View source for AECM-85-0212, Forwards Preliminary Data in Support of NRC Review of Safety Relief Valve in-plant Test Plan,Per 850626 Telcon.Addl Tests Unnecessary

{{Adams
| number = ML20129E644
| issue date = 07/03/1985
| title = Forwards Preliminary Data in Support of NRC Review of Safety Relief Valve in-plant Test Plan,Per 850626 Telcon.Addl Tests Unnecessary
| author name = Dale L
| author affiliation = MISSISSIPPI POWER &amp; LIGHT CO.
| addressee name = Denton H
| addressee affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR REGULATION (NRR)
| docket = 05000416, 05000417
| license number = 
| contact person = 
| document report number = AECM-85-0212, AECM-85-212, TAC-57860, NUDOCS 8507170016
| document type = CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS, INCOMING CORRESPONDENCE, UTILITY TO NRC
| page count = 110
| project = TAC:57860
| stage = Other
}}

=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:MISSISSIPPI POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
             ]
E6MMddB Helping Build Mississippi P. O. B OX 184 0 J A C K S O N, MIS SIS SIP PI 39215-1640 July 3, 1985 NUCLEAR LICENSING & SAFETY DEPARTMENT U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Washington, D. C. 20555 Attention:        Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director

==Dear Mr. Denton:==

==SUBJECT:==
Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Units 1 and 2 Docket Nos. 50-416 and 50-417 License No. NPF-29 File: 0260/0650 SRV In-Plant Test Plan, Additional Information AECM-85/0212 Mississippi Power & Light (MP&L) provided a summary of the Safety Relief Valve (SRV) test results conducted April 23 through April 25, 1985 at the Grand Gulf Nuclear Station (GGNS) by {{letter dated|date=June 6, 1985|text=letter dated June 6, 1985}} (AECM-85/0179). MP&L requested in this letter NRC concurrence with MP&L's position that no additional SRV testing is necessary. Additional information on this subject requested by the NRC staff was submitted by MP&L {{letter dated|date=June 18, 1985|text=letter dated June 18, 1985}} (AECM-85/0196). During a teleconference on June 26, 1985, the NRC staff requested further information regarding the GGNS test response spectra and comparison of GGNS with the Kuosheng Nuclear Plant test results.
The attached information is provided in response to the NRC staff's request. This data should be regarded as preliminary and is submitted to support your review of the above referenced MP&L letters. A final comprehensive test report will be submitted as required by license condition 2.C.(34).
As stated in AECM-85/0179, we believe the additional SRV tests would provide little additional information. In addition if the tests were to be performed, a plant shutdown and outage would be required to replace certain test valves which are currently exhibiting seat leakage. Further, the additional testing represents added duty on the SRV's and other components which would otherwise be avoided if additional testing is not conducted.
8 fDR507170016          850703                         1 30 p        ADOCK 05000416 PDR J13AECM85070302 - 1            Member Middle South Utilities System

e AECM-85/0212 Page 2 If we.can further assist your review of this matter, please contact this office.
Yours truly, L. F. Dale Director MLC/JGC:vog Attachment cc:  Mr. J. B. Richard (w/a)
Mr. O. D. Kingsley, Jr. (w/a)
Mr. R. B. McGehee (w/a)
Mr.'N. S. Reynolds (w/a)
Mr. G. B. Taylor (w/o)'
Mr. R. C. Butcher (w/a)
Mr. James M. Taylor, Director (w/a)
Office of Inspection & Enforcement U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Dr. J. Nelson Grace, Regional Administrator (w/a)
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region II 101 Marietta St., N. W.,  Suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia- 30323 J13AECM85070302 - 2

Page 1 of 5 CGNS SRV IN-PLANT TEST PRELIMINARY INFORMATION BASED ON RECORDED DATA REDUCTION
: 1.   

==Background:==

A summary of the SRV in-plant test results conducted April 23 through April 25, 1985 at GGNS was provided to the NRC in the MP&L {{letter dated|date=June 6, 1985|text=letter dated June 6, 1985}} (AECM-85/0179). MP&L has concluded that all test objectives have been met and additional testing to complete the test matrix is not necessary. The NRC concurrence was requested for the conclusion of the SRV in-plant testing. The additional information requested by the NRC Staff to support their review on this subject was provided in the MP&L {{letter dated|date=June 18, 1985|text=letter dated June 18, 1985}} (AECM-85/0196). In a teleconference held on June 26, 1985, the NRC Staff requested further information based on reduction of the recorded data in progress. The information provided here is preliminary since DC offsets, ringing effects, and noise responses have not been eliminated from various response spectra plots.
: 2. Instrumentation Summary:
The thirty-two (32) pressure sensors installed in the Grand Gulf plant are shown in Figures 2.1, 2.2 and 2.3. The thirty four (34) strain gauges mounted in the plant are shown in Figures 2.4 and 2.5.
The fifty-six (56) accelerometers installed in the plant are listed in Tables 2.1, 2.2 and 2.3, and are shown in Figures 2.6 through 2.11.
: 3. Test Results and Discussion 3.1      Suppression Pool Pressure Data The pressure data reported here was collected from sensors located on the basemat, drywell wall, and quencher supports. For each test, pressore sensors were located within a radius of 2r of the quencher to read peak bubble pressure.
A 100 Hz low pass filter was used in the playback to eliminate acoustic response, and provide results comparable to the analytical cut-off frequency used in the original plant design. The reduced pressures recorded for all tests, are presented in Table 3.1.
3.1.1      Single Valve Actuations (SVA)
Three SVA tests have been completed. The peak measured pressures during SVA was +4.88/-5.78 psid. A statistical evaluation on the measured data, Table 3.2, produces a 95-95 peak pressure of
      +5.37/-5.38 psid. These results compare very favorably with the design value of +18.2/-7.7 psid. Some typical pressure time histories for SVA are shown in Figures 3.1 through 3.5. The Power Spectral Density (PSD) plots are shown in Figures 3.6 through 3.10.
NMEREP 112 SRV IN-PLANT TEST

Pags 2 of 5 The pressure time histories at similar locations and PSD's for the Kuosheng test for SVA are shown in Figures 3.11 through 3.15.
The pressure time histories and PSD's clearly show repeatability of the Grand Gulf SVA test and sufficient data has been collected to perform statistical evaluation.
3.1.2      consecutive Valve Actuations (CVA)
Even though not originally planned and required by the NRC approved plan, the optional CVA tests were performed to provide infor-mation to confirm the adequacy of the Grand Gulf design for which the most limiting SRV loading is the CVA. Each SVA was followed by a CVA test.
The peak measured pressures during CVA was +7.47/-4.47 psid. A statistical evaluation on the measured data, Table 3.3, produces a 95-95 pressure of +8.52/-4.62 psid. These results are easily bounded by the Grand Gulf CVA design value of +18.2/-7.7 psid (adjusted for the 75% power level test conditions). Some typical pressure time histories and PSD's for CVA are shown in Figures 3.16 through 3.25. Once again, repeatability of.the Grand Gulf CVA tests is clearly established and sufficient data has been collected to confirm the adequacy of the Grand Gulf unique design.
The pressure time histories at similar locations and PSD's for the Kuosheng test for CVA are shown in Figures 3.26 through 3.29.
3.1.3      Multiple Valve Actuations (MVA)
One MVA (4-valve) test was conducted at GGNS. The test program was temporarily suspended following the single MVA test because test valves were exhibiting seat weepage, as anticipated.
Pressures measured during the MVA were less than or equal to those measured during various SVA's at GGNS. The peak measured pressures during MVA was +4.06/-2.60 psid. A statistical evaluation of the measured data, Table 3-4, produces a 95-95 pressure of +5.57/-3.46 psid. These results compare very favorably with the SVA results, and are well below the Grand Gulf design value of +18.2/-7.7 psid.
Some typical pressure time histories and PSD's for MVA are shown in Figures 3.30 through 3.41. The pressure time histories at similar locations and PSD's for the Kuosheng test for MVA are shown in Figures 3.42 through 3.45.
NMEREP 112 SRV IN-PLANT TEST

p.
Page 3 of 5
                 '3.2                   SRVDL and Quench'er Internal Pressures Pressure tranducers were located in the SRV Discharge Line (S RVDL) ,2 and in the quencher hub and arm, for quencher V-12 as
                                       ~s hown on-Figures 2.2 and 2.3. Pressure sensors P21 (SRVDL) and P23 (quencher hub) were recorded as real time datc. The peak line pressure observed was a high frequency spike with a magnitude of 450 psi, compared.to the 550 psi design. The peak 4-hub 1 pressure of 250-psi observed for both tests is less than half               -
the design value of 550 psi.
13.3                    Strain Data The measured strains for all tests, are presented in Table
                                       -3.5.
The maximum recorded strain for the quencher support was 29
                                       . micro in/in, which is equivalent to a stress value of 870 psi. The maximum recorded' strains for'the basemat and the containment liners are 50 and 46 micro in/in, which is equivalent to stress values of 1400 and 1300 psi, respectively. The maximum recorded strain for the submerged piping was 12 micro in/in, which is
: equivalent to a stress value of 360 ' psi.
_ Typical strain time histories are shown in Figures 3.46 through 3.49.                  Also, some typical equivalent stress time his-tories based on measured strains for the Kuosheng test are shown in Figures 3.50 and 3.51.
The GGNS test strain data confirms the conclusions from the Kuosheng test results which showed that recorded strain data was always considerably less than expected values.
3.4                   AcceIerometer Data The peak measured accelerations for all tests are presented in Table 3.6.                  There were twenty-six (26) accelerometers mounted on the Reactor Building structures and four (4) were mounted on the Auxiliary Building structures. Additionally, there were eleven (11) accelerometers mounted on equipment and fifteen (15) were mounted on valves and supports.
i                                                         The peak measured accelerations at all locations are well below predicted and' design values.
I i
f-t
         .NMEREP 112.SRV IN-PLANT TEST

Page 4 of 5
: 4. Response Spectra Response Spectra have been generated utilizing measured acceleration time histories for various locations in the Reactor Building. The enveloped spectra for SVA, CVA and MVA are presented in Figures 4.1 through 4.20. The corresponding Grand Gulf SRV design spectra are also plotted on these curves. Most of the spectra are entirely enveloped by the Grand Gulf SRV Design Spectra. In a few cases there appears to be some minor exceedance at very high frequency (approximately above 70 Hz) which will have very minimal, if any, structural responses.
For a quick comparison envelopes of SVA, CVA and MVA for the CGNS test results are plotted with those from the Kuosheng test results. The Grand Gulf and Kuosheng plant SRV design spectra for similar locations are also shown in these plots. These results are shown in Figures 4.21 through 4.30. The various node locations for the GGNS is shown in Figure 4.31.
These results clearly show similarity between the GGNS and Kuosheng plant SRV test results and also show that most of the spectra are well below the design values.
: 5. Comparison With Kuosheng Plant SRV Test Data A comparison of the suppression pool pressure is presented in Table 5.1. The peak pressures observed at GGNS were considerably lower than those observed at Kuosheng for SVA, CVA and MVA tests. The pressure time histories at similar locations compare favorably with the Kuosheng results.
The measured strains on the basemat and the containment liners, the quencher supports and the submerged structures also compare favorably with those measured during the Kuosheng test which showed that equivalent measured stresses were always considerably less than their expected values.
The enveloped spectra for SVA, CVA and MVA compare favorably with the Kuosheng SVA spectra at similar locations.
: 6. Conclusions Major conclusions drawn from the data reduction of the SRV test conducted at GGNS are as follows:
o The measured peak pressures during SVA, MVA and CVA are well below the GCNS design values.
o The pressure time history data compare favorably to the GESSAR methodology. Air clearing / water spike is less pronounced at GGNS.
The CVA time histories are very similar to that in GESSAR with the correct ratio of peak positive and negative pressures.
NMEREP 112 SRV IN-PLANT TEST

Prge 5 of 5 o The measured strains in the basemat and the containment liners, the quencher supports and the submerged structures are considerably less than the predicted values.
o The peak measured accelerations at all locations are well below predicted and design values.
o The enveloped spectra for SVA, MVA and CVA are well below the CGNS SRV Design Spectra.
o Based on the above it is concluded that the GESSAR methodology used for generating SRV discharge loadings is conserystive and there is considerabic margin in the CGNS design for SRV discharge loading.
: 7. Justification For Concluding The SRV In-Plant Testing One MVA test was conducted at CGNS. The four test valves used for MVA are located about 90* from one another. It was axpected that there would be very little interaction of hydrodynamic loa <s and MVA test would be similar to four valves actuated independently. Similar observations were made at the Kuosheng plant testing. The acceptance criteria used for MVA are identical to that of SVA for GCNS. The measured pressures confirm the above hypothesis. Pressures measured during MVA were less than or equal to those measured during various SVA's at GGNS. The 95-95 pressure based on measured MVA data are well below the GGNS design value. Spectra for MVA and SVA are of the same order of magnitude. The enveloped spectra for SVA, CVA and MVA are well below the GGNS SRV Design Spectra.
Any additional testing would merely confirm this.
Based on above information, MP&L has concluded that all test objectives have been met and additional testing to complete the test matrix is not necessary.
i NMEREP 112 SRV IN-PLANT TEST

f TABLE 2.1 LOCATION OF ACCELEROMETERS - STRUCTURE
(
Sensor            Location                                    NLAE Environ- Direc II)    Node I.D. Azimuth  Elev. Radius       ment     tion      Fig. 4.13 f                                                  Reactor Building Sensors:
[                                                  Al      32'       93.0"     65'0"        E2        R            254 E                                                  A2      32'       93.0"     65'0"        E2        V            254 A3      32*      109.12'    65'0"        E2        R            277 A4      32*      109.12'    65'0"        E2        V            277 l-                                                  AS      302*     109.12'    65'0"        E2        R            277 A6      302*     109.12'    65'0"        E2        T            277 A7      0*       147.58'    62'0"        E2        R            291 A8      0*       147.58'    62'0"        E2        V            291 l                                                   A9      270*     147.58'    62'0"        E2        R            291 A10     270*     147.58'    62'0"        E2        T            291 g                                                   All     32*      237.0'     62'0"        E2        R            300 l                                                   A12     32*      237.0'     62'0"        E2        V            300 A13     32*      302.25'    0'0"         E2        V            309 A14     32'      302.25'    0'0"         E2        R            309
* A15     32*      120.83'    41'6"        E2        R             48 A16     32*      120.83'    41'6"        E2        V             48 A17     302*     120.83'    41'6"        E2        R             48 A18     302*     120.83'    41'6"        E2        T             48 A19     0*       147.58'    41'6"        E2        R             30 I~ (                                                A20     0*
302*
147.58'    41'6"        E2 E2 V             30 A21              184.5'     41'0"                  R               8 A22     302*     184.5'     41'0"      ' E2        T               8 L                                                   A23     32'      208.83'    41'6"        E2        R               8 A24     32*      208.83'    41'6"        E2        V               8 l                                                   A25 A26 0*
0*
100.75'    10'7"        E2 E2 R
V 79 79 L                                                                    100.75'    10'7" A27     270*   , 100.75'    10'7"        E2        R             79 A28     270*     100.75'    10'7"        E2        T             79 Auxiliary Building Sensors:
A53     32'       93.0'     68'0"        E2        R            N/A AS4     32'       93.0'     68'0"        E2        V            N/A A55     32*      184.5'     66'0"        E2        V            N/A A56     32*      184.5'     66'0"        E2        R            N/A    ,
  ~
NOTES:  (1)  R = Horizontal, radial V = Vertical T = Horizontal, tangential L
m

f f
f(
                                                                                ~
TABLE  2.2 LOCATION OF ACCELEROMETERS - EQUIPMENT I
Sensor  Equipment       Location          Direction    Comments ID     Description  Azimuth Elevation A29    Polar                              R (0*-180')
A30    Crane            0*    237'0"      V A31    Girder                             T (90-270*)
I A32    Base of                            R l           A33    Hydrogen       130'    208'10"     V l            A34    Recombiner                         T A35    Top of                             R A36    Hydrogen       130'    208'10"     V
      ,       A37    Recombiner                         T L
L c
h m.
L e
    'M' -
g O

f              p                 ;  F             (""""" !""*                                  Puum                                               f*'un   r                   p     w        m                      een         ame;     q              q                  =-al y.9 f                                                                                                                                                  D Table 2.3 LOCATION OF ACCELERONETERS - PIPING l
t SENSOR        BECHTEL              ELEVATION                                                                           DIRECTION                DATA         PIPE                              EQUIPNENT ID            DRANING                                                                                                    (1)                    POINT        CLASS                             DESCRIPTION NO./Rev.                                                                                                   NO.
A38                                                                                                                        X                                                                  Valve Operator A39            HL-1348E                               101'-9"                                                               Y                    140   18"-GBB-17                              SQlE12G014-A40                                                                                                                         2                                                                 F0038-8 A41                                                                                                                        X A42 Snubber (X)
H-1328J/D                     149'3-1/2"                                                                     Y                      30   12"-DBA-17                             801821G026R03 A43                                                                                                                        2 A44                                                                                                                        X                                                                  Valve Operator A45           HL-1348A                      126'9-3/4"                                                                     Y                     135   20"-DBA-64                             $QlE12G012 A46                                                                                                                        2                                                                  -F009-B A47                                                                                                                        X                                                                  Valve Operator A48           HL-1348F                     167'l-1/2"                                                                      Y                     751   12"-Geo-115 801E12G015 A49                                                                                                                        2                                                                  -F037A-A A50                                                                                                                        X                                                                  Valve Oper.
ASI           HL-1348F                    170'9-1/2"                                                                       Y                     216   18"-Gas-118 801E12G015 A52                                                                                                                        2                                                                  -F0288-B Notes:        1.      X = horizontal, azimuth 90*
Y = vertical up 2 = horizontal, azimuth 180*
: 2.      Environmental conditions are E2 for all sensors, with the exception that the maximum temperature is 450*F.
                 . _ - . .;-_.-_,~_.,-.____-.m         . - .    -                              , , .                                                   .- - . , __ -         - - . . . _ , .              _,                ,__...m  _ ~ - .       mm.-. _ _ . , , _ . . , - . _ _ . , ~ ,     . _ _ _ . . . _ _ . .

