ML20101U361

Supplemental Motion of Inmates at Graterford,Pa State Correctional Inst Re Full Disclosure of Evacuation Plan for Inst.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20101U361
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	02/06/1985
From:	Love A MONTGOMERY COUNTY, PA
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#185-420 NUDOCS 8502070282
Download: ML20101U361 (11)

Text

_ _ _ _ _ __ __ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Lp0 .

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA UCrTrico NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION d'E BEFORE'THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSIN07 BOARD

~6 MO :30 In the Matter of  : Docket N67.'050--35 2c t. _,

J'.50-353V N

PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY '

(Limerick Generating Station,

• Units 1 and 2)  :

SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION OF THE INMATES AT SCIG REGARDING FULL DISCLOSURE OF THE EVACUATION PLAN FOR SCIG I. INTRODUCTION

\

On December 20, 1984, the inmates at the State Correction-al Institute at Graterford, Pennsylvania, filed a Motion before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board requesting full disclosure of the evacuation plan for the State Correctional Institute at Graterford, Pennsylvania. On January 2, 1985, che Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff filed an Answer to said Motion. The applicant and the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Association also filed responses.- On January 22, 1985, during a public hear-ing before the Board, Chairman Hoyt requested counsel for the inmates to res' pond to the' N.R.L. staff request on page 5, which states, ". . . the inmates should be required to specify the informa-tion the'y need, based on expert opinion, which is beyond that .

provided in the sanitized' version." The purpose of this supplemental motion is to respond to this question.

[O$

o 0 $

1)

=__ . . -- -

-- a

'1 II. Inmates have retained John Case, Field Director of the Penn~sylvania Prison Society as their expert.

Initially, the inmates would'like the record to reficct that they have retained the services of John Case to act as their expert in this matter. Mr. Case is currently the Field Director of the Pennsylvania Prison Society (see Vita attached as Exhibit A).

III. The' inmates' expert, John Case, requests that'all informa-tion contained in the unsanitized version of the evacuation plan is needed in order to ascertain the'vi' ability of'such, i

The inmates' expert, John Case, served twenty-one years in the United States Marine Corps (1942-62). During this period, he obtained a security rating of Top Secret "Q". It is his opinion that all the information contained in the sanitized ver-sion is necessary to determine the viability of the plan. He further indicated that said material is secure in his hands due to his prior security clearances in the Marine Corps and his top secret rating. He also indicated that the unsanitized version contains virtually no useful information, therefore further in-quiries as to the type of information needed are premature.

Accordingly, the inmates request full disclosure of the plan to 1

l

[

their expert and counsel. See Pacific Gas and Electric Company (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2, ALAB-592 11'N.R.C. (1980). .'

Respect. fully submitted Wf l .' ) M> L ,

GLS R. 'fDVT SQUi.RE Montgom :rC ty Legal Aid s

?,

!~

=

L

• . I s

! , t f: ,

J

t .

l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matte of  : ' Docket Nos. 50-352 50-353 UHILADELPHIAELECTRICCOMPANY (Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 and 2)  :

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Angus R. Love, attorney for hsntes, .SCIQ, hereby certify thatatrueandaccuratecopyoftheSupplementalMotionoftbe Inmates at SCIG Regarding Full Disclosurs of the Evacuation Plan sfor SCIG, in reference to the above-captioned matter, was mailed on January 28, 1985 via regular first class mail, postage prepaid, to the following list:

Helen F. Hoyt, Chairperson Ms. Phyllis Zitzer, Pres.

Administrative Judge Ms. Maureen Mulligan Atomic Safety and Licensing Limerick Ecology Action Board Panel 762 Queen Street U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Pottstown, PA 19462 Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. Edward G. Bauer, Jr.

Dr. Richard F. Cole V.P. and General Counsel Administrative Judge Philadel?hia Electric Co.

Atomic Safety and Licensing 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, P A19101 i Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Troy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.

Washington, D.C. 20555 Mark J. Wetterhahn, Esq.

