ML20153A482
| ML20153A482 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 06/15/2020 |
| From: | Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards |
| To: | State of GA, State of SC |
| James Firth, NRC/NMSS | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20153A470 | List: |
| References | |
| STC-20-046 | |
| Download: ML20153A482 (11) | |
Text
Applicants Environmental Report Operating License Renewal Stage for Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 Southern Nuclear Operating Company Docket No. 50-424 License No. NPF-068 and Docket No. 50-425 License No. NPF-081 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 2.1 Location and Features t
u 1 Columbia McCormick Richla 23 Lexington Edgefield Lincoln Sumter t
u 1
§
¨ I26 National Edgefield 121 Calhoun Wilkes Forest 19 t
u 302 Columbia Evans
§
¨ I20 Aiken Martinez North 4 Augusta Augusta Aiken Orangeburg Thomson Warren McDuffie §
¨ I520 New Ellenton Williston Orangeburg Fort Gordon Blackville Richmond Barnwell Jackson Savannah t
u 278 t
u 78 80 River Hephzibah Glascock Site Barnwell Bamberg t
u 25 125 t
u 1 Waynesboro _
[
23 Sa va Jefferson Allendale Girard nn Burke Louisville ah Colleton 24 Sardis Allendale Washington 24 Ri v t u
278 Wadley er Hampton 56 Millen Jenkins Sylvania Hampton Johnson Screven Emanuel t
u 25 t
u 301 t
u 278 Swainsboro Bulloch Jasper
§
¨ I95 Treutlen Statesboro Effingham
§
¨ Candler I16 Legend Major Roads 50-Mile Radius County Boundary _
[ Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Urban Areas Lakes and Rivers 0 5 10 20 30 Miles Federal Land Figure 2.1-1 50-Mile Vicinity Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 2.1-3 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 2.1 Location and Features Aiken SOUTH CAROLINA 56 125 o
sp an Tr rta tio n 80 R iv e r
R oa d ck L anding R Barnwell co d n
Ha D-Area Power House Sa va Vogtle n Rai l Sp ur _
[ n ah Ri ve Savannah River Site r
Cre ek am v rd Telfair B ea e Ri r
Pond ve Ro ad Yuchi WMA Burke Telfair X 23 Woods GEORGIA 6- M i le R ad iu s Girard X 24 Legend Federal Land Transmission Corridors
[ Vogtle Electric Major Roads Generating Plant Lakes and Rivers Site Boundary 0 0.5 1 2 3 Miles Wildlife Mgmt Area Figure 2.1-2 6-Mile Vicinity Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 2.1-4 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 2.11 Cultural Resources 2.11 Cultural Resources The Central Savannah River Area is one of the oldest and most historically rich areas of the state. Colonists led by James Oglethorpe settled Savannah in 1733 and Augusta in 1736.
Native Americans and early settlers used the Savannah River as a major transportation route between the Coast and the Piedmont. Burke County is one of Georgias original eight counties, and was named for Edmund Burke, an English spokesman for American liberty.
SNC has initiated informal discussions with the Georgia State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) regarding the construction of proposed new units, and the license renewal process.
Agreement has been reached on management of cultural resource issues and documentation of the terms of the agreement should be available by the end of the summer 2007. No new cultural resource issues are anticipated as a result of license renewal activities. Existing commitments and monitoring for cultural resources will continue through the renewed license period.
Historic or Archaeological Sites in the Vicinity of the VEGP Site The Environmental Report (GPC 1972) and the Final Environmental Statement (FES) (AEC 1974 ) describe the known historic resources in the area in the early 1970s. Shell Bluff Landing is approximately 7 miles north-northwest of the VEGP site. It has both historic and archaeological significance. It was the site of the original grave of Dr. Lyman Hall, a signer of the Declaration of Independence. His body was later reinterred in Augusta. The original ER also reports that Shell Bluff Landing was important during the era of steamboat river traffic and was fortified during the War Between the States. Shell Bluff takes its name from a large bed of fossils of the giant oyster (Crassostrea gigantissima) found there. This bed likely was formed during the Eocene epoch when the coastal plain of Georgia was under the Atlantic Ocean. The site of an Indian village with artifacts dated from 4,000 years ago lies between Shell Bluff and Boggy Gut Creek, approximately 7.5 miles from VEGP. (GPC 1972)
Seven sites in Burke County are on the National Register of Historic Places (Table 2.11-1).
One National Register listed building, the Sapp Plantation, is within 10 miles of VEGP. The SRS, located directly across the Savannah River from VEGP, is the only other historical site within 10 miles determined to be eligible for listing, is directly across the Savannah River from VEGP, in South Carolina. Twenty-two archaeological sites on the SRS and within 10 miles of VEGP have been determined to be eligible for listing.
