View source for AECM-87-0179, Forwards Response to NRC Comments on Basis for Incorporating Certain Remaining Insps on Div II Emergency Diesel Generator Into Later Schedule 5-yr Confirmatory Insp,Per 870908 Telcon

{{Adams
| number = ML20238F349
| issue date = 09/11/1987
| title = Forwards Response to NRC Comments on Basis for Incorporating Certain Remaining Insps on Div II Emergency Diesel Generator Into Later Schedule 5-yr Confirmatory Insp,Per 870908 Telcon
| author name = Kingsley O
| author affiliation = SYSTEM ENERGY RESOURCES, INC.
| addressee name = 
| addressee affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION &amp; RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM)
| docket = 05000416
| license number = 
| contact person = 
| document report number = AECM-87-0179, AECM-87-179, TAC-65683, NUDOCS 8709160096
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE, UTILITY TO NRC
| page count = 7
| project = TAC:65683
| stage = Other
}}

=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:- _ _ - _ _ _ -
SYSTEM ENERGY RE50LJRCES, INC.
Ouwa D KNGaEt JR
[lgf[$c,3                       September 11, 1987 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555                                                                             l Attention: Document Control Desk Gentlemen:

==SUBJECT:==
Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Unit 1 Docket Nc. 50-416 License No. NPF-29 Limited Deferral of Inspections on the Division II EDG, Supplemental Information AECM-87/0179 System Energy Resources, Incorporated (SERI) provided the basis for incorporating certain remaining inspections on the Division II Emergency Diesel generator into a later schedule 5-year confirmatory inspection. The above basis was provided by {{letter dated|date=June 30, 1987|text=letter dated June 30, 1987}} (AECM-87/0065).
During the NRC staff review of the above report, NRC comments were generated. The comments and SERI resporses were discussed with members of NRC staff by telephone conference on August 10, 1987. SERI's response to the NRC staff comments was provided by {{letter dated|date=August 21, 1987|text=letter dated August 21, 1987}} (AECM-87/0157).
Additional comments were generated on the above report during the NRC staff review. These additional comments and SERI responses were discussed with members of the NRC staff on September 8, 1987 during a telephone conversation. This letter documents SERI's response to the additional NRC comments. An attachment to this letter provides the NRC comments and SERI's responses.
If additional information is needed to support the NRC staff's review please contact this office.
Your     uly,
(
ODK:bms                                                               .
Attachment cc:                (See Next Page) 8709160096 870911 PDR    ADOCK 05000416 G                    PDR o o me ) senx e m m.m l , m.m
                                                                                                           &q t-J16AECM87090903 - 1
                                                            *""~#~
                                                                                                             \\

4                                                                                                                              AECM-87/0179                                                   f c                                                                                                                                   Page 2 f.:
            .                                                                                                                                                                                     I cc: Mr. T. H. Cloninger (w/a) l             Mr. R. B. McGehee (w/a)                                                                                                                                                              .
L             Mr. N. S. Reynolds (w/a)                                                                                                                                                             l Mr. H. L. Thomas (w/o)                                                                                                                                                             i Mr.'R.C. Butcher (w/a)
Dr. J. Nelson Grace, Regional Administrator (w/a)
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region II 101 Marietta St., N. W., Suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia 30323 Mr. L. L. Kintner, Project Manager (w/a)
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7920 Norfolk Avenue Bethesda, Maryland 20814 J16AECM87090903 - 2 l                                                                                                                                                                                                ,

