ML063450092: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
| issue date = 12/06/2006 | | issue date = 12/06/2006 | ||
| title = Letter to Stakeholders Consideration of Rulemaking to Reduce the Likelihood of Funding Shortfalls for Decommissioning Under the License Termination Rule | | title = Letter to Stakeholders Consideration of Rulemaking to Reduce the Likelihood of Funding Shortfalls for Decommissioning Under the License Termination Rule | ||
| author name = Rathbun D | | author name = Rathbun D | ||
| author affiliation = NRC/FSME/DILR | | author affiliation = NRC/FSME/DILR | ||
| addressee name = Adler B, Allen R, Anderson R, Boeldt E, Boyd M, Charbeneau R | | addressee name = Adler B, Allen R, Anderson R, Boeldt E, Boyd M, Charbeneau R, Cloud P, Conley T, Couture G, Culberson D, Domotor S, Ernst J, Folkers C, Ford R, Holman C, Hostetter D, Karakantas S, Langhorst S, Lochbaum D, Maiers R, Mcnulty P, Miller J, Moore B, Nimitz R, O'Neill T, Orth S, Pilmer D, Quattrocchi J, Rice T, Riley J, Schrader J, Sullivan T, Vannoordennen G, Warren J | ||
| addressee affiliation = American Nuclear Insurers, AREVA NP, Inc, Bayer Material Science, Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Co, Entergy Nuclear, Inc, Exelon Corp, Fuel Cycle Facilities Forum, Gamma Industry Processing Alliance, General Electric Co, Honeywell International, Inc, Merck & Co, Inc, North Carolina Waste Awareness & Reduction Network (NC WARN), NRC/RGN-I, NRC/RGN-III, Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI), Nuclear Fuel Services, Inc, Nuclear Information & Resource Service (NIRS), Pennsylvania State Univ, Public Citizen, Inc, Southern California Edison Co, Southern Nuclear Operating Co, Inc, State of IL, Emergency Management Agency, State of KS, Dept of Health & Environment, State of NY, Dept of Environmental Conservation, State of PA, Dept of Environmental Protection, Temple Univ, Union of Concerned Scientists, Univ of Missouri, Univ of Texas, US Dept of Energy (DOE), US Dept of the Army, US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Washington Univ in St. Louis | | addressee affiliation = American Nuclear Insurers, AREVA NP, Inc, Bayer Material Science, Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Co, Entergy Nuclear, Inc, Exelon Corp, Fuel Cycle Facilities Forum, Gamma Industry Processing Alliance, General Electric Co, Honeywell International, Inc, Merck & Co, Inc, North Carolina Waste Awareness & Reduction Network (NC WARN), NRC/RGN-I, NRC/RGN-III, Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI), Nuclear Fuel Services, Inc, Nuclear Information & Resource Service (NIRS), Pennsylvania State Univ, Public Citizen, Inc, Southern California Edison Co, Southern Nuclear Operating Co, Inc, State of IL, Emergency Management Agency, State of KS, Dept of Health & Environment, State of NY, Dept of Environmental Conservation, State of PA, Dept of Environmental Protection, Temple Univ, Union of Concerned Scientists, Univ of Missouri, Univ of Texas, US Dept of Energy (DOE), US Dept of the Army, US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Washington Univ in St. Louis | ||
| docket = | | docket = | ||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:December 6, 2006 TO: | {{#Wiki_filter:December 6, 2006 TO: Stakeholders Interested In Regulation of Subsurface Contamination and Decommissioning Financial Assurance | ||
==SUBJECT:== | ==SUBJECT:== | ||
PUBLIC MEETING ON CONSIDERATION OF RULEMAKING TO REDUCE THE LIKELIHOOD OF FUNDING SHORTFALLS FOR DECOMMISSIONING UNDER THE LICENSE TERMINATION RULE On January 10, 2007, the NRC will host a public meeting using a "roundtable" format. The purpose of the meeting is to allow stakeholders an opportunity to discuss concerns and interact with other interested parties on the regulatory issues summarized below. | PUBLIC MEETING ON CONSIDERATION OF RULEMAKING TO REDUCE THE LIKELIHOOD OF FUNDING SHORTFALLS FOR DECOMMISSIONING UNDER THE LICENSE TERMINATION RULE On January 10, 2007, the NRC will host a public meeting using a "roundtable" format. | ||
The purpose of the meeting is to allow stakeholders an opportunity to discuss concerns and interact with other interested parties on the regulatory issues summarized below. | |||
The meeting will take place from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM EST at the Residence Inn Bethesda Downtown, 7335 Wisconsin Avenue, Bethesda, MD (301-718-0200). The NRC is asking those planning to attend the meeting to pre-register by contacting Jayne McCausland, (301) 415-6219, fax (301) 415-5369, or e-mail jmm2@nrc.gov. You may also register the day of the meeting beginning at 8:30 AM. | The meeting will take place from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM EST at the Residence Inn Bethesda Downtown, 7335 Wisconsin Avenue, Bethesda, MD (301-718-0200). The NRC is asking those planning to attend the meeting to pre-register by contacting Jayne McCausland, (301) 415-6219, fax (301) 415-5369, or e-mail jmm2@nrc.gov. You may also register the day of the meeting beginning at 8:30 AM. | ||