Dr. Jerry Harbour Conner and Wetterhahn Administrative Judge 1747 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W Atomic Safety and Licensing Washington, D.C. 20006 Board Panel Mr. Marvin I. Lewis U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 6504 Bradford Terrace Philadelphia, PA 19149 Mr. Frank R. Romano Air and Water Pollution Patrol 61-Forest Avenue Ambler, PA 19002 I

Joseph H. White, III Zori G. Ferkin 15 Ardmore Avenue Governor's Energey Council Ardmore, PA 19003 P.O. box 8010 1625 N. Front Street Martha W. Buxh, Esq. Harrisburg, PA 17105 Kathryn S. Lewis, Esq. "

1500 Municigal Services Bldg. Spence W. Perry, Esq.,

15th and JFI Blvd. Associate General Counsel Philadelphia, PA 19107 Federal Emerg. Managemt Agency Room 840, 500 C. Street, s.W.

Thomas Gerusky, Director Washington, D.C. 20472 Bureau of Radiation Protection De7t. of Environmental Resources Robert J. Sugarman, Esq.

5th Floor, Fulton Bank Bldg. Sugarman, Denworth & Hellegers Third and Locust Streets 16th Fl. Center Plaza Harrisburg, PA 17120 101 N. Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19107 Director Pennsylvania Emergency James Wiggins Management Agency Sr. Resident Inspector Basement, Transportation & U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

. Safety Bldg. P.O. Box 47 Harrisburg, PA 17120 Sanatoga, PA 19464 Robert L. Anthony Atomic Safety and Licensing Friends of the Earth of Board Panel the Delaware Valley U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

103 Vernon Lane, Box 186 Washington, D.C. 20555 Moylan, PA 19065 Atomic Safety and Licensing Charles W. Elliott, Esq. Appeal Board Panel Brose & Poswistilo U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

325 N. 10th Street Washington, D.C. 20555 Easton, PA 18042 Docketing and Service Section David Wersan Office of the Secretary Consumer Advocate U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm.

Office of Attorney General Washington, D.C. 20555 1425 Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 Gregory Minor MHB Technical Associates Jay Gutierrez 1723 Hamilton Avenue Regional Counsel San Jose, CA 95126 ar e ue Timothy R.S. Campbell, Director King of Prussia,PA 19406 Department of Emerg. Services 14 East Biddle Street Steven P. Hershey, Esq. West Chester, PA 19380 Community Legal Services, Inc.

5219 Chestnut Street Philadelphia, PA 19139 g AMI < /) //V '~

ANGUS R Montgo ,p0VFFESQl(IRE ary County Legal Aid

)

-~, _ _ < W

,.. I t

VITA JOHN D. CASE

. WORK EXPERIENCE The Pennsylvania Prison Society, Field Directori

• May 1977 to present Philadelphia, PA 19107 and County December 1962 to

' Warden, Bucks County Prison, Doylestown Frbruary 1977 Dephrtment of Corrections lvania Member, Governor's Justice Commission, Pennsy Corps 1969 to 1978 .

Private to Major, United States MarineInstractor, M January 1942 to 1954 to 1957 Staff Schooli Quantico, VA December 1962 Custody Officer, Naval Prison, 1948 to 1950 Portsmouth, N.H. Marine Corps Dase, 1960 to 1962 CampDrig Officerr LeJeune, N.C.

\

EXPERT WITNESS Nez vs Marila, U.S. District Court of Arizona, June 1970 H70-216 ization Legislative-Executive Task Force on ReorganCom August 13, 1970 of Government ntatives, Committee on the Judiciary, House of Represe

'Nay 29,1971 Washington, D.C. ited Committee on the Judiciary, Senate of the Un June 22, 1972 States, Washington, D.C.

027 9, U.S.

July 1977 Sutton vs Washington, Civil Action H77 ,

Civil Action H78-270, ty U. S.

Jail)

March 1979 Valentin vs Englehadt, District Court for New Jer ,

11, U.S.

Ippolito vs Howell, Civil Action H78-09 Jerscy f

= September 1979 District Court for Cho District of New(Consen (Atlantic County Jail) consoll-Civil Action H77-0765 U.S. Di str cit Morrison vs Brennano lington 1989 dated with Civil Action H78-0628, Court County Jail) Consent Decree.

d f

Laroau Vs Mansone Civil Action'HH 1

Octobor 23, 1980 Connecticut. civil Smith vs Montgomery County and Commissionors, h Castern 28, 1981 action H80-4492, U.S. District Court for t e

.Nanuary lvania

g, -- ,

1-A h

U EXPERT WITNESS h

Marcho 1980 Davis vs H.G. Evatto Sheriff of Hamilton County y Tennessee, Civil Action M1-79-200, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee y 1980 .