,                                                                          Attachment to AECM-87/0179-
  ~
: 1. ' NRC Comment Were the inspection results similar for the Refueling Outage One (RF01) Division II Emergency Diesel Generator (EDG) Design Review /
Quality Revalidation (DR/QR) inspection when compared with the Division I EDG DR/QR inspection.
SERI Response Attached in Table 1 is a compilation of inspection results of the Division I and II engines. The components listed have been chosen to illustrate similarities between inspection results. It is evident from Table 1 that both Division I and II have very similar inspection results. This is due in part to the fact that the key engine components of both engines are of similar as-manufactured quality. This similarity of materials, design, and fabrication of key components for as-manufactured quality was provided in greater detail by_ {{letter dated|date=July 5, 1984|text=letter dated July 5,1984}} (AECM-84/0345).
: 2.    'NRC Comment The Division II EDG DR/QR inspections were reported 79% complete as of RF01. What percentage of DR/QR inspections will be complete after RF02?
SERI Response SERI stated in the {{letter dated|date=June 30, 1987|text=June 30, 1987 letter}} to the NRC (AECM-87/0065) that the GGNS DR/QR baseline inspections are over 79% complete c-the Division II EDG with no significant adverse finding which would effect the design function of the engine. The basis for this number is the inspection documentation which is kept at GGNS. Due to the nature and number of records kept on-site, all of the records were not available at the June 30 letter date; therefore the 79% value represented a conservative estimate at that time. The actual updated completion percentage of Division II DR/QR baseline inspection is presently 87%.
SERI has reported to the NRC, in {{letter dated|date=June 30, 1987|text=letter dated June 30, 1987}}, that several of the remaining DR/QR baseline inspections are to be performed at RF02. These components are the fuel tappet. assembly, air start valves, rocker arm capscrews, exhaust manifold, and the hydraulic valve lifters. Upon completion of the DR/QR inspections associated with these components, GGNS DR/QR baseline inspections will be approximately 89% complete on the Division II EDG.
J16AECM87090903 - 4

0
          . .                                         1 4           ,
4 o                       ;
y      3      d e g               t                             t          -      ecl f                         n                   -
i          2      inl o                      i                   e                            s . 0      f ai s       w    . u                             oe            i nt 1                         s       el      d                               rr            t es i         rl        -
ou             nt ene e                        m       ce        s                             pt      s g                                sh        g               .                c    g     di r a                        g           s     n         t                   ou      n     i ae
                                           'n                                                        g mw P                        n              -
i             a               t r      i i       i g         r           o                    t    r r           n     a         l                   e s,    a       nds si        e       . f                   u       e     i og e     ds        bg            -
dt         B      f on l       l a              n      r                    s        .
f gi z
z ec wt t'
sr uo i
t o
o C
d a ec s
c" ra u
sae 3         o                                   5         t 2         n     k e         rc          r     1           cn      g                 b .
s                      0                 cl      h s             -
3           ei      n     ds - e n                      /         y       an      t             e       -     j .        i        na          ,l a
i o                      2 2
r a'
ti d
eg
                                                           &     l b
2 0
ed re n
h s
u       gece d "e ba t               I       0         n     dn                      a                1 c              I         -       o . eo      t n         t          -.
si     B        ncic e                      P       is      k           ci          c      s          ra            i ati p                  . M       te        cg        et          e      r          et     d        rl cv opar s              V                 an      au      jt          j        e          nn      o n              I         r     t a       rl        ei          e      n      i o        R        cere S rps I               D        e      Sv      Cp        Rp          R       i       L c g                -
                                                             -           L                -
g        -
I                        r                                                                n I                        a                                             r                 i h         =
e      '
t
        .                   c      -       -         -           -       d         -         c     -
v                       o                                             n                  e i                       b                                             i                   n D                     .
r                                           l                    n u                                            y                  o d                       T                                             C                  C n                          -
a I
1 e i v
l b  D a
T  f o
n                                        w    .
e s
o                                        el                                                                 p        r s                                        rl i                                     g   ce                                                      r         idu r                                    n   sh                                             B        o n
weo th a                                gi          s                                          0 n                                                     igrc p                               ns    i g 4
3        mnoef m                             i s n                                             -        - inpo o                                ri 2      dris C                                     m   si 0        eamnri e e    d s t e
   &                               l d     l a zn      ec                                                    ibo                  b y                                za      w t                                              s    b           t em t                                 o                                             d          g    i1               ru .
i                                 ns    k e                                       e        n    h',uw        een) r                      '
t   cl                                      c      i        x                     e a                      3          yl     an                                      r.       r      e gd                wm l                       2          ro   ti                                      i          a             n       soi i                       0         ab                                              p        e      sid gl t m                      /         n-    d n                           C           e      B        gh en                  -
i                       2         on . eo                          5           r               nccian S                       2       ies     k .                           1                  &      it ar                   u 0       tk e      cg                          3           e               ral ah r
                              -      aon     au                            -         n        s      arpet P       t ra      rl                          2           o        g      eceBif I       M       Sbv     C p                           0         N          n    B sr( wo
                     - .                                                                    i
                         .                                                                  h V                                                                          s I                                                                          u D               -       -                                                B      -
s r                d e                  o r                                             n                R e                                           i L                    n g
r                                                                o a                                             r                i h                                               e                 t c                                           d                    c o                                             n                  e b                                             i                    n r                                           l                    n u                                             y                  o T                                             C                  C l