Table 3.1 MEASURED PEAK PRESSURE DATA (PSID)
CVA Tests SVA Tests MT70                                    MT11                                MT21               MT31 MTIO                  MT20              MT30
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                + 3.13/- 2.10                           + 0.7 5/- 0.59                     +2.3 2/- 1.6 8     + 2. 6 5/- 2.0 4 P1     + 0.8 6/- 0. 41       +1.2 9/-1.51      +0.9 3/-1.2 9                                                                                                     -2.46/-1.85 i
                                                                                                                                                                                                            + 1.3 0/- 1.60      + 1.4 6/- 1.11                          + 0.9 8/-0.8 2                     + 2.2 3/- 1.4 2 P2     +0.88/-1.00           +1.89/-1.87                                                                   + 1.15/- 0. 7 0                    +1.76/-1.24         +1. 9 2/-1. 57 P3     + 1.13/- 0. 8 0       +1.7 0/-1. 7 6    +1. 4 0/- 1.5 9     +1.5 2/- 1. 4 8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                + 0.5 5/-0.6 4                          + 0.5 4/-0.6 2                     + 1.6 0/-1.10      + 2.0 7/- 1.7 3 P4     + 0.51/-0. 47         + 0.97/-0.98      + 1.14 /- 0.8 3                                                                                                    + 4.4 9/- 3.2 9
                                                                                                                                                                                          +1.9 4/- 3.0 6    + 2.15/- 2. 0 4     + 0. 8 0/- 0. 8 9                       +1. 2 7/- 0.7 6                    +3.4 2/-2.6 3 P5     + 0.9 7/- 0.71                                                                                      +1.68/-1.29                        + 5.4 8/- 3.35     + 7.4 4/-4.4 7 P6     + 1.2 0/- 1.30        + 4.0 5/- 2.66    + 3.0 8 /-2.0 8     + 1.0 7/-0.81
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                +1.2 8/- 1.0 5                          +2. 2 9/- 1.10                     + 3. 6 9/- 3. 2 7   + 4. 9 9/- 3. 6 8 P7     + 1.5 3/-1.6 3        +2.9 7/-3.2 6     + 3.2 4/- 2. 5 8                                                                                                   + 4.2 7/- 3.12
                                                                                                                                                                                          + 2.4 7/- 2.54    + 2.5 8 /- 2.20     + 1.5 9/- 1.20                          + 1.3 3/-0.97                      + 3.6 8/-2.71 PS     + 0.7 6/-1.17                                               + 0.14/- 0.9 6                          +2. 8 3/- 1.7 0                     + 2. 6 8/- 2. 0 0  + 3. 01/- 2. 4 7 P9     + 2. 4 5/-2.2 8       +3.6 8/- 3.2 3    + 3.31/- 2.8 7                                                                                                     + 2.5 8/-1.9 2
                                                                                                                                                                                          + 2.2 5/- 2.09    + 1.8 2/- 1.9 4     + 1.0 8/-0.73                           + 1.7 0/-1.31                      +2.18/-1.75 P10    +1.58/-1.59                                                 +0.4 4/-0.3 3                           +0.8 6/-0.4 2                       + 0. 8 9/- 0.7 4   +0.9 6/- 1.0 2 P11    +0.8 6/- 0. 4 6       +0.7 7/- 0.8 5    +0. 6 0/-0.9 4                                                                                                     + 5.17/- 2.9 8
                                                                                                                                                                                                            + 4.18/-4.8 9       + 1.4 8/- 1.14                          + 7.4 7/- 3.67                      + 4.5 6/- 2.81 P12    + 4.6 3/-5.7 8        + 4.12/-4.20                                                                  + 5.5 0/- 3.5 0                      +1. 8 5/- 1. 3 3  + 2. 27/- 1. 5 3 P13    + 4. 8 8/-2.3 0       +1.4 9/-1. 5 8    +1.0 5/- l . 4 9    +1.0 2/- 0. 9 9
                                                                                                                                                                                                            + 1.6 3/-1.64       + 1.15/-0.97                            + 3.2 8/-2.76                       + 1.5 3/-0.96      + 1.91/- 1.2 8 P14    + 3.3 4/-2.87         + 2.0 4/- 1.67                                                                                                     +1. 3 7/-1.14     +1.5 2/-1.2 2
                                                                                                                                                                                          + 2.0 3/- 1. 5 4  + 1.7 9/- 1.5 2     +1.0 2/- 1.0 2                          + 2. 57/-1.7 4 P15    + 2. 4 9/- 2. 2 6                                                                                   + 1.7 0/-1.26                       + 0.7 0/-0.37      + 0.7 9/-0.5 5 P16    + 1.4 2/~ 1.4 8       + 1.0 8/-0.7 3    +0.9 3/-0.71        + 1.3 0/-0.65
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                +1. 6 7/-1.0 7                          + 2. 0 4/- 1.15                      +0.5 2/- 0. 3 6   + 0. 6 6/-0. 6 0 P17    + 2.0 2/- 1. 6 6      + 1. 3 5/- 1.15   +1.17/-1.2 0                                                                                    + 0.15/-0.09       + 0.14 /-0.12
                                                                                                                                                                    + 0.3 6/-0. 40        + 0.0 5/-0.16     + 0.10/-0.16        +1.55/-1.50                             + 0.2 9/-0.30 P18                                                                +2.7 5/-2.4 0                           + 0. 4 4/- 0. 2 8                    + 0. 0 9/- 0.18   + 0.14/- 0. 21 P19    + 0.5 3/- 0. 3 4      +0.27/-0.38       +0.2 5/-0. 41                                                                                   + 0.2 0/-0.10      + 0.12/-0.12
                                                                                                                                                                                          + 0.14/-0.15      + 0.0 9/-0.16       + 2.7 7/-1.52                           + 0.0 8/-0.0 4 P20    + 0.0 9/-0.12                                                                                        + 0. 9 8/- 1.0 7                    +1.4 3/-1.3 0     +1.4 9/-1.6 6 P26     + 0. 8 7/- 0. 6 4 -  +1.34/-1.51       +0.7 2/- 0. 8 9     +0.7 0/-0.6 7                                                                                  + 2.3 3/- 2.2 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                            +1.28/-1.14         + 0.8 8/-0.8 0                          + 1.2 5/- 1.8 5                      + 2.10/- 1.75 P27    + 1.0 9/-0.97         + 1.8 6/- 2.14                                                                                                     + 0.2 0/- 0.0 9   + 0.14/- 0.18
                                                                                                                                                                                          +0.10/-0.18       +0.11/-0.12          + 4.0 6/-2. 6 0                         +0.1 1/- 0.0 5 P29     +0.15/-0.10                                                                                        + 0.5 4 /-0.3 2                      + 0.19/- 0.14     + 0.2 4 /- 0.19
                                                                                                                                                                    + 0.8 2/-0. 4 5       + 0.31/-0. 4 7    + 0.4 0/-0.49       + 3.3 2/- 2.10 P30                                                                 +3.5 9/-1.9 4                           +0.0 6/- 0.0 5                      +0.16/- 0.0 9      + 0.13/- 0.15 P31     +0.10/-0.56          + 0.13/- 0.15      + 0.11/- 0.14                                                                                                     + 0.13/-0.14
                                                                                                                                                                                          +0.11/-0.20       + 0.11/-0.13        + 3.5 6/-2.20                            + 0.0 7/-0.10                       + 0.14/-0.0 8 P32     +0.12/-0.10                                                                                                                        _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 +4.18               + 4.06                                  +7.47                               + 5.4 8            +7.44 Peak        +4.88                +4.12                                                                                                              -3.35              -4.47
                                                                                                                                                                                               -4.20             -4.89               -2.60                                    -3.67 Pressures       -5.78
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           -                  W

1 l
l Table 3.2 SVA 95-95 PRESSURES ( PSI D) _
l Pressure l       Te st                Se nsor                                               Ne gative
'                                                Posit ive MT10                  P12                  +4. 6 3                           -5.78 l
P13                  +4.88                             -2.30 P14                  + 3. 3 4                          -2.87 MT20                  P5                   + 1.9 4                           -3.06 P6                   +4.0 5                            -2.66 P7                   +2.97                             -3.26 P8                   +2. 4 7                           -2.54 l                             P12                  +4.12                             -4.20 1
MT30                  P5                   +2.15                             -2 04 l                             P6                   +3.80                             -2.08 I                             P7                   +3.24                             -2.58 l                             P8                   +2.58                             -2.20 l                             P12                  +4.18                             -4.89 MT70                 P19                  +2.75                             -2.40 l                             P20                  +2. 7 7                           -1.52 l                             P29                  +4.06                             -2.60 P30                   +3.3 2                           -2.10 P31                  +3.59                             -1.94 P32                  + 3. 5 6                           -2.20 t
Positive Pressure                          Negative Pressure X = 3.3 9                                               X = -2. 8 0 S = 0.82                                                8 = - 1.0 7 f
tg= 2.41 i
95-95 pressure = 5.37 psid                 95-95 pressure = -5.38                      paid gge..*'n''O\
i

ss Table 3.3 CVA 95-95 PRESSURES (PSID)
Pressure Test            Se nsor           Positive                                                           Ne ga tive MTil              P12               +7. 4 7                                                            -3.67 P13                + 5.50                                                             -3.50 P14                +3. 2 8                                                            -2.76 MT21             P5                 +3.42                                                              -2.63 P6                +5. 4 8                                                            -3.35 P7                +3.69                                                              -3.27 P8                +3. 6 8                                                            -2.71 P12               +4.56                                                              -2.81 MT31              P5                +4.49                                                              -3.29 P6                +7.44                                                              -4.47 P7                +4.99                                                              -3.68 P8                +4.27                                                              -3.12 P12               +5.17                                                              -2.98 Positive Pressure                 Negative Pressure X = 4.88                            X = -3. 2 5 S = 1.36                            S = -0.51 t13 = 2.68 95-95 pressure = 8.52 psid         95-95 pressure = -4.62 paid Q\\$t I
I                                                  _    _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Table 3.4 MVA 95-95 PRESSURES (PSID)
Pressure Te st            Se nsor         Po sit ive           Ne ga tive P1                +3.13               -2.10 MT7 0 P2                +1.46               -1.11 P8                +1.59               -1.20 P19               + 2.7 5             -2.40 P20               +2.7 7              -1.52 P29               +4.06               -2.60 P30               +3. 3 2             -2.10 P31               +3.59               -1.94 P32               +3.56                -2.20 Positive Pressure                   Negative Pressure X = 2.91                             X = -1. 91 S = 0.89                             S = -0.52 tg = 2.99                              ,
95-95 pressure = 5.57    paid       95-95 pressure = -3.46 paid MPti-01-220 Revision A L

I l
l i
i                                                                                                                                                Table 3.5 PEAK STRAIN DATA (sin /in)
Sensor                                                                                                                                   MVA Test                           Espected RTI S                                 MT20                                       MT3 0                                        MT70             MTl 1 MT21 MT3I  Vatue 51           2                                     4                                                            3                         16                2     5    5    (1) 52          13                                    to                                                        11                             8               17    10    9    (1) 53          13                                    12                                                        11                             7               15     e   11    (1) 54          31                                    20                                                       20                             to               34    15  22     (I) 55           3                                     2                                                            3                         12                2     4    5     98 56           1                                     3                                                           3                          17                2     3   6     98 57          25                                    17                                                        15                            12               29    14   17     98 SS           3                                     4                                                          2                           22                2    3     3    98 510           2                                     4                                                           2                           9                2     3    4    (2)
S11          12                                     9                                                          9                            8               11    13   12   (1)
        $12          43                                    50                                                       41                             18               42    32   31   (t)
St3           4                                     3                                                           3                           7               4     3   46    (1) 514           5                                     5                                                          5                            5                3     4    5   (1) 516           1                                     3                                                           3                           9               2     6    12    56 517           3                                     4                                                          5                            5                3    6    12     56 Sie           3                                     4                                                          4                            6               2     3    5     56 519           2                                     4                                                          4                            5                2     3   5      44 S20           1                                     3                                                          3                            8               2     3    3     44 521           4                                     5                                                          5                            5                5    4     4    44 522           1                                     5                                                          4                            7               2     3    4     54 523           2                                     3                                                           3                           5                2    4     3   (2) 524           1                                     3                                                          3                            8                1    3    4     44 525           4                                     4                                                           3                           5                3    4    5    (1) 526           1                                     3                                                         2                             7               2     5    4    (1)
S27           3                                     4                                                          4                            5                3    5    4    (1)
S29           3                                    5                                                          5                             7               2     4    7    (1) 529           4                                     5                                                          5                            7                3    4    6    (2) 530           2                                     3                                                         4                            19               3     3    7    22 531           9                                     7                                                          8                           10               6     5    7     45 532           3                                    4                                                         5                             14               4     4    6    45 S33           5                                     7                                                          4                           20               3     5    5     45 S34           4                                    4                                                         5                             14               5     6    4    45 Isot es:  1. Expected watues not calculated, allowable strain is 980 min /in.
: 2. Valees not calculated - part of strain rosettes or insufficient information avattable.

9 4 e
                                                                                                                                  > w0 U US mobemewwW44memNmmeNNNNNNNNN4 NM M                                                                       O. N. O. N. N. eM O. M. M.                                                                      32N N O. O. M. C. M. M. O. O. O. O. O. O. O. e3  O. O. O N 4                                   4                                     000000000                                                                                           COOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Rw&
4 C
                                                                                                                                 > 09                                                                       wemmeOWOO(geowme@MmmmNmmNNN4 U M 3 N eM                                                                       O M. O. M. M. N. O. N. N.                                                                       33N N C. O. M.O.M. M. M.O.O. O.O. O. O. O. O.EO. N gg                                                      COOOOOOOO                                                                                            CC00000000000000 m                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       .
Nw                 NMgm 4
NcNmmemNMbmNMmNNMOOMMMMODOOM e                            >                                       0000000000000000000000000000 e                                                                                                        e 2                           U                                       C000000000000000000000000000 M
4 c
4 e
Nw                 wmmw E                              4 NNNwMNNmMNwNMcN@NCOMMMMOOOOM g                                       C.O. O. O. O. O.O. O. O. M. O. O.O. O.O. O. O. O. O.O.O.O.O. O. O. O. O. O.
w                                       C000000000000000000000000000 Nw                 MNwN M
O M
m N4NmM%mMM@NNMNNMMOOMMMMOOOOM w                                                                                                H                                       C.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0e 0                                                                                   e 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 E                                       C000000000000000000000000000 M
E H                                                                    *
(                                                                   W                                                                                                                                                                                         Nw                 NM@@
                                             @5                                                                                       9                           M N@NMN@NMM@NNMANNMOOMMMMODOOM
                                                     . W                                                                               G                          N m aW                                                                                    b                             H                                       0e C. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0e 0 0 0 0 0 0 0e 0 0 0e 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 e
E                                       0000000000000000000000000000 0                                                                  4 WO                                                                                   >
M                     4                                                                 Y D
4 O HW                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Nw                 NMNN m
D M
M@HeMmmMMNwNM@NmMOOMMMMOOOOM m                                                                                                                                       C. 0 0 0e 0 0e 0 0e C. M. C.e 0e 0 0 0 0 0 0                                                                           e 0 0 0   e0e 0 0e@     O e0e0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       . e 4                                                                                                                                       C00000000000000000000000@C00 W
R U
W
                                                                  &                                                                           W a O                                                        NempNeNmNeMeMcN@NCOMMNMOOOON em                 wNem G
H                                                            C Oe O. Me C. O. O. O O eMoMeOeOe O O. O.O eOeOeOoOeOe Oe Oe O                                                                                eOe O e D 4
C000000000000000000000000000 E
Nw                 mmmw O                                        NeN@NNNmMNwNM4NoMOOMMMMOOOOM C0000000.C.MO0000000000,0000000 e e                                                                  e                       e e e     e e e      e e          e e        e    e C000000000000000000000000000 W
u W                                                                                                                                                                                          Nw                 eNNw H
G                           O                                       NemMMmNwMO@NMwN@N OOMMNMOOOOM Ce 0e 0e 0 0 0e0e0e0e M. O. 0 0 0 0 e0 e0 e0 e0 e0 e0 e0 0 0 0 0e 0e 0e 4                                                                     0000000000000000000000000000 Nw                 wwmW D
M N@N@MNNmMwwNMwNeNCOMMMMODOOM H                                       Ce 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e0o0eMe O                                                                         e 0e 0 e 0e 0 0e 0e 0e 0e 0e 0o 0e 0e 0o 0e 0 0. Ce K                                      0000000000000000000000000000 b
OMNmwe@NeeCMNmwe@ Nee a
9

