View source for JAFP-08-0109, Submittal of the Final Ultrasonic Test Results on the N2C-SE Weld Overlay

{{Adams
| number = ML082970190
| issue date = 10/20/2008
| title = Submittal of the Final Ultrasonic Test Results on the N2C-SE Weld Overlay
| author name = Dorman E
| author affiliation = Entergy Nuclear Northeast, Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc
| addressee name = 
| addressee affiliation = NRC/Document Control Desk, NRC/NRR
| docket = 05000333
| license number = DPR-059
| contact person = 
| case reference number = JAFP-08-0109
| document type = Inservice/Preservice Inspection and Test Report, Letter type:JAFP
| page count = 9
}}

=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Entergy Nuclear Northeast Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
James A. Fitzpatrick NPP
   ---- Entergy                                                          P.O. Box 110 Lycoming, NY 13093 Tel 315-342-3840 JAFP-08-0109 October 20, 2008 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555

==SUBJECT:==
James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant Docket No. 50-333 License No. DPR-59 Submittal of the Final Ultrasonic Test Results on the N2C-SE Weld Overlay

==REFERENCES:==
: 1) Entergy Letter to NRC, JAFP-08-0102, "James A. FitzPatrick Request for Relief (RR-7 Revision 1) - Proposed Alternative to ASME Code Requirements for Weld Overlay Repairs", dated October 1, 2008

==Dear Sir or Madam:==
of reference 1 documented commitments to submit to the NRC, within fourteen days of the completion of the final ultrasonic test (UT) on the weld overlay proposed in the subject relief request, the following:
: 1) Weld overlay examination results including a listing of indications detected;
: 2) Disposition of indications using the standards of ASME Section Xl, Subsection IWB-3514-2 and/or IWB-3514-3 criteria and, if possible, the type and nature of the indications; and
: 3) A discussion of any repairs to the weld overlay material and/or base metal and the reason for the repairs.
In summary the weld overlay repair was performed to N-2C-SE per work order 00106631 and Relief Request RR-7. No repairs, to the weld overlay material and/or base material, were required. Ultrasonic Examination of the weld overlay was performed per ASME Appendix VIII requirements (see Enclosure 1). The examination identified no recordable indications and noted the original axial flaw as previously identified in the original examination. No indications required evaluation to ASME Section Xl, Subsection IWB 3514-2 and/or IWB-3514-3 criteria. of this letter contains a copy of the GE Hitachi Examination Summary, Report No.
08UT175.
There are no new commitment made in this letter and the final commitment made in reference 1 will be completed as scheduled.

JAFP-08-0109 Page 2 of 2 If you have any questions or require additional information, please contact Mr. Eugene Dorman, Acting Licensing Manager, at 315-349-6810.
Sincerely, Eugene Dorman Acting Licensing Manager ED/ed cc:
Mr. Samuel J. Collins, Regional Administrator     Mr. Bhalchandra Vaidya, Project U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region        Manager 475 Allendale Road                                Plant Licensing Branch King of Prussia, PA 19406-1415                    U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop O-8-C2A Office of NRC Resident Inspector                  Washington, DC 20555 James A. Fitzpatrick Nuclear Power Plant P.O. Box 136                                      Mr. Charles Donaldson, Esquire Lycoming, New York 13093                          Assistant Attorney General New York Department of Law Mr. Paul Tonko, President                         120 Broadway New York State Energy Research and                New York, New York 10271 Development Authority 17 Columbia Circle                                Mr. Paul Eddy Albany, New York 12203-6399                       New York State Department of Public Services
: 3. Empire State Plaza Albany, NewYork 12223-1350

Enclosure 1 to JAF-08-0109 James A. Fitzpatrick Nuclear Power Station Docket No. 50-333 GE HITACHI EXAMINATION 

