................................................................11.2.15-1 11.2.15.1 Accident and Natural Phenomena Events Evaluation for Maine Yankee Site Specific Spent Fuel.........................................................11.2.15-1 11.2.16 Fuel Rods Structural Evaluation for Burnup to 60,000 MWd/MTU.................11.2.16-1 11.2.16.1 PWR Fuel Rod Evaluation..................................................................11.2.16-1 11.2.16.2 BWR Fuel Rod Evaluation.................................................................11.2.16-9 11.2.16.3 Thermal Evaluation of Fuel Rods.................................................... 11.2.16-15 11.3 References............................................................................................................................ 11.3-1
11-iv FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System March 2004 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 3
List of Figures
Figure 11.1.1-1 Concrete Temperature (°F) for Off-Normal Storage Condition 106F Ambient Temperature (PWR Fuel)........................................... 11.1.1-3 Figure 11.1.1-2 Vertical Concrete Cask Air Temperature (°F) Profile for Off-Normal Storage Condition 106F Ambient Temperature (PWR)
Fuel)...................................................................................................... 11.1.1-4 Figure 11.1.1-3 Concrete Temperature (°F) for Off-Normal Storage Condition -40F Ambient Temperature (PWR Fuel)........................... 11.1.1-5 Figure 11.1.1-4 Vertical Concrete Cask Air Temperature (°F) Profile for Off-Normal Storage Condition -40F Ambient Temperature (PWR Fuel)...................................................................................................... 11.1.1-6 Figure 11.1.3.1-1 Canister and Basket Finite Element Model.......................................... 11.1.3-4 Figure 11.2.4-1 Concrete Cask Base Weldment..........................................................11.2.4-13 Figure 11.2.4-2 Concrete Cask Base Weldment Finite Element Model......................11.2.4-14 Figure 11.2.4-3 Strain Rate Dependent Stress-Strain Curves for Concrete Cask Base Weldment Structural Steel.........................................................11.2.4-15 Figure 11.2.4-4 Acceleration Time-History of the Canister Bottom During the Concrete Cask 24-Inch Drop Accident With Static Strain Properties.............................................................................................11.2.4-16 Figure 11.2.4-5 Acceleration Time-History of the Canister Bottom During the Concrete Cask 24-Inch Drop Accident With Strain Rate Dependent Properties..........................................................................11.2.4-17 Figure 11.2.4-6 Quarter Model of the PWR Basket Support Disk..............................11.2.4-18 Figure 11.2.4-7 Quarter Model of the BWR Basket Support Disk..............................11.2.4-19 Figure 11.2.4-8 Canister Finite Element Model for 60g Bottom End Impact.............11.2.4-20 Figure 11.2.4-9 Identification of the Canister Sections for the Evaluation of Canister Stresses due to a 60g Bottom End Impact............................11.2.4-21 Figure 11.2.6-1 Temperature Boundary Condition Applied to the Nodes of the Inlet for the Fire Accident Condition.................................................... 11.2.6-4 Figure 11.2.11-1 Principal Dimensions and Moment Arms Used in Tornado Evaluation....................................................................................... 11.2.11-14 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-1 Basket Drop Orientations Analyzed for Tip-Over Conditions -
PWR................................................................................................. 11.2.12-27 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-2 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - PWR....................... 11.2.12-28 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-3 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Canister.................. 11.2.12-29 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-4 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Support Disk -
PWR................................................................................................. 11.2.12-30
11-v FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
List of Figures (Continued)
Figure 11.2.12.4.1-5 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Support Disk Loading - PWR................................................................................ 11.2.12-31 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-6 Canister Section Stress Locations.................................................... 11.2.12-32 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-7 Support Disk Section Stress Locations - PWR - Full Model......... 11.2.12-33 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-8 PWR - 109.7 Hz Mode Shape......................................................... 11.2.12-34 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-9 PWR - 370.1 Hz Mode Shape......................................................... 11.2.12-35 Figure 11.2.12.4.1-10 PWR - 371.1 Hz Mode Shape......................................................... 11.2.12-36 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-1 Fuel Basket Drop Orientations Analyzed for Tip-Over Condition - BWR............................................................................. 11.2.12-54 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-2 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - BWR....................... 11.2.12-55 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-3 Fuel Basket/Canister Finite Element Model - Support Disk - BWR...................................................................................... 11.2.12-56 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-4 Support Disk Section Stress Locations - BWR - Full Model.......... 