In 2003, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) decided to proceed with a proposed rulemaking to reduce the likelihood of sites that fail to complete decommissioning actions. Such sites are called "legacy sites," which are sites that are in decommissioning but whose operators cannot complete the work and terminate the license in accordance with NRC regulations | In 2003, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) decided to proceed with a proposed rulemaking to reduce the likelihood of sites that fail to complete decommissioning actions. Such sites are called "legacy sites," which are sites that are in decommissioning but whose operators cannot complete the work and terminate the license in accordance with NRC regulations because of technical or financial reasons. | ||
Regulatory amendments are under consideration that will affect both facility operations and licensee financial assurance for decommissioning. One proposed change would require each NRC licensee to conduct operations, to the extent practicable, so as to minimize the presence of contamination in the subsurface environment. A second would require certain licensees, based on their capability for causing long-lasting subsurface | To date, the legacy sites have been materials facilities, primarily those that processed uranium and thorium, all of which had subsurface contamination. A risk-informed approach for NRC regulation of subsurface contamination to prevent legacy sites would affect several hundred facilities, including those with materials licenses and operators of nuclear power reactors. NRC is soliciting public input by holding a roundtable meeting as part of its work on a proposed rule which has as its objective the prevention of future legacy sites. | ||
Regulatory amendments are under consideration that will affect both facility operations and licensee financial assurance for decommissioning. One proposed change would require each NRC licensee to conduct operations, to the extent practicable, so as to minimize the presence of contamination in the subsurface environment. A second would require certain licensees, based on their capability for causing long-lasting subsurface contamination, to check for the presence of such contamination. NRC experience with legacy sites demonstrates that soil or groundwater contamination, if not addressed during the operating life of the facility, can increase decommissioning costs to levels much higher than initially funded and may contribute to off-site radionuclide migration, causing additional expense and delay in returning the site to other productive uses. | |||
contamination, to check for the presence of such contamination. NRC experience with legacy sites demonstrates that soil or groundwater contamination, if not addressed during the operating life of the facility, can increase decommissioning costs to levels much higher than initially funded and may contribute to off-site radionuclide migration, causing additional expense and delay in returning the site to other productive uses. | |||
Another regulatory amendment under consideration is to eliminate the escrow account as an approved financial assurance mechanism due to its ineffectiveness in bankruptcy actions. Two other financial assurance mechanisms that pose similar financial risk during bankruptcy are the unsecured Parent Company Guarantee and unsecured Self- | Another regulatory amendment under consideration is to eliminate the escrow account as an approved financial assurance mechanism due to its ineffectiveness in bankruptcy actions. Two other financial assurance mechanisms that pose similar financial risk during bankruptcy are the unsecured Parent Company Guarantee and unsecured Self- | ||
Guarantee. Reliance on these financial assurance mechanisms may increase the likelihood of future legacy sites. | Guarantee. Reliance on these financial assurance mechanisms may increase the likelihood of future legacy sites. | ||
As stated above, the format for this public meeting will be a "roundtable" format. | As stated above, the format for this public meeting will be a "roundtable" format. | ||