Since the original ER was written, two important discoveries have been made near the Vogtle site and are discussed below.
The University of South Carolina Institute of Archaeology and Anthropology is excavating a prehistoric site on the Savannah River in Allendale County, approximately 15 miles downstream Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 2.11-1 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 2.11 Cultural Resources of the Vogtle property. Material from the site has been tentatively dated to 50,000 years ago (Powell 2004). If the dating techniques are accurate, the site, known as the Topper site, provides the earliest evidence of humans on the North American continent.
In 1983, during construction of the VEGP intake structure, the fossil of a 40-million-year-old whale species was uncovered in the Blue Bluff marl approximately 30 feet below ground surface. The skeleton of the whale, now known as Georgiacetus vogtlensis, is housed at the Georgia Southern University Museum in Statesboro, Georgia. (Reuters Limited 1998)
Historic or Archaeological Sites on the VEGP Site In 1973 an archaeological survey of the VEGP site was performed under the direction of the Georgia State Archaeologist and the Georgia Historical Commission and submitted to the U.S.
Atomic Energy Commission (the predecessor agency to the NRC). The survey identified seven archaeological sites (GPC 1972) (New South Associates [NSA] 2006). Four sites are along the river bluff, south of the barge canal. One was destroyed during construction of the barge slip.
This site is the location of the Brown Cabin, which apparently also was destroyed during construction. The remaining two sites are shown to be on the plateau west of Mallard Pond on the maps in the 1973 report, however, the Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM) coordinates for these two sites do not place them in the location shown on the report map (NSA 2006). Based on the 1973 study the State Archaeologist considered that the archaeological resources at the VEGP site had been sufficiently characterized (GPC 1972; amendment 3, 2/27/1974).
In 2005 NSA surveyed VEGP property likely to be disturbed during construction of proposed new units. The survey identified 10 new archaeological sites (3 historic and 7 prehistoric) and 7 isolated finds (NSA 2006). None of the seven sites identified in the 1973 survey were examined during the 2005 survey. Two of the new sites are eligible and two are potentially eligible for inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places. The rest are recommended ineligible. Table 2.11-2 provides brief descriptions of the sites.
Native American Cultural Resources and Concerns No federally-recognized tribes reside in the state of Georgia. Through OCGA 44-12-300, the state of Georgia officially recognized the following tribes of Georgia as legitimate American Indian tribes (500 Nations 2005):
- The Lower Muscogee Creek Tribe, Route. 2, Box 370, Whigham, Georgia 31797
- The Cherokee of Georgia, Saint George, Georgia 31646 Native Americans that settled in the Burke County area include a band of Chickasaw that lived near Augusta from about 1723 to the opening of the American Revolution: (Georgia Indian Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 2.11-2 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 2.11 Cultural Resources Table 2.11-2. Historic or Archaeological Sites Identified During a 2005 Survey of the VEGP Site Site Number / Location Description Eligibility 9BK414; on plateau W of Mallard Homesite, likely the W. M.
Pond Buxton home 9BK415; just W of railroad cut and Homesite identified from a approximately 2000 ft E of the 1989 topographic map that nearest site boundary noted a home and outbuilding 9BK416; on river bluff N of intake Large multi-component Eligible structure prehistoric site 9BK417; N of road to barge landing Liquor still and intake 9BK418; overlooking headwaters of Undiagnostic lithic scatter Mallard Pond; composed of dirt road and landfill pit 9BK419; under transmission line Woodland prehistoric site Potentially eligible from switchyard to Plant Wilson 9BK420; under transmission line to Undiagnostic lithic site Potentially eligible Plant Wilson on ridge overlooking Savannah River 9BK421; under SCE&G Undiagnostic lithic scatter transmission line; bench of a ridge side overlooking Savannah River 9BK422; near the training center Small scatter of historic and overlooking Beaverdam Creek prehistoric artifacts; disturbed by logging and clearcutting 9BK423; on a small bench above Multi-component prehistoric Eligible the floodplain N of the intake campsite structure Source: NSA 2006.
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 2.11-5 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 3.1 General Plant Information atmosphere. Provision is made during cold weather to direct all of the circulating water flow to the periphery of the cooling tower. This directs the total heat load to the peripheral region. Air flowing through the peripheral spray is thus preheated which allows deicing in the central cooling tower spray region.
