ML20206N316

Responds to Ltr to NRC on Continued Events Re Transfer of Generation Assets Between Dl & Firstenergy.Info Will Be Considered as NRC Monitor Pending License Transfer Application of Bvps,Units 1 & 2 & Pnpp

ML20206N316
Person / Time
Site:	Beaver Valley, Perry
Issue date:	05/06/1999
From:	Matthews D NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
To:	Kotecki D UTILITY WORKERS UNION OF AMERICA
Shared Package
ML20206N320	List: ML20206N316 ML20206N336
References
NUDOCS 9905170199
Download: ML20206N316 (8)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ _ _

l 1

May 6, 1999 I Mr. David T. Kotecki President / Local 270 Utility Workers Union of America 4205 Chester Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44103-3615

Dear Mr. Kotecki:

I have been a's ked by Mr. Collins to respond to your letter to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) dated April 5,1999.

The NRC reviews those nuclear matters that deal with public health and safety, and the protection of the environment for the facilities we regulate. The NRC strives to achieve public  !

confidence in our regulatory programs and processes by encouraging public participation.

Therefore, we appreciate your letter informing us of the continuing events concerning the pending transfer of the nuclear generating assets between Duquense Light Company and FirstEnergy.

The NRC is aware that, as of the date of your letter, there has been no negotiated settlement between FirstEnergy and Local 270 pertaining to the tentative generation asset exchange. The NRC will remain observant of your suit filed in Federal Court, and your complaint against FirstEnergy with the National Labor Relations Board.

However, you have not identified in your letter any specific issues over which the NRC has any regulatory responsibilities. We will consider the information provided in your letter as we monitor the pending license transfer applications and operations of Beaver Valley Power Station Units 1 and 2, and the Perry Nuclear Power Plant. If however, you have specific safety concems with respect to the operation of Beaver Valley or Perry, we request that you bring them to our immediate attention.

Sincerely, Original Signed By:

David B. Matthews, Director Division of Regulatory improvement Programs Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation ./

DISTRIBUTION: See attached page M45

• SEE PREVIOUS CONCURRENCES Document Name:g:\nlad\ LOC 270 e ,t k OFFICE RGEEfk 4 SCQGJp*- OGC* C:RGEB D:Dhk Bkah SHon[

NAME MDukadiwskyj:sw" CCarpentek DMatthews DATE 5/M99 5/4/99 5/k /99 5/(0/99 i 5/4/99 OFFICIAL OFFICE COPY gj }

9905170199 990506 -

PDR ADOCK 05000334

( P PM .

pgR- j l q $ N M NY 4

? k i

)

p 0%q\ UNITED STATES y

j 2

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20066-0001 1

g I

• • • • • May 6,1999 Mr. David T. Kotecki President / Local 270 ,

Utility Workers Union of America 1 4205 Chester Avenue  !

Cleveland, Ohio 44103-3615

Dear Mr. Kotecki:

i i have been asked by Mr. Coliins to respond to your letter to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) dated April 5,1999. )

I The NRC reviews those nuclear matters that deal with public health and safety, and the j protection of the environment for the facilities we regulate. The NRC strives to achieve public confidence in our regulatory programs and processes by encouraging public participation.

Therefore, we appreciate your letter informing us of the continuing events concerning the l pending transfer of the nuclear generating assets between Duquense Light Company and FirstEnergy.

The NRC is aware that, as of the date of your letter, there has been no negotiated settlement 1 between FirstEnergy and Local 270 pertaining to the tentative generation asset exchange. The ]

NRC will remain observant of your suit filed in Federal Court, and your complaint against j FirstEnergy with the National Labor Relations Board. J l

However, you have not identified in your letter any specific issJes over which the NRC has any regulatory responsibilities. We will consider the information provided in your letter as we monitor the pending license transfer applications and operaticos of Beaver Valley Power Station Units 1 and 2, and the Perry Nuclear Power Plant. If however, you have specific safety concerns with respect to the operation of Beaver Valley or Perry, we request that you bring them to our immediate attention.