Table 3.7 PEAft MEASURED ACCELEllATIONS (0)
(Concluded)
SVA Tests                                                                                                  CVA Tests                         Nean Value                                   NA/UA      NA/ A Sensor                                     NVA Test                                                                                                                                                            De sig n Predicted MT10            MT20    MT30     MT70                             MT11                                                                MT21  MT31  SVA             cvA                               Value     value A30      0.001            0.001  0.001    0.002                            0.00                                                                0.001 0.001 0.001           0.001                                 N/A     N/A A31      0.01              0.01  0.01     0.02                             0.01                                                                0.01  0.01  0.01            0.01                                  N/A     N/A A32      0.01             0.03   0.02     0.02                             0.01                                                                0.01  0.01  0.02            0.01                                  N/A     N/A A33      0.02              0.02  0.02     0.03                              0.02                                                               0.01  0.01  0.02            0.01                                  N/A     N/A A34      0.01             0.02   0.02     0.03                             0.01                                                                0.01  0.01  0.02            0.01                                  N.A     N/A A35      0.02             0.03   0.03     0.03                             0.02                                                                0.02  0.02  0.03            0.02                                  N/A     N/A A36      0.02             0.02   0.03     0.03                             0.03                                                                0.01  0.02  0.02            0.02                                  N/A     N/A A37      0.03              0.G   0.05     0.07                              0.03                                                               0.03  0,44  0.05             0.03                                 N/A     N/A A38      0.03             0.03   0.03     0.05                             0.02                                                                0.02  0.03  0.03            0.02                                 0.36    0.29 A39      0.02              0.02  0.02     0.04                             0.01                                                                0.02  0.03  ?.02            0.02                                 0.41    0.33 A40      0.004            0.005  0.004    0.07                             0.005                                                               0.005 0.007 0.0G?           0.005                                0.25    0.20 A41      0.05              0.07  0.11     0.21                              0.08                                                               0.10  0.09  0.08            0.09                                  N/A     N/A A42      0.09              0.11  0.10     0.38                             0.16                                                                0.08  0.11  0.10            0.12                                 1.21    0.97 A43      0.06              0.1   0.12     0.15                              0.12                                                               0.14  0.11  0.10            0.12                                 1.59    1.27 A44      0.04              0.06  0.04     0.05                             0.04                                                                0.04  0.04  0.05            0.04                                 2.00    1.60 A45      0.01              0.02  0.01     0.03                             0.01                                                                0.03  0.02  0.01            0.02                                 2.01    1.60 A46      0.07              0.06  0.04     0.04                             0.07                                                                0.05  0.05  0.06            0.06                                 2.81    2.25 A47      0.30              0.50  0.45     0.38                              0.30                                                               0.13  0.14  0.42            0.19                                 2.01    1.60 A49      0.01              0.03  0.02     0.04                             0.01                                                                0.02  0.03  0.02            0.02                                 1.97    1.56 A50      0.05              0.04  0.01     0.02                              0.04                                                               0.03  0.01  0.03            0.03                                 2.52    1.80 ASI      0.13              0.10  0.03     0.06                             0.13                                                                0.06  0.03  0.09            0.07                                 1.20    0.96 l                                                                                                              A52      0.16              0.18  0.04     0.06                              0.15                                                               0.08  0.03  0.13            0.09                                 2.84    2.27 l                                                                                                              A53      0.01              0.02  0.02     0.04                             0.01                                                                0.02  0.02  0.02            0.02                                  N/A     N/A i                                                                                                              AS 4     0.01              0.02  0.02     0.03                              0.01                                                               0.02  0.02  0.02            0.02                                  N/A     N/A l                                                                                                              A55      0.01              0.01  0.01     0.005                            0.01                                                                0.003 0.004 0.01            0.01                                  N/A     N/A l                                                                                                              A56      0.004             0.005 0.004    0.003                            0.003                                                               0.002 0.003 0.004           0.003                                 N/A     N/A 1
1 1
                                                                                                             -    -_ r,      ,_   . - . -

Table 5.1 Comparison of Pressure During SRV In-Plant Testing for GGNS and Kuosheng Nuclear Plant (1)
PLANT                      SVA           NVA            CVA               DESIGN 95-95%        +5.37/-5.38    +5.57/-3.46    +8.52/-4.62          +18.2/-7.7 GGNS Max./ Min.    +4.88/-5.78    +4.06/-2.60    +7.47/-4.47 95-95         +7.62/-5.71      N/A            N/A                +16.6/-7.38 Max./ Min.    +12.05/-7.15   +10.11/-8.89   +9.81/-9.44 NOTE:    (1) All pressures are in paid i
l l
4                                                                                          i NMEREF 112 TA81.E 5.1

f                           .'
535
                               )                                   *            ,,,-
s t                                i
                                                                                 't255*
(
2 v1                                                ,
y ,.
                                 \
Py                   ,
                                                                                                                                          /
32*
                             #            -                                     ma                                              .                *
* v4                                             '
(                                                                                                             .
                            'dWW                              '                                                           .-        L9         *
{                       {, * @.* ::                      ' .-* l!.       ..
y9)                                        '
                                                                                               ),, .
5                                 '                                                                                                .                               -
                                                                                                            ..; j y
                                                                                                   ' h.      ~
i                   --
(*N                                      ,
Pf6 1                                                                                                     .
_,$$5*
::*.* *.          +
                                                                                                                                        \'             )            p,s    I
* M's
(                                                                           ets.t9 Pa. t. *'
                                                                                                   ~
                                                                                                                                         ^
                                                                                                                                                                                            ..g*
1                                                                                                                                                  ) ,5 p o,i L                                     -                                                  -                                                                                   ,             . i t,'
                                                                                                                           *b                              p,                               s s.% *
: o. '
{                                                                                        .-
                                                                                                       .-l
                                                                                                                          /m   s           a
                                                                                                        *
* pg s                                                                                                      ,-
                                                                                     . . -:.:. ..                                                                                      - 16' o                                '
2,. , -
                                        'b....
t k,                                                         ..
3t.
                                       *Y.TA O                       .
                                                                        \
N i
                                     ,                                                                               \
11 0 '
Figuro 2.1          -
Supprossion Pool Pressuro ':'ransducer 1,         '
Locations - Plan View
 .=
e mo .,

F        f     f          P       [        P                 N                 P                    W                M           M             ".
* N        N    9                          M   M    "I 1
i 1
i
* l l
                                                                           -n      m                                                                                                        ~-__-s gu                        _
s\ . .                   -*
N.          .
                                                                                   's.%                 -
4             .
                                                                                       .              \.
_U g                                                                             .
                                                                                      . .                                                                                            Pal
                                              . - - -        _              _.                      ._9-
                                                              ~-
                                                                                        . .                               P4              ,
                                                                   =   f pg,                                                           . .                                                   -
e_ d                                      .                   .
                                                                                                                                     .1 .*
                                                               ~
                                                                                    ,                                !S            ale                                                       *
                                                                                                                     %}
                                                                                       .                                            f                 QUENO4EA VI2
                                                                                                                     %ps                             az.3:.)        U                       .
                        -;                                            [P21-P t.6.13,                  PfS                                  -            .
8 4                                                                                                 6                                                                  -                           -
pio. s
                        ~*
                              .? $+                        -
2;-                              .(y ()                                                       -
b                                                      -               -
                                                                                                                         \en,in          a s,.                     e r.                                              -
                                     ;  i                      -
                                                                                                                            . 4. v-      -i                                                -
                                                                                                                    ~g, 3
                                                                                                                                     )                                n. ... . .       ,g,
                                                                                     ._ -                                          .r
                                                                                                                                               ,e* ein h=,% nnn se exh * * ~ -.
                                                                                                                                                                                            . ..                                a
                                                                               ...                  .re      -
                                                                                                                    =
2' 6 (l - ' -(-s*
5
                                                                                                                                                        ~
z*
u -o- ro t                   '
                                                                                                                           .-o.               .s . O.       ,  3. _ ..
CS CONTAAimJENT
                            ~
4e"    t."   TO 4                                                                           enj. G*
oc LONTAsNMLNT Figure 2.2 - Suppression Pool Pressure Transducers - Elevation View (Sensors Rotated Into View)                                                                                        .

f SRV VIE 1                                                                      ~
g                                                                        .
(                                               Vacuum W AKER                       b
[]'     h 1
s M
                                                                            +
d 1
t
            \.~ -
A           ,.
b k'
i pts x    -
s
                ~
f P El, t-t                               .a
                                                    .     *s     *
                       =s t
i L
Figuro 2.3 .. gW DischaMO tido Prossure Transducers L
s

1
                                                                                                                                                                   .i,.           \
L           u r
                                                                                                                                                                             .2                _.                                                    :O _*
9                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        o
                                            ._-                                                                                    -
* y . )r-           -
M                .'
                                                  ~                                                                                         .                                                          .
                        ~                            -
N                                                                                                              _                         .                                                                                                                                                      ,
                                      ,.g-                                                                           _
1
                                                                           -                                                             3j                                                                                                                                               .
                        .,-                                             s-                        -
3                       rt s
u W                %As. E.
t g*
o4 s
2, s
t 4s oa
: e. ra.
4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         \                .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           'f-o.
( R i
o A      n o
ee 8
s                                                                                                                                                  i 8                e4
                       -                                                                       _1.
( s,      z2     L s                                                                                   ss                s                           .
1         t
      'M T                                                                 5e            2                                                                                                                                                       .                                    s,        a s                   .
v
     '8                .E
                        .T S
G2 S2 s
i, 2,        e 6                                                                                                                                                                                           s        l 5
q                                                                                                                                                             .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            %        E
      "                                                                                                                                I                                                                                                                                ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             '                                          )
      "                                 c                                                                                          w                                                                                                                                                         .
     '''                     '                                                                             g                           ,L                                                i                                                                                    ;
c
                   ~
                                        -                                                                                \>g                                                                                                                                                                                          si nn
     "                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 e' ,                                       =
ia o
8 E -
g\                                                                               y;. ...-                                      2 9,
o t e-an
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  )              8 s   cT N                                                  h s        8 t 8         s 8
cE                     .
t.
S. u   o B-                                                                                                                                                                             (
I                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              e a1             6                                                                                                                           0 E                                                  s          B 3
9 t.
D A
Ld s UT                                                            G                                                                                                                              4                                                           s    R    e9 e
M                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      -                          _                                -
TS                                                             E                                                                                                                              9 i
G    $-
U                                                                               -                                                                                                      8                                               .
S g: -
CA t
Ji                                                                   at
     ^
t                                     I CW                                                                                                            i.4
[                                                 (                       /       y                                                   $
5 Gn D
t                                    RE                                                                                                      .                l                                                                             _                      \                                     n
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              )L
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             +
t g
                                                                                                                                                                 ^l-t g
j                      4 I                 ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 )5J I
iq ay
                                                                                            -                                                                                                                        3 s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  )                                                           . . =                   rn s
o A                        .
3         te Sn n S                                                                                                   a M                                                                                                                                                                           +gg t j
C
(
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           '                                                        4
                 .l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ~                                                                       7
                                                                          .-                     . N)                                                                                                                                                                             -
                                                                                                                                             . . .                                           . .                                             .                                                                      2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  .         G m*.
N                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        a N.,~.,..
S         e
                                                                          -                                                                      . .                                                                                                                                                                 r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~                       -        .
u g
i
                                                                                                                                                                                               ..                                                                                                                   F F                             .
                                           .                            s%.%        .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~
                          .\
   ^
s                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .
E
   ~~                                               -
- ^'
T
{

t                                                                                                                                                                .
     ~
r       .                        .
l i                                                                        .. . i
(
4
                                                                                                                                                      .J                                                             .
('                            VIO
                                                                                                                                                ,.                                                                      e l
: l.                                                                                                                        e             .~'* ' .
                                                                                                                                                        , , 'U , SGI                  j i, .-- 53 2                             .
                                                                                                                                                             ,                                        33 4
                              ':i *
                                    ),[.                                                                                ,                - . . . . .
                                                                                                                                                                                   / h 80 *
* A1 0, i%                    ~ A Z 0.s*
                                                                                                                                                     ',                                                 SG l2                 %
8888                    .'    SG 3,14
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .            SG 25,26
,g l              l
                                                                                                                                                                                       ~,
                                                                                                                                                                                               ~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                . At s e
                                                                                                                                                                                    ! ss 2.;2s                                                 AZ 8.5*
                                                                                                                           ./.',.'.
l                                                        e               % et,20,2r,21.13,24
                                                                                                                 ,..                                                                SG IS                    8
(                                                                                .
5G16 i                                        _-
5 17                                                    .A 'AI 28' m,                                 s                                                                         ,/                         .
s                                                                                                                                  -
                                   ~~                                                                              .               .
g#                         -           '
kid TURetuE EXHAUST e ..                                                                               .
I
                                 ,.e                                                        .
l 90                             ,      /
: 6.                                                                     .
                             /
Figure 2.5                          -      Strain Gage Locations - Plan
(                 .
                                                     *m                                                          .
O                                                    we M.%
           - - -     _ _ . _                . _ .         - _ - . .      ,y     .te_--

[                                                                          b als,g T              -
C F                                                                            .
u A19,50,BI                   ,,               _]
RECOMBNER                                                                                                                          All,12.
fj      .
I                                                     A35, 3 (,,37 8-L.
s 1
                                                   /._, , A 32,33,S4                                                       .A23.14
                                                                                                                                  .s
                         ,                                   1                                                                    -
[
1l                               .
                                                     .                                                  Ati,21
                                                                                          ,                                            ,     . A5 5. 5(,
                                           ,..                 1 F.               . .g
* 1 1                                                               .
Q
                                                                         .          CD.         .                                 .
                                                                                     .k                            :. ,A19,20                A7,8,9,10
* A15,16, c '.                                                                              ee 17,18
                                                                                                                  ,t A3,4,5,6
                                        -E.                       ..       A15,1(e,        ,.
d
                                                                                                             -a-
                                        -O-                         .
17,28 ee                            -E-
                                        -E-                'l '
                                                                                            '.** ** ' ~ -E-                                  4:*g l                                        ~                    ,,
A S3,5'4
                               ..,               ..      ..,                          : + +.'                '' .
I Figure         2.6 - Accelerometer Locations-Structure (Elevation View - Accelerometers Rotated into View)
L e

(                                             -
f C
f f
I                                           .
f                                                    RHR HEAT h" EXCHANGER + g,9 o
80015 s0    +6, l                                                 t p.
Y I-                                                .
o
                                                      ~~'   ,                       A38, AS9, A40 f                                        '
g   -         E L. l o t '- 9"
                                                    "                 k   b   % Qi E 12GolcW O7
* l
                                                   - A ,,
N            ,
[                                                               i FOO35-5 g                                                                    b L                                                           C                 ~
s     GlEl?.GoldROS l -                                Figure 2.7 - Pipe Mounted Accelerometers A38, A39, A40 L
  '6
  's mw.

C in 6
O f(              A41, A 41 i A45 E L . I 4 9 '- 3 '/2.
                /QIEb2iGottoROS/                                      .
I I
1 I
     '(                                       I
     ~
                                           ]~ TO k I
1.
F.igure 2.8 - Pipe Mounted Accelerometers A41, A42, A43 L
t

i
                                                        ,O .
O
                                                                  '* Te o T   .
SUARD
{(
FIPE                           '',
i.
g                                                                             2 DRYWELL WALL      3 wi e,2eo,2 a,e/
7 I
F OO9-6
                                                .....e...
                                                      ~
E G. I 1 'c     - 9 */;"~
y                         Foto
 ~
t L                            f 7[Qll53MO23 Rot /
d O
                            ,i O
N kN
        ' Figure 2.9 - Pipe Mounted Accelerometers A44, A45, A46 e
h

i
      .-(
ci                            -
{                                                                       W 3                                                                       D 0
                                                                                                            /
                                                                                                   ,\
{
E T
                                                                                    +&
0,y$ ' &'
e                 s
                                                                   .D
[                                                             G g
g 4'                             4o.d,  o
                                                                                                  &        +,
q*%-
r
                                                                                                ~
A47 A48 ( A49
                                                  ..                          #~              @~
E.L . Iro7'- IYg"                                           A
                                                                             <f
{(                                                                                              .
                                                        #                                     $        9 Y                                      s-s'b, /
o
              \1,                                                              -.
L L
t I
  ~
Piqure 2.10 - Pipe Mounted Accelerometers A47, A48, A49 I
L Y

f
                                                                                          /
(                                                                  .  ,$       &
I     -
g et g6
[(                                                        &**
o' \O
[                                           :
i r                                            d l                                            a 6
{        AGC, ASI & AG7.                      -
E L. 170 ' - 9 '/g" I                                      %
6 6G I.
                                                                              \'         ,,
                                                                            -       s,sC,
                                                               \,               \y\,
                                                                                  /
                                                              / Q%"* Y *Q.'-
W, L                                                           9Y*'
(                                                , . . <.
p
                                                                                    \
          -                                                             \g$#
                                                                            \g&
                                                                   @'gt G-
                                                        .)
I
    %               Figure 2.11 - Pipe Mounted Accelerometers A50, A51, A52
  ,L I