l       jl r
                                                                                                                . e
      .                                                     .                                                 s      f r             f                                      g       s
-                                                        a                 o                                  u       n e                           de                      l        a w                 r          nl                      p       r                 ,
4                         r                             i              ub .                           t             h e              l                  a          oas                    d                     t p                                  n                     g f                        h                a                           ftt pn                  e l
a             n o                  dt                     m                e                                                        e eor                   r                r         dee                             t 2                   l
                                          ,ia            o r
acm                     e s
e m
l l                      n                           oct o                      m e                   aep                                     o        l as r             u g                   gl e                  o                n          e       u               o P
a oh or             t              i m
rsj pad l         o n           i m,
t        d             e                                   a   E            o     i               xh ta                u             d            td           0          t         m             at el e                d                   e        l er         4                                  mg uor                                      r        oto         3            e       o                  n dbh                  d               i            ban              -        u      t            de t          e                 u             ui      2          d               9       el A     de                     c                  q . dl m         0                    e     5     d 0       end             . a                 es        oa                     d         u     3       er 4       coeg               l                    ra       rvg                      e     d         -     ee cp s                   3       a         rn         p                        e     En                    c             2 n                         l nii                  e             hr            g      i                 a     d       0       xo o                   2 pi u n               r               ta          n       r    y         l p
e             erp i                    0      e          qa                            e       i .i         l                   t c             g t             I              rsee                 g                  ed      tdu          b            e c            I                 drl               n             Te            ceq          m           r       e      s      no e                    s    da              c    i                          t  exe          e                 j        e    it p                . d       oes                 t              kt            nar          s           s       e      v     t s            V       o    Rrdd                 l                    ce       nl           s           n       r     l     lt n            I      R          hon               o                  ar       oer         A          i                a      ou I             D            1tra                 B                Rf          Cro                      P       3      V     Bc g                                                                     n                        t I                     n                                                                   i P                            r I                    i t                                                       ~                                         a
             .                 c   -                     ~               ~                          n         ~       -       t     -
v                    e                                                                     o                        S i                      n                                                                   t D                      n                                                                    s                          r i
o                                                                  i P                          A d                    C n
a I
1 e   i v                                                                          de l
b     D                                                                              nl a                                                                                  ub       .
T     f                                                                              oas o                                                                          ftt pn n                                           .                              dee                                e o                                         g r
acm oct e
s d
i s                                    dn o       s              m i                                       ei                              o . l as u
r                                     rn         oh        .         ns      e       u                o      t a                              tia              tt y             ia          rsd                    l         u              m p                          ol ue                     i l              mer    paj a                o o .
a ir xe m                         t o ql                 ewb                                                 t        ee            ap o                              b ec              u        m      da         td                                gr             mor C                            e          r        dde                    e    l er e       aa un           d              es             rd     oto
         &                          disn                 dts               ie         Ban                       u       m            dp da          eaa                  ut         ui                  d        ar           do e
y                         dso                    ci s                 qt    dl m                             da t                           edrr                  aci                  ee     oa                      d           e           et i                    A      ca            i     l od                   rr    Rvg          E            e       ew             e ct r                  0       aera                  ps                      f      En       0            c       m og             xu a                   4     l rep                  es&             h           g      i    4            a .
l                    3       ph h e               ra                tf        n       r   3           l s      rn             ec i                       -    ettr                          y           eo    i .i                 -    pg     hi r                                         e                               eu      ch             g , .
m                   2                 o          ggl                        tdu ceq 2
0            rl         s  9        nhh i                    0          d       ,d        nnb                tr S                           de             a     iim                      i   exe                         p    ru    5      itt tgg ol ee               tl e               ka        nar                      s       ob    3 Rll r                ll s                  cp     nl                       nd      n        -   l nn aoh              oas                  ae     oer                     in      if     2        oee I            1 ght                Bga                Rr       Cro                      P e     Mo     0      Bll y
V                                                                          l b
I D            ~                    -                  ~        ~                m       ~       ~        s     -
s                                                                       e                        e d                                                                        s                        v o                                                                       s                      l R                                                                     A                           a V                    2 g                                                                       n                       t                      -
n                                                                    i P                           r i
t                                                                                                a                   C n                     t                    S c                                                                        o                      S                    I e                                                                     t                                              M n                                                                         s                      r                   6 n                                                                                                                    1 o                                                                    i P
i A                    J C
illl,                      ,jl                ll       lj[!i(l!                     ll[l1!lI                              l  l; l!l