Sincerely, d 'f j David B. Matthews, Director Division of Regulatory improvement Programs i Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation l l

1 l

e 4

y y y g kedn l l dt ,

r r e a n l E

e tr t get alri et r e " o (a n e o t

de no A ns 1, e auo n uk t s r r isn 1,  ;.w0 euog acp o au62. '" s .

e s n l- io2 h e r a di e mvt a ar t

i

,o1 ks qnens age s e gs nar s in .t q 4. ' A 4 .

it bi w01 t

u e oh e l

luu a dt t r

nncr p - e d4 i s it o e s s t r p f s

'e e e saol a s- p ph l ipe d u .- e s n s

n epUt s o ndtra i cwss y pt ek g so s hPs o cit r oh t d oo w nehuP ra edM ie s msb l

e l l i o id e ga r xy oic n dl s ii asse ct v eh s4 ioO n f e vp ud e pees .sc a dt optrd h elri nc sl rru v o c e v ol vr a u e e h t aI nt et auoi l ol o ch olo O tot ri s vted c ei f s r r gt vi pef a frl aign pni i

a vSePci h "- vqsei i

L l s

.si al e c s u lauevl eri vuew ne a u er e vp edn o gi s

f o n ceLic s s s t Vl g l v

oinw cgt n _

uo' f a r i id c eisb iieS Pg 'dco t t e eef at t cnisceie t n

no i i ahh st h n o .

t it t n 2dl a ngs u c e ).

iri aenht r p a

n g a ).

re a tac t r t t pMepe r ek s no i t

n n

m r e an p)i od e( nc potp a t, co r

et r

e m n (c l

si m so u u a 8' i

c"w"u n"o t s l ad s n 2 msnAl ne e has o2 a Tr eUr ul a cee se c h if i

_ae s s: s a. h e re svo2 i

svvCh ee v c1 at s s ce'9"lol e r EJvu i i

t cs ei ee r

_ b d pi t c

- bSo eI p o FeT'f g

4 4Tecva4 hxlolacc3 il i

t ar v

eOie pL w p t

r hx Tei4 n c a 2 s

e rl v d dea ,

ese e seP v4 vic se4

.s neR d lvi a r c

g larve l Ved xwhVeac' o l n r x o i

t 2 eo t, r 2t e c s it ed eesg eg T

e nr e l penvi r inani r e

e Uaubadl d e sTse vd sh au Usreu s d vd n

r nvd adl olvl eo2d ct e nl a ad ve s e i s t

lA I

t vcadno e

s gV e U c l

I it eo sl -

i n ein i cedn i s s n he cd s.n d Uh ruit rh U esaonw es e t, d n xet i e w s o t, o

p ht s enUelecd h le nd t

r t t c r eba l

e eeh i eu rb e u otphawes xh e a ph i r P Pt PTos eo e g . d s a ht n l n f

e uo l

o g o i2 o e re t t iw0 l 0 r ac t

g d m n uw e on nMdsete44.s int a s n t

g s , d s6 e a n n s te a usll i l t nus t s o iue e e as h o ht s2s 0

yl rh d e a i

s eh yie r a a aa sl r is b I t t l c s e f or e u t e io nl c eef nS e e e k nv i

m T ss f, omob ig cIla ooh o seh ere c e rpla qd c p aP ecant r t n srfst c e

x l . et a nr is e onrl s

eieih gr t r cHvok l oeoi s ar g n aNam l

o . v s e i, e h t r n e ep eo E noiu xir a cob aPl ri t r ad w

- das e valea ick s c oerto u r s mn e emtah i ex eeosFo 0 _

ei qeut e tx s or e h qepeos tasish c . ukona ek a eef efa f. r e -

cpa(t inlvmr

, i v r i ta4 r t t 2-la V

epnu s r mr pdewt ir ut dichi c et u fossoht c ag cl e ys4 pl t 1 la e n ohl v hel ar p s. d s

A g

o r o pd uet noit n u ph t ot s si n o l

c seS tre n3 t r t aet i a caen o ht ta c o o1 n n e re cei n a gs nndlaa r aV ceyt h unf r t c i

n t r seio) l t icpnc. unc u pd e wle nt ee Feun r t io t t e in i -

r r iwtuia w5tn isi i e h ai nqen leok h p h e u s.e f gp r r r

s a _

s ondl s1isf gh ueml a i e b n a d l f

e e cue1 v( i f ch r uv h ht h a, t r oi sf f s e

f vd i m y?

