View source for 05000387/LER-1984-017, Updated LER 84-017-01:on 840310,during Performance of Weekly Preventive Maint Activity,Spray Pond Riser Networks A-1 & B-2 Found Frozen.W/Advent of Mild Weather,Networks Thawed & Pumped down.Long-term Fixes Investigated

{{Adams
| number = ML20091P633
| issue date = 06/06/1984
| title = Updated LER 84-017-01:on 840310,during Performance of Weekly Preventive Maint Activity,Spray Pond Riser Networks A-1 & B-2 Found Frozen.W/Advent of Mild Weather,Networks Thawed & Pumped down.Long-term Fixes Investigated
| author name = Keiser H, Kuczynski L
| author affiliation = PENNSYLVANIA POWER &amp; LIGHT CO.
| addressee name = 
| addressee affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
| docket = 05000387
| license number = 
| contact person = 
| document report number = LER-84-017, LER-84-17, PLA-2228, NUDOCS 8406130119
| document type = LICENSEE EVENT REPORT (SEE ALSO AO RO), TEXT-SAFETY REPORT
| page count = 4
}}
{{LER
| Title = Updated LER 84-017-01:on 840310,during Performance of Weekly Preventive Maint Activity,Spray Pond Riser Networks A-1 & B-2 Found Frozen.W/Advent of Mild Weather,Networks Thawed & Pumped down.Long-term Fixes Investigated
| Plant = 
| Reporting criterion = 
| Power level = 
| Mode = 
| Docket = 05000387
| LER year = 2084
| LER number = 17
| LER revision = 
| Event date = 
| Report date = 
| ENS = 
| abstract = 
}}

=text=
{{#Wiki_filter:-. .-_            -_____- -______ _ ___ _ - ______
NRC Pere 300                                                                                                                   U S. NUCLEAR EEGULATO2V COMMIS$60N APcROVED OMe No 3150-4104
                                                                                                                                                       '"''REs ar3i en LICENSEE EVENT REPORT (LER)
DOCKET NUMSER (2)                                              PAGE G FACILITY NAME Hi Susquehanna Steam Electric Station - Unit 1                                                              o l5 l 0 l 010131817                                        1 lOFl0 13 TITLE toe Emercency Service Water Spray Networks Frozen.
EVENT DATE (El                    LER NunaBER (6)                     REPORT DATE 171                    OTHER F ACILITIES INVOLVED (Si YEAR          IIQ       'A'     '
MONTM       DAY    YEAR            FactLITV Navas                                            COCKET NUUSERis)
MONTM     DAY    YEAR                      q      ,
Susquehanna - Unit 2                                               0 i s t o l 0 t o 13 is l g
                                      ~                  ~
0l 3      1l 0    8 4     8l 4          0 l 1l7             0l1 0 l6           0l6 8l4                                                                           0 1 5 1 01 0 1 0 1 I I WIS RMRT 4 BuemmD NWANT TO DE REQUIREMENTS OF 10 CFR j- he one w ann of W wow HH OPERATING I
4         20.402(bl                              20.405tel                      80.734sH2Hivl                                                     73.71tal POvet R                      30.408teH1HO                           90.36teHH                    x 90.73teH2Hel                                                      73.71(el
                           -                                        -                                ~
10        01010           20.40si.HiHsi 20.408taH1Hiell so.3eieH2 to.73(all2Ht) so.73t.H2Hval 60.73teH2HouiHA)
                                                                                                                                                                   ]      gMERyg,A,*.g J6dAJ 20 408hH1HND                           to.73teH2Het                   90.73tsH2HvmHB) i 20.4tlSisH1Het                         90.734sH2Han                   to.73teH2Hal LsCENSEE CONTACT FOR TMis LER H2)
NAME                                                                                                                                                             TELEPHONE NUMSER ARE A CQDE                                                          l L.A. Kuczynski - Nuclear Plant Specialist III                                                                                                                                    l 711 17 514121-l31715 19 CoasPLETE ONE LINE FOR EACM COMPONENT P A8 LURE DESCRISED IN TMeS REPORT (13)
CAUSE SYSTEM      COMPONENT           "'y T              T                               CAU$E SYSTEM  COMPONENT
                                                                                                                            "^
TU
                                                                                                                                                  ^
O NPRDS L     '
C     BIT       IPISIX SI 31215                         '. 7
* I      t i f             I I I                                                              l l
l      1 I I               I I I                                                    I      I I I             I I I SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT EXPECTEO 114                                                                                              MONTH  DAY   YEAR SUS W $510N
  } vEs ur vs,. m expecreo svowssiOor oArar
                                                                              """"} No                                                                                        ol9   9 l3   gl4 AeST ACT (bmst M 7400 more, u, aseroseviemy hfmen sempeasce rueentma haeW 088 The A-1 (89 risers) and B-2 (43 risers) spray pond riser networks were found to be frozen during the performance of a weekly preventive maintenance activity to pump down the risers. Af ter four days of milder weather, all four networks were thawed out and successfully pumped down. Unit I was shut down throughout the event; Unit 2 was in a pre-fuel load status. All spray headers and risers were inspected and no damage was found. The networks were pumped down every two days and monitored for leakage every day until March 31, 1984, when it was considered that the probability of the risers freezing again would be very low. Long term fixes are being investigated that will ensure that freezing of the spray networks does not occur again.
8406130119 e40606 gDRADOCK 05000387 PDR NaC ew. 3 (9431

