ML20008F425

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Responses to NRC 810212 Questions Re Reactor Vessel Support Mods for Design Approval.Requests Responses on Design Concept by 810301 to Meet Const Schedule.W/O Encl. Related Correspondence
ML20008F425
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 02/24/1981
From: Jackie Cook
CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To: Harold Denton
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
11345, NUDOCS 8103130440
Download: ML20008F425 (3)


Text

/:

pf f - ,' /~) --

2 '

'/

. , REuTED CORRESPONDENPJ power O Consumers ON c.a.r. ome: io4s w.,t p.<n.4i no.a. a.ca.on, us 4stoi . cs t ri 7 Jarnes W Cook nce hesdent - hojects, Engsneenng and Constnetwn Q t m*1 N g\ ./g G CD February 2h, 1981 g gf

  1. = =n S 9

B[Q/((yAo %J c :.-

!*y,1 '

g MAR Harold R Denton, Director ISOIh ,, 61981 > d0 Office of Iiuclear Reacter Regulation US ';uelear Regulater'/ Cc==ission k y mu&, ' GT's.

k%g & % te.im  %

\ 'g

  • ff Washingten, DC 20555 f'NO_- s /s.'

MIDLA:iL PROJECT e n,. - aav9

~ ' 4 W. u lER I'7ALUATIC:i A'iD AFFROVAL OF REACTOR FRESSURE VISSEL SUFFCET MCOITICATIO:iS FILE: 35.h/3, 0505.803 UFI: 02300s, 70*01*10*03 SERIAL: 113h5 Our correspendence , Serial-97ST dated Dece=ber 10,1930 tc the :3C's Region III Cffice, advised of cur intent to =eet with the Office of :iuclear Reacter Regula-tien (:33) to resolve any remaining Staff eencerns en the reactor vessel suppert

=cdific atiens . The intent cf this =eeting veuld have teen tc assist the :3R in the ec=pletien of its evaluation and apprcval of the design concept en a tine-table which veuld suppert cur construction schedule. C Februa y 12, 1931, the Staff advised us of their remaining concerns and suggested that these could be decu=ented and resolved without the necessity of a meeting.

The attached Enclosure represents a ec=plete respense to the nine (9) cuestions verbally ccnveyed to us by the Staff. It is cur expectatien that these respenses vill allev the :iRR to ec=plete its evaluation and provide the :3C's Region III Office with an approval of the design cencept. If the :33 does find the =cdified ,

suppert cencept acceptable, we are prepared to implement this sa=e modification en both Unit 1 and Unit 2. This should relieve any 33 concerns en the acceptability of the Unit 2 reactor vessel anchor bolts.

In crier to support our eenstruction schedule, :!ER's apcroval to the Region III Office vould be appreciated by March 1,1931.

m /

r

/  :

$':'.*(} b5 }- ' .fY (

t . . . , ,

i o n w / .w4 Yb/.

Inclosure Respenses to :2R Questions en Reacter Vessel Support Modification f

CC Director of Office of Inspection & Enforcement (US :3C)

Director, Office of Management (US :EC)

C-ander, :Taval Surface Weapons Center Regional Director, Office of Inspection & Enforcement (Region III) t t

"9-e'" 6 ,

8103130 N g p

2 LJAuge, rrC v/a RL3aker,3&W/AA,v/a v"JCock, P-26-3363 v/a .

RJCock, Midland Resident Inrpector v[a.