11.2.12-57 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-5 BWR - 79.3 Hz Mode Shape.......................................................... 11.2.12-58 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-6 BWR - 80.2 Hz Mode Shape.......................................................... 11.2.12-59 Figure 11.2.12.4.2-7 BWR - 210.9 Hz Mode Shape........................................................ 11.2.12-60 Figure 11.2.13-1 PWR Configuration Temperature HistoryAll Vents Blocked.......11.2.13-3 Figure 11.2.13-2 BWR Configuration Temperature HistoryAll Vents Blocked.......11.2.13-3 Figure 11.2.15.1.2-1 Two-Dimensional Support Disk Model.............................................11.2.15-9 Figure 11.2.15.1.2-2 PWR Basket Impact Orientations and Case Study Loading Positions for Maine Yankee Consolidated Fuel.............................. 11.2.15-10 Figure 11.2.15.1.5-1 Two-Dimensional Beam Finite Element Model for Maine Yankee Fuel Rod.............................................................................. 11.2.15-27 Figure 11.2.15.1.5-2 Mode Shape and First Buckling Shape for the Maine Yankee Fuel Rod........................................................................................... 11.2.15-28 Figure 11.2.15.1.6-1 Two-Dimensional Beam Finite Element Model for a Fuel Rod with a Missing Grid.......................................................................... 11.2.15-34 Figure 11.2.15.1.6-2 Modal Shape and First Buckling Mode Shape for a Fuel Rod with a Missing Grid.......................................................................... 11.2.15-35 Figure 11.2.16-1 Overall Model Plot for a Typical PWR Fuel Assembly....................11.2.16-6 Figure 11.2.16-2 Detailed View of the PWR 14x14 Fuel Assembly Model................11.2.16-7 Figure 11.2-16-3 ANSYS Model for the PWR Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation............11.2.16-8 Figure 11.2.16-4 Overall Model Plot for a Typical BWR Fuel Assembly................. 11.2.16-12 Figure 11.2.16-5 Detailed View of the BWR 10x10 Fuel Assembly Model............. 11.2.16-13 Figure 11.2.16-6 ANSYS Model for the BWR Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation......... 11.2.16-14
11-vi FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
11.2.16 Fuel Rods Structural Evaluation for Burnup to 62,500 MWd/MTU
This section presents a structural evaluation of PWR and BWR fuel rods with a maximum burnup of 62,500 MWd/MTU for normal and accident conditions of storage.
During normal and off-normal conditions for the fuel in the canister, the loads applied to the fuel assembly are minimal and do not require further evaluation. The only significant axial loading the fuel assembly will experience is the 24-inch drop of the vertical concrete cask. The bounding lateral loading on the fuel assembly occurs during the tip-over accident condition. As presented in Section 11.2.16.1, the lateral loading and axial loading conditions are evaluated for PWR fuel rods considering a bounding configuration of a grid spacer missing for an unsupported fuel rod length up to 60 inches. Based on results of the drop analysis presented in the following sections, PWR fuel assemblies with one or more grid spacers missing or damaged for an unsupported fuel rod length up to 60 inches are, therefore, considered to be undamaged assemblies for loading within the UMS Universal Storage System. Section 11.2.16.2 presents the evaluation for the BWR fuel rods for the end drop and tip-over accident events.
11.2.16.1 PWR Fuel Rod Evaluation
End Drop Evaluation This section presents the buckling evaluation for the UMS Universal Storage System high burnup PWR fuel rods (peak rod average burnup of 62.5 GWd/MTU). In order to account for the cladding oxide layer, a conservative 120-micron thick layer is assumed to be removed from the reference clad in the rod structural evaluation. The 120-micron clad removal is conservative, as this value represents double the maximum oxide layer thickness listed for end-of-life PWR fuel rods in PNL-4835[62]. Applying a time-dependent oxide layer growth approximation to the PNL-4835-reported maximum thickness of 60 microns to account for an increase in burnup from standard (45 GWd/MTU) to high (62.5 GWd/MTU) yields a maximum end-of-life oxide layer in the range of 90 microns. As high burnup claddings are designed to reduce oxidation, actual layers are expected to be significantly lower (reported as low as 20 microns for >70 GWd/MTU M5 zircaloy clad). Therefore, a significant margin exists to the evaluated oxide layer levels.
A 24-inch end drop of the concrete cask subjects the fuel rods to axial loading. The analyses in this section show that the maximum stresses in the high burnup PWR fuel remain below the yield strength in the design basis accident events and confirm that the fuel rods will return to their original configuration following the end drop event.
11.2.16-1 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
11.2.16-2 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
11.2.16-3 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
Margin of Safety Against Case Maximum Stress Intensity (ksi) Yield Strength 1 25.4 +1.93 2 21.8 +2.41 3 41.9 +0.77 4 34.7 +1.14
The case using the 60-inch spacing in conjunction with the minimal cross-section (Case 3) is identified as the bounding case. All stresses were shown to be less than the yield strength.