Cooling tower make-up is drawn from the Savannah River through the weir arrangement described previously into the intake canal, then into one of four intake bays (two per cooling tower), each equipped with a vertical turbine pump with a pumping capacity of 22,000 gpm. The makeup water is supplied to the cooling tower basin. The river water makeup pumps supply water to the circulating water system to replace water losses due to evaporation, drift, and blowdown. Normally, only one or two of the makeup pumps are operating, depending upon the makeup demand.
Sodium hypochlorite and sodium bromide, are injected into the circulating water system to minimize fouling in the cooling towers and condensers. The residual oxidants are removed by addition of a reducing agent (typically ammonium bisulfite) into the blowdown mixing sump prior to discharge. Compliance with National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit requirements is determined by sampling and analysis (GDNR 2004).
3.1.2.2 Groundwater Resources VEGP has nine groundwater wells that variously supply the nuclear service cooling water system, plant water treatment system, fire protection system, potable and sanitary water systems, and the landscape irrigation system. All the wells are permitted under a single groundwater withdrawal permit from the Environmental Protection Division of the GDNR (GDNR 2000). The permitted annual daily average withdrawal is 5.5 MGD. Between 2000 and 2004, the annual average daily withdrawal for all purposes was approximately 1.05 MGD (SNC 2000a, b, 2001a, b, 2002a, b, 2003a, b, 2004a, b, 2005b).
The sites main production wells are MU-1 and MU-2A. Well MU-1 has a 2,000 gpm pump capacity and is the primary well. MU-2A has a 1,000 gpm pump and is the backup well. These wells are approximately 2,100 ft apart. MU-1 is approximately 1,000 ft from the eastern site boundary and the Savannah River. MU-2A is approximately 5,700 ft from the western site boundary and River Road. Both wells are in the Cretaceous aquifer. Each well, its capacity and its primary purpose are provided in Table 3.1-1.
3.1.3 Transmission Facilities The FES (NRC 1985) identifies two 500-kilovolt (kV) and three 230-kV transmission lines that would be built to connect VEGP to the electric grid. A pre-existing line from Plant Wilson to the Goshen substation crosses the VEGP property. One of the 500-kilovolt lines would run west to Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 3.1-4 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 3.1 General Plant Information Plant Scherer, routed near, but not connected to, the Wadley substation. The other 500-kilovolt line would run south to the Thalmann substation, routed near, but not connected to, the Effingham substation. Two of the 230-kV lines would run in the same corridor to the Goshen substation just south of Augusta. These lines would parallel the existing Wilson-Goshen line.
The remaining 230-kV line would run north then east to a substation within the Savannah River Plant (now called the SRS, a DOE facility). The two 500-kV lines were to be connected to the Unit 2 switchyard; the 230-kV lines were to be connected to the Unit 1 switchyard.
Subsequent to the publication of the FES, two changes were made to the transmission system.
y The Wilson-Goshen line was rerouted to connect to VEGP instead of Wilson. The segment between Wilson and VEGP was used to connect the two plants together. Furthermore, a connection was made to this VEGP-Goshen line to connect to the Augusta Newsprint substation. This line is now known as the Augusta Newsprint line. The short segment to Wilson is known as the Wilson line.
y The Thalmann line was connected to the West McIntosh substation and is now known as the West McIntosh (Thalmann) line.
As a result of these system changes, the transmission lines of interest for this report are somewhat different than those described in the FES, as indicated below. Figure 3.1-2 is a map of the transmission system of interest.
y Scherer - This 500-kV line runs generally westward to Plant Scherer, north of Macon, Georgia. Built in 1986, it is 154 miles long and in a corridor that is mostly 150 ft wide, but up to 400 feet wide in some locations. The terrain is flat to rolling.
y West McIntosh (Thalmann) - Running 69 miles to the south, this 500-kV line, in a 150-ft wide corridor, connects VEGP to the West McIntosh substation near Plant McIntosh, just north of Savannah, Georgia. It then continues for 90 miles to its termination at the Thalmann substation near Brunswick.
y Goshen (Black) and Goshen (White) - The two 230-kV Goshen lines connect to the Goshen substation approximately 19 corridor miles from VEGP. The corridor is 275 ft wide and the lines were built in 1986. These two lines, plus 17 miles of the Augusta Newsprint line, share the corridor. The terrain is generally flat.
y Augusta Newsprint - The Augusta Newsprint substation is approximately 20 corridor miles from VEGP. The corridor is 275 ft wide until the 230-kV Augusta Newsprint line diverges from the Goshen lines at 17 miles and is 100 to 125 ft wide for the remaining distance. The Augusta Newsprint line was built in 1983. The terrain is generally flat.
y SCE&G - Built in 1986, this 230-kV line runs north and east for 4.5 miles to cross the Savannah River and then an additional 17 miles to a substation operated by SCE&G. The Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 3.1-5 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 3.1 General Plant Information corridor in South Carolina is 100 ft wide and the Georgia segment is 125 ft wide. The part of the corridor in South Carolina is wholly contained on the Savannah River Site and is maintained by South Carolina Electric and Gas. The terrain is mostly flat.
y Wilson - This 1.4-mile long transmission line is wholly contained on GPC property. It connects VEGP to Plant Wilson at 230-kV. The corridor is 150 ft wide. The Wilson line provides offsite power in the event of an emergency.