FILTERED ORTA 8                                                             ORIGINAL SAMPLING RRTE
            .                                                                   M10-12 U-l 1
8 a-I       -
08._
l       (n -r Q_
i l
i       w             l to
                )
1 D.              }>
(D o.
(n
!       w                I                                                                           -
e to T-1 8
6                                                                            ,
            'O.00    0'.20     0'.40       0'.60             0'.80 l'.00   l'.20       1.40     1.60 TIME (SEC)
CRAND CULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                          MATRIX TEST MT-10 CHANNEL 12                                                                                          '
Figure 3.1

i i
o e
                                                                  ~
W                                                                       O a
m                                   .                                   ",
Eo ez E                                H o
o-                                                                        I a
o C.
_=r .
wrw                                      %
i MG-win i
- o                                                                       (n sa-                                                                       LLJ
~E*
a cv l-S                        X                                    -J        X E                                                                       ~
oc l-o       C Z
S O   CD o tu    LU
_$o
                                                                    -     l-L'J            N I   F-         A
                                                                      ~
Z          e
* __!       O
_o Z
o       >
                                                                  =r      GC
                                                                ~o        U3 LL
                                                                          .J o       D
_9        O o
O Z
C o       Z o
* O 00'9  00'h  00'E   00'O                     00*d-      00*h-                     -
(OISd) 38nSS38d                                                       a W
Z Z
E Z
U

o to
                                                                                             ~
w                                                                                                 O w                                                                                                 N a
u            -
l G
V EN                                                                                       o a          S o ~;
o a-                                                                                     #
E E r-W moi                                                                                                 O
    - o                                                                                                 u.i d$E                                                                                      o          r w5                                                                                       n o                                                                                    .
                                                                                             ^
E                                                                                                 "
oc H
CE
                                                                                             $          Z V
U      O ow         LLI D lJ")     L     --                              n*
_.w           '
o                                                n g
e r      P 5
Z                                     $
r           _1                               5" o
to         CL I
                                                                                           ~o 7
0          %
to-           D B
__J o              D
                                                                                             "          O
                                                                                          -o O
                                              , ;                                                       Z CE
                                              ;:                                             o          Of I                                              o 3                                                 .        O 00'9   00''h      00*E               00'0   0 0
* E'-                           00*h-I O I S d)           380SS38d                                                                                       w a
Z Z
T Z
U

o                                                       FILTERED DRTR ORIGINAL SAMPLING RATE
            }_                                                       M10-8 8
J-58 Bu O_
1
             ~
f
       =
0 1
w                                                             -
                            )
: j.                                        I I
8
 .        J
           'O.00  0'.20     0'.40 0'.60       0'.80    1'.00  l'.20        l'.40  1.60 T IME (SEC)
CRAND CULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,               MATRIX TEST MT-20 CHANNEL    8 Figure 3.4

I o                                                                                               o in g
N                                                                                           N m                                                                                             l e
    -o                                                                                                I-ez                                                                                          o o-
_J
::r   I o n.                                                                                        -
wrm                                                                                               t-xe-w sn s                                                                                            Ln O_;S                                                                                              W CE*   -
o m
S                                                                                    -J     X E                                                                                           ~
Z I-o     c
_. X
                                                                                                    - I-o CD ow    w o
6-      m c;
w I l-      8 Z        S
                                                                                                    " __J     c e                8     Q-
_.       i o
Z m
o     >
e                           =r    Z 2             -d     (D
                                                         ~
_                               LL
                                                                                                      ._J o     D
_"     O o
O Z
c 5     %
o
                                                                                                  . o     N 00*di I00*8              00*h                         00*O          00*h'- 00*B              -
(OISd) 380SS38d                                                      a w
Z Z
G I
U

o M10-12 d-8 d-o LLI W
i o
f_
a 5-O .                                       _
         %.00     2'0.00 4'0.00 6'0.00      8'0.00   l'00.00 l'20.00    l'40.00   160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
CRAND CULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,              MATRIX TEST MT-10 CHANNEL 12 Figure 3.6

o                                                             M10-14 c5-8 d-u                                                                           -
tu
     $m W    ._
ko
     ~
(n
     $=r o
in o_
Q_
a 5-a f  '
3 .00     2'O.00 11'0.00 &'O.00 6          8'0.00   l'00.00 l'20.00     l'40.00   180.00 FREQUENCY [HZ)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                MATRIX TEST-MT-10 CHANNEL 14 Figure 3.7

O O
d e
                                                                                 ~
O N
o         I o      F--
d
_=r r
r,-                                                                           ~
o                                                                                    &
i                                                                                    m o      LLI H
o N
                                                                                 -      X S      f--
                                                                                   -    C
_S      Z l~-
* i      N I  f--
                                                                             )   o-o >-
(D y
pd                  m i  oZ'J   H u
D  H           8 O  Z           a j
J           E SS$    Q.-
u
_o w
_   I Z
m 4   5      >
d      M
                                                                                 =r     <n 1.1._
o      J o      D
_d      O
                                                                                 ~
O
                                                           <                            Z C
x S      T O!'O  90'O     90'O                h0'O   20'O                 00 *[                       ''
33S*E**ISd-OSd                                                                 d Z
E 5

o                                                      M10-8 d-E 5-o LLJ W
W 9_
                   *o m
(D O_
12 09_
(D o     l Q.
o 5-8  f                    <
1 k.00    2'O.00 y'0 b   Ob       8'O 00 1'00.00 l'20.00    l'40.00-  160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,         MATRIX TEST MT-20 CHANNEL    8 Figure 3.9

                                                                                      ''.**'.y,p .t 3                                                          M10-12 5-8 d-o tij OJ 3_
4o 4
sa (D
           =9 0  9_
(D o O_
o 5-
                 ' \h                      9 i       V               A Ab      i Vm- _
           %.00     2'0.00 4'O.00 6'O.00       8'0.00 1'00.00 l'20.00     l'y O. 00    160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,             MATRIX TEST MT-20 CHANNEL 12 Figure 3.10

l 1
g>        .g.              .
                                                                                                                                                                .g.   .g.                              .g.
6'        '4' 9 b                                                                         ;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       .d
                                 ,                                                                                  .                                ;f                            .                                         <
d.i
{   .
d   ,
4                                                                                                                                                                                                                          e   m
                                                                                                      .           .                                                                                                       4 1                                      .
i                                .
.i                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .
l i                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               .
M M.
n
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .              O                     o W
m                      L4
:s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .                                  CD
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,g
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             >                  C:
                                                                                                            .                                                                                                                                                                E
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .               C g
40 w
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .               Z m
T.                  .           .
Ed E
O W
9''
m          m O                                                                             W                                                                             LD                                                                                        >-
;                      W-                                                                   -        o p     -                                                                       o                                                                                            wC EL                                                                            Q.
p     -
m
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              . >- o g.
G.                                                                                        Z          fu
                                                                                              .                                                                                                                                                                             C   *l*
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           .                E P-  CC
                                                                                                                            ~
* EH
                                                                                                                                                           ~                            -
LaJ t,n 20
                                                                         .                                                                                                                                                                                                  m mo 4
T      ,1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          .                 W 8d
: o. u-h
                          -                                                                                                                   ~>
1 >,                     .           .                                   4 l
4 e                                                                                                                 .
1 -      ..                                                                                                                                    c
                                                                                                          .  ...f.              .t.                      .t.      .t.                                                '
                                                                                                                                                                       .                           .t.   .t.                     .t.        .t.
SO                                           O                   Sn m                                               O m
M
                                                                                                                                                                                         .                              .                                . .d.
a 6
C                               n 1
4 QISd GISd                                                                    GISd i

               .g.  .,. o       g-    g-                                                 .
_l,*
fu r
           ,                 %                                         i        F        .
4                                         a        4 t
i s
i e
r 4
                             \                                        A :C b'                                      3* C J                                               >
f!
                                                  '                      < t d,'
* E it d ,
4
                                                                        *E N
v4
         ~                                                  -
                                              .                                     =           0 W
                                                                                                @              C
                                                                                      -                        Le D
                                                                                                   >=          @
Ci          =A
                                                                                      "           O           k.
t-O N
                                                                                      .           Z w       O K       W w       m W                                                                                             t-D-                                                 O d .                                                N P                                        -
F
                                                                                                    . Do D.
m   e+
Z HN c   I". .-*
J                                                ~-                                w m ZO ta mo
                                                     !               j w O*
30 ws 4
                   ?-                                                                      .
I
: f.                 I-    I-O n                 o                   A,           &
a            o 1
GISd                                         QISd
* I

l I                                                     i 6            I i i
                                       ' J,
* 6 g                       N T F                                                                                                                              -~
1 h                         .           .
                                                                                                                                                  };
s                                                                                                 ,
al J F 1                  .
3,,,.                                                                                                    h 4  h                                                                                                     I 4         -
                                         -      L                                                                                            &
                                                                                                                                                  <  r 1
j     ;r                                                                                                 .
E 9
[
a t
: a. ,-i=
4; f
                                                                              .                                                                                                                          m O                           s W                           n' w
                                                                                                              .                                                                                           c u
3-                       3 E                        D Q                       =e4 w
m w
                                                                                                                                                                .               I m
W                     U
                                                                .           .                                                                                                   I"                    W m                     m v                                                                  t.D
                                                                                                                                                                                >-        t o                                                                  o                                           (D o                                                                      oo F-F
                                                                                                                                                                                  .       O           o.
Q.                                                                 Q.
H                                        -
m CL                                                           Z        >=fu C         I* w
                                                                                                                                                               .                E
                                                                                                                                                                                >= CO Z F-
                                                                                                                                                                                  . W
                                                       -                                                                                                                        LO TO LO T                                                                                                                                           W O     m o.
d                         *           '
                                                                                                           "
* E 30 Me Q.
I >
k",                                   .                                                            '
4, c
                 . . . . f . , . . l< '....
I f I        l    t t                              .'L                              .
o O
                                                              .              .        .       .       .    .             .                      .            .=.
W          O                       M            v          N      O       fu   v           W                  O                   m
         ==                                                  8                                            e e                                                      a GISd                                                       GISd                                         GISd i

           '    ''                 ''             --            --             =w          .-
.                                                                                                                               .      O a
                                                                                                                                .                                         1 l
O
* in
                   *e4                                                                           -
0                                                               +:, .-                                     -
3 N
      =            g                                   -
_          ru, 1               O                                                                                        .
C-W                                                                                                                              .
g   .
3 M
e                            m
      =                                                                                                                                 O
                                                                                                                                  .     -             N                 o Z               u C                                                                                                                   :
N
                                                                                                                                                                       ?
e4 W
                                                                                                                                  .                                o C         W W         W
                             \                                                                                                                           C.
v                                                                                                                                                              40 O                                                                                                                                    o                   .
p-                          l                                                                                             - O                         m      >-
E tu.
: c. ":                                                                                                                           :                      z e
s -.
Q:
t-     CO
                                                                                                                                  .                             Z h=
* W t.D    IO W WO
                                                                                                                                  .                      LaJ    O=
C2: 30 Q. Mw e
        ,       t..        .       f..  . . . f., .   . t. ,     ,     t..         f..       .       f. . ..                    3 o      a                 fu             m              v             sa           to                r=              go O O   I                  e              e             o              e           e                 e               s             *
* O                 O                             O                                           O
               ==                 m             Oe             .              .O.e        Oe
                                                                                          .                .                .O.e ZH 83d 03Wn05 GISd

                                                                                                                     ,-m.       -                                              --     a    ._s a    a a a a-4 g-'              g''         g' "           g'"
n
                                                                                                                                                          .om 4
e D
4 3
4 e
           =                                                                           ~
m                                                         2              -
O
                                                                      ~
G 4
m
       -                                                                                                                                                                                ~.
5                                                                                      -
n
                                                                                                                                                  .      *sz                             e
       .                                                                                                                                          '                                      u
                                                                                                                                                 "                                       D a4 d
he DO M
O O        - LaJ C
Ui           M Q.
O, .                                                                                                                                                                            O W.                                                                                                                                                  o               .
C6 -
                                                                                                                                             ~
o          m       .Oe su.
z we
                                                                                                                                               ~                    C Ee GC t==     GC Z >=
i,aa m 20 m (n o+
IAJ O Ol: 3O Q.      Md 9
r..            t..               l. ,                                                                                                          M
                           . .                   -       f. -           - =    I--                 I"        I--              I" o             m                 N                  M                     M
                                                                                                                                      ' '              8 a                                                                                        M           @
b               'o b                     'o                'o
                                                                                                           'o               Qo              Y m*
o ZH H3d 038Vn05 QISd

'                                                                            ~
FILTERED DRTR o                                                                ORIGINAL SAMPLING RATE Q
m M10-14 8
l                           a-l 1                       mm~                      I b                          I Eo               W           I h
I   /     ,
I     llt
                                            \
                        '8                                                               \
                            +                 s a
8
                   .        J             ,            ,  _ _ _ _ _ , _ .-        ,    ,        ,          ,
                             'O.00       0.20        0.40        0.60           0.80  1.00     1.20       1.40      1.60 TIME (SEC1 GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                              MATRIX TEST MT-11 CHANNEL 14 Figure 3.16

FILTERED ORTA o                                                                   ORICINAL SRMPLING RRTE-M10-5 m,
8 bo
                  -< R.
m eu                              p G.                                                                                                       '
                 ~                                 f' H
Eo                              ,
                 ~3R      . . _ . . . _ _
s m,      . . . -            ,
l               Lo k                          j     W       k y
9                                                                              ) hl         (p 7-                                                                                          V 8
J
                     'O.00                 0'.20        0'.40 0'.60        0'.80   l'.00   l'.20        l'.40        1.60 TIME (SEC)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                                 MATRIX TEST MT-21 CHANNEL    5                                           Figure 3.17

FILTERED DATR ORIGIN     AMPLING RATE
        =
1 Sk 5"           V        hi   I            I N
g   =.= =,
f
                                            \    f                              I m
x                      v                              llf\                       -
      '8 k-o                 ]
        ?
0.00      0'.20     0'.40 0'.60       0'.80 I'.00   l'.20       l'.40     1.60 TIME (SEC)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                MATRIX TEST MT-21 CHANNEL   7 Figure 3.18

o m
U                                                       m E
e                                                      m I
E 3                                                S      I o n.                                     . ll5ise--                   *               '
EEe                                      7                                 r saa                                                                         (n d5!E                                                                        to
: u. z                                                                  o      H G                                                 m E                                                         X o                                                         ~
M l-o       C
                                                                                   -d
                                                                                         -  w A                              ..
o
                                                         %                              Y e
Z         g
                                                          -                         8      d I Z.
e S
                                                                                 -ic       (D LL l
                                                               ==
o
                                                                                   "       D
_         O o
O Z
C o       E I<                  9       O 00 *di                        00*8      00*h    00*O i
00*h- 00'9 o               W (OISd) 38nSS3Hd                                   a W
a T
U

OR]CI      L  RATE
         =                        .
J-f           1 08 b#               g
                                                 \
f 0- g nI_
                         ,                 j i
((J /%g h                 Q            .
t U
8
        =;
          'O.00    0'.20         0'.40   0'.60        0'.80 l'.00    l'.20 l'.40      1.60 TIME (SEC1 GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                     MATRIX TEST MT-31 CHANNEL     8                                  Figure 3.20

o                                                     M10-14 d-8 d-u                                                                  -
uJ
       $S W1 wo m
(n Q_
i2 OS (D o Q.
d-o b.co
                    .c w 20.00 40.00 60.00       80.00 FREQUENCY (HZ) 100.00 120.00 140.00   180.00 l
CRAND CULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,           MATRIX TEST MT-11 CHANNEL 14                     Figure 3.21 J

y                                                                                           M10-5 d-3               .s
: s.                    1
* 44 7     .       ;                        }
n, d-o to m
w*o m                         ^
  ~
a_                                                                                                                                        .
eo 07                                                                                                                     s m o-                                                          -
n_                                      >
m o
         ,                 f                                                                                                   ~                   ;
a          .
g j 9
s C3 i
                                            -   x  '_     _       -               _
s I
3 .00          2'O.00     4'O.00        6'O.00       8'0.00         l'00.00    l'20.00         l'40.00         160.00 FREQUENGY (HZ1 -
                                                                                                                              '.         i
                                                                 \ .i.
GRAND CUdF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                                       MATRIX TEST MT-21 CHANNEL'    5 Figure 3.22

0 0
0 6
1 1
2 0          -
0 T
M 0
7                                             '4
  -                                            l 0
1 T
M                                                      S 0       E 0
                                                 . T 0
                                              '2 l       X I
R 0       T 0
                                                 . A 0
0       M
                                              'l
                                                   )
Z H   T
                                            -  0
(
S 0Y      E      3 O.C     T      2
                                              '8N             3 E
U   T       e r
Q   N       u g
_0 E        L      i F
0R
                                                 .F    P O          -
_'6 N
_           I
_0           V 0
O R
                                              '4       S F
0 L
0       U O
G
                                              '2 D
N A
0 0
R
                                                 . G od    Ed      W7O 1
m    o 5d        83                  7 ow  n#* uOi o D a_
(                                 L E
N N
R H
C
:!               i  i

                    !j'      l        1 1     i)l'  <i-0 0
2o@
2 0
6 1
C E
S
* 20 2 .,
         *1 I
S P
          - 0
_          8 D .,
S0 P
0 1
1 0
0 0
p
              . c      >-
                             !f
: 1. l l   '
ca         Wo             Co 8      c                a         Co 8   - vO'ao t
                                                                                                   ~
                                                                                                  -C  oC     m? OO _
ne,eCmmoCmQc_C       - IN-                                     _
0     ZO       --
gcFT    l   )
fX< - Z.4IZi inr U
                                                                     ) l ZoHX~X HrU-  n)    l    1
(                -                 s                           -l W" p
nZZ22m"     m                                         2g2 w,y
                                                                                  !ll       I

g                                                               M10-8 5-
   .             e d-o w
To e_
Mo m
to a  m.
(f) O
* Q e
d-t Y
U 3 .00 (A      -
y'O.00 2'0.00            60.00       8'O.00 l'00.00 l'20.00    l'40.00   160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
: t.                    GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                   MATRIX TEST MT-31 CHANNEL      8                            Figure 3.25

f
                    ' v.                                                                   g
                                                                     . .  .g.       ..
8                                                    3,.             ~
M 5
                     -g.             .      .              .
M               .      .              -             4m.-
                     $                                                      4 r
T'        -
2 l-    [6           -         -            -        -
3g         -
4 5               -
n.
gY
                    =.-            .
L f-q m
               -                -         -            -         -                     -     a W          c m          u g
             '-       -                   .               .      .                             C z        ,
E O
m w                -
w,                                                      &
w                                          a S-a.
S  -            -
R  -                      -
g     ~o
: a.                    a.                                z     .-ru e    r-m e  eo
                                                                                                 .w
                   @==_  -
D                        S                     $   $$
                                                                                               = 2o
: n. w-i
                                                                                 , . , .g d        d          & J               d    J 4             4     d     f j~
GISd                         GISd                      GISd b.