The results confirm that high burnup PWR fuel with a maximum distance of 60 inches from the bottom to the first grid will remain structurally adequate for the storage design basis cask end drop load conditions.
Tip-Over Evaluation
11.2.16-4 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
Stresses are evaluated against the cladding yield stress at a bounding fuel temperature of 752°F (400°C) to compute margins of safety. The minimum margins of safety in the three cladding materials all occur in the BW17x17 Mark C fuel rod and are summa rized in the following table.
Therefore, the PWR high burnup fuel rods remain structurally adequate during the cask tip-over accident event.
11.2.16-5 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
Figure 11.2.16-1 Overall Model Plot for a Typical PWR Fuel Assembly
See Figure 11.2.16-2 for PWR 14x14 Fuel Assembly Model
11.2.16-6 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
Figure 11.2.16-2 Detailed View of the PWR 14x14 Fuel Assembly
11.2.16-7 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
Figure 11.2.16-3 ANSYS Model for the PW R Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation
11.2.16-8 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
11.2.16.2 BWR Fuel Rod Evaluation
This section presents the structural evaluations of the BWR high burnup fuel assemblies for the cask 24-inch end drop and tip-over accident conditions. The high burnup BWR fuel is considered to have a cladding oxide layer of 125 microns thick. A reduced cladding thickness is assumed due to the cladding oxide layer.
End Drop Evaluation In the end drop orientation, the fuel rods are laterally restrained by the grids and come into contact with the fuel assembly base. The fuel assembly is considered to have an initial of bow of 0.157 inch [64]. The evaluation of the BWR fuel rod is based on the following representative samples of BWR fuel assemblies:
BWR Fuel Cladding Cladding Fuel Rod Gap between fuel Assembly Diameter (in) Thickness Pitch assembly and fuel (in) (in) tube wall (in) 8X8 0.483 0.032 0.64 0.937 9X9 0.433 0.026 0.572 0.891 10X10 0.396 0.024 0.51 0.914
Review of the design basis fuel inventory indicates that the largest gap between the envelop of the fuel rods of a straight fuel assembly and the basket fuel tube inner wall could be 0.937 inch.
In this evaluation, an assembly with an initial bow of 0.157 inch is permitted to displace an additional 0.78 inch to the full gap displacement of 0.937 inch. To implement a bow of 0.157 inch into the fuel assembly, the half symmetry ANSYS model corresponding to a row of fuel rods (Figure 11.2.16-4) is used. The clad is modeled with shell elements (see Figure 11.2.16-5).
Each grid is modeled using brick elements to maintain the spacing between the fuel rods at the grid. The fuel tube is modeled using brick elements to restrict the lateral motion of the fuel assembly. Each of the fuel rods in the ANSYS model is simply supported at each end. A static force is applied to the ANSYS model at the grid nearest the axial center to develop a 0.157 inch lateral displacement. The purpose of the ANSYS model and solution is to provide the coordinates of the fuel clad for the LS-DYNA model. This is accomplished by obtaining a static solution with the ANSYS model, and then using the option to update the coordinates of the nodes based on the displacements from the solution.
11.2.16-9 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
Three (3) LS-DYNA models are considered for the 24-inch cask end drop conditions. All models incorporate a bow of 0.157 inch. These cases envelope the range of the cross-sectional moment of inertia for the BWR fuel rods and the largest grid spacing of the fuel assembly are summarized in the following Table.
Case Fuel Assembly Largest grid spacing (inch) 1 8x8 23.61 2 9x9 22.28 3 10x10 22.57 In each case the thickness of the clad was reduced by 125 microns (0.0049inch). Each case requires a separate ANSYS model and a LS-DYNA model to represent unique coordinates or boundary conditions. The LS-DYNA model employs the same nodes and elements as the ANSYS model (with the incorporation of the 0.157 inch bow). Elastic properties are used in the ANSYS model and the bilinear properties are employed in the LS-DYNA model. An initial downward velocity of 136 in/sec (corresponding to a 24-inch end drop of the storage cask) is assigned to all nodes in the model. The deceleration time history is applied to the nodes of the brick elements representing the fuel tube. The acceleration time history is obtained from the analysis for the 24-inch drop of the VCC in Section 11.2.4. The side walls of the fuel tube are restrained in the lateral direction to maximize the effect of the fuel rods impacting the fuel tube side wall.
The LS-DYNA analyses for Cases 1 through 3 were performed for the duration of 0.08 second to capture the response of the fuel after the 0.02 second loading duration. Post-processing each analysis result identifies the maximum shear stress occurring at the shell surface. The maximum shear stress result from LS-DYNA is factored by two to determine the maximum stress intensity.