D r

l vg pie rl aio n e c aninp voc nt s s e itcy t yt s cf e eio o t sjWit iml e f ir iwt e

V pd w e ol aec uo3 e

.k v T c n4 el s, n iwt i del ct is epvge r

t ah a anlca e 3

• 1 d a fo aa e enr vner et icjt i s nit n k ih c mt r ee ina lenp ws r elvat r s d

• md ie

- un ci c cr a d V o. n dvgisih i r o stulaeht iri t

e s c a mhcuiu4 o e r nhhjnd npd ootem e omr a ent i

hc ei 2pa L. tcb2 it r egnah nt elvp r nnai ia pupr epreiooa t t i r t t it SI n ra e1 i

f a

c icd poa vf gfee rl elu oya o, onrl e sl f t t or o ycp o nP p Ul e

o

,ur tdeSpu3

,a r a

r p ed aggr r

oef nit v gf ea e ei s t i

m i

nao r - cl a ss t

r l s m d V, e i h p eei t n si nn ad sproe gsn t

s mf v ois ns oaei v1 u4 o.. a e ecr er wot ,dsp ee u - an e t J

's ir soe e ge s c i

i e sul ot i a W f.

r, ish d  : n agl 1 meo v . a! v na1 3 n1 _

enri laif lve u ht o pmh o a wo t v p a o d, w t edd gd r

anh i t n x st f

Am, . u , ige s

t r i nwe a ;., b V iot a r v oe e ~

, n .Alb nniu e nt

- es g Se rene mp , gmt t it d eilr oot s s sg t

). aec i shis a olakc wh,d en s e ei s

e icn . e pd teI h et r i wkowic s S et l a imr s or oc yP v mi nt seso e d pt f ni t i l

uvi r eno4d h ed vi t

i c pplt aourds el Inyo a of l oAwvd ola u i T etx f el t ot i p bibds Trd

" p a exs pi bn e e rxo L

• sI asI ec 8 8 8 8 7 7 7 7 g 0A 0- n 4A 0- n i

n w

41 0 3 G0B 8- 13 t yi o m t e 4t 0 3 G13 8 t yi tome fe ct fe esct 1 1 1 a

r . o 7 9 es 7 9 7h 9h ajy 7h 9h ajny DN 8S - 2S SI nS 8S 2S SI S es n 2 n 2: S i

o d d o v d d C t

a n n d i la n n nR c a , . a, lo V a , a, wgn o ei t if I 4444 sl 12341 1 C9 kc I 01 1 2 s8855 o ni s dit e vn lae t

in3333 t

I 1 S ge it 4466 t

u lol avl Peh n3333 h ooa VId UVVVV LLC UVVVV SCiVs _

) )

3 4 r

e 30 -0 4

04 b

m I S S

- I I 1 S --5 u 2 - 2 _

U- JU-I U

N IU-- J m JS S J S I

t e

C( C S C(C o

L .

g _

l e f nt e l r h a e e oh oie t k t i

t k o M d n k _

eoe s . oawit n . o kt s nip r O a d . _

oe uar s n ec t

is top e s trd s- n ht is s n s r n tso 1 tr v at t c en r

t lluiiot an

- ht pm l lunl a di ht et ht n ap n li t 0, eo e w a e epr lus i op u ef ss iu l4l r a f s f 1 _

f s s a vb ul epr) s od .

spc ntrp fs pi o antr _

nc

' i isys p oc = g eog icre *o at g e t

r ah lr e a s d nc(

v e c2 x= n d ien ar x= tr nai n d nn sP pt er ret rpo iopa2 e= c ig r vhiud.

ot )c. e= rlc eprg i

opwM v e h osaSl ti u a f

pe on3 r oe a r hd ~( oe z ha t h ir a r o oO la ybhc pt pet dh t

c qC t lar eh is4 n 1 eb noos ~2 laysfo u r c eh ut x n Ritn 1

f c e vt cl e e o n heoge c

iow, t

at o0 h rh ct et hva toin2 it i t cl s i er atr el h ivt t oshi w no ct

.).