e NRC Feren 3e4A                                                                           U S. NUCLE AR KEGULATO3Y COMMIS$lON LICENSEE EVENT REPORT (LER) TEXT CONTINUATION                      AreRovEo oMe No siso-oio.
EXPERES 8/3i/85 FACILITY NAME (1)                                 DOCKET NUMSER C4)            LER NUMSER (6)                    PAGE431 ygg,     stoutw eat      . Revtsooav Susquehanna Steam Electric Station                                              " ''"          " ''"
Unit 1 015 lo [0 l0 l318l 7 8]4   -
0 l 1l 7    -
0l 1     0l 2 OF     0l3 TEXT rs          o m          <wer.ni.asse,nm During the investigation performed in response to spray pond riser crm damage caused by ice formation on the spray nozzles (LERs 84-002 and 84-002, Rev. 1), concerns were raised that leakag a past the seats of the spray pond riser network inlet valves (2-30 in butterfly) could lead to ice formation in the risers themselves. A preventive maintenance activity was instituted to pump down the riser networks on a weekly basis to min-imize the possibility of freezing in the risers. Routinc maintenance of the riser network inlet valves is impractical since complete isolation of ESW is required and results in a one hour L.C.O.
The A-1, A-2, B-1 and B-2 spray pond networks were pumped down for the first time under the new procedure in February 27, 1984 at 2240 hours.
On March 7, 1984 at 1505 hours the B-1 and B-2 networks were successfully pumped down. The A-1 and A-2 network pumpdown was not attemped because of a prerequisite in the pumpdown procedure which required RHttSW and ESW systems to be shut down. When ESW and RHRSW are running, it is very diffi-cult to pump down the networks associated with this loop. The spray piping drain pump discharges into the RHRSW Bypass line upstream of a restricting orifice. When RHRSW and ESW pumps are running (discharging through the bypass line), sufficient back pressure is created by the restricting orifice to drive the capacity of the drain pump far back cn its pump curve (small flow). A combination of this small flow and the leakage past the isolation valves, makes the time to drain down a network excessively long. The A loop of RHRSW was required to be running to support other plant evolutions and was not able to be shut down. On March 10, 1984, the A-1 and A-2 spray networks were attemped to be pumped down. The A-2 network was successfully drained but the A-1 network had indications of being frozen (no flow ob-served thru the A-1 spray network). After determining the A-1 network was frozen, the B-1 and B-2 networks were examined for similar conditions.
The B-1 network was not frozen and the B-2 network was suspected to be frozen. Outside air temperature was approximately'6*F when the frozen networks were identified.
Even though;a Limiting Condition for Operation was not incurred because of the risers being frozen, Unit I was in cold shutdown and Unit 2 was pre-fuel load, all risers were to be returned to service prior to re-start of Unit 1. Ambient temperatures moderated over the next few days and all riser networks were able to be pumped down when the procedure was run on March 14, 1984.- All spray headers and risers were inspected and no damage was found.                                                                                  '
From March 14, 1984 through March-31, 1984, the riser networks were pumped .
down every two days and monitored for leakage every day. Present directions regarding riser network pumpdown specify that, between September 1 and March.
:31, the pumpdown will be done once per week, except when either of the following occur:
                        - when the outside air temperature drops 'to 35*F, riser' pumpdown will commence within 12 hrs., and will occur once every two days while temperature-is-below 35'F, or E   ,"." N "" ""
M                                                                                                                                i
                            ~
                                  ~                                                                                _