Participants at the roundtable will be the invited stakeholders representing the broad spectrum of interests who may be affected by this rulemaking. The roundtable format is being used for this meeting to promote a dialogue among the representatives at the table on the issues of concern. Opportunities will be provided for comments and questions from the audience. Questions on the meeting format, including participation in the roundtable, should be directed to the meeting facilitator, Lance Rakovan. Mr. Rakovan can be reached at (301) 415-2589 or via e-mail LRC2@nrc.gov. If an attendee will require special services, such as services for the hearing impaired, please notify Ms. | Participants at the roundtable will be the invited stakeholders representing the broad spectrum of interests who may be affected by this rulemaking. The roundtable format is being used for this meeting to promote a dialogue among the representatives at the table on the issues of concern. Opportunities will be provided for comments and questions from the audience. Questions on the meeting format, including participation in the roundtable, should be directed to the meeting facilitator, Lance Rakovan. Mr. | ||
Rakovan can be reached at (301) 415-2589 or via e-mail LRC2@nrc.gov. If an attendee will require special services, such as services for the hearing impaired, please notify Ms. | |||
McCausland of these requirements when pre-registering. Individuals unable to attend the meeting will be able to listen via teleconference. For teleconference information, please contact Ms. McCausland. | McCausland of these requirements when pre-registering. Individuals unable to attend the meeting will be able to listen via teleconference. For teleconference information, please contact Ms. McCausland. | ||
The NRC staff is in the process of developing a notice of this public meeting which will be published soon in the Federal Register. The meeting notice and a meeting agenda | The NRC staff is in the process of developing a notice of this public meeting which will be published soon in the Federal Register. The meeting notice and a meeting agenda will be posted on the NRC web site at: http://www.nrc.gov/public-involve/public-meetings/index.cfm. | ||
Sincerely, | |||
will be posted on the NRC web site at: | /RA/ | ||
http://www.nrc.gov/public-involve/public-meetings/index.cfm. Sincerely, | Dennis Rathbun, Director Division of Intergovernmental Liaison and Rulemaking Office of Federal and State Materials and Environmental Management Programs | ||
List of Stakeholders that were sent the stakeholder letter Adler, Bruce | List of Stakeholders that were sent the stakeholder letter Adler, Bruce General Electric Company Allen, Rich Illinois Emergency Management Agency Anderson, Ralph Nuclear Energy Institute Boeldt, Eric Pennsylvania State University Boyd, Michele Public Citizen Charbeneau, Randall University of Texas Cloud, Paul US Army Conley, Tom Kansas Dept of Health & Environment Couture, Gerard Westinghouse Electric Company Culberson, Dave Fuel Cycle Facilities Forum Domotor, Stephen US Dept of Energy Ernst, John University of Missouri Folkers, Cindy Nuclear Information and Resource Services Ford, Robert US Environmental Protection Agency Holman, Charlie Areva NP, Inc. | ||
Hostetter, Dwight Southern Nuclear Karakantas, Susan Temple University Langhorst, Susan Washington University Lochbaum, David Union of Concerned Scientists Maiers, Robert Pennsylvania Dept of Environmental Protection McNulty, Paul Entergy Nuclear Pilgrim Station Miller, John Merck & Co Moore, B. Marie Nuclear Fuel Services, Inc. | |||
Nimitz, Ronald NRC R-I O'Neill, Thomas Exelon Corporation Orth, Steve NRC R-III Pilmer, David Southern California Edison Quattrocchi, John American Nuclear Insurers Rice, Tim New York State Dept of Environmental Conservation Riley, Jack Honeywell International, Inc. | |||
Schrader, John Gamma Industry Processing Alliance Sullivan, Terrence Bayer MaterialScience van Noordennen, Gerry Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company Warren, Jim North Carolina Waste Reduction & Awareness Network}} | |||
Latest revision as of 12:27, 23 November 2019
Text
December 6, 2006 TO: Stakeholders Interested In Regulation of Subsurface Contamination and Decommissioning Financial Assurance
SUBJECT:
PUBLIC MEETING ON CONSIDERATION OF RULEMAKING TO REDUCE THE LIKELIHOOD OF FUNDING SHORTFALLS FOR DECOMMISSIONING UNDER THE LICENSE TERMINATION RULE On January 10, 2007, the NRC will host a public meeting using a "roundtable" format.
The purpose of the meeting is to allow stakeholders an opportunity to discuss concerns and interact with other interested parties on the regulatory issues summarized below.
The meeting will take place from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM EST at the Residence Inn Bethesda Downtown, 7335 Wisconsin Avenue, Bethesda, MD (301-718-0200). The NRC is asking those planning to attend the meeting to pre-register by contacting Jayne McCausland, (301) 415-6219, fax (301) 415-5369, or e-mail jmm2@nrc.gov. You may also register the day of the meeting beginning at 8:30 AM.