t aeiitint o ngss4 a d n gd 1 a r o ar pi o oi t inc a rk p sl p nmpsh ou e t

r sh ltei ntut r r at pu reipw,n on1 r pugnt a t e e r ns o n gl

. c

. (

ui f ut s nret acisP a

imqeg ea ltis d acr ed1 o0 nqnt r

el pit oga lteic a

i gJ 2 s vm l i at s vu islluph e ed n h e rd xo M el i l e xl e oh ur s t t isvu i l as e m e ri er EJ t i f ot a TecO it vd aa h TecsP a i vr tehd t a h Ted cnw124 xu n

e s d

l pn e - o lvl c eow v d o ih s g m

a lug laed t, r g

n V fsi nr Viu s t eu l d it 2i u 2 erchs b ad s it ed e nl n v it nel xd Ts e T

e Uvp ae Us oc eo vlc d ieg dnck o lads s.

t a

n r aed n ivn al Ve m hci es l

t e I c .

I t

vardu 2i n c w A it s r nie s n nid s it eo r U ht, x nxd d

e ew U h t, s e Uet u s

o e s e o es o eihs p ht le k td ht le c l h e t

s o rb ou rb d rl vd l P

r ea rh s PTts ea n PTa e ao Pvc f

n o p ea r eo g ir 4 lue ht p w n t ed vl n

g 0iuyt, a s d mno lo f a n ig t

nla uo 2- f ae onec l

t uigef r a al el v i

s pt w icr e

0- rod cs E(l vdb u eij r ti e gut t c mh ol ns str a hb caah r pe n t w

E x Sseodd aasu igr mpr un pe pi t eirf ht ef s oI o r

ol vw yne .d e

v 3 0 ev h oa a nl Ib l hcpyt a

u oreteo sdl e una i ph su t

7 n nms

.d 1 agan inp t t l

a - i pl a -

f ni glyh e t l V 2 0er s et s niu or oieut n A is lt opa t _

g - h et Et fpo n t w ogne r t

n u p glp m n a igi vh ti _

S ot opa l e s e ege n r

r e r e rnldpu l i toh mf a c atcwe io t

ad rh t id _

f e h hlpo e auao o n r e af S eh r

e lui hd h ai t

r t _

D it t

ct pt d eC pow ce r e, iegt nad n d".

omolr d R "p. o e p x fo e gi h aak gof uer i g w tsht e vnr ut l e go c nrla oht nd n n

o land i

t if r uT ia wto n t ir u ait n eon a isc ve) s p niai nd enplinh s dC .st i la dS n en s

iOo h

s pa v ep aTodwp eV h eCra ah ge i

t iny ym lvRt mt e p. rl an f t at i t slir st f ear r lah f a l ee a %

o e a ph e t

s e vt vh vd u iset h et tah mt u a n s

+.

t ist cla ".

o6pr t

J s

's n ut e e h mI e s s na rl h loit pwi r6 t

r e pel or zpia rr eb t gs wggn s t gf oe ri z n .dre

- derb e pt uis ni riinn r a

in s u r eoi t isd egg s ps pd ot u q t

otshS cs e lolud r rS o e er L

L Inut

" miRapu n CTf re n esd Co aaaC ehh l

Cur msedl nie a

" wh ccR " ppafb 8

7 & 8 7

8 7 & 8 7 &

g 0 . v.

l a 0 0 l a 0- l n - B - A - A a G0 G h e icel G1 GI2 ceJm G2 ic el o .

8 S,R.

i i .

m mrom mu m ;e w

a 0 2 1 el ut nt e s 0 1 - 2 8 8

- 2 m el ut mr .

r .o 7 9 1 Ay 1

982 7 el sy 9 n 7h 9726 h ooy 7h 9h h o . h oo DN 8S 201 1 CVCS 8S 2S C V C.S t 9h 2S CVCS n 2 k 2 kn v e n o d c  :

io yahue it n d al y a a n a Ta l n gl t

a r

ic a el V o no ei t f I 1 i l =C ye I 1 mrot 2 23 igIs e lae vn t i4 s3 i x

u

= rla v ts0 r 5 ut nl t e t i5 r a nl ev n2 pa loou Vid UV ANSV n2 UV VCO n2 UV CLV hi a

) ) _

3 4 _

r 3

0 0- 4 0 -0 5

0

- I e l I l

- I I

b l i m

u C-C I - 2 CC I 2 I

C-N U- U - U- -U 2 U-J J m J S S JS J e C S S C(C t

i C( C 5

.  ?

-