NRC Feem 3e6A                                                                                     u 5 huCLEAM P!MLATORY COMD SUON LICENSEE EVENT REPORT (LER) TEXT CONTINUATION                         AreaovEo own No mo-oi a ExPtRES 8/31 M FACILITY NAME 11) ,                                           DOCKET NUMSER (21          LER NUMSEP (El                   PAGE (3)
Susquehanna Steam Electric Station                                         . . . sagn              7v;5,y; Unit 1                                                                                     1 0F 0151010101318 l 7 8 14 0 l1 l 7 l-- 0 10 0I3                  0 l3 TEXT t# more apoco e regu.e4 see seutonalNAC form JK4'sJ 817)
                             -when the outside air temperature drops to 33*F, riser pumpdown will commence within one naur and will occur once every two days while temperature is below 33*F.
Guidelines have also been developed for spray pond operation to avoid freezing fo the risers and spray nozzles at low ambient temperature (32*F or below) when Residual Heat Removal Service Water (RHRSW) and Emergency Service Water (ESW) system heat loads make it desirable to direct flow through the spray networks. If pond temperature is above 75*F, the sprays may be run with the riser network bypass valves closed. This configuration insures that the pond can provide adequate cooling under even the worst case heat loads under the most severe hot weather meteorological condition anticipated. If pond temperature is between 60*F and 70*F, the sprays should be run with the riser netwcrk bypasu valves open. This configu-ration provides moderate cooling and regulation of the rate of change of pond temperature. If the pond temperature is A0*F or less, the cr7;/s should remain isolated with the riser ne.twork bypass valves open. If tne pond temperature is less than 60*F and the use of sprays is unavoidable, flow through the sprays should be maintained so that the height of the sprays is 4-12 inches above the nozzles (accomplished by opening the by-pass valve). If the sprays are ooerated in this range, a stagnant con-dition is avoided and the potential for free n ing is reduced because droplet sizes are maximized and the amount of time t he droplets are exposed to the air is minimized.
This occurrencs is reported under 10CFR50.73(a)(2)(v), because one large and one small spray network would have been unable to perform their safety function of heat removal from cooling water used in the Emergency Service Water system and the Residual Heat Removal Service Water system. Since positive assurance could not be provided that the frozen risers would be thawed prior to the need to utilize the spray network, it must be assumed that the single failure criteria for the spray network could no longer be met. The Station's FSAR (Section 9.2.7.3.1) contains analysis of spray pond capabilities under a LOCA/ Forced Shutdown scenario with only one spray network available, and concludes that the spray pond would still meet the performance requirements of an ultimate heat. sink. Thus, while the single failure criteria could not be met, the units could have been safely maintained under a LOCA/ Forced Shutdown situation (A-2 and B-1 spray arrays were available throughout this event). Also, engineering
                  . evaluation has shown that for single unit - operation, a LOCA can be safely dissapated by only one large array. (At the date of occurrence, only
                 . one unit was licensed for operation and one large and one small array were -
available for operation.) The bypass lines which allow returning water to be injected directly to the spray pond without passing through a spray network were available for operation throughout the. event.
Long term fixes'will be developed and submitted.to NRC Region.I by September 1
1, 1984, to ensure the freezing of the' spray header does.not. reoccur.
           ,                                                                                                                                   4
    . ;g, 0aM 3=.
L,                                                                                                                                            j

PP&l;      Pennsylvania Power & Light Company
                                    *"      "       * #" " * " ' ^ '
June 6, 1984 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 SUSQUEHANNA STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LICENSEE EVENT REPORT 84-017-01 ER 100450           FILE 841-23        Docket No. 50-387 PLA-2228                               License No. NPF-14 Attached is Licensee Event Report 84-017-01. This event was determined to be reportable per 10CFR50.73(a)(2)(v) in that, during a preventive maintenance activity to pump down the spray pond network risers, portions 1       f the spray pond network risers were discovered to be frozen. A long-term fix will be developed and submitted to NRC Region I by September 1,1984.
H.W. Keiser Superintendent of Plant-Susquehanna LAK/pjg cc:   Dr. Thomas E. Murley Regional Administrator, Region I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, PA 19406 Mr. R.H. Jacobs Senior Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P.O. Box 52 Shickshinny, PA 18655 ff*S$
f'
}}

{{LER-Nav}}