In 2003, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) decided to proceed with a proposed rulemaking to reduce the likelihood of sites that fail to complete decommissioning actions. Such sites are called "legacy sites," which are sites that are in decommissioning but whose operators cannot complete the work and terminate the license in accordance with NRC regulations because of technical or financial reasons.
To date, the legacy sites have been materials facilities, primarily those that processed uranium and thorium, all of which had subsurface contamination. A risk-informed approach for NRC regulation of subsurface contamination to prevent legacy sites would affect several hundred facilities, including those with materials licenses and operators of nuclear power reactors. NRC is soliciting public input by holding a roundtable meeting as part of its work on a proposed rule which has as its objective the prevention of future legacy sites.
Regulatory amendments are under consideration that will affect both facility operations and licensee financial assurance for decommissioning. One proposed change would require each NRC licensee to conduct operations, to the extent practicable, so as to minimize the presence of contamination in the subsurface environment. A second would require certain licensees, based on their capability for causing long-lasting subsurface contamination, to check for the presence of such contamination. NRC experience with legacy sites demonstrates that soil or groundwater contamination, if not addressed during the operating life of the facility, can increase decommissioning costs to levels much higher than initially funded and may contribute to off-site radionuclide migration, causing additional expense and delay in returning the site to other productive uses.
Another regulatory amendment under consideration is to eliminate the escrow account as an approved financial assurance mechanism due to its ineffectiveness in bankruptcy actions. Two other financial assurance mechanisms that pose similar financial risk during bankruptcy are the unsecured Parent Company Guarantee and unsecured Self-
Guarantee. Reliance on these financial assurance mechanisms may increase the likelihood of future legacy sites.
As stated above, the format for this public meeting will be a "roundtable" format.
Participants at the roundtable will be the invited stakeholders representing the broad spectrum of interests who may be affected by this rulemaking. The roundtable format is being used for this meeting to promote a dialogue among the representatives at the table on the issues of concern. Opportunities will be provided for comments and questions from the audience. Questions on the meeting format, including participation in the roundtable, should be directed to the meeting facilitator, Lance Rakovan. Mr.
Rakovan can be reached at (301) 415-2589 or via e-mail LRC2@nrc.gov. If an attendee will require special services, such as services for the hearing impaired, please notify Ms.
McCausland of these requirements when pre-registering. Individuals unable to attend the meeting will be able to listen via teleconference. For teleconference information, please contact Ms. McCausland.
The NRC staff is in the process of developing a notice of this public meeting which will be published soon in the Federal Register. The meeting notice and a meeting agenda will be posted on the NRC web site at: http://www.nrc.gov/public-involve/public-meetings/index.cfm.
Sincerely,
/RA/
Dennis Rathbun, Director Division of Intergovernmental Liaison and Rulemaking Office of Federal and State Materials and Environmental Management Programs
List of Stakeholders that were sent the stakeholder letter Adler, Bruce General Electric Company Allen, Rich Illinois Emergency Management Agency Anderson, Ralph Nuclear Energy Institute Boeldt, Eric Pennsylvania State University Boyd, Michele Public Citizen Charbeneau, Randall University of Texas Cloud, Paul US Army Conley, Tom Kansas Dept of Health & Environment Couture, Gerard Westinghouse Electric Company Culberson, Dave Fuel Cycle Facilities Forum Domotor, Stephen US Dept of Energy Ernst, John University of Missouri Folkers, Cindy Nuclear Information and Resource Services Ford, Robert US Environmental Protection Agency Holman, Charlie Areva NP, Inc.
Hostetter, Dwight Southern Nuclear Karakantas, Susan Temple University Langhorst, Susan Washington University Lochbaum, David Union of Concerned Scientists Maiers, Robert Pennsylvania Dept of Environmental Protection McNulty, Paul Entergy Nuclear Pilgrim Station Miller, John Merck & Co Moore, B. Marie Nuclear Fuel Services, Inc.
Nimitz, Ronald NRC R-I O'Neill, Thomas Exelon Corporation Orth, Steve NRC R-III Pilmer, David Southern California Edison Quattrocchi, John American Nuclear Insurers Rice, Tim New York State Dept of Environmental Conservation Riley, Jack Honeywell International, Inc.
Schrader, John Gamma Industry Processing Alliance Sullivan, Terrence Bayer MaterialScience van Noordennen, Gerry Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company Warren, Jim North Carolina Waste Reduction & Awareness Network