6        4        e i i                        : 4                     6 N
:4
                                                                                                         ?
t b'
d 4   ,
                                                       -                                                 I',
3 e
l 5                                                       .
7
                                                       *                                       .         1 i
8 N
Y
                                                     ?-                                                                         -                      -             o LaJ O
en b
                                                                                                                                                                         =
Cl:,
                                                                                                                                                                         >=
tr>
w g
W Ld           u E           w
                                                       .                                                                                                                 M           W H
tn                                                                           &                                                       O w,                                                                           gy
* p-                                                                      -    g  -                      _
m       w v  O.
a                                                                            a                                           Z       >=fu
                                                                                                                                                                         <r      Ee
* W
                                                                                                                                                                         & CO Z b-
* W Lf3 ZC in WO w C+
                                                                                                                                -                                        E       .'3 O (1. M .-e
                                                               . . . . .                                           .                 .                     g 48               T                N                O              m       O   RA         O       &n S
* e GISd                                                    GISd I
e
    - , - - - - - - - .   . , - - . , - , - , . - , . > . _ , , , - , - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - . _ , , - , , . . - .             -            ,_        , , - ,      .-n-,,    , - . . , . - - -

u 6-          r           6.         6..          ,-
r      .mo 19-5 T'   2
                                                   ^
                                                                                          ~
o
                                      ? E L~ ~
S,A- ^
o' Vs-         W
: a.               e ~
                %                                                                                                    N M
                                                                                                  **                  O
                                                                                            -      o                  u
                                                                                                   -g                 a w
                                                                                                                     -e4 II4
                          .                                                                     .                  o Q       LaJ m       m II.
O o         +  # fL3 B   -                                                                                    -
o     m    .4   +
o_W.
                                                                                                     -     z --
                                                                                                           < EM D. .                                                                                                 m
                                                                                                           & CO Z l-
                                                                                                              . w w 10 m t.n o+
La. O x DO
: c. Md j.
g.. J.
                                                                                                      'g .
            -        m b
                                'o T                      ,
s 2     s           o
             'o       -          -              e          2                          -          -
ZH B3d 03avnOS GISd zu-o's-31o                                                                                                 nuteC

l
                                                                                                                                                 ~
 ;                                 ,'-            g-          g          ,.             4"       s''             a ''                  4'        4''
                                                                                                                                                              ]mO 4
w-R__
T2 c%
88 o
                               .                     S~
m' (L
4 Ch N.
n
                                                                                                                                                                    .Oe N             Q E             w 3
0 et
                                                                                                                                                             .                        b e
W U
Q           W W           W N                                                                                                                                                  Q.
fU                                                                                                                                                             O M7                                                                                                                                ~
O o
W g        e ru.
G-.                                                                                                                                  *      **
                                                                                                                                                           .              Z 8 - .=e C     I". *
                                                                                                                                                           '              E l-    00 Z P=
* t.aJ D ZO W mo i
WO           +
E 30 Q. MW e
                           ,.                                      t
                                                                                   ?         *
* e         *               *'*
;                           o                -        ,u        n              ,-          m            .
O               e        a         e              e          s              e
                                                                                                                                 ~           .         . O*
                              =*                                                                                                  e          e         s
                                              .O4      .Oe        O.             O           O                                     O
                                                                  .              .                         .O.e                    .          .O.e      .O ZH 83d 03Bvn05 GISd

q FILTERED DATR o                                                                            ORICIN      RMPLING' RATE 4-8 J-8o
      ~
: 8)                               l
      $ ,                                            I            l I
(   [    1        h           \\
t              Il '
T4     )      l             l
                                                                                                         \
kJ        kl T
                                                                              \
8 h-                                      1
                                       \
        = *
         'O.00     0'.20         0'.40       0'.60          0'.80       l'.00          l'.20       l'.40       1.60 TIME (SEC)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                                 MATRIX TEST MT-70 Figure 3.30 CHANNEL   2

t FILTERED ORTR
'                    o                                                ' ORIGINAL SAMPLING RATE M10-19 m_
t E
a-Q8 um.
o_
                 ~
l 0
l    l N@o w
La tr Y) 8 i-
             .       8 J
                      'O.00  0'.20 0'.40    0'.60         0'.80 l'.00     l'.20        l'.40   1.60 TIME (SEC)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,              MATRIX TEST MT-70 CHANNEL 19                            Figure 3.31

                                                                                              . .o W                                                                                                                 o a                                                                                                                 &
m:        -
I E
Es                                                                                           o                       1-aa                                                                                            :r I
                                                                                                ~
SIo een                                                                                                                  w wni
  ,O en W
dd2 mz                                                                                           o                      t--
N G                                                                                        -;                      ><
2 O                                                                                                                -
oc i-O o                      r
                                                                                              -A i--
U                 U) oW                     l.1 I W
e                             _$
o H        N, g                          n E                 Y         o
                                                              .2                                    C                 __3      N g                      o.-
* _.                        I z
S                      oc
                                                                                              -g                      v, u_
__2 o
N O
                                                                                              -g                      O a
z G
o                      QC
                                                                                                 .                    O O                                 a oo'c 00'E                       U     00 0               0 0 . I'-                 00*E                                     N (O sd) 3gnss38d                                                                                 a y
e Z
U

o e
                                                                                                                                                  ~
       =
w O
    .E                                                                                                                                                         b
       =                       -
                                                                                                                                                                    'l E
eu                                                                                                                                                         I-CZ                                                                                                                                            o
    *3                                                                                                                                         .-
w            r OIm eEm
                                                                                                                                                 ^
W wni e o (D
s s-
    -Er w
    'Z                                                                                       7                                                  o             &
o                                                             -
W                                                             m X
E                                                                                                                                                      -
i-a                                                                                                      o o
CE I
n       &
W       W ow            u!                 m oui           y
                                                                                                                                              .g -                               n w                          a
                                                          %                                                                                           r       I-                 0
                                                                                   *                                                                  ~
l--
z                  &
w                                                                                                      8            L
                                                                                           /                                                  -d                    I Z
                                                                                                                                                             ~
o             >
s             M
                                                                                                                                              -d             (D u_
_1 o
N D
Wh                                                     ~,             O u                                                       o 9
Z
                                                                                        .)                                                                  CC o            &
o
                                                                                                                                                   .        O                      .
s         00*h             00 t                                      00'0           00 g-                                    00 P                                     "
( 01 Sd)                                  380SS38d                                                                                          =
Z Z
E I
o

ORICI          L   C RATE
              =
J-58 A
o p                         i l
i MY         9         q e
s
           '8 Vi            b' 1
8 O.00   0'.20 0'.40     0'.60        0'.80    l'.00    l'.20      l'.40        1.60
    .                                        TIME (SEC)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                  MATRIX TEST MT-70
~
Figure 3.34 CHRNNEL 29

o e
                                                                                           ~
O N
  =                                                                                                b
  "                                                                                                  i
=                        J                                                                         >-
EE o-                                                                                         E       Z o$                                                                                     _.
                                                                                           ~
EER
* tn W"_,a a -                                                                                                W
-az wz                                                                                         o       r N
G                                                                                          '
E                                                                                                "
o F--
o        C o        r E
s
                                                                                               -   F--
O   Ln ow       u.J Rl0 o
                                                                                                   &      Q
                 '                                                                             w          n 2
I   l--     .
Z Q
* _J     h" w
                                                                                          @        L
                                                                                      -g             I
_                                                  Z
                                                                                                   ~
o        >
                                                                                          .s       &
                                                                                      -d           in u.
J o        ""3 N        O o
O Z
                           '                                                                       C o        x
     '             '            .                          i 9
o 0     -
00*9 00*'h  00*t           00'0                     00*E-            00
* h                            m (OISd) 380SS38d                                                                             g
                                                                                                         =
E 5

g                                                                  M10-2 N"
7 O c Y$ -
UO M:-
W 5
4 L o~
Q (D
b e     f o
I        n E
             %.00 k    /
2'O.00 MWm 4'O.00 6'O.00 8'0.00   l'00.00 l'20.00     l'40.00  160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
GRAND CULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                     MATRIX TEST MT-70 Figure 3.36 CHRNNEL    2

E                                                               M10-19 J-7 C o
         #1es US tu (D N 5
(N 4
4 t~~
Q (n
Q O ~
l 0
                            )
8    3     /W             w __          __    m k.00         2'O.00 4'O.00   6'O.00      8'O.00 l'00.00 l'20.00    l'40.00   160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
CRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                  MATRIX TEST MT-70 Figure 3.37 CHANNEL 19

o M10-20 d-5-
o tu
     $5 N R_
      *o 4
(n ks O R.
(D o O.
o 5-
        ?     hK                ~_ __ ._          _
3 .00   2'O.00 11'0 . 0 0       6'O.00      8'O.00   l'00.00 l'20.00     l'140.00 160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
                                                                                               ~
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                        MATRIX TEST MT-70 CHRNNEL 20                                     naure 3.38 o

y                                                                       M10-29 5-R 5-u La (n
W ._
                                   %O 4
(n D
G n_
E d-1 k    H            _ . _ _ _ _ - __.        ________a
                                     %.00    2'O.00 4'O.00               6'O.00       8'O 00 l'00.00 l'20.00     l'40.00 160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,
        ~
MATRIX TEST MT-70 Figure 3.39 CHRNNEL 28

o,                                                                   M10-30 d-E d-U tu
     $m W 9_
      *o 4
U3
:P Q  ._
U3 o Q.
o 5-I     M o
9           v  N       .__m         _ __ _        -_
        %.00    2'O.00  t[0.00      6'O.00         8'O.00    l'00.00 l'20.00    l'40.00   160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                        MATRIX TEST MT-70 CHANNEL 29                              ngt2re 3.40

g                                                              M10-32 d-S                     -
5-u LLI
* u) m
       *"?
40 4
m sn O
07 u)o-
          =
d-f
          %.00 W
                  \}
2'O.00 4'O.00
                                  .m__
l'00.00 6'O.00     8'O.00         l'20.00    l'40.00   160.00 FREQUENCY (HZ)
GRAND GULF SRV IN-PLNT TEST,                  MATRIX TEST MT-70 Ngure 3.u CHANNEL 31

4                       i                 e                          I   i ~             ' 6     4 f
l                                                            k'I a     L                      -
1                                                i '
1,r                                             a    -
1'          -                                                 ,                                              v '
L            i,.                               ,             i    ;             .        .                   i
        '          J h                                               q j   a W        "*                                     a    t                                          a L
        >           a     b n                                                .
a         r I          .3 g
* 1 dl ,=
ak 4
J ,
                                                                                                                         'k "5 L                                               %                                              j     g         .
l$      '
e dE N
J I
i r
        '.                *                    .       ,            a     -
1
                                                                                                   '                 I, I If 1L                                            jL h
N 4
n*
O
          -                                  .          .                             .             .                                        .          O             u W             D LA            m
                                                                                                                                                                     *.4
           ,                                            ,           ,                     .          ,                                                               g
                                                                                                                                                           *>=
E O
H 4A w
           .                                    .       .                                 .          ,                                                     Z LA W       O
::      LA.
m       m T                                               LA                                        (D                                                                   O O"                                        "     o   *
* o      "                                       "
(A
                                                                                                                                                             . oo 00
* D=                                              H                                         l--
IL                                              G.                                        Q.                                                           Z >= fU C    I" . 4
                                                                                          .           ,                                                    m
                                                                                                                                                           & CO Z P-
* W
                           ~                              -
* Ln ZO 3                                                                                                                                   LA tA O 5                                                                                                                                   W o=
      '               3,                                                                                                                                   2    ~3 0 j   ,
: n. w.4 k
1 l
l
                                  ...l..     .                  l .           I   i .                     .1 . l  .            . I     i .         o LA            O             LA      O         v                O             is to                            O                    La 0     -e                                          e                                                     8 8
OISd                                       GISd                                    GISd

                         &    t al p
I                                          i              4 k p.                 -
                        =
F d
q<                                                                                            .
a
* J        =
1y-                                                 *
         ,            A.            b J.                      .
J
                                   'r
                                    =
                                                              ;L L
9 J ''                    '
l i F                                   a                                               a s           F                         ii                                              1.r  '
J                                      ;
L,,
g             g     -          -
q [.                    -          -
J     -
J y                                     ,
M.
a4       .,          .        ,
g        ,
J       ,l                                     -
gp "p1                                              1 1r                                                                                   9      F l
L
                                                                                                             )p'L EL<     ;                            )    .
L, m
e NF                            '
1          h 1h                                        5 4
o
         -                                           .                                            -                                 _        o          u w          D
                                                                                                                                                       *=4
                                                                                                                                               >=
E O
g W
w
                                             .                                                                                          .      I m
w         u w
                                             .        ,                                            ,                                    .      .E.       m v                                          m                                           U3                                                          Q C                                          o                                           o                                                   e tu s -                                  -
s     -                              -
s     -                                 -
m     on o.
: c.                                         c.,                                         n,                                                z >- ru C Ed E
go t-
                                                                                                                                                 . w m xo 7                                              7                                m wo 7;'                                       I WO          *
: d.                                                                                   ;                             E Do g,    we b
.i                            <
h;      . .                  .              .   ..I...                      ..           . t....         o
              .                    .           .         .              .          .       .          .              .        .          .=
O             Om                       O            m    Om                         O           m       O.e O.
         .                                 w                                      6   **                                     e       .
8                                           0                                             0 OISd                                               GISd                                         GISd

r g r-g g--          g--
g-v
                                                                                               .        O
                                                                              -1
                                               -                        s        .w o-                  -
C.
e
                                                                                                        ~
O         A
                                                                                                          -  N Z       W 44
                                                             .                                                       D D
4 W
                                                                                                    .                   O A        kJ W        W Q.
O O        + Osd
                                                                                                 "        O
                                                                                                          **   (A 00 +
pe Q-   -
E .-e E
t-   00 Z 0-
                                                                                                                 + LaA U1 ZQ W VIO LaJ  O+
m DO Q. Mw e
l..          f ..     . Im   .    . f"      I"         I"^               8 t... . .           . .        .
W
             .a tu m            T              W                 7O        Y O
O                      'O                          O         O        *           **
O.,.          m            Oe            m         **
a ZH H3d 038vn05 QISd

g ..          g..          ,..             ,..           g..             g ..
         .                                                                                                         O IL                                                                                                      .                    .
l e
p '. '%
                                                              =
d W
l L
y
      ?                                                                                                             ee N x          u D
a m
W k
W U
O     W 80    4*
E CPh                                                                                                                        C M*
* O       e  Mtu p                                                                                                               O    W 00 +
L   ,                                                                                                      .'        E >= "
                                                                                                                ,        e t-E
                                                                                                                         >= 09 0
                                                                                                               .             ZH Lb m
                                                                                                                             $8 W      +
2     O A W ==*
e.e e      . . t .. .   . f... .. . f......   . f   ...       t ..       . f......  .
e o            en            tu           n                 v           sn               tm            9* O O         C             8             8               i             e               0             0      *.
          **                       O                             O            O                              O O.
                     .             ==            O.
                                                 .                                             .O.           -e ZH H3d 038VnOS                                           .
GISd I

I o
e
                                                                                                                                                      ~
w                                                                                                                                             O E                                                                                                                                             M
                  =                                .
i E
                -u E2 H
o-                                                                                                                                    O,        I
* a                                                                                                                                  _.
c a.                                                                                                                                  -                                       ,
WEN ER=                                                                                                                                             H
* wei                                                                                                                                             v)
               .a _ -o                                                                                                                                          UJ
                ~gE                                                                                                                                            H o
                  -                                                                                                                                   m
* u                                                                                                                                     .                                     .
                  -                                                                                                                                   -         X                             -
g                                                                                                                                            w                              ,
e H                             r j                                                                                                                                        o        C                             !
5                                                              o         :E-                          !
                                                                                      <L.                                                               :                                     i l                                                                                                                                                      s                          !
                                                                                                                                                           -   >                              r i                                                                                                                                              U   W                              !
            ,                                                                                                                                         CW       LJ                            '
                                                                                                                                                      -o l                                                                        da                                                            ld-r w
* I                                                                             .d                                                       I       T   H               **
            '                                                                                                                                              ~
N                                                       i       .-. --
                                                                                                                                                               ~
ci
                                                                                      %,$                                                          !*          __I              !!
           ,                                                                                                                                       'E          0-.              &
L.            ,             -
{,                                                             4>                                                                       i l
Z l                                                                                 C                                                     l t                                           --
                                                                                                                                                   .c          >
s                                                                                                                                      l =r        Q:*
i                                                                                            -
                                                                                                                                                   -d          v)
           ,                                                                        ,)g                                                            .
a t
r
           !                                                                          V                                                            !
                                                                                                                                                               ,,_J D                             !
l,                                                                                                                                       !"o         O l                                                                                                                                        Io
:                                                                            &                                                                       Q Z                             :
O        Z                             l
                                                                                  ,                                                                   O
* O n
00'0h                          00'0C                                00'0          00'02-                         00'05- 00'09 e                                =
( N I / N I -0 E D I W) N I S)J J.S                                                                                      a w
E E
C Z
U             l t
i I

o e
b                                                         1      0 E      '
1 s2                                                          o     &
                           "~
                              .2 r
u gE-W           -
O
(
                           -{s                                                         o u)
                                                                                      -l     %
E                                                               -
                                                                    %                        W
                                                       }                               o o
C
                                                                                      -J
                                                               <r
                                                                                             &               4 C O 4                         e u.i D rn uJ W
Cx          2 e
                                                                                           ~ 1     -
                                                                                           " 9     8 Ioc      g     &
t   *
                                                                                    \o       7
                                                             -                               ~
i g
                                                 %..                                w
{g       m u_
4                          D d"                   9      o o
O Z
G o      %
                                                                  '                   o
                                                                                        . O     n on.dc 00.gg                         00'O        00'Oi- M                :r g7jko',d,h 31W) N18819 d         '
g a