==SUMMARY==
SHEET REPORT No. 08UT175

Report No.:
HITACHI                                     EXAMINATION 

==SUMMARY==
SHEET                                           08UT175 Site:                           Fitzpatrick               Component ID:                                  N2C-SE Outage:                                RFO18                                                                 WELD OVERLAY System:
vj .......
02-2                  ASME Cot.:       B-F          ASME Item          B5.10     Aug Req                   N/A
-I
     - Exams            Data Sheet                Cal Sheet i         Procedure                Calibration Block         Exam / Oper,     Cert Leve
                                                                                                                                                       . i Date Performed                                                                                                              Personnel
                                                ,i III        !10/4/2008 45' RL                 D-106                  N/A        ENN-NDE-9.29 Ve./Rev 1          CAL-DPTH-070             Scott Erickson D-105                  N/A        ENN-NDE-9.29 Ver/Rev 1          CAL-DPTH-070            Scott Erickson                      10/4/2008 70' RL                 D-104                  N/A        ENN-NDE-9.29 Ver/Rev 1          CAL-DPTH-070            Scott Erickson          HIl         10/4/2008
_o0*Long...-              D-103                  N/A. -     ENN-NDE-9.29 Ver/Rev 1          CAL-DPTH-070            Scott Erickson         Ill          1o0/4/2008 Examination Results:
During the Manual Ultrasonic Examination of the above referenced componenL no new ISIor PSI recordable indications were detected utilizing a 0*, 700 RL,and ODCR RL for the PSI portion and 450 RLfor the SI portion of the exam.
No change observed to the thru-wall height (0.51') of previously recorded flow prior to weld overlay repair.
100% of the code required volume was examined.
This UT Examination meets the 2001 Edition of ASME Section xi with the 2003 Addenda and is in accordance with Appendix VIII2001 Edition as amended and mandated by 10CFR50 Amended Requirements, Final Rule dated October 1, 2004 Examination results were compared to Data Report                             N/A             from:       N/A                                       -    Change These examinations were performed under Work Order:                               00125346                                                              No Change This Summary and the following data sheets have been reviewed and ac/ed                               by the following personnel:
                                                                                                                                           )RWRP              N/A N7         10     -&                                                                 Dose:         251      mr.
Prepared By-                                       Level:      Date:     UtiIit                                        Date:
ANII Review.                                  Date:            Page    1       of    6

0            &#xfd; HITACHI Ultrasonic Calibration and Examination Record Manual Piping and Components                                              I Report Number.             08UT175
.Site/Unit:         Fitzpatrick/i                                                                                        Data Sheet Number:         D-106 Outage:           RFO18                                                                                                Linearity Sheet            L-007 Prncpdijrp         ENN-NDE-9 29
    \.UILk   iAAU        nJt  fn.AA 01     6LJW~A.f'A _     I~-                                  Procedur           ENN-N--.-9.
Ver/Rev:        1                  DRR:     N/A ss               FLAT           2.0"      Calibration        Cal Time Material             Size         Thick       Initial Cal:                                                    Search Unit Data i105
* Ultra gel /II0                              22    iCal Check Couplant              Couplar it batch                                                         RTD                     01-107               2(8x14) mm/Rect.
Cal Check-        1314                  Manufacturer-           Serial Number                   Size/Shape:
261732                      95 Thermometer S/N                 Cal Temp.             Final Cal:        1400                         0.45                         45.                        45.
Incident Point:              Nominal Angle:            Measured Angle:
DAC Construction 2.0 MHz          TRL2-Aust                RL                  2 Frequency:            Style:              Mode:            Elements:
Scan Direction                       Ax Cal Reflector                    .8"SDH                                                                               Search Unit Cable Signal Amplitude:                  80%
RG-174                   1Z                 0 Signal Sweep:                   5.40 Div                                                                    Cable Type:            Length:         Connectors:
Signal dB:                       27.1 dB Sweep 0-10=               2.000 in          Metal Path                                                               Instrument Settings Calibration Verification                                                      Panametrics / Epoch 4                     031534305 Manufacturer/Model:                   Serial Number.
Field Simulator Block S/N;                CAL-RHOM-117 Reflector             NSDH                  NIA                           7.615eus            02318 in./usec.                     0.8-3.0 Zero:                   Velocity:               Narrowband Filter:
Amplitude               40%                  NIA Gain (dB)              27.1                 N/A                            Auto          Fullwove               2.000 in           Sq. i Max Sweep (SD) I              22                  .1A                       Rep Rate:      Rectification:             Range:         Pulser/Energy:
400 Ohms             0%                2.0 MHz             Dual Acceptable Linearity performed :                12 Damping:           Reject:           Frequency:          Mode:
Exam Data for Weld: N2C-SE WELD OVERLAY                                                            Exam Comments / Limitations:
Configuration:                                         Exams performed to maintain a 5% to 20% noise level.
00                          120* F                     261732                          ?&9iFWoav'P
                                                                                                                 ~          ~           4,              "
Exam Surface:                   Exam Temp.             Exam Thermometer Axial U-PST       Scan-ald     I Recordable        Exam Circ                      DNST                      Indications I Angle UPSr             3               NRI           4?-
ONST            33 .1             NRI           45" Circ                       UPST           39.1 --*          NRI
                                                                            --      :45 i
* Em StartL "E~am                    1252               Exam End:            1314 Circ                      DNST            39.1              NRI           450 c       .                    Scot EricksonI Initials:     Examiner:                                  Level:             GE Reviewe By:                               Level:       Date:
N/A                         N/A Utility Rey     .                             Date:
Initials:      Examiner 2:                                Level:
initial Col/Exam Date:                   10/4/2008                             ANII Review.--      -                                             Page 2         of6 Dote