! Tammy Lee, James Earl Moreheado et al vs Bradley County, Tennessee, et als C01'1 Action #1-80-38 in the U.S.

District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee r Southern Division (Consent Decree)

Aprilo 1981 f{ Laurie DeMier et al vs Arlington County, Civil e

Action H80-1086-A o U.S. District Court Eastern District of Virginia (Consent Decree)

April 2r 1981

[q [i L Fisher vs Arlington County, et al, Civil Action W H80-1204, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Virginia

, Augusto 195t1 Pontato, at al vs Richard Froy of Jofforson Countua j7 Civil Action HC75-0031-L(A) C79-0492-L (A) o C79-0570-L (A) ,

U.S. District Courto Western District of Kentucky at Loulsville a

\

O-

. July 3r 1981 Raymond La ttisaw, et al vs Hughes, ot 'al o civil Action H8-78-1718, (Depos1C20n) U.S. District Courte District of Maryland January, ~1982 Early vs District of Columbia, Civil Action H1245178 and Civil Action H739579o' Suporlor Court of District; of Columbia

(~ Januarya 1982 V. -Dianda et al vs Norvella Sheriif of SC. Lucie Countyo Florida r ot. ale Civil AcClan H80-8251-CIV-JCP (80-0016-CIV-MAG-PJK)

U.S. District Court for

-Southern Dist'rict of Florida ForC Pietce Division o

o (Consent Decroe)

=Dscembero 1981 Billy Cuttsinger et al vs Billy Ray Shephards at al e

'of Bullitt Countyr Civil Action HC80-0048-L(A): U.S.

e District Court, Western District of Kentucky at Louisville r (Consent ' Decree) '

l March lo-1982 McElvern - et al vs County of Prince William et al o

- o Civil Action H81-1049'ANs U.S. District Court of Virginiao Alexandria Division

?Nay: 1982.

Gary Hendricks vs Paul Davis ot ale Civil Action :

o

• HHM-80-2038 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland

Februarge 1984-Wheeler vs Sullivan o et air Civil ' Action H80-177-WRS '

U.S. District Court of the District of Delaware December'7: '1984 Michae' l Wayne Spivey vs Roy Banks, et als Civil Action v ,

• 182-1060-CRT of North Carolina U.S.Raleigh r

DistrictDivision Court for Eastarn District v .. _

9 h: e AQARDS 1968 G. Howland Shaw Award of the National Jail Associa-Y-l tion, Jailer of the Year, prosented at the American l

Correctional Association Convention, San Francisco i t j 1975 Exemplary Project Award for Corrections, presented

.

• by the National Association of Counties 197,6 Ambassador of the Ye'v a o presented by the Bucks County Chamber of Commerce

! 1976- Liberty Bell Award, Ydung Lawyers, Pennsylvania Bar Association i

1977 Citizen of the Decade rpresented by the Bucks County Association for Corrections and Rehabilitation F

i- 1977' Commendation from the Senate of Pennsylvania for nino years of service as a member of the Governor

• s Justice Commission

. PUBLISHED ARTICLES

^ January-February, 1965 Modern Corrections in Old County Jailo American g Journal of Corrections s ..

! i 1965 Citizan Participation in the County Jail, American Correctional Association Proceeding Septemberg 1966 Wo Oporato a Salvago Dusiness--Not a Junk Yardi Foderal Probation Quarterly Decemboro 1966 Citizan Participation An Exporimont in Prison =

Community Relations, Federal -Probation Quartarly

' Marche;1967 "Doing Time" in the Communityr Federal Probation Quarterly

' Spring-Summero 1967 Incentives in a County Prisono Prison Journal i

' January or 1969 j Pennsulvania's County Prisonso a presentation to i

Task Force on Correctionso the Legislature of the; Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

t. . June,1969 Raintogration of tho Offondor into tho Community

];

l, February ~9, 1971 Does Anybody Realig Care? Presented at New York V University, and published as a chapter in book l Social Disabilities.

i .. .