                                                                                                                                                                                     'E  .
w                                                                                                                                                                                         -
E                                                                                                                                                                                         N
                         ,=                                                                                                                                                                                            i UE                                                                                                                                                             o I
                         "O                                                                                                                                                           _5                                                       '
k                                                                                                                                     . . .
                                                                                                                                                                                        ~
r 5%T                                                                                                                                                                                         v3 OsS                                                                                                                                                                                         w o                            H
                         " E. *                                                                                                                                                         ~
E                                                                                                                                                            ./                           x g                                                                                                               -                                                                         -
P                       -
w o                             C r
5                                                                                             -                        E
                                                                                                                                                     %.                                      u                        u) 2                                   oW                            W
                                                                                                                                                                                      ."o??                           w          =
h                               u                                   ?
                                                                           '                                                                                                                 r                        &
N                                                                                              -                        z          8
                                                                                                                                                             %
* _J         $
8                             o_
                                                                                                                                                                                      -d                                 I z
T                          o                             >
F                                                                                                  R                             x g                         o                             u7 e                                                                                                                                              u_
s                                            l o
N D
                                                                                                                                                                         ~~
                                                                                                                                                                                      ~.                              O
                                                                                              >                                                                                         o C
z C
8                             M
                                                                                                                                                                                           .                          o 00
* h'2 00'*9'1                            00'8                                                                        00'O                 0 0
* B'- 00*91-                                            $
(N1/NI-0831W)NIU81S                                                                                                                                               a w
E i
u

o i
G E
* N l
Eu                                                                H g=                                                        3      I of wzm                                                      -J H
"$7                                                              m La                                                               u.i
[E.E                                                      o      F-u                                                       m
:    x E                                                              ~
a:
F--
o       C r
s
                                                              -  +
u  m ow co      bJ   e
                                                       . o. m_   w    <.
g        n r  F--  g z    a
_J    E 8      o-
                                                       -g         I z
o,-
0:
                                                      "d        t.n C                                               u_
m                          J o       ""3 3-
                                                      .",       o o
z C
8        Q 00*dh o
00 ' 0'E         00*'O   00'02'-   00*0h'- 00'09-               E (NI/NI-0MJIW)NI681S                                     a E
E z
U

j         o.a       .
s                                                                   -
i                                                                                                                                                       s                                       -
                                ^bl
                                       ^
l                      Y                               y- di,=^i<                   . % "!-                       '
i                  -
I l                           f
!       -o.at o,3;              .        .       .  . SG,35 ,                  ,
                                                                                    @AXSTR{SS,   ,
l                 -
O.
t
                      @.' ^.",%",",                                                      y h                                                      ,
t
       -0.3 i
                                                                        .            .         .           s           .      .          .    . i '-           .          .
l       o.2    -
                         -        -       -   - $ 36 i
                                                                 ,     ,           UNAX STRESS ,' _
    !    8-Wk                                                                                                              k                              W^''Y'Y~M"5'^^ '
      -0.2   -
i_,                                                  ,
;          10.
                                                                                                                             ...a                         .     .          .        .
!                                                                                                                                                                                         1a.                ~
j STRAIN GAGE STRESS CALC.
KU0SHENG MT32 10.00 TO 12.00 SECS                                                Figure 3.50 i
l

e     e       e                                               .      .-
4 i
6'J, ,> 6 - r 6                              6                        e-i                     -
1*
                                                                                                                       .                            .a.                                               -
j< =
* m' 1       [
                                                                                                <a                                                   <
,                                        ;  ?                 .                                       l                                           * ,>
t t
                                                                                                                                                    *    ?
                                                                                                                                                         =
: 1.                                                                                                              *
                                                                                                                                                       =
4E
                                        .                                                           .                                                t 6                 .         .
1* q 1             -                                          -                -                                       -             -
r            -
i i    :
                                                                                                                     .          .                 J    L                 .
                                                                                                                                                  -    R:'
                                                                                                                                                =      =-
gb                       .
s 9
m                                                        e                                                       e m                                                        to                                                      m                                                             n w                                               -        W                                               -       w-                                         -          O       C (Y.                                                      CC p-                                                       6-CC
                                                                                                                         >-                                                    W       k W                                                                                                                                                                      un      D 4.D W                                                             D x                                                        X                                                       X A
e 4                                                        C                                                       C
: g.                                                .      a,
                                                                                                                   . E.
g
                                                                                                                                                                                  <C O
m       u
_ .                                                                                              -                              (A      W m
m-                                                       m                                                       .
g                                                        m                                                       m-                                                      .-
g-                                             -
g                                         -             Lt1 gfU ,
m                                                       W
_siin                                                   ~
y HN*~
g d       -
gg p-     O m   g, l
          .          . e       .               .                           e    .      . O            ,                                               e.
                                                                                                                                   ... ..                        e f
: e.                           o
                                                        .           m.                        o
: e.         m.                     o
                                                                                                                                                     .             ma e                                                         o                                           o o e
: e.                                                        e                                                  O.                                     ,
15d3                                                    15d3                                                     I Sd'.A          .
          ..                                                                                                                                                                                              i 8
l
                                                                                                                                                                                                        . 1

k.
                                                                                                 ~
r3 0.47                                        '
ENVELOPESVA,CVAANDMVAfRVTESTCASES l          \
a 3'
        , Accelerometer Al                                                                                                            \,
I                 \                               l
                                                                                                                      /    t     1
                                                                                                                                           \
                                                                                                                                             \
l l
M,                                                                                                                          I            's PlEDMINAk/
a     x N
f                                     i L3                                                                                                                                                      I I              /
J                                                                                               r            ~J                                          \;
d-                                                                                       at                                                                             .
z                                                                                           RI                                   {                        I'!
l  o                                                                                          3 l,
C                                                                                         4'                                                                      J ce                                                                                          I >                                                                 , ;
E'U-                                                                                      ,                                                           A     ii    $,
d O                                                                                       I th
                                                                                                                                                   . "V l,'
O                                                                                      J                                                        l E co <                                                                                                                                      . . L '-                g o                                                              ,                                                                      . /(9 N V, o                                                                      .                                        A         /            Vs                           l
      !b                                                                                                                                                                  ,
10                       2                 $     4            s                $ issli o'                          2          $         4     $      $i5SIl 0' FREQUENCY                       [ CPS           )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                                                                           83       DRMPING = .010 e1CVA                                 3 2 SVA        4            3              MVA Figure 4.1

l.
3.9 7n s
i                                                                             3.l (                               3.56V                                                        .
l                                       ENVELOPE SVA, CVA AND MVA SF,'V TEST                                                               7 ,1 CASES i.v ,c - - /                                      (
l           8 acceler=eter A3
            ~
i n g ,,1 y 5                                              ' {N\                \                l
                                                                  .I                                                                                                    1 l                                                                 l                                                                                       \             l l                                                                l                                                                                                      I o                                                   /                                                                                           \           '
1                                                   PRLIMINA; "
                                                              ,                                                                                               \          .
l~                                                          J                                            $
                                                                                                                                                                \
Io c                                                    .i                                                                                   {
      -1                                                                                                                                                           \
:           o                                        >at                                                                                   l
<z                                                   oc                J*                                                                /,                          \
o                                              v>l               =
l     i                       \
      ~                                                                                                                              ni' E2                                                !                                                                        !T !\ /         .
x-                                                                                                                         i,              i
                                                                                                                                ' V; v           i
      $5-       ,                                     I                                                                                                                  ,
        .tJ                                                                                                                   f                    i                     i u                                                                                                                       :
o Co
                                                                                                                            *I f
N g-                                   1 l'
                                                                                                                 / Nf('                                         f\
j N
                                                                                                                                                              'Y k       '
o o
                                    /
f u,~l         ,
               .c-                                                                                                        .                          .           .
Tfir     i                 $        4      $$i$$110             2
                                                                                                                    $           $      0           s $ i~$ $ 10              2 FREQUENCY               ( CPS                              '
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                                      85                            DRMPING = .010 o1 CVA           a2 syA                +3    MVA Figure 4.2

                                                         ,P1(_(
l       \
                                                       \          \
                                                                    \
l l
                                                                      \
L _ Q o_s;2-ENVELOPESVA,ChAANDMVASRVTEST                                 ASES I
3 048 kAccelerometerA4                          ,
i
                                                                                           \s 0;                                                                                                         l l                                     l                                             \                   \
                                               \                                                \
m                                      IJ               \                   '
                                                                                                  \
e-                                  Ph.lM\ARY                                               \
     -                                      I a
_=
                                           )                                                          F
                                         ,                                                           /
f                                i       9                                             Q           Y \ 'Nlf
     -                              #        e 52g-                         $'       $                                !'                            +j-t
                                  ,                                                                 y 0                                       I
                                                                                          ~
RyJfif Q                    i J\        l11}Y' UW
[]
a    w          -
                                                                           }$
5                                                                                  i $$iAA 10    $      $    0    $    $iAS!! O'                              $     $                              10' FREQUENCY                        { CPS       )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                            86          DAMPING = .010 o1 CVA     A2 syA      .3    MVA l                                                           Figure 4.3 i
i

.                                                                               .]
                                                                                                 \
                                                                        /   3. f.
JA-                                  \
                                                            /                                        \
                                                         /                                             \
                                                       /                                                 \
                                                     /                                    <22              \
                                        .76       /                                                            O ENVELOP [SVA,CVAANDMVASRVTESTCASE,,,Q
                                                         "'                                                      N%
                                                              /. 3 0                                       /                                                                           s 5 Accelerometer A5                    /     .40   _
                                                                                                                               .55 o (                                               *
                                       /
q_
o
                                     /            PRE M NARY
  ,                              tlW o                           A                                                                        /
h4/
                               /
  -@~
z                          l                                                                 [\[(
I
                                                                                                           \
S
  -                        /                                                                         7 bo E*                     !                                                                                   p W                    /
                                                                                                    /            ,I,
_, a-W                  /                                                                 .4 b     f)'i U                                                                                  11                                     al o
C co
                   /                                                                f.'\   i \                         .2v#
m o_          /                                                                     ,
               /                                                          J        /
             /
10             $         $      0    $$i$$!10'                     $             $        A        N   $ i'$ $ 10' FREQUENCY             ( CPS       )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                              87    DAMPING = .010 o1 CVA            a2      SVA        +3   MVA                                                                    >
Figure 4.4

.                                                                              f   s.9  ~\
i    3.4      \
                                                                           /                 \
r$I                          \
                                                                /                                \
                                                              '                                    \
                                                     #@ '                                              \ i.o ENVELOPhSVA,CVAANDMVA                   RV TEST CASES            N    %
                                                                , ,, 3                           .eo Accelerometer A6                         /   j                                                              , , gg o                                           /
                                              /
l
                                           /
w                                    I
} o    ,
t<4ly PREL% NARY
_a                                /
g-
                                   /
l
  ?                              '
i                                                                          h e                      f                                                                 i fN      l!
a-                   l                                                                 f                       f;I
                                                                                         \
                                                                                                       'I l\
b o
                     /                                                                h t
                                                                                                                );
f                                                           ,                                     '
  "5             /
jf
             /
ne$0                   $           $       0    $$i$$310'                    $      $    0        $$i$$ 10           2 FREQUENCY           ( CPS     )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                                 S8      DRMPING = .010 01      CVA            3 2 syg                3   MVA 5'ioure 4.5

r"     ~7 I              \
I                .\ p g_
I                   y ENVELOPE SVA,,'CVA AND MVA SRV TEST CASES
                                                                              ,48            \
a                                                 I                              i
                                                                                              \
   $ Accelerometer A8                              /                                           g l                                               \
l                                                   \
                                                                                                    \
m                                         I                                                                                     ,
l 2-                                      g           PE_IVjlNA RY                                  \
~
                  .                     @                                                              t             j    '
o                                         I                                                             i            ,
_k   ~
I                                                               \
z                                     f                      )         {                                    s N h 8                                    /                                                                      t\           f[    I 5e                                 t k ,I}<       !         i e-                                                                                             ,              y           .
La d-                            I                                                             U
                                                                                                                                 \
<                              I                                                          ''
* A i                                                                       ,2 s
                                                                                      /,,8,                        "          '
Mg                            )                                , f'sA                                  \
N
   =$  '
                          /
l^SR                                          Nj sl 8           /
10         $      $ 0         $      $ i $ $ '10'                     $          $              0      $ s i $ $ '10' FREQUENCY                     ( CPS        1 ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                                90      DAMPING = .010 e1     CVA      a2 SVA     +3           MVA Figure 4.6

I-                                                                         u.s% I
                                                                          /        \ N
                                                                                    \ f.3
(
                                                                      /                              \
                                                                    /                                  \
I43q             /      '
                                                                                                         \
l           \,/ *80                                         \
                                                                                                             \
ENVELOPESVA,CVA AND MVA SRV TEST CASE 3                                        \                   -
I
                                                   . se
                                                                                                                 \
     ~
Accelerometer B9                /             \                                                         \'
                                                                                                                     \
i I
f S                         \  N N
                                    '                                                                                       x j/
l 2-                                               PR    .lMINARY                           .
v/
o                          V
_g                       s/                                                                  /
g-                   /
E) z                          o                                                          .
o                      /                                                             :          1 D                      /$                                                            !*          0 gs                                                                                 /             vi         I tu g-a
                      /
                                                                                                        \
U u
                                                                                  .~       l           v           '   < /\/ \
S          j/                                                           l       l                             'h a~
l                                                          -
l%I                                      Uh\
               ,/                                                                                                              \
g
            /s                           -        ,,       -p 10          $         $     0         $    $i$$Il 0'             i           5             0        $$i$$ 10          2 FREQUENCY           ( CPS    )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                              91    DAMPING = .010 c1     CVA     A2      SVA          +3 MVA Figure 4.7

                                                                           '/ /.5 \        '\
                                                                                     \/3      \
''                                                                     /                        \
rE m~            '                               \
g l        s  , ' ,Bo
                                                                                                      \
                                           /                                                            \
                                         /                                                                '
ENVELOPE SVA, CVA AND MVA SRV TEST CASES
                                       /           s2
                                                                                                           \   s e
Accelerometer Aio. /              [         \                                                        ,,)N,,30
                                     /                                                           4 o                         A
                                  !/                                                            I I
s-                       y1                     PRR    V' NARY
   ~
o
                              /                                                             hi 8                     /                                                               b'; ai i                  i 2
c 5~
                         /                                                                    k,$[  r..e I
f!
   ~                   l                                                                      \n \ Y't              (
. 5,                 I
                                                                                       ?\)     Q fI pj      !
ff $
                   /                                                                                                          ..
ua            /                                                               ,      /\,;[G ('              fj d           i                                                               j'''\l1 Q                       1]h "I~ '                                                             .\     ^ lt\hg /l
             /            _
_V                                      ,p 8 '
17                                     -                        -
10-            2          3   4       5  678910   1 2          $      0      s      A i$s!!O    2 FREQUENCY          [ CPS         )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                           92      DAMPING = .010 e2   CVA          a2 SVA          4 3     MVA Figure 4.8

J     3 L.os n.I I%j-mj/
                                                   /                            \
                                                                                   \
                                             %[f.
X-Aq f              k(              s.
s~     ,1
                                                                                                                ~
f                     .,                 1 ENVELOPE SVA,             VA AND MVA SRV TEST C                  ES
                            , i 5:
o                                    ,
11 7 Acclerometer A14                                                                                                ,l o                             j
                             /
8
                           /                  %_ _1V. ,my f
                        -l                                                                       A I\f\    \
%                     :/                                                                        i
- 92                                                                                                            h 2
                     /         i                                                                iii             F 5!                 /          5                                                               l
(?     (i 55 to g
                 /                                                                      r j} f <        (    0c y
a u              /                                                                     M, ,\ J ,/ _!Mi              qi 9                                                                    /s           A       U/! N iP-            ,]
"8 l        /                                                      2 ll  \ N    ,    "  'h. r;/    l  J '5 o-
           /                                                     ,o       ''n!       .
i l                                     /              jj jh'M \^l''             \j o                                        /
R v/ /
2 10'           $       $      0       $ $ i 5 $ '10'                5             5        U    $  $ i $.$ 10 FREQUENCY          ( CPS          J ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                         96       DRMPING = .010 e!   CVA       a2 SVA              ., 3 MVA Figure 4.9

v j'~ ~ ~\
                                                           \
                                          /                         ~\                                           .
ENVELOPESVA,CVAANDMVASRVTEqTCASES o    Accelerometer A16                                                     7 6'
d                                                                              j                        +
l i                                      \
  ~
ll             papy) py                                        \        '7, j
                             ^l                                                                         k
  %                                                                     /                               y 7_
z                                            N                                     O E
gg tu d-I                                               ,
                                                                                 , h\!
t V     ly
[^\l                .!
N                                 i                                      l                    l         N' u                               S                                       /                  i,
(
E =. ,
i                     '
                                          /
r\l                  /g N                l A .&j tj v
3 0
0-    .    'e
                    /         [                        4i
        'I O         $     $      0     $  $i$$h0        2
                                                                    $        3     0     $      $ i $ 510      2 FRECUENCY           ( CPS    )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                    98     DAMPING = .010 e1      CVA    3 2 SVA        +3   MVA Figure 4.10