In total, the transmission lines considered in Section 4.13 are contained in approximately 360 miles of corridor that occupy approximately 7,200 acres. The corridors pass through land that is primarily agricultural and forest. The Scherer line crosses the Oconee National Forest, northeast of Plant Scherer. The West McIntosh (Thalmann) line crosses the Yuchi WMA, the Tuckahoe WMA, and Ebenezer Creek Swamp near the West McIntosh plant. The lines cross numerous county, state, and U.S. highways after leaving the switchyard. Corridors that pass through farmlands generally continue to be used as farmland. Southern Company plans to maintain these transmission lines, which are integral to the larger transmission system, indefinitely. These transmission lines will remain a permanent part of the transmission system after VEGP is decommissioned.
The transmission lines were designed and constructed in accordance with the National Electrical Safety Code (NESC) and other industry guidance that was current when the lines were built. Ongoing surveillance and maintenance of these transmission facilities ensure continued conformance to design standards. These maintenance practices are described in Section 4.13.
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 3.1-6 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 3.1 General Plant Information ad Ro ng ndi Savannah La Sav k an River oc na Site Hanc h Ri ver Mallard's Pond Intake Structure Switchyard Discharge Line Turbine Building Ri ver Cooling a Towers Ro d
Containment Building ad Ro Combustion s
ces Turbine Ac Plant a nt Pl n
ai M
Road Vogtle Training River Center LEGEND Railroads Transmission Line Alvin W. Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Property Line 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Miles Facilities Scale is approximate.
Figure 3.1-1 General Plant Layout Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 3.1-8 June 2007
Applicants Environmental Report 3.1 General Plant Information Newton Jasper Morgan Greene Warren
, 20 McDuffie Columbia Fort Gordon Aiken REDCLIFFE PLANTATION STATE PARK W N
E Richmond Augusta Newsprint Putnam Goshen % % Substation Savannah Hancock Substation River Site Barnwell S
BARNWELL STATE PARK INDIAN SPRINGS Oconee National SCE&G STATE PARK Forest Glascock Substation % Bamberg Monroe Plant Scherer % Jones Baldwin Jefferson Ú RIVERS BRIDGE STATE PARK Burke PIEDMONT NATIONAL Washington WILDLIFE REFUGE Francis Plantation
[
% Allendale
% Wadley Substation MAGNOLIA SPRINGS STATE PARK Tuckahoe WMA Bibb Bond Swamp National Wildlife Refuge Wilkinson Jenkins
[
% LAKE WARREN STATE PARK Screven 75 Twiggs Hampton Robins Air Johnson Force Base Peach MEMORIAL PARK HILBURN PARK STUBBS PARK Emanuel GEORGE L SMITH STATE PARK Houston Effingham Laurens 16 Jasper Bleckley Treutlen Candler Ebenezer Creek Swamp National Natural Landmark %[
Bulloch West McIntosh Plant Pulaski Montgomery Savannah National Wildlife Refuge Dodge Dooly LITTLE OCMULGEE STATE PARK Evans Wheeler Toombs GORDONIA ALATAMAHA STATE PARK Bryan Wilcox Fort Stewart Hunter Army GEORGIA VETERANS Airfield Telfair MEMORIAL PARK Crisp Tattnall Chatham Liberty 95 Jeff Davis JEFFERSON DAVIS Ben Hill Appling MEMORIAL PARK Long Turner Townsend Harris Neck National Worth Irwin Range Wildlife Refuge Tift GENERAL COFFEE Bacon Wayne Coffee STATE PARK Blackbeard Island McIntosh National Wildlife Refuge Pierce Berrien Ware LIONS PARK Wolf Island Wilderness Atkinson Glynn Colquitt Cook Brantley Thalmann % Federal Law Enforcement Training Center BALLARD PARK REED BINGHAM STATE PARK ROADWAY STREET OKEFENOKEE NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE Legend
Ú Plant Vogtle Existing Transmission Lines Parks Primary road with limited access Primary road
Ú VEGP State Boundary County Boundary 10 0 10 20 Miles Military Base Federal Land Urban Area Figure 3.1-2 Transmission System Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 3.1-9 June 2007