LHCurtis, 3echtel v/a DFJudd, B&W v/a GSKeeley, P-lh-ll33 v/a C3echhoefer, ASL3 v/o GALinenber6er, ASL3 v/o FPCovan, ASL3 v/o AS&L Appeal Panel v/o

.MMCherry, Esq v/o

.vSinclair, v/o CRStephens, US HRC v/o VDPaten, Esq, US :TRC w/o FJKelly, Esq, Attorney General v/o GTTaylcr, Esq, Asst Attorney General v/o k~r24arshall v/o M

9

U w:2*. ,-er + . g . -

a- .

u.y

. ., .pg J Kv 7 Ju %gw vm. s y....,.,,,

.(W  ; .. .1r:.*Aj .= .-  ; .

s, g .

e,., vi.

s -

. M v .g., aw4 n _. Y, . g* .f.l%.. 4 *.. **Q p tr.e. . . ew. e N . .. ,. e.w.a , g;,r.ss . yt. ;; py / Q*

. w,y. .g . , g o, ,.j,

.- ,,4 . . ~ . - ,w- .. .. ,.,  !. ..m.

+-

' .i.p.lo e.

,,. se

,a,s, p s,,, . p_:.. g, g,,,

s.g , .. g ,.n.g, -g,y,4 .

. j Y, . ..

f h S e' N N* !. a

- e w*p:9.W

\

i f',.. . ',.:& ... +r.fsk-h5 M,Gh$yg"..h.Df. .y wm.%".Y ,g;$.hM **n97 yp> At ps.eu. 3*n. <&.

y  :-?.y? - .- .<

c-4 2 5 . M .. s$ w. -t

%. q ~e&. L.rd, *" < </ 3

.f .. - M' M;.,1.*ft =

r.
  • W . o,,u - .M s- ,c T. .'. ,4#-.

t p

. r y . p;, , c

,yy,; ., .. S .- g j,p- . y . , e .--..u...u.,...;

v...u. .,4,...,,yan,c.p..%-wi _ .<;..s. ., ,- ,4r','..,,%.,..,.>. y go

.e

,.r .

e

,s s a s %. _ , ,

,-: sm .--, s . r. ; n-..,.,y

c. . j*

,.M,.,,-,- s. - ~ i

...,.,.o.;.

.t * .

. . u. . .%,w. -

$, , s .a .

An,, s..

Q'h'ON.h'e.h.A'. ~** > - r<;,,"*.'s v.y+rr~s. e.i y u%~ g. ~.- ,,.n&

.~. -

  • a f, h
  • f.h $,,+yf.x,.NT )%k,. 5 $.,',h k,'hO f & *Q

. i

' l .Q .h". v';.;-Q Y, ,., ' g.Q!^'";,

'$e *;. ? :*E. c

~

  • l*3 f.5. ]N~,* f f.' g , $ .\; $ '

if@&@,~** G"(  :,,.V'

%'i..j'*Q'Q-C.S.Cg+&a.'*gMM'q '[MMy. Q*j$ -

~ j, . .~ a....*: % . ? '-.' ,l n .s ,:< y  % *.,.. . , . .

,3. a :.

.a - , c.*-:,-

w% . ? . . m. ..;t . ..yg . = - m. . , ps s. g - .u;a.g.=. 3- w" ;,-.,-",,,%9.. &, ~vy ..x:y;eg;.'% ..- y

.1lr

. ~

-s -

.. m y ' . ,-- - . : -

m

.a

-.w~...

^

. e e .=. $-

, ..y s.,*.=

,k'

  • 1

. w2 =,

. .- .~ 4.** r

..,...,.....,,'dJ-7,,, . .-.,, *.*,, .

-s;*4 .,c . ' .- .~-. -' . '  !

p..,.

i.4,.A' -

  • , . us+ p .

. *f w

,..g-

.- , M ..s n, - ~.,a y

.s. .

4*,. =

. .. ".%-r *r-an. *. .: .

c* e -

a*'

.I~.s.,..a...v**.-~a.

- . - " i- - L.

'g-'

. Q.*' %* 7 *. y

  • 4 - ./T , '.'#' I*.* s *** g .- * * * , * .r**

, ~ * .Q*'Q .' 8 '* Q ..i

. . ',i *. ; - -. 1.N fiL/ J , e 5.

  • r-%M . .

~

3, [Q l

.4 , . .,~.i - sw ** , .e s , }

6.,- g

,t . ..c . . - r .C

,- .,, tw

f *.

.-e zn . '".*R . . . . . . . ' * -l ;-%..g.,

. '_~7

  • N. s*

y -

f _m.L'...<p= Jf,~ %.~.* , + . p . ~ g ' c.r, . - % s .

> #. M. . . y l ,

7 r ~_ , . s- ,,

g 6,_

s

.w. - y n ..y W. ,r ey.. . of .r.. - ., - . * * * . ,, x,, m , j ' =

n..,.

c ,.- . st 7. s

-:-7 .a,4. - -

+ , * -

r c t.,

3-

7. : ' : c. 3. '..'*.7...r?---
T A . .

h O. C i m ._ .. _. ~-r, ,-. . , .

-}N.

. . . = . ... , .

c m ., -

t s

.. o. :.,. _c

.~,.

.. 1 -

) .

n-e -

, =. :- .

_.ec -

t 2

=> m t.

f E, c m *

< e, .~s u <: g~o

,~  ! unn Coo *f ain q ak. ,

a, a i. f, f, unu 55 2 - - -

t a b3

  • w  : -

vi .,

b$

-~ g e c.

l.__ (

, , ) -0

.~.: .

> - s- w, ..q

.w -

. rv m.

.x . . .

. . . :7. n . ,~.x......,. _

-~w . - .

  • .~- _ 4._%;. ,,h N. ..'. ):* **%*;;';5 . . .

- l'..  :' . * ' ' .:.,'.';. *

          • '*'22. 'C api;..z$.% <
  • .--. , - .-*==mm

, . . .. y -e -c:t  %. h,.- u- - .

_ y. .. -

.r . ,

.. e w ,... .. .- + w.,, w..,. . . . _

-%... . ;w.

-vT.- w..* ~~....++---

  • Mi' * ~ ~ - - ~ - ~:-.- - - ~ ~ ~ - ~-.-

. n-

' ' Ar**y,h. -p ,'f; v . . ydy 3 m s . A* 'C; . h "'" "*;Yi**. - *?.

., e - 2. g . . T .y . v : f'./C ~ ~

.r.~  :

,}w.% M.o.

.c %+~iGw' uss 1 g 9 ssV *=a 8 'k *r W"-* 3r':P ~ :.0~**A L****be.=".* a &&.  ;-**'W'-' -~' **-F~

N 4- .-*

o. . . cf 4 9 ;. . .- h e , .. s '. .'*a/*Af.E .J.& . . -. - .: : , ' . - * - . - - . - - - . .- 6

' M ....-..,. cy .  ;% %u'i.'=.r*-

-w m] ., -: . . . . : f .'m'* *C.*J .- t'

.. ~_.

'u.%.,.

Jr . '.7.* v

-v'=

+'

2W ~e ~.:.

.f%." ?'.-

v~c= -* T ~.

<t.. -r

-n .- ..-1

~~- 3

---=

h

".w,n y: w~.w.  :-rv  : . .w - .. w,~w.=e

~~ ; -

g::: .. .e n

.% >&e.r-rs . w %o v. ~ ..

s .msw lw- n y s-^* '

s, c an--+ - ' - n?'.J.

. m.* -^= a-+~

- m *-- 7 '*% "

- ." s

'L.'

-m" 2 .-i..bhh "

.d'Db '--. - 'bODO ~

E1 ~* *

n. 2 9;;k$$ ,I".2 WWsin 5 2'kkkM,b7)54  % % W S $ W bN>ad*-.h.( .Y' W:W b hW:' .'.tW:O O.' h* * ~

. ;c .. O .-a . 2 %#cc . rwrgq.m% e ae %.www,mfgcwscw.gw-l 4-E w

.:W w .,as. -

-w 4m s5 .6m ces a *b,.n.v.& w+&rw"v:+, ^

WhW=~m W *.$'~W; +.:N a ~*W'u *ww--M .

as . $ < N.'43.a.

l .x . t -Q U tu . ~ L ox .

e .. *CM s..e.. ,..s 0.p t$h'..m % e;.