b-: -June 23, 1971 Testimony, Committee on the Judiciary, United States SI Hous.e of Representatives, Washington e D. C, J January-Febt,uary: 1973 Correctional Volunteers in Bucks County, The American

, Journal of Corrections h

4

-CONSULTANT EXPERIENCE AND STUDIES 3 l ki 1968 to present Cortified Jail Consultant, National Jail Associacion =

f' 4 1968 Jail Study, Dixon County, Sioux City, Nebraska ^

1969 Monroe County, Rochester, New York =d Rockland County, New York 4 1970 Hamilton County, Cinncinnati, Ohio

1971 Jefferson County, Louis,villo, Kentucky 1973 Onondago County, Jamesville, New York A 1974-1975 Burlington County, Mount Holly, New Jersey (consulted in planning cf new minimum security corrections center)

} 1978 Columbia County, Bloomsburg, PA -

t 1978 2 Lancastor County, Lancastora PA 1981-1982

}

Dauphin, Lycoming, Westmoreland, Lackawanna Councias SPECIAL PROJECTS y

1964 Planned and opened Bucks County Rehabilitacion Centor, n minimum security institution, first such institution $

s in any county in thu Unitud Status.

1966 n Assisted in preparation of Chapter 3, Community _--

Detention Facility, of 1966 odition of Manual of -

Correctional Standards, American Correctional ^

l Association. ""

1970-1971 Member ad hoc committee on work rolcase, American '

Correctional Association -

i 1972 Member of team which conducted seven training seminars 5

(three days each) for sheriffs under sponsorship of '"

National Shariffs Association 2 1973 Rember of ad hoc committee of American Correctional Association to cost accrodication procedutos. Incl udod y visits to several institutions to ovaluato all aspects -

for accreditation.

PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS

=

National Jail Association - Was' Director and past President. Now called American Jail Association, sorving as Parliamentarian. -f

=

American Correctional Association - Former Director

_3 e

Pennsylvania Association on Probatione Parole and .

Q Corrections -2 Member, American Correctional Association - Local h Dotontion Committoo ]

-b,

9 1

)'

, ' TRAINIhG

.. . l

January 1955 .

Instructor Orientation Course, Marine Corps School, \

l '

Quantico, VA Y February,1960 Senior Officers Short Course in Military Justice Januaryr1962 Correctional Administration Course, Class H1, V. Fort Gordon, Georgia L

April to Juner 1962 Correctional Adminis' tration, American University, Washington, D. C. (2 months, full-time)

July, 1962 Course in Jail Management, Federal Jail Inspection Service, Bureau of Prisons, Washington, D. C.

November,^1962 Speed Reading Course, Marine Corps Base, Camp LeJeune, N. C.

}. Mayr'1964 Counseling of Inmates, Public Service Institute of Pennsylvania December, 1964 Clinical Criminology I, Public Service Institute, Department of Public Instructioni Harrisburg, PA t  !

Mayo - 19qS Security and Discipline in Prison, Pubilc Service s

Ins ti tu te s

June, 1965 Group and Case Counseling in Correctional Settings, Public Service Institute June,1966 Correctional Counselinge Paychotherapeutic Techniques, f

Public Service Institute January, 1967' Prison Staff Developmente Public Service Institute

' Nays .1967 Modern Approach to Administration of ~Justicei Pennsylvania State University

' Decembero 1967 Advanced Course - Prison Security January, 1968 1

The Executive Workshopo Pennsylvania Adult Correctional -

s Training Instituto Pennsylvania r State University

.Augusto 1968..

Juvenile Behavior and Child Cater Public Service Instituto October 1968 Jail Management Correspondence Course r Jail Manage-o men t . Insti tu to r Bureau of Prisons December,;1968 . Group Counseling Public Service Institute d

1 O

s

-eA

- g .

V *

EDUCATION 1940.to'1942~ After high school graduation (valedictorian), I

~

attended Fordham University: Bronx, New York, ,

on a combined athletic (football) and scholastic scholarship (Dean's List) . In 1942, I enlisted  ;

in the U.S. Marine Corps. During my Marine Corps l

.' career,' I attended Fordham University and George Washington College p' art-time, but did not complete the work required for a degree.

> r 1 0

f n

k i

D.

u **

}

h 4

S

' ~ -

T '

g c

+,  :*- r ye