1 4
39 af '   s
                                                                        /          \
                                                                      /               \
j                     i .B ENVELOPESVA,CVAANDMVA(RVTE                                         SES            .9 j .'s /                       '3          '%
Accelerometer A17                              / .yg                                        f .55          s c                                                 r                                                                 s
                                                                                                                            \
I xl N~
IA                                             I 5-                                            I
  -                                                IP EUMINARY                                                               (g
                                                 '                                                                       \         N 4                                                                                                 l z                                                                                                      /
e
  ~
s/              r                                            l 9'V 2
i 8                                              'l f*                                      f                                                           -
bo                                                                                               i         l J                                     /                                                        /           i U                                                                                                                i u                                  /                                                         f I
3 f          i o                                                                                          '
cc m
                                   /                                                                A
: s. i I\
                                                                                                           \         ' h,        s
                                                                                                  / V ;J '
                                                                                                                                 ' fo:
                                 /                                                                                    if *g 0_
                               /                                          /                      l                                 J\
                           )                                                        '
j %,Y
     .o
     ~ %"
                                      ^                           J\J                   ,
I l 0'       $      $      0     $ $ i $ $ '10'                       $            $           0    $ 5 i'$ $ 10' FREOUENCY                 ( CP5        )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                            99       DAMPING = .010 o1 CVA        a2 syA           + 3 MVA Figure 4.11

r ' ''4 s  i.
                                                                . ''S
                                                            /
Z.s2
                                                        /                   'x
                                                                                \
                                               .x                                 y                   -
ENVELOPE SVA, CV,A 'AND MVA SRV TEST CASg S Accelerometer Als
                                         '''(( '"                                                 g O                                   /                                                   %   .
r' e
                               =
5-                         f/
-                           @                                                                 l q-                                      PRELIMINARY
_,. o                       /
5                             E'                                                        l h8                        [                                                               d 'Iy f[i u; g-                                                                              I' h              7                                    . . _x
                                                              \ , ,l/
VY I'
      .. ,    ~
Y                      r;
   =., 9/
10         i     $      4   $$i56!10'                      i       $   0  $6i$$ 10         2 FREQUENCY           ( CPS       )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                100         ORMPING = .010 0 1 CVA         a2 gyg.      +3 MVA Figure 4.12

M
                                                                                \
iir I
[                  I .4
                                                                            .,\ .                        s            .3 N
ENVELOPE SVA, CVA AND MV4 SRV TEST CAS                                                         .2.
                                                         .2.s /                                    .s 7           ~                                                            ~
j%
0 Accelerometer A19         /        .,-
                                                                                                                        ,gg           _.
m j.1 I
n                    j                                                                      n b s-                    p       4            %JMINAh                             I
                                                                                    -             4 i
  -                     s                                                                          \
                      */
to i             ;
                                                                                                         ,                           t
  ^?                                                                      f                A'                     [           )    I c a-
                    /     s c r                                          I 1\
v l
                                                                                       \i \ .
                                                                                              \         )
L          ,
j
                                                                                                                              ~
e r
                                               '                        l\                     'V 1
Il z                                       /                    /\
l\ j 28                                     l       ,
                                                   \,q            y                                                  ,
w            l                   i
* a
                                                                                                                   .-     (\o\m
    >                         J                                                                 hj Wo          //                                                                               fy%p                                  n
                                                                                       ' V
          'l                                                            dh                              i 10      i          $    4    $    $ i $ 6110'                     i          i           4            $       s i $ $ 10         2 FREQUENCY             [ CPS           }
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 101                                D MiP I N G =                    .010 i
l       0 1 CVA     a2 syA           4 3 MVA Figure 4.13 i
r

f                   67%
3 1      N f.Y2.            .mx ENVELOPEf i9[SVA,CVAANDMVASVTESTC i
2.s                               i i
1 N
o accelerometer A20        [/ '                ,,
                                                               ^
                                                                                                 ,[        ~
                                       /                                        t m                              /
f          PREYNMY t.O                        I                                                                       h
    ~
ly                                                                .        Al 8                           fy                                                       a n  $
f
    ;                          / n                                                       j.     [
gg                                                                              nl i, f/.
                                                                                             )
w a-                                                            j\            I     j \j u
d                          ,
                                                 \
I\         ,/      j         !
                                                                  /                                          .
    "~
j L h yy% N]$h 8
            '10       $       $     0    $ $ i $ $ '10'                $          $       0  $  $ i $ $ '10' FREQUENCY          ( CPS       )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 102                      DRMPING = .010 0 1 CVA     a2 syA         ,3  MVA Figure 4.14
                                                                                                               . . . ~

                                                           .lT5
                                                                                ~
                                                                        . Ii b
                                                         '           i                                                   '
ENVELOPESVA,gAANDMyASRVTESTCASES a                                        p . I 2. t                   . IIS Accelerometer A22           M5         .m    1                     '' 7
    *l                             l                                              \
    -                            l                                                    \
b-                                Ellb. 1Qy f
                              -l                                           b            \
o                                                                        l t[
Y.                          /
h\
l          \rl                    \
z                                       \                                                           }
SE3 W                  f
                           .)
l l\        \
                                                                                     \      t
                                                                                              \.
G      y
                                                                                                          \
I   bV 8                '        /                                           !.            \
Ll<:\
                                                                                                    )l O l -
nd i /                  '                i y u
a~                                                                j                             ;
9            /                                                 /                  ;
C                                                            f           f
                                                                                  ,"J l                --
              }
oc     D                                  ;
o   r                              -
l 10         $      $    0     $  $ i $ $ '10'             $              $         0     $ $ i $ $Il0            2 FREQUENCY          [ CPS          )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL                  10 L1     DAMPING = .010 e1 CVA       3 2 SVA      +3 MVA Figure 4.15

o.9T k         <s
(),50
                                                  /           s\ / av5Q.co t
ENVELOPEVA,CVAANDMVA{RVTg_TgS                           _,
W Accelerometer A24
                                                      .22s g'
s
   .                                         /                                            \
O                                                                                                               i
                                            /                                               \
                                                                                              \
l e                                      /                                                        s
  #                                                 P r.M NAY
                                       /                                                            s s                                                                  \
O                                #                                                                      N
: s.                                                                                                      '
3                             nl J
s 5                                /            g 5:
l}                                                                        \
we W
l#                                                     /N lJ  r j                                                                            i O                                                                                          \
  =
                          /j 1
l
                                                                              ,E
                                                                                 /
                                                                                            \r
                                                                                                     \
p\
                      /      j                                              lll Y'       '\ efhghL 8,   s
           /                         -
i                                                      i
     ~
10                   $       4          $$i$$!!0     2
                                                                                   $       4      $$i$$ 10          2 FREQUENCY      ( CPS          )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 106                             DAMPING = .010 e!      CVA     a2 syA               a 3     MVA Figure 4.16

o.36 f ~ 'n .
p               u.v, o.as     g f
o.s                              y ENVELOPE SVA, CVA AND MVA SR' TEST CASES \
a                                             ! ..iis                        \,3 q Accelerometer A25                       {          \                          4 l                          \,          \
                                                                                         \
8s                                       l e                                           -
                                                    , rem gy                               \
  -                                          I
                                                                                             \
     =
  - 9_,                                    J                                                   \
     ~
z                                      [          i
                                                                                                 \
s
  -                                   si       e x
C :r 3r         M                                  k I#             L
  $ 9_
o                           r%/
                                   /                                      a./_/
I d                            ,             /                                                )
E 2                        /
     &                   /                                                            n
                     /                                                               l l-
                                                                                                   ~
c:
ow p-
                                                       /\m.Q& /
N \]B                 I 10         $      $    0     $   $i$$Il 0'                   $     $    0    $       $ i $ $ 10' FREQUENCY              ( CPS      '
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 107                          DAMPING = .010 e1    CVA    3 2 SVA       .3   MVA Figure 4.17

0.81
[~on     %     o.a               o.u
                                        /                      3 4--
                                  /                                     ,,,,          N 0''
                            /                                  om
                        !                                ....                                 \o.i g 4I              E SVA, CVA AND MVA SRV TEST CASES
                                                                                   ^V                  -
ENVEL o       /
9 Aj:celerometer A26 i
m
                                                                                              \
o
  ? .9                                                                                          s AREj.jy;';\Agi-                              1
   ~8'                                                                                    ,
o J-           y                                                                       1
   -    !        $                                                                       !\
z 38                                                                /                  i I
  - [2-                                               /,
x w                                         /                                        b'l u8
                                                                               */i D
_                                                    i
   %                           L A W Ny
          /
t io       i      $    4   $    $ i $ 6110 2
2         $      0   $SiA6 10        2 FREQUENCY          ( CPS      )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 108                      DAMPING = .010 I
e! CVA        a2 SVA      +3    MVA Figure 4.18

                                                    ~
0.36 r-
                                                                    \.32L ps/                        \
o.3         g
                                                                              \
                                             / uns                                                   '
ENVELOPE SVA, Cy     AND   VA      V TEST      SES \*Ss 8 Accelerometer A27 rd                                            s         '
                                       +                                                 \
                                                                                           \
                                     /
  ?
       ._                                                                                      \
7                                      PJ
                                ,           Wl.Il4lNJRY
  -8                          /
o es-EI 8-                 &
is g                /
                       /
                               #r                                                  q"(       t U
do             /                                             /   .
b~          /                                             [ Id                If         l.})
n   '
h3 8V                                                         i 10        i       $   4   $    $i$$110                        5      0 $$i$$ 10          2 FREQUENCY          ( CPS       )
ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 109                    DAMPING = .010 -
l o1    CVA    3 2 SVA     ,3    MVA i                                             Figure 4.19

W-0.%
y-4
                                                     /         ''' \e:K
                                              ..,4 /                      *t x
T-ENVELOPESVA,CV$ANDMVASVTES                   CASES s..,3                           .
s f     '"
                                                                                     >t A S Accelerometer A28                                                  o.1                    N y                                      3.y j                                    ,
    =
j
                                /
~
 'a a-                        l 2                          ,              PREwgggy
 -s                   9 s/
a u-                                                                                   lI
                      /           &                                                     !
z                              so ES                           #                                                        I"
                    /
 + '-                                                                                  l cc                                                                                    >
x                                                                                     i 1J                                                                                    $    t,
_a US                                                                                 .'-
A h> cs-                                                    ,     n   ile,z'y                      ...
                                              %jA'' $8nn               '"' ,.
o
            /
             /
                                       /                                                                  ,
        . .       /
k   V 10          $      $    4   $$i$$110           2 i       $      4   $$i$$ 10' FREQUENCY           ' CPS     1 ENVELOPE FOR CHANNEL 110                    DAMPING = .010 oI      CVA    a2   SVA     +3   MVA Figure 4.20

1
* RESPONSC SPECTRA COMPARISON LEGEND I.-
   '                                                                                              . ___.s. sui.r                      snv                                                                         . _ _ . .
                                                                   ..e                                                                              .
MUO M NG SRV
                                                                                     ..........SVR COLD
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .  .._           ..         _.      _                 , , . _ _ _ . .,m 3.5                 _.
s.
r.
: t.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            .____._ _ _ __
    ,6                                                                                                                                                                                                                          .      .. _    _ _ _._.,                  _.    .._.
s.. .                                                                                    ..                      .
                                                                          -                   =                         .__          .       _ _ _ _ . .
n
              +
              ~
t:       -
e      a.s.  .      . . . _ _. . . _ _ _.__. _..._..
c                                                           ,
i                             .                             e
  .a a.. .  .._      ---
3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .
                                 ~
J'..
d 9-
                                                                    ,,,_       . . _. . . . _                         _.._.._              .____. _.           ..                ..._.           a_                       . _ . .        . . . ...        .
3.,.
d??
* l
                                                                                                      .                                      _: _ . . . .__ ...____ .                      . _   .            ._                    ..__                       (_.____  _  r,
[_.     .
t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             \ s --\
:t   .
e       ._   .     .               .f-_
w\
p' -                                                                                                                                                                                                          ;_./
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                =" gseasTe#(Q....                                            ieb v                            . A            /
                                                                                                                                                                                                    -~'
to
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    .- ..             .f                                      -n,.. . .,.s.s n.g                                                             8 FRCOUCNCY ICPSI 9
t-                                                                                                                                                                                                        R 12E,                        GG.N S Accelewo ,cie- Na RCCELEROMETER ENVELOP:
T VS. KSHG NODE 282 CONTNMT EL-28.08 HOR [Z Figure 4.21                             VS. G..G. NODE 277 CONTNMT EL109.]7 HOR [Z
                                                                                                .                                                                                                                                                                                                                              I

I RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPARISON                                                                                                        s LEGEND o.se                                                        ~                                                                        '                                                                                   "~
                                                    .G. GULr SRy ROO5HCler'  . ?Jtv
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ~~    '
O.1%                                                                                                                               '                            -
                                       ..........SVR COLD                                                                                      i
(
g, gg .                  -
                                                        -1'                       .                                             .           f I F-        -
I
              .. es .     -       -                               -          -
                                                                                                                            ,l                                                                                             --    - - ~ ~ -
I
          ,~  0. en .     - - . - -                                                                                                    I                              -  --         -                                  -
h                                                                                              l--                                                -
9 j_           .
g .. ,, .         .                                                                            L     .
j             . ..           ..
1                  . - - -_
l c
                                                                       ,                              i
                                                                                                                   \                                                     ;[.                                    I E;  .. w .              -
il ,                             p I
                                                                                                                                                                    - (-
                                                                                                                                                                            -     -                             I-                    -.
7 h   ..,s .                .
                                                                                                                        /                                .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  \.               ..
O. JW .                                               !                             'l             ~     '        --                                                -
piy           *        -'----            -
f                                                                                                                I p' g g .     ..                                                              .       r- "                      ._ _ .                         _           __
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -g
: 0. le .                    l                  - -'                                                               - ~ ~ -                        =         "                 -                   -\                 - ~ ~ -
                                                                                               !-                           cms +
                                                                                                                                      .,              f..
                                                                                                                                                                                                             ./.f.'.W.
j       ..       -     - -
                                                                                                                            /_____,
: 0. 8                                            1                                                  10                                                                              100 TRCOUCPCY I CP'.,8 ACCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                    A125 &G.N 5 A cc.elevomeiew AY V':. . I.511G HODE 282 CONTNMT EL-28.08 VERT Figure 4.22                            VS. G.G. NODE 277 CONTNMT ELi09.I7 VERT
: r.                                                            .
 ?
 'Y RESPONSE SPECTRR COMPARISON                                                                       .
o.e .                 .                                             -                                                     ,.
"-                                                        LEGEND G. GULT $NV                                                                             q=,                                                                   ~~
8'                                               kUDSHCNC. SRV                                                 l
                                          ..........SVR cnLD                                                                                                                                                           .
e.e .                                        -
I O
l J                                                     .        . . _.
                  =                                                                                                                                      f t''                     -
7 5                                                                                                              -
L
                                                                                                                                    ] /..
l f                                                                                                                                                           t s                                                                                                                                                          I
:-            ;2 .., .  ...             .           .         .                                                                                     ,.                      .,.
                                                                                                                                                   .[                                           j
 't
                                                                                                                                      \.I                                                    -
l                                [                      h i                      e                              d
                                                                                                                                                    ]
k            \    !
                                                                                                                                                                               \                      A'oeb.4d, g::
i.
                                                                                                                      /
                                                                                                                        /--.
c69s gJ.
                                                                                                                                                                  \
w
                                                                                                                                                                                          .f)                            1 l('*               0.l.       -                   --     - - -          - -<     -   - - -   - - - - - - - - -
r                                                  h-, ,
* I             - *.
s         - - - -
                                                                                    ,                     7 i                                                        ,.-
yM%            ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                 '      .w, ._           --..
J        /                                              ,
y                                      ......              -.
                                                                                                                   '-            -          ~
0.0                                                                    ,                                                                                                      ,
  ,                       0.8                                                               8                                                  80                                                gre FRCOUCNCT ICPSI RCCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                         A14.A15 C3Ex.N5 Ac.celevomdev API
(               Figure 4.23 vs. KSHG NODE 329 CONTNMT EL169.30 HORIZ v5. G.G. Nr.lDE 709 CONINMT EL300.06 HORIZ
-l
     }                                                                                                                                                                                                 .                               .I
  .y c.