The following table contains the maximum stress intensity and the margin of safety (M.S.) for
All stresses are shown to be well below the yield strength. The results confirm th at high burnup BWR fuel will remain structurally adequate for the storage design basis cask end drop load condition.
11.2.16-10 NAC PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REMOVED FSAR - UMS Universal St orage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
Tip-Over Evaluation
11.2.16-11 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
Figure 11.2.16-4 Overall Model Plot for a Typical BWR Fuel Assembly
Overall plot of BWR Model The model without the fuel clad
Top lateral constraint
Inside dimension for the fuel tube is 5.9 inches
The sides of the Grid locations fuel tube measured from bottom of fuel rod (inch)
8x8 9x9 10x10
18.75 18.36 2.15
38.90 38.51 18.80
59.05 58.66 38.95
79.20 78.81 59.10
99.35 98.96 79.25
119.50 119.11 99.40
139.65 139.26 119.55
163.25 161.54 139.70
162.27 See Figure 11.2.16-5 for BWR 10x10 2nd spacer grid
1st spacer grid
11.2.16-12 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A Figure 11.2.16-5 Detailed View of the BWR 10x10 Fuel Assembly Model
Detailed view of the axial section of the fuel assembly
The gap between the assembly and the side is reduced by 0.157 inch to simulate the bow in the fuel assembly.
All shell elements were modeled at the midplane thickness of the clad. The LS-DYNA interface takes into account the thickness of the shell element when determining the contact.
Brick elements for the grid.
A small gap (0.01 inch) was modeled between the fuel rod and bottom brick elements
Brick elements representing the sides of the fuel tube.
The deceleration time history was applied to nodes of these brick The nodes in the elements bricks for the sides and the bottom are restrained in the lateral direction
11.2.16-13 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision 23A
Figure 11.2.16-6 ANSYS Model for the BWR Fuel Rod Tip-Over Evaluation
11.2.16-14 FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
11.2.16.3 Thermal Evaluation of Fuel Rods The UMS system limits normal storage condition fuel cladding temperatures to levels below zirconium alloy or stainless steel cladding temperature limits; therefore, degradation is not expected to occur below this temperature in an inert gas environment.
As shown in Chapter 4, fuel cladding temperature limits for PWR and BWR fuel rods have been established at 400°C (752°F) for normal and off-normal conditions of storage, including transfer operations, and 570°C (1,058ºF) for accident conditions. Chapter 4 demonstrates that the maximum fuel cladding temperatures are well below the temperature limits for all design conditions of storage.
11.2.16-15 THIS PAGE LEFT INTENTIONALLY BLANK FSAR - UMS Universal Storage System September 2023 Docket No. 72-1015 Revision23A
- 56. ASME Section II Part D - Properties, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, United Engineering Center, 345 East 47th Street, New York, 1995/1995 Addenda.
- 57. Impact Dynamics, eds. Z.A. Zukas et al, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
- 58. Seismic Analysis of Safety Related Nuclear Structures and Commentary, ASCE 4-98, American Society of Civil Engineers.
- 59. Combining Modal Responses and Spatial Components in Seismic Response Analysis, Regulatory Guide 1.92, Revision 1, February 1976, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Standards Development.
- 60. ISG-15, Materials Evaluation, Interim Staff Guidance-15, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, January 2001.
- 61. Mechanical Properties for Irradiated Zircaloy, K. J. Geelhood and C. E. Beyer, Transactions of the American Nuclear Society, Volume 93, 2005.
- 62. PNL-4835, Technical Basis for Storage of Zircaloy-Clad Spent Fuel in Inert Gases, Pacific Northwest Laboratory, A. B. Johnson, Jr. and E. R. Gilbert, September 1983.
- 63. ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code,Section XI, Rules for Inservice Inspection of Nuclear Power Plant Components, 1995 Edition, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, July 1995.
- 64. D. A. Williamson, Postirradiation Fuel Assembly Dimensions for Transportation and Storage Cask Dimensions, Radwaste magazine, January 1994.
- 65. U.S. Department of Energy, PNNL-17700, PNNL Stress/Strain Correlation for Zircaloy, Geelhood, K.J, et al., July 2008.
- 66. B. Cazalis, C., et al., The PROMETRA Program: A Reliable Material Database for Highly Irradiated ZIRCALOY-4, ZIRLOTM, and M5TM Fuel Claddings, Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Technology, Beijing, China, August 2005.
- 67. Bourdiliau, B, et al., Impact of Irradiation Damage Recovery During Transportation of the Subsequent Room Temperature Tensile Behavior of Irradiated Zirconium Alloys, JAI Vol.
7 No. 9.
11.3-5 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK