ML20094A666

Motion for Leave to Withdraw Confidential Exhibit 10 Filed in Support of Joint Intervenors 840214 Motion to Augment or Reopen Record.Declaration in Support of Motion & Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20094A666
Person / Time
Site:	Diablo Canyon
Issue date:	07/30/1984
From:	Reynolds J CENTER FOR LAW IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST, JOINT INTERVENORS - DIABLO CANYON
To:	NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
References
OL, NUDOCS 8408060046
Download: ML20094A666 (9)

Text

-

. (A.6 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION --.

BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL BOARD

' : ~l ,,

. + . ;g

)

In the Matter of )

)

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-274 0.L.

) 50-323 O.L.

(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power )

Plant, Units 1 and 2) ) ,,,.. ()L 7 7.c u u . .t.. . A o' e f 3 _:F;73 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO WITHDRAW CONFIDENTIAL EXHIBIT PREVIOUSLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO AUGMENT OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, TO REOPEN THE RECORD The Joint Intervenors hereby move this Appeal Board for leave to withdraw a confidential exhibit previously served on the Board in support of their February _ 14, 1984 Motion to Augment or, in the Alternative, to Reopen the Record (" Motion to Augment") in this proceeding. As appears below, this motion is necessitated by the continuing refusal of the affiant to authorize the Joint Intervenors to release the affidavit to the NRC Staff or PGandE, despite this Board's orders directing such release.

BACKGROUND On February 14, 1984, the Joint Intervenors filed a Motion to Augment or, in the Alternative, to Reopen the Record in this proceeding. Following various responses and supplementary filings, this Board, by Order dated May 23, 1984, invited the 8400060046 840730 PDR ADOCK 05000275

)}05

_1_

Q PDR

. . .= . . - . ._ -

- .. _- . = ..

Joint Intervenors to submit a reply based on affidavits by qualified experts or persons having knowledge of the information on which the motion was based.

On June 11, 1984, the Joint Intervenors submitted a reply supported by ten exhibits, of which four -- Exhibits 3, 4, j 7, and 10 -- were served only on the Board. The motion was accompanied by a Motion for Protective Order requesting this Board's permission to withhold Exhibits 3, 4, 7, and 10 from the t

other parties because the affiants had provided the information (af fidavits and supporting documentation) only upon express assurances that their identities would not be divulged to PGandE.

.The motion for protective order was based on (1) past inadvertent disclosure by the NRC Staff of information that led to the loss of

) anonymity of previous' confidential affiants, and (2) past incidents of harassment on-site following such' inadvertent disclosure.

By Order dated June 28, 1984, the Board denied both the Motion to Augment and the Motion for Protective Order and directed the Joint Intervenors to serve Exhibits 3, 4, 7, and 10 on the NRC Staff and PGandE, apparently for purposes of any appeal by the Joint Intervenors of the denial of their Motion to Augment.

In response to the Board's Order, the Joint Intervenors sought to obtain authorization for release from the sources of Exhibits 3, 4, 7, and 10. Because the Motion to Augment had already been denied, those efforts proved' unsuccessful, as the affiants refused the requested authorization, and the Joint F Intervenors' counsel so informed this Board and all parties by letter dated July 17, 1984. The Joint Intervenors assumed in so

- , - ,...,.~.._--.. , . . , .. , , - , . , ..~.w.,_..,.,_..,...._,_.m... ...,,~,.._.,_,.w_,,.r. -

doing that, because the exhibits could not be served as directed, they would necessarily be disregarded for purposes of any appeal of the denial of their Motion to Augment.

On the morning of July 30, 1984, the Joint Intervenors' counsel was informed by a San Luis Obispo County newspaper reporter that this Board had issued an order on July 25, 1984 directing the Joint Intervenors to serve Exhibits 3, 4, 7, and 10 by no later than July 31, 1984 or sanctions would be imposed, including possible dismissal of the Joint Intervenors from this proceeding. Although the Joint Intervenors had not yet received such order,A/ they immediately attempted once again to obtain the essential authorization for release of the exhibits in light of the Board's most recent order.

As the Joint Intervenors' counsel informed the Board by telephone on July 30, 1984, one of the affiants -- the source of Exhibit 10 -- will not consent to release, notwithstanding the possibility of sanctions stated by the Board in its July 25 Order.

Because, as an ethical matter, the Joint Intervenors cannot release the affidavit without the consent of the affiant, the Joint Intervenors immediately telephoned the Board and requested leave to withdraw the exhibit in question. The Chairman of this Board, through C. Jean Shoemaker, suggested that the instant Motion for Leave to Withdraw Confidential Exhibit be filed by in- l hand delivery to the Board no later than July 31, 1984.

I l

1/ The Board's July 25, 1984 Order was not received by the Joint Intervenors' counsel until the early afternoon of July 30, 1984.

, , - _ . , _ - - - - , . - . - - - ,r .- , , , , _ - - , - _ . - . . - . , , . - - , , - - - , , . - - - _ _ , . - . - , - - .

DISCUSSION By Express Mail today, the Joint Intervenors have served counsel for the NRC Staff and PGandE with copies of Exhibits 3, 4, and 7 to the Joint Intervenors' Jtly 11, 1984 Reply, thus complying with this Board's July 25, 1984 Order as to those exhibits. However, as to Exhibit 10, the Joint Intervenors have been unable to obtain the affiant's consent to its release, and, consequently, the Joint Intervenors cannot comply with this Board's Order, despite their good faith desire and efforts to do so, without breaching the conditions under which the affidavit was initially provided. Consequently, in light of the affiant's continuing refusal, and in order to prevent any prejudice to the other parties, the Joint Intervenors wish affirmatively to withdraw Exhibit 10 from this proceeding, for purposes of the initial Motion to Augment, the appeal of this Board's denial of that motion, or any other purpose in this licensing proceeding.

The Joint Intervenors wish to emphasize that this motion and their prior failure to serve the withheld exhibits was in no way intended as willful disregard of the Board's prior order

. denying the motion for protective order, but was solely a result of their effort to comply with their ethical obligations based on j the conditions under which the affidavits were obtained in the first instance. Because the Motion to Augment was itself denied by the Board, the affiants felt that there was no reason to risk possible on-the-job harassment or threats as a result of release i

of the exhibits; consequently, they refused to authorize the Joint Intervenors to serve them as directed by the Board. The Joint Intervenors' July 17, 1984 letter to the Board was intended to  !

notify.the Board and all parties that the Joint Intervenors had been unsuccessful in their efforts to obtain consent for release of the exhibits. Since that time, the Joint Intervenors have not sought to pursue the matter further, believing that even without

~

the four affidavits the record was sufficient to justify a petition to the Commission for hearing on ALAB-775.

+

, To comply with the Board's most recent order, however, three of the exhibits have now been served. The author of

, Exhibit 10 has not consented to its release, thus necessitating i' this application to the Board for leave to withdraw the exhibit in its entirety. Accordingly, the Joint Intervenors request that this Motion for Leave to Withdraw Exhibit 10 be granted.

Dated: July 30, 1984 Respectfully submitted, JOEL R. REYNOLDS, ESQ.

ETHAN P. SCHULMAN, ESQ.

ERIC HAVIAN, ESQ.

JOHN R. PHILLIPS, ESQ.

Center for Law in the Public Interest 4 10951 W. Pico Boulevard

! Los Angeles, CA 90064 (213) 470-3000 ,

DAVID S. FLEISCHAKER, ESQ.

P.O. Box 1178 Oklahoma City, OK 73101 '

r i

By ,

l JO;sL R. RFBf4G11DS V

i Attorneys for Joint Intervenors l

< - .._ _ . - , _ , _ _ _. _._,___..__._.._-._..____.____..________..O

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

-NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL BOARD

)

In the Matter of )

)

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY

) Docket Nos. 50-274 0.L.

) 50-323 0.L.

(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power )

Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

)

DECLARATION OF JOEL R. REYNOLDS IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO WITHDRAW CONFIDENTIAL EXHIBIT PREVIOUSLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO AUGMENT OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, TO REOPEN THE RECORD I, Joel R. Reynolds, declare and say:

1. I am one of the attorneys for the Joint Intervenors in this proceeding.

2. I have read the attached Motion for Leave to Withdraw confidential Exhibit Previously Filed in Support of Motion to Augment or, in the Alternative, to Reopen the Record. The facts as. stated therein are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

Executed thic 30th day of July, 1984, at Tos Angeles, California.

)

geeLe.yx,eLee

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

~

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD

)

In the Matter of )

)

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-275 O.L.

) 50-323 0.L.

(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power )

Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

)

)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this 30th day of July, 1984, I have served-copies of the foregoing MOTION FOR LEAVE TO WITHDRAW CONFIDENTIAL EXHIBIT PREVIOUSLY FILED IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO AUGMENT OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, TO REOPEN THE RECORD; DECLARATION OF JOEL R. REYNOLDS in support thereof, mailing them through the U.S. mails, first class, postage prepaid, to the attached list.

L5[uf & Clog /on CHRISTINA CONCEPC' ION

SERVICE LIST Nunzio Palladino, Chairman James Asselstine, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Lando W. Zech, Jr. Commissioner Frederick Bernthal, Commissioner U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Thomas Roberts, Commissioner Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

• • Thomas S. Moore, Chairman **Dr. W. Reed Johnson Atomic Safety & Licensing Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Board Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission 4350 East West Highway 4350 East West Highway 3rd Floor Guard Desk 3rd Floor Guard Desk Bethesda, MD 20814 Bethesda, MD 20814

• • Dr. John H. Bucl:

• Docket and Service Branch Atomic Safety & Licensing Office of the Secretary Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 4350 East West Highway 3rd Floor Guard Desk Bethesda, MD 20814

• Lawrence Chandler, Esq.

Office of the Executive Legal Director - BETH 042 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 David S. Fleischaker, Esq.

Post Office Box 1178 Oklahoma City, OK 73101

• Bruce Norton, Esq.

Norton, Burke, Berry & French 2002 E. Osborn Phoenix, AZ 85064

• Malcolm H. Furbush, Esq.

Vice President & General Counsel Philip A. Crane, Esq.

Pacific Gas and Electric Company 77 Beale Street San Francisco, CA 94106

.o John Van de Kamp, Attorney General Andrea Sheridan Ordin, Chief Attorney General Michael J. Strumwasser, Special Counsel to the Attorney General Office of the Attorney General State of California 3580 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 800 Los Angeles, CA 90010 Richard B. Hubbard MHB Technical Associates 1723 Hamilton Avenue Suite K San Jose, CA 95125 Virginia and Gordon Bruno Pecho Ranch Post Office Box 6289 Los Osos, CA 93402 Sandra and Gordon Silver 1760 Alisal Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 Carl Neiburger Telegram Tribune Post Office Box 112 San Luis Obispo, CA 93402 Tom Devine Government Accountability Project 1901 Que Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20009 Eric Havian, Esq.

Heller, Ehrman, White & McAuliffe 44 Montgomery Street., 31st Floor San Francisco, CA 94104

• Via Express Mail

• • Via Federal Express

.