 'I-
        -n
     ,e 1-RESPONSE SPECTRR COMPARISON                                                                                                                                 .
o sn                                                         .                                     .                                                                                       ,..                                      ,     .    .... . .                   ,         -
F*.
LEGEND
                          , , ,                                             . c. cut.r av                                                              ,
r,-          .
  ".                                                                             tUOSHtNG SRV                                                         j
                                                 ..........SVR COLD l                         p.tn                                                                                        -      -      --                                                   -- -           -             -                                       L           - -- -                        ---
j i
i                                                                                         f                       -7
: 0. '% .            -                                -     ---*.-                        -                                                                        ~~~     - - --                                                                          - - - - - '~ ~~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           }
I I                                                                                                                                                                                          '~I                                       ,
I
                      *p  o. 3n .. . . . _ . . .                            .       ..                                         _
i I.                  Op 1
t
  !                   i   p, ,.g .  . _ . . . . .                      ..         . . .        . --       .                .
p
_     ..         5/.          .
                                                                                                                                                                                                  ..L     . .                 .
_. _\ . . . .. . . . ..
l i
_q nl                              i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       \
y   O. .*0 - ' - - - - -                                                                                              1                                                                                      l I
.i i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      )1                                                                    I l ._
l q .-
j                                                                                                   4'            .
g, go _
                                                                                                                                  ..f.. . .                  .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ... ..L            .             _ . . ,     y. . .
($1%%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~
, g,                     o,e9               . . . . . .~.           -.                   .       .          .. .. =_-                  _... - . ..                  .       .  --
g
                                                                                                                                                                                                  /              p *.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ~   ~~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ..(Yw        '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ;.1             .
a )..                  /                                                          *
    ~
g                                                 -
0.8                                                                      8                                                               10                                                                                    300 ratoutscr icesi ACCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                                          R43, A45 G.CxN.5 Accdo uk                                                                                                   A R V .. F5HG NODE 80 DRYWELL EL-14.83 VERT Figure 4.24                                           VS. G.G. NODE 48 DRYHELL EL120.83 VERT e

i                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .
RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPARISON s.o                        . - .                          - - - - - - -                     -                                                              -                                        -                                              - - -                  **    -
LEGEND G. GULF SRV 35                                                                                                             ~~~               '~       ~'
                                                                                                                                                                                                  , ' ~ ~ ~ ~~~
                                                                                                                                                                             '~'~
KU0STNG SRV
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ' - '    ~ ''                              ~ ~ ~ ~                   ~
                                                       . . . . . . . . . . S v n cot.o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      /
t                   \
3.._
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          . . - - -q---... --.c. _ _ . - _ . .
i    ll                                                                                                               ,_        l 2,g .                                         .         . . . _. . . .   ..      -  -      _                               .._....                     .._                     ._. . _ _ .
__F.__.
T
                        ?                                                                                                       ,
t i
e
                        ~    g. ..                            .             ..       . . . ._ - . ..__..         _    .           .              ..  ..         ._. . _..                            .                 . . . . ..
I                                     \
b A
M,                                                                                                                                                                                                    (-
                   . t                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      I
                              ,,g.    . _ _ __. .__ _ _ _                                     . _.._.___                                . . . .     . . .     . . _.       .       ,       _ . _ . .      ___.          .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              . ___._                   ..         _      ._._L.                 . . __
g--- w           -
J                                                       \
t
                           -e.o.                         -> -                .             .      --                        - -       -.--- ----             -           -
                                                                                                                                                                                             -l-                                    -     - - .~ . -         -~-         ---           .-      . _ _ .
I r-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     \
o,g .
[.'.
_                                                   M                          *.                                  v
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           /YaozUN_k:-
tg
                                                    ._ _      . . . . . .           ._.. _ . .       ..      __. . . .                 .. ..-._. __._ ._                                           ..                                          .                 _      r                            _
bD IO                                        ,      s             g ,
                                                                                                                                                    ,/ N
_ . .Y                                                        ' ~ -
n.e                                                                                    ,
                                                                                                                                                                     ~ '
: o. :
recoucuer ices
                                                                                                                                                                                   .,so W
* ACCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                                                   A44,R46                                         GGNS AcMo Al7 Al8 VS. KSMG NODE 80 DRYWELL EL-14.83 HORIZ Figure 4.25                                            VS. G.G., NODE 48 DRYH, ELL EL120.83 HORIZ

                       .t RESPONSE SPECThR COMPARISON i..-                                                                      .
:                       , LEGEND                                                              '
                                                                                                         .     ...s.      c ut.r sa v                                                                                                                                         [
kuoSTNr. SRV
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              . g..                                        g.._.                     . _ _ .               ._
                                                                                            . . . . . . . . . . s wa cm.o
(,                  j
                                                                                                                      .                                                                                                                                               1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          >        t i          !
y..         _      _.__            _              _
en                                                                                                                                                                              t u         _
1 La
                                          -                                                                                                                                                                           ._)
m E
c                                                                                                                                                                         j
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              \                                                '
                                                ....    . _ . . _ _ . .                               .       ..  .i. . __.           .      _..                   ._ .                     . . . -      .   ..l...           ._        . _ _ .        ._. . .__..                        .
l                            .
M                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        '
                                                ....   .                                 . . . _...._....._.___              . . __.       _. . . _ . . .                _   ..    . _ . ...     .._. _L__.                  ..                    .
i 1
I
                                              '                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         i
                                                                                                                                                                                          .    ._ _...       -b_J                                 _ . . .q... _ __ __1_
3                                                                                                                                                                                                              S                                            \
J   _                                                                  -.                                      %
e.a .   - -.- - ..                              .-                                                      - - - - --- ---
                                                                                                                                                                                          -- --( (- ---                        _.. - _ _ -..              .      ..
E       -
y J                                                                                                                     .kM N j                                                                         .-       .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .   ,/
racoutwcricesI, Ms M'''
RCCELER0 METER ENVELOP:                                                                     R54, RSS, R57. R58 G.G. N 5 A cuba-c+e-Figure 4.26                                                        VS. KSHG NODE 68 DRYWELL CL 17.00 HORIZ                                                                                                                                                                  A19 VS. G.G. NODE 30 DRYHELL ell 47.58 HORIZ                                                                                                                                               .

 'i I
RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPARISON                                                                                                 '
                                                                        . 0.w -                                                                                                                                                                               ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ,-_.,~                                                                  ,                 . . .
LEGEND                                                                             I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      \
o.es                                                                      .G. GULT SRv                               .
i     i l
4U05 M SRV                                                            j
                                                                                               ..........$1R COLD
: 0. te ,  -                                                                                                                                                         -
j                                   ,.
g- *                                 ,-
r
: e. n .                                                                                                                                         .                   .,          p   -
r                                 i                       k.
i                               L,          f                                  t o.m .     . - . . . . .
5 "'                                                                         .
I g                                                                                                                                                                         't                                     i                               i C      o. .n .          -    --                                                -       -              -
y                         t   I                         .                                     . . .                       - . . . i '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ~~
i                                                              I s
f      0.N <                    .
i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 )                                     \
l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              /
: 0. 8 s .   - - - -                    --                             --                             --               -              --                                          --                                      .. . .     -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   .\                      . - ..
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      )                                                                                                       -
e            0. se -                                                             --         -   --        -      --        - - -                 --   -                       - - - - - - - - -                   -.           ...- . .-...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      \
ase2                                     .r                                tya (., . .                    ..
: 0. e9 -    - - -                                                                                                                                                                                                        "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             . - . ,= ,
                                                                                                 -                                                          --              -    --     -- -      - - - -        ~              - - ----
r-      -                 -.
i                                                                                                                                                                                                     -_-.- ..   .
y
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ,             ..-                                    -.               -u.
0.8                                                                                               I                                                  to                                                                  g{o FRC01.EPCT ICPSI RCCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                                 A53,RS6                      &G.NS Au.ciev mehew R Lo VS. KSHG NODE 68 DRYWELL EL 17.00 VERT Figure 4.27 VS..G.G. NODE 30 DRYHELL EL147.58 VERT

                   ;.k
                                                                                                                                              , , '                                                                                 u.                ..
u, .:    : .:w.
                                                        .                                                                                                                                             ..e
                                                                                                                                                                 .<.-                 .r .~                            ,                        .
                                                                                          . waa .u.
                  . ., . g .
tv                                                                                                                            .
                   'y*
n,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .
a
              -  u;.]
g .1 hjk                                                                                                                                                                                                            RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPAR['.~ ON                                                                                                                      .,
1 t's
: g. '             ,
e.ee                     ..                   .         ..
y
                 . .;b                                                                                                                                                                         LEGEND                                                                                                                   y I,.i .j g.
                                                                                                                                                                                                     .o. ca.r sRv
'                                                                                                                                                 a.s*
_I                                   l 3/k                                                                                                                                o.se .   -
IL00SHCNG SRV
                                                                                                                                                                             . . . . . . . . . . syn cow                                                                 r h                                 "       '                              -    ~~           '-              ""~ ~ '
Eg.c7.. '
i 7                                                                                    ,
                          . y.
I                                                                                                                         - - - -    -
                          .g   .                                                                                                                                                               - - -.                                      --
                  .y                                                                                                                               o.es .     . - - .
r    -
1 s..r .n.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      )                              i
                    ..6                                                                                                                            o, ee .                            .-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ..                   ...                             ..4                    . -.                       . . . .               ..   .    ,-.         . - . _ . . .
               . . k,.
Y.%.'.'       y,'                                                                                                                -
I t
i                                                                                                                             --                                        .   -- . .-- .                        . . . --
p...f..: .                                                                                                                       a o.n .       . . - -                .....e. - . .-.              .....                 . .
l1
             ,a?,r q .
               ,r   .s.-    '
o                                              .                                                                                                                             ' " -'                    ' ' -        '-        ''-~--               - ' ' ' -
                                                                                                                                                                                          .p- . . . l.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -   ' - ~ -
g o.w .                                                                                                                  r
(; g' n:. f is E
n                                                - ..                 -.
L             T- m. ~ .        ...                            -.
M,.,'                                                                                                                 y n,as     . _ . . .
t
{
I..2..                             .
I                                                                                            .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              \                                                        _ _
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               .             ...     .                                          3; E,                                                                                                                      o,; .
s%&
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      \                 f a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,                      1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               .kh 1.
                          .:.                                                                                                                       o, g g .                    .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .                                           . ._4.
H 3-                ___,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ,            . m lr. '
* h     i' l
N g
Lj  .n   .                     ._
aws %
4.*                                                                                                                                                                           .--
e, g e . - . . . . <                        .-
                   .;                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 e 8__i L m                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   %* \ ..                                                                 ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      % .:_N 4.*                                                                                                                                                                                                                 - - . . . ..-.-            -.-          ...                          .~                  ,.          ..
                   ''.':*',                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   F
* 1        .
e,es ._.                               .
                        *s.::
                          ..                                                                                                                                                                              l                                                                                                         '
                         .e                                                                                                                                                                                                                        "          -. ..   ..    '-        .          ..**.*
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         -   m-  a                       -
                        ).".
                           $,'* E i
0.98                                                                          .
e no                                                                                        slo o.s                                                                                             FREOUENCY sCPSI
                       ,g7.         *t.
R59, R62 G&N5 Rue 6mh, A-2'l
              '5-l                                                                                                                                                                                     RCCELEROMETER ENVELOP:
j                                                                                                                                                                            VS. KSHG NODE 31 DRYNELL EL 49.25 VERT V5. G.G. NDDp.8 DRYWELL EL182.17 VERT
                                                                                                                                                                                  ~
                          .;, -                                                                                                                      nam 4.28

I                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              -
l RESPONSE SPECTRA COMPARISON a,                                                               ..                         _.              ..            .                                                                                                                                                                                 ..        ..            .-.              . . . _ . ___ .
F
                                                                ~
j                                                                                                               LEGEND
: e. g, .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             7 -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               -7 . . - --
l       ',;                                                                                                                      g gg gy                                                               .                                               .                                                                     .
1      .
       ;-                                                                                                                        nuosic s sav                                                                                                                                                                                             [
             ;.                                                                                    .........3,,
n.
g                                                                                         . . _ . _ . . .    . . . . .. . .__. . ..            .....
1
                                                                          .. .          _ . . . . __. .. _ . .                             _. . . ....           . . . . . . .      . . . .           .     . _               -     ..                 .                                                           .   ._a__..... . -. . _
         .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              t
                                                                          ,,,,.     . . .          ~           .     .        .               .                          ..             . . .__                 ....                                                                             . . . .                     _..           . _    -..
: x.                                                          ,;;                                    e.
r      -
1
                                                                          . 35     . . . ~ . , ..                       _._      .                        .   .               ..             .  . _ .            .                      .                                                                                  . . .   ...       ._    ..   .     .. . . .
s
         ..                                                       .E     ..,..     ._
i 1                  .
y                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ;
1                                          i j
    . :.                                                                 .. n -   --                               -                  -                         -                     ---       -                      -             -->         --                                                                       - - -       -            -                .-
L.
3-  .
L
   }                .                                                    , . , .  ..                                    ._...           '.                                   ,.,.
                                                                                                                                                                                                  ..                          .-    . :             .    . . .                         1. . .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ]--...                    ..    .
_ _. } ._
r                                                   .
4                                                                   ..,,.
J_
j-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          )
e..                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                [
W l.~-
                                                                      ~ ,qgg .                                                                                                                                           $-_..
J
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     =
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 . Ad                               *
                                                                                                                                                                                                          .-._-.I f e                                                                                                                                                                                                                     .                   =,                                                                                     .._. . .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                               ~
45 kk\ %                                                                                                                   %
  #J                                                                                                                                                                                                           --
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ) - >(
:3
                                                                         .. e, -                          --                               --    --                    - - - -                                                                    ^---"              ---'                                                                  ' -
w l [                          /:                                                                                                                         '. ...            .
: 0. 8                                                                          8                                                                  10                                                                                                                        ld0 rREOUENCY ICP$1 l'
::r-                                                                                                                          ACCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                                              872,R73,A75,A76                                                                                                                    f.x.(= N 5
  ?.                                                                                                                            VS. KSHG NODE 82 PEDESTAL EL-9.33 HORIZ B CC*b                                                                                                                                                                                                   ^
g.
Figure 4.29                                             VS. G.G. NODE 47 PEDESTRL EL121.42 HORIZ                                                                                                                                                                                                                             l j
6" 4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      . . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _                                                               ~

I
                                                                                                                                                                    /
     .                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              t
  .                                                                                                                              -              RES,FONSE SPECTRA COMPfiRISON o.se                   - - . - . .                                                         ---            .                                              -                                                                                                                                     -- -
LCGCND                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    \
: c. ,                     ..                        ._..                             .G. GULF SRy                                              _.            ..          ..
KU056 SRV                                                                               i 4
                                                ..........svn ca.o                                                                                                                                       !  l                                                                                                                       !
                         '"                                                                                                                                    '          '     ~~' -
                                                                                                                                                                                                   'T
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~'                                       '           '' -~ "     ~~                        ' " " ~             ~
                         .. n .     . . _ . . . _ .. . _ _.. ._.                                                             ._.                  _ _ . . _           . . . _       ...       .
                                                                                                                                                                                                     ,        _             .i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           \
9 o
                   .E                                            .                                                                                                                                 i              I  .
(
                   - .. n _                                                                                                                                                                        '
                                                                                                                                             '                                                                       \
l                                               I                                                     '
                                                                                                                                                                                                 ,                          ]
O.Je :                                                                            -    --      --    --    --     -                 --                                  -~-                 '-- ---~                - -        -- - '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                \                                                        /
j                                                                         -
_j.. ..._.                 _ _ _ . . . . .
b le. W.
                        ..,0      . . . .              .                                               ..         .                     -.. _ ..                 . . _ _ .
J'._ .                                        --                  ._
Ll                 .
(
_._.q... _.._j,._.
3
                                                                                                                                                                 -j                                                                 .....    ....    .    .* 7                                  , ' , .__-
                        ..ee                         ....                                              ..       ..        .                                                                 .              .
i racoucnersced                                                    hgs Yg                                    'i' RCCELEROMETER ENVELOP:                                                                                      R71,R74                                  M NS h e\evamehu M 6 VS. KSHG NODE 82 PEDESTAL EL-9.33 VERT Figure 4.30                                                                        VS. G.G. NODE 47 PEDESTAL EL121.42 VERT C

f
:r l-
[(                          __
l.
                                                                                    ,s
                                                                                            ._ _-- d _ - - _ __ _ - -
i
                                                                                                     ~~
                                                                                                           'so,.'          -
                                                                                                                                                      = - -
                                                                       ./ , -                                            3Co                                                         .
f                            -
                                        /
so+
I                         -
                                                                                                                                                         \-so, l                                p
                                                                                                                                  ._ ._ -g
                                     /                                                                                                                 N g'   C._ON_ TAI.N.. .M.E_N_T 29s     .         -
l                                                     a
                                                                                             .. C.%-
4
                                                                                               ,/              ]
r-wl
                                                                                   ..,+
      -(     R E ACTO R.                       - i
                                                                       ~.,.          %
                                                                                                                                          . 8 ass i
Sz      e . .:....
1 SHIE LD        -
                                                                                                                         .w                                        193 r9            -
4 D RY W E L L-----                                                                                           39                    3
* 29' I
L                                                             '                      '
4         . 42 L.,'                                                  ,  (m,/
: PEDESTAL                                               ;x 3       i ih s
4 ,
237
                                                              ~
7g h       ,
w,,.:a'                  -
s          f
                                                                             ,           a                          to                -
a
                                                                                              ..I l                                                                       Y
_                      i                                                                                                                                                        -
Figure 4.31                           -
Grand Gulf NLAE Model Node Locations L
   .e r}}