Ultrasonic Calibration and Examination Record HITACHI                                                     Manual Piping and Components Report Number.             08UT175 I
'Site/Unit:        Fit-zptrick/1                                                                                      Data Sheet Number:         D-105 Outage:           RF018                                                                                             Linearity Sheet            L-007 Calibration Data for Block:                  CAL-DPTH-070                                     Procedure:        ENN-NDE-9.29 Ver / Rev:     1                DRR:      NIA 55             FLAT          2.0"     i Calibration       Cal Time Material           Size         Thick       Initial Cal:                                                     Search Unit Data Ultrael                     06225             Col Check 1237                         RTD                    04-392                2('1045)mm/Rect.
Couplant            Couplant batch Cal Check         1251                    Manufacturer:          Serial Number                  Size/Shape:
261732                    95*F Thermometer S/N                Cal Temp.         i Final Cal:       11407                          0.5                      ODCR                           80.
incident Point:           Nominal Angle:              Measured Angle:
DAC Construction 2.0 MHz        85rRL2-Aust                RL                  2 Frequency:            Style:             Mode:            Elements:
Scan Direction                    Ax Cal Reflector                  .1'501-                                                                              Search Unit Cable Signal Amplitude:                80%
RG-174                  6L                0 Signal Sweep:                  3.80 Div                                                                  Cable Type:            Length:         Connectors:
Signal dB:                     35.7 dB Sweep 0-10=            L500 in          Metal Path                                                                Instrument Settings Calibration Verification                                                      Ponametrics/ Epoch 4                      031534305 Manufacturer/model:                   Serial Number:
Field Simulator Block S/N:              CAL-RHOM-117
                    . Reflector      i     NSDH                  N/A 9.825 us             02311 in./sec.                     0.8- 3.0 Zero:                  Velocity:                Norrowband Filter:
Amplitude              80%                  N/A
                                                              ;- "N/A . .
Gain *dB)             31.4                                                Auto           Fullwave              L500 in            sq. / Max N/A                          Rep Rote:     Rectification:           Range:
Sweep (ISD)             6.1                                                                                                     Pulser/Energy:
400 Ohms             0%               2.0 MHz             Dual Acceptable Linearity performed:             9118 Damping:           Reject            Frequency:           Mode:
Exam Data for Weld: N2C-SE WELD OVERLAY                                                            Exam Comments / Limitations:
Configuration:                                         i Exams performed to maintain a 5% to 20% noise /de/l.
00                        120&deg; F                    261732
                                                                                                           #&&j~4JSW0 A-7            /      M.g Exam Surface:                  Exam Temp.            Exam Thermometer Axial                   SUPST DNST        I Scan   dB     Recordable Indications       Exam Angle Circ Ax                    (UPST           37.7             NRI             80 Ax                    DNST            37.7             NRI             807 Circ                    LIPST           37.7             NRI      i8
                                                                                      -       Exam Start:           1237              Exam End:             1251 Circ                   DNST            37.7             NRI             80 Scott Erickson                      III Initials-     Examin er.                              Level:              GE eied           B      y                 Level:         Date:
Date1/./,      e" N/A                         N/A Dote:
Initials:     Exomin er 2:                           Level:              utility Rev Initial Col/Exam Dot e:               10/4/2008                            ANI Reve.                                                         Page     3      of 6 Dote:

Ultrasonic Calibration and Examination Record 0
                   ,a,            HITACHI                                                     Manual       Piping      and Components Report Number                 08U T175 I
(.. Site/Unit:
Outage:           Fitzpatrick/1 RF018 Data Sheet Number:
Linearity Sheet D-104 L-007 Calibration Data for Block.                  CAL-DPTH-070                                   i Procedure:           ENN-NDE-9.29 Ver/Rev:         1                 DRR-       N/A SS              FLAT         2.0"      Calibration         Cal Time Material            Size        Thick        n
                                                        *initial Cal:
Cal:        ..
                                                                          ;,1108      .                                      Search Unit Data
                  *;                   o*s             iCal Check- 1218 Couplant             Couplant batch                                                           RTD                     87-296                    2f(x844 mm/Rect Cal Check           1236                     Manufacturer:            Serial Number                     Size/Shape:
261732                     95&deg; F Thermometer S/N                Cal Temp.           Final Cal:         1405                          0.35                           70*                            70" Incident Point             Nominal Angle:                  Measured Angle:
DAC Construction 2.0 MHz          70'TRL2-Aust                  RL                  2 Frequency:             Style:                 mode:            Elements:
Scan Direction Cal Reflector                  .5" SDH                                                                                  Search Unit Cable Signal Amplitude                 80%
RG-174                   12'                  0 Signal Sweep:                  5.70 Div                                                                     Cable Type:              Length:           Connectors:
Signal dB:                     47.1 d8 Sweep 0-10 =            2.500 in       Metal Path                                                                     Instrument Settings Calibration Verification                                                         f'anametrics / Epoch 4                       031534305 Manufacturer/Model:                     Serial Number.
FlieId Simulator Block S/N:            coAL-RHOM-117 9.275 uis              0.231 in.jJsec.                       0.8- 3.0 Reflector           NSDH                 NIA Zero:                    velocity:                   Norrowband Filter i   Amplitude            80%                 N/A Gain (dB)           47.1                NIA                               Auto            Fullwave                2.500 in             sq. / Max Rep Rate:       Rectification:            Range:            Pulser/Energy:
1Sweep (SD)             3.8                N/A 400 Ohms               0%                 2.0 MHz              Dual Acceptable Linearity performed:                                                                        Reject              Frequency:           Mode:
Damping:
Exam Data for Weld: N2c-SE WELD OVERLAY                                                                Exam Comments / Limitations:
Configuration:                                            Exams performed to maintain a 5% to 20% noise levo I _OD                     120&deg; F                    261732                                                       .4~ T'   ~
2A      (Kfs           -     IL Exam Surface:                Exam Temp.             Exam Thermometer Axial                    UPSTI       Scan d         Recordable          Exam Circ                   DNST     1 Indications        Angle Ax                     UPST          49. 1      !      NRI              70&deg; Ax                      NST          49.
NRI             70" Circ                   UPST          49.
1 NRI           70       Exam Start:             1218               Exam End:               1235 Circ                   DNST           49.        S      NR       i      70.
Scott Erickson Initials:      Examiner.                              Level:               GE RevieGwed By                               Level:           Clate:
N/A                        N/A Level:              Utility Rev    .                               Date:
Initials:      Examiner 2: .
Initial Col/Exam Dote:               101412008                                                                                                       Page    4      of 6 ANII Review.                                   Dote:

I   ....
HITACHI                          !
Ultrasonic Calibration and Examination Record Manual Piping and Components Report Number.              08UT175 I
:Site/Unit          Fitzpatrick/1                                                                                         Data Sheet Number           0-103 Outage:           RFO18                                                                                                 Linearity Sheet:            L-007 Calibration Data for Block:                    CAL-DPTH-070                                       Procedure:         ENN-NDE-9.29 Ver / Rev:       1               DRR:       NIA 55             FLAT          2.0"      'Calibration          Cal Time Material            Size        Thick       initial Cal:       i                                                Search Unit Data Liltragel 11                06225              Clcek iCoICheck            1/152 15 Couplont            Couplant botch            - o              t    -217 KBA                   01031                   .43N.2ZlRnd.
Manufacturer'            Serial Number                  Size/Shape:
261732 26132                5FCal Cal.Temp..Fin.l.Cal 95/N                     Check       11217
                                                                           *4-2 Thermomete r SIN                Cal Temp.          1:Final Col:       1=1402                                                                                        A NIA                        0*                           0.s incident Point:            Nominal Angle:              Measured Angle:
DAC Construction 2.0 MHz           MSEB2                Lond.                 2 Frequency:            Style:              Mode:             Elements:
Scan Direction                     AX Col Reflector                   .5" SDH                                                                                 Search Unit Cable Signal Amplitude:                  80%
RG-174                 12Z                  0 Signal Sweep:                   2.40 Div                                                                       Cable Type:           Length:          Connectors:
Signal dB:                       37.6 dB Sweep 0-10 =             2.000 in         Metal Path                                                                   Instrument Settings Calibration Verification                                                          Ponametnics / Epoch 4                    031534305 Manufacturer/Model:                   Serial Number.
Field Simulator Block S/N:              CAL-RHOH-117 Reflector           NSDH                   NIA                             9.96eus              02283 in./lsec.                 0.8-3.0MHz Zero:                  velocity:                 Norrowband Filter:
Amplitude             80%           i       NIA GainldB)             34.4                  h-/A                             Auto           Fullwave             2.000 in            Sq. / Max Sweep (SD)               1.5                N/A                           Rep Rate:      Rectification:           Range:          Pulser/Energy:
400 Ohms              0%               2.0 MHz           " Dual Acceptable Linearity performed:             91      008 Damping:           Reject:           Frequency:           Mode:
Exam Data for Weld: Nac-SE WELD OVERLAY                                                               Exam Comments / Limitations:
Configuration:                                             Exams performed to maintain a 5% to 20% noise level.
OD                      120* F                      261732 Exam Surface:                Exam Temp.              Exam Thermometer Axial                    UIPST         Scan cB        Recordable       I Exam_x Circ                  DNST                        Indications           Angle Ax                     UPST            43.6             NRI              o" Ax ...                  NT     .       43.6             NRI
                                                                                          .    . Exam Stort:            1W58              Exam End:              1216 Scott Erickson Initials:      Examiner.                                Level:                GE Revie~ed By                            Level:         Dote:
                                                                                                                              /o/ A"/,/,
N/A                         N/A Date:
Initials:      Examiner 2:                              Level:               utilyRv Initial Col/Exam Dote:                 10/412008                                                                                                   Page 5        of 6 ANII Revie.       _,.-.-                   Date:

Ultrasonic Examination Indication Report                                                  ..       Data Report Number:         08UT175 SHITACHI Cal  Data Sheet Number      D-106 Site:   Fitzpatrick                                 Procedure:        ENN-NDE-9.29 / 1/N/A Weld ID:     N2C-SE                               Drawing:    MKS-003                               Size:     FLAT     Thickness:         2.0"                                      Exam Start:   1252 Lo Location: Toa Dead Center                     Wo Location:    Weld Overlay Centerline           Weld Width:        NI/A                    Weld Height:     NIA                  Exam End:     1314 Ind    Angle    % of   I_ndication Lenth        I      W Distance          I        Metal Path.            AxI Circ Upst/      I No. Used     DAC I U I L Max I L2              WI      WMax I W 2         1P I     MP Max 1 MP2                     Dnst                                            Comments:
1      45       30    -.4 1      0    +.4        N/A _ _..5_     &#xfd;, N/A    1.538      233      . N/A
                                                                                                     ------ Circ       CenterlineTWS=0.51" no change In thru-woll size from pre-WOR exam 108UTOi ill. Transducer
                                                                                                                                 !location for flow signal tip.
ISketch
  ~fScott Erickson                III  101412        GE Revi                      Level:     Dote:        Utility Review:                                 Date:     1 ANII Review:                          Dote:'
Examiner                     Level:   Date:                                                                                                                                                Pa         6 of_6}}