6 q?R%Q?-lh*?q .ved-w L. a .> . c. . .- %.

m J cwS.W WJ+fWNH*1r**

h'w%-sp,v

- mmra e. .:..~..., .@

m;.nV@$w. .'Nk%-.

.~- W m "'5 p *R.W}

ec ..--~.

~ +

e -

- m sM.w -m.G '* -2 ** s* ; e"s'a.s" '. -.

. ; 2 ,%. o f- ,

s4 : & .**nc e W i.sA,, Mc.;. , '.w *- W p~1 u k G w.6A *Mrfim M.Af +'~.M;*w oww V

. On -wry . u.w f* *L+H y ^y r- *

' M, :J

-gl:*2?Q ~ '%'e.QQ5' *,'WM M W.'; tm:%; s,* ^n.~ e' "

C ,'. s o'

'.MGQh%9*!f-*Q*4i&*fgQ~ L*:.n'.:..

f w'z w .;v - m . y A .e v <s-.sg.?-- +.v  %:'+:^

}L- .. .. <c- c'3 .a -.w  ; &.dm.^s. L.wc> w m.:m.M9-M.. N:.w &-' ',n....,~k.? 'o M..

.. g ..? ..

% , .P .e i.4$ _... w .., y. -

e .; . - ,

e -

W . :Q'M&, %, .s.. A,%.$%'{'?:k%..',~.;;dk =;; ig . . _'.UGb V ' M.W.5 % * *m r "

w c<$

t.n n . .. .,u.h..-.y. --.e. .

s. . ,., .-G : a.M

. . . .. . ip . :.

r ,a +. .....o ~. e .m.

. .. . .e ' ~ c' A ~

.e

's. s . ~.m

. : ,- % w .. . -

'r-U ma,h., . a.

G $

~

.,:I.

. . . .. . ,EQ;W .s..... ~. &w .,. .:Y' .w.. W:N. .. - WC.. : < ., . '  : s &.T w ' ^

g . ~ . . .. - .

En .u -> ~

~ - ' # " . 4 '

'T-

-- &.aph q ~ - w...*g:,3 4@w.:.~., .

C y - * ' ' .*

%~h"; a q '-+ .#

Q  ; rj.W . . . . C . Z c -: , .. .. - . s ,_. . .,

y e e . e-. . .. ..m .

p-. ss

c. . 2 o c- se s -

e r..

~*<.e *, .

-*m -

' ^

i ! 6 S g,.. - *-

h , . . . .u d.e,.C ,M - :;

4..3'c"~ ,[ s.- f.'J,w. . -Ef :.. .

.~

y  :> .:.~ . .%. . w.

.a.. . w v. x

  • %- =r. . **o

' * ~e.. ' .- ~e -

4-

. + .tw e-~; . . + . '*.3_,} =M

--o .. w a.?.>r..c..,a m. e, .y?M N,. . ._*3-y.,-.* g-sc o a , . - *

v. ~r .
  • N, . A "a'k- *r...'.:'..,..s,.,,. ./.A +-

n . .%. m.4 J* xs -y- ' ^ *g-

.~+r.

u.. .*~+.* -

- .- t

%s A *' '

  • lm m^*  % ..l'.~.

n . g ,w_'~^ -g i 'yg,QcW. h.. ,r a,Cd,;,* ,%.; 9.a~Q' ., ~. s..u Y.-. T'. Q A ^y.~ ~&' * "u~% - * .:"'+%,g 9' u %c"  ?

,. L ww 4n.fn ):'S nrW<?.s- &T, a ="2A "-yn.h:2.M-;33.M w : ... ' ' ;N

.w s :q,,~4r%& <u,.j- @;,.h n.: '. ;"-: ;

,, w -~.- -

_