4' f
o                                          f o
3
.                                                      k     -
e e                                 c         c                 o g                                 e         n        B      t a                             ,
d           e        &
P                                             d          A        e e       i                   u r .       v               d is          e        0 fa                   9      d          A' e        ,       3       e         5 nr        s            -    cg       2 oa        e         2       an        4 d            0    l i           -
dg        i                   pp       2        r s                                    .         en        u                 ep       0        a n                                 s          ii          g          y      ri                e o                                k           ft                   l            h              w i                                   c         ia          e        b        sc         r t               I                   a         te          v           m     p          a      r c              I                   r           ns      l r          e      ud         e      o e                              'c             e         aa         s      cn        G      f p                  .                         de          ve         s           a s              V          A     'r           iv               w    A     d            e     d n              I          0        e             l      t                  or ra v
c e
I               D          6        v           sa        sl        t                 i r
3        o         kv          ua        f            e            a I
2
                                       -     c           c ad am h r         h a    h w s
D      l p
I                                  t 0      6             rn        xo         S      uo          r      e
               .                           S           Ca        E n               Pt            e    R i
v s
m r
t a
D                          d                                        A               h a                         ~
d                            e    -           -         ^             r   -            t     ~
n                        H                                          e                 e a                                                                  k                k c
r                                        c I                           e                                         o                 a 1                               d                                         R                J
     ~
               .                      n e i v'                        i l
l b    D                            y a                             C T    f o                                                                               s a
n                                             e         r                       e o                                             r         a                   eg s                                             a         e                 ud i                                                         w               d e r                                             g a                                             n       d                 dd p                                           i           e                   ee m                                            t         t                  ck o                                             a        i                    ac                     ~
C                                               e       bg                l a pr               r s       in           B
         &                                                       hi                    ec               a s           e         xt       _A
                                                                           .A          r -              e   a y                               k             v         et         0           d             w t                  -                c         l               i      9        sn i                                   a           a         sp         3        pa      A        r r                                 r           v         e             -     u       5        o a                                 c                    d r         2        cd      2      f l                                               n        i o         0            e   4 i                                    r        i            un      _      d p            -   d op               e m                        A         e                   Gi                           2 c
i                          0         v          s               m             ri      0 S                          6         o        k            e          y          h             a 3         c          c          vh     'l      h c                l
                                        -  b             a        l t         b        s         r      p 2         u          r          ai         m       uo        a      e I          0     S           C          Vw           e    Pt           e     R s               G
                              .                                                s V                                                   A                  e I                                                                      v D                 -           ~         ~           t     ~          i       ~
f                  r s                                        a               D d                                         h a                                       S                  r e                                                          e              s.
H                                         m r
t a
r                                       A                 W e                                        r                t d
a                                        e                 e i                                        k                 k l                                         c                 c y                                        o                 a
                                  ~  C                                        R                 J

d e
t 4                             e                p c                e f                             a          sc o                          - f          ec ht r                ca 4                    tpu                 n ies                 a ,
e                    wccn               rg g                                       an a                   dao                 ei P                     e       t         lh t ss                cs                                     ,a cai                      u                               g e       p          nb td                 i                                      5 eeo .                    o                                 .
dtt)               dt                                            3_
a      t      e-                                    y suds              in                                             :
nl ea             fi                                             -
s                           oatc              i p n                          i vu-              t -                                   L    "
o                          teb s               nn         .                        !
i                            a       ia          eo1                                      ~
t         I         C        cd r(             dt                                   '
c        I         0       int                i sd I
e                  4       dats                spc i e p            . 3        n        an I
s n
V I
D 2
0
                                   -   iE rN ot D ri o      e i nl l ep a
N I
a           i       aee mwr I                            eh ed I                     s      ntl n               ot ne ,
t       iibo
                .               r      Lwac               Ab4 v                 i i                   k D                   S d                     n     ~                  ~
n                   o a                  t s
I                   i 1                       P l
e i v
b   D a
T    f o                                                    nn       l         d ii          a        e n                                                    pp         n        c o                                      f                      i t .      a s                                   n6               nnsgad             l i                            s      i                 ooai             e  p r                           n      ha          ntt              rsl      e a                           o       ti        i ssd oeb                  r p                          idi r                    ii e d p pt nne cm     g m                          t nwe                                          n
,,           c                           aa          t      e            aias C                            c       gi        i nduhrs                  i iE nr              fenl t ea                 h
            &                           dDi c              ieaail                      s y
nN e               t w nt ee vwos  t a   bg u   .
i       b e t                                h        c       eer            r     w      n h       i r
rt sn aiaa db o ,od i         bs         ee ni i r
    }
l a
n ew     d p t           s sennl ui gern          po c
i                           i dee                 ecoibt g                 ns m                  C      l et c             inth acn                    o i                    0            t ac         l asst ae                  t o S                    4        rcuaR               a r i u pf               st 3        oel           Q     m a pb eue             i
                                     -    nt ae/              oe             cnm     P e u
2      i evhR                nl oocai I         0      Md etD              Actt amt                  1d V                                    '
I D                -                   ~                         ~
s t
r i
k S
_                                   n
-                                   o t
s i
P
      ~
l            L'

                             =
                                                             .g--                                                           . ,
                                                                                                                                        -f
                                                                                                                                                   ,j
                                                                                                                                 / j
* t <
1d '                                                                                                                 s.
yW s
t
                                                           ,                          A  $
4 a
1 - ,,- a                                                                                   l f.
in                s e                           ,      m      .
                                  - O' i
m l
t.)                                            /
!-
* s' rd D
* f
                                                                           )
L''                                LO                                    ,
e D        .
                                                                         .?                             t
>:                                                                       l l                                                                 '                                                          f 1*                                                                                                              i-r l
f                                                                                                  ', j'
                         .e-
                                                                           +
c         r
                                                                                                                                                .j
                      'e                                                                                ,
                                                                                                            +
t t
r>
j 4
3
                                                                 '(                                          .,
l
                                                                                                     ~k I
                                                                                                                                                      /
                                                                                                      /                                    ,
I i
      --i _ _ _ _ . _}}